X0306 4 2017-01-26 0001035002 VALERO ENERGY CORP/TX VLO 0001350220 Gorder Joseph W P.O. BOX 696000 SAN ANTONIO TX 78269-6000 1 1 0 0 COB, President and CEO Common Stock, $.01 par value 2017-01-26 4 M 0 25420 0 A 364377 D Common Stock, $.01 par value 2017-01-26 4 M 0 37164 0 A 401541 D Common Stock, $.01 par value 2017-01-26 4 M 0 30425 0 A 431966 D Common Stock, $.01 par value 2017-01-26 4 S 0 39057 67.845 D 392909 D Performance Shares 2017-01-26 4 M 0 12710 0 D 2017-01-26 2017-01-26 Common Stock 25420 0 D Performance Shares 2017-01-26 4 M 0 17523 0 D 2017-01-26 2018-01-26 Common Stock 37164 17523 D Performance Shares 2017-01-26 4 M 0 19590 0 D 2017-01-26 2019-01-26 Common Stock 30425 39180 D The 392,909 amount does not include 3,140.233 shares indirectly owned by the person in a thrift plan. Settlement of previously awarded performance shares at 200% of base shares. Settlement of previously awarded performance shares at 150% of base shares. Ethan A. Jones, as Attorney-in-Fact for Joseph W. Gorder 2017-01-30