As filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission on April 20, 2023
UNITED STATES SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION
Washington, D.C. 20549
Form
ANNUAL REPORT PURSUANT TO SECTION
13 OR 15(d) OF
THE SECURITIES EXCHANGE ACT OF 1934
For the fiscal year ended
Empresa
Distribuidoray Comercializadora Norte S.A. (
(Exact name of
Registrant as specified in its charter)
Distribution and Marketing Company of the North S.A. | Argentine Republic |
(Translation of Registrant’s name into English) | (Jurisdiction of incorporation or organization) |
Ciudad de Buenos Aires,
(Address of principal executive offices)
Tel.: Chief Financial Officer (Name, Telephone, E-mail and/or Facsimile number and Address of Company Contact Person) |
Securities registered or to be registered pursuant to Section 12(b) of the Act:
Title of each class: | Trading Symbol | Name of each exchange on which registered |
EDN |
New York Stock Exchange, Inc. |
* Not for trading, but only in connection with the registration of American Depositary Shares, pursuant to the requirements of the Securities and Exchange Commission.
___
Securities registered or to be registered pursuant to Section 12(g) of the Act: None
Securities for which there is a reporting obligation pursuant to Section 15(d) of the Act: N/A
Indicate the number of outstanding shares of each of the issuer’s classes of capital or common stock as of the close of the period covered by the annual report:
Class A Common Shares, Class B Common Shares and Class C Common Shares.Indicate by check mark if the registrant is a well-known seasoned issuer, as defined in Rule 405 of the Securities Act.
Yes ☐
If this
report is an annual or transition report, indicate by check mark if the registrant is not required to file reports pursuant to Sections
13 or 15(d) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934. Yes ☐
Note: Checking the box above will not relieve any registrant required to file reports pursuant to Section 13 or 15(d) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 from their obligations under those Sections.
Indicate
by check mark whether the registrant (1) has filed all reports required to be filed by Section 13 or 15(d) of the Securities Exchange
Act of 1934 during the preceding 12 months (or for such shorter period that the registrant was required to file such reports) and (2)
has been subject to such filing requirements for the past 90 days.
Indicate by check mark whether the registrant has submitted electronically
every Interactive Data File required to be submitted pursuant to Rule 405 of Regulation S-T (§232.405 of this chapter) during the
preceding 12 months (or for such shorter period that the registrant
was required to submit such fi les).
Indicate by check mark whether the registrant is a large accelerated filer, an accelerated filer, a non-accelerated filer, or an emerging growth company. See the definitions of “large accelerated filer,” “accelerated filer,” and “emerging growth company” in Rule 12b-2 of the Exchange Act. (Check one):
Large Accelerated Filer | ☐ | Accelerated Filer | ☐ |
☒ | Emerging Growth Company |
If an emerging growth company that prepares its financial statements in accordance with U.S. GAAP, indicate by check mark if the registrant has elected not to use the extended transition period for complying with any new or revised financial accounting standards† provided pursuant to Section 13(a) of the Exchange Act. ☐
† The term “new or revised financial accounting standard” refers to any update issued by the Financial Accounting Standards Board to its Accounting Standards Codification after April 5, 2012.
Indicate
by check mark whether the registrant has filed a report on and attestation to its management’s assessment of the effectiveness of
its internal control over financial reporting under Section 404(b) of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act (§ 15 U.S.C. 7262(b)) by the registered
public accounting firm that prepared or issued its audit report.
If securities are registered pursuant to Section 12(b) of the Act, indicate by check mark whether the financial statements of the registrant included in the filing reflect the correction of an error to previously issued financial statements. ☐
Indicate by check mark whether any of those error corrections are restatements that required a recovery analysis of incentive based compensation received by any of the registrant’s executive officers during the relevant recovery period pursuant to §240.10D-1(b). ☐
Indicate
by check mark which basis of accounting the registrant has used to prepare the financial statements included in this filing: U.S. GAAP
☐
If “Other” has been checked in response to the previous question, indicate by check mark which financial statement item the registrant has elected to follow: Item 17 ☐ Item 18 ☐
If
this is an annual report, indicate by check mark whether the registrant is a shell company (as defined by Rule 12b-2 of the Exchange
Act). Yes ☐
PART I
Item 1. | Identity of Directors, Senior Management and Advisors |
Not applicable.
Item 2. | Offer Statistics and Expected Timetable |
Not applicable.
Item 3. | Key Information |
In this annual report, except as otherwise specified, references to “we”, “us”, “our” and “the Company” are references to (i) Empresa Distribuidora y Comercializadora Norte S.A. (EDENOR S.A.), or “Edenor”. For more information, see “Item 4—Information on the Company—History and Development of the Company.”
FORWARD-LOOKING STATEMENTS
This annual report includes forward-looking statements, principally under the captions “Item 3. Key Information - Risk Factors”, “Item 4. Information on the Company” and “Item 5. Operating and Financial Review and Prospects”. We have based these forward-looking statements largely on our current beliefs, expectations and projections about future events and financial trends affecting our business. Forward-looking statements may also be identified by words such as “believes”, “expects”, “anticipates”, “projects”, “intends”, “should”, “seeks”, “estimates”, “future” or similar expressions. Many important factors, in addition to those discussed elsewhere in this annual report, could cause our actual results to differ materially from those expressed or implied in our forward-looking statements, including, among other things:
· | the treatment of tariff updates according to the Integral Tariff Revision process (Revisión Tarifaria Integral or “RTI”); |
· | uncertainties related to future Government interventions or legal actions; |
· | general political, economic, social, demographic and business conditions in the Republic of Argentina, (“Argentina”) and, particularly, in the geographic market we serve; |
· | the evolution of energy losses and the impact of fines and penalties and uncollectible debt; |
· | the impact of regulatory reform and changes in the regulatory environment in which we operate; |
· | electricity shortages; |
· | the high temperatures and extreme climate registered during the year which affects the provision of transport and distribution energy services |
· | potential disruption or interruption of our service; |
· | the revocation or amendment of our concession by the granting authority; |
· | our ability to implement our capital expenditure plan, including our ability to arrange financing when required and on reasonable terms; |
· | high depreciation of the Peso; |
· | the impact of high rates of inflation on our costs; |
· | the unsustainability of the tariff freeze in the distribution of energy margin; |
· | our ability to continue as a going concern; |
· | Argentina’s renegotiation with the International Monetary Fund (“IMF”); and |
· | additional matters identified in “Risk factors”. |
Forward-looking statements speak only as of the date they were made, and we undertake no obligation to update publicly or to revise any forward-looking statements after we file this annual report because of new information, future events or other factors. In light of these limitations, undue reliance should not be placed on forward-looking statements contained in this annual report.
1 |
PRESENTATION OF FINANCIAL INFORMATION
We are a stock corporation (sociedad anónima) incorporated under the laws of the Republic of Argentina. Unless otherwise stated, references to the financial results of “Edenor” are to the consolidated financial results of Edenor. We hold a concession to distribute electricity on an exclusive basis to the northwestern part of the greater Buenos Aires metropolitan area and in the northern part of the City of Buenos Aires, comprising an area of 4,637 square kilometers and a population of approximately 9 million people. .
Our financial statements as of December 31, 2022 and 2021 and for the years ended December 31, 2022, 2021 and 2020, and the notes thereto (the “Financial Statements”) are set forth on pages F-1 through F-67 of this annual report.
Our Financial Statements, which are prepared in accordance with International Financial Reporting Standards (“IFRS”) as issued by the International Accounting Standards Board (“IASB”), have been approved by resolution of the Board of Directors’ meeting held on March 9, 2023 and have been audited by an independent registered public accounting firm.
Argentina has been considered a high-inflation economy for accounting purposes according to the IAS 29 “Financial reporting in hyperinflationary economies” since July 1, 2018. Therefore, the financial information included in this annual report for all the periods reported are presented on the basis of constant Argentine Pesos as of December 31, 2022 (“current currency”). See “Item 3. Key Information— Risk Factors—As of July 1, 2018, the Argentine Peso qualifies as a currency of a hyperinflationary economy and we are required to restate our historical financial statements in accordance with IFRS, in terms of the measuring unit current at the end of the reporting year, which could adversely affect our results of operation and financial condition”, “Item 5. Operating and Financial Review and Prospects—Factors Affecting Our Results of Operations” and Note 3 to our Financial Statements.
We maintain our accounting records and prepare our financial statements in Argentine Pesos, which is our functional currency.
Certain amounts and ratios contained in this annual report (including percentage amounts) may have been rounded up or down to facilitate the summation of the tables in which they are presented. The effect of this rounding is not material. These rounded amounts and ratios may also be included within the text of this annual report.
EXCHANGE RATES
In 2022, the Argentine Peso continued to depreciate against major foreign currencies, particularly against the U.S. dollar. According to the exchange rate information published by the Banco de la Nación Argentina, the Argentine Peso depreciated by 72.5% against the U.S. dollar during the year ended December 31, 2022 (compared to 22.1%, 40.5% and 58.9% in the years ended December 31, 2021, 2020 and 2019, respectively).
The following table sets forth the high, low, average and period-end exchange rates for the periods indicated, expressed in Pesos per U.S. Dollar and not adjusted for inflation. When preparing our financial statements, we utilize the selling exchange rates for U.S. Dollars quoted by the Banco de la Nación Argentina (“Banco Nación”) to translate our U.S. Dollar denominated assets and liabilities into Pesos. There can be no assurance that the Peso will not further depreciate or appreciate in the future. The Federal Reserve Bank of New York does not report a noon buying rate for Pesos. For more information regarding depreciation, see “Item 3. Key Information—Risk Factors—Factors Relating to Argentina—Fluctuations in the value of the Peso could adversely affect the Argentine economy and, which could, in turn adversely affect our results of operations.”
2 |
In this annual report, except as otherwise specified, references to “U.S.$” and “Dollars” are to U.S. Dollars, and references to “Ps.”, “AR$” and “Pesos” are to Argentine Pesos. Solely for the convenience of the reader, we have converted certain amounts included in this annual report from Pesos into Dollars using, for the information provided as of December 31, 2022, the selling exchange rate reported by the Banco Nación, as of December 31, 2022, which was Ps.177.16 to U.S.$1.00 unless otherwise indicated. These conversions should not be considered representations that any such amounts have been, could have been or could be converted into U.S. Dollars at that or at any other exchange rate. On April 11, 2023, the exchange rate was Ps. 213.76, to U.S.$1.00. As a result of fluctuations in the Dollar Peso exchange rate, the exchange rate at such date may not be indicative of current or future exchange rates.
Low | High | Average | Period End | |||||||||
(Pesos per U.S. Dollar) | ||||||||||||
Year ended December 31, | ||||||||||||
2018 | 18.41 | 41.25 | 29.26 | (1) | 37.70 | |||||||
2019 | 36.90 | 60.40 | 47.82 | (1) | 59.89 | |||||||
2020 | 59.82 | 84.15 | 70.87 | (1) | 84.15 | |||||||
2021 | 84.15 | 105.20 | 95.13 | (1) | 102.72 | |||||||
2022 | 102.72 | 177.16 | 131.08 | (1) | 177.16 | |||||||
Month | ||||||||||||
November-22 | 157.28 | 167.28 | 162.07 | (2) | 167.28 | |||||||
December-22 | 167.72 | 177.16 | 172.38 | (2) | 177.16 | |||||||
January-23 | 177.16 | 187.00 | 182.12 | (2) | 187.00 | |||||||
February-23 | 187.29 | 197.15 | 191.97 | (2) | 197.15 | |||||||
March-23 | 197.57 | 209.01 | 202.92 | (2) | 197.57 | |||||||
_____________________ | ||||||||||||
Source: Banco Nación |
(1) Represents the average of the exchange rates on the last day of each month during the period.
(2) Average of the lowest and highest daily rates in the month.
RISK FACTORS
The following summarizes some, but not all, of the risks provided below. Please carefully consider all of the information discussed in this Item 3.D. “Risk Factors” of this annual report for a more thorough description of these and other risks:
Risks Related to Argentina
· | A global or regional financial crisis and unfavorable credit and market conditions may negatively affect our liquidity, users, business, and results of operations. |
· | The Argentine economy remains vulnerable and any significant decline may adversely affect our business, results of operations, and financial condition. |
· | Economic and political developments in Argentina, and future policies of the Argentine Government may affect the economy as well as the operations of the energy distribution industry, including Edenor. |
· | If high levels of inflation continue, the Argentine economy and our results of operations could be adversely affected. |
3 |
· | As of July 1, 2018, the Argentine Peso qualifies as a currency of a hyperinflationary economy and we are required to restate our historical financial statements in accordance with IFRS, in terms of the measuring unit current at the end of the reporting year, which could adversely affect our results of operation and financial condition. |
· | The credibility of several Argentine economic indexes was called into question, which may lead to a lack of confidence in the Argentine economy and, in turn, limit our ability to access credit and the capital markets. |
· | Argentina’s ability to obtain financing from international markets could be limited, which may impair its ability to implement reforms and foster economic growth and, consequently, affect our business, results of our operations and growth prospects. |
· | Fluctuations in the value of the Argentine Peso could adversely affect the Argentine economy and could in turn adversely affect our results of operations. |
· | Intervention by the Argentine Government may adversely affect the Argentine economy and, as a result, our business and results of operations. |
· | Argentine corporations may be restricted to make payments in foreign currencies or import certain products. |
· | Argentine public expenditures may adversely affect the Argentine economy. |
· | The Argentine economy remains vulnerable to external shocks that could be caused by significant economic difficulties of Argentina’s major regional trading partners, or by more general “contagion” effects. Such external shocks and “contagion” effects could have a material adverse effect on Argentina’s economic growth and, therefore, our results of operations and financial condition. |
· | The global and local economies and our results of operations could be adversely affected as a result of the outbreak of war between Ukraine and Russia. |
· | The application of certain laws and regulations could adversely affect our results of operations and financial condition. |
· | The Argentine economy and finances may be adversely affected as a consequence of a decrease in the international prices of commodities that Argentina exports. |
· | Failure to adequately address actual and perceived risks of institutional deterioration and corruption may adversely affect Argentina’s economy and financial condition. |
· | Any downgrade in the credit rating or rating outlook of Argentina could adversely affect both the rating and the market price of our ADS, our Class B common shares and our corporate debt, affecting also our liquidity. |
Risks Relating to the Electricity Distribution Sector
· | The Argentine Government has intervened in the electricity sector in the past, and may continue intervening. |
· | There is uncertainty as to what other measures the Argentine Government may adopt in connection with tariffs on public services and their impact on the Argentine economy. |
· | Electricity distributors were severely affected by the emergency measures adopted during the economic crisis, many of which remain in effect. |
· | Electricity demand may be affected by tariff increases, which could lead distribution companies, such as us, to record lower revenues. |
· | Energy shortages may act as a brake on growing demand for electricity and disrupt distribution companies’ ability to deliver electricity to their customers, which could result in customer claims and material penalties imposed on these companies. |
· | If the demand for energy is increased suddenly, the difficulty in increasing the capacity of distribution companies in a short or medium term, could adversely affect the Company, which in turn could result in customer complaints and substantial fines for any interruptions. |
4 |
Risks Relating to Our Business
· | We operate our business pursuant to our Concession Agreement granted by the Argentine Government, the revocation or termination of which would have a material adverse effect on our business. |
· | Downgrades in our credit ratings could have negative effects on our funding costs and business operations. |
· | Our business is subject to risks arising from natural disasters, catastrophic accidents and terrorist attacks. Additionally, our businesses are subject to the risk of mechanical or electrical failures and any resulting unavailability may affect our ability to fulfil our contractual commitments and thus adversely affect our business and financial performance. |
· | Our operations could cause environmental risks and any change in environmental laws, climate change legislation or regulations restricting emissions of greenhouse gases (“GHGs”) and legal frameworks promoting an increase in the participation of energies from renewable sources could significantly impact our business and result in increased operating costs. |
· | Failure or delay to negotiate further improvements to our tariff structure, including increases in our distribution margin, and/or to have our tariffs adjusted to reflect increases in our distribution costs in a timely manner or at all, affected and may continue to affect our capacity to perform our commercial obligations and could also have a material adverse effect on our ability to perform our financial obligations. |
· | We may not be able to adjust our tariffs to reflect increases in our distribution costs in a timely manner, or at all, which may have a material adverse effect on our results of operations. |
· | Our distribution tariffs may be subject to challenges by Argentine consumer and other groups. |
· | We have been, and may continue to be, subject to fines and penalties that could have a material adverse effect on our financial condition and results of operations. |
· | The increase in the illegal settlements within the greater Buenos Aires metropolitan area may affect the Company’s ability to distribute energy to its customers, as well as produce an increase in public safety risks. |
· | If we are unable to control our energy losses, especially the theft of energy, our results of operations could be adversely affected. |
· | Under the Concession Agreement, the Argentine Government could foreclose on its pledge over our Class A common shares under certain circumstances, which could have a material adverse effect on our business and financial condition. |
· | Default by the Argentine Government could lead to termination of our concession, and have a material adverse effect on our business and financial condition. |
· | The expiration of the management period could result in the sale of the Company’s controlling interest. |
· | We may be unable to import certain equipment to meet growing demand for electricity, which could lead to a breach of our Concession Agreement and could have a material adverse effect on the operations and financial position. |
· | We employ a largely unionized labor force and could be subject to an organized labor action, including work stoppages that could have a material effect on our business. |
· | We could incur material labor liabilities in connection with our outsourcing that could have an adverse effect on our business and on our results of operations. |
· | Our performance is largely dependent on recruiting and retaining key personnel. |
· | We are subject to anti-corruption, anti-bribery, anti-money laundering and antitrust laws and regulations in Argentina. Any violation thereunder could have a material adversed effect on our reputation and the results of our operation. |
· | We are involved in various legal proceedings which could result in unfavorable decisions for us, which could in turn have a material adverse effect on our financial position and results of operations. |
· | In the event of an accident or other event not covered by our insurance, we could face significant losses that could materially adversely affect our business and results of operations. |
· | We currently are not able to effectively hedge our currency risk in full and, as a result, a devaluation of the Peso may have a material adverse effect on our results of operations and financial condition. |
· | A substantial number of our assets are not subject to attachment or foreclosure and the enforcement of judgments obtained against us by our shareholders may be substantially limited. |
5 |
· | The loss of the exclusivity of electricity distribution in our service area may be adversely affected by technological or other changes in the energy distribution industry, which could have a material adverse effect on our business. |
· | A potential nationalization or expropriation of 51% of our capital stock, represented by Class A shares, may limit the ability of Class B shares to participate in the Board of Directors. |
· | We may not be able to raise the funds necessary to repay our commercial debt with CAMMESA, our major supplier. |
· | We may not have the ability to collect the amounts corresponding to the discounts of the Social Rate, the ceilings of the Social Rate and the bonuses for neighbourhood clubs, that must be financed by the Province of Buenos Aires and the Autonomous City of Buenos Aires. |
· | All of our outstanding financial indebtedness contains bankruptcy, reorganization proceedings and expropriation events of default, and we may be required to repay all of our outstanding debt upon occurrence of any such events. |
· | We may not have the ability to raise the funds necessary to finance a change of control offering as required by our Senior 2025 Notes and Senior 2024 Notes. |
· | The New York Stock Exchange and/or ByMA may suspend trading and/or delist our ADSs and Class B common shares, upon the occurrence of certain events relating to our financial situation. |
· | Changes in weather conditions or the occurrence of severe weather (whether or not caused by climate change or natural disasters), could adversely affect our operations and financial performance. |
· | Cybersecurity events, such as interruptions or failures in our information technology systems as well as cyber-attacks, could adversely affect our business, financial condition, results of operations and cash flows. |
· | The Company’s operations and business could be affected by the adoption of restrictions on the import of products or the technical conditions applicable thereto. |
Risks relating to our ADSs and Class B common shares
· | Restrictions on the movement of capital out of Argentina may impair the ability of holders of ADSs to receive dividends and distributions on, and the proceeds of any sale of, the Class B common shares underlying the ADSs, which could affect the market value of the ADSs. |
· | Our shareholders’ ability to receive cash dividends may be limited. |
· | Our shareholders may be subject to liability for certain votes of their securities. |
· | If we fail to maintain an effective system of internal controls, we may be unable to accurately report our financial results or prevent fraud and investor confidence and the market price of our securities may be adversely impacted. |
· | Provisions of Argentine securities laws could deter takeover attempts and have an adverse impact on the price of our shares and ADSs. |
Risks Related to Argentina
Overview
We are a stock corporation (sociedad anónima) incorporated under the laws of the Republic of Argentina and all of our revenues are earned in Argentina and all of our operations, facilities, and users are located in Argentina. Accordingly, our financial condition and results of operations depend to a significant extent on macroeconomic, regulatory, political and financial conditions prevailing in Argentina, including growth rates, inflation rates, currency exchange rates, taxes, interest rates, and other local, regional and international events and conditions that may affect Argentina in any manner. For example, a slowdown in economic growth or economic recession could lead to a decreased demand for electricity in our concession area or a decline in the purchasing power of our users, which, in turn, could lead to a decrease in collection rates from our users or increased energy losses due to illegal use of our service. For example, Argentina’s economy grew in 2017, 2021 and slightly in 2022, but contracted in 2018, 2019 and 2020. Several factors have impacted the Argentine economy in the recent past, and may continue to impact it in the future, including among others, inflation rates, exchange rates, commodity prices, public debt, availability of IMF SDRs, amendments to the tax regime and policies on trade and fiscal balances.
6 |
Our activity is highly regulated and subject to uncertainties due to politic and economic factors, changes in legislation, termination and modification of contractual rights, control of prices and currency fluctuations, among others.
We cannot assure that the Argentine Government will not adopt other policies that could adversely affect the Argentine economy or our business, financial condition or results of operations. In addition, we cannot assure you that future economic, regulatory, social and political developments in Argentina will not impair our business, financial condition or results of operations, nor cause the market value of our ADSs and Class B common shares to decline.
A global or regional financial crisis and unfavorable credit and market conditions may negatively affect our liquidity, users, business, and results of operations
The effects of a global or regional financial crisis and related turmoil in the global financial system may have a negative impact on our business, ability to access credit and the international capital markets, financial condition and results of operations, which is likely to be more severe on an emerging market economy, such as Argentina. See “Item 3. Key Information—Risk Factors—Factors Relating to Argentina—Argentina’s ability to obtain financing from international markets could be limited, which may impair its ability to implement reforms and foster economic growth and, consequently, affect our business, results of our operations and growth prospects”.
Global economic and financial crises, and the general weakness of the global economy due to the COVID-19 pandemic negatively affected emerging economies like Argentina’s economy. Additionally, abrupt changes in monetary and fiscal policies or foreign exchange regime could rapidly affect local economic output, while lack of appropriate levels of investment in certain economy sectors could reduce long-term growth. Access to the international financial markets could be limited. Consequently, an increase in public spending not correlated with an increase in public revenues could affect the Argentina’s fiscal results and generate uncertainties that might affect the economy’s growth level.
In addition to the severe social and market disruption at a global scale during 2020 caused by the COVID 19 outbreak, in recent years, several trading partners of Argentina (such as Brazil, Europe and China) have experienced significant slowdowns or recession periods in their economies. While the vast majority of economies recovered during 2021 and 2022, if such slowdowns or recessions were to recur, this may impact the demand for products coming from Argentina and hence affect its economy. Additionally, there is uncertainty as to how the trade relationship between the Mercosur member States will unfold, in particular between Argentina and Brazil. We cannot predict the effect on the Argentine economy and our operations if trade disputes arise between Argentina and Brazil, or in case either country decided to exit the Mercosur.
In addition, the global macroeconomic environment is facing challenges. There is considerable uncertainty over the long-term effects of the expansionary monetary and fiscal policies adopted by the central banks and financial authorities of some of the world’s leading economies in 2020 and 2021, including the United States and China. There have been concerns over unrest and terrorist threats in the Middle East, Europe and Africa and over the conflicts involving Iran, Ukraine, Syria and North Korea. Moreover, political and social crises arose in several countries of Latin America during 2019, as the economy in much of the region has slowed down after almost a decade of sustained growth, among other factors. There have also been concerns on the relationship among China and other Asian countries, which may result in or intensify potential conflicts in relation to territorial disputes, and the possibility of a trade war between the United States and China. In addition, United Kingdom exited the European Union (“Brexit”) on January 31, 2020. The medium and long term implications of Brexit could adversely affect European and worldwide economic and market conditions and could contribute to instability in global financial and foreign exchange markets.
