Remarks of Stephen M. Swad, Deputy Chief Accountant, Office of the Chief Accountant
(c) Copyright 1996. All rights reserved.
As a matter of policy, the Commission disclaims responsibility
for any private publications or statements by any of its
employees. The views expressed are those of the author, and do
not necessarily represent the views of the Commission or the
author’s colleagues on the staff.
INTRODUCTION
Good morning. Chairman Levitt, Commissioner Wallman, and
Mike Sutton all have talked about global issues facing
registrants and the profession. As someone responsible for the
day-to-day operations and workload of the Office of the Chief
Accountant, I thought it would be appropriate for me to discuss
some of the projects currently in process as well as areas that
are gaining the attention of the staff. Perhaps the best way to
characterize my presentation, is that I plan to give you an
executive summary of the papers in my in-box.
BEST PRACTICES
Before I begin describing some projects currently underway,
let me share with you an overview of the Office’s current
workload. This is a rather easy way for me to begin because it
is something I deal with everyday. In addition, I have become
rather proficient in describing the Office’s workload -- we are
swamped. Over the past year, we have seen dramatic increases in
both the standard setting activities that we monitor and the
volume of questions that we receive from other divisions within
the Commission and from registrants. This may be due, in part,
to an overall increase in market activity as well as an increase
in the complexity of business transactions. Whatever the reason,
the fact is the volume of questions is up.
One of the goals of the Office is to provide a timely
response on each registrant inquiry that we receive. Since the
size of our staff is relatively fixed, we are continually
searching for ways to increase the efficiency and effectiveness
of the registrant inquiry process.
One thing that I think will help is the “best practices”
guidance that is being developed by the AICPA’s SEC Regulations
Committee. Although this guidance is still in draft form, one of
its objectives is to provide helpful guidance for improving the
efficiency and effectiveness of communications between
registrants and the staff. In essence, it’s a “how to guide” on
dealing with the SEC staff. This guidance covers many practical
topics such as what should be included in written communications
to the staff and when should National Office personnel be
involved in issues. Overall, I think it includes a lot of good
ideas and, when complete, should improve the registrant inquiry
process.
Let’s move on, starting with the portion of my in-box
labeled “in-process.” At the top of the box is the derivatives
release.
DERIVATIVES RELEASE
As most of you know, in late 1995 the Commission issued for
comment a release designed to improve disclosures about
derivatives and other financial instruments. The release called
for more explicit accounting policy footnote disclosures for
derivatives and disclosure of qualitative and quantitative
information about market risk inherent in derivatives and other
financial instruments.
The comment period for the release ended in May and about
100 comment letters were received from users of financial
information, like analysts, preparers, and auditors. In general,
users were supportive of the proposal. They generally commented,
for example, that quantitative information about market risk
would be useful. Many corporate preparers, however, generally
were not supportive. They often were critical of the
quantitative disclosures, principally because they thought that
market risk is not one of their primary business exposures. Some
also suggested that disclosures about market risk could reveal
proprietary information, which may be used in a harmful way by
competitors.
The views of auditors and financial institution preparers
fell in between users and corporate preparers. These two groups
generally were supportive of the proposal, but made
recommendations on how to improve it. Some commented, for
example, that registrants should not be restricted solely to the
three proposed methods for presenting quantitative information
about market risk. Instead, they recommended that market risk
disclosures be made using a “management approach” -- that is, the
approach used by management to monitor market risk. Also, some
suggested that the disclosures should be revised to allow
different disclosure alternatives for reporting quantitative
information about trading and non-trading portfolios. For
example, they commented that a bank should be able to choose to
use value at risk for disclosures about its trading portfolio and
sensitivity analysis for disclosures about its asset/liability
management portfolio, rather than using one or the other
disclosure alternative for both portfolios.
The staff is currently in the process of finalizing its
recommendations to the Commission on how to proceed. Our
objective is to have something to the Commission in the next few
weeks. Because year-end 1996 is fast approaching, the staff is
not planning to recommend that quantitative information about
market risk be required for 1996 year-end reporting. On the
other hand, the interpretive section of the release is effective
for 1996. At this time, the applicability of the remaining
portions of the release to 1996 year-end disclosures is dependent
on the timing of the issuance of the final rules. In the
meantime, the staff is reminding registrants of their reporting
obligations under MD&A, FAS 119, and APB 22 and the impact those
requirements have on the need to provide qualitative disclosures
about market risk and informative disclosures about derivatives
accounting policies.
Let’s move on. The next item in my in-box is a project
relating to the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995.
PRIVATE SECURITIES LITIGATION REFORM ACT OF 1995
In late 1995, Congress passed the Private Securities
Litigation Reform Act of 1995. This legislation included a new
Section 10A of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, which expands
the obligations of auditors to report, in a timely manner,
certain uncorrected illegal acts.
In August 1996, the Commission proposed a rule that
describes how to implement the reporting requirements of the new
law. The comment period for this proposal ended in October. The
Commission received 8 comment letters. The proposed rule
specifies that registrants and auditors should submit any notice
or report required by section 10A in a written confidential
communication to the Office of the Chief Accountant. The report
would include information identifying the issuer and the auditor,
and would be exempt from the Freedom of Information Act to the
same extent as Commission investigative records.
The staff currently is completing its recommendations to the
Commission. Our goal is to recommend a final release to the
Commission in early 1997.
A third project that is in-process relates to Industry Guide
3.
