X0303 4/A 2009-05-04 2009-05-04 0 0000093859 STEAK & SHAKE CO SNS 0001446446 Roberts Dennis J. 36 S. PENNSYLVANIA SUITE 500 INDIANAPOLIS IN 46204 0 1 0 0 SVP, Operations Excellence Common Stock 2009-05-04 4 A 0 100 11.82 D 5027 D In accordance with the 16,873 shares granted to Mr. Roberts under the Company's Capital Appreciation Plan (which vested on March 29, 2009), Mr. Roberts elected to have the Company withhold 4,467 shares to cover taxes owed related to the shares granted to him. Consequently 9,494 shares (reported in Box 5 of the original filing) minus 4,467 shares (amount withheld) equals 5,027 shares (reported in Box 5 above). Barry C. Paige, Attorney in Fact 2009-05-19