7 |
Furthermore, in February 2022, Russian troops invaded Ukraine. Although the severity and duration of the ongoing military action are unpredictable, the conflict in Ukraine, Russia’s prior annexation of Crimea, recent recognition of two separatist republics in the Donetsk and Luhansk regions of Ukraine and subsequent military interventions in Ukraine have led to sanctions being levied by the United States, the European Union and other countries against Russia. Russia’s military incursion and the market volatility has adversely affected and may continue to affect the global economy and financial markets and thus could affect our business, financial condition or results of operations. The extent and duration of the military action, sanctions and resulting market disruptions are difficult to predict, but could be substantial. Any such disruptions caused by Russian military action or resulting sanctions may magnify the impact of other risks described in this annual report and may result in compliance and operational challenges for the Company. Trade restrictions imposed on Russia have led to increasing prices of oil, fluctuation in commodities markets and foreign currency exchange volatility. Russia’s military incursion and the market volatility could adversely affect the global economy and financial markets and thus could affect our business, financial condition or results of operations. Further escalation of such armed conflict could lead to supply disruptions and higher energy costs, among others, which could adversely affect our results of operations.
The effects of an economic crisis on our users and on us cannot be predicted. Weak global and local economic conditions, together with increased international tension and oil & gas constraints, could lead to reduced demand or lower prices for energy, hydrocarbons and related oil products and petrochemicals, which could have a negative effect on our revenues. Economic factors such as unemployment, inflation and the unavailability of credit could also have a material adverse effect on the demand for energy and, therefore, on our business, financial condition and results of operations. The financial and economic situation in Argentina or in other countries in Latin America, such as Brazil, may also have a negative impact on us and third parties with whom we do, or may do, business.
The Argentine economy remains vulnerable and any significant decline may adversely affect our business, results of operations, and financial condition
The Argentine economy has experienced significant volatility in recent decades, characterized by periods of low or negative growth, high levels of inflation and currency depreciation. Sustainable economic growth in Argentina depends on a variety of factors including the international demand for Argentine exports, the stability and competitiveness of the Peso against foreign currencies, confidence among consumers and foreign and domestic investors and a stable rate of inflation, national employment levels and the circumstances of Argentina’s regional trade partners. The Argentine macroeconomic environment, in which we operate, remains vulnerable, as reflected by the following economic conditions:
· according to the recent data published by the INDEC in 2023, for the year ended December 31, 2022, Argentina’s real GDP increased by 5.2% compared to the same period in 2021;
· continued increases in public expenditures have resulted and could continue to result in fiscal deficit and affect economic growth;
· | inflation remains high and may continue at those levels in the future, while regulated tariffs may lag behind; |
· | investment as a percentage of GDP remains low to sustain the growth rate of the past decades; |
8 |
· | protests or strikes may adversely affect the stability of the political, social and economic environment and may negatively impact the global financial market’s confidence in the Argentine economy; |
· | energy or natural gas supply by generators may not be sufficient to supply increased industrial activity (thereby limiting industrial development) and consumption, mostly at peak demand such as in the winter season; |
· | unemployment and informal employment remain high, which could have a bearing on energy theft levels potentially impacting our results and operations; and |
· | the Argentine Government’s economic expectations may not be met and the process of restoring the confidence in the Argentine economy may take longer than anticipated. |
As in the recent past, Argentina’s economy may be adversely affected if political and social pressures inhibit the implementation by the Argentine Government of policies designed to control inflation, generate growth and enhance consumer and investor confidence, or if policies implemented by the Argentine Government that are designed to achieve these goals are not successful. These events could materially affect our financial condition and results of operations, or cause the market value of our ADSs and our Class B common shares to decline.
The Argentine Peso has been subject to significant depreciation against the U.S. dollar in the past and may be subject to fluctuations in the future. We cannot predict whether and to what extent the value of the Peso could depreciate or appreciate against the U.S. dollar and the way in which any such fluctuations could affect our business. The value of the Peso compared to other currencies is dependent, in addition to other factors listed above, on the level of international reserves maintained by the Central Bank of the Republic of Argentina (Banco Central de la República Argentina, the “Central Bank” or “BCRA”), which have also shown significant fluctuations in recent years. As of December 31, 2022, the international reserves of the BCRA totaled U.S.$44,598 million. According to the exchange rate information published by the Banco de la Nación Argentina, the Argentine Peso depreciated by 72.5% against the U.S. dollar during the year ended December 31, 2022 (compared to 22.1%, 40.5% and 58.9% in the years ended December 31, 2021, 2020 and 2019, respectively).
In 2019, as a result of the economic instability, economic uncertainty, and rising inflation rates, the former Argentine administration and the BCRA adopted a series of measures reinstating foreign exchange controls, which applied with respect to access to the foreign exchange market by residents for savings and investment purposes abroad, the payment of external financial debts, the payment of dividends in foreign currency abroad, payments of goods and services in foreign currencies, payments of imports of goods and services, and the obligation to repatriate and settle for Pesos the proceeds from exports of goods and services, among others. Other financial transactions such as derivatives and securities related operations, were also covered by the new foreign exchange regime. Following the change in government, the new administration extended the validity of such measures, which were originally in effect until December 31, 2019, and established further restrictions by means of the enacted Law No. 27,541 on Social Solidarity and Productive Reactivation in the Framework of the Public Emergency (Ley de Solidaridad Social y Reactivación Productiva en el Marco de la Emergencia Pública, or the “Productive Reactivation Law”), regulated by Decrees No. 58 and 99/19, including a new tax on certain transactions involving the purchase of foreign currency by both Argentine individuals and entities. Although the official exchange rate has stabilized since the adoption of the foreign exchange controls, we cannot assure you that the official exchange rate will not fluctuate significantly in the future. There can be no assurances regarding future modifications to exchange controls. Exchange controls could adversely affect our financial condition or results of operations and our ability to meet our foreign currency obligations and execute our financing plans. See “Item 10. Additional Information— Exchange Controls.”
9 |
The success of these measures or other measures that the BCRA may implement in the future, is uncertain and any further depreciation of the Argentine Peso or our inability to acquire foreign currency could have a material adverse effect on our financial condition and results of operations. We cannot predict the effectiveness of these measures. We cannot predict whether, and to what extent, the value of the Argentine Peso may depreciate or appreciate against the U.S. dollar or other foreign currencies, and how these uncertainties will affect electricity consumption. Furthermore, no assurance can be given that, in the future, no additional currency or foreign exchange restrictions or controls will be imposed. Existing and future measures may negatively affect Argentina’s international competitiveness, discouraging foreign investments and lending by foreign investors or increasing foreign capital outflow which could have an adverse effect on economic activity in Argentina, and which in turn could adversely affect our business and results of operations. We cannot predict how these conditions will affect the consumption of services provided by Edenor or our ability to meet our liabilities denominated in currencies other than the Argentine Peso, including our Senior Notes due 2024 and 2025 for U.S.$60 million and U.S.$55 million, respectively. Any restrictions on transferring funds abroad imposed by the Government could undermine our ability to pay dividends on our ADSs or make payments (of principal or interest) under our outstanding indebtedness in U.S. dollars, as well as to comply with any other obligation denominated in foreign currency.
Due to the above mentioned macroeconomic situation, the financial impact on the Company is discussed in Note 1 to our 2022 financial statements, where the Company’s Board and management concluded that a material uncertainty exists that may cast significant doubt (or raise substantial doubt as contemplated by the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (United States) (“PCAOB”) standards) about Edenor’s ability to continue as a going concern, which was also expressed by our independent registered public accounting firm in their report appearing elsewhere herein. A decline in economic growth, an increase in economic instability or the expansion of economic policies and measures taken or that may be adopted in the future by the Argentine Government to control inflation or address other macroeconomic developments that affect private sector entities such as us, all developments over which we have no control, could have an adverse effect on our business, financial condition or results of operations or would not have a negative impact on the market value of our ADSs and Class B common shares.
Economic and political developments in Argentina, and future policies of the Argentine Government may affect the economy as well as the operations of the energy distribution industry, including Edenor
The Argentine Government has historically exercised significant influence over the economy, and our Company has operated in a highly regulated environment. The Argentine Government may promulgate numerous, far-reaching regulations affecting the economy and electricity companies in particular.
In the event of any economic, social or political crisis, companies operating in Argentina may face the risk of strikes, expropriation, nationalization, mandatory amendment of existing contracts, and changes in taxation policies, including tax increases and retroactive tax claims. In addition, Argentine courts have sanctioned modifications on rules related to labor matters, requiring companies to assume greater responsibility for the assumption of costs and risks associated with subcontracted labor and the calculation of salaries, severance payments and social security contributions. Since we operate in a context in which the governing law and applicable regulations change frequently, also as a result of changes in government administrations, it is difficult to predict if and how our activities will be affected by such changes.
We cannot assure you that future economic, regulatory, social and political developments in Argentina will not adversely affect our business, financial condition or results of operations, or cause the decrease of the market value of our securities.
10 |
If the high levels of inflation continue, the Argentine economy and our results of operations could be adversely affected
Historically, inflation has materially undermined the Argentine economy and the Argentine Government’s ability to create conditions that allow growth. In recent years, Argentina has confronted inflationary pressures, evidenced by significantly higher fuel, energy and food prices, among other factors.
According to data published by the INDEC, Consumers Price Index (“CPI”) rates for 2022, 2021 and 2020 were 94.8% in 2022 50.9% in 2021 and 36.1%, , respectively and 6.0% and 6.6% in January and February 2023, respectively. See “Item 3. Key Information— Risk Factors—Risks Related to Argentina—The credibility of several Argentine economic indexes was called into question, which may lead to a lack of confidence in the Argentine economy and, in turn, limit our ability to access credit and the capital markets” below. The Argentine Government’s adjustments to electricity and gas tariffs, as well as the increase in the price of gasoline have affected prices, creating additional inflationary pressure. If the value of the Argentine Peso cannot be stabilized through fiscal and monetary policies, an increase in inflation rates could be expected.
A high inflation rate affects Argentina’s foreign competitiveness by diluting the effects of the Peso depreciation, negatively impacting employment and the level of economic activity and undermining confidence in Argentina’s banking system, which may further limit the availability of domestic and international credit to businesses. In turn, a portion of the Argentine debt continues to be adjusted by the Stabilization Coefficient (Coeficiente de Estabilización de Referencia, or “CER”), a currency index, that is strongly related to inflation. Therefore, any significant increase in inflation would cause an increase in the Argentine external debt and consequently in Argentina’s financial obligations, which could exacerbate the stress on the Argentine economy. The efforts undertaken by the Argentine Government to reduce inflation have not achieved the desired results. A continuing inflationary environment could undermine our results of operations, adversely affect our ability to finance the working capital needs of our businesses on favorable terms, and it could adversely affect our results of operations and cause the market value of our ADSs and our Class B common shares to decline.
There is uncertainty regarding the effectiveness of the policies implemented by the Argentine Government to reduce and control inflation and the potential impact of those policies. An increase in inflation may adversely affect the Argentine economy, which in turn may have a negative impact in our financial condition and the result of our operations.
As of July 1, 2018, the Argentine Peso qualifies as a currency of a hyperinflationary economy and we are required to restate our historical financial statements in accordance with IFRS, in terms of the measuring unit current at the end of the reporting year, which could adversely affect our results of operation and financial condition
As of July 1, 2018, the Peso qualifies as a currency of a hyperinflationary economy and we are required to restate our historical financial statements by applying inflationary adjustments to our financial statements.
Pursuant to IAS 29 “Financial Reporting in Hyperinflationary Economies”, the financial statements of entities whose functional currency is that of a hyperinflationary economy must be restated for the effects of changes in a suitable general price index. IAS 29 does not prescribe when hyperinflation arises, but includes several characteristics of hyperinflation. The IASB does not identify specific hyperinflationary jurisdictions. However, in June 2018, the International Practices Task Force of the Centre for Quality (“IPTF”), which monitors “highly inflationary countries”, categorized Argentina as a country with projected three-year cumulative inflation rate greater than 100%. Additionally, some of the other qualitative factors of IAS 29 were present, providing prima facie evidence that the Argentine economy is hyperinflationary for the purposes of IAS 29. Therefore, Argentine companies using IFRS are required to apply IAS 29 to their financial statements for periods ending on and after July 1, 2018.
11 |
We cannot predict the future impact that the eventual inflation adjustments described above will have on our financial statements or their effects on our business, results of operations and financial condition.
The credibility of several Argentine economic indexes was called into question, which may lead to a lack of confidence in the Argentine economy and, in turn, limit our ability to access credit and the capital markets
Prior to 2015, the credibility of the CPI, as well as other indices published by the INDEC were called into question.
On January 8, 2016, based on its determination that the INDEC had failed to produce reliable statistical information, particularly with respect to CPI, GDP, inflation and foreign trade data, as well as with poverty and unemployment rates, the Argentine Government declared a state of administrative emergency for the national statistical system and the INDEC. The INDEC temporarily suspended the publication of certain statistical data until a reorganization of its technical and administrative structure to recover its ability to produce reliable statistical information.
In 2017, the INDEC began publishing a national CPI, which is based on a survey conducted by the INDEC and several provincial statistical offices in 39 urban areas including each of Argentina’s provinces. The official CPI inflation rate for the year ended December 31, 2022 was 94.8%.
Any future required correction or restatement of the INDEC indexes could result in decreased confidence in Argentina’s economy, which, in turn, could have an adverse effect on our ability to access international capital markets to finance our operations and growth, and which could, in turn, adversely affect our results of operations and financial condition and cause the market value of our ADSs and Class B common shares to decline.
Argentina’s ability to obtain financing from international markets could be limited, which may impair its ability to implement reforms and foster economic growth and, consequently, affect our business, results of our operations and growth prospects
Argentina’s history of defaults on its external debt and the protracted litigation with holdout creditors may reoccur in the future and prevent Argentine companies such as us from accessing the international capital markets readily or may result in higher costs and more onerous terms for such financing, and may therefore negatively affect our business, results of operations, financial condition, the value of our securities, and our ability to meet our financial obligations.
Following the default on its external debt in 2001, Argentina sought to restructure its outstanding debt exchange offers in 2005 and again in 2010. Holders of approximately 93% of Argentina’s defaulted debt participated in the exchanges. Nonetheless, a number of bondholders held out from the exchange offers and pursued legal actions against Argentina.
In 2016, the Argentine Government settled several agreements with the defaulted bondholders, ending more than 15 years of litigation.
12 |
In 2020, the Argentine Government reached an agreement with private creditors to renegotiate certain debt conditions as maturity dates and interest rates applicable for the following first years. On April 21, 2020, Argentina invited holders of approximately U.S.$66.5 billion aggregate principal amount of its foreign currency external bonds to exchange such bonds for new bonds. The invitation contemplated the use of collective action clauses included in the terms and conditions of such bonds, whereby the decision by certain majorities would bind holders that do not tender into the exchange offer. On August 31, 2020 it announced that it had obtained bondholder consents required to exchange and or modify 99.01% of the aggregate principal amount outstanding of all series of eligible bonds invited to participate in the exchange offer. The restructuring settled on September 4, 2020. As a result of the invitation, the average interest rate paid by Argentina’s foreign currency external bonds was lowered to 3.07%, with a maximum rate of 5.0%, compared to an average interest rate of 7.0% and maximum rate of 8.28% prior to the invitation. In addition, the aggregate amount outstanding of Argentina’s foreign currency external bonds was reduced by 1.9% and the average maturity of such bonds was extended.
On June 22, 2021, the Minister of Economy announced that the Argentine Government had obtained a “time bridge” within the framework of the Paris Club negotiations, consequently avoiding default. The understanding provides that the Argentine Government will have until March 31, 2022 to reach a restructuring agreement with the Paris Club members, which was further extended until July 31, 2022. On October 28, 2022, the Minister of Economy announced a new agreement with the Paris Club, which is an addendum to the Paris Club 2014 Settlement Agreement. This new agreement recognizes a principal amount of US$1.97 billion, extending the repayment period to thirteen semi-annual installments, starting in December 2022 to be repaid in full in September 2028. As part of the agreement, the interest rate applicable to the first three installments was reduced from 9% to 3.9%, with subsequent gradual increases to 4.5%. The payment profile implies semi-annual payments averaging US$170 million (principal and interest included). Over the next two years, Argentina will repay 40% of the principal amount outstanding.
On January 28, 2022, the IMF and the Argentine authorities reached an understanding on key policies as part of their ongoing discussions on an IMF-supported program for the refinancing of the debt of U.S.$44.1 billion set to mature in 2022 and 2023. On March 4, 2022, the Argentine Government reached a staff-level agreement with the IMF and a bill was sent to the Argentine Congress. On March 11, 2022, the lower house of the Argentine Congress passed and sent to the Senate the bill that supports the agreement between Argentina and the IMF. On March 17, 2022, the Senate approved the agreement “Program of Extended Facilities” between the Argentine Government and the IMF, following the Argentine Congress’ endorsement of the understanding with the IMF, and on March 25, the Program of Extended Facilities was approved by the Executive Board of the IMF.
As a result, the Law No. 27,668 was sanctioned on March 18, 2022, and consequently the Program of Extended Fund Facility was approved, allowing the IMF to pay out U.S.$44.500 million. This agreement includes an obligation to develop an energetic plan, that focuses on improving energy efficiency, and researching for a cleaner and cheaper way to produce and distribute electricity among other goals to achieve. Furthermore, the law reinforces Argentina’s commitment to create a new subsidy segmentation scheme, concentrated on improving the energy distribution as well as protecting the low- and middle-income users.
In June 2022, the IMF’s staff published the first review of the Extended Agreement, taking into the account the exceptional risk resulting from the war in Ukraine, a resurgence of the pandemic and a slowdown in key emerging economies. The IMF strongly supported the Decree No. No. 332/2022, which created a new subsidy segmentation scheme, eliminating the subsidies for the top 10 percent of residential consumers with the highest income level.
On September 19, 2022, the second review of the arrangement took place. Although ir acknowledged the registered growth of real GDP and the decisive steps taken by the authorities to restore macroeconomic stability, the Staff reiterated the need to significantly reduce subsidies for residential users with greatest payment capacity and commercial users. In addition, the IMF encouraged the Argentine Government to continue reducing subsidies, while improving its performance in the following aspects: database improvement, allowing consumers to self- declare their income and assets and reduce the number of non-registered consumers; linkage of prices to cost, instead of wages; less generous consumption ceilings, together with the introduction of a ceiling for low–income consumers, focusing on energy efficiency; and enhanced targeting, composed of three groups and the chance of reconsideration.
13 |
On December 2, 2022, the IMF Staff published a third review, with positive feedback on macroeconomic aspects, but underlining the challenging global environment. Focusing on the energy aspect, the IMF reinforced the need to reduce subsidies for residential users with the greatest payment capacity and commercial users. In both cases, the remaining subsidies would be removed in February 2023, establishing a cap for electricity and gas prices during peak consumption months to ensure the fiscal targets. On the other side, middle and low-income residential users would cap the cost of energy at 40 percent and 80 percent of growth in the wage index, respectively. Furthermore, the tariff agreements with electricity distributors within the metropolitan region of Buenos Aires would be updated in February 2023 to improve CAMMESA’s income, including an arrangement to eliminate distributors’ arrears to or from CAMMESA and therefore alleviate the pressures on government finances.
On March 13, 2023, the IMF web page published an article emphasising a successful fourth review, as a result of the agreement between its Staff and the Argentine authorities.
We cannot assure whether the agreement with IMF could not affect Argentina’s ability to implement reforms and public policies and boost economic growth, nor the impact of the result that renegotiation will have in Argentina’s ability to access international capital markets (and indirectly in our ability to access those markets) to access international capital markets, in the Argentine economy or in our economic and financial situation or in our capacity to extend the maturity dates of our debt or other conditions that could affect our results and operations or businesses.
Fluctuations in the value of the Argentine Peso could adversely affect the Argentine economy and could in turn adversely affect our results of operations
The Argentine Peso suffered important fluctuations during the last four years. We are unable to predict the future value of the Peso against the U.S. Dollar. If the Peso devaluates further, the negative effects on the Argentine economy could have adverse consequences on our business, our results of operations and the market value of our ADSs, including as measured in U.S. Dollars.
Fluctuations in the value of the Peso may also adversely affect the Argentine economy, our financial condition and results of operations. The Peso has been subject to significant depreciation against the U.S. dollar in the past and may be subject to further fluctuation in the future. A depreciation of the Peso against major foreign currencies may also have an adverse impact on our capital expenditure program and increase the Peso amount of our trade liabilities and financial debt denominated in foreign currencies. The depreciation of the Peso may have a negative impact on the ability of certain Argentine businesses to service their foreign currency-denominated debt, lead to high inflation, significantly reduce real wages, jeopardize the stability of businesses whose success depends on domestic market demand, including public utilities, and the financial industry and adversely affect the Argentine Government’s ability to honor its foreign debt obligations.
Intervention by the Argentine Government may adversely affect the Argentine economy and, as a result, our business and results of operations
In the recent past, the Argentine Government intervened in the economy, including through the implementation of expropriation and nationalization measures, price controls and exchange controls, among others.
14 |
In the future, the Argentine Government may introduce new exchange controls and/or strengthen the existing ones, create restrictions on transfers to other countries, restrictions to capital movements or other measures in response to an eventual capital flight or an important depreciation in the Peso, measures that can, in turn, affect our ability to access the international capital markets. Such restrictions and measures may generate political and social tensions and deteriorate the Argentine Government´s public finances, as has occurred in the past, generating an adverse effect in the Argentine economic activity and, in consequence, adversely affecting our business and the result of our operations, and cause the market value of our ADSs and our Class B common shares to decline. See “Item 10. Additional Information— Exchange Controls.” Moreover, we cannot preditct the measures that may be adopted by the current or any future government, such as expropriation, nationalization, forced renegotiation or modification of existing contracts, new taxation policies, changes in laws, regulations and policies affecting foreign trade and investments, restrictions to transfers to other countries or to capitals movement, or an important depreciation of the Peso will not have a material adverse effect on the Argentine economy and, as a consequence, adversely affect our financial condition, our results of operations or cause the market value of our ADSs and our Class B common shares to decline.
Argentine corporations may be restricted to make payments in foreign currencies or import certain products
There are certain restrictions in Argentina that affect corporations’ ability to access to the exchange market (Mercado Libre de Cambios, or the “MLC”) to acquire foreign currency, transfer funds abroad, service debt payments in foreign currency, make payments outside Argentina and other operations, requiring, in some cases, previous approval by the Central Bank.
These restrictions may affect our operations and our expansion projects, as they require the import of services and goods for which payment may be restricted. The Argentine Government may impose or create further restrictions on the access to the MLC. In such case, the ability of Argentine corporations to make payments outside Argentina and to comply with their obligations and duties may be affected.
We cannot predict how the current foreign exchange restrictions may evolve after this annual report, mainly regarding limitations to transfer funds outside the country. The Argentine Government may impose further exchange controls or restrictions to capital transfers and modify and adopt other policies that may limit or restrict our ability to access international capital markets, to make payments of principal and interests and other additional amounts outside the country (including payments relating to our notes), or affect in other ways our business and the results of our operations, or cause the market value of our ADSs and our Class B common shares to decline.
Exchange controls in an economic environment in which the access to local capital markets is restricted may cause an adverse effect in our activities, mainly in our ability to make payments of principal and/or interests of our notes in foreign currency. See “Item 10. Additional Information—Exchange Controls.”
Argentine public expenditure may affect the Argentine economy
Public expenditure increased throughout the last decade in Argentina. The Argentine Government adopted several measures to finance its public expenditure.
As of the date of this annual report, we cannot predict how the measures that the Argentine Government has applied and may continue to apply will impact the Argentine economy, and, in turn, our business, our financial condition and the results of our operations.
15 |
The Argentine economy remains vulnerable to external shocks that could be caused by significant economic difficulties of Argentina’s major regional trading partners, or by more general “contagion” effects. Such external shocks and “contagion” effects could have a material adverse effect on Argentina’s economic growth and, therefore, our results of operations and financial condition
Although economic conditions vary from country to country, investors’ perceptions of events occurring in certain countries have in the past substantially affected, and may continue to substantially affect, capital flows into and investments in securities of issuers from other countries, including Argentina. There can be no assurance that the Argentine financial system and securities markets will not be adversely affected by policies that may be adopted by foreign governments or the Argentine Government in the future. Argentina can also be adversely affected by negative economic or financial events that take place in other countries, subsequently affecting our operations and financial condition, including our ability to repay our debt at its maturity date.
Argentina’s economy is vulnerable to external shocks. For example, economic slowdowns, especially in Argentina’s major trading partners such as Brazil, led to declines in Argentine exports in the last few years. Specifically, fluctuations in the price of commodities sold by Argentina and a significant devaluation of the Peso against the U.S. dollar could harm Argentina’s competitiveness and affect its exports. In addition, international investors’ reactions to events occurring in one market may result in a “contagion” effect which could lead to an entire region or class of investment being disfavored by international investors. Additionally, financial and securities markets in Argentina are also influenced by economic and market conditions in other markets worldwide.
The situation of the U.S. economy and the restrictive economic measures taken by the federal administration could adversely affect the economy of developing countries, including Argentina.
