EX-99.8 11 ex99-8.htm EXHIBIT 99.8 ex99-8.htm

Exhibit 99.8
 
PRO FORMA VALUATION UPDATE REPORT
 
CAPITOL FEDERAL FINANCIAL, INC.
Topeka, Kansas
 
PROPOSED HOLDING COMPANY FOR:
CAPITOL FEDERAL SAVINGS BANK
Topeka, Kansas
 
Dated As Of:
August 30, 2010
 

 
Prepared By:
 
RP® Financial, LC.
1100 North Glebe Road
Suite 1100
Arlington, Virginia  22201
 

 
 
 

 
 
RP® FINANCIAL, LC.
 
Serving the Financial Services Industry Since 1988
 
                                                        August 30, 2010
 
Boards of Directors
Capitol Federal Savings Bank MHC
Capitol Federal Financial
Capitol Federal Savings Bank
700 Kansas Avenue
Topeka, Kansas  66603
 
Members of the Boards of Directors:
 
We have completed and hereby provide an updated appraisal of the estimated pro forma market value of the common stock which is to be issued in connection with the mutual-to-stock conversion described below.
 
This updated appraisal is furnished pursuant to the conversion regulations promulgated by the Office of Thrift Supervision (“OTS”).  Specifically, this appraisal has been prepared in accordance with the “Guidelines for Appraisal Reports for the Valuation of Savings and Loan Associations Converting from Mutual to Stock Form of Organization” as set forth by the OTS, and applicable regulatory interpretations thereof.   Our original appraisal report, dated May 28, 2010 (the “Original Appraisal”), and previous appraisal update report, dated August 13, 2010 (the “First Update”), are incorporated herein by reference.  As in the preparation of our Original Appraisal and First Update, we believe the data and information used herein is reliable; however, we cannot guarantee the accuracy and completeness of such information.
 
On May 5, 2010, the respective Boards of Directors of Capitol Federal Savings Bank MHC (the “MHC”) and Capitol Federal Financial (“CFFN”) adopted a Plan of Conversion and Reorganization (the “Plan of Conversion”) whereby the MHC will convert to stock form.  As a result of the conversion, CFFN, which currently owns all of the issued and outstanding common stock of the Capitol Federal Savings Bank, Topeka, Kansas (the “Bank”) will be succeed by a Maryland corporation with the name of Capitol Federal Financial, Inc. (“Capitol Federal Financial” or the “Company”).  Following the conversion, the MHC will no longer exist.  For purposes of this document, the existing consolidated entity will hereinafter be referred to as Capitol Federal Financial or the Company.  As of June 30, 2010, the MHC had a majority ownership interest in, and its principal asset consisted of, approximately 70.54% of the common stock (the “MHC Shares”) of Capitol Federal Financial.  The remaining 29.46% of Capitol Federal Financial’s common stock is owned by public stockholders.
   
   
Washington Headquarters
 
Three Ballston Plaza
Telephone: (703) 528-1700
1100 North Glebe Road, Suite 1100
Fax No.: (703) 528-1788
Arlington, VA 22201
Toll-Free No.: (866) 723-0594
www.rpfinancial.com
E-Mail: mail@rpfinancial.com
 
 
 

 
 
Board of Directors
August 30, 2010
Page 2
 
It is our understanding that Capitol Federal Financial has offered its stock, representing the majority ownership interest held by the MHC, in a subscription offering to Eligible Account Holders, Tax-Qualified Employee Stock Benefit Plans, including the Bank’s employee stock ownership plans (the “ESOP”), Supplemental Eligible Account Holders and Other Members, as such terms are defined for purposes of applicable federal regulatory requirements governing mutual-to-stock conversions.  The stock has also been offered to the public at large in a community offering and a syndicated offering.  Upon completing the mutual-to-stock conversion and stock offering (the “second-step conversion”), the Company will be 100% owned by public shareholders, the publicly-held shares of CFFN will be exchanged for shares in the Company at a ratio that retains their ownership interest at the time the conversion is completed and the MHC assets will be consolidated with the Company.
 
The Appraisal is based on Capitol Federal Financial’s representation that the information contained in the regulatory applications and additional information furnished to us by Capitol Federal Financial and its legal counsel and other authorized agents are truthful, accurate and complete.  We did not independently verify the financial statements and other information provided by Capitol Federal Financial, or its legal counsel and other authorized agents nor did we independently value the assets or liabilities of Capitol Federal Financial.  The valuation considers Capitol Federal Financial only as a going concern and should not be considered as an indication of Capitol Federal Financial’s liquidation value.
 
Our appraised value is predicated on a continuation of the current operating environment for Capitol Federal Financial and for all thrifts and their holding companies.  Changes in the local, state and national economy, the legislative and regulatory environment for financial institutions and mutual holding companies, the stock market, interest rates, and other external forces (such as natural disasters or significant world events) may occur from time to time, often with great unpredictability and may materially impact the value of thrift stocks as a whole or the value of Capitol Federal Financial’s’ stock alone.  It is our understanding that there are no current plans for selling control of Capitol Federal Financial following completion of the second-step conversion.  To the extent that such factors can be foreseen, they have been factored into our analysis.
 
The estimated pro forma market value is defined as the price at which Capitol Federal Financial’s common stock, immediately upon completion of the second-step stock offering, would change hands between a willing buyer and a willing seller, neither being under any compulsion to buy or sell and both having reasonable knowledge of relevant facts.
 
 
 

 
 
Board of Directors
August 30, 2010
Page 3
 
Our valuation is not intended, and must not be construed, as a recommendation of any kind as to the advisability of purchasing shares of the common stock.  Moreover, because such valuation is necessarily based upon estimates and projections of a number of matters, all of which are subject to change from time to time, no assurance can be given that persons who purchase shares of common stock in the conversion will thereafter be able to buy or sell such shares at prices related to the foregoing valuation of the pro forma market value thereof.  RP Financial is not a seller of securities within the meaning of any federal and state securities laws and any report prepared by RP Financial shall not be used as an offer or solicitation with respect to the purchase or sale of any securities.  RP Financial maintains a policy which prohibits the company, its principals or employees from purchasing stock of its client institutions.
 
This updated appraisal reflects the following noteworthy items:  (1) a review of recent developments in Capitol Federal Financial’s financial condition, including financial data through June 30, 2010; (2) an updated comparison of Capitol Federal Financial’s financial condition and operating results versus the Peer Group companies identified in the Original Appraisal; (3) a review of stock market conditions since the date of the First Update; and (4) the results of Capitol Federal Financial’s subscription, community  and syndicated offerings.
 
Discussion of Relevant Considerations
 
1.       Financial Results
 
Table 1 presents summary balance sheet and income statement details for the twelve months ended March 31, 2010 and updated financial information through June 30, 2010.  Capitol Federal Financial’s assets increased by $57.9 million or 0.7% from March 31, 2010 to June 30, 2010.  Cash and investment securities accounted for most of the Company’s asset growth during the quarter, which was partially offset by decreases in mortgage-backed securities and loans receivable.  Overall, Capitol Federal Financial’s cash and investments (inclusive of FHLB stock) increased from $1.166 billion or 13.7% of assets at March 31, 2010 to $1.415 billion or 16.6% of assets at June 30, 2010.  Loans receivable decreased from $5.380 billion or 63.4% of assets at March 31, 2010 to $5.316 billion or 62.2% of assets at June 30, 2010, while over the same time period mortgage-backed securities decreased from $1.757 billion or 20.7% of assets to $1.620 billion or 19.0% of assets.  The balance of bank-owned life insurance (“BOLI”) increased nominally during the quarter and remained at 0.6% of assets.
 
Updated credit quality measures showed little change during the quarter ended June 30, 2010. Non-accruing loans decreased from $34.0 million at March 31, 2010 to $33.3 million at June 30, 2010, while real estate owned increased from $6.9 million at March 31, 2010 to $7.2 million at June 30, 2010.  Overall, non-performing assets decreased from $40.9 million or 0.48% of assets at March 31, 2010 to $40.3 million or 0.47% of assets at June 30, 2010.
 
 
 

 
 
Board of Directors
August 30, 2010
Page 4
 
Table 1
Capitol Federal Financial
Recent Financial Data
 
   
At March 31, 2010
   
At June 30, 2010
 
   
Amount
   
Assets
   
Amount
   
Assets
 
    ($000)    
(%)
    ($000)    
(%)
 
Balance Sheet Data
                           
Total assets
  $ 8,485,465       100.0 %   $ 8,543,357       100.0 %
Cash, cash equivalents
    60,735       0.7       75,886       0.9  
Investment securities
    970,431       11.4       1,203,064       14.1  
Mortgage-backed securities
    1,757,310       20.7       1,620,623       19.0  
Loans receivable, net
    5,380,852       63.4       5,316,172       62.2  
FHLB stock
    135,050       1.6       136,055       1.6  
Bank-owned life insurance
    54,000       0.6       54,350       0.6  
Deposits
    4,319,066       50.9       4,373,844       51.2  
Borrowings
    3,109,451       36.6       3,110,246       36.4  
Total equity
    946,073       11.2       960,000       11.2  
             
   
12 Months Ended
   
12 Months Ended
 
   
March 31, 2010
   
June 30, 2010
 
   
Amount
   
Avg. Assets
   
Amount
   
Avg. Assets
 
    ($000)    
(%)
    ($000)    
(%)
 
Summary Income Statement
                               
Interest income
  $ 395,772       4.73 %   $ 384,179       4.56 %
Interest expense
    (218,673 )     (2.61 )     (212,115 )     (2.52 )
Net interest income
    177,099       2.11       172,064       2.04  
Provisions for loan losses
    (10,050 )     (0.12 )     (8,754 )     (0.10 )
Net interest income after provis.
    167,049       2.00       163,310       1.94  
                                 
Non-interest operating income
    26,435       0.32       26,575       0.31  
Gain on sale of securities/loans
    8,248       0.10       7,591       0.09  
Non-interest operating expense
    (95,288 )     (1.14 )     (89,462 )     (1.06 )
    Income (loss) before income taxes    
106,444
      1.27       108,014       1.28  
Income taxes
    (38,495 )     (0.46 )     (38,783 )     (0.46 )
Net income
  $ 67,949       0.81 %   $ 69,231       0.82 %
 
Sources:
Capitol Federal Financial’s prospectus, audited and unaudited financial statements, and RP Financial calculations.
 
 
 

 
 
Board of Directors
August 30, 2010
Page 5
 
Asset growth was primarily funded by deposit growth during the quarter ended June 30, 2010.  Total deposits increased from $4.319 billion or 50.9% of assets at March 31, 2010 to $4.374 billion or 51.2% of assets at June 30, 2010, while borrowings increased nominally from $3.109 billion or 36.6% of assets at March 31, 2010 to $3.110 billion or 36.4% of assets at June 30, 2010.  The composition of borrowings at June 30, 2010 consisted of $2.4 billion of FHLB advances, $660,000 million of repurchase agreements and $53.6 million of trust preferred debt, which was substantially unchanged from the Company’s composition of borrowings at March 31, 2010.  Capitol Federal Financial’s equity increased by $13.9 million during the quarter, which was mostly attributable to retention of earnings and, to a lesser extent, an increase in the net unrealized gain maintained on available for sale investment securities.  Equity growth kept pace with asset growth, as the Company’s equity-to-assets ratio equaled 11.2% at March 31, 2010 and at June 30, 2010.
 
Capitol Federal Financial’s operating results for the twelve months ended March 31, 2010 and June 30, 2010 are also set forth in Table 1.  The Company’s reported earnings increased from $67.9 million or 0.81% of average assets for the twelve months ended March 31, 2010 to $69.2 million or 0.82% of average assets for the twelve months ended June 30, 2010.  The increase in earnings was largely due to a decrease in operating expenses.
 
Capitol Federal Financial’s net interest income decreased from $177.1 million during the twelve months ended March 31, 2010 to $172.1 million during the most recent twelve month period, which served to decrease the net interest income to average assets ratio from 2.11% during the twelve months ended March 31, 2010 to 2.04% during the twelve months ended June 30, 2010.  The decrease in the net interest income ratio was reflective of a narrower yield-cost spread for the quarter ended June  30, 2010 compared to the year ago quarter, which was due to a larger reduction in the weighted average yield on interest-earning assets relative to the weighted average rate paid on interest-bearing liabilities.  The more significant reduction in interest-earning asset yields was in part related to a shift in the Company’s interest-earning asset composition towards a higher concentration of lower yielding cash and investments.  Overall, the Company’s interest rate spread decreased from 1.93% during the quarter ended June 30, 2009 to 1.70% during the quarter ended June 30, 2010.
 
Operating expenses were $5.8 million lower during the most recent twelve month period, decreasing as a percent of average assets from 1.14% during the twelve months ended March 31, 2010 to 1.06% during the twelve months ended June 30, 2010.  The decrease in operating expenses was mostly related to a decrease in FDIC insurance premiums, which was mostly related to the FDIC’s industry-wide special five basis assessment recorded in the quarter ended June 30, 2009.  Overall, Capitol Federal Financial’s updated ratios for net interest income and operating expenses provided for a slightly more favorable expense coverage ratio, (net interest income divided by operating expenses), as the expense coverage ratio increased from 1.85x for the twelve months ended March 31, 2010 to 1.92x  for the twelve month ended June 30, 2010.
 
 
 

 
 
Board of Directors
August 30, 2010
Page 6
 
Non-interest operating income was substantially unchanged in the Company’s updated earnings, equaling 0.32% and 0.31% of average assets for the twelve month ended March 31, 2010 and June 30, 2010, respectively.  Overall, when factoring non-interest operating income into core earnings, the Company’s updated efficiency ratio of 45.1% (operating expenses, net of goodwill amortization, as a percent of net interest income and non-interest operating income) was slightly more favorable compared to its 46.9% efficiency ratio recorded for the twelve months ended March 31, 2010.
 
Non-operating income remained a minor factor in the Company’s updated earnings, with gains and losses on the sale of securities and loans remaining the only non-operating items recorded in the Company’s updated earnings.  Overall, net non-operating income equaled 0.10% and 0.09 of average assets for the twelve months ended March 31, 2010 and June 30, 2010, respectively.
 
Loan loss provisions were down slightly during the most recent twelve month period, decreasing from 0.12% of average assets for the twelve months ended March 31, 2010 to 0.10% of average assets for the twelve months ended June 30, 2010.  As of June 30, 2010, the Company maintained valuation allowances of $15.7 million, equal to 0.29% of net loans receivable and 47.25% of non-performing loans.
 
Income taxes remained constant as a percent of average assets, equaling 0.46% of average assets for both periods shown in Table 1.  The Company’s effective tax rate equaled 36.16% during the twelve months ended March 31, 2010 compared to 35.91% during the twelve months ended June 30, 2010.  As set forth in the Original Appraisal and First Update, the Company’s marginal effective statutory tax rate approximates 38.32%.
 
2.       Peer Group Financial Comparisons
 
Tables 2 and 3 present the financial characteristics and operating results for Capitol Federal Financial, the Peer Group and all publicly-traded thrifts.  The Company’s and the Peer Group’s ratios are based on financial results through June 30, 2010.  NewAlliance Bancshares of Connecticut, which was one of the Peer Group companies identified in the Original Appraisal, is the subject of an announced acquisition by First Niagara Financial Group of New York and, therefore, has been eliminated from the Peer Group.
 
In general, the comparative balance sheet ratios for the Company and the Peer Group did not vary significantly from the ratios exhibited in the Original Appraisal. Consistent with the Original Appraisal, the Company’s updated interest-earning asset compositions continued to reflect a higher concentration of cash and investments and a lower concentration of loans relative to the updated ratios for the Peer Group.  Overall, the Company’s updated interest-earning assets amounted to 97.7% of assets, which remained above the comparable Peer Group ratio of 94.0%.  The Company’s non-interest earning assets included BOLI equal to 0.6% of assets, while the Peer Group’s non-interest earning assets included goodwill and intangibles equal to 1.7% of assets and BOLI equal to 0.8% of assets.
 
 
 

 
 
Board of Directors
August 30, 2010
Page 7
 
Table 2
Balance Sheet Composition and Growth Rates
Comparable Institution Analysis
As of June 30, 2010
                                                                                                                           
     
Balance Sheet as a Percent of Assets
   
Balance Sheet Annual Growth Rates
   
Regulatory Capital
 
      Cash &
Equivalents
    MBS &
Invest
   
BOLI
   
Loans
   
Deposits
   
Borrowed
Funds
   
Subd.
Debt
   
Net
Worth
   
Goodwill
& Intang
   
Tng Net
Worth
   
Assets
   
MBS, Cash &
Investments
   
Loans
   
Deposits
   
Borrows.
&Subdebt
   
Net
Worth
   
Tng Net
Worth
   
Tangible
   
Core
   
Reg.Cap.
 
                                                                                                                           
Capitol Federal Financial
                                                                                                                       
  June 30, 2010
    0.9 %     34.6 %     0.6 %     62.2 %     51.2 %     36.4 %     0.0 %     11.2 %     0.0 %     11.2 %     2.69 %     15.45 %     -4.07 %     4.76 %     -0.46 %     4.05 %     4.05 %     9.70 %     9.70 %     23.54 %
                                                                                                                                                                   
All Public Companies
                                                                                                                                                               
  Averages
    5.9 %     20.5 %     1.4 %     67.2 %     72.3 %     14.2 %     0.5 %     11.7 %     0.9 %     10.9 %     4.44 %     14.82 %     1.12 %     8.49 %     -14.36 %     2.36 %     2.14 %     10.94 %     10.88 %     18.23 %
  Medians
    4.6 %     18.4 %     1.4 %     68.6 %     73.4 %     12.6 %     0.0 %     10.3 %     0.0 %     9.4 %     2.32 %     7.69 %     -0.76 %     5.64 %     -12.33 %     1.97 %     1.49 %     9.54 %     9.54 %     15.71 %
                                                                                                                                                                   
Comparable Group
                                                                                                                                                               
  Averages
    4.6 %     22.1 %     0.8 %     67.3 %     69.2 %     17.7 %     0.6 %     11.4 %     1.7 %     9.7 %     7.46 %     9.42 %     4.23 %     12.51 %     -4.30 %     10.78 %     9.84 %     11.63 %     11.63 %     17.49 %
  Medians
    3.9 %     18.6 %     1.2 %     67.5 %     66.2 %     17.8 %     0.1 %     11.5 %     1.3 %     8.9 %     4.64 %     6.44 %     1.18 %     6.40 %     -0.11 %     10.50 %     11.00 %     9.85 %     9.85 %     16.70 %
                                                                                                                                                                   
Comparable Group
                                                                                                                                                               
BKMU  
Bank Mutual Corp. of WI
    4.6 %     47.1 %     1.6 %     41.2 %     60.4 %     26.0 %     0.0 %     11.5 %     1.5 %     9.9 %     1.02 %     15.43 %     -13.34 %     1.59 %     -0.11 %     -0.69 %     -0.68 %     9.85 %     9.85 %     21.84 %
BRKL
Brookline Bancorp, Inc. of MA
    3.3 %     12.9 %     0.0 %     80.5 %     64.0 %     16.5 %     0.0 %     18.6 %     1.7 %     16.9 %     0.69 %     -2.00 %     1.18 %     13.44 %     -30.14 %     1.46 %     1.92 %     15.60 %     15.60 %  
NA
 
DNBK
Danvers Bancorp, Inc. of MA
    3.9 %     25.3 %     1.3 %     64.7 %     76.4 %     9.8 %     1.2 %     11.6 %     1.3 %     10.3 %     39.94 %     33.50 %     38.96 %     48.67 %     3.92 %     30.54 %     15.60 %  
NA
   
NA
      16.70 %
DCOM
Dime Community Bancshares of NY
    5.1 %     6.9 %     1.2 %     83.0 %     58.8 %     29.3 %     1.7 %     7.6 %     1.3 %     6.2 %     4.38 %     -11.22 %     6.71 %     6.40 %     -0.05 %     11.02 %     13.71 %  
NA
   
NA
   
NA
 
FFCH
First Financial Holdings Inc. of SC
    1.9 %     14.5 %     0.0 %     75.8 %     73.6 %     14.4 %     1.4 %     9.7 %     1.2 %     8.6 %     -7.84 %     -22.19 %     -5.76 %     4.56 %     -42.44 %     10.50 %     11.00 %  
NA
   
NA
   
NA
 
FFIC
Flushing Financial Corp. of NY
    0.7 %     18.6 %     1.7 %     76.7 %     68.3 %     21.4 %     0.8 %     8.9 %     0.4 %     8.5 %     4.64 %     0.30 %     5.77 %     8.38 %     -9.45 %     21.65 %     23.16 %  
NA
   
NA
   
NA
 
PBNY
Provident NY Bancorp, Inc. of NY
    1.4 %     31.8 %     1.7 %     56.6 %     66.2 %     17.8 %     0.0 %     14.5 %     5.6 %     8.9 %     4.93 %     15.69 %     -0.62 %     4.70 %     7.92 %     1.98 %     4.04 %   9.44 %     9.44 %  
NA
 
TRST
TrustCo Bank Corp. NY of NY
    14.2 %     23.3 %     0.0 %     59.8 %     89.8 %     3.0 %     0.0 %     6.7 %     0.0 %     6.7 %     6.81 %     6.44 %     6.50 %     6.26 %     36.33 %     7.16 %     7.18 %  
NA
   
NA
      13.94 %
WFSL
Washington Federal, Inc. of WA (1)
    6.7 %     18.3 %     0.0 %     67.5 %     65.0 %     20.8 %     0.1 %     13.2 %     1.9 %     11.3 %     12.56 %     48.78 %     -1.29 %     18.62 %     -4.70 %     13.41 %     12.60 %  
NA
   
NA
   
NA
 
 
(1)  Financial information is for the quarter ending March 31, 2010.
 
Source:  SNL Financial, LC. and RP® Financial, LC. calculations.  The information provided in this table has been obtained from sources we believe are reliable, but we cannot guarantee the accuracy or completeness of such information.
 
Copyright (c) 2010 by RP® Financial, LC.
 
 
 

 
 
Board of Directors
August 30, 2010
Page 8
 
Table 3
Income as Percent of Average Assets and Yields, Costs, Spreads
Comparable Institution Analysis
For the 12 Months Ended June 30, 2010
                                                                                                                     
           
Net Interest Income
         
Other Income
         
G&A/Other Exp.
   
Non-Op. Items
   
Yields, Costs, and Spreads
             
                             
Loss
   
NII
                     
Total
                                             
MEMO:
   
MEMO:
 
     
Net
                     
Provis.
   
After
   
Loan
   
R.E.
   
Other
   
Other
   
G&A
   
Goodwill
   
Net
   
Extrao.
   
Yield
   
Cost
   
Yld-Cost
   
Assets/
   
Effective
 
     
Income
   
Income
   
Expense
   
NII
   
on IEA
   
Provis.
   
Fees
   
Oper.
   
Income
   
Income
   
Expense
   
Amort.
   
Gains
   
Items
   
On Assets
   
Of Funds
   
Spread
   
FTE Emp.
   
Tax Rate
 
                                                                                                                     
Capitol Federal Financial
                                                                                                                 
  June 30, 2010
    0.82 %     4.56 %     2.52 %     2.04 %     0.10 %     1.94 %     0.00 %     0.00 %     0.31 %     0.31 %     1.06 %     0.00 %     0.09 %     0.00 %     4.68 %     2.88 %     1.80 %   $ 12,346       35.91 %
                                                                                                                                                           
All Public Companies
                                                                                                                                                       
  Averages
    -0.07 %     4.74 %     1.74 %     2.99 %     0.95 %     2.04 %     0.03 %     -0.07 %     0.77 %     0.73 %     2.77 %     0.05 %     0.03 %     0.01 %     5.07 %     2.00 %     3.06 %   $ 5,919       32.57 %
  Medians
    0.27 %     4.79 %     1.74 %     3.04 %     0.53 %     2.37 %     0.00 %     -0.01 %     0.56 %     0.51 %     2.64 %     0.00 %     0.04 %     0.00 %     5.06 %     2.00 %     3.13 %   $ 4,868       32.49 %
                                                                                                                                                           
Comparable Group
                                                                                                                                                       
  Averages
    0.51 %     4.87 %     1.76 %     3.11 %     0.94 %     2.17 %     0.03 %     -0.07 %     0.70 %     0.66 %     2.19 %     0.03 %     0.03 %     0.00 %     5.16 %     2.02 %     3.14 %   $ 8,045       29.29 %
  Medians
    0.71 %     5.06 %     1.68 %     3.16 %     0.48 %     2.74 %     0.01 %     -0.01 %     0.66 %     0.56 %     2.02 %     0.02 %     0.07 %     0.00 %     5.23 %     1.99 %     3.24 %   $ 6,799       36.49 %
                                                                                                                                                           
Comparable Group
                                                                                                                                                       
BKMU  
Bank Mutual Corp. of WI
    0.16 %     3.79 %     2.14 %     1.65 %     0.52 %     1.12 %     0.02 %     -0.10 %     0.66 %     0.58 %     2.02 %     0.01 %     0.55 %     0.00 %     4.09 %     2.49 %     1.61 %   $ 4,546       30.24 %
BRKL
Brookline Bancorp, Inc. of MA
    0.96 %     5.06 %     1.60 %     3.46 %     0.27 %     3.19 %     0.00 %     0.00 %     0.05 %     0.05 %     1.68 %     0.05 %     0.09 %     0.00 %     5.23 %     1.99 %     3.24 %   $ 11,317       40.40 %
DNBK
Danvers Bancorp, Inc. of MA
    0.58 %     4.89 %     1.52 %     3.37 %     0.25 %     3.11 %     0.01 %     -0.04 %     0.48 %     0.45 %     2.89 %     0.07 %     0.07 %     0.00 %     5.18 %     1.75 %     3.43 %   $ 6,799       14.29 %
DCOM
Dime Community Bancshares of NY
    0.89 %     5.29 %     2.13 %     3.16 %     0.39 %     2.77 %     0.00 %     -0.01 %     0.23 %     0.22 %     1.51 %     0.00 %     -0.04 %     0.00 %     5.57 %     2.38 %     3.19 %   $ 10,475       38.14 %
FFCH
First Financial Holdings Inc. of SC
    -1.07 %     5.42 %     1.67 %     3.75 %     3.73 %     0.02 %     0.10 %     -0.01 %     1.82 %     1.91 %     3.53 %     0.02 %     -0.12 %     0.00 %     5.86 %     1.88 %     3.98 %   $ 3,250       40.58 %
FFIC
Flushing Financial Corp. of NY
    0.71 %     5.51 %     2.47 %     3.04 %     0.48 %     2.56 %     0.08 %     0.00 %     0.21 %     0.30 %     1.59 %     0.01 %     -0.10 %     0.00 %     5.75 %     2.73 %     3.02 %   $ 12,769       38.31 %
PBNY
Provident NY Bancorp, Inc. of NY
    0.69 %     4.12 %     0.97 %     3.15 %     0.42 %     2.74 %     0.00 %     0.00 %     0.68 %     0.68 %     2.70 %     0.07 %     0.23 %     0.00 %     4.59 %     1.15 %     3.43 %   $ 5,529       24.11 %
TRST
TrustCo Bank Corp. NY of NY
    0.82 %     4.47 %     1.11 %     3.35 %     0.50 %     2.86 %     0.00 %     -0.12 %     0.68 %     0.56 %     2.21 %     0.00 %     0.09 %     0.00 %     4.59 %     1.20 %     3.39 %   $ 5,231       36.49 %
WFSL
Washington Federal, Inc. of WA (1)
    0.83 %     5.27 %     2.24 %     3.03 %     1.87 %     1.16 %     0.07 %     -0.34 %     1.47 %     1.20 %     1.60 %     0.01 %     -0.55 %     0.00 %     5.58 %     2.59 %     2.99 %   $ 12,491       1.01 %
 
(1)  Financial information is for the quarter ending March 31, 2010.
 
