XML 45 R28.htm IDEA: XBRL DOCUMENT v3.7.0.1
Contingencies (Tables)
3 Months Ended
Mar. 31, 2017
Commitments and Contingencies Disclosure [Abstract]  
Schedule of contingencies
The activity in the Company’s accruals for the MSA and tobacco litigation for the three months ended March 31, 2017 were as follows:


    
 
Current Liabilities
 
Non-Current Liabilities
 
Payments due under Master Settlement Agreement
 
Litigation Accruals
 
Total
 
Payments due under Master Settlement Agreement
 
Litigation Accruals
 
Total
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Balance as of January 1, 2017
$
16,192

 
$
3,659

 
$
19,851

 
$
22,257

 
$
27,513

 
$
49,770

Expenses
31,928

 
1,610

 
33,538

 
—

 
—

 
—

NPM Settlement adjustment
33

 
—

 
33

 
(928
)
 
—

 
(928
)
Change in MSA obligations capitalized as inventory
189

 
—

 
189

 
—

 
—

 
—

Payments
—

 
(3,891
)
 
(3,891
)
 
—

 
—

 
—

Reclassification to/(from) non-current liabilities
—

 
4,266

 
4,266

 
—

 
(4,266
)
 
(4,266
)
Interest on withholding
—

 
63

 
63

 
—

 
670

 
670

Balance as of March 31, 2017
$
48,342

 
$
5,707

 
$
54,049

 
$
21,329

 
$
23,917

 
$
45,246




The activity in the Company's accruals for the MSA and tobacco litigation for the three months ended March 31, 2016 were as follows:
 
Current Liabilities
 
Non-Current Liabilities
 
Payments due under Master Settlement Agreement
 
Litigation Accruals
 
Total
 
Payments due under Master Settlement Agreement
 
Litigation Accruals
 
Total
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Balance as of January 1, 2016
$
29,241

 
$
22,904

 
$
52,145

 
$
20,094

 
$
24,718

 
$
44,812

Expenses
14,835

 
2,504

 
17,339

 
—

 
—

 
—

Change in MSA obligations capitalized as inventory
(406
)
 
—

 
(406
)
 
—

 
—

 
—

Payments
—

 
(21,171
)
 
(21,171
)
 
—

 
—

 
—

Reclassification from non-current liabilities
—

 
3,252

 
3,252

 
—

 
(3,252
)
 
(3,252
)
Interest on withholding
35

 
197

 
232

 
—

 
568

 
568

Balance as of March 31, 2016
$
43,705

 
$
7,686

 
$
51,391

 
$
20,094

 
$
22,034

 
$
42,128

As of March 31, 2017, the following Engle progeny cases have resulted in judgments against Liggett:
Date
 
Case Name
 
County
 
Liggett Compensatory
Damages (as adjusted)
 (1)
 
Liggett Punitive Damages
 
Status (2)
June 2002
 
Lukacs v. R.J. Reynolds
 
Miami-Dade
 
$12,418
 
$—
 
Liggett satisfied the judgment and the case is concluded.
August 2009
 
Campbell v. R.J. Reynolds
 
Escambia
 
156
 
—
 
Liggett satisfied the judgment and the case is concluded.
March 2010
 
Douglas v. R.J. Reynolds
 
Hillsborough
 
1,350
 
—
 
Liggett satisfied the judgment and the case is concluded.
April 2010
 
Clay v. R.J. Reynolds
 
Escambia
 
349
 
1,000
 
Liggett satisfied the judgment and the case is concluded.
April 2010
 
Putney v. R.J. Reynolds
 
Broward
 
17
 
—
 
On June 12, 2013, the Fourth District Court of Appeal reversed and remanded the case for further proceedings regarding the amount of the award. Both sides sought discretionary review from the Florida Supreme Court. In February 2016, the Florida Supreme Court reinstated the jury's verdict. The defendants moved for clarification of that order. The court clarified that it reversed the district court's decision regarding the statute of repose only, leaving the remaining portions of the decision intact, which, among other things, reversed an approximately $3,000 compensatory award against Liggett. The case was remanded to the trial court for proceedings consistent with those portions of the district court's decision that were not reversed. A hearing occurred on March 14, 2017. A decision is pending.
April 2011
 
