XML 27 R17.htm IDEA: XBRL DOCUMENT v3.24.3
Loans Receivable and Allowance for Credit Losses
9 Months Ended
Sep. 30, 2024
Receivables [Abstract]  
Loans Receivable and Allowance for Credit Losses Loans Receivable and Allowance for Credit Losses
Loans receivable at September 30, 2024 and December 31, 2023 are summarized as follows:
September 30,December 31,
20242023
(In thousands)
Real estate loans:
One-to-four family$2,737,190 $2,792,833 
Multifamily1,399,000 1,409,187 
Commercial real estate2,312,759 2,377,077 
Construction510,439 443,094 
Commercial business loans586,447 533,041 
Consumer loans:
Home equity loans and advances261,041 266,632 
Other consumer loans2,877 2,801 
Total gross loans7,809,753 7,824,665 
Purchased credit-deteriorated ("PCD") loans11,795 15,089 
Net deferred loan costs, fees and purchased premiums and discounts35,642 34,783 
Loans receivable$7,857,190 $7,874,537 

    The Company had no loans held-for-sale at September 30, 2024 and December 31, 2023. During the three months ended September 30, 2024, the Company sold $6.2 million and $2.8 million of one-to-four family real estate loans and Small Business Administration ("SBA") loans included in commercial business loans held-for-sale, respectively, resulting in gross gains of $459,000 and no gross losses. During the nine months ended September 30, 2024, the Company sold $6.4 million, $6.8 million, and $2.7 million of one-to-four family real estate loans, SBA loans included in commercial business loans, and construction loans held-for-sale, respectively, resulting in gross gains of $825,000 and no gross losses.

During the three months ended September 30, 2023, the Company sold $6.8 million, $7.1 million, and $1.9 million, of one-to-four family real estate loans, SBA loans included in commercial business loans, and construction loans held-for-sale, respectively, resulting in gross gains of $455,000 and gross losses of $58,000. During the nine months ended September 30, 2023, the Company sold $64.6 million, $21.4 million, $18.4 million, and $5.7 million, of one-to-four family real estate loans and home equity loans and advances, commercial real estate loans, SBA loans included in commercial business loans, and construction loans held-for-sale, respectively, resulting in gross gains of $1.4 million and gross losses of $383,000.

During the three and nine months ended September 30, 2024, no loans were purchased by the Company. During the three months ended September 30, 2023 no loans were purchased by the Company. During the nine months ended September 30, 2023, the Company purchased a $14.7 million commercial real estate participation loan from a third party financial institution.
9.    Loans Receivable and Allowance for Credit Losses (continued)

At September 30, 2024 and December 31, 2023, commercial business loans included $530,000 and $809,000, respectively, in SBA Payroll Protection Program ("PPP") loans.

At September 30, 2024 and December 31, 2023, the carrying value of loans serviced by the Company for investors was $513.0 million and $551.0 million, respectively. These loans are not included in the Consolidated Statements of Financial Condition.

The following tables summarize the aging of loans receivable by portfolio segment, including non-accrual loans and excluding PCD loans at September 30, 2024 and December 31, 2023:
September 30, 2024
30-59 Days60-89 Days90 Days or MoreTotal Past DueNon-accrual CurrentTotal
(In thousands)
Real estate loans:
One-to-four family$14,915 $6,989 $2,982 $24,886 $7,368 $2,712,304 $2,737,190 
Multifamily — — — — — 1,399,000 1,399,000 
Commercial real estate15,492 450 — 15,942 9,413 2,296,817 2,312,759 
Construction— — — — — 510,439 510,439 
Commercial business loans3,686 1,253 1,404 6,343 11,061 580,104 586,447 
Consumer loans:
Home equity loans and advances560 139 13 712 172 260,329 261,041 
Other consumer loans— — — 2,875 2,877 
Total loans$34,655 $8,831 $4,399 $47,885 $28,014 $7,761,868 $7,809,753 

December 31, 2023
30-59 Days60-89 Days90 Days or MoreTotal Past DueNon-accrualCurrentTotal
(In thousands)
Real estate loans:
One-to-four family$11,079 $4,254 $1,558 $16,891 $3,139 $2,775,942 $2,792,833 
Multifamily — — — — — 1,409,187 1,409,187 
Commercial real estate1,711 2,472 2,740 6,923 2,740 2,370,154 2,377,077 
Construction— — — — — 443,094 443,094 
Commercial business loans1,727 4,917 6,518 13,162 6,518 519,879 533,041 
Consumer loans:
Home equity loans and advances779 14 170 963 221 265,669 266,632 
Other consumer loans— — — 2,800 2,801 
Total loans$15,297 $11,657 $10,986 $37,940 $12,618 $7,786,725 $7,824,665 

