XML 42 R15.htm IDEA: XBRL DOCUMENT v3.6.0.2
Note 8 - Employee Benefit Plans
12 Months Ended
Dec. 31, 2016
Notes to Financial Statements  
Pension and Other Postretirement Benefits Disclosure [Text Block]
Note
8:
Employee Benefit Plans
 
Pensions and Other Post-retirement Plans
 
We sponsor defined benefit pension plans covering substantially all U.S. employees. The following tables provide a reconciliation of the changes in the plans’ benefit obligations and fair value of assets over the
two
-year period ended
December
 
31,
2016,
and the funded status as of
December
 
31,
2016
and
December
 
31,
2015
(in thousands):
 
 
 
Pension Benefits
 
 
 
2016
 
 
2015
 
Change in benefit obligation:
               
Benefit obligation at beginning of year
  $
120,237
    $
118,284
 
Service cost
   
4,309
     
4,216
 
Interest cost
   
5,230
     
4,823
 
Actuarial loss (gain)
   
7,500
     
(2,617
)
Benefits paid
   
(5,006
)
   
(4,469
)
Benefit obligation at end of year
   
132,270
     
120,237
 
Change in fair value of plan assets:
               
Fair value of plan assets at beginning of year
   
73,321
     
74,551
 
Actual return (loss) on plan assets
   
9,950
     
(2,221
)
Employer contributions
   
9,092
     
5,460
 
Benefits paid
   
(5,006
)
   
(4,469
)
Fair value of plan assets at end of year
   
87,357
     
73,321
 
Underfunded status at end of year
  $
(44,913
)
  $
(46,916
)
 
 
The following table provides the amounts recognized in the consolidated balance sheets as of
December
 
31,
2016
and
December
 
31,
2015
(in thousands):
 
 
 
 
Pension Benefits
 
 
 
2016
 
 
2015
 
Current liabilities:
               
Accrued benefit liability
  $
(420
)
  $
(402
)
Non- current pension liability:
               
Accrued benefit liability
   
(44,491
)
   
(46,513
)
Accumulated other comprehensive loss
   
40,917
     
42,103
 
Net amount recognized
  $
(3,994
)
  $
(4,812
)
 
The benefit obligation and prepaid benefit costs were calculated by applying the following weighted average assumptions:
 
 
 
 
Pension Benefits
 
 
 
2016
 
 
2015
 
Discount rate: net periodic pension cost
   
4.45
%
   
4.17
%
Discount rate: projected benefit obligation
   
4.14
%
   
4.45
%
Expected rate of return on plan assets
   
6.80
%
   
7.20
%
Rate of compensation increase: net periodic pension cost
   
2.00
%
   
2.00
%
Rate of compensation increase: projected benefit obligation
(1)
 
0.00%/2.00
%  
0.00%/2.00
%
 
 
(1)
0%
was assumed for years
2016
through
2018
and
2%
was assumed thereafter.
 
The above assumptions were calculated based on information as of
December
 
31,
2016
and
December
 
31,
2015,
the measurement dates for the plans. The discount rate is based on the yield curve for investment-grade corporate bonds as published by the U.S. Treasury Department. The expected rate of return on plan assets is based upon consideration of the plan’s current asset mix, historical long-term return rates and the plan’s historical performance. Our current expected rate on plan assets of
6.8%
is based on historical returns over the past
five
years.
 
