EX-12.1 9 a50173114ex12-1.htm EXHIBIT 12.1 a50173114ex12-1.htm
Exhibit 12.1


OTTER TAIL CORPORATION
CALCULATION OF RATIOS OF EARNINGS TO FIXED CHARGES AND PREFERRED DIVIDENDS

   
Year Ended December 31,
 
   
2007
   
2008
   
2009
   
2010
   
2011
 
Earnings
                             
Pretax income from continuing operations
  $ 71,470,896     $ 47,142,602     $ 19,341,943     $ (11,808,010 )   $ 19,205,944  
Plus fixed charges (see below)
    28,025,370       30,785,207       31,761,177       39,435,307       38,767,710  
Total earnings (1)
  $ 99,496,266     $ 77,927,809     $ 51,103,120     $ 27,627,297     $ 57,973,654  
Fixed Charges
                                       
Interest charges
  $ 22,359,811     $ 28,094,844     $ 27,555,741     $ 34,191,232     $ 34,212,298  
Amortization of debt expense, premium and discount
    1,108,559       990,363       2,097,436       2,825,076       2,233,412  
Estimated interest component of operating leases
    4,557,000       1,700,000       2,108,000       2,419,000       2,322,000  
Total fixed charges (2)
  $ 28,025,370     $ 30,785,207     $ 31,761,177     $ 39,435,308     $ 38,767,710  
                                         
Preferred Dividend Requirement*
  $ 1,033,385     $ 981,547     $ 633,832     $ (954,325 )*   $ 332,627  
                                         
Total Fixed Charges and Preferred Dividend Requirement (3)
  $ 29,058,754     $ 31,766,754     $ 32,395,010     $ 38,480,982     $ 39,100,336  
                                         
Ratio of Earnings to Fixed Charges
(1) Divided by (2)
    3.55       2.53       1.61       0.70 **     1.50  
Ratio of Earnings to Fixed Charges and Preferred Dividends (1) Divided by (3)
    3.42       2.45       1.58       0.72       1.48  

The preferred dividend requirement represents the amount of pre-tax earnings required to cover preferred stock dividend requirements, with a tax gross-up adjustment based on the Company’s ratio of income before income taxes to net income. In 2010, because of income tax adjustments, the Company recorded a net after-tax loss while its income before income taxes was positive, resulting in a ratio of income before income taxes to net income of  (194%). For 2010, a 40.0% incremental tax rate from ongoing operations was used to calculate the tax gross-up adjustment instead of the ratio of income before income taxes to net income.
 
** To increase ratio to 1:1, Total earnings would need to increase by $11,808,010.
 
 
 
1