X0306 4/A 2014-03-03 2014-03-05 0 0000069488 MYERS INDUSTRIES INC MYE 0001219577 ORR JOHN C 1293 SOUTH MAIN STREET AKRON OH 44301 1 1 0 0 President and CEO Common Stock 2014-03-03 4 M 0 5737 12.55 A 37155 D Common Stock 2014-03-03 4 S 0 5737 21.13 D 31418 D Common Stock 2014-03-03 4 J 0 38400 0.00 A 69818 D Common Stock 2014-03-03 4 F 0 17127 0.00 D 52691 D Common Stock 2014-03-03 4 J 0 15433 0.00 A 68124 D Common Stock 2014-03-03 4 F 0 7221 0.00 D 60903 D Restricted Stock Award 2014-03-03 4 J 0 38400 0.00 D 28150 D Common Stock 63212 I By Spousal Trust Restricted Stock Unit 2014-03-03 4 J 0 15433 0.00 D Common Stock 15433 30867 D Common Stock Option 12.55 2014-03-03 4 M 0 5737 D 2018-04-23 Common Stock 5737 908240 D The exercise reported in this Form 4 was effected pursuant to a Rule 10b5-1 trading plan, entered into November 21, 2013 The sale reported in this Form 4 was effected pursuant to a Rule 10b5-1 trading plan, entered into November 21, 2013 Mr. Orr exercised stock options for 5,737 shares at an exercise price of 12.55 The sale price is a weighted average for the sale transaction. The sales prices range from a low of $21.26 per share to a high of $22.15 The exercise rights vested in three equal annual installments beginning April 23, 2009 The forfeiture provisions with respect to 28,150 of these Restricted Stock Awards lapse in 2015 if John Orr is still employed by Myers Industries, Inc. on the anniversary date of the grant. Represents a disposition of shares to Myers Industries, Inc. Such disposition is exempt under Section 16(b) under Rule 16b-3(e). 38,400 shares of restricted stock vested on March 3, 2014. 15,433 Restricted Stock Units vested on March 3, 2014. A Restricted Stock Unit is the grant of the right to receive an amount equal to the fair market value of a share on the date that payment is made with respect to the Restricted Stock Unit. The Restricted Stock Units vest in three equal installments on each of the first three anniversaries of the date of the grant. The date of Earliest Transaction has been revised to state 3/3/14 and the Signature Date has been revised to state 3/5/14. /s/ Megan L. Mehalko pursuant to POA dated 10/25/06 and filed 4/25/08 2014-03-05