Source:  SNL Financial, LC. and RP® Financial, LC. calculations.  The information provided in this table has been obtained from sources we believe are reliable, but we cannot guarantee the accuracy or completeness of such information.
 
Copyright (c) 2010 by RP® Financial, LC.
 
 
 

 

Board of Directors
August 30, 2010
Page 9
 
The updated mix of deposits and borrowings maintained by Capitol Federal Financial and the Peer Group also did not change significantly from the Original Appraisal.  Capitol Federal Financial’s funding composition continued to reflect a lower concentration of deposits and a higher concentration of borrowings relative to the comparable ratios for the Peer Group.  Updated interest-bearing liabilities-to-assets ratios equaled 87.6% and 87.5% for the Company and the Peer Group, respectively.  Capitol Federal Financial posted an updated tangible equity-to-assets ratio of 11.2%, versus the Peer Group’s ratio of 9.7%.
 
Overall, Capitol Federal Financial’s updated interest-earning assets-to-interest-bearing liabilities (“IEA/IBL”) ratio equaled 111.5%, which remained  above the comparable Peer Group ratio of 107.4%.  As discussed in the Original Appraisal, the additional capital realized from stock proceeds should serve to increase Capitol Federal Financial’s IEA/IBL ratio, as the level of interest-bearing liabilities funding assets will be lower due to the increase in capital realized from the offering and the net proceeds realized from the offering will be primarily deployed into interest-earning assets.
 
Updated growth rates for Capitol Federal Financial and the Peer Group are based on growth for the twelve months ended June 30, 2010.  Capitol Federal Financial recorded an increase in assets of 2.7%, versus asset growth of 7.5% recorded by the Peer Group.  The Company’s asset growth was sustained by an increase in cash and investments, which was partially offset by a slight decrease in loans.  Comparatively, the Peer Group’s asset growth was sustained by increases in both loans and cash and investments.
 
Asset growth for the Company was funded by a 4.8% increase in deposits, which funded a 0.5% reduction in borrowings as well.  Similarly, asset growth for the Peer Group was funded by deposit growth of 12.5%, which also funded a 4.3% reduction in the Peer Group’s borrowings.  Capitol Federal Financial’s updated tangible net worth growth rate of 4.1% remained below the comparable Peer Group growth rate of 9.8%.
 
Table 3 displays comparative operating results for Capitol Federal Financial and the Peer Group, based on their earnings for the twelve months ended June 30, 2010.  The Company’s updated earnings showed net income equal to 0.82% of average assets, versus net income equal to 0.51% of average assets for the Peer Group.  Lower operating expenses and loan loss provisions continued to support the Company’s higher return, while the Peer Group continued to maintain earnings advantages with respect to net interest income and non-interest operating income.
 
 
 

 
 
Board of Directors
August 30, 2010
Page 10
 
In terms of core earnings strength, updated expense coverage ratios posted by Capitol Federal Financial and the Peer Group equaled 1.92x and 1.40x respectively.  The Company’s stronger expense coverage ratio continued to be realized through maintenance of a lower operating expense ratio (1.06% of average assets versus 2.22% of average assets for the Company), which was partially offset by the Peer Group’s higher net interest income ratio (3.11% of average assets versus 2.04% of average assets for the Company).  A higher interest income ratio and a lower interest expense ratio both contributed to the Peer Group’s higher net interest income ratio.
 
Non-interest operating income remained a less significant contributor to the Company’s earnings, as such income amounted to 0.31% and 0.66% of the Company’s and the Peer Group’s average assets, respectively.  Accordingly, taking non-interest operating income into account in assessing Capitol Federal Financial’s core earnings strength relative to the Peer Group’s, the Company’s updated efficiency ratio of 45.2% remained more favorable than the Peer Group’s efficiency ratio of 58.1%.
 
Loan loss provisions remained a less significant factor in the Company’s earnings, as updated loan loss provisions established by the Company and the Peer Group equaled 0.10% and 0.94% of average assets, respectively.
 
Updated non-operating gains equaled 0.09% of average assets for the Company, versus non-operating gains equal to 0.03% of average assets for the Peer Group.  As set forth in the Original Appraisal, typically, such gains and losses are discounted in the valuation analyses as they tend to have a relatively high degree of volatility, and thus are not considered part of core operations.  If gains are attributable to secondary market loan sales on a regular basis, then such gains may warrant some consideration as a core profitability component, depending on the prevailing market environment.  However, loan sale gains are typically viewed as a more volatile source of income than income generated through the net interest margin and non-interest operating income, and are given less consideration in developing core earnings for valuation purposes.  Extraordinary items remained a non-factor in the Company’s and the Peer Group’s updated earnings.
 
Taxes remained a slightly larger factor in the Company’s earnings, with the Company and the Peer Group showing updated effective tax rates of 35.91% and 29.29%, respectively.  As indicated in the prospectus, the Company’s effective marginal tax rate is equal to 38.32%.
 
 
 

 
 
Board of Directors
August 30, 2010
Page 11
 
In general, the Company’s updated credit quality measures remained more favorable than the comparable measures for the Peer Group.  As shown in Table 4, the Company’s non-performing assets/assets and non-performing loans/loans equaled 0.47% and 0.62%, respectively, versus comparable ratios of 2.33% and 3.25% for the Peer Group.  The Company’s loan loss reserves as a percent of non-performing loans and loans equaled 47.25% and 0.29%, respectively, versus comparable ratios of 86.68% and 1.56% for the Peer Group.  Net loan charge-offs were a more significant factor for the Peer Group, as net loan charge-offs for the Company equaled 0.06% of loans versus 0.53% of loans for the Peer Group.
 
3.       Stock Market Conditions
 
Since the date of the First Update, the performance of the broader stock was mixed.  The downturn in the broader stock market accelerated in the second half of August 2010, as a number of economic reports for July showed the economy was losing momentum which more than overshadowed a pick-up in merger activity.  The Dow Jones Industrial Average (“DJIA”) had its worst August in nearly a decade, with the DJIA showing a loss of over 4% for the month.  On August 30, 2010, the DJIA closed at 10009.73, or 2.8% lower since the First Update and the NASDAQ closed at 2119.97 or 2.5% lower since the date of the First Update.
 
After trending lower into mid-August, the sell-off in thrift stocks became more pronounced in the second half of August as signs of slower growth impacted most sectors of the stock market.  Thrift stocks were particularly hard hit by the dismal housing data for July, which showed sharp declines in both existing and new home sales.  On August 30, 2010, the SNL Index for all publicly-traded thrifts closed at 518.3 a decrease of 3.2% since August 13, 2010 and a decrease of 12.8% since the Original Appraisal date of May 28, 2010.
 
Consistent with the SNL Index for all publicly-traded thrifts, the updated pricing measures for the Peer Group and all publicly-traded were generally slightly lower since the First Update and reflected fairly significant declines since the Original Appraisal.  The increase reflected in the core P/E multiple average for all publicly-traded thrifts was believed to be largely related to some core P/E ratios going from not meaningful (“NM”) to relatively high P/E ratios.  In general, the Peer Group’s updated pricing measures reflected more significant declines relative to the comparable averages for all publicly-traded thrifts.  From May 28, 2010 through August 30, 2010, the closing stock prices of all nine of the remaining Peer Group companies declined.  A comparative pricing analysis of the Peer Group and all publicly-traded thrifts is shown in the following table, based on market prices as of May, 28, 2010, August 13, 2010 and August 30, 2010.
 
 
 

 
 
Board of Directors
August 30, 2010
Page 12
 
Table 4
Credit Risk Measures and Related Information
Comparable Institution Analysis
As of June 30, 2010 or Most Recent Date Available
                                                   
           
NPAs &
                     
Rsrves/
             
     
REO/
   
90+Del/
   
NPLs/
   
Rsrves/
   
Rsrves/
   
NPAs &
   
Net Loan
   
NLCs/
 
Institution
 
Assets
   
Assets
   
Loans
   
Loans
   
NPLs
   
90+Del
   
Chargoffs
   
Loans
 
     
(%)
   
(%)
   
(%)
   
(%)
   
(%)
   
(%)
    ($000)    
(%)
 
                                                     
Capitol Federal Financial
    0.08 %     0.47 %     0.62 %     0.29 %     47.25 %     38.87 %   $ 3,184       0.06 %
                                                                   
All Public Companies
                                                               
  Averages
    0.51 %     4.25 %     4.92 %     1.69 %     65.87 %     52.38 %   $ 1,552       0.72 %
  Medians
    0.20 %     2.56 %     3.33 %     1.39 %     45.65 %     40.24 %   $ 642       0.32 %
                                                                   
Comparable Group
                                                               
  Averages
    3.05 %     2.33 %     3.25 %     1.56 %     86.68 %     70.72 %   $ 2,990       0.53 %
  Medians
    0.13 %     1.44 %     2.14 %     1.52 %     78.67 %     70.98 %   $ 2,173       0.50 %
                                                                   
Comparable Group
                                                               
BKMU
Bank Mutual Corp. of WI
    0.59 %     2.25 %     8.20 %     1.52 %     7.94 %     12.03 %   $ 2,811       0.76 %
BRKL
Brookline Bancorp, Inc. of MA
    0.03 %     0.61 %     0.56 %     1.41 %     253.47 %     187.53 %   $ 874       0.16 %
DNBK
Danvers Bancorp, Inc. of MA
    0.04 %     0.81 %     1.17 %     0.98 %     83.76 %     79.58 %   $ 565       0.14 %
DCOM
Dime Community Bancshares of NY
    0.02 %     0.50 %     0.57 %     0.67 %     120.09 %     112.94 %   $ 5,024       0.58 %
FFCH
First Financial Holdings Inc. of SC
    25.00 %     6.40 %     6.40 %     3.34 %     40.86 %     38.15 %  
NM
   
NM
 
FFIC
Flushing Financial Corp. of NY
    0.18 %     2.80 %     3.38 %     0.79 %     23.33 %     21.76 %   $ 2,122       0.26 %
PBNY
Provident NY Bancorp, Inc. of NY
    0.11 %     1.11 %     1.31 %     1.82 %     138.49 %     94.66 %   $ 2,173       0.52 %
TRST
TrustCo Bank Corp. NY of NY
    0.14 %     1.44 %     2.14 %     1.68 %     78.67 %     70.98 %   $ 7,359       1.28 %
WFSL
Washington Federal, Inc. of WA
    1.32 %     5.09 %     5.56 %     1.86 %     33.53 %     18.89 %  
NM
   
NM
 
 
Source:
Audited and unaudited financial statements, corporate reports and offering circulars, and RP® Financial, LC. calculations.  The  information provided in this table has been obtained from sources we believe are reliable, but we cannot guarantee the accuracy or completeness of such information.
   
Copyright (c) 2010 by RP® Financial, LC.
 
 
 

 

Board of Directors
August 30, 2010
Page 13
 
   
Average Pricing Characteristics
       
                         
         
Interim
             
   
At May 28,
   
At Aug.13,
   
At Aug. 30,
   
% Change
 
   
2010(2)
   
2010
   
2010(2)
   
5/28/10-8/30/10
 
Peer Group(1)
                       
Price/Earnings (x)
    20.12 x     16.58 x     16.23 x     (19.3 )%
Price/Core Earnings (x)
    18.04       17.00       16.68       (7.5 )
Price/Book (%)
    115.05 %     100.24 %     97.65 %     (15.1 )
Price/Tangible Book(%)
    133.10       115.99       112.92       (15.2 )
Price/Assets (%)
    12.36       10.85       10.54       (12.2 )
Avg. Mkt. Capitalization ($Mil)
  $ 565.48     $ 499.76     $ 478.21       (15.4 )
                                 
All Publicly-Traded Thrifts
                               
Price/Earnings (x)
    18.56 x     18.35 x     18.42 x     (0.8 )%
Price/Core Earnings (x)
    16.60       17.73       17.62       6.1  
Price/Book (%)
    76.73 %     70.52 %     69.54 %     (9.4 )
Price/Tangible Book(%)
    85.20       78.48       77.31       (9.3 )
Price/Assets (%)
    8.54       8.15       8.07       (5.5 )
Avg. Mkt. Capitalization ($Mil)
  $ 346.94     $ 315.95     $ 308.55       (11.1 )

(1)
NewAlliance Bancshares of Connecticut has been excluded from the Peer Group averages for all dates shown.
(2)
Pricing dates for establishing valuation range.
 
As set forth in the Original Appraisal and previous updates, the “new issue” market is separate and distinct from the market for seasoned issues like the Peer Group companies in that the pricing ratios for converting issues are computed on a pro forma basis, specifically:  (1) the numerator and denominator are both impacted by the conversion offering amount, unlike existing stock issues in which price change affects only the numerator; and (2) the pro forma pricing ratio incorporates assumptions regarding source and use of proceeds, effective tax rates, stock plan purchases, etc. which impact pro forma financials, whereas pricing for existing issues are based on reported financials.  The distinction between the pricing of converting and existing issues is perhaps most evident in the case of the price/book (“P/B”) ratio in that the P/B ratio of a converting thrift will typically result in a discount to book value, whereas in the current market for existing thrifts the P/B ratio may reflect a premium to book value.  Therefore, it is appropriate to also consider the market for new issues, both at the time of the conversion and in the aftermarket.
 
 
 

 
 
Board of Directors
August 30, 2010
Page 14
 
Two standard conversions and six second-step conversions have been completed during the past three months.  The recently completed second-step conversion offerings are considered to be more relevant for our analysis, which were completed in late-June and the first half of July.  In general, second-step conversions tend to be priced (and trade in the aftermarket) at higher P/B ratios than standard conversions.  We believe investors take into consideration the generally more leveraged pro forma balance sheets of second-step companies, their track records as public companies prior to conversion, and their generally higher pro forma ROE measures relative to standard conversions in pricing their common stocks.  As shown in Table 5, with the exception of Oritani Financial Corp., all of the second-step conversion offerings were completed between the minimum and midpoint of their offering ranges.  Oritani Financial Corp.’s offering was completed at slightly above the midpoint of its offering range.  The average closing pro forma price/tangible book ratio of the recent second-step conversion offerings equaled 79.1%.  On average, the second-step conversion offerings reflected a 2.3% decrease in price from their IPO prices after the first week of trading.  As of August 30, 2010, the recent second-step conversion offerings reflected an average decrease of 4.5% in price from their IPO prices.
 
Shown in Table 6 are the current pricing ratios for the fully-converted offerings completed during the past three months that trade on NASDAQ or an Exchange.  The current average P/TB ratio for the recent fully-converted offerings equaled 73.91%, based on closing stock prices as of August 30, 2010.
 
As set forth in the Original Appraisal and First Update, RP Financial’s analysis of stock market conditions also considered recent trading activity in Capitol Federal Financial’s stock.  From August 13, 2010 through August 30, 2010, the trading price of the Company’s stock ranged from a low closing price of $25.56 on August 30, 2010 to a high closing price of $29.69 on August 17, 2010.  The Company’s closing stock price of $25.56 on August 30, 2010 was down 13.6% from the August 13, 2010 closing price of $29.60 and down 20.1% from its closing price of $32.00 as of the Original Appraisal date of May 28, 2010.  The Company’s closing stock price of $25.56 indicates an implied market valuation of $1.9 billion.
 
4.   Results of the Offering
 
As set forth in the First Update, Capitol Federal Financial’s subscription and community stock offerings commenced on July 9, 2010 and terminated on August 12, 2010.  On August 18, 2010, the Company issued a press release that set forth the preliminary results of the subscription and community phase of its stock offering.  The total takedown in the subscription and community offerings amounted to $143.1 million, which included an assumed purchase by the ESOP of $68.0 million based on a purchase equal to 4.0% of the shares sold at the midpoint of the offering range.  The press release also stated the remaining shares were being offered in a syndicated offering, which was expected to be completed during the week of August 23, 2010.
 
 
 

 
 
Board of Directors
August 30, 2010
Page 15
 
Table 5
Pricing Characteristics and After-Market Trends
Recent Conversions Completed (Last Three Months)
 
Institutional Information
 
Pre-Conversion Data
   
Offering Information
 
Contribution to
Insider Purchases
   
       
Financial Info.
   
Asset Quality
                         
Charitable Found.
% Off Incl. Fdn.
         
                                                               
Benefit Plans
     
Initial
 
 
Conver.
         
Equity/
   
NPAs/
   
Res.
   
Gross
   
%
   
% of
   
Exp./
     
% of
         
Recog.
   
Stk
   
Mgmt.&
Dividend
 
 Institution
Date
Ticker
 
Assets
   
Assets
   
Assets
   
Cov.
   
Proc.
   
Offered
   
Mid.
   
Proc.
 
Form
 
Offering
   
ESOP
   
Plans
   
Option
   
Dirs.
Yield
 
       
($Mil)
   
(%)
   
(%)
   
(%)
   
($Mil.)
   
(%)
   
(%)
   
(%)
     
(%)
   
(%)
   
(%)
   
(%)
   
(%)(2)
(%)
 
                                                                                           
 Standard Conversions
                                                                                         
                                                                                           
 Peoples Federal Bancshares, Inc. - MA
7/7/10  
PEOP-NASDAQ
  $ 488       10.77 %     0.32 %     199 %      $ 66.1       100 %     132 %     2.8 %
 Stock
    8.0 %     8.0 %     4.0 %     10.0 %     3.3 %     0.00 %
 Fairmount Bancorp, Inc. - MD
6/3/10  
FMTB-OTCBB
  $ 67       10.57 %     0.40 %     152 %   $ 4.4       100 %     89 %     15.8 %
 N.A.
 
N.A.
      8.0 %     4.0 %     10.0 %     14.6 %     0.00 %
                                                                                                                       
  Averages - Standard Conversions:    $ 278       10.67 %     0.36 %     176 %   $ 35.3       100 %     111 %     9.3 %
 N.A.
    8.0 %     8.0 %     4.0 %     10.0 %     9.0 %     0.00 %
  Medians - Standard Conversions:    $ 278       10.67 %     0.36 %     176 %   $ 35.3       100 %     111 %     9.3 %
 N.A.
    8.0 %     8.0 %     4.0 %     10.0 %     9.0 %     0.00 %
                                                                                                                       
 Second Step Conversions
                                                                                                                     
                                                                                                                       
 Jacsonville Bancorp, Inc. - IL
7/15/10  
JXSB-NASDAQ
  $ 290       9.12 %     1.02 %     111 %   $ 10.4       54 %     89 %     12.0 %
 N.A.
 
N.A.
      4.0 %     0.0 %     10.0 %     9.6 %     3.00 %
 Colonial Financial Services - NJ
7/13/10  
COBK-NASDAQ
  $ 568       8.20 %     0.43 %     124 %   $ 23.0       55 %     85 %     8.0 %
 N.A.
 
N.A.
      4.0 %     4.0 %     10.0 %     1.6 %     0.00 %
 Oneida Financial Corp.- NY
7/7/10  
ONFC-NASDAQ
  $ 596       9.61 %     0.90 %     1041 %   $ 31.5       55 %     100 %     8.0 %
 N.A.
 
N.A.
      4.0 %     4.0 %     10.0 %     4.2 %     6.00 %
 ViewPoint Financial Group - TX
7/7/10  
VPFG-NASDAQ
  $ 2,477       8.42 %     0.61 %     108 %   $ 198.6       57 %     99 %     4.0 %
 N.A.
 
N.A.
      4.0 %     4.0 %     10.0 %     0.2 %     0.00 %
 Fox Chase Bancorp, Inc. - PA
6/29/10  
FXCB-NASDAQ
  $ 1,156       10.83 %     2.91 %     38 %   $ 87.1       60 %     85 %     5.0 %
 N.A.
 
N.A.
      4.0 %     3.1 %     7.9 %     0.7 %     0.00 %
 Oritani Financial Corp. - NJ
6/24/10  
ORIT-NASDAQ
  $ 2,054       12.38 %     2.03 %     60 %   $ 413.6       74 %     106 %     2.8 %
 N.A.
 
N.A.
      4.0 %     4.0 %     10.0 %     0.5 %     3.00 %
                                                                                                                       
  Averages - Second Step Conversions:    $ 1,190       9.76 %     1.32 %     247 %   $ 127.4       59 %     94 %     6.6 %
 N.A.
 
N.A.
      4.0 %     3.2 %     9.7 %     2.8 %     2.00 %
  Medians - Second Step Conversions:    $ 876       9.37 %     0.96 %     110 %   $ 59.3       56 %     94 %     6.5 %
 N.A.
 
N.A.
      4.0 %     4.0 %     10.0 %     1.2 %     1.50 %
                                                                                                                       
                                                                                                                       
 Mutual Holding Company Conversions
                                                                                                                 
                                                                                                                       
  Averages - Mutual Holding Company Conversions:                                                                                                                    
  Medians - Mutual Holding Company Conversions:                                                                                                                   
                                                                                                                       
  Averages - All Conversions:    $ 962       9.99 %     1.08 %     229 %   $ 104.3       69 %     98 %     7.3 %
  NA
    8.0 %     5.0 %     3.4 %     9.7 %     4.3 %     1.50 %
  Medians - All Conversions:    $ 582       10.09 %     0.76 %     118 %   $ 48.8       59 %     94 %     6.5 %
NA
    8.0 %     4.0 %     4.0 %     10.0 %     2.5 %     0.00 %
                                                                                                                   

Institutional Information
 
Pro Forma Data
         
Post-IPO Pricing Trends
 
       
Pricing Ratios(3)
   
Financial Charac.
         
Closing Price:
 
                                                 
First
         
After
         
After
                   
 
Conver.
         
Core
         
Core
         
Core
   
IPO
   
Trading
   
%
   
First
   
%
   
First
   
%
   
Thru
   
%
 
 Institution
Date
Ticker
 
P/TB
    P/E      P/A    
ROA
   
TE/A
   
ROE
   
Price
   
Day
   
Change
   
Week(4)
   
Change
   
Month(5)
   
Change
   
8/30/10
   
Change
 
       
(%)
   
(x)
   
(%)
   
(%)
   
(%)
   
(%)
   
($)
   
($)
   
(%)
   
($)
   
(%)
   
($)
   
(%)
   
($)
   
(%)
 
                                                                                                   
 Standard Conversions
                                                                                                 
                                                                                                   
 Peoples Federal Bancshares, Inc. - MA
7/7/10  
PEOP-NASDAQ
    64.7 %     45.5       13.1 %     0.3 %     20.2 %     1.4 %      $ 10.00     $ 10.40       4.0 %     $ 10.69       6.9 %     $ 10.42       4.2 %     $ 10.30       3.0 %
 Fairmount Bancorp, Inc. - MD
6/3/10  
FMTB-OTCBB
    43.9 %     11.4       6.5 %     0.6 %     14.8 %     0.6 %   $ 10.00     $ 11.00       10.0 %   $ 12.00       20.0 %   $ 11.00       10.0 %   $ 12.00       20.0 %
                                                                                                                             
  Averages - Standard Conversions:       54.3 %     28.5 x     9.8 %     0.5 %     17.5 %     1.0 %   $ 10.00     $ 10.70       7.0 %   $ 11.35       13.45 %   $ 10.71       7.10 %   $ 11.15       11.50 %
  Medians - Standard Conversions:       54.3 %     28.5 x     9.8 %     0.5 %     17.5 %     1.0 %   $ 10.00     $ 10.70       7.0 %   $ 11.35       13.45 %   $ 10.71       7.10 %   $ 11.15       11.50 %
                                                                                                                             
                                                                                                                             
 Second Step Conversions
                                                                                                                       
                                                                                                                             
 Jacsonville Bancorp, Inc. - IL
7/15/10  
JXSB-NASDAQ
    59.3 %     19.07       6.5 %     0.3 %     11.0 %     2.9 %   $ 10.00     $ 10.65       6.5 %   $ 10.58       5.8 %   $ 10.13       1.3 %   $ 10.25       2.5 %
 Colonial Financial Services - NJ
7/13/10  
COBK-NASDAQ
    63.4 %     14.01       7.1 %     0.5 %     11.2 %     4.5 %   $ 10.00     $ 10.05       0.5 %   $ 9.65       -3.5 %   $ 9.80       -2.0 %   $ 9.75       -2.5 %
 Oneida Financial Corp.- NY
7/7/10  
ONFC-NASDAQ
    97.3 %     15.12       9.2 %     0.6 %     9.9 %     4.5 %   $ 8.00     $ 7.50       -6.3 %   $ 7.50       -6.3 %   $ 7.90       -1.3 %   $ 7.75       -3.1 %
 ViewPoint Financial Group - TX
7/7/10  
VPFG-NASDAQ
    93.2 %     28.61       13.2 %     0.5 %     14.2 %     3.3 %   $ 10.00     $ 9.50       -5.0 %   $ 9.55       -4.5 %   $ 9.70       -3.0 %   $ 8.95       -10.5 %
 Fox Chase Bancorp, Inc. - PA
6/29/10  
FXCB-NASDAQ
    72.1 %  
NM
      11.8 %     -0.1 %     16.4 %     -0.6 %   $ 10.00     $ 9.59       -4.1 %   $ 9.60       -4.0 %   $ 9.68       -3.2 %   $ 9.43       -5.7 %
 Oritani Financial Corp. - NJ
6/24/10  
ORIT-NASDAQ
    89.4 %     38.03       23.0 %     0.6 %     25.7 %     2.4 %   $ 10.00     $ 10.31       3.1 %   $ 9.86       -1.4 %   $ 9.91       -0.9 %   $ 9.22       -7.8 %
                                                                                                                             
  Averages - Second Step Conversions:       79.1 %     23.0 x     11.8 %     0.4 %     14.7 %     2.8 %   $ 9.67     $ 9.60       -0.9 %   $ 9.46       -2.3 %   $ 9.52       -1.5 %   $ 9.23       -4.5 %
  Medians - Second Step Conversions:       80.8 %     19.1 x     10.5 %     0.5 %     12.7 %     3.1 %   $ 10.00     $ 9.82       -1.8 %   $ 9.63       -3.8 %   $ 9.75       -1.6 %   $ 9.33       -4.4 %
                                                                                                                             
 Mutual Holding Company Conversions
                                                                                                                       
                                                                                                                             
  Averages - Mutual Holding Company Conversions:                                                                                                                         
  Medians - Mutual Holding Company Conversions:                                                                                                                         
                                                                                                                             
  Averages - All Conversions:       72.9 %     24.5 x     11.3 %     0.4 %     15.4 %     2.4 %   $ 9.75     $ 9.88       1.1 %   $ 9.93       1.6 %   $ 9.82       0.6 %   $ 9.71       -0.5 %
  Medians - All Conversions:       68.4 %     19.1 x     10.5 %     0.5 %     14.5 %     2.6 %   $ 10.00     $ 10.18       1.8 %   $ 9.76       -2.5 %   $ 9.86       -1.1 %   $ 9.59       -2.8 %
                                                                                                                             
   
 Note: * - Appraisal performed by RP Financial; BOLD=RP Financial did the Conversion Business Plan. “NT” - Not Traded; “NA” - Not Applicable, Not Available;  C/S-Cash/Stock.
   
