EX-99.1 2 tm2320355d1_ex99-1.htm CONSULTANT REPORT OF CBIZ MHM, LLC

 

  

 

 

 

Golden Pear Funding AssetCo, LLC

Golden Pear Funding OpCo, LLC

PEAR 2023-1, LLC

 

Golden Pear Securitization, Series 2023-1

 

Consultant Report

 

 

June 30, 2023

 

 

 

For information related to this report, contact:

 

CBIZ MHM, LLC

401 Plymouth Road, Suite 200

Plymouth Meeting, PA 19462

 

M. Michael Aquino Kristin D. Stanton
Lead Managing Director Senior Manager
(610) 862-2737 (610) 862-2205
maquino@cbiz.com kstanton@cbiz.com

 

 

 

This Report is for CLIENT’s Internal Use Only and Should Not Be Relied
Upon By Any Third Party.

 

 

 

   

 

  

 

 Golden Pear Securitization, Series 2023-1

Consulting Report

 

 

Consultant Engagement

  

 

Client and Seller Name: Golden Pear Funding AssetCo, LLC
  2 Wall Street, FL 6
  New York, NY 10005
   
   
Company and Issuer Address: PEAR 2023-1, LLC
  2 Wall Street, FL 6
                        New York, NY 10005

 

 

Client and Company Principal Contact: Dan Amsellem
   
   
Client and Company Phone Number: 212-792-8104

  

 

Consultants: Carla Prebelli-Elwell  
  Alan Goldenberg  
  Kristin D. Stanton  
     
     
Report Date: June 30, 2023
     
     
Engagement Dates: May 17 – June 30, 2023  

  

 

Client and Company Contact: Dan Amsellem – Chief Financial Officer

 

2

 

 

 Golden Pear Securitization, Series 2023-1

Consulting Report

 

 

June 30, 2023

 

 

PRIVATE & CONFIDENTIAL

 

Mr. Dan Amsellem

Golden Pear Funding

Chief Financial Officer

2 Wall Street, FL 6

New York, NY 10005

 

Dear Mr. Amsellem:

 

Please find our enclosed Consultant Report (“the Report”) which was prepared at the request of Golden Pear Funding AssetCo, LLC (“GP Assetco”, “Seller”, “you” or the “Client”), Golden Pear Funding OpCo, LLC (“GP opco” or “Servicer”) and PEAR 2023-1, LLC (“Issuer” or “Company”) in connection with the Preliminary Private Placement Memorandum for the Golden Pear Securitization, Series 2023-1 (“PPM”), which date still needs to be determined (“Transaction”) and in accordance with the terms of our Engagement Letter dated April 26, 2023.

 

Client Acknowledgements

 

By acceptance of the Report, you acknowledge that (1) you have determined that the procedures we performed are the procedures that you requested us to perform, that you are solely responsible for the sufficiency of such procedures for your purposes, and that you do not require us to perform any further procedures, (2) we make no representations and express no opinion as to the sufficiency of the procedures for your purposes and had we performed additional procedures, other matters might have come to our attention that would have been reported to you, (3) the procedures that we performed should not be taken to supplant additional inquiries and procedures that you should undertake in your evaluation of the Transaction, (4) you have made available to us all financial records and related data that you received from the Company that you believe are necessary for us to complete our procedures, and (5) the decision whether to consummate the Transaction lies solely with you, and neither our work nor our findings shall in any way constitute a recommendation whether you should or should not consummate the Transaction, or on what terms.

 

Limitations of Procedures

 

The procedures we performed do not constitute, in accordance with generally accepted auditing or other applicable professional standards, (1) an audit, review, or compilation of the Company’s historical financial statements or specified elements, accounts or items thereof as per the attestation standards established by the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants, (2) an examination or compilation of the Company’s prospective financial information, (3) an appraisal of the Company or of any of the Company’s assets or liabilities or (4) an examination of the Company’s internal controls, and, accordingly, we express no opinion, limited assurance or any other form of assurance thereon and our work cannot be relied upon to disclose errors, fraud or illegal acts that may exist.

 

3

 

 

 Golden Pear Securitization, Series 2023-1

Consulting Report

 

 

The Report contains a description of the following:

 

(i)the type of assets;
(ii)the sample size;
(iii)how the sample size was determined and, if applicable, computed; and
(iv)the scope and manner of the Services performed.

 

None of the engagement Scope Procedures or Report was intended to address, nor did they address, the following:

 

(i)the value of collateral securing such assets;
(ii)the compliance of the originator of the assets with federal, state, and local laws and regulations; or

(iii)the conformity of the origination of the assets to stated underwriting or credit extension guidelines, standards, criteria or other requirements.

 

We have not verified the information we obtained or presented in the Report, unless specified therein.

