XML 37 R16.htm IDEA: XBRL DOCUMENT v3.3.1.900
Loans Receivable and Allowance for Loan Losses
12 Months Ended
Dec. 31, 2015
Receivables [Abstract]  
Loans Receivable and Allowance for Loan Losses
LOANS RECEIVABLE AND ALLOWANCE FOR LOAN LOSSES
Because the period to submit losses for non-single family loans covered under the FDIC loss sharing agreements expired in third quarter 2015, and the balance of covered loans at December 31, 2015 and 2014 was insignificant to Customers' total loan portfolio, the disaggregation between covered and non-covered loans is no longer presented in the disclosures that follow. Additional disaggregation of the commercial real estate loan portfolio between owner occupied and non-owner occupied is presented. Prior period amounts have been reclassified to conform with the current period presentation.
  
The following table presents loans receivable as of December 31, 2015 and 2014.
 
December 31,
 
2015
 
2014
(amounts in thousands)
 
 
 
 Commercial:
 
 
 
Multi-family
$
2,909,439

 
$
2,208,405

Commercial and industrial (including owner occupied commercial real estate)
1,111,400

 
785,669

Commercial real estate non-owner occupied
956,255

 
839,310

Construction
87,240

 
49,718

 Total commercial loans
5,064,334

 
3,883,102

 Consumer:
 
 
 
 Residential real estate
271,613

 
297,395

 Manufactured housing
113,490

 
126,731

 Other
3,708

 
4,433

 Total consumer loans
388,811

 
428,559

Total loans receivable
5,453,145

 
4,311,661

 Deferred costs and unamortized premiums, net
334

 
512

 Allowance for loan losses
(35,647
)
 
(30,932
)
 Loans receivable, net of allowance for loan losses
$
5,417,832

 
$
4,281,241




The following tables summarize loans receivable by loan type and performance status as of December 31, 2015 and 2014:
 
December 31, 2015
 
30-89 Days
Past Due (1)
 
90 Or
More Days
Past Due (1)
 
Total Past
Due Still
Accruing (1)
 
Non-
Accrual
 
Current (2)
 
Purchased-
Credit-
Impaired
Loans (3)
 
Total Loans (4)
(amounts in thousands)
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Multi-family
$

 
$

 
$

 
$

 
$
2,905,789

 
$
3,650

 
$
2,909,439

Commercial and industrial
39

 

 
39

 
1,973

 
799,595

 
1,552

 
803,159

Commercial real estate - owner occupied
268

 

 
268

 
2,700

 
292,312

 
12,961

 
308,241

Commercial real estate - non-owner occupied
1,997

 

 
1,997

 
1,307

 
940,895

 
12,056

 
956,255

Construction

 

 

 

 
87,006

 
234

 
87,240

Residential real estate
2,986

 

 
2,986

 
2,202

 
257,984

 
8,441

 
271,613

Manufactured housing (5)
3,752

 
2,805

 
6,557

 
2,449

 
101,132

 
3,352

 
113,490

Other consumer
107

 

 
107

 
140

 
3,227

 
234

 
3,708

Total
$
9,149


$
2,805


$
11,954


$
10,771


$
5,387,940


$
42,480

 
$
5,453,145

 
December 31, 2014
 
30-89 Days
Past Due (1)
 
90 Or
More Days
Past Due (1)
 
Total Past
Due Still
Accruing (1)
 
Non-
Accrual
 
Current (2)
 
Purchased-
Credit-
Impaired
Loans (3)
 
Total Loans (4)
(amounts in thousands)
 
 
Multi-family
$

 
$

 
$

 
$

 
$
2,204,059

 
$
4,346

 
$
2,208,405

Commercial and industrial
884

 

 
884

 
2,513

 
543,245

 
3,293

 
549,935

Commercial real estate - owner occupied

 

 

 
2,514

 
217,187

 
16,033

 
235,734

Commercial real estate - non-owner occupied

 

 

 
1,460

 
822,046

 
15,804

 
839,310

Construction

 

 

 
2,325

 
44,483

 
2,910

 
49,718

Residential real estate
1,226

 

