CORRESP 1 filename1.htm corresp
 

(EMULEX LETTERHEAD)
April 26, 2006
VIA EDGAR AND FAX
Stephen Krikorian
Accounting Branch Chief
Division of Corporation Finance
Securities and Exchange Commission
Mail Stop 4561
100 F Street, N.E.
Washington D. C. 20549
Re:    Emulex Corporation (File No. 001-31353)
Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended July 3, 2005
Form 10-Q for the fiscal quarters ended October 2, 2005 and January 1, 2006
Dear Mr. Krikorian:
     On behalf of Emulex Corporation (the “Company” or “Emulex”), I am providing a supplemental response to your letter dated April 10, 2006 relating to the above-referenced annual and quarterly reports.
     As mentioned in a voice mail to Christopher White, Staff Accountant, by our outside counsel, the enclosed response restates our response to comment 3 contained in our April 25, 2006 letter in order to correct certain errors relating to the reclassification of amortization expense. In particular, in preparing the sample financial statements for our April 25, 2006 response, we inadvertently reclassified the amortization associated with patents acquired in a business combination from operating expenses to cost of goods sold, in addition to the core and developed technology intangible assets acquired. Our intention was to reclassify only the amortization of our core and developed technology assets acquired in business combinations in accordance with your recommendation. We apologize for the inconvenience this may have caused and enclose our revised response to comment 3 from your April 10, 2006 letter.
Form 10-K for Fiscal Year Ended July 3, 2005
Item 7. Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations
Fiscal 2005 versus Fiscal 2004
Consolidated Statement of Operations, page 54

 


 

  3.   Comment:
Your response to prior comment number 4 confirms that your products include intangible assets related to core technology which are being amortized in the income statement. Therefore, as your products sales include such technology, it appears that the appropriate line-item within continuing operations for this amortization should be cost of sales. In this regard, we note your reference to paragraph 42 of SFAS 142, and that this literature requires classification of amortization expense “as deemed appropriate for each entity.” This guidance does not support classifying the amortization expense simply based on an entity’s “policy election” without considering the nature of the charge. As your acquired technology is part of your cost of sales, it appears that based on the nature of this charge it should be classified in the cost of sales section. We further note your response references the guide of SAB Topic 11.B. Since you are presenting a gross profit line item in your statements of operations, in MD&A and in Note 16 — Quarterly Financial Data, the amortization charge must be included in cost of sales to properly present your gross profit. Revise or provide an analysis using SAB 99 that supports your conclusion not to amend prior Exchange Act Filings to properly present your gross profit.
Response:
In response to the Staff’s comments, the Company proposes to reclassify this amortization expense to cost of sales in future filings and to enhance our footnote disclosure. In order for the Staff to better understand the effect the reclassification will have on future filings, for your convenience, we have attached statements of operations which present the reclassified amounts compared to the previous presentation for the periods impacted by the reclassification. Those periods are the years ended June 27, 2004 and July 3, 2005, the three months ended January 1, 2006 and October 2, 2005, and the six months ended January 1, 2006. In future filings we will also reclassify statement of operations and related Disclosures in Management’s Discussion and Analysis to conform to the current presentation as necessary.
Additionally, the Company will amend its intangible assets footnote (currently footnote 7) in future filings to clarify where amortization expense of intangibles is classified in the statement of operations. The proposed changes to the footnote are presented in brackets and italics to assist in more clearly identifying them for purposes of this response.
“Goodwill related to the purchase of Vixel in 2004 and the purchase of Giganet in 2001. Core technology and patents relate to the purchase of Vixel and Giganet and to the purchase of the technology assets of Trebia Corporation for $2.1 million in October 2003. All other intangible assets subject to amortization relate to the purchase of Vixel. [The amortization expense associated with core technology and developed technology is included within the cost of sales line item in the Statement of Operations. The amortization expense associated with patents, customer relationships, tradename and covenants not-to-compete is included in the amortization of other intangibles line item which is within operating expenses.]”

