CORRESP 1 filename1.htm snfccorr032009.htm



SECURITY NATIONAL FINANCIAL CORPORATION
5300 South 360 West, Suite 250
Salt Lake City, Utah 84123
Telephone (801) 264-1060
 

 
March 20, 2009
 

 
VIA EDGAR

U. S. Securities and Exchange Commission
Division of Corporation Finance
100 F Street, N.E., Mail Stop 4561
Washington, D. C. 20549

Attn: 
Sharon M. Blume
  Assistant Chief Accountant
 

Re: 
Security National Financial Corporation
   
Form 10-K for the Fiscal Year Ended December 31, 2007
   
Form 10-Q for Fiscal Quarter Ended June 30, 2008
   
File No. 0-9341

Dear Ms. Blume:

Security National Financial Corporation (the “Company”) hereby supplements its responses to its previous response letters dated February 20, 2009, January 15, 2009, November 6, 2008, and October 9, 2008.  With this supplemental response is provided as additional information concerning the Company’s mortgage loan operations and the appropriate accounting that the Company follows in connection with such operations.

The Company has also included in this response the table that was part of its November 6, 2008 reply to the Securities Exchange Commission to assist in explaining the methodology that the Company follows in determining fair value of the mortgage loans repurchased.  In the table the Company has changed the heading “Loan Principal Amount” to “Unpaid Principal Amount on Date of Repurchase.”  In addition, the Company has added two columns showing the “Fair Value at Repurchase Date” and the “Unrecognized Gains and (Losses)” with respect to the mortgage loans.

The fair value at the repurchase date was based upon the following criteria:

 
·
For loans where there was a market, the Company used the market price on the repurchase date;

 
·
For loans where there was no market but there was a similar product, the Company used the market value for the similar product on the repurchase date; and
 
 
 

 
 
 
·
For loans where no market existed on the repurchase date, the Company determined the unpaid principal balance that best approximated the market value on the repurchase date, after considering the fair value of the underlying real estate collateral and the estimated future cash flows.

The appraisal of the collateral of the original loans adds significance to the Company’s determination of fair value because if any of the loans become delinquent the Company has sufficient value to collect the unpaid principal balance or the carrying value of the loans.

In determining the fair value on the date of repurchase, the Company considered the total value of all of the mortgage loans because any sale of loans would be made as a pool.  As shown on the table, the total fair value at the date of repurchase was $36,379,793, which is in excess of the cost of $36,290,743. The repurchased mortgage loans were recorded at the cost of the outstanding principal balance of the loans. The aggregate fair value of the repurchased loans was $89,050 greater than the outstanding principal balance of the loans. This excess of the fair value over the cost of the mortgage loans was not recognized.

The enclosed table is the quantitative lower of cost or market analysis, which has been reviewed by the Company’s independent registered public accounting firm.

In connection with the Company’s responses to the comments, the Company hereby acknowledges as follows:
 
 
·
The Company is responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in the filing;
 
 
·
The staff comments or changes to disclosure in response to staff comments do not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the filing; and
 
 
·
The Company may not assert staff comments as defense in any proceeding initiated by the Commission or any person under the federal securities laws of the United States.
 
If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to call me at (801) 264-1060 or (801) 287-8171.

 
 
Very truly yours,
   
  /s/ Stephen M. Sill
   
  Stephen M. Sill
  Vice President, Treasurer and
  Chief Financial Officer

 
 

 

         
Unpaid
             
Date
 
         
Principal
             
Transferred
 
   
Date
   
Amount
   
Fair Value at
   
Unrecognized
 
to Mortgage
 
   
Originally
Date
 
on Date of
   
Repurchase
   
Gains
 
Loans Held
 
Loan No.
 
