XML 52 R32.htm IDEA: XBRL DOCUMENT v2.4.0.6
RETIREMENT BENEFITS (Tables)
12 Months Ended
Dec. 31, 2011
Retirement benefits  
Schedule of the Company's benefit plans' projected benefit obligations

 

 

 
  Pension   SERP   OPEB  
 
  2011   2010   2011   2010   2011   2010  

Benefit obligation at beginning of year

  $ 186,840   $ 169,055   $ 2,895   $ 2,575   $ 80,938   $ 69,911  

Service cost

    5,596     4,887     93     70     2,266     2,138  

Interest cost

    10,405     10,115     183     153     4,383     4,329  

Net actuarial (gain)/loss

    20,869     10,946     1,883     160     (2,136 )   6,454  

Plan participant's contribution

                    863     949  

Benefits and expenses paid

    (8,622 )   (8,163 )   (191 )   (63 )   (3,261 )   (2,966 )

Federal subsidy

                    173     123  
                           

Benefit obligation at end of year

  $ 215,088   $ 186,840   $ 4,863   $ 2,895   $ 83,226   $ 80,938  
                           
Schedule of fair value of the plans' assets

 

 

 
  Pension   SERP   OPEB  
 
  2011   2010   2011   2010   2011   2010  

Fair value of plan assets at beginning of year

  $ 120,353   $ 107,076   $   $   $ 56,730   $ 50,036  

Actual return on plan assets — gain/(loss)

    (625 )   11,740             279     4,825  

Employer contribution

    29,869     9,700             3,544     3,681  

Benefits paid

    (8,622 )   (8,163 )           (3,160 )   (2,845 )

Plan participant's contribution

                    826     917  

Federal subsidy

                    165     116  
                           

Fair value of plan assets at end of year

  $ 140,975   $ 120,353   $   $   $ 58,384   $ 56,730  
                           
Schedule of the funded status

 

 

 
  Pension   SERP   OPEB  
 
  2011   2010   2011   2010   2011   2010  

Fair value of plan assets

  $ 140,975   $ 120,353   $   $   $ 58,384   $ 56,730  

Projected benefit obligations

    (215,088 )   (186,840 )   (4,863 )   (2,895 )   (83,226 )   (80,938 )
                           

Funded status

  $ (74,113 ) $ (66,487 ) $ (4,863 ) $ (2,895 ) $ (24,842 ) $ (24,208 )
   
Schedule of amounts recognized in the balance sheet

 

 

 
  Pension   SERP   OPEB  
 
  2011   2010   2011   2010   2011   2010  

Accounts Payable and Accrued Liabilities

  $   $   $ 311   $ 64   $ 136   $ 121  

Pension and other postretirement benefit obligation

  $ 74,113   $ 66,487   $ 4,552   $ 2,831   $ 24,706   $ 24,087  
Schedule of employee pension plan accumulated benefit obligation

 

 

 
  Pension Benefits   SERP  
 
  2011   2010   2011   2010  

Accumulated benefit obligation

  $ 191,295   $ 164,340   $ 4,670   $ 2,431
Schedule of net periodic benefit pension cost

 

 

 
  Pension   OPEB  
 
  2011   2010   2009   2011   2010   2009  

Service cost

  $ 5,596   $ 4,887   $ 4,612   $ 2,266   $ 2,138   $ 1,830  

Interest cost

    10,405     10,115     9,876     4,383     4,329     3,907  

Expected return on plan assets

    (11,139 )   (9,847 )   (10,379 )   (4,157 )   (3,844 )   (3,843 )

Amortization of prior service cost(1)

    532     531     604     (1,011 )   (1,011 )   (1,011 )

Amortization of actuarial loss(1)

    5,494     3,996     3,182     1,762     1,499     869  
                           

Net periodic benefit cost

  $ 10,888   $ 9,682   $ 7,895   $ 3,243   $ 3,111   $ 1,752  
                           

Net Periodic Pension Benefit Cost:

 
  SERP  
 
  2011   2010   2009  

Service cost

  $ 93   $ 70   $ 61  

Interest cost

    183     153     148  

Expected return on plan assets

             

Amortization of prior service cost(1)

    (8 )   (8 )   (8 )

Amortization of actuarial loss(1)

    171     96     103  
               

Net periodic benefit cost

  $ 439   $ 311   $ 304  
               
(1)
Amounts are amortized from our regulatory asset originally recorded upon recognizing our net pension liability on the balance sheet.
Schedule of activity in the regulatory asset accounts

 

 

 
   
