“Insurance Products: The Responsibilities of a Growing Industry”
Introduction
Thank you, Jim, for your kind introduction. The variable
insurance industry continues to show the staying power of
that pink, battery-powered rabbit that’s always on t.v.
Despite what seem to be countless attempts to take away its
tax benefits, the industry keeps on going, experiencing
astounding growth. Variable annuity sales reached over $73
billion last year, a 40% increase over the year before.
Assets in variable products have grown from just $30
billion in 1990 to over $300 billion this past June. And if
the numbers don’t speak for themselves, the Wall Street
Journal’s introduction earlier this year of a weekly
“Annuities Watch” column is a testament to the industry’s
increasing importance to individual investors. Can the
final step into mainstream America be far behind? That
final step is, of course, variable insurance making it into
the comics.
Insurance companies are developing new and innovative
products to satisfy ever-increasing demand and to deal with
the challenges of ever-intensifying competition in the
financial services business. In many ways, the industry is
effectively and impressively meeting the changing retirement
and other investment needs of millions of Americans.
Together with the industry’s success, however, comes added
responsibility. Responsibility for fairness.
Responsibility for honesty. And responsibility for clear
and understandable communication with investors.
The responsibilities of compliance and disclosure must be
borne by everyone in the industry. But they fall most
squarely on the shoulders of those on the legal and
compliance side of the business. More than anyone else,
you have the obligation for seeing that your clients and
firms operate within both the letter and spirit of laws that
are intended to protect investors and foster the integrity
of the markets. Counsel also wield significant influence
over the quality of information that investors receive about
variable insurance products, helping to ensure that
investors understand the products they buy before they buy -
- and not in a lawsuit down the road.
Meeting these responsibilities is not an easy task. Many
investors in variable annuities and life insurance are new
to these products. They may not have the background to
understand readily the risks involved in the products being
sold today. Care is required to make prospectuses, sales
materials, and oral presentations clear and succinct, so
they will be useful to investors. Take the case of the 86-
year old widow, described in this Monday’s Wall Street
Journal “Annuities Watch” column.<2> Intending to withdraw
a lump sum from her annuity, she found that she had
inadvertently annuitized. The mistake was corrected, but
then she arranged to withdraw her money on an as-needed
basis, subjecting herself -- perhaps unnecessarily -- to heavy
surrender charges and taxes. More effective disclosure
would almost certainly have helped this seemingly
inexperienced investor. Indeed, in view of the complexity of
variable insurance products, even the most sophisticated
investors benefit from efforts to improve and clarify disclosure.
In the area of sales practices, firms today are challenged
with the need to oversee far-flung sales forces selling an
ever-growing number of new and complex products. Whether a
life company has a captive or independent sales force,
distributes its products through banks or investment
advisers, direct marketing, or some other channel, controls
must be in place to prevent sales practice problems to the
greatest extent possible. When problems do occur, effective
systems should be in place to detect and correct them.
Firms that carry out their responsibilities well perform an
invaluable service for investors. At the same time, they
build their own reputations for integrity. Improving
disclosure and focusing attention on compliance will build
integrity, foster investor confidence, and fuel continued
growth.
Much in the way the industry is meeting its unique
challenges and carrying out its responsibilities is
encouraging and positive. There is, nonetheless,
considerable room for improvement. Prospectuses still are
often murky and filled with jargon and legalese. Sales
practices problems such as churning and questionable
suitability determinations remain a concern. Supervisory
practices and internal controls need to be scrutinized.
This morning, I want to focus on three topics that highlight
some of the ways that the industry can strengthen its
efforts in the areas of compliance and disclosure. The
topics are equity index products and how they are marketed,
development of a new registration form for variable life
insurance products, and sales practices and internal
controls.
Equity Index Products
Equity index products, introduced a mere two years ago, are
a prime example of the innovation and remarkable growth in
the insurance industry. By the end of 1995 only four
insurers offered equity index annuities. A year later, over
30 equity index annuities were available. In 1997, insurers
are offering an estimated 45 equity index annuity contracts.
