XML 98 R21.htm IDEA: XBRL DOCUMENT v3.22.4
Concentrations of Credit Risk
12 Months Ended
Dec. 31, 2022
Risks and Uncertainties [Abstract]  
Concentrations of Credit Risk Concentrations of Credit Risk
Concentrations of credit risk arise when a number of customers and counterparties engage in similar activities or have similar economic characteristics that make them susceptible to similar changes in industry conditions, which could affect their ability to meet their contractual obligations. Based on our assessment of business conditions that could impact our financial results, we have determined that concentrations of credit risk exist among:
single-family and multifamily borrowers (including geographic concentrations and loans with certain higher-risk characteristics);
mortgage insurers;
mortgage sellers and servicers;
multifamily lenders with risk sharing; and
derivative counterparties and parties associated with our off-balance sheet transactions.
Concentrations for each of these groups are discussed below.
Single-Family Loan Borrowers
Regional economic conditions may affect a borrower’s ability to repay a mortgage loan and the property value underlying the loan. Geographic concentrations increase the exposure of our guaranty book of business to changes in credit risk. Single-family borrowers are primarily affected by home prices and interest rates.
To manage credit risk and comply with our charter requirements, we typically require primary mortgage insurance or other credit enhancements if the current LTV ratio (i.e., the ratio of the unpaid principal balance of a loan to the current value of the property that serves as collateral) of a single-family conventional mortgage loan is greater than 80% when the loan is delivered to us.
Multifamily Loan Borrowers
Numerous factors affect a multifamily borrower’s ability to repay the loan and the value of the property underlying the loan. Multifamily loans are generally non-recourse to the borrower. The most significant factors affecting credit risk are rental income, property valuations, and general economic conditions. The average unpaid principal balance for multifamily loans is significantly larger than for single-family borrowers and, therefore, individual defaults for multifamily borrowers can result in more significant losses. We continually monitor the performance and risk characteristics of our multifamily loans, underlying properties and borrowers on an ongoing basis.
As part of our multifamily risk management activities, we perform detailed loan reviews that evaluate property performance, borrower and geographic concentrations, lender qualifications, counterparty risk and contract compliance. We generally require mortgage servicers to obtain and submit periodic property operating information and condition reviews, allowing us to monitor the performance of individual loans. We use this information to evaluate the credit quality of our portfolio, identify potential problem loans and initiate appropriate loss mitigation activities.
Geographic Concentration
The following table displays the regional geographic concentration of single-family and multifamily loans in our guaranty book of business, measured by the unpaid principal balance of the loans.
Geographic Concentration(1)
Percentage of Single-Family Conventional Guaranty Book of BusinessPercentage of Multifamily Guaranty Book of Business
As of December 31,As of December 31,
2022202120222021
Midwest14 %14 %12 %11 %
Northeast16 16 15 15 
Southeast23 23 27 27 
Southwest19 18 22 22 
West28 29 24 25 
Total100 %100 %100 %100 %
(1)Midwest consists of IL, IN, IA, MI, MN, NE, ND, OH, SD and WI. Northeast consists of CT, DE, ME, MA, NH, NJ, NY, PA, PR, RI, VT and VI. Southeast consists of AL, DC, FL, GA, KY, MD, MS, NC, SC, TN, VA and WV. Southwest consists of AZ, AR, CO, KS, LA, MO, NM, OK, TX and UT. West consists of AK, CA, GU, HI, ID, MT, NV, OR, WA and WY.
Risk Characteristics of our Guaranty Book of Business
One of the measures by which we gauge our credit risk is the delinquency status of the mortgage loans in our guaranty book of business.
For single-family and multifamily loans, we use this information, in conjunction with housing market and other economic data, to structure our pricing and our eligibility and underwriting criteria to reflect the current risk of loans with higher-risk characteristics, and in some cases we decide to significantly reduce our participation in riskier loan product categories. Management also uses this data together with other credit risk measures to identify key trends that guide the development of our loss mitigation strategies.
We report the delinquency status of our single-family and multifamily guaranty book of business below. We report loans receiving COVID-19-related payment forbearance as delinquent according to the contractual terms of the loans.
Single-Family Credit Risk Characteristics
For single-family loans, management monitors the serious delinquency rate, which is the percentage of single-family loans (based on number of loans) that are 90 days or more past due or in the foreclosure process, and loans that have higher risk characteristics, such as high mark-to-market LTV ratios.
The following tables display the delinquency status and serious delinquency rates for specified loan categories of our single-family conventional guaranty book of business.