The Company considers a loan to be delinquent when we have not received a payment within 30 days of its contractual due date, or when the Company does not expect to receive all principal and interest payments owed substantially in accordance with the terms of the loan agreement, regardless of the past due status. Non-accruing loans are returned to accrual status after there has been a sustained period of repayment performance and both principal and interest are deemed collectible. The Company identifies loans that may need to be charged-off as a loss, by reviewing all delinquent loans, classified loans and other loans for which management may have concerns about collectability.
9.    Loans Receivable and Allowance for Credit Losses (continued)

At September 30, 2024 and December 31, 2023, non-accrual loans totaled $28.0 million and $12.6 million, respectively. Included in non-accrual loans at September 30, 2024 and December 31, 2023, are 32 and 10 loans totaling $23.6 million and $1.6 million, respectively, which are less than 90 days in arrears.

At September 30, 2024 and December 31, 2023, there were no loans past due 90 days or more still accruing interest.

Purchased credit-deteriorated ("PCD") loans were loans acquired at a discount primarily due to deteriorated credit quality. These loans were initially recorded at fair value at acquisition, based upon the present value of expected future cash flows, with no related allowance for credit losses. Loans acquired in a business combination are recorded in accordance with ASC Topic 326, which requires loans as of the acquisition date, that have experienced a more than insignificant deterioration in credit quality since origination, to be classified as PCD loans.

At September 30, 2024 and December 31, 2023, PCD loans acquired in the Stewardship Financial Corporation ("Stewardship") acquisition totaled $1.2 million and $1.7 million, respectively, PCD loans acquired in the Freehold Bank acquisition totaled $247,000 and $2.8 million, respectively, and PCD loans acquired in the RSI Bank acquisition totaled $10.4 million and $10.6 million, respectively.

    We may obtain physical possession of real estate collateralizing a residential mortgage loan via foreclosure or through an in-substance repossession. At September 30, 2024, the Company held one commercial property with a carrying value of $2.0 million in other real estate owned that was acquired through foreclosure on a nonresidential mortgage loan. At December 31, 2023, the Company had no real estate owned. At September 30, 2024 we had four residential mortgage loans with a carrying value of $1.2 million collateralized by residential real estate, which were in the process of foreclosure. At December 31, 2023, we had one residential mortgage loan and one home equity loan with carrying values of $576,000 and $93,000, respectively, collateralized by residential real estate which were in the process of foreclosure.

The Company has made an accounting policy election to exclude accrued interest receivable from the amortized cost basis of loans receivable. Accrued interest receivable on loans receivable is reported as a component of accrued interest receivable in the Consolidated Statement of Financial Condition, which totaled $33.6 million and $32.9 million at September 30, 2024 and December 31, 2023, respectively, and is excluded from the estimate of credit losses.

The determination of the allowance for credit losses (“ACL”) on loans is considered a critical accounting estimate by management because of the high degree of judgment involved in determining qualitative loss factors, the subjectivity of the assumptions used, and the potential for changes in the forecasted economic environment. The ACL is maintained at a level management considers adequate to provide for estimated losses and impairment based upon an evaluation of known and inherent risk in the loan portfolio. The ACL consists of two elements: (1) identification of loans that must be individually analyzed for impairment and (2) establishment of an ACL for loans collectively analyzed.

Portfolio segments are defined as the level at which an entity develops and documents a systematic methodology to determine its allowance for credit losses. Management developed segments for estimating losses based on the type of borrower and collateral which is generally based upon federal call report segmentation. The segments have been combined or sub-segments have been added as needed to ensure loans of similar risk profiles are appropriately pooled.

We maintain a loan review system that provides a periodic review of the loan portfolio and the identification of individually analyzed loans. The ACL for individually analyzed loans is based on the fair value of collateral or cash flows. While management uses the best information available to make such evaluations, future adjustments to the allowance may be necessary if economic conditions differ substantially from the assumptions used in making the evaluations.

