0001193125-16-563512.txt : 20160428 0001193125-16-563512.hdr.sgml : 20160428 20160428153943 ACCESSION NUMBER: 0001193125-16-563512 CONFORMED SUBMISSION TYPE: 20-F PUBLIC DOCUMENT COUNT: 8 CONFORMED PERIOD OF REPORT: 20151231 FILED AS OF DATE: 20160428 DATE AS OF CHANGE: 20160428 FILER: COMPANY DATA: COMPANY CONFORMED NAME: Macro Bank Inc. CENTRAL INDEX KEY: 0001347426 STANDARD INDUSTRIAL CLASSIFICATION: COMMERCIAL BANKS, NEC [6029] IRS NUMBER: 000000000 STATE OF INCORPORATION: C1 FISCAL YEAR END: 1231 FILING VALUES: FORM TYPE: 20-F SEC ACT: 1934 Act SEC FILE NUMBER: 001-32827 FILM NUMBER: 161599714 BUSINESS ADDRESS: STREET 1: SARMIENTO 447 CITY: BUENOS AIRES STATE: C1 ZIP: 1041 BUSINESS PHONE: 54-11-5222-6500 MAIL ADDRESS: STREET 1: SARMIENTO 447 CITY: BUENOS AIRES STATE: C1 ZIP: 1041 FORMER COMPANY: FORMER CONFORMED NAME: Macro Bansud Bank Inc. DATE OF NAME CHANGE: 20051220 20-F 1 d176736d20f.htm FORM 20-F Form 20-F
Table of Contents

 

 

UNITED STATES

SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION

Washington, D.C. 20549

 

 

FORM 20-F

 

 

(Mark One)

¨ Registration statement pursuant to Section 12(b) or 12(g) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934

or

 

x Annual report pursuant to Section 13 or 15(d) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2015

or

 

¨ Transition report pursuant to Section 13 or 15(d) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 for the transition period from                      to                     

or

 

¨ Shell Company Report Pursuant to Section 13 or 15(d) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934

Date of the event requiring this shell company report.                     

Commission file number: 001-32827

BANCO MACRO S.A.

(Exact Name of Registrant as Specified in its Charter)

Macro Bank, Inc.

(Translation of registrant’s name into English)

Argentina

(Jurisdiction of incorporation or organization)

Sarmiento 447, City of Buenos Aires, Argentina

(Address of registrant’s principal executive offices)

 

 

Jorge Scarinci

Finance and Investor Relations Manager

Banco Macro S.A.

401 Sarmiento, 3th Floor

Buenos Aires—C1041AAI, Argentina

Telephone: (+54-11-5222-6730)

Facsimile: (+54-11-5222-7826)

(Name, telephone, e-mail and/or facsimile member and address of company contact person)

Securities registered or to be registered pursuant to Section 12(b) of the Act:

 

Title of Each Class

 

Name of Each Exchange On Which Registered

American Depositary Shares

Class B ordinary shares, par value Ps.1.00 per share

 

New York Stock Exchange

New York Stock Exchange(*)

 

 

 

(*) Ordinary shares of Banco Macro S.A. are not listed for trading but only in connection with the registration of American Depositary Shares which are evidenced by American Depositary Receipts.

 

 

Securities registered or to be registered pursuant to Section 12(g) of the Act:

None

Securities for which there is a reporting obligation pursuant to Section 15(d) of the Act:

 

9.75% Fixed/Floating Rate Non-Cumulative Junior Subordinated Bonds Due 2036
8.50% Notes Due 2017

Indicate the number of outstanding shares of each of the issuer’s classes of capital or common stock as of the close of the period covered by the annual report.

11,235,670 Class A ordinary shares, par value Ps.1.00 per share

573,327,358 Class B ordinary shares, par value Ps.1.00 per share

 

 

Indicate by check mark if the registrant is a well-known seasoned issuer, as defined in Rule 405 of the Securities Act.    Yes  ¨    No  x

If this report is an annual or transition report, indicate by check mark if the registrant is not required to file reports pursuant to Section 13 or 15(d) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934.    Yes  ¨    No  x

Indicate by check mark whether the registrant (1) has filed all reports required to be filed by Section 13 or 15(d) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 during the preceding 12 months (or for such shorter period that the registrant was required to file such reports), and (2) has been subject to such filing requirements for the past 90 days:    Yes  x    No  ¨

Indicate by check mark whether the registrant has submitted electronically and posted on its corporate Web site, if any, every Interactive Data File required to be submitted and posted pursuant to Rule 405 of Regulation S-T (§232.405 of this chapter) during the preceding 12 months (or for such shorter period that the registrant was required to submit and post such files).    Yes  ¨    No  x

Indicate by check mark whether the registrant is a large accelerated filer, an accelerated filer, or a non-accelerated filer. See definition of “accelerated filer and large accelerated filer” in Rule 12b-2 of the Exchange Act. (Check one):

Large accelerated filer  x                Accelerated filer  ¨                Non-accelerated filer  ¨

Indicate by check mark which basis of accounting the registrant has used to prepare the financial statements included in this filing:

 

U.S. GAAP  ¨     

International Financial Reporting  ¨

Standards as issued by the International Accounting Standards

Board  ¨

   Other  x

If “Other has been checked in response to the previous question, indicate by check mark which financial statement item the registrant has elected to follow:

Indicate by check mark which financial statement item the registrant has elected to follow:

Item 17  ¨    Item 18   x

If this is an annual report, indicate by check mark whether the registrant is a shell company (as defined in Rule 12b-2 of the Exchange Act).

Yes  ¨    No  x

(APPLICABLE ONLY TO ISSUERS INVOLVED IN BANKRUPTCY PROCEEDINGS DURING THE PAST FIVE YEARS)

Indicate by check mark whether the registrant has filed all documents and reports required to be filed by Sections 12, 23 or 15(d) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 subsequent to the distribution of securities under a plan confirmed by the court.

Yes  ¨    No  ¨

Please send copies of notices and communications from the Securities and Exchange Commission to:

 

Hugo N. L. Bruzone

Bruchou, Fernández Madero & Lombardi

Ing. Butty 275, 12th Floor

C1001AFA - Buenos Aires, Argentina

 

Jeffrey Cohen

Linklaters LLP

1345 Avenue of the Americas

New York, NY 10105

 

 

 


Table of Contents

Table of Contents

 

PART I        4   
Item 1.  

Identity of Directors, Senior Management and Advisers

     4   
Item 2.  

Offer Statistics and Expected Timetable

     4   
Item 3.  

Key Information

     4   
Item 4.  

Information on the Bank

     25   
Item 4A.  

Unresolved Staff Comments

     83   
Item 5.  

Operating and Financial Review and Prospects

     83   
Item 6.  

Directors, Senior Management and Employees

     102   
Item 7.  

Major Shareholders and Related Party Transactions

     110   
Item 8.  

Financial Information

     112   
Item 9.  

The Offer and Listing

     115   
Item 10.  

Additional Information

     116   
Item 11.  

Quantitative and Qualitative Disclosure About Market Risk

     132   
Item 12.  

Description of Securities Other Than Equity Securities

     134   
PART II        135   
Item 13.  

Defaults, Dividend Arrearages and Delinquencies

     135   
Item 14.  

Material Modifications to the Rights of Security Holders and Use of Proceeds

     135   
Item 15.  

Controls and Procedures

     135   
Item 16A.  

Audit Committee Financial Expert

     136   
Item 16B.  

Code of Ethics

     136   
Item 16C.  

Principal Accountant Fees and Services

     137   
Item 16D.  

Exemptions from the Listing Standards for Audit Committees

     137   
Item 16E.  

Purchases of Equity Securities by the Issuer and Affiliated Purchasers

     137   
Item 16F.  

Change in Registrant’s Certifying Accountant

     137   
Item 16G.  

Corporate Governance

     137   
PART III        140   
Item 17.  

Financial Statements

     140   
Item 18.  

Financial Statements

     140   
Item 19.  

Exhibits

     141   

 

1


Table of Contents

Certain defined terms

In this annual report, we use the terms “the registrant,” “we,” “us,” “our” and the “Bank” to refer to Banco Macro S.A. and its subsidiaries, on a consolidated basis. References to “Banco Macro” refer to Banco Macro S.A. on an individual basis. References to “Class B shares refer to shares of our Class B common stock and references to “ADSs” refer to American depositary shares representing our Class B shares, except where the context otherwise requires. References to our “2036 Notes” refer to our 9.75% Fixed/Floating Rate Non-Cumulative Junior Subordinated Bonds due 2036. References to our “2017 Notes” refer to our 8.50% Notes due 2017. Except where the context otherwise requires, reference to our “notes” refer to our 2036 Notes and our 2017 Notes.

The term “Argentina” refers to the Republic of Argentina. The terms “Argentine government” or the “government” refer to the federal government of Argentina, the term “Argentine Congress” refer to Argentine National Congress, the legislative branch of the government of Argentina, the term “Central Bank” refers to the Banco Central de la República Argentina, or the Argentine Central Bank, the term “Superintendency” refers to the Superintendencia de Entidades Financieras y Cambiarias or the Superintendency of Financial and Exchange Entities, the term “CNV” refers to the Comisión Nacional de Valores, or the Argentine Securities Commission, the term “MERVAL” refers to the Mercado de Valores de Buenos Aires, or the Buenos Aires Stock Market, the term “NYSE” refers to the New York Stock Exchange, the term “IGJ” refers to the Inspección General de Justicia, or Public Registry of Commerce and the term “ANSES” refers to the Administración Nacional de la Seguridad Social or National Social Security Agency.

The terms “U.S. dollar” and “U.S. dollars” and the symbol “US$” refer to the legal currency of the United States. The terms “Peso” and “Pesos” and the symbol “Ps.” refer to the legal currency of Argentina. “U.S. GAAP” refers to generally accepted accounting principles in the United States, “Argentine GAAP” refers to generally accepted accounting principles in Argentina and “Central Bank Rules” refers to the accounting and other regulations of the Central Bank. The term “INDEC” refers to the National Statistics Institute (Instituto Nacional de Estadísticas y Censos, “INDEC”).

The term “GDP” refers to gross domestic product and all references in this annual report to GDP growth are to real GDP growth. The term “CER,” or benchmark stabilization coefficient, is an index issued by the Argentine government which is used to adjust value of credits and deposits. Assets and liabilities indexed by CER were adjusted according to the Autonomous City of Buenos Aires Urban Consumer Price Index (Indice de Precios al Consumidor de la Ciudad Autónoma de Buenos Aires, the “IPCBA”) for the months of December 2015 and January 2016, that replaced the prior measurement. Pursuant to Resolution 100/2016, from the Ministry of Economy and Finance, as of February 2016 and up to April 25, 2016, the San Luis Urban Consumer Price Index (Índice de Precios al Consumidor de la Provincia de San Luís) will be used to adjust the CER.

Presentation of certain financial and other information

We maintain our financial books and records in Pesos and prepare and publish our consolidated financial statements in Argentina in conformity with Central Bank Rules, which differ in certain significant respects from U.S. GAAP and, to a certain extent, from Argentine GAAP. Our consolidated financial statements contain a description of the principal differences between Central Bank Rules and Argentine GAAP. Under Central Bank Rules, our consolidated financial statements were adjusted to account for the effects of wholesale-price inflation in Argentina for the periods through February 28, 2003. For the periods subsequent to February 28, 2003, the inflation adjustments were no longer applied to our consolidated financial statements under Central Bank Rules. In reviewing our financial statements, investors should consider that, in recent years, there have been significant changes in the prevailing prices of certain inputs and economic indicators, such as salary cost, interest and exchange rates, however, local regulations have not required the application of inflation adjustments to our consolidated financial statements.

Our consolidated financial statements consolidate the financial statements of the following companies:

 

  Banco del Tucumán S.A. (“Banco del Tucumán”)

 

  Macro Bank Limited (an entity organized under the laws of Bahamas)

 

  Macro Securities S.A.

 

  Macro Fiducia S.A.

 

  Macro Fondos S.G.F.C.I. S.A.

Our audited consolidated financial statements as of and for the three years ended December 31, 2015 included in this annual report have been reconciled to U.S. GAAP. See note 35 to our audited consolidated financial statements as of and for the three years ended December 31, 2015 for a reconciliation of our consolidated financial statements to U.S. GAAP. See also Item 5.A “Operating and Financial Review and Prospects” for a reconciliation of Central Bank Rules to U.S. GAAP.

Due to the modification of certain disclosure methods for certain items on the consolidated balance sheets and the consolidated statements of income, which did not affect the shareholders’ equity of the Bank, the consolidated financial statements as of December 31, 2012 were modified for the sole purpose of comparability with the consolidated financial statements as of December 31, 2013, 2014 and 2015.

 

2


Table of Contents

Our financial information in conformity with Central Bank Rules is sent on a monthly basis to the Central Bank and is published on its website www.bcra.gob.ar. In addition, we also file quarterly and annual financial statements with the Central Bank, the CNV, the MERVAL and the MAE.

Rounding

Certain figures included in this annual report have been subject to rounding adjustments. Accordingly, figures shown as totals in certain tables may not be an arithmetic aggregation of the figures that precede them.

Market position

We make statements in this annual report about our competitive position and market share in, and the market size of, the Argentine banking industry. We have made these statements on the basis of statistics and other information from third-party sources that we believe are reliable. Although we have no reason to believe any of this information or these reports are inaccurate in any material respect, we have not independently verified the competitive position, market share and market size or market growth data provided by third parties or by industry or general publications.

Our internet site is not part of this annual report

We maintain an internet site at www.macro.com.ar. Information contained in or otherwise accessible through this website is not a part of this annual report. All references in this annual report to this Internet site are inactive textual references to this URL, or “uniform resource locator” and are for your informational reference only.

Cautionary statement concerning forward-looking statements

This annual report contains certain statements that we consider to be “forward-looking statements”. We have based these forward-looking statements largely on our current beliefs, expectations and projections about future events and financial trends affecting our business. Many important factors, in addition to those discussed elsewhere in this annual report, could cause our actual results to differ substantially from those anticipated in our forward-looking statements, including, among other things:

 

    changes in general economic, business, political, legal, social or other conditions in Argentina and worldwide;

 

    effects of the global financial markets and economic crisis;

 

    deterioration in regional business and economic conditions;

 

    inflation;

 

    fluctuations and declines in the exchange rate of the Peso;

 

    changes in interest rates which may adversely affect financial margins;

 

    governmental intervention and regulation (including banking and tax regulations);

 

    adverse legal or regulatory disputes or proceedings;

 

    credit and other risks of lending, such as increases in defaults by borrowers and other delinquencies;

 

    increase in the provisions for loan losses;

 

    fluctuations and declines in the value of Argentine public debt;

 

    decrease in deposits, customers loss and revenue losses;

 

    competition in banking, financial services and related industries and the loss of market share;

 

    cost and availability of funding;

 

    technological changes, changes in consumer spending and saving habits, and inability to implement new technologies; and

 

    the risk factors discussed under Item 3.D “Risk factors’’.

The words “believe,” “may,” “will,” “aim,” “estimate,” “continue,” “anticipate,” “intend,” “expect,” “forecast” and similar words are intended to identify forward-looking statements. Forward-looking statements include information concerning our possible or assumed future results of operations, business strategies, financing plans, competitive position, industry environment, potential growth opportunities, the effects of future regulations and the effects of competition. Forward-looking statements speak only as of the date they were made, and

 

3


Table of Contents

we undertake no obligation to update publicly or to revise any forward-looking statements after we distribute this annual report because of new information, future events or other factors. In light of the risks and uncertainties described above, the forward-looking events and circumstances discussed in this annual report might not occur and are not guarantees of future performance.

Sections of this annual report that by their nature contain forward-looking statements include, but are not limited to, Item 3. “Key Information,” Item 4. “Information on the Bank,” Item 5. “Operating and Financial Review and Prospects” and Item 11. “Quantitative and Qualitative Disclosure About Market Risk”.

PART I

Item 1. Identity of Directors, Senior Management and Advisers

Not applicable.

Item 2. Offer Statistics and Expected Timetable

Not applicable.

Item 3. Key Information

A. Selected Financial Data

The following tables present summary historical consolidated financial data for each of the periods indicated. You should read this information in conjunction with our consolidated financial statements and related notes, and the information under Item 5. “Operating and Financial Review and Prospects” included elsewhere in this annual report.

We have derived our selected consolidated financial data as of and for the three years ended December 31, 2015 from our audited consolidated financial statements included in this annual report. We have derived our selected consolidated financial data for the years ended December 31, 2011, 2012 and 2013 from our audited consolidated financial statements not included in this annual report. Such financial information has been restated mainly due to the modification of certain disclosure methods for certain accounts and items on the consolidated balance sheets and consolidated statements of income, which did not affect the shareholders’ equity of the Bank. Solely for the convenience of the reader, the reference exchange rate for U.S. dollars as of December 31, 2015, as reported by the Central Bank was Ps.13.0050 to US$1.00. See Item 10. “Additional Information-Exchange-Controls” for additional information regarding Peso/U.S. dollar exchange ratios.

 

     Year Ended December 31,  
     2011 (1)     2012(1)     2013     2014     2015  
    

(in thousands of Pesos, except for number of shares,

net income per share and dividends per share)

 

Selected Consolidated Income Statement

          

Central Bank Rules:

          

Financial income

     4,698,648        6,904,370        9,753,531        14,682,649        20,109,123   

Financial expense

     (1,718,721     (2,827,590     (4,021,540     (6,582,561     (8,842,655

Gross intermediation margin

     2,979,927        4,076,780        5,731,991        8,100,088        11,266,468   

Provision for loan losses

     (273,224     (600,424     (540,032     (664,882     (877,134

Service charge income

     1,969,173        2,644,731        3,426,324        4,655,788        6,115,362   

Service charge expense

     (427,954     (685,392     (917,807     (1,215,759     (1,714,833

Administrative expenses

     (2,488,577     (3,115,385     (4,015,356     (5,498,879     (7,225,908

Other income

     190,560        196,662        253,214        351,203        409,172   

Other expense

     (105,839     (156,089     (143,688     (262,350     (443,684

Minority Interest in subsidiaries

     (10,111     (13,790     (18,173     (23,492     (35,359

Income Tax

     (657,858     (853,475     (1,332,909     (1,962,186     (2,485,663

Net income

     1,176,097        1,493,618        2,443,564        3,479,531        5,008,421   

Net income per share (2)

     1.98        2.56        4.18        5.95        8.57   

Dividends per share approved by the shareholders’ meeting

     0.00        0.00        1.02        1.02        1.10   

Dividends per share in US$ approved by the shareholders’ meeting

     0.00        0.00        0.16        0.12        0.08   

Dividends per share approved by the Central Bank

     0.00        0.00        1.02        0.39           (3) 

Dividends per share in US$ approved by the Central Bank

     0.00        0.00        0.16        0.05           (3) 

Number of outstanding shares (in thousands)

     584,485        584,485        584,485        584,563        584,563   

U.S. GAAP: (4)

          

Net income before extraordinary items

     1,198,411        1,551,994        2,479,680        3,572,933        4,947,144   

Extraordinary Gain

          

Less: Net income attributable to the non-controlling interest

     (8,380     (14,159     (18,521     (25,424     (37,299

Net income attributable to the controlling interest

     1,190,031        1,537,835        2,461,159        3,547,509        4,909,845   

Net income per share before extraordinary item(s)

     2.02        2.66        4.24        6.11        8.46   

Net income per share attributable to the controlling interest (5)

     2.01        2.63        4.21        6.07        8.40   

Weighted average number of outstanding shares (in thousands)

     593,220        584,485        584,485        584,537        584,563   

 

4


Table of Contents
(1) Due to the modification of certain disclosure methods used for certain items in the consolidated balance sheets and consolidated statements of income, figures have been restated for comparability purposes. See “Presentation of certain financial and other information.”
(2) Net income in accordance with Central Bank Rules divided by weighted average number of outstanding shares.
(3) For the fiscal year ended December 31, 2015 dividends are pending approval from the Central Bank as of the date of this annual report.
(4) See note 35 to our audited consolidated financial statements as of and for the three years ended December 31, 2015 for a summary of significant differences between Central Bank Rules and U.S. GAAP.
(5) Net income in accordance with U.S. GAAP divided by weighted average number of outstanding shares.

 

5


Table of Contents
     As of December 31,  
     2011 (1)     2012 (1)     2013     2014     2015  
     (in thousands of Pesos)  

Selected Consolidated Balance Sheet

          

Central Bank Rules:

          

Assets

          

Cash and due from banks and correspondents

     6,172,446        10,047,048        12,860,529        15,434,202        19,402,821   

Government and private securities

     4,396,862        2,343,078        2,441,316        10,312,498        15,391,372   

Loans:

          

to the non-financial government sector

     336,189        586,557        640,158        604,417        748,067   

to the financial sector

     343,282        299,250        364,897        213,867        227,390   

to the non-financial private sector and foreign residents

     24,238,011        31,203,946        39,023,795        44,108,055        62,852,922   

Allowances for loan losses

     (599,224     (887,156     (1,006,495     (1,186,044     (1,495,964

Other assets

     6,291,633        4,301,342        4,970,834        5,508,639        7,825,351   

Total assets

     41,179,199        47,894,065        59,295,034        74,995,634        104,951,959   

Average assets

     34,839,066        44,792,602        53,268,656        67,852,744        86,493,207   

Liabilities and shareholders’ equity

          

Deposits:

          

from the non-financial government sector

     5,836,211        8,318,383        6,580,041        8,570,055        9,588,378   

from the financial sector

     17,731        24,222        26,874        38,683        40,145   

from the non-financial private sector and foreign residents

     23,313,136        27,846,067        36,820,103        46,107,816        66,893,075   

Other liabilities from financial intermediation and other liabilities

     6,487,435        4,575,660        6,023,432        7,228,056        10,187,824   

Provisions

     112,816        131,683        159,381        171,923        259,493   

Subordinated corporate bonds

     647,753        740,192        981,142        1,287,317        1,957,618   

Items pending allocation

     6,981        7,408        7,128        6,966        21,039   

Minority interest in subsidiaries

     37,584        51,355        69,502        93,001        128,305   

Total liabilities

     36,459,647        41,694,970        50,667,603        63,503,817        89,075,877   

Shareholders’ equity

     4,719,552        6,199,095        8,627,431        11,491,817        15,876,082   

Average shareholders’ equity

     4,400,739        5,510,363        7,344,336        10,425,703        13,477,595   

U.S. GAAP: (2)

          

Shareholders’ equity attributable to the controlling interest

     4,325,759        5,876,589        8,332,414        11,323,047        15,740,455   

Non-controlling interests

     37,375        51,534        70,055        95,479        132,778   

Shareholders’ equity

     4,363,134        5,928,123        8,402,469        11,418,526        15,873,233   

 

(1) Due to the modification of certain disclosure methods defined for certain items in the consolidated balance sheets and consolidated statements of income, figures have been restated for comparability purposes. See “Presentation of certain financial and other information.”
(2) See note 35 to our audited consolidated financial statements as of and for the three years ended December 31, 2015 for a summary of significant differences between Central Bank Rules and U.S. GAAP.

 

     As of and for the year ended December 31,  
Selected consolidated ratios:    2011     2012     2013     2014     2015  

Profitability and performance

          

Net interest margin (%) (1)

     10.93        12.07        13.70        15.74        17.90   

Fee income ratio (%) (2)

     39.79        39.35        37.41        36.50        35.18   

Efficiency ratio (%) (3)

     50.28        46.35        43.84        43.11        41.57   

Ratio of earnings to fixed charges (excluding interest on deposits) (4)

     14.37     17.63     20.70     25.04     31.40

Ratio of earnings to fixed charges (including interest on deposits) (5)

     2.32     2.00     2.14     2.01     2.07

Fee income as a percentage of administrative expense (%)

     79.13        84.89        85.33        84.67        84.63   

Return on average equity (%)

     26.72        27.11        33.27        33.37        37.16   

Return on average assets (%)

     3.38        3.33        4.59        5.13        5.79   

Liquidity

          

Loans as a percentage of total deposits (%)

     85.43        88.67        92.17        82.11        83.41   

Liquid assets as a percentage of total deposits (%) (6)

     34.74        31.75        33.34        40.57        38.43   

Capital

          

Total equity as a percentage of total assets (%)

     11.46        12.94        14.55        15.32        15.13   

Regulatory capital as a percentage of risk-weighted assets (%)

     18.26        19.01        25.29        24.02        20.79   

Asset Quality

          

Non-performing loans as a percentage of total loans (%) (7)

     1.51        1.78        1.66        1.95        1.55   

Allowances for loan losses as a percentage of total loans

     2.40        2.76        2.51        2.64        2.34   

Allowances for loan losses as a percentage of non-performing loans (%) (7)

     159.16        155.39        151.67        135.29        151.48   

Differences due to court orders (Amparos) as a percentage of equity (%)

     1.08        0.00        0.00        0.00        0.00   

Operations

          

Number of branches

     414        428        430        434        439   

Number of employees (8)

     8,452        8,500        8,613        8,693        8,727   

 

6


Table of Contents
(1) Net interest income divided by average interest earning assets.
(2) Service charge income divided by the sum of gross intermediation margin and service charge income.
(3) Administrative expenses divided by the sum of gross intermediation margin and service charge income.
(4) For the purpose of computing the ratio of earnings to fixed charges excluding interest on deposits, earnings consist of income before income taxes plus fixed charges; fixed charges excluding interest on deposits consist of gross interest expense minus interest on deposits.
(5) For the purpose of computing the ratio of earnings to fixed charges including interest on deposits, earnings consist of income before income taxes plus fixed charges; fixed charges including interest on deposits is equal to gross interest expense.
(6) Liquid assets include cash, cash collateral, reverse repos, LEBACs and NOBACs and interfinancing loans.
(7) Non-performing loans include all loans to borrowers classified as “3- troubled/medium risk,” “4-with high risk of insolvency/high risk,” “5-irrecoverable” and “6-irrecoverable according to Central Bank’s Rules” under the Central Bank loan classification system.
(8) Were workers performing their duties pursuant to the “Acciones de entrenamiento para el trabajo” program of the Ministry of Labor, Employment and Social Security and other casual workers included, the number of employees of the Bank would have been 8,459, 8,534, 8,708, 8,728 and 8,765 for 2011, 2012, 2013, 2014 and 2015 respectively. We do not account for such workers as employees, as the Bank does not remunerate them for their services, which are paid directly by the Argentine province where they work.

B. Capitalization and Indebtedness

Not applicable.

C. Reasons for the Offer and Use of Proceeds

Not applicable.

D. Risk Factors

You should carefully consider the risks described below with all of the other information included in the annual report before deciding to invest in our Class B shares or our ADSs or our notes. If any of the following risks actually occurs, it may materially harm our business and our financial condition and results of operations. As a result, the market price of our Class B shares, our ADSs or our notes could decline and you could lose part or all of your investment.

Investors should carefully read this annual report in its entirety. They should also take into account and evaluate, among other things, their own financial circumstances, their investment goals, and the following risk factors.

Risks relating to Argentina

The Argentine economy remains vulnerable and any significant decline could adversely affect our financial condition

Presidential and congressional elections in Argentina took place on October 25, 2015, and a runoff election (ballotage) between the two leading presidential candidates was held on November 22, 2015, which resulted in Mr. Mauricio Macri being elected President of Argentina. The Macri administration assumed office on December 10, 2015.

Since assuming office, the Macri administration has announced several significant economic and policy reforms, including:

 

    INDEC reforms. The Macri administration appointed Mr. Jorge Todesca, previously a director of a private consulting firm, as head of the INDEC, the national statistics agency. It is expected that the INDEC will implement certain methodology reforms and adjust certain macroeconomic statistics on the basis of these reforms. Despite these expected reforms, there is uncertainty as to whether official data will be sufficiently reliable and within what time period such data will be revised, and what effect these reforms will have on the Argentine economy. In January 2016, the new INDEC authorities appointed by the Macri administration announced the discontinuance of the methodology used by the former administration and declared a state of administrative emergency, suspending the publication of all indices until the INDEC is able to calculate such indices based on accurate official data. In the meantime, during this period the INDEC is continuing to publish the inflation rate based on data provided by the province of San Luis and the city of Buenos Aires.

 

    Foreign exchange reforms. In addition, the Macri administration announced certain reforms to the foreign exchange market that are expected to provide greater flexibility and easier access to the foreign exchange market. The principal measures adopted as of the date hereof include (i) the elimination of the requirement to register foreign exchange transactions in the AFIP’s Exchange Transactions Consultation Program, (ii) the elimination of the requirement to transfer the proceeds of new financial indebtedness transactions into Argentina and settle such proceeds through the single and free floating foreign exchange market (the “MULC” as per the initials in Spanish) , (iii) the reestablishment of the US$2.0 million monthly limit per resident on the creation of offshore assets, (iv) a decrease to 0% (from 30%) of the registered, non-transferable and non-interest-bearing deposit required in connection with certain transactions involving foreign currency inflows, (v) the reduction of the required period that the proceeds of any new financial indebtedness incurred by residents, held by foreign creditors and transferred through the MULC must be kept in Argentina, from 365 calendar days to 120 calendar days from the date of transfer and (vi) the elimination of the requirement of a minimum holding period (72 business hours) for purchases and subsequent sales of the securities. In addition, on December 17, 2015, because certain restrictions were lifted, the Peso devalued against the U.S. dollar and, therefore, no assurance can be given that new restrictions on the foreign exchange market may arise. See “—Significant devaluation of the Peso against the U.S. dollar may adversely affect the Argentine economy” and “Exchange Controls.”

 

7


Table of Contents
    Foreign trade reforms. The Argentine government eliminated export duties on wheat, corn, beef, and regional products, and reduced the duty on soybeans by 5% to 30%. Further, the 5% export duty on most industrial exports was eliminated. With respect to payments for imports of goods and services to be performed abroad, no quantitative limitations remain in effect.

 

    Infrastructure state of emergency and reforms. The Argentine government has also declared a state of emergency with respect to the national electricity system, which will remain effective until December 31, 2017. The state of emergency will allow the Argentine government to take certain actions designed to guarantee the supply of electricity. The state of emergency will allow the Government to take actions designed to guarantee the supply of electricity to the country, such as instructing the Ministry of Energy to design and implement, with the cooperation of all federal public entities, a coordinated program to guarantee the quality and security of the electricity system. In addition, through Resolution No. 6/2016 of the Ministerio de Energía y Minería de la Nación (National Ministry of Energy and Mining) and Resolution No. 1/2016 of the Ente Nacional Regulador de la Electricidad (National Electricity Regulatory Agency), the Macri administration announced the elimination of certain energy subsidies currently in effect and a substantial increase in electricity rates. In addition, through Resolution No. 31/2016 of the Ministerio de Energía y Minería de la Nación (National Ministry of Energy and Mining), the Macri administration announced the elimination of certain subsidies to natural gas and adjustments to natural gas rates.

 

    Financial policy: Soon after taking office the Macri administration sought to settle the outstanding claims with holdout creditors. On April 22, 2016 the new Argentine administration issued bonds in an aggregate amount of US$16.5 billion, which proceeds were partially used to pay holdouts with whom there was an agreement.

As of the date hereof, the impact that these measures and any future measures taken by the new administration will have on the Argentine economy as a whole and the financial sector in particular cannot be predicted. In addition, there is uncertainty as to which measures announced during the presidential campaign of the Macri administration will be taken and when. We cannot predict how the Macri administration will address certain other political and economic issues that were central during the presidential election campaign, such as the financing of public expenditures, public service subsidies and tax reforms, or the impact that any measures related to these issues that are implemented by the Macri administration will have on the Argentine economy as a whole. In addition, political parties opposed to the Macri administration retained a majority of the seats in the Argentine Congress in the recent elections, which will require the Macri administration to seek political support from the opposition for its economic proposals and creates further uncertainty as to the ability of the Macri administration to obtain approval of any measure which it seeks to implement. Political uncertainty in Argentina relating to the measures to be taken by the Macri administration could lead to volatility in the market prices of securities of Argentine companies, including in particular companies in the financial sector, such as ours, given the high degree of regulatory oversight and involvement in this sector.

Argentina’s economic performance may not be sustainable.

The Argentine economy has experienced significant volatility in recent decades, with periods of low or negative growth, high inflation and currency devaluation. Since the 2001 economic crisis, Argentina recovered significantly by increasing at a substantial level its real GDP, at an average of 8.5% on annual basis between 2003 and 2008. As a result of the 2008 world economic crisis, Argentina GDP´s growth rate decreased up to 0.9% in 2009, but it returned to 9.2% growth in 2010 and 8.9% growth in 2011. During 2012, the Argentine economy experienced a slowdown with GDP increasing at a rate of 1.9%. In March 2014, the Argentine government announced a new method of calculating GDP as requested by the International Monetary Fund (“IMF”) (using 2004 as the base year instead of 1993, which was the base reference year used in the prior method of GDP calculation).

Following changes in the methodology used in calculating GDP, INDEC reported that Argentina´s GDP´s growth rate for 2013 was 3%, and 0.5% for 2014. On March 30, 2016, INDEC published preliminary GDP information for 2015, according to which GDP grew by 2.1% in 2015.

The inflation rate in December 2015 was 6.5% based on data provided by the province of San Luis and 3.9% based on data provided by the City of Buenos Aires.

A less favorable international economic environment, a lack of stability, competitiveness of the Peso against other foreign currencies, the low level of confidence among consumers and foreign and domestic investors, a higher inflation rate and future political uncertainties, among other factors, may affect the development of the Argentine economy and cause volatility in the local capital markets.

Substantially all our operations, properties and customers are located in Argentina. As a result, our business is to a very large extent dependent upon the economic, social and political conditions prevailing in Argentina. No assurance can be given that future economic, social and political developments in Argentina, over which we have no control, will not have a material adverse effect on our business, financial condition and results of operations.

The Argentine economy could be adversely affected by economic developments in the global markets.

 

8


Table of Contents

Financial and securities markets in Argentina are influenced by economic and market conditions in other markets worldwide. The international scenario shows contradictory signals of global growth, as well as high financial and exchange uncertainty. The global financial crisis that commenced in the last quarter of 2008, and from which many economies have not yet fully recovered, negatively affected the economies of several countries around the world, including Argentina and certain of its trading partners. In late 2011, the global financial system experienced unprecedented volatility and disruption. The resulting financial turmoil caused greater restrictions on access to credit, low liquidity, extreme volatility in foreign exchange markets and securities, and capital flight from emerging markets, including Argentina. In this context, and for the first time in history, on August 5, 2011, Standard & Poor’s Financial Services downgraded the debt instruments issued by the United States from “AAA” to “AA+”. The year 2015 presented a similarly challenging global macroeconomic environment which included foreign exchange volatility and lower prices of commodities.

Moreover, emerging economies have been affected by the change in the U.S. monetary policy, resulting in the sharp unwinding of speculative asset positions, depreciations and increased volatility in the value of their currencies and higher interest rates. The general appreciation of the U.S. dollar resulting from a more restrictive U.S. monetary policy contributed to the fall of the international price of raw materials, increasing the difficulties of emerging countries which are exporters of these products.

Although economic conditions vary from country to country, investors’ perceptions of events occurring in other countries have in the past and may continue to substantially affect capital flows into and investments in securities from issuers in other countries, including Argentina. A prolonged slowdown in economic activity in Argentina or negative effects on the Argentine financial system or the securities markets would adversely affect our business, financial condition and results of operations.

Argentina’s economy is vulnerable to external shocks that could be caused by significant economic difficulties of its major regional trading partners or by more general “contagion” effects.

Argentina’s economy is vulnerable to adverse developments affecting its principal trading partners. A significant decline in the economic growth of any of Argentina’s major trading partners, such as Brazil, China or the United States, could have a material adverse impact on Argentina’s trade balance and adversely affect Argentina’s economic growth. The economic performance of other trading partners such as Chile, Spain and Canada may also affect Argentina’s trade balance.

Economic conditions in South America have recently been adversely impacted by falling commodity prices and political uncertainty. More specifically, the current devaluation of the Brazilian currency and the slowdown of its economy may negatively affect the Argentine economy, and in turn, our business and results of operations.

Global economic slowdowns and uncertainty have led to declines in exports in 2015 of 23% with Mercosur (including Brazil), 22% with NAFTA (USA and Canada), 19% with the European Union and 9% with Chile, each as compared to 2014. Declining demand for Argentine exports could have a material adverse effect on Argentina’s economic growth.

Because international investors’ reactions to the events occurring in one market sometimes demonstrate a “contagion” effect in which an entire region or class of investment is disfavored by international investors, Argentina could be adversely affected by negative economic or financial developments in other countries. This “contagion” effect, in turn, may have an adverse effect on our business, financial condition and results of operations.

Argentina’s ability to obtain financing from international markets is limited, which may impair its ability to implement reforms and public policies and foster economic growth.

Argentina’s 2001 default and its failure to fully restructure its sovereign debt and negotiate with the holdout creditors has limited and may continue to limit Argentina’s ability to access international capital markets. In 2005, Argentina completed the restructuring of a substantial portion of its indebtedness and settled all of its debt with the IMF. Additionally, in June 2010, Argentina completed the renegotiation of approximately 67% of the defaulted bonds that were not swapped in the 2005 restructuring. As a result of the 2005 and 2010 debt swaps, Argentina has restructured approximately 91% of its defaulted debt that was eligible for restructuring. Holdout creditors that declined to participate in the exchanges commenced numerous lawsuits against Argentina in several countries, including the United States, Italy, Germany, and Japan. Additionally, on May 29, 2014, the Argentine government and representatives of the Paris Club creditors reached an agreement to clear Argentina’s debt due to the Paris Club creditors, in arrears, in the total amount of US$9.7 billion as of April 30, 2014.

In related cases brought before the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York (the “District Court”), the plaintiffs argued that allowing Argentina to make payments under the new bonds issued pursuant to the debt swaps while it remained in default on its pre-2002 bonds violates the pari passu clause in the original bonds and entitles the plaintiffs to injunctive relief barring Argentina from making payments on the new bonds without making comparable payments on the original bonds. In late October 2012, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit in New York affirmed the District Court’s ruling that the pari passu clause in the pre-2002 bonds prevents Argentina from making payments unless it makes ratable payments to the holdout creditors at the same time. On November 21, 2012, the District Court specified that ratable payments to the holdout creditors would be the full amount owed on the bonds (including interest) and ordered Argentina to pay approximately US$1.3 billion plus interest owed to the holdout creditors party to such proceedings.

On appeal, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit ordered Argentina to submit a payment plan proposal for the holdout creditors, which Argentina did on March 29, 2013. On August 23, 2013, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit rejected Argentina’s payment proposal and affirmed the District Court’s November 21, 2012 injunctions.

 

9


Table of Contents

On or about June 27, 2014, Argentina transferred to The Bank of New York Mellon, in its capacity as trustee, amounts due June 30, 2014 in respect of certain of its restructured bonds. The District Court, however, prohibited such payment and ordered Argentina and the holders of its non-restructured bonds to agree on a payment schedule. Following negotiations between Argentina and the litigating bondholders, Argentina and such bondholders failed to reach an agreement in respect of its defaulted debt. By July 30, 2014, the end of the grace period provided under Argentina’s relevant restructured bonds for the payment of debt service thereunder, Argentina and the holdout creditors had not arrived on an agreement and The Bank of New York Mellon complied with the order of the District Court to not deliver the funds previously deposited by Argentina for payment to the holders of the restructured bonds under foreign law. While Argentina asserted that it complied with its obligation to the holders of the restructured bonds by making such deposit, and that the indenture trustee had the obligation to deliver such payment, on such date Standard & Poor’s Rating Services downgraded Argentina’s foreign currency credit rating to “selective default”, or “SD”, while on July 31, 2014, Fitch Ratings Inc. downgraded Argentina’s foreign currency issuer default rating to “restricted default”, or “RD”.

After the pari passu injunction became effective, litigation continued regarding Argentina’s efforts to make payments to exchange bondholders. These payments have been made, however, the chain of payments has been interrupted as a consequence of judicial orders, and various exchange bondholders have sought release of such funds through litigation before the District Court and in various jurisdictions. As of the date hereof, litigation initiated by the litigating bondholders seeking payments from Argentina continues in the U.S. and in courts in other jurisdictions.

The Macri administration engaged in negotiations with holders of defaulted bonds in December 2015. In February 2016, the Argentine government entered into an agreement in principle to settle with certain holders of defaulted debt and put forward a proposal to other holders of defaulted debt, including those with pending claims in U.S. courts, subject to two conditions: obtaining approval by the Argentine Congress and the lifting of the pari passu injunctions.

On March 2, 2016 the District Court ordered that the pari passu injunctions, be automatically lifted upon fulfillment of two conditions: (i) Argentina repealing all legislative obstacles to settlement with holdout bondholders, including certain lock laws (Law No. 26,017, Law No. 26,547 and Law No. 26,886) and the Sovereign Payment Law (Law No. 26,984) (which have already been repealed); and (ii) Argentina making full payment with respect to agreements in principle entered into between plaintiffs and Argentina on or before February 29, 2016 in accordance with the specific terms of such preliminary agreements. The District Court’s order was appealed and the Court of Appeals confirmed the ruling on April 13, 2016.

 

10


Table of Contents

In addition, on March 31, 2016, Congress approved the law, thereby repealing the legislative obstacles to settlement and approval of Argentina’s settlement proposal

On April 22, 2016 the new Argentine administration issued bonds in an aggregate amount of US$16.5 billion, which proceeds were partially used to pay holdouts with whom there was an agreement.

Not all creditors have agreed to settle on Argentina’s proposed terms. The continuation and outcome of this litigation may continue to prevent Argentina from obtaining favorable terms or interest rates when accessing international capital markets. Litigation initiated by holdout creditors or other parties may result in material judgments against the Argentine government and could result in attachments of, or injunctions relating to, Argentina’s assets, which could have a material adverse effect on the country’s economy and affect our ability to access international financing. In addition, litigation initiated by holdouts could eventually bring Argentina to be considered in default of its obligations and cause acceleration of the existing exchange debt due to cross default clauses which could have a material adverse effect on the on the country’s economy, and consequently, our business, financial condition and results of operations.

Argentina is subject to litigation by foreign shareholders of Argentine companies and holders of Argentina’s defaulted bonds, which have resulted and may result in adverse judgments or injunctions against Argentina’s assets and limit its financial resources.

Foreign shareholders of several Argentine companies, including public utilities, and bondholders that did not participate in the exchange offers described above, have filed claims in excess of US$20 billion in the aggregate with the International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes (the ‘‘ICSID’’) alleging that the emergency measures adopted by the government differ from the just and equal treatment standards set forth in several bilateral investment treaties to which Argentina is a party. As of the date hereof, there are four final awards issued by ICSID tribunals against Argentina in the aggregate amount of US$470.66 million and Argentina is seeking the annulment of four additional awards in the aggregate amount of US$831.73 million. There are six ongoing cases against Argentina before ICSID with claims totaling US$2.2 billion (including two cases with claims for amounts that are currently undetermined), and in three of these cases (with aggregate claims for US$2.1 billion) the ICSID tribunal has already ruled that it has jurisdiction over the claims. There are eight additional cases with claims totaling US$6.17 billion in which the parties agreed to suspend the proceedings pending settlement discussions.

Furthermore, the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law (“UNCITRAL”) under the rules of the International Chamber of Commerce (“ICC”) has issued rulings against. As of the date hereof, there are three final awards against Argentina for an aggregate total of US$246.27 million and Argentina is seeking the annulment of an additional award for US$96,509. There are three ongoing cases against Argentina before UNCITRAL and ICC tribunals with claims totaling US$625.08 million, including one case with a US$507.80 million claim in which the tribunal has already ruled that it has jurisdiction over the case. There is one additional case with a claim of US$168.69 million in which the parties agreed to suspend the proceedings pending settlement discussions.

Litigation, as well as ICSID and UNCITRAL claims against the Argentine government, have resulted in material judgments and may result in new material judgments against the government, and could result in attachments of or injunctions relating to assets of Argentina that the government intended for other uses. As a result, the Argentine government may not have all the necessary financial resources to honor its obligations, implement reforms and foster growth, which could have a material adverse effect on the country’s economy, and consequently, our business, financial condition and results of operations.

Government intervention could adversely affect the Argentine economy.

Substantially all our operations, properties and customers are located in Argentina. As a result, our business is to a very large extent dependent upon the political, social and economic conditions prevailing in Argentina. In recent years, the Argentine government has increased its direct intervention in the economy and in private sector operations and companies, limiting certain aspects of private sector businesses.

In May 2013, the Argentine Congress passed a law providing for the expropriation of 51% of the share capital of YPF (Yacimientos Petroliferos Fiscales S.A.), the principal Argentine oil company, which shares were owned by Repsol, S.A. and its affiliates. In February 2015, the Argentine government sent a bill to the Congress in order to revoke certain train concessions, return the national rail network to state control and provide powers to review all concessions currently in force. The bill was enacted on May 20, 2015 as Law No. 27,132.

In addition, on September 23, 2015 the Congress passed Law No. 27,181, which limits the sale of the Argentine government’s shares held in Argentine companies without prior approval of two-thirds of the members of Congress, with the exception of the Argentine government’s shareholding in YPF.

Furthermore, financial institutions operate in a highly regulated environment. See “—The amendment of the Central Bank’s Charter and the Convertibility Law may adversely affect the Argentine economy” and “—Governmental measures and regulatory framework affecting financial entities could have a material adverse effect on the operations of financial entities”. As of the date of this annual report, several different bills to amend the Financial Institutions Law No. 21,526 as amended (the “Financial Institution Law”) have been put forth for review in the Argentine Congress, seeking to amend different aspects of the Financial Institutions Law. A thorough amendment of the Financial Institutions Law would have a substantial effect on the banking system as a whole.

 

11


Table of Contents

Moreover, the Argentine government has in the past enacted laws and regulations requiring private sector companies to maintain certain salary levels and provide their employees with additional benefits. Employers, both in the public and private sector, have also been experiencing intense pressures from their personnel, or from the labor unions representing them, demanding salary increases and certain benefits for the workers, given the high inflation rates.

Actions taken by the Argentine government concerning the economy, including decisions with respect to interest rates, taxes, price controls, salary increases, provision of additional employee benefits foreign exchange controls and potential changes in the foreign exchange market, have had and could continue to have a material adverse effect on Argentina´s economic growth and in turn affect our financial condition and results of operations. In addition, any additional Argentine government policies to preempt, or in response to, social unrest could adversely and materially affect the economy, and thereby our business.

Expropriations, interventions and other direct involvement by the Argentine government in the economy may have an adverse impact on the level of foreign investment in Argentina, the access of Argentine companies like us to the international financial markets and Argentina’s commercial and diplomatic relations with other countries.

Argentina’s foreign trade measures may lead to a decrease in exports and retaliation by trading partners.