As of December 31,
20222021
30 Days Delinquent60 Days Delinquent
Seriously Delinquent(1)
30 Days Delinquent60 Days Delinquent
Seriously Delinquent(1)
Percentage of single-family conventional guaranty book of business based on UPB0.84 %0.20 %0.60 %0.73 %0.16 %1.20 %
Percentage of single-family conventional loans based on loan count0.96 0.23 0.65 0.86 0.20 1.25 
As of December 31,
20222021
Percentage of
Single-Family
Conventional
Guaranty Book
of Business Based on UPB
Seriously Delinquent
Rate(1)
Percentage of
Single-Family
Conventional
Guaranty Book
of Business Based on UPB
Seriously Delinquent
Rate(1)
Estimated mark-to-market LTV ratio:
80.01% to 90%5 %0.68 %%0.88 %
90.01% to 100%3 0.40 0.51 
Greater than 100%*4.04 *12.41 
Geographical distribution:
California19 0.46 19 1.01 
Florida6 0.90 1.59 
Illinois3 0.86 1.55 
New Jersey3 0.85 1.90 
New York5 1.12 2.24 
All other states64 0.62 64 1.16 
Vintages:
2008 and prior2 2.78 4.90 
2009-202298 0.53 97 1.01 
* Represents less than 0.5% of single-family conventional book of business.
(1)Based on loan count, consists of single-family conventional loans that were 90 days or more past due or in the foreclosure process as of December 31, 2022 and 2021.
Multifamily Credit Risk Characteristics
For multifamily loans, management monitors the serious delinquency rate, which is the percentage of multifamily loans, based on unpaid principal balance, that are 60 days or more past due, and loans with other higher risk characteristics to determine our overall credit quality of our multifamily book of business. Higher risk characteristics include, but are not limited to, current DSCR below 1.0 and original LTV ratios greater than 80%. We stratify multifamily loans into different internal risk categories based on the credit risk inherent in each individual loan.
The following tables display the delinquency status and serious delinquency rates for specified loan categories of our multifamily guaranty book of business.
As of December 31,
2022(1)
 2021(1)
30 Days Delinquent
Seriously Delinquent(2)
30 Days Delinquent
Seriously Delinquent(2)
Percentage of multifamily guaranty book of business0.04 %0.24 %0.03 %0.42 %
As of December 31,
20222021
Percentage of Multifamily Guaranty Book of Business(1)
Serious Delinquency Rate(2)(3)
Percentage of Multifamily Guaranty Book of Business(1)
Serious Delinquency Rate(2)(3)
Original LTV ratio:
Greater than 80%1 %0.85 %%0.13 %
Less than or equal to 80%99 0.24 99 0.42 
Current DSCR below 1.0(4)
3 3.88 13.90 
(1)Calculated based on the aggregate unpaid principal balance of multifamily loans for each category divided by the aggregate unpaid principal balance of loans in our multifamily guaranty book of business.
(2)Consists of multifamily loans that were 60 days or more past due as of the dates indicated.
(3)Calculated based on the unpaid principal balance of multifamily loans that were seriously delinquent divided by the aggregate unpaid principal balance of multifamily loans for each category included in our multifamily guaranty book of business.
(4)For 2022, our estimates of current DSCRs are based on the latest available income information from quarterly and annual statements for these properties including the related debt service. For 2021, our estimates of current DSCRs are based on the latest available annual statements.
Other Concentrations
Mortgage Insurers. Mortgage insurance “risk in force” refers to our maximum potential loss recovery under the applicable mortgage insurance policies in force and is generally based on the loan-level insurance coverage percentage and, if applicable, any aggregate pool loss limit, as specified in the policy.
The following table displays our total mortgage insurance risk in force by primary and pool insurance, as well as the total risk-in-force mortgage insurance coverage as a percentage of the single-family conventional guaranty book of business.
As of December 31,
20222021
Risk in ForcePercentage of Single-Family Conventional Guaranty Book of BusinessRisk in ForcePercentage of Single-Family Conventional Guaranty Book of Business
(Dollars in millions)
Mortgage insurance risk in force:
Primary mortgage insurance$193,549 $176,587 
Pool mortgage insurance237 261 
Total mortgage insurance risk in force$193,786 5 %$176,848 %
Mortgage insurance only covers losses that are realized after the borrower defaults and title to the property is subsequently transferred, such as after a foreclosure, short-sale, or a deed-in-lieu of foreclosure. Also, mortgage insurance does not protect us from all losses on covered loans. For example, mortgage insurance does not cover
property damage that is not covered by the hazard insurance we require, and such damage may result in a reduction to, or a denial of, mortgage insurance benefits. Specifically, a property damaged by a flood that was outside a Federal Emergency Management Agency (“FEMA”)-identified Special Flood Hazard Area, where we require coverage, or a property damaged by an earthquake are the most likely scenarios where property damage may result in a default not covered by hazard insurance.
The table below displays our mortgage insurer counterparties that provided 10% or more of the risk in force mortgage insurance coverage on mortgage loans in our single-family conventional guaranty book of business.
Percentage of Risk-in-Force Coverage by Mortgage Insurer
As of December 31,
20222021
Counterparty:(1)
Mortgage Guaranty Insurance Corp.19 %19 %
Arch Capital Group Ltd.18 19 
Radian Guaranty, Inc. 17 17 
Enact Mortgage Insurance Corp.(2)
17 17 
Essent Guaranty, Inc.16 16 
National Mortgage Insurance Corp.12 11 
Others1 
Total100 %100 %
(1)Insurance coverage amounts provided for each counterparty may include coverage provided by affiliates and subsidiaries of the counterparty.