The ACL quantitative allowance for each segment is measured using a discounted cash flow methodology incorporating an econometric, probability of default (“PD”) and loss given default (“LGD”) with distinct segment-specific multi-variate regression models applied. Expected credit losses are estimated over the life of the loans by measuring the difference between the net present value of modeled cash flows and amortized cost basis. Contractual cash flows over the contractual life of the loans are the basis for the modeled cash flows, adjusted for model defaults and expected prepayments and discounted at the loan-level effective interest rate. The contractual term excludes expected extensions, renewals, and modifications.
9.    Loans Receivable and Allowance for Credit Losses (continued)

Management estimates the ACL using relevant and reliable information from internal and external sources, related to past events, current conditions, and a reasonable and supportable forecast. Historical credit loss experience for both the Company and its segment-specific peers provides the basis for the estimate of expected credit losses. Credit losses over a defined period are converted to PD rate curves through the use of segment-specific LGD risk factors that convert default rates to loss severity based on industry-level, observed relationships between the two variables for each segment, primarily due to the nature of the underlying collateral. These risk factors were assessed for reasonableness against the Company’s own loss experience and adjusted in certain cases when the relationship between the Company’s historical default and loss severity deviate from that of the wider industry. The historical PD curves, together with corresponding economic conditions, establish a quantitative relationship between economic conditions and loan performance through an economic cycle.

Using the historical relationship between economic conditions and loan performance, management’s expectation of future loan performance is incorporated using a single economic forecast of macroeconomic variables (i.e., unemployment, gross domestic product, vacancy, and home price index). This forecast is applied over a period that management has determined to be reasonable and supportable. Beyond the period over which management can develop or source a reasonable and supportable forecast, the model reverts to long-term average historical loss rates using a straight-line, time-based methodology. The Company's current forecast period is six quarters, with a four-quarter reversion period to long-term average historical loss rates.

After quantitative considerations, management applies additional qualitative adjustments that consider the expected impact of certain factors not fully captured in the quantitative reserve. Qualitative adjustments include but are not limited to concentrations of large loan balances, delinquency trends, change in collateral values within segments, and other considerations.

The ACL is established through the provision for credit losses that are charged to income, which is based upon an evaluation of estimated losses in the current loan portfolio, including the evaluation of individually analyzed loans. Charge-offs against the ACL are taken on loans where management determines that the collection of loan principal and interest is unlikely. Recoveries made on loans that have been charged-off are credited to the ACL. Although we believe we have established and maintained the ACL on loans at appropriate levels, changes in reserves may be necessary if actual economic and other conditions differ substantially from the forecast used in estimating the ACL.

Our financial results are affected by the changes in and the level of the ACL. This process involves our analysis of internal and external variables, and it requires that we exercise judgment to estimate an appropriate ACL. As a result of the uncertainty associated with this subjectivity, we cannot assure the precision of the amount reserved, should we experience sizable loan losses in any particular period and/or significant changes in assumptions or economic condition. We believe the primary risks inherent in the portfolio are a general decline in the economy, a decline in real estate market values, rising unemployment, increasing vacancy rates, and increases in interest rates in the absence of economic improvement or any other such factors. Any one or a combination of these events may adversely affect a borrower's ability to repay its loan, resulting in increased delinquencies and loan losses. Accordingly, we have recorded loan credit losses at a level which is estimated to represent the current risk in its loan portfolio.

For our non-performing loans, the allowance is determined on an individual basis using the present value of expected cash flows, or for collateral dependent loans, the fair value of the collateral less estimated costs to sell. We continue to assess the collateral of loans and update our appraisals on these loans on an annual basis. To the extent the property values decline, there could be additional losses on these non-performing assets, which may be material. Management considered these market conditions in deriving the estimated ACL. Should economic difficulties occur, the ultimate amount of loss could vary from our current estimate.
9.    Loans Receivable and Allowance for Credit Losses (continued)