 (1)
Non-OTS regulated thrift.
 (2)
As a percent of MHC offering for MHC transactions.
 (3)
Does not take into account the adoption of SOP 93-6.
 (4)
Latest price if offering is less than one week old.
 (5)
Latest price if offering is more than one week but less than one month old.
 (6)
Mutual holding company pro forma data on full conversion basis.
 (7)
Simultaneously completed acquisition of another financial institution.
 (8)
Simultaneously converted to a commercial bank charter.
 (9)
Former credit union.
August 30, 2010  
 
 
 
 
 

 
 
Board of Directors
August 30, 2010
Page 16
 
Table 6
Market Pricing Comparatives
Prices As of August 30, 2010

     
Market
 
Per Share Data
                                                                 
     
Capitalization
 
Core
 
Book
                     
Dividends (4)
 
Financial Characteristics (6)
 
     
Price/
 
Market
 
12 Month
 
Value/
 
Pricing Ratios (3)
 
Amount/
     
Payout
 
Total
 
Equity/
 
Tang Eq/
 
NPAs/
 
Reported
 
Core
 
Financial Institution
 
Share (1)
 
Value
 
EPS (2)
 
Share
  P/E   P/B   P/A  
P/TB
 
P/Core
 
Share
 
Yield
 
Ratio(5)
 
Assets
 
Assets
 
Assets
 
Assets
 
ROA
 
ROE
 
ROA
 
ROE
 
     
($)
 
($Mil)
 
($)
 
($)
 
(x)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(x)
 
($)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
($Mil)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
                                                                                     
All Public Companies
  $ 9.52   $ 268.53   ($ 0.12 ) $ 12.76   18.60 x 75.49 %    9.10 % 82.94 %    18.15 x $ 0.23   2.02 %   30.08 %    $ 2,697   11.41 % 10.65 % 4.25 % -0.09 % 0.64 % -0.13 % -0.03 %
Converted Last 3 Months (no MHC)
  $ 9.38   $ 165.27    $ 0.36   $ 13.86   23.82 x 69.21 % 11.44 % 73.91 % 21.82 x $ 0.18   2.12 % 12.66 % $ 1,196   11.66 % 11.00 % 0.85 % 0.36 % 3.66 % 0.39 % 4.12 %
                                                                                                 
Converted Last 3 Months (no MHC)
                                                                                             
COBK
Colonial Financial Services of NJ
  $ 9.75   $ 40.69    $ 0.71   $ 15.78   20.31 x 61.79 % 6.93 % 61.79 % 13.73 x $ 0.00   0.00 % 0.00 % $ 587   7.46 % 7.46 %
NA
  0.34 % 4.58 % 0.50 % 6.77 %
FXCB
Fox Chase Bancorp, Inc. of PA
  $ 9.43   $ 137.18   ($ 0.08 ) $ 13.88  
NM
  67.94 % 11.13 % 67.94 %
NM
  $ 0.00   0.00 %
NM
  $ 1,233   10.86 % 10.86 %
NA
  -0.09 % -0.87 % -0.09 % -0.87 %
JXSB
Jacksonville Bancorp Inc. of IL
  $ 10.25   $ 19.72    $ 0.52   $ 18.27   12.97 x 56.10 % 6.61 % 60.83 % 19.71 x $ 0.30   2.93 % 37.97 % $ 298   8.59 % 7.67 %
NA
  0.51 % 5.93 % 0.34 % 3.90 %
ONFC
Oneida Financial Corp. of NY
  $ 7.75   $ 55.53    $ 0.53   $ 11.69   14.90 x 66.30 % 8.92 % 94.28 % 14.62 x $ 0.53   6.84 %
NM
  $ 623   8.74 % 5.11 %
NA
  0.60 % 6.84 % 0.61 % 6.97 %
ORIT
Oritani Financial Corp. of NJ
  $ 9.22   $ 518.18    $ 0.26   $ 11.18   34.15 x 82.47 % 21.20 % 82.47 % 35.46 x $ 0.30   3.25 %
NM
  $ 2,444   15.77 % 15.77 %
NA
  0.62 % 3.94 % 0.60 % 3.79 %
PEOP
Peoples Federal Bncshrs, Inc. of MA
  $ 10.30   $ 73.56    $ 0.22   $ 15.45   36.79 x 66.67 % 13.48 % 66.67 %
NM
  $ 0.00   0.00 % 0.00 % $ 546   19.18 % 19.18 %
NA
  0.37 %
NM
  0.29 %
NM
 
VPFG
ViewPoint Financial Group of TX
  $ 8.95   $ 312.04    $ 0.35   $ 10.76  
NM
  83.18 % 11.81 % 83.41 % 25.57 x $ 0.16   1.79 %
NM
  $ 2,642   11.05 % 10.98 %  0.85 % 0.17 % 1.55 % 0.46 % 4.18 %
 
     
(1)
Average of High/Low or Bid/Ask price per share.
(2)
EPS (estimate core basis) is based on actual trailing 12 month data, adjusted to omit non-operating items on a tax-effected basis.
(3)
P/E = Price to earnings; P/B = Price to book; P/A = Price to assets; P/TB = Price to tangible book value; and P/Core = Price to core earnings.
(4)
Indicated 12 month dividend, based on last quarterly dividend declared.
(5)
Indicated 12 month dividend as a percent of trailing 12 month estimated core earnings.
(6)
ROA (return on assets) and ROE (return on equity) are indicated ratios based on trailing 12 month common earnings and average common equity and total assets balances.
(7)
Excludes from averages and medians those companies the subject of actual or rumored acquisition activities or unusual operating characteristics.
   
Source:
SNL Financial, LC. and RP® Financial, LC. calculations.  The information provided in this report has been obtained from sources we believe are reliable, but we cannot guarantee the accuracy or completeness of such information.
   
Copyright (c) 2010 by RP® Financial, LC.
 
 
 

 
 
Board of Directors
August 30, 2010
Page 17
 
Based on our discussions with Sandler O’Neill & Partners, L.P. (“Sandler O’Neill”), which is acting as sole book-running manage for the Company’s stock offering, indications of interest from the syndicate were less than the minimum of the offering range as set forth in Original Appraisal and confirmed in the First Update.  On August 25, 2010, the Company announced that it intended to seek an extension of time from the OTS to complete the stock offering, based on an updated appraisal to reflect the downturn in stock market conditions for thrift stocks since the date of the Original Appraisal.
 
Summary of Adjustments
 
In the First Update, we made the following adjustments to Capitol Federal Financial’s pro forma value based upon our comparative analysis to the Peer Group:
 
Key Valuation Parameters:
   
PreviousValuation
Adjustment
 
     
Financial Condition
 
Slight Upward
Profitability, Growth and Viability of Earnings
 
Moderate Upward
Asset Growth
 
No Adjustment
Primary Market Area
 
Slight Upward
Dividends
 
No Adjustment
Liquidity of the Shares
 
No Adjustment
Marketing of the Issue
 
Slight Downward
Management
 
No Adjustment
Effect of Govt. Regulations and Regulatory Reform
 
No Adjustment
 
The factors concerning the valuation parameters of primary market area, dividends, liquidity of the shares, management and effect of government regulations and regulatory reform did not change since the First Update.  Accordingly, those parameters were not discussed further in this update.
 
In terms of financial condition, a slight upward adjustment remained appropriate based on positive adjustments for the Company’s  credit quality and capital strength.  No adjustment remained appropriate for asset growth, as the Peer Group’s stronger historical growth was viewed to be offset by the Company’s greater pro forma leverage capacity.  A moderate upward adjustment remained appropriate for earnings, as the relative earnings adjustments for the Company’s updated earnings did not change from the Original Appraisal.
 
 
 

 
 
Board of Directors
August 30, 2010
Page 18
 
The general market for thrift stocks was down considerably from the May 28, 2010 date when the current valuation range was established in the Original Appraisal, which included some deterioration in thrift prices since the August 13, 2010 date of the First Update when the valuation range was confirmed following the close of the subscription and community offerings.  Since the date of the Original Appraisal, the SNL Index for all publicly-traded thrifts was down 12.8%.  The updated pricing measures for the Peer Group generally showed a more significant decline relative to the SNL Index, as well as the updated pricing measures for all publicly-traded thrifts.  Five out of the six recently completed second-step conversion offerings are currently trading slightly below their respective IPO prices.
 
Capitol Federal Financial’s stock was down 13.6% since the date of the First Update and down 20.1% since the date of the Original Appraisal.  Capitol Federal Financial’s subscription and community offerings had total orders that were well below the minimum of the range and the syndicated community offering terminated without sufficient interest at the minimum of the offering range.  Based on our discussions with Sandler O’Neill, the sell-off in thrift stocks in general and the weak after market performance of the recently completed second-step conversion offerings were factors that contributed to the limited interest in the syndicated offering.  Accordingly, a more significant downward adjustment has been applied for marketing of the issue.
 
Overall, taking into account the foregoing factors, we believe that a decrease in the Company’s estimated pro forma market value as set forth in the Original Appraisal and confirmed in the First Update is appropriate.
 
Overall, taking into account the foregoing factors, RP Financial concluded that as of August 30, 2010, the aggregate pro forma value of Capitol Federal Financial’s conversion stock equaled $1,970,529,000 at the midpoint, which is an 18.2% reduction in value from the midpoint value set forth in the Original Appraisal and confirmed in the First Update.  The midpoint and resulting valuation range is based on the sale of a 70.54% ownership interest to the public, which provides for a $1.390 billion public offering.  The 70.54% ownership interest was based on the Company’s shares outstanding as of June 30, 2010, which is consistent with the pro forma data in the Company’s supplemental prospectus.  As set forth below, the reduction in the pro forma market value results in a 7.9% reduction in the Company price/tangible book ratio as set forth in the Original Appraisal.  Comparatively, the Peer Group’s price/tangible book ratio was down 15.2% from the May 28, 2010 Original Appraisal date through August 30, 2010.
 
Comparative Change in Price/Tangible Book Ratios
 
   
At May 28,
   
Aug. 30,
    % Change  
   
2010
   
2010
   
5/28/10-8/30/10
 
                         
Peer Group
    133.10 %     112.92 %     (15.2 )%
                         
Capitol Federal Financial
    98.04 %     90.25 %     (7.9 )
 
 
 

 
 
Board of Directors
August 30, 2010
Page 19
 
Valuation Approaches
 
    In applying the accepted valuation methodology promulgated by the regulatory agencies, i.e., the pro forma market value approach, we considered the three key pricing ratios in valuing Capitol Federal Financial’s to-be-issued stock -- price/earnings (“P/E”), price/book (“P/B”), and price/assets (“P/A”) approaches -- all performed on a pro forma basis including the effects of the conversion proceeds.
 
    In computing the pro forma impact of the conversion and the related pricing ratios, we have incorporated the valuation parameters disclosed in the Company’s prospectus supplement for reinvestment rate, effective tax rate, stock benefit plan assumptions and expenses (summarized in Exhibits 3 and 4).
 
    Consistent with the Original Appraisal and First Update, this updated appraisal continues to be based primarily on fundamental analysis techniques applied to the Peer Group, including the P/E approach, the P/B approach and the P/A approach.  Also consistent with the Original Appraisal and First Update, this updated appraisal incorporates a “technical” analysis of recently completed conversion offerings, including principally the P/B approach which (as discussed in the Original Appraisal and First Update is the most meaningful pricing ratio as the pro forma P/E ratios reflect an assumed reinvestment rate and do not yet reflect the actual use of proceeds.
 
    RP Financial also considered the trading price of Capitol Federal Financial’s stock, which had a closing price of $25.56 as of August 30, 2010, a decrease of 13.6% from its closing price as of August 13, 2010 and a decrease of 20.1% from its closing price as of May 28, 2010.  The $25.56 closing trading price implied a pro forma market capitalization for Capitol Federal Financial of approximately $1.9 billion, which is below the minimum of the valuation range as set forth in the Original Appraisal and confirmed in the First Update.
 
    The Company has adopted Statement of Position (“SOP” 93-6) which causes earnings per share computations to be based on shares issued and outstanding excluding shares owned by an ESOP where there is not a commitment to release such shares.  For the purpose of preparing the pro forma pricing tables and exhibits, we have reflected all shares issued in the offering including shares purchased by the ESOP as outstanding to capture the full dilutive impact of such stock to the Company’s shareholders.  However, we have considered the impact of the Company’s adoption of SOP 93-6 in the determination of pro forma market value.
 
 
 

 
 
Board of Directors
August 30, 2010
Page 20
 
    1.           P/E Approach.  In applying the P/E approach, RP Financial’s valuation conclusions considered both reported earnings and a recurring or “core” earnings base, that is, earnings adjusted to exclude any one time non-operating and extraordinary items, plus the estimated after tax-earnings benefit from reinvestment of net stock proceeds.  The Company’s reported earnings equaled $69.231 million for the twelve months ended June 30, 2010.  In deriving Capitol Federal Financial’s core earnings, the only adjustment made to reported earnings was to eliminate the net gain on the sale of securities and loans.  The net gain on the sale of securities and loans equaled $7.591 million for the twelve months ended June 30, 2010.  As shown below, on a tax effected basis, assuming an effective marginal tax rate of 38.32% for the earnings adjustments, the Company’s core earnings were determined to equal $64.549 million for the twelve months ended June 30, 2010.  (Note:  see Exhibit 2 for the adjustments applied to the Peer Group’s earnings in the calculation of core earnings).
 
   
Amount
 
      ($000)  
         
Net income(loss)
  $ 69,231  
Deduct: Gain on sale of loans and securities(1)
    (4,682 )
  Core earnings estimate
  $ 64,549  
 
(1)  Tax effected at 38.32%.
 
Based on Capitol Federal Financial’s reported and estimated core earnings, incorporating the impact of the pro forma assumptions, the Company’s reported and core P/E multiples at the midpoint value of $2.0 billion equaled 25.96 times and 27.67 times, respectively.  The Company’s reported and core P/E multiples indicated premiums of 59.95% and 65.89% relative to the Peer Group’s average reported and core P/E multiples of 16.23 times and 16.68 times, respectively (versus premiums of 72.28% and 79.30% relative to the Peer Group’s average reported and core P/E multiples at the midpoint valuation in the First Update).  The Company’s updated reported and core P/E multiples indicated premiums of 73.76% and 92.02% relative to the Peer Group’s median reported and core P/E multiples of 14.94 times and 14.41 times, respectively (versus premiums of 83.15% and 81.49% relative to the Peer Group’s median reported and core P/E multiples at the midpoint valuation in the First Update).  The Company’s pro forma P/E ratios based on reported earnings at the minimum and the maximum are 22.39 times and 29.44 times, respectively, and based on core earnings at the minimum and the maximum are 23.88 times and 31.35 times, respectively.  The Company’s implied conversion pricing ratios relative to the Peer Group’s pricing ratios are indicated in Table 7, and the pro forma calculations are detailed in Exhibits 3 and 4.
 
 
 

 
 
Board of Directors
August 30, 2010
Page 21
 
Table 7
Public Market Pricing
Capitol Federal Financial and the Comparables
As of August 30, 2010
                                                                                             
     
Market
 
Per Share Data
                                                                         
     
Capitalization
 
Core
 
Book
                     
Dividends (4)
 
Financial Characteristics (6)
     
2nd Step
 
     
Price/
 
Market
 
12 Month
 
Value/
 
Pricing Ratios (3)
 
Amount/
     
Payout
 
Total
 
Equity/
 
Tang Eq/
 
NPAs/
 
Reported
 
Core
 
Exchange
 
Offering
 
   
Share (1)
 
Value
 
EPS (2)
 
Share
  P/E   P/B   P/A  
P/TB
 
P/Core
 
Share
 
Yield
 
Ratio (5)
 
Assets
 
Assets
 
Assets
 
Assets
 
ROA
 
ROE
 
ROA
 
ROE
 
Ratio
 
Amount
 
     
($)
 
($Mil)
 
($)
 
($)
 
(x)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(x)
 
($)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
($Mil)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
     
($Mil)
 
Capitol Federal Financial
                                                                                         
  Maximum
  $ 10.00   $ 2,266.11    $ 0.32   $ 10.47   29.44   95.51 % 22.76 % 95.51 %   31.35   $ 0.00   0.00 %   0.00 %   9,956   23.83 %   23.83 %   0.41 %   0.77 %   3.24 %   0.73 % 3.05 % 3.0627     1,598.500  
  Midpoint
  $ 10.00   $ 1,970.53    $ 0.36   $ 11.08   25.96   90.25 % 20.17 % 90.25 %   27.67   $ 0.00   0.00 %   0.00 %   9,767   22.36 %   22.36 %   0.41 %   0.78 %   3.47 %   0.73 % 3.26 % 2.6632     1,390.000  
  Minimum
  $ 10.00   $ 1,674.95    $ 0.42   $ 11.92   22.39   83.89 % 17.49 % 83.89 %   23.88   $ 0.00   0.00 %   0.00 %   9,579   20.84 %   20.84 %   0.42 %   0.78 %   3.75 %   0.73 % 3.51 % 2.2637     1,181.500  
                                                                                                                         
All Non-MHC Public Companies (7)
                                                                                                                     
  Averages
  $ 9.91   $ 308.55   ($ 0.19 ) $ 13.91   18.42 x 69.54 % 8.07 % 77.31 %   17.62 x $ 0.24   2.05 %   31.48 % $ 2,930   11.05 %   10.26 %   4.06 %   -0.16 %   0.33 %   -0.22 % -0.66 %          
  Medians
  $ 9.60   $ 61.32    $ 0.23   $ 13.56   15.07 x 67.94 % 6.80 % 72.79 %   15.78 x $ 0.20   1.80 %
NM
  $ 967   9.85 %   8.97 %   2.63 %   0.22 %   2.43 %   0.17 % 1.60 %          
                                                                                                                         
Comparable Group Averages
                                                                                                                     
  Averages
  $ 9.88   $ 478.21    $ 0.29   $ 10.92   16.23 x 97.65 % 10.54 % 112.92 %   16.68 x $ 0.28   3.05 %   43.19 % $ 4,554   11.36 %   9.87 %   2.33 %   0.49 %   4.69 %   0.47 % 4.54 %          
  Medians
  $ 9.30   $ 339.87    $ 0.41   $ 11.11   14.94 x 89.55 % 10.32 % 115.79 %   14.41 x $ 0.24   3.03 %   50.00 % $ 3,483   11.48 %   9.44 %   1.44 %   0.68 %   5.17 %   0.72 % 4.81 %          
                                                                                                                         
Comparable Group
                                                                                                                     
BKMU
Bank Mutual Corp. of WI
  $ 5.05   $ 230.84   ($ 0.16 ) $ 8.69  
NM
  58.11 % 6.63 % 67.24 %
NM
  $ 0.12   2.38 %
NM
  $ 3,483   11.48 %   10.09 %   2.25 %   0.16 %   1.36 %   -0.21 % -1.81 %          
BRKL
Brookline Bancorp, Inc. of MA
  $ 9.15   $ 540.20    $ 0.40   $ 8.34   21.28 x 109.71 % 20.31 % 120.87 %   22.88 x $ 0.34   3.72 %
NM
  $ 2,660   18.60 %   17.17 %   0.61 %   0.96 %   5.17 %   0.89 % 4.81 %          
DNBK
Danvers Bancorp, Inc. of MA
  $ 14.96   $ 319.77    $ 0.56   $ 13.76   24.52 x 108.72 % 12.64 % 122.93 %   26.71 x $ 0.08   0.53 %   13.11 % $ 2,529   11.63 %   10.42 %   0.81 %   0.58 %   4.94 %   0.54 % 4.53 %          
DCOM
Dime Community Bancshares of NY
  $ 12.26   $ 423.56    $ 1.07   $ 9.11   11.79 x 134.58 % 10.21 % 163.47 %   11.46 x $ 0.56   4.57 %   53.85 % $ 4,148   7.59 %   6.33 %   0.50 %   0.89 %   12.05 %   0.92 % 12.40 %          
FFCH
First Financial Holdings Inc. of SC
  $ 9.30   $ 153.70   ($ 2.30 ) $ 15.66  
NM
  59.39 % 4.62 % 69.72 %
NM
  $ 0.20   2.15 %
NM
  $ 3,324   9.74 %   8.69 %   6.40 %   -1.18 %   -12.26 %   -1.10 % -11.47 %          
FFIC
Flushing Financial Corp. of NY
  $ 10.88   $ 339.87    $ 0.96   $ 12.15   12.51 x 89.55 % 7.99 % 93.96 %   11.33 x $ 0.52   4.78 %   59.77 % $ 4,252   8.93 %   8.54 %   2.80 %   0.65 %   7.40 %   0.72 % 8.16 %          
PBNY
Provident NY Bancorp, Inc. of NY
  $ 7.92   $ 305.93    $ 0.41   $ 11.11   15.23 x 71.29 % 10.32 % 115.79 %   19.32 x $ 0.24   3.03 %   46.15 % $ 2,964   14.48 %   9.44 %   1.11 %   0.68 %   4.74 %   0.54 % 3.73 %          
TRST
TrustCo Bank Corp. NY of NY
  $ 5.33   $ 409.73    $ 0.37   $ 3.32   13.33 x 160.54 % 10.70 % 161.03 %   14.41 x $ 0.26   4.88 %   65.00 % $ 3,829   6.67 %   6.65 %   1.44 %   0.83 %   12.46 %   0.77 % 11.53 %          
WFSL
Washington Federal, Inc. of WA
  $ 14.05   $ 1,580.26    $ 1.32   $ 16.15   14.95 x 87.00 % 11.45 % 101.30 %   10.64 x $ 0.20   1.42 %   21.28 % $ 13,803   13.16 %   11.52 %   5.09 %   0.83 %   6.38 %   1.17 % 8.96 %          

(1)
Average of High/Low or Bid/Ask price per share.
(2)
EPS (estimate core basis) is based on actual trailing 12 month data, adjusted to omit non-operating items on a tax-effected basis, and is shown on a pro forma basis where appropriate.
(3)
P/E = Price to earnings; P/B = Price to book; P/A = Price to assets; P/TB = Price to tangible book value; and P/Core = Price to core earnings.
(4)
Indicated 12 month dividend, based on last quarterly dividend declared.
(5)
Indicated 12 month dividend as a percent of trailing 12 month estimated core earnings.
(6)
ROA (return on assets) and ROE (return on equity) are indicated ratios based on trailing 12 month common earnings and average common equity and total assets balances.
(7)
Excludes from averages and medians those companies the subject of actual or rumored acquisition activities or unusual operating characteristics.
     
Source:
SNL Financial, LC. and RP® Financial, LC. calculations.  The information provided in this table has been obtained from sources we believe are reliable, but we cannot guarantee the accuracy or completeness of such information.
 
 
 

 
 
Board of Directors
August 30, 2010
Page 22
 
    2.           P/B Approach.  P/B ratios have generally served as a useful benchmark in the valuation of thrift stocks, with the greater determinant of long term value being earnings.  In applying the P/B approach, we considered both reported book value and tangible book value.  Based on the $2.0 billion midpoint value, the Company’s P/B and P/TB ratios both equaled 90.25%.  In comparison to the average P/B and P/TB ratios indicated for the Peer Group of 97.65% and 112.92%, respectively, Capitol Federal Financial’s updated ratios reflected a discount of 7.58% on a P/B basis and a discount of 20.08% on a P/TB basis (versus discounts of 0.14% and 16.39% from the average Peer Group’s P/B and P/TB ratios at the midpoint valuation in the First Update).  In comparison to the median P/B and P/TB ratios indicated for the Peer Group of 89.55% and 115.79%, respectively, Capitol Federal Financial’s updated ratios reflected a premium of 0.78% and a discount of 22.06% at the $2.0 billion midpoint value (versus a premium of 3.65% and a discount of 18.26% from the Peer Group’s median P/B and P/TB ratios at the midpoint valuation in the First Update).  At the maximum of the range, the Company’s P/B and P/TB ratios both equaled 95.51%.  In comparison to the Peer Group’s average P/B and P/TB ratios, the Company’s P/B and P/TB ratios at the maximum of the range reflected discounts of 2.19% and 15.42%, respectively.  In comparison to the Peer Group’s median P/B and P/TB ratios, the Company’s P/B and P/TB ratios at the top of the range reflected a premium of 6.66% and a discount of 17.51%, respectively.
 
In addition to the fundamental analysis applied to the Peer Group, RP Financial utilized a technical analysis of recent conversion offerings.  As indicated in the Original Appraisal and First Update, the pricing characteristics of recent conversion offerings are not the primary determinate of value.  Consistent with the Original Appraisal and First Update, particular focus was placed on the P/TB approach in this analysis since the P/E multiples do not reflect the actual impact of reinvestment and the source of the conversion funds (i.e., external funds versus deposit withdrawals).
 
As discussed previously, the six recently completed second-step offerings reflected an average forma price/tangible book ratio at closing of 79.1% (see Table 5).  In comparison, the Company’s pro forma price/tangible book ratio at the midpoint value reflects a premium of 14.10%.  The current average P/TB ratio of the six recent second-step conversions, based on closing stock prices as of August 30, 2010, equaled 75.1%.  In comparison to current P/TB ratio of the six recent second-step conversions, the Company’s P/TB ratio at the midpoint value reflects an implied premium of 20.17%.
 
    3.           P/A Approach.  P/A ratios are generally not as a reliable indicator of market value, as investors do not place significant weight on total assets as a determinant of market value.  Investors place significantly greater weight on book value and earnings -- which have received greater weight in our valuation analysis.  At the $2.0 billion midpoint value, Capitol Federal Financial’s pro forma P/A ratio equaled 20.17%.  In comparison to the Peer Group’s average P/A ratio of 10.54%, Capitol Federal Financial’s P/A ratio indicated a premium of 91.37% (versus a premium of 117.21% at the midpoint valuation in the First Update).  In comparison to the Peer Group’s median P/A ratio of 10.32%, Capitol Federal Financial’s P/A ratio at the $2.0 billion midpoint value indicated a premium of 95.45% (versus a premium of 125.33% at the midpoint valuation in the First Update).
 
 
 

 
 
Board of Directors
August 30, 2010
Page 23
 
Valuation Conclusion
 
Our analysis indicates that the Company’s estimated pro forma market should be decreased from the midpoint value as set forth in the Original Appraisal and confirmed n the First Update.  Accordingly, based on the foregoing, it is our opinion that, as of August 30, 2010, the estimated aggregate pro forma valuation of the shares of the Company to be issued and outstanding at the end of the conversion offering – including (1) newly-issued shares representing the MHC’s current ownership interest in the Company and (2) exchange shares issued to existing public shareholders of the Company - was $1,970,529,000 at the midpoint, equal to 197,052,900 shares at a per share value of $10.00.  The resulting range of value and pro forma shares, all based on $10.00 per share, are as follows:  $1,674,949,650 or 167,494,965 shares at the minimum and $2,266,108,350 or 226,610,835 shares at the maximum.
 
