Investor Bulletin: 10 Questions to Consider Before Opening a 529 Account
Dec. 4, 2017
The SEC’s Office of Investor Education and Advocacy is issuing this Investor Bulletin to answer questions that may arise when investing in a 529 plan account. Please also see our companion Bulletin, An Introduction to 529 Plans, for background information on the plans.
1. Who can use a 529 plan to save for college or other post-high school education?
A 529 plan can be used to save for a college or other post-secondary education for any student in your family, including yourself. The person who opens the 529 plan account is called the account holder or the college saver. The person the account is opened for is called the beneficiary or the student. The account holder and the beneficiary can be the same person.
2. When should I start saving for a higher education?
You should consider saving as early as you can, but you should first take into account your family’s overall financial situation. Instead of saving for college, you may want or need to focus on other financial goals. You face penalties or could lose benefits if you do not use the money in a 529 account for qualified higher education expenses.
3. Should I save for college through a 529 plan or are there other ways to save?
Investing in a 529 plan is only one of several ways to save for college. Other tax-advantaged ways to save for college include Coverdell education savings accounts, Uniform Gifts to Minors Act (UGMA) accounts, Uniform Transfers to Minors Act (UTMA) accounts, tax-exempt municipal securities, and savings bonds. Saving or investing for college in a taxable account or with other types of investments are also options. Each option for saving for college has advantages and disadvantages and may have a different impact on your student’s eligibility for financial aid. For additional information on tax implications, please consult a tax adviser.
4. Should I invest in a 529 college savings plan or a 529 prepaid tuition plan?
In addition to traditional 529 college savings plans that allow college savers to open investment accounts to save for college, some states and a group of private colleges also offer 529 prepaid tuition plans. Prepaid tuition plans allow college savers to purchase units or credits at participating colleges and universities for future tuition and mandatory fees at current prices. Both types of 529 plans offer tax benefits, have a similar impact on financial aid, and the savings must be used for qualified higher education expenses.
Prepaid tuition plans usually have residency requirements, restrict where you can redeem the credits (usually public, in-state colleges and universities) and what the credits can cover (often tuition and mandatory fees only). If the student doesn’t attend a participating college or university, the prepaid tuition plan may pay less than if the beneficiary attended a participating college or university. It may only pay a small return on the original investment. When considering a prepaid tuition plan, you should understand the restrictions and limitations of the plan, including the extent to which your money is guaranteed and what happens to your money if the beneficiary doesn’t attend a participating college or university.
College savings plans are typically more flexible. They usually don’t have residency requirements, offer different kinds of investment options, and can generally be used at any college or university for tuition, mandatory fees and room and board. But, as with any investment, college savings plans also expose your saved money to investment risk, including loss of principal.
Please see the Investor Bulletin, An Introduction to 529 Plans, for more information about the differences between college savings plans and prepaid tuition plans.
5. If I choose a 529 college savings plan, which plan should I choose?
You can invest in almost any state 529 college savings plan or even in multiple plans regardless of where you live. You should compare plans to determine which one(s) is right for your family, but a good place to start your research is your state’s plan. Many states offer tax incentives or other benefits for their residents. You should consider what sort of incentives your state plan may offer, but you also should understand the fees charged, including those of the underlying investments. Sometimes, the tax incentives or other benefits that are offered to state residents do not outweigh the fees charged by the in-state plan. In addition, you should understand all of the limitations or restrictions of any plans you are considering. There may be reasons other than fees and residency benefits that make one plan more desirable for your family, such as investment choices or the ability to change the account holder or beneficiary.
6. If I have the option, should I go through a broker or open a 529 account directly?
Many states have both direct-sold and broker-sold 529 college savings plans available. If you already have a financial professional or you want someone who will help you with the process, you may consider opening an account in a broker-sold 529 plan. But, keep in mind that broker-sold plans often have additional fees. If you prefer not to use the services of a broker or are generally comfortable making your own investment decisions, you should consider opening an account directly with the state sponsor or program manager.
