X0306 4 2019-11-07 0001094810 MUTUALFIRST FINANCIAL INC MFSF 0001491007 Cook Christopher D C/O MUTUALFIRST FINANCIAL, INC. 110 E. CHARLES STREET MUNCIE IN 47305 0 1 0 0 Sr. VP, Treasurer, & CFO Common Stock 2019-11-07 4 M 0 9000 6.93 A 36788 D Common Stock 2019-11-12 4 M 0 11462 7.05 A 48250 D Common Stock 2019-11-07 4 S 0 1 40.13 D 48200 D Common Stock 2019-11-07 4 S 0 800 40.12 D 47450 D Common Stock 2019-11-07 4 S 0 352 40.11 D 47098 D Common Stock 2019-11-07 4 S 0 100 40.02 D 46998 D Common Stock 2019-11-07 4 S 0 1739 40.01 D 45259 D Common Stock 2019-11-07 4 S 0 100 40.03 D 45159 D Common Stock 2019-11-07 4 S 0 17369 40 D 27790 D Common Stock 4883 I Held by ESOP Stock Option (Right to Purchase) 6.93 2019-11-07 4 M 0 9000 0 D 2012-12-21 2021-12-21 Common Stock 9000 0 D Stock Option (Right to Purchase) 7.05 2019-11-07 4 M 0 11462 0 D 2012-12-21 2026-12-21 Common Stock 11462 10000 D These options were issued under the Issuer's 2008 Stock Option and Incentive Plan. These options were issued under the Issuer's 2000 Stock Option and Incentive Plan. /s/Melissa Greer, POA for Christopher Cook 2019-11-12