Based on this valuation and taking into account the ownership interest represented by the shares owned by the MHC, the midpoint of the offering range is $1,390,000,000, equal to 139,000,000 shares at $10.00 per share.  The resulting offering range and offering shares, all based on $10.00 per share, are as follows:  $1,181,500,000, or 118,150,000 shares at the minimum and $1,598,500,000 or 159,850,000 shares at the maximum.  The pro forma valuation calculations relative to the Peer Group are shown in Table 7 and are detailed in Exhibit 3 and Exhibit 4.
 
 
 

 
 
Board of Directors
August 30, 2010
Page 24
 
Establishment of the Exchange Ratio
 
OTS regulations provide that in a conversion of a mutual holding company, the minority stockholders are entitled to exchange the public shares for newly issued shares in the fully converted company.  The Board of Directors of Capitol Federal Financial has independently determined the exchange ratio, which has been designed to preserve the current aggregate percentage ownership in the Company held by the public shareholders.  The exchange ratio to be received by the existing minority shareholders of the Company will be determined at the end of the offering, based on the total number of shares sold in the subscription, community and syndicated offerings and the final appraisal.  Based on the valuation conclusion herein, the resulting offering value and the $10.00 per share offering price, the indicated exchange ratio at the midpoint is 2.6632 shares of the Company for every one public share held by public shareholders.  Furthermore, based on the offering range of value, the indicated exchange ratio is 2.2637 at the minimum and 3.0627 at the maximum.  RP Financial expresses no opinion on the proposed exchange of newly issued Company shares for the shares held by the public stockholders or on the proposed exchange ratio.
 
  Respectfully submitted,
  RP® FINANCIAL, LC.
     
   /s/
William E. Pommerening
 
   
William E. Pommerening
   
Chief Executive Officer and 
Managing Director
     
  /s/
Gregory E. Dunn
 
   
Gregory E. Dunn
   
Director
 
 
 

 
 
EXHIBITS
 
 
 

 
 
RP Financial, LC.
 
LIST OF EXHIBITS
           
Exhibit
Number 
   
Description
 
       
 
1
 
Stock Prices:  As of August 30, 2010
       
 
2
 
Peer Group Core Earnings Analysis
       
 
3
 
Pro Forma Analysis Sheet
       
 
4
 
Pro Forma Effect of Conversion Proceeds
       
 
5
 
Firm Qualifications Statement
 
 
 

 
 
Stock Prices
As of August 30, 2010
 
 
 

 
 
   
RP FINANCIAL, LC.
 
Financial Services Industry Consultants
 
1100 North Glebe Road, Suite 1100
 
Arlington, Virginia 222011
 
(703) 528-1700
 
 
Exhibit 1
Weekly Thrift Market Line - Part One
Prices As Of August 30, 2010
                                                                                     
                                                         
Current Per Share Financials
 
   
Market Capitalization
   
Price Change Data
                     
Tangible
Book
Value/
Share (4)
       
         
Shares
Outst-
anding
   
Market
Capita1-
ization(9)
   
52 Week (1)
         
% Change From
   
Trailing
12 Mo.
EPS (3)
   
12 Mo.
Core
EPS (3)
   
Book
Value/
Share
   
Assets/
Share
 
Financial Institution
 
Price/
Share(l)
   
High
   
Low
   
Last
Week
   
Last
Week
   
52 Wks
Ago (2)
   
MostRcnt
YrEnd (2)
 
   
($)
      (000)    
($Mi1)
   
($)
   
($)
   
($)
   
(%)
   
(%)
   
(%)
   
($)
   
($)
   
($)
   
($)
   
($)
 
                                                                           
Market Averages. All Public
Companies (no MHC)
                                                                         
                                                                                       
All Public Companies (110)
    9.91       29,132       308.5       13.04       8.12       10.02       -1.95       -6.49       1.54       -0.11       -0.19       13.91       12.79       144.96  
NYSE Traded Companies (6)
    9.10       150,943       1,724.7       13.55       7.18       9.50       -7.05       -13.44       -10.18       -0.62       -0.89       10.18       6.98       112.33  
AMEX Traded Companies (1)
    29.90       2,091       62.5       35.75       26.01       28.75       4.00       -9.86       -5.71       3.46       3.35       35.65       33.89       366.09  
NASDAQ Listed OTC Companies (103)
    9.75       22,093       226.0       12.78       7.99       9.86       -1.70       -6.04       2.32       -0.11       -0.19       13.92       12.93       144.71  
California Companies (4)
    7.21       6,895       55.0       12.06       3.86       7.37       -1.85       3.39       32.72       -0.48       -0.80       12.89       12.89       196.55  
Florida Companies (2)
    1.16       29,689       34.2       4.58       1.12       1.39       -16.52       -69.98       -31.50       -3.17       -3.28       2.51       2.37       90.49  
Mid-Atlantic Companies (34)
    10.88       48,496       580.1       13.43       8.70       11.07       -2.19       1.32       5.34       0.21       0.25       13.67       12.29       149.74  
Mid-West Companies (31)
    8.48       13,301       60.1       12.36       6.63       8.57       -1.58       -9.09       5.31       -0.22       -0.57       14.22       13.39       160.02  
New England Companies (17)
    12.88       41,091       499.8       15.16       11.12       12.92       -1.24       -3.01       0.32       0.49       0.48       15.57       13.47       136.58  
North-West Companies (4)
    5.96       37,312       425.7       9.75       5.58       6.28       -4.11       -27.61       -23.37       -0.72       -0.60       10.97       9.58       93.80  
South-East Companies (12)
    10.52       6,033       53.6       13.57       9.35       10.40       1.23       -12.93       -5.81       -0.68       -0.63       15.75       14.99       144.99  
South-West Companies (2)
    10.06       23,384       222.5       12.54       9.36       10.28       -2.29       5.41       -0.66       0.12       0.16       13.82       13.81       85.35  
Western Companies (Excl CA) (4)
    9.72       15,595       115.8       13.62       8.62       9.92       -4.63       -12.65       -22.57       -0.34       -0.24       11.71       11.71       81.47  
Thrift Strategy (104)
    9.82       25,993       273.9       12.87       8.10       9.93       -1.82       -5.72       0.62       -0.08       -0.17       13.93       12.83       143.87  
Mortgage Banker Strategy (3)
    3.27       32,664       61.7       7.33       1.78       3.35       -7.25       -53.22       41.69       -1.59       -2.13       6.32       6.18       104.51  
Real Estate Strategy (l)
    1. 93       25,642       49.5       4.39       1.58       1.98       -2.53       -11.87       -0.52       -0.15       -0.34       3.33       3.33       34.68  
Diversified Strategy (2)
    24.73       187,409       2,453.1       31.58       18.39       25.12       -2.53       3.40       9.66       0.19       0.36       25.81       22.46       296.25  
Companies Issuing Dividends (69)
    11.81       38,184       454.6       14.89       9.68       11.93       -1.47       -2.51       2.74       0.40       0.37       15.02       13.60       159.44  
Companies Without Dividends (41)
    6.58       13,347       54.0       9.81       5.39       6.68       -2.77       -13.43       -0.54       -0.99       -1.18       11. 98       11.39       119.72  
Equity/Assets <6% (14)
    3.08       24,260       53.2       7.57       2.62       3.28       -6.89       -46.11       -28.34       -3.08       -3.15       8.10       7.49       173.59  
Equity/Assets 6-12% (58)
    11.11       20,040       202.6       14.43       8.61       11.18       -1.33       -0.78       10.89       0.38       0.22       15.51       14.55       179.98  
Equity/Assets >12% (38)
    10.25       44,308       548.2       12.68       9.11       10.41       -1.31       -2.55       -3.04       0.10       0.12       13.35       11.84       83.38  
Converted Last 3 Mths (no MHC) (7)
    9.38       18,003       165.3       12.00       8.04       9.44       -0.62       1.28       1.60       0.34       0.36       13.86       13.16       94.73  
Actively Traded Companies (5)
    17.97       33,198       458.1       23.24       14.90       17.75       -2.95       -3.53       -2.39       0.97       1.12       21.45       19.96       274.35  
Market Value Below $20 Million (23)
    6.03       4,109       13.1       9.35       4.57       6.02       -1.74       -15.13       -2.84       -1.52       -1.57       12.60       12.40       171.44  
Holding Company Structure (105)
    9.62       30,210       319.8       12.76       7.92       9.77       -2.07       -7.35       1.37       -0.19       -0.27       13.77       12.66       142.42  
Assets Over $1 Bi1lion (52)
    9.62       57,030       615.4       13.56       8.16       9.91       -3.79       -11.28       -1.70       -0.15       -0.25       12.64       11.08       126.02  
Assets $500 Million-$l Billion (33)
    10.30       6,050       49.6       12.78       8.07       10.30       -1.19       -5.71       0.12       -0.09       -0.11       14.94       13.99       172.84  
Assets $250-$500 Million (20)
    10.44       3,173       29.8       13.00       8.64       10.32       0.80       0.89       2.18       0.25       0.09       15.36       14.81       147.79  
Assets less than $250 Million (5)
    8.15       1,700       12.0       9.67       5.91       8.09       0.72       6.85       40.53       -1.22       -1.32       14.22       14.15       144.63  
Goodwill Companies (65)
    10.21       40,604       464.9       13.58       8.42       10.44       -2.52       -6.98       1.96       0.07       0.01       14.15       12.25       152.64  
Non-Goodwill Companies (45)
    9.47       12,706       84.6       12.26       7.68       9.42       -1.13       -5.80       0.95       -0.37       -0.49       13.57       13.57       133.97  
Acquirors of FSLIC Cases (1)
    14.05       112,474       1,580.3       21.65       14.04       14.98       -6.21       -8.05       -27.35       0.94       1.32       16.15       13.87       122.72  
 
(1)
Average of high/low or bid/ask price per share.
(2)
Or since offering price if converted or first listed in the past 52 weeks. Percent change figures are actual year-to-date and are not annualized
(3)
EPS (earnings per share) is based on actual trailing twelve month data and is not shown on a pro forma basis.
(4)
Excludes intangibles (such as goodwill, value of core deposits, etc.).
(5)
ROA (return on assets) and ROE (return on equity) are indicated ratios based on trailing twelve month common earnings and average common equity and assets balances.
(6)
Annualized, based on last regular quarterly cash dividend announcement.
(7)
Indicated dividend as a percent of trailing twelve month earnings.
(8)
Excluded from averages due to actual or rumored acquisition activities or unusual operating characteristics.
(9)
For MHC institutions, market value reflects share price multiplied by public (non-MHC) shares.
   
*
Parentheses following market averages indicate the number of institutions included in the respective averages. All figures have been adjusted for stock splits, stock dividends, and secondary offerings.
 
Source:
SNL Financial, LC. and RP Financial, LC. calculations. The information provided in this table has been obtained from sources we believe are reliable, but we cannot guarantee the accuracy or completeness of such information.
 
Copyright (c) 2010 by RP Financial, LC.
 
 
 

 
 
RP FINANCIAL, LC.
 
Financial Services Industry Consultants
 
1100 North Glebe Road, Suite 1100
 
Arlington, Virginia 222011
 
(703) 528-1700
 
 
Exhibit 1 (continued)
Weekly Thrift Market Line - Part One
Prices As Of August 30, 2010
                                                                                     
                                                         
Current Per Share Financials
 
   
Market Capitalization
   
Price Change Data
                     
Tangible
Book
Value/
Share(4)
       
         
Shares
Outst-
anding
   
Market
Capital-
ization(9)
   
52 Week (1)
         
% Change From
   
Trailing
12 Mo.
EPS (3)
   
12 Mo.
Core
EPS (3)
   
Book
Value/
Share
       
   
Price/
Share (1)
               
Last
Week
   
Last
Week
   
52 Wks
Ago (2)
   
MostRcnt
YrEnd (2)
   
Assets/
Share
 
Financial Institution
 
High
   
Low
 
   
($)
     (000)    
($Mi1)
   
($)
   
($)
   
($)
   
(%)
   
(%)
   
(%)
   
($)
   
($)
   
($)
   
($)
   
($)
 
                                                                                       
Market Averages.
MHC Institutions
                                                                         
                                                                                       
All Public Companies (32)
    7.86       32,915       97.3       10.40       6.70       8.04       -3.05       -8.46       0.32       0.19       0.22       7.84       7.42       68.94  
NASDAQ Listed OTC Companies (32)
    7.86       32,915       97.3       10.40       6.70       8.04       -3.05       -8.46       0.32       0.19       0.22       7.84       7.42       68.94  
Mid-Atlantic Companies (17)
    7.93       26,299       89.4       10.80       7.20       8.19       -4.27       -16.01       -13.43       0.23       0.26       8.00       7.69       72.86  
Mid-West Companies (7)
    7.49       61,452       142.7       9.89       5.95       7.56       -1.12       -3.84       22.62       0.11       0.01       7.43       6.78       52.90  
New England Companies (5)
    8.15       14,916       58.6       9.69       5.95       8.19       -1.40       12.93       18.43       0.13       0.37       7.86       7.35       78.28  
Thrift Strategy (32)
    7.86       32,915       97.3       10.40       6.70       8.04       -3.05       -8.46       0.32       0.19       0.22       7.84       7.42       68.94  
Companies Issuing Dividends (22)
    8.22       14,547       41.5       10.80       7.16       8.35       -2.31       -12.62       -6.88       0.18       0.22       7.91       7.61       67.57  
Companies Without Dividends (10)
    7.09       71,945       215.8       9.57       5.73       7.39       -4.64       0.40       15.62       0.19       0.23       7.69       7.01       71.84  
Equity/Assets 6 - 12% (19)
    7.78       17,917       66.4       9.86       6.23       8.00       -3.97       -1.38       10.09       0.31       0.32       8.27       7.86       87.41  
Equity/Assets >12% (13)
    7.96       52,003       136.5       11.10       7.29       8.09       -1.88       -17.47       -12.12       0.03       0.09       7.30       6.86       45.43  
Market Value Below $20 Million (2)
    4.72       4,134       7.1       6.68       4.01       5.10       -8.29       -10.79       -3.55       0.72       0.59       8.79       8.02       126.73  
Holding Company Structure (29)
    7.91       34,204       101.5       10.35       6.69       8.07       -2.80       -6.47       2.35       0.18       0.21       7.99       7.53       70.75  
Assets Over $1 Billion (11)
    8.98       78,087       233.8       11.90       7.96       9.17       -2.13       -12.08       3.08       0.23       0.18       7.29       6.89       57.46  
Assets $500 Million-$l Billion (10)
    5.61       9,968       21.4       9.16       4.66       5.97       -6.29       -18.57       -18.87       -0.04       0.05       7.53       7.45       69.48  
Assets $250 - $500 Million (10)
    8.05       5,825       18.8       9.36       6.68       8.12       -2.12       4.07       11.83       0.31       0.40       8.66       8.14       84.34  
Assets less than $250 Million (l)
    9.57       7,851       29.9       13.77       7.80       9.60       -0.31       -27.94       -13.00       0.00       0.00       7.38       5.50       30.36  
Goodwill Companies (19)
    8.33       53,219       163.2       10.82       6.92       8.46       -1.67       -0.91       3.57       0.21       0.25       7.96       7.14       68.48  
Non-Goodwill Companies (13)
    7.36       10,918       25.8       9.95       6.46       7.59       -4.56       -16.63       -3.21       0.16       0.18       7.72       7.72       69.43  
MHC Institutions (32)
    7.86       32,915       97.3       10.40       6.70       8.04       -3.05       -8.46       0.32       0.19       0.22       7.84       7.42       68.94  
 
(1)
Average of high/low or bid/ask price per share.
(2)
Or since offering price if converted or first listed in the past 52 weeks. Percent change figures are actual year-to-date and are not annualized
(3)
EPS (earnings per share) is based on actual trailing twelve month data and is not shown on a pro forma basis.
(4)
Excludes intangibles (such as goodwill, value of core deposits, etc.).
(5)
ROA (return on assets) and ROE (return on equity) are indicated ratios based on trailing twelve month common earnings and average common equity and assets balances.
(6)
Annualized, based on last regular quarterly cash dividend announcement.
(7)
Indicated dividend as a percent of trailing twelve month earnings.
(8)
Excluded from averages due to actual or rumored acquisition activities or unusual operating characteristics.
(9)
For MHC institutions, market value reflects share price multiplied by public (non-MHC) shares.
   
*
Parentheses following market averages indicate the number of institutions included in the respective averages. All figures have been adjusted for stock splits, stock dividends, and secondary offerings.
 
Source:
SNL Financial, LC. and RP Financial, LC. calculations. The information provided in this table has been obtained from sources we believe are reliable, but we cannot guarantee the accuracy or completeness of such information.
 
Copyright (c) 2010 by RP Financial, LC.
 
 
 

 
 
RP FINANCIAL, LC.
 
Financial Services Industry Consultants
 
1100 North Glebe Road, Suite 1100
 
Arlington, Virginia 222011
 
(703) 528-1700
 
 
Exhibit 1 (continued)
Weekly Thrift Market Line - Part One
Prices As Of August 30, 2010
                                                                                       
                                         
Current Per Share Financials
 
     
Market Capitalization
   
Price Change Data
                     
Tangible
       
           
Shares
   
Market
   
52 Week (1)
         
% Change From
   
Trailing
   
12 Mo.
   
Book
   
Book
       
     
Price/
   
Outst-
   
Capital-
               
Last
   
Last
   
52 Wks
   
MostRcnt
   
12 Mo.
   
Core
   
Value/
   
Value/
   
Assets/
 
Financial Institution
 
Share (1)
   
anding
   
ization (9)
   
High
   
Low
   
Week
   
Week
   
Ago (2)
   
YrEnd (2)
   
EPS (3)
   
EPS (3)
   
Share
   
Share (4)
   
Share
 
     
($)
      (000)    
($Mil)
   
($)
   
($)
   
($)
   
(%)
   
(%)
   
(%)
   
($)
   
($)
   
($)
   
($)
   
($)
 
                                                                                         
NYSE Traded Companies
                                                                                     
AF
Astoria Financial Corp. of NY*
    11.90       97,892       1,164.9       17.55       9.24       12.20       -2.46       12.90       -4.26       0.46       0.39       12.53       10.64       200.94  
BBX
BankAtlantic Bancorp Inc of FL*
    1.15       53,921       62.0       4.17       1.13       1.36       -15.44       -72.29       -11.54       -3.28       -3.39       1.43       1.15       86.34  
FBC
Flagstar Bancorp, Inc. of MI*
    2.28       153,338       349.6       13.80       2.25       2.62       -12.98       -72.20       -62.00       -3.32       -4.97       5.47       5.47       93.47  
NYB
New York Community Bcrp of NY*
    15.60       435,505       6,793.9       18.20       10.20       16.05       -2.80       44.58       7.51       1.18       1.46       12.51       6.70       96.46  
NAL
NewAlliance Bancshares of CT*
    12.37       105,080       1,299.8       13.48       10.50       12.97       -4.63       5.10       3.00       0.55       0.54       13.93       8.62       82.91  
PFS
Provident Fin. Serv. Inc of NJ*
    11.31       59,924       677.7       14.10       9.75       11.78       -3.99       1.25       6.20       0.66       0.65       15.20       9.29       113.87  
                                                                                                                   
AMEX Traded Companies
                                                                                                               
TSH
Teche Hlding Cp of N Iberia LA*
    29.90       2,091       62.5       35.75       26.01       28.75       4.00       -9.86       -5.71       3.46       3.35       35.65       33.89       366.09  
                                                                                                                   
NASDAQ Listed OTC Companies
                                                                                                               
ABBC
Abington Bancorp, Inc. of PA*
    10.07       20,355       205.0       10.20       6.28       9.84       2.34       23.56       46.15       -0.26       -0.26       10.44       10.44       62.30  
ALLB
Alliance Bank MHC of PA (40.7)
    7.50       6,696       20.4       8.89       7.50       7.99       -6.13       -11.76       -10.71       0.15       0.15       7.25       7.25       66.97  
ABCW
Anchor BanCorp Wisconsin of WI (8)*
    0.63       21,683       13.7       1.55       0.37       0.62       1.61       -50.78       0.00       -6.12       -6.50       0.15       -0.18       184.43  
AFCB
Athens Bancshares, Inc. of TN*
    10.84       2,777       30.1       11.85       10.50       11.02       -1.63       8.40       8.40       0.06       0.07       18.08       17.92       101.54  
ACFC
At1 Cst Fed Cp of GA MHC (34.9) (8)
    2.40       13,423       11.2       4.25       1.18       2.30       4.35       14.29       58.94       -2.16       -1.86       4.20       4.19       68.09  
BCSB
BCSB Bancorp, Inc. of MD*
    9.75       3,121       30.4       10.50       8.05       9.75       0.00       13.24       8.94       -0.60       -0.64       16.17       16.15       199.40  
BKMU
Bank Mutual Corp of WI*
    5.05       45,710       230.8       9.11       5.03       5.54       -8.84       -42.81       -27.13       0.12       -0.16       8.69       7.51       76.19  
BFIN
BankFinancial Corp. of IL*
    8.80       21,060       185.3       10.50       8.12       8.67       1.50       -12.52       -11.11       0.01       0.04       12.32       11.08       74.34  
BFED
Beacon Federal Bancorp of NY*
    9.98       6,521       65.1       10.25       8.14       9.80       1.84       8.36       6.17       0.79       0.88       16.31       16.31       164.36  
BNCL
Beneficial Mut MHC of PA (44.1)
    8.36       81,700       301.5       11.05       8.17       8.63       -3.13       -7.21       -15.04       0.31       0.28       8.07       6.49       59.69  
BHLB
Berkshire Hills Bancorp of MA*
    17.57       14,037       246.6       23.81       16.20       18.38       -4.41       -22.57       -15.04       -1.11       -1.11       27.40       14.96       195.73  
BOFI
Bofi Holding, Inc. Of CA*
    11.15       10,l85       113.6       19.27       6.77       11.62       -4.04       53.79       11.50       2.01       1.45       12.25       12.25       139.53  
BYFC
Broadway Financial Corp. of CA*
    2.86       1,744       5.0       7.70       1.78       2.94       -2.72       -44.03       -52.17       -3.61       -3.45       9.90       9.90       316.27  
BRKL
Brookline Bancorp, Inc. of MA*
    9.15       59,038       540.2       11.63       8.63       9.22       -0.76       -13.68       -7.67       0.43       0.40       8.34       7.57       45.05  
BFSB
Brooklyn Fed MHC of NY (28.2)
    3.67       12,889       13.3       13.77       3.67       4.16       -11.78       -72.81       -63.45       -1.08       -0.41       5.68       5.68       40.68  
CITZ
CFS Bancorp, Inc of Munster IN*
    4.66       10,847       50.5       6.25       2.93       4.89       -4.70       12.02       44.27       -0.09       -0.06       10.40       10.39       100.98  
CMSB
CMS Bancorp Inc of W Plains NY*
    10.50       1,863       19.6       10.50       6.76       10.50       0.00       37.25       54.19       -0.13       -0.32       11.39       11.39       130.20  
CBNJ
Cape Bancorp, Inc. of NJ*
    7.50       13,314       99.9       8.75       5.35       7.58       -1.06       -9.42       11.61       -1.24       -1.07       9.83       8.09       80.54  
CFFN
Capitol Fd Fn MHC of KS (29.5) (8)
    25.56       73,991       557.0       38.49       25.51       28.68       -10.88       -21.16       -18.75       0.94       0.93       12.97       12.97       115.46  
CARV
Carver Bancorp, Inc. of NY*
    4.82       2,483       12.0       9.66       4.25       5.34       -9.74       -17.04       -46.74       -1.67       -1.41       16.29       16.21       323.77  
CEBK
Central Bncrp of Somerville MA*
    10.03       1,667       16.7       14.17       7.96       10.87       -7.73       19.26       20.84       1.09       1.17       21.50       20.16       315.99  
CFBK
Central Federal Corp. of OH*
    1.10       4,093       4.5       3.00       0.83       1.10       0.00       -59.41       -26.67       -3.65       -3.76       2.47       2.43       67.21  
CHEV
Cheviot Fin Cp MHC of OH (38.5)
    8.50       8,865       29.0       9.55       7.00       8.35       1.80       1.07       15.02       0.19       0.17       7.91       7.91       39.60  
CBNK
Chicopee Bancorp, Inc. of MA*
    11.02       6,335       69.8       13.95       10.79       11.26       -2.13       -15.30       -11.70       -0.23       -0.11       14.93       14.93       87.92  
CZWI
Citizens Comm Bncorp Inc of WI*
    4.35       5,113       22.2       5.30       3.01       4.30       1.16       -14.87       27.94       0.15       0.30       11.03       9.76       112.73  
CSBC
Citizens South Bnkg Corp of NC*
    5.51       10,966       60.4       7.24       4.40       5.72       -3.67       -5.00       20.31       -1.93       -0.80       6.92       6.74       98.25  
CSBK
Clifton Svg Bp MHC of NJ (36.4)
    8.21       26,137       78.9       10.89       8.13       8.33       -1.44       -21.96       -12.38       0.29       0.29       6.71       6.71       42.61  
COBK
Colonial Financial Serv. of NJ*
    9.75       4,173       40.7       10.85       5.86       9.80       -0.51       22.18       26.30       0.48       0.71       15.78       15.78       140.68  
CFFC
Community Fin. Corp. of VA*
    4.35       4,362       19.0       5.29       3.32       4.19       3.82       11.54       0.23       0.71       0.71       8.62       8.62       126.62  
DNBK
Danvers Bancorp, Inc. of MA*
    14.96       21,375       319.8       17.09       12.32       15.53       -3.67       15.61       15.17       0.61       0.56       13.76       12.17       118.33  
DCOM
Dime Community Bancshars of NY*
    12.26       34,548       423.6       14.32       10.25       12.56       -2.39       4.34       4.52       1.04       1.07       9.11       7.50       120.07  
ESBF
ESB Financial Corp. of PA*
    12.67       12,039       152.5       14.96       10.62       12.20       3.85       -7.04       -4.16       1.07       1.12       14.41       10.87       161.78  
ESSA
ESSA Bancorp, Inc. of PA*
    10.99       13,523       148.6       13.75       10.62       10.92       0.64       -17.12       -6.07       0.36       0.32       13.06       13.06       78.91  
EBMT
Eagle Bancorp Montanta of MT*
    9.20       4,083       37.6       11.58       7.50       9.32       -1.29       27.07       7.10       0.79       0.79       12.29       12.29       79.90  
ESBK
Elmira Svgs Bank, FSB of NY*
    16.00       1,959       31.3       17.20       13.06       15.35       4.23       -3.38       -4.48       1.67       1.26       19.26       12.62       254.85  
FFDF
FFD Financial Corp of Dover OH*
    14.98       1,011       15.1       15.50       11.83       14.50       3.31       12.21       10.31       0.91       0.70       17.89       17.89       196.95  
FFCO
FedFirst Fin MHC of PA (42.5) (8)
    4.90       6,324       13.2       6.95       3.20       4.70       4.26       15.29       44.12       0.14       0.14       6.95       6.73       56.32  
FSBI
Fidelity Bancorp, Inc. of PA*
    5.08       3,049       15.5       10.50       4.00       5.08       0.00       -24.74       1.40       -1.07       -0.43       13.62       12.74       232.24  
FABK
First Advantage Bancorp of TN*
    10.72       4,188       44.9       10.98       9.85       10.72       0.00       8.83       1.04       0.17       0.16       16.25       16.25       82.40  
FBSI
First Bancshares, Inc. of MO*
    8.50       1,551       13.2       10.95       6.80       8.75       -2.86       -2.97       2.66       -0.58       -0.65       15.46       15.37       137.84  
FCAP
First Capital, Inc. of IN*
    15.05       2,788       42.0       17.88       13.17       15.12       -0.46       -7.10       -0.92       0.85       0.73       17.13       15.15       164.27  
FCLF
First Clover Leaf Fin Cp of IL*
    5.40       7,938       42.9       8.00       5.19       5.28       2.27       -30.32       -26.53       0.15       0.12       9.80       8.21       70.95  
FCFL
First Community Bk Corp of FL*
    1.17       5,457       6.4       4.99       1.10       1.42       -17.61       -67.68       -51.45       -3.05       -3.17       3.59       3.59       94.63  
FDEF
First Defiance Fin. Corp of OH*
    9.07       8,118       73.6       18.93       8.53       10.12       -10.38       -48.32       -19.66       0.30       0.11       24.89       16.96       251.13  
FFNM
First Fed of N. Michigan of MI*
    2.49       2,884       7.2       2.79       1.02       2.42       2.89       27.69       104.10       -2.21       -2.28       8.15       7.88       78.69  
FFBH
First Fed. Bancshares of AR*
    1.72       4,847       8.3       4.69       1.50       1.67       2.99       -60.73       -24.89       -8.75       -8.82       5.82       5.82       139.90  
FFNW
First Fin NW, Inc of Renton WA*
    3.95       18,805       74.3       7.64       3.63       4.20       -5.95       -45.89       -39.69       -3.01       -3.07       9.93       9.93       69.48  
FFCH
First Fin. Holdings Inc. of SC*
    9.30       16,527       153.7       18.64       9.28       10.06       -7.55       -46.55       -28.46       -2.46       -2.30       15.66       13.34       201.15  
FFHS
First Franklin Corp. of OH*
    7.77       1,686       13.1       16.49       4.91       7.03       10.53       26.34       -2.75       -1.45       -2.33       12.94       12.94       166.67  
FPTB
First PacTrust Bancorp of CA*
    9.45       4,244       40.1       10.76       4.44       9.60       -1.56       37.96       76.64       -0.40       -0.35       18.21       18.21       207.70  
 
 
 

 
 
RP FINANCIAL, LC.
 
