1
<JAY>
Before we get started, please take a moment to review this slide,
which has important information for our time together. Some of the
business and financial topics we discuss may be considered
forward–looking statements under U.S. securities laws. It’s
important that all understand that actual events and results could
differ from our comments today.
2
3
<REGIONAL DIRECTOR>
Good morning.
As your regional directors on the CHS Board of Directors, we would
like to welcome you to Rochelle, and introduce ourselves, in case we
haven’t had a chance to meet yet.
Each director introduces himself, gives background and talks about
his farm operation
Thanks again for coming and now we’d like to introduce you to our
CHS Board of Directors chairman, Dan Schurr.
4
<DAN>
Good morning.
Welcome to the 2017 Your CHS Town Hall in Rochelle. This town hall
is one of 10 the board of directors and your CHS management team
is hosting throughout the country – from oil refineries to export
terminals, to ethanol plants and joint ventures with member
cooperatives.
We’re excited for this opportunity for all of us to be together today
and explore these facilities and also talk about some significant
topics impacting our cooperative system.
If we haven’t met before, I’m Dan Schurr. I’ve served on the board
for 11 years, elected by Region 7. I farm in Le Claire, Iowa, where I
grow corn and soybeans and operate a commercial trucking
business.
After Dave Bielenberg stepped down, I was elected by your board to
move from the vice chair role into the board chair role. I want to
thank Dave for his service to this cooperative.
I’m also pleased to welcome Jay Debertin, whom our board elected
as the new president and CEO of CHS in May. Many of you know Jay
because he has been with CHS for more than 30 years, leading a
variety of teams in energy and processing and food ingredients. Jay
is originally from the Red River Valley area of Minnesota and North
Dakota.
4
<JAY>
Thanks, Dan. And, thanks to all of you for coming out today. We
know it’s a busy time of year and we’re going to use your time
wisely.
Before we get into the formal program, I’d like to talk about what is
likely on your minds. I’d like to take a moment and discuss this
recent leadership transition with you.
As you know, Carl Casale served our cooperative as president and
CEO during a period of record growth and profitability in the
agricultural industry. I have a lot of respect for Carl and his vision
for the agricultural industry. He brought a lot of value to our
leadership team as an executive and also as the operator of a family
farm. Over the past several months, everyone – including Carl -
recognized we were entering a new chapter for CHS and for the ag
industry.
Just as we had under Carl’s leadership, we are faced with both
opportunities and challenges – and we will get after all of them.
What I want to say up front about this change is that all parties
involved are satisfied with this outcome. And, all of us are focusing
our time and energy on moving forward, in partnership with all of
you.
<DAN>
And, as for our leadership changes on the board, everyone who has
served and continues to serve has helped create a strong
foundation that we’re going to continue to build upon. Do we have
4
disagreements at times? Yes, we do, that’s what we’re elected to do
– discuss things, debate and sometimes disagree, but in the end,
make our decisions as one board. And all of those decisions are
made with only one objective in mind: helping our owners grow and
prosper. It’s not easy work. Our board members serve with real
purpose on behalf of all of you to ensure the long-term vitality and
success of this cooperative system.
Questions
We’ll have more time for questions throughout the day, so as you
think of questions please feel free to jot them down.
I’d like to ask the board members here today to stand and briefly
introduce themselves to you.
Each board member stands and introduces himself
Thanks all, and I’d encourage everyone to get to know each other
and share insights over lunch or later in the program.
Here is a look at our agenda for this morning:
• Jay will help kick us off with the plan to strengthen and grow
CHS – sharing insights on where we’ve been this year and
where we’re headed in the future
• Tim will give us an overview of the Q3 financials and some
specific events that occurred this year
• Then, we’ll get real-time market updates and insights from some
4
of our CHS business leaders
• Finally, we’ll wrap up by learning more about the asset we are
visiting today, and its importance to CHS
• We’ve also built in plenty of time for conversation – which is the
primary reason we are here - to listen and learn what’s on your
mind and answer the questions you have
So, whether you came from just down the road or across several
states, I welcome you to this CHS town hall.
