EX-99.35 36 ex99-35.htm DIGITAL RISK REBUTTAL FINDINGS REPORT

 

CSMC 2022-NQM3 Trust ABS-15G

 

Exhibit 99.35

 

Loan Number Loan IDs Finding # Last Name Note Date Audit Category Audit Issue Finding ID Exception Finding Remediation Status Exception Rebuttal Exception Response Status Comment Initial Findings Grade Final Findings Grade Initial Loan Grade Final Loan Grade
XXXX 434067698 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 434067698 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 434067698 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. CDA in file supported the appraised value.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 432517875 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 432517875 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 432517875 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The loan file contains a CDA that supports the opinion of value in the origination appraisal report.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 432709923 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 432709923 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 432709923 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The loan file contains a CDA, dated XX/XX/XXXX which supports the appraised value.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 432261465 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 432261465 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 432261465 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The loan file contains a CDA that supports the opinion of value in the origination appraisal report.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 432709928 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 3 1
XXXX 432709928 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit Assets - Cash to Close XXXX The file did not contain evidence the borrower had the proper amount of funds required to close. The Borrower had verified assets of $XXXX. However, total assets to be verified were $XXXX. Despite, this requirement there is a shortage of verified assets in the amount of $XXXX. Resolved Rebuttal 1 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXPM)
Attached is the ernest money deposit of $XXXX

Response 1 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXAM)
Documentation received is sufficient. (Resolved)

3 1 3 1
XXXX 432709928 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The loan file contains a CDA that supports the opinion of value in the origination appraisal report.   1 1 3 1
XXXX 433283601 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 4 1
XXXX 433283601 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit Initial Application - Missing XXXX The Initial application in the file is illegible. Resolved Rebuttal 1 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXAM)
Initial app attached

Response 1 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXPM)
Documentation received is sufficient. (Resolved)

4 1 4 1
XXXX 433283601 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The loan file contains a CDA that supports the opinion of value in the origination appraisal report.   1 1 4 1
XXXX 433479768 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance HMDA - Government Monitoring XXXX The Government Monitoring Section on the application was not completed in Race Section . Home Mortgage Disclosure Act (Regulation C)12 CFR 1003.4(b)Equal Credit Opportunity Act (Regulation B)12 CFR 1002.13 Resolved Rebuttal 1 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXPM)
Loan app attached

Response 1 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXPM)
The documentation provided is sufficient to cure the finding. (Resolved)

2 1 2 1
XXXX 433479768 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 2 1
XXXX 433479768 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The loan file contains a CDA, dated XX/XX/XXXX which supports the appraised value.   1 1 2 1
XXXX 433283620 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 4 1
XXXX 433283620 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit Initial Application - Missing XXXX The Initial application is missing as required by guides. The loan application is illegible. Resolved Rebuttal 1 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXPM)
Initial app attached

Response 1 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXPM)
Documentation received is sufficient. (Resolved)

4 1 4 1
XXXX 433283620 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The loan file contains a CDA that supports the opinion of value in the origination appraisal report.   1 1 4 1
XXXX 433752657 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 3 2
XXXX 433752657 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit Program Parameters - Loan Amount XXXX The loan amount exceeds maximum allowable under the guidelines. The lender guidelines state that if the borrower owned the subject property for less than 12 months, the loan amount will be limited to XXXX% of the acquisition cost plus the costs of documented improvements. According to the appraisal in the loan file, the subject property was purchased by the borrower on XX/XX/XXXX for $XXXX. The loan-to-value was based on the appraised value of $XXXX and loan amount of $XXXX; however, the loan file did not contain documentation supporting the improvements and the increase in value as required. Resolved Rebuttal 1 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXAM)
Docs attached indicating acquisition price of $XXXX and $XXXX of improvements

Rebuttal 2 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXAM)
Property was sold on XX/XX/XXXX, recorded XX/XX/XXXX, for $XXXX. FraudGuard transaction history and supporting construction draw schedule attached.