Financial Services Industry Consultants
 
1100 North Glebe Road, Suite 1100
 
Arlington, Virginia 222011
 
(703) 528-1700
 
 
Exhibit 1 (continued)
Weekly Thrift Market Line - Part One
Prices As Of August 30, 2010
                                                                                       
                                         
Current Per Share Financials
 
     
Market Capitalization
   
Price Change Data
                     
Tangible
       
           
Shares
   
Market
   
52 Week (1)
         
% Change From
   
Trailing
   
12 Mo.
   
Book
   
Book
       
     
Price/
   
Outst-
   
Capital-
               
Last
   
Last
   
52 Wks
   
MostRcnt
   
12 Mo.
   
Core
   
Value/
   
Value/
   
Assets/
 
Financial Institution
 
Share (1)
   
anding
   
ization (9)
   
High
   
Low
   
Week
   
Week
   
Ago (2)
   
YrEnd (2)
   
EPS (3)
   
EPS (3)
   
Share
   
Share (4)
   
Share
 
     
($)
      (000)    
($Mil)
   
($)
   
($)
   
($)
   
(%)
   
(%)
   
(%)
   
($)
   
($)
   
($)
   
($)
   
($)
 
                                                                                         
NASDAQ Listed OTC
Companies (continued)
                                                                                     
FPFC
First Place Fin. Corp. of OH*
    3.64       16,974       61.8       5.71       2.43       3.68       -1.09       12.35       31.41       -2.04       -2.86       10.82       10.30       185.79  
FSFG
First Savings Fin. Grp. of IN*
    13.36       2,415       32.3       14.22       10.02       13.40       -0.30       23.70       27.85       0.97       1.26       22.18       18.67       207.66  
FFIC
Flushing Fin. Corp. of NY*
    10.88       31,238       339.9       15.00       10.17       11.58       -6.04       -17.82       -3.37       0.87       0.96       12.15       11.58       136.12  
FXCB
Fox Chase Bancorp, Inc. of PA*
    9.43       14,547       137.2       11.22       8.00       9.35       0.86       4.89       5.96       -0.08       -0.08       13.88       13.88       84.75  
GSLA
GS Financial Corp. of LA*
    12.25       1,258       15.4       16.48       9.36       11.10       10.36       -23.53       -18.28       0.07       -0.45       22.57       22.57       217.77  
GCBC
Green Co Bcrp MHC of NY (44.1)
    17.25       4,119       31.3       18.50       13.84       16.40       5.18       19.05       12.16       1.19       1.19       10.80       10.80       120.25  
HFFC
HF Financial Corp. of SD*
    9.39       6,942       65.2       13.00       8.05       9.50       -1.16       -26.35       -3.40       0.93       0.70       13.50       12.79       177.83  
HMNF
HMN Financial, Inc. of MN*
    3.85       4,310       16.6       6.85       3.20       4.32       -10.88       -1.53       -8.33       -2.42       -2.69       15.27       15.27       226.27  
HBNK
Hampden Bancorp, Inc. of MA*
    10.10       7,151       72.2       11.07       9.01       10.02       0.80       -4.63       -5.16       -0.12       -0.12       13.13       13.13       80.81  
HARL
Harleysville Svgs Fin Cp of PA*
    15.00       3,674       55.1       16.20       12.02       15.42       -2.72       7.14       8.23       1.35       1.36       14.29       14.29       236.01  
HBOS
Heritage Fn Gp MHC of GA (24.3) (8)
    8.69       10,398       22.0       13.39       6.51       9.21       -5.65       -0.11       19.86       -0.12       -0.17       5.93       5.78       55.24  
HIFS
Hingham Inst. for Sav. of MA*
    38.49       2,124       81.8       38.50       28.31       35.09       9.69       21.23       25.42       4.32       4.28       32.47       32.47       457.52  
HBCP
Home Bancorp Inc. Lafayette LA*
    13.00       8,481       110.3       14.49       11.91       13.00       0.00       8.24       6.64       0.45       0.58       15.65       15.43       83.64  
HOME
Home Federal Bancorp Inc of ID*
    12.35       16,688       206.1       16.12       11.05       12.47       -0.96       8.43       -7.21       0.35       -0.61       12.33       12.33       52.09  
HFBC
HopFed Bancorp, Inc. of KY*
    9.05       6,942       62.8       15.03       8.91       9.40       -3.72       -11.36       -3.10       0.36       0.16       13.80       13.66       159.38  
HCBK
Hudson City Bancorp, Inc of NJ*
    11.42       526,611       6.013.9       14.75       11.35       11.96       -4.52       -11.27       -16.82       1.07       0.99       10.53       10.23       115.71  
ISBC
Investors Bcrp MHC of NJ (43.6)
    10.59       114,894       530.0       14.50       9.06       11.16       -5.11       13.99       -3.20       0.45       0.40       7.74       7.52       77.17  
JXSB
Jacksonville Bancorp Inc of IL*
    10.25       1,924       19.7       15.97       8.12       10.12       1.28       -2.10       9.16       0.79       0.52       18.27       16.85       155.11  
JFBI
Jefferson Bancshares Inc of TN*
    3.62       6,659       24.1       7.28       3.05       3.39       6.78       -38.64       -23.63       0.16       0.04       12.03       8.37       99.59  
KFED
K-Fed Bancorp MHC of CA (33.3) (8)
    7.38       13,290       32.7       10.39       7.26       7.42       -0.54       -15.27       -16.04       0.19       0.21       7.00       6.69       67.20  
KFFB
KY Fst Fed Bp MHC of KY (39.8)
    9.57       7,851       29.9       13.77       7.80       9.60       -0.31       -27.94       -13.00       0.00       0.00       7.38       5.50       30.36  
KRNY
Kearny Fin Cp MHC of NJ (26.0)
    8.66       68,344       155.2       11.07       8.41       8.87       -2.37       -20.48       -14.00       0.09       0.10       7.05       5.85       32.95  
LSBX
LSB Corp of No. Andover MA (8) *
    20.85       4,507       94.0       20.99       9.40       20.71       0.68       112.54       114.73       1.17       0.77       14.22       14.22       176.82  
LSBI
LSB Fin. Corp. of Lafayette IN*
    9.76       1,554       15.2       13.00       8.27       9.71       0.51       -20.97       -0.41       0.54       0.29       22.20       22.20       243.62  
LPSB
LaPorte Bancrp MHC of IN (45.0)
    7.05       4,586       14.6       8.04       4.14       7.03       0.28       41.00       60.23       0.60       0.44       10.92       8.91       95.61  
LSBK
Lake Shore Bnp MHC of NY (40.2)
    8.20       6,075       20.1       8.50       7.46       8.25       -0.61       4.06       4.33       0.46       0.46       9.49       9.49       75.79  
LEGC
Legacy Bancorp, Inc. of MA*
    8.16       8,702       71.0       11.52       7.64       8.26       -1.21       -27.21       -17.24       -0.93       -0.48       13.66       11.90       109.89  
LABC
Louisiana Bancorp, Inc. of LA*
    14.56       4,208       61.3       16.59       13.65       14.80       -1.62       5.13       0.41       0.58       0.50       15.97       15.97       77.89  
MSBF
MSB Fin Corp MHC of NJ (40.9)
    6.90       5,226       14.7       9.45       6.37       7.26       -4.96       -23.33       -13.10       0.08       0.10       7.67       7.67       69.34  
MGYR
Magyar Bancorp MHC of NJ (44.7)
    3.43       5,783       8.9       5.36       2.91       3.89       -11.83       -14.46       -14.25       0.69       0.55       7.60       7.60       93.97  
MLVF
Malvern Fed Bncp MHC PA (44.6)
    7.50       6,103       20.4       9.85       7.30       8.20       -8.54       -23.08       -21.79       -0.16       -0.19       11.21       11.21       113.93  
MFLR
Mayflower Bancorp, Inc. of MA*
    8.20       2,086       17.1       8.93       5.68       8.15       0.61       3.80       22.39       0.56       0.31       9.82       9.81       122.50  
EBSB
Meridian Fn Serv MHC MA (41.8)
    10.58       22,506       100.0       12.30       8.20       10.95       -3.38       11.25       21.61       0.44       0.40       9.17       8.67       76.79  
CASH
Meta Financial Group of IA*
    33.15       3,083       102.2       37.88       17.10       35.00       -5.29       51.72       58.61       2.98       2.41       22.64       21.75       311.81  
MFSF
MutualFirst Fin. Inc. of IN*
    7.01       6,985       49.0       9.71       5.51       7.20       -2.64       -9.43       17.22       0.20       0.30       14.69       13.95       206.43  
NASB
NASB Fin, Inc. of Grandview MO*
    13.49       7,868       106.1       31.78       12.71       13.85       -2.60       -55.70       -42.08       1.29       -2.38       21.01       20.68       179.96  
NECB
NE Comm Bncrp MHC of NY (45.0)
    6.15       13,225       36.6       7.85       4.40       5.89       4.41       -15.17       -6.39       -0.18       -0.18       8.15       8.0 l     39.09  
NHTB
NH Thrift Bancshares of NH*
    10.10       5,772       58.3       11.93       8.77       10.20       -0.98       -0.49       4.23       1.20       0.64       14.30       9.26       172.07  
NVSL
Naug Vlly Fin MHC of CT (40.4) (8)
    6.47       7,023       18.4       7.42       4.11       6.05       6.94       43.78       12.72       0.34       0.33       7.29       7.28       80.49  
NFSB
Newport Bancorp, Inc. of RI*
    11.93       3,639       43.4       12.99       10.91       11.88       0.42       -3.01       -2.61       0.34       0.37       13.86       13.86       123.77  
FFFD
North Central Bancshares of IA*
    15.27       1,351       20.6       19.66       13.33       13.85       10.25       -0.52       -4.38       1.10       0.91       28.50       28.50       334.66  
NFBK
Northfield Bcp MHC of NY (43.6) (8)
    10.99       43,541       209.7       15.30       10.57       11.00       -0.09       -11.58       -18.71       0.34       0.32       9.18       8.81       50.71  
NWBI
Northwest Bancshares Inc of PA*
    10.56       110,775       1.169.8       12.79       8.87       10.96       -3.65       14.78       -6.30       0.38       0.48       11.83       10.24       73.45  
OBAF
OBA Financial Serv. Inc of MD*
    11.00       4,629       50.9       11.50       9.95       11.12       -1.08       10.00       10.00       -0.23       0.11       17.27       17.27       81.79  
OSHC
Ocean Shore Holding Co. of NJ*
    10.70       7,308       78.2       11.81       7.68       10.38       3.08       14.19       19.55       0.71       0.71       13.66       13.66       109.30  
OCFC
OceanFirst Fin. Corp of NJ*
    11.09       18,823       208.7       13.56       9.37       11.86       -6.49       -17.30       -1.77       0.81       0.75       10.35       10.35       117.92  
OABC
OmniAmerican Bancorp Inc of TX*
    11.17       11,903       133.0       12.35       10.12       11.25       -0.71       11.70       11.70       0.11       -0.04       16.88       16.88       94.94  
ONFC
Oneida Financial Corp. of NY*
    7.75       7,165       55.5       10.95       7.25       7.69       0.78       -17.29       -20.92       0.52       0.53       11.69       8.22       86.93  
ORIT
Oritani Financial Corp of NJ*
    9.22       56,202       518.2       11.43       8.31       9.43       -2.23       -0.86       0.77       0.27       0.26       11.18       11.18       43.49  
PSBH
PSB Hldgs Inc MHC of CT (42.9)
    3.97       6,529       11.1       5.33       2.61       4.30       -7.67       4.75       16.76       -0.71       0.35       6.78       5.65       75.84  
PVFC
PVF Capital Corp. of Solon OH*
    1.93       25,642       49.5       4.39       1.58       1.98       -2.53       -11.87       -0.52       -0.15       -0.34       3.33       3.33       34.68  
PFED
Park Bancorp of Chicago IL*
    4.27       1,193       5.1       8.60       3.14       4.26       0.23       -39.94       31.38       -4.07       -4.05       18.22       18.22       179.48  
PVSA
Parkvale Financial Corp of PA*
    6.46       5,529       35.7       12.39       6.25       7.11       -9.14       -28.22       -7.05       -3.27       -3.02       15.77       10.61       333.22  
PBHC
Pathfinder BC MHC of NY (36.3)
    6.00       2,485       5.4       8.00       5.11       6.30       -4.76       -7.12       7.14       0.74       0.63       9.97       8.43       159.49  
PEOP
Peoples Fed Bancshrs Inc of MA*
    10.30       7,142       73.6       10.85       10.10       10.37       -0.68       3.00       3.00       0.28       0.22       15.45       15.45       76.39  
PBCT
Peoples United Financial of CT*
    12.63       367,700       4,644.1       17.16       12.62       13.24       -4.61       -21.31       -24.37       0.22       0.23       14.72       9.89       59.70  
PROV
Provident Fin. Holdings of CA*
    5.38       11,407       61.4       10.49       2.43       5.33       0.94       -34.15       94.93       0.10       -0.86       11.20       11.20       122.68  
PBNY
Provident NY Bncrp, Inc. of NY*
    7.92       38,628       305.9       10.62       7.86       8.07       -1.86       -15.47       -6.16       0.52       0.41       11.11       6.84       76.72  
PBIP
Prudential Bncp MHC PA (29.3)
    6.30       10,031       19.1       11.15       5.52       7.05       -10.64       -40.68       -33.82       0.32       0.35       5.63       5.63       53.66  
PULB
Pulaski Fin Cp of St. Louis MO*
    6.25       10,307       64.4       8.64       5.50       6.48       -3.55       -27.66       -6.72       -0.12       -0.39       8.07       7.67       134.67  
RIVR
River Valley Bancorp of IN*
    14.95       1,510       22.6       16.45       11.36       14.61       2.33       22.04       19.60       1.81       1.55       17.91       17.86       261.22  
RVSB
Riverview Bancorp, Inc. of WA*
    1.92       10,924       21.0       4.39       1.76       1.98       -3.03       -41.64       -14.29       -0.37       -0.36       7.85       5.48       79.04  
RCKB
Rockville Fin MHC of CT (43.3)
    11.43       18,853       93.3       14.12       8.82       10.90       4.86       -19.05       8.86       0.61       0.57       8.61       8.55       84.97  
ROMA
Roma Fin Corp MHC of NJ (26.9)
    10.26       30,781       85.4       13.19       10.11       10.51       -2.38       -19.15       -16.99       0.14       0.19       7.03       7.01       47.33  
ROME
Rome Bancorp, Inc. of Rome NY*
    9.31       6,778       63.1       9.95       7.61       9.32       -0.11       7.01       16.96       0.53       0.49       9.04       9.04       48.63  
 
 
 

 
 
RP FINANCIAL, LC.
 
Financial Services Industry Consultants
 
1100 North Glebe Road, Suite 1100
 
Arlington, Virginia 222011
 
(703) 528-1700
 
 
Exhibit 1 (continued)
Weekly Thrift Market Line - Part One
Prices As Of August 30, 2010
                                                                                       
                                         
Current Per Share Financials
 
     
Market Capitalization
   
Price Change Data
                     
Tangible
       
           
Shares
   
Market
   
52 Week (1)
         
% Change From
   
Trailing
   
12 Mo.
   
Book
   
Book
       
     
Price/
   
Outst-
   
Capital-
               
Last
   
Last
   
52 Wks
   
MostRcnt
   
12 Mo.
   
Core
   
Value/
   
Value/
   
Assets/
 
Financial Institution
 
Share (1)
   
anding
   
ization (9)
   
High
   
Low
   
week
   
week
   
Ago (2)
   
YrEnd (2)
   
EPS (3)
   
EPS (3)
   
Share
   
Share (4)
   
Share
 
     
($)
      (000)    
($Mil)
   
($)
   
($)
   
($)
   
(%)
   
(%)
   
(%)
   
($)
   
($)
   
($)
   
($)
   
($)
 
                                                                                         
NASDAQ Listed OTC
Companies (continued)
                                                                                     
SIFI
SI Fin Gp Inc MHC of CT (38.2)
    6.64       11,777       29.9       7.00       4.15       6.60       0.61       54.78       26.48       0.19       0.17       6.89       6.54       75.52  
SVBI
Severn Bancorp, Inc. of MD*
    4.01       10,067       40.4       6.57       1.55       4.37       -8.24       7.22       59.13       -0.86       -0.88       7.85       7.82       99.56  
SUPR
Superior Bancorp of AL (8)*
    1.16       12,560       14.6       4.50       1.13       1.32       -12.12       -57.04       -64.74       -5.80       -6.35       11.02       9.85       267.38  
THRD
TF Fin. Corp. of Newtown PA*
    22.11       2,685       59.4       22.99       17.66       22.49       -1.69       18.24       16.55       1.47       1.27       27.31       25.62       268.44  
TFSL
TFS Fin Corp MHC of OH (26.3)
    8.98       308,315       729.1       14.46       8.98       9.23       -2.71       -21.50       - 26.03       0.03       -0.04       5.71       5.68       35.48  
TBNK
Territorial Bancorp, Inc of HI*
    16.88       12,233       206.5       21.23       15.47       17.37       -2.82       5.50       -6.48       0.69       0.91       18.23       18.23       118.27  
TSBK
Timberland Bancorp, Inc. of WA*
    3.90       7,045       27.5       5.33       2.90       3.95       -1.27       -14.85       -12.16       -0.45       -0.27       9.93       9.04       103.96  
TRST
TrustCo Bank Corp NY of NY*
    5.33       76,873       409.7       7.18       5.22       5.46       -2.38       -15.66       -15.40       0.40       0.37       3.32       3.31       49.81  
UCBA
United Comm Bncp MHC IN (40.7)
    7.05       7,846       22.5       8.00       6.06       7.21       -2.22       8.96       14.63       0.10       0.09       7.11       7.11       56.16  
UCFC
United Community Fin. of OH*
    1.20       30,898       37.1       2.30       1.15       1.33       -9.77       -13.67       -17.24       -0.88       -1.08       6.88       6.87       74.90  
UBNK
United Financial Bncrp of MA*
    13.50       16,359       220.8       15.16       11.31       13.76       -1.89       9.85       2.97       0.48       0.59       13.64       13.13       94.44  
UWBK
United Western Bncp, Inc of CO*
    0.45       29,377       13.2       5.56       0.44       0.52       -13.46       -91.62       -83.70       -3.17       -2.07       3.99       3.99       75.61  
VPFG
ViewPoint Financal Group of TX*
    8.95       34,865       312.0       12.73       8.61       9.31       -3.87       -0.89       -13.02       0.13       0.35       10.76       10.73       75.77  
WSB
WSB Holdings, Inc. of Bowie MD*
    2.30       7,896       18.2       4.65       1.70       2.50       -8.00       0.44       -0.86       -0.80       -0.87       6.61       6.61       52.90  
WSFS
WSFS Financia1 Corp. of DE*
    36.83       7,117       262.1       46.00       24.16       37.00       -0.46       28.10       43.70       0.16       0.48       36.90       35.02       532.79  
WVFC
WVS Financial Corp. of PA*
    10.30       2,057       21.2       15.71       8.31       11.50       -10.43       -32.24       -27.72       0.44       0.52       14.15       14.15       183.37  
WFSL
Washington Federa1, Inc. of WA*
    14.05       112,474       1,580.3       21.65       14.04       14.98       -6.21       -8.05       -27.35       0.94       1.32       16.15       13.87    
122.72
 
WSBF
Waterstone Fin MHC of WI (26.2)
    3.79       31,250       31.1       5.49       1.75       3.93       -3.56       -24.65       84.88       -0.28       -0.58       5.55       5.55       60.19  
WAYN
Wayne Savings Bancshares of OH*
    8.00       3,004       24.0       9.06       4.80       8.00       0.00       50.94       37.69       0.78       0.71       12.64       11.95       135.64  
WFD
Westfield Fin. Inc. of MA*
    7.58       29,244       221.7       10.37       7.23       7.48       1.34       -17.79       -8.12       0.14       0.13       8.19       8.19       42.23  

 
 

 
 
RP FINANCIAL, LC.
 
Financial Services Industry Consultants
 
1100 North Glebe Road, Suite 1100
 
Arlington, Virginia 22201
 
(703) 528-1700
 
 
Exhibit 1
Weekly Thrift Market Line - Part Two
Prices As Of August 30, 2010
                                                                                            
   
Key Financial Ratios
 
Asset Quality Ratios
 
Pricing Ratios
 
Dividend Data (6)
   
Equity/
Assets
 
Tang.
Equity/
Assets
                     
NPAs
Assets
 
Resvs/
NPAs
 
Resvs/
Loans
 
Price/
Earning
 
Price/
Book
 
Price/
Assets
 
Price/
Tang.
Book
 
Price/
Core
Earnings
 
Ind.
Div./
Share
 
Divi-
dend
Yield
 
Payout
Ratio (7)
       
Reported Earnings
 
Core Earnings
                     
Financial Institution
     
ROA (5)
 
ROE (5)
 
ROI (5)
 
ROA (5)
 
ROE (5)
                     
   
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(x)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(x)
 
($)
 
(%)
 
(%)
                                                                                           
Market Averages. All Public
Companies (no MHCs)
                                                                         
                                                                                           
All Public Companies (110)
   
