The Securities and Exchange Commission has not necessarily reviewed the information in this filing and has not determined if it is accurate and complete.
The reader should not assume that the information is accurate and complete.

UNITED STATES SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION
Washington, D.C. 20549
FORM 13F

FORM 13F INFORMATION TABLE
OMB APPROVAL
OMB Number: 3235-0006
Estimated average burden
hours per response: 23.8
COLUMN 1 COLUMN 2 COLUMN 3 COLUMN 4 COLUMN 5 COLUMN 6 COLUMN 7 COLUMN 8
VALUE SHRS OR SH/ PUT/ INVESTMENT OTHER VOTING AUTHORITY
NAME OF ISSUER TITLE OF CLASS CUSIP (x$1000) PRN AMT PRN CALL DISCRETION MANAGER SOLE SHARED NONE
AT&T INC COM 00206R102 3,734 86,415 SH   SOLE   0 0 86,415
ABBOTT LABS COM 002824100 1,246 31,705 SH   SOLE   0 0 31,705
ABBVIE INC COM 00287Y109 1,624 26,232 SH   SOLE   0 0 26,232
ADAM NAT RES FD INC COM 00548F105 2,260 112,360 SH   SOLE   0 0 112,360
ALLIANZGI NFJ DIVID INT & PR COM 01883A107 958 77,736 SH   SOLE   0 0 77,736
ALPHABET INC CAP STK CL C 02079K107 2,937 4,243 SH   SOLE   0 0 4,243
ALPHABET INC CAP STK CL A 02079K305 1,757 2,498 SH   SOLE   0 0 2,498
ALPINE GLOBAL PREMIER PPTYS COM SBI 02083A103 693 126,251 SH   SOLE   0 0 126,251
ALTRIA GROUP INC COM 02209S103 1,076 15,601 SH   SOLE   0 0 15,601
AMAZON COM INC COM 023135106 1,321 1,846 SH   SOLE   0 0 1,846
AMERICAN ELEC PWR INC COM 025537101 432 6,169 SH   SOLE   0 0 6,169
AMERISOURCEBERGEN CORP COM 03073E105 409 5,161 SH   SOLE   0 0 5,161
AMGEN INC COM 031162100 226 1,485 SH   SOLE   0 0 1,485
ANDERSONS INC COM 034164103 394 11,090 SH   SOLE   0 0 11,090
APACHE CORP COM 037411105 1,939 34,829 SH   SOLE   0 0 34,829
APPLE INC COM 037833100 6,330 66,213 SH   SOLE   0 0 66,213
ARES CAP CORP COM 04010L103 3,223 226,979 SH   SOLE   0 0 226,979
ATHERSYS INC COM 04744L106 83 38,400 SH   SOLE   0 0 38,400
AUTOMATIC DATA PROCESSING IN COM 053015103 804 8,747 SH   SOLE   0 0 8,747
BP PLC SPONSORED ADR 055622104 569 16,010 SH   SOLE   0 0 16,010
BANK AMER CORP COM 060505104 206 15,514 SH   SOLE   0 0 15,514
BECTON DICKINSON & CO COM 075887109 775 4,571 SH   SOLE   0 0 4,571
BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY INC DEL CL B NEW 084670702 4,448 30,721 SH   SOLE   0 0 30,721
BIOGEN INC COM 09062X103 1,119 4,628 SH   SOLE   0 0 4,628
BLACKROCK INC COM 09247X101 474 1,383 SH   SOLE   0 0 1,383
BLACKROCK GLOBAL OPP EQTY TR COM 092501105 219 18,443 SH   SOLE   0 0 18,443
BLACKSTONE GROUP L P COM UNIT LTD 09253U108 1,861 75,846 SH   SOLE   0 0 75,846
BOULDER GROWTH & INCOME FD I COM 101507101 188 23,172 SH   SOLE   0 0 23,172
BRISTOL MYERS SQUIBB CO COM 110122108 703 9,563 SH   SOLE   0 0 9,563
BROOKFIELD ASSET MGMT INC CL A LTD VT SH 112585104 1,086 32,854 SH   SOLE   0 0 32,854
