XML 29 R11.htm IDEA: XBRL DOCUMENT v3.8.0.1
Note 6 - Business Segments and Sales of Products
3 Months Ended
Mar. 31, 2018
Notes to Financial Statements  
Segment Reporting Disclosure [Text Block]
Note
6.
    Business Segments and Sales of Products
 
We discover, acquire, develop, produce, and market concentrates and doré containing silver, gold, lead and zinc. We are currently organized and managed in
four
segments, which represent our operating units: the Greens Creek unit, the Lucky Friday unit, the Casa Berardi unit, and the San Sebastian unit.
 
General corporate activities
not
associated with operating units and their various exploration activities, as well as discontinued operations and idle properties, are presented as “other.”  Interest expense, interest income and income taxes are considered general corporate items, and are
not
allocated to our segments.
 
The following tables present information about reportable segments for the
three
months ended
March 
31,
2018
and
2017
(in thousands):
 
   
Three Months Ended
March 31,
 
   
2018
   
2017
 
Net sales to unaffiliated customers:
               
Greens Creek
  $
65,850
    $
58,850
 
Lucky Friday
   
4,977
     
20,010
 
Casa Berardi
   
55,548
     
41,712
 
San Sebastian
   
13,334
     
21,972
 
    $
139,709
    $
142,544
 
Income (loss) from operations:
               
Greens Creek
  $
23,152
    $
14,114
 
Lucky Friday
   
(4,146
)
   
3,880
 
Casa Berardi
   
3,250
     
(2,245
)
San Sebastian
   
5,017
     
13,454
 
Other
   
(15,324
)
   
(13,332
)
    $
11,949
    $
15,871
 
 
The following table presents identifiable assets by reportable segment as of
March 
31,
2018
and
December 
31,
2017
(in thousands):
 
   
March 31,
2018
   
December 31,
2017
 
Identifiable assets:
               
Greens Creek
  $
669,042
    $
671,960
 
Lucky Friday
   
432,369
     
432,400
 
Casa Berardi
   
802,017
     
804,505
 
San Sebastian
   
67,576
     
62,198
 
Other
   
427,087
     
393,894
 
    $
2,398,091
    $
2,364,957
 
 
Our products consist of both metal concentrates, which we sell to custom smelters and brokers, and unrefined bullion bars (doré), which
may
be sold as doré or further refined before sale to precious metals traders. Revenue is recognized upon the completion of the performance obligations and transfer of control of the product to the customer.
 
For sales of metals from refined doré, the performance obligation is met and revenue is recognized at the time of transfer of control of the agreed-upon metal quantities to the customer by the refiner. For sales of doré, the performance obligation is met, the transaction price is known, and revenue is recognized at the time of transfer of title and control of the doré containing the agreed-upon metal quantities to the customer. Refining, selling and shipping costs related to sales of doré and metals from doré are recorded to cost of sales as incurred.
 
For concentrate sales, the performance obligation is met, the transaction price can be reasonably estimated, and revenue is recognized generally at the time of shipment. Concentrates sold at our Lucky Friday unit typically leave the mine and are received by the customer within the same day. However, there is a period of time between shipment of concentrates from our Greens Creek unit and their physical receipt by the customer, and judgment is required in determining when control has been transferred to the customer for those shipments. We have determined the performance obligation is met and title is transferred to the customer upon shipment of concentrate parcels from Greens Creek because, at that time,
1
) legal title is transferred to the customer,
2
) the customer has accepted the parcel and obtained the ability to realize all of the benefits from the product,
3
) the concentrate content specifications are known, have been communicated to the customer, and the customer has the significant risks and rewards of ownership of it,
4
) it is very unlikely a concentrate parcel from Greens Creek will be rejected by a customer upon physical receipt, and
5
) we have the right to payment for the parcel.
 
Judgment is required in identifying the performance obligations for our concentrate sales. Most of our concentrate sales involve “frame contracts” with smelters that can cover multiple years and specify certain terms, under which individual parcels of concentrates are sold. However, some terms are
not
specified in the frame contracts and/or can be renegotiated as part of annual amendments to the frame contract. We have determined parcel shipments represent individual performance obligations satisfied at a point in time when control of the shipment is transferred to the customer.
 
Our concentrate sales involve variable consideration, as they are subject to changes in metals prices between the time of shipment and their final settlement. However, we are able to reasonably estimate the transaction price for the concentrate sales at the time of shipment using forward prices for the month of settlement, and previously recorded sales and accounts receivable are adjusted to estimated settlement metals prices until final settlement with the customer. Also, it is unlikely a significant reversal of revenue for any
one
concentrate parcel will occur. As such, we use the expected value method to price the parcels until the final settlement date occurs, at which time the final transaction price is known. At
March 
31,
2018,
metals contained in concentrates and exposed to future price changes totaled
1.5
million ounces of silver,
6,151
ounces of gold,
11,030
tons of zinc, and
1,800
tons of lead.  However, as discussed in
Note
11
, we seek to mitigate the risk of negative price adjustments by using financially-settled forward contracts for some of our sales.
 
Sales and accounts receivable for concentrate shipments are recorded net of charges for treatment, refining, smelting losses, and other charges negotiated by us with the customers, which represent components of the transaction price. Charges are estimated by us upon shipment of concentrates based on contractual terms, and actual charges typically do
not
vary materially from our estimates. Costs charged by customers include fixed treatment and refining costs per ton of concentrate and
may
include price escalators which allow the customers to participate in the increase of lead and zinc prices above a negotiated baseline. Costs for shipping concentrates to customers are recorded to cost of sales as incurred.
 