11.13
 
10.33
   
-0.16
 
0.33
   
2.40
 
-0.22
   
-0.66
 
4.06
   
56.54
 
1.77
   
18.42
 
69.54
   
8.07
 
77.31
   
17.62
 
0.24
   
2.05
 
31.48
NYSE Traded Companies (6)
   
9.48
 
6.61
   
-0.69
 
5.64
   
5.43
 
-0.94
   
6.08
 
4.69
   
38.02
 
2 .56
   
19.68
 
84.16
   
8.45
 
125.27
   
20.38
 
0.37
   
2.82
 
58.79
AMEX Traded Companies (1)
   
9.74
 
9.30
   
0.94
 
9.99
   
11.57
 
0.91
   
9.68
 
2.35
   
49.04
 
1.48
   
8.64
 
83.87
   
8.17
 
88.23
   
8.93
 
1.42
   
4.75
 
41.04
NASDAQ Listed OTC Companies (103)
   
11.24
 
10.56
   
-0.14
 
0.00
   
2.15
 
-0.19
   
-1.04
 
4.04
   
58.63
 
1.72
   
18.51
 
68.52
   
8.04
 
74.32
   
17.57
 
0.22
   
1.98
 
30.08
California Companies (4)
   
7.45
 
7.45
   
0.05
 
-0.12
   
5.22
 
-0.23
   
-3.50
 
9.57
   
34.62
 
2.69
   
5.55
 
54.96
   
4.46
 
54.96
   
7.69
 
0.07
   
1.06
 
20.00
Florida Companies (2)
   
2.72
 
2.56
   
-3.33
 
-38.41
   
0.00
 
-3.46
   
-39.92
 
12.73
   
31.70
 
3.63
   
NM
 
56.51
   
1.28
 
66.30
   
NM
 
0.00
   
0.00
 
0.00
Mid-Atlantic Companies (34)
   
11.14
 
10.16
   
0.22
 
2.30
   
2.37
 
0.24
   
2.57
 
2.55
   
55.58
 
1.39
   
17.15
 
81.54
   
9.09
 
93.83
   
17.24
 
0.33
   
2.89
 
49.09
Mid-West Companies (31)
   
9.21
 
8.7l
   
-0.39
 
-0.79
   
3.11
 
-0.62
   
-2.91
 
4.84
   
40.52
 
2.07
   
18.66
 
56.60
   
5.22
 
60.05
   
17.39
 
0.19
   
1.78
 
21.61
New England Companies (17)
   
14.17
 
12.56
   
0.30
 
2.80
   
2.86
 
0.30
   
2.67
 
1.08
   
123.75
 
1.14
   
20.95
 
83.20
   
11.87
 
97.55
   
20.82
 
0.30
   
2.29
 
28.50
North-West Companies (4)
   
11.73
 
10.43
   
-1.10
 
-6.73
   
-8.04
 
-0.99
   
-5.81
 
8.74
   
26.40
 
2.39
   
14.95
 
47.63
   
5.83
 
54.81
   
10.64
 
0.05
   
0.36
 
21.28
South-East Companies (12)
   
12.25
 
11.76
   
-0.54
 
-0.90
   
1.78
 
-0.44
   
0.17
 
4.07
   
63.01
 
2.11
   
18.28
 
62.49
   
8.20
 
65.37
   
16.65
 
0.23
   
1.53
 
8.21
South-West Companies (2)
   
15.99
 
15.97
   
0.15
 
1.23
   
1.22
 
0.21
   
1.93
 
0.85
   
60.85
 
1.02
   
NM
 
74.68
   
11.79
 
74.79
   
25.57
 
0.08
   
0.89
 
0.00
Western Companies (Excl CA) (4)
   
14.94
 
14.94
   
-0.36
 
3.57
   
5.17
 
-0.48
   
-13.53
 
0.25
   
48.36
 
1.94
   
23.80
 
69.72
   
12.52
 
69.72
   
15.10
 
0.20
   
1.62
 
46.29
Thrift Strategy (104)
   
11.16
 
10.40
   
-0.13
 
0.38
   
2.56
 
-0.19
   
-0.48
 
3.65
   
57.75
 
1.68
   
18.42
 
69.30
   
8.08
 
76.79
   
17.62
 
0.24
   
2.08
 
31.30
Mortgage Banker Strategy (3)
   
5.39
 
5.23
   
-1.77
 
0.95
   
1.86
 
-2.21
   
-8.18
 
10.29
   
35.66
 
4.41
   
NM
 
64.23
   
2.86
 
74.02
   
NM
 
0.02
   
0.37
 
40.00
Real Estate Strategy (1)
   
9.60
 
9.60
   
-0.43
 
-6.38
   
-7.77
 
-0.98
   
-14.47
 
9.73
   
35.01
 
4.69
   
NM
 
57.96
   
5.57
 
57.96
   
NM
 
0.00
   
0.00
 
0.00
Diversified Strategy (2)
   
15.79
 
12.31
   
0.21
 
0.96
   
1.09
 
0.24
   
1.38
 
2.30
   
71.35
 
1.80
   
NM
 
92.81
   
14.03
 
116.44
   
NM
 
0.55
   
3.11
 
0.00
Companies Issuing Dividends (69)
   
11.46
 
10.44
   
0.31
 
2.85
   
3.81
 
0.28
   
2.66
 
2.81
   
56.14
 
1.47
   
17.48
 
79.45
   
9.29
 
90.16
   
17.35
 
0.38
   
3.22
 
44.07
Companies Without Dividends (41)
   
10.55
 
10.14
   
-0.99
 
-4.80
   
-1.06
 
-1.10
   
-7.19
 
6.06
   
57.17
 
2.27
   
21.69
 
52.25
   
5.94
 
54.90
   
18.90
 
0.00
   
0.00
 
0.00
Equity/Assets <6% (14)
   
4.58
 
4.35
   
-2.43
 
-13.91
   
-11.49
 
-2.51
   
-17.61
 
8.10
   
41.08
 
3.41
   
NM
 
40.66
   
1. 80
 
44.72
   
NM
 
0.07
   
1.19
 
0.00
Equity/Assets 6-12% (58)
   
8.88
 
8.37
   
0.11
 
1.86
   
3.32
 
0.02
   
0.79
 
4.00
   
56.83
 
1.66
   
15.55
 
70.56
   
6.12
 
75.87
   
15.93
 
0.28
   
2.16
 
30.14
Equity/Assets >12% (38)
   
16.56
 
15.16
   
0.14
 
0.66
   
1.84
 
0.13
   
0.82
 
2.44
   
62.65
 
1.39
   
23.49
 
77.12
   
12.97
 
89.76
   
20.81
 
0.23
   
2.15
 
34.24
Converted Last 3 Mths (no MHC) (7)
   
16.14
 
15.43
   
0.36
 
3.66
   
3.66
 
0.39
   
4.12
 
0.85
   
60.85
 
1.24
   
23.82
 
69.21
   
11.44
 
73.91
   
21.82
 
0.18
   
2.12
 
12.66
Actively Traded Companies (5)
   
8.71
 
7.93
   
0.25
 
3.06
   
0.58
 
0.35
   
3.95
 
0.00
   
0.00
 
1.70
   
11.02
 
77.89
   
6.91
 
84.83
   
9.40
 
0.38
   
1.99
 
20.31
Market Value Below $20 Million (23)
   
7.64
 
7.54
   
-1.25
 
-6.94
   
0.56
 
-1.27
   
-9.60
 
6.10
   
37.39
 
2.34
   
12.91
 
45.41
   
3.66
 
46.02
   
19.32
 
0.10
   
0.99
 
28.98
Holding Company Structure (105)
   
11.16
 
10.35
   
-0.19
 
0.02
   
2.01
 
-0.25
   
-0.92
 
4.06
   
56.54
 
1.78
   
18.78
 
68.91
   
8.06
 
76.63
   
17.76
 
0.23
   
2.06
 
31.50
Assets Over $1 Billion (52)
   
11.48
 
10.33
   
-0.14
 
0.98
   
2.35
 
-0.19
   
-0.44
 
3.85
   
55.59
 
1.78
   
19.34
 
76.37
   
9.05
 
88.61
   
18.77
 
0.25
   
2.38
 
38.38
Assets $500 Million-$l Billion (33)
   
10.27
 
9.59
   
-0.16
 
-0.13
   
1.74
 
-0.22
   
-0.47
 
5.20
   
45.49
 
1.89
   
18.40
 
61.60
   
6.77
 
66.37
   
12.97
 
0.22
   
1.58
 
21.80
Assets $250-$500 Million (20)
   
11.90
 
11.64
   
-0.01
 
2.01
   
4.03
 
-0.10
   
1.02
 
3.04
   
85.05
 
1.56
   
16.78
 
68.30
   
8.35
 
71.56
   
20.20
 
0.27
   
2.24
 
28.45
Assets less than $250 Million (5)
   
9.91
 
9.84
   
-1.00
 
-9.12
   
-0.66
 
-1.07
   
-9.93
 
3.11
   
31.58
 
1.58
   
16.46
 
56.98
   
5.48
 
57.25
   
21.40
 
0.14
   
0.91
 
74.73
Goodwill Companies (65)
   
10.36
 
9.01
   
-0.03
 
1.12
   
1.98
 
-0.05
   
0.86
 
3.35
   
56.98
 
1.64
   
17.64
 
71.38
   
7.55
 
84.57
   
16.83
 
0.30
   
2.56
 
34.49
Non-Goodwill Companies (45)
   
12.22
 
12.22
   
-0.34
 
-0.91
   
3.07
 
-0.46
   
-2.97
 
5.97
   
55.37
 
1.95
   
19.80
 
66.90
   
8.81
 
66.90
   
18.99
 
0.16
   
1.32
 
27.46
Acquirors of FSLIC Cases (1)
   
13.16
 
11.52
   
0.83
 
6.38
   
6.69
 
1.17
   
8.96
 
0.00
   
0.00
 
1.86
   
14.95
 
87.00
   
11.45
 
101.30
   
10.64
 
0.20
   
1.42
 
21.28
 
(1)
Average of high/low or bid/ask price per share.
(2)
Or since offering price if converted or first listed in the past 52 weeks. Percent change figures are actual year-to-date and are not annualized
(3)
EPS (earnings per share) is based on actual trailing twelve month data and is not shown on a pro forma basis.
(4)
Excludes intangibles (such as goodwill, value of core deposits, etc.).
(5)
ROA (return on assets) and ROE (return on equity) are indicated ratios based on trailing twelve month common earnings and average common equity and assets balances; ROI (return on investment) is current EPS divided by current price.
(6)
Annualized, based on last regular quarterly cash dividend announcement.
(7)
Indicated dividend as a percent of trailing twelve month earnings.
(8)
Excluded from averages due to actual or rumored acquisition activities or unusual operating characteristics.
   
*
Parentheses following market averages indicate the number of institutions included in the respective averages. All figures have been adjusted for stock splits, stock dividends, and secondary offerings.

   
Source:
SNL Financial, LC. and RP Financial, LC. calculations. The information provided in this table has been obtained from sources we believe are reliable, but we cannot guarantee the accuracy or completeness of such information.
 
Copyright (c) 2010 by RP Financial, LC.

 
 

 
 
RP FINANCIAL, LC.
 
Financial Services Industry Consultants
 
1100 North Glebe Road, Suite 1100
 
Arlington, Virginia 22201
 
(703) 528-1700
 
 
Exhibit 1 (continued)
Weekly Thrift Market Line - Part Two
Prices As Of August 30, 2010
                                                                                            
   
Key Financial Ratios
 
Asset Quality Ratios
 
Pricing Ratios
 
Dividend Data (6)
   
Equity/
Assets
 
Tang.
Equity/
Assets
                     
NPAs
Assets
 
Resvs/
NPAs
 
Resvs/
Loans
 
Price/
Earning
 
Price/
Book
 
Price/
Assets
 
Price/
Tang.
Book
 
Price/
Core
Earnings
 
Ind.
Div./
Share
 
Divi-
dend
Yield
 
Payout
Ratio (7)
       
Reported Earnings
 
Core Earnings
                     
Financial Institution
     
ROA (5)
 
ROE (5)
 
ROI (5)
 
ROA (5)
 
ROE (5)
                     
   
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(x)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(x)
 
($)
 
(%)
 
(%)
                                                                                           
Market Averages.
MHC Institutions
                                                                               
                                                                                           
All Public Companies (32)
   
12.89
 
12.24
   
0.19
 
1.90
   
1.29
 
0.27
   
2.50
 
4.95
   
37.13
 
1. 33
   
19.45
 
100.99
   
13.50
 
107.04
   
20.28
 
0.17
   
1. 92
 
24.35
NASDAQ Listed OTC Companies (32)
   
12.89
 
12.24
   
0.19
 
1.90
   
1.29
 
0.27
   
2.50
 
4.95
   
37.13
 
1. 33
   
19.45
 
100.99
   
13.50
 
107.04
   
20.28
 
0.17
   
1. 92
 
24.35
Mid-Atlantic Companies (17)
   
12.56
 
12.11
   
0.21
 
2.58
   
2.17
 
0.31
   
3.11
 
8.94
   
24.62
 
1.46
   
17.99
 
99.69
   
12.78
 
104.16
   
18.84
 
0.17
   
1.90
 
27.10
Mid-West Companies (7)
   
15.61
 
14.45
   
0.16
 
0.81
   
0.85
 
0.00
   
-0.62
 
4.14
   
42.36
 
1.30
   
11.75
 
104.40
   
17.42
 
114.35
   
16.02
 
0.21
   
2.60
 
0.00
New England Companies (5)
   
10.03
 
9.42
   
0.18
 
0.97
   
-1.38
 
0.51
   
4.86
 
1.79
   
44.43
 
0.90
   
25.91
 
100.76
   
10.31
 
106.88
   
24.23
 
0.09
   
0.98
 
34 .17
Thrift Strategy (32)
   
12.89
 
12.24
   
0.19
 
1.90
   
1.29
 
0.27
   
2.50
 
4.95
   
37.13
 
1.33
   
19.45
 
100.99
   
13.50
 
107.04
   
20.28
 
0.17
   
1.92
 
24.35
Companies Issuing Dividends (22)
   
13.70
 
13.13
   
0.17
 
1.94
   
0.96
 
0.27
   
2.52
 
6.10
   
40.60
 
1.29
   
20.30
 
104.42
   
14.60
 
109.62
   
21.04
 
0.25
   
2.82
 
48.70
Companies Without Dividends (10)
   
11.16
 
10.34
   
0.24
 
1.81
   
1.98
 
0.27
   
2.45
 
3.81
   
33.68
 
1.39
   
18.25
 
93.70
   
11.17
 
101.57
   
19.40
 
0.00
   
0.00
 
0.00
Equity/Assets 6-12% (19)
   
9.74
 
9.35
   
0.33
 
3.28
   
3.24
 
0.36
   
3.67
 
3.56
   
40.50
 
1.26
   
17.81
 
93.57
   
9.28
 
97.43
   
18.77
 
0.12
   
1.29
 
26.67
Equity/Assets >12% (13)
   
16.90
 
15.93
   
0.02
 
0.14
   
-1.19
 
0.15
   
1.01
 
6.90
   
32.43
 
1.42
   
24.37
 
110.43
   
18.88
 
119.28
   
25.33
 
0.22
   
2.72
 
17.39
Market Value Below $20 Million (2)
   
7.17
 
6.71
   
0.61
 
8.20
   
16.22
 
0.50
   
6.72
 
0.00
   
0.00
 
1.26
   
6.54
 
52.66
   
3.71
 
58.15
   
7.88
 
0.06
   
1.00
 
8.11
Holding Company Structure (29)
   
12.87
 
12.16
   
0.15
 
1.62
   
1.02
 
0.23
   
2.25
 
4.95
   
37.13
 
1.39
   
18.54
 
99.59
   
13.33
 
106.17
   
19.76
 
0.16
   
1. 82
 
20.88
Assets Over $1 Billion (11)
   
13.66
 
12.96
   
0.39
 
2.81
   
1.82
 
0.31
   
1.94
 
3.96
   
38.65
 
1.20
   
24.32
 
122.80
   
17.09
 
129.83
   
26.23
 
0.11
   
1.16
 
7.87
Assets $500 Million-$l Billion (l0)
   
12.06
 
11.94
   
-0.27
 
-0.39
   
-1.07
 
-0.02
   
1.05
 
8.56
   
28.34
 
1.87
   
19.87
 
76.73
   
9.25
 
77.81
   
21.10
 
0.10
   
1.60
 
41.89
Assets $250-$500 Million (l0)
   
11.40
 
10.94
   
0.32
 
2.72
   
2.48
 
0.45
   
4.29
 
2.07
   
42.36
 
1.09
   
13.04
 
92.16
   
10.74
 
96.30
   
13.84
 
0.24
   
2.64
 
31. 80
Assets less than $250 Million (1)
   
24.31
 
19.31
   
0.00
 
0.00
   
0.00
 
0.00
   
0.00
 
1.30
   
54.31
 
0.87
   
NM
 
129.67
   
31.52
 
174.00
   
NM
 
0.40
   
4.18
 
0.00
Goodwill Companies (19)
   
13.76
 
12.51
   
0.25
 
2.13
   
1.78
 
0.32
   
3.03
 
2.68
   
42.70
 
1.14
   
21.16
 
107.65
   
15.43
 
119.29
   
22.35
 
0.12
   
1.34
 
14.84
Non-Goodwill Companies (13)
   
11.95
 
11.95
   
0.13
 
1.64
   
0.76
 
0.21
   
1.92
 
11.78
   
20.45
 
1.57
   
17.06
 
93.78
   
11.41
 
93.78
   
16.97
 
0.22
   
2.54
 
43.37
MHC Institutions (32)
   
12.89
 
12.24
   
0.19
 
1.90
   
1.29
 
0.27
   
2.50
 
4.95
   
37.13
 
1.33
   
19.45
 
100.99
   
13.50
 
107.04
   
20.28
 
0.17
   
1.92
 
24.35
 
(1)
Average of high/low or bid/ask price per share.
(2)
Or since offering price if converted or first listed in the past 52 weeks. Percent change figures are actual year-to-date and are not annualized
(3)
EPS (earnings per share) is based on actual trailing twelve month data and is not shown on a pro forma basis.
(4)
Excludes intangibles (such as goodwill, value of core deposits, etc.).
(5)
ROA (return on assets) and ROE (return on equity) are indicated ratios based on trailing twelve month common earnings and average common equity and assets balances; ROI (return on investment) is current EPS divided by current price.
(6)
Annualized, based on last regular quarterly cash dividend announcement.
(7)
Indicated dividend as a percent of trailing twelve month earnings.
(8)
Excluded from averages due to actual or rumored acquisition activities or unusual operating characteristics.
   
*
Parentheses following market averages indicate the number of institutions included in the respective averages. All figures have been adjusted for stock splits, stock dividends, and secondary offerings.

Source:
SNL Financial, LC. and RP Financial, LC. calculations. The information provided in this table has been obtained from sources we believe are reliable, but we cannot guarantee the accuracy or completeness of such information.

Copyright (c) 2010 by RP Financial, LC.

 
 

 
 
RP FINANCIAL, LC.
 
Financial Services Industry Consultants
 
1l00 North Glebe Road, Suite 1100
 
Arlington, Virginia 22201
 
(703) 528-1700
 
 
Exhibit 1 (continued)
Weekly Thrift Market Line - Part Two
Prices As Of August 30, 2010
                                                                                                                
   
Key Financial Ratios
   
Asset Quality Ratios
   
Pricing Ratios
   
Dividend Data (6)
 
         
Tang.
                                                                     
Price/
   
Price/
   
Ind.
   
Divi-
       
   
Equity/
   
Equity/
   
Reported Earnings
   
Core Earnings
   
NPAs
   
Resvs/
   
Resvs/
   
Price/
   
Price/
   
Price/
   
Tang.
   
Core
   
Div./
   
dend
   
Payout
 
Financial Institution
 
Assets
   
Assets
   
ROA (5)
   
ROE (5)
   
ROI (5)
   
ROA (5)
   
ROE (5)
   
Assets
   
NPAs
   
Loans
   
Earning
   
Book
   
Assets
   
Book
   
Earnings
   
Share
   
Yield
   
Ratio (7)
 
     
(%)
   
(%)
   
(%)
   
(%)
   
(%)
   
(%)
   
(%)
   
(%)
   
(%)
   
(%)
   
(x)
   
(%)
   
(%)
   
(%)
   
(x)
   
($)
   
(%)
   
(%)
 
NYSE Traded Companies
                                                                                                           
AF
Astoria Financial Corp. of NY*
    6.24     5.35     0.22     3.72     3.87     0.19     3.15     2.63     40.73     1.37     25.87     94.97     5.92     111.84     30.51     0.52     4.37    
NM
 
BBX
BankAtlantic Bancorp Inc of FL*
    1.66     1.34     -3.62    
NM
   
NM
    -3.74    
NM
    12.73     31.70     5.25    
NM
    80.42     1.33     100.00    
NM
    0.00     0.00    
NM
 
FBC
Flagstar Bancorp, Inc. of MI*
    5.85     5.85     -3.33    
NM
   
NM
    -4.99    
NM
   
NA
   
NA
    5.75    
NM
    41.68     2.44     41.68    
NM
    0.00     0.00    
NM
 
NYB
New York community Bcrp of NY*
    12.97     7.39     1.34     10.37     7.56     1.65     12.83     1.95     17.20     0.48     13.22     124.70     16.17     232.84     10.68     1.00     6.41    
NM
 
NAL
NewAlliance Bancshares of CT*
    16.80     11.11     0.68     4.03     4.45     0.66     3.95    
NA
   
NA
    1.11     22.49     88.80     14.92     143.50     22.91     0.28     2.26     50.91  
PFS
Provident Fin. Serv. Inc of NJ*
    13.35     8.61     0.58     4.45     5.84     0.57     4.38     1.44     62.45     1.42     17.14     74.41     9.93     121.74     17.40     0.44     3.89     66.67  
                                                                                                                 
AMEX Traded Companies
                                                                                                             
TSH
Teche Hlding Cp of N Iberia LA*
    9.74     9.30     0.94     9.99     11.57     0.91     9.68     2.35     49.04     1.48     8.64     83.87     8.17     88.23     8.93     1.42     4.75     41.04  
                                                                                                                 
NASDAQ Listed OTC Companies
                                                                                                             
ABBC
Abington Bancorp, Inc. of PA*
    16.76     16.76     -0.43     -2.43     -2.58     -0.43     -2.43     2.78     20.29     0.96    
NM
    96.46     16.16     96.46    
NM
    0.20     1.99    
NM
 
ALLB
Alliance Bank MHC of PA (40.7)
    10.83     10.83     0.22     2.07     2.00     0.22     2.07    
NA
   
NA
    1.46    
NM
    103.45     11.20     103.45    
NM
    0.12     1.60    
NM
 
ABCW
Anchor BanCorp Wisconsin of WI (8)*
    0.08     -0.10     -2.91    
NM
   
NM
    -3.09    
NM
    12.12     34.39     5.16    
NM
   
NM
    0.34    
NM
   
NM
    0.00     0.00    
NM
 
AFCB
Athens Bancshares, Inc. of TN*
    17.81     17.68     0.06     0.44     0.55     0.07     0.51    
NA
   
NA
    1.64    
NM
    59.96     10.68     60.49    
NM
    0.20     1.85    
NM
 
ACFC
Atl Cst Fed Cp of GA MHC (34.9) (8)
    6.17     6.15     -3.05     -43.03    
NM
    -2.63     -37.05     5.07     22.42     1.67    
NM
    57.14     3.52     57.28    
NM
    0.00     0.00    
NM
 
BCSB
BCSB Bancorp, Inc. of MD*
    8.11     8.10     -0.32     -3.13     -6.15     -0.34     -3.34     2.23     45.31     1.56    
NM
    60.30     4.89     60.37    
NM
    0.00     0.00    
NM
 
BKMU
Bank Mutual Corp of WI*
    11.41     10.01     0.16     1.36     2.38     -0.21     -1.81    
NA
   
NA
    1.52    
NM
    58.11     6.63     67.24    
NM
    0.12     2.38    
NM
 
BFIN
BankFinancial Corp. of IL*
    16.57     15.16     0.01     0.08     0.11     0.05     0.32     4.25     28.52     1.66    
NM
    71.43     11.84     79.42    
NM
    0.28     3.18    
NM
 
BFED
Beacon Federal Bancorp of NY*
    9.92     9.92     0.48     5.06     7.92     0.54     5.63    
NA
   
NA
    2.17     12.63     61.19     6.07     61.19     11.34     0.20     2.00     25.32  
BNCL
Beneficial Mut MHC of PA (44.1)
    13.52     11.17     0.55     3.96     3.71     0.50     3.58     2.49     41.90     1.81     26.97     103.59     14.01     128.81     29.86     0.00     0.00     0.00  
BHLB
Berkshire Hills Bancorp of MA*
    14.00     8.16     -0.58     -3.95     -6.32     -0.58     -3.95    
NA
   
NA
    1.57    
NM
    64.12     8.98     117.45    
NM
    0.64     3.64    
NM
 
BOFI
Bofi Holding, Inc. Of CA*
    8.78     8.78     1.51     19.57     18.03     1.09     14.12    
NA
   
NA
    0.75     5.55     91.02     7.99     91.02     7.69     0.00     0.00     0.00  
BYFC
Broadway Financial Corp. of CA*
    3.13     3.13     -1.21     -19.26    
NM
    -1.16     -18.41     11.30     29.62     4.01    
NM
    28.89     0.90     28.89    
NM
    0.04     1.40    
NM
 
BRKL
Brookline Bancorp, Inc. of MA*
    18.51     17.10     0.96     5.17     4.70     0.89     4.81     0.61     187.53     1.41     21.28     109.71     20.31     120.87     22.88     0.34     3.72    
NM
 
BFSB
Brooklyn Fed MHC of NY (28.2)
    13.96     13.96     -2.64     -17.20     -29.43     -1.00     -6.53     19.04     21.80     5.15    
NM
    64.61     9.02     64.61    
NM
    0.04     1.09    
NM
 
CITZ
CFS Bancorp, Inc of Munster IN*
    10.30     10.29     -0.09     -0.87     -1.93     -0.06     -0.58     7.41     21.70     2.33    
NM
    44.81     4.61     44.85    
NM
    0.04     0.86    
NM
 
CMSB
CMS Bancorp Inc of W Plains NY*
    8.75     8.75     -0.10     -1.15     -1.24     -0.25     -2.83    
NA
   
NA
    0.46    
NM
    92.19     8.06     92.19    
NM
    0.00     0.00    
NM
 
CBNJ
Cape Bancorp, Inc. of NJ*
    12.21     10.27     -1.53     -12.61     -16.53     -1.32     -10.89    
NA
   
NA
    1.51    
NM
    76.30     9.31     92.71    
NM
    0.00     0.00    
NM
 
CFFN
Capitol Fd Fn MHC of KS (29.5) (8)
    11.23     11.23     0.83     7.38     3.68     0.82     7.30     0.71     25.69     0.29     27.19     197.07     22.14     197.07     27.48     2.00     7.82    
NM
 
CARV
Carver Bancorp, Inc. of NY*
    5.03     5.01     -0.51     -6.56    
NM
    -0.43     -5.54    
NA
   
NA
    2.40    
NM
    29.59     1.49     29.73    
NM
    0.10     2.07    
NM
 
CEBK
Central Bncrp of Somerville MA*
    6.80     6.41     0.33     4.15     10.87     0.36     4.45    
NA
   
NA
    0.74     9.20     46.65     3.17     49.75     8.57     0.20     1.99     18.35  
CFBK
Central Federal corp. of OH*
    3.68     3.62     -5.31    
NM
   
NM
    -5.47    
NM
    5.05     72.44     4.41    
NM
    44.53     1.64     45.27    
NM
    0.00     0.00    
NM
 
CHEV
Cheviot Fin Cp MHC of OH (38.5)
    19.97     19.97     0.49     2.44     2.24     0.44     2.18    
NA
   
NA
    0.45    
NM
    107.46     21.46     107.46    
NM
    0.44     5.18    
NM
 
CBNK
Chicopee Bancorp, Inc. of MA*
    16.98     16.98     -0.27     -1.55     -2.09     -0.13     -0.74    
NA
   
NA
    0.94    
NM
    73.81     12.53     73.81    
NM
    0.00     0.00    
NM
 
CZWI
Citizens Comm Bncorp Inc of WI*
    9.78     8.76     0.13     1.38     3.45     0.27     2.75     1.79     33.34     0.75     29.00     39.44     3.86     44.57     14.50     0.00     0.00     0.00  
CSBC
Citizens South Bnkg Corp of NC*
    7.04     6.87     -2.27     -22.36    
NM
    -0.94     -9.27    
NA
   
NA
    1.26    
NM
    79.62     5.61     81.75    
NM
    0.16     2.90    
NM
 
CSBK
Clifton Svg Bp MHC of NJ (36.4)
    15.75     15.75     0.72     4.33     3.53     0.72     4.33    
NA
   
NA
    0.43     28.31     122.35     19.27     122.35     28.31     0.24     2.92    
NM
 
COBK
Colonial Financia1 Serv. of NJ*
    11.22     11.22     0.34     4.58     4.92     0.50     6.77    
NA
   
NA
    0.84     20.31     61.79     6.93     61.79     13.73     0.00     0.00     0.00  
CFFC
Community Fin.Corp. of VA*
    6.81     6.81     0.57     6.40     16.32     0.57     6.40    
NA
   
NA
    1.62     6.13     50.46     3.44     50.46     6.13     0.00     0.00     0.00  
DNBK
Danvers Bancorp, Inc. of MA*
    11.63     10.42     0.58     4.94     4.08     0.54     4.53     0.81     79.58     0.98     24.52     108.72     12.64     122.93     26.71     0.08     0.53     13.11  
DCOM 
Dime Community Bancshars of NY*
    7.59     6.33     0.89     12.05     8.48     0.92     12.40     0.50     112.94     0.67     11.79     134.58     10.21     163.47     11.46     0.56     4.57     53.85  
ESBF
ESB Financial Corp. of PA*
    8.91     6.87     0.66     7.79     8.45     0.69     8.16     0.30     107.90     0.93     11.84     87.93     7.83     116.56     11.31     0.40     3.16     37.38  
ESSA
ESSA Bancorp, Inc. of PA*
    16.55     16.55     0.46     2.68     3.28     0.41     2.38    
NA
   
NA
    0.95     30.53     84.15     13.93     84.15     34.34     0.20     1.82     55.56  
EBMT
Eagle Bancorp Montanta of MT*
    15.38     15.38     0.99    
NM
    8.59     0.99    
NM
   