BUCKEYE PARTNERS L P UNIT LTD PARTN 118230101 1,553 22,087 SH   SOLE   0 0 22,087
CSX CORP COM 126408103 1,858 71,259 SH   SOLE   0 0 71,259
CVS HEALTH CORP COM 126650100 1,913 19,979 SH   SOLE   0 0 19,979
CENTRAL FED CORP COM NEW 15346Q202 602 442,350 SH   SOLE   0 0 442,350
CERNER CORP COM 156782104 1,844 31,462 SH   SOLE   0 0 31,462
CHEVRON CORP NEW COM 166764100 6,539 62,374 SH   SOLE   0 0 62,374
CINCINNATI FINL CORP COM 172062101 875 11,679 SH   SOLE   0 0 11,679
CISCO SYS INC COM 17275R102 670 23,355 SH   SOLE   0 0 23,355
COCA COLA CO COM 191216100 620 13,681 SH   SOLE   0 0 13,681
COGNIZANT TECHNOLOGY SOLUTIO CL A 192446102 870 15,200 SH   SOLE   0 0 15,200
COHEN & STEERS INFRASTRUCTUR COM 19248A109 651 30,402 SH   SOLE   0 0 30,402
COLGATE PALMOLIVE CO COM 194162103 548 7,481 SH   SOLE   0 0 7,481
COMCAST CORP NEW CL A 20030N101 1,409 21,618 SH   SOLE   0 0 21,618
CONOCOPHILLIPS COM 20825C104 1,435 32,923 SH   SOLE   0 0 32,923
COPART INC COM 217204106 326 6,650 SH   SOLE   0 0 6,650
CORNING INC COM 219350105 606 29,572 SH   SOLE   0 0 29,572
COSTCO WHSL CORP NEW COM 22160K105 684 4,356 SH   SOLE   0 0 4,356
DANAHER CORP DEL COM 235851102 356 3,525 SH   SOLE   0 0 3,525
DEERE & CO COM 244199105 442 5,459 SH   SOLE   0 0 5,459
DIAGEO P L C SPON ADR NEW 25243Q205 2,222 19,683 SH   SOLE   0 0 19,683
DISNEY WALT CO COM DISNEY 254687106 2,421 24,748 SH   SOLE   0 0 24,748
DOMINION RES INC VA NEW COM 25746U109 1,018 13,058 SH   SOLE   0 0 13,058
DOW CHEM CO COM 260543103 1,410 28,369 SH   SOLE   0 0 28,369
DU PONT E I DE NEMOURS & CO COM 263534109 750 11,574 SH   SOLE   0 0 11,574
DUKE ENERGY CORP NEW COM NEW 26441C204 326 3,795 SH   SOLE   0 0 3,795
EATON VANCE TAX MNGD GBL DV COM 27829F108 494 57,668 SH   SOLE   0 0 57,668
EATON VANCE RISK MNGD DIV EQ COM 27829G106 227 23,195 SH   SOLE   0 0 23,195
EATON VANCE NATL MUN OPPORT COM SHS 27829L105 1,396 60,610 SH   SOLE   0 0 60,610
ENERGY TRANSFER EQUITY L P COM UT LTD PTN 29273V100 250 17,380 SH   SOLE   0 0 17,380
ENTERPRISE PRODS PARTNERS L COM 293792107 2,866 97,951 SH   SOLE   0 0 97,951
EXPEDITORS INTL WASH INC COM 302130109 1,010 20,587 SH   SOLE   0 0 20,587
EXPRESS SCRIPTS HLDG CO COM 30219G108 5,166 68,154 SH   SOLE   0 0 68,154
EXXON MOBIL CORP COM 30231G102 6,560 69,986 SH   SOLE   0 0 69,986
FNB CORP PA COM 302520101 129 10,250 SH   SOLE   0 0 10,250
FACEBOOK INC CL A 30303M102 293 2,562 SH   SOLE   0 0 2,562
FARMERS NATL BANC CORP COM 309627107 93 10,514 SH   SOLE   0 0 10,514
FIRST TR MORNINGSTAR DIV LEA SHS 336917109 1,198 44,642 SH   SOLE   0 0 44,642
FIRST TR LRGE CP CORE ALPHA COM SHS 33734K109 1,696 37,652 SH   SOLE   0 0 37,652
FLUOR CORP NEW COM 343412102 718 14,563 SH   SOLE   0 0 14,563
FORTUNE BRANDS HOME & SEC IN COM 34964C106 837 14,443 SH   SOLE   0 0 14,443