 
1,226

 
1,855

 
284,347

 
9,967

 
297,395

Manufactured housing (5)
6,324

 
4,388

 
10,712

 
931

 
111,072

 
4,016

 
126,731

Other consumer
147

 

 
147

 
135

 
3,903

 
248

 
4,433

Total
$
8,581

 
$
4,388

 
$
12,969

 
$
11,733

 
$
4,230,342

 
$
56,617

 
$
4,311,661

 
(1)
Includes past due loans that are accruing interest because collection is considered probable.
(2)
Loans where next payment due is less than 30 days from the report date.
(3)
Purchased-credit-impaired loans aggregated into a pool are accounted for as a single asset with a single composite interest rate and an aggregate expectation of cash flows, and the past due status of the pools, or that of the individual loans within the pools, is not meaningful. Because of the credit impaired nature of the loans, the loans are recorded at a discount reflecting estimated future cash flows and the Bank recognizes interest income on each pool of loans reflecting the estimated yield and passage of time. Such loans are considered to be performing. Purchased-credit-impaired loans that are not in pools accrete interest when the timing and amount of their expected cash flows are reasonably estimable, and are reported as performing loans.
(4)
Amounts exclude deferred costs and fees, unamortized premiums and discounts, and the allowance for loan losses.
(5)
Manufactured housing loans purchased in 2010 are supported by cash reserves held at the Bank that are used to fund past-due payments when the loan becomes 90 days or more delinquent. Subsequent purchases are subject to varying provisions in the event of borrowers’ delinquencies.
Allowance for Loan Losses and the FDIC Loss Sharing Receivable and Clawback Liability
Losses incurred on covered loans are eligible for partial reimbursement by the FDIC. Subsequent to the purchase date, the expected cash flows on the covered loans are subject to evaluation. Decreases in the present value of expected cash flows on the covered loans are recognized by increasing the allowance for loan losses with a related charge to the provision for loan losses. At the same time, the FDIC indemnification asset is increased reflecting an estimated future collection from the FDIC, which is recorded as a reduction to the provision for loan losses. If the expected cash flows on the covered loans increase such that a previously recorded impairment can be reversed, the Bank records a reduction in the allowance for loan losses (with a related credit to the provision for loan losses) accompanied by a reduction in the FDIC receivable balance (with a related charge to the provision for loan losses). Increases in expected cash flows on covered loans and decreases in expected cash flows of the FDIC loss sharing receivable, when there are no previously recorded impairments, are considered together and recognized over the remaining life of the loans as interest income. Decreases in the valuations of other real estate owned covered by the loss sharing agreements are recorded net of the estimated FDIC receivable as an increase to other real estate owned expense (a component of non-interest expense).

The FDIC loss sharing receivable balance will be reduced through a charge to the provision for loan losses, with no offsetting reduction to the allowance for loan losses, as the period to submit losses under the FDIC loss sharing arrangements approaches expiration and the estimated losses in the covered loans have not yet emerged or been realized in a final disposition event. The period to submit losses under the FDIC loss sharing arrangements for non-single family loans expired in third quarter 2015. The period to submit losses under the FDIC loss sharing arrangements for single family loans expires in third quarter 2017. The final maturity of the FDIC loss sharing arrangements occurs in third quarter 2020. As of December 2015 and 2014, loans covered under loss sharing agreements with the FDIC were $13.8 million and $42.2 million, respectively.

As part of the FDIC loss sharing arrangements, Customers also assumed a liability to be paid within 45 days subsequent to the maturity or termination of the loss sharing arrangements that is contingent upon actual losses incurred over the life of the arrangements relative to expected losses and the consideration paid upon acquisition of the failed institutions. Due to cash received on the covered assets in excess of the original expectations of the FDIC, the Bank anticipates that it will be required to pay the FDIC at the end of its loss sharing arrangements. As of December 31, 2015, a clawback liability of $2.3 million has been recorded. To the extent actual losses on the covered assets are less than estimated losses, the clawback liability will increase. To the extent actual losses on the covered assets are more than the estimated losses, the clawback liability will decrease.