In 2012, the Argentine government introduced a procedure pursuant to which local authorities must pre-approve the import of products and services to Argentina as a pre-condition to permit such import and the consequent access to the foreign exchange market for the payment of the imported products or services. Members of Mercosur and other countries have complained against these measures, and some have filed claims against Argentina with the World Trade Organization. In response to such claims, in January 2016, the Macri administration established a new regime for the import of goods and services named Sistema Integral de Monitoreo de Importaciones (Integral System of Monitoring of Imports) which follows the main guidelines set forth by the World Trade Organization for easing restrictions and applicable procedures for the approval of import of products and services in Argentina.

During recent years under the former administration, the Argentine government has issued regulations and taken certain actions seeking to control the value of the Peso and offset mismatches on the country’s balance of payments. Such measures or other similar measures that may be taken in the future, among others, may affect diplomatic commercial relations among Argentina and its trading partners, as well as the trade balance.

With respect to payments for imports of goods and services to be performed abroad, the Macri administration announced the gradual elimination of amount limitations for access to the MULC for transactions originated before December, 17, 2015, which will be totally eliminated as of June 2016. No quantitative limitation will apply for import transactions carried out after December 17, 2015.

Repeated complaints from various countries against past or future import restrictions implemented by Argentina, suspension of export preferences or retaliations by trading partners may have an adverse effect on Argentine exports, affect the trade balance and, consequently, adversely impact Argentina’s economy. Diminished foreign trade would also adversely impact our business, financial condition and results of operations.

Exchange controls and capital inflow and outflow restrictions have limited, and could continue to limit, the availability of international credit and may impair our ability to make payments on our obligations.

Since 2002, Argentina has imposed exchange controls and transfer restrictions substantially limiting the ability of companies to retain foreign currency or make payments abroad. In June 2005, the government issued Decree No. 616/2005, which established additional controls on capital inflows and outflows.

In addition, from 2011 until President Macri assumed office, the Argentine government increased controls on the sale of foreign currency and the acquisition of foreign assets by local residents, limiting the possibility of transferring funds abroad. Regulations were issued in 2012, pursuant to which certain foreign exchange transactions were subject to prior approval by Argentine tax authorities. During the former administration, through a combination of foreign exchange and tax regulations, the Argentine authorities significantly curtailed access to the foreign exchange market by individuals and private-sector entities. Furthermore, during the last few years under the former administration, the Central Bank has exercised a de facto prior approval power for certain foreign exchange transactions otherwise authorized to be carried out under the applicable regulations, such as dividend payments or repayment of principal of inter-company loans as well as the import of goods, by means of regulating the amount of foreign currency available to financial institutions to conduct such transactions.

The number of exchange controls introduced in the past under the former administration gave rise to an unofficial U.S. dollar trading market, and the Peso/U.S. dollar exchange rate in such market substantially differed from the official Peso/U.S. dollar exchange rate. Certain relevant foreign exchange restrictions were lifted in December 2015 and, as a result, such spread has substantially decreased. For more information, see Item 10.D “Exchange Controls”.

The level of international reserves deposited with the Central Bank significantly decreased from US$47.4 billion as of November 1, 2011 to US$25.4 billion as of December 31, 2015, resulting in a reduced capacity of the Argentine government to intervene in the foreign exchange market and to provide access to such markets to private sector entities like us. Furthermore, on January 29, 2016, the Central Bank entered into a repo agreement with a syndicate of international banks for an aggregate amount of approximately US$5 billion in order to obtain additional liquidity support against the current uncertain environment in the international capital markets. Pursuant to such, as of March 31, 2016 the level of international reserves deposited with the Central Bank was US$29.6 billion.

 

12


Table of Contents

Despite the measures recently adopted by the new administration, in the future the Argentine government could impose further exchange controls, transfer restrictions, required repatriation through the MULC of proceeds raised through capital markets transactions conducted abroad or restrictions on the movement of capital and/or take other measures in response to capital flight or a significant depreciation of the Peso, which could limit our ability to access the international capital markets. Such measures could lead to political and social tensions and undermine the Argentine government’s public finances, as has occurred in the past, which could adversely affect Argentina’s economy and prospects for economic growth, which, in turn, could adversely affect our business and results of operations.

Additional controls may adversely affect Argentine entities’ ability to access the international capital markets for credit. Furthermore, the imposition of any future restrictions on the transfer of funds abroad may impede our ability to transfer dividends to ADS holders or interest or principal payments to the holders of our notes.

Severe or sustained declines in the international prices for Argentina’s main commodity exports or the occurrence of a climate disaster could have an adverse effect on Argentina’s economic growth.

High commodity prices have in the past contributed significantly to increases in Argentine exports as well as in governmental revenues from export taxes (witholdings). Argentina’s reliance on the export of certain commodities, such as soy, has made the Argentine economy more vulnerable to fluctuations in their prices.

Recently, commodity prices have suffered declines. If international commodity prices were to further decline or experience sustained declines, the Argentine government’s revenues would further decrease significantly affecting Argentina’s economic activity. Accordingly, declines in international commodity prices may adversely affect Argentina’s economy, which in turn would produce a negative impact on our financial condition and results of operations.

In addition, adverse weather conditions can affect production of commodities by the agricultural sector, which account for a significant portion of Argentina’s export revenues. These circumstances would have a negative impact on the levels of government revenues, availability of foreign exchange and the government’s ability to service its sovereign debt, and could either generate recessionary or inflationary pressures, depending on the government’s reaction. The occurrence of any of the above would adversely impact Argentina’s economy growth and, therefore, our business, financial condition and results of operations.

An increase in inflation could have a material adverse effect on Argentina’s economic prospects.

In recent years, Argentina has experienced inflationary pressures, including in the form of significantly higher fuel, energy and food prices. According to inflation data published by the INDEC, the Argentine consumer price index (“CPI”) increased 10.8% in 2012 and 10.9% in 2013 and the wholesale price index increased 13.1% in 2012 and 14.8% in 2013

The accuracy of the statistical information released by the INDEC, the only institution in Argentina with the statutory authority to produce official nationwide statistics, has been called into question by the IMF and numerous private sector participants. In February 2014, the INDEC created a new index, the National Urban Consumer Price Index (Índice de Precios al Consumidor Nacional Urbano, the “IPCNU”), that aims to more broadly reflect changes in consumer prices by measuring 520 products and services in all of Argentina’s 23 provincial capitals, the City of Buenos Aires and other major cities in the country, which total 40 urban areas. This new index demonstrated an inflation rate of 23.9% in 2014 and 11.9% in the ten-month period ended October 31, 2015. The wholesale price index increased 28.3% in 2014 and 10.6% in the ten-month period ended October 31, 2015.

In January 2016, the new INDEC authorities appointed by the Macri administration announced the discontinuance of the methodology used by the prior administration to calculate national statistics and declared a state of administrative emergency, suspending the publication of all indices until the INDEC is able to calculate such indices based on accurate official data. As a result, pursuant to this INDEC reform process, the IPCNU is not being published as of the date of this report. In the meantime, during this period the INDEC is continuing to publish the inflation rate based on data provided by the province of San Luis and the City of Buenos Aires. According to the reports of each of these jurisdictions, the inflation rate in November and December 2015 was 2.9% and 6.5%, respectively, based on data provided by the province of San Luis and 2.0% and 3.9% respectively, based on data provided by City of Buenos Aires. In January and February 2016, the monthly inflation rate as measured by the City of Buenos Aires was 4.1% and 4.0%, respectively, while according to the Province of San Luis, the inflation rate was 4.2% and 2.7%, respectively.

In addition, during 2013, 2014 and 2015, the former administration imposed price controls on certain goods and services to control inflation. The Macri administration has stated its intention to keep these price controls in effect, but as of the date of this report, there is uncertainty regarding specifically how the Macri administration will maintain such controls.

In the past, inflation has materially undermined the Argentine economy and Argentina’s ability to create conditions that would permit growth. High inflation may also undermine Argentina’s competitiveness abroad and lead to a decline in private consumption which, in turn, also affects employment levels, salaries and interest rates. Moreover, a high inflation rate could undermine confidence in the Argentine financial system, reducing the Peso deposit base and negatively impacting long-term credit markets.

There can be no assurance that inflation rates will not continue to escalate in the future or that the measures adopted or that may be adopted by the Argentine government to control inflation will be effective or successful. Inflation remains a challenge for Argentina. Significant inflation could have a material adverse effect on Argentina’s economy and in turn could increase our costs of operation, in particular labor costs, and may negatively impact our financial condition and results of operations. See “—Failure by the Argentine government to follow the International Monetary Fund’s recommendations could further strain relations with the IMF”.

 

13


Table of Contents

Failure by the Argentine government to follow the International Monetary Fund’s recommendations could further strain relations with the IMF.

During the past years, Argentina’s relations with the IMF have been strained. Due to generalized complaints against INDEC’s quality of official data, in December 2010, Argentina accepted to begin working with the IMF for technical assistance in order to prepare a new CPI with the aim of modernizing the current statistical system. During the first quarter of 2011, a team from the IMF started working in conjunction with the INDEC. In addition, on February 1, 2013 the IMF issued a declaration of censure against Argentina in connection with its failure to address the quality of the official data reported to the IMF for CPI and Gross Domestic Product (GDP). Furthermore, on December 9, 2013 the IMF recognized Argentina’s ongoing work and intention to introduce a new national CPI in early 2014. The IMF also noted that Argentina was working to address shortcomings in its GDP data.

As a result, the IMF adopted a decision calling on Argentina to implement specified actions to address the quality of its official CPI and GDP data according to a specified timetable. Such specified actions include the public release of a new national CPI and revised GDP estimates, by the end of March 2014. On February 13, 2014, the INDEC published the IPCNU, agreed by the IMF. Moreover, in March 2014, the Argentine government announced a new method of calculating GDP (using 2004 as the base year instead of 1993, which was the base reference year used in the prior method of GDP calculation).

In December 15, 2014, the IMF recognized the progress of Argentine authorities to remedy the inaccurate provision of data, but has delayed the definitive evaluation of the new index.

If in the future, the IMF finds that the methodology of INDEC for calculating a national consumer price index or GDP is inaccurate, or concludes that its methodology must be adjusted, this could create adverse financial and economic effects for Argentina, including an inability to secure financing from such organization. If these measures were to be adopted, the Argentine economy could suffer adverse effects, either by limiting access to international financial markets or increasing the financing cost associated therewith, which in turn would adversely affect our financial condition and results of operations.

Although the future relationship between the Argentine government and the IMF still remains uncertain as of the date hereof, during January, 2016 the Macri administration has publicly announced its intention to willingly submit to the IMF’s periodic supervision and recommendations made pursuant to Section IV of the IMF’s Articles of Agreement, in an attempt to reestablish a more stable relationship between the Argentine government and the IMF in the near future.

Significant devaluation of the Peso against the U.S. dollar may adversely affect the Argentine economy.

Despite the positive effects of the real depreciation of the Peso on the competitiveness of certain sectors of the Argentine economy, it also had a far-reaching negative impact on the Argentine economy and on the financial condition of businesses and individuals. The devaluation of the Peso had a negative impact on the ability of Argentine businesses to honor their foreign currency-denominated debt, led to very high inflation initially, significantly reduced real wages, had a negative impact on businesses whose success is dependent on domestic market demand, such as utilities and the financial industry.

After several years of moderate variations in the nominal exchange rate, the stock of the international reserves of the Central Bank started to decrease and in order to contain the fall in reserves the Central Bank accelerated the rate of nominal devaluation of the Peso. During 2013 the Peso lost more than 30% of its value with respect to the U.S. Dollar and the same occurred during 2014. In 2015, the Peso lost approximately 52% of its value with respect to the U.S. Dollar. This was followed by a devaluation of the Peso with respect to the U.S. Dollar of approximately 12% in March 31, 2016. The stock of international reserves of the Central Bank was US$25.6 billion as of December 31, 2015 and US$29.6 billion as of March 31, 2016.

The Argentine macroeconomic environment, in which we operate, was affected by such devaluation which had an impact on our financial and economic position. If the Peso devalues significantly, all of the negative effects on the Argentine economy related to such devaluation could recur, with adverse consequences to our business, financial condition and results of operations.

High public expenditure could result in long lasting adverse consequences for the Argentine economy.

During the last few years, the Argentine government has substantially increased public expenditure. In 2015, public sector expenditure increased by 38% year over year and the government reported primary fiscal deficit. During recent years, the Argentine government has resorted to the Central Bank and to the ANSES to source part of its funding requirements.

In light of increasingly tight public finances, the Argentine government has commenced revising its subsidy policies, particularly those related to energy, electricity and gas, water and public transportation. Changes in these policies could materially and adversely impact consumer purchase capacity and economic activity and lead to an increase in prices, because they occur in a context of high inflation and high interest rates.

We cannot assure you that the government will not seek to finance its deficit by gaining access to the liquidity available in the local financial institutions. In that case, government initiatives that increase the exposure of local financial institutions to the public sector would affect our liquidity and assets quality and impact negatively on clients’ confidence.

 

14


Table of Contents

In addition, a further deterioration in fiscal accounts could negatively affect the government’s ability to access the international financing markets and could result in increased pressure on the Argentine private sector to cover the government’s financial needs. This would adversely impact the Argentine economy and our financial condition and results of operations.

The amendment of the Central Bank’s Charter and the Convertibility Law may adversely affect the Argentine economy.

On March 22, 2012, the Argentine Congress passed Law No. 26,739, which amended the charter of the Central Bank (the “Central Bank’s Charter”) and Law No. 23,298 (the “Convertibility Law”). This law amended the principal objectives of the Central Bank and removed certain provisions previously in force. Pursuant to the amendment, the Central Bank focuses on promoting monetary and financial stability as well as development with social equity.

The key component of the amendment of the Central Bank Charter related to the use of the international reserves and the implementation of polices by the Central Bank in order to interfere in the fixing of interest rates and terms of loans to financial institutions. Pursuant to the amendment, Central Bank reserves may be made available to the government for the repayment of debt or to finance public expenses. During 2013, the currency reserves in U.S. dollars held by the Argentine government in the Central Bank significantly decreased, from US$44.3 billion in 2012 to US$30.6 billion in 2013. During 2014, the reserves slightly increased to US$31.4 billion, and reduced again over 2015 to US$ 25.6 billion as of December 31, 2015. The stock of the international reserves of the Central Bank was US$29.6 billion as of March 31, 2016.

The use of Central Bank reserves for the expanded purposes may result in Argentina being more vulnerable to inflation or external shocks, affecting the country’s capacity to overcome the effects of an external crisis.

Risks relating to the Argentine financial system

The health of Argentina’s financial system depends on the growth of long-term credit market.

In recent years, the loan portfolio of the Argentine financial system has grown significantly. Loans to the private sector grew by approximately 31% in 2013, 20% in 2014 and 37% in 2015 for the financial system as a whole. In spite of the recovery of credit activity, the long-term loans market (pledged loans and mortgage loans) did not grow at the same pace and grew only 19% to the private sector in 2015.

Since most deposits are short-term deposits, a substantial portion of the loans must have the same or similar maturities, and there is a small portion of long-term credit lines.

The uncertainty of the level of inflation for future years is a principal obstacle preventing a faster recovery of Argentina’s private sector long-term lending. This uncertainty has had and may continue to have a significant impact on both the supply of and demand for long-term loans as borrowers try to hedge against inflation risk by borrowing at fixed rates while lenders hedge against inflation risk by offering loans at floating rates.

If longer-term financial intermediation activity does not grow, the ability of financial institutions, including us, to generate profits will be negatively affected.

The health of the financial system depends upon the ability of financial institutions, including us, to retain the confidence of depositors.

As a consequence of the 2008 global economic crisis, the banking industry in Argentina suffered a significant slowdown. This trend was reversed by the end of 2009. Total deposits with the financial system increased by 26% in 2013, 30% in 2014 and 38% in 2015, but the ratio of total financial system deposits to GDP is still low when compared to international levels and lower than the periods prior to the crisis. The average total deposits of the Argentine financial system represented 19% of GDP during 2015.

In spite of the positive trend in previous years, the deposit base of the Argentine financial system, including ours, may be affected in the future by adverse economic, social and political events. If there were a loss of confidence due to such economic, social and political events causing depositors to withdraw significant holdings from banks, there would be a substantial negative impact on the manner in which financial institutions, including us, conduct their business and on their ability to operate as financial intermediaries. International loss of confidence in the financial institutions may also affect the behavior of Argentine depositors.

The asset quality of financial institutions, including us, may be affected by exposure to public sector debt.

Financial institutions hold bonds of, and extend loans to, the Argentine federal and provincial governments as part of their portfolios. Exposure to public sector of the financial system has decreased year after year, from 48.9% in 2002 to 2.9% in 2015.

As of December 31, 2015, our exposure to the public sector, not including Lebacs (Letras del Banco Central) and Nobacs (Notas del Banco Central), totaled approximately Ps. 5.3 billion, representing 5.0% of our total assets.

 

15


Table of Contents

To some extent, the value of the assets held by Argentine banks, as well as their income generation capacity, is dependent on the Argentine public sector’s creditworthiness, which is in turn dependent on the government’s ability to promote sustainable long-term economic growth, generate tax revenues and control public spending.

Our asset quality and that of other financial institutions may deteriorate if the Argentine private sector is affected by economic events in Argentina or international macroeconomic conditions.

The capacity of many Argentine private sector debtors to repay their loans has in the past deteriorated as a result of certain economic events in Argentina or macroeconomic conditions, materially affecting the asset quality of financial institutions, including us.

From 2009 to 2011, the ratio of non-performing private sector lending declined overall, with a record minimum ratio of 1.4% as of December 31, 2011 for the financial system as a whole. These improvements were reflected in both the consumer loan portfolio and the commercial portfolio. From 2012, the ratio of non-performing private sector lending increased, standing at 1.9% as of December 31, 2014. During 2015, the ratio of non-performing private sector lending decreased to 1.6% for the financial system as a whole.

Our credit portfolio quality ratio followed the financial system trend standing at 1.5% for our entire portfolio, as of December 31, 2015. During 2015 our coverage ratio reached 151%.

Despite the quality of our portfolio, we may not succeed in recovering substantial portions of loans that were provisioned. If Argentina’s economic growth slows or the financial condition of the private sector deteriorates, the financial system, including us, will experience an increase in the incidence of non-performing loans.

Class actions against financial entities for an indeterminate amount may adversely affect the profitability of the financial system.

Certain public and private organizations have initiated class actions against financial institutions in Argentina. The Argentine National Constitution and Law No. 24,240 (the “Consumer Protection Law”) contain certain provisions regarding class actions. However, their guidance with respect to procedural rules for instituting and trying class action cases is limited. Nonetheless, by means of an ad hoc doctrine construction, Argentine courts have admitted class actions in some cases, including various lawsuits against financial entities related to “collective interests” such as alleged overcharging on products, applied interest rates, and advice in the sale of public securities, among others. If class action plaintiffs were to prevail against financial institutions, their success could have an adverse effect on the financial industry and on our business.

The application of the Consumer Protection Law may prevent or limit the collection of payments with respect to services rendered by us.

The Consumer Protection Law sets forth certain rules and principles designed to protect consumers, which include our customers. The Consumer Protection Law was amended on March 12, 2008 by Law No. 26,361 to expand its applicability and the penalties associated with violations thereof.

Additionally, Law No. 25,065 (as amended by Law No. 26,010 and Law No. 26,361, the “Credit Card Law”) also sets forth several mandatory regulations designed to protect credit card holders.

On September 18, 2014, a new pre-judicial dispute resolution mechanism was created by Law No. 26,993, in order for consumers and providers to resolve any dispute within the course of 30 days, and which levies fines upon companies that do not attend the hearings.

Both the involvement of the applicable administrative authorities at the federal, provincial and local levels, and the enforcement of the Consumer Protection Law and the Credit Card Law by the courts are increasing. This trend has increased general consumer protection levels. We cannot provide any assurance that judicial and administrative rulings based on the applicable regulation, or measures adopted by the enforcement authorities, will not increase the consumer protection given to debtors and other clients in the future, or that they will not favor the claims initiated by consumer groups or associations, and in such event, certain penalties and remedies could prevent or limit the collection of payments due from services and financing provided by banks engaged in such practices, materially and adversely affect our financial condition or results of operations.

Furthermore, the rules that govern the credit card business provide for variable caps on the interest rates that financial entities may charge clients and the fees that they may charge merchants. Moreover, general legal provisions exist pursuant to which courts could decrease the interest rates and fees agreed upon by the parties on the grounds that they are excessively high. A change in applicable law or the existence of court decisions that lower the cap on interest rates and fees that clients and merchants may be charged would reduce our revenues and therefore negatively affect our results of operations.

Limitations on enforcement of creditors’ rights in Argentina may adversely affect financial institutions.

To protect debtors affected by the economic crisis, beginning in 2002, the Argentine government has adopted measures that temporarily suspended proceedings to enforce creditors’ rights, including mortgage foreclosures and bankruptcy petitions. Such limitations have restricted creditors’ ability to collect defaulted loans. Most of these measures have been rescinded. However, we cannot assure you that in an adverse economic environment the government will not adopt new measures in the future, restricting the ability of creditors to enforce their rights, which could have a material adverse effect on the financial system and our business.

 

16


Table of Contents

Governmental measures and regulatory framework affecting financial entities could have a material adverse effect on the operations of financial entities.

The Argentine government has historically exercised significant influence over the economy. Financial institutions, in particular, have operated in a highly regulated environment. Between 2001 and 2015, a series of new regulations were issued, mainly regulating the foreign exchange market, capital and minimum cash requirements, lending activity, interest rate limits and dividend distribution for financial institutions.

Moreover, the Central Bank imposed new restrictions on the distribution of dividends, including a limitation on the maximum distributable amount of dividends which cannot exceed the excess in minimum regulatory capital, exclusively considering, to such end, a 75% incremental adjustment to the capital requirement; requiring that the capital remaining after the distribution of dividends must be sufficient to meet the regulatory capital requirement increased by 75%. In addition, since January 2016, pursuant to the Central Bank Communication “A” 5827, additional capital margins requirements have to be complied with, a capital conservation margin and a countercyclical margin. The capital conservation margin shall be 2.5% of the amount of capital risk weighted assets (RWA), in the case of entities considered systemically important (D-SIB), like us, the margin will be increased to 3.5% of the amount of capital risk weighted assets (RWA). The countercyclical margin shall be within a range of 0% to 2.5% of RWA, but Communication “A” 5938 of the Central Bank, established countercyclical margin in 0% as of April 1, 2016. This margin can be reduced or cancelled by the Central Bank when it considers that the systematic risk has been diminished.

Since June 2012, the Central Bank has had in place a regime to finance productive investment pursuant to which certain financial entities, including us, must allocate a certain amount of their deposits from the non-financial private sector in pesos at a fixed interest rate established by the Central Bank, to fund investment projects for (i) the acquisition of capital goods; (ii) the construction of plants; or (iii) the marketing of goods or the acquisition of property (subject in this latter case to certain additional requirements). The Central Bank extended the term of this regime for each of 2013, 2014 and 2015. As a result of the Macri administration taking office, the Central Bank further affirmed the regime and established the applicable minimum of at least the 14% of the average deposits from non-financial private sector (for first semester of 2016, calculated based on the average November 2016 balances).

Furthermore, the Central Bank has established certain regulations granting broad protections to consumers of financial services that provide more control over the relationship between them and their customers. The Central Bank regulations provide for (i) a rule that prior authorization will be required to implement new fees for new products and/or services offered and to increase existing fees, whether or not the products are considered basic and (ii) rules limiting the ability of financial institutions to receive remuneration or profits from any insurance product that customers are obligated to purchase as a condition for accessing financial services.

Since January 2015, and pursuant to Central Bank Communication “A” 5827 (as amended), financial entities must make an accounting entry of any administrative and/or disciplinary penalties and adverse criminal judgments pending before the courts, provisioning 100% of the respective penalty provided under each such action until payment is made or a final judgment is entered. In January 2015, pursuant to such regulations, the Bank made provisions for administrative and/or disciplinary sanctions pending or initiated by the Central Bank, Financial Intelligence Unit (the “UIF”) or CNV. Such provisions totaled Ps. 11,7 million as of December 31, 2015. In April 2016, Central Bank issued Communication “A” 5940, pursuant to which the financial entities that, to the date thereof, have an amount for these items registered in the account “Provisions – For administrative, disciplinary and criminal penalties”, must analyze, according to the enforcing legal reports, if each such penalty meets the conditions for its total or partial accountable registration, according to the provisions in the “Accounts Plan and Manual” (which set forth that penalties must be probable and that their amount can be reasonably estimated).

In addition, in March 2016, the Central Bank established that the net global position in foreign currency of financial institutions cannot exceed the lesser of 10% of the RPC or the liquid funds of the institution, effective as of April, 2016. This limit shall be increased by an amount equal to the increase in the monthly balance of financing received from abroad and settled through the MULC, converted to pesos at the reference exchange rate, during the time period between January 31, 2014 and the last month to which the global net position is referred. As a result, financial entities, including us, sold part of their position in U.S. dollars to comply with such rule. We cannot assure that laws and regulations currently governing the economy or the financial sector will not continue to change in the future or that any changes will not adversely affect our business, financial condition and results of operations.

Moreover, any insolvency proceeding against financial institutions would be subject to the powers of and intervention by the Central Bank, which may limit remedies otherwise available and extend the duration of the proceedings. Finally, special rules that govern the subordination of debt of financial institutions in Argentina, granting priority to depositors with respect to most other creditors, may negatively affect other shareholders in the event of our judicial liquidation or bankruptcy.

Such and future changes in the regulatory framework could limit the ability of financial institutions, including us, to make long-term decisions, such as asset allocation decisions, that could cause uncertainty with respect to the future financial condition and results of operations. We cannot assure that laws and regulations currently governing the economy or the financial sector will not continue to change in the future or that any changes will not adversely affect our business, financial condition and results of operations. For more information, see Item 4.B “Argentine banking regulation”.

Argentina’s insufficient or incorrect implementation of certain anti-money laundering and combating the financing of terrorism (“AML/CFT”) recommendations may result in difficulties to obtain international financing and attract direct foreign investments.

In October 2010, the Financial Action Task Force (“FATF”) issued a Mutual Evaluation Report (the “Mutual Report”) on Anti-Money Laundering and Combating the Financing of Terrorism in Argentina. This report stated that since the prior evaluation in 2004, Argentina had not made adequate progress in addressing a number of deficiencies identified at the time, and the FATF subsequently placed Argentina under enhanced monitoring.

 

17


Table of Contents

In June 2011, Argentina made a high-level political commitment to work with the FATF to address its strategic AML/CFT deficiencies. In compliance with recommendations made by the FATF on money laundering prevention, on June 1, 2011 the Congress enacted Law No. 26,683. Under this law, money laundering is now a crime per se, and self-laundering money is also considered a crime.

In June 2012, the Plenary meeting of the FATF held in Rome highlighted the progress made by Argentina but also urged the country to make further progress regarding its AML/CFT deficiencies. Notwithstanding the improvements that Argentina made, in October 2012 the FATF determined that certain strategic AML/CFT deficiencies continued, and that Argentina would be subject to continued monitoring.

Since October 2013, Argentina has taken steps towards improving its AML/CFT regime, including by issuing new regulations strengthening suspicious transaction reporting requirements and the financial sector regulator’s existing powers to apply sanctions for AML/CFT deficiencies. Such progress has been recognized by the FATF. In this regard, in June 2014 the FATF stated that Argentina had made significant progress in addressing the deficiencies in its AML/CFT measures as identified in the Mutual Report, and that subsequent to the adoption of such measures, Argentina had strengthened its legal and regulatory framework, citing certain specific examples. As a result of such progress, the FATF Plenary decided that Argentina had taken sufficient steps in addressing technical compliance with the core and key recommendations to be removed from the monitoring process. In addition, on October 24, 2014 the FATF welcomed Argentina’s significant progress in improving its AML/CFT regime and stated that Argentina would no longer be subject to the FATF’s AML/CFT compliance monitoring process and that Argentina would work with the FATF and the Financial Action Task Force of Latin America (Grupo de Acción Financiera de América del Sur, or “GAFISUD”) as it continued to address the full range of AML/CFT issues identified in its Mutual Report.

Although Argentina has made significant improvements in its AML/CFT regulations, and is no longer subject to the FATF’s ongoing global AML/CFT compliance process, no assurance can be given that Argentina will continue to comply with AML/CFT international standards, or that Argentina will not be subject to the FATF’s ongoing global AML/CFT compliance process in the future, circumstances which could adversely affect Argentina’s ability to obtain financing from international markets and attract foreign investments.

Risks relating to us

Our target market may be the most adversely affected by economic recessions.

Our business strategy is to increase fee income and loan origination in our target market, low- and middle-income individuals and small- and medium-sized businesses.

This target market is particularly vulnerable to economic recessions and, in the event of a recession, growth in our target market may slow and consequently adversely affect our business. The Argentine economy as a whole, and our target market in particular, have not stabilized enough for us to be certain that demand will continue to grow. Therefore, we cannot assure you that our business strategy will ultimately be successful.

Major shareholders have the ability to direct our business and their interests could conflict with yours.

As of March 31, 2016, our major shareholders, Jorge Horacio Brito and Delfín Ezequiel Carballo, directly or beneficially own 5,366,463 Class A shares and 109,285,244 Class B shares and 4,895,416 Class A shares and 106,805,523 Class B shares, respectively. Although currently there is no formal agreement among them, if voting together they could virtually control all decisions with respect to our company made by shareholders. They may, without the concurrence of the remaining shareholders, elect a majority of our directors, effect or prevent a merger, sale of assets or other business acquisition or disposition, cause us to issue additional equity securities, effect a related party transaction and determine the timing and amounts of dividends, if any. Their interests may conflict with your interests as a holder of Class B shares, ADSs or notes, and they may take actions that might be desirable to the major shareholders but not to other shareholders or holders of our notes.

We will continue to consider acquisition opportunities, which may not be successful.

We have historically expanded our business primarily through acquisitions. We will continue to consider attractive acquisition opportunities that we believe may offer additional value and are consistent with our business strategy. We cannot assure you, however, that we will be able to identify suitable acquisition candidates or that we will be able to acquire promising target financial institutions on favorable terms or that the Central Bank will approve any such transaction. Additionally, our ability to obtain the desired effects of any such acquisitions will depend in part on our ability to successfully complete the integration of those businesses and capture expected synergies, of which there can be no assurance. The integration of acquired businesses entails significant risks, including customer retention, integration and liability assumption risks.

Increased competition in the banking industry may adversely affect our operations.

We expect that competition with respect to small- and medium-sized businesses is likely to increase. As a result, even if the demand for financial products and services from these markets continues to grow, competition may adversely affect our results of operations by decreasing the net margins we are able to generate.

 

18


Table of Contents

Reduced spreads between interest rates received on loans and those paid on deposits without corresponding increases in lending volumes could adversely affect our profitability.

The spread for Argentina’s financial system between the interest rates on loans and deposits could be affected as a result of increased competition in the banking sector and the government’s tightening of monetary policy in response to inflation concerns.

Since 2009, the interest rate spreads throughout the financial system have increased. This increase was sustained by a steady demand for consumer loans in recent years. During 2014, the Central Bank established new limits on borrowing and lending rates. However, the net interest margin of the financial system remained stable due to a substantial growth both in loan and deposit portfolios. As of December 17, 2015 these limits were removed by the new administration.

We cannot guarantee that interest rate spreads will remain attractive unless increases in our volume of lending or additional cost-cutting takes place. A reversal of this trend could adversely affect our profitability.

Our estimates and established reserves for credit risk and potential credit losses may prove to be inaccurate and/or insufficient, which may materially and adversely affect our financial condition and results of operations.

A number of our products expose us to credit risk, including consumer loans, commercial loans and other receivables. Changes in the income levels of our borrowers, increases in the inflation rate or an increase in interest rates could have a negative effect on the quality of our loan portfolio, causing us to increase provisions for loan losses and resulting in reduced profits or in losses.

We estimate and establish reserves for credit risk and potential credit losses. This process involves subjective and complex judgments, including projections of economic conditions and assumptions on the ability of our borrowers to repay their loans. We may not be able to timely detect these risks before they occur, or due to limited resources or available tools, our employees may not be able to effectively implement our credit risk management system, which may increase our exposure to credit risk.

Overall, if we are unable to effectively control the level of non-performing or poor credit quality loans in the future, or if our loan loss reserves are insufficient to cover future loan losses, our financial condition and results of operations may be materially and adversely affected.

Changes in market conditions, and any risks associated therewith, could materially and adversely affect our financial condition and results of operations.

We are directly and indirectly affected by changes in market conditions. Market risk, or the risk that values of assets and liabilities or revenues will be adversely affected by variation in market conditions, is inherent in the products and instruments associated with our operations, including loans, deposits, securities, bonds, long-term debt and short-term borrowings. Changes in market conditions that may affect our financial condition and results of operations include fluctuations in interest and currency exchange rates, securities prices, changes in the implied volatility of interest rates and foreign exchange rates, among others.

Cybersecurity events could negatively affect our reputation, our financial condition and our results of operations.

We depend on the efficient and uninterrupted operation of internet-based data processing, communication and information exchange platforms and networks, including those systems related to the operation of our ATM network. We have access to large amounts of confidential financial information and control substantial financial assets belonging to our customers as well as to us. In addition, we provide our customers with continuous remote access to their accounts and the possibility of transferring substantial financial assets by electronic means. Accordingly, cybersecurity is a material risk for us. Cybersecurity incidents, such as computer break-ins, phishing, identity theft and other disruptions could negatively affect the security of information stored in and transmitted through our computer systems and network infrastructure and may cause existing and potential customers to refrain from doing business with us.

In addition, contingency plans in place may not be sufficient to cover liabilities associated with any such events and, therefore, applicable insurance coverage may be deemed inadequate, preventing us from receiving full compensation for the losses sustained as a result of such a disruption.

Although we intend to continue to implement security technology devices and establish operational procedures to prevent such damage, we cannot assure you that all of our systems are entirely free from vulnerability and these security measures will be successful. If any of these events occur, it could damage our reputation, entail serious costs and affect our transactions, as well as our results of operations and financial condition.

We are susceptible to fraud, unauthorized transactions and operational errors.

As with other financial institutions, we are susceptible to, among other things, fraud by employees or outsiders, unauthorized transactions by employees and other operational errors (including clerical or record keeping errors and errors resulting from faulty computer or telecommunications systems). Given the high volume of transactions that may occur at a financial institution, errors could be repeated or compounded before they are discovered and remedied. In addition, some of our transactions are not fully automated, which may further increase the risk that human error or employee tampering will result in losses that may be difficult to detect quickly or at all. Losses from fraud by employees or outsiders, unauthorized transactions by employees and other operational errors could have a material adverse effect on us.

 

19


Table of Contents

If we should fail to comply with all applicable banking and securities laws and regulations or detect money laundering and other illegal or inappropriate activities in a comprehensive or timely manner, the business interests and reputation of the Bank may be harmed.

We must be in compliance with all applicable banking and securities laws and regulations. In recent years, the Argentine government and relevant governmental agencies have modified policies and mechanisms of control over financial activity, as well as the parameters surrounding monetary and disciplinary penalties that may affect our results of operations and reputation.

For example, on November 29, 2012, the Argentine Congress passed the “Capital Markets Law”, which modified the public offer regime set forth by Law No.17,811, as amended. One of the most significant amendments introduced by such law refers to the powers of the CNV. The incorporation of Section 20 raises concern in the market, especially among listed companies, since it entitles the CNV to (i) appoint supervisors with powers of veto on resolutions adopted by a company’s board of directors and (ii) disqualify a company’s board of directors for a period of 180 days when, as determined by the CNV, the interests of the minority shareholders and/or security holders are infringed. In addition, pursuant to section 51 of the Capital Markets Law, the CNV may suspend registered broker agents on a preventive basis, as occurred during the first quarter of 2015 to several financial system entities, including with Banco Macro and our subsidiary Macro Securities. For more information see Item 8. “Legal Proceedings”.

In addition, anti-money laundering laws and regulations require, among other things, that we adopt and implement control policies and procedures which involve “know your customer” principles that comply with the applicable regulations and reporting suspicious or unusual transactions to the applicable regulatory authorities. While we have adopted policies and procedures intended to detect and prevent the use of our network for money laundering activities and by terrorists, terrorist organizations and other types of organizations, those policies and procedures may fail to fully eliminate the risk that we have been or are currently being used by other parties, without our knowledge, to engage in activities related to money laundering or other illegal activities.

To the extent that we do not comply with banking and securities laws and regulations or we don’t detect illegal activities from an anti-money laundering or other standpoint, the relevant governmental agencies (including the Central Bank, the CNV and the UIF) are authorized and empowered to impose fines, suspensions and other penalties on the Bank. In particular, pursuant to Communication “A” 5785 (as amended), sanctions imposed by the Central Bank, the UIF, the CNV and/or the National Superintendency of Insurance on financial institutions and/or their authorities, may result in the revocation of their licenses to operate as financial institutions. Such revocation may occur when, in the opinion of the Board of Directors of the Central Bank, there was a material change in the conditions deemed necessary to maintain such license, including those relating to the suitability, experience, moral character or integrity of (i) the members of a financial institution’s board of directors (directors, counselors or equivalent authorities), (ii) its shareholders, (iii) the members of its supervisory committee and (iv) others, such as its managers.

We cannot assure you that relevant governmental agencies will not continue to impose penalties or that such penalties will not adversely affect our business, reputation, financial condition and results of operations.

Argentine corporate disclosure and governance requirements differ from those regulating highly-developed capital markets, such as the United States, and differences in the accounting standards applicable in Argentina and the United States may make it difficult to compare our financial statements and reported earnings with companies in other countries, such as the United States.

As a foreign private issuer, the Bank applies disclosure policies and requirements that differ from those governing U.S. domestic registrants. The securities laws of Argentina that govern publicly listed companies, such us, impose disclosure requirements that are more limited than those in the United States. In addition, publicly available corporate information about us in Argentina is different from and may be more difficult to obtain than the information available for registered public companies in certain countries with highly developed capital markets, such as the United States. See Item 16.G “Corporate Governance”.

Moreover, there are important differences between accounting and financial reporting standards applicable to financial institutions in Argentina and to those in the U.S. Except as otherwise described herein, we prepare our financial statements in accordance with Central Bank Rules, which differ in certain significant respects from U.S. GAAP and, to a certain extent, from Argentine GAAP. As a result, our financial statements and reported earnings are not directly comparable to those of banks in the United States. See Item 5. “Operating and Financial Review and Prospects—U.S. GAAP and Central Bank Rules Reconciliation” for a description of the principal differences between Central Bank Rules and U.S. GAAP and how they affect our financial statements and note 35 to our audited consolidated financial statements as of and for the three years ended December 31, 2015 for a summary of significant differences between Central Bank Rules and U.S. GAAP.

On February 12, 2014, the Central Bank, through Communication “A” 5541, established the general guidelines towards conversion of the Central Bank Rules to IFRS issued by the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) for preparing financial statements of the entities under its supervision, for the annual fiscal years beginning on January 1, 2018, as well as those of interim-periods. The Bank is implementing such IFRS conversion process. See note 7 to our audited consolidated financial statements as of and for the three years ended December 31, 2015. Following our adoption of IFRS our results of operation may differ significantly from previous amounts reported under Central Bank Rules. In particular, we expect that adoption of IFRS, as applicable under Argentine regulations, will have relevant effects on our accounting for certain items of our consolidated financial statements such as shareholders’ equity and net income.

 

20


Table of Contents

Risks relating to our Class B shares and the ADSs

Holders of our Class B shares and the ADSs may not receive any dividends.

In 2003, the Central Bank prohibited financial institutions from distributing dividends. In 2004, the Central Bank amended the restriction to require the Central Bank’s prior authorization for the distribution of dividends. We have consistently obtained authorization from the Central Bank to distribute dividends corresponding to fiscal years 2003 through 2010. Under new Central Bank Rules on distribution of dividends, the capital remaining after the distribution of dividends must be sufficient to meet the regulatory capital increased by 75%. See “Risks relating to the Argentine Financial System – Governmental measures and regulatory framework affecting financial entitites could have a material adverse effect on the operations of financial entities”.

Since January 2016, pursuant to Central Bank Communication “A” 5827, additional capital margins requirement have to be complied with, a capital conservation margin and a countercyclical margin. The capital conservation margin shall be 2.5% of the amount of capital risk weighted assets (RWA), in the case of entities considered systemically important (D-SIB), like us, the margin will be increased to 3.5% of the amount of capital risk weighted assets (RWA). The countercyclical margin shall be within a range of 0% to 2.5% of RWA, but Communication “A” 5938 of the Central Bank, established countercyclical margin in 0% as of April 1, 2016. This margin can be reduced or cancelled by the Central Bank when it considers that the systematic risk has been diminished.

Since January 2015, Central Bank Communication “A” 5827 (as amended) has required that financial entities must make an accounting entry of any administrative and/or disciplinary penalties and adverse criminal judgments pending before the courts, provisioning 100% of the respective penalty provided under each such action until payment is made or a final judgment is entered. Pursuant to Central Bank Communication “A” 5827 this provisioned amount must also be deducted from the distributable amount. In April 2016, Central Bank issued Communication “A” 5940, pursuant to which the financial entities that, to the date thereof, have an amount for these items registered in the account “Provisions – For administrative, disciplinary and criminal penalties”, must analyze, according to the enforcing legal reports, if each such penalty meets the conditions for its total or partial accountable registration, according to the provisions in the “Accounts Plan and Manual” (which set forth that penalties must be probable and that their amount can be reasonably estimated).

For fiscal years ended December 31, 2011 and 2012, we were not able to distribute dividends because we did not reach the regulatory threshold for dividend distribution under Central Bank regulations. For fiscal years ended December 31, 2013 and 2014, we reached such regulatory threshold and, in compliance with current regulations. For fiscal year 2014 we obtained authorization from the Central Bank to distribute dividends and distributed dividends in March 2016. In addition, we have met the regulatory threshold for dividend distribution for fiscal year and 2015 and we are currently awaiting Central Bank approval to pay dividends for fiscal year 2015.

No assurance can be given that in the future we will be able to reach the regulatory threshold or that if so, the Central Bank will continue to grant us the authorization to distribute dividends by our shareholders at the annual ordinary shareholders’ meeting or that such authorization shall be for the full amount of distributable dividends.

Additional regulatory and contractual restrictions exist which could affect the distribution of earnings and are included in note 16 to our audited consolidated financial statements as of and for the three years ended December 31, 2015.

Holders of our Class B shares and the ADSs located in the United States may not be able to exercise preemptive rights.

Under Argentine Corporate Law No. 19,550 (the “Argentine Corporate Law”), if we issue new shares as part of a capital increase, our shareholders may have the right to subscribe to a proportional number of shares to maintain their existing ownership percentage. Rights to subscribe for shares in these circumstances are known as preemptive rights. In addition, shareholders are entitled to the right to subscribe for the unsubscribed shares remaining at the end of a preemptive rights offering on a pro rata basis, known as accretion rights. Upon the occurrence of any future increase in our capital stock, United States holders of Class B shares or ADSs will not be able to exercise the preemptive and related accretion rights for such Class B shares or ADSs unless a registration statement under the Securities Act is effective with respect to such Class B shares or ADSs or an exemption from the registration requirements of the Securities Act is available. We are not obligated to file a registration statement with respect to those Class B shares or ADSs. We cannot assure you that we will file such a registration statement or that an exemption from registration will be available. Unless those Class B shares or ADSs are registered or an exemption from registration applies, a U.S. holder of our Class B shares or ADSs may receive only the net proceeds from those preemptive rights and accretion rights if those rights can be sold by the depositary; if they cannot be sold, they will be allowed to lapse. Furthermore, the equity interest of holders of Class B shares or ADSs located in the United States may be diluted proportionately upon future capital increases.

Changes in the Argentine tax laws may adversely affect the results of our operations and the tax treatment of our Class B shares and/or ADSs.

On September 23, 2013, Law No. 26,893 amending the Income Tax Law was enacted. According to the amendments, the distribution of dividends is subject to income tax at a rate of 10.0%, unless they are distributed to Argentine corporate entities, and the sale, exchange or disposition of shares and other securities not traded in or listed on capital markets and securities exchanges is subject to income tax at a rate of 15.0% when the income is obtained by Argentine resident individuals or by foreign beneficiaries. These amendments were regulated by Decree 2334/2013. See “Taxation—Material Argentine tax considerations relating to our Class B shares and ADSs”. However, as of today, many aspects of both taxes currently remain unclear. Pursuant to certain announcements made by Argentine tax authorities, both new taxes would be subject to further regulation and interpretation, which may adversely affect the results of the Bank and our subsidiaries, as well as the tax treatment of our Class B shares and/or ADSs.

 

21


Table of Contents

Non-Argentine companies that own our Class B shares directly and not as ADSs may not be able to exercise their rights as shareholders unless they are registered in Argentina.

Under Argentine law, foreign companies that own shares in an Argentine corporation incorporated within the City of Buenos Aires, are required to register with IGJ, in order to exercise certain shareholder rights, including voting rights. If you own Class B shares directly (rather than in the form of ADSs) and you are a non-Argentine company and you fail to register with IGJ, your ability to exercise your rights as a holder of our Class B shares may be limited.

You may not be able to sell your ADSs at the time or the price you desire because an active or liquid market may not develop.

Prior to March 24, 2006, there has not been a public market for the ADSs or, in the case of our Class B shares, a market outside of Argentina. We cannot assure you that any market for our Class B shares or for the ADSs will be available or liquid or the price at which the Class B shares or the ADSs may be sold in that market.

The relative volatility and illiquidity of the Argentine securities markets may substantially limit your ability to sell Class B shares underlying the ADSs at the price and time you desire.

Investing in securities that trade in emerging markets, such as Argentina, often involves greater risk than investing in securities of issuers in the United States, and such investments are generally considered to be more speculative in nature. The Argentine securities market is substantially smaller, less liquid, more concentrated and can be more volatile than major securities markets in the United States, and is not as highly regulated or supervised as some of these other markets. There is also significantly greater concentration in the Argentine securities market than in major securities markets in the United States. The ten largest companies in terms of market capitalization represented more than 90% of the aggregate market capitalization of the BCBA as of December 31, 2015. Accordingly, although you are entitled to withdraw the Class B shares underlying the ADSs from the depositary at any time, your ability to sell such shares at a price and time at which you wish to do so may be substantially limited. Furthermore, new capital controls imposed by the Central Bank could have the effect of further impairing the liquidity of the BCBA by making it unattractive for non-Argentines to buy shares in the secondary market in Argentina.

We are traded on more than one market and this may result in price variations; in addition, investors may not be able to easily move shares for trading between such markets.