The U.S. economy has registered its highiest inflation rates over the last decades. We cannot predict the decisions and policies that the Biden administration will adopt in the future, which could generate uncertainty in the international markets and could have a negative effect on developing economies, including Argentina.
In July 2019, the Southern Common Market (“MERCOSUR”) signed a strategic partnership agreement with the European Union (the “EU”), which is expected to enter into force in the near future, subject to the approval of the corresponding legislatures of each member country. Such approval is pending as of today, as some member countries are demanding amendments to the agreement (for example, the French government has demanded the inclusion of guarantees regarding the protection of the Amazon, compliance with European agri-food and phytosanitary standards and the fight against climate change). The objective of this agreement is to promote investment, regional integration, increase the competitiveness of the economy and achieve an increase in GDP. However, the effect that this agreement could have on the Argentine economy and on the policies implemented by the Argentine Government is uncertain. Regarding other free trade agreement negotiations, the current Argentine government announced on April 24, 2020 that it would stop participating in Mercosur’s trade agreement negotiations with countries such as South Korea, Singapore, Lebanon, Canada and India, excluding those already concluded with the EU.
Moreover, the challenges faced by the EU in stabilizing some of its member economies have had and may continue to have international implications affecting the stability of global financial markets, which has hampered economies around the world.
Finally, international investors’ perceptions of events occurring in one market may generate a “contagion” effect by which an entire region or class of investment is disfavored by international investors. Argentina could be adversely affected by negative economic or financial developments in other emerging and developed countries, which in turn may have material adverse effects on the Argentine economy and, indirectly, on our business, financial condition and results of operations, and the market value of our ADSs and Class B common shares.
16 |
The global and local economies and our results of operations could be adversely affected as a result of the outbreak of war between Ukraine and Russia.
In October 2021, Russia began moving troops and military equipment near the border with Ukraine, generating concerns about a possible invasion. By December 2021, more than one hundred thousand troops were located near the border.
In mid-December 2021, the Russian Foreign Ministry issued a series of demands that included a ban on Ukraine joining the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (“NATO”) and the reduction of NATO troops and military equipment in Eastern Europe for its military forces to withdraw. The United States and other NATO allies rejected those demands and warned Russia that they would retaliate if Russia invaded Ukraine, including the imposition of economic sanctions. Tensions remained high as negotiations continued without any apparent progress toward a formal agreement.
Subsequently, on February 23, 2022, Russian President Vladimir Putin declared a “special military operation” in Ukraine. On the same day, several media organizations reported explosions in several cities and evidence of large-scale military operations throughout Ukraine. Following the Russian invasion of Ukraine, many countries have imposed economic sanctions against Russia, which has impacted the global economy as many commercial, industrial and financial businesses are closing operations in Russia. Trade restrictions imposed on Russia have led to increasing prices of oil, fluctuation in commodities markets and foreign currency exchange volatility. Russia’s military incursion and the market volatility could adversely affect the global economy and financial markets and thus could affect our business, financial condition or results of operation. Further escalation of such armed conflict could lead to supply disruptions and higher energy costs, among others, which could adversely affect our results of operations.
We are not sure and cannot predict if and to what extent this war will impact the global economy, nor can we foresee what measures the Argentine Government may take to address any scenario, and if those measures will result in any negative effect on the Argentine economy, which could, in turn, affect our business and results of operations.
The application of certain laws and regulations could adversely affect our results of operations and financial condition
The Company’s operations and business could be affected by the adoption of restrictions on the import of products.
As of the date of this annual report, Edenor cannot guarantee that in the future, measures limiting or restricting import of products or the technical conditions will not be adopted which may have an impact on the goods used by the Company as inputs, causing the Company an adverse effect on its net worth, economic, financial or other situation, its results of operations, business operations and/or its ability to comply with its obligations in general.
On August 7, 2014, Law No. 26,944 on State Responsibility was enacted to regulate the liability of the Argentine Government and public officers, including state liability for unlawful and lawful actions. Such law regulates the Argentine Government’s liability on damages that its activity or inactivity may cause to individuals’ properties or rights, establishing that (i) the Argentine Government’s liability is objective and direct, (ii) the provisions of the Argentine Civil and Commercial Code are not applicable to the actions of the Argentine Government in a direct or subsidiary manner and (iii) no dissuasive financial penalties may be imposed on the Argentine Government, its agents or officers. Additionally, it specifies that the Argentine Government shall not be liable for the damages caused by public services concessionaires.
17 |
On September 18, 2014, the Argentine Congress enacted Law No. 26,991 amending Law No. 20,680 (the “Supply Law”), which became effective on September 28, 2014, to increase control over the supply of goods and provision of services. The Supply Law applies to all economic processes linked to goods, facilities and services which, either directly or indirectly, satisfy basic consumer needs (“Basic Needs Goods”) and grants a broad range of powers to its enforcing agency. It also grants the enforcing agency the power to order the sale, production, distribution or delivery of Basic Needs Goods throughout Argentina in case of a shortage of supply. The Supply Law includes the ability of the Argentine Government to regulate consumer rights under Article 42 of the Constitution and permits the creation of an authority to maintain the prices of goods and services (the “Observer of Prices of Goods and Services”). The Supply Law, as amended: (i) requires the continued production of goods to meet basic requirements; (ii) creates an obligation to publish prices of goods and services produced and borrowed; (iii) allows financial information to be requested and seized; and (iv) increases fines for legal entities and individuals. Additionally, on September 18, 2014 the Argentine Congress enacted Law No. 26,993, amending, among other laws, Law No. 25,156, which provides (i) the creation of a preliminary system where consumers may request a settlement of their complaints with companies, (ii) the incorporation of a new branch within the Judicial Power, namely the “National Courts on Consumer Relations” and (iii) the amendment of Law No. 24,240 (the “Consumer Defense Law”). Such reforms and creation of the Observer of Prices of Goods and Services could adversely affect our operations.
By means of Executive Order No. 990/20, the 2021 Budget Law was partially approved. In its Section 87, the law provides for a system for the settlement of debts with CAMMESA and/or the Wholesale Electric Market (Mercado Eléctrico Mayorista or “WEM”) accumulated by the electricity distribution companies as of September 30, 2020, whether on account of the consumption of energy, power, interest and/or penalties, in accordance with the conditions to be set out by the application authority, which may provide for credits equivalent to up to five times the monthly average bill or to 60% percent of the existing debt, whereas the remaining debt is to be paid in up to sixty monthly installments, with a grace period of up to six months, and at the rate in effect in the WEM, reduced by 50%.
Consequently, by means of Resolution No. 40/2021, the SE established the “Special System for the Regularization of Payment Obligations” of electricity distribution companies that are agents of the WEM for the debts held with CAMMESA and/or the WEM whether on account of the consumption of energy, power, interest and/or penalties, accumulated as of September 30, 2020. It also established a “Special System of Credits” for those electricity distribution companies that are agents of the WEM and have no debts with CAMMESA and/or the WEM or whose debts are regarded as being within reasonable values vis-à-vis their levels of transactions as of September 30, 2020.
Subsequently, the SE determined that it was suitable to establish as indicators for purposes of calculating the credits to be recognized, the maintenance of the electricity rate schedules throughout the year 2020, the policies implemented by each distribution company that is an agent of the WEM aimed at benefiting the demand, the effect of the application of the provisions of Executive Order No. 311 dated March 24, 2020, as amended and supplemented, as well as the investment commitments on energy efficiency, technology applied to the provision of the service and/or energy infrastructure works that imply an improvement in the quality of the service provided to users. Therefore, it issued Resolution No. 371/2021, which supplements Resolution No. 40/2021.
On February 22, 2022, by means of Executive Order No. 88/2022, the Argentine Government extended until December 31, 2022 the implementation of the “Special System for the Regularization of Payment Obligations” provided for in Section 87 of Law No. 27,591. In this context, we expressed our interest in participating in the execution of an agreement for the implementation of the above mentioned regime and after some negotiations, on December 29, 2022, we reached an agreement with the Argentine Government to restructure our commercial debt with CAMMESA as of August 2022 (the “2022 Agreement”). (Detailed information on the 2022 Agreement can be found in the section “Agreement on the Regularization of Payment Obligations – Debt for the purchase of energy in the MEM).
18 |
The implementation of the aforementioned laws and regulations has modified Argentina’s legal system. Future changes in applicable laws and regulations (including as a result of a change in government administration), administrative or judicial proceedings, including potential future claims by us against the Argentine Government, cannot be predicted and we cannot assure you that such changes will not adversely affect our business, financial condition and results of operations.
The Argentine economy and finances may be adversely affected as a consequence of a decrease in the international prices of commodities that Argentina exports
The commodities market is characterized by its volatility. Commodities exports have contributed significantly to the Argentine Government’s incomes. Subsequently, the Argentine economy has remained relatively dependent on the price of its exports (mainly soy).
A sustained decrease in the international price of the main commodities exported by Argentina, or any future climate event or condition may have adverse effect in the agriculture, and therefore in the Argentine Government’s incomes and its capacity to comply with the payments of its public debt, eventually generating recessive or inflationary pressures, thus affecting our business, financial situation and the results of our operations.
Failure to adequately address actual and perceived risks of institutional deterioration and corruption may adversely affect Argentina’s economy and financial condition
A lack of a solid and transparent institutional framework for contracts with the Argentine Government and its agencies and corruption allegations have affected and continue to affect Argentina. Argentina ranked 94 of 180 in the Transparency International’s 2022 Corruption Perceptions Index.
As of the date of this annual report, various investigations into allegations of money laundering and corruption being conducted by the Office of the Argentine Federal Prosecutor, including the largest such investigation, known as Los Cuadernos de las Coimas (the “Notebooks Investigation”) have negatively impacted the Argentine economy and political environment. Depending on the results of these investigations and how long it takes to finalize them, companies involved in the Notebooks Investigation may be subject to, among other consequences, a decrease in their credit ratings, having claims filed against them by investors in their equity and debt securities, and may further experience restrictions in their access to financing through the capital markets, all of which will likely decrease their income. Additionally, as the criminal cases against the companies involved in the Notebooks Investigation move forward, they may be restricted from rendering services or may face new restrictions due to their customers’ internal policies and procedures. These adverse effects could restrict these companies’ ability to conduct their operating activities and to fulfill their financial obligations. Consequently, the number of suppliers available for our operations may be reduced which could in turn have an adverse effect on our commercial activities and results of operations.
Recognizing that the failure to address these issues could increase the risk of political instability, distort decision-making processes and adversely affect Argentina’s international reputation and ability to attract foreign investment, the Argentine Government has announced several measures aimed at strengthening Argentina’s institutions and reducing corruption. These measures include the reduction of criminal sentences in exchange for cooperation with the government in corruption investigations, increased access to public information, the seizing of assets from corrupt officials, increasing the powers of the Anticorruption Office (Oficina Anticorrupción), submitting a bill for the issuance of a new public ethic law, among others. The Argentine Government’s ability to implement these initiatives is uncertain as it would be subject to independent review by the judicial branch, as well as legislative support from opposition parties.
19 |
We cannot estimate the impact that these investigations could have on the Argentine economy. Similarly, it is not possible to predict the duration of the corruption investigations, nor which other companies might be involved or how far-reaching the effects of these investigations might be, particularly in the energy sector, or if there will be any other future investigations in this or other industry, which may negatively impact the Argentine economy. In turn, the decrease in investor confidence resulting from any of these, among other issues, could have a significant adverse effect on the growth of the Argentine economy, which could, in turn, harm our business, our financial condition and operational results and affect the trading price of our Class B common shares and ADSs.
Any downgrade in the credit rating or rating outlook of Argentina could adversely affect both the rating and the market price of our ADS, our Class B common shares and our corporate debt, affecting also our liquidity
On June 24, 2021, Morgan Stanley Capital International (“MSCI”) announced the reclassification of Argentina to the standalone or independent category with effect as of November 2021, thus being excluded from the MSCI indexes. In June 2019, Argentina had entered the emerging market category. According to MSCI the main reason for this decision lies in the reinstatement of exchange controls, which have been in force since September 2019.
There can be no assurance that Argentina’s credit rating or rating outlook will not be downgraded in the future, which could have an adverse effect both on the rating and the market price of our ADS and Class B common shares.
Risks Relating to the Electricity Distribution Sector
The Argentine Government has intervened in the electricity sector in the past, and may continue intervening
Historically, the Argentine Government has exerted a significant influence on the economy, including the energy sector, and companies such as us that operate in such sector have done so in a highly regulated context that aims mainly at guaranteeing the supply of domestic demand.
To address the Argentine economic crisis in 2001 and 2002, the Argentine Government adopted the Public Emergency Law and other regulations, which made a number of material changes to the regulatory framework applicable to the electricity sector. These changes severely affected electricity generation, distribution and transmission companies and included the freezing of nominal distribution margins, the revocation of adjustment and inflation indexation mechanisms for tariffs, a limitation on the ability of electricity distribution companies to pass on to the user increases in costs due to regulatory charges and the introduction of a new price-setting mechanism in the Wholesale Electric Market (Mercado Eléctrico Mayorista or “MEM”) which had a significant impact on electricity generators and generated substantial price differences within the market. From time to time, the Argentine Government intervened in this sector by, for example, granting temporary nominal margin increases, proposing a new social tariff regime for residents of poverty-stricken areas, removing discretionary subsidies, creating specific charges to raise funds that were transferred to government-managed trust funds that finance investments in generation and distribution infrastructure and mandating investments for the construction of new generation plants and the expansion of existing transmission and distribution networks.
20 |
On December 17, 2015, the Argentine Government issued Decree No. 134/15 declaring the emergency of the national electricity sector which was in effect until December 31, 2017 and instructing the Ministry of Energy and Mining (“ME&M”) to adopt any measure it deemed necessary regarding the generation, transmission and distribution segments, to adjust the quality and guarantee the provision of electricity.
During 2017, the Argentine Government, through the relevant agencies enacted several resolutions to establish the penalties regime and adjust tariffs. On February 1, 2017, an RTI process was completed and a new tariff scheme for the following five-year period was enacted. However, on December 21, 2019, the Argentine Congress adopted the Productive Reactivation Law, which adopts measures that will significantly impact the Argentine economy, including the declaration of the public emergency in tariffs and energy matters until December 31, 2020, and the delegation to the Federal Executive Power of certain powers normally reserved to Congress or otherwise not within the purview of the Argentine Executive Power (including the ability to make determinations in the renegotiation of public tariffs). Additionally, on December 16, 2020, the Executive Branch issued Decree No. 1020/20 which extended the freeze on electricity rates prescribed by the Productive Reactivation Law until March 31, 2021, or until the new transitional electricity rate schedules come into effect, whichever occurs first. Additionally, by means of Decree No. 1020/20, the Argentine Executive Power provided for the commencement of the Tariff Structure Review renegotiation process, which may not exceed two years, suspending the agreements relating to the respective Tariff Structure Reviews in effect. Interim Renegotiation Agreements may be entered into, which modify to a limited extent the conditions of the tariff review imposing a Transitional Tariff System until a Definitive Renegotiation Agreement is reached.
On March 30, 2021, the National Electricity Regulatory Agency (“Ente Nacional Regulador de la Electricidad” or “ENRE” by its acronym in Spanish) called a public hearing, with the main goal of determining a transitional rate schedule for electricity distribution until the next RTI. As a result of such process, the ENRE approved a 20,9% of own distribution costs (“CPD”, also referred as value-added for distribution (“VAD”) in this annual report) (which resulted in a final 9% tariff’s increase).
On April 30, 2021, in order to reach a temporary solution to guarantee the continuity, accessibility and normal transportation and distribution of electric energy, through Resolutions No. 106/2021 and 107/2021, the ENRE defined a 9% increase in the average tariff for Edenor and Edesur users, effective as from May 1, 2021.
On February 3, 2022, the ENRE issued Resolutions No. 41/2022 and 42/2022, increasing the average tariff for residential, non-residential and large users of Edenor and Edesur, effective as from February 1, 2022. This increase did not affect households, businesses and large public users of health and education services of Edenor and Edesur, for which the ENRE called for a public hearing to be held on February 17, 2022. On February 17, 2022, the ENRE called another public hearing, with the main goal of determining a transitional rate schedule for electricity distribution until the next RTI. Our Company explained the need of an additional Ps. 56,800 million required to maintain and continue the improvement in the quality of electricity services. Additionally, we explained our financial situation, the investments that have been made to satisfy demand and the improvement in the provision of the services, and proposed a rate schedule structure that allows better control by customers.
On February 26, 2022, the ENRE granted an additional 8% in CPD. However, it also enacted an increase of the penalty rate applicable to the energy sector, which resulted in a net increase of 4%.
21 |
On June 16, 2022, Decree No. 332/2022 set forth a mandatory reclassification of the users. Upon the registration of each user at a National Registry of Users (“RASE” for its acronym in Spanish), declaring certain personal and economic information, residential users have been classified in three new categories, where N1 has lost 100% of their subsidies, N2 and N3 have partially lost their subsidies over time (see “Business Overview – Edenor Tariff categories”). Such governmental decision, in line with the SDRs agreed with the IMF, may have an impact on our collections, causing unfavorable alterations on our remuneration scheme.
On March 1, 2023, ENRE granted increases of 107.8% applicables from April 2023 and other 73.7% applicable as form June 2023.
Since the new RTI should become effective prior to December 31, 2023, Edenor is preparaing all the necessary information and documentation to support the request of additional increases. Nevertheless, the Company expects that the adjustment indicated above may represent an increase in the Company’s income for the year 2023 of Ps. 86,656 million, which would be insufficient to cover the requirement of Ps. 205,759 million requested by it as necessary to deal with the deficit for the period, affecting the our ability to operate and meet our obligations.
We cannot assure you that certain other regulations or measures that may be adopted by the Argentine Government will not have a material adverse effect on our business and results of operations or on the market value of our shares and ADSs, or that the Argentine Government will not adopt further regulations in the future that may increase our obligations, including increased taxes, unfavorable alterations to our tariff structures or remuneration scheme and other regulatory obligations, compliance with which would increase our costs and may have a direct negative impact on our results of operations and cause the market value of our ADSs and Class B common shares to decline. See “Item 4. Information on the Company—Business Overview—Edenor Concession.”
There is uncertainty as to what other measures the Argentine Government may adopt in connection with tariffs on public services and their impact on the Argentine economy
As explained in other risk factors in this annual report, following the economic crisis of 2001-2002, the subsequent freeze on electricity rates in Pesos and the significant depreciation of the Argentine Peso against the U.S. dollar, there was a lack of investment in the distribution capacities of electricity and, at the same time, demand for electricity increased substantially.
On February 1, 2017, an RTI process was completed. Through Resolution No. 63/17 (amended by ENRE Resolutions No. 82/17 and No. 92/17), the ENRE approved a rate of return for us of 12.46% before taxes. The resulting income was determined by applying the Net Replacement Value (“NRV”) methodology, over a slightly lower base capital than the one we had submitted in our proposal, reaching an amount of Ps.34 billion. The difference with our proposal was mainly explained by the fact that the ENRE excluded the fully depreciated assets from the regulatory net asset base. Moreover, the ENRE stated that our acknowledged remuneration as of December 2015 was Ps.12.5 billion, which adjusted to February 2017 reached to Ps.17.2 billion. The ENRE also established a non-automatic mechanism to adjust our tariffs, as it had done under the original Concession Agreement and the Adjustment Agreement (as defined below), in order to preserve the economic and financial sustainability of the concession in the event of price fluctuations in the economy. This mechanism has a biannual basis and includes a combined formula of wholesale and consumer price indexes (WPI, CPI and salaries increases) which trigger the adjustment of tariffs when the result is above 5%.
We filed an administrative appeal (“recurso de reconsideración”) against ENRE’s Resolution No. 63/17. On October 25, 2017, the ENRE, through Resolution No. 524/17, rejected the appeal filed by Edenor.
22 |
On January 31, 2018, the ENRE issued Resolution No. 33/18 which approved the new distribution cost for us to be applied as from February 1, 2018, and the new tariff scheme.
Furthermore, such resolution approved the new adjustments to CPD (last stage of 17% according to Resolution No 63/17, including the inflation adjustment of 11.9% for the period July 2017-December 2017 and a stimulus factor “E” of negative 2.51%) and determined the deferred income to be recovered in 48 installments for a total amount of Ps.6,343.4 million. Additionally, it reported that the price of the average tariff reached Ps.2.4627/ KWh.
Furthermore, on September 19, 2019, we and the Federal Government entered into an Electricity Rate Schedules Maintenance Agreement, which provided for the following:
§ | to keep the electricity rate schedules that were effective prior to August 1, 2019, for all electricity tariff categories; |
§ | to postpone until January 1, 2020, the application of the CPD that was to be applied as from August 1, 2019, regarding the January-June 2019 period, which amounted to 19.05%; |
§ | to update the electricity rate schedules in relation to seasonal energy prices as from January 1, 2020; and |
§ | to regulate the difference of the CPD and the seasonal energy prices generated between those applied as from August 1, 2019, and those to be applied as from January 1, 2020, for the August 1, 2019-December 31, 2019, period. Such difference shall be recovered in seven monthly and consecutive installments as from January 1, 2020, and shall be adjusted in accordance with the relevant CPD adjustment and the plan set forth in late payment procedures applied by CAMMESA, respectively. |
The Productive Reactivation Law, authorized the Executive Branch to (i) initiate either a renegotiation process of the tariff structure in effect or an extraordinary review, and (ii) freeze electricity rates for 180-days (term that was extended until December 31, 2020 by means of Decree No. 543/2020 and later on extended until March 31, 2021 by means of Decree No. 1020/20 until March 31, 2021), or until the new transitional electricity rate schedules come into effect, whichever occurs first. For more information on tariffs, see “Item 5. Operating and Financial Review and Prospects—Operating Results—Tariffs.”
According to Decree No. 1020/20, and ENRE Resolutions 16/2021 and 17/2021, the procedure for the transitional electricity rate schedules has been initiated.
On December 27, 2019, the ENRE instructed us to not apply the electricity rate schedules from January 1, 2020, resulting from the provisions of the Electricity Rate Schedules Maintenance Agreement as of September 19, 2019, as such agreement had lost enforceability due to the electricity rate emergency provided in the aforementioned law, and the electricity rate schedule that had been approved by ENRE Resolution No. 104/19 dated April 30, 2019 remained in effect.
Decree No. 260 dated March 12, 2020, extended the public emergency in health matters established by Law No. 27,541, as a consequence of the Pandemic declared by the World Health Organization (“WHO”) in respect of the COVID-19 virus.
On March 30, 2021, the ENRE called a public hearing, with the main goal of determining a transitional rate schedule for electricity distribution until the next RTI. As a result of such process, the ENRE approved a 20,9% of CPD (which resulted in a final 9% tariff´s increase).
23 |
On February 17, 2022, the ENRE called another public hearing, with the main goal of determining a transitional rate schedule for electricity distribution until the next RTI. The Company explained the need of an additional Ps. 56,800 million of funds required to maintain and continue the improvement in the company’s invent plan and the quality of electricity services. Additionally, we explained our financial situation, the investments that had been made to satisfy demand and the improvement in the provision of the services, and proposed a rate schedule structure that allows for better control by customers.
In spite of the presentations made stating the need for an additional cash flow of Ps. 283 million, as of February 26, 2022, the ENRE granted an additional 8% in CPD only, which -after being offset against the increase in the potentially applicable penalty computations- resulted in a net increase of 4%.
On March 22, 2022, the Company filed an administrative appeal (recurso de reconsideración) against ENRE´s Resolution No. 76/2022 since, there has been an increase in the value of the average tariff, it still did not reflect the increase in operating costs and the amounts projected for the investments necessary in the electrical network. The Company is expecting the publication of the new RTI before the end of 2022.
The adjustment indicated above represents an increase in our income for the year 2022 of Ps. 2,915 million, which is insufficient to cover the requirement of Ps. 56,800 million requested by us as necessary to deal with the deficit for the period, affecting our ability to operate and meet its obligations.
Later, under Decree No. 1020/2020 dated December 16, 2020, and by Resolutions of the ENRE No. 16 and No. 17 dated January 19, 2021, the procedure for the transitory adjustment of the tariffs of the public distribution and transportation services, respectively, was initiated with the purpose of establishing a Transitional Tariff Regime until a Definitive Renegotiation Agreement is reached.
Then, by Resolutions No. 41 of 2022, the ENRE set the new average tariffs applicable to us as from February 2022, and on which the subsidy to be provided by the national government will be calculated. And by Resolution No. 25 of 2022, the ENRE convened a public hearing to be held on February 17, 2022, in order to inform and hear opinions regarding: (i) the treatment of the establishment of the seasonal reference prices of Power, Stabilized Energy in the WEM, as well as the Stabilized Price of Transportation (“PET”) and for the Wholesale Electric Market of the Tierrra del Fuego System (Mercado Eléctrico Mayorista del Sistema Tierra del Fuego or “MEMSTDF” for its acronym in Spanish); (ii) the proposals of the concessionaires of the public electric power transmission and distribution service, aimed at obtaining a transitory adjustment of tariffs, within the ITR renegotiation process and prior to defining the tariffs to be applied by the concessionaires.
