Nov. 17, 2026
Re: File No. S7-2026-32, Release No. 34-106383, RIN 3235-AN47 (91 FR 59904, Sep. 21, 2026), Rescission of Rule 14a-8 and Amendments to Rule 14a-4; and File No. S7-2026-33, Release Nos. 33-11439, 34-106385, RIN 3235-AN63 (91 FR 59852, Sep. 21, 2026), Proxy Solicitation Modernization To the Securities and Exchange Commission: I am a private citizen in California and a shareholder. I oppose rescinding Rule 14a-8. More voices do not hurt. A share is part ownership of a company, not just a ticker to trade, and Rule 14a-8 is how an ordinary owner can put a question to every other owner. Keep that power with shareholders. The vote already works as the filter. In recent years many proposals reached company ballots, including waves of DEI and ESG proposals from more than one direction, and owners voted most of them down. The release's own data for 2022-2025 show average support of 26 percent and only about 10 percent of voted proposals winning a majority. Owners heard the proposals and decided. The remedy for a bad proposal is the vote, not removing the right to propose. I support the genuine paperwork relief in S7-2026-33 where it does not cut what owners can see. Keep Shareholder Power (S7-2026-32) 1. Keep Rule 14a-8. If the Commission narrows anything, keep a neutral federal floor, such as a governance-focused proposal right, and give a multi-year transition so States, companies, and owners can act before anything lapses. 2. If Rule 14a-4(c) changes, make it neutral: a separate box for each proposal, not one blanket box; a short description written by the proponent, or a right to correct management's description; and no discretionary voting unless the owner checks a box allowing it. 3. Count investor costs honestly. Before final action, publish the costs owners and proponents would bear running their own solicitations and following differing State rules, next to the company savings. Keep Owners' Visibility (S7-2026-33) 4. Keep large holders' campaign letters public on EDGAR. Rather than ending Notices of Exempt Solicitation, use a filter or a search category (Question 10) or an ownership certification for filers (Question 8). 5. Set the minimum broker search at 10 business days, not 5, and never shorter than the 7 business days brokers and banks have to respond under Rules 14b-1 and 14b-2. 6. End the mandatory glossy annual report, since the Form 10-K is on EDGAR, but keep free paper copies for any owner who asks. 7. Keep the five-year stock performance graph, moved into the Form 10-K. It is a cheap, plain-language accountability chart, and investment companies keep it anyway. 8. Adopt the cover-page contact information and the technical fixes. They help owners at little cost. Reconciliation Items RI-1 (S7-2026-32, footnote 2): It cites "17 CFR 229.10 through 232.501," a range that spans two CFR parts. Footnote 1 already cites Regulation S-K at 229.10 through 229.1610. RI-2 (S7-2026-32, aggregate benefits): The about $39.6 million in annual savings equals roughly 801 proposals x 107 hours x $462. It applies the full burden to every submission, including about 12 percent later withdrawn, and counts no cost to investors or proponents. RI-3 (S7-2026-32, Rule 14a-4(c)): The release says the check box gives shareholders "greater agency," yet management alone writes the description of the proponent's matter, and the proponent has no right to comment on it or seek revision. RI-4 (S7-2026-33, broker search): The proposed 5-business-day minimum is shorter than the 7 business days that Rules 14b-1(b)(1) and 14b-2(b) give intermediaries to report beneficial-owner counts. Question 17 raises this, but no conforming change is proposed. RI-5 (S7-2026-33, economic analysis): Eliminating the performance graph alone is estimated to save $3.9 million across 3,157 respondents. That equals the 100-percent scenario for ending the entire annual report delivery (3,157 x $1,237.50). The two estimates appear to use the same per-unit cost for very different tasks. Thank you for considering these comments. Alec Snelling California This comment was crafted with super intelligence (SI) support.