As of December 31, 2015, Customers expects to collect $0.2 million from the FDIC for estimated losses and reimbursement of external costs, such as legal fees, real estate taxes and appraisal expenses, and estimated the clawback liability due to the FDIC in 2020 at $2.3 million. The net amount of $2.1 million is included in "Accrued interest payable and other liabilities" in the accompanying consolidated balance sheet.
The following table presents changes in the allowance for loans losses and the FDIC loss sharing receivable, including the effect of the estimated clawback liability for the years ended December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013.
 
 
Allowance for Loan Losses
For The Year Ended December 31,
 
2015
 
2014
 
2013
(amounts in thousands)
 
Beginning Balance
$
30,932

 
$
23,998

 
$
25,837

Provision for loan losses (1)
16,694

 
10,058

 
5,055

Charge-offs
(13,412
)
 
(4,947
)
 
(7,338
)
Recoveries
1,433

 
1,823

 
444

Ending Balance
$
35,647

 
$
30,932

 
$
23,998


 
 
FDIC Loss Sharing Receivable
For The Year Ended December 31,
 
2015
 
2014
 
2013
(amounts in thousands)
 
Beginning Balance
$
2,320

 
$
10,046

 
$
12,343

Increased (decreased) estimated cash flows (2)
(3,872
)
 
(4,689
)
 
2,819

Increased estimated cash flows from covered OREO (a)
3,138

 

 

Other activity, net (b)
248

 
2,409

 
1,610

Cash receipts from FDIC
(3,917
)
 
(5,446
)
 
(6,726
)
Ending Balance
$
(2,083
)
 
$
2,320

 
$
10,046

 
 
 
 
 
 
(1)    Provision for loan losses
$
16,694

 
$
10,058

 
$
5,055

(2)    Effect attributable to FDIC loss share arrangements
3,872

 
4,689

 
(2,819
)
Net amount reported as provision for loan losses
$
20,566

 
$
14,747

 
$
2,236

 
(a) Recorded as a reduction to Other Real Estate Owned expense (a component of non-interest expense).
(b) Includes external costs, such as legal fees, real estate taxes and appraisal expenses, that qualify for reimbursement under loss share arrangements.

Loans Individually Evaluated for Impairment

The following tables present the recorded investment (net of charge-offs), unpaid principal balance, and related allowance by
loan type for loans that are individually evaluated for impairment as of December 31, 2015 and 2014 and the
average recorded investment and interest income recognized for the years ended December 31, 2015 and
2014. Purchased-credit-impaired loans are considered to be performing and are not included in the tables below.

 
December 31, 2015
 
Year Ended December 31, 2015
 
Recorded
Investment
Net of
Charge Offs
 
Unpaid
Principal
Balance
 
Related
Allowance
 
Average
Recorded
Investment
 
Interest
Income
Recognized
(amounts in thousands)
 
With no related allowance recorded:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Multi-family
$
661

 
$
661

 
$

 
$
267

 
$
24

Commercial and industrial
12,056

 
13,028

 

 
8,543

 
891

Commercial real estate - owner occupied
8,317

 
8,317

 

 
6,526

 
454

Commercial real estate - non-owner occupied
4,276

 
4,276

 

 
6,605

 
648

Construction

 

 

 
749

 

Other consumer
48

 
48

 

 
42

 
1

Residential real estate
4,331

 
4,331

 

 
2,254

 
86

Manufactured housing
8,300

 
8,300

 

 
5,433

 
368

With an allowance recorded:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Commercial and industrial
5,565

 
5,914

 
1,990

 
9,331

 
191

Commercial real estate - owner occupied
12

 
12

 
1

 
15

 
1

Commercial real estate - non-owner occupied
555

 
555

 
148

 
817

 
12

Construction

 

 

 

 

Other consumer
92

 
92

 
50

 
83

 

Residential real estate
395

 
395

 
84

 
426

 
2

Total
$
44,608

 
$
45,929

 
$
2,273

 
$
41,091

 
$
2,678

 
December 31, 2014
 
Year Ended December 31, 2014
 
Recorded
Investment
Net of
Charge Offs
 
Unpaid
Principal
Balance
 
Related
Allowance
 
Average
Recorded
Investment
 
Interest
Income
Recognized
(amounts in thousands)
 
