XML 66 R16.htm IDEA: XBRL DOCUMENT v3.20.1
Electric plant, construction and related agreements
12 Months Ended
Dec. 31, 2019
Property, Plant and Equipment [Abstract]  
Electric plant, construction and related agreements Electric plant, construction and related agreements:
a. Electric plant
We, along with Georgia Power, have entered into agreements providing for the purchase and subsequent joint operation of certain electric generating plants. Each co-owner is responsible for providing their own financing. The plant investments
disclosed in the table below represent our undivided interest in each plant. A summary of our plant investments and related accumulated depreciation as of December 31, 2019 and 2018 is as follows:
20192018
(dollars in thousands)
PlantInvestmentAccumulated
Depreciation
InvestmentAccumulated
Depreciation
In-service(1)
Owned property
Vogtle Units No. 1 & No. 2
(Nuclear – 30% ownership)
$2,989,693  $(1,815,258) $2,975,727  $(1,775,569) 
Vogtle Units No. 3 & No. 4
(Nuclear – 30% ownership)
56,991  (4,956) 55,861  (3,479) 
Hatch Units No. 1 & No. 2
(Nuclear – 30% ownership)
934,567  (462,063) 910,259  (441,240) 
Wansley Units No. 1 & No. 2
(Fossil – 30% ownership)
749,971  (360,014) 655,618  (311,606) 
Scherer Unit No. 1
(Fossil – 60% ownership)
1,284,508  (545,908) 1,222,538  (442,840) 
Doyle (Combustion Turbine - 100% ownership)
137,513  (113,259) 137,133  (109,509) 
Rocky Mountain Units No. 1, No. 2 & No. 3
(Hydro – 75% ownership)
618,939  (270,058) 618,621  (258,359) 
Hartwell (Combustion Turbine - 100% ownership)
226,316  (110,008) 226,156  (105,540) 
Hawk Road (Combustion Turbine - 100% ownership)
260,494  (67,065) 254,925  (75,308) 
Talbot (Combustion Turbine - 100% ownership)
294,809  (144,847) 293,638  (136,007) 
Chattahoochee (Combined cycle - 100% ownership)
317,210  (150,805) 315,463  (141,279) 
Smith (Combined cycle - 100% ownership)
655,106  (195,638) 648,464  (179,486) 
Wansley (Combustion Turbine – 30% ownership)
3,887  (3,738) 3,887  (3,626) 
Transmission plant96,198  (59,096) 95,861  (56,973) 
Other96,522  (57,826) 93,503  (56,193) 
Property under capital lease:
Scherer Unit No. 2 (Fossil – 60% leasehold)
789,991  (472,486) 776,316  (447,391) 
Total in-service$9,512,715  $(4,833,025) $9,283,970  $(4,544,405) 
Construction work in progress
Vogtle Units No. 3 & No. 4
$4,617,654  $3,600,631  
Environmental and other
generation improvements
198,357  263,146  
Other885  2,265  
Total construction work in progress$4,816,896  $3,866,042  
(1)Amounts include plant acquisition adjustments at December 31, 2019 and 2018 of $197,000,000.

Our proportionate share of direct expenses of joint operation of the above plants is included in the corresponding operating expense captions (e.g., fuel, production) on the accompanying Statement of Revenues and Expenses.
b. Construction
Vogtle Units No. 3 and No. 4
We, Georgia Power, the Municipal Electric Authority of Georgia, and the City of Dalton, Georgia, acting by and through its Board of Water, Light and Sinking Fund Commissioners, doing business as Dalton Utilities (collectively, the Co-owners) are parties to an Ownership Participation Agreement that, along with other agreements, governs our participation in two additional nuclear units under construction at Plant Vogtle, Units No. 3 and No. 4. The Co-owners appointed Georgia Power to act as agent under this agreement. Our ownership interest and proportionate share of the cost to construct these units is 30%. Pursuant to this agreement, Georgia Power has designated Southern Nuclear Operating Company, Inc. as its agent for licensing, engineering, procurement, contract management, construction and pre-operation services.