    The following tables summarize loans receivable (including PCD loans) and allowance for credit losses by portfolio segment and impairment method at September 30, 2024 and December 31, 2023:
September 30, 2024
One-to-Four FamilyMultifamily Commercial Real EstateConstructionCommercial Business Home Equity Loans and AdvancesOther Consumer LoansTotal
(In thousands)
Allowance for credit losses:
Individually analyzed loans$— $— $— $— $— $— $— $— 
Collectively analyzed loans12,837 8,515 15,527 7,076 13,115 1,384 58,462 
Loans acquired with deteriorated credit quality— 29 — — — — 33 
Total $12,841 $8,515 $15,556 $7,076 $13,115 $1,384 $$58,495 
Total loans:
Individually analyzed loans$7,238 $5,743 $7,578 $— $12,062 $171 $— $32,792 
Collectively analyzed loans2,729,952 1,393,257 2,305,181 510,439 574,385 260,870 2,877 7,776,961 
Loans acquired with deteriorated credit quality1,834 — 9,503 — 311 147 — 11,795 
Total loans$2,739,024 $1,399,000 $2,322,262 $510,439 $586,758 $261,188 $2,877 $7,821,548 
9.    Loans Receivable and Allowance for Credit Losses (continued)

December 31, 2023
One-to-Four FamilyMultifamily Commercial Real EstateConstructionCommercial Business Home Equity Loans and AdvancesOther Consumer LoansTotal
(In thousands)
Allowance for credit losses:
Individually analyzed loans$186 $$237 $— $154 $30 $— $614 
Collectively analyzed loans12,827 8,735 15,378 7,758 7,742 1,862 54,309 
Loans acquired with deteriorated credit quality— 142 — 27 — — 173 
Total $13,017 $8,742 $15,757 $7,758 $7,923 $1,892 $$55,096 
Total loans:
Individually analyzed loans$4,063 $382 $15,360 $— $11,550 $601 $— $31,956 
Collectively analyzed loans2,788,770 1,408,805 2,361,717 443,094 521,491 266,031 2,801 7,792,709 
Loans acquired with deteriorated credit quality1,893 — 12,689 — 369 138 — 15,089 
Total loans$2,794,726 $1,409,187 $2,389,766 $443,094 $533,410 $266,770 $2,801 $7,839,754 

    On January 1, 2023, the Company adopted ASU 2022-02, Financial Instruments-Credit Losses (Topic 326), Troubled Debt Restructurings and Vintage Disclosures, which eliminated the accounting guidance for troubled debt restructurings (“TDRs”) while enhancing disclosure requirements for certain loan refinancing and restructurings by creditors when a borrower is experiencing financial difficulty. This guidance was applied on a prospective basis. Modifications made to borrowers experiencing financial difficulty may include principal or interest forgiveness, forbearance, interest rate reductions, term extensions, or a combination of these events intended to minimize economic loss and to avoid foreclosure or repossession of collateral.
9.    Loans Receivable and Allowance for Credit Losses (continued)

The following table presents the modifications of loans to borrowers experiencing financial difficulty that were modified
during the three and nine months ended September 30, 2024 and 2023:

For the Three Months Ended September 30, 2024
Amortized CostInterest Rate Reduction% of Total Class of Loans Receivable
(In thousands)
Commercial real estate$1,536 $1,536 0.07 %
Total loans$1,536 $1,536 0.02 %

For the Three Months Ended September 30, 2023
Amortized CostTerm ExtensionCombination of Term Extension, Interest Rate Reduction, and Principal Forgiveness% of Total Class of Loans Receivable
(In thousands)
Commercial real estate$1,038 $1,038 $— — %
Commercial business 5,000 — 5,000 0.09 
Total loans$6,038 $1,038 $5,000 0.01 %

For the Nine Months Ended September 30, 2024
Amortized CostInterest Rate ReductionTerm ExtensionCombination of Term Extension, Interest Rate Reduction, and Principal Forgiveness% of Total Class of Loans Receivable
(In thousands)
Commercial real estate$1,536 $1,536 $— $— 0.07 %
Commercial business 3,700 — 3,700 — 0.63 %
Total loans$5,236 $1,536 $3,700 $— 0.07 %
9.    Loans Receivable and Allowance for Credit Losses (continued)

For the Nine Months Ended September 30, 2023
Amortized CostTerm ExtensionCombination of Term Extension, Interest Rate Reduction, and Principal Forgiveness% of Total Class of Loans Receivable
(In thousands)
Commercial real estate$1,038 $1,038 $— — %
Construction2,317 2,317 — 0.60 %
Commercial business 5,240 240 5,000 1.00 %
Total loans$8,595 $3,595 $5,000 0.10 %

The following table describes the types of modifications of loans to borrowers experiencing financial difficulty during the
three and nine months ended September 30, 2024 and 2023:
                                                                        For the Three Months Ended September 30, 2024
Type of Modifications
Commercial real estateInterest rate reduction