7. How do I choose among the investment options in a 529 college savings plan?
Each college savings plan typically has a range of investment portfolio options, which generally include various underlying mutual funds and exchange-traded funds (ETFs) and a principal-protected bank product. These portfolios also may include static fund portfolios and age-based portfolios (sometimes called target-date portfolios). Age-based portfolios automatically shift over time to include more conservative investments as your student gets closer to college age. You can allocate your money among several investment options or just one.
When considering your options, you should think about the fees of each investment option (usually the lower the better, all things being equal), and the level of risk and potential investment return you want (both of which may depend on how long until your student attends college).
You should consider how often you want to review the investments and allocations, and potentially reallocate or change your options as your student gets older. Do you want to be in control of those changes or do you want it to happen automatically? Current federal tax law allows you to change investment options up to twice a year or when you change the plan’s beneficiary. But if you want the change to happen automatically, you may want to consider an age-based portfolio. Be aware that age-based portfolios sometimes have higher fees.
8. How should I fund the 529 account?
You should save money in your 529 account in a way that makes sense for your family. Many plans have a minimum initial deposit, often $250 or lower, and a minimum for subsequent deposits. Sometimes the minimum for subsequent deposits is lower if you set up an automatic investment plan, which may also help you stick to your savings goal. Keep in mind that states that offer tax benefits for contributions often limit the size of the annual contribution that is eligible for the tax benefit. Also, most plans have a lifetime limit on contributions.
9. What do I do while my student is in college or other covered school?
You should consider how you are going to withdraw and use the money from your student’s 529 plan account to fund his or her education. You may want to consider, for example, what other types of financial aid your student is receiving, how you want to structure any loans during the years your student is in college, the impact using the 529 funds will have on subsequent years’ financial aid awards, and how much money you have available in the 529 account or in other savings vehicles. If you have multiple investments, consider how you want to allocate your withdrawals among the investments. For example, you may want to redeem a certain investment first or make withdrawals proportionately among all your investments. Also, if your student is the beneficiary of multiple 529 plans, you should consider how you want to allocate your withdrawals among the plans.
If you can afford it, there may be benefits to continuing to contribute to the 529 account while your student is in college. You can continue to get any state income tax benefits on the contributions and tax free income on the investments.
10. What can I do if my student didn’t use all the money in the 529 account?
Some families may end up with money in a 529 account after their student is finished with college. If you use the money for purposes other than paying for qualified higher education expenses, the earnings portion of any non-qualified withdrawals will be subject to federal income tax as well as a 10% penalty. Non-qualified withdrawals may also be subject to state income tax if you claimed a deduction or credit for your contributions. If your student received a scholarship, you can generally withdraw the money from a 529 account without a penalty, but you will still have to pay taxes on any income earned. You may be able to avoid paying any penalties and taxes if you change the beneficiary of the 529 account or transfer the assets to another 529 account, in both instances to a person in the same family. Or you could keep the savings in the 529 account if your student is considering graduate school. Make sure you understand the tax implications of investing in a 529 account and consider whether to consult a tax adviser.
You can find the offering circular for most 529 plans through the College Savings Plan Network website, which has a link for state 529 plans. Consider comparing fees and expenses of different 529 plans with FINRA’s 529 Analyzer.
You can learn more about the mutual funds and ETFs that are investment options in a college savings plan by reading each product’s prospectus, statement of additional information, and semiannual and annual shareholder report, which are available in the SEC’s EDGAR Database. The SEC’s Office of Investor Education and Advocacy also has a publication called Mutual Funds and ETFs – A Guide for Investors.
You can read about the impact fees and expenses have on your investment portfolios in the SEC’s Office of Investor Education and Advocacy’s Investor Bulletin: How Fees and Expenses Affect Your Investment Portfolio.
You can find information about investment advisers who manage the underlying mutual funds and ETFs or the 529 plans themselves at Investor.gov. You can also look up the brokers who sell 529 plans at Investor.gov.
You can also find educational information about 529 plans on the Municipal Securities Rulemaking Board’s education center website.