 

Use of the Report

 

This letter and the Report are solely for your information and internal use and to assist you in the evaluation of the Transaction. You agree that without the prior written consent of CBIZ MHM, LLC (“CBIZ” or “Consultant(s)”), you will not circulate, quote or otherwise refer to this Report or a copy of all or any portion thereof. Notwithstanding the foregoing, you may provide copies of the Report in accordance with the terms and conditions set forth in the Engagement Letter dated April 26, 2023 and to your legal representatives or other professional advisors solely for their informational use in connection with the Transaction provided that (1) this letter shall be attached at the front of the Report at the time of disclosure, and (2) any such legal representative or other professional advisor has agreed to keep the Report confidential and fully releases CBIZ from any liability arising out of, or in reliance upon, this Report.

 

Updating the Report

 

We have no responsibility to update this letter or the Report for events or circumstances occurring after the date of this letter.

 

Very truly yours,

 

CBIZ MHM, LLC

 

 

By:          ___________________________________________

M. Michael Aquino, Lead Managing Director

 

 

 

CBIZ MHM, LLC

 

THIS REPORT IS FOR CLIENT’S INTERNAL USE ONLY AND SHOULD NOT BE RELIED UPON BY ANY THIRD PARTY

 

4

 

 

 Golden Pear Securitization, Series 2023-1

Consulting Report

 

 

Legal Notice

 

This Report is provided solely to Client for its internal use and information, pursuant to our Engagement Letter dated April 26, 2023 with no third party beneficiaries being created thereby, and is subject in all respects to the terms and conditions of that letter, including restrictions on disclosure of this Report to third parties.

 

If this Report is received by anyone other than Client, the recipient is placed on notice that the attached Report has been prepared solely for Client for their internal use and this Report and its contents may not be shared with or disclosed to anyone without the express written consent of Client and CBIZ. CBIZ shall have no liability and shall pursue all available legal and equitable remedies against recipient, for the unauthorized use or distribution of this Report to third parties.

 

Legal Representation

 

Client acknowledges and agrees that it is responsible for its own legal representation and guidance related to the Transaction and that it will consult its own legal resources before acting upon any deliverables CBIZ provides under this Report. Client further acknowledges and agrees CBIZ is not a law firm and is not providing legal advice or analysis and that CBIZ has not engaged legal counsel with respect to the services, and that matters of legal interpretation are beyond the scope of the services. CBIZ expressly disclaims any and all responsibility for the accuracy, adequacy, completeness or appropriateness of any legal document, relating to the Transaction or otherwise, reviewed during the performance of services as outlined herein.

 

5

 

 

 Golden Pear Securitization, Series 2023-1

Consulting Report

 

 

General Information

 

During this engagement, the Consultants conducted discussions with the following Company personnel:

 

Individual Title Tenure
Dan Amsellem Chief Financial Officer 8 years
Maria Ocasio VP of Portfolio Management 5 years

 

Report-Specific Terminology

 

The following abbreviated terminology is used at times throughout this Report:

 

· Client, GP Assetco, or Seller Golden Pear Funding AssetCo, LLC
· GP opco or Servicer Golden Pear Funding OpCo, LLC
· Issuer or Company PEAR 2023-1, LLC
· M $000s
· MM $000,000s
· PPM Preliminary Private Placement Memorandum dated TBD
· Final PPM Final Private Placement Memorandum dated TBD
· Transaction Golden Pear Securitization, Series 2023-1
· Case Cash JV Partner of Golden Pear

 

Other Notes

 

Throughout the various tables presented in the report and accompanying exhibits, slight differences in totals may exist due to rounding occurrences. Any material variances that may occur are discussed within the body of the report.

 

6

 

 

 Golden Pear Securitization, Series 2023-1

Consulting Report

 

 

TABLE OF CONTENTS

 

SCOPE OF SERVICES

 

9
A.  RESULTS OF TESTING 11

 

 

EXHIBITS

 

 

A.1       DATA INTEGRITY TEST FOR ADVANCES

 

A.2        RECALCULATION OF SCOPE OF SERVICES STEPS 4 & 5

 

 

7

 

 

 Golden Pear Securitization, Series 2023-1

Consulting Report

 

 

STATEMENT OF WORK

PURSUANT TO THE ENGAGEMENT LETTER DATED APRIL 26, 2023
BY AND BETWEEN CBIZ MHM, LLC (“CBIZ”) AND
GOLDEN PEAR FUNDING ASSETCO, LLC (“GP ASSETCO”, “SELLER”, “YOU”, OR THE
“CLIENT”), GOLDEN PEAR FUNDING OPCO, LLC (GP OPCO” OR “SERVICER”) AND
PEAR 2023-1, LLC (“ISSUER” OR “COMPANY”)

 

 

Relevant Entities:

 

Golden Pear Funding AssetCo, LLC (“GP Assetco”, “Seller”, “you” or the “Client”), Golden Pear Funding OpCo, LLC (“GP opco” or “Servicer”) and PEAR 2023-1, LLC (“Issuer” or “Company”)

 

Time Periods to be tested:

 

Data Tape as of May 15, 2023

 

Location:

 

Testing to be performed remotely in CBIZ’s office

 

Additional Request:

 

Document all discussions with and inquiries of management.