Now, let’s hear from our president and CEO Jay Debertin…
4
<JAY>
Thanks, Dan. And, thanks to all of you for coming out today.
We know it’s a busy time of year and we’re going to use your
time wisely.
First, I’d like to introduce you to the members of our Strategic
Leadership Team that are here. I’d ask that they stand and
introduce themselves.
Each SLT member in attendance stands and introduces
him/herself.
Thanks again to all, and now let’s get on with our program.
5
<JAY>
One thing that never changes in any cycle, are the CHS shared
values which are core to who we are as a cooperative system.
From…
• Managing our business with the highest integrity
• To our people and their innovative spirit
• Building lasting and mutually rewarding customer
relationships
• Being responsible stewards in our community
• And our tradition of partnership and shared success
Each of these values fuels our promise to all of you – to help our
owners grow. You have my commitment to make sure CHS is
always performing to these standards.
6
<JAY>
As we talk about strengthening to grow, there’s no place more
fitting for us to be gathered than at an asset that provides a critical
link in our supply chain.
The Rochelle ethanol plant is positioned squarely within corn
country. The plant produces 135 million gallons of ethanol
annually from 47 million bushels of corn, all sourced within 60
miles. On average, 200 semi-trucks cross the receiving scales here
daily. Rochelle has site storage capacity of 2 million bushels of
corn and 2.3 million gallons of ethanol.
CHS acquired Rochelle from Illinois River Energy in 2014. As you
noticed coming in, the plant is easily accessible (and visible) from
nearby Interstate 39.
7
<JAY>
E-85 ethanol leaves the plant by truck and is marketed by CHS
Renewable Fuels locally and to nearby Chicago fuel blenders for
delivery to thousands of gas stations and convenience stores.
CHS Rochelle has earned Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)
recognition as one of the agency’s efficient producers, using fewer
resources (water, electricity, steam) while diligently complying with
EPA regulations and permits.
Recent plant investments include a $1.7 million corn oil centrifuge
to improve corn oil recovery.
Stewardship is a big focus at Rochelle as well, with its 61
employees actively engaged to raise money for the community
through an annual golf tournament, Thanksgiving food drives, 4-H
and county fair funding and Ag in the Classroom. Employees also
visit local schools to discuss career opportunities.
All of the things I’ve outlined, proximity to customer, source of
supply, operational excellence, supply chain, etc. are what makes
this facility of great value to our owners and our system.
8
<JAY>
It’s important we focus on these values due to the cyclical nature
of our business.
We’re seeing drought conditions in North Dakota, half of the state
is experiencing drought and 30% of the state is in extreme
drought. The USDA is saying one third of soybeans are in poor
condition and 70% of pastures are also in poor condition.
South Dakota and eastern Montana are also experiencing
challenging drought conditions. All of this of course means
markets are pricing big weather premiums on the unknowns of
U.S. fall production. We’re keeping a close eye on that price rally
and the competitiveness of U.S. grains exports.
9
<Jay>
And while west of us is severely dry, you’ve seen recent heavy rain
and flooding in and around Rochelle. As all of you know, the Kyte
Creek is now back within its banks and it sounds like clean up is
going well.
Our operations here were not impacted by the heavy rain, but this
speaks to our continued ups and downs that can impact our
business. There will always been challenges that are out of our
control – drought in some places and floods in others - but we will
put ourselves in the best position to control what we can.
10
<JAY>
The crop nutrient marketplace shows a pretty quiet market in an
over-supply situation. We’re seeing cautious buying interest into
the fall by retailers and producers due to pressure on profitability
and a cautious risk management approach. Spring of 2018 pricing
likely will take direction from the grain markets, the amount of
acres planted to corn, the financial condition of the U.S. producer
and global market conditions.
11
<JAY>
On the Energy side, crude oil prices currently are near $45,
continuing to trade range bound in the low-to-mid $40’s. Common
external outlook for the balance of 2017 and 2018 is that oil prices
should remain in the $40 to $50 range.