  Amount Recognized  
Regulatory
Assets
  Beginning
Balance
12/31/10
  Current Year
Actuarial
Loss
  Amortization
of Actuarial
Loss
  Amortization
of Prior
Service
(Cost)/Credit
  Ending
Balance
12/31/11
 

Pension

  $ 67,050     32,632     (5,494 )   (532 ) $ 93,656  

SERP

  $ 1,291     1,884     (171 )   8   $ 3,012  

OPEB

  $ 16,031     1,740     (1,762 )   1,011   $ 17,020  
Schedule of net actuarial gains / losses, transition obligations / assets and prior period service costs in regulatory assets not yet recognized as a component of net periodic benefit cost and the amounts expected to be recognized in the subsequent year

 

 

 
  Pension Benefits   SERP   OPEB  
 
  2011   Subsequent
Period
  2011   Subsequent
Period
  2011   Subsequent
Period
 

Net actuarial loss

  $ 91,144   $ 7,799   $ 3,051   $ 305   $ 22,637   $ 1,871  

Prior service cost (benefit)

    2,512     532     (39 )   (8 )   (5,617 )   (1,011 )
                           

Total

  $ 93,656   $ 8,331   $ 3,012   $ 297   $ 17,020   $ 860  
                           
Schedule of assumptions used to determine the benefit obligation

 

 

 
  Pension Benefits   OPEB  
 
  2011   2010   2011   2010  

Discount rate

    4.70 %   5.50 %   4.90 %   5.50 %

Rate of compensation increase

    3.50 %   4.50 %   3.50 %   4.50 %
Schedule of assumptions used to determine the periodic costs

 

 

 
  Pension Benefits   OPEB  
 
  2011   2010   2009   2011   2010   2009  

Discount rate

    5.50 %   6.00 %   6.30 %   5.50 %   6.00 %   6.30 %

Expected return on plan assets

    8.00 %   8.00 %   8.50 %   7.00 %   7.00 %   7.45 %

Rate of compensation increase

    4.50 %   4.50 %   4.50 %   4.50 %   4.50 %   4.50 %
Pensions
 
Retirement benefits  
Schedule of expected benefit payments

 

 

Year
  Payments from Trust   Payments from
Company Funds
 

2012

  $ 8.4   $ 0.3  

2013

    9.0     0.3  

2014

    9.7     0.3  

2015

    10.4     0.3  

2016

    11.1     0.3  

2017 – 2021

  $ 65.9   $ 1.9  
Schedule of fund assets measured at fair value

 

 

 
  Fair Value Measurements as of December 31, 2011  
 
  Quoted Prices
in Active
Markets for
Identical
Assets
(Level 1)
  Significant
Other
Observable
Inputs
(Level 2)
  Significant
Unobservable
Inputs
(Level 3)
  Total   Percentage
of Plan
Assets
 

Short term investments

  $   $ 1,787   $   $ 1,787     1.2 %

Equity securities

                               

U.S. equity

    57,228             57,228     40.6 %

International equity

    19,151             19,151     13.6 %

Fixed income

                               

Common collective trust

        22,904         22,904     16.3 %

U.S. corporate debt

        11,692         11,692     8.3 %

U.S. government debt

    794             794     0.6 %

Other types of investments

                               

Equity long/short hedge funds

            27,419     27,419     19.4 %
                       

 

  $ 77,173   $ 36,383   $ 27,419   $ 140,975     100.0 %
                       

 

 
  Fair Value Measurements as of December 31, 2010  
 
  Quoted Prices
in Active
Markets for
Identical
Assets
(Level 1)
  Significant
Other
Observable
Inputs
(Level 2)
  Significant
Unobservable
Inputs
(Level 3)
  Total   Percentage
of Plan
Assets
 

Short term investments

  $   $ 1,387   $   $ 1,387     1.1 %

Equity securities

                               

U.S. equity

    47,797             47,797     39.7 %

International equity

    15,876             15,876     13.2 %

Fixed income

                               

Common collective trust

        32,955         32,955     27.4 %

Other types of investments

                               

Equity long/short hedge funds

            22,338     22,338     18.6 %
                       

 

  $ 63,673   $ 34,342   $ 22,338   $ 120,353     100.0 %
                       
Schedule of fair value measurements using significant unobservable inputs (level 3)
 
  2011   2010  
 
  Equity long/short
hedge funds
  Equity long/short
hedge funds
 

Beginning Balance, January 1,

  $ 22,338   $ 23,515  

Actual return on plan assets:

             

Relating to assets still held at the reporting date

    (669 )   1,423  

Relating to assets sold during the period

         

Purchases

    5,750      

Sales

        (2,600 )

Settlements

           

Transfers into and (out of) Level 3

         
           