 

Note: Samples are selected as noted in the Statement of Work.

 

Consultant report should provide for glossary of defined terms which will serve as a point of reference for all capitalized terms found in the consulting report.

 

Consultant report should provide for a table listing individuals at the Client and Company that provided assistance and/or are referenced in the Consultant report. Table should provide for the following: name, title, phone number, affiliation, and tenure.

 

Note that the names of Obligors should remain anonymous in documenting test results. 

 

8

 

 

 Golden Pear Securitization, Series 2023-1

Consulting Report

 

 

SCOPE OF SERVICES

 

CBIZ to perform the following procedures to verify the completeness and accuracy of the litigation funding lien and medical lien assets (“Receivables Pool” or “Pledged Receivables”) included in the data tape utilized for the Preliminary Private Placement Memorandum for the Golden Pear Securitization, Series 2023-1 (“PPM”), which date still needs to be determined (“Transaction”) (“Data Tape”) as of the effective date of May 15, 2023.

 

CBIZ will judgmentally sample the following assets from the Date Tape (“Sample Group”):

 

a.90 litigation receivable assets; and
b.10 medical receivable assets.

 

CBIZ will perform the following procedures.

 

A.From the May 15, 2023 Data Tape provided by the Client, judgmentally select the Sample Group and perform the below data integrity test (the “Data Integrity Review”). For items marked below as “confirm”, note whether the item is noted as part of the underlying source documentation. For items marked as “compare”, agree the item on the Data Tape to the Servicer’s underlying operating system. For items marked as “recalculate”, recalculate the noted item listed below for accuracy:

 

1.Perform the following to verify the existence of the Receivable asset:

 

a.Confirm the contract advance amount (net of any partial payments, if any) per the legal contract to the principal amount per the Data Tape.
b.Compare the claimant funded date reported in the Data Tape to the Client’s Servicing System (“CSS”) or accounting system for the Company.
c.Compare advance type per the Data Tape to the CSS or accounting records.
d.Confirm contract advance amount reported in the Data Tape to proof of payment (e.g. check copy, wire confirmation, bank statements or accounting system).

 

2.Verify accuracy of the reported aging of the Receivables Pool included in the Data Tape as follows:

 

a.Compare the most recent advance date reported in the Data Tape to the accounting records or CSS by inspecting trial balance report from CSS and determining that the most recent date of funding agrees to the most recent funded date for that ID in the CSS report.
b.Recalculate months since most recent advance date for each selection and agree to the Data Tape information.
c.Compare the Raw Claim Type as shown in the Data Tape to the accounting records.

 

3.For the Sample Group, Compare the Raw Primary Carrier as shown in the Data Tape to the accounting records or CSS.

 

9

 

 

 Golden Pear Securitization, Series 2023-1

Consulting Report

 

 

4.Recalculate individual tables and agree them to the tables as shown in the PPM using the Indicative Portfolio & Strats data file provided by the Client:

 

a.Agree the Individual and Unique Plaintiffs advance/case count totals and the total Portfolio Principal Advance Amount in the schedules included in the Indicative Portfolio & Strats data file provided by the Client to the Data Tape.
b.Recalculate the formulas in the designated tables included in the Indicative Portfolio & Strats data file provided by the Client for accuracy.

 

5.Agree the designated tables in the Indicative Portfolio & Strats data file provided by the Client to the corresponding items in Appendix A of the Preliminary PPM.

 

10

 

 

 Golden Pear Securitization, Series 2023-1

Consulting Report

 

 

A. Data Integrity Review

 

The Client provided a month-end electronic data file as of May 15, 2023 for all Pledged Receivables for Scope Steps A.1 – A.3. The Client also provided an Indicative Portfolio and Strats data file as of May 15, 2023 for Scope Steps A.4 and A.5.

 

For Steps A.1 - A.3, the Consultants judgmentally selected a sample of 100 assets (“Sample Group”) consisting of:

 

a.90 litigation receivable assets; and
b.10 medical receivable assets.

 

All 100 Pledged Receivables were tested according to the requested Scope procedures. The schedule for the Data File Integrity Test can be found as Exhibit A.1.

