X0206 3 2016-09-21 0 0001676479 CapStar Financial Holdings, Inc. CSTR 0001044541 WILT TOBY S 201 4TH AVENUE NORTH, SUITE 950 NASHVILLE TN 37219 1 0 0 0 Common Stock 253839 D Common Stock 75000 I WF Partners Common Stock 25000 I Joanne Wilt Banks Common Stock 4800 I Pershing LLC Cust Mark Banks IRA Common Stock 5200 I Mark R. Banks Common Stock 25000 I Wilt Fleming TR UA JAN 21 00 Samuel M. Fleming Charitable Lead Annuity Trust Common Stock 12500 I Dallas Hagewood Wilt Common Stock 14000 I Lucianne Forcum Wilt Family Common Stock 5000 I James F. & Elissa Watkins, as joint tenants Common Stock 30000 I Lucianne Forcum Wilt Common Stock 20000 I Samuel Fleming Wilt Common Stock 25000 I Toby Stack Wilt, Jr. Restricted Common Stock 405 D Restricted Common Stock 976 D Restricted Common Stock 1525 D Warrants 10.00 2008-07-14 2018-07-14 Common Stock 22500 D Warrants 10.00 2008-07-14 2018-07-14 Common Stock 3750 I WF Partners Warrants 10.00 2008-07-14 2018-07-14 Common Stock 1250 I Joanne Wilt Banks Warrants 10.00 2008-07-14 2018-07-14 Common Stock 500 I Mark R. Banks Warrants 10.00 2008-07-14 2018-07-14 Common Stock 1250 I Wilt Fleming TR UA JAN 21 00 Samuel M. Fleming Charitable Lead Annuity Trust Warrants 10.00 2008-07-14 2018-07-14 Common Stock 625 I Dallas Hagewood Wilt Warrants 10.00 2008-07-14 2018-07-14 Common Stock 700 I Lucianne Forcum Wilt Family Warrants 10.00 2008-07-14 2018-07-14 Common Stock 250 I James F. & Elissa Watkins, as joint tenants Warrants 10.00 2008-07-14 2018-07-14 Common Stock 1500 I Lucianne Forcum Wilt Warrants 10.00 2008-07-14 2018-07-14 Common Stock 1000 I Samuel Fleming Wilt Warrants 10.00 2008-07-14 2018-07-14 Common Stock 1250 I Toby Stack Wilt, Jr. Option (right to buy) 10.00 2018-11-13 Common Stock 12000 D Option (right to buy) 10.00 2020-01-20 Common Stock 6000 D The reporting person disclaims beneficial ownership of these securities except to the extent of his pecuniary interest therein, and the inclusion of these shares in this report shall not be deemed an admission of beneficial ownership of all of the reported shares for purposes of Section 16 or for any other purpose. The reported item represents the unvested portion of an award of restricted stock on February 27, 2014. The balance of this award vests on the third anniversary of the grant date, or February 27, 2017. The reported item represents the unvested portion of an award of restricted stock on February 27, 2015. 488 shares of restricted stotck under this award vest on the second anniversary of the grant date, or February 27, 2017, and the remaining 488 shares of restricted stotck under this award vest on the second anniversary of the grant date, or February 27, 2018. The reported item vests in three equal installments beginning on the first anniversary of the March 3, 2016, grant date. These options vested in four equal annual installments beginning one year after the November 13, 2008, grant date. These options vested in four equal annual installments beginning one year after the January 20, 2010, grant date. /s/ Toby S. Wilt 2016-09-21