Response 1 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXPM)
The loan file does not support a $XXXXX acquisition cost. The appraisal reflects a purchase price of $XXXX on XX/XX/XXXX. (Upheld)

Response 2 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXAM)
Documentation received is sufficient. (Resolved)

3 1 3 2
XXXX 433752657 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Other XXXX There are bars on the bedroom windows that do not have safety latches.   2 2 3 2
XXXX 433283622 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 433283622 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 433283622 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The loan file contains a CDA that supports the opinion of value in the origination appraisal report.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 433752659 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 3 1
XXXX 433752659 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit Assets - Minimum Reserves XXXX Sufficient reserves to meet underwriting requirements and PITI were not verified in the file. The Borrower had 2 other properties that closed on the same day. In total the Borrower reserves in the amount of $XXXX were required. The borrower had verified assets of $XXXX. As a result, there was a shortage of assets in the amount of $XXXX. Resolved Rebuttal 1 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXPM)
Assets doc attached showing available balance of $XXXX

Response 1 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXPM)
Documentation received is sufficient. (Resolved)

3 1 3 1
XXXX 433752659 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The loan file contains a CDA that supports the opinion of value in the origination appraisal report.   1 1 3 1
XXXX 433621031 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 433621031 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 433621031 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The loan file contains a CDA that supports the opinion of value in the origination appraisal report.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 433283636 1 of 5 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 3 1
XXXX 433283636 2 of 5 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit Initial Application - Missing XXXX The Initial application is illegible. Resolved Rebuttal 1 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXPM)
Loan app attached

Response 1 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXPM)
Documentation received is sufficient. (Resolved)

4 1 3 1
XXXX 433283636 3 of 5 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit LDP/EPL - Missing XXXX The Fraud Report provided is not completely legible. Resolved Rebuttal 1 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXPM)
Fraud report attached

Response 1 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXPM)
Documentation received is sufficient. (Resolved)

3 1 3 1
XXXX 433283636 4 of 5 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Illegible XXXX The appraisal provided was illegible. The Auditor was unable to review the appraisal report. Resolved Rebuttal 1 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXPM)
Appraisal attached

Response 1 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXPM)
Documentation received is sufficient. (Resolved)

3 1 3 1
XXXX 433283636 5 of 5 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The loan file contains a CDA that supports the opinion of value in the origination appraisal report.   1 1 3 1
XXXX 433621037 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 3 1
XXXX 433621037 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit Assets - Cash to Close XXXX The file did not contain evidence the borrower had the proper amount of funds required to close. The borrower was required to bring cash to close of $XXXX and reserves totaling $XXXX. The loan file does not contain asset documentation. Resolved Rebuttal 1 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXPM)
Asset verification attached

Response 1 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXPM)
Documentation received is sufficient. (Resolved)

3 1 3 1
XXXX 433621037 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The loan file contains a CDA that supports the opinion of value in the origination appraisal report.   1 1 3 1
XXXX 434315015 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 434315015 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 434315015 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The loan file contains a CDA, dated XX/XX/XXXX which supports the appraised value.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 434067713 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 434067713 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 434067713 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The loan file contains a CDA, dated XX/XX/XXXX which supports the appraised value.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 434315023 1 of 4 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 3 1
XXXX 434315023 2 of 4 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit Appraisal - Other XXXX There are additional appraisal findings. Subject appraisal completed XXX; FEMA Individual Assistance was authorized on XX/XX/XXXX for (XXX) in subject XXX County. Resolved Rebuttal 1 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXPM)
CDAIR attached

Response 1 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXAM)
Documentation received is sufficient. (Resolved)

3 1 3 1
XXXX 434315023 3 of 4 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 3 1
XXXX 434315023 4 of 4 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. CDA in file supports the appraised value.   1 1 3 1
XXXX 436082637 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082637 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082637 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The loan file contains a CDA which supports the opinion of value in the origination appraisal report.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 434315042 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 434315042 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 434315042 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. CDA in file supports the appraised value.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 434553282 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 434553282 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 434553282 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. CDA in file supports the appraised value.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082638 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082638 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082638 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The File contains a CDA which supports the opinion of value in the origination report.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082639 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082639 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082639 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The loan file contains a CDA which supports the opinion of value in the origination appraisal report.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 434950693 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 434950693 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 434950693 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. CDA in file supports the appraised value.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082640 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082640 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082640 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The File contains a CDA which supports the opinion of value in the origination report.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082641 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082641 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082641 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The loan file contains a CDA which supports the opinion of value in the origination appraisal report.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082642 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 3 1
XXXX 436082642 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit Hazard Insurance - Missing/Insufficient XXXX Subject transaction is a NCO refinance of a STR property. Per the guidelines, rent loss coverage is required even when the property is vacant. The hazard insurance obtained XX/XX/XXXX is a One-Shot, Residential Vacant Policy which is for new construction/remodeling. The policy does not contain rent loss coverage. The file contains an email stating since no one is living in the property, the insured does not qualify for Business Income/Loss of Rents coverage. Property was recently renovated; however, now complete. The hazard insurance policy should have been updated from One-Shot, Residential Vacant Property Policy to a 3D-P Policy with rent loss coverage. Resolved Rebuttal 1 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXPM)
ER document attached showing approval of no rent loss coverage