In 2008, Georgia Power, acting for itself and as agent for the Co-owners, entered into an Engineering, Procurement and Construction Agreement (the EPC Agreement) with Westinghouse Electric Company LLC and Stone & Webster, Inc., which was subsequently acquired by Westinghouse and changed its name to WECTEC Global Project Services Inc. (collectively, Westinghouse). Pursuant to the EPC Agreement, Westinghouse agreed to design, engineer, procure, construct and test two 1,100 megawatt nuclear units using the Westinghouse AP1000 technology and related facilities at Plant Vogtle.
Until March 2017, construction on Units No. 3 and No. 4 continued under the substantially fixed price EPC Agreement. In March 2017, Westinghouse filed for bankruptcy protection under Chapter 11 of the United States Bankruptcy Code. Effective in July 2017, Georgia Power, acting for itself and as agent for the other Co-owners, and Westinghouse entered into a services agreement (the Services Agreement), pursuant to which Westinghouse is providing facility design and engineering services, procurement and technical support and staff augmentation on a time and materials cost basis. The Services Agreement provides that it will continue until the start-up and testing of Vogtle Units No. 3 and No. 4 is complete and electricity is generated and sold from both units. The Services Agreement is terminable by the Co-owners upon 30 days’ written notice.
In October 2017, Georgia Power, acting for itself and as agent for the other Co-owners, entered into a construction completion agreement with Bechtel Power Corporation, pursuant to which Bechtel serves as the primary contractor for the remaining construction activities for Vogtle Units No. 3 and No. 4 (the Bechtel Agreement). The Bechtel Agreement is a cost reimbursable plus fee arrangement, whereby Bechtel is reimbursed for actual costs plus a base fee and an at-risk fee, which is subject to adjustment based on Bechtel’s performance against cost and schedule targets. Each Co-owner is severally, and not jointly, liable for its proportionate share, based on its ownership interest, of all amounts owed to Bechtel under the Bechtel Agreement. The Co-owners may terminate the Bechtel Agreement at any time for their convenience, provided that the Co-owners will be required to pay amounts related to work performed prior to the termination (including the applicable portion of the base fee), certain termination-related costs and, at certain stages of the work, the applicable portion of the at-risk fee. Bechtel may terminate the Bechtel Agreement under certain circumstances, including certain Co-owner suspensions of work, certain breaches of the Bechtel Agreement by the Co-owners, Co-owner insolvency and certain other events.
Cost and Schedule
Our current budget for our 30% ownership interest in Vogtle Units No. 3 and No. 4 is $7.5 billion, which includes capital costs, allowance for funds used during construction, our allocation of the project-level contingency and a separate Oglethorpe-level contingency. As of December 31, 2019, our total investment in the additional Vogtle units was approximately $4.9 billion. The Georgia Public Service Commission approved in-service dates for Vogtle Units No. 3 and No. 4 are November 2021 and November 2022, respectively.
The current project-level budget includes an $800 million construction contingency estimate, of which our 30% interest is $240 million. As of December 31, 2019, approximately $307 million of this project-level contingency, or $92 million for our 30% interest, was allocated to the base capital cost forecast for cost risks including, among other factors, construction productivity; craft labor incentives; adding resources for supervision, field support, project management, initial test program, start-up, and operations and engineering support; subcontracts; and procurement. Georgia Power has stated its expectation to allocate the remainder of this project-level contingency by completion of the project. The project-level contingency is separate and in addition to our Oglethorpe-level contingency.
As part of its ongoing process, Southern Nuclear continues to evaluate cost and schedule forecasts on a regular basis to incorporate current information available, particularly in the areas of commodity installation, system turnovers and workforce statistics.
In April 2019, Southern Nuclear completed a cost and schedule validation process to verify and update quantities of commodities remaining to install, labor hours to install remaining quantities and related productivity, testing and system turnover requirements, and forecasted staffing needs and related costs. This process confirmed the total estimated project capital cost forecast for Vogtle Units No. 3 and No. 4 and did not change the regulatory-approved in-service dates of November 2021 for Unit No. 3 and November 2022 for Unit No. 4. As part of this process, Southern Nuclear also established aggressive target values for monthly construction production and system turnover activities as part of a strategy to maintain margin to the regulatory-approved in-service dates. The project has faced challenges with the April 2019 aggressive strategy targets, including, but not limited to, electrical and pipefitting labor productivity and closure rates for work packages, which resulted in a backlog of activities and completion percentages below the April 2019 aggressive strategy targets.