In said hearing, Edenor and Edesur presented the investments made in 2021, highlighted their losses and asked for $100 billion more in revenues this year to guarantee the service they provide, which could be met through tariff increases, subsidies or a combination of both. However, this request was rejected. On March 1, 2023, the ENRE granted increases of 107.8% applicable as from April 2023 and other 73.7% applicable as from June 2023.
Notwithstanding the measures recently adopted, there is uncertainty as to what measures the Argentine Government may adopt in connection with tariffs, whether tariffs will be updated in connection with the RTI which shall take place by December 31, 2023, and from time to time to reflect an increase in operating costs, and their impact on demand. Likewise, no assurance can be given that any future reduction in subsidies will not increase the clients’ default or a delay in the collection of debts.
24 |
Electricity distributors were severely affected by the emergency measures adopted during the economic crisis, many of which remain in effect
Distribution tariffs include a regulated margin that is intended to cover the costs of distribution and provide an adequate return over the distributor’s asset base. Under the Convertibility Regime, which established a fixed exchange rate of one Peso per U.S. Dollar, distribution tariffs were calculated in U.S. Dollars and distribution margins were adjusted periodically to reflect variations in U.S. inflation indexes. However, the Public Emergency Law, which came into effect in January 2002, froze all distribution margins, revoked all margin adjustments provisions in distribution concession agreements and converted distribution tariffs into Pesos at a rate of Ps.1.00 per U.S.$1.00. These measures, coupled with the effect of high inflation and the depreciation of the Peso, led to a decline in distribution revenues and an increase of distribution costs in real terms, which could no longer be recovered through adjustments to the distribution margin. This situation, in turn, led many public utility companies, including us and other important distribution companies, to suspend payments on their commercial debt (which continued to be denominated in U.S. Dollars despite the pesification of revenues), effectively preventing these companies from obtaining further financing in the domestic or international credit markets and making additional investments.
In the past, the Argentine Government granted temporary and partial relief to some distribution companies, including limited increases in distribution margins, a temporary cost adjustment mechanism which was not fully implemented and the ability to apply certain additional charges to users.
On December 21, 2019, the Argentine Congress adopted the Productive Reactivation Law, which included the declaration of the public emergency in tariffs and energy matters (among others) and the delegation to the Federal Executive Power of certain powers normally reserved to Congress or otherwise not within the purview of the Federal Executive Power (including the ability to make determinations in the renegotiation of public tariffs). The effects of this law were extended until March 31, 2021, postponing the update of the electricity rate schedule.
As part of the measures adopted within the framework of the declaration of public emergency, the ENRE, through Resolution No. 58, instructed the Company to refrain from pursuing the collection of debts originated during the validity of the imposed lockdown and related governmental measures due to Covid-19 (“Aislamiento Social Previentivo y Obligatorio or “ASPO” and Distranciamiento Social Previcentivo y Obligatorio or “DISPO”) regimes, ordering it to reflect them separately in its invoices to users. We cannot foresee what other measures may be enacted in the future and, in turn, affect the Company’s capacity to generate current income.
Any measures that may be taken as a result of the enactment of the Productive Reactivation Law and the declaration of public emergency, coupled with the economic crisis, may have an adverse impact on the Company. Our inability to cover the costs or to receive an adequate return on our asset base may further adversely affect our financial condition and results of operations.
Electricity demand may be affected by tariff increases, which could lead distribution companies, such as us, to record lower revenues
From 2013 through 2022, electricity demand in Argentina increased by 11%, which in part reflects the relative low cost, in real terms, of electricity to users due to the freezing of tariffs and therefore the distribution margins, the establishment of subsidies in the purchase price of energy and the elimination of the inflation adjustment provisions in distribution concessions, coupled with the depreciation of the Peso and inflation through 2021.
25 |
In 2022, the Company’s electricity demand amounted to 27,158GWh, which represented a 3% increase compared to 2021, while the WEM demand amounted to 138,755GWh (+3.6% year-on-year). The variation in the Company’s demand was mainly due to temperature, elasticity, price and the level of economic activity.
Very high temperatures were registered during 2022, which mainly affected demand.
We cannot make any assurance that any future increases in the cost of electricity will not have a material adverse effect on electricity demand or result in a decline in collections from users. In this respect, we cannot assure you that these measures or any future measure will not lead electricity companies, like us, to record lower revenues and results of operations, which may, in turn, have a material adverse effect on the market value of our ADSs and Class B common shares.
Energy shortages may act as a brake on growing demand for electricity and disrupt distribution companies’ ability to deliver electricity to their customers, which could result in customer claims and material penalties imposed on these companies
Argentine electricity generators are currently operating at near full capacity and could be required to ration supply in order to meet a national energy demand that exceeds the current generation capacity. In addition, the economic crisis and the resulting emergency measures have had and continue to have a material adverse effect on other energy sectors, including oil and gas companies, which has led to a significant reduction in natural gas supplies to generation companies that use this commodity in their generation activities. In addition, Argentina needs to import energy or gas and their prices have recently risen. As a result, electricity generators may not to be able to guarantee the supply of electricity to distribution companies, which, in turn, could prevent these companies, including us, from experiencing continued growth in their businesses and could lead to failures to provide electricity to customers. Under Argentine law, distribution companies are responsible to their customers for any disruption in the supply of electricity. As a result, distribution companies may face customer claims and fines and penalties for disruptions caused by energy shortages even when these are attributable to generators and transportation companies unless the relevant Argentine authorities determine that energy shortages constitute force majeure. To date, the Argentine authorities have not been called upon to decide under which conditions energy shortages may constitute force majeure. In the past, however, the Argentine authorities have recognized the existence of force majeure only in limited circumstances, such as internal malfunctions at the customer’s facilities, extraordinary meteorological events (such as major storms) and third-party work in public thoroughfares. We cannot make assurances that we will not experience a lack of energy supply that could adversely affect our business, financial condition and results of operations, as well as our ability to repay our debts.
If the demand for energy is increased suddenly, the difficulty in increasing the capacity of distribution companies in a short or medium term, could adversely affect the Company, which in turn could result in customer complaints and substantial fines for any interruptions
In recent years, the increase in electricity demand was greater than the structural increase in electricity distribution capacities, which led to power shortages and disruptions, in certain occasions. A sustained increase in electricity demand could generate future shortages. In addition, the condition of the Argentine electricity market has provided little incentive to generators and distributors to further invest in increasing their generation and distribution capacity, respectively, which would require material long-term financial commitments. In 2020, 2021 and 2022, the increase in the capacity of our own facilities resulting from the investment process was higher than the increase in demand, and the service quality indicators have continued improving. Regarding the coming years, there is uncertainty about the availability of resources to continue with this process. With respect to generation, depending on the availability of water and fuels, supply could be affected. For these cases, we are exempted from liability according to Resolution ENRE No. 63/2017.
26 |
Additionally, according to Argentine law, distribution companies, such as us, are responsible to their users for any disruption in the supply of electricity. Consequently, customers can direct their claims to the distribution companies. Also, distribution companies are subject to fines and penalties for service disruptions caused by energy shortages, unless the respective Argentine authorities determine that energy shortages constitute force majeure events. As a result, we could face user claims and fines and penalties for service disruptions caused by energy shortages unless the relevant Argentine authorities determine that energy shortages constitute force majeure.
We cannot assure that we will not experience a lack in the supply of energy or that such claims, fines, penalties or government intervention will not have a materially adverse effect on our financial condition and results of operations and cause the market value of our ADSs and Class B common shares to decline.
Risks Relating to Our Business
We operate our business pursuant to our Concession Agreement granted by the Argentine Government, the revocation or termination of which would have a material adverse effect on our business
We conduct our business pursuant to our concession agreement dated August 5, 1992 (“Concession Agreement”) granted by the Argentine Government. Such agreement contains several requirements regarding the operation of our business and compliance with laws and regulations. Compliance with our obligations under our Concession Agreement is secured by a pledge of our Class A common shares in favor of the Argentine Government. Accordingly, upon the occurrence of specified events of default under our Concession Agreement, the Argentine Government would be entitled to foreclose on its pledge on our Class A common shares, which would have a severe negative impact on our ability to operate a material portion of our business, and as a result, our results of operations would be materially adversely affected. Finally, our Concession Agreement also generally provides for termination in the case of our insolvency or bankruptcy. If our Concession Agreement is terminated or if the Argentine Government forecloses its pledge over Class A common shares, we may not be able to continue to operate as a going concern, and in turn our consolidated results of operations would be materially adversely affected and the market value of our Class B common shares and ADSs could decline.
Downgrades in our credit ratings could have negative effects on our funding costs and business operations
Credit ratings are assigned to the Company. The credit ratings are based on information furnished by us or obtained by the credit rating agencies from independent sources and are also influenced by the credit ratings of Argentine Government bonds and general views regarding the Argentine financial system as a whole. The credit ratings are subject to revision, suspension or withdrawal by the credit rating agencies at any time. A downgrade, suspension or withdrawal in our credit ratings could result in, among others, the following: (i) increased funding costs and other difficulties in raising funds; (ii) the need to provide additional collateral in connection with financial market transactions; and (iii) the termination or cancellation of existing agreements. As a result, our business, financial condition and results of operations could be materially and adversely affected.
27 |
Our business is subject to risks arising from natural disasters, catastrophic accidents and terrorist attacks. Additionally, our businesses are subject to the risk of mechanical or electrical failures and any resulting unavailability may affect our ability to fulfil our demand and thus adversely affect our business and financial performance
The electric power distribution infrastructure that we rely on, may be damaged by flooding, hurricanes, strong windstorms, fires, earthquakes and other catastrophic disasters arising from natural or accidental or intentional human causes. We could experience severe business disruptions, significant decreases in revenues based on lower demand arising from catastrophic events, or significant additional costs to us not otherwise covered by insurance policies. There may be an important time lag between a major accident, catastrophic event or terrorist attack and our definitive recovery from our insurance policies, which typically carry non-recoverable deductible amounts. In addition, any of these events could cause adverse effects on the energy demand of some of our customers and of consumers generally in the affected market. Some of these considerations, could have a material adverse effect on our business, financial condition and our result of operations.
Additionally, our assets are subject to the risk of mechanical or electrical failures and may experience periods of unavailability affecting our ability to fulfil our energy demand. Any unplanned unavailability of our energy demand, so we could be subject to fines and penalties. For example, in June 2019, Argentina suffered a general blackout which hindered the distribution of energy in our concession area. Although our facilities did not suffer any damage, we cannot assure that any other event in the Argentine network will not affect our facilities and consequently their availability to fulfil our energy demand and our operational results.
Between January 10, 2022 and January 16, 2022, our facilities and networks have been affected by a meteorological phenomenon known as “heat wave”. This event is characterized by the persistence of very high minimum and maximum temperatures for several consecutive days (minimum temperatures above 30°C and maximum temperatures above 41°C). A heat wave with extraordinary temperatures for the summer season due to the direct incidence of the La Niña phenomenon took place in the Metropolitan Area of Buenos Aires where our whole concession area is located, as it was duly recognized and published by the National Meteorological Service and by the Federal Executive Power through Decree No. 16/2022. The increase in demand has had a direct and definitive effect on our facilities during the period from January 10, 2022 to January 16, 2022, when they were subjected to thermal overload that affected their dissipation conditions, adding as a factor of utmost importance, the high consumption sustained during that period by users. The characteristics of said meteorological phenomenon were verified consecutively and without interruption from January 10, 2022 to January 16, 2022. During March 2023, we were affected by several factors: (i) a “heat wave” with temperatures above 38.9°; (ii) energy demand of 29,105MW (an increase of 40% at the national level and 60% in our Concession, compared to same period in 2022); and (iii) a big fire affecting the high-voltage electricity transmission system that caused an extraordinary interruption and loss of generation (7,000MW) and demand (11,000MW), disconecting Cordoba, Santa Fe, La Rioja, Tucumá, La Pampa, Río Negro, Neuquén, Mendoza, San Juan and the greater Buenos Aires metropolitan area.
In anticipation of the impact that the heat wave could have on the installations, we have decided:
· | all Edenor’s and contractors’ operating personnel to attend eventual needs of the network; |
· | all activities not related to repairs and network management were suspended as a preventive measure in order to have all resources available to meet possible contingencies; |
· | the guards of all auxiliary services were reinforced to keep the operation running permanently (warehouses, fleet maintenance, etc.); |
28 |
· | the diagrams of the technical personnel were adapted to operate with extended working hours, to increase the capacity to respond to the possible operational needs of the areas; |
· | the time required to deal with any faults that might occur was shortened, thus favoring the operation of the network in its normal state; and |
· | to increase our capacity to respond to potential failures, we extended our contracts with suppliers of generator sets and cable fault locating equipment. |
Regarding the supply interruptions caused by the heat wave and the trasmission event, we have requested the ENRE to exclude them from the calculation of the service quality indicators.
Our operations could cause environmental risks and any change in environmental laws, climate change legislation or regulations restricting emissions of greenhouse gases (“GHGs”) and legal frameworks promoting an increase in the participation of energies from renewable sources could significantly impact our business and result in increased operating costs.
In December 1993, Argentina approved the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (“UNFCCC”) through Law No. 24,295. The UNFCCC, which entered into force on March 21, 1994, deals with the stabilization of the GHGs concentrations in the atmosphere at a level that would prevent dangerous anthropogenic interference with the climate system.
On February 16, 2005, the Kyoto Protocol to the UNFCCC (“Protocol”) entered into force. This Protocol, which deals with the reduction of certain Greenhouse Gases (“GHGs”) (carbon dioxide, methane, nitrous oxide, hydrofluorocarbons, perfluorocarbons and sulphur hexafluoride) in the atmosphere, was in force until 2020 as a consequence of the ratification of the Doha Amendment to the Protocol.
Argentina approved the Protocol through Law No. 25,438 on June 20, 2001, and the Doha Amendment through Law No. 27,137 on April 29, 2015.
The 2015 United Nations Climate Change Conference adopted by consensus the Paris Agreement, which is known to be the successor of the Protocol. The agreement deals with GHG emission reduction measures, targets to limit global temperature increases and requires countries to review and “represent a progression” in their intended nationally determined contributions. Countries agreed they will aim to achieve the long term goal to limit global warming to well below 2°C above pre-industrial levels, and pursue efforts to further limit the temperature increase to 1.5°C. On October 5, 2016, the threshold for entry into force of the Paris Agreement was achieved. International treaties together with increased public awareness related to climate change may result in increased regulation to reduce or mitigate GHG emissions. Under Federal Law No. 27,270, dated September 1, 2016, Argentina approved the Paris Agreement.
Furthermore, Argentine Law No. 26,190, as amended and complemented by Law No. 27,191 and its implementing decrees, established a legal framework which promotes an increase in the participation of energies from renewable sources in Argentina’s electricity market.
Compliance with legal and regulatory changes relating to climate change, including those resulting from the implementation of international treaties, may in the future increase our costs to operate and maintain our facilities, install new emission controls on our facilities and administer and manage any GHG emissions program. More stringent environmental regulations can result in the imposition of costs associated with GHG emissions, either through environmental agency requirements relating to mitigation initiatives or through other regulatory measures such as GHG emissions taxation and market creation of limitations on GHG emissions that have the potential to increase our operating costs. Revenue generation and strategic growth opportunities may also be adversely affected. Any long-term material adverse effect on the telecommunications industry could adversely affect the financial and operational aspects of our business, which we cannot predict with certainty as of the date of annual report.
29 |
Some of our operations are subject to environmental risks that could arise unexpectedly and cause material adverse effects on our results of operations and financial condition. In addition, the occurrence of any of these risks could lead to personal injury, loss of life, environmental damage, repair and expenses, equipment damage and liability in civil and administrative proceedings. We cannot assure you that we will not incur additional costs related to environmental issues in the future, which could adversely affect our results of operations and financial condition. In addition, we cannot ensure that our insurance coverage is sufficient to cover the losses that could potentially arise from these environmental risks.
In addition, we are subject to a broad range of environmental legislation, both in Argentina. Local, provincial and national authorities in Argentina may implement new environmental laws and regulations and may require us to incur higher costs to comply with new standards. The imposition of more stringent regulatory and permit requirements in relation to our operators in Argentina could significantly increase the costs of our activity.
We cannot predict the general effects of the implementation of any new environmental laws and regulations on our financial condition and results of operations.
Failure or delay to negotiate further improvements to our tariff structure, including increases in our distribution margin, and/or to have our tariffs adjusted to reflect increases in our distribution costs in a timely manner or at all, affected and may continue to affect our capacity to perform our commercial obligations and could also have a material adverse effect on our ability to perform our financial obligations
Since the execution of the agreement entered into between us and the Argentine Government on February 13, 2006, relating to the adjustment and renegotiation of the terms of our Concession Agreement (“Acta Acuerdo sobre la Adecuación del Contrato de Concesión del Servicio Público de Distribución y Comercialización de Energía Eléctrica” or the “Adjustment Agreement”) and as required by the Argentine Government, we were engaged in an RTI with the ENRE through February 1, 2017.
The Adjustment Agreement contemplated a cost adjustment mechanism for the transitional period during which an RTI process was being conducted. This mechanism, known as the Cost Monitoring Mechanism (“CMM”), required the ENRE to review our actual distribution costs every six months (in May and November of each year) and adjust our distribution margins to reflect variations of 5% or more in our distribution cost base. We could also request that the ENRE apply the CMM at any time that the variation in our distribution cost base was at least 10% or more. Any adjustments, however, were subject to the ENRE’s assessment of variations in our costs, and the ENRE’s approval of adjustments were not sufficient to cover our actual incremental costs in a timely manner. During such time, even when the ENRE approved adjustments to our tariffs, there was a lag between the time when we actually experienced increases in our distribution costs and the time when we received increased income following the corresponding adjustments to our distribution margins pursuant to the CMM.
In this context and in light of the situation that affected the electricity sector, the ENRE issued Resolution No. 347/12 in November 2012, which established the application of fixed and variable charges that allowed the Company to obtain additional revenue as from November 2012 through 2016. However, changes made by Resolution No. 250/13 and Notes No. 6,852/13, No. 4,012/14, No. 486/14 and No. 1,136/14 of the SE and additional revenue obtained through Resolution No. 347/12 were insufficient to make up for our operating deficit in 2014, due to the constant increase in operating costs.
30 |
In March 2015, Resolution No. 32/15 of the former SE granted us a temporary increase in income through funds provided by CAMMESA applicable retroactively as from February 1, 2015 through February 1, 2016, to cover costs and investments associated with the regular provision of the public service of distribution of energy on account of an RTI.
In January 2016, the ME&M issued Resolution No. 7/16, pursuant to which the ENRE implemented VAD adjustment to the tariff schedule on account of the future RTI in effect as of February 1, 2016.
In addition, such resolution: (i) abrogated the Energy Rational Use Program (“Programa de Uso Racional de la Energía Eléctrica” or “PUREE”); (ii) repealed Resolution No. 32/15 as from the date the ENRE resolution implementing the new tariff schedule becomes effective; (iii) discontinued the application of mechanisms that imply the transfer of funds from CAMMESA in the form of loan agreements with CAMMESA; (iv) ordered the implementation of the actions required to terminate the trusts created pursuant to Resolution No. 347/12 of the ENRE and (v) prohibited the distribution of dividends in accordance with Section 7.04 of the Adjustment Agreement.
However, pursuant to Resolution No. 7/16, the ENRE issued Resolution No. 1/16 establishing a new tariff structure, which remained in force (with certain suspensions as a result of injunctions, which are no longer in effect) until February 2017, when an RTI process was completed.
Prior to the completion of such RTI process, several regulatory mechanisms, programs or changes were implemented from time to time by the ENRE to adjust our tariffs to reflect increased costs. Any requested adjustments were usually subject to the ENRE’s assessment of variations in our costs, and not sufficient to cover our actual incremental costs in a timely manner.
On April 1, 2016, the ENRE issued Resolution No. 55/16, which approved the program for the review of the distribution tariff scheme, establishing the criteria and methodologies for completing an RTI process.
On September 5, 2016, pursuant to Resolution No. 55/16, we submitted our rate schedule proposal for the following five-year period. On October 28, 2016, a public hearing was held to provide information and listen to the public opinion on an RTI.
Such RTI was completed on February 1, 2017, on which date the ENRE issued Resolution No. 63/17, through which it approved a new tariff scheme that established our new VAD for the following five-year period (For more information, see “Item 5—Operating and Financial Review and Prospects—Operating Results—Tariffs —Integral Tariff Revision”). On January 31, 2018, the ENRE issued Resolution No. 33/18 approving the new distribution cost for Edenor applicable as from February 1, 2018 and the new tariff scheme applicable to the Company. On July 31, 2018, the ENRE issued Resolution No. 208/18, pursuant to which it approved the CPD for January-June 2018 period of which 7.93% was applied as of August 1, 2018, and 6.51% in six consecutive monthly installments as of February 1, 2019. The CPD amounted to 15.85%.
Within the framework of the aforementioned Electricity Rate Schedules Maintenance Agreement, in 2020, the Company made different presentations to the ENRE with the estimates of the electricity rate schedules that were to be applied during 2020, according to the terms of the Electricity Rate Schedules Maintenance Agreement entered between the Company and the Federal Government. However, the ENRE has instructed the Company to not apply the rates, in accordance with the Productive Reactivation Law. As mentioned above, the freeze on electricity rates was extended until March 31, 2021, or until the new transitional electricity rate schedules resulting from the Transitional Tariff System come into effect, whichever occurs first.
31 |
On May 10, 2019, the Company and the SE, on behalf of the Argentine Government, entered into the Agreement on the Regularization of Obligations. By virtue of this agreement, the Company (i) undertook to pay users certain penalty and compensation amounts relating to the 2006-2016 period; and (ii) agreed to make investments, in addition to those agreed upon in the RTI, to contribute to improve the reliability and safety of the service. In return, the Argentine Government partially recognized the claim duly made by the Company, by fully offsetting pending obligations and cancelling penalties payable to the National Treasury. Furthermore, the Company waived any rights to which it may be entitled and abandoned any actions against the Federal Government.
On March 30, 2021, the ENRE called a public hearing, with the main goal of determining a transitional rate schedule for electricity distribution until the next RTI. As a result of such process, the ENRE approved a 20,9% of own distribution costs (“CPD”) (which resulted in a final 9% tariff´s increase). Later on April 30, 2021, Edenor obtained an additional 8% increase on CPD.
On February 17, 2022, the ENRE called another public hearing, with the main goal of determining a transitional rate schedule for electricity distribution until the next RTI. Our Busines Control Manager, Federico Mendez, explained the need of an additional Ps. 56,800 million required to maintain and continue the improvement in the quality of electricity services. Additionally, he explained our financial situation, the investments that have been made to satisfy demand and the improvement in the provision of the services, and he proposed a rate schedule structure that allows better control by customers.
On February 26, 2022, the ENRE granted an additional 8% in CPD. However, it also enacted an increase of the penalty rate applicable to the energy sector, which resulted in a net increase of 4%.
On December 29, 2022, the Company, the SE and ENRE, on behalf of the Argentine Government, entered into the 2022 Agreement. By virtue of this agreement, the Company (i) undertook to pay users certain compensation amounts relating to the COVID period; and (ii) agreed to make investments, in addition to those agreed upon in the RTI, to contribute to improved reliability and safety of the service. In return, the Argentine Government partially recognized credits in favor of the Company and those credits will be set off against the commercial debt with CAMMESA. As a condition to the 2022 Agreement, the SE acknowledged and agreed to recognized a tariff increase, which has been approved by Resolution ENRE No. 241/2023 authorizing an increase of 107.8% and 73.7% of VAD as from April and June, respectively.
Although such amount became an important recognition to Edenor, if we are not able to recover all future cost increases and have them reflected in our tariffs, and/or if there is a significant lag of time between when we incur the incremental costs and when we receive increased income we may be unable to comply with our financial obligations, we may suffer liquidity shortfalls and we may need to restructure our debt to ease our financial condition, any of which, individually or in the aggregate, could have a material adverse effect on our business and results of operations and may cause the value of our ADSs and Class B common shares to decline. For more information, see “Item 5. Operating and Financial Review and Prospects—Operating Results—Tariffs.”