GABELLI HLTHCARE & WELLNESS SHS 36246K103 495 46,357 SH   SOLE   0 0 46,357
GENERAL DYNAMICS CORP COM 369550108 1,431 10,279 SH   SOLE   0 0 10,279
GENERAL ELECTRIC CO COM 369604103 792 25,165 SH   SOLE   0 0 25,165
GILEAD SCIENCES INC COM 375558103 1,655 19,835 SH   SOLE   0 0 19,835
GRAINGER W W INC COM 384802104 535 2,354 SH   SOLE   0 0 2,354
HARRIS CORP DEL COM 413875105 1,409 16,885 SH   SOLE   0 0 16,885
HOME DEPOT INC COM 437076102 321 2,516 SH   SOLE   0 0 2,516
HONEYWELL INTL INC COM 438516106 2,173 18,683 SH   SOLE   0 0 18,683
HOWARD HUGHES CORP COM 44267D107 220 1,925 SH   SOLE   0 0 1,925
INTEL CORP COM 458140100 272 8,279 SH   SOLE   0 0 8,279
INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MACHS COM 459200101 369 2,431 SH   SOLE   0 0 2,431
ISHARES TR CORE US AGGBD ET 464287226 227 2,017 SH   SOLE   0 0 2,017
ISHARES TR MSCI EMG MKT ETF 464287234 274 7,965 SH   SOLE   0 0 7,965
ISHARES TR RUS MDCP VAL ETF 464287473 270 3,635 SH   SOLE   0 0 3,635
ISHARES TR RUS MID-CAP ETF 464287499 220 1,308 SH   SOLE   0 0 1,308
ISHARES TR CORE S&P MCP ETF 464287507 891 5,961 SH   SOLE   0 0 5,961
ISHARES TR NASDQ BIOTEC ETF 464287556 250 970 SH   SOLE   0 0 970
ISHARES TR CORE S&P SCP ETF 464287804 480 4,129 SH   SOLE   0 0 4,129
ISHARES TR IBOXX HI YD ETF 464288513 478 5,644 SH   SOLE   0 0 5,644
ISHARES TR 1-3 YR CR BD ETF 464288646 440 4,151 SH   SOLE   0 0 4,151
ISHARES TR 3-7 YR TR BD ETF 464288661 205 1,608 SH   SOLE   0 0 1,608
JPMORGAN CHASE & CO COM 46625H100 978 15,739 SH   SOLE   0 0 15,739
JOHNSON & JOHNSON COM 478160104 5,148 42,441 SH   SOLE   0 0 42,441
KKR & CO L P DEL COM UNITS 48248M102 200 16,204 SH   SOLE   0 0 16,204
KELLOGG CO COM 487836108 299 3,666 SH   SOLE   0 0 3,666
KRAFT HEINZ CO COM 500754106 262 2,966 SH   SOLE   0 0 2,966
L BRANDS INC COM 501797104 455 6,781 SH   SOLE   0 0 6,781
LEUCADIA NATL CORP COM 527288104 388 22,415 SH   SOLE   0 0 22,415
LIBBEY INC COM 529898108 575 36,197 SH   SOLE   0 0 36,197
LIBERTY MEDIA CORP DELAWARE COM C SIRIUSXM 531229607 260 8,420 SH   SOLE   0 0 8,420
LOWES COS INC COM 548661107 708 8,941 SH   SOLE   0 0 8,941
MAGELLAN MIDSTREAM PRTNRS LP COM UNIT RP LP 559080106 1,428 18,785 SH   SOLE   0 0 18,785
MASTERCARD INC CL A 57636Q104 3,240 36,790 SH   SOLE   0 0 36,790
MAXIM INTEGRATED PRODS INC COM 57772K101 722 20,216 SH   SOLE   0 0 20,216
MCDONALDS CORP COM 580135101 416 3,458 SH   SOLE   0 0 3,458
MERCK & CO INC COM 58933Y105 348 6,032 SH   SOLE   0 0 6,032
MICROSOFT CORP COM 594918104 1,922 37,561 SH   SOLE   0 0 37,561
MICROCHIP TECHNOLOGY INC COM 595017104 698 13,750 SH   SOLE   0 0 13,750
MIDDLEFIELD BANC CORP COM NEW 596304204 396 12,500 SH   SOLE   0 0 12,500
MONDELEZ INTL INC CL A 609207105 343 7,538 SH   SOLE   0 0 7,538