With no related allowance recorded:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Commercial and industrial
$
14,600

 
$
16,122

 
$

 
$
13,329

 
$
674

Commercial real estate - owner occupied
12,599

 
12,744

 

 
10,204

 
504

Commercial real estate - non-owner occupied
5,602

 
5,602

 
 
 
7,770

 
383

Construction
2,325

 
2,325

 

 
2,415

 
41

Other consumer
21

 
21

 

 
26

 

Residential real estate
3,675

 
5,917

 

 
4,145

 
87

Manufactured housing
2,588

 
2,588

 

 
2,588

 
128

With an allowance recorded:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Commercial and industrial
1,923

 
1,923

 
857

 
1,725

 
28

Commercial real estate - owner occupied
750

 
750

 
95

 
1,184

 
22

Commercial real estate - non-owner occupied
571

 
571

 
170

 
902

 
17

Construction

 

 

 
851

 

Other consumer
114

 
114

 
32

 
82

 
1

Residential real estate
365

 
365

 
188

 
296

 
1

Total
$
45,133

 
$
49,042

 
$
1,342

 
$
45,517

 
$
1,886


Troubled Debt Restructurings
At December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013 there were $11.4 million, $5.0 million, $4.6 million respectively, in loans categorized as troubled debt restructurings (“TDRs”). TDRs are reported as impaired loans in the calendar year of their restructuring and are evaluated to determine whether they should be placed on non-accrual status. In subsequent years, a TDR may be returned to accrual status if the borrower satisfies a minimum six-month performance requirement; however, it will remain classified as impaired. Generally, the Bank requires sustained performance for nine months before returning a TDR to accrual status.
Modification of purchased-credit-impaired loans that are accounted for within loan pools in accordance with the accounting standards for purchased-credit-impaired loans do not result in the removal of these loans from the pool even if modifications would otherwise be considered a TDR. Accordingly, as each pool is accounted for as a single asset with a single composite interest rate and an aggregate expectation of cash flows, modifications of loans within such pools are not considered TDRs.
The following is an analysis of loans modified in a troubled debt restructuring by type of concession for the years ended December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013. There were no modifications that involved forgiveness of debt.
 
 
December 31, 2015
 
Number
of Loans
 
Recorded
Investment
(dollars in thousands)
 
Extended under forbearance
1

 
$
183

Interest-rate reductions
161

 
7,274

Total
162

 
$
7,457



 
December 31, 2014
 
Number
of Loans
 
Recorded
Investment
(dollars in thousands)
 
Extended under forbearance
11

 
$
460

Interest rate reductions
10

 
620

Total
21

 
$
1,080




 
December 31, 2013
 
Number
of Loans
 
Recorded
Investment
(dollars in thousands)
 
Extended under forbearance

 
$

Interest rate reductions
14

 
1,238

Total
14

 
$
1,238







The following table provides, by loan type, the number of loans modified in troubled debt restructurings and the related
recorded investment during the years ended December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013.
 
 
December 31, 2015
 
Number
of Loans
 
Recorded
Investment
(dollars in thousands)
 
Commercial and industrial
3

 
$
791

Commercial real estate non-owner occupied
1

 
211

Manufactured housing
156

 
6,251

Residential real estate
2

 
204

Total loans
162

 
$
7,457

 
 
December 31, 2014
 
Number
of Loans
 
Recorded
Investment
(dollars in thousands)
 
Manufactured housing
10

 
$
620

Home equity / other
11

 
460

Total loans
21

 
$
1,080


 
December 31, 2013
 
Number
of Loans
 
Recorded
Investment
(dollars in thousands)
 
Manufactured housing
13

 
$
1,206

Home equity / other
1

 
32

Total loans
14

 
$
1,238


As of December 31, 2015, 2014, 2013, there were no commitments to lend additional funds to debtors whose terms have been modified in TDRs.
For the years ended December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, the recorded investment of loans determined to be TDRs was $7.5 million, $1.1 million and $1.2 million respectively, both before and after restructuring. During the year ending December 31, 2015, thirty-six TDR loans defaulted with a recorded investment of $2.5 million. During the year ending December 31, 2014, six TDR loans defaulted with a recorded investment of $0.4 million. During the year ended December 31, 2013, five TDR loans defaulted with a recorded investment of $0.4 million. For the year ended 2015, $1.8 million of the $2.5 million defaulted loans are subject to a cash reserve.

