XML 62 R36.htm IDEA: XBRL DOCUMENT v2.4.0.8
Contingencies (Tables)
6 Months Ended
Jun. 30, 2014
Commitments and Contingencies Disclosure [Abstract]  
Schedule of Tobacco Related Cases Pending Against Company
The table below lists the number of tobacco-related cases pending against us and/or our subsidiaries or indemnitees as of July 30, 2014, August 1, 2013 and August 1, 2012:
 
Type of Case
 
Number of
Cases Pending as of July 30, 2014
 
Number of Cases Pending as of
August 1, 2013
 
Number of Cases Pending as of
August 1, 2012
Individual Smoking and Health Cases
 
63
 
63

 
74

Smoking and Health Class Actions
 
11
 
11

 
10

Health Care Cost Recovery Actions
 
15
 
15

 
14

Lights Class Actions
 
1
 
1

 
2

Individual Lights Cases
 
2
 
1

 
7

Public Civil Actions
 
2
 
4

 
3

Schedule of Verdicts and Post-Trial Developments
The table below lists the verdicts and post-trial developments in the following cases where verdicts were returned in favor of plaintiffs:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Date
  
Location of
Court/Name of
Plaintiff
  
Type of
Case
  
Verdict
  
Post-Trial
Developments
September 2009
  
Brazil/Bernhardt
  
Individual Smoking and Health
  
The Civil Court of Rio de Janeiro found for plaintiff and ordered Philip Morris Brasil to pay R$13,000 (approximately $5,800) in “moral damages.”
  
Philip Morris Brasil filed its appeal against the decision on the merits with the Court of Appeals in November 2009. In February 2010, without addressing the merits, the Court of Appeals annulled the trial court's decision and remanded the case to the trial court to issue a new ruling, which was required to address certain compensatory damage claims made by the plaintiff that the trial court did not address in its original ruling. In July 2010, the trial court reinstated its original decision, while specifically rejecting the compensatory damages claim. Philip Morris Brasil appealed this decision.
In March 2011, the Court of Appeals affirmed the trial court's decision and denied Philip Morris Brasil's appeal. The Court of Appeals increased the amount of damages awarded to the plaintiff to R$100,000 (approximately $44,800). Philip Morris Brasil has appealed this decision.

Date
  
Location of
Court/Name of
Plaintiff
  
Type of
Case
  
Verdict
  
Post-Trial
Developments
February 2004
  
Brazil/The Smoker Health Defense Association
  
Class Action
  
The Civil Court of São Paulo found defendants liable without hearing evidence. The court did not assess actual damages, which were to be assessed in a second phase of the case. The size of the class was not defined in the ruling.
  
In April 2004, the court clarified its ruling, awarding “moral damages” of R$1,000 (approximately $450) per smoker per full year of smoking plus interest at the rate of 1% per month, as of the date of the ruling. The court did not award actual damages, which were to be assessed in the second phase of the case. The size of the class was not estimated. Defendants appealed to the São Paulo Court of Appeals, which annulled the ruling in November 2008, finding that the trial court had inappropriately ruled without hearing evidence and returned the case to the trial court for further proceedings. In May 2011, the trial court dismissed the claim. Plaintiff has appealed. In addition, the defendants filed a constitutional appeal to the Federal Supreme Tribunal on the basis that the plaintiff did not have standing to bring the lawsuit. This appeal is still pending.