Sold
Repurchased
 
Repurchase
   
Date
   
(Losses)
 
for Investment
Comment
  0000359018  
1/3/2007
5/25/2007
  $ 80,618     $ 80,215     $ (403 )
5/25/2007
 
  0000353101  
1/8/2007
4/5/2007
    336,179       337,019       840  
4/5/2007
 
  0000359820  
1/8/2007
7/5/2007
    97,266       97,266       -  
7/5/2007
 
  0000358565  
1/10/2007
4/6/2007
    98,024       98,514       490  
4/6/2007
 
  0000361386  
1/24/2007
4/19/2007
    272,520       276,949       4,428  
4/19/2007
 
  0000361909  
1/26/2007
4/18/2007
    118,526       118,378       (148 )
4/18/2007
 
  0000362032  
1/26/2007
5/25/2007
    221,139       216,440       (4,699 )
5/25/2007
 
  0000360538  
2/1/2007
7/5/2007
    151,384       148,924       (2,460 )
7/5/2007
 
  0000364462  
2/14/2007
4/19/2007
    176,512       176,070       (441 )
4/19/2007
 
  0000364111  
2/16/2007
4/19/2007
    140,230       140,581       351  
4/19/2007
 
  0000365108  
2/22/2007
7/5/2007
    228,779       228,493       (286 )
7/5/2007
 
  0000363101  
2/28/2007
5/16/2007
    343,754       340,316       (3,438 )
5/16/2007
 
  0000363543  
3/1/2007
5/16/2007
    229,188       232,625       3,438  
5/16/2007
 
  0000363163  
3/2/2007
5/25/2007
    283,182       287,430       4,248  
5/25/2007
 
  0000367001  
3/6/2007
7/5/2007
    413,528       411,978       (1,551 )
7/5/2007
 
  0000366253  
3/13/2007
7/18/2007
    165,249       160,498       (4,751 )
7/18/2007
 
  0000367878  
3/19/2007
7/23/2007
    94,479       93,298       (1,181 )
7/23/2007
 
  0000368126  
3/22/2007
6/8/2007
    76,734       77,309       576  
6/8/2007
 
  0000368489  
3/22/2007
7/5/2007
    93,720       92,782       (937 )
7/5/2007
 
  0000369548  
3/22/2007
7/18/2007
    223,105       219,480       (3,625 )
7/18/2007
 
  0000369672  
4/2/2007
7/18/2007
    407,882       404,823       (3,059 )
7/18/2007
 
  0000371240  
4/5/2007
4/5/2007
    212,093       214,479       2,386  
4/5/2007
 
  0000371402  
4/5/2007
4/5/2007
    139,194       141,977       2,784  
4/5/2007
 
  0000370997  
4/17/2007
7/25/2007
    114,759       116,337       1,578  
7/25/2007
 
  0000372876  
4/20/2007
8/3/2007
    260,916       249,501       (11,415 )
8/3/2007
 
  0000371498  
4/26/2007
7/25/2007
    426,805       424,671       (2,134 )
7/25/2007
 
  0000373738  
5/3/2007
7/25/2007
    260,564       259,261       (1,303 )
7/25/2007
 
  0000373805  
5/3/2007
8/3/2007
    324,505       322,477       (2,028 )
8/3/2007
 
  0000373859  
5/3/2007
7/25/2007
    262,122       256,224       (5,898 )
7/25/2007
 
  0000372868  
5/4/2007
8/15/2007
    161,550       160,338       (1,212 )
8/15/2007
 
  0000377442  
5/10/2007
5/10/2007
    292,355       292,355       -  
5/10/2007
 
  0000376305  
5/21/2007
8/15/2007
    245,272       247,418       2,146  
8/15/2007
 
  0000378002  
5/22/2007
7/23/2007
    298,889       293,285       (5,604 )
7/23/2007
 
  0000374865  
5/23/2007
5/23/2007
    528,019       542,539       14,521  
5/23/2007
 
  0000373779  
5/25/2007
7/23/2007
    404,022       406,042       2,020  
7/23/2007
 
  0000379701  
5/30/2007
8/17/2007
    395,096       387,194       (7,902 )
8/17/2007
 
  0000376921  
5/31/2007
5/29/2007
    359,532       359,981       449  
5/29/2007
 
  0000379859  
5/31/2007
7/23/2007
    96,415       95,451       (964 )
7/23/2007
 
  0000377932  
6/1/2007
8/16/2007
    174,760       166,241       (8,520 )
8/16/2007
 
