X0306 4 2015-12-30 0 0001223786 NuStar GP Holdings, LLC NSH 0001349304 Barron Bradley C 19003 IH-10 WEST SAN ANTONIO TX 78257 1 1 0 0 CEO & President Common Units 2015-12-30 4 F 0 172 19.21 D 39332 D "Common Units" reported are units not distributed to the reporting person in order to satisfy the reporting person's tax obligations on grants. The grant of phantom units (called "Restricted Units" under the plan under which the grant was made) was originally reported on January 25, 2011. /s/ Michelle S. Miller, as Attorney-in-Fact for Bradley C. Barron 2016-01-04