The trading prices of our ADSs and our Class B shares on the different markets may differ due to different factors. Any decrease in the price of our Class B shares on the MERVAL or the MAE could cause a decrease in the trading price of the ADSs on the NYSE. Investors could seek to sell or buy our shares to take advantage of any price differences between the markets through a practice referred to as arbitrage. Any arbitrage activity could create unexpected volatility in both our share prices on one exchange, and the ADSs available for trading on the other exchange. In addition, holders of ADSs will not be immediately able to surrender their ADSs and withdraw the underlying Class B shares for trading on the other market without effecting necessary procedures with the depositary. This could result in time delays and additional cost for holders of ADSs.

Our shareholders may be subject to liability for certain votes of their securities.

Our shareholders are not liable for our obligations. Instead, shareholders are generally liable only for the payment of the shares they subscribe. However, shareholders who have a conflict of interest with us and who do not abstain from voting may be held liable for damages to us, but only if the transaction would not have been approved without such shareholders’ votes. Furthermore, shareholders who willfully or negligently vote in favor of a resolution that is subsequently declared void by a court as contrary to Argentine Corporate Law or our bylaws may be held jointly and severally liable for damages to us or to other third parties, including other shareholders.

Our Class B shares or the ADSs may have been characterized as stock in a ‘‘passive foreign investment company’’ in the past, or may be so characterized in the future, for U.S. federal income tax purposes.

The application of the “passive foreign investment company” rules to equity interests in banks such as us is unclear under current U.S. federal income tax law. While we do not believe that we are currently a passive foreign investment company, the test for determining our “passive foreign investment company” status is a factual one based upon a periodic evaluation of our assets and income and is unclear when applied to banking businesses such as our own. In addition, we may have been a PFIC in the past. It is therefore possible that our Class B shares or the ADSs could be characterized as stock in a “passive foreign investment company” for U.S. federal income tax purposes, which could have adverse tax consequences to U.S. holders (as defined in Item 10.E “Taxation—Material U.S. Federal Income Tax Considerations”) in some circumstances. If we were classified as a passive foreign investment company in the past, U.S. holders of our Class B shares or the ADSs that held such Class B shares or ADSs at that time generally would be subject to special rules and adverse U.S. tax consequences with respect to certain distributions made by us and on any gain recognized on the sale or other disposition of our Class B shares or the ADSs. In addition, if we are treated as a passive foreign investment company in future tax years, U.S. holders of our Class B shares or the ADSs in such future periods may be subject to these same rules. In either case, U.S. holders might be subject to a greater U.S. tax liability than might otherwise apply and incur tax on amounts in advance of when U.S. federal income tax would otherwise be imposed. A U.S. holder of our Class B shares or the ADSs might be able to avoid these rules and consequences by making an election to mark such shares to market (although it is not clear if this election is available for the Class B shares). U.S. holders should carefully read Item 10.E “Taxation—Material U.S. Federal Income Tax Considerations—Passive Foreign Investment Companies” and consult their tax advisors regarding the “passive foreign investment company” rules.

 

22


Table of Contents

Risks relating to our notes

The notes are effectively subordinated to our secured creditors and our depositors.

Unless otherwise specified, the notes rank at least pari passu in right of payment with all of our existing and future unsecured and unsubordinated indebtedness, other than obligations preferred by statute or by operation of law, including, without limitation, tax and labor-related claims and our obligations to depositors.

In particular, under Financial Institutions Law, all of our existing and future depositors will have a general priority right over holders of notes issued under our medium-term note program. The Financial Institutions Law provides that in the event of judicial liquidation or insolvency, all depositors would have priority over all of our other creditors (including holders of notes), except certain labor creditors and secured creditors. Moreover, depositors would have priority over all other creditors, with the exception of certain labor creditors, to funds held by the Central Bank as reserves, any other funds at the time of any revocation of our banking license and proceeds from any mandatory transfer of our assets by the Central Bank.

We have issued and may also issue additional subordinated notes. In that case, in addition to the priority of certain other creditors described in the preceding paragraphs, subordinated notes will also rank at all times junior in right of payment to certain of our unsecured and unsubordinated indebtedness.

Exchange controls and restrictions on transfers abroad may impair your ability to receive payments on the notes.

In 2001 and 2002, Argentina imposed exchange controls and transfer restrictions, substantially limiting the ability of companies to retain foreign currency or make payments abroad. Furthermore, new regulations were issued in 2012 and 2013, pursuant to which certain foreign exchange transactions could not be effected unless they were previously approved by Argentine tax authorities. Since then, these restrictions have been substantially eased, including those requiring the Central Bank’s prior authorization for the transfer of funds abroad in order to pay principal and interest on debt obligations and the elimination of the requirement to register foreign exchange transactions in the Argentine tax authorities Exchange Transactions Consultation Program (Programa de Consulta de Operaciones Cambiarias).

Notwithstanding the foregoing, in the future Argentina may impose new exchange controls and transfer restrictions. In such event, your ability to receive payments on the notes may be impaired.

We may redeem the notes prior to maturity.

The notes are redeemable at our option in the event of certain changes in Argentine taxes and, if so specified, the notes may also be redeemable at our option for any other reason. We may choose to redeem those notes at times when prevailing interest rates may be relatively low. Accordingly, an investor may not be able to reinvest the redemption proceeds in a comparable security at an effective interest rate as high as that of the notes.

As a financial institution, any bankruptcy proceeding against us would be subject to intervention by the Central Bank, which may limit remedies otherwise available and extend the duration of proceedings.

If we are unable to pay our debts as they come due, the Central Bank would typically intervene by appointing a reviewer, request us to file a reorganization plan, transfer certain of our assets and liabilities and possibly revoke our banking license and file a liquidation petition before a local court. Upon any such intervention, noteholders’ remedies may be restricted and the claims and interests of our depositors and other creditors may be prioritized over those of noteholders. As a result, the noteholders may realize substantially less on their claims than they would in a bankruptcy proceeding in Argentina, the United States or any other country.

Holders of notes may find it difficult to enforce civil liabilities against us or our directors, officers and controlling persons.

We are organized under the laws of Argentina and our principal place of business (domicilio social) is in the City of Buenos Aires, Argentina. Most of our directors, officers and controlling persons reside outside the United States. In addition, all or a substantial portion of our assets and their assets are located outside of the United States. As a result, it may be difficult for holders of notes to effect service of process within the United States on such persons or to enforce judgments against them, including any action based on civil liabilities under the U.S. federal securities laws. Based on the opinion of our Argentine counsel, there is doubt as to the enforceability against such persons in Argentina, whether in original actions or in actions to enforce judgments of U.S. courts, of liabilities based solely on the U.S. federal securities laws.

The ratings of the notes may be lowered or withdrawn depending on various factors, including the rating agency’s assessment of our financial strength and Argentine sovereign risk.

Independent credit rating agencies may assign credit ratings to the notes. The ratings of the notes reflect the relevant rating agency’s assessment of our ability to make timely payment of principal and interest on the notes. Moreover, the methods of assigning ratings used by Argentine rating agencies may differ in important aspects from those used by the rating agencies in the United States or other countries. The ratings of the notes are not a recommendation to buy, sell or hold the notes, and the ratings do not comment on market prices or suitability for a particular investor. We cannot assure you that the ratings of the notes will remain for any given period of time or that the ratings will not be lowered or withdrawn. A downgrade in ratings will not be an event of default with respect to the notes. The assigned ratings may be raised or lowered depending, among other things, on the rating agency’s assessment of our financial strength as well as its assessment of Argentine sovereign risk generally, and any change to these may affect the market price or liquidity of the notes.

 

23


Table of Contents

Risks relating to our 2036 Notes

Interest on the 2036 Notes may be limited to the extent we do not have sufficient Distributable Amounts.

No interest on the 2036 Notes will be due and payable in the event that the payment of such interest, together with any other payments or distributions (other than payments in respect of redemptions or repurchases) on or in respect of our parity obligations (including the notes) previously made or scheduled to be made during the distribution period in which such interest payment date falls, would exceed our distributable amounts for such distribution period. Interest payments on the notes are non-cumulative such that if an interest payment is not made in full as a result of the limitation described in the preceding sentence, such unpaid interest will not accrue or be due and payable at any time and, accordingly, holders of 2036 Notes will not have any claim thereon, whether or not interest is paid with respect to any other interest period.

The distributable amount available for payments of interest on the 2036 Notes on an interest payment date is based principally on our unappropriated retained earnings from the prior year. Subject to certain limited exceptions, Argentine law does not restrict our shareholders from approving the payment of dividends to themselves out of our unappropriated retained earnings, and the indenture relating to the notes does not restrict our ability to pay dividends unless interest on the notes has not been paid in full as scheduled. In addition, distributable amounts available for payment of interest on the 2036 Notes depends on the amount of payments or other distributions on or in respect of our parity obligations previously made or schedule to be made during the relevant distribution period. Although we do not currently have any parity obligations outstanding, the indenture relating to the notes will not restrict our ability to issue parity obligations in the future. Accordingly, we cannot assure you that we will have sufficient distributable amounts to make interest payments on the 2036 Notes.

We may be prevented by the Central Bank or Argentine banking regulations from making interest or other payments on or in respect of the 2036 Notes.

No interest on the 2036 Notes will be due and payable on an interest payment date in the event that we would be prevented from paying interest on the Notes on such interest payment date as a result of (X) a general prohibition by the Central Bank on paying interest or making other payments or distributions on or in respect of our parity obligations (including the notes) or (Y) as provided in Communications “A” 5485 of the Central Bank or any successor regulations thereto, if (a) we are subject to a liquidation procedure or the mandatory transfer of our assets by the Central Bank in accordance with Sections 34 or 35 bis of the Financial Institutions Law or successors thereto; (b) we are receiving financial assistance from the Central Bank (except liquidity assistance under the pesification rules pursuant to Decree No. 739/2003); (c) we are not in compliance with or have failed to comply on a timely basis with our reporting obligations to the Central Bank; (d) we are not in compliance with minimum capital requirements (both on an individual and consolidated basis) or with minimum cash reserves (on average); or (e) we are subject to significant penalties imposed by the UIF unless certain corrective actions have been implemented by the Superintendency or if a risk mitigation plan has been required.

As a result of the 2001 Argentine crisis, all banks were prohibited by the Central Bank from paying dividends in 2002 and 2003. As the economy recovered, the Central Bank eased the prohibition but still requires prior authorization for the distribution of dividends by banks. Although the prohibition is no longer in effect, we cannot assure you that, if confronted with a similar crisis, the Central Bank will not prevent banks from making interest payments on parity obligations, including the 2036 Notes.

The 2036 Notes are unsecured and subordinated and, in the event of our bankruptcy, the 2036 Notes will rank junior to our unsubordinated obligations and certain of our subordinated obligations.

The 2036 Notes constitute our unsecured and subordinated obligations. In the event of our bankruptcy, the 2036 Notes will rank junior to all claims of our unsubordinated creditors and certain of our subordinated creditors. By reason of the subordination of the notes, in the case of our bankruptcy, although the notes would become immediately due and payable at their principal amount together with accrued interest thereon, our assets would be available to pay such amounts only after all such creditors have been paid in full. We expect to incur from time to time additional obligations that rank senior to the notes, and the indenture relating to the notes does not prohibit or limit the incurrence of such obligations.

Under Argentine law, our obligations under the 2036 Notes will also be subordinated to certain statutory preferences such as tax and labor-related claims and our obligations to depositors. In particular, under the Financial Institutions Law, all of our existing and future depositors will have a general priority right over holders of notes. The Financial Institutions Law provides that in the event of our bankruptcy or insolvency, all depositors would have priority over all of our other creditors (including holders of notes), except certain labor creditors and secured creditors. Moreover, depositors would have priority over all other creditors, with the exception of certain labor creditors, to funds held by the Central Bank as reserves, any other funds at the time of any revocation of our banking license and proceeds from any mandatory transfer of our assets by the Central Bank.

If we do not satisfy our obligations under the 2036 Notes, your remedies will be limited.

Payment of principal on the 2036 Notes may be accelerated only in certain events involving our bankruptcy. There is no right of acceleration in the case of a default in the performance of any of our covenants, including a default in the payment of principal, premium or interest.

 

24


Table of Contents

The U.S. federal income tax treatment of the 2036 Notes is unclear.

Because of certain features of the 2036 Notes, the U.S. federal income tax treatment applicable to the 2036 Notes is uncertain. While we do not intend to treat the 2036 Notes as subject to the “contingent payment debt instrument” rules under U.S. federal income tax regulations, it is possible that the U.S. Internal Revenue Service (“IRS”) could assert such treatment. If this assertion were successful, U.S. holders (as defined in Item 10.E “Taxation—Material U.S. Federal Income Tax Considerations”) generally would be required to include interest income on a constant yield basis at a rate that could differ from, and could at certain times be in excess of, the stated interest on the 2036 Notes. In addition, any gain on the sale of 2036 Notes derived by a U.S. holder would be treated as ordinary income rather than capital gain.

It is also possible that the IRS could assert that the 2036 Notes should be treated as equity for U.S. federal income tax purposes. If this assertion were successful, U.S. holders could also be subject to adverse tax rules (including an interest charge on and ordinary income treatment of any gain derived with respect to the notes) if it were also determined that we are a “passive foreign investment company” for U.S. federal income tax purposes. While we do not believe that we are currently a passive foreign investment company, the test for determining “passive foreign investment company” status is a factual one based upon a periodic evaluation of our assets and income and is unclear when applied to banking businesses such as our own. Thus we cannot provide any assurance that we will not be determined to be a “passive foreign investment company” as of the issuance of the 2036 Notes or in any future period.

Certain definitions.

“Parity Obligations” means (i) all claims in respect of our obligations, or our guarantees of liabilities, that are eligible to be computed as part of our Tier 1 capital under Argentine banking regulations (without taking into account any limitation placed on the amount of such capital); and (ii) all claims in respect of any of our other obligations (including guarantees) that rank, or are expressed to rank, pari passu with the 2036 Notes.

“Distribution Period” means, with respect to an Interest Payment Date, the period from and including the date of our annual ordinary shareholders’ meeting immediately preceding such Interest Payment Date to but excluding the date of our annual ordinary shareholders’ meeting immediately following such Interest Payment Date.

“Distributable Amounts” for a Distribution Period means the aggregate amount, as set out in our audited financial statements for our fiscal year immediately preceding the beginning of such Distribution Period, prepared in accordance with Central Bank Rules and approved by our shareholders, of our unappropriated retained earnings minus: (i) required legal and statutory reserves; (ii) asset valuation adjustments as determined and notified by the Superintendency, whether or not agreed to by us, and the asset valuation adjustments indicated by our external auditor, in each case to the extent not recorded in such financial statements; and (iii) any amounts resulting from loan loss or other asset valuation allowances permitted by the Superintendency including adjustments arising from the failure to put into effect an agreed upon compliance plan. For the avoidance of doubt, the calculation of Distributable Amounts in respect of a particular Distribution Period shall be made prior to the appropriation or allocation of any amounts to any voluntary or contingent reserves and any dividends or distributions on any Junior Obligations or Parity Obligations during such Distribution Period.

Item 4. Information on the Bank

A. History and development of the Bank

Our legal and commercial name is Banco Macro S.A. We are a financial institution incorporated on November 21, 1966 as a sociedad anónima, a stock corporation, duly incorporated under the laws of Argentina for a 99-year period and registered on March 8, 1967 with the Public Registry of Commerce of the City of Bahía Blanca, in the Province of Buenos Aires, Argentina under No. 1154 of Book 2, Volume 75 of Estatutos. We subsequently changed our legal address to the City of Buenos Aires and registered it with the IGJ on October 8, 1996 under No. 9777 of Book 119, Volume A of Sociedades Anónimas.

Our principal executive offices are located at Sarmiento 447, City of Buenos Aires, Argentina, and our telephone number is (+ 54-11-5222-6500). We have appointed CT Corporation System as our agent for service of process in the United States, located at 111 Eight Avenue, New York, New York, 10011.

Our history – Banco Macro S.A.

Banco Macro commenced operations as a non-banking financial institution in 1985, through the acquisition of Macro Compañía Financiera S.A. (created in 1977). In May 1988, it received the authorization to operate as a commercial bank and it was incorporated as Banco Macro S.A. Subsequently, as a result of the merger process with other entities, it adopted other names (among them, Banco Macro Bansud S.A.) and since August 2006, the name of “Banco Macro S.A.”

From then onwards and up to 1995, Banco Macro operated as a wholesale bank, being a pioneer in corporate bonds issuances. It mainly acted in the areas of money market, trading of government and corporate bonds and financial services for medium and big companies.

Since 1994, Banco Macro has substantially changed its business strategy, focusing on retail banking in market areas with a low level of banking transactions and high growth potential and the Bank has focused on the regional areas outside the City of Buenos Aires. Following this strategy, in 1996, we started to acquire entities as well as assets and liabilities resulting from the privatization of provincial and other banks, including Banco Misiones, Banco Salta and Banco Jujuy.

 

25


Table of Contents

In 2001, 2004, 2006 and 2010, Banco Macro acquired control of Banco Bansud S.A., Nuevo Banco Suquía S.A., Nuevo Banco Bisel S.A. and Banco Privado de Inversiones S.A., respectively, expanding through these acquisitions its presence in the south and center of the country. Such entities merged with us on December 2003, October 2007, August 2009 and December 2013, respectively. In addition, during 2006, Banco Macro acquired control of Banco del Tucumán S.A.

The Bank currently offers traditional bank products and services to companies, including those operating in regional economies, as well as to individuals, thus reinforcing the Bank’s objective to be a multi-service bank.

In addition, Banco Macro performs certain transactions through its subsidiaries, including mainly Banco del Tucumán, Macro Bank Limited, Macro Securities S.A., Macro Fiducia S.A. and Macro Fondos S.G.F.C.I. S.A.

Our shares have been publicly listed on the MERVAL since November 1994, and on the NYSE since March 24, 2006 and have been authorized to list on the Mercado Abierto Electrónico (“MAE”) since October 2015.

Investment in property

In 2011 we acquired from the Government of the City of Buenos Aires a site located at Av. Eduardo Madero No. 1180, in the City of Buenos Aires, for an aggregate amount of Ps.110 million. The Bank has developed a project to build its new corporate offices on this site. Works were initiated in 2012 and are expected to be completed by 2017. As of December 31, 2015 the total aggregate amount invested in the project was Ps.734.9 million (approximately US$91.2 million at the applicable exchange rates as of the respective dates of such investments). The total cost of this project, is estimated at approximately US$160 million.

For more information, see Item 4.D “Property, plants and equipment”.

B. Business Overview

We are one of the leading banks in Argentina. With the most extensive private-sector branch network in the country, we provide standard banking products and services to a nationwide customer base. We distinguish ourselves from our competitors by our strong financial position and by our focus on low- and middle-income individuals and small- and medium-sized businesses, generally located outside of the City of Buenos Aires. We believe this strategy offers significant opportunity for continued growth in our banking business. According to the Central Bank, as of November 30, 2015, we were ranked first in terms of branches, second in terms of equity and third in terms of total loans and total deposits among private banks in Argentina.

As of December 31, 2015, on a consolidated basis, we had:

 

    Ps.104,952.0 million (US$8,070.1 million) in total assets;

 

    Ps.62,852.9 million (US$4,833.0 million) in loans to the non-financial private sector and foreign residents;

 

    Ps.76,521.6 million (US$5,884.0 million) in total deposits;

 

    approximately 3.1 million retail customers and 0.1 million corporate customers; and

 

    approximately 1.4 million employee payroll accounts for private sector customers and provincial governments and 0.7 million retiree accounts.

Our consolidated net income for the year ended December 31, 2015 was Ps.5,008.4 million (US$385.1 million), representing a return on average equity 37.2% and a return on average assets of 5.8%.

In general, given the relatively low level of banking intermediation in Argentina currently, there are limited products and services being offered. We are focusing on the overall growth of our loan portfolio by expanding our customer base and encouraging them to make use of our lending products. We have a holistic approach to our banking business; we do not manage the Bank by segments or divisions or by customer categories, by products and services, by regions, or by any other segmentation for the purpose of allocating resources and assessing profitability. We offer savings and checking accounts, credit and debit cards, consumer finance loans and other credit-related products and transactional services available to our individual customers and small- and medium-sized businesses through our branch network. We also offer Plan Sueldo payroll services, lending, corporate credit cards, mortgage finance, transaction processing and foreign exchange. In addition, our Plan Sueldo payroll processing services for private companies and the public sector give us a large and stable customer deposit base.

 

26


Table of Contents

Our competitive strengths

We believe we are well positioned to benefit from opportunities created by the economic and business environment in Argentina. Our competitive strengths include the following:

 

    Strong financial position. As of December 31, 2015 we had excess capital of Ps.6,915.6 million (20.8% capitalization ratio). Our excess capital is aimed at supporting growth, and consequently, a higher leverage of our balance sheet.

 

    Consistent profitability. As of December 31, 2015, we had obtained profitability for the last 56 consecutive quarters, the only bank with such a track record in Argentina, with a return on average equity of 33.3%, 33.4% and 37.2% for 2013, 2014 and 2015 compared to 29.5%, 32.7% and 32.4%, respectively, for the Argentine banking system as a whole.

 

    Our shareholders’ equity as of December 31, 2013, 2014 and 2015 as calculated under Central Bank Rules, was Ps.8,627.4 million, Ps.11,491.8 million and Ps.15,876.1, respectively, and our shareholders’ equity under U.S. GAAP at December 31, 2013, 2014 and 2015 was Ps.8,402.5 million, Ps.11,418.5 million and 15,873.2 million, respectively.

 

    Strong presence in fast-growing target customer market. We have achieved a leading position with low- and middle-income individuals and among small- and medium-sized businesses, generally located outside the City of Buenos Aires, which have been relatively underserved by the banking system. Based on our experience, this target market offers significant growth opportunities and a stable base of depositors.

 

    High exposure to export-led growth. Given the geographical location of the customers we target, we have acquired banks with a large number of branches outside of the City of Buenos Aires with the aim of completing our national coverage. The Bank’s focus is particularly on some export oriented provinces. Most of these provinces engage in economic activities primarily concentrated in areas such as agriculture, mining, cargo transportation, edible oils, ranching and tourism, which have benefited from the export-driven growth in the Argentine economy.

 

    Largest private-sector branch network in Argentina. With 439 branches, we have the most extensive branch network among private-sector banks in Argentina. We consider our branch network to be our key distribution channel for marketing our products and services to our entire customer base with a personalized approach. In line with our strategy, approximately 93% of these branches are located outside of the City of Buenos Aires.

 

    Loyal customer base. We believe that our customers are loyal to us due to our presence in traditionally underserved markets and our Plan Sueldo payroll services. We have benefited from Argentine regulations that require all employees to maintain Plan Sueldo accounts for the direct deposit of their wages. In addition, we emphasize face-to-face relationships with our customers and offer them personalized advice.

 

    Exclusive financial agent for four Argentine provinces. We perform financial agency services for the governments of the provinces of Salta, Jujuy, Misiones and Tucumán in northern Argentina. As a result, each provincial government’s bank accounts are held in our bank and we provide their employees with Plan Sueldo accounts, giving us access to substantial low cost funding and a large number of loyal customers.

 

    Strong and experienced management team and committed shareholders. We are led by committed shareholders who have transformed the Bank from a small wholesale bank to one of the strongest and largest banks in Argentina and by a senior management team with large experience in the banking industry.

Our strategy

Our competitive strengths position us to better participate in the future development of the Argentine financial system.

For the last three years, we have been operating in accordance with our sustainability policy based on five business-related strategic pillars that impact all our clients, establishing a short-, medium- and long-term sustainability strategy. Our strategic sustainability pillars are:

 

    Financial inclusion and education: encouraging the use of banking products and accessibility, focused on lower income sectors and the financial education of all communities.

 

    Direct and indirect environmental impact: encouraging the protection of the environment and society, both internally and in our value chain.

 

    Responsibility for the wellbeing and inclusion of people: aiming to improve the quality of life of individuals, we support the professional development of our staff and encourage diversity and inclusion.

 

    Development of small- and medium-sized companies (“Pymes”) and enterprises: accompanying our clients in the development of their businesses, offering customized products services and providing knowledge, advice and the best customer service.

 

    Transparency in all our actions: in order to create a framework of trust and credibility for all our interest groups, in compliance with the main national and international transparency and management responsibility standards and best practices.

 

27


Table of Contents

Our goal is to promote the overall growth of the Bank by increasing our customer base, expanding our loan portfolio and generating more fee income from transactional services. We achieve this goal by managing the Bank on a holistic basis, focusing our growth strategy on the marketing and promotion of our standard banking products and services. We have pursued our growth strategy by acquiring banks throughout Argentina, which has enabled us to significantly expand our branch network and customer base. We have taken advantage of the opportunities presented by the Argentine financial system to move into new locations by acquiring banks or absorbing branches from banks liquidated by the Central Bank.

We intend to continue enhancing our position as a leading Argentine bank. The key elements of our strategy include:

 

    Focus on underserved markets with strong growth potential. We intend to continue focusing on both low- and middle-income individuals and small- and medium-sized businesses, most of which have traditionally been underserved by the Argentine banking system and are generally located outside the City of Buenos Aires, where competition is relatively weaker and where we have achieved a leading presence. We believe that these markets offer attractive opportunities given the low penetration of banking services and limited competition.

 

    Further expand the branch network management model and the development of the network by opening new branches, reinforcing the local business opportunities and targeting the support and sale points in accordance with the specific needs of our clients.

 

    Further expand our customer base. We intend to continue growing our customer base, which is essential to increasing interest and fee-based revenues. To attract new customers we intend to:

 

    Offer medium- and long-term credit. We intend to capitalize on the increased demand for long-term credit that we believe will accompany the expected economic growth in Argentina. We intend to use our strong liquidity and our capital base to offer a more readily available range of medium- and long-term credit products than our competitors.

 

    Focus on corporate banking customers. Increase corporate financing by means of a wide offer of credit and transaction products that suit each client’s profile and needs

 

    Expand Plan Sueldo payroll services. We will continue to actively market our Plan Sueldo payroll services, emphasizing the benefits of our extensive network for companies with nationwide or regional needs.

 

    Strengthen our market share in credit cards by increasing promotional activity and benefits for clients.

 

    Further expand the use of automatic channels both in customer acquisition and retail products, increasing operational efficiency.

 

    Further expand the development of the customer service support, granting them different means to carry out financial transactions without time limits, in a total secure, simple and comfortable manner.

 

    Focus on new sustainability objectives, in line with the Bank’s business, in the fundamental areas of the Bank and further expand such initiatives.

Our products and services

We provide our customers with a combination of standard products and services that are designed to suit individual needs. We have two broad categories of customers: (i) retail customers, who include individuals and entrepreneurs and (ii) corporate customers, which include small, medium and large companies and major corporations. In addition, we provide services to four provincial governments. We offer a relatively narrow range of standard products, which are generally available to both our retail and corporate customers. We have a holistic approach to our banking business; we do not manage the Bank by segments or divisions or by customer categories, products and services, regions, or any other segmentation for the purpose of allocating resources or assessing profitability. Our strategy is to grow our business, as demand for credit in Argentina increases by focusing on cross-selling opportunities among our broad customer base. The following discussion of our business follows the broad customer categories of retail and corporate as a way to understand who our customers are and the products and services that we provide.

Retail customers

Overview

We serve natural persons with the objective of satisfying their financial needs, whether of savings, transactional or funding. Retail customers are classified according to their labor condition or their main income source, in the following categories: Plan Sueldo (Salary Plan), Retired, Open Market and Professionals and Business. We provide services to them throughout Argentina, in particular outside the City of Buenos Aires, which has higher concentrations of low- and middle-income individuals who are traditionally underserved by large private banks. We serve our retail customers through our extensive, nationwide branch network. Approximately 93% of our branches are located outside the City of Buenos Aires.

 

28


Table of Contents

We offer our retail customers traditional banking products and services, such as savings and checking accounts, time deposits, credit and debit cards, consumer finance loans (including personal loans), mortgage loans, automobile loans, overdrafts, credit-related services, home and car insurance coverage, tax collection, utility payments, automatic teller machines (“ATMs”) and money transfers.

Our retail customers provide us with a key source of funding as well as a significant interest and fee income. We believe that our large retail customer client base provides us with an excellent opportunity to expand the volume of our lending business. For example, of our retail customers, only 23% currently have a personal loan from us and only 38% currently have a credit card, and we believe there is strong potential to increase these percentages.

Our efforts have been aimed at strengthening relationships with our customers by offering them the products that are best suited to their needs and circumstances, through our individualized, professional advice, which we believe is an important feature that distinguishes us in our target markets.

Our main goals for the retail bank are to keep the leading and competitive position of our personal loans portfolio, increase our market share in the credit cards business, using this product as a tool to strengthen relations with customers, improve credit quality ratios and promote a diversified time deposit portfolio and to generate a strong and stable fee base.

In this regard, and aiming to continue growing in the credit card market, we intensified efforts to increase consumption and total assets. We also improved the use of our clients’ information as a tool to implement better cross selling, client retention and default prevention commercial actions.

In 2015, the market share of our consumer financing product lines remained stable, maintaining a sustained leading position, competitive position of our personal loan portfolio and significant growth of our credit card products.

Savings and checking accounts and time deposits

We generate fees from providing account maintenance, account statements, check processing and other direct banking transactions, direct debits, fund transfers, payment orders and bank debit cards. In addition, our time deposits provide us with a strong and stable funding base.

Our commercial and customer bonding actions enabled us to achieve growth in the deposit portfolio above market levels, mainly due to an increase in time deposits of retail customers which intensified funding diversification. In 2013, the portfolio showed significant growth of 33.5%, driven by a significant increase in demand deposits. In 2014, the deposit portfolio increased by 29% with an increase in demand deposits of 20% and time deposits of 35%. During 2015 deposits increased by 46% in average as compared to 2014. Our growth is mainly driven by funds from Plan Sueldo and retirement accounts.

In 2012 the government established that all payments made to pensioners by the ANSES must take place through financial institutions, which in our case resulted in the opening of over 200,000 accounts. Likewise, in 2013 the payment of governmental family credits into bank accounts was implemented, resulting in the opening of over 45,000 accounts and the issuance of the associated debit cards. In 2014 we recorded an increase of approximately 180,000 accounts. In 2015, the amount of retail accounts increased by 17%.

Our “Debit Card” product is critical within the framework of our strategies to increase customer transactions by encouraging the use of accounts. Its secondary purpose is to develop account balances due to increased deposits into transactional accounts, thus expanding our demand deposits base. With respect to transactional accounts, the monetary volume of purchase transactions increased by 40%, 45% and 51% in 2013, 2014 and 2015, respectively, while the number of debit card purchases increased by 31%, 27% and 15% in the same respective periods. In 2015 we increased our market participation from 7% to 9%.

The following table reflects the number of retail accounts as of December 31, 2013, 2014 and 2015:

 

    

Approximate number of retail accounts

(as of December 31, of each year)

 
Product    2013      2014      2015  

Savings

        

Total savings accounts

     2,231,442         2,340,533         2,725,792   

Plan Sueldo (private and public sector)

     1,138,655         1,209,496         1,365,612   

Retirees

     696,858         700,340         711,514   

Open market, professionals and business

     395,929         430,697         648,666   

Checking

        

Checking accounts

     538,407         610,184         713,577   

Electronic account access

        

Debit cards

     2,174,140         2,327,188         2,558,520   

Lending products and services

We offer personal loans, document discounts, (housing) mortgages, overdrafts, pledged loans and credit card loans to our retail customers.

 

29


Table of Contents

We intend to continue to increase our retail lending by focusing our marketing efforts on underserved target markets such as low- and middle-income individuals and to cross-sell our retail lending products to our existing customers, particularly those who have savings and checking accounts with us because we provide payroll and pension services.

In 2012, the Bank increased its market share in consumer loans, consolidating the Bank´s leadership and competitiveness in the personal loans market. In this context and focused on our continuous growth in the credit card market, we have reinforced our actions aiming to increase credit card consumption and total assets. The credit quality of the portfolio remained strong, improving the balance of risk assumed and benefits obtained from this portfolio. The efficiency of our marketing efforts was improved by implementing new channels (external marketing agencies and sales force).

In 2013, our retail loan portfolio grew by 30% as compared to December 31, 2012, which allowed us to maintain our market share and leadership in consumer loans. During 2013 our growth in personal loans reached 28%. This growth was accompanied by a substantial increase in profitability, which allowed us to maintain our leading position with a market share of 14% in 2013. Growth during 2013 was closely related to direct and mass communication campaigns launched in mid-2012 through highly efficient and low-cost and innovative communication channels. Text, voice and multimedia messaging actions were added to those already implemented.

In addition, aiming to strengthen our relationship with our customers and generating automatic loan extension mechanisms, two new personal loan extension channels were added in 2013: “pronto cash on line” whereby customers can obtain a loan in seconds directly through Home Banking and “pronto cash telefónico”, which allows customers to call our toll-free number and obtain cash immediately, to the extent they are pre-qualified.

To continue growing in the credit card market, actions aiming to increase consumption and total assets were strengthened. An aggressive new accounts and client acquisition plan was developed, supplemented with direct marketing campaigns to promote consumption and use of credit cards by phone. We maintained our point-of-sale promotion strategy, offering discounts and interest free payment installments, resulting in increased additional card consumption and automatic debits on credit cards. As a result of our actions, the credit card portfolio grew by 41% in 2013 as compared to 2012, attaining a market share of 8% in 2013.

During 2014, our retail loan portfolio increased by 21%, as compared to 2013, maintaining the second position among other institutions in the financial system in terms of volume of personal loan and credit card portfolios.

Our growth in personal loans during 2014 reached 16%, which allowed us to maintain our leading position with a market share of 14% in 2014, achieved as a result of our continuing with the mass communication strategy started in 2013. In addition to the communication tools already used by the Bank, mainly based on mobile devices, we included the “pre-approved loan notice”, through an alert on the Bank’s homebanking page. With the aim of improving the service and streamlining the granting of loans, we developed internal campaigns to encourage lending through automatic channels.

Our credit card business grew significantly in 2014, with the portfolio balance increasing by 35% and the consumption increasing by 43% as compared to the values reported as of December 31, 2013. During the year, an aggressive telemarketing program was executed aiming to improve benchmarks, including product activation, increased consumption and higher limits. Efforts were made to improve efficiency and reduce service costs, resulting in a material increase in the number of accounts subscribing to our e-account statement service. During the year we observed a significant increase in the profitability of these products, due to the implementation of a strategy aimed at increasing fees and reducing funding costs while not affecting business volumes.

In 2015, our retail loan portfolio increased by 47%, our personal loan portfolio grew by 44% and our credit card portfolio increased by 60% in each case as compared to 2014.

We are one of the major credit card issuers in Argentina, with approximately 2.2 million credit cards in circulation for retail costumers as of December 31, 2015. One of our initiatives to expand lending is to encourage low- and middle-income customers to use credit cards for larger purchases.

 

30


Table of Contents

As of December 31, 2013, 2014 and 2015, our consumer loan portfolio was as follows:

 

     Consumer loan portfolio  
     (as of December 31, of each year)  
     (in millions of Pesos and as percentage of consumer loan portfolio)  
     2013     2014     2015  

Overdrafts

     245.4         1.     251.1         0.91     290.2         0.7

Documents

     371.3         1.7     443.7         1.6     591.7         1.5

Mortgage and pledged loans

     874.6         3.9     959.3         3.6     1,014.7         2.6

Credit card loans

     6,358.4         28.5     8,554.9         31.8     13,661.9         34.5

Personal loans

     14,109.7         63.25     16,401.5         61.0     23,688.9         59.8

Other

     355.5         1.6     289.7         1.1     384.8         1.0

Total

     22,314.9         100.0     26,900.2         100.0     39,632.2         100.0

As of December 31, 2015, personal loans, the most representative share of our portfolio, carried an annual average interest rate of 40.1% and an average maturity of 46.4 months. Interest rates and maturities vary across products.

Plan Sueldo payroll services

Since 2001, Argentine labor law has provided for the mandatory payment of wages through accounts opened by employers in the name of each employee at financial institutions within two kilometers of the workplace, in the case of urban areas, and ten kilometers of the workplace, in the case of rural areas. There are similar requirements in place for pension payments.

We handle payroll processing for private sector companies and the public sector, which require employers to maintain an account with us for the direct deposit of employee wages. Currently, we provide payroll services for the governments of the Argentine provinces of Misiones, Salta, Jujuy and Tucumán and to the private sector for a total aggregate of 2.1 million retail clients (including retirees). Our Plan Sueldo payroll services provide us with a large and diversified deposit base with significant cross-selling potential.

Corporate customers

Overview

Legal and natural persons of the private non-financial sector that develop commercial and/or industrial activities are included. We provide our corporate customers with traditional banking products and services such as deposits, lending (including overdraft facilities), check cashing advances and factoring, guaranteed loans and credit lines for financing foreign trade and cash management services. We also provide them trust, payroll and financial agency services, corporate credit cards and other specialty products.

The corporate business is focused on the classification by sizes and sectors. We have four categories for our corporate customers: small companies, which register up to Ps.100 million in sales per year; medium-sized companies, which register more than Ps.100 million and less than Ps.150 million in sales per year; large companies, which register more than Ps.150 million in sales per year; and agro companies, which include individuals and companies who operate in agriculture or in the commerce of agricultural products.

As in previous years, the Bank continued developing its decentralized segment-specific service strategy aimed at improving customer service. At present, the Bank has a network of branches with business officials specialized in each category, offering a wide range of products, including working capital facilities, investment projects, leasings and foreign trade transactions.

Our corporate customer base also acts as a source of demand for our excess liquidity through overnight and short-term loans to large corporate customers. See Item 5.B “Operating and Financial Review and Prospects—Liquidity and Capital Resources”.

Lending products and services

Most of our current lending activity consists of working capital loans to small- and medium-sized businesses. Our historic focus on small- and medium-sized businesses has enabled us to diversify our credit risk exposure, by granting smaller-sized loans to clients in diverse business sectors. As of December 31, 2015, our 20 largest private sector loans accounted for 10% of our total corporate loans.

We offer short-term and medium- to long-term corporate lending products.

Short-term: Products include credit lines for up to 180 days and consist mainly of overdraft facilities, corporate credit and debit cards and factoring, as well as foreign trade related financing, such as pre-export, post-shipment and import financing. These products also include contingency lines, such as short-term guarantees (performance guarantees and bid bonds) and import letters of credit. The credit risk assigned to these kinds of transactions is the debtor rating described below, unless increased as a result of a pledge or a guarantee.

Medium- to long-term: Products include credit lines and specific lending facilities of more than 180 days. Credits are usually asset-based, such as leasing, whereby a credit enhancement is achieved by means of the underlying asset.

Medium- to long-term facility risks are mitigated through different mechanisms that range from pledges and mortgages to structured deals through financial trusts whereby the debtor pledges the underlying asset, mostly future income flows. Regardless of the term and based on the fact that these credit lines are devoted to small to medium-sized companies, our policy is to require personal guarantees from the owners, although the underlying debtor rating remains unchanged.

 

31


Table of Contents

In 2013, our corporate loan portfolio recorded a 19% increase compared to 2012. This development was driven by an increase in long term facilities, mainly pledge loans and mortgage loans. As in 2012, the contribution of the agribusiness and small and medium-sized companies, which were once again the most dynamic, was critical in 2013. Loans to agrocompanies and small companies, grew by 36% and 44%, respectively, in 2013 as compared to 2012. Medium-sized and large companies’ loan portfolio increased 9% and 4%, respectively, as compared to 2012.

During 2013, we provided a total of Ps.2.5 billion in financing through our Credit Facilities for Productive Investments, an amount above the mandatory minimum amount required by Central Bank Rules, supporting the Bank’s commitment to finance productive activities. The total outstanding amount as of December 31, 2013 was Ps. 3.0 billion.

In 2014, our corporate loan portfolio (without loans to large companies) increased by 17%, driven by an increase in pledge loans, discounted checks, work progress certificates and credit cards. This increase was offset by a 28% decrease in the large companies’ loan portfolio.

In respect of agribusiness banking, the weather in 2014 was not as harsh as in 2013, resulting in increased yields of traditional crops. In areas with higher productive potential, yields were in line with historical average values and in certain areas poor yields recorded in the two previous years were reversed. However, the general profitability of the sector is still affected by taxation and export controls, resulting in stagnation of business activity.

During 2014 we covered the financial needs of more than 15,000 agricultural producers, such as working capital financing, including approximately 1,000 investment projects totaling over Ps.578 million through the Credit Facilities for Productive Investments. Additionally, measures adopted in connection with Macro Agro Cards were especially important, resulting in a more effective activation of accounts and an increase in consumption volumes and portfolio balances of 51% and 62%, respectively, in 2014 mainly as a result of the new alliances. Loans to agribusiness companies grew by 14% in 2014 as compared to 2013.

In 2014, the loan portfolio for Pymes increased 22%, mainly due to the increase in discounted checks, pledged loans and other advances. Through our Credit Facilities for Productive Investments, the Bank funded venture projects for over 1,500 companies in an aggregate amount of Ps.935 million. In this regard, the Bank’s strategy was essential to reach more clients, offering them a wide range of products subject to a fast approval process.

In 2014, the medium-sized companies’ loan portfolio increased 14%, as compared to 2013.

In 2015, we focused on expanding our leadership in the corporate banking business.

We focused on supporting the development of the Pymes and local businesses. The greater portion of the Credit Facilities for Productive Investments was assigned to this group of clients, supporting investment projects that further develop these businesses and their related communities.

We forged strategic partnerships with corporate banking, urging them to offer high quality products to our Pyme clients. We created the Comunidad de Negocio (Business Community) concept, a management model that allowed us to increase our Pyme loan portfolio by 48% in the amount of granted credits. We also created specific credit facilities for Pymes.

In 2015, we developed specific credit lines for medium-sized and large companies. For large companies, the Bank was able to increase the penetration of Plan Sueldo (Salary Plan) accounts by embracing the geographic distribution of the network and the relationship with large companies.

In 2015, for the agribusiness sector, the Bank focused on positioning itself as a Banco de Proximidad (Local Bank), forging stronger relationships with producers, by means of periodic meetings with our clients in strategic zones.

The Macroagro Cards presented the greatest growth in 2015, showing the greatest increase in market share. We continued supporting local economies with customized products for the tobacco, sugar and “yerba” sectors.

We created strategic partnerships with large suppliers, which enabled our clients to purchase inputs at a minimal financial cost. This was very beneficial for segments with seasonal activities.

We relaunched our credit line for the development of the regional exports related to the Federal Investment Commission. In 2015, under this program, 11 transactions were closed totaling Ps.6.7 million.

As result of these measures, in 2015 the commercial loan portfolio increased by 34%, as compared to 2014. Loans to small and medium-sized companies increased by 47% in 2015, as compared to 2014, driven by a 53% increase in documents and a 62% increase in mortgage loans. Loans to agribusiness companies grew by 42% in 2015, as compared to 2014, driven by a 68% increase in credit card loans, a 46% increase in documents and a 47% increase in mortgage loans. Medium-sized and large companies’ loan portfolio increased by 30% and 2%, respectively, as compared to 2014.

 

32


Table of Contents

During 2015 we provided Ps. 3.0 billion in financing through our Credit Facilities for Productive Investments. As of December 31, 2015, the total amount outstanding was Ps. 6.3 billion.

As of December 31, 2013, 2014 and 2015, our commercial loan portfolio was as follows:

 

     Commercial loan portfolio (1)  
     (as of December 31, of each year)  
     (in millions of Pesos and as percentage of commercial loan portfolio)  
     2013     2014     2015  

Overdrafts

     4,371.6         24.7     3,261.9         18.1     4,547.8         18.8

Documents

     3,896.4         22.0     4,115.6         22.8     5,823.7         24.1

Mortgage and pledged loans

     2,957.7         16.7     3,483.6         19.1     4,782.4         19.8

Credit cards

     483.0         2.7     634.6         3.5     1,131.4         4.7

Personal loans

     16.4         0.1     14.2         0.1     14.8         0.1

Other

     5,988.8         33.8     6,516.3         36.1     7,896.0         32.6

Total

     17,713.9         100.0     18,026.1         100.0     24,196.1         100.0

 

(1) Including loans to micro credit institutions and commercial loans that for the consolidated statements of debtors was included as consumer portfolio following the criteria described in “-Argentine banking regulation – credit portfolio”.

Transaction services

We offer transaction services to our corporate customers, such as cash management, collection services, payments to suppliers, payroll services, foreign exchange transactions, foreign trade services, corporate credit cards, and information services, such as our Datanet and Interpymes services. There are usually no credit risks involved in these transactions, except for intra-day gapping (payments done against incoming collections), as well as settlement and pre-settlement related to foreign exchange transactions which, in general, are approved following the debtor rating process.

Payments to suppliers. Our payments to suppliers service enable our customers to meet their payment obligations to their suppliers on a timely basis through a simple and efficient system. This service also provides payment liquidations, tax payment receipts, invoices and any other documents required by the payer.

Collection services. Our collection services include cash or check deposits at our 439 branches, automatic and direct debits from checking or savings accounts and the transportation of funds collected from corporate customers to our branches for deposit. Our extensive branch network enables us to offer fast and efficient collection services throughout Argentina, which is of critical importance to both regional and nationwide companies.

Datanet and Interpymes. We provide our corporate clients with access to the Datanet service, which is an electronic banking network linking member banks in Argentina. These services permit our clients to obtain reliable on-line information on a real-time basis from their bank accounts in Datanet as well as, to perform certain transactions.

Interpymes is an electronic banking system designed to meet the needs of small businesses. It does not require special installation procedures and is easily accessible through the Internet, helping to simplify day-to-day operations for our customers.

Tax collection and financial agency services. We also have exclusive, long-term arrangements to provide tax collection and financial agency services to four provinces.

Payroll services. We provide payroll services to four provinces and to the private sector. See “Our products and services – Retail customers”.

Our distribution network

As of December 31, 2015, we had the largest private sector branch network in the country, with 439 branches spread throughout Argentina. In particular, in line with our strategy of expanding nationally, we have extensive coverage in the provinces of Argentina with 93% of our branches located outside the City of Buenos Aires. Furthermore, as of December 31, 2015 we had 1,333 ATMs, 922 self-service terminals (“SSTs”), 62 service points used for social security benefit payments and servicing of checking and savings accounts and an internet banking service (home banking).