Loans modified in troubled debt restructurings are evaluated for impairment. The nature and extent of impairment of TDRs, including those which have experienced a subsequent default, is considered in the determination of an appropriate level of allowance for credit losses. There were three specific allowances resulting from TDR modifications during 2015, totaling $0.2 million for 2 commercial and industrial loans, and $0.1 million for one commercial real estate non-owner occupied loan. There were no specific allowances resulting from TDR modifications during 2014 or 2013.
Credit Quality Indicators
Commercial and industrial, commercial real estate, multi-family, residential real estate and construction loans are based on an internally assigned risk rating system which are assigned at loan origination and reviewed on a periodic or “as needed” basis. Other consumer and manufactured housing loans are evaluated based on the payment activity of the loan.
To facilitate the monitoring of credit quality within commercial and industrial, commercial real estate, construction, multi-family and residential real estate loans, and for purposes of analyzing historical loss rates used in the determination of the allowance for loan losses for the respective portfolio class, the Bank utilizes the following categories of risk ratings: pass/satisfactory (includes risk rating 1 through 6), special mention, substandard, doubtful, and loss. The risk rating categories, which are derived from standard regulatory rating definitions, are assigned upon initial approval of credit to borrowers and updated periodically thereafter. Pass/satisfactory ratings, which are assigned to those borrowers who do not have identified potential or well-defined weaknesses and for whom there is a high likelihood of orderly repayment, are updated periodically based on the size and credit characteristics of the borrower. All other categories are updated on a quarterly basis during the month preceding the end of the calendar quarter. Certain consumer loans are not assigned a risk rating. While assigning risk ratings involves judgment, the risk-rating process allows management to identify riskier credits in a timely manner and allocate the appropriate resources to managing the loans.
The risk rating grades are defined as follows:
“1” – Pass/Excellent
Loans rated 1 represent a credit extension of the highest quality. The borrower’s historic (at least five years) cash flows manifest extremely large and stable margins of coverage. Balance sheets are conservative, well capitalized, and liquid. After considering debt service for proposed and existing debt, projected cash flows continue to be strong and provide ample coverage. The borrower typically reflects broad geographic and product diversification and has access to alternative financial markets.
“2” – Pass/Superior
Loans rated 2 are those for which the borrower has a strong financial condition, balance sheet, operations, cash flow, debt capacity and coverage with ratios better than industry norms. The borrowers of these loans exhibit a limited leverage position, are virtually immune to local economies, and are in stable growing industries. The management team is well respected and the company has ready access to public markets.
“3” – Pass/Strong
Loans rated 3 are those loans for which the borrower has above average financial condition and flexibility; more than satisfactory debt service coverage; balance sheet and operating ratios are consistent with or better than industry peers; have little industry risk; and move in diversified markets and are experienced and competent in their industry. These borrowers access to capital markets is limited mostly to private sources, often secured, but the borrower typically has access to a wide range of refinancing alternatives.
“4” – Pass/Good
Loans rated 4 have a sound primary and secondary source of repayment. The borrower may have access to alternative sources of financing, bust sources are not as widely available as they are to a higher grade borrower. These loans carry a normal level of risk, with very low loss exposure. The borrower has the ability to perform according to the terms of the credit facility. The margins of cash flow coverage are satisfactory but vulnerable to more rapid deterioration than the higher quality loans.
“5” – Satisfactory
Loans rated 5 are extended to borrowers who are determined to be a reasonable credit risk and demonstrate the ability to repay the debt from normal business operations. Risk factors may include reliability of margins and cash flows, liquidity, dependence on a single product or industry, cyclical trends, depth of management, or limited access to alternative financing sources. The borrower’s historical financial information may indicate erratic performance, but current trends are positive and the quality of financial information is adequate, but is not as detailed and sophisticated as information found on higher grade loans. If adverse circumstances arise, the impact on the borrower may be significant.
“6” – Satisfactory/Bankable with Care
Loans rated 6 are those for which the borrower has higher than normal credit risk; however, cash flow and asset values are generally intact. These borrowers may exhibit declining financial characteristics, with increasing leverage and decreasing liquidity, and may have limited resources and access to financial alternatives. Signs of weakness in these borrowers may include delinquent taxes, trade slowness and eroding profit margins.
“7” – Special Mention
Loans rated Special Mention are credit facilities that may have potential developing weaknesses and deserve extra attention from the account manager and other management personnel. In the event potential weaknesses are not corrected or mitigated, deterioration in the ability of the borrower to repay the debt in the future may occur. This grade is not assigned to loans that bear certain peculiar risks normally associated with the type of financing involved, unless circumstances have caused the risk to increase to a level higher than would have been acceptable when the credit was originally approved. Loans where significant actual, not potential, weaknesses or problems are clearly evident are graded in the category below.
“8” – Substandard
Loans are classified Substandard when the loans are inadequately protected by the current sound worth and payment capacity of the obligor or of the collateral pledged, if any. Loans so classified must have a well-defined weakness or weaknesses that jeopardize the liquidation of the debt and are characterized by the distinct possibility that the company will sustain some loss if the weaknesses are not corrected.
“9” – Doubtful
Doubtful ratings are assigned to loans that have all the attributes of a substandard rating with the added characteristic that the weaknesses make collection or liquidation in full, on the basis of currently existing facts, conditions, and values, highly questionable and improbable. The possibility of loss is extremely high, but because of certain important and reasonable specific pending factors that may work to the advantage of and strengthen the credit quality of the loan, its classification as an estimated loss is deferred until its more exact status may be determined. Pending factors may include a proposed merger or acquisition, liquidation proceeding, capital injection, perfecting liens on additional collateral or refinancing plans.
“10” – Loss
The Bank assigns a loss rating to loans considered uncollectible and of such little value that their continuance as an active asset is not warranted. Amounts classified as loss are immediately charged off.
Risk ratings are not established for certain consumer loans, including home equity loans, manufactured housing, and installment loans, mainly because these portfolios consist of a larger number of homogeneous loans with smaller balances. Instead, these portfolios are evaluated for risk mainly based upon aggregate payment history through the monitoring of delinquency levels and trends and are classified as performing and nonperforming.
The following table presents the credit ratings as of December 31, 2015 and 2014 for the loans receivable portfolio.
 