Sales of metal concentrates and metal products are made principally to custom smelters, brokers and metals traders. The percentage of sales contributed by each segment is reflected in the following table:
 
   
Three Months Ended
March 31,
 
   
2018
   
2017
 
                 
Greens Creek
   
46
%
   
41
%
Lucky Friday
   
4
%
   
14
%
Casa Berardi
   
40
%
   
29
%
San Sebastian
   
10
%
   
16
%
     
100
%
   
100
%
 
Sales of products by metal for the thee-month periods ended
March 
31,
2018
and
2017
were as follows (in thousands):
 
   
Three Months Ended
March 31,
 
   
2018
   
2017
 
                 
Silver
  $
35,222
    $
51,357
 
Gold
   
73,044
     
62,701
 
Lead
   
9,227
     
13,619
 
Zinc
   
30,109
     
29,865
 
Less: Smelter and refining charges
   
(7,893
)
   
(14,998
)
     
139,709
     
142,544
 
 
The following is sales information by geographic area based on the location of smelters and brokers (for concentrate shipments) and location of parent companies (for doré sales to metals traders) for the
three
-month periods ended
March 
31,
2018
and
2017
(in thousands):
 
   
Three Months Ended
March 31,
 
   
2018
   
2017
 
                 
Canada
  $
88,668
    $
100,219
 
Korea
   
32,703
     
28,971
 
Japan
   
13,773
     
12,290
 
United States
   
4,081
     
5,205
 
Other
   
(131
)
   
(48
)
Total, excluding gains/losses on forward contracts
   
139,094
     
146,637
 
 
Sales by significant product type for the
three
-month periods ended
March 
31,
2018
and
2017
were as follows (in thousands):
 
   
Three Months Ended
March 31,
 
   
2018
   
2017
 
                 
Doré and metals from doré
  $
73,492
    $
68,981
 
Lead concentrate
   
34,334
     
48,917
 
Zinc concentrate
   
25,652
     
24,218
 
Bulk concentrate
   
5,616
     
4,521
 
Total, excluding gains/losses on forward contracts
   
139,094
     
146,637
 
 
Sales of products for the
first
three
months of
2018
and
2017
included net gains of
$0.6
million and net losses of
$4.1
million, respectively, on financially-settled forward contracts for silver, gold, lead and zinc contained in our concentrate sales.  See
Note
11
for more information.
 
Sales of products to significant customers as a percentage of total sales were as follows for the
three
-month periods ended
March 
31,
2018
and
2017:
 
   
Three Months Ended
March 31,
 
   
2018
   
2017
 
                 
CIBC
   
47
%
   
24
%
Scotia
   
2
%
   
20
%
Korea Zinc
   
23
%
   
20
%
Teck Metals Ltd.
   
4
%
   
15
%
Ocean Partners
   
10
%
   
10
%
 
Our trade accounts receivable balance related to contracts with customers was
$19.7
million at
March 
31,
2018
and
$14.8
million at
December 
31,
2017,
and included
no
allowance for doubtful accounts.
 
We have determined our contracts do
not
include a significant financing component. For doré sales and sales of metal from doré, payment is received at the time the performance obligation is satisfied. Consideration for concentrate sales is variable, and we receive payment for a significant portion of the estimated value of concentrate parcels within a relatively short period of time after the performance obligation is satisfied.
 
We do
not
incur significant costs to obtain contracts, nor costs to fulfill contracts which are
not
addressed by other standards. Therefore, we have
not
recognized an asset for such costs as of
March 
31,
2018
or
December 
31,
2017.
 
The sales and income (loss) from operations amounts reported above include results from our Lucky Friday segment. The Lucky Friday mine is our only operation where some of our employees are subject to a collective bargaining agreement, and the most recent agreement expired on
April 30, 2016.
On
February 19, 2017,
the unionized employees voted against our contract offer. On
March 13, 2017,
the unionized employees went on strike and have been on strike since that time. Production at Lucky Friday was suspended from the start of the strike until
July 2017,
when limited production resumed. For the
first
quarter of
2018
and
2017,
suspension costs
not
related to production of
$4.1
million and
$1.2
million, respectively, along with
$0.9
million and
$0.4
million, respectively, in non-cash depreciation expense, are reported in a separate line item on our consolidated statement of operations. We cannot predict how long the strike will last or whether an agreement will be reached. As a result of the strike or other related events, operations at Lucky Friday could continue to be disrupted, which could adversely affect our financial condition and results of operations. If the strike continues for an extended period or it is determined an eventual resolution is unlikely, it
may
be appropriate in the future to review the carrying value of properties, plants, equipment and mineral interests at Lucky Friday. Under such review, if estimated undiscounted cash flows from Lucky Friday were less than its carrying value, an impairment loss would be recognized for the difference between the carrying value and the estimated fair value. The carrying value of properties, plants, equipment and mineral interests at Lucky Friday as of
March 
31,
2018
was approximately
$422
million. However, Lucky Friday has significant identified reserves and mineralized material and a current estimated mine life of approximately
22
years.
 
On
April 30, 2018,
we settled with the National Labor Relations Board ("NLRB") an unfair labor practice claim made by the union. As part of the settlement, Hecla Limited rescinded its last, best and final contract offer implemented in
March 2017.
We do
not
believe the settlement with the NLRB will resolve any of the key differences in the ongoing labor dispute. On
May 4, 2018,
we gave notice to the union that the parties to the labor dispute are at impasse, and implemented portions of our revised final offer presented in
December 2017.