  0000378701  
6/5/2007
7/24/2007
    874,890       882,545       7,655  
7/24/2007
 
  0000377762  
6/6/2007
8/15/2007
    320,170       312,966       (7,204 )
8/15/2007
 
  0000378301  
6/6/2007
8/17/2007
    545,500       545,500       -  
8/17/2007
 
  0000379200  
6/6/2007
8/17/2007
    175,922       172,184       (3,738 )
8/17/2007
 
  0000378219  
6/8/2007
6/8/2007
    700,898       711,412       10,513  
6/8/2007
 
  0000380975  
6/11/2007
7/23/2007
    232,393       230,360       (2,033 )
7/23/2007
 
  0000378523  
6/15/2007
8/16/2007
    234,502       230,691       (3,811 )
8/16/2007
 
  0000378492  
6/19/2007
8/15/2007
    434,552       429,120       (5,432 )
8/15/2007
 
  0000380891  
6/28/2007
8/24/2007
    210,581       212,950       2,369  
8/24/2007
 
  0000383783  
6/28/2007
9/5/2007
    276,201       276,201       -  
9/5/2007
 
 
 
 

 

         
Unpaid
             
Date
 
         
Principal
             
Transferred
 
   
Date
   
Amount
   
Fair Value at
   
Unrecognized
 
to Mortgage
 
   
Originally
Date
 
on Date of
   
Repurchase
   
Gains
 
Loans Held
 
Loan No.
 
Sold
Repurchased
 
Repurchase
   
Date
   
(Losses)
 
for Investment
Comment
  0000383111  
6/29/2007
10/15/2007
  $ 450,297     $ 450,297     $ -  
10/15/2007
 
  0000384760  
7/5/2007
9/7/2007
    59,556       59,556       -  
9/7/2007
Second mortgage
  0000383321  
7/6/2007
9/7/2007
    87,273       87,273       -  
9/7/2007
Second mortgage
  0000384014  
7/6/2007
9/7/2007
    121,398       121,398       -  
9/7/2007
Second mortgage
  0000384048  
7/6/2007
10/2/2007
    67,345       67,850       505  
10/2/2007
 
  0000384301  
7/12/2007
11/2/2007
    89,339       91,684       2,345  
11/2/2007
 
  0000386724  
7/13/2007
10/23/2007
    367,577       368,496       919  
10/23/2007
 
  0000384842  
7/18/2007
9/7/2007
    91,326       91,326       -  
9/7/2007
Second mortgage
  0000383794  
7/20/2007
9/7/2007
    12,711       12,711       -  
9/7/2007
Second mortgage
  0000384918  
7/20/2007
9/7/2007
    69,096       69,096       -  
9/7/2007
Second mortgage
  0000380779  
7/23/2007
11/2/2007
    32,612       33,753       1,141  
11/2/2007
 
  0000383208  
7/23/2007
10/2/2007
    288,808       288,808       -  
10/2/2007
 
  0000384902  
7/23/2007
8/8/2007
    275,615       271,481       (4,134 )
8/8/2007
 
  0000387455  
7/23/2007
9/7/2007
    148,091       148,091       -  
9/7/2007
Second mortgage
  0000386316  
7/27/2007
1/10/2008
    76,040       76,040       -  
1/10/2008
 
  0000387760  
7/27/2007
9/7/2007
    52,415       52,415       -  
9/7/2007
Second mortgage
  0000386848  
7/30/2007
9/7/2007
    23,552       23,552       -  
9/7/2007
Second mortgage
  0000387513  
7/30/2007
11/8/2007
    321,637       329,276       7,639  
11/8/2007
 
  0000388152  
7/30/2007
9/7/2007
    45,805       45,805       -  
9/7/2007
Second mortgage
  0000383602  
7/31/2007
11/8/2007
    518,174       518,174       -  
11/8/2007
 