INDUSTRY GUIDE 3
Guide 3 was originally enacted in 1976 to improve the
disclosures for banks and thrifts. Since it was last revised,
which was over ten years ago, there have been many changes --
both in accounting standards and in the way banks conduct
business. For example, over the past few years the accounting
and disclosure requirements for loans, securities, mortgage
servicing rights, and securitizations have changed. Also,
balance sheets and income statements have changed by the use of
securitizations, derivatives, and off-balance sheet financing
techniques. As a consequence, the staff has been prompted to
undertake a fundamental reexamination of the Guide 3
requirements.
The staff recently completed the first stage of a fairly
intensive review of financial institution filings to identify
best practices and determine how registrants are complying with
existing Guide 3 requirements. While it would be premature to
describe a final proposal, I would like to walk through some
preliminary observations.
At a minimum there is a need to modify the disclosure
requirements of the Guide to conform with the requirements in the
current accounting standards. Also, there seems to be room to
remove some redundant disclosures that exist between Guide 3 and
GAAP.
Another idea being considered, because banks and thrifts are
comparable to other financial intermediaries, is to expand the
scope of the Guide beyond banks and thrifts, to encompass all
financial intermediaries with significant lending, investing, or
deposit-taking activities. After all, it doesn’t seem to make
sense to have registrants with similar activities be subject to
different disclosure rules.
Lastly, the staff has observed wide variations in the
quality of forward-looking disclosures relating to credit risk.
Some registrants, for example, provide insightful disclosures
about loans and other assets that are of concern to management,
but not yet considered impaired or troubled. This type of
disclosure seems to provide informative, early-warning signals
that could help investors better anticipate potential problems or
losses. Unfortunately, others provide very little in the way of
disclosure in this area. Thus, it seems that Guide 3 could do a
better job of prescribing disclosures in this important area.
As I mentioned earlier, the staff is just beginning its work
and has a number of issues to consider. Before any specific
recommendations are made or a proposal is released for comment,
these areas and others will be need to be analyzed further.
I would like to conclude with some words about poolings. As
you probably could guess, a speech about the day-to-day
operations of the Office wouldn’t be complete without some
discussion about pooling of interests accounting.
POOLING OF INTERESTS ACCOUNTING
The deepest portion of my in-box and the single largest area
where the staff receives questions is related to poolings. With
the increase in stock prices, the use of common stock as a form
of consideration in a business combination appears to have become
more popular. And, when all stock deals become popular, the
desire to use pooling of interests accounting increases. As a
consequence, many registrants and their auditors increasingly
find themselves evaluating the appropriateness of applying
pooling of interests accounting to a given business combination.
That is no easy task, particularly because the pooling rules
often require much interpretation and the application of a lot of
judgment.
Not surprisingly, two of the more subjective paragraphs of
APB 16 seem to be where the staff spends most of its time. One
paragraph -- 47c -- relates to the prohibition of pooling
accounting if equity interests are altered in contemplation of a
pooling and the other paragraph -- 48c -- prohibits pooling when
there are plans to dispose of a significant amount of assets.
Current practice recognizes that transactions “in
contemplation” of a pooling or those “planned” to occur after a
pooling cause problems. Where the diversity seems to exist is in
interpreting if a transaction is “planned” or “in contemplation.”
That is, when is the transaction related to the pooling? Most
accountants, including the staff, analyze these transactions
based on facts and circumstances surrounding specific
transactions. In practice, a lot of emphasis is placed on the
timing of the transaction relative to the initiation and
consummation of the business combination. From a timing
perspective, transactions can fall into one of five categories:
(i) well before initiation, (ii) just before initiation, (iii)
between initiation and consummation, (iv) just after
consummation, and (v) well after consummation.
Some practitioners suggest that transactions that fall
within the first and last category -- either well before
initiation or well after consummation -- generally are not a
problem. However, transactions that fall into the other
categories cause a pooling violation, unless evidence exists that
demonstrates that the transactions were made for reasons
unrelated to the business combination.
When the staff encounters these issues, we tend to
scrutinize transactions falling in those middle three categories
-- transactions that fall right before initiation, between
initiation and consummation, and right after consummation. The
staff tries to evaluate whether there is clear, objectively
verifiable evidence that overcomes the presumption that those
transactions were related to the combination. The problem is
that it is difficult to conclude that a transaction that occurs
relatively close to the pooling was not related, at least in
part, to the pooling. After all, if a business combination is on
the horizon or was just recently completed, how can it be clear
that a transaction or a planned transaction was not influenced by
the combination?
Without some clarification of the application of this part
of the literature, the staff is becoming increasingly concerned
that practice will erode not just the letter, but also the
spirit, of the pooling literature. The staff is encouraged that
the FASB recently has agreed to take up the accounting for
business combinations. However, as a interim solution, the staff
is considering whether there is a need to issue guidance to
improve the consistency of interpretations of paragraphs 47c and
48c of APB 16. Perhaps guidance similar to that in SAB 96 would
be helpful and improve practice in this area.
CONCLUSION
In conclusion, as work progresses on the derivatives
release, section 10A, and Guide 3, the amount of space dedicated
to these topics in my in-box will certainly decline. Also, as
the AICPA’s Regulations Committee’s efforts on best practices
begin to take hold, my in-box just has to benefit. As for
poolings, however, I expect that an inordinate amount of space in
my in-box will continue to be consumed, until some better
guidance is provided. I look forward to additional discussions
with you in these areas and I appreciate your attention.
Last Reviewed or Updated: Dec. 11, 1996