The following table breaks down the distribution of our branches per province as of December 31, 2015:

 

     As of December 31, 2015  
Province    Branches    % of total  

City of Buenos Aires

   32      7.3

Buenos Aires (Province)

   61      13.9

Catamarca

   1      0.2

Chaco

   1      0.2

Chubut

   5      1.1

Cordoba

   66      15.0

Corrientes

   3      0.7

Entre Rios

   10      2.3

Formosa

   0      0.0

Jujuy

   15      3.4

La Pampa

   2      0.5

La Rioja

   2      0.5

Mendoza

   15      3.4

Misiones

   33      7.5

Neuquen

   5      1.1

Rio Negro

   6      1.4

Salta

   32      7.3

San Juan

   1      0.2

San Luis

   1      0.2

Santa Cruz

   2      0.5

Santa Fe

   106      24.1

Santiago del Estero

   2      0.5

Tierra del Fuego

   2      0.5

Tucuman

   36      8.2

TOTAL

   439      100.0

Source: Central Bank

 

33


Table of Contents

Technology and automated channels

The Bank’s technological development is continuous and the number of alternative methods to perform banking transactions is increasing. Automated channels allow our clients to perform banking transactions with enhanced speed, comfort and safety, offering a wide variety of available transactions.

During the last three years we have focused on automatic channels, giving customers more accessible and flexible services. As a result, the use of automated channels continued expanding, in terms of volume of transactions and number of users.

New actions were implemented to maintain high security, service quality and availability standards in our ATM network through preventive management and training strategies. We increased the number of ATMs with cash recognition and online deposit crediting and the number of ATMs with voice guidance for the blind or vision impaired.

This placed the Bank in a leading position as to service quality, which is especially important considering the number and geographical dispersion of ATMs installed by us.

Furthermore, we continued strengthening and updating the technology offered at our ATMs, reaching a total of 1,333 operating ATMs, representing one of the widest reaching networks in the country.

We have self-service terminals distributed in our branch network across the country, offering an ample variety of operations, including the possibility of making deposits 24x7 all year long. In 2014, we incorporated the smart check deposit functionality. This development has been beneficial both to the Bank (increased efficiency by reducing operating tasks in branches) and to clients (safety and reduced transaction times). In 2015, new SSTs were installed, totaling 922 SSTs.

In respect of the use of home banking, we have implemented a collections service for companies, offering the following benefits: security (no cash or checks are transported to the branch), practicality (easy and safe, backup of receipts in a PDF file, possibility to review the history of payments and receipts), accessibility (from any PC) and no additional cost. Also we used home banking to inform our retail customers about the possibility of getting a personal loan, the amount available and how to apply for it. The transactions performed through home banking increased by 10% in 2015.

Our “Macro Banca Móvil” channel has developed significantly in the last three years. In 2015 the number of users has doubled,the number of total transactions increased by 170% and the amounts involved increased by 136%.

In line with the characteristics of the users and the technological trends supporting the development of the service, the “Macro Banca Móvil” application is available in the main virtual stores of the principal operating systems.

The significant and sustained increase in the number of users and transactions performed by automated channels evidences the effectiveness and level of acceptance of these services in the market. Our challenge for 2016 is to continue developing new client offerings like investment products, such as the purchase and sale of securities through automated channels.

In 2015 we made significant investments and developments in technology, including the following:

 

    Completion of development of the new infrastructure for Virtualization

 

    Commencement of implementation Cyberbank system that will allow the integration of multiple channels of customer service with the goal of achieving a coherent and consistent communication throughout the various channels used by the client

 

    Simplification of the structure of the branches in order to reduce complexity and the time spent managing internal infrastructure

 

    Replacement of the entire Network Core LAN (Local Area Network)

 

    Implementation of the post-sale system supported by Siebel in branch and telephone support

 

    Implementation of SAP

The total amount that we plan to invest in technology in 2016 is approximately US$46 million

Risk management policies

To comply with the “Risk Management Guidelines for Financial Institutions” set forth under Communication “A” 5203, as amended, we have adopted various measures at our organizational structure level and have implemented procedures to ensure the establishment of an independent risk management process.

 

34


Table of Contents

As to the Bank’s organizational structure, the board of directors has created a Risk Management Committee and appointed a Comprehensive Risk Manager responsible for coordinating the application of risk management policies and the relevant responsible officers. For more information, see Item 6.C “Board Practices”.

The Comprehensive Risk Manager coordinates the heads of financial risk, credit risk and operational risk, who are in charge of implementing the guidelines contained in the risk management framework policy.

Our risk management framework policy establishes the environment for the risk management process under the notions of risk identification, measurement, monitoring and mitigation. In addition, it lays out the duties of each organizational level in the process.

Our risk management process includes the setting of acceptable risk levels by the board of directors, monitoring of the Bank’s compliance with such levels by responsible officers, the issuance of regular reports for the Risk Management Committee, the follow up on alerts and the application of action plans in connection with such alerts and the guidelines for the development of stress tests, which commenced in 2013 based on an action plan approved by the Risk Management Committee.

The development of the stress test program was established and planned. The process includes documenting and formalizing the program, including selecting the persons in charge of carrying out the program, the frequency of testing and validation of the system. It also contemplates the contingency plan based on test results. The Risk Management Committee leads and coordinates these tasks.

Additionally, the system is supplemented with policies and procedures specific to each risk (financial, credit, operational, counterparty credit, country risk, securitization, reputational, compliance, strategic risks, among others).

Economic capital estimate

Economic capital is the estimated amount of unexpected losses identified for each one of the individual risks (financial, credit, counterparty credit, concentration, operational, securitization, strategic and reputational) determined for the Bank on a consolidated basis.

Starting in January 2014, we implemented a formal procedure for quantifying economic capital, both current and prospective, and it is a tool used in the day-to-day management of risks, in preparing the “business plan” and in the “stress tests”.

The methods used to measure the economic capital of each risk were documented and approved by management, pursuant to the internal rules on corporate governance and risk management.

The most significant risks managed by the Bank are financial risk, credit risk and operational risk.

Financial risk

Financial risk is understood to be comprised of liquidity, market and interest rate risks, which, independently or in an interrelated manner, can affect the Bank’s liquidity and solvency.

The Bank has strategies, policies and limits defined for each exposure which have been approved by the board of directors within the framework of market, liquidity and interest rate risk management. This process is reviewed periodically by the Risk Management Committee in accordance with the guidelines set forth by Central Bank.

The purpose of the financial risk policy is to ensure that the Risk Management Committee and senior management have the proper procedures, tools and information to enable them to measure, manage and control the applicable risks.

For more information on financial risk definition and management processes see note 18 “Risk management policies” to our audited consolidated financial statements as of and for the three years ended December 31, 2015.

Credit risk

Credit policy and credit risk management

The Credit Risk Management Committee is responsible for establishing the policies and procedures for risk management and monitoring our senior management’s activities involving the management of credit risks, among others. It advises the board of directors on the Bank’s risks.

The Credit Risk Management area is in charge of interpreting, executing and guaranteeing the application of the General Credit Policy approved by the board of directors, ensuring proper identification, assessment, control, follow-up and mitigation of the credit risk.

Credit risk results from the possibility of loss derived from customers or counterparties from fully or partially breaching financial obligations they have undertaken with the Bank.

The Bank has counterparty and credit risk policies and strategies, the purpose of which is to ensure that risks fall within a risk tolerance level decided by the board of directors and regulators.

 

35


Table of Contents

Credit risk rating and approval process

In order to determine the credit risk, our Credit Risk Department qualifies each individual or company by means of a risk rating model, assigning a rating to each debtor, taking into consideration quantitative as well as qualitative concepts. The Credit Risk Department has focused its actions on increasing the quality and efficiency of the credit risk rating process.

There are specific policies and procedures for loan granting for Corporate and Retail customers, which differ according to the segment to which they belong (public or private payroll, retirees or open market).

Credit risk assessment for retail customers includes the use of risk applications based on screening and scoring methods related to an arrears level. There is also a mass-scale and centralized qualification process for clients and credit prequalification models for the assessment of potential customers from different sales campaigns.

Various credit committees, composed of members of the business and risk areas are responsible for reviewing and determining whether to approve certain loans, depending upon relevant market targeted and the amount involved. These include a senior credit committee, a junior credit committee, a credit committee by business, a credit committee by region and a small agribusiness committee. The senior credit committee consists of members of the board of directors and senior management and considers loan proposals in excess of Ps.25 million.

In Corporate Banking, approval by credit committees is required and specific risk reports are prepared by the customer or by the group of companies to support credit decisions. To streamline this process of approving pre-defined products and smaller amounts, there are decentralized assessment methods in place for agribusinesses, pymes and microprojects, including screening and scoring parameters, which allow speeding up the approval of pre-defined products and smaller accounts.

The Bank has a Management Information System according to the magnitude of its operations. Its components include an automated tool for the calculation of key performance indicators, for which alert and limit values have been determined in order to monitor business changes according to the risk appetite defined by the board of directors. Other credit risk management tools used are evaluation or score models, which are used at different stages of the credit cycle, attributing an internal risk rating to customers, according to which the assigned credit limits are managed and according to which the portfolio is monitored. Those tools are complemented with expected losses, forecast and provision models.

For more information on the credit risk management process see note 18 “Risk management policies” to our audited consolidated financial statements as of and for the three years ended December 31, 2015.

Operational risk

Operational risk, which we define pursuant to the Basel II Accord and Communication “A” 5398 of the Central Bank, consists of the risk of suffering losses due to inadequate or failed in the internal processes, systems or persons, or due to external events. This definition includes legal risk but excludes strategic and reputational risk.

The Bank has policies, procedures and structures, appointing a head of operational risk and an operational risk committee, whose main objective is to secure an operational risk management plan which includes policies, programs, measurements and competencies for identifying, assessing and managing risks, with the purpose of assisting area managers and the Bank’s board of directors, in an environment of rapidly changing and significant risks.

In this context, the Evolutionary Comprehensive Operational Risk Management Model was developed, which involves the identification, measurement, management and monitoring of operational risks. A training plan was designed to begin conveying the concepts inherent to Operational Risk and the cultural change that this generates, and an implementation plan of the model was put into practice to achieve full implementation of all of its stages.

A quantitative approach is used to measure operational risk and technological risk. In respect of risk management related to the IT and information systems, we have contingency and business continuity plans in place to minimize the risks that could affect the Bank’s continuity of operations.

We have an incentives system to manage operational risk in such a way that it would encourage involvement and risk assessment. The risk assessment policy has also been reinforced for new products and in modifications to existing products.

In addition, the implementation of improvements on different functions of our risk management system also continued.

For more information on operational risk management processes see note 18 “Risk management policies” to our audited consolidated financial statements as of and for the three years ended December 31, 2015.

Competition

We believe that we have an important advantage over our competitors in providing banking products and services to small communities in the provinces of Argentina as a result of the close community relationships and strong loyalty we have developed over time with our customers in these areas.

 

36


Table of Contents

We consider Banco Santander Río S.A., Banco de Galicia y Buenos Aires S.A., BBVA Banco Francés S.A., HSBC Bank Argentina S.A. and Banco Patagonia S.A. to be our main competitors among private banks. We also compete with regional banks.

In the future, we expect competition to increase in corporate transactions products, long-term lending, mortgage lending and other secured financings, credit cards, personal loans, payroll services and investment management services.

Competitive landscape

We are ranked as the third private bank and the fifth bank overall in Argentina in terms of total loans and total deposits as of November 30, 2015. In terms of equity we are ranked as the second private bank and the third bank overall in Argentina as of November 30, 2015. Below are the rankings of banks across these metrics:

 

Total Loans

(As of November 30, 2015)

 

Ps.

Thousands

   

Market Share

(% share of total private
sector loans for the
Argentine

financial system)

 
1  

BANCO DE LA NACION ARGENTINA(1)

    142,269,672        16.7
2  

BANCO DE LA PROVINCIA DE BUENOS AIRES(1)

    82,299,183        9.7
3  

BANCO SANTANDER RIO S.A.

    79,345,579        9.3
4  

BANCO DE GALICIA Y BUENOS AIRES S.A.

    68,950,154        8.1
5  

BANCO MACRO S.A. (2)

    61,194,298        7.2
6  

BBVA BANCO FRANCES S.A.

    53,219,783        6.3
7  

BANCO DE LA CIUDAD DE BUENOS AIRES(1)

    34,501,780        4.1
8  

HSBC BANK ARGENTINA S.A.

    33,563,941        3.9
9  

BANCO PATAGONIA S.A.

    30,933,856        3.6
10  

BANCO CREDICOOP COOPERATIVO LIMITADO

    27,229,068        3.2
 

OTHERS

    237,190,843        27.9
 

TOTAL

    850,698,157        100.0

Source: Central Bank

 

(1) Public sector banks.
(2) Figures from Banco Macro S.A. and Banco del Tucumán S.A.

 

Total Deposits

(As of November 30, 2015)

 

Ps.

Thousands

   

Market Share

(% share of total
deposits for the
Argentine financial
system)

 
1  

BANCO DE LA NACION ARGENTINA(1)

    362,619,202        28.7
2  

BANCO DE LA PROVINCIA DE BUENOS AIRES(1)

    114,187,469        9.0
3  

BANCO SANTANDER RIO S.A.

    94,646,535        7.5
4  

BANCO DE GALICIA Y BUENOS AIRES S.A.

    88,299,380        7.05
5  

BANCO MACRO S.A. (2)

    71,990,628        5.7
6  

BBVA BANCO FRANCES S.A.

    66,683,345        5.3
7  

BANCO CREDICOOP COOPERATIVO LIMITADO

    50,802,972        4.0
8  

HSBC BANK ARGENTINA S.A.

    45,504,043        3.6
9  

BANCO DE LA CIUDAD DE BUENOS AIRES(1)

    42,855,697        3.4
10  

BANCO PATAGONIA S.A.

    37,581,534        3.0
 

OTHERS

    290,306,402        22.9
 

TOTAL

    1,265,477,207        100.0

Source: Central Bank

 

(1) Public sector banks.
(2) Figures from Banco Macro S.A. and Banco del Tucumán S.A.

 

Equity

(As of November 30, 2015)

  

Ps.

Thousands

    

Market Share

(% share of equity for
the Argentine
financial system)

 
1  

BANCO DE LA NACION ARGENTINA(1)

     55,344,165         25.3
2  

BANCO SANTANDER RIO S.A.

     15,515,032         7.1
3  

BANCO MACRO S.A.(2)

     15,231,565         7.0
4  

BBVA BANCO FRANCES S.A.

     13,425,107         6.1
5  

BANCO DE GALICIA Y BUENOS AIRES S.A.

     13,318,791         6.1
6  

BANCO DE LA PROVINCIA DE BUENOS AIRES(1)

     9,076,151         4.1
7  

HSBC BANK ARGENTINA S.A.

     9,030,986         4.1
8  

CITIBANK N.A.

     8,021,690         3.7
9  

BANCO PATAGONIA S.A.

     7,422,897         3.4
10  

BANCO DE LA CIUDAD DE BUENOS AIRES(1)

     6,384,511         2.9
 

OTHERS

     66,274,775         30.3
 

TOTAL

     219,045,670         100.0

Source: Central Bank

 

(1) Public sector banks.
(2) Figures from Banco Macro.

There is a large concentration of branches in the City and province of Buenos Aires in the financial system as a whole, as shown by the following table. However, we have the most extensive private-sector branch network in Argentina, and a leading regional presence holding 71% of our total branches in nine provinces including Santa Fe, Córdoba, Mendoza, Río Negro, and Tierra del Fuego, in addition to Misiones, Salta, Tucumán and Jujuy.

 

37


Table of Contents
     As of November 30, 2015  
     Banking system     Banco Macro (1)    

Market Share

(% share of

total of

branches in

each province)

 
Province    Branches      % of total     Branches      % of total        

City of Buenos Aires

     762         17.4     32         7.3     4.2

Buenos Aires (Province)

     1362         31.1     61         14.0     4.5

Catamarca

     25         0.6     1         0.2     4.0

Chaco

     63         1.4     1         0.2     1.6

Chubut

     98         2.2     5         1.1     5.1

Cordoba

     441         10.1     66         15.1     15.0

Corrientes

     93         2.1     3         0.7     3.2

Entre Rios

     140         3.2     10         2.3     7.1

Formosa

     24         0.5     0         0.0     0.0

Jujuy

     33         0.8     15         3.4     45.5

La Pampa

     108         2.5     2         0.5     1.9

La Rioja

     26         0.6     2         0.5     7.7

Mendoza

     159         3.6     15         3.4     9.4

Misiones

     63         1.4     33         7.6     52.4

Neuquen

     97         2.2     5         1.1     5.2

Rio Negro

     72         1.6     6         1.4     8.3

Salta

     61         1.4     30         6.9     49.2

San Juan

     37         0.8     1         0.2     2.7

San Luis

     52         1.2     1         0.2     1.9

Santa Cruz

     46         1.1     2         0.5     4.3

Santa Fe

     459         10.5     106         24.3     23.1

Santiago del Estero

     53         1.2     2         0.5     3.8

Tierra del Fuego

     22         0.5     2         0.5     9.1

Tucuman

     81         1.9     36         8.2     44.4

TOTAL

     4,377         100.0     437         100.0     10.0

Source: Central Bank

 

(1) Includes branches of Banco Macro and Banco del Tucumán.

Approximately 83% of the branches in the Argentine financial system are located outside the City of Buenos Aires; in our case, approximately 93% of our branches are outside the City of Buenos Aires. The ten largest banks, in terms of branches, account for 70% of the total number of branches in the Argentine financial system. As of November 30, 2015 we were second to Banco de la Nación Argentina in terms of market share outside the City of Buenos Aires, with a market share of 11.2%. The following ranking is based on financial institutions with a relevant number of branches as of November 30, 2015:

 

     As of November 30, 2015  
Entity    Total
Number of
Branches
     Market
Share of
Branches in
Argentina
    Branches
in City of
Buenos
Aires
     Market
Share of
Branches in
City of
Buenos Aires
    Branches
in the Rest
of Country
     Market
Share of
Branches in
Rest of
Country
    % of
Branches in
the Rest of
Country
 

BANCO DE LA NACION ARGENTINA (1)

     633         14.5     63         8.3     570         15.8     90.0

BANCO MACRO S.A. (2)

     437         10.0     32         4.2     405         11.2     92.7

BANCO DE LA PROVINCIA DE BUENOS AIRES (1)

     392         9.0     103         13.5     289         8.0     73.7

BANCO SANTANDER RIO S.A.

     340         7.8     38         5.0     302         8.4     88.8

BANCO DE GALICIA Y BUENOS AIRES S.A.

     259         5.9     84         11.0     175         4.8     67.6

BANCO CREDICOOP COOPERATIVO LIMITADO

     257         5.9     40         5.2     217         6.0     84.4

BBVA BANCO FRANCES S.A.

     250         5.7     81         10.6     169         4.7     67.6

BANCO DE LA PROVINCIA DE CORDOBA S.A.(1)

     173         4.0     40         5.2     133         3.7     76.9

BANCO PATAGONIA S.A.

     172         3.9     1         0.1     171         4.7     99.4

HSBC BANK ARGENTINA S.A.

     138         3.2     45         5.9     93         2.6     67.4

OTHERS

     1,326         30.3     237         31.0     1,089         30.1     82.1

TOTAL

     4,377         100.0     762         100.0     3,615         100.0     82.5

Source: Central Bank

 

(1) Public sector bank.
(2) Includes branches of Banco Macro and Banco del Tucumán.

Argentine banking regulation

Overview

Founded in 1935, the Central Bank is the principal monetary and financial authority in Argentina. Its mission is to promote monetary and financial stability, employment and economic development with social equity. It operates pursuant to its charter, which was amended in 2012 by Law No. 26,739 and the provisions of the Financial Institutions Law. Under the terms of its charter, the Central Bank must operate independently from the Argentine government.

 

38


Table of Contents

Since 1977, activities in Argentina have been regulated primarily by the Financial Institutions Law, which empowers the Central Bank to regulate the financial sector. The Central Bank regulates and supervises the Argentine banking system through the Superintendency. The Superintendency is responsible for enforcing Argentina’s banking laws, establishing accounting and financial reporting requirements for the banking sector, monitoring and regulating the lending practices of financial institutions and establishing rules for participation of financial institutions in the foreign exchange market and the issuance of bonds and other securities, among other functions.

The powers of the Central Bank include the authority to fix monetary base, interest rate, minimum capital, liquidity and solvency requirements, regulate credit, approve bank mergers, approve certain capital increases and transfers of stock, grant and revoke banking licenses, and to authorize the establishment of branches of foreign financial institutions in Argentina and the extension of financial assistance to financial institutions in cases of temporary liquidity or solvency problems.

The Central Bank establishes certain “technical ratios” that must be observed by financial entities, such as ratios related to levels of solvency, liquidity, the maximum credits that may be granted per customer and foreign exchange assets and liability positions.

In addition, financial entities need the authorization of the Central Bank for the disposition of their assets, such as opening or changing branches or ATMs, acquiring share interests in other financial or non-financial corporations and establishing liens over their assets, among others.

As supervisor of the financial system, the Central Bank requires financial institutions to submit information on a daily, monthly, quarterly, semi-annual and annual basis. These reports, which include balance sheets and income statements, information relating to reserve funds, use of deposits, classifications of portfolio quality (including details on principal debtors and any allowances for loan losses), compliance with capital requirements and any other relevant information, allow the Central Bank to monitor the business practices of financial entities. In order to confirm the accuracy of the information provided, the Central Bank is authorized to carry out inspections.

If the Central Bank’s rules are not complied with, various sanctions may be imposed by the Superintendency, depending on the level of infringement. These sanctions range from a notice of non-compliance to the imposition of fines or, in extreme cases, the revocation of the financial entity’s operating license. Additionally, non-compliance with certain rules may result in the compulsory filing of specific adequacy or restructuring plans with the Central Bank. These plans must be approved by the Central Bank in order to permit the financial institution to remain in business.

Banking Regulation and Supervision

Central Bank Supervision

Since September 1994, the Central Bank has supervised the Argentine financial entities on a consolidated basis. Such entities must file periodic consolidated financial statements that reflect the operations of head offices or headquarters as well as those of their branches in Argentina and abroad, and of their significant subsidiaries, whether domestic or foreign. Accordingly, requirements in relation to liquidity and solvency, minimum capital, risk concentration and loan loss provisions, among others, should be calculated on a consolidated basis.

Permitted activities and investments

The Financial Institutions Law governs any individuals and entities that perform habitual financial intermediation and, as such, are part of the financial system, including commercial banks, investment banks, mortgage banks, financial companies, savings and loan companies for residential purposes and credit unions. Except for commercial banks, which are authorized to conduct all financial activities and services that are specifically established by law or by regulations of the Central Bank, the activities that may be carried out by Argentine financial entities are set forth in the Financial Institutions Law and related Central Bank Rules. Commercial banks are allowed to perform any and all financial activities inasmuch as such activities are not forbidden by law. Some of the activities permitted for commercial banks include the ability to (i) receive deposits from the public in both local and foreign currency; (ii) underwrite, acquire, place or negotiate debt securities, including government securities, in both exchange and over-the-counter markets (subject to prior approval by the CNV, if applicable); (iii) grant and receive loans; (iv) guarantee customers’ debts; (v) conduct foreign currency exchange transactions; (vi) issue credit cards; (vii) act, subject to certain conditions, as brokers in real estate transactions; (viii) carry out commercial financing transactions; (ix) act as registrars of mortgage bonds; (x) participate in foreign exchange transactions; and (xi) act as fiduciary in financial trusts. In addition, pursuant to the Financial Institutions Law and Central Bank Communication “A” 3086, as amended, commercial banks are authorized to operate commercial, industrial, agricultural and other types of companies that do not provide supplemental services to the banking services (as defined by applicable Central Bank Rules) to the extent that the commercial bank’s interest in such companies does not exceed 12.5% of its voting stock or 12.5% of its capital stock. Nonetheless, if the aforementioned limits were to be exceeded, the bank should (i) request Central Bank’s authorization; or (ii) give notice of such situation to the Central Bank, as the case may be. However, even when commercial banks’ interests do not reach such percentages, they are not allowed to operate such companies if (i) such interest allows them to control a majority of votes at a shareholders’ or board of directors’ meeting, or (ii) the Central Bank does not authorize the acquisition.

Furthermore, in respect of supplementary services, pursuant to Communication “A” 5700, commercial banks are authorized to operate in local or foreign companies that have one or two of the exclusive corporate purposes listed in section 2.2 of Communication “A” 5700, in which the commercial bank’s interest either exceeds 12.5% of such companies’ voting stock or allows the commercial bank to control a majority of votes at a shareholders’ or board of directors’ meeting. If the corporate purposes of such companies include two of the corporate purposes listed in section 2.2 of Communication “A” 5700, the authorization of the Central Bank is required.

 

39


Table of Contents

Under Central Bank Rules, the total amount of the investments of a commercial bank in the capital stock of third parties, including interests in Argentine mutual investment funds, may not exceed 50% of such bank’s regulatory capital (Responsabilidad Patrimonial Computable, or “RPC”). In addition, the total amount of a commercial bank’s investments in the following: (i) unlisted stock, excluding interests in companies that provide services that are supplementary to the finance business and interests in state-owned companies that provide public services, (ii) listed stock and interests in mutual funds that do not give rise to minimum capital requirements on the basis of market risk, and (iii) listed stock that does not have a “largely publicly available market price,” taken as a whole, is limited to 15% of such bank’s RPC. To this effect, a given stock’s market price is considered to be “largely publicly available” when daily quotations of significant transactions are available, and the sale of such stock held by the bank would not significantly affect the stock’s quotation.

Operations and activities that banks are not permitted to perform

The Financial Institutions Law prohibits commercial banks from: (a) creating liens on their assets without prior approval from the Central Bank, (b) accepting their own shares as security, (c) conducting transactions with their own directors or managers and with companies or persons related thereto under terms that are more favorable than those regularly offered in transactions with other clients, and (d) carrying out commercial, industrial, agricultural or other activities without prior approval of the Central Bank, except those considered financially related activities under Central Bank Rules. Notwithstanding the foregoing, banks may own shares in other financial institutions with the prior approval of the Central Bank, and may own shares or debt of public services companies, if necessary to obtain those services.

Liquidity and solvency requirements

As of 1994, the Central Bank supervision of financial institutions is carried out on a consolidated basis. Therefore, all of the documentation and information filed with the Central Bank, including financial statements, must show the operations of each entity’s headquarters and all of its branches (in Argentina and abroad), the operations of significant subsidiaries and, as the case may be, of other companies in which such entity holds stock. Accordingly, all requirements relating to liquidity, minimum capital, risk concentration and bad debts’ reserves, among others, are calculated on a consolidated basis.

Legal reserve

Pursuant to the Financial Institutions Law, we are required to maintain a legal reserve which must be funded with no more than 20% and no less than 10% of yearly income. Pursuant to Central Bank Rules, we maintain a legal reserve which is funded with 20% of our yearly income. This reserve can only be used during periods in which a financial institution has incurred losses and has exhausted all other reserves. If a financial institution does not comply with the required legal reserve, it is not allowed to pay dividends to its shareholders.

Non-liquid assets

Since February 2004, non-liquid assets (computed on the basis of their closing balance at the end of each month, and net of those assets that are deducted to compute the regulatory capital) plus the financings granted to a financial institution’s related parties (computed on the basis of the highest balance during each month for each customer) cannot exceed 100% of the Argentine regulatory capital of the financial institution, except for certain particular cases in which it may exceed up to 150%.

Non-liquid assets consist of miscellaneous assets and receivables, bank property and equipment, assets securing obligations, except for swap, futures and derivative transactions, certain intangible assets and equity investments in unlisted companies or listed shares, if the holding exceeds 2.5% of the issuing company’s equity. Non-compliance with the ratio produces an increase in the minimum capital requirements equal to 100% of the excess on the ratio.

Minimum capital requirements

The Central Bank requires that financial institutions maintain minimum capital amounts measured as of each month’s closing. The minimum capital is defined as the greater of (i) the basic minimum capital requirement, which is explained below, or (ii) the sum of the credit risk, operational risk and market risk. Financial institutions (including their domestic Argentine and international branches) must comply with the minimum capital requirements both on an individual and a consolidated basis.

The capital composition to be considered in order to determine compliance with minimum capital requirements is the financial institution’s RPC (Communication “A” 5580).

Minimum capital requirements of commercial banks acting as custodians of securities representing investments of the Fondo de Garantía de Sustentabilidad del Sistema Integrado Previsional Argentino and/or as registrar of mortgage securities must comply with an extra 0.25% of the value of securities in custody and/or mortgage securities and must be invested in Argentine public bonds or monetary regulation instruments.

 

40


Table of Contents

Basic minimum capital

The basic minimum capital requirement varies depending on the type of financial institution and the jurisdiction in which the financial institution’s headquarter is registered, with Ps.26 million for banks under category I and II (Ps.12 million for other financial entities under this category), and Ps.15 million for banks under category III to VI (Ps.8 million for other financial entities under this category).

 

Category

 

Banks

 

Other Entities (*)

I and II

  Ps.26 million   Ps.12 million

III and IV

  Ps.15 million   Ps.8 million

(*)    Except credit unions.

Additionally, financial entities located in ports and airports must comply with Category I requirements and those entities engaged in foreign trade transactions must comply with the requirements applicable to banks under such category.

Notwithstanding the foregoing, the regulatory capital of commercial banks acting as custodians of securities representing investments of the Fondo de Garantía de Sustentabilidad del Sistema Integrado Previsional Argentino must be equal to or exceed the greater of Ps.400 million or an amount equivalent to 1% of the total book value of the securities in custody.

Regulatory Capital of Financial Institution: Tier 1 and Tier 2 capital regulations

Argentine financial institutions must comply with guidelines similar to those adopted by the Basel Committee on Banking Regulations and Supervisory Practices, as amended in 1995 (the “Basel Rules”). In certain respects, however, Argentine banking regulations require higher ratios than those set forth under the Basel Rules.

The Central Bank takes into consideration a financial institution’s RPC in order to determine compliance with capital requirements. Pursuant to Communications “A” 5369 and “A” 5580, as amended and supplemented, RPC consists of Tier 1 Capital (Basic Net Worth) and Tier 2 Capital (Complementary Net Worth).

Tier 1 Capital consists of (i) Common Equity Tier 1 (COn1), (ii) deductible concepts from Common Equity Tier 1 (CDCOn1), (iii) Additional Tier 1 (CAn1), and (iv) deductible items from Additional Tier 1 (CDCAn1).

COn1 includes the following net worth items: (i) capital stock (excluding preferred stock), (ii) non-capitalized capital contributions (excluding share premium), (iii) adjustments to shareholders’ equity, (iv) earnings reserves (excluding the special reserve for debt instruments), (v) unappropriated earnings, (vi) other results either positive or negative, in the following terms:

 

    with respect to results from prior fiscal years, 100% of net earnings or losses recorded until the last quarterly financial statements with limited review report, corresponding to the last full fiscal year and in respect of which the auditor has not issued the audit report;

 

    100% of net earnings or losses for the current year as of the date of the most recent audited quarterly financial statements;

 

    50% of profits or 100% of losses for the most recent audited quarterly or annual financial statements; and

 

    100% of losses not shown in the financial statements, arising from quantification of any facts and circumstances reported by the auditor;

(vii) share premiums of the instruments included in COn1, and, in the case of consolidated entities, (viii) minority shareholdings (common shares issued by subsidiaries subject to consolidated supervision and belonging to third parties, if certain criteria are met).

In order for the shares to fall under COn1, at the time of issuance, the financial entity must not generate any expectation that such shares will be reacquired, redeemed or amortized, and the contractual terms must not contain any clause that might generate such an expectation.

The above-mentioned items will be considered without certain deductions pursuant to subsection 8.4.1 and 8.4.2 (as applicable) of the Central Bank Communication “A” 5580.

Deductible Items

Items deductible from COn1 include, among others: (a) positive balances resulting from the application of income tax withholdings above 10% of the previous months of basic net worth; (b) deposits maintained in a corresponding account with a foreign financial institutions that are not rated as “investment grade,” (c) debt securities not held by the relevant financial institutions, except in the case of securities registered by or in custody of the Central Bank (CRYL), Caja de Valores S.A., Clearstream, Euroclear or Depository Trust Company; (d) securities issued by foreign governments whose credit rating is at least ‘investment grade’ according to Communication “A” 5671; (e) subordinated debt instruments issued by other financial institutions; (f) certain credits related to the application of tax deferrals; (g) shareholders; (h) real property added to the assets of the financial entity and with respect to which the title deed is not duly recorded at the pertinent Argentine real property registry, except where such assets shall have been acquired in a court-ordered auction sale; (i) goodwill; (j) organization and development costs; (k) items pending allocation, debtor balances and other; (l) certain assets, as required by the Superintendency resulting from differences between carry amount and the fair value of assets or actions taken to distort or disguise the true nature or scope of operations; (m) any deficiency relating to the minimum loan loss provisions required by the Superintendency; (n) equity interests in companies that have the following activities: (i) financial assistance through leasing or factoring agreements, (ii) transitory equity acquisitions in other companies in order to further their development to the extent the ultimate purpose is selling such interest after development is accomplished and (iii) the issuance of credit or debit cards as provided by Communication “A” 5700; (o) excess in the granting of asset-backed guaranties, according to Central Bank’s regulations; (p) the highest balance of that month’s financial assistance to

 

41


Table of Contents

the public sector, when certain conditions are met; (q) earnings from sales related to securitizations under certain circumstances; (r) gains and losses related to derivate transactions due to changes in the credit risk of the financial institution; (s) losses from derivatives under certain circumstances and (t) equity interests in other Argentine or foreign financial institutions subject to a consolidated supervision.

CAn1 includes certain debt instruments of financial entities not included under COn1 and meet the regulatory criteria established in section 8.3.2 of Communication “A” 5580 (as amended and supplemented), and share premiums resulting from instruments included in CAn1. Furthermore, in the case of consolidated entities, it includes instruments issued by subsidiaries subject to consolidated supervision and belonging to third parties, pursuant to applicable regulatory requirements.

Moreover, debt instruments included under CAn1 must comply with the following requirements:

 

    Must be totally subscribed and paid in full.

 

    Subordinated to depositors, unsecured creditors and to the subordinated debt of the financial entity. The instruments must contemplate that in the case of the entity’s bankruptcy and once all debts with all the other creditors are satisfied, its creditors shall have priority in the distributions of funds only and exclusively with respect to the shareholders (irrespective of their class), with the express waiver of any general or special privilege.

 

    Must not be insured or guaranteed by the issuer or a related entity, and with no agreement improving, either legally or economically, the payment priority in the case of the entity’s bankruptcy.

 

    They shall not contemplate any type of capital payment, except in the case of liquidation of the financial entity. Provisions gradually increasing remuneration or other incentives for anticipated amortization are not allowed.

 

    After 5 years as from the issuance date, the financial entity can buy back the debt instruments if: (i) it has the previous authorization of the Superintendency, (b) the entity does not create any expectations regarding the exercise of the purchase option, and (c) the debt instrument is replaced by a RPC of equal or greater value sustained by its revenue capacity, or if it is demonstrated that once the purchase option is exercised its RPC significantly exceeds at least by 20% of the minimum capital requirements.

 

    Any capital repayment requires previous authorization from the Superintendency. In the case of a capital repayment, the financial entity must not create any market expectations regarding the granting of such authorization.

 

    The financial entity can pay dividends/interest coupons at any time. The included dividends/interest coupons shall not have periodic adjustments because of the financial entity’s credit risk.

 

    They should not have been bought by the financial entity or any other entity over which the financial entity has control or significant influence.

 

    They should not have been bought with direct or indirect financing from the financial entity and they shall not contain elements that make re-capitalization difficult.

Instruments considered liabilities must absorb losses once a pre-established triggering event takes place. The instruments must do so through their conversion into common shares and a mechanism assigning losses to the instrument.

The regulatory provisions regarding the RPC issued by Communication “A” 5369 became effective on February 1, 2013. Pursuant to such communication, capital instruments that do not comply with the new regulatory requirements (including our 2036 Notes) will be excluded from the RPC’s calculations as of the aforementioned date. Thus, as long as those instruments maintain the same conditions that previously allowed them to be included in the RPC’s determination, the value to be computed shall be the accounting values of the instruments at the end of each month, using the methodology applied at that time. Its recognition as RPC will be limited to 90% to the value so obtain, and it will be reduced by 10% every twelve months.

Complementary Net Worth (NWc): Tier 2

Tier 2 Capital includes (i) certain debt instruments of financial entities which are not included in Tier 1 Capital, and meet the regulatory criteria established in section 8.3.3 of Communication “A” 5580 (as amended and supplemented), (ii) share premium from instruments included in Tier 2 Capital, and (iii) loan loss provisions on the loan portfolio of debtors classified as being in a “normal situation” pursuant to Central Bank Rules on debtor classification and of financing with preferred security “A” not exceeding 1.25% of the assets measured for credit risk. Additionally, in the case of consolidated entities, it includes (iv) debt instruments issued by subsidiaries subject to a consolidated supervision and belonging to third parties, if they meet the criteria in order to be included under NWc. The above-described items will be considered minus deductible items pursuant to section 8.4.2 of Communication “A” 5580 (as amended and supplemented) issued by the Central Bank, which is described below.

Moreover, debt instruments included under NWc must comply with the following requirements:

 

    Must be totally subscribed and paid in full.

 

    Subordinated to depositors, unsecured creditors and the subordinated debt of the financial entity.

 

    Not insured or guaranteed by the issuer or a related entity, and with no agreement improving either legally or economically the payment priority in case of the entity’s bankruptcy.

 

    Maturity: (i) original maturity date within no less than 5 years, (ii) clauses considering gradually increasing remuneration or other incentives for anticipated amortization are not allowed, and (iii) from the beginning of the last five years of life of the indebtedness, the computable amount will be diminished by 20% of its nominal issuance value. After 5 years as from the issuance date, the financial entity can buy back the debt instruments with the previous authorization of the Superintendency, and if the entity does not create any expectations regarding the exercise of the purchase option. The debt instrument must be replaced by an RPC of equal or greater value sustained by its revenue capacity, or if it is demonstrated that once the purchase option is exercised its RPC significantly exceeds at least in a 20% of the minimum capital requirements.

 

42


Table of Contents
    The investor shall not be entitled to accelerate the repayment of future projected payments, except in the case of bankruptcy or liquidation.

 

    They cannot incorporate dividends/coupons with periodic adjustments linked to the financial entity’s credit risk.

 

    They should not have been bought by the financial entity or any other entity over which the financial entity has control or significant influence.

 

    They should not have been bought with direct or indirect financing from the financial entity.

Additionally, instruments included in Tier 2 Capital and CAn1, shall present the following conditions in order to assure their loss-absorbency capacity:

 

  a) Their terms and conditions must include a provision pursuant to which the instruments must absorb losses–either through a release from debt or its conversion into ordinary capital–once a triggering event has occurred, as described hereunder.

 

  b) If the holders receive compensation for the debt release performed, it should be carried out immediately and only in the form of common shares, pursuant to applicable regulations.

 

  c) The financial entity must have been granted the authorization required for the immediate issuance of the corresponding common shares in the case of a triggering event, as described below.

Triggering events of regulatory provisions described above are: (i) when the solvency or liquidity of the financial entity is threatened and the Central Bank rejects the regularization plan submitted or revokes its authorization to function, or authorizes restructuring protecting depositors (whichever occurs first), or (ii) upon the decision to capitalize the financial entity with public funds.

Further criteria regarding the eligibility of items included in the RPC calculation must be followed pursuant to the regulatory requirements of minority and other computable instruments issued by subsidiaries, subject to consolidated supervision by third parties. A minority shareholding may be included in COn1 of the financial entity if the original instrument complies with the requirements established for its qualification as common shares regarding the RPC.

Deductible items applied to the different capital levels:

Investments in computable instruments under the financial entity’s RPC are not subject to consolidated supervision when the entity owns up to 10% of the issuer’s ordinary capital according to the following criteria: (i) investments include direct, indirect or synthetic interests; (ii) investments include the acquired net position; (iii) securities issued are placed within 5 business days. When the holdings in other financial entity’s capital (individually representing less than 10% of each issuer’s COn1) exceed 10% of the COn1 of the financial entity, net of deductions, the amount over 10% must be deducted from each one of the capital levels according to the following formula:

 

    Amount to be deducted from COn1: the amount exceeding 10% multiplied by the proportion of holdings of COn1 over total capital interests.

 

    Amount to be deducted from CAn1: the amount exceeding 10% multiplied by the proportion of holdings of CAn1 over total capital interests.

 

    Amount to be deducted from NWc: the amount exceeding 10% multiplied by the proportion that represents the holdings of NWc over total capital interests.

Investments in computable instruments under the financial entity’s RPC are not subject to consolidated supervision when the entity owns up to 10% of the issuer’s ordinary capital or when the issuer is a subsidiary of a financial entity according to the following criteria: (i) investments include direct, indirect or synthetic interests; (ii) investments include the acquired net position; and (iii) securities issued are placed within 5 business days.

Limitations

Communication “A” 5580 (as amended and supplemented) establishes minimum thresholds regarding capital integration: (i) for COn1, the amount resulting from multiplying the capital risk weighted assets (“RWA”) by 4.5% ; (ii) for NWb, the amount resulting from multiplying RWA by 6% and (iii) for the RPC, the amount resulting from multiplying RWA by 8%. It is important to note that the RWA calculation results from multiplying the required minimum capital under Central Bank Rules by 12.5. The lack of compliance with any of these limitations is considered as an infringement to minimum capital integration requirements.

Pursuant to Communication “A” 5867, which became effective on March 1, 2016, RWA shall be calculated as follows:

RWA = RWAc + [(MR+OR) x 12.5]

Where:

RWAc: credit risk weighted assets

MR: minimum capital requirement for market risk

OR: minimum capital requirement for operational risk

Economic Capital

Communication “A” 5398 of the Central Bank requires financial institutions to have an integrated global internal process in place to assess the adequacy of their economic capital based on their risk profile (the “Internal Capital Adequacy Assessment Process” or “ICAAP”), as

 

43


Table of Contents

well as a strategy aimed at maintaining their regulatory capital. If, as a result of this internal process, it is found that the regulatory capital is insufficient, financial institutions must increase regulatory capital based on their own estimates to meet the regulatory requirement.

The economic capital of financial institutions is the amount of capital required to pay not only unexpected losses arising from exposure to credit, operational and market risks, but also those arising from other risks to which the financial institution may be exposed.

Financial institutions must demonstrate that their internal capital targets are well-funded and adequate in terms of their general risk profile and operations. The ICAAP should take into consideration all material risks to which the institution is exposed. To this end, institutions must define an integral process for the management of credit, operational, market, interest rate, liquidity, securitization, graduation, reputational and strategic risks and use stress tests to assess potential adverse scenarios that may affect their regulatory capital.

The ICAAP must include stress tests supplementing and validating any other quantitative or qualitative approach employed by the institution in order to provide the board of directors and senior management with a deeper understanding of the interaction among the various types of risk under stress conditions. In addition, the ICAAP must consider the short- and long-term capital needs of the institution and ensure the prudent accumulation of excess capital during positive periods of the economic cycle.

The required amount of capital of each institution shall be determined based on its risk profile, taking into consideration other external factors such as the effects of the economic cycle and the economic scenario.

Requirements applicable to dividend distribution

The Central Bank imposed certain restrictions on the payment of dividends, limiting the ability of financial institutions to distribute dividends without its prior consent.

By means of Communication “A” 5273 (as amended and supplemented), the Central Bank amended and restated its regulations regarding dividend distribution by financial institutions. Pursuant to such regulation, the Superintendency will review the ability of a financial entity to distribute dividends upon their request for approval. The request must be filed within 30 business days prior to the shareholders’ meeting that will consider dividend distributions. The Superintendency may authorize the distribution of dividends when each of the following circumstances are applicable during the month preceding the request:

 

  (i) the financial institution is not subject to a liquidation procedure or the mandatory transfer of assets ordered by the Central Bank in accordance with section 34 or 35 bis of the Financial Institutions Law;

 

  (ii) the financial institution is not receiving financial assistance from the Central Bank;

 

  (iii) the financial institution is in compliance with its reporting obligations to the Central Bank;

 

  (iv) the financial institution is in compliance with minimum capital requirements (both on an individual and consolidated basis and excluding any individual franchise granted by the Superintendency) and with minimum cash reserves (on average), whether in Pesos, foreign currency or securities issued by the public sector; and

 

  (v) the financial institution is not subject to any significant fines, debarment, suspension, revocation or prohibition imposed in the last five years by the Central Bank, the UIF, the CNV, and/or the National Superintendency of Insurance (Superintendencia de Seguros de la Nación), except when such financial institution has implemented corrective measures that are satisfactory to the Superintendency (such corrective measures would also be brought to the attention of the regulatory body that originally imposed the sanction). The Superintendency also takes into consideration information that it receives from, and/or sanctions imposed by, equivalent foreign agencies or authorities. When weighing the significance of the sanctions, the Superintendency takes into account the type of sanctions, the underlying reason for such sanctions and the amount of sanctions imposed on the financial institution. Additionally, the Superintendency factors in the degree of participation in the events leading up to the sanction, the economic effects of the violation, the degree of damage caused to third parties, the economic benefit that the sanctioned party received from the violation, the sanctioned party’s operating volume, its liability and the title or function that such party holds.

Financial institutions that comply with all of the above-mentioned conditions may distribute dividends up to an amount equal to: (i) the positive balance of the account “unappropriated earnings” (“resultados no asignados”) at the end of the fiscal year, (ii) plus voluntary reserves for future dividend payments and (iii) minus voluntary reserves and mandatory statutory reserves and other items, such as (a) balance of account related to payments made under pesification judicial rulings; (b) the net positive balance of the book-value and the market-value of certain public debt securities and Central Bank notes that the financial institution owns that are not marked to market; (c) unrecorded adjustments of asset value informed by the Superintendency or mentioned by external auditors on their report; (d) individual exemptions for asset valuation granted by the Superintendency; (e) balance of judicial deposits in foreign currency and accounting value of such deposits as required by Law No. 25,561 and Decree No. 214/02; and (f) net results of losses due to application of rules for valuation of securities of the non-financial public sector and monetary regulations of the Central Bank.

Dividends cannot be paid, however, in any of the following circumstances:

 

    if the average minimum cash reserve is lower than the amount of cash required by the latest reported position or the pro-forma position after making the dividend payment;

 

    if the minimum regulatory capital after making the dividend payment is lower than the minimum capital required increased by 75%; and/or

 

    if the entity did not comply with the applicable additional capital margins (as defined below).

 

44


Table of Contents

In addition, for financial institutions that are branches of foreign financial institutions, the Superintendency will consider the liquidity and solvency of their headquarters and the markets in which they operate.

Pursuant to Communication “A” 5580, the minimum regulatory capital has to account for the requirement of counterparty risk capital for securitizations for every ongoing transaction at the time of determination.

In January 2015, within the scope of the principles of the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision, the Central Bank graded Banco Macro S.A. a domestic systemically important entity (D-SIB).

In November 2015, the Central Bank issued Communication “A” 5827 in force as of January 1, 2016, which aims to comply with the guidelines for the capital consolidation of the financial entities agreed in Basel III, introducing the capital conservation margin and the counter-cycle capital margin.