In February 2020, Southern Nuclear updated its cost and schedule forecast, which did not change the projected overall capital cost forecast and confirmed the regulatory-approved in-service dates. This update included initiatives to improve productivity while refining and extending system turnover plans and certain near term milestone dates. Achieving completion in advance of the regulatory-approved in-service dates relies on meeting increased monthly production target values during 2020. Specifically, existing craft, including subcontractors, construction productivity must improve and be sustained above historical average levels, appropriate levels of craft laborers, particularly electrical and pipefitter craft labor, must be maintained, and additional supervision and other field support resources must be retained. Southern Nuclear and Georgia Power continue to believe that pursuit of an aggressive site work plan is an appropriate strategy to achieve completion of the units by their regulatory-approved in-service dates.
In February 2020, Southern Nuclear also provided a schedule benchmark that forecasts production levels and adjusts project milestones to align with the regulatory-approved in-service dates. We believe the production levels and timeframes in this benchmark provide reasonable assurance that Units No. 3 and No. 4 will meet the regulatory-approved in-service dates of November 2021 and November 2022, respectively.
As construction, including subcontract work, continues and testing and system turnover activities increase, risks remain that challenges with management of contractors and vendors; subcontractor performance; supervision of craft labor and related craft labor productivity, particularly in the installation of electrical and mechanical commodities, ability to attract and retain craft labor and/or related cost escalation; procurement, fabrication, delivery, assembly, installation, system turnover, and the initial testing and start-up, including any required engineering changes or any remediation related thereto, of plant systems, structures or components (some of which are based on new technology that has only within the last few years began initial operation in the global nuclear industry at this scale), or regional transmission upgrades, any of which may require additional labor and/or materials; or other issues could arise and further impact the projected schedule and estimated cost.
Additionally, the current coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic may disrupt or delay construction, testing, supervisory and support activities at Vogtle Units No. 3 and No. 4. Southern Nuclear has implemented policies and procedures designed to mitigate the risk of transmission at the construction site, including limiting exposure of individuals who are showing symptoms consistent with coronavirus, being tested for coronavirus or in close contact with such persons, self-quarantine and additional precautionary measures. It is too early to determine what impact, if any, suspected or actual cases may have on the current construction schedule or budget.
There have been technical and procedural challenges to the construction and licensing of Vogtle Units No. 3 and No. 4 at the federal and state level and additional challenges may arise. Processes are in place that are designed to assure compliance with the requirements specified in the Westinghouse Design Control Document and the combined construction and operating licenses, including inspections by Southern Nuclear and the Nuclear Regulatory Commission that occur throughout construction. As a result of such compliance processes, certain license amendment requests have been filed and approved or are pending before the Nuclear Regulatory Commission. Various design and other licensing-based compliance matters, including the timely submittal by Southern Nuclear of inspections, tests, analyses, and acceptance documentation for each unit and the related reviews and approvals by the Nuclear Regulatory Commission necessary to support Nuclear Regulatory Commission authorization to load fuel, may arise, which may result in additional license amendments or require other resolution. If any license amendment requests or other licensing-based compliance issues are not resolved in a timely manner, there may be further delays in the project schedule that could result in increased costs to the Co-owners.
The ultimate outcome of these matters cannot be determined at this time.
Co-owner Contracts and Other Information
In November 2017, the Co-owners entered into an amendment to their joint ownership agreements for Vogtle Units No. 3 and No. 4 to provide for, among other conditions, additional Co-owner approval requirements. These joint ownership agreements, including the Co-owner approval requirements, were subsequently amended, effective August 31, 2018. As described below, certain provisions of the Joint Ownership Agreements were modified further on September 26, 2018 by the Term Sheet that was memorialized on February 18, 2019 when the Co-owners entered into certain amendments (the Global Amendments) to the Joint Ownership Agreements (as amended, the Joint Ownership Agreements).