U.S. refineries continue to run near record levels with crude inputs
averaging roughly 17 million barrels per day. Overall, U.S.
inventories on crude oil, gasoline and diesel remain near seasonal
highs with inventories likely to remain elevated for the balance of
2017.
We’ve experienced these types of ups and downs in our markets
for the past 85 years and that’s going to continue. In our
businesses, we are price-takers on both ends with what we buy
and what we sell. So, we have to operate in whatever market
environment is out there. Which is why, it’s imperative that we’re
not only able to ride these cycles but that we’re able to succeed in
them.
12
<JAY>
Unfortunately, our challenges this year, especially this quarter, go
beyond the typical ups and downs of cyclical markets. We
experienced significant losses due to three events, two that occurred
this quarter and one that spanned the past three quarters.
This quarter, we took significant specific charges related to a trading
partner in Brazil entering bankruptcy proceedings under Brazilian law
and two asset impairment charges. And, when we look at our results
for the 9-month period year to date, we have the large producer loan
loss that we’ve been reporting on for the last few quarters.
We’ll discuss each of these serious issues today and I’ll walk us
through how we’re responding to these events by aggressively
addressing gaps moving forward to strengthen and grow CHS.
While I won’t understate the seriousness of this quarter’s earnings
results, we remain confident in the future of CHS and our ability to
serve all of you. Overall, our core businesses have had solid
performance so far this year and some business units have had
strong performance.
13
<JAY>
It has been a challenging quarter, but there is good news to share too.
When we look at the performance of many of our businesses in the
current ag economy, I believe that our performance has been good.
And the fact that our core businesses are showing stable
performance allows us to focus our immediate efforts on closing
gaps, driving operational excellence and strengthening and growing
CHS.
We’re going to work hard at this. Make no mistake – we have our
sleeves rolled up on work that we believe will both strengthen and
grow CHS in the days, weeks, and years ahead.
14
<JAY>
The first thing we will focus on is strengthening our relationships,
especially our connection with all of you. CHS runs on
relationships. Relationships with owners, customers, employees
and business partners have been the driving force behind our
shared success. And, when times are more challenging, those
relationships are what get you through. So we’re renewing our
focus on our relationships.
15
<JAY>
We’ll be mindful about safety, always. CHS continues to strive to
achieve our goal of no accidents, no injuries and no deaths. We
will continue to put the environment, health and safety first in all
we do.
16
<JAY>
We are strengthening by enhancing the rigor in how we do business
so we limit losses and really win when the businesses are performing
well.
17
<JAY>
As your partner, it’s vital that we think strategically about our assets
to ensure each is driving the performance we need and expect. To do
this, we’ve created a custom portfolio review tool that is helping us
analyze assets across our company and giving us a holistic look at
what’s performing well, what’s core and what needs improvement.
18
<JAY>
And, we will grow in the markets where we can increase share and
perform well for our owners and our partners around the world.
Now I’d like to turn it over to Tim for the financial update.
19
<TIM>
Thanks Jay and good morning to you all.
The financial results for the third quarter of 2017 are disappointing
and quite frankly challenging. Despite solid year-over-year
performance in most of our base businesses, the three specific
events Jay mentioned are resulting in CHS reporting a substantial
financial loss this quarter.
20
<TIM>
Let’s review our third quarter results. On July 14th, we reported a net
loss of $45.2 million for the third quarter of the 2017 fiscal year,
compared to net income of $190.3 million for the same period one
year ago. This net loss includes the impact of these specific events.
We can see the solid volume performance of our businesses when we
look at our sales for the third quarter, which were $8.6 billion, which
represents a 10 percent increase when compared to the same time
last year.
So, let’s look a bit closer at each of our businesses.
The CHS Energy segment experienced a loss before income taxes of
$9.3 million in the third quarter, compared to income before taxes of
$109.4 million for the same period in fiscal 2016. Results were driven
primarily by significantly reduced refining margins and a $32.7 million
charge incurred due to a cancelled capital project. The company’s
propane, transportation and lubricants businesses experienced
decreases in earnings compared to the same period a year ago.
