XML 74 R56.htm IDEA: XBRL DOCUMENT v3.3.1.900
LEGAL PROCEEDINGS AND CONTINGENCIES (Details)
$ in Millions
1 Months Ended 12 Months Ended
Oct. 21, 2015
patents
May. 01, 2012
patents
Feb. 03, 2011
USD ($)
May. 05, 2010
patents
Dec. 18, 2009
patents
Nov. 04, 2009
patent
patents
Dec. 22, 2008
Dec. 12, 2008
USD ($)
Nov. 07, 2008
patents
May. 23, 2008
patents
Oct. 10, 2006
USD ($)
Oct. 20, 2004
patents
Dec. 31, 2015
USD ($)
Feb. 28, 2014
USD ($)
patent
patents
Dec. 31, 2012
patents
Apr. 30, 2012
patents
Feb. 28, 2010
USD ($)
patents
Dec. 31, 2015
USD ($)
Counterclaims [Member] | Patent Infringement Claim Three [Member]                                    
Gain and Loss Contingencies [Line Items]                                    
Number of patents in filed infringement claims       2                            
Number of patents added to infringement claims       1                            
Number of patents withdrawn from infringement claims       1                            
Counterclaims [Member] | Patent Infringment Claim Five [Member]                                    
Gain and Loss Contingencies [Line Items]                                    
Number of patents in filed infringement claims   5                                
Loss Contingency, Damages Awarded, Value | $                                   $ 2.4
Judicial Ruling [Member] | Patent Infringement Claim Two [Member]                                    
Gain and Loss Contingencies [Line Items]                                    
Number of patent infringements                               2    
Judicial Ruling [Member] | Patent Infringement Claim Two Counterclaim [Member]                                    
Gain and Loss Contingencies [Line Items]                                    
Number of patents not infringed                               1    
Judicial Ruling [Member] | Patent Infringement Claim Four [Member]                                    
Gain and Loss Contingencies [Line Items]                                    
Number of patents not infringed                             4      
Pending Litigation [Member] | Patent Infringement Claim One [Member]                                    
Gain and Loss Contingencies [Line Items]                                    
Period for petition for further stay of permanent injunction             90 days                      
Pending Litigation [Member] | Patent Infringement Claim Two [Member]                                    
Gain and Loss Contingencies [Line Items]                                    
Number of patents in filed infringement claims                   3                
Pending Litigation [Member] | Patent Infringement Claim Two Counterclaim [Member]                                    
Gain and Loss Contingencies [Line Items]                                    
Number of patents in filed infringement claims                 3                  
Number of patents withdrawn from infringement claims         1                          
Number of patents remaining in infringement claims         2                     2    
Percent of revenue impacted by patents involved in litigation                                   0.30%
Pending Litigation [Member] | Patent Infringement Claim Four [Member]                                    
Gain and Loss Contingencies [Line Items]                                    
Number of patents in filed infringement claims                                 4  
Damages sought after the Company | $                                 $ 19.0  
Pending Litigation [Member] | Patent Infringment Claim Five [Member]                                    
Gain and Loss Contingencies [Line Items]                                    
Number of patents in filed infringement claims   4                                
Number of patents withdrawn from infringement claims   1                                
Pending Litigation [Member] | Patent Infringment Claim Six [Member]                                    
Gain and Loss Contingencies [Line Items]                                    
Number of patents in filed infringement claims 2                                  
Positive Outcome of Litigation [Member] | Patent Infringement Claim One [Member]                                    
Gain and Loss Contingencies [Line Items]                                    
Number of patents in filed infringement claims                       4            
Damages awarded to the Company | $     $ 12.9         $ 6.1     $ 34.0              
Positive Outcome of Litigation [Member] | Patent Infringement Claim Three [Member]                                    
Gain and Loss Contingencies [Line Items]                                    
Number of patents in filed infringement claims           2               2        
Number of Patents in Infringement Case, Unenforceable | patent           1               1        
Damages awarded to the Company | $                         $ 139.8 $ 105.0