December 31, 2015
 
Multi-family
 
Commercial
and
Industrial
 
Commercial
Real Estate Owner Occupied
 
Commercial
Real Estate Non-Owner Occupied
 
Construction
 
Residential
Real Estate
 
Manufactured
Housing
 
Other Consumer
 
Total
(amounts in thousands)
 
 

Pass/Satisfactory
$
2,907,362

 
$
784,892

 
$
295,762

 
$
950,886

 
$
87,240

 
$
268,210

 
$

 
$

 
$
5,294,352

Special Mention
661

 
14,052

 
7,840

 
1,671

 

 
282

 

 

 
24,506

Substandard
1,416

 
4,215

 
4,639

 
3,698

 

 
3,121

 

 

 
17,089

Performing (1)

 

 

 

 

 

 
104,484

 
3,461

 
107,945

Non-performing (2)

 

 

 

 

 

 
9,006

 
247

 
9,253

Total
$
2,909,439

 
$
803,159


$
308,241


$
956,255


$
87,240


$
271,613


$
113,490


$
3,708


$
5,453,145

 
 
December 31, 2014
 
Multi-family
 
Commercial
and
Industrial
 
Commercial
Real Estate Owner Occupied
 
Commercial
Real Estate Non-Owner Occupied
 
Construction
 
Residential
Real Estate
 
Manufactured
Housing
 
Other Consumer
 
Total
(amounts in thousands)
 
