X0306 5 2020-12-31 0 0 0 0001042046 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC AFG 0000942061 LINDNER S CRAIG 301 EAST FOURTH STREET CINCINNATI OH 45202 1 1 0 0 Co-CEO & Co-President Common Stock 2020-09-30 5 J 0 33943 0.00 D 1178747 I Indirect #2 Common Stock 2020-09-30 5 J 0 33943 0.00 A 1914061 I Indirect #1 Common Stock 2020-10-30 5 J 0 134044 0.00 D 1780017 I Indirect #1 Common Stock 2020-10-30 5 J 0 134044 0.00 A 134044 I Indirect #6 Common Stock 2020-11-04 5 J 0 52356 0.00 D 63873 I Indirect #3 Common Stock 2020-12-30 5 J 0 22845 0.00 D 1757172 I Indirect #1 Common Stock 2020-12-30 5 J 0 22845 0.00 A 86718 I Indirect #3 Common Stock 2020-12-30 5 G 0 22845 0.00 D 63873 I Indirect #3 Common Stock 2020-12-31 5 J 0 32253 0.00 D 1146494 I Indirect #2 Common stock 2020-12-31 5 J 0 32253 0.00 A 1789425 I Indirect #1 Common Stock 3000 I Indirect #4 Common Stock 3000 I Indirect #5 Common Stock 100543.97 I Indirect #12 Phantom Stock Common 35695.86 D GRAT distribution from Indirect #2 to Indirect #1 Indirect #2: By SCL Trust. Indirect #1: SCL TTEE of the SCL Living Trust DTD 03/30/83. Indirect #1 transferred shares to Indirect #6. Indirect #6: FRL, Cust. CFL Under OH Tsfr to Min Act. Indirect #3 transferred shares to Grandchildren Trusts. Indirect #3: By Frances R. Lindner, Trustee for the Frances R. Lindner Living Trust dated 9/13/93. Indirect #1 transferred shares to Indirect #3. GRAT distribution from Indirect #2 to Indirect #1. Indirect #4: By Dynasty Trust. Indirect #5: By GST Trust. Indirect #12: Held in the Company's Retirement and Savings Plan. The number of shares of Common Stock is based on a statement dated as of 12/31/20. Represents amounts held by Reporting Person in a retirement plan of the Issuer based on a statement dated 12/31/20. Each share is the economic equivalent of one share of common stock. The Reporting Person's account balance is distributed in cash following termination of employment. S. Craig Lindner By: Karl J. Grafe, as Attorney-in-Fact 2021-02-03