We may not be able to adjust our tariffs to reflect increases in our distribution costs in a timely manner, or at all, which may have a material adverse effect on our results of operations
32 |
The Adjustment Agreement currently contemplates a cost adjustment mechanism for the transition period during which an RTI is being conducted. This mechanism, known as the Cost Monitoring Mechanism (“CMM”), requires the ENRE to review our actual distribution costs every six months (in May and November of each year) and adjust our distribution margins to reflect variations of 5% or more in our distribution cost base. We may also request that the ENRE apply the CMM at any time that the variation in our distribution cost base is at least 10% or more. Any adjustments, however, are subject to the ENRE’s assessment of variations in our costs, and we cannot guarantee that the ENRE will approve adjustments that are sufficient to cover our actual incremental costs. In the past, even when the ENRE has approved adjustments to our tariffs, there has been a lag between when we actually experience increases in our distribution costs and when we receive increased revenues following the corresponding adjustments to our distribution margins pursuant to the CMM.
Despite the adjustment we were granted under the CMM in October 2007 and July 2008, we cannot make assurances that we will receive similar adjustments in the future. As of the date of this annual report, we have requested four increases under the CMM beginning in May 2008 that are still being reviewed by the ENRE. Under the terms of the Adjustment Agreement, these five increases should have been approved in May 2008, November 2008, May 2009, November 2009 and May 2010. If we are not able to recover all of these incremental costs and all such future cost increases or there is a significant lag time between when we incur the incremental costs and when we receive increased revenues, we may experience a material decline in our results of operations, which could adversely affect our ability to repay the notes.
Our distribution tariffs may be subject to challenges by Argentine consumer and other groups
In recent years, our tariffs have been challenged by Argentine consumer associations, such as three actions brought against us between 2009 and 2022 by Argentine consumer associations. See “Item 8. Financial Information—Legal and Administrative Proceedings—Legal Proceedings”.
If those or any future legal challenge were successful and prevented us from implementing any tariff adjustments granted by the Argentine Government, we could face a decline in collections from our users, and a decline in our results of operations, which could have a material adverse effect in our financial condition and the market value of our ADSs and Class B common shares.
We have been, and may continue to be, subject to fines and penalties that could have a material adverse effect on our financial condition and results of operations
We operate in a highly regulated environment and have been, and in the future may continue to be, subject to significant fines and penalties imposed by regulatory authorities, including for reasons outside our control, such as service disruptions attributable to problems at generation facilities or in the transmission network that result in a lack of electricity supply. Since 2001, the amount of fines and penalties imposed on our Company has increased significantly. As of December 31, 2022, 2021 and 2020, our accrued fines and penalties totaled Ps.23,032 million (of which Ps.17,186 million are adjustments set forth under the Regularization Agreement), Ps.25,183 million and Ps.26,601 million, respectively (taking into account adjustments made to fines and penalties following the ratification of the Adjustment Agreement and recent regulation). See “Item 4. Information on the Company—Business Overview—Fines and Penalties.”
On October 19, 2016, pursuant to Note No. 123,091 the ENRE established the average rate values (Ps./KWh) to be applied as from December 2012, for calculating the penalties payable to the Argentine Government. In accordance with the terms of the Concession Agreement, such values should correspond to the average sale price of energy charged to users. Since the amounts set forth in the note were not consistent with the principle contained in our Concession Agreement, on November 1, 2016, the Company submitted a claim to the ENRE requesting that the amounts in Note No. 123,091 be modified to reflect the amounts contained in the Concession Agreement. As of the date of this annual report, we have received the response from the ENRE (Note No. 129,061), which clarified that the increases or adjustments are not applicable, and only the values paid by the users should be considered.
33 |
On February 1, 2017, the ENRE issued Resolution No. 63/17, through which it approved new parameters related to the quality standards, with the purpose of achieving an acceptable quality level by the end of the 2017-2021 period. In this regard, the ENRE established a penalty regime to be applied in the event of non-compliance with the requisite quality rates.
On March 29, 2017, through Note No. 125,248 the ENRE established a new methodology for the calculation of fines and penalties, determining that they must be valued according to the KWh values in effect as of the first day of the six-month period during which the event giving rise to the penalty occurred or the KWh values in effect as of the date of the occurrence of the event in the case of penalties arising from specific events.
On January 17, 2022, by Resolution No. 7, the ENRE initiated a summary proceeding and filed charges against the Company, since it allegedly failed to report the power outages that took place on January 11, 14 and 15, 2022. The Company has already filed an answer. To date, the ENRE has not issued a decision on the matter.
On March 5, 2021, through Resolution No. 58, the ENRE instructed us to issue invoices only with the amounts corresponding to the consumption for the period and, separately, report the debts that have originated or increased during the effectiveness of the ASPO and DISPO regimes, without contemplating interest. The balances owed will be paid to the concessionaires in accordance with the guidelines established by the ENRE. As of September 2021, we began to implement the aforementioned resolution. Likewise, we were instructed to refrain from pursuing the collection of accumulated consumption from the ASPO until February 28, 2021, without -said body- having established the guidelines for payment of such amounts by users to date. We have obtained a recognition of those credits under the 2022 Agreement which will be set-off during 2023 upon the fulfillment of our obligations thereunder.
We cannot assure you what may be the outcome of this procedure, nor that we will not incur significant fines in the future, which could have a material adverse effect on our financial condition, our results of operations and the market value of our ADSs and Class B common shares.
The increase in the illegal settlements within the greater Buenos Aires metropolitan area may affect the Company’s ability to distribute energy to its customers, as well as produce an increase in public safety risks.
Within the second and third regions of the greater Buenos Aires metropolitan area, the number of illegal settlements has increased over the years, and the existing ones have grown larger in terms of the number of people living in them as well as in terms of the size and complexity of the constructions built to foster its inhabitants. These fenomena is particularly present in the third ring of the Great Buenos Aires area, where energy theft represents the main cause of the company´s energy lost. Furthermore, such illegal conections to the electricity grid are performed in land over which Edenor has governmental permits to install high and medium voltage networks. The growth of such constructions on such land increases the risk of physical contact with such networks which may cause service interruption and even provoke accidents.
Edenor continuously reports to the community, the governmental authorities, and the ENRE about these situations and also files criminal proceedings in connection therewith. However, Edenor does not have the legal authority to remove such illegal constructions, and Edenor cannot assure that those contruction will continue to grow and affect the electric system in general.
34 |
If we are unable to control our energy losses, especially the theft of energy, our results of operations could be adversely affected
Our concession does not allow us to pass through to our users the cost of additional energy purchased to cover any energy losses that exceed the loss factor contemplated by our concession, which is, on average, 10%. As a result, if we experience energy losses in excess of those contemplated by our concession, we may record lower operating profits than we anticipate. Prior to the 2001 and 2002 economic crisis in Argentina, we were able to reduce the high level of energy losses experienced at the time of the privatization down to the levels contemplated (and reimbursed) under our concession. However, during the last years, our level of energy losses, particularly our non-technical losses, started to grow again, in part as a result of the increase in poverty levels and, in turn, in the number of delinquent accounts and fraud. In the regions in which new settlements of vulnerable neighbourhoods continue to be made, which are added to the growth of the already existing ones, mainly in the third region of the Greater Buenos Aires area, energy theft represents one of the main factors in the increase in total losses of the Company. Although we continue to make investments to reduce energy losses, these losses continue to exceed the average 10% loss factor contemplated by the concession and, based on the current tariff schedule and the economic turmoil, we do not expect these losses to decrease in the near term. Our energy losses amounted to 15.89% in 2022, 17.6% in 2021, and 19.6% in 2020. In 2022, we surpassed Ps.4,689 million (energy cost) and Ps.3,307 million (margin). We cannot assure you that our energy losses will not continue to increase in future periods, in particular due to the change of governmental policy on subsidies which may lead to lower margins and could affect our results of operations.
Under the Concession Agreement, the Argentine Government could foreclose on its pledge over our Class A common shares under certain circumstances, which could have a material adverse effect on our business and financial condition
Pursuant to our Concession Agreement and the provisions of the Adjustment Agreement, the Argentine Government has the right to foreclose on its pledge over our Class A common shares and sell these shares to a third-party buyer if:
· | the fines and penalties incurred in any given year exceed 20% of our gross energy sales, net of taxes, which corresponds to our energy sales; |
· | we repeatedly and materially breach the terms of our concession and do not remedy these breaches upon the request of the ENRE; |
· | our controlling shareholder creates any lien or encumbrance over our Class A common shares (other than the existing pledge in favor of the Argentine Government); |
· | we or our controlling shareholder obstructs the sale of Class A common shares at the end of any management period under our concession; |
· | our controlling shareholder fails to obtain the ENRE’s approval in connection with the disposition of our Class A common shares; or |
· | our shareholders amend our articles of incorporation or voting rights in a way that modifies the voting rights of the Class A common shares without the ENRE’s approval; |
35 |
On February 1, 2017, the ENRE issued Resolution No. 63/17 establishing the new tariff scheme resulting from the completion of an RTI process, for the following five-year period. In accordance with the provisions of the Adjustment Agreement, Electricidad Argentina S.A. (“EASA”) (currently merged into Pampa Energía S.A.) and EDF International S.A. (“EDFI”) withdrew their ICSID claim, and on March 28, 2017, the ICSID acknowledged the discontinuance of the procedure.
In 2022, our fines and penalties represented 1.59% of our net energy sales. See “Item 4. Information on the Company—Business overview—Edenor Concession—Fines and Penalties.”
If the Argentine Government were to foreclose on its pledge of our Class A common shares, pending the sale of those shares, the Argentine Government would also have the right to exercise the voting rights associated with such shares. In addition, the potential foreclosure by the Argentine Government on its pledge over our Class A common shares could be deemed to constitute a change of control under the terms of our Senior Notes due 2024 and 2025. If the Argentine Government forecloses on the pledge of our Class A common shares, our results of operations and financial condition could be significantly affected and the market value of our Class B common shares and ADSs could also be affected.
Default by the Argentine Government could lead to termination of our concession, and have a material adverse effect on our business and financial condition
If the Argentine Government breaches its obligations in such a way that we cannot comply with our obligations under our Concession Agreement or in such a way that our service is materially affected, we may request the termination of our concession, after giving the Argentine Government a 90 days’ prior notice, in writing. Upon termination of our concession, all our assets used to provide the electricity distribution service would be transferred to a new state-owned company to be created by the Argentine Government, whose shares would be sold in an international public bidding procedure. The amount obtained in such bidding would be paid to us, net of the payment of any debt owed by us to the Argentine Government, plus an additional compensation established as a percentage of the bidding price, ranging from 10% to 30%, depending on the management period in which the sale occurs. Any such default could have a material adverse effect on our business and financial condition.
The expiration of the management period could result in the sale of the Company’s controlling interest.
Our concession is currently set to expire on August 31, 2087, after a term of 95 years, and may be extended for one additional 10-year period if Edenor requests the extension at least 18 months before expiration. The term of the concession is divided into management periods. On February 25, 2021, through resolution 65, the ENRE established that the first management period will be considered fulfilled at the end of the term established for the renegotiation of an RTI, which will take place during 2023, according to Decree No. 1,020 dated December 16, 2020, as ammended.
Six months before the end of each management period, the regulatory authority shall call to Concurso Público Internacional on the Class “A” shares sale representing 51% of the share capital of Edenor, currently held by Empresa de Energía del Cono Sur S.A. (“Edelcos”). However, if Edelcos matches the highest bid or its bid represents the highest bid received, it will continue to hold the Class “A” shares, and no further disbursements will be necessary. On the contrary, if Edelcos’s offer is not the highest, the Class “A” shares shall be awarded to the bidder who made the highest bid and the proceeds from the sale shall be payable by Grantor Government to Edelcos, net of any payments owed to the Argentine Government. The before mentioned price shall be delivered within the term of 30 days once the Grantor Control received it. The first management period commenced on September 1, 1992, and was extended by the regulatory authority through Resolution 467/2007.
36 |
We may be unable to import certain equipment to meet growing demand for electricity, which could lead to a breach of our Concession Agreement and could have a material adverse effect on the operations and financial position
Certain exchange controls established by the Argentine Government and future restrictions on imports that may be adopted in the future could limit or delay our ability to purchase capital goods that are necessary for our operations (including carrying out specific projects). Under our concession, we are obligated to satisfy all of the demand for electricity originated in our concession area, maintaining at all times certain service quality standards that have been established for our concession. If we are not able to purchase significant capital goods to satisfy all of the demand or suffer unexpected delays in the import process, we could face fines and penalties which may, in turn, adversely affect our activity, financial position, results of operations and/or the market value of our ADSs and Class B common shares. For more information on exchange controls, see “Item 10. Additional Information—Exchange Controls”.
We employ a largely unionized labor force and could be subject to an organized labor action, including work stoppages that could have a material effect on our business
As of December 31, 2022, approximately 80% of our employees were union members. Although our relations with unions are currently stable and we have had an agreement in place with the two unions representing our employees since 1995, we cannot assure you that we will not experience work disruptions or stoppages in the future, which could have a material adverse effect on our business and revenues. We cannot assure you that we will be able to negotiate salary agreements or labor conditions on the same terms as those currently in effect, or that we will not be subject to strikes or work stoppages before or during the negotiation process. If we are unable to negotiate salary agreements or if we are subject to demonstrations or work stoppages, our results of operations, financial conditions and the market value of our ADSs, Class B common shares and our Senior Notes due 2024 and 2025 could be materially adversely affected.
We could incur material labor liabilities in connection with our outsourcing that could have an adverse effect on our business and results of operations
We outsource a number of activities related to our business to third-party contractors in order to maintain a flexible cost base. As of December 31, 2022, we had approximately 5,756 third-party employees related to third party´s contracts. Although we have very strict policies regarding compliance with labor and social security obligations by contractors, we are not in a position to ensure that contractors will not initiate legal actions to seek indemnification from us based upon a number of judicial rulings issued by labor courts in Argentina which have recognized joint and several liability between the contractor and the entity to which it is supplying services under certain circumstances.
Our performance is largely dependent on recruiting and retaining key personnel
Our current and future performance and the operation of our business are dependent upon the contributions of our senior management and our skilled team of engineers and other employees. We depend on our ability to attract, train, motivate and retain key management and specialized personnel with the necessary skills and experience. There is no guarantee that we will be successful in retaining and attracting key personnel and the replacement of any key personnel who were to leave could be difficult and time consuming. The loss of the experience and services of key personnel or the inability to recruit suitable replacements and additional staff could have a material adverse effect on our business, financial condition and results of operations.
37 |
We are subject to anti-corruption, anti-bribery, anti-money laundering and antitrust laws and regulations in Argentina. Any violation thereunder could have a material adversed effect on our reputation and the results of our operation
We are subject to national and international anti-corruption, anti-bribery, anti-money laundering and antitrust laws and regulations. Likewise, we are subject to certain restrictions and our relationship with certain non-cooperative countries. Edenor has internal processes and an Ethic and Compliance Code that are mandatory for all its personnel and suppliers. However, no assurance can be given that such policies and processes are sufficient to prevent or detect frauds, violation of the law or inappropriate behaviour from our employees, directors, officers, shareholders, agents and suppliers.
We are involved in various legal proceedings which could result in unfavorable decisions for us, which could in turn have a material adverse effect on our financial position and results of operations
We are party to a number of legal proceedings, some of which have been pending for several years. We cannot be certain that these claims will be resolved in our favor and responding to the demands of litigation may divert our management’s time and attention and our financial resources and unfavorable decisions may have a material adverse effect on our financial position and results of operations. See “Item 8. Financial Information—Legal and Administrative Proceedings—Legal Proceedings.”
In the event of an accident or other event not covered by our insurance, we could face significant losses that could materially adversely affect our business and results of operations
As of December 31, 2022, our physical assets were insured for up to U.S.$1,816 million. However, we do not carry insurance coverage for losses caused by our network or business interruption, including for loss of our concession. See “Item 4. Information on the Company—Business Overview—Insurance.” Although we believe our insurance coverage is commensurate with standards for the distribution industry, no assurance can be given of the existence or sufficiency of risk coverage for any particular risk or loss. If an accident or other event occurs that is not covered by our current insurance policies, we may experience material losses or have to disburse significant amounts from our own funds, which may have a material adverse effect on our financial condition and results of operations and the market value of our Class B common shares and ADSs.
We currently are not able to effectively hedge our currency risk in full and, as a result, a devaluation of the Peso may have a material adverse effect on our results of operations and financial condition
Our revenues are collected in Pesos pursuant to tariffs that are not indexed to the U.S. dollar, while a significant portion of our existing financial indebtedness is denominated in U.S. dollars, which exposes us to the risk of loss from devaluation of the Peso. We currently seek to hedge this risk in part by converting a portion of our excess cash denominated in Pesos into local U.S. dollar-denominated instruments such as local government bonds, but we continue to have substantial exposure to the U.S. dollar. The Argentine Government does not allow companies, including us, to access the the market to acquire U.S. dollars to hedge our financial position. If we continue to be unable to effectively hedge all or a significant portion of our currency risk exposure, a devaluation of the Peso may significantly increase our debt service burden, which, in turn, may have a material adverse effect on our financial condition and results of operations, as well as our ability to repay our debts.
38 |
A substantial number of our assets are not subject to attachment or foreclosure and the enforcement of judgments obtained against us by our shareholders may be substantially limited
A substantial number of our assets are essential to the public service we provide. Under Argentine law, as interpreted by the Argentine courts, assets which are essential to the provision of a public service are not subject to attachment or foreclosure, whether as a guarantee for an ongoing legal action or in aid of enforcement of a court judgment. Accordingly, the enforcement of judgments obtained against us by our shareholders may be substantially limited to the extent our shareholders seek to attach those assets to obtain payment on their judgment.
The loss of the exclusivity of electricity distribution in our service area may be adversely affected by technological or other changes in the energy distribution industry, which could have a material adverse effect on our business.
Although our concession grants us the exclusive right to distribute electric energy within our service area, this exclusivity may be revoked in whole or in part if technological developments make it possible for energy distribution to evolve from its current condition of natural monopoly to a competitive business. In no event does the total or partial revocation of our exclusive distribution rights entitle us to claim or obtain reimbursement or indemnification. Although, to our knowledge, there are no current projects to introduce new technologies in the medium or long term that could reasonably modify the composition of the electricity distribution business, we cannot assure you that future developments will not allow competition in our sector that would adversely affect the exclusivity right granted to us under our concession. Any total or partial loss of our exclusive right to distribute electricity within our service area would likely lead to increased competition and result in lower revenues, which could have a material adverse effect on our financial condition, our results of operations and the market value of our Class B shares and our ADSs.
A potential nationalization or expropriation of 51% of our capital stock, represented by Class A shares, may limit the ability of Class B shares to participate in the Board of Directors.
As of the date of this annual report, ANSES owned shares representing 26.8% of our capital stock and jointly appointed five Class B and five Class C directors at our last shareholders’ meeting. The remaining directors were appointed by Class A shares.
If the Argentine Government was to expropriate 51% of our capital stock, represented by our Class A shares, the Argentine Government would be the sole holder of the Class A shares and ANSES would hold the majority of the Class B shares. Certain strategic transactions require the approval of the holders of the Class A shares. Accordingly, the Argentine Government and ANSES could determine substantially all matters requiring the approval of a majority of our stockholders, including the election of a majority of our directors, and could direct our operations.
If the Argentine Government nationalizes or expropriates 51% of our capital stock, as represented by the Class A shares, our results and financial condition could be adversely affected and this could cause the market value of our ADSs and Class B shares to decline.
We may not be able to raise the funds necessary to repay our commercial debt with CAMMESA, our major supplier
Pending obligations with the WEM for electrical energy purchases through 2019 have been fully compensated. However, as a result of (i) the enactment of the Productive Reactivation Law (in the framework of the public emergency), (ii) the subsequent instruction to the Company to refrain from applying, as from January 1, 2020, the Electricity Rate Schedules Maintenance Agreement entered into between the Company and the Argentine Government on September 19, 2019 (the “Electricity Rate Schedules Maintenance Agreement”); and (iii) the lack of approval by ENRE of new tariff that are sufficient to cover our actual incremental cost, the Company partially postponed during 2022 payments to CAMMESA.
39 |
As of December 31, 2022, we accumulated a past due principal balance of Ps. 63,689 million plus interest and charges for Ps. 79,640 millions (excluding the effects of the debt compensated under the 2022 Agreement).
On December 29, 2022, we have reached into an agreement with the Argentine Government to cover our debt with CAMMESA as of August 2002 (the “2022 Agreement”). Under the 2022 Agreement, the Company recognised an accumulated debt as of August 31, 2022, of Ps. 57,159 million and the Argentine Government also recognised a credit in favor of the Company of Ps. 24,174 million, reduced the outstanding debt to Ps.32,985 million, which will be paid in 96 installments; a six-month grace period (ending in August 2023), and accrue interest at a rate equivalent to 50% of the interest rate applicable by the WEM (i.e. as of December 2022, 41.47% on an annual basis). Under the 2022 Agreement the Company acknowledged and accepted to pay 100% of its commercial debt with CAMMESA since March 2023.
We may not have the ability to collect the amounts corresponding to the discounts of the Social Rate, the ceilings of the Social Rate and the bonuses for neighbourhood clubs, that must be financed by the Province of Buenos Aires and the Autonomous City of Buenos Aires
If we are not able to recover the revenue corresponding to the discounts applied pursuant to the Social Rate regime, the ceilings of the Social Rate and the bonuses for neighborhood clubs, and/or if there is a significant lag of time between when we incur the incremental costs and when we receive the amounts related to these concepts, we may suffer liquidity shortfalls, any of which, individually or in the aggregate, could have a material adverse effect on our business and results of operations.
All of our outstanding financial indebtedness contains bankruptcy, reorganization proceedings and expropriation events of default, and we may be required to repay all of our outstanding debt upon occurrence of any such events
As of the date of this annual report, U.S.$98 million of our financial debt represented by our Senior Notes due 2022 were cancelled and U.S.$ 55.2 million Senior Notes due 2025 were issued in exchange therefor, which accrue interest at a fixed nominal annual interest rate of 9.75% (the “Senior 2025 Notes”). In addition, U.S.$ 60 million New Class No. 2 Corporate Notes due 2024 were issued in Argentina (of which U.S.$ 30 million were issued on March 7, 2023), which are denominated in United States Dollars, accruing interest at 9.75% annually (the “Senior 2024 Notes,” and together with the Senior 2025 Notes, the “Senior Notes”). Under our Senior Notes, certain expropriation and condemnation events with respect to us may constitute an event of default, which, if declared, could trigger the acceleration of our obligations under the notes and require us to immediately repay all such accelerated debt. In addition, all of our outstanding financial indebtedness contains certain events of default related to bankruptcy and voluntary reorganization proceeding. If we are not able to comply with certain payment obligations as a result of our current financial situation and if the requirements set forth in the Argentine Bankruptcy Law No. 24,522 are met, any creditor, or even us, could file for our bankruptcy, or we could file for a voluntary reorganization proceeding. In addition, all of our outstanding financial indebtedness also contains cross-default provisions or cross-acceleration provisions that could cause all of our debt to be accelerated if the debt containing expropriation or bankruptcy and/or reorganization proceeding events of default goes into default or is accelerated. In such a case, we would expect to actively pursue formal waivers from the corresponding financial creditors to avoid such potential situation, but in case those waivers are not timely obtained and immediate repayment is required, we could face short-term liquidity problems, which could adversely affect our results of operations and cause the market value of our ADSs and Class B common shares to decline.
40 |
We may not have the ability to raise the funds necessary to finance a change of control offering as required by our Senior 2025 Notes and Senior 2024 Notes.
Under the terms of our Senior Notes, in the event of a change of control, we must offer to repurchase any and all outstanding Notes at a purchase price equal to 100% of the aggregate principal amount of such Notes, plus accrued and unpaid interest thereon and additional amounts, if any, through the date of purchase. We may not have sufficient funds to make the required repurchases of our Senior Notes in the event of a change of control. If we fail to make the change of control offer, that could constitute an event of default under the terms and conditions of issuance, which in turn could trigger cross-default provisions under the terms of issuance of other debt instruments from time to time outstanding, whereby the results of operations could be adversely affected and the market value of our ADSs and Class B common stock could decline.
The New York Stock Exchange and/or ByMA may suspend trading and/or delist our ADSs and Class B common shares, upon the occurrence of certain events relating to our financial situation
The New York Stock Exchange (“NYSE”) and/or the Argentine stock exchange and markets (Bolsas y Mercados Argentinos S.A. or “BYMA”) may suspend and/or cancel the listing of our ADSs and Class B common shares, respectively, in certain circumstances, including upon the occurrence of certain events relating to our financial situation. For example, the NYSE may decide such suspension or cancellation if our shareholders’ equity becomes negative.
The NYSE may in its sole discretion determine on an individual basis the suitability for continued listing of an issue in the light of all pertinent facts. Some of the factors mentioned in the NYSE Listed Company Manual, which may subject a company to suspension and delisting procedures, include: “unsatisfactory financial conditions and/or operating results”, “inability to meet current debt obligations or to adequately finance operations,” and “any other event or condition which may exist or occur that makes further dealings or listing of the securities on the NYSE inadvisable or unwarranted in the opinion of NYSE.”
