<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<edgarSubmission xmlns="http://www.sec.gov/edgar/twentyfourf2filer" xmlns:feec="http://www.sec.gov/edgar/feecommon" xmlns:com="http://www.sec.gov/edgar/common">
  <!--Generated by Workiva-->
  <schemaVersion>X0101</schemaVersion>
  <headerData>
    <submissionType>24F-2NT</submissionType>
    <filerInfo>
      <liveTestFlag>LIVE</liveTestFlag>
      <filer>
        <issuerCredentials>
          <cik>0000802222</cik>
          <ccc>XXXXXXXX</ccc>
        </issuerCredentials>
      </filer>
      <flags>
        <overrideInternetFlag>false</overrideInternetFlag>
        <confirmingCopyFlag>false</confirmingCopyFlag>
      </flags>
      <investmentCompanyType>N-4</investmentCompanyType>
    </filerInfo>
  </headerData>
  <formData>
    <annualFilings>
      <annualFilingInfo>
        <item1>
          <nameOfIssuer>SEPARATE ACCOUNT I OF NATIONAL INTEGRITY LIFE INS CO</nameOfIssuer>
          <addressOfIssuer>
            <street1>400 BROADWAY ST</street1>
            <street2>MAIL STATION 24</street2>
            <city>CINCINNATI</city>
            <state>OH</state>
            <country>X1</country>
            <zipCode>45202</zipCode>
          </addressOfIssuer>
        </item1>
        <item2>
          <reportClass>
            <annualClassInfo>
              <className>AnnuiChoice Flexible Premium Variable Annuity</className>
              <classId>C000002835</classId>
            </annualClassInfo>
            <annualClassInfo>
              <className>Grandmaster flex3 Flexible Premium Variable Annuity</className>
              <classId>C000002837</classId>
            </annualClassInfo>
            <annualClassInfo>
              <className>IQ 3 the Smart Annuity Flexible Premium Variable Annuity</className>
              <classId>C000002838</classId>
            </annualClassInfo>
            <annualClassInfo>
              <className>IQ Advisor Flexible Premium Variable Annuity</className>
              <classId>C000002839</classId>
            </annualClassInfo>
            <annualClassInfo>
              <className>Pinnacleplus Flexible Premium Variable Annuity</className>
              <classId>C000002840</classId>
            </annualClassInfo>
            <annualClassInfo>
              <className>AnnuiChoice II</className>
              <classId>C000034991</classId>
            </annualClassInfo>
            <annualClassInfo>
              <className>AdvantEdge Flexible Premium Variable Annuities</className>
              <classId>C000063172</classId>
            </annualClassInfo>
            <annualClassInfo>
              <className>VAROOM</className>
              <classId>C000091444</classId>
            </annualClassInfo>
            <annualClassInfo>
              <className>Pinnacle (before April 30, 1998)</className>
              <classId>C000104724</classId>
            </annualClassInfo>
            <annualClassInfo>
              <className>Pinnacle III (May 1, 1998 to December 31, 2001)</className>
              <classId>C000109521</classId>
            </annualClassInfo>
            <annualClassInfo>
              <className>Pinnacle IV (January 1, 2002 to April 30, 2007)</className>
              <classId>C000109522</classId>
            </annualClassInfo>
            <annualClassInfo>
              <className>Pinnacle V (May 1, 2007 to December 31, 2011)</className>
              <classId>C000109523</classId>
            </annualClassInfo>
            <annualClassInfo>
              <className>Pinnacle V (post 1-1-12)</className>
              <classId>C000109527</classId>
            </annualClassInfo>
            <annualClassInfo>
              <className>VAROOM II</className>
              <classId>C000110550</classId>
            </annualClassInfo>
          </reportClass>
        </item2>
        <item3>
          <investmentCompActFileNo>811-04846</investmentCompActFileNo>
          <securitiesActFileNumbers>
            <securitiesActFileNo>
              <fileNumber>333-167372</fileNumber>
            </securitiesActFileNo>
          </securitiesActFileNumbers>
        </item3>
        <item4>
          <lastDayOfFiscalYear>12/31/2023</lastDayOfFiscalYear>
          <isThisFormBeingFiledLate>false</isThisFormBeingFiledLate>
          <isThisTheLastTimeIssuerFilingThisForm>false</isThisTheLastTimeIssuerFilingThisForm>
        </item4>
        <item5>
          <aggregateSalePriceOfSecuritiesSold>4016415.07</aggregateSalePriceOfSecuritiesSold>
          <aggregatePriceOfSecuritiesRedeemedOrRepurchasedInFiscalYear>39262405.91</aggregatePriceOfSecuritiesRedeemedOrRepurchasedInFiscalYear>
          <aggregatePriceOfSecuritiesRedeemedOrRepurchasedAnyPrior>644203008.21</aggregatePriceOfSecuritiesRedeemedOrRepurchasedAnyPrior>
          <totalAvailableRedemptionCredits>683465414.12</totalAvailableRedemptionCredits>
          <netSales>0</netSales>
          <redemptionCreditsAvailableForUseInFutureYears>(679448999.05)</redemptionCreditsAvailableForUseInFutureYears>
          <multiplierForDeterminingRegistrationFee>0.0001476</multiplierForDeterminingRegistrationFee>
          <registrationFeeDue>0</registrationFeeDue>
        </item5>
        <item6>
          <amountOfSecuritiesDeducted>0</amountOfSecuritiesDeducted>
          <numberOfSharesOrOtherUnitsRemainingUnsold>0</numberOfSharesOrOtherUnitsRemainingUnsold>
        </item6>
        <item7>
          <interestDue>0</interestDue>
        </item7>
        <item8>
          <totalOfRegistrationFeePlusAnyInterestDue>0</totalOfRegistrationFeePlusAnyInterestDue>
        </item8>
        <item9/>
        <signature>
          <signature>/s/ Wade M. Fugate</signature>
          <nameAndTitle>Wade M. Fugate, Vice President and Controller</nameAndTitle>
          <signatureDate>03/19/2024</signatureDate>
        </signature>
      </annualFilingInfo>
    </annualFilings>
  </formData>
</edgarSubmission>