MONOGRAM RESIDENTIAL TR INC COM 60979P105 186 18,248 SH   SOLE   0 0 18,248
MOTOROLA SOLUTIONS INC COM NEW 620076307 265 4,024 SH   SOLE   0 0 4,024
NEXTERA ENERGY INC COM 65339F101 248 1,905 SH   SOLE   0 0 1,905
NIKE INC CL B 654106103 1,003 18,174 SH   SOLE   0 0 18,174
NORFOLK SOUTHERN CORP COM 655844108 655 7,689 SH   SOLE   0 0 7,689
NORTHROP GRUMMAN CORP COM 666807102 415 1,868 SH   SOLE   0 0 1,868
NOVO-NORDISK A S ADR 670100205 222 4,125 SH   SOLE   0 0 4,125
NUVEEN SELECT TAX FREE INCM SH BEN INT 67062F100 282 18,185 SH   SOLE   0 0 18,185
NUVEEN SELECT TAX FREE INCM SH BEN INT 67063X100 176 11,110 SH   SOLE   0 0 11,110
NUVEEN CR STRATEGIES INCM FD COM SHS 67073D102 260 32,174 SH   SOLE   0 0 32,174
ORACLE CORP COM 68389X105 3,851 94,090 SH   SOLE   0 0 94,090
PNC FINL SVCS GROUP INC COM 693475105 500 6,139 SH   SOLE   0 0 6,139
PARKER HANNIFIN CORP COM 701094104 1,245 11,518 SH   SOLE   0 0 11,518
PEPSICO INC COM 713448108 4,881 46,070 SH   SOLE   0 0 46,070
PFIZER INC COM 717081103 1,419 40,313 SH   SOLE   0 0 40,313
PHILIP MORRIS INTL INC COM 718172109 580 5,706 SH   SOLE   0 0 5,706
PHILLIPS 66 COM 718546104 2,341 29,505 SH   SOLE   0 0 29,505
PRAXAIR INC COM 74005P104 310 2,759 SH   SOLE   0 0 2,759
PRICELINE GRP INC COM NEW 741503403 3,030 2,427 SH   SOLE   0 0 2,427
PROCTER & GAMBLE CO COM 742718109 5,234 61,816 SH   SOLE   0 0 61,816
QUALCOMM INC COM 747525103 2,043 38,138 SH   SOLE   0 0 38,138
RPM INTL INC COM 749685103 1,197 23,955 SH   SOLE   0 0 23,955
REPUBLIC SVCS INC COM 760759100 1,825 35,567 SH   SOLE   0 0 35,567
SPDR S&P 500 ETF TR TR UNIT 78462F103 815 3,890 SH   SOLE   0 0 3,890
SCHLUMBERGER LTD COM 806857108 2,967 37,514 SH   SOLE   0 0 37,514
SCHWAB CHARLES CORP NEW COM 808513105 865 34,172 SH   SOLE   0 0 34,172
SCHWAB STRATEGIC TR US BRD MKT ETF 808524102 295 5,864 SH   SOLE   0 0 5,864
SCHWAB STRATEGIC TR US LRG CAP ETF 808524201 5,317 106,841 SH   SOLE   0 0 106,841
SCHWAB STRATEGIC TR EMRG MKTEQ ETF 808524706 1,038 48,751 SH   SOLE   0 0 48,751
SCHWAB STRATEGIC TR US DIVIDEND EQ 808524797 488 11,774 SH   SOLE   0 0 11,774
SCHWAB STRATEGIC TR INTL EQTY ETF 808524805 4,026 148,523 SH   SOLE   0 0 148,523
SCHWAB STRATEGIC TR US AGGREGATE B 808524839 12,954 241,140 SH   SOLE   0 0 241,140
SCHWAB STRATEGIC TR SHT TM US TRES 808524862 229 4,500 SH   SOLE   0 0 4,500
SELECT SECTOR SPDR TR SBI INT-INDS 81369Y704 266 4,750 SH   SOLE   0 0 4,750
SHERWIN WILLIAMS CO COM 824348106 554 1,885 SH   SOLE   0 0 1,885
SMUCKER J M CO COM NEW 832696405 18,982 124,547 SH   SOLE   0 0 124,547
SOUTHERN CO COM 842587107 751 13,999 SH   SOLE   0 0 13,999
SPECIAL OPPORTUNITIES FD INC COM 84741T104 345 25,063 SH   SOLE   0 0 25,063
SQUARE INC CL A 852234103 109 12,000 SH   SOLE   0 0 12,000
TJX COS INC NEW COM 872540109 628 8,134 SH   SOLE   0 0 8,134