The BYMA may cancel the listing of our Class B common shares if it determines that our shareholders’ equity and our financial and economic situation do not justify our access to the stock market or if the NYSE cancels the listing of our ADSs.
We cannot assure you that the NYSE and/or the BYMA will not commence any suspension or delisting procedures in light of our financial situation, including if our shareholders’ equity becomes negative. A delisting or suspension of trading of our ADSs or Class B common shares by the NYSE and/or the BYMA, respectively, could adversely affect our results of operations and financial conditions and cause the market value of our ADSs and Class B common shares to decline.
Changes in weather conditions or the occurrence of severe weather (whether or not caused by climate change or natural disasters), could adversely affect our operations and financial performance
41 |
Weather conditions have influenced and in the future may influence the demand for electricity, our ability to provide it and the costs of providing it. In particular, severe weather may adversely affect our results of operations by causing significant demand increases, which we may be unable to meet without a significant increase in operating costs. This could strongly impact the continuity of our services and our quality indicators. For example, the exceptional heat wave that occurred in January 2022 and March 2023 affected the continuity of our services, both in the low voltage and medium voltage networks. See “Item 4. Information on the Company—Business Overview—Quality Standards—Edenor Concession”. Furthermore, any such disruptions in the provision of our services could expose us to fines and orders to compensate those users affected by any such power cuts, as has occurred in the past (see “Item 4. Information on the Company—Business Overview—Quality Standards—Fines and Penalties”). Our financial condition, results of operations and cash flows could therefore be negatively affected by increased operating costs, litigation or decreases in revenue relating to changes in weather conditions and severe weather.
Cybersecurity events, such as interruptions or failures in our information technology systems as well as cyber-attacks, could adversely affect our business, financial condition, results of operations and cash flows
We depend on the efficient and uninterrupted operation of internet-based data processing communication and information exchange platforms and networks, including administrative and business-related systems (such as Supervisory Control and Data Acquisition (“SCADA”) and DCS Software, Inc. (“DCS”). Cybersecurity risks have generally increased in recent years as a result of the proliferation of new technologies and the increased sophistication and activities of cyber-attacks. Through part of our grid and other initiatives, we have increasingly connected equipment and systems to the internet. Due to the critical nature of our infrastructure and the increased accessibility enabled through connection to the internet, we may face a heightened risk of cybersecurity incidents such as computer break-ins, phishing, identity theft and other disruptions that could negatively affect the security of information stored in and transmitted through our computer systems and network infrastructure. In the event of a failure of any of our information technology systems or a cyber-attack, we could have our business operations disrupted, property damaged and user information stolen; experience substantial loss of revenues, response costs and other financial loss; and be subject to increased regulation, litigation and damage to our reputation. It should be mentioned that contingency plans in place may not be sufficient to cover liabilities associated with any such events and therefore, applicable insurance coverage may be deemed inadequate, preventing us from receiving full compensation for the losses sustained as a result of such a disruption. Although we intend to continue to implement security technology devices and establish operational procedures (such as, our Disaster Recovery Plan, which aims to respond and recover business’ core applications in the event of serious incidents) to prevent disruption resulting from, and counteract the negative effects of cybersecurity incidents within the next three years, it is possible that not all of our current and future systems are or will be entirely free from vulnerability and these security measures will not be successful. Accordingly, cybersecurity is a material risk for us and a cyber-attack could adversely affect our business, results of operations and financial condition. For more information see “Item 4. Information on the Company—Business Overview—Information Technology and Telecommunications—Cybersecurity”.
The Company’s operations and business could be affected by the adoption of restrictions on the import of products or the technical conditions applicable thereto.
In February 2011, the then Ministry of Industry issued Resolution No. 45/11 by means of which, among other issues, it resolved to extend the application of the non-automatic licensing system with respect to the import of products that the Ministry of Industry considers to be luxury or that compete unfairly with local production on the understanding that such national production was capable of satisfying domestic demand. On January 25, 2013 and by means of Decree No. 11/13, the Ministry of Economy repealed Resolution No. 45/11 putting an end to the mechanism that required importers to process an authorization certificate to enter certain products into the country. On January 8, 2020, the Secretariat of Industry, Knowledge Economy and External Trade Management of the Ministry of Productive Development issued Resolution (SIECGCE) No. 1/20, which (i) incorporated new tariff items that shall process non-automatic licenses (“LNA”), (ii) modified the forms for the import license application, (iii) decreased the tolerance in the FOB unit value of goods subject to the processing of LNA, (iv) decreased the term of validity of the LNA from 180 to 90 days as from its approval in the SIMI, (v) extended the scope of imports of goods to the territory of the Isla Grande de la Tierra del Fuego (except for products coming from the continental territory), and (vi) established the Undersecretariat of Trade Policy and Management of the Secretariat of Industry, Knowledge Economy and External Trade Management as the enforcement authority.
42 |
In addition, through Resolution of the Secretariat of Domestic Trade No. 247/2019 as amended and 380/2022, it has been established that before December 31, 2022, electric meters must comply with certain characteristics that none of the suppliers based in Argentina had, which lead to increased imports and, therefore, subject to the restrictions on import that exist.
Through Joint General Resolution No. 5,271/2022 of the AFIP and the Secretary of Commerce, General Joint Resolution No. 4,185 and its amendments were repealed, creating the “Argentine Republic Import System” (“SIRA”) and replacing the previous one “Comprehensive Import Monitoring System” (“SIMI”), intended to obtain the necessary information to generate predictability and traceability in import operations in advance, which will work in accordance with the guidelines established herein.The SIRA is applicable to importers registered in the Special Customs Registries provided for by General Resolution No. 2,570, its amendments and supplements, in relation to the final destinations of importation for consumption.The importer must inform the term in calendar days between the official dispatch and the estimated date of access to the Free Exchange Market (MLC) for making import payments. The Ministry of Commerce and the BCRA will evaluate the information provided by the importer and inform the term between the official clearance and the date on which access to said market will be allowed.
In addition, the system of consultation and registration of exchange operations called "Current Account of Foreign Trade" was created, in which the entities authorized to operate in the MLC by the BCRA must consult and register the amount in Pesos of the total of each one of the exchange operations indicated below, at the time it is carried out.
The Foreign Trade Single Current Account covers foreign currency sales operations -currency or banknotes- to cancel operations that have been previously registered through a SIRA/SIMI and are in the “OUTPUT” state, SIRASE in the “APPROVED” state, shipments of officialized import and entry destinations to the Free Zone (ZFI).
As of the date of this annual report, we cannot guarantee that in the future, measures similar to those adopted through the date of this annual report will not be adopted that may have an impact on the goods used by the Company as inputs, causing the Company an adverse effect on its economic, financial or other situation, its results of operations, business or its ability to comply with its obligations in general.
Risks relating to our ADSs and Class B common shares
Restrictions on the movement of capital out of Argentina may impair the ability of holders of ADSs to receive dividends and distributions on, and the proceeds of any sale of, the Class B common shares underlying the ADSs, which could affect the market value of the ADSs
The Argentine Government has re-established restrictions on the conversion of Argentine currency into foreign currencies and on the remittance to foreign investors of proceeds from their investments in Argentina. Conversion of dividends, distributions, or the proceeds from any sale of shares from Pesos into U.S. dollars, as well as the transfer of those funds abroad is strongly limited. See “Item 10. Additional Information—Exchange Controls”. Future restrictions on foreign exchange market access, other than those already imposed, may affect even more the conversion of dividends, distributions, or the proceeds from any sale of shares, as the case may be, from Pesos into U.S. dollars and the remittance of such U.S. dollars abroad. Also, certain of our indebtedness includes covenants limiting the payment of dividends. We cannot assure you that the Argentine Government will not take new measures or deepen those already established in the future. The depositary for the ADSs may hold the Pesos it cannot otherwise convert for the account of the ADS holders who have not been paid. Any future adoption by the Argentine Government of constraints on the movement of capital out of Argentina may deepen the restrictions on the ability of our foreign shareholders and holders of ADSs to obtain the full value of their shares and ADSs, and may adversely affect the market value of our Class B common shares and ADSs.
43 |
Our shareholders’ ability to receive cash dividends may be limited
According to current regulations, transfer of funds abroad in order to pay dividends does not require Central Bank approval, to the extent such dividend payments are made in compliance with the requirements set forth under Central Bank (see “Item 10—Additional Information—Exchange Controls”). Our shareholders’ ability to receive cash dividends may be limited by the ability of the depositary to convert cash dividends paid in Pesos into U.S. dollars. Under the terms of our deposit agreement with the depositary for the ADSs, the depositary will convert any cash dividend or other cash distribution we pay on the common shares underlying the ADSs into U.S. dollars, if it can do so on a reasonable basis and can transfer the U.S. dollars to the United States. If this conversion is not possible or if any government approval is needed and cannot be obtained, the deposit agreement allows the depositary to distribute the foreign currency only to those ADS holders to whom it is possible to do so. If the exchange rate fluctuates significantly during a time when the depositary cannot convert the foreign currency, shareholders may lose some or all of the value of the dividend distribution. Additionally, any payment of dividends may need to be approved by ENRE. We cannot assure you that your ability to receive dividends, as an ADSs holder, will not be affected due to current or future regulations, and that the Argentine Government will not adopt new measures or deepen those already implemented, which could result in more restrictions on the access to the foreign exchange market.
Holders of ADSs may be unable to exercise voting rights with respect to the Class B common shares underlying the ADSs at our shareholders’ meetings
Shares underlying the ADSs are held by the depositary in the name of the holder of the ADS. As such, we will not treat holders of ADSs as one of our shareholders and, therefore, holders of ADSs will not have shareholder rights. The depositary will be the holder of the Class B common shares underlying the ADSs and holders may exercise voting rights with respect to the Class B common shares represented by the ADSs only in accordance with the deposit agreement relating to the ADSs. There are no provisions under Argentine law or under our by-laws that limit the exercise by ADS holders of their voting rights through the depositary with respect to the underlying Class B common shares. However, there are practical limitations on the ability of ADS holders to exercise their voting rights due to the additional procedural steps involved in communicating with these holders. For example, holders of our Class B common shares will receive notice of shareholders’ meetings through publication of a notice in an official gazette in Argentina, an Argentine newspaper of general circulation and the daily bulletin of the Buenos Aires Stock Exchange (“BASE”), and will be able to exercise their voting rights by either attending the meeting in person or voting by proxy. ADS holders, by comparison, do not receive notice directly from us. Instead, in accordance with the deposit agreement, we provide the notice to the depositary. If we ask it to do so, the depositary will mail to holders of ADSs the notice of the meeting and a statement as to the manner in which instructions may be given by holders. To exercise their voting rights, ADS holders must then instruct the depositary as to voting the Class B common shares represented by their ADSs. Due to these procedural steps involving the depositary, the process for exercising voting rights may take longer for ADS holders than for holders of Class B common shares and Class B common shares represented by ADSs may not be voted as the holders of ADSs desire. Class B common shares represented by ADSs for which the depositary fails to receive timely voting instructions may, if requested by us, be voted at the corresponding meeting either in favor of the proposal of the Board of Directors or, in the absence of such a proposal, in accordance with the majority.
44 |
Our shareholders may be subject to liability for certain votes of their securities
Because we are a limited liability corporation, our shareholders are not liable for our obligations. Shareholders are generally liable only for the payment of the shares they subscribe. However, shareholders who have a conflict of interest with us and who do not abstain from voting at the respective shareholders’ meeting may be liable for damages to us, but only if the transaction would not have been approved without such shareholders’ votes. Furthermore, shareholders who wilfully or negligently vote in favor of a resolution that is subsequently declared void by a court as contrary to the law or our by-laws may be held jointly and severally liable for damages to us or to other third parties, including other shareholders.
If we fail to maintain an effective system of internal controls, we may be unable to accurately report our financial results or prevent fraud and investor confidence and the market price of our shares and ADSs may be adversely impacted.
Effective internal controls over financial reporting are necessary for us to provide reliable financial reports and, together with adequate disclosure controls and procedures, are designed to provide reasonable assurance of achieving the control objectives. Any failure to implement required new or improved controls, or difficulties encountered in their implementation could cause us to fail to meet our reporting obligations. In addition, any testing by us conducted in connection with Section 404 (a) of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 (the “Sarbanes-Oxley Act”), or any eventual testing that may be required by our independent registered public accounting firm pursuant to Section 404 (b) of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act, if and when required if our status as a non-accelerated filer changes, may reveal additional deficiencies in our internal controls over financial reporting that are deemed to be material weaknesses or that may require prospective or retroactive changes to our consolidated financial statements or identify other areas for further attention or improvement. If in the future we identify new material weaknesses in our internal control over financial reporting, if we are unable to comply with the requirements of Section 404 in a timely manner or assert that our internal control over financial reporting is effective, or, if and when applicable, our independent registered public accounting firm is unable to express an opinion as to the effectiveness of our internal control over financial reporting, investors may lose confidence in the accuracy and completeness of our financial reports and the market price of our ordinary shares could be negatively affected, and we could become subject to investigations by the stock exchange on which our securities are then listed, the SEC, or other regulatory authorities, which could require additional financial and management resources. Ineffective internal controls could also cause investors to lose confidence in our reported financial information, which could have a negative effect on the market price of our shares and ADSs.
Provisions of Argentine securities laws could deter takeover attempts and have an adverse impact on the price of our shares and ADSs
Argentine securities Law No. 26,831 contains provisions that may discourage, delay or make more difficult a change in control of our Company, such as the requirement, upon the acquisition of a controlling interest in of our capital stock, to launch a mandatory tender offer to acquire all our voting stock and any securities convertible into, or entitling the holder thereof to subscribe for or acquire, any voting shares in our capital stock. These provisions may affect the market value of our shares and ADSs.
45 |
Item 4. | Information on the Company |
History and Development of the Company
Empresa Distribuidora y Comercializadora Norte S.A. (EDENOR S.A.) (Distribution and Marketing Company of the North S.A.), or Edenor, is a public service company incorporated as a sociedad anónima (stock corporation) under the laws of Argentina. Our principal executive offices are located at Avenida del Libertador 6363, 11° floor, City of Buenos Aires, C1428ARG, Argentina, and our general telephone number at this location is +54 11 4346 5000.
We were incorporated on July 21, 1992, under the name Empresa Distribuidora Norte Sociedad Anónima, as part of the privatization of the Argentine state-owned electricity utility, Servicios Eléctricos del Gran Buenos Aires S.A. (SEGBA). The Company’s term of duration is 95 years. In anticipation of its privatization, SEGBA was divided into three electricity distribution companies, including our company, and four electricity generation companies, and on May 14, 1992, the Argentine Ministry of Economy and Public Works and Utilities approved the public sale of all of our company’s Class A common shares, representing 51% of the capital stock of our company. As of June 24, 2021, Edelcos became the controlling shareholder of Edenor, through the acquisition of 100% of Edenor´s Class A shares.
Please see below our share equity composition as of December 31, 2022:
Shareholders | Class A | Class B | Class C | % of capital stock | % of the Class | |||||
Edelcos | 462,292,111 | - | - | 51.00% | 100.00% | |||||
Treasury shares | - | 30,994,291 | - | 3.43% | 7.01% | |||||
FGS ANSES | - | 242,999,553 | - | 26.81% | 54.95% | |||||
Floating | - | 168,216,541 | - | 18.56% | 38.04% | |||||
PPP | - | - | 1,952,604 | 0.21% | 100.00% | |||||
Total per class | 462,292,111 | 442,210,385 | 1,952,604 | 100.00% | 100.00% | |||||
Total capital stock | 906,455,100 |
Business Overview
We believe we are the largest electricity distribution company in Argentina and one of the largest in Latin America in terms of number of users and electricity sold (both in GWh and in Pesos) in 2022. We hold a concession to distribute electricity on an exclusive basis to the northwestern part of the greater Buenos Aires metropolitan area and in the northern part of the City of Buenos Aires, comprising an area of 4,637 square kilometers and a population of approximately 9 million people. As of December 31, 2022, Edenor increased its sales by 5.1% (*1,116 GWH), serving 3.3 million users.
46 |
The following table shows the percentage of the electricity produced and sold by generating companies that was purchased by us in the periods indicated:
Year | Electricity demand in Gwh(1) | Edenor demand in Gwh(2) | Edenor’s demand as % of total demand | |||
2012 | 131,944 | 23,933 | 18.1% | |||
2013 | 125,162 | 24,902 | 19.9% | |||
2014 | 126,421 | 24,860 | 19.7% | |||
2015 | 131,998 | 26,322 | 19.9% | |||
2016 | 133,111 | 26,838 | 20.2% | |||
2017 | 132,426 | 25,950 | 19.6% | |||
2018 | 132,925 | 25,906 | 19.5% | |||
2019 | 128,880 | 24,960 | 19.4% | |||
2020 | 127,306 | 25,124 | 19.7% | |||
2021 | 133,872 | 26,373 | 19.7% | |||
2022 | 138,755 | 27,158 | 19.6% |
Source: CAMMESA
(1) | Demand in the Mercado Eléctrico Mayorista Sistema Patagónico (Patagonia wholesale electricity market, or MEMSP). |
(2) | Calculated as electricity purchased by us and our wheeling system users. |
Edenor Concession
Edenor’s concession is currently set to expire on August 31, 2087, after a term of 95 years, and may be extended for one additional 10-year period if Edenor requests such extension at least 18 months before expiration. The term of the concession is divided into management periods: a first period of 15 years and subsequent periods of 10 years each. The first period will be deemed to start upon the occurrence of a new RTI, which has been postponed and is expected to take place by December 31, 2023. Six months before the end of each management period, the regulatory authority shall launch an international public bidding procedure in respect of the Class “A” shares representing 51% of the share capital of Edenor, currently held by Edelcos. If Edelcos matches the highest bidor its bid represents the highest bid received, it will continue to hold the Class “A” shares, and no further disbursements will be necessary. On the contrary, if Edelcos’s offer is not the highest, the Class “A” shares shall be awarded to the bidder who made the highest bid and the proceeds from the sale shall be payable by Grantor Government to Edelcos, net of any payments owed to the Argentine Government. The beforementioned price shall be delivered within the term of 30 days once the Grantor Control received it. The first management period commenced on September 1, 1992, and was extended by the regulatory authority through Resolution 467/2007.
No specific fee must be paid by the Company under the Concession Agreement during the term of the concession.
The Company is subject to the terms of its Concession Agreement and the provisions of the regulatory framework comprised by Laws No. 14,772, 15,336 and 24,065, resolutions and regulatory and supplementary standards issued by certain authorities. Thus, the Company is responsible for the distribution and sale of electricity as a public service with a satisfactory quality level pursuant to the requirements set forth in the aforementioned Concession Agreement and regulatory framework.
47 |
Geographic Exclusivity
Our concession gives us the exclusive right to distribute electricity within our concession area during the term of our concession. Under our concession, neither the national nor the provincial or local Governments may grant further concessions to operate electricity distribution services within our concession area. In that respect, we are obligated to satisfy all of the demand for electricity originated in our concession area, maintaining at all times a service quality standard that has been established in our Concession Agreement. This geographic exclusivity may be terminated in whole or in part by the Argentine Government if technological changes make it possible for the energy distribution industry to evolve from its present condition as a natural monopoly into a competitive business. However, the Argentine or the Provincial Government may only exercise their right to alter or terminate our geographical exclusivity at the end of each management period under our concession, by prior written notice at least six months before the expiration of the corresponding management period.
The electricity distribution and sale service is provided exclusively to all the users connected to the network within the area comprised of the following:
Region I City of Buenos Aires: the area encompassing Dock “D”, “unnamed street”, path of the Autopista Costera (coastline highway), extension of Pueyrredón Ave., Córdoba Ave., Ferrocarril San Martín railway tracks, General San Martín Ave., Zamudio, Tinogasta, General Paz Ave. and Río de La Plata river, and Province of Buenos Aires: the districts of San Martín, Tres de Febrero, San Isidro and Vicente López.
Region II Province of Buenos Aires: the districts of Morón, Ituzaingó, Hurlingham, Merlo, Marcos Paz, Las Heras and La Matanza.
Region III Province of Buenos Aires: the districts of San Fernando, Tigre, Escobar, Malvinas Argentinas, San Miguel, José C. Paz, Pilar, Moreno and General Rodríguez.
Our Obligations
We are obligated to supply electricity upon demand by the owner or occupant of any property in our concession area. We are entitled to charge for the electricity supplied rates that are established by tariffs set with the prior approval of the ENRE under applicable regulations. Pursuant to our concession, we must also meet specified service quality standards relating to:
· | the time required to connect new users; |
· | voltage fluctuations; |
· | interruptions or reductions in service; and |
· | the supply of electricity for public lighting and to certain municipalities. |
Our concession requires us to make the necessary investments to establish and maintain the applicable service quality standards and to comply with the stringent minimum public safety standards as specified for our concession. We are also required to furnish the ENRE all information requested by it and must obtain the ENRE’s prior consent for the disposition of assets that are assigned to the provision of our electricity distribution services. The ENRE also requires us to compile and submit various types of reports regarding the quality of our service and other technical and commercial data, which we must periodically report to the ENRE.
We are obligated to allow certain third parties (namely, other agents and large users) to access any available transportation capacity within our distribution system upon payment of a wheeling fee. Consequently, we must render the distribution service on an uninterrupted basis to satisfy any reasonable demand. We are prohibited from engaging in practices that limit competition or result in monopolistic abuses.
48 |
Under our concession, we may also be required to continue rendering services after the termination of the Concession Agreement’s term upon the request of the Argentine Government, but for a period not to exceed 12 months.
In accordance with our concession, our controlling shareholder, Edelcos, has pledged its 51% stake in the Company to the Argentine Government to secure obligations under our concession. The Adjustment Agreement required that the pledge be extended to secure our obligations under such agreement. The Argentine Government may foreclose on its pledge over the Class A shares and sell them in an international public bidding procedure if certain situations occur. See “Item 4. Information on the Company—Business Overview—Foreclosure on the Pledge of Our Class A common shares or Revocation of Our Concession”.
Quality Standards
Service quality
Pursuant to our concession, we are required to meet certain levels of technical quality of the product delivered (voltage level and waveform) and the service provided (frequency and duration of interruptions). With the adoption of the new Sub-Annex IV which has been in force since March 2017 and the start of the RTI’s five-year period (2017-2022) (the “RTI Five-Year Period”), the admissible disruptions gaps in the voltage level may not exceed the following percentages:
High voltage | -5.0% to +5.0% |
Overhead network (medium or low voltage) | -8.0% to +8.0% |
Buried network (medium or low voltage) | -8.0% to +8.0% |
Rural | -8.0% to +8.0% |
The concession granted to Edenor stipulates that fines will be applied when registered stress sets exceed the preceding limits for more than 3% of the total measurement time (5% for the case of measurements of perturbations to the waveform). The penalty rate for each KWh delivered in poor conditions depends on the magnitude of the setback with respect to the rated voltage and follows a quality path that increases that rate over the RTI Five-Year Period. For the particular case of voltage set-offs in selected points, regulation provides for an increase in the bonuses to be credited to the customer in case the set-off outside the tension limits persists over time. Fines are credited to the invoice of the affected user.
The technical service quality levels set out in Edenor’s concession refer to the frequency and duration of interruptions. It will be sufficient for one of the limits to be exceeded for the penalized time of said interruption and the rest computable interruptions to be included in the calculation of the bonuses. During the RTI Five-Year Period, the quality requirement is also increased by the percentage of the cost of unsupplied energy corresponding to the customer’s tariff based on the semester of the five-year period and the penalized duration of the interruption. In the event of an extraordinary impact on the provision of the service (i.e., 70,000 or more affected customers for five or more days in a row), a special compensation is provided to the T1R customers affected during those periods for more than the time limit applicable to the corresponding semester of the five-year period.
The last six-month period of the 2017-2022 five-year period, ended in February 2022. Consequently, through ENRE Resolution No. 65 dated February 25, 2022, semesters 11 and 12 were added, which are known as transition periods, comprised of semesters 52 (March - August 2022) and 53 (September 2022 - February 2023) and through Resolution No. 252/2023 dated March 3, 2023, semesters 13 and 14 were added to the transition periods, comprised of semesters 54 (March - August 2023) and 55 (September 2023 - February 2024).
49 |
In addition to incorporating district and commune-based service quality controls, a quality improvement path with increasing requirements was implemented, regarding not only interruption frequency limits and admissible interruption duration but also the cost of non-delivered energy. Additionally, an automatic penalty mechanism was implemented so that the discounts applied on account of deviations from the established limits may be credited to customers within a term of 60 days as from the end of the controlled six-month period. As for the values of the definitive penalties, the decision of the ENRE concerning the information submitted for each six-month period is required.