Tullo v. R.J. Reynolds
 
Palm Beach
 
225
 
—
 
Liggett satisfied the judgment and the case is concluded.
January 2012
 
Ward v. R.J. Reynolds
 
Escambia
 
1
 
—
 
Liggett satisfied the merits judgment. Subsequently, the trial court entered a joint and several final judgment on attorneys' fees and costs for $981 and defendants appealed that judgment. Briefing is underway.
May 2012
 
Calloway v. R.J. Reynolds
 
Broward
 
—
 
—
 
A joint and several judgment for $16,100 was entered against R.J. Reynolds, Philip Morris, Lorillard and Liggett. On January 6, 2016, the Fourth District Court of Appeal reversed in part, including the $7,600 punitive damages award against Liggett, and remanded the case to the trial court for a new trial on certain issues. Both sides moved for rehearing and in September 2016, the Fourth District Court of Appeal reversed the judgment in its entirety and remanded the case for a new trial. As a result, the $1,530 compensatory award against Liggett was also reversed. The plaintiff filed a notice to invoke the discretionary jurisdiction of the Florida Supreme Court. The court declined to accept jurisdiction. This case was settled in December 2016 as part of Engle Progeny Settlement II.
December 2012
 
Buchanan v. R.J. Reynolds
 
Leon
 
2,750
 
—
 
Liggett satisfied the judgment and the case is concluded.
May 2013
 
D. Cohen v. R.J. Reynolds
 
Palm Beach
 
—
 
—
 
This case was settled in December 2016 as part of Engle Progeny Settlement II.
August 2013
 
Rizzuto v. R.J. Reynolds
 
Hernando
 
3,479
 
—
 
Liggett settled its portion of the judgment for $1,500 and the case is concluded as to Liggett.
August 2014
 
Irimi v. R.J. Reynolds
 
Broward
 
—
 
—
 
This case was settled in December 2016 as part of Engle Progeny Settlement II.
October 2014
 
Lambert v. R.J. Reynolds
 
Pinellas
 
3,600
 
9,500
 
Liggett satisfied the judgment and the case is concluded.
November 2014
 
Boatright v. R.J. Reynolds
 
Polk
 
—
 
300
 
In November 2014, the jury awarded compensatory damages in the amount of $15,000 with 15% fault apportioned to plaintiff and 85% to Philip Morris.  A joint and several judgment was entered in the amount of $12,750 on the compensatory damages. Judgment was also entered against Liggett for $300 in punitive damages. Defendants appealed and plaintiff cross-appealed. The Second District Court of Appeal reversed the trial court's decision to reduce the judgment by plaintiff's assessed fault and affirmed as to all other issues on that appeal. In a separate appeal, the Second District Court of Appeal also reversed the trial court's ruling that plaintiff's proposals for settlement were invalid and remanded for determination of attorney's fees.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Any potential liability as a result of the pending appeals is included in the amount Liggett will pay under Engle Progeny Settlement II.
June 2015
 
Caprio v. R.J. Reynolds
 
Broward
 
—
 
—
 
This case was settled in December 2016 as part of Engle Progeny Settlement II.
March 2017
 
Santoro v. R.J. Reynolds
 
Broward
 
160
 
15
 
In April 2017, a joint and several judgment was entered against R.J. Reynolds, Philip Morris and Liggett for $1,027, for compensatory damages. Judgment was also entered against Liggett for $15 in punitive damages. Post trial motions are pending but have not been set for hearing.
Total Damages Awarded:
24,505
 
10,815
 
 
Amounts accrued, paid or compromised:
(24,328)
 
(10,800)
 
 
Damages remaining on Appeal:
$177
 
$15
 
 
(1) Compensatory damages are adjusted to reflect the jury's allocation of comparative fault and only include Liggett's jury allocated share, regardless of whether a judgment was joint and several. The amounts listed above do not include attorneys' fees or statutory interest.
(2) See Exhibit 99.1 for a more complete description of the cases currently on appeal.
The following table lists the number of Individual Actions by state:
State
 
Number
of Cases
Maryland
 
16
Florida
 
6
New York
 
6
Louisiana
 
2
West Virginia
 
2
Missouri
 
1
Ohio
 
1