  0000383603  
7/31/2007
9/7/2007
    63,680       63,680       -  
9/7/2007
Second mortgage
  0000386048  
7/31/2007
9/7/2007
    133,116       133,116       -  
9/7/2007
Second mortgage
  0000386780  
7/31/2007
9/7/2007
    110,480       110,480       -  
9/7/2007
Second mortgage
  0000388419  
7/31/2007
9/7/2007
    172,853       172,853       -  
9/7/2007
Second mortgage
  0000388472  
7/31/2007
9/7/2007
    33,492       33,492       -  
9/7/2007
Second mortgage
  0000388498  
7/31/2007
11/6/2007
    377,907       383,575       5,669  
11/6/2007
 
  0000388621  
7/31/2007
9/7/2007
    101,723       101,723       -  
9/7/2007
Second mortgage
  0000386108  
8/2/2007
9/12/2007
    183,349       187,016       3,667  
9/12/2007
 
  0000386202  
8/2/2007
9/12/2007
    291,258       294,171       2,913  
9/12/2007
 
  0000387432  
8/2/2007
10/9/2007
    149,738       152,920       3,182  
10/9/2007
 
  0000387770  
8/2/2007
9/24/2007
    142,583       146,148       3,565  
9/24/2007
 
  0000387785  
8/2/2007
10/15/2007
    59,554       59,554       -  
10/15/2007
 
  0000383933  
8/3/2007
11/8/2007
    141,977       144,284       2,307  
11/8/2007
 
  0000385514  
8/3/2007
11/2/2007
    107,018       107,018       -  
11/2/2007
 
  0000385541  
8/3/2007
9/7/2007
    82,294       82,294       -  
9/7/2007
Second mortgage
  0000386886  
8/3/2007
11/6/2007
    190,418       190,418       -  
11/6/2007
 
  0000388616  
8/3/2007
11/6/2007
    146,115       146,115       -  
11/6/2007
 
  0000388687  
8/3/2007
9/7/2007
    47,523       47,523       -  
9/7/2007
Second mortgage
  0000389017  
8/3/2007
9/7/2007
    24,313       24,313       -  
9/7/2007
Second mortgage
  0000384348  
8/6/2007
11/6/2007
    163,561       163,561       -  
11/6/2007
 
  0000380328  
8/8/2007
11/8/2007
    730,330       730,330       -  
11/8/2007
 
  0000383148  
8/8/2007
9/7/2007
    124,616       124,616       -  
9/7/2007
Second mortgage
  0000387151  
8/8/2007
11/6/2007
    186,961       186,961       -  
11/6/2007
 
  0000389674  
8/8/2007
9/7/2007
    45,424       45,424       -  
9/7/2007
Second mortgage
  0000383141  
8/10/2007
11/6/2007
    498,008       500,498       2,490  
11/6/2007
 
  0000388263  
8/10/2007
11/6/2007
    184,244       184,244       -  
11/6/2007
 
  0000388413  
8/10/2007
9/7/2007
    51,402       51,402       -  
9/7/2007
Second mortgage
  0000389295  
8/10/2007
11/6/2007
    211,963       211,963       -  
11/6/2007
 
  0000389373  
8/10/2007
9/7/2007
    50,438       50,438       -  
9/7/2007
Second mortgage
  0000390584  
8/10/2007
9/7/2007
    20,728       20,728       -  
9/7/2007
Second mortgage
  0000387861  
8/13/2007
9/7/2007
    64,435       64,435       -  
9/7/2007
Second mortgage
  0000390568  
8/15/2007
11/6/2007
    180,303       181,204       902  
11/6/2007
 
  0000387977  
8/16/2007
11/6/2007
    448,085       448,085       -  
11/6/2007
 
  0000391441  
8/17/2007
9/7/2007
    35,183       35,183       -  
9/7/2007
Second mortgage
 
 
 

 

         
Unpaid
             
Date
 
         
Principal
             
Transferred
 
   
Date
   
Amount
   
Fair Value at
   
Unrecognized
 
to Mortgage
 
   
Originally
Date
 
on Date of
   
Repurchase
   
Gains
 
Loans Held
 
Loan No.
 