 


 

“Aggregated amortization expense for these intangibles for the years 2006, 2005 and 2004, was $XX.X million, $26.2 million and $19.1 million, respectively, [of which $X.X million, $14.8 million and $11.5 million of amortization expense related to core technology and developed technology, respectively has been included in cost of sales within the Statement of Operations.]”
     Please do not hesitate to call me if you have any further comments or questions regarding this response.
         
  Very truly yours,

     Emulex Corporation
 
 
       By:   /s/ Michael J. Rockenbach   
    Michael J. Rockenbach, Chief Financial Officer   
       
 
cc:    Christopher White, Staff Accountant
Paul F. Folino
Randall Wick
Natalie Smith
Mark Clemens
Robert M. Steinberg

 


 

Emulex
Proposed Income Statement Changes
Reclassification of Purchased Intangible Assets Amortization Expense to Cost of Sales
Form 10-K, Fiscal Years 2005 and 2004 — REVISED
                                 
    As Presented     As Revised  
Description   2005     2004     2005     2004  
 
                               
Net Revenues
  $ 375,653     $ 364,422     $ 375,653     $ 364,422  
Cost of Sales
    139,682       131,803       154,530       143,311  
 
                       
Gross Profit
    235,971       232,619       221,123       221,111  
 
                               
Operating Expenses:
                               
 
                               
Engineering and development
    79,971       73,211       79,971       73,211  
Selling and Marketing
    32,441       28,035       32,441       28,035  
General and administrative
    11,636       18,815       11,636       18,815  
Amortization of intangibles
    26,162       19,093       11,314       7,585  
Impairment of goodwill
    1,096       583,499       1,096       583,499  
In-process research and development
          11,400             11,400  
 
                       
Total operating expenses
    151,306       734,053       136,458       722,545  
 
                       
 
                               
Operating income (loss)
    84,665       (501,434 )     84,665       (501,434 )
 
                               
Nonoperating income:
                               
Interest income
    13,106       9,149       13,106       9,149  
Interest expense
    (4,202 )     (4,754 )     (4,202 )     (4,754 )
Gain on repurchase of convertible subordinated notes
    20,514       2,670       20,514       2,670  
Other income (expense), net
    (2,273 )     109       (2,273 )     109  
 
                       
Total nonoperating income
    27,145       7,174       27,145       7,174  
 
                       
 
                               
Income (loss) before income taxes
    111,810       (494,260 )     111,810       (494,260 )
 
                               
Income tax provision
    40,221       38,062       40,221       38,062  
 
                               
Net income (loss)
  $ 71,589     $ (532,322 )   $ 71,589     $ (532,322 )
 
                       
 
                               
Net income (loss) per share:
                               
Basic
  $ 0.86     $ (6.47 )   $ 0.86     $ (6.47 )
 
                       
Diluted
  $ 0.80     $ (6.47 )   $ 0.80     $ (6.47 )
 
                       
 
                               
Number of shares used in per share computations:
                               
Basic
    82,819       82,293       82,819       82,293  
 
                       
Diluted
    92,970       82,293       92,970       82,293  
 
                       

 


 

Emulex
Proposed Income Statement Changes
Reclassification of Purchased Intangible Assets Amortization Expense to Cost of Sales
Form 10-Q, Six months ended January 1, 2006 — REVISED
                 
    As Presented     As Revised  
Description   January 1, 2006     January 1, 2006  
 
               
Net Revenues
  $ 214,647     $ 214,647  
Cost of Sales
    79,861       87,161  
 
           
Gross Profit
    134,786       127,486  
 
               
Operating Expenses:
               
 
               
Engineering and development
    44,190       44,190  
Selling and Marketing
    17,211       17,211  
General and administrative
    11,848       11,848  
Amortization of intangibles
    12,757       5,457  
Impairment of goodwill
           
 
           
Total operating expenses
    86,006       78,706  
 
           
 
               
Operating income
    48,780       48,780  
 
               
Nonoperating income:
               