(2)Genworth Mortgage Insurance Corp. was renamed Enact Mortgage Insurance Corp. effective February 7, 2022.
We have counterparty credit risk relating to the potential insolvency of, or non-performance by, monoline mortgage insurers that insure single-family loans we purchase or guarantee. There is risk that these counterparties may fail to fulfill their obligations to pay our claims under insurance policies. On at least a quarterly basis, we assess our mortgage insurer counterparties’ respective abilities to fulfill their obligations to us. Our assessment includes financial reviews and analyses of the insurers’ portfolios and capital adequacy. If we determine that it is probable that we will not collect all of our claims from one or more of our mortgage insurer counterparties, it could increase our loss reserves, which could adversely affect our results of operations, liquidity, financial condition and net worth.
When we estimate the credit losses that are inherent in our mortgage loans and under the terms of our guaranty obligations, we also consider the recoveries that we expect to receive from primary mortgage insurance, as mortgage insurance recoveries reduce the severity of the loss associated with defaulted loans if the borrower defaults and title to the property is subsequently transferred. Mortgage insurance does not cover credit losses that result from a reduction in mortgage interest paid by the borrower in connection with a loan modification, forbearance of principal, or forbearance of scheduled loan payments. We evaluate the financial condition of our mortgage insurer counterparties and adjust the contractually due recovery amounts to ensure that expected credit losses as of the balance sheet date are included in our loss reserve estimate. As a result, if our assessment of one or more of our mortgage insurer counterparties’ ability to fulfill their respective obligations to us worsens, it could increase our loss reserves. As of December 31, 2022 and 2021, our estimated benefit from mortgage insurance, which is based on estimated credit losses as of period end, reduced our loss reserves by $2.2 billion and $559 million, respectively.
When an insured loan held in our retained mortgage portfolio subsequently goes into foreclosure, we charge off the loan, eliminating any previously-recorded loss reserves, and record REO and a mortgage insurance receivable for the claim proceeds deemed probable of recovery, as appropriate. However, if a mortgage insurer rescinds, cancels or denies insurance coverage, the initial receivable becomes due from the mortgage seller or servicer. We had outstanding receivables of $515 million recorded in “Other assets” in our consolidated balance sheets as of December 31, 2022 and $533 million as of December 31, 2021 related to amounts claimed on insured, defaulted loans excluding government-insured loans. We assessed these outstanding receivables for collectability, and established a valuation allowance of $462 million as of December 31, 2022 and $479 million as of December 31, 2021, which reduced our claim receivable to the amount considered probable of collection.
Mortgage Servicers and Sellers. Mortgage servicers collect mortgage and escrow payments from borrowers, pay taxes and insurance costs from escrow accounts, monitor and report delinquencies, and perform other required activities, including loss mitigation, on our behalf. Our mortgage servicers and sellers may also be obligated to repurchase loans or foreclosed properties, reimburse us for losses or provide other remedies under certain circumstances, such as if it is determined that the mortgage loan did not meet our underwriting or eligibility requirements, if certain loan
representations and warranties are violated or if mortgage insurers rescind coverage. Our representation and warranty framework does not require repurchase for loans that have breaches of certain selling representations and warranties if they have met specified criteria for relief.
Our business with mortgage servicers is concentrated. The table below displays the percentage of our single-family conventional guaranty book of business serviced by our top five depository single-family mortgage servicers and top five non-depository single-family mortgage servicers (i.e., servicers that are not insured depository institutions), and identifies one servicer that serviced 10% or more of our single-family guaranty book of business as of December 31, 2021, based on unpaid principal balance.
Percentage of Single-Family Conventional
Guaranty Book of Business
As of December 31,
20222021
Wells Fargo Bank, N.A. (together with its affiliates)9 %10 %
Remaining top five depository servicers13 11 
Top five non-depository servicers23 23 
Total45 %44 %
The table below displays the percentage of our multifamily guaranty book of business serviced by our top five multifamily mortgage servicers, and identifies two servicers that serviced 10% or more of our multifamily guaranty book of business based on unpaid principal balance.
Percentage of Multifamily
Guaranty Book of Business
As of December 31,
20222021
Walker & Dunlop, Inc.13 %12 %
Wells Fargo Bank, N.A. (together with its affiliates)11 11 
Remaining top five servicers24 24 
Total48 %47 %
Multifamily Lenders with Risk Sharing. We enter into risk sharing agreements with lenders pursuant to which the lenders agree to bear all or some portion of the credit losses on the covered loans. Our maximum potential loss recovery from lenders under these risk sharing agreements on both DUS and non-DUS multifamily loans was $103.9 billion as of December 31, 2022, compared with $97.6 billion as of December 31, 2021. As of December 31, 2022, 53% of our maximum potential loss recovery on multifamily loans was from five DUS lenders, as compared with 52% as of December 31, 2021.
Derivatives Counterparties. For information on credit risk associated with our derivative transactions and repurchase agreements see “Note 8, Derivative Instruments” and “Note 14, Netting Arrangements.”