Ending Balance, December 31,

  $ 27,419   $ 22,338  
           
Schedule of permissible investments

 

 

Equity Oriented
 
Fixed Income Oriented and Real Estate
  Common Stocks     Bonds
  Preferred Stocks     GICs, BICs
  Convertible Preferred Stocks     Corporate Bonds (minimum quality rating
  Convertible Bonds       of Baa or BBB)
  Covered Options     Cash-Equivalent Securities (e.g., U.S.
  Hedged Equity Funds of Funds       T-Bills, Commercial Paper, etc.)
    protection     Certificates of Deposit in institutions with FDIC/FSLIC
          Money Market Funds / Bank STIF Funds
          Real Estate — Publicly Traded

        The above assets can be held in commingled (mutual) funds as well as privately managed separate accounts.

        Those investments prohibited by the Investment Committee without prior approval are:

Prohibited Investments Requiring Pre-approval

  Privately Placed Securities     Warrants
  Commodities Futures     Short Sales
  Securities of Empire District     Index Options
  Derivatives        
OPEB
 
Retirement benefits  
Schedule of expected benefit payments

 

 

Year
  Payments from Trust   Expected Federal
Subsidy
  Payments from
Company Funds
 

2012

  $ 2.3   $ 0.3   $ 0.1  

2013

    2.6     0.3     0.1  

2014

    2.9     0.4     0.1  

2015

    3.1     0.4     0.1  

2016

    3.5     0.5     0.2  

2017 – 2021

  $ 21.3   $ 3.1   $ 0.9  
Schedule of effect of 1% change in assumed healthcare cost growth rates

 

 

 
  1% Increase   1% Decrease  

Effect on total of service and interest cost

  $ 1,258   $ (990 )

Effect on post-retirement benefit obligation

  $ 12,663   $ (10,235 )
Schedule of fund assets measured at fair value

 

 

 
  Fair Value Measurements as of December 31, 2011  
 
  Quoted Prices
in Active
Markets for
Identical
Assets
(Level 1)
  Significant
Other
Observable
Inputs
(Level 2)
  Significant
Unobservable
Inputs
(Level 3)
  Total   Percentage
of Plan
Assets
 

Cash and cash equivalents

  $ 1,536   $   $   $ 1,536     2.6 %

Fixed income

                               

U.S. government debt

        1,839         1,839     3.1 %

U.S. corporate debt

        17,232         17,232     29.5 %

Foreign debt

        1,460         1,460     2.5 %

Mutual funds — fixed income

    2,107             2,107     3.6 %

Equity securities

                               

U.S. equity

    21,080             21,080     36.1 %

International equity

    1,784             1,784     3.1 %

Mutual funds — equity

    11,075             11,075     19.0 %
                         

 

    37,582     20,531         58,113        
                           

Accrued interest & dividends

                      271     0.5 %
                             

 

                    $ 58,384     100 %
                             

 

 
  Fair Value Measurements as of December 31, 2010  
 
  Quoted Prices
in Active
Markets for
Identical
Assets
(Level 1)
  Significant
Other
Observable
Inputs
(Level 2)
  Significant
Unobservable
Inputs
(Level 3)
  Total   Percentage
of Plan
Assets
 

Cash and cash equivalents

  $ 3,897   $   $   $ 3,897     7.0 %

Fixed income

                               

U.S. government debt

        4,091         4,091     7.2 %

U.S. corporate debt

        15,156         15,156     26.7 %

Foreign debt

        420         420     0.7 %

Mutual funds — fixed income

    1,496             1,496     2.6 %

Equity securities

                               

U.S. equity

    17,592             17,592     31.0 %

International equity

    1,274             1,274     2.2 %

Mutual funds — equity

    12,556             12,556     22.1 %
                         

 

    36,815     19,667         56,482        
                           

Accrued interest & dividends

                      248     0.5 %
                             

 

                    $ 56,730     100 %
                             
Schedule of permissible investments

 

 

Equity
 
Fixed Income
  Common Stocks     Cash-Equivalent Securities with a maturity
  Preferred Stocks       of one-year or less
          Bonds
          Money Market Funds / Bank STIF Funds
          Certificates of Deposit in institutions with FDIC protection
          Corporate Bonds (minimum quality rating of A)

        The above assets can be held in commingled (mutual) funds as well as privately managed separate accounts.

        Listed below are those investments prohibited by the Investment Committee:

Prohibited Investments

  Privately Placed Securities     Margin Transactions
  Commodities Futures     Short Sales
  Securities of Empire District     Index Options
  Derivatives     Real Estate and Real Property
  Instrumentalities in violation of the Prohibited Transactions Standards of ERISA     Restricted Stock