21
The CHS Ag segment, which includes domestic and global grain
marketing and crop nutrients businesses, renewable fuels, local
retail operations, and processing and food ingredients, generated a
loss before income taxes of $221.2 million in the third quarter,
compared to income before taxes of $24.2 million for the same
period in fiscal 2016. Grain marketing earnings decreased primarily
due to a $230 million charge driven by a trading partner in Brazil
entering bankruptcy proceedings under Brazilian law. The
wholesale crop nutrients and renewable fuels businesses
experienced decreases due to lower margins. The processing and
food ingredients business earnings decreased primarily due to
impairment charges taken on certain assets in the third quarter.
Country Operations earnings increased due primarily to increased
volumes.
The Nitrogen Production segment generated income of $8.7 million
during the third quarter, compared to $25.0 million during the same
period last year. The decrease is primarily due to lower production
margins.
The company’s Foods segment, previously reported as a
component of Corporate and Other, generated pretax earnings of
$7.0 million during the third quarter of fiscal 2017, compared to
$17.0 million in the same period the previous year. The decreases
were primarily due to reduced margins at Ventura Foods, LLC, the
investment that makes up the Foods segment.
Corporate and Other generated pretax income of $5.6 million during
the third quarter, compared to $18.9 million during the same time
period the previous year. Earnings in this category are primarily
derived from the company’s equity investment in the Ardent Mills,
LLC, wheat milling joint venture and our Business Solutions
operations.
21
<TIM>
If we look at our performance year to date…
Our net income for the nine-month period ended May 31, 2017, was
$178.5 million, compared to $425.8 million for the same period last
year. The decrease is primarily the result of charges related to the
specific events that Jay and I have both touched on, including the
Brazilian trading partner entering into bankruptcy proceedings under
Brazilian law, loan loss reserve charges, of which a significant portion
relate to a single large producer borrower, and asset impairment
charges.
Revenues for the nine-month period ended May 31, 2017, were $24.0
billion, compared to $22.2 billion for the same period last year, an
increase of 8 percent.
22
<TIM>
Given the impact on our results from these specific events, I’d like to
share a bit more about each. I’ll start with the large producer loan
loss.
Over the past four quarters, we have reported on the loan loss reserve
associated with loans to a single large producer in the Midwestern
region of the U.S.
During the third quarter of fiscal 2017, CHS Capital concluded a
transaction with the single producer borrower whereby CHS Capital
obtained from the borrower approximately 14,000 acres of land and
improvements that, prior to the transaction, were owned by the
borrower and served as collateral for the outstanding loans to CHS
Capital. The amount corresponding to the fair value of the land and
improvements, approximately $139 million, was credited against the
notes receivable from this single producer borrower.
As a result of this arrangement, all remaining outstanding notes
receivable balances and corresponding reserves related to this single
producer borrower were removed from the balance sheet of CHS for
financial reporting purposes. However, we continue to enforce our
rights under the various agreements between CHS Capital and the
producer borrower to pursue future potential recoveries.
The second significant event occurred when Seara, a long-time grain
originator and supply chain partner for our subsidiary in Brazil, filed 23
for Judicial Reorganization under Brazilian law, which is similar to
bankruptcy in the U.S.
CHS Brazil had maintained a grain origination relationship with
Seara for over a decade. The loss represents various advances and
credit that CHS had extended to Seara and these are covered by the
bankruptcy proceedings. We also are a secured creditor of certain
affiliate companies that are part of the bankruptcy proceeding. We
are seeking recovery under Brazilian bankruptcy law and through
other legal proceedings. Any recovery that CHS Brazil receives will
be recognized as income at that time in the future.
CHS is actively managing the situation to mitigate the loss and our
Brazilian affiliate continues its grain origination operation.
This event and the large producer loan loss highlight the need for
us to re-focus and improve our risk management practices. One
example is we are establishing a specific Credit Center of
Excellence that will focus on effective management of the credit
risks CHS faces across the enterprise. This is an important
component of our program to restore CHS’s financial flexibility.