Sold
Repurchased
 
Repurchase
   
Date
   
(Losses)
 
for Investment
Comment
  0000389620  
8/20/2007
9/7/2007
  $ 48,660     $ 48,660     $ -  
9/7/2007
Second mortgage
  0000392712  
8/22/2007
9/7/2007
    90,105       90,105       -  
9/7/2007
Second mortgage
  0000389032  
8/23/2007
3/22/2008
    388,488       393,344       4,856  
3/22/2008
 
  0000389795  
8/23/2007
9/7/2007
    116,754       116,754       -  
9/7/2007
Second mortgage
  0000391266  
8/23/2007
2/6/2008
    285,985       289,560       3,575  
2/6/2008
 
  0000389080  
8/27/2007
9/7/2007
    58,159       58,159       -  
9/7/2007
Second mortgage
  0000390829  
8/27/2007
9/7/2007
    61,284       61,284       -  
9/7/2007
Second mortgage
  0000388125  
8/28/2007
10/18/2007
    163,487       167,370       3,883  
10/18/2007
 
  0000391848  
8/28/2007
1/10/2008
    279,006       280,052       1,046  
1/10/2008
 
  0000388411  
8/30/2007
11/6/2007
    105,766       108,014       2,248  
11/6/2007
 
  0000386777  
8/31/2007
3/22/2008
    284,456       292,990       8,534  
3/22/2008
 
  0000390339  
8/31/2007
9/7/2007
    50,432       50,432       -  
9/7/2007
Second mortgage
  0000390635  
8/31/2007
11/6/2007
    488,577       488,577       -  
11/6/2007
 
  0000391526  
8/31/2007
11/6/2007
    170,101       168,825       (1,276 )
11/6/2007
 
  0000391531  
8/31/2007
9/7/2007
    20,993       20,993       -  
9/7/2007
Second mortgage
  0000392283  
8/31/2007
11/6/2007
    291,486       292,579       1,093  
11/6/2007
 
  0000392717  
8/31/2007
11/6/2007
    76,395       76,968       573  
11/6/2007
 
  0000393295  
8/31/2007
2/6/2008
    213,907       214,441       535  
2/6/2008
 
  0000393413  
8/31/2007
10/23/2007
    61,416       63,182       1,766  
10/23/2007
 
  0000392734  
9/6/2007
9/7/2007
    16,450       16,450       -  
9/7/2007
Second mortgage
  0000393755  
9/14/2007
11/6/2007
    307,655       308,808       1,154  
11/6/2007
 
  0000397794  
9/28/2007
11/6/2007
    490,469       503,344       12,875  
11/6/2007
 
  0000394599  
10/3/2007
2/6/2008
    34,484       34,484       -  
2/6/2008
 
  0000398973  
10/12/2007
1/30/2008
    193,848       196,998       3,150  
1/30/2008
 
  0000397237  
10/18/2007
10/26/2007
    229,819       234,416       4,596  
10/26/2007
 
  0000397546  
10/18/2007
2/6/2008
    290,205       292,744       2,539  
2/6/2008
 
  0000397836  
10/29/2007
1/17/2008
    249,140       250,697       1,557  
1/17/2008
 
  0000401347  
11/1/2007
2/6/2008
    285,493       290,132       4,639  
2/6/2008
 
  0000399618  
11/2/2007
3/3/2008
    380,195       381,145       950  
3/3/2008
 
  0000400563  
11/2/2007
3/3/2008
    178,995       180,562       1,566  
3/3/2008
 
  0000401874  
11/2/2007
3/3/2008
    333,152       333,984       833  
3/3/2008
 
  0000398717  
11/7/2007
3/3/2008
    144,115       145,376       1,261  
3/3/2008
 
  0000401129  
11/7/2007
1/17/2008
    185,702       187,327       1,625  
1/17/2008
 
  0000402579  
11/8/2007
3/3/2008
    76,192       76,859       667  
3/3/2008
 
  0000401965  
11/15/2007
1/17/2008
    115,918       116,353       435  
1/17/2008
 
  0000401640  
11/19/2007
1/17/2008
    211,187       210,131       (1,056 )
1/17/2008
 