TARGET CORP COM 87612E106 255 3,659 SH   SOLE   0 0 3,659
TEMPLETON EMERG MKTS INCOME COM 880192109 614 58,630 SH   SOLE   0 0 58,630
TESLA MTRS INC COM 88160R101 249 1,175 SH   SOLE   0 0 1,175
3M CO COM 88579Y101 3,313 18,919 SH   SOLE   0 0 18,919
TIME WARNER INC COM NEW 887317303 1,686 22,923 SH   SOLE   0 0 22,923
TRAVELERS COMPANIES INC COM 89417E109 1,037 8,714 SH   SOLE   0 0 8,714
US BANCORP DEL COM NEW 902973304 1,454 36,057 SH   SOLE   0 0 36,057
UNILEVER PLC SPON ADR NEW 904767704 1,375 28,707 SH   SOLE   0 0 28,707
UNION PAC CORP COM 907818108 3,500 40,111 SH   SOLE   0 0 40,111
UNITED PARCEL SERVICE INC CL B 911312106 530 4,920 SH   SOLE   0 0 4,920
UNITED TECHNOLOGIES CORP COM 913017109 3,961 38,627 SH   SOLE   0 0 38,627
UNITEDHEALTH GROUP INC COM 91324P102 2,373 16,804 SH   SOLE   0 0 16,804
VANGUARD SPECIALIZED PORTFOL DIV APP ETF 921908844 230 2,765 SH   SOLE   0 0 2,765
VANGUARD BD INDEX FD INC INTERMED TERM 921937819 327 3,713 SH   SOLE   0 0 3,713
VANGUARD BD INDEX FD INC SHORT TRM BOND 921937827 222 2,740 SH   SOLE   0 0 2,740
VANGUARD WHITEHALL FDS INC HIGH DIV YLD 921946406 261 3,659 SH   SOLE   0 0 3,659
VANGUARD WORLD FDS HEALTH CAR ETF 92204A504 761 5,833 SH   SOLE   0 0 5,833
VANGUARD WORLD FDS INF TECH ETF 92204A702 554 5,173 SH   SOLE   0 0 5,173
VANGUARD SCOTTSDALE FDS SHRT TRM CORP BD 92206C409 1,913 23,667 SH   SOLE   0 0 23,667
VANGUARD INDEX FDS S&P 500 ETF SHS 922908363 2,535 13,187 SH   SOLE   0 0 13,187
VANGUARD INDEX FDS REIT ETF 922908553 234 2,636 SH   SOLE   0 0 2,636
VANGUARD INDEX FDS MID CAP ETF 922908629 318 2,570 SH   SOLE   0 0 2,570
VANGUARD INDEX FDS EXTEND MKT ETF 922908652 1,197 14,011 SH   SOLE   0 0 14,011
VERIZON COMMUNICATIONS INC COM 92343V104 2,006 35,922 SH   SOLE   0 0 35,922
VISA INC COM CL A 92826C839 992 13,375 SH   SOLE   0 0 13,375
W P CAREY INC COM 92936U109 1,910 27,520 SH   SOLE   0 0 27,520
WALGREENS BOOTS ALLIANCE INC COM 931427108 389 4,675 SH   SOLE   0 0 4,675
WELLS FARGO & CO NEW COM 949746101 2,494 52,691 SH   SOLE   0 0 52,691
WELLTOWER INC COM 95040Q104 3,867 50,765 SH   SOLE   0 0 50,765
WESTERN ASSET MUN HI INCM FD COM 95766N103 131 15,864 SH   SOLE   0 0 15,864
WEYERHAEUSER CO COM 962166104 1,185 39,804 SH   SOLE   0 0 39,804
WEYERHAEUSER CO PREF CONV SER A 962166872 642 12,743 SH   SOLE   0 0 12,743
ZOETIS INC CL A 98978V103 2,291 48,282 SH   SOLE   0 0 48,282
ZWEIG FD COM NEW 989834205 175 13,932 SH   SOLE   0 0 13,932
ALLERGAN PLC SHS G0177J108 281 1,218 SH   SOLE   0 0 1,218
AON PLC SHS CL A G0408V102 617 5,650 SH   SOLE   0 0 5,650
ACCENTURE PLC IRELAND SHS CLASS A G1151C101 880 7,770 SH   SOLE   0 0 7,770
EATON CORP PLC SHS G29183103 3,675 61,527 SH   SOLE   0 0 61,527
SIGNET JEWELERS LIMITED SHS G81276100 687 8,335 SH   SOLE   0 0 8,335