                                                                        For the Three Months Ended September 30, 2023
Type of Modifications
Construction
12 month term extension
Commercial business
12 month term extension, interest rate reduction, and/or principal forgiveness
                                                                        For the Nine Months Ended September 30, 2024
Type of Modifications
Commercial real estateInterest rate reduction
Commercial business
15 month term extension
                                                                        For the Nine Months Ended September 30, 2023
Type of Modifications
Commercial real estate
12 month term extension
Construction
12 month term extension
Commercial business
12 month term extension, interest rate reduction, and/or principal forgiveness
9.    Loans Receivable and Allowance for Credit Losses (continued)

The Company closely monitors the performance of modifications of loans to borrowers experiencing financial difficulty to understand the effectiveness of these modification efforts. The Company did not extend any commitments to lend additional funds to borrowers experiencing financial difficulty whose loans had been modified during the three and nine months ended September 30, 2024.
The following tables present the aging analysis of modifications of loans to borrowers experiencing financial difficulty at September 30, 2024 and December 31, 2023:
 September 30, 2024
Current30-59 Days60-89 Days90 Days or MoreNon-accrual Total
(In thousands)
Commercial real estate$1,530 $— $— $— $1,029 $2,559 
Commercial business — — — — 3,686 3,686 
Total loans$1,530 $— $— $— $4,715 $6,245 
December 31, 2023
Current30-59 Days60-89 Days90 Days or MoreNon-accrual Total
(In thousands)
Commercial real estate$1,035 $— $— $— $— $1,035 
Construction2,317 — — — — 2,317 
Commercial business — — 4,917 — 237 5,154 
Total loans$3,352 $— $4,917 $— $237 $8,506 
9.    Loans Receivable and Allowance for Credit Losses (continued)

The activity in the allowance for credit losses by portfolio segment for the three and nine months ended September 30, 2024 and 2023 are as follows:
 For the Three Months Ended September 30,
One-to-Four FamilyMultifamily Commercial Real EstateConstructionCommercial Business Home Equity Loans and AdvancesOther Consumer LoansTotals
(In thousands)
2024
Balance at beginning of period$14,888 $8,391 $15,080 $8,549 $7,494 $2,654 $$57,062 
Provision for (reversal of) credit losses(2,055)124 440 (1,474)8,267 (1,275)76 4,103 
Recoveries— 36 50 102 
Charge-offs— — — — (2,696)— (76)(2,772)
Balance at end of period$12,841 $8,515 $15,556 $7,076 $13,115 $1,384 $$58,495 
2023
Balance at beginning of period$11,026 $9,392 $16,212 $6,935 $7,690 $2,193 $$53,456 
Provision for (reversal of) credit losses1,063 117 (454)10 1,688 (53)2,379 
Recoveries— — — — 624 49 674 
Charge-offs(218)— — — (2,168)— (10)(2,396)
Balance at end of period$11,871 $9,509 $15,758 $6,945 $7,834 $2,189 $$54,113 
9.    Loans Receivable and Allowance for Credit Losses (continued)

For the Nine Months Ended September 30,
One-to-Four FamilyMultifamily Commercial Real EstateConstructionCommercial Business Home Equity Loans and AdvancesOther Consumer LoansTotals
(In thousands)
2024
Balance at beginning of period$13,017 $8,742 $15,757 $7,758 $7,923 $1,892 $$55,096 
Provision for (reversal of) credit losses(184)(227)(117)(685)13,076 (522)234 11,575 
Recoveries10 — 36 455 14 521 
Charge-offs(2)— (120)— (8,339)— (236)(8,697)
Balance at end of period$12,841 $8,515 $15,556 $7,076 $13,115 $1,384 $$58,495 
2023
Balance at beginning of period$11,802 $7,877 $18,111 $6,425 $6,897 $1,681 $10 $52,803 
Provision for (reversal of) credit losses421 1,632 (2,203)520 2,725 460 77 3,632 
Recoveries— — — — 830 73 909 
Charge-offs(352)— (150)— (2,618)(25)(86)(3,231)
Balance at end of period$11,871 $9,509 $15,758 $6,945 $7,834 $2,189 $$54,113 
9.    Loans Receivable and Allowance for Credit Losses (continued)

The following tables present individually analyzed loans by segment, excluding PCD loans, at September 30, 2024 and December 31, 2023:

