X0306 4 2019-02-04 0 0001710366 CONSOL Energy Inc. CEIX 0001713960 Rothka John 1000 CONSOL ENERGY DRIVE, SUITE 100 CANONSBURG PA 15317 0 1 0 0 Chief Accounting Officer Common stock, par value $0.01 per share 2019-02-04 4 A 0 660 0.00 A 4380 D Common stock, par value $0.01 per share 2019-02-04 4 F 0 182 35.30 D 4198 D Common stock, par value $0.01 per share 2019-02-06 4 F 0 61 34.72 D 4137 D Represents shares of common stock from the vesting and settlement of performance share units previously granted to the reporting person under the 2018 Long Term Incentive Program for the 2018 performance period. Represents shares of common stock withheld to satisfy the reporting person's tax liability resulting from the vesting and settlement of performance share units previously reported herein. Represents shares of common stock withheld to satisfy the reporting person's tax liability resulting from the vesting of restricted stock units previously granted to him. Of the 4,137 shares reported, 2,678 are restricted stock units (including dividend equivalent rights). /s/ Martha A. Wiegand, as Attorney-in-Fact for John Rothka 2019-02-06