X0303 4 2009-07-27 0 0000783603 AMERICAN SAFETY INSURANCE HOLDINGS LTD ASI 0001454716 Chorney Harris 44 CHURCH STREET P.O. BOX HM 2064 HAIMLTON D0 HM 11 BERMUDA 1 0 0 0 Common Stock 2009-07-27 4 A 0 1395 14.34 A 2395 D Common Stock 2009-07-27 4 A 0 2790 14.34 A 5185 D Shares issued under the Director Compensation Policy. Per the policy shares will be held in escrow until the 2010 Shareholders meeting. Shares issued under the Director Compensation Policy. Per the policy shares will be held in escrow until the 2010 Shareholders meeting. Shares present prorated amount based on 2007 service as Director of the Company. /s/ Harris Chorney 2009-10-28