Additionally, through Resolution No. 198/2018, the ENRE established additional penalties of 300 or 600 KWh per user depending on the Feeder Six-Month Track Factor (Factor de Sendero Semestral del Alimentador, or “FSSA”) and the Consumer Six-Month Track Factor (Factor de Sendero Semestral de Usuario, or “FSSU”) as from the fourth six-month period of the RTI Five-Year Period, which commenced in September 2018. The penalties that may eventually be applied must be calculated and reported to the ENRE within 120 calendar days from the end of the six-month control period and deposited in an escrow account.
The following table indicates the stipulated levels for the frequency and duration of interruptions per customer during the first semester of the RTI Five-Year Period:
Category of user |
Frequency of |
Duration of interruption | |
High voltage | 6 | 4 hours | |
Medium voltage | 8 | 6 hours | |
Low voltage: (small and medium demand) | 12 | 20 hours | |
Large demand | 12 | 12 hours |
_______________________
(1) | Interruptions of less than three minutes are not recorded. |
The values for the final semester of the RTI Five-Year Period, which are in force for the year 2022, are as follows:
User category |
Frequency of interruptions (maximum number of interruptions per semester) | Interrupt duration (maximum amount of Time per interruption)(1) |
High Voltage | 3 | 2 hours |
Medium Voltage | 4 | 3 hours |
Low Voltage: (Small and Medium Demands) | 6 | 10 hours |
Big Demands | 6 | 6 hours |
(1) Interruptions of less than or equal to three minutes are not recorded
The 2022/2023 transition period began in March 2022. With regard to interruption frequency and duration limits per district and commune, the limits of the last six-month period according to Sub-Appendix IV to the Concession Agreement established by the RTI were maintained for the first six-month period of the aforementioned transition period. For the second six-month period of the transition period, the ENRE set new values with a decrease less pronounced than that established for the last six-month periods of the RTI’s five-year period.
50 |
The following table sets forth the average of frequency and duration (SAIDI and SAIFI) of interruptions to our service in the periods indicated, registering historic demand in 2022:
Year ended December 31, | ||||||||
Per customers | 2022 | 2021 | 2020 | 2019 | ||||
Average frequency of interruptions (times) | 3.60 | 4.12 | 4.64 | 6.15 | ||||
Average duration of interruption (hours) | 8.61 | 10.67 | 12.23 | 15.94 |
The trend towards improvement of the interruption frequency indicator as compared to the previous year continued, which was reflected in a similar proportion in the total interruption duration indicator, with a slight improvement in average interruption duration. Investment actions in distribution networks, and their ripening over time, often lead in the first place to a decrease in the frequency indicator.
Product quality
With regard to product quality, the regulations that established a quality path for the RTI Five-Year Period (2017-2022), setting voltage deviation limits for MV and LV supplies at a unified value of 8%, 5% exclusively for HV, and the cost of energy delivered in poor condition at incremental values throughout the path for both voltage levels and disturbances.
The regulations applicable to the last six-month period of the RTI’s five-year period (2017-2021) were maintained for the 2022/2023 transition period, with voltage deviation limits for MV and LV supplies having been set at a unified value of 8%, 5% exclusively for HV, and the cost of energy delivered in poor condition for both voltage levels and disturbances.
Others
In addition, to meet required quality levels, we must comply with certain operational requirements related to the quality of our commercial services, safety in public streets, data gathering and processing (including through reports that must be submitted to the ENRE for supervision and control) and other contractual requirements related to our environmental management plan and the claims filed with the ENRE by users which have been resolved after the established period.
Fines and Penalties
Under the terms of our concession, the ENRE may impose fines and penalties if we fail to comply with our obligations.
Fines relating to our failure to meet any of the quality and delivery standards described above are payable by granting credits or bonuses to our users to offset a portion of their electricity charges. Since 1996, we have operated a central information system that allows us to directly credit users who are affected by these quality or delivery deficiencies in the amount of the applicable fines.
51 |
Fines and penalties that are not directly related to services rendered to our users are owed to the ENRE, including fines imposed on us by the ENRE for any network installations found to create a safety or security hazard in a public space, such as streets and sidewalks. In addition, the ENRE may fine us for furnishing it inconsistent required technical information. Fines paid to the ENRE are deposited in the Third-Party Reserve Fund of the ENRE (Reserva de Fondos de Terceros del ENRE) in an account held with Banco Nación. Payments accumulate in the account until the amount deposited reaches Ps.5.6 million at which point, with the ENRE’s authorization, the amount is proportionally distributed among our users.
The following table shows the adjustments to Edenor’s standalone accruals for ENRE fines and penalties, including current fines and penalties and adjustments to past fines due to increases in our tariffs pursuant to the Adjustment Agreement, for the periods specified:
Year ended December 31, | ||||||||||||
(in millions of Pesos) | ||||||||||||
2022 | 2021 | 2020 | ||||||||||
Accruals at beginning of year | 25,183 | 26,601 | 29,281 | |||||||||
ENRE Fines and Penalties | 15,905 | 10,842 | 7,729 | |||||||||
Quality of Technical Service | 1,268 | 1,747 | 68 | |||||||||
Quality of Technical Product | 133 | 84 | 39 | |||||||||
Quality of Commercial Service | 1,877 | 1,270 | 964 | |||||||||
Public Safety | 793 | 777 | 688 | |||||||||
Reporting Violations | 741 | 466 | 524 | |||||||||
Others | 138 | 43 | 27 | |||||||||
Agreement on the Regularization of obligations | 10,955 | 6,455 | 5,419 | |||||||||
Payments of the year | (2,657 | ) | (1,689 | ) | (2,564 | ) | ||||||
Quality of Technical Service | (597 | ) | (900 | ) | (867 | ) | ||||||
Quality of Technical Product | (128 | ) | (39 | ) | (45 | ) | ||||||
Quality of Commercial Service | (674 | ) | (154 | ) | (826 | ) | ||||||
Public Safety | (404 | ) | (536 | ) | (826 | ) | ||||||
Others | (240 | ) | (60 | ) | — | |||||||
Agreement on the Regularization of obligations | (614 | ) | — | — | ||||||||
Result from exposure to inflation for the year | (15,399 | ) | (10,571 | ) | (7,845 | ) | ||||||
Accruals at year-end | 23,032 | 25,183 | 26,601 |
Note: The facts or events that generated the amounts charged in each period may have occurred in prior periods and not necessarily in the period in which the charge is made.
Fines and penalties imposed on us by the ENRE amounted to Ps.15,905 million and Ps.10,842 million as of December 31, 2022 and 2021, respectively.
As of December 31, 2022, total accrued fines and penalties imposed on us amounted to Ps.23,032 million, of which Ps.22,079 million (including accrued interest) corresponded to penalties accrued but not yet imposed on us and Ps.953 million (including accrued interest) correspond to penalties imposed on us but not yet paid.
52 |
Additionally, pursuant to Note No. 125,248 dated March 29, 2017, the ENRE set the applicable penalty determination and adjustment mechanisms in relation to the control procedures, the service quality assessment methodologies, and the penalty system applicable as from February 1, 2017 for the 2017 – 2022 period established by ENRE Resolution No. 63/17.
In accordance with the provisions of Sub-Appendix XVI to such Resolution, the Company is required to submit within a term of 60 calendar days, the calculation of global indicators, interruptions for which force majeure has been alleged, the calculation of individual indicators, and shall determine the related discounts, crediting the amounts thereof within 10 business days. In turn, the ENRE will examine the information submitted by the Company, and in the event that the crediting of such discounts is not verified, it will impose a fine, payable to the Federal Government, for an amount equivalent to twice the value of the original amount that should have been recorded.
In this regard, the ENRE has implemented an automatic penalty mechanism so that the discounts on account of deviations may be credited to customers within a term of 60 days as from the end of the relevant six-month period.
The penalty system provides that penalties are updated in accordance with the variation of distributor’s CPD or by the energy tariff average price as the case may be. Subsequently, through different resolutions concerning penalties relating to the commercial service and the safety on streets and public spaces, the ENRE provided for the application of increases and adjustments, applying for such purpose a criterion different from the one applied by the Company.
Additionally, and following the completion of a RTI process, the ENRE issued new penalty procedures, such as:
· | ENRE Resolution No. 118/18: Regulating the compensation for extraordinary service provision interruptions. |
· | ENRE Resolution No. 170/18: Regulating the Penalty System for Deviations from the Investment Plan, whereby real investments are compared to the annual investment plan submitted by the Company, and the investment plan carried out for the five-year period is assessed against the five-year plan proposed in the RTI. |
· | ENRE Resolution No. 198/18: Adopting a new Supplementary Penalty Procedure of Technical Service Quality, which penalizes deviations from quality parameters at feeder level. |
· | ENRE Resolution No. 91/18: Stating that, through the filing of charges, the ENRE informs Edenor about the penalty procedure to be applied for failure to comply with meter-reading and billing time periods. |
· | ENRE Resolution No. 5/19: Stating that, through the filing of charges, the ENRE notifies Edenor about the penalty system to be applied for failure to comply with customer service timing requirements in commercial offices (Intelligent Routing and Customer Service System – Sistema Inteligente de Direccionamiento y Atención de Usuarios (SIDyAA)). |
· | ENRE Resolution No. 42/2020: Approving the new plan for crediting and distributing the penalties payable to all of active users and the methodology for crediting the penalties payable to Edenor’s non-active users, as well as the manner in which distribution companies must produce certain information and submit it to the ENRE. |
· | ENRE Resolution No. 15/2021: Approving a new methodology for crediting and distributing the penalties payable to all active users and the methodology for crediting penalties to the Solidarity Account for Users in Vulnerable Situations, as well as the manner in which Edenor must produce certain information and submit it to the ENRE. |
· | ENRE Resolution No 547/2022: Approving a new methodology for supervising and processing the information concerning interruptions. |
53 |
The effects of the resolutions detailed above have been quantified by the Company and recognized as of December 31, 2022 and 2021, which does not imply the Company consents to the criteria applied.
On May 10, 2019, the Company and the SE, on behalf of the Federal Government, entered into the Agreement on the Regularization of Obligations. By virtue of this agreement, the Company (i) undertook to pay users certain penalty and compensation amounts relating to the 2006-2016 period; and (ii) agreed to make investments, in addition to those agreed upon in the RTI, to contribute to improve the reliability and safety of the service. In return, the Federal Government partially recognized the claim duly made by the Company, by fully offsetting pending obligations and cancelling penalties payable to the National Treasury. Furthermore, the Company waived any rights to which it may be entitled and abandoned any actions against the Federal Government.
On September 21, 2021, the Argentine Ministry of Economy issued ME Resolution No. 590/2021 declaring such agreement contrary to the public interest, thus paving the way for the filing of a legal action to declare it null and void. It also provided for the suspension of the administrative procedures relating to the fulfilment of the obligations arising from such agreement.
Nevertheless, based on the terms of the second clause of the aforementioned agreement, the Company recorded, as of December 31, 2022, an update to the amounts related to “penalties to be used for investments” for a total of Ps.10,760 million, amounting to a total liability (pending of application) of Ps. 17,186 million at nominal values, which was allocated as financial interest.
Foreclosure on the Pledge of Our Class A common shares or Revocation of Our Concession
Under the terms of our concession, the Argentine Government has the right to revoke our concession if we enter into bankruptcy and the Argentine Government decides that we may not continue rendering services, in which case all of our assets will be transferred to a new state-owned company that will be sold in an international public bidding procedure. At the conclusion of such bidding process, the purchase price would be delivered to the bankruptcy court in favor of our creditors, net of any debt owed by us to the Argentine Government. Any residual proceeds would be distributed among our shareholders.
Periodic bidding for control of Edenor
Before the end of each management period under our concession, the regulatory authority shall launch an international public bidding procedure in respect of the Class “A” common shares representing 51% of the share capital of Edenor, currently held by Edelcos. If Edelcos matches the highest bid or its bid represents the highest bid received, it will continue to hold the Class “A” shares, and no further disbursements will be necessary. On the contrary, if Edelcos’s offer is not the highest, the Class “A” shares shall be awarded to the bidder who made the highest bid and the proceeds from the sale shall be payable by Grantor Government to Edelcos, net of any payments owed to the Argentine Government. The beforementioned price shall be delivered within the term of 30 days once the Grantor Control received it. The first management period commenced on September 1, 1992, and was extended by the regulatory authority through Resolution 467/2007.
Default of the Argentine Government
If the Argentine Government breaches its obligations in such a way that we cannot comply with our obligations under our concession or in such a way that our distribution service is materially affected, we may request the termination of our concession, after giving the Argentine Government a 90-day prior notice. Upon termination of our concession, all our assets used to provide electricity distribution service will be transferred to a new state-owned company to be created by the Argentine Government, which shares will be sold in an international public bidding procedure. The amount obtained in such bidding will be paid to us, net of any payment owed by us to the Argentine Government, plus certain compensation established as a percentage of the bidding price, ranging from 10% to 30% depending on the management period in which the sale occurs.
54 |
Edenor Network
As of December 31, 2022, the system through which the Company supplies electricity comprises 81 HV/HV, HV/HV/MV and HV/MV transformer substations, which represents 19,519 MVA of installed power and 1,557 kilometers of 220 kV, 132 kV and 27.5 kV high-voltage networks. The MV/LV and MV/MV distribution system comprises 19,019 MV/LV transformers, which represents 9,433 MVA of installed power, 12,056 kilometers of 33 and 13.2 kV medium-voltage lines, and 27,967 kilometers of 380/220 V low-voltage lines.
The table below shows the most significant data related to the transmission and distribution system for the last five years:
Electricity is conveyed from points of interconnection with the Argentine Interconnection System (“SADI”), 500 kV-220 kV Rodríguez Substation, 220 kV Ezeiza Substation, and from the local power plants, mainly Puerto and Costanera. In turn, the transmission network links these nodes with Casanova, Colegiales, Malaver, Matheu, Morón, Rodríguez, Talar and Zappalorto 220 kV head substations, and with Matanza, Ramos Mejía, Agronomía, Puerto Nuevo, Edison, Pilar, and Malvinas 132 kV head substations. Additionally, other local thermal-generation power plants are linked to Pilar, Zappalorto and Matheu Substations.
The transmission and distribution system, together with Edesur’s and Edelap S.A. (“Edelap”)’s systems, form the Greater Buenos Aires system that is operated by SACME, a company jointly controlled by the Company and Edesur S.A. SACME is responsible for the management of the high-voltage regional distribution network in the Buenos Aires metropolitan area, coordinating, controlling and supervising the operation of the generation, transmission and distribution network in the City of Buenos Aires and the Buenos Aires metropolitan area, including coordination with the SADI in the Company’s and Edesur’s concession areas.
The Company distributes energy from the high/medium voltage substations through the primary 13.2kV and 33kV system to a secondary 380/220 V low-voltage system, distributing the electricity to final users with varied voltage levels depending on their requirements. In exceptional cases, certain users are supplied with power at higher voltages.
55 |
Investments
Investments made in 2022 amounted to Ps.33,900 million in constant currency. The execution of investment projects was given priority over any other disbursements as a way to maintaining the provision of the public service, object of the concession, under reliable conditions.
In order to meet the demand, improve the quality of the service, and reduce non-technical losses, the majority of the investments were earmarked for the increase of capacity, the installation of remote control equipment in the medium-voltage network, the connection of new electricity supplies, and the installation of self-administered energy meters. All the investments were made prioritizing environmental protection and public safety.
During 2022 the additional investment plan of the Agreement for the Development of the preventive and corrective work plan for the electrical distribution network in the greater Buenos Aires metropolitan area executed in December 2020 between the Ministry of Economy, Ministry of Energy, ENRE and Edenor, was completed. The investment made within this Plan reached $1,222 million in 2022, totaling $3,092 million in the period 2021-2022, and comprising 354 works.
Transmission structure:
Our HV transmission network takes energy mainly from the Argentine Interconnected System through the Rodríguez and Ezeiza Substations, and the Puerto Nuevo, Nuevo Puerto, Costanera, Parque Pilar and Matheu III local thermal power plants; additionally it exchanges energy with other companies at transmission, distribution and distributed generation levels.
56 |
With the aim of improving the quality of the service and meeting the growth in demand, in 2022, we made significant investments in the HV network, among which the following are worth mentioning:
§ | Replacement of a 2.3 km-long section of a 132 kV oil-paper cable with a 2.4 km-long section of an XLPE-type dry cable in the power line that links Puerto Nuevo and Melo Substations. |
§ | Continuation of both the works to replace a 2.4 km-long section of a 132 kV oil-paper cable with a 2.5 km-long section of an XLPE-type dry cable in the power line that links Puerto Nuevo and Colegiales Substations, and the works for the sectioning of the 132 kV power lines that link Talar and Matheu Substations, at Benavidez Substation. |
§ | Commencement of construction works of a new 220/132 - 1x300 MVA transformer in Pantanosa Substation, which is expected to be put into service in the first half of 2023. |
§ | Commencement of works on two new 132 kV power lines between Pantanosa and Aeroclub Substations. |
§ | Commencement of works to increase installed capacity in 220/132 kV Zappalorto Substation from 2 x 300 MVA to 3 x 300 MVA. |
Subtransmission Structure
Our substransmission network is the link between HV (HV/HV) head substations and the substations where voltage is transformed from high to medium (HV/MV), adopting generally the 132 kV voltage level. The overhead network (double radial deviation or double loop deviation) and the underground network (in “simple circuit” loops or double loop deviation) are considered as the basic structure of the subtransmission network.
In 2022, some of the main works performed were:
Completion of:
§ | the new 132/13.2 kV - 2x80 MVA Aeroclub Substation, along with the authorization to operate the second MV switchboard. |
§ | the enlargement of the 132/13.2 kV Altos Substation, along with the authorization to operate the second MV switchboard. |
§ | the enlargement of the 132/13.2 kV Nordelta Substation, along with the authorization to operate the second MV switchboard. |
57 |
§ | authorization to operate the new 132/13.2 kV - 2x40 MVA Oro Verde Substation with its overhead 132 kV (2x2, 1 km) linking power lines. The works on the Medium-Voltage Switchboard continue. |
§ | continuation of construction works of both the new 220/13.2 kV - 2x80 MVA Trujui Substation and its underground 220 kV (2x100 meters) linking power lines, and the new 132/13.2 kV - 2x40 MVA Garín Substation and its underground 132 kV (2x3.1 km) linking power lines. |
§ | commencement of construction works of the new 132/13.2 kV - 2x80 MVA Martínez Substation |
Distribution Structure:
The distribution network comprises all the equipment, medium voltage (13.2 and 33 kV) lines and cables that link subtransmission substations with medium and medium/low-voltage transformer centers. The network’s basic structure consists of open normal operation feeders forming rings with other feeders of another busbar of the same substation or with neighboring substations.
In 2022, the following works were performed, among others:
§ | 47 new MV feeders were authorized to operate in new and existing Substations, increasing the length of the medium-voltage network in 102 km. |
§ | 376 new MV/LV transformer centers were installed and another 395 were extended, increasing installed capacity in 243 MVA. |
§ | 497 new remote control points and 200 new remote supervision points were incorporated in the MV network, which make it possible to reduce restoration times. |
Network improvement
The improvements made to the networks in 2022 comprised all voltage levels. The most significant improvements are:
§ | HV network: replacement of bushings in 220/132 kV and 132/13.2 kV transformers and replacement of 132/13.2 kV 40 MVA transformers. Continuation of the replacement plan of metering transformers. Replacement of 132 kV and 220 kV circuit breakers/disconnectors, and of 132 and 220 kV transformer and line protection switchboards. |
§ | MV network: replacement of both switchboards in Bancalari and Colegiales Substations and disconnectors in Catonas and Ciudadela Substations. Replacement of a 17 km-long section of old technology underground network, change of MV/LV transformers, and change of switchgear equipment in transformer centers. |
§ | LV network: replacement of underground and overhead network. |
Distribution Technical Management
In 2022, we were able to improve the quality of the service while continuing with the plans and projects implemented in prior years. The results obtained represented a significant improvement in SAIFI and SAIDI service quality indicators.
58 |
Among the main operation and maintenance-related activities carried out throughout the year, the following are worth mentioning:
Distribution
Special Maintenance plans: change and adjustments of line poles
§ | 3,783 MV line poles, 30% of which were replaced by reinforced concrete columns. |
§ | 59,352 LV line poles |
Pruning plan in MV network
§ | Consolidation of the procedure consisting of three inspections per year with the related adjustments, which contributed to reducing faults created by vegetation contact on power lines. |
§ | In the year, 150,000 trees were pruned or trimmed. |
Inspections in distribution networks
§ | 4,916 Km of MV networks. |
§ | 27,998 Km of LV networks. |
§ | 5,839 inspections of Transformer Centers. |
§ | 1,909 thermographic inspections. |
§ | Complete census of “Not Measured” equipment installations (Public lighting, traffic lights, cable television equipment, etc.). |
Leveraging MV planned installation procedures
§ | When a facility is put out of service on a scheduled basis, a complete examination is made along with the necessary adjustments to take advantage of the power cut. Through this procedure, more than 3,799 tasks, which include 1,088 replacements of MV line poles, were carried out in the year. |
Tasks performed by distribution mobile teams:
§ | 61,117 grouped LV interruptions |
§ | 347,829 responses to individual LV claims |
§ | 52,622 installations of new electricity supplies |
§ | 341,022 energy recovery-related inspections in T1 customers |
§ | 21,293 energy recovery-related inspections in T2 and T3 customers; |
§ | 354,013 switching operations in the MV network during planned works |
§ | 69,828 switching operations in the MV network during forced events |
§ | 1,743 LV underground splices |
§ | 2,106 MV underground splices |
Diagnosis center
§ | Progress was made with the installation of AMI meters for medically dependent on electricity users, with the number of meters installed in medically dependent on electricity active customers surpassing 500. |
§ | Carrying out of 27 Projects and Works aimed at adapting internal facilities for the installation of alternative energy sources (AES) in vulnerable medically dependent on electricity users, totaling 40 Projects and Works in the last 15 months. |
§ | Installation of 93 AES, reaching a total of 173 active AES as of 12/31/22. |
§ | More than 93% of the medically dependent on electricity customers that had made a technical claim was contacted effectively. |
59 |
§ | Installation of 750 power generator sets that had been requested by medically dependent on electricity customers due to scheduled or unplanned power cuts of our Network. |
Response to claims/outages reported at night
§ | Implementation of nightshift crews on a permanent basis since winter (from 10 pm to 6 am) with a Supervisor for the analysis, dispatch, and management of priorities. |
§ | Implementation, for the Summer Plan, of the follow-up in the night shift of EEMM Contractors dedicated exclusively to preparing grouped documents. |
Electricity access and smart consumption
§ | 237,736 activated Smart Electricity meters (“MIDE"). |
Energy theft
§ | Continuation of specific control operations in some residential neighborhoods and gated communities. |
Remote control and remote supervision
In 2022, the remote control plan continued to be carried out and the substations’ remote control equipment was improved.
§ | 410 new remote control operational points in the MV distribution network, achieving a total of 3,113 over the existing 1,731 MV feeders. |
§ | Incorporation of 192 remote supervision points in the MV network, achieving a total of 2,721 points. Remote supervision of the physical quantities of 8 power generation groups, thus avoiding the presence of permanent staff to control their functioning. |
§ | Inspection of protections in 24 Large Customers distributed in the MV network, adjusting those with inadequate calibration or those that did not work, thus reducing the possibility of internal failure without affecting adjacent customers. |
§ | Thanks to the remote control implementation achieved in both substations and the MV distribution network, it was possible to normalize 46% of the customers affected by MV scheduled and unscheduled power cuts in less than 15 minutes and 18% of them in less than 3 minutes, thereby improving (SAIDI and SAIFI) service quality indicators. |
§ | Extension of the application of IT Security concepts to the remote control networks of three HV/HV, HV/MV and MV/MV substations. At present, 52 remote control pieces of equipment in substations are protected against cyber-attacks. |
§ | Technology renewal of the remote control equipment in seven substations. |
Transmission
§ | Compliance with the Preventive Maintenance Plan of HV facilities and substations in accordance with regulations. |
§ | Compliance with the Preventive Maintenance Plan of MV overhead lines. |
§ | Incorporation of MV overhead network termography into routine maintenance, which made it possible to identify and fix problems avoiding failures. |
§ | Training of and equipment provision to HV LLW staff for the carrying out of circuit breakers bypass and cleaning tasks at the same potential in 220 Kv facilities. |
60 |
§ | Development of the Procedure to be followed for the replacement of energized line poles. |
§ | The LLW Insulation Testing Laboratory once again received IRAM-ISO/IEC 17025 accreditation by the Argentine Accreditation Agency. |
§ | There is an Application in place for the “Follow-up of status and identification of fault patterns in HV metering transformers”, including status indicators associated with moisture in oil, aged oil, aged cellulose, chromatology and status of energized switches. The tool is essential not only for the management of each transformer but also for the management of all the transformers as a whole, thus allowing for decision making on the basis of objective evidence. The Company plans to replicate this Application for HV metering transformers in 2023. |
§ | Current development of an application for the “Monitoring of micro-processed Protections”, which would avoid periodical Preventive Maintenance and make it possible to act in advance in the event of a protection failure. |
§ | Further extension of LLW (Live line working) capacity. Twelve (12) new teams were added in order to avoid interrupting the electricity supply due to maintenance tasks in the MV network. At present, light and heavy LLW teams total twenty-four (24) and fourteen (14), respectively. |
Management of Information Technology and Telecommunications
In 2022 progress continued to be made towards the area’s goal of being a strategic pillar of the Company’s transformation by accelerating changes in technology, processes and the culture of work. In this regard, digital capabilities were strengthened and progress was made towards the consolidation of a flexible and robust technology architecture with a “cross-company” vision of the processes, taking into consideration a new era for the Company that creates opportunities and poses a challenge to development in order to continue providing quality and efficient service.
