CORRESP 2 filename2.htm Nicor Inc SEC Comment Letter Response Exhibit A

               
Exhibit A
 
Nicor
 
Significant Subsidiary Test
 
12/31/2004
 
(dollars in thousands)
 
                   
Investment and Advances
                         
                           
Triton
                         
Investment in Triton at 12/31/04
             
$
87,087
       
Advances to Triton at 12/31/04
               
-
       
               
$
87,087
       
                           
Nicor's consolidated total assets @ 12/31/04
             
$
3,975,229
       
                           
Percentage
               
2.2%
 
     
Threshold indicating subsidiary is significant
               
10.0%
 
     
                           
Total Assets
                         
                                
   
Assets @ 9/30/04
Ownership    
Nicor's
       
Triton
   
After Interco Elims
   
Percentage
   
Share
       
1997 Tranche
 
$
61,741
   
24%
 
$
14,818
       
1998 Tranche
   
185,452
   
18%
 
 
33,381
       
1999 Tranche
   
149,897
   
18%
 
 
26,981
       
2000 Tranche
   
245,795
   
10%
 
 
24,580
       
2001 Tranche
   
176,469
   
15%
 
 
26,470
       
2002 Tranche
   
142,914
   
20%
 
 
28,583
       
2003 Tranche
   
200,112
   
19%
 
 
37,521
       
               
$
192,334
       
                           
Nicor's consolidated total assets @ 12/31/04
             
$
3,975,229
       
                           
Percentage
               
4.8%
 
     
Threshold indicating subsidiary is significant
               
10.0%
 
     
                           
Equity in Income Before Income Taxes (before extraordinary items or cumulative effect of accounting changes)
                           
                           
Triton
                         
IBIT for 12 months ended 9/30/04
             
$
113,744
       
X portion allocated to Nicor
               
5.465%
 
     
Nicor's share of Triton IBIT for 12 months ended 9/30/04
               
6,216
       
Less 4Q 2003 estimate plus 4Q 2004 estimate
               
275
       
Nicor's share of Triton IBIT recorded in 2004
             
$
6,491
       
                           
Nicor's 2004 consolidated IBIT
             
$
105,341
       
Add back: Equity losses recorded by Nicor in 2004
               
2,413
       
Nicor's 2004 consolidated IBIT used for this analysis
             
$
107,754
       
                           
Percentage
               
6.0%
 
     
Threshold indicating subsidiary is significant
               
10.0%
 
     
                           
CONCLUSION:
                         
Triton is not considered a significant subsidiary accounted for by the equity method because none of the conditions listed in Rule 1-02 of Regulation S-X are met.