At September 30, 2024
Recorded InvestmentUnpaid Principal BalanceSpecific Allowance
(In thousands)
With no allowance recorded:
Real estate loans:
One-to-four family$7,238 $7,287 $— 
Multifamily 5,743 5,743 — 
Commercial real estate7,578 8,238 — 
Commercial business loans12,062 15,031 — 
Consumer loans:
Home equity loans and advances171 171 — 
32,792 36,470 — 
With a specific allowance recorded:
— — — 
Total:
Real estate loans:
One-to-four family7,238 7,287 — 
Multifamily 5,743 5,743 — 
Commercial real estate7,578 8,238 — 
Commercial business loans12,062 15,031 — 
Consumer loans:
Home equity loans and advances171 171 — 
Total loans$32,792 $36,470 $— 
9.    Loans Receivable and Allowance for Credit Losses (continued)
At December 31, 2023
Recorded InvestmentUnpaid Principal BalanceSpecific Allowance
(In thousands)
With no allowance recorded:
Real estate loans:
One-to-four family$1,170 $1,519 $— 
Multifamily 49 52 — 
Commercial real estate12,741 14,364 — 
Commercial business loans5,814 6,764 — 
Consumer loans:
Home equity loans and advances145 163 — 
19,919 22,862 — 
With a specific allowance recorded:
Real estate loans:
One-to-four family2,893 2,911 186 
Multifamily333 333 
Commercial real estate2,619 2,622 237 
Commercial business loans5,736 5,736 154 
Consumer loans:
Home equity loans and advances456 456 30 
12,037 12,058 614 
Total:
Real estate loans:
One-to-four family4,063 4,430 186 
Multifamily 382 385 
Commercial real estate15,360 16,986 237 
Commercial business loans11,550 12,500 154 
Consumer loans:
Home equity loans and advances601 619 30 
$31,956 $34,920 $614 

    Specific allocations of the allowance for credit losses attributable to individually analyzed loans totaled $0 and $614,000 at September 30, 2024 and December 31, 2023, respectively. At September 30, 2024 and December 31, 2023, impaired loans for which there was no related allowance for credit losses totaled $32.8 million and $19.9 million, respectively.

    
9.    Loans Receivable and Allowance for Credit Losses (continued)
    
The following table presents interest income recognized for individually analyzed loans by loan segment, excluding PCD loans and non-accrual loans, for the three and nine months ended September 30, 2024 and 2023:
 For the Three Months Ended September 30,
20242023
Average Recorded InvestmentInterest Income RecognizedAverage Recorded InvestmentInterest Income Recognized
(In thousands)
Real estate loans:
One-to-four family$3,808 $— $4,329 $54 
Multifamily 2,872 — 411 
Commercial real estate8,258 48 16,653 214 
Commercial business loans11,477 — 7,657 78 
Consumer loans:
Home equity loans and advances93 — 626 15 
Total loans$26,508 $48 $29,676 $366 

For the Nine Months Ended September 30,
20242023
Average Recorded InvestmentInterest Income RecognizedAverage Recorded InvestmentInterest Income Recognized
(In thousands)
Real estate loans:
One-to-four family$3,352 $13 $4,394 $154 
Multifamily 1,543 429 15 
Commercial real estate10,393 88 16,452 516 
Commercial business loans10,905 — 4,780 148 
Consumer loans:
Home equity loans and advances224 657 32 
Total loans$26,417 $103 $26,712 $865 

Management prepares an analysis each quarter that categorizes the entire loan portfolio by certain risk characteristics such as loan type (residential mortgage, commercial mortgage, construction, commercial business, etc.) and loan risk rating. The categorization of loans into risk categories is based upon relevant information about the borrower's ability to service their debt.
The Company utilizes a risk rating system to summarize its loan portfolio into categories with similar risk characteristics. Loans deemed to be “acceptable quality” are rated 1 through 4, with a rating established for loans with minimal risk. Loans rated 4w are watch loans, which may have a potential concern that warrants increased oversight and tracking by management. We enhanced our level of scrutiny and focus regarding documentation related to credit risk rating benchmark guidelines that pertain to debt-service coverage ratios, LTV ratios, borrower strength, asset quality, and funded cash reserves. Other factors such as guarantees, market strength, and remaining loan term and borrower equity are also reviewed and are factored into determining the credit risk rating assigned to each loan. Loans that are deemed to be of “questionable quality” are rated 5 (Special Mention) or 6 (Substandard). Loans with adverse classifications are rated 7 (Doubtful) or 8 (Loss). The risk ratings are also confirmed through periodic loan review examinations which are currently performed by both an independent third-party and the Company's credit risk review department. The Company requires an annual review be performed above certain dollar thresholds, depending on loan type, to help determine the appropriate risk ratings. Results from examinations are presented to the Audit Committee of the Board of Directors.
9.    Loans Receivable and Allowance for Credit Losses (continued)