NA
   
NA
    0.62     11.65     74.86     11.51     74.86     11.65     0.28     3.04     35.44  
ESBK
Elmira Svgs Bank, FSB of NY*
    7.56     5.08     0.65     6.00     10.44     0.49     4.53    
NA
   
NA
    1.00     9.58     83.07     6.28     126.78     12.70     0.80     5.00     47.90  
FFDF
FFD Financial Corp of Dover OH*
    9.08     9.08     0.48     5.13     6.07     0.37     3.95    
NA
   
NA
    1.09     16.46     83.73     7.61     83.73     21.40     0.68     4.54     74.73  
FFCO
FedFirst Fin MHC of PA (42.5) (8)
    12.34     12.00     0.25     2.09     2.86     0.25     2.09    
NA
   
NA
    1.14     35.00     70.50     8.70     72.81     35.00     0.00     0.00     0.00  
FSBI
Fidelity Bancorp, Inc. of PA*
    5.86     5.51     -0.45     -6.78     -21.06     -0.18     -2.72     2.30     34.90     1.46    
NM
    37.30     2.19     39.87    
NM
    0.08     1.57    
NM
 
FABK
First Advantage Bancorp of TN*
    19.72     19.72     0.20     1.02     1.59     0.19     0.96    
NA
   
NA
    1.29    
NM
    65.97     13.01     65.97    
NM
    0.20     1.87    
NM
 
FBSI
First Bancshares, Inc. of MO*
    11.22     11.16     -0.40     -3.73     -6.82     -0.45     -4.17     3.11     31.58     1.82    
NM
    54.98     6.17     55.30    
NM
    0.00     0.00    
NM
 
FCAP
First Capital, Inc. of IN*
    10.43     9.34     0.52     5.05     5.65     0.45     4.34    
NA
   
NA
    1.26     17.71     87.86     9.16     99.34     20.62     0.76     5.05    
NM
 
FCLF
First Clover Leaf Fin Cp of IL*
    13.81     11.84     0.20     1.52     2.78     0.16     1.22    
NA
   
NA
    1.50     36.00     55.10     7.61     65.77    
NM
    0.24     4.44    
NM
 
FCFL
First Community Bk Corp of FL*
    3.79     3.79     -3.05     -38.41    
NM
    -3.17     -39.92    
NA
   
NA
    2.00    
NM
    32.59     1.24     32.59    
NM
    0.00     0.00    
NM
 
FDEF
First Defiance Fin. Corp of OH*
    9.91     6.97     0.12     1.04     3.31     0.04     0.38     2.62     72.68     2.45     30.23     36.44     3.61     53.48    
NM
    0.00     0.00     0.00  
FFNM
First Fed of N. Michigan of MI*
    10.36     10.05     -2.72     -25.43    
NM
    -2.81     -26.24    
NA
   
NA
    1.87    
NM
    30.55     3.16     31.60    
NM
    0.00     0.00    
NM
 
FFBH
First Fed. Bancshares of AR*
    4.16     4.16     -5.84    
NM
   
NM
    -5.89    
NM
    12.45     37.37     6.70    
NM
    29.55     1.23     29.55    
NM
    0.00     0.00    
NM
 
FFNW
First Fin NW, Inc of Renton WA*
    14.29     14.29     -4.31     -25.04    
NM
    -4.40     -25.54     14.06     16.25     2.98    
NM
    39.78     5.69     39.78    
NM
    0.00     0.00    
NM
 
FFCH
First Fin. Holdings Inc. of SC*
    7.79     6.71     -1.18     -12.26     -26.45     -1.10     -11.47    
NA
   
NA
    3.34    
NM
    59.39     4.62     69.72    
NM
    0.20     2.15    
NM
 
FFHS
First Franklin Corp. of OH*
    7.76     7.76     -0.82     -10.78     -18.66     -1.32     -17.32    
NA
   
NA
    2.14    
NM
    60.05     4.66     60.05    
NM
    0.00     0.00    
NM
 
FPTB
First PacTrust Bancorp of CA*
    8.77     8.77     -0.19     -1.75     -4.23     -0 .17     -1.53    
NA
   
NA
    2.44    
NM
    51.89     4.55     51.89    
NM
    0.20     2.12    
NM
 
FPFC
First Place Fin. Corp. of OH*
    5.82     5.56     -1.06     -12.77    
NM
    -1.49     -17.91    
NA
   
NA
    1.78    
NM
    33.64     1.96     35.34    
NM
    0.00     0.00    
NM
 
 
 
 

 
 
RP FINANCIAL, LC.
 
Financial Services Industry Consultants
1100 North Glebe Road, Suite 1100
Arlington, Virginia 22201
(703) 528-1700
 
 
Exhibit 1 (continued)
Weekly Thrift Market Line - Part Two
Prices As Of August 30, 2010
                                                                                             
     
Key Financial Ratios
 
Asset Quality Ratios
 
Pricing Ratios
 
Dividend Data (6)
           
Tang.
                                                         
Price/
 
Price/
 
Ind.
 
Divi-
   
     
Equity/
 
Equity/
 
Reported Earnings
 
Core Earnings
 
NPAs
 
Resvs/
 
Resvs/
 
Price/
 
Price/
 
Price/
 
Tang.
 
Core
 
Div./
 
dend
 
Payout
Financial Institution
 
Assets
 
Assets
 
ROA (5)
 
ROE (5)
 
ROI (5)
 
ROA (5)
 
ROE (5)
 
Assets
 
NPAs
 
Loans
 
Earning
 
Book
 
Assets
 
Book
 
Earnings
 
Share
 
Yield
 
Ratio (7)
   
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(x)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(x)
 
($)
 
(%)
 
(%)
                                                                                             
NASDAQ Listed OTC Companies (continued)
                                                                                         
FSFG
First Savings Fin. Grp. of IN*
   
10.68
 
9.15
   
0.53
 
4.42
   
7.26
 
0.69
   
5.74
 
NA
   
NA
 
1.20
   
13.77
 
60.23
   
6.43
 
71.56
   
10.60
 
0.00
   
0.00
 
0.00
FFIC
Flushing Fin. Corp. of NY*
   
8.93
 
8.54
   
0.65
 
7.40
   
8.00
 
0.72
   
8.16
 
2.80
   
21.76
 
0.79
   
12.51
 
89.55
   
7.99
 
93.96
   
11.33
 
0.52
   
4.78
 
59.77
FXCB
Fox Chase Bancorp, Inc. of PA*
   
16.38
 
16.38
   
-0.09
 
-0.87
   
-0.85
 
-0.09
   
-0.87
 
NA
   
NA
 
1.74
   
NM
 
67.94
   
11.13
 
67.94
   
NM
 
0.00
   
0.00
 
NM
GSLA
GS Financial Corp. of LA*
   
10.36
 
10.36
   
0.03
 
0.31
   
0.57
 
-0.21
   
-2.01
 
4.32
   
29.07
 
1.81
   
NM
 
54.28
   
5.63
 
54.28
   
NM
 
0.40
   
3.27
 
NM
GCBC
Green Co Bcrp MHC of NY (44.1)
   
8.98
 
8.98
   
1.03
 
11.53
   
6.90
 
1.03
   
11.53
 
NA
   
NA
 
1.34
   
14.50
 
159.72
   
14.35
 
159.72
   
14.50
 
0.70
   
4.06
 
58.82
HFFC
HF Financial Corp. of SD*
   
7.59
 
7.22
   
0.54
 
7.70
   
9.90
 
0.41
   
5.79
 
NA
   
NA
 
1.07
   
10.10
 
69.56
   
5.28
 
73.42
   
13.41
 
0.45
   
4.79
 
48.39
HMNF
HMN Financial, Inc. of MN*
   
6.75
 
6.75
   
-1.02
 
-10.69
   
NM
 
-1.13
   
-11.89
 
NA
   
NA
 
3.36
   
NM
 
25.21
   
1.70
 
25.21
   
NM
 
0.00
   
0.00
 
NM
HBNK
Hampden Bancorp, Inc. of MA*
   
16.25
 
16.25
   
-0.15
 
-0.90
   
-1.19
 
-0.15
   
-0.90
 
NA
   
NA
 
NA
   
NM
 
76.92
   
12.50
 
76.92
   
NM
 
0.12
   
1.19
 
NM
HARL
Harleysville Svgs Fin Cp of PA*
   
6.05
 
6.05
   
0.59
 
9.74
   
9.00
 
0.59
   
9.81
 
NA
   
NA
 
0.47
   
11.11
 
104.97
   
6.36
 
104.97
   
11.03
 
0.76
   
5.07
 
56.30
HBOS
Heritage Fn Gp MHC of GA (24.3) (8)
   
10.73
 
10.49
   
-0.24
 
-2.01
   
-1.38
 
-0.34
   
-2.85
 
NA
   
NA
 
1.54
   
NM
 
146.54
   
15.73
 
150.35
   
NM
 
0.36
   
4.14
 
NM
HIFS
Hingham Inst. for Sav. of MA*
   
7.10
 
7.10
   
0.99
 
13.99
   
11.22
 
0.98
   
13.86
 
NA
   
NA
 
0.86
   
8.91
 
118.54
   
8.41
 
118.54
   
8.99
 
0.92
   
2.39
 
21.30
HBCP
Home Bancorp Inc. Lafayette LA*
   
18.71
 
18.50
   
0.64
 
2.89
   
3.46
 
0.82
   
3.72
 
0.40
   
133.23
 
0.83
   
28.89
 
83.07
   
15.54
 
84.25
   
22.41
 
0.00
   
0.00
 
0.00
HOME
Home Federal Bancorp Inc of ID*
   
23.67
 
23.67
   
0.72
 
2.84
   
2.83
 
-1.26
   
-4.94
 
NA
   
NA
 
3.74
   
35.29
 
100.16
   
23.71
 
100.16
   
NM
 
0.22
   
1.78
 
62.86
HFBC
HopFed Bancorp, Inc. of KY*
   
8.66
 
8.58
   
0.24
 
2.86
   
3.98
 
0.11
   
1.27
 
NA
   
NA
 
1.35
   
25.14
 
65.58
   
5.68
 
66.25
   
NM
 
0.48
   
5.30
 
NM
HCBK
Hudson City Bancorp. Inc of NJ*
   
9.10
 
8.86
   
0.94
 
10.55
   
9.37
 
0.87
   
9.76
 
NA
   
NA
 
0.60
   
10.67
 
108.45
   
9.87
 
111.63
   
11.54
 
0.60
   
5.25
 
56.07
ISBC
Investors Bcrp MHC of NJ (43.6)
   
10.03
 
9.77
   
0.61
 
6.06
   
4.25
 
0.54
   
5.39
 
NA
   
NA
 
0.99
   
23.53
 
136.82
   
13.72
 
140.82
   
26.48
 
0.00
   
0.00
 
0.00
JXSB
Jacksonville Bancorp Inc of IL*
   
11.78
 
10.86
   
0.51
 
5.93
   
7.71
 
0.34
   
3.90
 
NA
   
NA
 
1.50
   
12.97
 
56.10
   
6.61
 
60.83
   
19.71
 
0.30
   
2.93
 
37.97
JFBI
Jefferson Bancshares Inc of TN*
   
12.08
 
8.73
   
0.16
 
1.33
   
4.42
 
0.04
   
0.33
 
NA
   
NA
 
2.17
   
22.63
 
30.09
   
3.63
 
43.25
   
NM
 
0.00
   
0.00
 
0.00
KFED
K-Fed Bancorp MHC of CA (33.3) (8)
   
10.42
 
10.00
   
0.29
 
2.72
   
2.57
 
0.32
   
3.01
 
3.54
   
40.59
 
1.67
   
38.84
 
105.43
   
10.98
 
110.31
   
35.14
 
0.44
   
5.96
 
NM
KFFB
KY Fst Fed Bp MHC of KY (39.8)
   
24.31
 
19.31
   
0.00
 
0.00
   
0.00
 
0.00
   
0.00
 
1.30
   
54.31
 
0.87
   
NM
 
129.67
   
31.52
 
174.00
   
NM
 
0.40
   
4.18
 
NM
KRNY
Kearny Fin Cp MHC of NJ (26.0)
   
21.40
 
18.43
   
0.28
 
1.28
   
1.04
 
0.31
   
1.42
 
NA
   
NA
 
0.84
   
NM
 
122.84
   
26.28
 
148.03
   
NM
 
0.20
   
2.31
 
NM
LSBX
LSB Corp of No. Andover MA(8) *
   
8.04
 
8.04
   
0.66
 
7.83
   
5.61
 
0.43
   
5.15
 
NA
   
NA
 
1.38
   
17.82
 
146.62
   
11.79
 
146.62
   
27.08
 
0.36
   
1.73
 
30.77
LSBI
LSB Fin. Corp. of Lafayette IN*
   
9.11
 
9.11
   
0.23
 
2.45
   
5.53
 
0.12
   
1.32
 
4.18
   
26.78
 
1.26
   
18.07
 
43.96
   
4.01
 
43.96
   
33.66
 
0.00
   
0.00
 
0.00
LPSB
LaPorte Bancrp MHC of IN(45.0)
   
11.42
 
9.52
   
0.67
 
5.59
   
8.51
 
0.49
   
4.10
 
1.50
   
66.21
 
1.49
   
11.75
 
64.56
   
7.37
 
79.12
   
16.02
 
0.00
   
0.00
 
0.00
LSBK
Lake Shore Bnp MHC of NY (40.2)
   
12.52
 
12.52
   
0.65
 
5.02
   
5.61
 
0.65
   
5.02
 
NA
   
NA
 
0.68
   
17.83
 
86.41
   
10.82
 
86.41
   
17.83
 
0.24
   
2.93
 
52.17
LEGC
Legacy Bancorp, Inc. of MA*
   
12.43
 
11.01
   
-0.85
 
-6.65
   
-11.40
 
-0.44
   
-3.43
 
2.50
   
39.57
 
1.44
   
NM
 
59.74
   
7.43
 
68.57
   
NM
 
0.20
   
2.45
 
NM
LABC
Louisiana Bancorp, Inc. of LA*
   
20.50
 
20.50
   
0.74
 
3.29
   
3.98
 
0.64
   
2.83
 
0.84
   
66.34
 
1.06
   
25.10
 
91.17
   
18.69
 
91.17
   
29.12
 
0.00
   
0.00
 
0.00
MSBF
MSB Fin Corp MHC of NJ (40.9)
   
11.06
 
11.06
   
0.12
 
1.03
   
1.16
 
0.15
   
1.28
 
NA
   
NA
 
NA
   
NM
 
89.96
   
9.95
 
89.96
   
NM
 
0.12
   
1.74
 
NM
MGYR
Magyar Bancorp MHC of NJ(44.7)
   
8.09
 
8.09
   
0.72
 
9.77
   
20.12
 
0.57
   
7.79
 
NA
   
NA
 
1.24
   
4.97
 
45.13
   
3.65
 
45.13
   
6.24
 
0.00
   
0.00
 
0.00
MLVF
Malvern Fed Bncp MHC PA(44.6)
   
9.84
 
9.84
   
-0.14
 
-1.41
   
-2.13
 
-0.17
   
-1.68
 
6.03
   
21.77
 
1.58
   
NM
 
66.90
   
6.58
 
66.90
   
NM
 
0.12
   
1.60
 
NM
MFLR
Mayflower Bancorp, Inc. of MA*
   
8.02
 
8.01
   
0.47
 
5.83
   
6.83
 
0.26
   
3.23
 
NA
   
NA
 
1.01
   
14.64
 
83.50
   
6.69
 
83.59
   
26.45
 
0.24
   
2.93
 
42.86
EBSB
Meridian Fn Serv MHC MA (41.8)
   
11.94
 
11.36
   
0.70
 
4.93
   
4.16
 
0.64
   
4.48
 
2.46
   
26.52
 
0.95
   
24.05
 
115.38
   
13.78
 
122.03
   
26.45
 
0.00
   
0.00
 
0.00
CASH
Meta Financial Group of IA*
   
7.26
 
7.00
   
1.02
 
17.08
   
8.99
 
0.82
   
13.81
 
NA
   
NA
 
1.36
   
11.12
 
146.42
   
10.63
 
152.41
   
13.76
 
0.52
   
1.57
 
17.45
MFSF
MutualFirst Fin. Inc. of IN*
   
7.12
 
6.78
   
0.10
 
1.07
   
2.85
 
0.15
   
1.60
 
2.31
   
48.85
 
1.57
   
35.05
 
47.72
   
3.40
 
50.25
   
23.37
 
0.24
   
3.42
 
NM
NASB
NASB Fin, Inc. of Grandview MO*
   
11.67
 
11.51
   
0.67
 
6.15
   
9.56
 
-1.24
   
-11.35
 
NA
   
NA
 
2.67
   
10.46
 
64.21
   
7.50
 
65.23
   
NM
 
0.00
   
0.00
 
0.00
NECB
NE Comm Bncrp MHC of NY (45.0)
   
20.85
 
20.56
   
-0.46
 
-2.19
   
-2.93
 
-0.46
   
-2.19
 
8.19
   
12.99
 
1.43
   
NM
 
75.46
   
15.73
 
76.78
   
NM
 
0.12
   
1.95
 
NM
NHTB
NH Thrift Bancshares of NH*
   
8.31
 
5.54
   
0.74
 
7.80
   
11.88
 
0.39
   
4.16
 
NA
   
NA
 
1.52
   
8.42
 
70.63
   
5.87
 
109.07
   
15.78
 
0.52
   
5.15
 
43.33
NVSL
Naug Vlly Fin MHC of CT (40.4) (8)
   
9.06
 
9.05
   
0.43
 
4.78
   
5.26
 
0.42
   
4.64
 
NA
   
NA
 
1.05
   
19.03
 
88.75
   
8.04
 
88.87
   
19.61
 
0.12
   
1.85
 
35.29
NFSB
Newport Bancorp. Inc. of RI*
   
11.20
 
11.20
   
0.27
 
2.40
   
2.85
 
0.30
   
2.62
 
0.30
   
259.65
 
1.00
   
35.09
 
86.08
   
9.64
 
86.08
   
32.24
 
0.00
   
0.00
 
0.00
FFFD
North Central Bancshares of IA*
   
8.52
 
8.52
   
0.33
 
3.09
   
7.20
 
0.27
   
2.55
 
3.55
   
56.02
 
2.48
   
13.88
 
53.58
   
4.56
 
53.58
   
16.78
 
0.04
   
0.26
 
3.64
NFBK
Northfield Bcp MHC of NY(43.6) (8)
   
18.10
 
17.50
   
0.73
 
3.75
   
3.09
 
0.68
   
3.53
 
2.88
   
30.08
 
2.47
   
32.32
 
119.72
   
21.67
 
124.74
   
34.34
 
0.20
   
1.82
 
58.82
NWBI
Northwest Bancshares Inc of PA*
   
16.11
 
14.25
   
0.55
 
4.03
   
3.60
 
0.69
   
5.10
 
1.87
   
49.45
 
1.36
   
27.79
 
89.26
   
14.38
 
103.13
   
22.00
 
0.40
   
3.79
 
NM
OBAF
OBA Financial Serv. Inc of MD*
   
21.12
 
21.12
   
-0.26
 
-1.79
   
-2.09
 
0.12
   
0.86
 
NA
   
NA
 
0.49
   
NM
 
63.69
   
13.45
 
63.69
   
NM
 
0.00
   
0.00
 
NM
OSHC
Ocean Shore Holding Co. of NJ*
   
12.50
 
12.50
   
0.68
 
6.05
   
6.64
 
0.68
   
6.05
 
NA
   
NA
 
0.61
   
15.07
 
78.33
   
9.79
 
78.33
   
15.07
 
0.24
   
2.24
 
33.80
OCFC
OceanFirst Fin. Corp of NJ*
   
8.78
 
8.78
   
0.75
 
8.53
   
7.30
 
0.69
   
7.89
 
NA
   
NA
 
1.02
   
13.69
 
107.15
   
9.40
 
107.15
   
14.79
 
0.48
   
4.33
 
59.26
OABC
OmniAmerican Bancorp Inc of TX*
   
17.78
 
17.78
   
0.12
 
0.90
   
0.98
 
-0.04
   
-0.33
 
NA
   
NA
 
1.16
   
NM
 
66.17
   
11.77
 
66.17
   
NM
 
0.00
   
0.00
 
0.00
ONFC
Oneida Financial Corp. of NY*
   
13.45
 
9.46
   
0.60
 
6.84
   
6.71
 
0.61
   
6.97
 
NA
   
NA
 
1.17
   
14.90
 
66.30
   
8.92
 
94.28
   
14.62
 
0.53
   
6.84
 
NM
ORIT
Oritani Financial Corp of NJ*
   
25.71
 
25.71
   
0.62
 
3.94
   
2.93
 
0.60
   
3.79
 
NA
   
NA
 
1.69
   
34.15
 
82.47
   
21.20
 
82.47
   
35.46
 
0.30
   
3.25
 
NM
PSBH
PSB Hldgs Inc MHC of CT (42.9)
   
8.94
 
7.56
   
-0.96
 
-11.25
   
-17.88
 
0.47
   
5.55
 
2.63
   
18.50
 
0.92
   
NM
 
58.55
   
5.23
 
70.27
   
11.34
 
0.00
   
0.00
 
NM
PVFC
PVF Capital Corp. of Solon OH*
   
9.60
 
9.60
   
-0.43
 
-6.38
   
-7.77
 
-0.98
   
-14.47
 
9.73
   
35.01
 
4.69
   
NM
 
57.96
   
5.57
 
57.96
   
NM
 
0.00
   
0.00
 
NM
PFED
Park Bancorp of Chicago IL*
   
10.15
 
10.15
   
-2.22
 
-20.44
   
NM
 
-2.21
   
-20.34
 
NA
   
NA
 
2.66
   
NM
 
23.44
   
2.38
 
23.44
   
NM
 
0.00
   
0.00
 
NM
PVSA
Parkvale Financial Corp of PA*
   
4.73
 
3.23
   
-0.96
 
-12.53
   
NM
 
-0.88
   
-11.58
 
NA
   
NA
 
1.83
   
NM
 
40.96
   
1.94
 
60.89
   
NM
 
0.20
   
3.10
 
NM
PBHC
Pathfinder BC MHC of NY (36.3)
   
6.25
 
5.34
   
0.49
 
6.62
   
12.33
 
0.42
   
5.64
 
NA
   
NA
 
1.28
   
8.ll
 
60.18
   
3.76
 
71.17
   
9.52
 
0.12
   
2.00
 
16.22
PEOP
Peoples Fed Bancshrs Inc of MA*
   
20.23
 
20.23
   
0.37
 
NM
   
2.72
 
0.29
   
NM
 
NA
   
NA
 
0.85
   
36.79
 
66.67
   
13.48
 
66.67
   
NM
 
0.00
   
0.00
 
0.00
PBCT
Peoples United Financial of CT*
   
24.66
 
18.03
   
0.38
 
1.54
   
1.74
 
0.40
   
1.61
 
NA
   
NA
 
1.13
   
NM
 
85.80
   
21.16
 
127.70
   
NM
 
0.62
   
4.91
 
NM
PROV
Provident Fin. Holdings of CA*
   
9.13
 
9.13
   
0.08
 
0.95
   
1.86
 
-0.67
   
-8.18
 
7.85
   
39.62
 
3.57
   
NM
 
48.04
   
4.39
 
48.04
   
NM
 
0.04
   
0.74
 
40.00
PBNY
Provident NY Bncrp, Inc. of NY*
   
14.48
 
9.44
   
0.68
 
4.74
   
6.57
 
0.54
   
3.73
 
1.11
   
94.66
 
1.82
   
15.23
 
71.29
   
10.32
 
115.79
   
19.32
 
0.24
   
3.03
 
46.15
PBIP
Prudential Bncp MHC PA (29.3)
   
10.49
 
10.49
   
0.62
 
5.80
   
5.08
 
0.68
   
6.34
 
NA
   
NA
 
0.99
   
19.69
 
111.90
   
11.74
 
111.90
   
18.00
 
0.20
   
3.17
 
62.50
PULB
Pulaski Fin Cp of St. Louis MO*
   
5.99
 
5.71
   
-0.09
 
-1.07
   
-1.92
 
-0.28
   
-3.48
 
4.78
   
40.43
 
2.14
   
NM
 
77.45
   
4.64
 
81.49
   
NM
 
0.38
   
6.08
 
NM
RIVR
River Valley Bancorp of IN*
   
6.86
 
6.84
   
0.70
 
9.51
   
12.11
 
0.60
   
8.15
 
NA
   
NA
 
0.87
   
8.26
 
83.47
   
5.72
 
83.71
   
9.65
 
0.84
   
5.62
 
46.41
RVSB
Riverview Bancorp, Inc. of WA*
   
9.93
 
7.15
   
-0.47
 
-4.60
   
-19.27
 
-0.45
   
-4.48
 
5.66
   
40.04
 
2.72
   
NM
 
24.46
   
2.43
 
35.04
   
NM
 
0.00
   
0.00
 
NM
RCKB
Rockville Fin MHC of CT (43.3)
   
10.13
 
10.07
   
0.73
 
7.34
   
5.34
 
0.69
   
6.86
 
1.08
   
75.89
 
0.94
   
18.74
 
132.75
   
13.45
 
133.68
   
20.05
 
0.24
   
2.10
 
39.34
ROMA
Roma Fin Corp MHC of NJ (26.9)
   
14.85
 
14.82
   
0.32
 
1.99
   
1.36
 
0.44
   
2.70
 
NA
   
NA
 
1.18
   
NM
 
145.95
   
21.68
 
146.36
   
NM
 
0.32
   
3.12
 
NM
ROME
Rome Bancorp, Inc. of Rome NY*
   
18.59
 
18.59
   
1.08
 
5.94
   
5.69
 
1.00
   
5.49
 
NA
   
NA
 
0.89
   
17.57
 
102.99
   
19.14
 
102.99
   
19.00
 
0.36
   
3.87
 
67.92
SIFI
SI Fin Gp Inc MHC of CT (38.2)
   
9.12
 
8.70
   
0.25
 
2.86
   
2.86
 
0.23
   
2.56
 
0.97
   
56.81
 
0.80
   
34.95
 
96.37
   
8.79
 
101.53
   
39.06
 
0.12
   
1.81
 
63.16
SVBI
Severn Bancorp, Inc. of MD*
   
7.88
 
7.86
   
-0.88
 
-8.01
   
-21.45
 
-0.90
   
-8.19
 
12.02
   
28.26
 
4.04
   
NM
 
51.08
   
4.03
 
51.28
   
NM
 
0.00
   
0.00
 
NM

 
 

 
 
RP FINANCIAL, LC.
 
Financial Services Industry Consultants
1100 North Glebe Road, Suite 1100
Arlington, Virginia 22201
(703) 528-1700
 
 
Exhibit 1 (continued)
Weekly Thrift Market Line - Part Two
Prices As Of August 30, 2010
                                                                                             
     
Key Financial Ratios
 
Asset Quality Ratios
 
Pricing Ratios
 
Dividend Data (6)
         
Tang.
                                             
Price/
 
Price/
 
Ind.
 