Our third event is a result of impairment testing we conducted
during the third fiscal quarter. In Q3 we took impairment charges on
certain long-lived assets and goodwill in our Ag segment.
Additionally, we recorded a $32.7 million impairment charge in our
energy segment relating to the cancellation of a capital project.
23
<TIM>
Looking forward, restoring CHS’s financial flexibility is our #1 financial
priority. I’ll provide a quick overview –
• First, we will continue to keep a sharp focus on managing our controllable
operating expenses. Maintaining expense and cost control is basic
blocking and tackling work for all of us.
• Second, we’re continuing to optimize working capital to ensure we
maintain appropriate levels of liquidity.
• Third, we will continue to limit capital investment to safety, regulatory and
maintenance capital. Growth capital will be limited until financial flexibility
is appropriately restored.
• Fourth, working with your CHS Board Capital Committee, we are
analyzing various equity management options.
• And fifth, we have conducted a strategic portfolio review of our assets.
Our commitment is to be prepared to selectively monetize assets as an
important lever to restore financial flexibility. If we complete any such
transactions, we intend to focus those proceeds on repaying debt.
I want to share that we are committed to restoring financial flexibility to our
CHS balance sheet as quickly as possible. We will take prudent actions.
Even with all that we have experienced this quarter, CHS’s financial
foundation is solid and our people remain committed to serving you, our
owners.
I’ll turn it back over to Jay, but will be available at the end for questions.
24
<JAY>
If you know me, you know I have a passion for this business and
believe deeply in CHS, our owners and all of our employees. While
we’ve talked through some tough topics today, it’s important you
know just how encouraged I am about our future together. We have
great opportunities to take our work to the next level.
25
<JAY>
Before we wrap up I want to share news about some of the really
incredible work our CHS Foundation and CHS Corporate giving is
doing to develop future ag leaders, improve ag safety and help
build strong rural communities. In 2016, CHS Stewardship
awarded 6.2 million dollars to local and national groups to cultivate
ag learning and growing.
26
<JAY>
Just few of the many giving examples in region 5 over the last 5
years
Developing future leaders examples:
• Support of national FFA and 15 state FFA associations, including
several states throughout the region (4)
• Awarded $325,000 in scholarships to 250 students attending
colleges throughout the region
• Support of 7 agriculture collegiate clubs to support professional
development and student learning
• Funding support to University of Illinois agricultural education
classroom renovation project
• Support of Agricultural Rural Leadership programs in IL, IN and
New York
27
Improving ag safety examples:
• $370,000 to help more than 30,000 kids attend safety days hosted
by the Progressive Agriculture Foundation
• Membership in several organizations that promote ag safety for
producers, families and employees
Building strong rural communities examples:
• $4.7 million and 3.4 million pounds of food donated to hungry
families across the U.S. through CHS Harvest for Hunger
• Grants in nearly 40 rural communities to support local fire
departments, FFA chapters and other community projects
• Celebrating six years of employees giving back through CHS
Days of Service
27
<JAY>
Those local dollars are what’s important to you. And, to localize
and give even more, the CHS Foundation this year launched Seeds
for Stewardship, which is:
• A grants program that will match your cooperative’s giving
dollars, up to $5,000
• Each CHS member cooperative is eligible to request to receive
this money to support projects that are important within your
own community – from making a playground more safe to
upgrading a fire truck
• There are grant periods throughout the year. For this current
round of giving, cooperatives can apply now through July 1,
2017.
• You can learn more at chsinc.com/stewardship
28
<JAY>
I’d like to talk more about our future with all of you. If you can
share some of your time this December please consider attending
the CHS annual meeting this year. It’s a great chance for you to
connect with other producers, leaders and folks at CHS. We
always love the opportunity to connect in person at this annual
event.
29
<JAY>
Dan and all SLT members present should join Jay and Jean near
the front for questions.
Jay, Jean and Dan will answer questions as well as pass some
along to other CHS Board members and SLT members as
appropriate.
30
31