EX-99.1 2 oct2024exhibit991bvaurorai.htm EX-99.1 Document
Exhibit 99.1
image_1.jpg    BLACK & VEATCH MANAGEMENT CONSULTING, LLC
11401 Lamar Avenue, Overland Park, KS 66211

October 25, 2024
Sunnova Energy Corporation
20 Greenway Plaza #475
Houston, TX 77046

Subject: Sunnova Residential Solar PV Portfolio, Consultant’s Report Findings and Conclusions
Black & Veatch Management Consulting, LLC (Black & Veatch) has been contracted by Sunnova Energy Corporation (Sunnova) to provide a third party technical due diligence report for a term financing collateralized by a residential solar photovoltaic (PV) rooftop portfolio (Portfolio).
The Portfolio consists of 11,643 rooftop systems in Puerto Rico. The aggregate generation capacity of the Portfolio is approximately 68.9 MWp, with an average system size of approximately 5.9 kWp. All of the systems within the Sunnova Portfolio contain a battery energy storage system (BESS) coupled to the PV system, with an average storage capacity of approximately 15.9 kWh. All of the systems are under Storage Lease Agreements, a type of solar service agreement (SSA).
SCOPE OF WORK – ITEM #4
In conducting the technical due diligence review, Black & Veatch performed the following services requested by Sunnova:
nMajor Equipment Technology, Experience, and Qualifications Review
nProcess and Design Overview
nProduction Estimate Process Review and Production Forecast on a Regional Basis
nOperations and Maintenance Review and Forecast
nContract Requirements Review
nFinancial Model Key Assumptions Review
In addition, Black & Veatch (1) discussed with, and posed questions to Sunnova that Black & Veatch, in its sole judgment, chose to ask about the Portfolio; and (2) reviewed certain technical reports prepared by others as identified in this report. The conclusions and findings that resulted from this review are summarized in this report (Report).
The conclusions and findings that resulted from this diligence review are summarized in this Report. The Report was prepared in accordance with the Independent Engineering Services Agreement effective as of June 30, 2017 and Exhibit A-9 effective as of November 2, 2023 between Sunnova and Black & Veatch (collectively, the IESA). The information contained herein was developed based on the needs of Sunnova as set forth in the IESA. The level of information included in the Report reflects the knowledge of issues gained by Black & Veatch during the course of due diligence review. The Report was prepared with respect to the potential financing of the Portfolio and is solely for use of Sunnova. The Report should not be relied upon by any other party or for any other purpose.


www.bv.com



        OCTOBER 25, 2024 | PAGE 2
Certain statements made in this Report are forward looking. The achievement of certain events, results or performance contained in such forward looking statements involve known and unknown risks and uncertainties that may cause actual events, results or performance to be materially different than originally intended. Black & Veatch does not plan to update or revise any forward-looking statements contained in this Report when such events, results or performance deviations occur.
APPROACH AND METHODOLOGY
The Black & Veatch team, consisting of professionals in project management, financial analysts, solar resource and technology specialists, environmental specialists, civil/structural engineers, and supporting engineers, reviewed documents provided by Sunnova in an electronic data room. Data requests for additional or updated documentation were submitted as Black & Veatch deemed necessary.
Black & Veatch reviewed operating data for systems in the Portfolio, provided by Sunnova. The provided data included historical monthly energy generation by system and operations and maintenance logs by system. Black & Veatch also reviewed the methodology for Sunnova’s energy production estimates and compared the production estimates to actual energy production. Black & Veatch reviewed Sunnova’s design and installation practices, equipment selection, form of commercial agreements with partners and vendors, and customer agreements.
During previous engagements with Sunnova, Black & Veatch has met with the Sunnova team at the company’s Houston headquarters to review documentation, understand Sunnova’s processes and procedures in detail (through a Q&A session), and interview available key personnel.
PRINCIPAL ASSUMPTIONS
During the due diligence for this review, Black & Veatch relied upon certain information provided by Sunnova. Black & Veatch believes the information provided is true, correct, and reasonable for the purposes of this Report. Black & Veatch has not been requested to make an independent judgment of the validity of the information provided by others. As such, Black & Veatch cannot, and does not, guarantee the accuracy thereof to the extent that such information, data, or opinions were based on information provided by others.
In preparing this report and the opinions presented herein, Black & Veatch has made certain assumptions with respect to conditions that may exist, or events that may occur in the future. Black & Veatch believes that the use of this information and assumptions is reasonable for the purposes of this Report. However, some events may occur or circumstances change that cannot be foreseen or controlled by Black & Veatch and that may render these assumptions incorrect. To the extent the actual future conditions differ from those assumed herein or provided to Black & Veatch by others, the actual results will differ from those that have been forecast in this Report. This Report summarizes Black & Veatch’s technical due diligence of the Project.
The following is a summary of principal considerations and assumptions made in developing the opinions expressed herein. Black & Veatch assumes that:
nAll contracts, agreements, rules, and regulations will be fully enforceable in accordance with their respective terms and that all parties will comply with the provisions of their respective agreements.
www.bv.com