The following table summarizes the Company's loans by year of origination and internally assigned credit risk rating, excluding PCD loans, at September 30, 2024 and December 31, 2023:

Loans by Year of Origination at September 30, 2024
20242023202220212020PriorRevolving LoansRevolving Loans to Term LoansTotal
(In thousands)
One-to-Four Family
Pass$87,553 $156,055 $765,664 $758,498 $255,413 $705,269 $— $— $2,728,452 
Special mention— — — — — — — — — 
Substandard— 747 2,116 1,494 600 3,781 — — 8,738 
Total One-to-Four Family87,553 156,802 767,780 759,992 256,013 709,050 — — 2,737,190 
Gross charge-offs— — — — — — — 
Multifamily
Pass16,708 123,376 307,033 336,837 166,583 440,868 — — 1,391,405 
Special mention— — — 750 — — — — 750 
Substandard— — 5,743 — — 1,102 — — 6,845 
Total Multifamily16,708 123,376 312,776 337,587 166,583 441,970 — — 1,399,000 
Gross charge-offs— — — — — — — — — 
Commercial Real Estate
Pass88,218 178,271 428,615 373,770 154,958 958,565 — — 2,182,397 
Special mention— — 1,035 2,798 43,947 — — 47,781 
Substandard— — 9,838 1,000 3,717 68,026 — — 82,581 
Total Commercial Real Estate88,218 178,271 439,488 374,771 161,473 1,070,538 — — 2,312,759 
Gross charge-offs— — — — — 120 — — 120 
Construction
Pass35,915 157,306 258,931 47,725 — — — — 499,877 
Special mention— — 5,554 — — — — — 5,554 
Substandard— — 5,008 — — — — — 5,008 
Total Construction35,915 157,306 269,493 47,725 — — — — 510,439 
Gross charge-offs$— $— $— $— $— $— $— $— $— 
9.    Loans Receivable and Allowance for Credit Losses (continued)

Loans by Year of Origination at September 30, 2024
20242023202220212020PriorRevolving LoansRevolving Loans to Term LoansTotal
(In thousands)
Commercial Business
Pass$71,735 $58,408 $54,552 $26,194 $23,293 $42,311 $258,085 $— $534,578 
Special mention— — 236 — 66 767 8,891 — 9,960 
Substandard1,465 326 273 523 235 7,428 31,261 — 41,511 
Doubtful— — — — — 398 — — 398 
Total Commercial Business73,200 58,734 55,061 26,717 23,594 50,904 298,237 — 586,447 
Gross charge-offs— — 364 3,033 — 4,942 — — 8,339 
Home Equity Loans and Advances
Pass11,015 17,596 19,144 16,708 10,145 81,599 36,902 67,761 260,870 
Special mention— — — — — — — — — 
Substandard— — — — — 171 — — 171 
Total Home Equity Loans and Advances11,015 17,596 19,144 16,708 10,145 81,770 36,902 67,761 261,041 
Gross charge-offs— — — — — — — — — 
Other Consumer Loans
Pass2,283 105 101 10 66 311 — 2,877 
Special mention— — — — — — — — — 
Substandard— — — — — — — — — 
Total Other Consumer Loans2,283 105 101 10 66 311 — 2,877 
Gross charge-offs— 62 118 54 — — — 236 
Total Loans314,892 692,190 1,863,843 1,563,510 617,809 2,354,298 335,450 67,761 7,809,753 
Total gross charge-offs$— $62 $482 $3,087 $— $5,066 $— $— $8,697 
9.    Loans Receivable and Allowance for Credit Losses (continued)