On January 11, 2018, the Georgia Public Service Commission issued an order related to the construction of Vogtle Units No. 3 and No. 4. Among other actions, the Public Service Commission (i) accepted Georgia Power’s recommendation to
continue construction of Vogtle Units No. 3 and No. 4, with Southern Nuclear serving as construction manager and Bechtel as primary contractor and (ii) approved the revised schedule placing Unit No. 3 in service in November 2021 and Unit No. 4 in service in November 2022. Third parties have filed two petitions with the Fulton County Superior Court appealing the Georgia Public Service Commission’s January 11, 2018 order. On December 21, 2018, the Superior Court granted Georgia Power’s motion to dismiss the two appeals. On January 9, 2019, those parties appealed that decision to the Georgia Court of Appeals. On October 29, 2019, the Georgia Court of appeals remanded the case to the Fulton County Superior Court to clarify its ruling (i) that the Georgia Public Service Commission’s January 11, 2018 order was not a final, appealable decision and (ii) whether the petitioners showed that review of the Public Service Commission’s final order would not provide them an adequate remedy. Georgia Power has stated that it believes the petitions have no merit; however, an adverse outcome in the appeal combined with subsequent adverse action by the Public Service Commission could have a material impact on our financial condition and results of operations.
As a result of an increase in the total project capital cost forecast and Georgia Power’s decision not to seek recovery of its allocation of the increase in the base capital costs and the increased construction budget in connection with Georgia Power’s 19th Vogtle construction monitoring (VCM) report in 2018, the holders of at least 90% of the ownership interests in Vogtle Units No. 3 and No. 4 were required to vote to continue construction. In September 2018, the Co-owners unanimously voted to continue construction of Vogtle Units No. 3 and No. 4.
In connection with the September 2018 vote to continue construction, Georgia Power entered into a binding term sheet with the other Co-owners and MEAG’s wholly-owned subsidiaries MEAG Power SPVJ, LLC, MEAG Power SPVM, LLC, and MEAG Power SPVP, LLC that mitigated certain financial exposure for the other Co-owners and offered to purchase production tax credits from each of the other Co-Owners, at that Co-owner’s option (the Term Sheet). On February 18, 2019, the Co-owners entered into the Global Amendments to memorialize the provisions of the Term Sheet. Pursuant to the Global Amendments and consistent with the Term Sheet, the Joint Ownership Agreements provide that:
each Co-owner is obligated to pay its proportionate share of construction costs for Vogtle Units No. 3 and No. 4 based on its ownership interest up to (i) the estimated cost at completion (“EAC”) for Vogtle Units No. 3 and No. 4 which formed the basis of Georgia Power’s forecast of $8.4 billion in Georgia Power’s nineteenth VCM report filed with the Georgia Public Service Commission plus (ii) $800 million of additional construction costs;
Georgia Power will be responsible for 55.7% of construction costs, subject to exceptions, that exceed the EAC in the nineteenth VCM report by $800 million to $1.6 billion (resulting in up to $80 million of potential additional costs to Georgia Power which would save Oglethorpe up to $44 million), with the remaining Co-owners responsible for 44.3% of such costs pro rata in accordance with their respective ownership interests (equal to 24.5% for our 30% ownership interest); and
Georgia Power will be responsible for 65.7% of construction costs, subject to exceptions, that exceed the EAC in the nineteenth VCM report by $1.6 billion to $2.1 billion (resulting in up to a further $100 million of potential additional costs to Georgia Power which would save Oglethorpe up to an additional $55 million), with the remaining Co-owners responsible for 34.3% of such costs pro rata in accordance with their respective ownership interests (equal to 19.0% for our 30% ownership interest).
If the EAC is revised and exceeds the EAC in the nineteenth VCM report by more than $2.1 billion, each of the Co-owners, other than Georgia Power, will have a one-time option at the time the project budget forecast is so revised to tender a portion of its ownership interest to Georgia Power in exchange for Georgia Power’s agreement to pay 100% of such Co-owner’s remaining share of construction costs in excess of the EAC in the nineteenth VCM report plus $2.1 billion. In this event, Georgia Power would have the option of cancelling the project in lieu of purchasing a portion of the ownership interest of any other Co-owner. If Georgia Power accepts the offer to purchase a portion of another Co-owner’s ownership interest in Vogtle Units No. 3 and No. 4, the ownership interest to be conveyed from the tendering Co-owner to Georgia Power will be calculated based on the proportion of the cumulative amount of construction costs paid by each such tendering Co-owner and by Georgia Power as of the commercial operation date of Vogtle Unit No. 4. For purposes of this calculation, payments made by Georgia Power on behalf of another Co-owner in accordance with the second and third bullets above will be treated as payments made by the applicable Co-owner. This option to tender a portion of our interest to Georgia Power upon such a budget increase would allow us to freeze our construction budget associated with the Vogtle project in exchange for a portion of our 30% ownership interest.