Response 1 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXPM)
Documentation received is sufficient. (Resolved)

3 1 3 1
XXXX 436082642 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The loan file contains a CDA which supports the opinion of value in the origination appraisal report.   1 1 3 1
XXXX 436082643 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082643 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082643 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The File contains a CDA which supports the opinion of value in theorigination report.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436021027 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436021027 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436021027 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The File contains a CDA which supports the opinion of value in the origination report.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082644 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082644 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082644 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The loan file contains a CDA which supports the opinion of value in the origination appraisal report.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082645 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082645 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082645 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The loan file contains a CDA which supports the opinion of value in the origination appraisal report.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082646 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082646 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082646 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The loan file contains a CDA which supports the opinion of value in the origination appraisal report.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082647 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082647 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082647 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The loan file contains a CDA which supports the opinion of value in the origination appraisal report.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436021038 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436021038 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436021038 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The loan file contains a CDA which supports the opinion of value in the origination appraisal report.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082648 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082648 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082648 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The loan file contains a CDA which supports the opinion of value in the origination appraisal report.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082649 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082649 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082649 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The loan file contains a CDA which supports the opinion of value in the origination appraisal report.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082650 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082650 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082650 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is not supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The loan file did not contain a CDA, Field Review, or 2nd Appraisal to support the origination appraised value. Lender did include an exception for not requiring the CDA but as a securitization review that is a requirement and a Lender Exception is invalid. Resolved Rebuttal 1 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXPM)
2nd Appraisal attached

Response 1 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXPM)
Second appraisal provided and supports original first appraisal value. (Resolved)

3 1 1 1
XXXX 436082651 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082651 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082651 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The loan file contains a CDA which supports the opinion of value in the origination appraisal report.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436021043 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436021043 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436021043 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. CDA in file supports the appraised value.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082652 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082652 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082652 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The loan file contains a CDA which supports the opinion of value in the origination appraisal report.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082653 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082653 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082653 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The loan file contains a CDA which supports the opinion of value in the origination appraisal report.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436021044 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436021044 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436021044 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The loan file contains a CDA which supports the opinion of value in the origination appraisal report.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082654 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082654 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082654 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The file contains a CDA which supports the opinion of value in the origination report.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082655 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082655 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082655 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The loan file contains a CDA which supports the opinion of value in the origination appraisal report.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082656 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082656 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082656 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The loan file contains a CDA which supports the opinion of value in the origination appraisal report.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436021060 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 3 1
XXXX 436021060 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit Title Commitment - Missing/Incomplete XXXX The file contains Schedule A of the Title Commitment; however, missing Schedule B, C and D. Resolved Rebuttal 1 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXPM)
Title Commitment schedules attached

Response 1 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXAM)
Documentation received is sufficient. (Resolved)

3 1 3 1
XXXX 436021060 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The loan file contains a CDA which supports the opinion of value in the origination appraisal report.   1 1 3 1
XXXX 436082657 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082657 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082657 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The loan file contains a CDA which supports the opinion of value in the origination appraisal report.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082658 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082658 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082658 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The File contains a CDA which supports the opinion of value in theorigination report   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082659 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082659 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082659 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The File contains a CDA which supports the opinion of value in the origination appraisal report.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082660 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082660 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082660 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The loan file contains a CDA which supports the opinion of value in the origination appraisal report.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082661 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082661 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082661 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The loan file contains a CDA which supports the opinion of value in the origination appraisal report.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082662 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082662 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082662 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The loan file contains a CDA which supports the opinion of value in the origination appraisal report.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082663 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082663 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082663 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The loan file contains a CDA which supports the opinion of value in the origination appraisal report.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082664 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082664 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082664 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The loan file contains a CDA which supports the opinion of value in the origination appraisal report.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082665 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082665 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082665 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The File contains a CDA which supports the opinion of value in the origination report.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082666 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082666 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082666 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The loan file contains a CDA which supports the opinion of value in the origination appraisal report.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082667 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082667 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082667 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied.The File contains a CDA which supports the opinion of value in the origination report.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082668 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082668 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082668 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The loan file contains a CDA which supports the opinion of value in the origination appraisal report.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082669 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082669 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082669 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The loan file contains a CDA which supports the opinion of value in the origination appraisal report.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 435050669 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 3 1
XXXX 435050669 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 3 1
XXXX 435050669 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is not supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The loan file did not contain a CDA, Field Review, or 2nd Appraisal to support the origination appraised value. Resolved Rebuttal 1 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXAM)
ER approval for guideline exception attached

