X0306 4 2019-10-01 0000789933 NACCO INDUSTRIES INC NC 0001247996 WILLIAMS CLARA R NACCO INDUSTRIES, INC. 5875 LANDERBROOK DRIVE, STE. 220 MAYFIELD HEIGHTS OH 44124 1 Member of a group Class A Common Stock 2019-10-01 4 A 0 452 A 14569 I By Spouse Class A Common Stock 11750 I By Assoc II Class A Common Stock 68094 I By Trust Class A Common Stock 7104 I By AssocII/Spouse Class A Common Stock 9945 I By AssocII/Daughter 2 Class A Common Stock 2553 I By Trust/Child2 Class A Common Stock 8570 I By Assoc II/Daughter Class A Common Stock 3927 I Trust/Child1 Class B Common Stock Class A Common Stock 69458 69458 I By RAI Class B Common Stock Class A Common Stock 41827 41827 I by RAIV B Class B Common Stock Class A Common Stock 9195 9195 I By Trust Spouse's shares of Class A Common Stock awarded to the Reporting Person's spouse as "Required Shares" under the company's Non-Employee Directors' Equity Compensation Plan N/A By Spouse. Reporting Person disclaims beneficial ownership of all such shares. Represents the Reporting Person's proportionate limited partnership interest in shares held by Rankin Associates II, L.P. Held by trust for the benefit of Reporting Person. Represents the Reporting Person's spouse's proportionate limited partnership interest in shares held by Rankin Associates II, L.P. Reporting Person disclaims beneficial ownership of all such shares. Represents the Reporting Person's daughter's proportionate limited partnership interest in shares held by Rankin Associates II, L.P. Reporting Person disclaims beneficial ownership of all such shares. Held by Trust, Reporting Person's spouse is Trustee, for the benefit of Reporting Person's minor child. Reporting Person disclaims beneficial ownership of all such shares. RAI-Represents Reporting Person's limited partnership interest in shares held by Rankin Associates I, L.P. /s/ John D. Neumann, attorney-in-fact 2019-10-02