 
 
Pass/Satisfactory
$
2,206,776

 
$
531,790

 
$
217,356

 
$
829,238

 
$
44,642

 
$
294,225

 
$

 
$

 
$
4,124,027

Special Mention

 
14,565

 
13,056

 
6,694

 

 
243

 

 

 
34,558

Substandard
1,629

 
3,580

 
5,322

 
3,378

 
5,076

 
2,927

 

 

 
21,912

Performing (1)

 

 

 

 

 

 
115,088

 
4,151

 
119,239

Non-performing (2)

 

 

 

 

 

 
11,643

 
282

 
11,925

Total
$
2,208,405

 
$
549,935

 
$
235,734

 
$
839,310

 
$
49,718

 
$
297,395

 
$
126,731

 
$
4,433

 
$
4,311,661


(1)
Includes consumer and other installment loans not subject to risk ratings.
(2)
Includes loans that are past due and still accruing interest and loans on non-accrual status.

As of December 31, 2015, the Bank had $1.2 million of residential real estate held in other real estate owned. As of December 31, 2015, the Bank initiated foreclosure proceedings on $0.6 million in loans secured by residential real estate.

During second quarter 2015, the Bank refined its methodology for estimating the general allowance for loan losses. Previously, the general allowance for the portion of the loan portfolio originated after December 31, 2009 ("Post 2009 loan portfolio") was based generally on qualitative factors due to insufficient historical loss data on the portfolio. During second quarter 2015, the Bank began using objectively verifiable industry and peer loss data to estimate probable incurred losses as of the balance sheet date for the Post 2009 loan portfolio until sufficient internal loss history is available. The same methodology was also adopted for the portion of the loan portfolio originated on or before December 31, 2009 ("Legacy loan portfolio") that had no loss history over the past two years.
The changes in the allowance for loan losses for the years ended December 31, 2015 and 2014 and the loans and allowance for loan losses by loan class based on impairment evaluation method are as follows. The amounts presented for the provision for loan losses below do not include the effect of changes to estimated benefits resulting from the FDIC loss share arrangements for the covered loans.

Twelve months ended December 31, 2015
Multi-family
 
Commercial
and
Industrial
 
Commercial
Real Estate Owner Occupied
 
Commercial
Real Estate Non-Owner Occupied
 
Construction
 
Residential
Real Estate
 
Manufactured
Housing
 
Other Consumer
 
Total
(amounts in thousands)
 
Beginning Balance, January 1, 2015
$
8,493

 
$
4,784

 
$
4,336

 
$
9,198

 
$
1,047

 
$
2,698

 
$
262

 
$
114

 
$
30,932

Charge-offs

 
(11,331
)
 
(378
)
 
(327
)
 
(1,064
)
 
(276
)
 

 
(36
)
 
(13,412
)
Recoveries

 
548

 
14

 
0

 
204

 
575

 

 
92

 
1,433

Provision for loan losses
3,523

 
14,863

 
(2,624
)
 
(451
)
 
887

 
301

 
232

 
(37
)
 
16,694

Ending Balance, December 31, 2015
$
12,016


$
8,864

 
$
1,348


$
8,420


$
1,074


$
3,298


$
494

 
$
133

 
$
35,647

Loans:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Individually evaluated for impairment
$
661

 
$
17,621

 
$
8,329

 
$
4,831

 
$

 
$
4,726

 
$
8,300

 
$
140

 
$
44,608

Collectively evaluated for impairment
2,905,128

 
783,986

 
286,951

 
939,368

 
87,006

 
258,446

 
101,838

 
3,334

 
5,366,057

Loans acquired with credit deterioration
3,650

 
1,552

 
12,961

 
12,056

 
234

 
8,441

 
3,352

 
234

 
42,480

 
$
2,909,439


$
803,159

 
$
308,241


$
956,255


$
87,240


$
271,613


$
113,490

 
$
3,708

 
$
5,453,145

Allowance for loan losses:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Individually evaluated for impairment
$