Digital architecture, data analytics and data governance
During the last few years, the Computer Technology and Telecommunications Division has been developing and implementing a new data management strategy. In this regard, in 2022, data management and governance practices, which make it possible to solve certain existing issues and support the process of making consolidated decisions at all the Company’s levels, continued to be implemented.
The practice of data governance allowed for the implementation of different Big Data use cases, which made it possible to cover and discover data relating to several of the Company’s most important systems. At the same time, other strategic projects, such as the Regulatory Capital and Assets Base (BACR) and the HR Data Model, were initiated.
To that end, the strategy of being a data-driven company continued, incorporating new components in the Big Data & Analytics architecture, which allows us to meet the different data processing and consumption needs. In this year, new use cases were implemented for the different divisions such as, for example: FSM, Account Balance, Delinquent Payment Balance, ENRE Reports, and Account, Premises, and Billing Models.
Furthermore, the Data Lab -multidisciplinary team that seeks to answer business questions by working on different use cases- continued to consolidate, applying new data discovery as well as predictive and prescriptive analytics methodologies.
61 |
At the same time, the implementation of an enterprise architecture tool was completed. This tool allows us to improve team work and cooperation among the areas, sharing accurate information that helps IT and business teams make the best decisions for business growth.
Technology solutions
One of the main projects undertaken in 2022 relates to the adjustment of the commercial system (CC&B) to meet the different regulatory regulations issued by the ENRE.
In particular that relating to the already mentioned electricity rate segmentation, which implied the application of differentiated and step-up rates to the three low-, average- and high-income customer segments from September 1, 2022. In order to comply with this regulation many changes were required in both configurations and integrations.
Furthermore, the meter-reading device technology development project, including the updating of devices with the revamping of the data collection portal and its optical sensor, was completed, which allowed for an improved and faster meter reading process.
In 2022, the Collections project, whose objective was to implement a reconciliation-concentration system of collections, was completed. As a result thereof, all the collection channels managed by Edenor are administered and integrated in this application.
A major milestone in 2022 was the successful implementation of the new Field Service Management tool Geocall, a market-leading application. This new system offers a wide range of benefits to the technical claims response, maintenance work orders, commercial field actions, works approval and materials management processes, because, in addition to extending current functionalities, the system allows for improved performance in terms of response times, stability and speed. Additionally, it allows for the integration of formerly distributed processes into a single tool, facilitating data integration and maintenance.
Additionally, the Electricity Sales application, which allows for the determination of an electricity balance from the values of both the electricity required by customers and the electricity consumed but not billed, was implemented. This solution, built with modern development tools and custom-tailored to Edenor’s specific requirements, replaces the use of non-enterprise tools, automates processes and makes online calculations that would otherwise be made manually. Therefore, the results obtained are more accurate, the best auditing practices are adopted and process times are optimized.
At the same time, several initiatives were implemented to attend to the Company’s support processes.
Finally, the automation of application testing continued, with a view to ensuring software quality and contributing to optimizing implementation times, providing support with agile initiatives. Moreover, the implementation of bots to streamline business processes (Robotic Process Automation -RPA-) consolidated.
Technical and operational support solutions
The smart electricity grid is another of the axes of the Company’s Digital Transformation. In this regard, we continued to carry out the technology replacement plan of MIDES, using components of the current smart metering architecture.
62 |
As for the other Smart technology applications, we were able to extend the advantages of the smart grid to other segments of our clientele, such as: Dependent on electricity for medical reasons, Residential, and Distributed Generation customers.
It is important to mention that internal remote metering was carried out, such as measurements in HV/MV Substations, measurements of internal boundaries, and measurements of low-voltage energy balance, among others.
In 2022, the Company’s own new Metering Laboratory, located in Azcuénaga Building, carried out, as part of its main functions, meter testing, fraud analysis, new conventional and smart metering equipment verification, and equipment programming activities.
Cybersecurity
With regard to information security, and giving consideration to the global increase in cybercrime, we worked on several fronts to strengthen incident detection and response levels. It is worth mentioning in particular, the implementation of a 7x24 Security Operation Center (SOC) that will allow for the constant monitoring of security events, the performance of cyber intelligence and the setting up of an Incident Response Team (IRT).
Additionally, another implementation that is worth pointing out was the one related to the paradigm shift in navigation technology control, achieved through a new proxy (Secure Web Gateway ), that allows for malware prevention, threats detection, websites filtering, data protection and cloud applications and services control.
Furthermore, workflows were defined for the enveloping and/or safeguarding of high-privileged accounts and different surveys were conducted to improve the strategy and design of the recovery plan in the event of disasters. At the same time, the cybersecurity control process for third parties continued, achieving greater visibility in the management of information owned by edenor and used by critical suppliers.
The Raising Cybersecurity and Information Safeguarding Awareness programs continued to be implemented, through phishing drills, newsletters and interactive modules.
The digital certificate infrastructure was improved by incorporating a continuous renewal and updating process.
Infrastructure and operations
A major milestone in 2022 was the implementation of a new Data center in world-class facilities, gaining access to the highest security and availability standards. These facilities allow us to expand our physical capacity to deal with any contingencies of Edenor’s Data center, operate more secure and on a continuous basis 365 days a year, reduce risks, and get prepared for the growth in demand.
In addition to the foregoing, in 2022 the following activities were carried out:
§ | revamping and deployment of new video conference rooms, improving equipment and spaces for remote collaborative work, and replacement of staff notebooks and phones. |
§ | continued implementation of ITIL (Information Technology Infrastructure Library) processes for IT&T management, which impact the management of edenor’s technology assets, and development and implementation of a new infrastructure to provide support to Edenor’s websites mounted on Amazon Cloud, with DevOps methodology and Infrastructure as Code. |
63 |
§ | automatic technology asset discovery processes (CMDB), which helped build an initial inventory of the configuration items that will comprise the CMDB. |
§ | first steps in Cloud Infrastructure Sanitization and Organization, with a view to moving along the path of growth of this type of implementation in a more efficient and secure manner. |
§ | Windows upgrading in all desktop computers to the version running on all notebooks, thus allowing for the uniform and automatic updating of the entire park of computers. |
§ | implementation of a Specialist Support Team for the Dispatch of Medium Voltage, with operators focused on the resolution of sector-specific problems. |
§ | implementation of the chat tool as a new contact channel for the Service Center, whose use increased as the months went by. This channel allows for more agile and friendly customer service. |
§ | incorporation of monitoring processes in the new platforms and applications, with the aim of proactively identifying any possible unavailability and/or impairment in the different components and integrations comprising them. |
Telecommunications
In 2022, the Company’s data network was strengthened and extended. This was achieved thanks to the upgrading of technology and equipment, the use of telecommunications and the increase by 45 km of the optical fiber network, totaling 2,800 km deployed on the entire concession area.
The plan for the Remote Control of Transformer Centers continued to be carried out with the aim of improving the service quality of the network, installing new remotely-controlled transformer centers.
Furthermore, technology migration and expansion of the Contact Center’s platform -consisting of the upgrading of the infrastructure and systems that support the management of the telephone customer service center- continued, integrating all active digital channels: Twitter, Facebook, WhatsApp and e-Mails.
Throughout the year, new sites with electronic security system, including the integrated IP video surveillance system, continued to be installed; thus adding 94 IP video cameras over a total of 1,250 cameras deployed on the entire network.
Users
The following graph shows the evolution of our user base over the last four years:
64 |
As of December 31, 2022, Edenor served 3,264,000 users. We define a “user” as one meter.
Edenor Tariff Categories
Edenor classifies its users pursuant to the following tariff categories:
· | Residential (T1-R1 to T1-R9): residential users whose peak capacity demand is less than 10kW. In 2021, this category accounted for approximately 46% of our electricity sales. |
· | Small commercial (T1-G1 to T1-G3): commercial users whose peak capacity demand is less than 10kW. In 2021, this category accounted for approximately 8% of our electricity sales. |
· | Medium commercial (T2): commercial users whose peak capacity demand is equal to or greater than 10kW but less than 50kW. In 2021, this category accounted for approximately 7% of our electricity sales. |
· | Industrial (T3): industrial users whose peak capacity demand is equal to or greater than 50kW. This category is applied to high-demand users according to the voltage at which each user is connected. The voltage ranges included in this category are the following: (i) Low Voltage (LV): voltage less than or equal to 1 kV; (ii) Medium Voltage (MV): voltage greater than 1kV but less than 66 kV; and (iii) High Voltage (HV): voltage equal to or greater than 66kV. In 2021, this category accounted for approximately 16% of our electricity sales. This category does not include users who purchase their electricity directly through the WEM under the wheeling system. |
· | Wheeling System: large users who purchase their electricity directly from generation or broker companies through the WEM. These tariffs follow the same structure as those applied under the Industrial category described above. As of December 31, 2021, the total number of such large users was 686, and this category represented approximately 17% of our electricity sales. |
· | Others: public lighting (T1-PL) and shantytown users whose peak capacity demand is less than 10kW. In 2021 this category accounted for approximately 6% of our electricity sales. See “Item 4. Information on the Company—Business Overview—Framework Agreement (Shantytowns)”. |
We aim to maintain an accurate categorization of our users to charge the appropriate tariff to each user. In particular, we focus on our residential tariff categorizations to both minimize the number of commercial and industrial users who are classified as residential users and identify residential users whose peak capacity demand exceeds 10 kW and therefore do not qualify as residential users.
65 |
We rely on the following measures to detect incorrectly categorized users:
· | reporting carried out by our employees tasked with reading meter information to identify observed commercial activities which are being performed by residential users, |
· | conducting internet surveys to identify advertisements for commercial services (such as medical or other professional services) that are linked to a residential user’s address, and |
· | analyzing user demand to determine whether we should further evaluate the peak capacity demand of a given user whose use might exceed 10kW. |
Reclassification
On June 16, 2022, Decree No. 332/2022 set forth a mandatory reclassification of users. Upon the registration of each user at a National Registry of Users (RASE), residential users have the option to maintain a percentage of subsidies on their invoices by declaring certain personal and economic information, where the category N1 has lost 100% of subsidies and N2 and N3 have partially lost their subsidies over time.
Please see the implementation funnel for those reclassified users:
Reading, Billing and Collecting
The Company bills its users based on their tariff categories. Residential users and small business users are billed a fixed monthly charge and a variable charge based on each unit of energy consumed.
66 |
On January 29, 2016, pursuant to Resolution No. 1/16, the ENRE established a monthly billing scheme providing for bimonthly consumption reading. On February 1, 2017, the ENRE issued Resolution No. 63/17, which established a new tariff scheme that maintains the billing methodology of Resolution No. 1/16.
In 2017, the implementation of the remote meter reading system for the tariff 3 (high demand) and tariff 2 (medium demand) user segments gradually began.
As part of the measures aimed at the restructuring of the electricity sector after the RTI became effective, a system was implemented for the monthly billing of the consumption measured every two months, dividing for such purpose the bimonthly consumption into two similar monthly periods with a view to providing T1 (small demand) users with more timely information regarding their consumption and facilitating payment.
Additionally, to measure the amount of actual readings for which service is billed, limits of estimated readings have been established in order to maximize user billing on actual readings. The Concession Agreement initially stipulated that the maximum limit of estimates was 8% of the total bills issued. As from the effective date of the RTI, a maximum of 2% of estimated bills over the total number of bills issued for each electricity rate category has been set as a global indicator.
Technology adaptations, such as remote meter readings, changes made in procedures, and the opening of new contact channels to coordinate meter readings notably reduced the number of cases that could not be billed in first instance, avoiding estimated consumption. Therefore, the subsequent processes of the commercial cycle have a regular flow; bill distribution tasks are more organized, due dates become more predictable and cash flows predictability is improved.
To those customers that require a MIDE, we have delivered 237,736 on 2022. However, MIDE installation ceased in July 2022, after Resolution No. 217/2022 was issued whereby the ENRE prohibited MIDEs unless its prior consent is obtained. All the projected installations submitted by the Company have not been approved as of the date of this annual report.
In 2022, approximately 18.3 million readings of electricity meters were conducted. The indicators showed that, despite the difficulties affecting the process, only 0.1% of such readings were estimated.
With an aim to optimizing the reading management process, at the beginning of 2022, a tender process for the provision of the meter-reading service was launched. Such process came to an end in December, and the selected service is expected to become operative during the first quarter of 2023.
In 2022, in the billing area, we reviewed and reorganized processes and teams so that the Company could adapt to the ENRE’s new regulations, which impacted the unrecorded energy billing recovery process.
Furthermore, we developed an intensive campaign to promote sign-ups for the digital bill, which resulted in more than 772 thousand Tariff 1 customers signing up for digital billing and more than 19.8 thousand Tariffs 2 and 3 customers receiving their bills by e-mail on a monthly basis.
Our residential and small commercial users are divided into subcategories based on their consumption, as follows:
67 |
Residential (Tariff 1-R or T1-R):
· | Tariff 1-R1: monthly energy consumption less than or equal to 300 KWh; |
· | Tariff 1-R2: monthly energy consumption greater than 301 KWh and less than or equal to 650 KWh; |
· | Tariff 1-R3: monthly energy consumption greater than 651 KWh and less than or equal to 800 KWh; |
· | Tariff 1-R4: monthly energy consumption greater than 801 KWh and less than or equal to 900 KWh; |
· | Tariff 1-R5: monthly energy consumption greater than 901 KWh and less than or equal to 1000 KWh; |
· | Tariff 1-R6: monthly energy consumption greater than 1001 KWh and less than or equal to 1200 KWh; |
· | Tariff 1-R7: monthly energy consumption greater than 1201 KWh and less than or equal to 1400 KWh; |
· | Tariff 1-R8: monthly energy consumption greater than 1401 KWh and less than or equal to 2800 KWh; and |
· | Tariff 1-R9: monthly energy consumption greater than 2800 KWh. |
Social Tariff
The social tariff applies to the same subcategories of residential rates, for which there was no variable charge for the first 150 KWh of monthly consumption until November 2017.
To qualify for the social tariff, users must comply with one of the following:
· | retirees or pensioners who receive two gross minimum wages or less; |
· | workers in employment relationships that earn two gross minimum wages or less; |
· | self-employed individuals falling in categories that correspond to annual income which monthly break out reaches two minimum gross wages or less; |
· | grantees of social programs; |
· | registered in the self-employed (monotributista) social category; |
· | grantees of non-contributory pensions with gross income equal to or less than two minimum wages; |
· | grantees of unemployment insurance; |
· | domestic service incorporated into the relevant special social security scheme; |
· | holders of the Lifetime Pension for Veterans of the South Atlantic War; |
· | persons with a disability certificate issued by a competent authority; and |
· | persons suffering or living with another person suffering from an illness whose treatment involves electrodependence (in this case, the variable charge for the first 600 KWh monthly consumption is free). |
In 2022, the Province of Buenos Aires and the Autonomous City of Buenos Aires assumed the social tariffs discounts and the ceilings (scheme of maximum percentages that the beneficiary would pay, with respect to what residential users of the same consumption before taxes pay), and the bonuses for neighborhood clubs.
68 |
Small commercial (Tariff 1-G):
· | Tariff 1-G1: bimonthly energy demand less than or equal to 1600 KWh; |
· | Tariff 1-G2: bimonthly energy demand greater than 1600 KWh but less than or equal to 4000 KWh; and |
· | Tariff 1-G3: bimonthly energy demand greater than 4000 KWh. |
Medium Commercial (Tariff 2):
Medium commercial users (demand greater than 10 kW but less than 50 kW - Tariff T2) are billed on a monthly basis, as follows: (1) a fixed charge per invoiced issued; (2) a fixed charge per each “scope of supply” of kW capacity agreed; (3) a fixed charge based on a maximum kW capacity (applicable to the maximum capacity registered during the billing period); (4) a variable charge based on each unit of energy consumed, without hour discrimination; and, (5) if applicable, a cos phi surcharge.
Industrial (Tariff 3):
Industrial users (demand equal or greater than 50 kW - Tariff T3) are billed on a monthly basis, as follows: (1) a fixed charge per invoice issued; (2) a fixed charge per each “scope of supply” of kW capacity agreed for low, medium or high voltage, with or without electricity consumption; (3) a fixed charge based on a maximum kW capacity registered, in low, medium or high voltage, applicable to the maximum capacity registered during the billing period; (4) a charge resulting from the electricity supplied in the voltage corresponding to the provision, in accordance with the consumption registered in each of the tariff timetables: “peak”, “night-time” and “remaining hours”; (5) if the supply is carried out in continuous current, a surcharge equivalent to a percentage of the price of the rectified electricity; and (6), if it is applicable, a cos phi surcharge.
Public Lighting (AP):
Public lighting users are billed a monthly variable energy charge based on each unit of energy consumed.
The table below shows the number of our users per tariff category as of December 31, for the years 2022, 2021 and 2020, respectively:
As of December 31, | ||||||||||||
2022 | 2021 | 2020 | ||||||||||
T1R | 2,885,678 | 2,852,029 | 2,785,165 | |||||||||
T1G | 339,567 | 338,832 | 327,923 | |||||||||
T2 | 30,813 | 30,837 | 30,980 | |||||||||
T3 | 7,076 | 6,924 | 6,881 | |||||||||
Wheeling system | 688 | 686 | 687 | |||||||||
Other* | 1,007 | 567 | 661 | |||||||||
Total | 3,264,829 | 3,229,875 | 3,152,297 |
* Represents public lighting and shantytown users.
69 |
All of the meters are read with portable meter-reading terminals, either with manual access or optical reading (in the case of electronic meters for T2, T3 and certain T1 users). The systems validate the readings, and any inconsistent reading is checked and/or corrected before billing. Estimates of user usage were significantly reduced as a result of this billing system. Once the invoices are printed, independent contractors in each operating area, that are subject to strict controls, distribute them.
Slow-Paying Accounts and Past Due Receivables
Pursuant to the Concession Agreement, certain procedures were established to reduce delinquency and enhance collection, which are followed with strict observance by the Commercial Department.
Municipal accounts make up a significant number of our accounts in arrears. The methods of collection on such arrears vary in each municipality. One method of collection is to withhold from the municipalities certain taxes collected from the public by us on behalf of the municipalities and using such taxes to offset any past due amounts owed to us by such municipalities. Another method of collection is to enter into refinancing agreements with the municipalities. Such methods significantly reduce the number of accounts in arrears.
Our past due receivables decreased to Ps.9,920.2 million as of December 31, 2022 from Ps.18,742.6 million as of December 31, 2021 due to the economic recovery after the pandemic. Past due receivables were measured as an equivalent of billing days and according to this measure, a decrease from 28.09 to 18.51 days was observed.
Throughout the year, 121,000 service suspension and cutoff actions were carried out and 43,300 customers were reconnected.
In addition to the carrying out of field actions, the arrangements with collection agencies continued, and through them constant communication was maintained with delinquent customers through the different channels. In 2022, two new collection agencies were added, totaling 7 agencies for the management of the portfolio.
The campaigns addressed to customers with early delinquent payments were reinforced through emails, SMS and IVR calls.
Taking into account the economic and social context, we offered our customers more flexible methods of payment and extended debt financing possibilities.
The result of such actions was a reduction of delinquent payments by 53% compared to 2021.
70 |
Moreover, taking into consideration our customers’ economic situation as a consequence of the pandemic, we offered more flexible methods of payment and extended debt financing possibilities.
The following graph shows Edenor’s delinquent balances as of December 31, of each year:
We also supply energy to low-income areas pursuant to the framework agreement with the Argentine Government and the Province of Buenos Aires, for which certain payments are still owed to us. See “Item 4. Information on the Company—Business Overview—Framework Agreement (Shantytowns).”
71 |
Energy Losses
Energy losses are equivalent to the difference between energy purchased and energy sold, and may be classified as technical and non-technical losses. Technical losses represent the energy that is lost during transmission and network distribution as a consequence of natural heating of the transformers and conductors that transmit the electricity from the generating plants to the users. The non-technical energy losses represent the remainder of our energy losses mainly due to the illegal use of its services and administrative and technical errors.
Energy losses require us to purchase additional energy to satisfy apparent demand, thereby increasing costs. Furthermore, illegally tied-in users typically consume more electricity than the average level of consumption for their category. We are unable to recover from users the cost of electricity purchased beyond the average loss factor set at 10% pursuant to our concession. Therefore, the reduction of energy losses reduces the amount of energy we have to purchase to satisfy apparent demand but cannot invoice, and increases the amount of electricity actually sold.
At the time of the privatization of the electricity sector in 1992, our total energy losses were approximately 26.54%. At that time, our non-technical losses were estimated at 17%, of the energy purchased; with over half of that amount due to fraud and illegal use of our service. In response to the high level of losses, we implemented a loss reduction plan in 1992, which emphasized accurate measurement of energy consumption through periodic inspections, reduction of administrative errors, regularization of shantytowns, reduction of illegal direct connections, provision of services to shantytowns and reduction of technical losses. However, from time to time, the Company has experienced an increase in non-technical losses as economic crises have impaired the ability of its users to pay their bills, and an increase in technical losses relative to the increase in the volume of energy that the Company supplied during such periods.
Our goal is to maintain our energy losses at an optimal level, while also considering the cost of reducing such losses and the level at which we are reimbursed for the cost of these losses under our concession. Our procedures for maintaining an optimal level of losses are focused on improving collections to ensure that users pay for all the energy that they consume and making investments in our network to control technical losses. To reduce the theft of electricity we have implemented vigilance and special technologies, such as networks that cannot be reached using normal ladders, shields close to the electricity posts, concentric cables, shielded meters and suspension of electricity service, among other remedies.
We aimed at normalizing clandestine consumers, inactive customers and chronic delinquent customers. In 2022, 15,070 MIDEs were installed. As of December 31, 2022, 237,552 meters were enabled. However, MIDE installation ceased in July 2022, after Resolution No. 217/2022 was issued whereby the ENRE prohibited MIDEs unless its prior consent is obtained. All the projected installations submitted by the Company have not been approvedas of the date of this annual report.
Furthermore, 314 data concentrators were installed, increasing the total number to 686. These facilities provide daily information on 73,000 meters allowing for an improved routing of inspections.
In Regions II and III, new shantytowns were formed while existing shantytowns continued to grow. In the third region of Greater Buenos Aires, energy theft represents the main factor in the increase in total losses.
The installation of the new type of multiple concentric network (MLCON), which had begun by the end of 2018, continued leveraging MIDE’s functionalities and increasing invulnerability (by adding security to the meter system) in neighborhoods with a high fraud rate.
72 |
The following table illustrates our estimates of the approximate disruption between technical and non-technical energy losses experienced in our concession area for the periods indicated:
Year ended December 31, | ||||||||||||
2022 | 2021 | 2020 | ||||||||||
Technical losses | 9.3 | % | 9.4 | % | 9.1 | % | ||||||
Non technical losses | 6.6 | % | 8.2 | % | 10.5 | % | ||||||
Total losses | 15.9 | % | 17.6 | % | 19.6 | % |
These losses in 2022 represented U.S.$4.6 million of energy purchases and a U.S.$3.3 million margin.
Framework Agreement (Shantytowns)
On January 10, 1994, the Company, Edesur, the Argentine Government and the Government of the Province of Buenos Aires entered into a Framework Agreement, whose purpose was to establish the guidelines under which the Company was to supply electricity to low-income areas and shantytowns (the “Framework Agreement”).
In accordance with the terms of our concession and given the nature of public service that the law grants for the distribution of electricity, the Company is required to supply electricity to all users within the concession area, including low-income areas and shantytowns located within our concession area. In October 2003, Edenor, Edesur and Edelap entered into a framework agreement with the Argentine Government and the Province of Buenos Aires (the “2003 Framework Agreement”) to regulate the supply of electricity to low-income areas and shantytowns. Under the 2003 Framework Agreement, the Company had the right to receive compensation for the services provided to shantytowns from funds collected from residents of each relevant shantytown, the Municipality in which it is located and, if there is a shortfall, by