Sales have taken off, with 1997 sales projected to be in the
$3-5 billion range. Different products have proliferated,
with single premium deferred annuities joined by flexible
premium deferred annuities, immediate annuities, and life
insurance policies.
In remarks to another insurance audience just over a year
ago, I noted that, on the basis of our then very limited
knowledge of equity index annuities, we had not concluded
that any of the available products needed to be registered
as securities. And when I spoke to this group a year ago, I
observed that the challenge for the Commission was to
educate ourselves about equity index annuities as rapidly as
possible so that we could determine whether or not they are
securities. I encouraged the industry to assist us in this
process.
In the last year, some in the industry have provided us with
useful information, and we appreciate those efforts. At the
same time, though, our concerns with respect to these
products have been heightened.
We are concerned that product marketing sometimes may create
the misimpression that equity index insurance products are a
means for participating fully in upside market returns
without any downside risk. It now appears that it may be
very difficult to market these products without giving undue
emphasis to their investment-related features. We are also
concerned that the varied and complicated forms of these
products may make it most difficult for investors to
understand what they are buying, and perhaps for agents --
particularly agents unfamiliar with the securities markets -
- to understand what they are selling.
As many, if not most of you know, in seeking broader and
more comprehensive information about equity index products,
the Commission recently issued a concept release requesting
public input on their operation and marketing. The comment
period closes in about a month, and we are looking forward
to receiving instructive comments.
Over the coming months, the Commission staff will do
its part in clarifying the regulatory status of these
products. The industry also must bear responsibility for
ensuring that products that should be registered with the
Commission are registered with the Commission. Insurers
should take particular care that they are not putting too
great a distance between an initial determination that an
equity index annuity need not be registered and subsequent
attention to the distribution of the product -- how it is
advertised and marketed -- in both written and oral sales
presentations.
N-6
The development of Form N-6 for variable life insurance
products, which we all acknowledge has for too long been
more of a dream than reality, is beginning to take shape.
The staff is hard at work drafting the proposed form, which
we expect the Commission will release for public comment
late this year or early next year. We believe that Form N-6
will represent a significant improvement, facilitating
clearer communications with variable life purchasers.
Currently, companies are using forms that were not designed
for variable life insurance products. As a result, these
forms lack some of the fundamental improvements that the
Commission has made over time to other investment company
registration forms, such as the N-4 for variable annuities
and the N-1A for mutual funds. Like those forms, the new
Form N-6 will be an integrated Securities Act and Investment
Company Act form, so that contracts will be registered on a
single form rather than the two forms now necessary. The
new form also will use the two-part format of prospectus and
statement of additional information, enhancing investor
understanding by moving more technical material to the
statement.
Our development of the new Form N-6 will profit from our
recent experience in improving Form N-1A. We are coming to
the end of the process of revising the mutual fund
disclosure form, and we have learned much in the process
about how to facilitate better, clearer, and more concise
disclosure to investors. We will apply those lessons as we
move forward with the Form N-6.
In developing the form, the staff is wrestling with a number
of difficult issues. One such issue concerns how fees
should be disclosed. Our goal is that they be described in
a format as transparent as possible that facilitates
comparisons to the greatest degree possible. The variable
insurance industry has argued long and hard for greater
flexibility in pricing these products. Now that last year’s
legislative changes have granted this flexibility, don’t
abuse it by doing a poor job of disclosing fees.
Another thorny issue involves illustrations. Quite frankly,
many of the illustrations included in prospectuses today
strike us as bad disclosure, confusing at best. The staff
is very concerned with the pages and pages of tables that
are sometimes included in variable life prospectuses, which
in many cases have very little relevance to most of the
individuals who receive the prospectus. We are taking a
fresh look at this area, hoping to eliminate much of this
disclosure shroud. At the same time, we expect that the
Form N-6 will provide insurers with the flexibility to
design prospectus illustrations that are helpful and to
supplement them, as appropriate, with personalized
illustrations that are relevant to individual purchasers.