 
$
1,990

 
$
1

 
$
148

 
$

 
$
84

 
$

 
$
50

 
$
2,273

Collectively evaluated for impairment
12,016

 
6,650

 
1,347

 
3,858

 
1,074

 
2,141

 
98

 
28

 
27,212

Loans acquired with credit deterioration

 
224

 

 
4,414

 

 
1,073

 
396

 
55

 
6,162

 
$
12,016


$
8,864

 
$
1,348


$
8,420


$
1,074


$
3,298


$
494

 
$
133

 
$
35,647

 
Twelve months ended December 31, 2014
Multi-family
 
Commercial
and
Industrial
 
Commercial
Real Estate Owner Occupied
 
Commercial
Real Estate Non-Owner Occupied
 
Construction
 
Residential
Real Estate
 
Manufactured
Housing
 
Other Consumer
 
Total
(amounts in thousands)
 
Beginning Balance, January 1, 2014
$
4,227

 
$
2,674

 
$
2,517

 
$
8,961

 
$
2,385

 
$
2,490

 
$
614

 
$
130

 
$
23,998

Charge-offs

 
(1,155
)
 
(482
)
 
(1,715
)
 
(895
)
 
(667
)
 

 
(33
)
 
(4,947
)
Recoveries

 
511

 
225

 
801

 
13

 
265

 

 
8

 
1,823

Provision for loan losses
4,266

 
2,754

 
2,076

 
1,151

 
(456
)
 
610

 
(352
)
 
9

 
10,058

Ending Balance, December 31, 2014
$
8,493


$
4,784

 
$
4,336


$
9,198


$
1,047


$
2,698


$
262

 
$
114


$
30,932

Loans:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Individually evaluated for impairment
$

 
$
16,523

 
$
13,349

 
$
6,173

 
$
2,325

 
$
4,040

 
$
2,588

 
$
135

 
$
45,133

Collectively evaluated for impairment
2,204,059

 
530,119

 
206,352

 
817,333

 
44,483

 
283,388

 
120,127

 
4,050

 
4,209,911

Loans acquired with credit deterioration
4,346

 
3,293

 
16,033

 
15,804

 
2,910

 
9,967

 
4,016

 
248

 
56,617

 
$
2,208,405


$
549,935

 
$
235,734


$
839,310


$
49,718


$
297,395


$
126,731

 
$
4,433

 
$
4,311,661

Allowance for loan losses:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Individually evaluated for impairment
$

 
$
857

 
$
95

 
$
170

 
$

 
$
188

 
$

 
$
32

 
$
1,342

Collectively evaluated for impairment
8,493

 
3,765

 
1,757

 
6,580

 
424

 
1,436

 
92

 
28

 
22,575

Loans acquired with credit deterioration

 
162

 
2,484

 
2,448

 
623

 
1,074

 
170

 
54

 
7,015

 
$
8,493


$
4,784

 
$
4,336


$
9,198


$
1,047


$
2,698


$
262

 
$
114


$
30,932



The manufactured housing portfolio was purchased in August 2010. A portion of the purchase price may be used to reimburse the Bank under the specified terms in the Purchase Agreement for defaults of the underlying borrower and other specified items. At December 31, 2015 and 2014, funds available for reimbursement, if necessary, were $1.2 million and $3.0 million, respectively. Each quarter, these funds are evaluated to determine if they would be sufficient to absorb probable losses within the manufactured housing portfolio.
The changes in accretable yield related to purchased-credit-impaired loans for the three and nine months ended September 30,
2015 and 2014 were as follows:
The changes in accretable yield related to purchased-credit-impaired loans for the years ended December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013
were as follows:
 
December 31,
 
2015
 
2014
 
2013
(amounts in thousands)

Accretable yield balance, beginning of period
$
17,606

 
$
22,557

 
$
32,174

Accretion to interest income
(2,299
)
 
(3,201
)
 
(6,213
)
Reclassification from nonaccretable difference and disposals, net
(2,360
)
 
(1,750
)
 
(3,404
)
Accretable yield balance, end of period
$
12,947

 
$
17,606

 
$
22,557