Net periodic pension cost for the plans consisted of the following in
2016,
2015,
and
2014
(in thousands):
 
 
 
 
Pension Benefits
 
 
 
2016
 
 
2015
 
 
2014
 
Service cost
  $
4,309
    $
4,216
    $
4,312
 
Interest cost
   
5,229
     
4,823
     
4,859
 
Expected return on plan assets
   
(5,299
)
   
(5,382
)
   
(4,996
)
Amortization of prior service benefit
   
(337
)
   
(337
)
   
(337
)
Amortization of net gain from earlier periods
   
4,372
     
4,260
     
3,275
 
Net periodic pension cost
  $
8,274
    $
7,580
    $
7,113
 
 
 
The allocations of investments at
December
 
31,
2016
and
December
 
31,
2015,
the measurement dates of the plan, by asset category in the Hecla Mining Company Retirement Plan and the Lucky Friday Pension Plan are as follows:
 
 
 
 
Hecla
 
 
Lucky Friday
 
 
 
2016
 
 
2015
 
 
2016
 
 
2015
 
Cash
   
3
%
   
2
%
   
3
%
   
4
%
Large cap U.S. equities
   
18
%
   
10
%
   
17
%
   
10
%
Small cap U.S. equities
   
9
%
   
5
%
   
9
%
   
5
%
Non-U.S. equities
   
24
%
   
9
%
   
25
%
   
9
%
Fixed income
   
20
%
   
34
%
   
20
%
   
33
%
Real estate
   
13
%
   
18
%
   
13
%
   
18
%
Absolute return hedge funds
   
6
%
   
15
%
   
6
%
   
14
%
Real return
   
%
   
1
%
   
%
   
1
%
Company stock
   
7
%
   
6
%
   
7
%
   
6
%
Total
   
100
%
   
100
%
   
100
%
   
100
%
 
"Company stock" asset category in the table above includes our common stock in the amounts of
$6.3
million and
$4.3
million at
December
 
31,
2016
and
December
 
31,
2015.
 
Each plan's statement of investment policy delineates the responsibilities of the board, the retirement/pension committee, the investment manager(s), and investment adviser/consultant, and provides guidelines on investment management. Investment objectives are established for each of the asset categories included in the pension plans with comparisons of performance against appropriate benchmarks. Each plan's policy calls for investments to be supervised by qualified investment managers. The investment managers are monitored on an ongoing basis by our outside consultant, with formal reporting to us and the consultant performed each quarter. The policy sets forth the following allocation of assets:
 
 
 
As of December 31, 2016
(1)
 
 
As of December 31, 2015
 
 
 
Target
 
 
Maximum
 
 
Target
 
 
Minimum
 
 
Maximum
 
Large cap U.S. equities
   
17
%
   
20
%
   
10
%
   
7
%
   
13
%
Small cap U.S. equities
   
8
%
   
10
%
   
5
%
   
4
%
   
6
%
Non-U.S. equities
   
25
%
   
30
%
   
10
%
   
8
%
   
12
%
Fixed income
   
20
%
   
25
%
   
35
%
   
29
%
   
43
%
Real estate
   
15
%
   
18
%
   
15
%
   
12
%
   
18
%
Absolute return
   
5
%
   
7
%
   
15
%
   
12
%
   
18
%
Company stock/Real return
   
10
%
   
13
%
   
10
%
   
8
%
   
12
%
 
 
(1)
The policy as of
December
 
31,
2016
does not include minimum investment thresholds.
 
Each plan's statement of investment policy and objectives aspires to achieve the assumed long term rate of return on plan assets established by the plan’s actuary plus
one
percent.
 
Accounting guidance has established a hierarchy of assets measured at fair value on a recurring basis. The
three
levels included in the hierarchy are:
 
Level
1:
quoted prices in active markets for identical assets or liabilities
 
Level
2:
significant other observable inputs
 
Level
3:
significant unobservable inputs
 
The fair values by asset category in each plan, along with their hierarchy levels, are as follows as of
December
 
31,
2016
(in thousands):
 
 
 
 
Hecla
 
 
Lucky Friday
 
 
 
Level 1
 
 
Level 2
 
 
Level 3
 
 
Total
 
 
Level 1
 
 
Level 2
 
 
Level 3
 
 
Total
 
Interest-bearing cash
  $
1,924
    $
    $
    $
1,924
    $
550
    $
    $
    $
550
 
