0001096906-24-000575.txt : 20240326 0001096906-24-000575.hdr.sgml : 20240326 20240326171951 ACCESSION NUMBER: 0001096906-24-000575 CONFORMED SUBMISSION TYPE: PX14A6G PUBLIC DOCUMENT COUNT: 2 FILED AS OF DATE: 20240326 DATE AS OF CHANGE: 20240326 EFFECTIVENESS DATE: 20240326 SUBJECT COMPANY: COMPANY DATA: COMPANY CONFORMED NAME: HP INC CENTRAL INDEX KEY: 0000047217 STANDARD INDUSTRIAL CLASSIFICATION: COMPUTER & OFFICE EQUIPMENT [3570] ORGANIZATION NAME: 06 Technology IRS NUMBER: 941081436 STATE OF INCORPORATION: DE FISCAL YEAR END: 1031 FILING VALUES: FORM TYPE: PX14A6G SEC ACT: 1934 Act SEC FILE NUMBER: 001-04423 FILM NUMBER: 24784746 BUSINESS ADDRESS: STREET 1: 1501 PAGE MILL ROAD CITY: PALO ALTO STATE: CA ZIP: 94304 BUSINESS PHONE: 6508571501 MAIL ADDRESS: STREET 1: 1501 PAGE MILL ROAD CITY: PALO ALTO STATE: CA ZIP: 94304 FORMER COMPANY: FORMER CONFORMED NAME: HEWLETT PACKARD CO DATE OF NAME CHANGE: 19920703 FILED BY: COMPANY DATA: COMPANY CONFORMED NAME: Bowyer Research, Inc. CENTRAL INDEX KEY: 0001996368 ORGANIZATION NAME: IRS NUMBER: 463874783 STATE OF INCORPORATION: PA FISCAL YEAR END: 1231 FILING VALUES: FORM TYPE: PX14A6G BUSINESS ADDRESS: STREET 1: PO BOX 120 CITY: MCKEESPORT STATE: PA ZIP: 15135 BUSINESS PHONE: 412-751-8603 MAIL ADDRESS: STREET 1: PO BOX 120 CITY: MCKEESPORT STATE: PA ZIP: 15135 PX14A6G 1 bowy_px14a6g.htm BOWYER RESEARCH - PX14A6G

NOTICE OF EXEMPT SOLICITATION SUBMITTED BY NON-MANAGEMENT

U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission

Washington, DC 20549

Notice of Exempt Solicitation under Rule 14a-103

Name of Registrant: Hewlett Packard Inc.

Name of person relying on exemption: Bowyer Research

Address of person relying on exemption: P.O. Box 120, McKeesport PA 15135

 

Vote No: Proposal 5 – Defending Corporate Fiduciary Duty

 

 

Bowyer Research submits the following:

 

Introduction

Hewlett Packard Inc. (HPQ) has proposed an amendment to its certificate of incorporation, known as Proposal 5, which seeks to limit the liability of its directors and officers for breaches of fiduciary duty, except in cases of intentional misconduct or knowing violation of law. This proposal, if passed, would significantly weaken the fiduciary responsibilities that are the bedrock of corporate governance and shareholder rights.

 

Fiduciary Duties Under Delaware Law

Delaware law imposes two primary fiduciary duties on corporate directors and officers: the duty of care and the duty of loyalty. These duties require that directors and officers act in the best interest of the corporation and its shareholders, with the care that a reasonably prudent person would use in similar circumstances.


The Exculpation Amendment

Proposal 5, the Exculpation Amendment, would alter the landscape of accountability by providing directors and officers with broad protections against liability for breaches of the duty of care. This amendment is permissible under recent changes to Delaware law but represents a departure from the principles of good governance.

 

Arguments Against Proposal 5

 

Erosion of Accountability

By limiting the liability of directors and officers, Proposal 5 would erode the accountability that ensures they act with due diligence and prudence in managing the company’s affairs.

 

Incentivizing Risky Behavior

The amendment could incentivize behavior that prioritizes short-term gains over long-term stability, potentially leading to decisions that are detrimental to HP and its shareholders.

 

Diminishing Shareholder Trust

Shareholder trust is predicated on the belief that directors and officers are fully accountable for their actions. Proposal 5 threatens to undermine this trust, which is essential for the proper functioning of capital markets.

 

Contrary to Best Practices

Good corporate governance practices advocate for strong oversight and accountability mechanisms. Proposal 5 runs counter to these practices and could set a concerning precedent for other corporations.

 

Conclusion

The Exculpation Amendment represented by Proposal 5 is a regressive step that would weaken the fiduciary responsibilities of directors and officers. It poses significant risks to shareholder interests and the integrity of corporate governance at HPE. As such, it is recommended that shareholders vote against Proposal 5 to maintain the high standards of accountability that have long been a hallmark of successful corporations.


 

This white paper provides a comprehensive argument against Proposal 5, focusing on the importance of maintaining strong fiduciary responsibilities for the health and success of the corporation and the protection of shareholder interests. It is essential for shareholders to consider the long-term implications of such amendments and to uphold the principles of accountability and trust that underpin corporate governance.

 

Conclusion

For these reasons, we urge you to vote AGAINST Shareholder Proposal No. 5 on HP’s 2024 Proxy.

 

Sincerely,

Jerry Bowyer

President

BOWYER RESEARCH

P.O. Box 120

McKeesport PA 15135

 

This is not a solicitation of authority to vote your proxy. Please do not send us your proxy card as it will not be accepted.

 

GRAPHIC 2 bowypx14a6g_1.jpg IMAGE begin 644 bowypx14a6g_1.jpg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end