Interest income
    8,538       8,538  
Interest expense
    (1,246 )     (1,246 )
Gain on repurchase of convertible subordinated notes
           
Other income (expense), net
    (20 )     (20 )
 
           
Total nonoperating income
    7,272       7,272  
 
           
 
               
Income before income taxes
    56,052       56,052  
 
               
Income tax provision
    22,407       22,407  
 
               
Net income
  $ 33,645     $ 33,645  
 
           
 
               
Net income per share:
               
Basic
  $ 0.40     $ 0.40  
 
           
Diluted
  $ 0.38     $ 0.38  
 
           
 
               
Number of shares used in per share computations:
               
Basic
    83,609       83,609  
 
           
Diluted
    91,115       91,115  
 
           

 


 

Emulex
Proposed Income Statement Changes
Reclassification of Purchased Intangible Assets Amortization Expense to Cost of Sales
Form 10-Q, Three months ended January 1, 2006 — REVISED
                 
    As Presented     As Revised  
Description   January 1, 2006     January 1, 2006  
 
               
Net Revenues
  $ 110,268     $ 110,268  
Cost of Sales
    41,712       45,359  
 
           
Gross Profit
    68,556       64,909  
 
               
Operating Expenses:
               
 
               
Engineering and development
    22,335       22,335  
Selling and Marketing
    9,254       9,254  
General and administrative
    5,904       5,904  
Amortization of intangibles
    6,373       2,726  
Impairment of goodwill
           
 
           
Total operating expenses
    43,866       40,219  
 
           
 
               
Operating income
    24,690       24,690  
 
               
Nonoperating income:
               
Interest income
    4,792       4,792  
Interest expense
    (622 )     (622 )
Gain on repurchase of convertible subordinated notes
           
Other income (expense), net
    (18 )     (18 )
 
           
Total nonoperating income
    4,152       4,152  
 
           
 
               
Income before income taxes
    28,842       28,842  
 
               
Income tax provision
    11,633       11,633  
 
           
 
               
Net income
  $ 17,209     $ 17,209  
 
           
 
               
Net income per share:
               
Basic
  $ 0.21     $ 0.21  
 
           
Diluted
  $ 0.19     $ 0.19  
 
           
 
               
Number of shares used in per share computations:
               
Basic
    83,821       83,821  
 
           
Diluted
    91,266       91,266  
 
           

 


 

Emulex
Proposed Income Statement Changes
Reclassification of Purchased Intangible Assets Amortization Expense to Cost of Sales
Form 10-Q, Three months ended October 2, 2005 — REVISED
                 
    As Presented     As Revised  
Description   October 2, 2005     October 2, 2005  
 
               
Net Revenues
  $ 104,379     $ 104,379  
Cost of Sales
    38,149       41,802  
 
           
Gross Profit
    66,230       62,577  
 
               
Operating Expenses:
               
 
               
Engineering and development
    21,855       21,855  
Selling and Marketing
    7,957       7,957  
General and administrative
    5,944       5,944  
Amortization of intangibles
    6,384       2,731  
Impairment of goodwill
           
 
           
Total operating expenses
    42,140       38,487  
 
           
 
               
Operating income
    24,090       24,090  
 
               
Nonoperating income:
               
Interest income
    3,746       3,746  
Interest expense
    (624 )     (624 )
Gain on repurchase of convertible subordinated notes
           
Other income (expense), net
    (2 )     (2 )
 
           
Total nonoperating income
    3,120       3,120  
 
           
 
               
Income before income taxes
    27,210       27,210  
 
               
Income tax provision
    10,774       10,774  
 
               
Net income
  $ 16,436     $ 16,436  
 
           
 
               
Net income per share:
               
Basic
  $ 0.20     $ 0.20  
 
           
Diluted
  $ 0.19     $ 0.19  
 
           
 
               
Number of shares used in per share computations:
               
Basic
    83,398       83,398  
 
           
Diluted
    90,825       90,825