Divi-
   
     
Equity/
 
Equity/
 
Reported Earnings
 
Core Earnings
 
NPAs
 
Resvs/
 
Resvs/
 
Price/
 
Price/
 
Price/
 
Tang.
 
Core
 
Div./
 
dend
 
Payout
Financial Institution
 
Assets
 
Assets
 
ROA (5)
 
ROE (5)
 
ROI (5)
 
ROA (5)
 
ROE (5)
 
Assets
 
NPAs
 
Loans
 
Earning
 
Book
 
Assets
 
Book
 
Earnings
 
Share
 
Yield
 
Ratio (7)
   
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(x)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(%)
 
(x)
 
($)
 
(%)
 
(%)
                                                                                           
NASDAQ Listed OTC Companies (continued)
                                                                                         
SUPR
Superior Bancorp of AL (8)*
   
4.12
 
3.70
   
-2.23
 
-35.71
   
NM
 
-2.44
   
-39.10
 
12.91
   
18.32
 
3.13
   
NM
 
10.53
   
0.43
 
11.78
   
NM
 
0.00
   
0.00
 
NM
THRD
TF Fin. Corp. of Newtown PA*
   
10.17
 
9.60
   
0.55
 
5.50
   
6.65
 
0.48
   
4.75
 
NA
   
NA
 
1.28
   
15.04
 
80.96
   
8.24
 
86.30
   
17.41
 
0.80
   
3.62
 
54.42
TFSL
TFS Fin Corp MHC of OH (26.3)
   
16.09
 
16.02
   
0.09
 
0.53
   
0.33
 
-0.11
   
-0.70
 
3.48
   
31.13
 
1.32
   
NM
 
157.27
   
25.31
 
158.10
   
NM
 
0.00
   
0.00
 
0.00
TBNK
Territorial Bancorp, Inc of  HI*
   
15.41
 
15.41
   
0.59
 
4.29
   
4.09
 
0.78
   
5.66
 
0.25
   
48.36
 
0.28
   
24.46
 
92.59
   
14.27
 
92.59
   
18.55
 
0.28
   
1.66
 
40.58
TSBK
Timberland Bancorp, Inc. of  WA*
   
9.55
 
8.77
   
-0.45
 
-3.65
   
-11.54
 
-0.27
   
-2.19
 
6.49
   
22.92
 
2.00
   
NM
 
39.27
   
3.75
 
43.14
   
NM
 
0.00
   
0.00
 
NM
TRST
TrustCo Bank Corp NY of NY*
   
6.67
 
6.65
   
0.83
 
12.46
   
7.50
 
0.77
   
11.53
 
1.44
   
70.98
 
1.68
   
13.33
 
160.54
   
10.70
 
161.03
   
14.41
 
0.26
   
4.88
 
65.00
UCBA
United Comm Bncp MHC IN (40.7)
   
12.66
 
12.66
   
0.19
 
1.41
   
1.42
 
0.17
   
1.27
 
NA
   
NA
 
NA
   
NM
 
99.16
   
12.55
 
99.16
   
NM
 
0.44
   
6.24
 
NM
UCFC
United Community Fin. of  OH*
   
9.19
 
9.17
   
-1.14
 
-12.17
   
NM
 
-1.40
   
-14.94
 
9.31
   
18.91
 
2.22
   
NM
 
17.44
   
1.60
 
17.47
   
NM
 
0.00
   
0.00
 
NM
UBNK
United Financial Bncrp of  MA*
   
14.44
 
13.98
   
0.55
 
3.56
   
3.56
 
0.68
   
4.38
 
1.20
   
52.43
 
0.89
   
28.13
 
98.97
   
14.29
 
102.82
   
22.88
 
0.32
   
2.37
 
66.67
UWBK
United Western Bncp, Inc of  CO*
   
5.28
 
5.28
   
-3.75
 
NM
   
NM
 
-2.45
   
-41.32
 
NA
   
NA
 
3.13
   
NM
 
11.28
   
0.60
 
11.28
   
NM
 
0.00
   
0.00
 
NM
VPFG
ViewPoint Financia1 Group of  TX*
   
14.20
 
14.16
   
0.17
 
1.55
   
1.45
 
0.46
   
4.18
 
0.85
   
60.85
 
0.88
   
NM
 
83.18
   
11.81
 
83.41
   
25.57
 
0.16
   
1.79
 
NM
WSB
WSB Holdings, Inc. of Bowie MD*
   
12.50
 
12.50
   
-1.44
 
-11.83
   
NM
 
-1.56
   
-12.87
 
NA
   
NA
 
3.71
   
NM
 
34.80
   
4.35
 
34.80
   
NM
 
0.00
   
0.00
 
NM
WSFS
WSFS Financial Corp. of  DE*
   
6.93
 
6.60
   
0.03
 
0.38
   
0.43
 
0.09
   
1.14
 
2.30
   
71.35
 
2.47
   
NM
 
99.81
   
6.91
 
105.17
   
NM
 
0.48
   
1.30
 
NM
WVFC
WVS Financial Corp. of  PA*
   
7.72
 
7.72
   
0.23
 
2.96
   
4.27
 
0.27
   
3.50
 
NA
   
NA
 
NA
   
23.41
 
72.79
   
5.62
 
72.79
   
19.81
 
0.64
   
6.21
 
NM
WFSL
Washington Federal, Inc. of  WA*
   
13.16
 
11.52
   
0.83
 
6.38
   
6.69
 
1.17
   
8.96
 
NA
   
NA
 
1.86
   
14.95
 
87.00
   
11.45
 
101.30
   
10.64
 
0.20
   
1.42
 
21.28
WSBF
Waterstone Fin MHC of WI (26.2)
   
9.22
 
9.22
   
-0.46
 
-5.10
   
-7.39
 
-0.96
   
-10.56
 
10.27
   
17.79
 
2.37
   
NM
 
68.29
   
6.30
 
68.29
   
NM
 
0.00
   
0.00
 
NM
WAYN
Wayne Savings Bancshares of OH*
   
9.32
 
8.86
   
0.58
 
6.40
   
9.75
 
0.53
   
5.82
 
NA
   
NA
 
1.22
   
10.26
 
63.29
   
5.90
 
66.95
   
11.27
 
0.24
   
3.00
 
30.77
WFD
Westfield Fin. Inc. of  MA*
   
19.39
 
19.39
   
0.34
 
1.64
   
1.85
 
0.31
   
1.52
 
NA
   
NA
 
1.64
   
NM
 
92.55
   
17.95
 
92.55
   
NM
 
0.24
   
3.17
 
NM

 
 

 
 
Core Earnings Analysis
 
 
 

 
 
RP® Financial, LC.
 
Exhibit 2
Core Earnings Analysis
Comparable Institution Analysis
For the 12 Months Ended June 30, 2010
                                               
                         
Less:
   
Estimated
             
       
Net Income
   
Less: Net
   
Tax Effect
   
Extraordinary
   
Core Income
         
Estimated
 
Comparable Group
   
to Common
   
Gains(Loss)
   
@ 34%
   
Items
   
to Common
   
Shares
   
Core EPS
 
        ($000)     ($000)     ($000)     ($000)     ($000)       (000)    
($)
 
                                                           
BKMU
Bank Mutual Corp. of WI
     $ 5,555      $ (19,322 )    $ 6,569     $ 0      $ (7,198 )     45,710      $ (0.16 )
BRKL
Brookline Bancorp, Inc. of MA
     $ 25,210      $ (2,407 )    $ 818     $ 0      $ 23,621       59,038      $ 0.40  
DNBK
Danvers Bancorp, Inc. of MA
     $ 12,985      $ (1,653 )    $ 562     $ 0      $ 11,894       21,375      $ 0.56  
DCOM
Dime Community Bancshares of NY
     $ 35,897      $ 1,591      $ (541 )   $ 0      $ 36,947       34,548      $ 1.07  
FFCH
First Financial Holdings Inc. of SC
     $ (40,683 )    $ 4,086      $ (1,389 )   $ 0      $ (37,986 )     16,527      $ (2.30 )
FFIC
Flushing Financial Corp. of NY
     $ 27,207      $ 4,106      $ (1,396 )   $ 0      $ 29,917       31,238      $ 0.96  
PBNY
Provident NY Bancorp, Inc. of NY
     $ 20,165     $ (6,825 )    $ 2,321     $ 0      $ 15,661       38,628      $ 0.41  
TRST
TrustCo Bank Corp. NY of NY
     $ 30,450      $ (3,319 )    $ 1,128     $ 0      $ 28,259       76,873      $ 0.37  
WFSL
Washington Federal, Inc. of WA (1)
     $ 102,127      $ 69,617      $ (23,670 )   $ 0      $ 148,074       112,474      $ 1.32  
 
(1)  Financial information is for the quarter ending March 31, 2010.
   
Source: SNL Financial, LC. and RP® Financial, LC. calculations.  The information provided in this table has been obtained from sources we believe are reliable, but we cannot guarantee the accuracy or completeness of such information.
 
Copyright (c) 2010 by RP® Financial, LC.  

 
 

 
 
Pro Forma Analysis Sheet
 
 
 

 
 
EXHIBIT 3
PRO FORMA ANALYSIS SHEET
Capitol Federal Financial
Prices as of August 30, 2010
                                         
           
Subject
   
Peer Group
   
All Public Thrifts
   
Valuation Midpoint Pricing Multiples
 
 
Symbol
   
at Midpoint
   
Average
   
Median
   
Average
   
Median
   
Price-earnings multiple
=
  P/E       25.96  x     16.23 x     14.94 x     18.42 x     15.07 x  
Price-core earnings multiple
=
 
P/CE
      27.67  x     16.68 x     14.41 x     17.62 x     15.78 x  
Price-book ratio
=
  P/B       90.25 %     97.65 %     89.55 %     69.54 %     67.94 %  
Price-tangible book ratio
=
 
P/TB
      90.25 %     112.92 %     115.79 %     77.31 %     72.79 %  
Price-assets ratio
=
  P/A       20.17 %     10.54 %     10.32 %     8.07 %     6.80 %  
 
Valuation Parameters
 
                     
Adjusted
   
                             
Pre-Conversion Earnings (Y)
  $ 69,231,000    
(12 Mths 06/10)
 
ESOP Stock (% of Offering + Foundation) (E)
      4.00 %  
Pre-Conversion Core Earnings (YC)
  $ 64,549,000    
(12 Mths 06/10)
  (2)  
Cost of ESOP Borrowings (S)
      0.00 %  
Pre-Conversion Book Value (B)
  $ 960,289,000     (2)      
ESOP Amortization (T)
      30.00        Years
Pre-Conv. Tang. Book Value (B)
  $ 960,289,000     (2)      
Stock Program (% of Offering + Foundation (M)
      2.00 %  
Pre-Conversion Assets (A)
  $ 8,543,357,000     (2)      
Stock Programs Vesting (N)
      5.00        Years
Reinvestment Rate (R)
    1.79 %          
Fixed Expenses
    $ 6,215,000    
Tax rate (TAX)
    38.32 %          
Variable Expenses (Blended Commission %)
      3.72 %  
After Tax Reinvest. Rate (R)
    1.10 %          
Percentage Sold (PCT)
      70.5394 %  
Est. Conversion Expenses (1)(X)
    4.17 %          
MHC Assets
    $ 289,000    
Insider Purchases
  $ 1,645,000            
Options as (% of Offering + Foundation) (O1)
      5.00 %  
Price/Share
  $ 10.00            
Estimated Option Value (O2)
      16.80 %  
Foundation Cash Contribution (FC)
  $ 40,000,000            
Option Vesting Period (O3)
      5.00        Years
Foundation Stock Contribution (FS)
  $ -            
% of Options taxable (O4)
      25.00 %  
Foundation Tax Benefit (FT)
  $ 15,328,000                          
                     
Calculation of Pro Forma Value After Conversion
         
               
1.    V=
P/E * (Y - FC * R)
 
 
V=
  $ 1,970,529,000  
 
1 - P/E * PCT * ((1-X-E-M-FS)*R - (1-TAX)*(E/T) - (1-TAX)*(M/N)-(1-TAX*O4)*(O1*O2/O3)))
           
                 
2.    V=
P/Core E * (YC)
   
V=
  $ 1,970,529,000  
 
1 - P/Core E * PCT * ((1-X-E-M-FS)*R - (1-TAX)*(E/T) - (1-TAX)*(M/N)-(1-TAX*O4)*(O1*O2/O3)))
           
                 
3.    V=
P/B  *  (B-FC+FT)
   
V=
  $ 1,970,529,000  
 
1 - P/B * PCT * (1-X-E-M)
             
                 
4.    V=
P/TB  *  (B-FC+FT)
   
V=
  $ 1,970,529,000  
 
1 - P/TB * PCT * (1-X-E-M)
             
                 
5.    V=
P/A * (A-FC+FT)
   
V=
  $ 1,970,529,000  
 
1 - P/A * PCT * (1-X-E-M)
             
 
Shares
       
2nd Step
   
Full
   
Plus:
   
Total Market
     
 
 
   
2nd Step
   
Exchange
   
Conversion
   
Foundation
 
Capitalization
   
Exchange
 
Conclusion
 
Offering Shares
   
Shares
   
Shares
   
Shares
   
Shares
   
Ratio
 
Maximum
    159,850,000       66,760,835       226,610,835       0       226,610,835       3.0627  
Midpoint
    139,000,000       58,052,900       197,052,900       0       197,052,900       2.6632  
Minimum
    118,150,000       49,344,965       167,494,965       0       167,494,965       2.2637  
                                                 
Market Value
                                               
           
2nd Step
   
Full
           
Total Market
     
 
 
   
2nd Step
   
Exchange
   
Conversion
   
Foundation
 
Capitalization
     
 
 
Conclusion
 
Offering Value
   
Shares Value
   
$ Value
   
$ Value
   
$ Value
         
Maximum
  $ 1,598,500,000     $ 667,608,350     $ 2,266,108,350       0     $ 2,266,108,350          
Midpoint
  $ 1,390,000,000     $ 580,529,000     $ 1,970,529,000       0     $ 1,970,529,000          
Minimum
  $ 1,181,500,000     $ 493,449,650     $ 1,674,949,650       0     $ 1,674,949,650          
 
(1) Estimated offering expenses at midpoint of the offering.
(2) Adjusted to reflect consolidation of $289,000 of MHC net assets.
 
 
 

 
 
Pro Forma Effect of Conversion Proceeds
 
 
 

 
 
Exhibit 4
PRO FORMA EFFECT OF CONVERSION PROCEEDS
Capitol Federal Financial
At the Minimum of the Range
 
1.
Fully Converted Value and Exchange Ratio
       
 
  Fully Converted Value
    $ 1,674,949,650  
 
  Exchange Ratio
      2.26372  
             
 
  2nd Step Offering Proceeds
    $ 1,181,500,000  
 
   Less: Estimated Offering Expenses
      50,154,463  
 
  2nd Step Net Conversion Proceeds (Including Foundation)
    $ 1,131,345,538  
             
             
2.
Estimated Additional Income from Conversion Proceeds
         
             
 
Net Conversion Proceeds
    $ 1,131,345,538  
 
    Less: Cash Contribution to Foundation
      (40,000,000 )
 
    Less: ESOP Stock Purchases (1)
      (47,260,000 )
 
    Less: RRP Stock Purchases (2)
      (23,630,000 )
 
Net Cash Proceeds
    $ 1,020,455,538  
 
Estimated after-tax net incremental rate of return
      1.10 %
 
Earnings Increase
    $ 11,266,564  
 
    Less: Consolidated interest cost of ESOP borrowings
      0  
 
    Less: Amortization of ESOP borrowings(3)
      (971,666 )
 
    Less: RRP Vesting (3)
      (2,914,997 )
 
    Less: Option Plan Vesting (4)
      (1,794,765 )
 
Net Earnings Increase
    $ 5,585,137  
 
                   
Net
       
             
Before
   
Earnings
   
After
 
3.
Pro Forma Earnings
         
Conversion
   
Increase
   
Conversion
 
                             
 
12 Months ended June 30, 2010 (reported)
    $ 69,231,000     $ 5,585,137     $ 74,816,137  
 
12 Months ended June 30, 2010 (core)
    $ 64,549,000     $ 5,585,137     $ 70,134,137  
                                   
       
Before
   
Net Cash
   
Tax Benefit
   
After
 
4.
Pro Forma Net Worth
   
Conversion(5)
   
Proceeds
   
and Other
   
Conversion
 
                                   
 
June 30, 2010
    $ 960,289,000     $ 1,020,455,538     $ 15,328,000     $ 1,996,072,538  
 
June 30, 2010 (Tangible)
    $ 960,289,000     $ 1,020,455,538     $ 15,328,000     $ 1,996,072,538  
                                     
       
Before
   
Net Cash
   
Tax Benefit
   
After
 
5.
Pro Forma Assets
   
Conversion(5)
   
Proceeds
   
and Other
   
Conversion
 
                                     
 
June 30, 2010
    $ 8,543,357,000     $ 1,020,455,538     $ 15,328,000     $ 9,579,140,538  
 
(1)
Includes ESOP purchases of 4% of the second step offering.
       
(2)
Includes RRP purchases of 2% of the second step offering.
       
(3)
ESOP amortized over 30 years, RRP amortized over 5 years, tax effected at:
    38.32%  
(4)
Option valuation based on Black-Scholes model, 5 year vesting, and assuming 25% taxable.
 
(5)
Adjusted to include consolidated MHC assets.
       
 
 
 

 
 
Exhibit 4
PRO FORMA EFFECT OF CONVERSION PROCEEDS
Capitol Federal Financial
At the Midpoint of the Range
 
1.
Fully Converted Value and Exchange Ratio
     
 
  Fully Converted Value
  $ 1,970,529,000  
 
  Exchange Ratio
    2.66320  
           
 
  2nd Step Offering Proceeds
  $ 1,390,000,000  
 
   Less: Estimated Offering Expenses
    57,910,663  
 
  2nd Step Net Conversion Proceeds (Including Foundation)
  $ 1,332,089,338  
           
           
2.
Estimated Additional Income from Conversion Proceeds
       
           
 
Net Conversion Proceeds
  $ 1,332,089,338  
 
    Less: Cash Contribution to Foundation
    (40,000,000 )
 
    Less: ESOP Stock Purchases (1)
    (55,600,000 )
 
    Less: RRP Stock Purchases (2)
    (27,800,000 )
 
Net Cash Proceeds
  $ 1,208,689,338  
 
Estimated after-tax net incremental rate of return
    1.10 %
 
Earnings Increase
  $ 13,344,801  
 
    Less: Consolidated interest cost of ESOP borrowings
    0  
 
    Less: Amortization of ESOP borrowings(3)
    (1,143,136 )
 
    Less: RRP Vesting (3)
    (3,429,408 )
 
    Less: Option Plan Vesting (4)
    (2,111,488 )
 
Net Earnings Increase
  $ 6,660,769  
 
                 
Net
       
           
Before
   
Earnings
   
After
 
3.
Pro Forma Earnings
       
Conversion
   
Increase
   
Conversion
 
                           
 
12 Months ended June 30, 2010 (reported)
    $ 69,231,000     $ 6,660,769     $ 75,891,769  
 
12 Months ended June 30, 2010 (core)
    $ 64,549,000     $ 6,660,769     $ 71,209,769  
                                 
     
Before
   
Net Cash
   
Tax Benefit
   
After
 
4.
Pro Forma Net Worth
 
Conversion (5)
   
Proceeds
   
of Foundation
   
Conversion
 
                                 
 
June 30, 2010
  $ 960,289,000     $ 1,208,689,338     $ 15,328,000     $ 2,184,306,338  
 
June 30, 2010 (Tangible)
  $ 960,289,000     $ 1,208,689,338     $ 15,328,000     $ 2,184,306,338  
                                   
     
Before
   
Net Cash
   
Tax Benefit
   
After
 
5.
Pro Forma Assets
 
Conversion (5)
   
Proceeds
   
of Foundation
   
Conversion
 
                                   
 
June 30, 2010
  $ 8,543,357,000     $ 1,208,689,338     $ 15,328,000     $ 9,767,374,338  
 
(1)
Includes ESOP purchases of 4% of the second step offering.
     
(2)
Includes RRP purchases of 2% of the second step offering.
     
(3)
ESOP amortized over 30 years, RRP amortized over 5 years, tax effected at:
    38.32%  
(4)
Option valuation based on Black-Scholes model, 5 year vesting, and assuming 25% taxable.
 
(5)
Adjusted to include consolidated MHC assets.
       
 
 
 

 
 
Exhibit 4
PRO FORMA EFFECT OF CONVERSION PROCEEDS
Capitol Federal Financial
At the Maximum of the Range
 
1.
Fully Converted Value and Exchange Ratio
     
 
  Fully Converted Value
  $ 2,266,108,350  
 
  Exchange Ratio
    3.06268  
           
 
  2nd Step Offering Proceeds
  $ 1,598,500,000  
 
   Less: Estimated Offering Expenses
    65,666,863  
 
  2nd Step Net Conversion Proceeds (Including Foundation)
  $ 1,532,833,138  
           
           
2.
Estimated Additional Income from Conversion Proceeds
       
           
 
Net Conversion Proceeds
  $ 1,532,833,138  
 
    Less: Cash Contribution to Foundation
    (40,000,000 )
 
    Less: ESOP Stock Purchases (1)
    (63,940,000 )
 
    Less: RRP Stock Purchases (2)
    (31,970,000 )
 
Net Cash Proceeds
  $ 1,396,923,138  
 
Estimated after-tax net incremental rate of return
    1.10 %
 
Earnings Increase
  $ 15,423,037  
 
    Less: Consolidated interest cost of ESOP borrowings
    0  
 
    Less: Amortization of ESOP borrowings(3)
    (1,314,606 )
 
    Less: RRP Vesting (3)
    (3,943,819 )
 
    Less: Option Plan Vesting (4)
    (2,428,211 )
 
Net Earnings Increase
  $ 7,736,401  
 
                 
Net
       
           
Before
   
Earnings
   
After
 
3.
Pro Forma Earnings
       
Conversion
   
Increase
   
Conversion
 
                           
 
12 Months ended June 30, 2010 (reported)
    $ 69,231,000     $ 7,736,401     $ 76,967,401  
 
12 Months ended June 30, 2010 (core)
    $ 64,549,000     $ 7,736,401     $ 72,285,401  
                                 
     
Before
   
Net Cash
   
Tax Benefit
   
After
 
4.
Pro Forma Net Worth
 
Conversion (5)
   
Proceeds
   
of Foundation
   
Conversion
 
                                 
 
June 30, 2010
  $ 960,289,000     $ 1,396,923,138     $ 15,328,000     $ 2,372,540,138  
 
June 30, 2010 (Tangible)
  $ 960,289,000     $ 1,396,923,138     $ 15,328,000     $ 2,372,540,138  
                                   
     
Before
   
Net Cash
   
Tax Benefit
   
After
 
5.
Pro Forma Assets
 
Conversion (5)
   
Proceeds
   
of Foundation
   
Conversion
 
                                   
 
June 30, 2010
  $ 8,543,357,000     $ 1,396,923,138     $ 15,328,000     $ 9,955,608,138  
 
(1)
Includes ESOP purchases of 4% of the second step offering.
       
(2)
Includes RRP purchases of 2% of the second step offering.
       
(3)
ESOP amortized over 30 years, RRP amortized over 5 years, tax effected at:
    38.32%  
(4)
Option valuation based on Black-Scholes model, 5 year vesting, and assuming 25% taxable.
 
(5)
Adjusted to include consolidated MHC assets.
       
 
 
 

 
 
Firm Qualifications Statement
 
 
 

 
 
RP® FINANCIAL, LC.
 
Serving the Financial Services Industry Since 1988
 
 
FIRM QUALIFICATION STATEMENT
 
RP® Financial (“RP®) provides financial and management consulting, merger advisory and valuation services to the financial services industry nationwide.  We offer a broad array of services, high quality and prompt service, hands-on involvement by principals and senior staff, careful structuring of strategic initiatives and sophisticated valuation and other analyses consistent with industry practices and regulatory requirements.  Our staff maintains extensive background in financial and management consulting, valuation and investment banking.  Our clients include commercial banks, thrifts, credit unions, mortgage companies and other financial services companies.
 
STRATEGIC PLANNING SERVICES
 
RP®’s strategic planning services are designed to provide effective feasible plans with quantifiable results.  We analyze strategic options to enhance shareholder value, achieve regulatory approval or realize other objectives.  Such services involve conducting situation analyses; establishing mission/vision statements, strategic goals and objectives; and identifying strategies to enhance franchise and/or market value, capital management, earnings enhancement, operational matters and organizational issues.  Strategic recommendations typically focus on:  capital formation and management, asset/liability targets, profitability, return on equity and stock pricing.  Our proprietary financial simulation models provide the basis for evaluating the impact of various strategies and assessing their feasibility and compatibility with regulations.
 
MERGER ADVISORY SERVICES
 
RP®’s merger advisory services include targeting potential buyers and sellers, assessing acquisition merit, conducting due diligence, negotiating and structuring merger transactions, preparing merger business plans and financial simulations, rendering fairness opinions, preparing mark-to-market analyses and supporting the implementation of post-acquisition strategies.  RP® is also expert in de novo charters, shelf charters and negotiating acquisitions of troubled institutions.  Through financial simulations, comprehensive data bases, valuation proficiency and regulatory familiarity, RP®’s merger advisory services center on enhancing shareholder returns.
 
VALUATION SERVICES
 
RP®’s extensive valuation practice includes bank and thrift mergers, thrift mutual-to-stock conversions, goodwill impairment, insurance company demutualizations, ESOPs, subsidiary companies, purchase accounting and other purposes.  We are highly experienced in performing appraisals which conform to regulatory guidelines and appraisal standards.  RP® is the nation’s leading valuation firm for thrift mutual-to-stock conversions, with appraised values ranging up to $4 billion.
 
OTHER CONSULTING SERVICES
 
RP® offers other consulting services including evaluating the impact of regulatory changes (TARP, etc.), branching and diversification strategies, feasibility studies and special research.  We assist banks/thrifts in preparing CRA plans and evaluating wealth management activities on a de novo or merger basis.  Our other consulting services are aided by proprietary valuation and financial simulation models.
 
KEY PERSONNEL (Years of Relevant Experience & Contact Information)
 
Ronald S. Riggins, Managing Director (29)
(703) 647-6543
rriggins@rpfinancial.com
William E. Pommerening, Managing Director (25)
(703) 647-6546
wpommerening@rpfinancial.com
Gregory E. Dunn, Director (26)
(703) 647-6548
gdunn@rpfinancial.com
James P. Hennessey, Director (23)
(703) 647-6544
jhennessey@rpfinancial.com
James J. Oren, Director (22)
(703) 647-6549
joren@rpfinancial.com
Timothy M. Biddle, Senior Vice President (19)
(703) 647-6552
tbiddle@rpfinancial.com
Janice Hollar, Senior Vice President (24)
(703) 647-6554
jhollar@rpfinancial.com

   
Washington Headquarters
 
Three Ballston Plaza
Telephone:  (703) 528-1700
1100 North Glebe Road, Suite 1100
Fax No.:  (703) 528-1788
Arlington, VA  22201
Toll-Free No.:  (866) 723-0594
www.rpfinancial.com
E-Mail:  mail@rpfinancial.com