Common stock
   
4,973
     
     
     
4,973
     
1,340
     
     
     
1,340
 
Real estate
   
     
     
8,974
     
8,974
     
     
     
2,389
     
2,389
 
Common collective funds
   
     
12,379
     
2,108
     
14,487
     
     
3,427
     
550
     
3,977
 
Mutual funds
   
38,326
     
     
     
38,326
     
10,417
     
     
     
10,417
 
Total fair value
  $
45,223
    $
12,379
    $
11,082
    $
68,684
    $
12,307
    $
3,427
    $
2,939
    $
18,673
 
 
The following is a roll-forward of assets in Level
3
of the fair value hierarchy (in thousands):
 
 
 
Hecla
 
 
Lucky Friday
 
 
 
Real estate
 
 
Common collective funds
 
 
Real estate
 
 
Common collective funds
 
Beginning balance at January 1, 2016
  $
10,326
    $
4,462
    $
2,856
    $
1,309
 
Net unrealized gains on assets held at the reporting date
   
283
     
80
     
71
     
20
 
Purchases
   
333
     
     
90
     
 
Sales
   
(1,968
)
   
(2,434
)
   
(628
)
   
(779
)
Ending balance at December 31, 2016
  $
8,974
    $
2,108
    $
2,389
    $
550
 
 
 
Of the
$14.0
million in plan assets classified as level
3,
$11.4
million was invested in real estate, and the remaining
$2.6
million was invested in collective investment funds.
 
The fair values by asset category in each plan, along with their hierarchy levels, were as follows as of
December
 
31,
2015
(in thousands):
 
 
 
Hecla
 
 
Lucky Friday
 
 
 
Level 1
 
 
Level 2
 
 
Level 3
 
 
Total
 
 
Level 1
 
 
Level 2
 
 
Level 3
 
 
Total
 
Interest-bearing cash
  $
936
    $
    $
    $
936
    $
76
    $
    $
    $
76
 
Common stock
   
3,284
     
     
     
3,284
     
989
     
     
     
989
 
Real estate
   
     
     
10,326
     
10,326
     
     
     
2,856
     
2,856
 
Common collective funds
   
     
9,862
     
4,462
     
14,324
     
     
2,573
     
1,309
     
3,882
 
Mutual funds
   
28,803
     
     
     
28,803
     
7,845
     
     
     
7,845
 
Total fair value
  $
33,023
    $
9,862
    $
14,788
    $
57,673
    $
8,910
    $
2,573
    $
4,165
    $
15,648
 
 
 
The following is a roll-forward of assets in Level
3
of the fair value hierarchy (in thousands):
 
 
 
Hecla
 
 
Lucky Friday
 
 
 
Real estate
 
 
Common collective funds
 
 
Real estate
 
 
Common collective funds
 
Beginning balance at January 1, 2015
  $
8,889
    $
8,454
    $
2,458
    $
2,306
 
Net unrealized gains on assets held at the reporting date
   
1,094
     
8
     
303
     
3
 
Purchases
   
343
     
     
95
     
 
Sales
   
     
(4,000
)
   
     
(1,000
)
Ending balance at December 31, 2015
  $
10,326
    $
4,462
    $
2,856
    $
1,309
 
 
 
Of the
$19.0
million in plan assets classified as level
3,
$13.2
million was invested in real estate, and the remaining
$5.8
million was invested in collective investment funds.
 
Generally, investments are valued based on information provided by fund managers to each plan's trustee as reviewed by management and its investment advisers. Mutual funds and equities are valued based on available exchange data. Commingled equity funds consist of publicly-traded investments. Fair value for real estate and private equity partnerships is primarily based on valuation methodologies that include
third
-party appraisals, comparable transactions, and discounted cash flow valuation models.
 
