April 21, 2008
Dear Ms. Morris,
This is a copied letter but I fully agree with its contents and it is a horrible travesty that this is allowed in the United States of America
I commend the SECs recent action to strengthen Regulation SHO through the elimination of the grandfather provision, the proposed elimination of the options market maker exemption1, and the consideration of increased enforcement2. I am pleased that Chairman Cox continues to speak about the abuses of naked short selling and the need to end these fraudulent practices.
However, despite these recent efforts and public comments, the abuses continue largely unabated. I believe that the current proposal does not address the critical aspects of this issue. A well functioning capital market should not have any settlement failures large enough and protracted enough to merit inclusion on the Regulation SHO Threshold List3.
The proposed Naked Short Selling Anti-Fraud Rule states that deceiving brokers or dealers regarding the ability or intent to deliver stock on the scheduled settlement date is an offense however, that is already a clear violation of the anti-fraud provision of Rule 10b-5. Simply restating that such fraud is an offense will do little to change the current situation.
Serious settlement failures will persist unless the SEC implements additional reforms. Specifically, the SEC should (a) require that all short sellers of threshold securities either (i) have possession of the stock in question or (ii) have entered into a bona fide contract to borrow the stock in advance of the sale and (b) increase transparency with regard to short selling and settlement failures to reduce the clouds of suspicion that arise4.
Members of Congress, the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, and other notable commentators, have called repeatedly for these changes. The SEC should promptly implement these two critical components of effective Regulation SHO reform.
Guy Maness (Long holding Dendreon shareholder)
1 It has been over seven months since the end of the comment period for the SECs previous proposal to amend Regulation SHO to eliminate the option market maker exemption however, the Commission still has yet to take any action on this proposal. The options market maker exemption is a well known tool of manipulation and should be eliminated immediately to ensure a level playing field for public companies and shareholders.
2 Despite the SEC claims, there is no evidence of any real enforcement activity.
3 Nearly 7,000 companies have appeared on the Regulation SHO Threshold List, with nearly 700 companies appearing for over 100 trading days. There are currently more than 400 companies on the Regulation SHO Threshold List, with more than 30 companies that have been on the list for more than 100 trading days.
4 While the SEC has recently begun to publish the daily volume of fails in each stock, that publication should be disseminated in a timelier manner – at least as frequently as the semi-monthly reports of legal short sales.