        OCTOBER 25, 2024 | PAGE 3
nNothing will occur that would change the historical solar resource at the Portfolio sites.
nThe Portfolio will be operated and maintained in accordance with good industry practices, with required renewals and replacements made in a timely manner, and the equipment will be operated in a manner consistent with the equipment manufacturer’s recommendations.
nAll licenses, permits and approvals, and permit modifications (if necessary) will be obtained and/or renewed on a timely basis, and all project participants will comply with the requirements and recommendations contained within the applicable licenses and permits.
CONCLUSIONS – ITEM #5
Based on the reviews and analyses described in this Report, Black & Veatch is of the opinion that:
Portfolio Participants
nSunnova, as project developer and operator, is capable of continuing its responsibilities to oversee the development, construction, operation, and maintenance of the assets in the Portfolio.
nSunnova’s asset management structure, asset monitoring services, and its Dealer network are consistent with other top-tier owners, which rely on Dealers to source portfolios of similar PV assets. Black & Veatch notes that Sunnova evolves its practices to be consistent with currently accepted practices in the residential rooftop solar industry.
Production Estimate Review
nThe modeling approach used by Sunnova to prepare production estimates for the Portfolio, utilizing both PVWatts and the SAM SDK from NREL, is being developed and updated in accordance with industry accepted practice. Black & Veatch believes that Sunnova’s current modeling approach is reasonable.
nThe Portfolio has achieved an irradiance-adjusted production ratio (actual production divided by the product of expected production and the irradiance anomaly) of 112.1 percent over the 12 months from October 2022 through September 2023.
nThe Portfolio has an expected 25-year P90 energy generation equal to 95.5 percent of the Black & Veatch P50 expected energy generation.
Major Equipment, Technology, & Qualifications Review
nThe major equipment (modules, inverters, racking) that will be used for the Portfolio are considered proven technology for the generation of electric energy from sunlight. The major equipment warranties are consistent with accepted industry practice.
nThe metering and communications systems for the Portfolio appear to be comparable to those present at comparable applications and are appropriate for cellular-based monitoring of the Portfolio’s PV systems.
nThe BESS used in the Portfolio are proven equipment for the storage of electrical energy and the associated warranties are consistent with accepted industry practice.
Design, Installation, and Quality Process Review
nSunnova’s Dealer selection process details the experience, certification, and financials of applicants and helps to ensure the Dealers have the competency to execute Sunnova projects.
www.bv.com



        OCTOBER 25, 2024 | PAGE 4
nThe scope of work defined in the directions to the Dealer generally provides the equipment, materials, and services required for the construction of a solar PV facility like those that will comprise the Portfolio and includes technical provisions generally comparable to other similar agreements for comparable solar energy projects.
nSunnova’s remote project monitoring system adequately complements the third-party QA/QC review of 5 percent of installed systems and is in line with other top-tier residential solar providers.
Operations and Design Checks
nSunnova’s O&M logs show consistent activity that aligns with the O&M plan and cost estimates.
nSunnova has demonstrated improved response time to O&M issues.
nSunnova’s ongoing design checks and monitoring program is consistent with other top-tier residential PV owners.
Contractual Requirements Review
nThe Channel Partner Agreements, Servicing Agreement, and Management Agreement generally provide the commodities and services required for the installation, operation, and maintenance of residential solar PV assets in accordance with accepted industry practices, and include technical provisions generally comparable to other similar agreements for comparable solar PV projects.
nBlack & Veatch notes that the customer is not provided with a performance guarantee under the Storage Lease Agreements.
nBlack & Veatch notes that the Dealer warranty under the Channel Partner Agreement does not include an energy production guarantee, and thus the warranty may not cover instances of actual performance below the Production Guarantee (if applicable), due to overestimation of solar resource or availability assumptions.
nBlack & Veatch notes that the Channel Partner Agreements warrant each system against defects for 10 years, though the warranty under the SSAs is for the full term of each SSA.
Financial Model Assumptions Review
nBlack & Veatch recommends adjusting the expected production of the Portfolio to approximately 112.1 percent of Sunnova’s forecasted energy generation. Adjustment factors are provided at P50, P75, and P90 levels.
nBlack & Veatch believes that a P50 assumption of 0.5 percent annual degradation assumed in the Financial Model aligns with typical industry long-term degradation assumptions utilized by investors who consider that the module warranted power performance is typically set at the upper confidence band.


Very truly yours,
BLACK & VEATCH MANAGEMENT CONSULTING, LLC
www.bv.com