The following are estimates of future benefit payments, which reflect expected future service as appropriate, related to our pension plans (in thousands):
 
Year Ending December 31,
 
Pension
Plans
 
2017
  $
5,775
 
2018
   
6,101
 
2019
   
6,471
 
2020
   
6,849
 
2021
   
7,128
 
Years 2022-2026
   
38,685
 
 
 
In
February
2016,
we contributed approximately
$2.6
million in shares of our common stock and cash to our defined benefit plans, and contributed
$6.1
million in shares of our common stock and cash in
July
2016,
with no additional contributions in
2016.
We expect to contribute a total of
$4.0
million in shares of our common stock or cash to our defined benefit plans in
2017.
We expect to contribute approximately
$0.4
million to our unfunded supplemental executive retirement plan during
2017.
 
The following table indicates whether our pension plans had accumulated benefit obligations ("ABO") in excess of plan assets, or plan assets exceeded ABO, (amounts are in thousands).
 
 
 
 
December 31, 2016
 
 
December 31, 2015
 
 
 
ABO Exceeds Plan Assets
 
 
Plan Assets Exceed ABO
 
 
ABO Exceeds Plan Assets
 
 
Plan Assets Exceed ABO
 
Projected benefit obligation
  $
132,270
    $
    $
120,237
    $
 
Accumulated benefit obligation
   
128,102
     
     
116,289
     
 
Fair value of plan assets
   
87,357
     
     
73,321
     
 
 
 
 
For the pension plans, the following amounts are included in "Accumulated other comprehensive loss, net" on our balance sheet as of
December
 
31,
2016,
that have not yet been recognized as components of net periodic benefit cost (in thousands):
 
 
 
Pension
Benefits
 
Unamortized net (gain)/loss
  $
42,161
 
Unamortized prior service benefit
   
(1,244
)
 
 
The amounts in "Accumulated other comprehensive loss, net" expected to be recognized as components of net periodic benefit cost during
2017
are (in thousands):
 
 
 
 
Pension
Benefits
 
Amortization of net loss
  $
4,132
 
Amortization of prior service benefit
   
(337
)
 
 
We do not expect to have any of the pension plans’ assets returned during
2017.
 
Non-U.S. employees are not eligible to participate in the defined benefit pension plans that we maintain for U.S. employees. Canadian employees participate in Canada's public retirement income system, which includes the following components: (i) the Canada (or Quebec) Pension Plan, which is a contributory, earnings-related social insurance program, and (ii) the Old Age Security program. In addition, the Registered Retirement Savings Plan is a tax-deferred individual savings plan available to Canadian employees. Mexican employees participate in Mexico's public retirement income system, which is based on contributions the employee, employer and the government submit to the retirement savings system. The system is administered through savings accounts managed by private fund managers selected by the participant.
 
Capital Accumulation Plans
 
Our Capital Accumulation Plan ("Hecla
401(k)
Plan") is available to all U.S. salaried and certain hourly employees and applies immediately upon employment. Employees
may
contribute from
1%
to
50%
of their annual compensation to the plan (subject to statutory limits). We make a matching contribution in the form of cash or stock of
100%
of an employee’s contribution up to
6%
of the employee’s earnings. Our matching contributions were approximately
$3.5
million in
2016,
$3.4
million in
2015,
and
$3.2
million in
2014.
 
Effective
January
1,
2014,
the Hecla
401(k)
Plan was restated to allow for payment of matching contributions to be made in Hecla common stock on a quarterly basis. Prior to
2014,
contributions were made in cash on a payroll-to-payroll basis.
 
We also maintain a
401(k)
plan that is available to all hourly employees at the Lucky Friday unit after completion of
six
months of service. Employees
may
contribute from
2%
to
50%
of their compensation to the plan (subject to statutory limits). The matching contribution is
55%
of an employee’s contribution up to, but not exceeding,
5%
of the employee’s earnings.  Our contributions were approximately
$442,000
in
2016,
$391,000
in
2015,
and
$292,000
in
2014.