Response 1 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXAM)
Exception granted by Investor. (Resolved)

Response 2 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXPM)
A LRA secondary valuation production was provided and supports the original appraised value. (Resolved)

3 1 3 1
XXXX 434315058 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 434315058 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 434315058 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is not supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The loan file did not contain a CDA, Field Review, or 2nd Appraisal to support the origination appraised value. Resolved Rebuttal 1 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXAM)
VRA attached

Response 1 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXPM)
Documentation received is sufficient. (Resolved)

1 1 1 1
XXXX 434315059 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 3 1
XXXX 434315059 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 3 1
XXXX 434315059 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is not supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The loan file did not contain a CDA, Field Review, or 2nd Appraisal to support the origination appraised value. Resolved Rebuttal 1 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXAM)
Executive approval guideline exception attached

Rebuttal 2 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXPM)
Client responded. VRA provided.

Response 1 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXAM)
Exception granted by Investor. (Resolved)

Response 2 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXAM)
VRA provided and supports original appraised value. (Resolved)

3 1 3 1
XXXX 434950719 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 3 1
XXXX 434950719 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit Appraisal - Other XXXX There are additional appraisal findings. Subject appraisal completed XX/XX/XXXX, FEMA Individual Assistance was authorized for (XXX) on XX/XX/XXXX for subject XXX County. Resolved Rebuttal 1 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXPM)
Property Inspection report attached

Response 1 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXAM)
Documentation received is sufficient to clear the exception. (Resolved)

3 1 3 1
XXXX 434950719 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is not supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The loan file did not contain a CDA, Field Review, or 2nd Appraisal to support the origination appraised value. Resolved Rebuttal 1 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXPM)
Loan originated under guidelines XXXX which state that for a 5-8 MF or 2-8 MU only one appraisal is required

Response 1 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXAM)
Documentation received is not sufficient to clear the exception. A VRA is required for all 5-8 MF and all mixed use properties. (Upheld)

Response 2 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXPM)
Documentation received is sufficient. (Resolved)

3 1 3 1
XXXX 435050670 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 3 1
XXXX 435050670 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 3 1
XXXX 435050670 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is not supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The loan file did not contain a CDA, Field Review, or 2nd Appraisal to support the origination appraised value. Resolved Rebuttal 1 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXPM)
Loan originated under guidelines 2021_09v2 which state that for a 5-8 MF or 2-8 MU only one appraisal is required

Rebuttal 2 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXAM)
VRA uploaded.

Response 1 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXAM)
A VRA secondary valuation product is required for the subject property type. (Upheld)

Response 2 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXAM)
Documentation received is sufficient. (Resolved)

3 1 3 1
XXXX 436021068 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 3 1
XXXX 436021068 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit Income - Rental Property/Missing Lease XXXX Subject transaction is a refinance of a 6 unit multi-family property. File documentation reflects leases were provided for all units. The file contains leases for units 1-5; however, missing lease for unit 6. Resolved Rebuttal 1 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXPM)
Lease 6 attached

Response 1 (XX/XX/XXXX XX:XXPM)
Documentation received is sufficient. (Resolved)

3 1 3 1
XXXX 436021068 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The loan file contains a CDA which supports the opinion of value in the origination appraisal report.   1 1 3 1
XXXX 436021069 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436021069 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436021069 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. CDA in file supports the appraised value.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082670 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082670 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082670 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX The appraised value was supported within 10% and all applicable appraisal guidelines were satisfied. The loan file contains a VRA which supports the value in the origination appraisal report.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082671 1 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Compliance No Compliance Findings XXXX The loan is in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082671 2 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Credit No Credit Findings XXXX The loan meets all applicable credit guidelines.   1 1 1 1
XXXX 436082671 3 of 3 XXXX XX/XX/XXXX Valuation Appraisal - Value is supported within 10% of original appraisal amount XXXX Subject contains a VRA which did not support value in origination appraisal report within 10%. However; VRA value was used for LTV calculation for subject transaction.   1 1 1 1