Our goal is for insurers to use illustrations that are
effective in helping prospective investors grasp the
essential characteristics of contracts and to eliminate
those that simply clutter the prospectus.
Development of Form N-6 is one of many areas in which the
Commission is working to improve disclosure. The Commission
cannot bring about clear and understandable disclosure on
its own, however. The industry also must be fully committed
to that goal. Responsibility is again the theme that must
guide the industry. No company needs to wait to work on
improving disclosure until Form N-6 is completed or proposed
Form N-1A is finalized. Insurers should redouble their
efforts now to ensure that investors receive the information
they need in a way that is understandable. Too many
prospectuses continue to be written in highly complex,
technical jargon. Prospectuses should be useful to
investors, and not viewed as liability protection documents
that are ignored and forgotten until a disappointed investor
commences a lawsuit.
And how can disclosure materials be improved? Prospectuses
can be shortened by eliminating unnecessary discussions. In
the case of annuity contracts, the statement of additional
information should be used for highly technical information
that is not needed in the prospectus. As I noted to you,
that option will soon be available for variable life
insurance contracts as well. Complex or technical terms
should be avoided altogether, or at least explained.
Tables, charts, and other graphic materials can be an
invaluable aid to investor understanding. The Commission
staff is committed to these goals and continues to stand
ready to assist the industry in reaching them. I submit
that our track record in assisting the industry in these
efforts to date has been excellent. And in this case, past
performance will be predictive of future results.
Sales Practices
Finally -- a brief word on sales practices. Much has been
said on this topic of late, but it is so important that it
bears emphasizing. The dramatic growth in sales of variable
insurance products over the past few years has heightened
the need for firms to police the activities of sales agents.
The growth has highlighted the importance of effective
internal controls to prevent, detect, and correct misleading
or abusive sales practices.
The Commission is concerned that sales practices and
compliance efforts sometimes fall short of the high
standards set by the securities laws and required to inspire
confidence among investors. Article after article it seems
has been written about the high level of so-called “1035
exchanges” in the industry. A Cerulli-Lipper study
estimated that these exchanges constitute 25% to 30% of
industry sales. Nothing is inherently wrong with these
transactions, some of which may work to the advantage of
customers who receive enhanced products. We are concerned,
though, that the high incidence of “1035 exchanges” may
reflect sales practice problems such as churning of policies
to generate commissions and the sale of unsuitable products
to unwary investors.
The Commission has recently begun to place greater emphasis
in its examination program on evaluating sales practices
associated with variable products. The inspections staff is
focusing on sales and marketing activities of registered
representatives and the supervision they receive from branch
managers and others.
While the Commission is carrying out its responsibilities in
conducting its examination program, the variable insurance
industry must recognize its responsibility to promote a
culture of compliance. The area of internal controls is
critical. Effective internal controls help protect a firm
from the actions of unscrupulous employees and prevent
irreparable damage to the firm’s reputation.
Conclusion
Today the variable products industry is a dynamic, highly
successful industry that is providing valuable services for
investors across the country. To retain and improve this
position, the industry needs a reputation for integrity and
fair dealing. The challenge is great, but the dividends in
investor satisfaction and business reputation are equally
great. Thank you.
_______________________________
<1> The Securities and Exchange Commission, as a matter of
policy, disclaims responsibility for any private publication
or statement by any of its employees. The views expressed
herein are solely those of the author and do not necessarily
represent the views of the Commission or other members of
the staff of the Commission.
<2> Ellen E. Schultz, “Planning Withdrawals Can Avoid
Snafus,” Wall Street Journal, October 20, 1997, at C.1.
Last Reviewed or Updated: Oct. 22, 1997