Communication “A” 5827 states that financial entities shall maintain a capital conservation margin in addition to the minimum capital requirements in order to ensure the accrual of owned resources to cope with eventual losses, reducing the non-compliance risk.

Financial entities considered domestic systemically important (“D-SIB’s”) or globally systemically important (“G-SIB’s”), shall have a capital level that permits a greater capacity for loss absorption, by virtue of negative externalities that the effects of insolvency of such entities or their foreign holdings could create in the financial system and the economy.

The conservation capital margin shall be 2.5% of the amount of risk-weighted assets (“RWA”). In cases of entities considered systemically important, the margin will be increased to 3.5% of the amount of capital risk weighted assets. These margins can be increased once again, according to the Counter-Cycle Margin, defined below. The conservation capital margin – increased in the case of entities considered systemically important – must be integrated exclusively with Common Equity Tier 1 (“COn1”), net from deductible items (“CDCOn1”).

When such margin is used, the entities must raise capital with new capital contributions, or reduce future distributions.

The dividend distribution shall be limited whenever the level and composition of the computable asset liability – even when it complies with the minimum capital requirements – is within the range of the capital conservation margin. This limitation reaches solely the dividend distribution, but not the operation of the entity. Entities shall be able to operate normally when levels of Con1 are within the range of conservation margin. When the coefficient of Common Equity Tier 1 – Con1 as percentage of RWA – is within the range of margins conservation of capital, the restriction to the results distribution shall be increased whenever the coefficient of Con1 comes close to the minimum required in section 8.5.1 of regulations over “Minimum Capital for Financial Entities”. The following table shows the maximum percentages of dividend distribution, according to the compliance with the conservation margin presented:

 

Coefficient of Common Equity Tier 1 (COn1) net of deductions

(CDcon1) – as percentage of RWA -.

  

Minimum coefficient of capital

conservation – as percentage of

dividend distribution -

Financial Entities – That are not

categorized as D-SIB’s or

G-SIB’s-

  

D-SIB’s and G-SIB’s Financial

Entities

  

4.5 – 5.13

   4.5 – 5.38    100

> 5.13 – 5.75

   > 5.38 – 6.25    80

> 5.75 – 6.38

   > 6.25 – 7.13    60

> 6.38 – 7.0

   > 7.13 – 8    40

> 7

   > 8    0

Currently, the maximum limits required by the regulations are:

 

    COn1/RWA: 4.5%

 

    NWb/RWA: 6.0%

 

    RPC/RWA: 8.0%

COn1 must be used in the first place to satisfy the minimum capital requirement of 4.5% of RWA. Subsequently, and in the event the total does not have enough Additional Tier 1 (“CAn1”) or Tier 2 Capital (“NWc”), the COn1 shall also be applied to meet requirements of 6% and 8% of Tier 1 Capital and total capital.

Only the remaining COn1, if any, can be computed to satisfy the applicable conservation margin, increased in function of the counter-cycle margin, if applicable.

Any entity that desires to exceed the dividend distribution limits shall finance this distribution by new contributions of COn1 in the excess amount.

The integration of the capital conservation margin shall occur as follows: financial entities must integrate additional capital equivalent to 2.5% of the RWA (3.5% for D-SIB’s and G-SIB’s entities) in a four year period: 2016 to 2019 in a proportion of 0.625% per year (0.875% for D-SIB’s and G-SIB’s entities).

 

45


Table of Contents

Communication “A” 5827 also establishes the counter-cycle margin in order to allow the financial entities’ capital levels to correspond to the accumulative systematic risk associated with an excessive credit expansion and the macro-financial context. Pursuant to such communication, when the Central Bank considers that the credit growth is excessive, creating an increase in systematic risk, it can establish – with a twelve month advanced notice – the obligation to constitute a counter-cycle margin within a range of 0% to 2.5% of RWA. This margin can be reduced or cancelled by the Central Bank when it considers that the systematic risk has been diminished.

Financial entities with international activity shall consider the geographic location of their credit exposure with local and foreign residents of the private sector and calculate the counter-cycle margin as the mean between the required margins in foreign jurisdictions. This includes all credit exposure to private sectors subject to the requirement of credit risk capital.

In order to determine which jurisdiction corresponds to each exposure, the principle of ultimate risk shall be applied. Pursuant to this principle, one must identify the jurisdiction where the guarantor of the risk resides. The counter-cycle margin shall be observed by means of an increase in the conservation capital margin and shall be satisfied exclusively with Common Equity Tier 1, net of deductible concepts (“CDCOn1”).

For more information, see Item 8.A “Consolidated Statements and Other Financial Information—Amounts available for distribution and distribution approval process”.

Credit Risk

The minimum capital requirement in respect of counterparty risk (“CRC”) must be calculated according to the monthly balance. The capital requirement for counterpart risk is defined as:

CRC = k * (0.08* RWAc + no DvP + RCD) + INC + IP.

Variable “k”: Minimum capital requirements also depend on the CAMELBIG rating (1 is the strongest, 5 is the weakest) assigned by the Superintendency, which also determines the “k” value. This rating system complies with international standards and provides a broad definition of the performance, risks and perspectives of financial entities. Financial entities have to adjust their capital requirements according to the following “k” factors:

 

CAMELBIG Rating

   K Factor  

1

     1.00   

2

     1.03   

3

     1.08   

4

     1.13   

5

     1.19   

For the purposes of the calculation of the capital requirement, the rating will be that of the third month after the month of the most recent rating informed to the entity. For so long as no notice is given, the “k” factor will be equal to 1.03.

Variable “A” refers to computable assets/exposures; “PFB” is computable items which are not registered on the balance sheet (“off balance sheet items”), whether or not accounted for under memorandum accounts; “CCF” the conversion credit factor; and “p” refers to the weighting factor, expressed on a per unit basis.

“RWAc” stands for capital risk weighted assets calculated by adding the value obtained from applying the following formula:

A * p + PFB * CCF * p

“DvP” refers to failed delivery against payment transactions (for purposes of these rules, failed payment against payment (PvP) transactions are also included). The amount is determined by the addition of the amounts arrived at by multiplying the current positive exposure by the applicable capital requirement.

In addition, “no DvP” refers to transactions that do not involve delivery against payment. The amount is determined by the addition of the amounts arrived at by applying the weighting factor (p) on the relevant transactions.

“RCD” refers to requirements for counterparty risk in over-the-counter (“OTC”) transactions.

“INC” incremental minimum capital requirements based on any excess in the fixed assets and other ratios, the limitations established under “Credit risk fractioning” rules, and the limitations derived from the credit risk degree.

“IP” refers to the incremental minimum capital requirements derived from the general limit on the global net negative foreign currency position.

Pursuant to Communication “A” 5867, which will be effective as from March 1, 2016, the minimum capital requirement for credit risk will be calculated as follows:

CRC = (k x 0.08 x RWAc) + INC + IP

Variable “k”, as defined above.

 

46


Table of Contents

RWAc: These are credit risk weighted assets, calculated by adding the following:

A x p + PFB x CCF x p + no DvP + (DVP + RCD+ INC(fractioning)) x 12.5

Variable “A” as defined above.

“no DvP”, as defined above.

“DvP”, as defined above.

“RCD”, as defined above.

“INC(fractioning)” means the incremental minimum capital requirements based on any excess over the following limits:

 

  - equity interest held in companies: 15%

 

  - total equity interests held in companies: 60%

The established maximum limits will be applied on the financial entity’s computable regulatory capital for the last day before the relevant date, as prescribed in the rules on “Credit risk fractioning.”

Each type of asset is weighted according to the level of risk assumed to be associated with it. In broad terms, the weights assigned to the different types of assets are:

 

Type of Asset    Weighting (%)

Cash and cash equivalents

  

Cash held in treasury, in transit (when the financial institution assumes responsibility and risk for transportation), in ATMs, in checking accounts and in special accounts with the Central Bank, gold coins or bars

   0

Cash items in the process of collection, cash in armored cars and in custody at financial institutions.

   20

Exposure to governments and central banks

  

To the Central Bank denominated and funded in pesos.

   0

To the public non-financial sector denominated and funded in pesos, including securitized exposures.

   0

To the public non-financial sector arising from financing granted to social security beneficiaries or public employees (with discount code).

   0

To the public non-financial sector and the Central Bank. Other.

   100

To other sovereign states or their central banks and other foreign public non-financial sector institutions.

   100

To the Bank for International Settlements, the IMF, the European Central Bank and the European Community.

   0

Exposure to the Multilateral Development Banks (MDB)

  

The International Bank for Reconstruction and Development (IBRD), the International Finance Corporation (IFC), the Inter-American Development Bank (IDB), the European Investment Bank (EIB), the Asian Development Bank (ADB), the African Development Bank (AFDB), the European Investment Fund (EIF), the Nordic Investment Bank (NIB), the Caribbean Development Bank (CBD), the Islamic Development Bank (IDB) and the European Council Development Bank (ECDB)

   0

Other.

   100

Exposure to local financial institutions

  

Denominated and funded in pesos arising from transactions with an initial contractual term of up to 3 months

   20

Other

   100

Exposure to foreign financial institutions

   100

Exposure to local and foreign companies and other entities - including national foreign exchange entities, insurance companies, brokerage houses and other companies considered non-financial private sector entities pursuant to the provisions of Section 1 of the regulations governing the “Financing of the non-financial public sector”

   100

Exposures included in the retail portfolio

  

Loans to individuals (provided that installments of loans granted by the institution do not exceed, at the time of the agreements, 30% of borrower’s income) and to Micro, Small- and Medium-Sized Companies (“MiPyMEs”).

   75

Other

   100

Exposures guaranteed by reciprocal guaranty companies (sociedades de garantía recíproca) or public security funds registered with the registries authorized by the Central Bank

   50

Primary mortgages and mortgages of any ranking on residential homes, to the extent the entity is the mortgagee

  

If credit facility does not exceed 75% of the appraised value of such real property

  

- Sole, permanently-occupied family home.

   35

- Other

   50

On the amount exceeding 75% of the appraised value of such real property

   100

Primary mortgages and mortgages of any ranking other than on residential homes, to the extent the entity is the mortgagee

  

Up to 50% of the lower of the real property market value or 60% of the mortgage loan.

   50

On the remaining portion of the loan.

   100

Delinquent loans over 90 days

  

Weighting varies according to the loan and specific provisions Created

   50-150

Interests in companies

   150

Exposures to central counterparty entities (CCP)

   2-100

Other assets and / or items off the balance sheet

   100

Excluded items include: (a) securities granted for the benefit of the Central Bank for direct obligations; (b) deductible assets pursuant to RPC regulations; and (c) financings and securities granted by branches or local subsidiaries of foreign financial entities by order and on account of their headquarters of foreign branches or the foreign controlling entity, to the extent: (i) the foreign entity has an investment grade rating, (ii) the foreign entity is subject to regulations that entail consolidated fiscalization, (iii) in the case of finance operations, they shall be repaid by the local branch or subsidiary exclusively with funds received from the aforementioned foreign intermediaries; and (iv) in the case of guarantees granted locally, they are in turn guaranteed by their foreign branch headquarters or the foreign controlling entity and foreclosure on such guaranty may be carried out immediately and at the sole requirement of the local entity.

 

47


Table of Contents

Interest rate risk

Until January 1, 2013, financial entities had to comply with minimum capital requirements regarding interest rate risk. These requirements are intended to capture the sensitivity of assets and liabilities to changes in the interest rates. Communication “A” 5369 removed all rules and regulations regarding minimum capital requirements for interest rate risk. Notwithstanding this change, financial entities must continue to calculate the interest rate risk and remain subject to the Superintendency’s supervision.

Market risk

Minimum capital requirements for market risks are computed as a function of the market risk of financial entities’ portfolios, measured as their value at risk (“VaR”). The regulation includes those assets traded on a regular basis in open markets and excludes those assets held in investment accounts, which must meet counterparty and interest rate risk minimum capital requirements.

There are five categories of assets. Domestic assets are divided into equity and public bonds/Central Bank’s debt instruments, the latter being classified in two categories based on whether their modified duration is less than or more than 2.5 years. Foreign equity and foreign bonds comprise two other categories and are also classified according to their duration, the latter of which is also broken up into two separate categories based on whether their modified duration is less than or more than 2.5 years. The fifth category is made up of foreign exchange positions, which are differentiated based on currency.

Overall capital requirements in relation to market risk are based on the sum of the five amounts of capital necessary to cover the risks arising from each category of assets.

Market risk minimum capital requirements must be met daily. Information must be reported to the Central Bank on a monthly basis. Since May 2003, the U.S. dollar has been included as a foreign currency risk component for the calculation of the market risk requirement and all assets and liabilities denominated in U.S. dollars are taken into account.

Pursuant to Communication “A” 5867, in force as of March 1st, 2016, market risk will be defined as the possibility of incurring losses in on- and off-balance sheet recorded positions as a result of adverse changes in market prices. The market risk minimum capital requirement will be the arithmetic sum of the minimum capital requirement for interest rate, stock, exchange rate and options risks. To meet this capital requirement, entities must apply a “Standard Measurement Method” based on an aggregate of components that separately capture the specific and general market risks for securities positions.

General considerations. Risks subject to this minimum capital requirement include risks derived from positions in instruments – such as securities and derivatives – recorded as part of the trading portfolio, and risks from foreign currency positions recorded, indistinctly, as part of the investment or trading portfolio. For the purpose of the above accounting recording, the trading portfolio of financial entities comprises positions in financial instruments included among an entity’s assets for purposes of trading or of providing hedging to other items contained in the portfolio. Pursuant to Communication “A” 5867, a financial instrument may be accounted for as part of the trading portfolio – for purposes of meeting the minimum capital requirement for market risk – if such instrument may be traded free from any restriction or if the instrument may be hedged in full. Also, the portfolio must be actively managed and its positions must be valued on a daily basis and with the required accuracy. Positions kept for trading purposes are those positions that the entity intends to sell in the short term or from which it intends to derive a profit as a result of changes, either actual or expected, in short-term prices, or by means of arbitrage activities. They include both positions that the entities keep for their own use and those they purchase in the course of services performed for customers or “market making’ activities”. Financial entities must calculate the minimum capital requirement for the counterparty credit risk involved in over-the-counter transactions involving derivatives and securities financing transactions (SFT) – such as repo transactions (repo agreements), recorded as part of the trading portfolio on a separate and additional basis to the calculation of capital requirements for general market risk and specific market risk of the underlying securities. For this purpose, entities will be required to apply the methods and weighting factors usually applicable when those transactions are recorded as part of the investment portfolio. Entities must have clearly defined policies and procedures in place, designed to determine the exposures that are to be included into or excluded from the trading portfolio in order to calculate their minimum capital requirement for market risk. On the other hand, the investment portfolio will include all securities held by the entity which are not included in the trading portfolio.

The minimum capital requirement for exchange rate risk will apply to the total position in each foreign currency. The minimum capital requirement for securities will be computed in respect of the instruments accounted for as part of the trading portfolio, which must be valued prudently (marked to market or marked to model). Instruments whose yield is determined in relation to CER must be considered fixed-rate securities. Whether recorded as part of the trading or of the investment portfolio, items to be deducted for purposes of calculating the RPC will be excluded from the calculation of the market risk minimum capital requirement.

Minimum capital requirement for interest rate risk: The minimum capital requirement for interest rate risk must be calculated in respect of any debt securities and other instruments accounted for as part of the trading portfolio, including any non-convertible preferred shares. This capital requirement is calculated by adding two separately calculated requirements: first, the specific risk involved in each instrument, either a short or a long position, and second, the general market risk – related to the effect of interest rate changes on the portfolio – a set off of the long and short positions held in different instruments will be allowed.

 

48


Table of Contents

Minimum capital requirement for positions in stock. The capital requirement for the risk of holding equity positions in the trading portfolio applies to both long and short positions in ordinary shares, convertible debt securities that function like shares and any call or put options for shares, as well as any other instrument with a market behavior similar to that of shares, excluding non-convertible preferred shares, which are subject to the minimum capital requirement for interest rate described in the preceding paragraph. Long and short positions in the same security may be computed on a net basis.

Minimum capital requirement for exchange rate risk. The capital requirement for exchange rate risk establishes the minimum capital required to hedge the risk involved in maintaining positions in foreign currency, including gold. To calculate the capital requirement for exchange rate risk, entities must first quantify its exposure in each currency, and then estimate the risks inherent in the combination of long and short positions in different currencies.

Minimum capital requirement for positions in options. The calculation of the capital requirement for the risk involved in positions in options may be based on the “simplified method” set forth in Communication “A” 5867 if the entity only purchases options – provided that the market value of all the options in its portfolio does not exceed 5% of the entity’s RPC for the previous month –, or if its positions in sold options are hedged by long positions in options pursuant to exactly the same contractual terms. In all other cases, the entity must use the alternative (“delta plus”) method, also contemplated in the regulation.

As from the effective date of Communication “A” 5867 and until August 31, 2016, financial entities will be required to calculate the market risk minimum capital requirement in accordance with the new method set forth in Communication “A” 5867 and also on an off-balance sheet basis, pursuant to the method in effect as of December 31, 2015, and to consider, for purposes of determining the minimum capital requirement, the result of the method involving the highest amount of the market risk capital requirements. After August 31, 2016, only the new method set forth in Communication “A” 5867 will be applicable.

Consequences of a Failure to Meet Minimum Capital Requirements

In the event of non-compliance with capital requirements by an existing financial institution, Central Bank Communication “A” 3171 provides the following:

 

  (i) Non-compliance reported by the institution: the institution must meet the required capital no later than the end of the second month after the date of non-compliance or submit a restructuring plan within 30 calendar days after the end of the month in which such non-compliance was reported. In addition, non-compliance with minimum capital requirements will entail a number of consequences for the financial institution, including a prohibition to open branches in Argentina or in other countries, establish representative offices abroad, or own equity in foreign financial institutions, as well as a prohibition to pay cash dividends. Moreover, the Superintendency may appoint a representative, who shall have the powers set forth by the Financial Institutions Law.

 

  (ii) Non-compliance detected by the Superintendency: the institution may challenge the non-compliance determination within 30 calendar days after being served notice by the Superintendency. If no challenge is made, or if the defense is dismissed, the non-compliance determination will be deemed to be final and the procedure described in the previous item will apply.

Furthermore, pursuant to Communication “A” 5282, if a financial institution fails to meet market risk daily minimum capital requirements, except for any failure to meet the requirements on the last day of the month, calculated as a sum of VaR of included assets (for failures occurring before March 1, 2016) or derived from the calculation of capital requirements for interest rate, exchange rate and stock risks (for failures occurring after March 1, 2016), the financial institution must replace its capital or decrease its financial position until such requirement is met, and has up to ten business days from the first day on which the requirement was not met to meet the requirement. If the financial institution fails to meet this requirement after ten business days, it must submit a regularization and reorganization plan within the following five business days and may become subject to an administrative proceeding initiated by the Superintendency.

Operational risk

The regulation on operational risk (“OR”) recognizes the management of OR as a comprehensive practice separated from that of other risks given its importance. OR is defined as the risk of loss resulting from inadequate or failed internal processes, people and systems or from external events. The definition includes legal risk but excludes strategic and reputational risk.

Financial institutions must establish a system for the management of OR that includes policies, processes, procedures and the structure for their adequate management. This framework must also allow the financial entity to evaluate capital sufficiency.

Seven OR event types are defined, according to internationally accepted criteria:

 

    internal fraud;

 

    external fraud;

 

    employment practices and workplace safety;

 

    clients, products and business practices;

 

    damage to physical assets;

 

    business disruption and system failures, and

 

    execution, delivery and process management.

 

49


Table of Contents

Financial entities are charged with implementing an efficient OR management system following the guidelines provided by the Central Bank. A solid system for risk management must have a clear assignment of responsibilities within the organization of financial entities. Thus, the regulation describes the roles prepared by each level of the organization in managing of OR (such as the roles of the board of directors, senior management and the business units of the financial institution).

A financial institution’s size and sophistication, and the nature and complexity of its products and processes, and the extent of the transaction determines the type of “OR Unit” required. For small institutions, this unit may even consist of a single person. This unit may functionally respond to the senior management (or similar) or a functional level with risk management decision capacity that reports to that senior management.

An effective risk management will contribute to prevent future losses derived from operational events. Consequently, financial entities must manage the OR inherent in their products, activities, processes and systems. The OR management process comprises:

 

a) Identification and assessment: the identification process should consider both internal and external factors that could adversely affect the development of the processes and projections done according to the business strategies defined by the financial institution. Financial entities should use internal data, establishing a process to register frequency, severity, categories and other relevant aspects of the OR loss events. This should be complemented with other tools, such as self-risk assessments, risk mapping and key risk indicators.

 

b) Monitoring: an effective monitoring process is necessary for quickly detecting and correcting deficiencies in the policies, processes and procedures for managing OR. In addition to monitoring operational loss events, banks should identify forward-looking indicators that enable them to act upon these risks appropriately.

 

c) Control and mitigation: financial entities must have an appropriate control system for ensuring compliance with a documented set of internal policies, which involve periodic reviews (at least annually) of control strategies and risk mitigation, and adjust these as necessary.

Pursuant to Communication “A” 5282, the minimum capital requirements regarding OR are equal to 15% of the annual average positive gross income of the last 36 months.

The OR formula is as follow:

 

LOGO

The variables in the OR formula are defined as follows:

 

    Cro: the capital requirement for operational risk.

 

    a: 15%.

 

    n: the number of 12-month consecutive terms with positive IB, based on the 36 months preceding the month of calculation. The maximum value of n is 3.

 

    IBt: gross income from 12-month consecutive terms, provided that it is a positive figure, corresponding to the 36 months preceding the month of calculation.

IB is defined as the sum of (a) financial and service income minus financial and service expenses and (b) other income minus other expenses.

The following items are excluded from items (a) and (b) above:

 

  (i) expenses derived from the creation or elimination of reserves during previous fiscal years and recovered credits during the fiscal year that were written off in previous fiscal years;

 

  (ii) profits or losses from holding equity in other financial institutions or companies, if these were deductible from RPC;

 

  (iii) extraordinary or unusual gains (i.e., those arising from unusual and exceptional events that resulted in gains) including income from insurance recovery; and

 

  (iv) gains from the sale of financial public sector notes, as set forth under the Central Bank regulations (“Valuación de instrumentos de deuda del sector público no financiero y de regulación monetaria del Banco Central de la República Argentina”).

New financial institutions must comply, in their first month, with an OR minimum capital requirement equivalent to 10% of the aggregate requirements determined for credit and market risks, in the latter case, for the positions on the last day of that month. As from the second and up to the thirty-sixth month, the monthly capital requirement will be equivalent to 10% of the average requirements determined for the months elapsed until, and including, the calculation period based on a consideration of the risks referred to in the preceding paragraph. From the thirty-seventh month onwards, the monthly requirement is calculated based on the OR formula.

Minimum cash reserve requirements

The minimum cash reserve requirement requires that a financial institution keep a portion of its deposits or obligations readily available and not allocated to lending transactions. Pursuant to Communication “A” 3498 (as amended and supplemented) as of March 1, 2002, the minimum cash requirement includes deposits and obligations for other financial intermediation transactions (overnight and fixed-term transactions).

 

50


Table of Contents

Minimum cash requirements are applicable to demand and time deposits and other liabilities arising from financial intermediation denominated in Pesos, foreign currency, or government and corporate securities, and any unused balances of advances in checking accounts under formal agreements not containing any clauses that permit the bank to discretionally and unilaterally revoke the possibility of using such balances.

Minimum cash reserve obligations exclude (i) amounts owed to the Central Bank, (ii) amounts owed to domestic financial institutions, (iii) amounts owed to foreign banks (including their head offices, entities controlling domestic institutions and their branches) in connection with foreign trade financing facilities, (iv) cash purchases pending settlement and forward purchases, (v) cash sales pending settlement and forward sales (whether or not related to repurchase agreements), (vi) overseas correspondent banking operations, and (vii) demand obligations for money orders and transfers from abroad pending settlement to the extent that they do not exceed a 72 business hour term as from their deposit.

The liabilities subject to these requirements are computed on the basis of the effective principal amount of the transactions, excluding interest accrued, past due, or to become due on the aforementioned liabilities, provided they were not credited to the account of, or made available to, third parties, and, in the case of fixed-term deposit of UVIs (as defined below), the accrued amount resulting from the increment of the value of such unit.

The basis on which the minimum cash reserve requirement is computed is the monthly average of the daily balances of the liabilities at the end of each day during each calendar month, except for the period ranging from December of a year to February of the next year, period in which it shall be applied on a quarterly average. Such requirement shall be complied with on a separate basis for each currency in which the liabilities are denominated.

The table below shows the percentage rates that should be applied (from April 2014 for peso denominated amounts, and as from February 1, 2016, for foreign currency denominated amounts) to determine the required minimum cash reserve requirement, which in the case of transactions in Peso, will depend on the category under which the jurisdiction of the main office of the financial entity falls (Communication “A” 5569 and Communication “A” 5873):

 

     Rate %  
   Category I      Categories II to VI  
   Pesos      Foreign
Currency
     Pesos      Foreign
Currency
 

1-Checking account deposits

     17            15      

2-Savings account, basic account and free universal account

     17         20         15         20   

3-Legal custody accounts, special accounts for savings clubs, “Unemployment Fund for Construction Industry Workers” (Fondo de Cese Laboral para los Trabajadores de la lndustria de la Construcción) and “Salary payment,” special checking accounts for legal entities and social security savings accounts

     17         20         15         20   

4-Other demand deposits and liabilities, pension and social security benefits credited by ANSES pending collection and immobilized reserve funds for liabilities covered by these regulations

     17         20         15         20   

5-Unused balances of advances in checking accounts under executed overdraft agreements

     17            15      

6-Deposits in checking accounts of non-bank financial institutions, computed for purposes of meeting their required minimum cash reserve

     100            100      

7-Time deposits, liabilities under acceptances, repurchase agreements (including responsibilities for sale or transfer of credits to agents different from financial institutions), stock-exchange repos (cautions and stock exchange passive repos), constant-term investments, with an option for early termination or for renewal for a specified term and variable income, and other fixed-term liabilities, except rescheduled deposits included in the following items 11, 12, 13 and 14 of this table:

     

(i) Up to 29 days

     13         20         12         20   

(ii) From 30 days to 59 days

     10         15         9         15   

(iii) From 60 days to 89 days

     6         10         5         10   

(iv) From 90 days to 179 days

     1         5         —           5   

(v) From 180 days to 365 days

     —           2         —           2   

(vi) More than 365 days

     —           —           —           —     

8-Liabilities owed due to foreign facilities (not executed by means of time deposits or debt securities)

     —              —        

9-Securities (including Notes)

     

(i) Up to 29 days

     14         20         14         20   

(ii) From 30 days to 59 days

     11         15         11         15   

(iii) From 60 days to 89 days

     7         10         7         10   

(iv) From 90 days to 179 days

     2         5         2         5   

(v) From 180 days to 365 days

     —           2         —           2   

(vi) From 365 days

     —           —           —           —     

10-Liabilities owing to the Trust Fund for Assistance to Financial and Insurance Institutions

     —              —        

11-Demand and time deposits made upon a court order with funds arising from cases pending before the court, and the related immobilized balances

     10         10         10         10   

12-Deposits as assets of a mutual fund

     19         20         19         20   

13-Special deposits related to inflows of funds. Decree 616/2005

        100            100   

14-Time deposits in nominative, non-transferable Peso-denominated certificates, belonging to public sector holders, with the right to demand early withdrawal in less than 30 days from its setting up

     15            14      

In addition to the abovementioned requirements, the reserve for any defect in the application of resources in foreign currency for a certain month shall be applied to an amount equal to the minimum cash requirement of the corresponding currency for each month.

 

51


Table of Contents

The minimum cash reserve must be set up in the same currency to which the requirement applies, and may include the following:

 

1. Accounts maintained by financial institutions with the Central Bank in Pesos.

 

2. Accounts of minimum cash maintained by financial institutions with the Central Bank in U.S. dollars, or other foreign currency.

 

3. Special guarantee accounts for the benefit of electronic clearing houses and to cover settlement of credit card and ATM transactions and immediate transfer of funds.

 

4. Checking accounts maintained by non-bank financial institutions with commercial banks for the purpose of meeting the minimum reserve requirement.

 

5. Special accounts maintained with the Central Bank for transactions involving social security payments by the ANSES.

 

6. Minimum cash sub-account 60, authorized in the Registration and Settlement Central for Public Debt and Financial Trusts – CRYL (“Central de Registro y Liquidación de Pasivos Públicos y Fideicomisos Financieros – CRYL”) for public securities and securities issued by the Central Bank at their market value.

These eligible items are subject to review by the Central Bank and may be changed in the future.

The Central Bank pays interest on reserve requirements up to the legal cash requirement level established for term transactions. Reserves in excess of that requirement will not be compensated.

Compliance time deposits in public bonds must be done with holdings marked to market and of the same type, only in terms of monthly status. Holdings must be deposited in special accounts at the Central Bank.

Compliance with the minimum cash reserve requirement will be measured on the basis of the monthly average of the daily balances of eligible items maintained during the month to which the minimum cash reserve refers by dividing the aggregate of such balances by the total number of days in the relevant period.

The aggregate balances of the eligible items referred to above, maintained as of each daily closing, may not, on any one day during the month, be less than 50% of the total required cash reserve, excluding the requirement for incremental deposits, determined for the next preceding month, recalculated on the basis of the requirements and items in force in the month to which the cash reserves relate. The daily minimum required is 70% when a deficit has occurred in the previous month.

Any deficiencies in meeting the required minimum cash reserve and the daily minimum reserve in Pesos are subject to a penalty equal to twice the private banks’ BADLAR rate for deposits in Pesos for the last business day of the month.

Any deficiencies in meeting the required minimum cash reserve and the daily minimum reserve in foreign currency are subject to a penalty equal to twice the private banks’ BADLAR rate for deposits in U.S. dollars or twice the 30-day U.S. dollar LIBOR rate for the last business day of the month (whichever is higher).

Minimum cash requirements may decrease with (i) the implementation of the Consumer Promotion Program and the Production of Goods and Services named “Ahora 12” created by Resolution 671/2014 of the Ministry of Economy and (ii) the payment of social security benefits. Minimum cash requirements may increase with a defect in the application of credit quotas to clients other than MiPyMEs.

Internal liquidity policies of financial institutions

Pursuant to Communication “A” 5693 financial institutions must adopt management and control policies that ensure the maintenance of reasonable liquidity levels to efficiently manage their deposits and other financial commitments. Such policies should establish procedures for evaluating the liquidity of the institutions in the framework of prevailing market conditions to allow them to revise projections, take steps to eliminate liquidity constraints and obtain sufficient funds, at market terms, to maintain a reasonable level of assets over the long term. Such policies should also address (i) the concentration of assets and liabilities in specific customers, (ii) the overall economic situation, likely trends and the impact on credit availability, and (iii) the ability to obtain funds by selling government debt securities and/or own assets.

The organizational structure of the entity must place a specific unit or person in charge of managing liquidity and assign levels of responsibility to the individuals who will be responsible for managing the liquidity coverage ratio (“LCR”), which will require daily monitoring. The participation and coordination of the entity’s top management authority (e.g., general manager) will be necessary.

In addition, financial institutions must designate a director or advisor who will receive reports at least weekly, or more frequently if circumstances so require, such as when changes in liquidity conditions require new courses of action to safeguard the entity. In the case of branches of foreign financial institutions the reports must be delivered to the highest authority in the country.

Appointed officers and managers will be responsible for managing the liquidity policy that, in addition to monitoring the LCR, includes taking the necessary steps to comply with minimum cash requirements.

Financial institutions must report the list of such officers and directors, as well as any subsequent changes, to the Superintendency within 10 calendar days from the date of any such change.

 

52


Table of Contents

Liquidity Parameters

In addition to the liquidity coverage ratio, there are other parameters that are used as systematic tools of control. These policies contain specific information regarding cash flows, balance structure and available underlining assets free of charge. These parameters, along with the liquidity coverage ratio, offer basic information to evaluate the liquidity risk. The included parameters are:

 

    Gaps in contractual terms;

 

    Funding Concentration; and

 

    Available assets free of restrictions.

Credit risk regulation

The regulations on credit risk establish standards in order to reduce such risk without significantly eroding average profitability. There are three types of ratios that limit a lender’s risk exposure, namely: risk concentration limits, limits on transactions with customers on the basis of the institution’s capital and credit limits on the basis of the customer’s net worth.

Risk concentration: regulations include the concept of risk concentration, defined as the sum of loans that individually exceed 10% of the financial institution’s RPC. Total operations may not exceed, at any time:

 

    three times the institution’s RPC for the previous month, without considering the operations involving local financial institutions;

 

    five times the institution’s RPC for the previous month, on total financings; and/or

 

    ten times the institution’s RPC for the previous month, for second tier commercial banks when taking into account transactions with other financial institutions.

The three times and five times limits listed above are increased to four times and six times the institution’s RPC for the previous month, respectively, whenever increases are allocated to provide assistance to trusts or fiduciary funds from the non-financial public sector.

Loans (other than inter-bank loans) that exceed 2.5% of the financial institution’s RPC must be recommended by senior management and approved by the institution’s board of directors or similar authority.

Diversification of risk: Financial institutions must ensure that their loan portfolio is diversified among the highest possible number of individuals or companies and across all economic sectors to avoid a concentration of risk arising from a small group of individuals or companies or related to a specific sector that could significantly affect the institution’s net worth.

Degree of risk: In the case of credit limits based on the customers’ net worth, as a general rule the financial assistance cannot exceed 100% of the customer’s net worth. The basic margin may be increased by an additional 200% provided such additional margin does not exceed 2.5% of the financial institution’s RPC as of the last day of the second month prior to the date of the financing and the increase is approved by the board of directors or similar authority of the relevant financial institution.

Limits on credit assistance

Maximum individual limits on credit assistance for non-related clients are calculated as a percentage of the financial institution’s RPC.

Maximum limits for credit assistance to non-financial public sector are as follows:

 

Transactions with the non-financial public sector    Maximum limit (*)  

i) Transactions with the national public sector

     50

ii) Transactions with each provincial jurisdiction or the City of Buenos Aires

     10

iii) Transactions with each municipal jurisdiction

     3

 

(*) Individual limits will be increased by 15% when the increase is applied to financial assistance granted to trusts or fiduciary funds, subject to certain conditions and related to the financing of public sector or the inclusion of debt instruments issued by them.

Globally, lending to the public sector cannot exceed 75% of the institution’s RPC. Monthly average daily credit assistance to the public sector cannot exceed 35% of a financial institution’s assets at the last day of the previous month.

Maximum limits for credit assistance to the non-financial private sector of the country and non-financial sector abroad are as follows:

 

Transactions with the non-financial private sector of the country and non-financial sector
abroad
   Maximum limit  

i) For each borrower

  

a) Unsecured financings

     15

b) Total financings (secured or unsecured) and/or collateralized obligations including financings guaranteed by third parties

     25

ii) For each Reciprocal Guarantee Company (RGC) (including affiliates) or public guarantee fund

     25

iii) For each export credit insurance company

     15

Maximum limits for credit assistance to the financial sector of the country are as follows:

 

Transactions with the financial sector of the country

  

Lender

   Taker  
      Rated 1, 2 or 3     Rated 4 or 5  

i) Financing by a financial institution that is not a second tier commercial bank to a local financial institution.

   Rated 1, 2 or 3      25 %*      25
   Rated 4 or 5      25     0

ii) Financing by a financial institution that is a second tier commercial bank

   Rated 1, 2 or 3
Rated 4 or 5
    

 

100

100


   

 

100

0


 

* This limit can be divided in two segments, with and without collateral, in each case by 25% subject to compliance with certain requirements.

 

53


Table of Contents

Maximum limits for credit assistance to the financial sector abroad are as follows:

 

Transactions with the financial sector abroad    Maximum limit  

i) Investment grade banks

     25

ii) Non-investment grade banks

     5

The allocation of margins for exposure to counterparty credit risk in derivative contracts is done on the basis of risk-sensitive measures and the features of each particular type of transaction (type of contract, frequency of marking to market, volatility of the asset). Transactions to be included are forwards, futures and options on shares and public bonds, and Central Bank debt instruments for which volatility is published, purchase and sale options on such assets, and swaps.

Limits for Affiliated Individuals

The aggregate amount of relevant transactions with affiliated companies or individuals may not exceed at any time the limits of the financial institution’s net worth as of the last day of the month prior to the month of calculation, according to the following general rules:

 

    in the case of local financial institutions which have transactions that are subject to consolidation by the lender or borrower, when the entity receiving financial assistance (i) has received a grade 1 rating by the Superintendency, the financial institution can provide assistance in an amount up to 100% of its computable net worth; or (ii) has received a grade 2 rating by the Superintendency, general financial assistance can be provided for an amount up to 10% of the financial institution’s computable net worth; and additional assistance in an amount up to 90% of said computable net worth as long as loans and other credit facilities mature within 180 days;

 

    in the case of local financial institutions not included in (i) above, the financial institution can provide assistance in an amount up to 10% of its computable net worth; and

 

    in the case of other related local companies that exclusively provide complementary services to the activity performed by the financial institution, as well as related foreign banks rated “investment grade,” such companies may receive assistance in an amount of up to 10% of the computable net worth of the financial institution which grants assistance.

If the financial institution has a rating of 4 or 5, financial assistance to a related person or company cannot be granted, except in certain special situations.

Finally, the total non-excluded amount of financial assistance provided to, and the shareholder participation in the related individuals and companies by a financial institution cannot exceed 20.0% of the institution’s Argentine regulatory capital, except when the applicable individual limit is 10.0% (Communication “A” 3129).

Under Central Bank Rules, a person (either an individual or a company) is “related” to a financial institution (and thus part of the same “economic group”):

 

    if the financial institution directly or indirectly controls, is controlled by, or is under common control with, such person;

 

    if any institution has shared directors with the entity or company that has direct or indirect control of the financial entity or with the financial entity, whenever those directors jointly make up the simple majority of each of boards; or

 

    as an exception, determined by the Board of Directors of the Central Bank (pursuant to a proposal from the Superintendency).

In turn, control by one person over another is defined under such regulations as:

 

    holding or controlling, directly or indirectly, 25.0% or more of the voting stock of the other person;

 

    having held 50% or more of the voting stock of the other person at the time of the last election of directors;

 

    holding, directly or indirectly, any other kind of participation in the other person (even if it represents a participating interest below the abovementioned percentages) so as to be able to prevail in its shareholders’ or board of directors’ meetings; or

 

    when the Board of Directors of the Central Bank, pursuant to a proposal from the Superintendency, determines that a person is exercising a controlling influence, directly or indirectly, in the direction or policies of another person.

The regulations contain several non-exclusive factors to be used in determining the existence of such controlling influence, including, among others:

 

    the holding of a sufficient amount of the other person’s capital stock as to exercise influence over the approval of such person’s financial statements and payment of dividends;

 

    representation on the other person’s board of directors;

 

    significant transactions between both persons;

 

    transfers of directors or senior officers between both persons;

 

    technical and administrative subordination by one person to the other; and

 

    participation in the creation of policies by one person to the other.

 

54


Table of Contents

Interest rate and fee regulations

Maximum lending rates

Pursuant to Communication “A” 5590, which was in force from June 2014 to December 2015, the Central Bank established limits to lending rates applicable to consumer financing with respect to personal loans and pledge loans granted to retail customers, that are not considered as micro, small and medium size companies (MiPyMEs).

Pursuant to these limits, two groups of institutions were defined: (i) financial entities with non-financial private sector deposits in Pesos, taking into account the average of the three months prior to April 2014, equal to or higher than 1% of the total non-financial private sector deposits of the financial system (Group I) and (ii) all other financial institutions (Group II).

In the case of institutions falling under Group I, the Central Bank would publish on a monthly basis the maximum interest rates that these financial institutions were authorized to apply to each financing disbursed and/or restructured. The maximum interest rates were based on the product of multiplying the most recent “reference interest rate” (as published by the Central Bank and based on the simple average of the cut-off rates applicable to Central Bank bills for a term closest to 90 days, two months before the disbursement) by the following multiples: (i) in respect of pledge loans: 1.25; (ii) in respect of overdrafts, credit card loans and mortgages on housing assigned to financial institutions by third parties, as receivables in respect to trusts where trust assets were constituted by them, and as collateral for granting loans: 2.00; and (iii) in respect of personal loans: 1.45.

In the case of Group II, the multiples used were as follows (i) in respect of pledge loans: 1.40; (ii) in respect of overdrafts, credit card loans and mortgages on housing assigned to financial institutions by third parties, as receivables in respect to trusts where trust assets were constituted by them, and as collateral for granting loans: 2.00; and (iii) in respect of personal loans: 1.80.

On December 17, 2015, the Central Bank issued Communication “A” 5853, pursuant to which the provisions that established maximum interest rates applicable to the lending transactions described above ceased to have effect in respect of any new transactions conducted as from and including such date. In addition, Communication “A” 5853 established the basic requirement that compensatory interest rates be freely agreed upon among financial institutions and their customers in accordance with established provisions under applicable statutory regulations, such as Central Bank Rules which state the maximum interest rate applicable to credit card facilities.

Minimum term deposit rates

Pursuant to Communication “A” 5640, which was in effect from October 2014 to December 2015, the Central Bank established minimum interest rates applicable to term deposits made by individuals (in a principal amount equal to or lower than the amount currently covered by SEDESA) (i.e., deposits not exceeding Ps.350,000). Communication “A” 5659, as amended and restated, increased the monthly contribution that banks were required to set aside each month to fund the Deposits Guarantee Fund (“Fondo de Garantía de los Depósitos”) from 0.015% to 0.060% of the monthly average of the daily deposits balance. Communication “A” 5943, in effect from April 7, 2016, established the contribution of 0.015% of daily deposits balance monthly average, as recorded second months prior. In addition, Communication “A” 5943 increased to Ps.450,000 the limit for amount covered by SEDESA.

The interest rate applicable to such deposits could not be lower than the result of multiplying the most recent “reference borrowing rate” (as published by the Central Bank and based on the simple average of the cut-off rates applicable to Central Bank bills for a term closest to 90 days, two months before the withdrawal of the deposits) by the following multiple, depending on the original term of each deposit: (a) from 30 to 44 days: 0.91, (b) from 45 to 59 days: 0.93 and (c) from 60 to 119 days: 0.97, (d) from 120 to 179 days: 0.98 and (e) over 180 days: 0.99.

On December 17, 2015, the Central Bank issued Communication “A” 5853, pursuant to which the provisions that established minimum interest rates applicable to the term deposits described above ceased to have effect in respect of any new transactions conducted as from and including such date. The remuneration for fixed-rate deposits will be established at a rate freely agreed upon among the parties.

Fees

On October 6, 2013, the Central Bank issued Communication “A” 5460, granting broad protection to financial services customers. The protection includes, among other things, the regulation of fees and commissions charged by financial institutions for services provided. Fees and charges must represent a real, direct and demonstrable cost and should be supported by a technical and economic justification.

On December 23, 2014, the Central Bank issued Communication “A” 5685 amending Communication “A” 5460, setting forth that any increase in commissions of new products or services must have the prior authorization of the Central Bank.

On August 21, 2015, the Central Bank issued Communication “A” 5795 (as amended and supplemented by several regulations, including but not limited to Communication “A” 5828) establishing additional rules aimed at protecting financial services customers by reinforcing regulations that prohibit financial institutions from charging fees and commissions related to insurance products that financial services customers purchase as accessories of financial services, regardless of whether it is a customer request or a condition set by the financial institution to access the financial service. In this regard, beginning on November 13, 2015, financial institutions may not receive remunerations or profits from such insurance products or receive remunerations or profits, directly or indirectly, from insurance companies with respect to such products.

On March 21, 2016, the Central Bank issued Communication “A” 5927 (as supplemented by Communication “A” 5928) that established new rules aimed at protecting the financial user and an increase of the banking services use. In this regard, beginning on April 1, 2016, the electronic transfers ordered or received by clients categorized as financial services costumers will not be charged with fees or commissions.

 

55


Table of Contents

For clients that do not meet this category, as companies, transfers of funds up to Ps.250,000, ordered or received by electronic means, will not be charged fees or commissions. Communication “A” 5927 also established that immediate transfers of funds up to Ps.100,000 per day and account can be made via internet (“home banking”) every day of the year.

On March 21, 2016, the Central Bank issued Communication “A” 5928, pursuant to which all saving accounts shall be free, including the use of the corresponding debit card. In this regard, all existing saving accounts shall be now free of charge, as well as for new clients. The saving accounts shall not have amount limits or any charge related to their creation, maintenance or renovation. In addition, pursuant to such regulation, commissions could be increased up to 20%, but such increase must be informed to the client 60 days in advance. Furthermore, as of September 1, 2016 commissions’ caps are eliminated, but financial institutions will have to inform its customers the commissions that other financial entities are charging.

Mandatory extension of credit facilities for productive investments

On July 5, 2012, the Central Bank issued Communication “A” 5319, mandating financial entities to extend credit facilities for productive investments (the “2012 Quota”), according to the terms and conditions described therein. Subsequently, the Central Bank issued Communication “A” 5380 and “A” 5449 (the “2013 Quota”), “A” 5516 and “A” 5600 (the “2014 Quota”), “A” 5681 and “A” 5771 (the “2015 Quota”), establishing new regulations applicable to credit facilities for productive investments (the “Quota”). The 2012 Quota, the 2013 Quota, the 2014 Quota and the 2015 Quota are not cumulative and must be complied with, independently, in each year. Financial Institutions subject to this regime are those operating as financial agents of the national, provincial, City of Buenos Aires and/or municipal governments and/or those whose average total deposits over a related three-month period are equal to or greater than 1% of the total deposits in the financial system.

2012 Quota

Financial entities included in the 2012 Quota must extend credit facilities for an amount equal to at least 5% of deposits of non-financial private sector deposits in Pesos, calculated according to the average balances as of the end of June 2012.

The maximum interest rate is 15.01% fixed per annum for at least the first 36 months. After the completion of this period, if the financing continues, institutions may apply a variable rate that may not exceed the total BADLAR rate in Pesos plus 400 basis points.

The 2012 Quota must target at least 50% of the credit facilities rendered to micro, small- and medium-sized enterprises. The credits granted must be denominated in Pesos and, at the time of disbursement of the funds, must have a weighted average life equal to or greater than 24 months and shall mature beyond 36 months. Financing under the 2012 Quota must be granted by December 31, 2012.

2013 Quota

Financial entities included in the 2013 Quota must extend credit facilities for an amount equivalent to 5% of the non-financial private sector deposits in Pesos, calculated according to the balance resulting as of the end of November 2012 for the first tranche, and as of the end of May 2013 for the second tranche.

