X0306 5 2016-12-31 0 0 0000789933 NACCO INDUSTRIES INC NC 0001247972 TAPLIN BEATRICE B NACCO INDUSTRIES, INC. 5875 LANDERBROOK DRIVE, STE. 220 MAYFIELD HEIGHTS OH 44124 1 Member of a group Class A Common Stock 2016-06-24 5 G 0 16950 0 D 62470 I BBT/Wells Fargo Trust Class A Common Stock 2016-12-29 5 G 0 11250 0 D 62470 I BBT/Wells Fargo Trust Class A Common Stock 2016-12-16 5 G 0 54750 0 D 62470 I BBT/Wells Fargo Trust Class A Common Stock 2016-03-01 5 J 0 1962 0 D 2 I Shares held in Trust: 2012 Taplin Annuity Trust #2 Class A Common Stock 2016-07-21 5 G 0 780 0 D 62470 I BBT/Wells Fargo Trust Class A Common Stock 2016-03-01 5 J 0 1962 0 D 2 I Shares held in Trust: 2012 Taplin Annuity Trust #2 Class A Common Stock 2016-03-01 5 J 0 1962 0 D 2 I Shares held in Trust: 2012 Taplin Annuity Trust #2 Class A Common Stock 2016-03-01 5 J 0 1962 0 D 2 I Shares held in Trust: 2012 Taplin Annuity Trust #2 Class A Common Stock 10104 I Proportionate membership interest in shares held by Abigail, LLC Class A Common Stock 29550 I Taplin Annuity Trust#1 Class A Common Stock 47640 I By Marital Trust/PNC Class A Common Stock 5250 I By Trust/GC#5 Class A Common Stock 5250 I By Trust/GC#4 Class A Common Stock 5250 I By Trust/GC#1 Class A Common Stock 5250 I By Trust/GC#2 Class A Common Stock 5250 I By Trust/GC#3 Class B Common Stock 0 Class A Common Stock 310000 310000 I By Marital Trust Class B Common Stock 0 Class A Common Stock 27310 27310 I By Trust N/A Held by Trust, National City Bank and Beatrice B. Taplin, Co-Trustees, for the benefit of Beatrice B. Taplin. Shares distributed from GRAT as per the terms of the GRAT. Shares held in Trust: 2011 Taplin Annuity Trust #1. Reporting Person serves as co-trustee with National City Bank of Trusts for the benefit of Reporting Person's grandchildren. Reporting Person disclaims beneficially ownership of all such shares. Shares represent the Thomas E. Taplin Marital Trust FBO Beatrice B. Taplin under Agreement dated 1/21/1966 as amended and restated between Thomas E. Taplin and National City Bank. National City Bank and Beatrice B. Taplin, Trustees. "Remark on Insider Relationship" - As a member of a "group" deemed to own more than 10% of an equity security as a result of being a party to a Stockholders' Agreement, dated as of March 15, 1990, beneficially owned by each of the signatories to such agreement (the "Agreement"), the Reporting Person disclaims beneficial ownership of any such shares of Stock owned by any other signatory to the Agreement. /s/ Jesse L. Adkins, attorney-in-fact 2017-02-14