 

The Consultants noted the following results amongst the sampled 100 Pledged Receivables based on inquiry of management and testing:

 

DATA INTEGRITY REVIEW SAMPLE SIZE EXCEPTIONS FOUND %
1. Perform the following to verify the existence of the Receivable asset:      
a.    Confirm the contract advance amount (net of any partial payments, if any) per the legal contract to the principal amount per the Data Tape 100 0 0%
b.    Compare the claimant funded date reported in the Data Tape to the Client’s Servicing System (“CSS”) or accounting system for the Company 100 0 0%
c.     Compare advance type per the Data Tape to the CSS or accounting records 100 0 0%
d.    Confirm contract advance amount reported in the Data Tape to proof of payment (e.g. check copy, wire confirmation, bank statements or accounting system) 100 0 0%
2. Verify accuracy of the reported aging of the Receivables Pool included in the Data Tape as follows:      
a.    Compare the most recent advance date reported in the Data Tape to the accounting records or CSS by inspecting trial balance report from CSS and determining that the most recent date of funding agrees to the most recent funded date for that ID in the CSS report. 100 0 0%
b.    Recalculate months since most recent advance for each selection and agree to the Data Tape 100 0 0%
c.     Compare Raw Claim Type as shown in the Data Tape to the accounting records 100 0 0%

 

11

 

 

 Golden Pear Securitization, Series 2023-1

Consulting Report

 

 

1.Perform the following to verify the existence of the Receivable asset:

 

a.The Consultants Confirmed the contract advance amount per legal contract to the principal amount per the Data Tape without exception.
b.The Consultants Compared the claimant funded date reported in the Data Tape to the Client’s Servicing System (“CSS”) or Accounting Records without exception.

c.The Consultants Compared advance type per the Data Tape to the CSS or Accounting Records without exception.
d.The Consultants Confirmed the contract advance amount reported in the Data Tape to proof of payment (e.g. check copy, wire confirmation, bank statements or accounting system) without exception.

 

2. Verify accuracy of the reported aging of the Receivables Pool included in the Data Tape as follows:

 

a.The Consultants Compared the most recent advance date reported in the Data Tape to the accounting records or by inspecting trial balance report from CCS and determining that the most recent date of funding agrees to the most recent funded date for that ID in the CCS report without exception.
b.The Consultants recalculated months since most recent advance date for each selection and agreed to the Data Tape information without exception.
c.The Consultants Compared the Raw Claim Type as shown in the Data Tape to the accounting records without exception.

 

3.For the 100 assets, the Consultants Compared the Raw Primary Carrier as shown in the Data Tape to the accounting records without exception.

 

DATA INTEGRITY REVIEW SAMPLE SIZE EXCEPTIONS FOUND %
Compare Raw Primary Carrier as shown in the Data Tape to the accounting records 100 0 0%

 

4.Recalculate individual tables and agree them to the tables as shown in the PPM using the Indicative Portfolio & Strats data file provided by the Client as of May 15, 2023:

 

a.The Consultants agreed without exception the Individual and Unique Plaintiffs advance/case count totals and the total Portfolio Principal Advance Amount in the schedules included in the Indicative Portfolio & Strats data file as of May 15, 2023 provided by the Client to the Data Tape.

 

LITIGATION RECALCULATIONS PER COMPANY PER CONSULTANTS
Number of Individual Advances 17,561 17,561
Total Portfolio Principal Advance Amount $91,506,310 $91,506,310

 

MEDICAL RECALCULATIONS PER COMPANY PER CONSULTANTS
Number of Individual Advances 1,437 1,437
Total Portfolio Principal Advance Amount $4,093,227 $4,093,227

 

b.The Consultants recalculated the formulas in the following tables included in the Indicative Portfolio & Strats data file provided by the Client as of May 15, 2023 for accuracy without exception. See Step 5.

 

 

12

 

 

 Golden Pear Securitization, Series 2023-1

Consulting Report

 

 

5.The Consultants agreed the following tables in the Indicative Portfolio & Strats data file provided by the Client as of May 15, 2023 to the corresponding items in Appendix A of the Preliminary PPM without exception. Please see Appendix A in Exhibit A.2.

 

For the Litigation Strats, the following were recalculated for accuracy:

 

·Composition of the Receivable Pool
·Advance Type
·Unique Obligor
·Injury/ Case Type
·Payment Source
·Payment Source NAIC Rating
·Law Firm
·Months from Earliest Advance Date
·Months from Most Recent Advance Date
·Expected Case Worth Ratio
·Plaintiff State

 

For the Medical Strats, the following were recalculated for accuracy:

 

·Composition of the Receivable Pool
·Advance Type
·Unique Obligor
·Injury/ Case Type
·Payment Source
·Payment Source NAIC Rating
·Law Firm
·Months from Earliest Advance Date
·Months from Most Recent Advance Date
·Expected Case Worth Ratio
·Medical Service Provider
·Plaintiff State

 

13