The maximum interest rate is 15.25% fixed per annum for at least the first 36 months (for both tranches). After the completion of this period, if the financing continues, institutions may apply a variable rate that may not exceed the total BADLAR rate in Pesos plus 400 basis points.

The 2013 Quota must target at least 50% of the credit facilities rendered to micro, small- and medium-sized enterprises. The credits granted must be denominated in Pesos and, at the time of disbursement of the funds, must have a weighted average life equal to or greater than 24 months and shall mature beyond 36 months. Financing under the first tranche must be granted by June 30, 2013. Financing under the second tranche must be granted by December 31, 2013.

2014 Quota

Financial entities included in the 2014 quota must extend credit facilities for an amount equivalent to 5% of the nonfinancial private sector deposits in Pesos, calculated according to the balance resulting as of the end of November 2013, for the first tranche, and for an amount equal to at least 5.5% of deposits of non-financial private sector deposits in Pesos, calculated according to the balance resulting as of the end of May 2014, for the second tranche.

The maximum interest rate for the first tranche is 17.50% and for the second tranche is 19.50% fixed per annum for at least the first 36 months. After the completion of this period, if the financing continues, institutions may apply a variable rate that may not exceed the total BADLAR rate in Pesos plus 300 basis points.

The 2014 Quota must target 100% of the credit facilities rendered to micro, small- and medium-sized enterprises. The credits granted must be denominated in Pesos and, at the time of disbursement of the funds, must have a weighted average life equal to or greater than 24 months and shall mature beyond 36 months. Financing under the first tranche must be granted by June 30, 2014. Financing under the second tranche must be granted by December 31, 2014.

 

56


Table of Contents

The maximum interest rate for the second semester of 2014 Quota is 19.50% fixed per annum for at least the first 36 months. After the completion of this period, if the financing continues, institutions may apply a variable rate that may not exceed the total BADLAR rate in Pesos plus 300 basis points.

2015 Quota

Financial entities included in the 2015 Quota must extend credit facilities in the first tranche for an amount equal to at least 6.5% of deposits of non-financial private sector deposits in Pesos, calculated according to the average balances of November 2014, and in the second tranche for an amount equal to at least 7.5% of deposits of non-financial private sector deposits in Pesos, calculated according to the average balances of May 2015.

The maximum interest rate for the 2015 Quota was established at a fixed 19% per annum for the first tranche and at a fixed 18% per annum for the second tranche, for at least the first 36 months. After the completion of this period, if the financing continues, institutions may apply a variable rate that may not exceed the BADLAR rate in Pesos plus 150 basis points for the first tranche and BADLAR rate in Pesos plus 50 basis points for the second tranche.

The 2015 Quota must target 80% of the credit facilities rendered to micro, small- and medium-sized enterprises. The remaining 20% can target enterprises that exceed the maximum established for their area of activity in the rules on “micro-, small- and medium- sized enterprises” and that the total exports do not exceed the 20% of total sales of the last financial year. The credits granted must be denominated in Pesos and, at the time of disbursement of the funds, must have a weighted average life equal to or greater than 24 months and shall mature beyond 36 months. All financing under the 2015 Quota must be granted by December 31, 2015.

Financing Lines for production and financial inclusion

Central Bank Communication “A” 5874, dated December 31, 2015, established regulations over “Financing Lines for production and financial inclusion” corresponding to the first semester of 2016. These regulations are effective from January 4, 2016 to June 30, 2016.

Financial entities acting as financial agents for the national, provincial, Autonomous City of Buenos Aires’ and/or municipal governments and/or whose share in the non-financial private sector deposits in pesos in the financial system is equal to or greater than 1%, based on the simple average of daily balances of the non-financial private sector deposit in pesos for the previous calendar six-month period, will be required to extend credit facilities equivalent to at least 14% of the non-financial private sector deposits in pesos, calculated on the basis of the monthly average of daily balances in November 2015.

Not less than 75% of the quota must be allocated to credit facilities intended for micro-, small- and medium- sized enterprises.

Communication “A” 5874 established the type of financing which may be considered eligible to this, which includes the following:

 

  (i) financing of investment projects (for the purchase of capital goods and/or the construction of facilities necessary for the production of goods and/or services and for the commercialization of goods and/or services; financing of working capital for investment projects; the purchase of real estate; financing for the purchase of motor vehicles and machinery; among others);

 

  (ii) discount of deferred payment checks, certificates of public works and trade acceptances for customers that are micro-, small- and medium- sized enterprises for up to an amount equivalent to 15% of the quota;

 

  (iii) inclusion, by means of an assignment or discount, of financing facilities provided to users of financial services, or of receivables in respect of trusts whose trust assets consist – primarily – of such financing provided by financial entities not included within the scope of the above mentioned rules, with a total nominal annual financial cost not exceeding 27%, which may amount to up to 5% of the quota;

 

  (iv) Microcredit extended to micro entrepreneurs that meet certain requirements. On a supplemental basis, micro entrepreneurs may be granted loans for the purchase of consumption goods or services;

 

  (v) Loans extended to natural persons at an interest rate of up to a nominal annual 22% for the first year and as from the second year, if the above rate is not maintained, at a variable interest rate equivalent to the peso BADLAR rate charged by private banks, plus 150 basis points. The proceeds of these loans must be used directly for the purchase of a sole family dwelling for the respective family group. This type of financing may collectively amount to up to 10% of the quota;

 

  (vi) Mortgage loans extended to individuals for the purchase, construction or enlargement of dwellings, at an interest rate of up to a nominal annual 22% for the first year and as from the second year, if the above rate is not maintained, at a variable interest rate equivalent to the peso BADLAR rate charged by private banks, plus 150 basis points. These loans may collectively amount to up to 10% of the quota; and

 

  (vii) Assistance provided to natural persons and/or legal entities in areas where an emergency situation prevails as a result of natural disasters. This assistance may amount to up to 15% of the quota.

The maximum interest rate to be applied, except for the financing facilities described in items (iii), (v) and (vi) above, will be a nominal annual fixed rate of 22%. The rate will be free for transactions with customers who do not meet the conditions of a micro-, small- or medium-sized enterprise.

Financing facilities must be denominated in pesos and have – at the time of disbursement – an average maturity period equal to or longer than 24 months, based on weighted principal maturities, and the total maturity period must not be less than 36 months. Financing facilities described in item (i) above and to be used for working capital purposes must have an effective weighted average maturity period equal to or longer than 24 months. The discount transactions contemplated in items (ii) and (iii) will not be subject to a minimum maturity period requirement. The mortgage loans referred to in item (vi) must have a minimum maturity period of 10 years.

 

57


Table of Contents

The entities may make up this portfolio with loans extended on a joint basis with other entities, in the relevant proportion.

In case early pre-payment is accepted, only debtors will be entitled to such pre-payment right.

Loans and Housing Units

On April 8, 2016, the Central Bank issued Communication “A” 5946, pursuant to which banks are enabled to take deposits and issue new loans that can be CER adjustable and denominated in housing units (“UVIs”), a new unit created by such communication. The Central Bank will periodically publish the daily value of each UVI in Pesos for deposits and loans. These new instruments will initially be offered by six entities, including us.

Foreign Exchange System

During the first quarter of 2002, the Argentine government established certain foreign exchange controls and restrictions.

On February 8, 2002, Decree No. 260 was issued, establishing as of February 11, 2002 a Local Foreign Exchange Market (“Mercado Único y Libre de Cambios”) system through which all foreign exchange transactions must be traded at exchange rates to be freely agreed upon.

On this date, the Central Bank issued Communications “A” 3471 and “A” 3473, which stated that the sale and purchase of foreign currency can only be performed with entities authorized by the Central Bank to operate in the foreign exchange. Item 4 of Central Bank Communication “A” 3471 stated that the sale of foreign currency in the local exchange market shall in all cases be against local currency.

Regulations imposed by the Central Bank have been subject to further modifications as of the date of this document. For further information, see Item 10.D “Exchange Controls.”

Foreign currency lending capacity

The Regulations on the allocation of deposits in foreign currencies, Communication “A” 4851 as amended, establish that the lending capacity from foreign currency deposits net of the minimum cash requirement, including interfinancial loans, must fall under one of the following categories: (a) pre-financing and financing of exports to be made directly or through principals, trustees or other brokers, acting on behalf of the owner of the merchandise and financing of providers of services to be exported; (b) financing for manufacturers, processors or collectors of goods, provided they refer to non-revocable sales agreements with exporters for foreign currency-denominated prices (irrespective of the currency in which such transaction is settled), and they refer to exchangeable foreign-currency denominated goods listed in local or foreign markets, broadly advertised and easily available to the general public or its main activity is production, processing and/or collection of listed merchandise that is normal or usual in foreign markets and the financing for such merchandise is comparable to the previous year; (c) financing for manufacturers of goods to be exported, as final products or as part of other goods, by third-party purchasers, provided that such transactions are secured or collateralized in foreign currency by third-party purchasers and/or firm sale contracts in foreign currency; (d) other financing for exporters, that expect future payment that is in foreign currency and bill in foreign currency that is registered in the country, for a reasonable amount relative to the commercial activity and its financing of investment projects; (e) financing for working capital or purchase of any kind of goods–including temporary imports of commodities that increase or are related to the production of goods to be exported, including syndicated loans, with the participation of local or foreign financial institutions; (f) financing for commercial clients or commercial loans considered as consumer loans, with the purpose of importing capital goods, whenever they help to increase goods production for the domestic market; (g) debt securities or financial trust participation certificates whose underlying assets are loans made by the financial entities in the manners set forth in (a) to (d) above (excluding syndicated loans); (h) financings for purposes other than those mentioned in (a) to (e) above, included under the IDB credit program (“Préstamos BID N° 119/OC-AR”), not exceeding 10% of the lending capacity; (i) inter-financing loans (any inter-financing loans granted with such resources must be identified).

Communication “A” 5534, as amended, provides the rates for the integration of the minimum currency amount, for operations in foreign currency.

The lending capacity shall be determined for each foreign currency raised, such determination being made on the basis of the monthly average of daily balances recorded during each calendar month. Any defect in the application shall give rise to an increase in the minimum cash requirement in the relevant foreign currency.

General Exchange Position

The general exchange position (“GEP”) includes all the liquid external assets of the institution, such as gold, currency and foreign currency notes reserves, sight deposits in foreign banks, investments in securities issued by OECD members’ governments with a sovereign debt rating not below “AA”, certificates of time deposits in foreign institutions (rated not less than “AA”), correspondents’ debit and credit balances and the third parties funds pending of settlement. It also includes purchases and sales of these assets already arranged and pending settlement involving foreign exchange purchases and sales performed with customers within a term not exceeding two business days and correspondent balances for third-party transfers pending settlement.

 

58


Table of Contents

It does not include, however, foreign currency notes held in custody, term sales and purchases of foreign currency or securities nor direct investments abroad (Communication “A” 4646 and “A” 4814).

The GEP ceiling is calculated every month and updated the first business day of the month. Pursuant to the relevant reporting system regulations this ceiling is set at 15.0% of the amount equivalent in U.S. dollars to the RPC at the end of the month immediately preceding the last month when filing with the Central Bank has already expired.

It will be increased by an amount equivalent in U.S. dollars to 5.0% of the total amount traded by the institution on account of the purchases and sales of foreign currency with clients in the calendar month prior to the immediately preceding month, and by 2.0% of the total demand and time deposits locally held and payable in foreign bills, excluding deposits held in custody, recorded by the institution at the end of the calendar month prior to the immediately preceding month. If the resulting ceiling is lower than US$8.0 million, the limit shall be set at US$ 8.0 million (Communication “A” 4646, “A” 4814, “A” 5837 and “A” 5850).

Institutions authorized to trade in exchanges failing to comply with the GEP ceilings or the exchange reporting regulations should refrain from exchanging until they are in compliance with the above (Communication “A” 4646).

Financial institutions can seek prior authorization from the Central Bank to exceed the prescribed limits, where required to meet specific needs and for a pre-determined period of time, which authorization may be granted provided it is consistent with the Central Bank’s monetary and foreign exchange objectives.

Foreign Currency Net Global Position

All assets and liabilities from financial intermediation in foreign currency and securities in foreign currency (deriving from cash and term transactions) are included in the net global position, including derivatives contracts related to those concepts (for ongoing and completed operations).

In addition, forward transactions under master agreements entered within domestic self-regulated markets paid by settlement of the net amount without delivery of the underlying asset are also included.

Likewise, participation certificates or debt instruments issued by financial trusts and credit rights with respect to ordinary trusts will be considered, in the corresponding ratio, when its underlying assets consist of foreign currency assets.

Deductible assets for determining RPC, securities issued by the Argentine government for up to the amount of primary placements carried out since November 1, 2014, any included items recorded by the financial entity in its foreign branches and the Argentine U.S. Dollar Sovereign Bonds (BAADE) purchased under primary placements are excluded from the ratio.

Limits:

 

  Negative Foreign Currency Net Global Position (liabilities exceeding assets):

As from January 1, 2007 (Communications “A” 4577 and 4598 of the Central Bank) this position could not exceed 15% of the RPC for the applicable preceding month.

This limit may be increased by up to 15 percentage points provided the records of the relevant financial institution show both: (i) Peso-denominated medium- and long-term financing operations, excluding potential liabilities, in accordance with “Debtor Classification” rules, extended to customers in the private non-financial sector for an amount equivalent to the increase of such general limit measured as a monthly average of daily balances. For this purpose, any financing balances with an average term recorded as of the last day of the month corresponding to the foreign currency net global position will be deemed included, provided such term exceeds four years, based on weighted principal maturity dates and not taking into account CER estimates, if any, without regard to the intended use of the proceeds and form of implementation of the transaction; and (ii) an increased minimum capital requirement for credit risk equivalent to the amount of the increase of the general limit of the negative foreign currency net global position of the relevant month.

 

  Positive Foreign Currency Net Global Position (assets exceeding liabilities):

As from September 2014, based on Communication “A” 5627 of the Central Bank, this position could not exceed 20% of the RPC for the applicable preceding month or the entity’s own liquid assets (own liquid assets meaning the RPC surplus over fixed assets and other concepts to be computed in accordance with Central Bank regulation related to the “Fixed assets and other concepts ratio”).

As from November 30, 2015, based on Communication “A” 5834 of the Central Bank, this position could not exceed the lesser of 15% of the RPC for the applicable preceding month or the entity’s own liquid assets and as from December 9, 2015, the position could not exceed the lesser of 10% of the RPC, computed for the applicable preceding month, or the entity’s own liquid assets.

Effective as from February 1, 2016, based on Communication “A” 5851, the Positive Foreign Currency Net Global Position must not exceed 15% of the lesser of the RPC, computed for the applicable preceding month, or the entity’s own liquid assets. From March 1, 2016 the limit to the Positive Foreign Currency Net Global Position is extended to 20% and since April 1, 2016 the limit is reduced to 10%.

 

59


Table of Contents

This limit should be extended by the amount of the increase in the daily balances between January 2014 and the previous day of the net global position, of the credit lines from abroad settled through the MULC converted to Pesos at the reference exchange rate.

Positive Foreign Currency Net Global Position limit for term transactions:

To determine the positive foreign currency net global position for term transactions should be considered relevant items included in other credits from financial intermediation, other liabilities from financial intermediation and off-balance sheet derivatives denominated in foreign currency, excluding any such items related to repurchase agreements. To this end, financial entities must not deduct sales transactions entered into with “related parties” (with some exemptions).

As from November 30, 2015, Central Bank Communication “A” 5834 established that the daily positive foreign currency net global position for term transactions (the daily balance converted to Argentine pesos at the reference exchange rate) could not exceed 7.5% of the RPC computed for the applicable previous month and as from December 9, 2015, this position could not exceed the lesser 5% of the RPC for the applicable preceding month or the entity’s own liquid assets.

Effective as from February 1, 2016, based on Communication “A” 5851, the positive foreign currency net global position for term transactions must not exceed 7.5% of the RPC. As from March 1, 2016 the positive foreign currency net global position for term transactions is extended to 10% and reduced to 5% from April 1, 2016 pursuant to Communication “A” 5935.

Pursuant to Communication “A” 5894, in force as of February 1st, 2016, transactions of term purchase for hedging of the financial entity that are originated in foreign currency financings are excluded for the calculation.

The excesses of these ratios are subject to a charge equal to 1.5 times the nominal interest rate of the Peso denominated Lebac (Central Bank bill).

In addition to the above-mentioned charge, sanctions set forth in Section 41 of the Financial Institutions Law shall apply (including: caution; warning; fine; temporary or permanent disqualification to dispose of a banking current account; temporary or permanent disqualification to act as promoters, founders, directors, administrators, members of surveillance committees, comptrollers, liquidators, managers, auditors, partner or shareholders; and license revocation).

Rosario Futures Index (“ROFEX”) U.S. dollar futures state of emergency

On December 14, 2015, Argentina Clearing S.A. and Mercado a Término de Rosario S.A. resolved, through Communication 657 (subject to the CNV’s express approval, which was subsequently granted): (i) to declare a state of emergency with respect to any open positions as of such date involving U.S. dollar futures contracts maturing prior to June 2016 and entered into after September 29, 2015; and (ii) to provide, in respect of any open purchased positions as of such date involving U.S. dollar futures maturing prior to and including June 2016, the following remedies: (a) the original transaction price was adjusted by adding Ps.1.25 per U.S. dollar for those transactions opened from and including September 30, 2015 to and including October 27, 2015; (b) the original transaction price was adjusted by adding Ps.1.75 per U.S. dollar for those transactions opened as of October 28, 2015.

The adjustments referred to in the preceding paragraph were applied by registering a sale transaction at the original transaction price and a simultaneous purchase at the original price plus the amount indicated in items (a) and (b) above, which caused a novation of the transactions involved into new transactions at the new established price.

For the purposes of complying with registration requirements involving the relevant ROFEX and Argentina Clearing S.A. transactions, the Central Bank was registered as counterparty to such transactions.

Assignment of foreign exchange positions by financial and foreign exchange entities

On December 17, 2015, Communication “A” 5852 provided that financial entities authorized to deal in exchange transactions and foreign exchange entities were required to sell to the Central Bank their respective positive foreign currency positions at closing on December 16, 2015, valued at the reference exchange rate of such date, and then repurchase them in full. The repurchase transaction could be effected on December 17, 18 or 21, 2015, at the Central Bank’s choice, at the reference exchange rate prevailing on the day of the repurchase.

In particular, an open purchase position in U.S. dollar futures traded on ROFEX and having had its original price adjusted as provided under Item II) of Communication 657 of Argentina Clearing and Mercado a Término de Rosario S.A. was required to be sold to the Central Bank at the adjusted original price resulting from the enforcement of such Communication, and then repurchased in full at the reference exchange rate prevailing on the day of the repurchase.

For the purpose of exercising the repurchase date option contemplated in the first paragraph, the entities were required to submit a letter signed by its president or chief local officer to the General Operations Sub-department before 10:00 a.m. of the selected day, expressly stating the decision it had adopted.

If an entity failed to exercise the option contemplated in the first paragraph or to comply with any of the formal requirements set forth above, the repurchase was to be completed on December 22, 2015 at the reference exchange rate prevailing on such date.

 

60


Table of Contents

The notion of “foreign currency position” referred to above was determined as follows: (i) for foreign exchange bureaus, agencies and offices: their general exchange position; and (ii) for financial entities authorized to deal in foreign exchange transactions: their net global foreign currency position, less any net assets corresponding to their liabilities in foreign-currency denominated government securities, based on the currency in which the respective financial services were paid (either a foreign currency or U.S. dollar-linked Argentine pesos).

If the determined foreign currency position was negative, no sale to the Central Bank and repurchase was required.

Fixed Assets and Other Items

The Central Bank determines that the fixed assets and other items maintained by the financial entities must not exceed 100% of the entity’s RPC.

Such fixed assets and other items include the following:

 

    Shares of local companies;

 

    Miscellaneous receivables;

 

    Property and equipment; and

 

    Other assets.

The calculation of such assets will be effected according to the month-end balances, net of depreciations, accumulated amortizations and allowances for loan losses.

Non-compliance with the ratio produces an increase in the minimum capital requirements equal to 100% of the excess on the ratio.

Credit Ratings

Communication “A” 5671 issued on November 28, 2014 supersedes the provisions issued by the Central Bank containing ratings requirements assigned by a local risk rating company. Where provisions require certain international ratings, the criteria set forth by Communication “A” 5671 govern.

The provisions of Communication “A” 5671 are basic guidelines to properly assess the credit risk that financial institutions must observe when implementing Central Bank Rules including the requirement of a particular rating and do not replace the credit assessment that each financial institution must make to their counterparts. International credit ratings that refer to these provisions shall be issued by rating agencies that have a code of conduct based on the “Principles of the Code of Conduct for Agents Rate Risk” issued by the International Organization of Securities Commissions (“IOSCO”).

Annex II of Communication “A” 5671 provides a table regarding the new qualification requirements for financial institutions. This table classifies the credit ratings requirements for different transactions.

Debt Classification and Loan Loss Provisions

Credit Portfolio

The regulations on debt classification are designed to establish clear guidelines for identifying and classifying the quality of assets, as well as evaluating the actual or potential risk of a lender sustaining losses on principal or interest, in order to determine (taking into account any loan security) whether the provisions against such contingencies are adequate. Banks must classify their loan portfolios into two different categories: (i) consumer or housing loans and (ii) commercial loans. Consumer or housing loans include housing loans, consumer loans, credit-card financings, loans of up to Ps.1,250,000 to micro-credit institutions and commercial loans of up to Ps.2,500,000 with or without preferred guarantees when the institution elected. All other loans are considered commercial loans. Consumer or housing loans in excess of Ps.2,500,000, the repayment of which is linked to the evolution of its productive or commercial activity are classified as commercial loans. If a customer has both kinds of loans (commercial and consumer or housing loans), the consumer or housing loans will be added to the commercial portfolio to determine under which portfolio they should be classified based on the amount indicated. In these cases, the loans secured by preferred guarantees shall be considered to be at 50% of its face value.

Under the current debt classification system, each customer, as well as the customer’s outstanding debts, are included within one of six sub-categories. The debt classification criteria applied to the consumer loan portfolio are primarily based on objective factors related to customers’ performance of their obligations or their legal standing, while the key criterion for classifying the commercial loan portfolio is each borrower’s paying ability based on their future cash flow.

 

61


Table of Contents

Commercial loans classification

The principal criterion used to evaluate a loan pertaining to the commercial portfolio is its borrower’s ability to repay it, whose ability is mainly measured by such borrower’s future cash flow. Pursuant to Central Bank Rules, commercial loans are classified as follows:

 

Classification

 

Criteria

Normal Situation   Borrowers that demonstrate their ability to comply with their payment obligations. High repayment capacity.

Subject to special

Monitoring/Under observation

  Borrowers that, among other criteria, are up to 90 days past due and, although considered to be able to meet all their financial obligations, are sensitive to changes that could compromise their ability to honor debts absent timely corrective measures.

Subject to special Monitoring/

Under negotiation or

refinancing agreement

  Borrowers who are unable to comply with their obligations as agreed with the bank and, therefore, formally state, within 60 calendar days after the maturity date, their intention to refinance such debts. The borrower must enter into a refinancing agreement with the bank within 90 calendar days (if up to two lenders are involved) or 180 calendar days (if more than two lenders are involved) after the payment default date. If no agreement has been reached within the established deadline, the borrower must be reclassified to the next category according to the indicators established for each level.
Troubled   Borrowers with difficulties honoring their financial obligations under the loan on a regular basis, which, if uncorrected, may result in losses to the bank.
With high risk of insolvency   Borrowers who are highly unlikely to honor their financial obligations under the loan.
Irrecoverable   Loans classified as irrecoverable at the time they are reviewed (although the possibility might exist that such loans might be collected in the future). The borrower will not meet its financial obligations with the financial institution.
Irrecoverable according to Central Bank’s Rules   (a) Borrower has defaulted on its payment obligations under a loan for more than 180 calendar days according to the corresponding report provided by the Central Bank, which report includes: (1) financial institutions liquidated by the Central Bank, (2) residual entities created as a result of the privatization of public financial institutions, or in the privatization or dissolution process, (3) financial institutions whose licenses have been revoked by the Central Bank and find themselves subject to judicial liquidation or bankruptcy proceedings and (4) trusts in which Seguro de Depósitos S.A. (SEDESA) is a beneficiary; or (b) certain kinds of foreign borrowers (including banks or other financial institutions that are not subject to the supervision of the Central Bank or similar authority of the country in which they are incorporated) that are not classified as “investment grade” by any of the rating agencies approved by the Central Bank.

Consumer or housing loans classification

The principal criterion applied to loans in the consumer and housing portfolio is the length of period for which such loans remain overdue. Under Central Bank Rules, consumer and housing borrowers are classified as follows:

 

Classification

 

Criteria

Normal Situation   If all payments on loans are current or less than 31 calendar days overdue and, in the case of checking account overdrafts, less than 61 calendar days overdue.
Low Risk   Loans upon which payment obligations are overdue for a period of more than 31 and up to 90 calendar days.
Medium Risk   Loans upon which payment obligations are overdue for a period of more than 90 and up to 180 calendar days.
High Risk   Loans in respect of which a legal action seeking collection has been filed or loans having payment obligations overdue for more than 180 calendar days, but less than 365 calendar days.
Irrecoverable   Loans in which payment obligations are more than one year overdue or the debtor is insolvent or in bankruptcy or liquidation.
Irrecoverable Loans   Loans in which payment obligations are more than one year overdue or the debtor is insolvent or in bankruptcy or liquidation.

Irrecoverable according to Central

Bank’s Rules

  Same criteria as for commercial loans in the Irrecoverable according to Central Bank Rules.

Minimum Credit Provisions

The following minimum credit provisions are required to be made by Argentine banks in relation to the credit portfolio category:

 

Category   With Preferred
Guarantees
    Without Preferred
Guarantees
 

“Normal situation””

    1     1

“Under observation” and “Low risk”

    3     5

“Under negotiation or refinancing agreement”

    6     12

“With problems” and “Medium Risk”

    12     25

“With high risk of insolvency” and “High Risk”

    25     50

“Irrecoverable”

    50     100

“Irrecoverable according to Central Bank’s Rules”

    100     100

The Superintendency may require additional provisioning if it determines that the current level is inadequate.

Financial institutions are entitled to record allowances for loan losses in amounts larger than those required by Central Bank Rules. In such cases and despite the existence of certain exceptions, recording a larger allowance for a commercial loan, to the extent the recorded allowance amount falls into the next credit portfolio category set forth by Central Bank Rules, shall automatically result in the corresponding debtor being recategorized accordingly.

 

62


Table of Contents

Minimum frequency for classification review

In accordance with Central Bank Rules financial institutions are required to develop procedures for the analysis of the credit facilities assuring an appropriate evaluation of a debtor’s financial situation and a periodic revision of its situation concerning objective and subjective conditions of all the risks taken. The procedures established have to be detailed in a manual called “Manual of Procedures for Classification and Allowances” which shall be permanently available for the Superintendency. The frequency of the review of existing classifications must answer to the importance considering all facilities. The classification analysis shall be duly documented. The classification review must include (i) clients whose credits (in Pesos and in foreign currency) exceed the lower of 1% of the financial institution’s RPC corresponding to prior month and Ps. 4.0 million and (ii) at least 20% of the financial institution’s total active credit portfolio, which, if applicable, shall be completed by incorporating clients (in decreasing order) whose total indebtedness is inferior to the limits described in the preceding point (i).

In the case of commercial loans, applicable regulations require a minimum frequency of review. Such review must take place: (i) quarterly for clients with indebtedness equal or greater than 5% of the financial entity’s RPC for the prior month and (ii) semi-annually for clients whose indebtedness is (x) higher than the lower of 1% of the financial entity’s RPC for the prior month and Ps. 4.0 million, and (y) lower than 5% of the financial entity’s RPC for the prior month. At the end of the first calendar semester, the total review under points (i) and (ii) should have covered no less than 50% of the financial entity’s commercial loan portfolio and, if less, it shall be completed by incorporating clients (in descending order) whose total indebtedness is inferior to the limits described in the preceding point (ii)(x).

In addition, financial institutions have to review the rating assigned to a debtor in certain instances, such as when another financial institution reduces the debtor classification in the “Credit Information Database” and grants 10% or more of the debtor’s total financing in the financial system. Only one-level discrepancy is allowed in relation to the information submitted by financial institutions to the “Credit Information Database” and the lower classification awarded by at least two other banks and total lending from such banks account for 40% or more of the total informed; if there is a greater discrepancy, the financial institution will be required to reclassify the debtor.

Allowances for loan losses

The allowance for loan losses is maintained in accordance with applicable regulatory requirements of the Central Bank. Increases in the allowance are based on the level of growth of the loan portfolio, as well as on the deterioration of the quality of existing loans, while decreases in the allowance are based on regulations requiring the write-off of non-performing loans classified as irrecoverable after a certain period of time and on decisions of the management to write off non-performing loans evidencing a very low probability of recovery.

Priority rights of depositors

Under Section 49 of the Financial Institutions Law, in the event of judicial liquidation or bankruptcy of a bank all depositors, irrespective of the type, amount or currency of their deposits, will be senior to the other remaining creditors (such as shareholders of the bank), with exceptions made for certain labor liens (section 53 paragraphs “a” and “b”) and for those creditors backed by a pledge or mortgage, in the following order of priority: (a) deposits of up to Ps.450,000 per person (including all amounts such person deposited in one financial entity), or its equivalent in foreign currency, (b) all deposits of an amount higher than Ps.450,000, or its equivalent in foreign currency, and (c) the liabilities originated in commercial lines granted to the financial institution and which directly affect international commerce. Furthermore, pursuant to section 53 of the Financial Institutions Law, as amended, Central Bank claims have absolute priority over other claims, except for pledged or mortgaged claims, certain labor claims, the depositors’ claims pursuant to section 49, paragraph e), points i) and ii), debt granted under section 17, paragraphs (b), (c) and (f) of the Central Bank’s Charter (including discounts granted by financial entities due to a temporary lack of liquidity, advances to financial entities with security interest, assignment of rights, pledges or special assignment of certain assets) and debt granted by the Banking Liquidity Fund backed by a pledge or mortgage.

The amendment to section 35 bis of the Financial Institutions Law by Law No. 25,780 sets forth that if a bank is in a situation where the Central Bank may revoke its authorization to operate and become subject to dissolution or liquidation by judicial resolution, the Central Bank’s Board of Directors may take certain actions. Among these actions, in the case of excluding the transfer of assets and liabilities to financial trusts or other financial entities, the Central Bank may totally or partially exclude the liabilities mentioned in section 49, paragraph e), as well as debt defined in section 53, giving effect to the order of priority among creditors. Regarding the partial exclusion, the order of priority of point e) section 49 must be followed without treating liabilities of the same grade differently.

Mandatory deposit insurance system

Law No. 24,485 passed on April 12, 1995, as amended, created a Deposit Insurance System, or “SSGD”, which is mandatory for bank deposits, and delegated the responsibility for organizing and implementing the system to the Central Bank. The SSGD is a supplemental protection to the privilege granted to depositors by means of Section 49 of the Financial Institutions Law, as mentioned above.

The SSGD has been implemented through the establishment of a Deposit Guarantee Fund, or “FGD”, managed by a private-sector corporation called Seguro de Depósitos Sociedad Anónima, (Deposit Insurance Corporation, or “SEDESA”). According to Decree No. 1292/96, the shareholders of SEDESA are the government through the Central Bank and a trust set up by the participating financial institutions. These institutions must pay into the FGD a monthly contribution determined by Central Bank Rules. The SSGD is financed through regular and additional contributions made by financial institutions, as provided for in Central Bank Communication “A” 4271, dated December 30, 2004.

 

63


Table of Contents

The SSGD covers deposits made by Argentine individuals and legal entities in pesos and foreign currency and maintained in accounts with the participating financial institutions, including checking accounts, savings accounts, and time deposits up to the amount of Ps.350,000, as set forth by Central Bank Communication “A” 5659, dated October 31, 2014, as amended. Pursuant to Communication “A” 5943, as of May 1, 2016, the Central Bank set Ps.450,000 as the guarantee amount for these deposits.

Effective payment on this guaranty will be made within 30 business days after revocation of the license of the financial institution in which the funds are held; such payments are subject to the exercise of the depositor’s priority rights described above.

In view of the circumstances affecting the financial system, Decree No. 214/2002 provided that SEDESA may issue registered securities for the purpose of offering them to depositors in payment of the guarantee in the event it should not have sufficient funds available.

The SSGD does not cover: (i) deposits maintained by financial institutions in other financial institutions, including certificates of deposit bought in the secondary market, (ii) deposits made by persons directly or indirectly affiliated with the institution, (iii) time deposits of securities, acceptances or guarantees, (iv) any transferable time deposits that have been transferred by endorsement, (v) any deposits benefiting from some incentive (e.g., car raffles) in addition to the agreed upon interest rate, (vi) any deposits in which the agreed-upon interest rate is higher than the reference interest rates periodically released by the Central Bank for time deposits and demand deposit account balances and available amounts from overdue deposits or closed accounts, and (vii) immobilized credit from deposits and excluded transactions.

Pursuant to Communication “A” 5710, every financial institution is required to contribute to the FGD a monthly amount of 0.06% of the monthly average of daily balances of deposits in local and foreign currency, as determined by the Central Bank. When fixed term deposits in U.S. dollars of the private non-financial sector are used to purchase Central Bank bills denominated in U.S. dollars, financial institutions must contribute 0.015% of the monthly average of daily balances of the net position of such bills. Prompt contribution of such amounts is a condition precedent to the continuing operation of the financial institution. The first contribution was made on May 24, 1995. The Central Bank may require financial institutions to advance the payment of up to the equivalent of two years of monthly contributions and debit the past due contributions from funds of the financial institutions deposited with the Central Bank. The Central Bank may require additional contributions by certain institutions, depending on its evaluation of the financial condition of those institutions. Pursuant to Communication “A” 5943, effective as of April 7, 2016, the monthly contribution to the FDG was established as 0.015%

When the contributions to the FGD reach the greater of Ps.2 billion or 5.0% of the total deposits of the system, the Central Bank may suspend or reduce the monthly contributions, and reinstate them when the contributions subsequently fall below that level.

Other restrictions

Pursuant to the Financial Institutions Law, financial institutions cannot create any kind of rights over their assets without the Central Bank’s authorization, nor enter into transactions with their directors, officers or affiliates in terms more favorable than arms-length transactions.

Capital Markets

Commercial banks are authorized to subscribe for and sell shares and debt securities. At present, there are no statutory limitations as to the amount of securities for which a bank may undertake to subscribe. However, under Central Bank Rules, underwriting of debt securities by a bank would be treated as “financial assistance” and, accordingly, until the securities are sold to third parties, such underwriting would be subject to limitations.

Law 26,831 (the “Capital Markets Law”), introduced substantial changes to regulations governing markets, stock exchanges and the various agents operating in capital markets, in addition to certain amendments to the CNV’s powers. On September 9, 2013, the CNV published Resolution No. 622/2013 (the “CNV Rules”) supplementing the Capital Markets Law. The CNV Rules have been in force since September 18, 2013.

One of the most significant modifications introduced by the Capital Markets Law and the CNV Rules is that agents and markets must comply with the CNV’s requirements for applying for an authorization to operate, as well as registration requirements. It further provides that each category of agent must meet minimum net worth and liquidity requirements.

Additionally, under the Capital Markets Law, the self-regulation of markets was eliminated, and authorization, supervision, control, as well as disciplinary and regulatory powers, are conferred to the CNV regarding all capital market players.

Financial institutions with economic difficulties

The Financial Institutions Law provides that any financial institution, including a commercial bank, operating at less than certain required technical ratios and minimum net worth levels, in the judgment of the Central Bank adopted by members representing the majority of the board of directors, with impaired solvency or liquidity or in any of the other circumstances listed in Section 44 of the Financial Institutions Law, must (upon request from the Central Bank and in order to avoid the revocation of its license) prepare a restructuring plan or a remediation and regularization plan. The plan must be submitted to the Central Bank on a specified date, not later than 30 calendar days from the date on which a request to that effect is made by the Central Bank. Upon the institution’s failure to submit, secure regulatory approval of, or comply with, a restructuring plan, the Central Bank will be empowered to revoke the institution’s license to operate as such.

 

64


Table of Contents

Furthermore, the Central Bank’s charter authorizes the Superintendency to fully or partially suspend, exclusively subject to the approval of the President of the Central Bank, the operations of a financial institution for a term of 30 days if the liquidity or solvency thereof is adversely affected. Such term could be renewed for up to 90 additional days, with the approval of the Central Bank’s board of directors. During such suspension term an automatic stay of claims, enforcement actions and precautionary measures is triggered, any commitment increasing the financial institution’s obligations shall be null and void, and debt acceleration and interest accrual shall be suspended. If per the Central Bank’s criteria a financial institution is undergoing a situation which, under the Financial Institutions Law, would authorize the Central Bank to revoke its license to operate as such, the Central Bank may, before considering such revocation, order a plan of restructuring that may consist of certain steps, including, among others:

 

    adoption of a list of measures to capitalize or increase the capital of the financial institution;

 

    revoke the approval granted to the shareholders of the financial institution to hold interests therein;

 

    restructure or transfer assets and liabilities;

 

    grant temporary exemptions to comply with technical regulations or payment of charges and penalties arising from such flawed compliance; or

 

    appoint a delegate or auditor (“interventor”) that may prospectively replace the board of directors of the financial institution.

Revocation of the license to operate as a financial institution

The Central Bank may revoke the license to operate as a financial institution in case a restructuring plan fails or is not deemed feasible, or local laws and regulations are violated, or the solvency or liquidity of the financial institution is affected, or significant changes occur in the institution’s condition since the original authorization was granted, or if any decision by the financial institution’s legal or corporate authorities concerning its dissolution is adopted, among other circumstances set forth in the Financial Institutions Law. In addition, pursuant to Communication “A” 5785, sanctions imposed by the Central Bank, the UIF, the CNV and/or the National Superintendency of Insurance (Superintendencia de Seguros de la Nación) on financial institutions and/or their authorities, may result in the revocation of their licenses to operate as financial institutions. Such revocation may occur when, in the opinion of the Board of Directors of the Central Bank, there was a material change in the conditions deemed necessary to maintain such license, including those relating to the suitability, experience, moral character or integrity of (i) the members of a financial institution’s board of directors (directors, counselors or equivalent authorities), (ii) its shareholders, (iii) the members of its supervisory committee and (iv) others, such as its managers. For such purposes, the Superintendency also takes into consideration information that it receives from, and/or sanctions imposed by, equivalent foreign agencies or authorities. When weighing the significance of the sanctions, the Superintendency takes into account the type of sanctions, the underlying reason for such sanctions and the amount of sanctions imposed on the financial institution. Additionally, the Superintendency factors in the degree of participation in the events leading up to the sanction, the economic effects of the violation, the degree of damage caused to third parties, the economic benefit that the sanctioned party received from the violation, the sanctioned party’s operating volume, its liability and the title or function that such party holds.

Once the license to operate as a financial institution has been revoked, the financial institution will be liquidated.

Liquidation of financial institutions

As provided in the Financial Institutions Law, the Central Bank must notify the revocation decision to a competent court, which will then determine who will liquidate the entity: the corporate authorities (extrajudicial liquidation) or an independent liquidator appointed by the court for that purpose (judicial liquidation). The court’s decision will be based on whether or not there is sufficient assurance that the corporate authorities are capable of carrying out such liquidation properly.

Bankruptcy of financial institutions

According to the Financial Institutions Law, financial institutions are not allowed to file their own bankruptcy petitions. In addition, the bankruptcy shall not be adjudged until the license to operate as financial institution has been revoked.

Once the license to operate as a financial institution has been revoked, a court of competent jurisdiction may adjudge the former financial institution in bankruptcy, or a petition in bankruptcy may be filed by the Central Bank or by any creditor of the bank, in this case after a period of 60 calendar days has elapsed since the license was revoked.

Once the bankruptcy of a financial institution has been adjudged, provisions of the Bankruptcy Law No. 24,522 (the “Bankruptcy Law”) and the Financial Institutions Law shall be applicable; provided however that in certain cases, specific provisions of the Financial Institutions Law shall supersede the provisions of the Bankruptcy Law (i.e. priority rights of depositors).

Merger, consolidation and transfer of goodwill

Merger, consolidation and transfer of goodwill may be arranged between entities of the same or different type and will be subject to the prior approval of the Central Bank. The new entity must submit a financial-economic structure profile supporting the project in order to obtain authorization from the Central Bank.

 

65


Table of Contents

Financial system restructuring unit

The Financial System Restructuring Unit was created to oversee the implementation of a strategic approach for those banks benefiting from assistance provided by the Central Bank. This unit is in charge of rescheduling maturities, determining restructuring strategies and action plans, approving transformation plans, and accelerating repayment of the facilities granted by the Central Bank.

Anti-money laundering

The concept of money laundering is generally used to denote transactions aimed at introducing funds from illicit activities in the institutional system and thus transform gains from illegal activities in assets of a seemingly legitimate source.

On April 13, 2000, the Argentine Congress passed Law No. 25,246, as amended by Laws No. 26,087, 26,119, 26,286, and 26,683 (together the “Anti-Money Laundering Law”), which sets forth an administrative criminal system and supersedes several sections of the Argentine Criminal Code related to money laundering.

This law defines money laundering as a crime committed whenever a person converts, transfers, manages, sells, encumbers, disguises or in any other way commercializes goods obtained through a crime, with the possible consequence that the original assets or the substitute thereof may appear to be of a legitimate origin, provided the value of the assets exceeds Ps.300,000, whether such amount results from one or more related transactions.

Also, money laundering is considered as a separate crime against the economic and financial order, independent from the legal concept of concealment, which is considered an offense against the public administration. Thus, money laundering is a crime which may be prosecuted independently, whether or not the money launderer took part in the preceding crime from which the proceeds of which are being laundered.

In compliance with recommendations made by the FATF on money laundering prevention, on June 1, 2011 the Argentine Congress enacted Argentine Law No. 26,683. Under this law, money laundering is a crime per se, and laundering one’s own money is also penalized. Also, this law extends reporting duties to certain members of the private sector who were formerly not under such an obligation.

In addition, the Anti-Money Laundering Law created the UIF, under the Argentine Ministry of Justice, Security and Human Rights, which is responsible for the handling and transmitting of information in order to prevent (a) the laundering of assets mainly originated from: (i) crimes related to illegal trafficking and commercialization of narcotics (Law No. 23,737); (ii) crimes related to arms trafficking (Law No. 22,415); (iii) crimes related to the activities of an illegal association as defined in Section 210 bis of the Argentine Criminal Code; (iv) illegal acts committed by illegal associations (Section 210 of the Argentine Criminal Code) organized to commit crimes with political or racial objectives; (v) crimes of fraud against the Public Administration (Section 174, Paragraph 5 of the Argentine Criminal Code); (vi) crimes against the Public Administration under Chapters VI, VII, IX and IX bis of Title XI of the Second Book of the Argentine Criminal Code; (vii) crimes of underage prostitution and child pornography under Sections 125, 125 bis, 127 bis and 128 of the Argentine Criminal Code; (viii) crimes involving terrorist financing (Sections 41 and 306 of the Argentine Criminal Code); (ix) extortion (Section 168 of the Argentine Criminal Code), (x) crimes contemplated by Law No. 24,769; and (xi) human trafficking, and (b) terrorism financing (Sections 41 and 306 of the Argentine Criminal Code).

The Anti-Money Laundering Law, like anti-money laundering laws of other countries, does not designate sole responsibility to the Argentine government for the monitoring of these criminal activities, but rather also delegates certain duties to diverse private sector entities such as banks, shareholders, stock markets and insurance companies, which became legally bound reporting parties. These obligations essentially consist of information gathering functions, such as: (a) obtaining from clients documents that indisputably prove the identity, legal status, domicile and other information, concerning their operations needed to accomplish the intended activity (know your customer policy); (b) reporting to the UIF any transaction considered suspicious (as such term is explained below), as well as any transaction that lacks economic or legal justification, or is unnecessarily complex, whether performed on isolated occasions or repeatedly; and (c) keeping any monitoring activities in connection with a proceeding pursuant to the Anti-Money Laundering Law confidential from both clients and third parties.

Argentine financial institutions must comply with all applicable anti-money laundering regulations as provided by the UIF, the Central Bank, and, if applicable (as is the case of Banco Macro), by the CNV. In this regard, in accordance with Resolution No. 229/2014 of the UIF, both the Central Bank and the CNV are considered “Specific Control Organs”. In such capacity, they must cooperate with the UIF in the evaluation of the compliance with the anti–money laundering proceedings of the legally bound reporting parties subject to their control. In that respect, they are entitled to supervise, monitor and inspect such entities, and in considered necessary, to implement certain corrective measures and actions.

Resolution 121/2011 issued by the UIF, as amended among others by Resolution No. 196/2015 (“Resolution 121”), is applicable to financial entities subject to the Financial Institutions Law, to entities subject to the Law No. 18,924, as amended, and to individuals and legal entities authorized by the Central Bank to intervene in the purchase and sale of foreign currency through cash or checks issued in foreign currency or through the use of credit or payment cards, or in the transfer of funds within or outside the national territory. Resolution No. 229/2011 of the UIF, as amended or supplemented by Resolutions No. 52/2012 and 140/2012 (“Resolution 229”), is applicable to brokers and brokerage firms, companies managing common investment funds, agents of the over-the-counter market, intermediaries in the purchase or leasing of securities affiliated with stock exchange entities with or without associated markets, and intermediary agents registered on forwards or option markets. Resolution 121 and Resolution 229 regulate, among others, the obligation to collect documentation from clients and the terms, obligations and restrictions for compliance with the reporting duty regarding suspicious money laundering and terrorism financing transactions.

 

66


Table of Contents

Resolution 121 and Resolution 229 set forth general guidelines in connection with the client’s identification (including the distinction between occasional and regular clients), the information to be requested, the documentation to be filed and the procedures to detect and report suspicious transactions.

Moreover, the main duties established by such resolutions are the following: a) to create a manual establishing the mechanisms and procedures to be used to prevent money laundering and terrorism financing; b) to appoint a member of the board of directors as compliance officer; c) to implement periodic audits; d) to offer personnel training; e) to create a record of detected unusual (as such term is explained below) and suspicious operations; f) to implement technological tools to allow the development of efficient control systems for prevention of money laundering and terrorism financing; g) to implement measures to allow persons obliged under Resolution 121 and Resolution 229, to electronically consolidate the transactions carried out with clients, and to develop electronic tools to identify certain behaviors and observe possible suspicious transactions, requesting information and, if applicable, supporting documents from its customers and h) to adopt reinforced identification methods applicable to customers with specific features as provided by applicable regulations. Entities covered by Resolution 121 and Resolution 229, as legally bound reporting parties, must report any money laundering suspicious activity to the UIF within 150 calendar days of its occurrence (or attempt) and any terrorism financing suspicious activity before a 48 hours period of its occurrence (or attempt) has elapsed. However, pursuant to Resolution UIF 3/2014, within the maximum 150 calendar days period, entities covered by Resolution 121 and Resolution 229 must report any money laundering suspicious activity to the UIF within 30 calendar days as of the day on which any such activity is qualified as suspicious by such legally bound reporting party.