In the event the actual costs of construction at completion of a unit are less than the EAC reflected in the nineteenth VCM report and (i) Vogtle Unit No. 3 is placed in service by the currently scheduled date of November 2021 or (ii) Vogtle Unit No. 4 is placed in service by the currently scheduled date of November 2022, Georgia Power will be entitled to 60.7% of the cost savings with respect to the relevant unit and the remaining Co-owners will be entitled to 39.3% of such savings on a pro rata basis in accordance with their respective ownership interests.
Pursuant to the Global Amendments, the Co-owners will continue to retain a third party to independently consult, advise and report to the Co-owners on issues pertaining to (i) project management and controls, (ii) organizational controls, (iii) commercial management plans and (iv) interim project reports until released by 67% of the Co-owners.
Pursuant to the Joint Ownership Agreements, as amended by the Global Amendments, the holders of at least 90% of the ownership interests in Vogtle Units No. 3 and No. 4 must vote to continue construction, or can vote to suspend construction, if certain adverse events occur, including: (i) the bankruptcy of Toshiba Corporation; (ii) termination or rejection in bankruptcy of certain agreements, including the Services Agreement, the Bechtel Agreement or the agency agreement with Southern Nuclear; (iii) Georgia Power publicly announces its intention not to submit for rate recovery any portion of its investment in Vogtle Units No. 3 and No. 4 (or associated financing costs) or the Georgia Public Service Commission determines that any of Georgia Power's costs relating to the construction of Vogtle Units No. 3 and No. 4 will not be recovered in retail rates, excluding any additional amounts paid by Georgia Power on behalf of the other Co-owners pursuant to the Global Amendment provisions described above and the first 6% of costs during any six-month VCM reporting period that are disallowed by the Public Service Commission for recovery, or for which Georgia Power elects not to seek cost recovery, through retail rates or (iv) an incremental extension of one year or more over the most recently approved schedule. In addition, pursuant to the Joint Ownership Agreements, the required approval of holders of ownership interests in Vogtle Units No. 3 and No. 4 is at least (i) 90% for a change of the primary construction contractor and (ii) 67% for material amendments to the Services Agreement or agreements with Southern Nuclear or the primary construction contractor, including the Bechtel Agreement.
The Global Amendments provide that Georgia Power may cancel the project at any time at its sole discretion. In the event that Georgia Power determines to cancel the project or fewer than 90% of the Co-owners vote to continue construction upon the occurrence of a subsequent project adverse event, we and the other Co-owners would assess our options for the Vogtle project. If the investment were to be written off, we would seek regulatory accounting treatment to amortize the investment over a long-term period, which requires the approval of our board of directors, and we would submit the regulatory accounting treatment details to the Rural Utilities Service for its approval. Further, if Georgia Power or the Co-owners decided to cancel the project, the Department of Energy would have the discretion to require that we repay all amounts outstanding under our loan guarantee agreement with the Department of Energy over a five-year period as discussed in Note 7.
The ultimate outcome of these matters cannot be determined at this time.
Financing
We may borrow up to $4.6 billion in federal loans from the Federal Financing Bank guaranteed by the Department of Energy, pursuant to which we have borrowed $3.0 billion as of December 31, 2019. For additional information regarding these loans and the related loan guarantee, including conditions for future advances, potential repayment over a five-year period, covenants and events of default under the loan guarantee agreement with the Department of Energy, see Note 7.
We have also financed $1.9 billion of the capital costs of the Vogtle units through capital market debt issuances. We anticipate financing any project costs not guaranteed by the Department of Energy in the capital markets.
The ultimate outcome of these matters cannot be determined at this time.