X0306 4 2018-03-08 0000789933 NACCO INDUSTRIES INC NC 0001521467 TIPTON HARRY B 5875 LANDERBROOK DR., SUITE 220 CLEVELAND OH 44124 1 Officer of a subsidiary, NAC Class A Common Stock 2018-03-08 4 J 0 34 D 0 I By Tipton LLC Class A Common Stock 2018-03-08 4 J 0 34 A 35 D Class A Common Stock 2018-03-08 4 J 0 66 A 101 D Distribution from a limited liability company for which the Reporting Person is a member. N/A Represents the Reporting Person's proportionate interests in shares held by Tipton, LLC. /s/ Jesse L. Adkins, attorney-in-fact 2018-03-12