Loans by Year of Origination at December 31, 2023
20232022202120202019PriorRevolving LoansRevolving Loans to Term LoansTotal
(In thousands)
One-to-Four Family
Pass$156,279 $786,735 $793,074 $272,215 $165,337 $614,351 $— $— $2,787,991 
Special mention— — — — — — — — — 
Substandard— 1,176 769 283 629 1,985 — — 4,842 
Total One-to-Four family156,279 787,911 793,843 272,498 165,966 616,336 — — 2,792,833 
Gross charge-offs— 208 197 — 29 151 — — 585 
Multifamily
Pass111,612 317,277 359,983 157,294 202,923 255,578 — — 1,404,667 
Special mention— — — — — 4,520 — — 4,520 
Substandard— — — — — — — — — 
Total Multifamily111,612 317,277 359,983 157,294 202,923 260,098 — — 1,409,187 
Gross charge-offs— — — — — — — — — 
Commercial Real Estate
Pass191,030 422,058 371,578 174,705 236,263 930,740 — — 2,326,374 
Special mention— — 465 — 871 24,405 — — 25,741 
Substandard— 5,743 905 1,799 — 16,515 — — 24,962 
Total Commercial Real Estate191,030 427,801 372,948 176,504 237,134 971,660 — — 2,377,077 
Gross charge-offs— — — — 64 86 — — 150 
Construction
Pass99,634 270,397 65,374 4,933 439 2,317 — — 443,094 
Special mention— — — — — — — — — 
Substandard— — — — — — — — — 
Total Construction99,634 270,397 65,374 4,933 439 2,317 — — 443,094 
Gross charge-offs$— $— $— $— $— $— $— $— $— 
9.    Loans Receivable and Allowance for Credit Losses (continued)

Loans by Year of Origination at December 31, 2023
20232022202120202019PriorRevolving LoansRevolving Loans to Term LoansTotal
(In thousands)
Commercial Business
Pass$67,529 $58,118 $28,989 $27,194 $15,499 $38,954 $272,698 $— $508,981 
Special mention127 303 — 97 14 1,389 4,587 — 6,517 
Substandard— 76 88 1,081 6,150 10,142 — 17,543 
Total Commercial Business67,656 58,497 29,077 27,297 16,594 46,493 287,427 — 533,041 
Gross charge-offs— — 31 34 2,249 304 — — 2,618 
Home Equity Loans and Advances
Pass20,198 20,713 18,139 11,368 9,877 84,261 37,261 64,558 266,375 
Special mention— — — — — — — — — 
Substandard— — — — — 257 — — 257 
Total Home Equity Loans and Advances20,198 20,713 18,139 11,368 9,877 84,518 37,261 64,558 266,632 
Gross charge-offs— — — — — 26 — — 26 
Other Consumer Loans
Pass2,199 151 38 18 68 321 — 2,801 
Special mention— — — — — — — — — 
Substandard— — — — — — — — — 
Total Other Consumer Loans2,199 151 38 18 68 321 — 2,801 
Gross charge-offs— 61 52 — — — — 115 
Total Loans648,608 1,882,747 1,639,402 649,900 632,951 1,981,490 325,009 64,558 7,824,665 
Total gross charge-offs$— $269 $280 $34 $2,342 $569 $— $— $3,494 
9.    Loans Receivable and Allowance for Credit Losses (continued)

The Company is required to include unfunded commitments that are expected to be funded in the future within the allowance calculation, other than those that are unconditionally cancellable. To arrive at that reserve, the reserve percentage for each applicable segment is applied to the unused portion of the expected commitment balance and is multiplied by the expected funding rate. To determine the expected funding rate, the Company uses a historical utilization rate for each segment. The allowance for credit losses for off-balance-sheet exposures is reported in other liabilities in the Consolidated Statements of Financial Condition. The liability represents an estimate of expected credit losses arising from off-balance-sheet exposures such as unfunded commitments. At September 30, 2024 and December 31, 2023, the balance of the allowance for credit losses on unfunded commitments, included in other liabilities, totaled $3.4 million and $5.5 million, respectively. The Company recorded a reversal of provision for credit losses on unfunded commitments, included in other non-interest expense in the Consolidated Statements of Income, of $548,000 and $520,000 and $2.0 million and $1.2 million during the three and nine months ended September 30, 2024 and 2023, respectively.

The following table presents the activity in the allowance for credit losses on off-balance-sheet exposures for the three and nine months ended September 30, 2024 and 2023:
 For the Three Months Ended September 30,For the Nine Months Ended September 30,
2024202320242023
(In thousands)
Allowance for Credit Losses:
Beginning balance
$3,988 $6,330 $5,484 $6,970 
(Reversal of) provision for credit losses(548)(520)(2,044)(1,160)
Balance at end of period
$3,440 $5,810 $3,440 $5,810