According to Resolution 121 and Resolution 229, unusual transactions are those attempted or consummated transactions, on a one-time or on a regular basis, without economic or legal justification, inconsistent with the economic and financial profile of the client, and which deviate from standard market. On other hand, under Resolution 121 and Resolution 229, suspicious transactions are those attempted or consummated transactions that, having been previously identified as unusual transactions by the legally bound reporting party, are inconsistent with the lawful activities declared by the client or, even if related to lawful activities, give rise to suspicion that they are linked or used to finance terrorism.

The Central Bank and the CNV must also comply with anti-money laundering regulations set forth by the UIF, including reporting suspicious transactions. In particular, the Central Bank must comply with UIF Resolution No. 12/2011, as supplemented, among others, by Resolutions No. 1/2012 and No. 92/2012, which, among other things, sets forth the Central Bank’s obligation to evaluate the anti-money laundering controls implemented by Argentine financial institutions (with the limitation of the access to the reports and records of suspicious operations, which are, as aforementioned, confidential and subject only to the UIF’s supervision), and lists examples of what circumstances should be specially considered in order to stablish if a particular transaction may be considered unusual and eventually qualified as suspicious.

The listed transactions must be particularly scrutinized by the Central Bank and include, among others, any transaction involving financial institutions, regular transactions involving securities (specially daily purchases and sales of the same amount of securities), capital contributions into financial institutions that have been paid-in in cash (or means other than bank transfers), and capital contributions by companies incorporated or domiciled in jurisdictions that do not allow for information relating to family relations of its shareholders, board members or members of its supervisory committee, deposits or withdrawals in cash for unusual amounts by entities or individuals that normally use checks or other financial instruments and/or whose declared business does not correspond with the type or amount of the transaction; subsequent cash deposits for small amounts that, in the aggregate, add up to a relevant sum; a single client holding numerous accounts that, in the aggregate, hold relevant sums inconsistent with such client’s declared business; transfers of funds for amounts inconsistent with the client’s business or usual kind of transaction; accounts with several authorized signatories that hold no apparent relation (in particular when domiciled or acting off-shore or in tax havens); clients that unexpectedly cancel loans; frequent cash deposits or withdrawals for relevant amounts without commercial justification. On the other hand, the CNV must comply with UIF Resolution No. 22/2011, as supplemented, among others, by Resolutions No. 1/2012 and No. 92/2012, which sets forth the CNV’s obligation to evaluate the anti-money laundering controls implemented by entities subject to its control (with the limitation of the access to the reports and records of suspicious operations, which are confidential and subject only to the UIF’s supervision), and also lists some examples of what circumstances should be specially considered in order to stablish if a particular transaction may be considered unusual and eventually qualified as suspicious.

Central Bank Rules require Argentine banks to take certain precautions to prevent money laundering. In this regard, Central Bank recommends financial institutions create an anti-money laundering committee, to assist in the compliance of the anti-money laundering regulations.

Additionally, as mentioned, each financial institution must appoint a member of the board of directors as the person responsible for money laundering prevention, in charge of centralizing any information the Central Bank may require on its own initiative or at the request of any competent authority and reporting any suspicious transactions to the UIF.

In addition, the guidelines issued by the Central Bank to detect unusual or suspected money laundering or terrorist financing transactions require the reporting of suspicious transactions, based on the resources of the entity subject to the reporting obligation and on the type of analysis performed. In particular, the following special circumstances, among others, shall be considered: (a) if the amount, type, frequency and nature of a transaction made by a customer bears no relationship to such customer’s previous history and financial activity; (b) amounts that are unusually high or transactions that are of a complexity and type not usual for the relevant customer; (c) if a customer refuses to provide information or documents required by the entity or the information furnished is found to have been altered; (d) if a customer fails to comply with any applicable regulation; (e) if a customer appears to show an unusual disregard for risks it may be assuming and/or costs involved in the transactions, and this is incompatible with the customer’s financial profile; (f) if a country or jurisdiction that is not a

 

67


Table of Contents

territory or associated state included in the cooperating countries list contained in Executive Decree No. 589/2013, section 2(b) is involved; (g) if a same address appears registered for different legal entities or the same natural persons have been empowered by and/or act as attorneys-in-fact for different legal entities and such circumstance is not justified by any financial or legal reason, in particular taking into account whether any such companies or entities are not organized, domiciled or resident in dominions, jurisdictions, territories or associated states included in the cooperating countries list contained in Executive Decree No. 589/2013, section 2(b), and their main business involves off-shore transactions; (h) if transactions of a similar nature, amount, type or which are conducted simultaneously, it may be presumed that a single transaction has been split into several for the purpose of avoiding the application of transaction detection and/or reporting procedures; (i) if continued profits or losses are derived from transactions repeatedly conducted between the same parties; or (j) if certain signs suggest an illegal source, handling or use of funds involved in the transactions, and the entity subject to the legal obligation does not have any explanation for this.

Furthermore, pursuant to Communication “A” 5738 (as amended and supplemented) of the Central Bank, in force as of February 2015, Argentina financial institutions must comply with certain additional “know your customer policies”. In this sense, pursuant to such Communication, under no circumstance new commercial relationships could be initiated if the “know your customer policies” and the risk management legal standards have not been complied with. In addition, as per the existing clients: if the “know your customer policies” could not be complied with, the Argentine financial institution must discontinue operations with such client (i.e. cease the relationship with the client in accordance with Central Bank’s regulations for each type of product) within 150 calendar days as of the notice of such circumstances. Operations do not have to be discontinued when the “know your customer policies” are complied with in such period or when simplified due diligence procedures were implemented pursuant to applicable laws. Furthermore, pursuant to this Communication, Argentine financial entities must keep the documentation related to the discontinuance for 10 years and include in their prevention manuals the detailed procedures to initiate and discontinue operations with clients in accordance with the above-mentioned additional “know your customer policies” implemented.

The CNV Rules (as amended in September 2013) include a specific chapter regarding “Prevention of Money Laundering and the Financing of Terrorism” and state that the persons set forth therein (including, among others, Negotiation Agents, Clearing and Settlement Agents (which are stockbrokers), and Distribution and Placement Agents) are to be considered legally bound reporting under the Anti-Money Laundering Law, and therefore must comply with all the laws and regulations in force in connection with anti-money laundering and terrorism financing, including resolutions issued by the UIF, presidential decrees referring to resolutions issued by the United Nations Security Council in connection with the fight against terrorism and the resolutions (and its annexes) issued by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs. In addition, CNV Rules impose certain restrictions in connection with payment arrangements (restricting, among others, to Ps.1,000 the cash amount that the entities set forth therein could receive or pay per day and per client) and impose certain reporting obligations.

In addition, the CNV Rules establish that the above-mentioned entities shall only be able to carry out any transactions therein contemplated under the public offering system, when such transactions are carried out or ordered by persons organized, domiciled or resident in dominions, jurisdictions, territories or associated States included in the cooperating countries list contained in Executive Decree No. 589/2013, section 2(b). When such persons are not included in such list and in their home jurisdiction qualify as registered intermediaries in an entity under control and supervision of a body that carries out similar functions to those carried out by the CNV, they will only be allowed to carry out such transactions if they provide evidence indicating that the relevant securities and exchange commission in their home jurisdiction has signed a memorandum of understanding for cooperation and exchange of information with the CNV.

For a thorough analysis of money laundering regulations in effect as of the date of this document, investors are advised to consult with their own legal counsel and to read Title XIII, Second Book of the Argentine Criminal Code and any regulations issued by the UIF, the CNV and the Central Bank in their entirety. For this purpose, interested parties may visit the websites of the Argentine Ministry of Economy and Public Finance, www.infoleg.gov.ar, the UIF, www.uif.gov.ar, the CNV, www.cnv.gob.ar or the Central Bank, www.bcra.gov.ar.

C. Organizational Structure

Subsidiaries

We have five subsidiaries: (i) Banco del Tucumán, our acquired retail and commercial banking subsidiary in the province of Tucumán; (ii) Macro Bank Limited, our subsidiary in the Bahamas through which we provide primarily private banking services; (iii) Macro Securities S.A., which is a member of the MERVAL, and through which we provide investment research, securities trading and custodial services to our customers; (iv) Macro Fiducia S.A., a subsidiary that acts as trustee and provides financial advisory and analysis services; and (v) Macro Fondos S.G.F.C.I. S.A., an asset management subsidiary.

 

     Banco Macro’s
direct and indirect interest
 

Subsidiary

   Percentage of Capital Stock     Percentage of possible votes  

Banco del Tucumán S.A. (1)

     89.932     89.932

Macro Bank Limited (2)

     99.999     100.00

Macro Securities S.A. (1)

     99.921     99.932

Macro Fiducia S.A. (1)

     98.605     98.605

Macro Fondos S.G.F.C.I. S.A. (1)

     99.936     100.00

 

(1) Country of residence: Argentina
(2) Country of residence: The Bahamas

 

68


Table of Contents

D. Property, plants and equipment

Property

Banco Macro dedicates 25,146 square meters of office space to headquarters, where management, accounting and administrative personnel are located, of which 23,646 square meters are owned by the Bank and 1,500 square meters are leased. Our headquarters are distributed at the offices located in Sarmiento 341-355, 401-447,731-735, Perón 564 and Leandro N. Alem 1110, all in the City of Buenos Aires. As of December 31, 2015, we have a branch network consisted of 439 branches in Argentina, of which 184 were leased properties.

In 2011 we acquired from the Government of the City of Buenos Aires a site located at Av. Eduardo Madero No. 1180, in the City of Buenos Aires, for an aggregate amount of Ps.110 million. The Bank has developed a project to build its new corporate offices on this site. Works were initiated in 2012 and are expected to be completed by 2017. The new corporate tower was designed to take full advantage of natural light and maximize energy efficiency, while also using materials that do not adversely affect the environment. It is being built in compliance with the Leed International Sustainability Standards of the “U.S. Green Building Council.”

The building will have an area of 52,700 square meters and the Bank estimates that its project will require an investment of approximately US$160 million. As of December 31, 2015 the total aggregate amount invested was Ps.734.9 million (approximately US$91.2 million at the applicable exchange rates as of the respective dates of such investments).

Selected Statistical Information

The following information is included for analytical purposes and should be read in conjunction with the consolidated financial statements as well as Item 5. “Operating and Financial Review and Prospects”. This information has been prepared from our financial records, which are maintained in accordance with the regulations established by the Central Bank and do not reflect adjustments necessary to state the information in accordance with U.S. GAAP. See Note 35 to our audited consolidated financial statements as of and for the three years ended December 31, 2015 for a summary of the significant differences between Central Bank Rules and U.S. GAAP.

Due to the modification of certain disclosure methods used for certain items in the consolidated balance sheets and consolidated statements of income, certain figures have been restated for comparability purposes. See “Presentation of certain financial and other information.”

Average balance sheets, interest earned on interest-earning assets and interest paid on interest-bearing liabilities

The following tables show average balances, interest amounts and nominal rates for our interest-earning assets and interest-bearing liabilities for the years ended December 31, 2013, 2014 and 2015.

 

69


Table of Contents
    2013     2014     2015  
    Average
Balance
    Interest
Earned/
(Paid)
   

Average
Nominal

Rate

    Average
Balance
    Interest
Earned/
(Paid)
   

Average
Nominal

Rate

    Average
Balance
    Interest
Earned/
(Paid)
   

Average
Nominal

Rate

 
    (in thousands of Pesos)  

ASSETS

                 

Interest-earning assets

                 

Government securities (1)

                 

Pesos

    2,892,521        283,493        9.80     8,322,927        1,971,981        23.69     10,926,858        3,377,979        30.91

Foreign currency

    741,385        34,498        4.65     1,654,116        47,449        2.87     3,032,056        191,906        6.33

Total

    3,633,906        317,991        8.75     9,977,043        2,019,430        20.24     13,958,914        3,569,885        25.57

Loans

                 

Private and financial Sector

                 

Pesos

    31,438,373        7,904,360        25.14     37,004,555        11,068,167        29.91     48,630,232        14,800,448        30.43

Foreign currency

    2,016,460        195,404        9.69     2,184,470        258,640        11.84     2,328,639        293,347        12.60

Total

    33,454,833        8,099,764        24.21     39,189,025        11,326,807        28.90     50,958,871        15,093,795        29.62

Public Sector

                 

Pesos

    575,666        132,437        23.01     610,798        201,470        32.98     512,488        112,880        22.03

Foreign currency

    0        0        0.00     0        0        0.00     0        0        0.00

Total

    575,666        132,437        23.01     610,798        201,470        32.98     512,488        112,880        22.03

Other assets

                 

Pesos

    2,141,519        283,594        13.24     1,893,423        131,748        6.96     2,744,649        591,426        21.55

Foreign currency

    937,545        11,163        1.19     1,010,274        31,904        3.16     990,097        39,116        3.95

Total

    3,079,064        294,757        9.57     2,903,697        163,652        5.64     3,734,746        630,542        16.88

Total interest-earning assets

                 

Pesos

    37,048,079        8,603,884        23.22     47,831,703        13,373,366        27.96     62,814,227        18,882,733        30.06

Foreign currency

    3,695,390        241,065        6.52     4,848,860        337,993        6.97     6,350,792        524,369        8.26

Total

    40,743,469        8,844,949        21.71     52,680,563        13,711,359        26.03     69,165,019        19,407,102        28.06

Non interest-earning assets

                 

Cash and due from banks

                 

Pesos

    2,040,616        0        —          2,710,272        0        —          3,072,264        0        —     

Foreign currency

    271,698        0        —          756,574        0        —          1,045,614        0        —     

Total

    2,312,314        0        —          3,466,846        0        —          4,117,878        0        —     

Investments in other companies

                 

Pesos

    11,124        0        —          11,595        0        —          9,870        0        —     

Foreign currency

    974        0        —          2,164        0        —          2,586        0        —     

Total

    12,098        0        —          13,759        0        —          12,456        0        —     

Property and equipment and miscellaneous and intangible assets and items pending of allocation

                 

Pesos

    1,315,587        0        —          1,767,760        0        —          2,609,333        0        —     

Foreign currency

    0        0        —          0        0        —          0        0        —     

Total

    1,315,587        0        —          1,767,760        0        —          2,609,333        0        —     

Allowance for loan losses

                 

Pesos

    (883,915     0        —          (1,038,264     0        —          (1,223,389     0        —     

Foreign currency

    (51,343     0        —          (57,546     0        —          (73,549     0        —     

Total

    (935,258     0        —          (1,095,810     0        —          (1,296,938     0        —     

Other assets

                 

Pesos

    5,612,108        0        —          6,588,491        0        —          8,086,665        0        —     

Foreign currency

    4,208,338        0        —          4,431,135        0        —          3,798,792        0        —     

Total

    9,820,446        0        —          11,019,626        0        —          11,885,458        0        —     

Total non interest-earning assets

                 

Pesos

    8,095,520        0        —          10,039,854        0        —          12,554,743        0        —     

Foreign currency

    4,429,667        0        —          5,132,327        0        —          4,773,443        0        —     

Total

    12,525,187        0        —          15,172,181        0        —          17,328,187        0        —     

TOTAL ASSETS

                 

Pesos

    45,143,599        0        —          57,871,557        0        —          75,368,970        0        —     

Foreign currency

    8,125,057        0        —          9,981,187        0        —          11,124,235        0        —     

Total

    53,268,656        0        —          67,852,744        0        —          86,493,207        0        —     

LIABILITIES

                 

Interest-bearing liabilities

                 

Savings accounts

                 

Pesos

    6,237,331        40,872        0.66     7,714,543        49,175        0.64     10,894,390        68,098        0.63

Foreign currency

    1,106,136        685        0.06     1,741,369        594        0.03     2,239,920        71        0.00

Total

    7,343,467        41,557        0.57     9,455,912        49,769        0.53     13,134,310        68,169        0.52

Time deposits

                 

Pesos

    19,059,864        3,054,652        16.03     23,407,958        5,128,065        21.91     29,119,497        6,655,538        22.86

 

70


Table of Contents
    2013     2014     2015  
    Average
Balance
    Interest
Earned/
(Paid)
   

Average
Nominal

Rate

    Average
Balance
    Interest
Earned/
(Paid)
   

Average
Nominal

Rate

    Average
Balance
    Interest
Earned/
(Paid)
   

Average
Nominal

Rate

 
    (in thousands of Pesos)  

Foreign currency

    1,804,392        12,959        0.72     2,142,104        10,962        0.51     2,264,310        51,250        2.26

Total

    20,864,256        3,067,611        14.70     25,550,062        5,139,027        20.11     31,383,807        6,706,788        21.37

Borrowing from the Central Bank

                 

Pesos

    18,129        1,603        8.84     14,957        1,308        8.75     9,201        793        8.62

Foreign currency

    42        0        0.00     75        0        0.00     23        0        0.00

Total

    18,171        1,603        8.82     15,032        1,308        8.70     9,224        793        8.60

Borrowings from other financial institutions

                 

Pesos

    142,310        14,562        10.23     116,446        23,331        20.04     115,511        22,720        19.67

Foreign currency

    147,728        5,318        3.60     282,786        9,997        3.54     91,129        5,137        5.64

Total

    290,038        19,880        6.85     399,232        33,328        8.35     206,640        27,857        13.48

Corporate Bonds

                 

Pesos

    0        0        0.00     0        0        0.00     0        0        0.00

Foreign currency

    1,404,885        131,117        9.33     2,082,246        194,864        9.36     2,376,493        220,402        9.27

Total

    1,404,885        131,117        9.33     2,082,246        194,864        9.36     2,376,493        220,402        9.27

Other liabilities

                 

Pesos

    0        0        0.00     0        0        0.00     0        0        0.00

Foreign currency

    4,613        0        0.00     26,740        0        0.00     0        0        0.00

Total

    4,613        0        0.00     26,740        0        0.00     0        0        0.00

Total Interest-bearing liabilities

                 

Pesos

    25,457,634        3,111,689        12.22     31,253,904        5,201,879        16.64     40,138,599        6,747,149        16.81

Foreign currency

    4,467,796        150,079        3.36     6,275,320        216,417        3.45     6,971,875        276,860        3.97

Total

    29,925,430        3,261,768        10.90     37,529,224        5,418,296        14.44     47,110,474        7,024,009        14.91

Non-interest bearing liabilities and Shareholders’ equity

                 

Demand deposits

                 

Pesos

    12,594,928        0        —          15,741,946        0        —          21,001,262        0        —     

Foreign currency

    376,681        0        —          555,170        0        —          579,129        0        —     

Total

    12,971,609        0        —          16,297,116        0        —          21,580,391        0        —     

Other liabilities

                 

Pesos

    2,399,233        0        —          2,477,047        0        —          3,301,677        0        —     

Foreign currency

    567,517        0        —          1,037,833        0        —          911,428        0        —     

Total

    2,966,750        0        —          3,514,880        0        —          4,213,105        0        —     

Minority Interest

                 

Pesos

    60,531        0        —          82,807        0        —          111,642        0        —     

Foreign currency

    0        0        —          3,014        0        —          0        0        —     

Total

    60,531        0        —          85,821        0        —          111,642        0        —     

Shareholders’ equity

                 

Pesos

    7,344,336        0        —          10,425,703        0        —          13,477,595        0        —     

Foreign currency

    0        0        —          0        0        —          0        0        —     

Total

    7,344,336        0        —          10,425,703        0        —          13,477,595        0        —     

Total non–interest bearing liabilities and shareholders’ equity

                 

Pesos

    22,399,028        0        —          28,727,503        0        —          37,892,176        0        —     

Foreign currency

    944,198        0        —          1,596,017        0        —          1,490,557        0        —     

Total

    23,343,226        0        —          30,323,520        0        —          39,382,733        0        —     

TOTAL LIABILITIES AND SHAREHOLDERS’ EQUITY

                 

Pesos

    47,856,662        0        —          59,981,407        0        —          78,030,775        0        —     

Foreign currency

    5,411,994        0        —          7,871,337        0        —          8,462,432        0        —     

Total

    53,268,656        0        —          67,852,744        0        —          86,493,207        0        —     

 

(1) Includes instruments issued by the Central Bank. The interest earned/paid includes changes due to mark-to-market of those securities.

Changes in interest income and interest expense; volume and rate analysis

The following tables allocate, by currency of denomination, changes in our interest income and interest expense segregated for each major category of interest-earning assets and interest-bearing liabilities into amounts attributable to changes in their average volume and their respective nominal interest rates for fiscal year ended December 31, 2013 compared to the fiscal year ended December 31, 2012; for fiscal year ended December 31, 2014 compared to the fiscal year ended December 31, 2013 and for fiscal year ended December 31, 2015 compared to fiscal year ended December 31, 2014.

 

71


Table of Contents
    December 2013/December 2012     December 2014/December 2013     December 2015/December 2014  
    Increase (Decrease) Due to Changes in     Increase (Decrease) Due to Changes in     Increase (Decrease) Due to Changes in  
    (in thousands of Pesos)  
    Volume     Rate     Net Change     Volume     Rate     Net Change     Volume     Rate     Net Change  

ASSETS

                 

Interest-earning assets

                 

Government securities

                 

Pesos

    (75,241     57,298        (17,943     532,228        1,156,260        1,688,488        616,959        789,039        1,405,998   

Foreign currency

    15,006        4,620        19,626        42,471        (29,520     12,951        39,527        104,930        144,457   

Total

    (60,235     61,918        1,683        574,699        1,126,740        1,701,439        656,486        893,969        1,550,455   

Loans

                 

Private and financial Sector

                 

Pesos

    1,879,027        384,301        2,263,328        1,399,471        1,764,336        3,163,807        3,477,273        255,008        3,732,281   

Foreign currency

    (47,161     68,569        21,408        16,281        46,955        63,236        17,070        17,637        34,707   

Total

    1,831,866        452,870        2,284,736        1,415,752        1,811,291        3,227,043        3,494,343        272,645        3,766,988   

Public Sector

                 

Pesos

    34,956        30,947        65,903        8,082        60,951        69,033        (32,427     (56,163     (88,590

Foreign currency

    0        0        0        0        0        0        0        0        0   

Total

    34,956        30,947        65,903        8,082        60,951        69,033        (32,427     (56,163     (88,590

Other assets

                 

Pesos

    (57,445     49,312        (8,133     (32,855     (118,991     (151,846     59,230        400,448        459,678   

Foreign currency

    1,472        (1,588     (116     866        19,875        20,741        (637     7,849        7,212   

Total

    (55,973     47,724        (8,249     (31,989     (99,116     (131,105     58,593        408,297        466,890   

Total interest-earning assets

                 

Pesos

    1,781,297        521,858        2,303,155        1,906,926        2,862,556        4,769,482        4,121,035        1,388,332        5,509,367   

Foreign currency

    (30,683     71,601        40,918        59,618        37,310        96,928        55,960        130,416        186,376   

Total

    1,750,614        593,459        2,344,073        1,966,544        2,899,866        4,866,410        4,176,995        1,518,748        5,695,743   

LIABILITIES

                 

Interest-bearing liabilities

                 

Savings accounts

                 

Pesos

    11,418        (4,037     7,381        9,680        (1,377     8,303        20,269        (1,346     18,923   

Foreign currency

    87        (200     (113     393        (484     (91     170        (693     (523

Total

    11,505        (4,237     7,268        10,073        (1,861     8,212        20,439        (2,039     18,400   

Time deposits

                 

Pesos

    497,152        403,425        900,577        696,853        1,376,560        2,073,413        1,251,247        276,226        1,527,473   

Foreign currency

    (1,869     (574     (2,443     2,425        (4,422     (1,997     625        39,663        40,288   

Total

    495,283        402,851        898,134        699,278        1,372,138        2,071,416        1,251,872        315,889        1,567,761   

Borrowing from the Central Bank

                 

Pesos

    398        17        415        (280     (15     (295     (503     (12     (515

Foreign currency

    0        0        0        0        0        0        0        0        0   

Total

    398        17        415        (280     (15     (295     (503     (12     (515

Borrowings from other financial institutions

                 

Pesos

    3,125        (1,676     1,449        (2,647     11,416        8,769        (187     (424     (611

Foreign currency

    (2,002     (74     (2,076     4,862        (183     4,679        (6,775     1,915        (4,860

Total

    1,123        (1,750     (627     2,215        11,233        13,448        (6,962     1,491        (5,471

Corporate Bonds

                 

Pesos

    (9,180     0        (9,180     0        0        0        0        0        0   

Foreign currency

    22,085        744        22,829        63,218        529        63,747        27,537        (1,999     25,538   

Total

    12,905        744        13,649        63,218        529        63,747        27,537        (1,999     25,538   

 

72


Table of Contents
    December 2013/December 2012     December 2014/December 2013     December 2015/December 2014  
    Increase (Decrease) Due to Changes in     Increase (Decrease) Due to Changes in     Increase (Decrease) Due to Changes in  
    (in thousands of Pesos)  
    Volume     Rate     Net Change     Volume     Rate     Net Change     Volume     Rate     Net Change  

Total Interest-bearing liabilities

                 

Pesos

    502,913        397,729        900,642        703,606        1,386,584        2,090,190        1,270,826        274,444        1,545,270   

Foreign currency

    18,301        (104     18,197        70,898        (4,560     66,338        21,557        38,886        60,443   

Total

    521,214        397,625        918,839        774,504        1,382,024        2,156,528        1,292,383        313,330        1,605,713   

Interest-earning assets: net interest margin and spread

The following table analyzes, by currency of denomination, the levels of our average interest-earning assets and net interest income, and illustrates the comparative margins and spreads for each of the years indicated.

 

     Year Ended December 31,  
     2013     2014     2015  
     (in thousands of Pesos, except percentages)  

Average interest-earning assets

      

Pesos

     37,048,079        47,831,703        62,814,227   

Foreign currency

     3,695,390        4,848,860        6,350,792   

Total

     40,743,469        52,680,563        69,165,019   

Net interest income (1)

      

Pesos

     5,492,195        8,171,487        12,135,584   

Foreign currency

     90,986        121,576        247,509   

Total

     5,583,181        8,293,063        12,383,093   

Net interest margin (2)

      

Pesos

     14.82     17.08     19.32

Foreign currency

     2.46     2.51     3.90

Weighted average rate

     13.70     15.74     17.90

Yield spread nominal basis (3)

      

Pesos

     11.00     11.32     13.25

Foreign currency

     3.16     3.52     4.29

Weighted average rate

     10.81     11.59     13.15

 

(1) Defined as interest earned less interest paid. Trading results from our portfolio of government and private securities are included in interest.
(2) Net interest income (including income from government and private securities) divided by average interest-earning assets.
(3) Defined as the difference between the average nominal rate on interest-earning assets and the average nominal rate on interest- bearing liabilities.

Investment portfolio: government and private securities

We own, manage and trade a portfolio of securities issued by the Argentine and other governments and private issuers. The following table analyzes, by currency of denomination, our investments in Argentine and other governments and private securities as of December 31, 2013, 2014 and 2015. Securities are stated before deduction of allowances.

 

    

Years Ended December 31,

 
     2013      2014      2015  
     (in thousands of Pesos)  

Government securities

        

In Pesos:

        

Government securities at market value (1)

        

Discount bonds at 5.83% – Maturity: 2033

     26,176         862,088         1,597,140   

Federal government bonds at Badlar Private + 2% – Maturity: 2017

     —           494,833         484,928   

Federal government bonds at Badlar Private + 2% – Maturity: 2016

     —           377,042         337,075   

Federal government treasury bonds – Maturity: May 2016

     —           —           313,686   

Federal government treasury bonds – Maturity: March 2016

     —           —           143,470   

Consolidation bonds – 8° Serie – Maturity: 2022

     3,381         65,085         119,119   

Secured bonds under Presidential Decree No. 1,579/02 at 2% – Maturity: 2018

     308,235         111,749         94,259   

Federal government treasury bonds – Maturity: July 2016

     —           —           76,822   

Federal government bonds at Badlar Private + 2.5% – Maturity: 2019

     —           38,560         47,577   

Federal government bonds at Badlar Private + 3% – Maturity: 2017

     —           —           22,647   

Others

     768,242         337,344         11,527   

Subtotal Government securities at market value

     1,106,034         2,286,701         3,248,250   

Government securities at amortized cost

        

Province of Chubut treasury bills Class II Series XVI – Maturity: 2016

     —           —           400,682   

Province of Neuquén guarantee treasury bills Class I Serie III – Maturity: 2017

     —           —           130,764   

Federal government bonds at Badlar Private + 2.5% – Maturity: 2019

     —           161,937         115,302   

Province of Neuquén guarantee Treasury Bills Class I Series II – Maturity: 2017

           67,704   

Province of Entre Ríos Treasury Bills – Maturity: 2016

     —           25,487         26,031   

Province of Chaco treasury bills Class I – Maturity: 2016

     —           —           24,556   

Province of Neuquén guarantee Treasury Bills Class I Series I – Maturity 2016

     —           —           19,723   

Province of Mendoza Bills – Maturity: 2016

     —           —           4,439   

Province of Tucumán bonds – 1° Serie – Maturity: 2018

     4,225         3,407         2,398   

Province of Chaco Treasury Bills – Maturity: 2015

     —           15,453         —     

Others

     98,759         —           —     

Subtotal Government securities at amortized cost

     102,984         206,284         791,599   

Instruments Issued by Central Bank of Argentina (2)

        

 

73


Table of Contents
    

Years Ended December 31,

 
     2013      2014      2015  
     (in thousands of Pesos)  

Listed Central Bank of Argentina bills and notes (Lebacs/Nobacs)

     12,980         3,820,548         5,066,846   

Unlisted Central Bank of Argentina bills and notes (Lebacs/Nobacs)

     160,051         1,618,630         1,105,912   

Subtotal Instruments Issued by Central Bank

     173,031         5,439,178         6,172,758   

Total Government securities in Pesos

     1,382,049         7,932,163         10,212,607   

In Foreign currency:

        

Government securities at market value (1)

        

Treasury Bills – Maturity: 2016

     —           —           1,478,556   

Federal government bonds at 8.75% – Maturity: 2024

     —           —           215,298   

Debt Securities of the Province of Neuquén Class I Series I – Maturity: 2016

     50,566         30,766         9,427   

Debt Securities of the Province of Córdoba at 12% – Maturity: 2017

     4,316         1,864         1,723   

GDP – Related Securities – Maturity: 2035 (NY)

     810         1,640         1,687   

Par bonds – Maturity: 2038 (governed by Argentine legislation)

           282   

Federal government bonds at 7% – Maturity: 2017

     159,817         27,313         45   

Discount Bonds – Maturity: 2033 (Reg. by Arg. law)

     —           9         15   

Argentine Republic Global International bonds – Maturity: 2017

     3         2         4   

GDP – Related Securities – Maturity: 2035 (AR)

     —           8,389         3   

Others

     696,223         1,112,932         —     

Subtotal Government securities at market value

     911,735         1,182,915         1,707,040   

Government securities at amortized cost

        

Argentine saving bond for the economy development at 4% – Maturity: 2016

     98,437         129,184         196,411   

Deposit certificates for investment

     —           —           17,681   

Province of Tucumán bonds – 2° Serie at 9.45% – Maturity: 2015

     1,281         834         —     

Secured Province of Neuquén Treasury Bills Class 1 – Maturity: 2014

     37,435         —           —     

Debt Securities Class 1 – Chubut development and infrastructure bonds at 4% – Maturity: 2019

     10,376         —           —     

Subtotal Government securities at amortized cost

     147,529         130,018         214,092   

Instruments Issued by Central Bank of Argentina (2)

        

Unlisted Central Bank of Argentina bills and notes (Lebacs/Nobacs)

     —           290,747         2,130,234   

Subtotal Instruments Issued by Central Bank

     —           290,747         2,130,234   

Total Government securities in foreign currency

     1,059,264         1,603,680         4,051,366   

Total Government securities

     2,441,313         9,535,843         14,263,973   

Investments in Listed Private Securities

        

In Pesos:

        

Mutual Funds

     41,084         88,047         174,416   

Shares

     3         776,655         1,127,399   

In Foreign currency:

        

Mutual Funds

     17         20         25   

Shares

     —           —           —     

Total Private securities

     41,104         864,722         1,301,840   

Total Government and Private securities

     2,482,417         10,400,565         15,565,813   

Investments in Unlisted Private Securities

        

In Pesos:

        

Certificates of Participation in Financial Trusts (3)

     297,738         244,965         234,345   

Debt Securities in Financial Trusts

     393,859         134,048         152,151   

Corporate Bonds (4)

     68,404         284,399         450,627   

In Foreign currency:

        

Certificates of Participation in Financial Trusts (3)

     —           —           —     

Debt Securities in Financial Trusts

     30,540         34,337         43,405   

Corporate Bonds (4)

     202,286         179,417         152,940   

Total Investments in Unlisted Private Securities

     992,827         877,166         1,033,468   

Total

     3,475,244         11,277,731         16,599,281   

 

(1) As of December 31, 2015 the book value and market value of instruments issued by the Argentine government amounted to Ps.3,465,584 thousand (not including Treasury bills, Central Bank bills and notes, and provincial debt securities).
(2) As of December 31, 2015 the book value and market value of instrument issued by Central Bank of Argentina amounted to Ps.8,302,992 thousand and Ps.8,307,056 thousand , respectively.
(3) The Bank booked allowances for impairment in value amounting to Ps.224,043 thousand, Ps.223,831 thousand and Ps.225,270 thousand as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively.
(4) The Bank booked allowances for uncollectivility and impairment in value amounting to Ps.13,148 thousand, Ps.8,743 thousand and Ps.4,084 thousand as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively.

 

74


Table of Contents

Remaining maturity of government and private securities

The following table analyzes the remaining maturities of our investment portfolio as of December 31, 2015 in accordance with issuance terms (before allowances).

 

    

Maturing

within 1

year

   

Maturing

after 1

year but
within 5
years

   

Maturing

after 5
years but
within 10
years

   

Maturing

after 10
years

   

Without
due

date

     Total  
     Book Value (in thousands of Pesos, except percentages)  

In Pesos:

             

Government securities at market value

             

Discount bonds at 5.83% – Maturity: 2033

     —          —          319,428        1,277,712        —           1,597,140   

Federal government bonds at Badlar Private + 2% – Maturity: 2017

     —          484,928        —          —          —           484,928   

Federal government bonds at Badlar Private + 2% – Maturity: 2016

     337,075        —          —          —          —           337,075   

Federal government treasury bonds – Maturity: May 2016

     313,686        —          —          —          —           313,686   

Federal government treasury bonds – Maturity: March 2016

     143,470        —          —          —          —           143,470   

Consolidation bonds – 8° Serie – Maturity: 2022

     —          45,265        73,854        —          —           119,119   

Secured bonds under Presidential Decree No. 1,579/02 at 2% – Maturity: 2018

     43,233        51,026        —          —          —           94,259   

Federal government treasury bonds – Maturity: July 2016

     76,822        —          —          —          —           76,822   

Federal government bonds at Badlar Private + 2.5% – Maturity: 2019

     —          47,577        —          —          —           47,577   

Federal government bonds at Badlar Private + 3% – Maturity: 2017

     —          22,647        —          —          —           22,647   

Other

     6,410        2,382        1,966        769        —           11,527   

Government securities at amortized cost

             

Province of Chubut treasury bills Class II Series XVI – Maturity: 2016

     400,682        —          —          —          —           400,682   

Province of Neuquén guarantee treasury bills Class I Serie III – Maturity: 2017

     26,153        104,611        —          —          —           130,764   

Federal government bonds at Badlar Private + 2.5% – Maturity: 2019

     —          115,302        —          —          —           115,302   

Province of Neuquén guarantee Treasury Bills Class I Series II – Maturity: 2017

     —          67,704        —          —          —           67,704   

Province of Entre Ríos Treasury Bills – Maturity: 2016

     26,031        —          —          —          —           26,031   

Province of Chaco treasury bills Class I – Maturity: 2016

     24,556        —          —          —          —           24,556   

Province of Neuquén guarantee Treasury Bills Class I Series I – Maturity 2016

     19,723        —          —          —          —           19,723   

Province of Mendoza Bills – Maturity: 2016

     4,439        —          —          —          —           4,439   

Province of Tucumán bonds – 1° Serie – Maturity: 2018

     1,100        1,298        —          —          —           2,398   

Instruments Issued by Central Bank of Argentina (2)

             

Listed Central Bank of Argentina bills and notes (Lebacs/Nobacs)

     5,066,846        —          —          —          —           5,066,846   

Unlisted Central Bank of Argentina bills and notes (Lebacs/Nobacs)

     1,105,912        —          —          —          —           1,105,912   

Total Government securities in pesos

     7,596,138        942,740        395,248        1,278,481        —           10,212,607   

In Foreign currency:

             

Government securities at market value

             

Treasury Bills – Maturity: 2016

     1,478,556        —          —          —          —           1,478,556   

Federal government bonds at 8.75% – Maturity: 2024

     —          71,737        143,561        —          —           215,298   

Debt Securities of the Province of Neuquén Class I Series I – Maturity: 2016

     9,427        —          —          —          —           9,427   

Debt Securities of the Province of Córdoba at 12% – Maturity: 2017

     861        862        —          —          —           1,723   

GDP – Related Securities – Maturity: 2035 (NY)

     —          —          —          1,687        —           1,687   

Par bonds – Maturity: 2038 (governed by Argentine legislation)

     —          —          —          282        —           282   

Federal government bonds at 7% – Maturity: 2017

     —          45        —          —          —           45   

Discount Bonds – Maturity: 2033 (Reg. by Arg. law)

     —          —          3        12        —           15   

Argentine Republic Global International bonds – Maturity: 2017

     —          4        —          —          —           4   

GDP – Related Securities – Maturity: 2035 (AR)

     —          —          —          3        —           3   

Government securities at amortized cost

             

Argentine saving bond for the economy development at 4% – Maturity: 2016

     196,411        —          —          —          —           196,411   

Deposit certificates for investment

     —          —          —          —          17,681         17,681   

Instruments Issued by Central Bank of Argentina (2)

             

Unlisted Central Bank of Argentina bills and notes (Lebacs/Nobacs)

     2,130,234        —          —          —          —           2,130,234   

Total Government securities in foreign currency

     3,815,489        72,648        143,564        1,984        17,681         4,051,366   

Total Government securities

     11,411,627        1,015,388        538,812        1,280,465        17,681         14,263,973   

Weighted average rate (1)

     20.32     29.81     7.45     3.82     

Private securities

             

Investments in listed private securities

             

In Pesos:

             

Mutual Funds

     174,416        —          —          —          —           174,416   

Shares

     —          —          —          —          1,127,399         1,127,399   

In foreign currency:

             

Mutual Funds

     25        —          —          —          —           25   

Shares

     —          —          —          —          —           —     

Investments in unlisted private securities

             

In Pesos:

             

Certificates of Participation in Financial Trusts (3)

     2,257        —          —          8,256        223,832         234,345   

Debt Securities in Financial Trusts

     141,041        11,110        —          —          —           152,151   

Corporate Bonds (4)

     39,002        405,125        —          —          6,500         450,627   

 

75


Table of Contents

In Foreign Currency:

             

Certificates of Participation in Financial Trusts (3)

     —          —          —          —          —           —     

Debt Securities in Financial Trusts

     9,138        34,267        —          —          —           43,405   

Corporate Bonds (4)

     —          152,940        —          —          —           152,940   

Total Private securities

     365,879        603,442        —          8,256        1,357,731         2,335,308   

Weighted average rate (1)

     17.57     24.58     0.00     0.00     

 

(1) Effective yield based on December 31, 2015 quoted market values.
(2) As of December 31, 2015, “Instruments Issued by the Central Bank” includes Ps.3,069,647 thousand to fall due in 30 days, Ps.2,882,410 thousand to fall due in 60 days, Ps.1,364,803 thousand to fall due in 90 days, Ps.932,530 thousand to fall due in 180 days and Ps. 53,602 thousand to fall due in 360 days.
(3) The Bank booked allowances for impairment in value amounting to Ps.224,043 thousand as of December 31, 2015.
(4) The Bank booked allowances for uncollectibility risk and impairment in value amounting to Ps.13,148 thousand as of December 31, 2015.

Loan portfolio

The following table analyzes our loan portfolio (without considering leasing agreements) by type as of December 31, 2011, 2012, 2013, 2014 and 2015.

 

     As of December 31,  
     2011     2012     2013     2014     2015  
     (in thousands of Pesos)  

To the non-financial government sector

     336,189        586,557        640,158        604,417        748,067   

To the financial sector (1)

     343,282        299,250        364,897        213,867        227,390   

To the non-financial private sector and foreign residents

          

Overdrafts (2)

     2,712,718        4,280,640        4,449,988        3,385,551        4,707,889   

Documents (3)

     3,178,058        3,651,390        4,320,772        4,627,375        6,550,151   

Mortgage loans

     1,142,944        1,508,463        2,308,916        2,466,073        3,508,512   

Pledged loans (4)

     667,102        928,693        1,429,414        1,857,121        2,152,645   

Consumer loans (5)

     12,092,079        15,551,778        20,715,186        25,310,403        38,024,897   

Other loans

     4,158,915        4,808,641        5,206,630        5,835,233        7,078,576   

Accrued Interest, adjustments, foreign exchange and quoted price differences receivables

     360,245        570,281        779,436        831,683        1,186,116   

Less: Unearned discounts

     (74,050     (95,940     (186,547     (205,384     (355,864

Less: Allowances

     (599,224     (887,156     (1,006,495     (1,186,044     (1,495,964

Total Loans

     24,318,258        31,202,597        39,022,355        43,740,295        62,332,415   

 

(1) Includes loans to financial institutions, interfinancing (granted call) and other financing to Argentine financial institutions.
(2) Includes overdraft lines of credit resulting from checking accounts.
(3) Includes the face values of drafts, promissory notes and other bills transferred to us by endorsement for which the assignor is liable, whenever the latter is part of the non- financial private sector.
(4) Includes the principal amounts actually lent of automobile and other collateral granted, for which the obligor is part of the non-financial private sector and productive investment loans.
(5) Includes personal loans, credit card loans and other consumer loans. Overdrafts to individuals are included under “Overdrafts”.

Maturity composition of the loan portfolio

The following table analyzes our loan portfolio as of December 31, 2015 by type and by the time remaining to maturity. Loans are stated before deduction of the allowance for loan losses. We expect most loans to be repaid at maturity in cash or through refinancing at market terms.

 

     Maturing  
    

Amount as of

December 31, 2015

   

Within

1 Year

   

After

1 Year but

Within

5 Years

   

After

5 Years

 
     (in thousands of Pesos, except percentages)  

To the non-financial government sector

     748,067        78,572        669,495        —     

To the financial sector (1)

     227,390        215,474        11,916        —     

To the non-financial private sector and foreign residents

        

Overdrafts (2)

     4,837,596        4,825,058        12,538        —     

Documents (3)

     6,415,354        6,413,529        1,825        —     

Mortgage loans

     3,602,126        1,583,036        1,893,221        125,869   

Pledged loans (4)

     2,194,920        975,246        1,219,674        —     

Consumer loans (5)

     38,497,076        22,265,102        16,222,377        9,597   

Other loans

     7,305,850        5,624,539        1,677,324        3,987   

Total Loans

     63,828,379        41,980,556        21,708,370        139,453   

Percentage of total loan portfolio

     100     66     34     0

 

(1) Includes loans to financial institutions, interfinancing (granted call) and other financing to Argentine financial institutions.
(2) Includes overdrafts lines of credit resulting from checking accounts.
(3) Includes the face value of drafts, promissory notes and other bills transferred to us by endorsement for which the assignor is liable, whenever the latter is part of the non- financial private sector.
(4) Includes the principal amount actually lent of automobile and other collateral granted, for which the obligor is part of the non- financial private sector and productive investment loans.
(5) Includes personal loans, credit card loans and other consumer loans. Overdrafts to individuals are included under “Overdrafts”.

 

76


Table of Contents

Interest rate sensitivity of outstanding loans

The following table presents the interest rate sensitivity of our outstanding loans with maturities over one year as of December 31, 2015:

 

     As of December 31, 2015  
     (in thousands of Pesos)  

Loans with maturities over one year:

  

Variable Rate

  

To the non-financial government sector

     669,479   

To the financial sector

  

To the non-financial private sector and foreign residents

     4,090,170   

Total

     4,759,649   

Fixed rate

  

To the non-financial government sector

     16   

To the financial sector

     11,916   

To the non-financial private sector and foreign residents

     17,076,242   

Total

     17,088,174   

Total Loans with maturities over one year

     21,847,823   

Loans—portfolio classification

The following table presents our loan portfolio, before deduction of the allowance for loan losses, using the classification system of the Central Bank in effect at the end of each year:

 

     As of December 31,  
Loan Portfolio    2011     2012     2013     2014     2015  
     (in thousands of Pesos, except percentages)  

Categories

                    

1 – Normal situation/ Performing

     24,360,917         97.78     31,096,866         96.91     38,927,002         97.25     43,634,978         97.13     62,363,785         97.70

2 – Subject to special monitoring –in observation- in negotiation or with rollover agreement/ Low risk

     180,080         0.72     421,981         1.31     438,254         1.10     414,729         0.92     477,035         0.75

3 – Troubled/Medium risk

     155,686         0.62     203,545         0.63     245,887         0.61     325,499         0.72     309,191         0.49

4 – With high risk of insolvency/ High risk

     155,612         0.62     185,723         0.58     345,494         0.86     449,355         1.00     493,598         0.77

5 – Irrecoverable

     64,797         0.26     181,502         0.57     71,926         0.18     101,574         0.23     184,309         0.29

6 – Irrecoverable according to Central Bank’s Rules

     390         0.0     136         0.00     287         0.00     204         0.00     461         0.00

Total Loans

     24,917,482         100.00     32,089,753         100.00     40,028,850         100.00     44,926,339         100.00     63,828,379         100.00

For the explanation of each category please see “Argentine banking regulation—Liquidity and Solvency Requirements—Debt classification and loan loss provisions”.

Non-performing loans

The following table presents our non-performing loan portfolio, before deduction of the allowance for loan losses, using the loan classification criteria of the Central Bank in effect, at the end of each year:

 

     As of December 31,  
Non-performing loans    2011      2012      2013      2014      2015  
     (in thousands of Pesos)  

With preferred guarantees

     37,419         45,260         104,181         203,224         209,469   

Unsecured

     339,066         525,646         559,413         673,408         777,952   

Total non-performing loans

     376,485         570,906         663,594         876,632         987,421   

For additional information on non-accrual loans, past due loans and restructured loans please see note 35.4.c) and d) to our audited consolidated financial statements as of and for the three years ended December 31, 2015.

