XML 41 R11.htm IDEA: XBRL DOCUMENT v3.8.0.1
Note 4 - Environmental and Reclamation Activities
12 Months Ended
Dec. 31, 2017
Notes to Financial Statements  
Environmental and Reclamation Activities [Text Block]
Note
4:
Environmental and Reclamation Activities
 
The liabilities accrued for our reclamation and closure costs at
December 
31,
2017
and
2016
were as follows (in thousands):
 
   
2017
   
2016
 
Operating properties:
               
Greens Creek
  $
41,677
    $
39,014
 
Lucky Friday
   
9,911
     
9,194
 
Casa Berardi
   
6,729
     
5,475
 
San Sebastian
   
5,067
     
5,592
 
Non-operating properties:
               
Troy mine
   
12,724
     
16,167
 
Johnny M
   
5,813
     
5,830
 
Republic
   
1,500
     
1,500
 
All other sites
   
2,624
     
2,808
 
Total
   
86,045
     
85,580
 
Reclamation and closure costs, current
   
(6,679
)
   
(5,653
)
Reclamation and closure costs, long-term
  $
79,366
    $
79,927
 
 
The activity in our accrued reclamation and closure cost liability for the years ended
December
 
31,
2017,
2016
and
2015
was as follows (in thousands):
 
 
Balance at January 1, 2015
  $
57,250
 
Accruals for estimated costs
   
15,114
 
Accretion expense
   
1,904
 
Revision of estimated cash flows due to changes in reclamation plans
   
4,112
 
Addition due to development and production at our San Sebastian unit
   
1,189
 
Liability addition due to acquisition of Revett
   
17,513
 
Payment of reclamation obligations
   
(1,544
)
Balance at December
31, 2015
   
95,538
 
Accruals for estimated costs
   
705
 
Accretion expense
   
3,158
 
Revision of estimated cash flows due to changes in reclamation plans
   
2,759
 
Liability addition due to acquisition of Mines Management
   
1,124
 
Payment of reclamation obligations
   
(17,704
)
Balance at December
31, 2016
   
85,580
 
Accruals for estimated costs
   
16
 
Accretion expense
   
4,870
 
Revision of estimated cash flows due to changes in reclamation plans
   
(578
)
Payment of reclamation obligations
   
(3,843
)
Balance at December
31, 2017
  $
86,045
 
 
 
 
In
June 2015,
we completed the acquisition of Revett, giving us
100%
ownership of the Troy mine and other interests in northwestern Montana (see
Note
15
for more information). As a result, we recorded a
$17.5
million liability for the present value of estimated costs for reclamation and closure of the Troy mine. Revett held an environmental risk transfer program ("insurance policy") which would have funded costs incurred prior to the expiration date of
March 29, 2020
for reclamation at the Troy mine up to a maximum limit of
$16.8
million. In the
third
quarter of
2016,
we reached a settlement on the insurance policy for cash proceeds to us of
$16.0
million.
 
On each of
June 15, 2016
and
September 19, 2016,
a Consent Decree settling environmental claims involving our wholly-owned subsidiary, CoCa Mines, Inc. ("CoCa") at the Nelson Tunnel/Commodore Waste Rock Pile site (Colorado) and Gilt Edge site (South Dakota), respectively, was approved and entered by the U.S. District Court in Colorado and South Dakota, respectively. Pursuant to the Consent Decrees, CoCa paid an aggregate of
$6
million in
August 2016
to the United States and the State of Colorado, and an aggregate of
$3.9
million in
November 2016
to the United States and the State of South Dakota (insurers and another potentially responsible party ("PRP") paid an additional
$6.7
million to settle the Gilt Edge matter). As a result, CoCa has resolved the claims with respect to the Gilt Edge and Nelson Tunnel sites. During the negotiations leading up to these settlements, in the
second
quarter of
2015
we accrued
$9.9
million by recording a liability for the total amount that would be paid by CoCa to settle these matters, and an asset for the amount to be recovered by CoCa from insurers and the other settling PRP with respect to the Gilt Edge site.
 
Asset Retirement Obligations
 
Below is a reconciliation as of
December
 
31,
2017
and
2016
(in thousands) of the asset retirement obligations ("ARO") relating to our operating properties, which are included in our total accrued reclamation and closure costs of
$86.0
million and
$85.6
million, respectively, discussed above. The estimated reclamation and abandonment costs were discounted using credit adjusted, risk-free interest rates ranging from
5.75%
to
14.5%
from the time we incurred the obligation to the time we expect to pay the retirement obligation. 
 
   
2017
   
2016
 
Balance January 1
  $
59,275
    $
53,433
 
Changes in obligations due to changes in reclamation plans
   
(578
)
   
2,760
 
Accretion expense
   
4,870
     
3,158
 
Payment of reclamation obligations
   
(183
)
   
(76
)
Balance at December 31
  $
63,384
    $
59,275
 
 
 
In the
fourth
quarter of
2017,
we updated the ARO at San Sebastian to include estimated costs for new underground mine development initiated in
2017
and to revise the timing for reclamation of the existing open pits, resulting in an increase in undiscounted costs of
$0.5
million and decrease in the ARO asset and liability of
$1.2
million.
 
In the
fourth
quarter of
2017,
we revised the ARO at Casa Berardi to include costs for reclamation related to the East Mine Crown Pillar open pit, resulting in an increase in undiscounted costs of
$1.0
million and increase in the ARO asset and liability of
$0.7
million.
 
The ARO layers related to the changes described above were discounted using a credit adjusted, risk-free interest rate of
5.75%
and inflation rates ranging from
2%
to
4%.