  0000402731  
11/19/2007
3/22/2008
    312,154       308,642       (3,512 )
3/22/2008
 
  0000403623  
11/19/2007
3/22/2008
    93,729       95,135       1,406  
3/22/2008
 
  0000403657  
11/19/2007
3/22/2008
    126,225       127,961       1,736  
3/22/2008
 
  0000392356  
11/28/2007
2/6/2008
    64,205       64,285       80  
2/6/2008
 
  0000398830  
12/3/2007
4/5/2008
    265,824       265,824       -  
4/5/2008
 
  0000403313  
12/3/2007
3/22/2008
    231,169       230,880       (289 )
3/22/2008
 
  0000403460  
12/3/2007
3/22/2008
    269,530       275,931       6,401  
3/22/2008
 
  0000403834  
12/3/2007
2/15/2008
    177,994       178,439       445  
2/15/2008
 
  0000404076  
12/3/2007
3/22/2008
    272,738       277,511       4,773  
3/22/2008
 
  0000404161  
12/3/2007
3/22/2008
    414,833       418,981       4,148  
3/22/2008
 
  0000405156  
12/3/2007
3/22/2008
    300,564       303,570       3,006  
3/22/2008
 
  0000405179  
12/3/2007
3/22/2008
    63,509       63,747       238  
3/22/2008
 
  0000406217  
12/3/2007
3/22/2008
    367,155       364,401       (2,754 )
3/22/2008
 
 
 
 

 

         
Unpaid
             
Date
 
         
Principal
             
Transferred
 
   
Date
   
Amount
   
Fair Value at
   
Unrecognized
 
to Mortgage
 
   
Originally
Date
 
on Date of
   
Repurchase
   
Gains
 
Loans Held
 
Loan No.
 
Sold
Repurchased
 
Repurchase
   
Date
   
(Losses)
 
for Investment
Comment
  0000399498  
12/5/2007
4/5/2008
  $ 133,408     $ 135,909     $ 2,501  
4/5/2008
 
  0000402910  
12/7/2007
3/22/2008
    84,303       83,986       (316 )
3/22/2008
 
  0000404475  
12/7/2007
3/22/2008
    104,584       104,584       -  
3/22/2008
 
  0000405718  
12/10/2007
4/2/2008
    403,441       400,415       (3,026 )
4/2/2008
 
  0000401355  
12/13/2007
4/2/2008
    198,604       198,604       -  
4/2/2008
 
  0000403433  
12/21/2007
3/6/2008
    60,372       61,353       981  
3/6/2008
 
  0000404292  
12/21/2007
4/14/2008
    561,902       561,902       -  
4/14/2008
 
  0000406046  
12/31/2007
4/2/2008
    355,669       356,113       445  
4/2/2008
 
  0000407797  
12/31/2007
4/14/2008
    419,647       431,711       12,065  
4/14/2008
 
  0000408472  
12/31/2007
4/14/2008
    271,094       268,044       (3,050 )
4/14/2008
 
  0000405587  
1/3/2008
5/2/2008
    88,655       90,539       1,884  
5/2/2008
 
  0000407451  
1/3/2008
3/6/2008
    101,156       101,283       126  
3/6/2008
 
  0000409219  
1/10/2008
5/7/2008
    256,620       254,695       (1,925 )
5/7/2008
 
  0000405832  
1/17/2008
5/2/2008
    286,063       286,063       -  
5/2/2008
 
  0000409945  
1/17/2008
5/2/2008
    153,398       154,165       767  
5/2/2008
 
  0000410311  
1/17/2008
5/2/2008
    101,733       100,716       (1,017 )
5/2/2008
 
  0000410513  
1/17/2008
5/7/2008
    295,687       298,274       2,587  
5/7/2008
 
  0000411123  
1/17/2008
5/7/2008
    359,280       359,280       -  
5/7/2008
 
  0000408350  
1/25/2008
5/2/2008
    148,812       148,812       -  
5/2/2008
 
                                     
            $ 36,290,743     $ 36,379,793     $ 89,050