X0202 5 2005-12-31 0 0 0000789933 NACCO INDUSTRIES INC NC 0001247860 BUTLER JOHN C JR NACCO INDUSTRIES, INC. 5875 LANDERBROOK DRIVE, STE. 300 MAYFIELD HEIGHTS OH 44124 1 1 VP-Corp Dev and Treasurer Member of a Group Class A Common Stock 2005-11-28 2005-11-28 5 J 0 523 0 A 38440 I By Spouse/Trust Class A Common Stock 1530 I By Trust-Child 1 Class A Common Stock 5294 I By Assoc II/Spouse Class A Common Stock 2800 I By IRA Class A Common Stock 6674 I By Trust Class A Common Stock 3973 I By Assoc II/Child 1 Class A Common Stock 3973 I Assoc II Class A Common Stock 3239 I By Assoc II/Child 2 Class A Common Stock 1375 I By Trust-Child 2 Held by Trust, Alfred M. Rankin, Jr., Trustee, for the benefit of Reporting Person's Spouse. Reporting Person disclaims benefici al ownership of all such shares. Shares of Class A Common Stock distributed from Reporting Person?s Spouse?s Father?s self-declaration trust into the Reporting Person?s Spouse?s trust. Held by Trust, John C. Butler, Jr., Trustee, for the benefit of Reporting Person's minor child. Reporting Person disclaims beneficial ownership of all such shares. Represents the Reporting Person's spouse's proportionate limited partnership interests in shares held by Rankin Associates II, L. P. Reporting Person disclaims beneficial ownership of all such shares. Held in an Individual Retirement Account for the benefit of the Reporting Person. Reporting Person serves as Trustee with National City Bank of the J.C. Butler, Jr. Revocable Trust. Represents the Reporting Person's child's proportionate limited partnership interests in shares held by Rankin Associates II, L.P . Reporting Person disclaims beneficial ownership of all such shares. Represents the Reporting Person's proportionate limited partnership interests in shares held by Rankin Associates II, L.P.------- "Remark on Insider relationship to Issuer" As a member of a "group" deemed to own more than 10% of an equity security as a result of being a party to a Stockholders' Agreement, dated as of March 15, 1990, beneficially owned by each of the signatories to such agreement (the "Agreement"), the Reporting Person disclaims beneficial ownership of any such shares of Stock owned by any other signatory to the Agreement. /s/Charles A. Bittenbender, attorney-in-fact for John C. Butler, Jr. 2006-02-14