Analysis of the allowance for loan losses

The table below sets forth the activity in the allowance for loan losses for the years ended December 31, 2011, 2012, 2013, 2014 and 2015:

 

     Year Ended December 31,  
     2011     2012     2013     2014     2015  
     (in thousands of Pesos)  

Balance at the beginning of the year

     514,910        599,224        887,156        1,006,495        1,186,044   

Provisions for loan losses

     290,651        688,966        707,370        757,445        1,057,228   

Charge off (1)

     (206,337     (401,034     (588,031     (577,896     (747,308

Overdrafts

     (11,793     (23,288     (49,973     (46,794     (37,210

Documents

     (4,703     (6,695     (10,819     (131     (25,533

Mortgage loans

     (2,999     (11,951     (9,617     (4,321     (34,810

Pledged loans

     (2,945     (5,766     (4,550     (3,703     (2,122

Consumer loans

     (111,209     (315,331     (464,967     (450,178     (525,453

Other

     (72,688     (38,003     (48,105     (72,769     (122,180

Balance at the end of year

     599,224        887,156        1,006,495        1,186,044        1,495,964   

Charge-off/average loans (1)

     1.05     1.52     1.76     1.47     1.47

 

(1) Charge-off includes reversals.

 

77


Table of Contents

Central Bank Rules allows the Bank to establish additional allowances for loan losses based on management’s risk policies. Our executive committee decided to increase the allowance for loan losses related to our loan portfolio as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013 after evaluating the risk of our loan portfolio.

Under Central Bank Rules, non-performing loans must be charged-off seven months after such loans were classified as “irrecoverable without preferred guaranties” and fully provisioned. Pursuant to the current regulations, we charge-off non-performing loans on the next month following the date on which such circumstances are verified. Such debts are registered in off-balance sheet accounts as the Bank continues with collection efforts.

Allocation of the allowances for loan losses

The following table allocates the allowance for loan losses by each category of loans and sets forth the percentage distribution of the total allowance for each of the years ended December 31, 2011, 2012, 2013, 2014 and 2015.

 

    As of December 31,  
    2011     2012     2013     2014     2015  
    (in thousands of Pesos, except percentages)  

Overdrafts

    59,136        9.87     111,419        12.56     122,006        12.12     84,162        7.10     91,149        6.09

Documents

    49,061        8.19     58,493        6.59     82,751        8.22     100,213        8.45     110,044        7.36

Mortgage loans

    25,800        4.31     30,126        3.40     48,361        4.80     67,760        5.71     115,025        7.69

Pledged loans

    13,075        2.18     16,772        1.89     23,258        2.31     31,064        2.62     37,855        2.53

Consumer loans

    351,887        58.72     503,441        56.75     584,583        58.08     736,390        62.09     916,072        61.24

Other loans

    100,265        16.73     166,905        18.81     145,536        14.46     166,455        14.03     225,819        15.10

Total allowances

    599,224        100.00     887,156        100.00     1,006,495        100.00     1,186,044        100.00     1,495,964        100.00

 

78


Table of Contents

Loans by economic activities

The table below analyzes our loan portfolio according to the borrowers’ main economic activity as of December 31, 2011, 2012, 2013, 2014 and 2015.

 

    As of December 31,  
    2011     2012     2013     2014     2015  
    (in thousands of Pesos, except percentages)  
    Loan
Portfolio
    % of
Loan
Portfolio
    Loan
Portfolio
    % of
Loan
Portfolio
    Loan
Portfolio
    % of
Loan
Portfolio
    Loan
Portfolio
    % of
Loan
Portfolio
    Loan
Portfolio
    % of
Loan
Portfolio
 

Retail Loans

    10,611,776        42.59     13,432,743        41.86     17,762,834        44.38     21,299,813        47.41     31,867,480        49.93

Agricultural livestock- Forestry- Fishing- Mining- Hunting

    3,201,824        12.85     4,191,012        13.06     4,155,033        10.38     4,526,591        10.08     6,625,416        10.38

Construction

    1,456,323        5.84     1,594,771        4.97     1,767,016        4.41     2,266,493        5.04     3,164,972        4.96

Other services

    1,808,807        7.26     1,920,122        5.98     1,682,547        4.20     2,027,874        4.51     2,547,403        3.99

Retail and consumer products

    1,840,756        7.39     2,260,041        7.04     3,484,567        8.71     4,036,678        8.98     5,485,954        8.60

Foodstuff and beverages

    1,178,894        4.73     2,393,940        7.46     2,894,059        7.23     2,542,659        5.66     3,245,347        5.09

Financial Services

    691,460        2.77     760,903        2.37     828,678        2.07     632,579        1.41     688,377        1.08

Governmental services

    480,892        1.93     764,150        2.38     870,545        2.17     1,211,314        2.70     1,666,133        2.61

Real estate, business and leases

    383,209        1.54     527,821        1.64     739,238        1.85     770,437        1.71     1,098,488        1.72

Transportation, storage and communications

    565,384        2.27     871,237        2.72     1,299,210        3.25     1,240,657        2.76     1,668,776        2.61

Manufacturing and wholesales

    603,487        2.42     754,009        2.35     1,247,855        3.12     1,022,551        2.28     1,692,774        2.65

Chemicals

    441,458        1.77     883,970        2.75     1,097,191        2.74     1,391,433        3.10     1,113,050        1.74

Electricity, oil, water

    190,792        0.77     210,974        0.66     164,620        0.41     178,516        0.40     452,372        0.71

Hotels and restaurants

    39,261        0.16     93,902        0.29     184,876        0.46     166,216        0.37     173,591        0.27

Other

    1,423,159        5.71     1,430,158        4.46     1,850,581        4.62     1,612,528        3.59     2,338,246        3.66

Total Loans

    24,917,482        100.00     32,089,753        100.00     40,028,850        100.00     44,926,339        100.00     63,828,379        100.00

Deposits

The following table sets out the composition of each category of deposits that exceeded 10% of average total deposits in each of the years ended December 31, 2013, 2014 and 2015.

 

     Year Ended December 31,  
     2013     2014     2015  
     (in thousands of Pesos)  

Deposits in Domestic Bank Offices

      

Non-interest-bearing Demand Deposits (1)

      

Average

      

Pesos

     12,593,823        15,739,885        20,999,761   

Foreign currency

     376,203        554,238        579,115   

Total

     12,970,026        16,294,123        21,578,876   

Saving Accounts

      

Average

      

Pesos

     6,237,331        7,714,543        10,894,390   

Foreign currency

     312,880        380,361        500,154   

Total

     6,550,211        8,094,904        11,394,544   

Average nominal rate

      

Pesos

     0.66     0.64     0.63

Foreign currency

     0.06     0.02     0.01

Total

     0.63     0.61     0.60

 

79


Table of Contents
     Year Ended December 31,  
     2013     2014     2015  
     (in thousands of Pesos)  

Time Deposits

      

Average

      

Pesos

     19,059,864        23,407,958        29,119,497   

Foreign currency

     1,637,447        1,916,721        2,264,310   

Total

     20,697,311        25,324,679        31,383,807   

Average nominal rate

      

Pesos

     16.03     21.91     22.86

Foreign currency

     0.74     0.52     2.26

Total

     14.82     20.29     21.37

Deposits in Foreign Bank Offices

      

Non-interest-bearing Demand Deposits

      

Average

      

Pesos

     1,105        2,061        1,501   

Foreign currency

     478        932        14   

Total

     1,583        2,993        1,515   

Saving Accounts

      

Average

      

Foreign currency

     793,256        1,361,008        1,739,766   

Total

     793,256        1,361,008        1,739,766   

Average nominal rate

      

Foreign currency

     0.06     0.04     0.00

Total

     0.06     0.04     0.00

Time Deposits

      

Average

      

Foreign currency

     166,945        225,383        —     

Total

     166,945        225,383        —     

Average nominal rate

      

Foreign currency

     0.51     0.47     0.00

Total

     0.51     0.47     0.00

 

(1) Non-interest-bearing demand deposits consist of checking accounts.

Maturity of deposits at December 31, 2015

The following table sets forth information regarding the maturity of our deposits at December 31, 2015.

 

     Maturing  
     Total     

Within 3

Months

    

After 3

but Within

6 Months

    

After 6

but Within

12 Months

    

After 12

Months

 
     (in thousands of Pesos)  

Checking accounts

     18,024,939         18,024,939         —           —           —     

Savings accounts

     17,922,635         17,922,635         —           —           —     

Time deposits

     37,755,403         35,060,875         1,952,621         717,716         24,191   

Investment accounts

     1,395,775         839,122         174,200         379,182         3,271   

Other

     1,422,846         1,422,417         0         429         0   

Total Deposits

     76,521,598         73,269,988         2,126,821         1,097,327         27,462   

Maturity of outstanding time deposits and investment accounts in amount of Ps.100,000 or more at December 31, 2015

The following table sets forth information regarding the maturity of our time deposits and investment accounts in denominations of Ps.100,000 or more at December 31, 2015.

 

     Maturing  
     Total      Within 3
Months
     After 3
but Within
6 Months
    

After 6

but Within

12 Months

     After 12
Months
 
     (in thousands of Pesos)  

Domestic Bank Offices

  

Times deposits

     31,556,441         29,240,074         1,652,759         641,255         22,353   

Investment accounts

     1,371,270         833,459         156,742         377,874         3,195   

Total

     32,927,711         30,073,533         1,809,501         1,019,129         25,548   

 

80


Table of Contents

Return on equity and assets

The following table presents certain selected financial information and ratios for the years indicated.

 

     Year Ended December 31,  
     2013     2014     2015  
     (in thousands of Pesos, except percentages)  

Net income

     2,443,564        3,479,531        5,008,421   

Average total assets

     53,268,656        67,852,744        86,493,207   

Average shareholders’ equity

     7,344,336        10,425,703        13,477,595   

Shareholders’ equity at the end of the fiscal year

     8,627,431        11,491,817        15,876,082   

Net income as a percentage of:

      

Average total assets

     4.59     5.13     5.79

Average shareholders’ equity

     33.27     33.37     37.16

Declared cash dividends

     596,254        227,708        643,019 (2) 

Dividend payout ratio (1)

     24.40     6.54     12.84

Average shareholders’ equity as a percentage of Average total assets

     13.79     15.37     15.58

 

(1) Declared cash dividends stated as percentage of net income
(2) For the fiscal year ended December 31, 2015 dividends are still pending approval from the Central Bank as of the date of this annual report.

Short-term borrowings

Our short-term borrowings totaled approximately Ps.2,728.9 million, Ps.3,958.7 million and Ps.5,155.3 million for the years ended December 31, 2013, 2014 and 2015, respectively. The table below shows the breakdown of those amounts at the end of each year.

 

     Year Ended December 31,  
     2013     2014     2015  
            Annualized            Annualized            Annualized  
     Amount      Rate     Amount      Rate     Amount      Rate  
     (in thousands of Pesos, except percentages)  

Central Bank of Argentina:

          

Total amount outstanding at the end of the reported period

     9,676         5.11     10,746         5.09     12,706         4.28

Average during year (1)

     6,929         4.50     11,669         4.61     12,456         4.52

Maximum month-end balance (2)

     9,676           13,511           13,245      

Banks and international institutions:

          

Total amount outstanding at the end of the reported period

     326,495         2.79     88,313         6.28     98,598         4.91

Average during year (1)

     166,824         3.28     257,405         3.71     94,337         5.43

Maximum month-end balance (2)

     326,495           421,242           126,441      

Non-subordinated Corporate Bonds:

          

Total amount outstanding at the end of the reported period

     24,561         8.50     32,225         8.50     49,005         8.50

Average during year (1)

     15,256         8.50     21,821         8.50     27,568         8.50

Maximum month-end balance (2)

     24,561           32,225           49,005      

Financing received from Argentine financial institutions:

          

Total amount outstanding at the end of the reported period

     11,973         5.25     15,534         5.43     61,644         13.41

Average during year (1)

     31,434         7.91     19,268         5.06     59,730         10.85

Maximum month-end balance (2)

     53,547           26,974           140,625      

Other:

          

Total amount outstanding at the end of the reported period

     2,352,716         0.01     3,807,404         0.00     4,926,449         0.00

Average during year (1)

     1,762,725         0.01     3,104,144         0.00     4,020,421         0.00

Maximum month-end balance (2)

     2,352,716           3,807,404           4,926,449      

Subordinated corporate bonds:

          

Total amount outstanding at the end of the reported period

     3,442         9.75     4,517         9.75     6,868         9.75

Average during year (1)

     12,875         9.75     19,268         9.75     21,809         9.75

Maximum month-end balance (2)

     23,999           35,074           39,031      

Total short –term borrowings

     2,728,863           3,958,739           5,155,270      

 

(1) Average balances are calculated from quarterly-end balances.
(2) Maximums are calculated from quarterly-end balances.

Interest rate sensitivity

The interest rate sensitivity measures the impact on the gross intermediation margin in response to a change in market interest rates. For any given period, the pricing structure is matched when an equal amount of assets and liabilities reprice. Any mismatch of interest-earning assets and interest-bearing liabilities is known as a gap position and is shown in the following tables. A negative gap denotes liability sensitivity and normally means that a decline in interest rates would have a positive effect on net interest income while an increase in interest rates would have a negative effect on interest income.

 

81


Table of Contents

The following table shows the interest rate sensitivity of our interest-earning assets and interest-bearing liabilities based on contractual maturities. Variations in interest rate sensitivity may also arise within the repricing periods presented.

 

    Remaining Maturity at December 31, 2015  
    0-1 Year     1-5 Years     5-10 Years     Over 10 years     Without due date     Total  
    (in thousands of Pesos)  

Interest-earning assets:

           

Interest-bearing deposits in other banks

    1,271,350        —          —          —          —          1,271,350   

Government securities (1)

    11,411,627        1,015,388        538,812        1,280,465        17,681        14,263,973   

Receivables from financial leases

    168,880        270,330        74        —          —          439,284   

Loans to the non-financial government sector (2)

    78,572        669,495        —          —          —          748,067   

Loans to the private and financial sector (2)

    41,901,984        21,038,875        84,483        54,970        —          63,080,312   

Other Assets

    191,438        603,442        —          8,256        230,332        1,033,468   

Total Interest-Earning Assets

    55,023,851        23,597,530        623,369        1,343,691        248,013        80,836,454   

Interest-bearing liabilities:

           

Checking accounts

    2,239,404        —          —          —          —          2,239,404   

Savings accounts

    17,921,404        —          —          —          —          17,921,404   

Time Deposits

    37,707,918        23,890        300        1        —          37,732,109   

Investment Accounts

    1,417,571        3,271        —          —          —          1,420,842   

Non- subordinated Corporate Bonds

    49,005        1,383,667        —          —          —          1,432,672   

Subordinated Corporate Bonds

    6,868        —          —          1,950,750        —          1,957,618   

Liabilities with Central Bank

    12,706        211        —          —          —          12,917   

Liabilities with Argentine financial institutions

    61,644        22,740        —          —          —          84,384   

Liabilities with Banks and International Institutions

    98,598        —          —          —          —          98,598   

Other liabilities

    5,182,396        3,736        93,876        —          —          5,280,008   

Total Interest-Bearing Liabilities

    64,697,514        1,437,515        94,176        1,950,751        —          68,179,956   

Asset (Liability) Gap

    (9,673,663     22,160,015        529,193        (607,060     248,013        12,656,498   

Cumulative Asset/Liability Gap

    (9,673,663     12,486,352        13,015,545        12,408,485        12,656,498        —     

Cumulative sensitivity gap as a percentage of total interest-earning assets

    -11.97     15.45     16.10     15.35     15.66  
    0-1 Year        1-5 Years        5-10 Years        Over 10 years        Without due date        Total   

Interest-earning assets in Pesos

           

Government securities (1)

    7,596,138        942,740        395,248        1,278,481        —          10,212,607   

Receivables from financial leases

    168,880        270,330        74        —          —          439,284   

Loans to the non financial government sector (2)

    78,572        669,495        —          —          —          748,067   

Loans to the private and financial sector (2)

    40,341,643        21,027,309        84,483        54,970        —          61,508,405   

Other Assets

    182,300        416,235        —          8,256        230,332        837,123   

Total Interest-Earning Assets in Pesos

    48,367,533        23,326,109        479,805        1,341,707        230,332        73,745,486   

Interest-bearing liabilities in Pesos

           

Checking accounts

    798        —          —          —          —          798   

Savings accounts

    14,162,534        —          —          —          —          14,162,534   

Time Deposits

    33,575,041        21,209        300        1        —          33,596,551   

Investment Accounts

    1,402,049        3,271        —          —          —          1,405,320   

Liabilities with Central Bank

    12,706        211        —          —          —          12,917   

Liabilities with Argentine financial institutions

    61,644        22,740        —          —          —          84,384   

Other Liabilities

    4,370,899        3,736        93,876        —          —          4,468,511   

Total Interest-Bearing Liabilities in Pesos

    53,585,671        51,167        94,176        1        —          53,731,015   

Asset (Liability) Gap

    (5,218,138     23,274,942        385,629        1,341,706        230,332        20,014,471   

Cumulative Asset/Liability Gap

    (5,218,138     18,056,804        18,442,433        19,784,139        20,014,471     

Cumulative sensitivity gap as a percentage of total interest-earning assets    

    -7.08     24.49     25.01     26.83     27.14  

 

82


Table of Contents
     0-1 Year     1-5 Years     5-10 Years     Over 10 years     without due date     Total  

Interest-earning assets in foreign currency

            

Interest-bearing deposits in other banks

     1,271,350        —          —          —          —          1,271,350   

Government securities (1)

     3,815,489        72,648        143,564        1,984        17,681        4,051,366   

Loans to the private and financial sector(2)

     1,560,341        11,566        —          —          —          1,571,907   

Other assets

     9,138        187,207        —          —          —          196,345   

Total Interest-Earning Assets

     6,656,318        271,421        143,564        1,984        17,681        7,090,968   

Interest-bearing liabilities in foreign currency

            

Checking accounts

     2,238,606        —          —          —          —          2,238,606   

Savings accounts

     3,758,870        —          —          —          —          3,758,870   

Time Deposits

     4,132,877        2,681        —          —          —          4,135,558   

Investment Accounts

     15,522        —          —          —          —          15,522   

Non-subordinated Corporate Bonds

     49,005        1,383,667        —          —          —          1,432,672   

Subordinated Corporate Bonds

     6,868        —          —          1,950,750        —          1,957,618   

Liabilities with Banks and International Institutions

     98,598        —          —          —          —          98,598   

Other liabilities

     811,497        —          —          —          —          811,497   

Total Interest-Bearing Liabilities

     11,111,843        1,386,348        —          1,950,750        —          14,448,941   

Asset (Liability) Gap

     (4,455,525     (1,114,927     143,564        (1,948,766     17,681        (7,357,973

Cumulative Asset/Liability Gap

     (4,455,525     (5,570,452     (5,426,888     (7,375,654     (7,357,973  

Cumulative sensitivity gap as a percentage of total interest-earning assets

     -62.83     -78.56     -76.53     -104.01     -103.77  

 

(1) Includes instruments issued by the Central Bank.
(2) Loan amounts are stated before deducting the allowance for loan losses. Non-accrual loans are included with loans as interest- earning asset.

Item 4A. Unresolved Staff Comments

None.

Item 5. Operating and Financial Review and Prospects

This section contains forward-looking statements that involve risks and uncertainties. Our actual results may differ materially from those discussed in the forward-looking statements as a result of various factors, including, without limitation, those set forth in “Cautionary statement concerning forward-looking statements,” “Risk Factors,” and the matters set forth in this annual report in general.

The following discussion is based on, and should be read in conjunction with, our consolidated financial statements and related notes contained elsewhere in this annual report, as well as “Selected Financial Data” and the other financial information appearing elsewhere in this annual report in general.

A. Operating results

FINANCIAL PRESENTATION

Our audited consolidated financial statements as of and for the three years ended December 31, 2013, 2014 and 2015, included elsewhere in this annual report, have been prepared in accordance with Central Bank Rules. Central Bank Rules differ in certain significant aspects from U.S. GAAP. See note 35 to our audited consolidated financial statements as of and for the three years ended December 31, 2015.

Our consolidated financial statements recognized the changes in the Peso purchasing power until February 28, 2003, when the adjustments to reflect those changes were discontinued, as provided by the professional accounting standards effective in the City of Buenos Aires and as required by Presidential Decree 664/2003, Article No. 312 of General Resolution No. 7/2015 of the IGJ, Central Bank Communication “A” 3921 and CNV General Resolution No. 441. In reviewing our financial statements, investors should consider that, in recent years, there have been significant changes in the prevailing prices of certain inputs and economic indicators, such as salary cost, interest and exchange rates, however, local regulations have not required the application of inflation adjustments to our consolidated financial statements.

MACROECONOMIC ENVIRONMENT

World economic growth slowed down after a short period of growth from 2010 and 2012, which overcame the 2008 crisis caused by private over-indebtedness in the United States and public debt problems in Europe.

 

83


Table of Contents

During 2013, the global economy grew at very different rates, affecting the performance of the Argentine economy. The United States and Europe maintained a weak recovery after the 2008 crisis due to fiscal adjustment and debt pressures partially offset by expansive monetary policies implemented by the respective central banks.

Although China’s expansion rate decreased, its demand for raw materials remained positive for commodity producing regions, specifically Latin America.

Latin America maintained its growth rate driven by two opposing forces: (i) the deceleration in the volume of exports coupled with a reduction in commodity prices and the slowdown in the Brazilian economy as a result of its anti-inflationary policy, and (ii) the inflow of financial capital and direct investment. Latin America’s growth rate remained at 3.5%, as in the previous year.

In this international context, Argentina grew by 3.0% in 2013, more than in 2012 but below the annual average of 7.2% maintained since 2003. An expansive fiscal policy resulted in an increase of primary expenditures (current and capital expenses) by 33% while the national government’s income increased by 30%. As a result, the national public sector reported a primary deficit of Ps.22.3 billion, equal to 0.8% of the GDP. Including the payment of interest, the financial deficit amounted to Ps.64.6 billion, or 2.4% of the GDP, a similar percentage of the previous year.

By the end of 2013, the Argentine government implemented an external risk mitigation process by increasing the devaluation rate, imposing quantitative restrictions on imports and higher taxes on luxury assets and on the purchase of foreign currency for tourism. Inflation reached a rate of 10.9% per annum according to the INDEC, while at the same time the Argentine Peso depreciated 32.6% against the U.S. dollar. See item 3.D “Risk Factors—An increase in inflation could have a material adverse effect on Argentina’s economic prospects”.

In 2014, the global economy expanded by approximately 3%, a slightly lower rate than the average annual 3.4% recorded between 2010 and 2013, evidencing the slow recovery of developed countries as well as the deceleration trend in emerging countries.

The United States reported growth of 2.3%, as in the post-crisis years of 2008 and 2009, further strengthening in the second semester of 2014 due to the reduction in the debt burden of families and the resulting increase of domestic spending stemming from the improvement in employment levels.

Despite the fiscal adjustment process in place since 2009 to stabilize public debt, Europe recorded a slight improvement as compared to the light contraction registered in 2013.                

China, recording a growing share, reached 12% of the world’s GDP as a result of a 7.4% year over year expansion. The sustained domestic market economic process driven by credit combined with increased migration to the cities, resulted in an increase in global demand for raw material.

Latin America, which represents 7.5% of the world’s GDP, experienced a slowdown as compared to the sustained growth rate recorded in the last few years due to a drop in the price of commodities and the deceleration of Brazil’s economy.

Brazil’s economy experienced a slowdown due to reduced productivity, higher public expenditure and a lower fiscal surplus, all of which resulted in high inflation and capital flight, stopping the inflow of investments of the preceding years. Brazil grew by 0.5%, following an average annual growth rate of 3.5% between 2003 and 2013.

Within the international context and considering the dynamics of macroeconomic imbalances, the actual GDP of Argentina did not expand in 2014. The slowdown of the domestic economy, coupled with a drop in the demand of Argentina`s main trading partners, resulted in a reduction in the trading volume, causing a decrease in the trade balance by 16% as compared to the previous year, with exports falling by 12% (due to a reduction of prices of 2% and of volumes of 10%) and imports by 11% (due to a reduction of prices of 1% and of volumes of 11%).

Contrary to the contraction in the private sector, the government maintained its expansionary fiscal policy in line with increased tax revenues. Tax revenues increased by 36% year over year, representing 27% of the GDP. Primary expenditures grew by 43% driven by the policy of subsidies to utilities and capital expenditures. National public expenditures, including interest expense, represented 26% of the GDP.    

Therefore, both the primary and financial deficits increased as compared to 2013. Within the context of the Argentine government’s debt reduction policy, the Central Bank has provided funds to the Argentine government by issuing additional Pesos and withdrawing funds out of reserves.

During 2015 the slow growth continued, with distinct speeds of growth among the developed, Asian and emerging markets.

The United States maintained its annual economic growth rate at 2.4%. Europe also sustained its rate of growth in 2015. In contrast, China experienced an economic slowdown and its annual economic growth rate for 2015 was below the annual 7% rate recorded in previous years.

The slow growth of most developed countries, coupled with decreases in China’s economic growth, negatively impacted the price of commodities, including raw materials such as steel, copper and oil and, to a lesser extent, agricultural and food prices. Accordingly, the effects on Latin America were different from other economies with a greater dependence on raw materials and/or less agricultural production.

 

84


Table of Contents

Under this adverse external context and related with the degree of commercial openness and the liberty of capital flows, the Argentine economy grew by 2.1%, recovering the previous biennium growth. Nonetheless, the recovery is based on non-sustainable resources, creating fiscal imbalance and increasing internal expenditures.

The increase in the fiscal imbalance was financed by high inflation, loss of reserves and debt placement. In 2015, the deficit represented 5% of GDP.

Money market and Argentine financial system

In 2014, a slight demonetization of the economy was observed due to a shift from an expansive monetary policy between 2010 and 2013 to a moderate monetary policy after the devaluation. The placement of Central Bank debt instruments absorbed a material portion of the monetary expansion derived from fiscal assistance to the government and the purchase of foreign currency from the private sector.

The Central Bank’s reserves as of December 31, 2014 amounted to US$31.4 billion, an increase of approximately US$844 million over the prior year. This increase was primarily the result of the private-sector purchase of foreign currency, certain swap transactions entered into with China and the issuance and placement of dollar-denominated Lebacs and Nobacs.

In line with the reduced growth of the monetary base, financial activity slowed down. The average total deposits and the average total credits increased by 27% and 24% respectively, as compared to the 27% and 30% increase reported in average in 2013.

Regarding deposits, the trend of the last few years continued in 2014, with private sector deposits growing more than public sector deposits as a result of the permanent fiscal deficit of the national and provincial governments.

With respect to interest earning assets, the growth rate of total loans in the financial system was lower than that of the previous year, but Lebac holdings doubled. The Lebac / Loan ratio increased from 19% in 2013 to 32% in 2014.    

Systemic liquidity grew from 33% to 45% with respect to deposits in December 2014 due to increased holdings of Lebac in the financial system.

Interest rates also rose during the year, offsetting the reduction in the monetary base. In 2014, the Central Bank implemented a scheme of maximum reference lending rates for consumer and pledge loans in order to increase the demand for credit.

During 2014, borrowing rates decreased due to excess funds. With respect to borrowing rates, the Central Bank implemented a control mechanism, establishing a minimum borrowing rate for certain term deposits.

Changes were implemented in the operation of the financial system as a result of the monetary and sector-specific policies of the Central Bank. In 2014, after nine years of positive results, the strength of the financial system increased, with a net worth of Ps.168.1 million (a 38% increase as compared to the previous year).

In 2014, the soundness of the financial system improved, increasing its capacity to overcome potential economically volatile scenarios.

In 2015, there was an average monetary base increase of 33%. This increase was related to the Central Bank’s assistance to the federal government, that almost doubled the amount for 2014. The effect of such assistance was offset by a strong contraction by sales of foreign currencies and by the issuance of notes and repurchase agreements with the Central Bank.

In line with a passive monetary administration of the Central Bank, the sale of foreign currencies for approximately US$8 billion lead to a net decrease of the Central Bank reserves of US$5.4 billion. The reserves of the Central Bank as of December 31, 2015 amounted to US$25.6 billion.

In this context, in 2015 the growth of the financial activity was speeded; increasing the degree of bancarization.

In terms of deposits, there was a greater increase in the private sector than in the public sector. The deposits in the private sector increased by 47% as compared to 2014, with an increase in private time deposits of 61%. There was a significant increase in the number of fixed-term deposits in the fourth quarter in light of the increase of interest rates initiated by the Central Bank.

In terms of profitable assets, the financial system registered a total increase of loans of 37% and an increase of tenure of Lebac of 23% over the prior year. The Lebac/Loan ratio decreased from 32% in 2014 to 29% in 2015.

Private sector loans increased by 37% over the prior year, recording a significant acceleration in consumer loans (credit cards and personal).

During 2015, the Central Bank implemented strong regulations relating to limits to lending rates, commissions and the launching of new financial products. These restrictions started to be reversed with the change to the Central Bank authorities. The change in the government in December lead to the implementation of a distinct monetary policy which has seen an initial increase in interest rates and the return of a floating exchange rate.

 

85


Table of Contents

RESULTS OF OPERATIONS

The following discussion of our results of operations is for the Bank as a whole and without reference to any operating segments. We do not manage the Bank by segments or divisions or by customer categories, by products and services, by regions, or by any other segmentation for the purpose of allocating resources or assessing profitability.

During 2015, newly promulgated regulations affected the local economic environment, as exemplified by minimum rates for time deposits and maximum quotas for commissions and retail portfolios rates.

In this context, the Bank was able to take advantage of its strength by efficiently managing its liquidity and resource allocation. The growth of the assets of the Bank overcame initial expectations, following a better position in the market.

Our loan portfolio to the private sector grew to Ps.39,024 million as of December 31, 2013 increasing 25% compared to 2012, to Ps.44,108 million as of December 31, 2014 increasing 13% compared to 2013 and to Ps.62,853 million as of December 31, 2015 increasing 42% compared to 2014.

Within a context of increasing prices, the Bank, as well as the financial system, benefited from a continuous demand of consumer loans, the main growth driver of our portfolio for the last three years. During 2013, 2014 and 2015 consumer loans (personal loans and credit card loans), which are short term loans, have driven the expansion of our loan portfolio, increasing 33%, 22% and 50% respectively.

During 2015, the Bank maintained its leading position in terms of personal loans, which increased by 44%, with a 15% of market share (as of November 30, 2015). As to its credit card products, in 2014 the Argentine government launched a plan for credit card purchases in 12 interest free installments, which led to increased consumption and use of credit cards. The credit card loans in 2015 obtained extraordinary increasing levels, with an increase of 61% over the previous year balance.

During 2013, 2014 and 2015, pledge and mortgages loans (mainly productive investments loans with mortgage and pledge guarantees respectively, according to Communication “A” 5319, “A” 5380,“A” 5449, “A” 5516, “A” 5600, “A” 5681 and “A” 5771 of BCRA), grew 53%, 16% and 31%, respectively.

During 2015, we continued with the policy of maintaining high coverage of non-performing loans through the creation of additional provisions to such required by the Central Bank. The coverage was maintained at approximately 151.5%. Delinquency levels followed the same trend as the financial system as a whole, decreasing to 1.55% of total loans as compared to 1.95% in the previous year.

The increase in deposits followed the needs of the business, in order to maintain conservative liquidity and solvency ratios in accordance with applicable regulations.

In 2015, the Bank maintained a high liquidity ratio of 38.4% and exceeded the liquidity ratio of the financial system as a whole.

Our total deposits increased by 20%, 26% and 40% as of December 31, 2013, 2014 and 2015, respectively, up to Ps. 76,522 million as of December 31, 2015.

During 2013 and 2014, private sector deposits increased by 32% and 25% respectively, with increase in time deposits and sight deposits. Public sector deposits decreased by 21% in 2013 and increased by 30% during 2014.

During 2015, private sector deposits were the main source of funding, increasing by 45% compared to 2014, with an increase in time deposits of 61% over the prior year. Public sector deposits increased by 12% during 2015. Despite being subject to the Central Bank’s rate controls for most of the fiscal year, there was an effort to maintain profitability for this line item by extending the term of time deposits.

The Bank was the third largest private financial institution in terms of volume of total loans and total deposits, with a 7.2% and 5.7% of market share, respectively, as of November 30, 2015, maintaining a leading position, as in the previous year.

 

86


Table of Contents

YEAR ENDED DECEMBER 31, 2015 COMPARED TO YEAR ENDED DECEMBER 31, 2014 AND YEAR ENDED DECEMBER 31, 2014 COMPARED TO YEAR ENDED DECEMBER 31, 2013

Net income

The following table sets forth certain components of our income statement for the years ended December 31, 2013, 2014 and 2015:

 

     Year Ended December 31,     Change December 31,  
     (in thousands of Pesos)  
     2013     2014     2015     2015-2014     2014-2013  

Financial income

     9,753,531        14,682,649        20,109,123        5,426,474        4,929,118   

Financial expenses

     (4,021,540     (6,582,561     (8,842,655     (2,260,094     (2,561,021

Gross intermediation margin

     5,731,991        8,100,088        11,266,468        3,166,380        2,368,097   

Provision for loan losses

     (540,032     (664,882     (877,134     (212,252     (124,850

Service charge income

     3,426,324        4,655,788        6,115,362        1,459,574        1,229,464   

Service charge expenses

     (917,807     (1,215,759     (1,714,833     (499,074     (297,952

Administrative expenses

     (4,015,356     (5,498,879     (7,225,908     (1,727,029     (1,483,523

Net other income (expense)

     109,526        88,853        (34,512     (123,365     (20,673

Minority interest in subsidiaries

     (18,173     (23,492     (35,359     (11,867     (5,319

Net income before income tax

     3,776,473        5,441,717        7,494,084        2,052,367        1,665,244   

Income tax

     (1,332,909     (1,962,186     (2,485,663     (523,477     (629,277

Net income

     2,443,564        3,479,531        5,008,421        1,528,890        1,035,967   

Our consolidated net income for 2015 increased 44% or Ps.1,528.9 million as compared to 2014, from Ps.3,479.5 million in 2014 to Ps.5,008.4 million in 2015. This increase was primarily attributable to:

 

    37% increase in financial income of Ps.5,426.5 million; and

 

    31% increase in service charge income of Ps.1,459.6 million.

This increase was partially offset by a:

 

    34% increase in financial expenses of Ps.2,260.1 million;

 

    41% increase in service charge expenses of Ps.499.1 million;

 

    31% increase in administrative expenses of Ps.1,727.0 million; and

 

    27% increase in income tax of Ps.523.5 million.

Financial income

The components of our financial income for the years ended December 31, 2013, 2014 and 2015 were as follows:

 

     Year Ended December 31,  
     2013      2014      2015  
     (in thousands of Pesos)  

Interest on cash and due from banks

     241         127         155   

Interest on loans to the financial sector

     51,468         64,293         87,991   

Interest on overdrafts

     1,074,900         1,338,170         1,407,015   

Interest on documents (1)

     654,111         960,429         1,146,153   

Interest on mortgage loans

     333,854         483,143         556,620   

Interest on pledged loans (2)

     197,135         274,287         385,022   

Interest on credit card loans

     1,022,177         1,930,082         2,646,060   

Interest on financial leases

     68,435         76,320         81,711   

Interest on other loans (3)

     4,782,671         6,272,353         8,811,767   

Income from government and private securities, net

     409,054         1,974,166         3,985,892   

Interest on other receivables from financial intermediation

     3,101         3,455         4,105   

Income from guaranteed loans (4)

     26,026         40,201         25,077   

CER (Indexation by benchmark stabilization coefficient) adjustment (5)

     35,155         78,299         58,463   

CVS (Indexation by salary variation coefficient) adjustment

     606         737         669   

Difference in quoted prices of gold and foreign currency

     808,143         827,599         653,120   

Other (6)

     286,454         358,988         259,303   

Total financial income

     9,753,531         14,682,649         20,109,123   

 

(1) Includes income on factoring, check cashing advances and loans with promissory notes.
(2) Includes primarily income on interest on loans with collateral pledge.
(3) Includes interest on loans not classified under prior headings, including interest on personal loans.
(4) Includes income on loans to the Argentine government that were issued in exchange for federal and provincial government bonds.
(5) Includes CER accrued for all the assets subject to CER adjustments.
(6) Mainly results from pre-financing and financing export transactions, forward foreign currency transactions and premiums on reverse repos.

2015 and 2014 - Our financial income increased 37% or Ps. 5,426.5 million as compared to 2014, driven primarily by higher income from government and private securities and higher income derived from interest on loans.

 

87


Table of Contents

Interest on loans (excluding guaranteed loans) grew 33%, or Ps.3,723.3 million, as a result of an increase of 29% in the average loan portfolio and to a lesser extend due to an increase in the average interest rate. Additionally the average interest rate for private sector loans increased from 28.9% in 2014 to 29.6% in 2015.

The main variation of total interest on loans was from consumer loans with interest on credit card loans which increased 37% and interest on other loans (including interest on personal loans) which increased 40% as compared to 2014. The average volume of credits cards increased 44% and the average volume of other loans increased 37%, in each case as compared to the average in 2014. On the commercial side, the main variation was from interest on documents increased 19% and interest on pledge loans increased 40% compared to 2014. The average volume of documents increased by 29% and the average volume of pledged loans increased by 34%, in each case as compared to 2014.

Income from government and private securities grew 102%, or Ps.2,011.7 million, mainly due to an increase in income from private securities and other government securities as a result of the general increase of market prices.

2014 and 2013 - Our financial income increased 51% or Ps.4,929.1 million as compared to 2013, driven primarily by income derived from higher interest on loans.

Interest on loans (i.e., for all loans in the aggregate, excluding income from guaranteed loans) grew 40% or Ps.3,206.4 million as compared to 2013, mainly as a result of an increase in interest rates (from 24.2% on average for 2013 to 28.9% on average for 2014) and in the average portfolio volume (volume grew by 17% as compared to 2013).

The main variation of total interest on loans was from interest on credit card loans which increased 89%, interest on documents which increased 47% and interest on other loans (including interest on personal loans) which increased 31% compared to 2013. The average volume of credit card loans increased by 37%, the average volume of documents grew by 19%, the average volume of personal loans grew by 18% and the average volume of other loans grew by 12%, in each case as compared to 2013.

Income from government and private securities increased Ps.1,565.1 million as compared to 2013 (383%), driven by our Lebac and Nobac portfolio due to an increase in the average portfolio of such securities from Ps.1,551.5 million on average in 2013 to Ps.7,416.0 million on average in 2014.

The following tables set forth the changes in financial income due to increases (decreases) in volume and increases (decreases) in nominal rates of average interest-earning assets. Such financial income excludes exchange valuation differences and premiums on forward sales of foreign exchange:

 

Changes in financial income (interest earned)   

December 31 2013

vs.

December 31 2012

    

December 31 2014

vs.

December 31 2013

    

December 31 2015

vs.

December 31 2014

 
     Increase (Decrease)      Increase (Decrease)      Increase (Decrease)  
     (in thousands of Pesos)  

Due to changes in the volume of interest-earning assets

     1,750,614         1,966,544         4,176,995   

Due to changes in average nominal rates of interest-earning assets

     593,459         2,899,866         1,518,748   

Net change

     2,344,073         4,866,410         5,695,743   

 

Changes in financial income due to changes in volume   

December 31 2013

vs.

December 31 2012

    

December 31 2014

vs.

December 31 2013

    

December 31 2015

vs.

December 31 2014

 
     Increase (Decrease)      Increase (Decrease)      Increase (Decrease)  
     (in thousands of Pesos)  

Government and private securities

     (60,235      574,699         656,486   

Loans to private and financial sector

     1,831,866         1,415,752         3,494,343   

Loans to public sector

     34,956         8,082         (32,427

Other assets

     (55,973      (31,989      58,593   

Net change

     1,750,614         1,966,544         4,176,995   

 

Changes in financial income due to changes in nominal rates   

December 31 2013

vs.

December 31 2012

    

December 31 2014

vs.

December 31 2013

    

December 31 2015

vs.

December 31 2014

 
     Increase (Decrease)      Increase (Decrease)      Increase (Decrease)  
     (in thousands of Pesos)  

Government and private securities

     61,918         1,126,740         893,969   

Loans to private and financial sector

     452,870         1,811,291         272,645   

Loans to public sector

     30,947         60,951         (56,163

Other assets

     47,724         (99,116      408,297   

Net change

     593,459         2,899,866         1,518,748   

 

88


Table of Contents

Financial expenses

The components of our financial expenses for the years ended December 31, 2013, 2014 and 2015 were as follows:

 

     Year Ended December 31,  
     2013      2014      2015  
     (in thousands of Pesos)  

Interest on checking accounts

     497         533         0   

Interest on savings accounts

     41,060         49,237         68,169   

Interest on time deposits

     3,065,823         5,137,168         6,704,910   

Interest on interfinancing received loans (received call)

     2,883         1,202         7,036   

Interest on other financing from the financial institutions

     7         17         1   

Interest on other liabilities from financial intermediation (1)

     61,674         91,733         96,022   

Interest on subordinated corporate bonds

     80,953         120,407         136,191   

Other interest

     3,369         3,109         2,634   

CER adjustment (2)

     4,295         9,183         4,595   

Contribution to Deposit Guarantee Fund

     67,808         151,048         418,437   

Other (3)

     693,171         1,018,924         1,404,660   

Total financial expenses

     4,021,540         6,582,561         8,842,655   

 

(1) Includes lines of credit from other banks, repurchase agreements and Central Bank borrowings.
(2) Includes CER accrued for all the liabilities subject to CER adjustments.
(3) Mainly resulting from turnover tax.

2015 and 2014 - Financial expenses increased 34% or Ps. 2,260.1 million as compared to 2014.

Interest on deposits represented 77% of total financial expenses and increased by 31% or Ps. 1,586.1 million as compared to 2014 due to an increase on average portfolio by 29% and a slight increase in the interest rate (from 20.1% on average in 2014 to 21.4% on average in 2015).

Other financial expenses increased by 38% as compared to 2014 mainly due to an increase in turnover tax as a result of our higher computable financial income and, to a lesser extent, an increase in tax rates in certain provinces in which we operate.

2014 and 2013 - Financial expenses increased 64% or Ps.2,561.0 million as compared to 2013.

Interest on deposits represented 79% of total financial expenses and increased by 67% or Ps.2,079.6 million as compared to 2013 due to an increase in interest from time deposits of 68% mainly as result of increasing interest rates (from 15% on average in 2013 to 20% on average in 2014) and an increase in the average volume.

Other financial expenses increased by 47% as compared to 2013 mainly due to an increase in turnover tax as a result of our higher computable financial income and, to a lesser extent, an increase in tax rates in certain provinces in which we operate.

Changes in financial expense (interest paid)

 

   

December 31 2013

vs.

December 31 2012

   

December 31 2014

vs.

December 31 2013

   

December 31 2015

vs.

December 31 2014

 
    Increase (Decrease)     Increase (Decrease)     Increase (Decrease)  
    (in thousands of Pesos)  

Financial Expense due to changes in the volume of interest-bearing liabilities

    521,214        774,504        1,292,383   

Financial Expense due to changes in average nominal rates of interest-bearing liabilities

    397,625        1,382,024        313,330   

Net change

    918,839        2,156,528        1,605,713   

Changes in financial expense due to changes in volume

 

    

December 31 2013

vs.

December 31 2012

    

December 31 2014

vs.

December 31 2013

    

December 31 2015

vs.

December 31 2014

 
     Increase (Decrease)      Increase (Decrease)      Increase (Decrease)  
     (in thousands of Pesos)  

Deposits

     506,788         709,351         1,272,311   

Borrowings from Central Bank and other financial institutions

     1,521         1,935         (7,465

Corporate Bonds

     12,905         63,218         27,537   

Net change

     521,214         774,504         1,292,383   

 

89


Table of Contents

Changes in financial expense due to changes in nominal rates

 

    

December 31 2013

vs.

December 31 2012

    

December 31 2014

vs.

December 31 2013

    

December 31 2015

vs.

December 31 2014

 
     Increase (Decrease)      Increase (Decrease)      Increase (Decrease)  
     (in thousands of Pesos)  

Deposits

     398,614         1,370,277         313,850   

Borrowings from Central Bank and other financial institutions

     (1,733      11,218         1,479   

Corporate Bonds

     744         529         (1,999

Net change

     397,625         1,382,024         313,330   

Provision for loan losses

2015 and 2014 – Provision for loan losses increased 32% or Ps. 212.3 million in 2015 mainly due to the increase in the loan portfolio and the increase in the provisions for loan losses related to non-performing commercial loans required by the Central Bank.

2014 and 2013 – Provision for loan losses increased 23% or Ps.124.9 million in 2014 mainly due to the increase in the provisions for loan losses related to non-performing consumer loans and based on our policy of maintaining high coverage of non-performing loans through the creation of additional provisions to such required by the Central Bank. Non-performing loans increased 29% in 2014.

 

90


Table of Contents

Service charge income

The following table provides a breakdown of our service charge income by category for the years ended December 31, 2013, 2014 and 2015:

 

     Year Ended December 31,  
     2013      2014      2015  
     (in thousands of Pesos)  

Service charges on deposit accounts

     2,022,656         2,798,967         3,561,203   

Debit and credit card income

     776,726         1,147,740         1,628,556   

Other fees related to foreign trade

     44,464         67,123         100,581   

Credit-related fees

     164,097         92,101         124,559   

Capital markets and securities activities

     4,338         7,895         18,273   

Lease of safe-deposit boxes

     70,791         84,201         95,553   

Fees related to guarantees

     1,434         1,672         1,266   

Other (1)

     341,818         456,089         585,371   

Total service charge income

     3,426,324         4,655,788         6,115,362   

 

(1) Includes insurance income and revenue from joint ventures.

2015 and 2014 - Service charge income increased 31% or Ps. 1,459.6 million in 2015, mainly due an increase in service charges on deposits accounts (27%) and higher debit and credit card income (42%). During 2015 the amount of active accounts increased 14% and the banking product packages increased 7% and the fees charged for such accounts and banking product packages grew 16% in average. The increase in charged fees is due to the increase in consumption of debit and credit cards.

2014 and 2013 - Service charge income increased 36% or Ps.1,229.5 million in 2014, mainly due to higher debit and credit card income (48%) and increasing service charges on deposits accounts (38%) and other service charge income (33%), mainly due to an increase in the amount of active accounts and banking product packages and the fees charged for such accounts and banking product packages.

Service charge expenses

2015 and 2014 - In 2015, service charge expenses increased 41% or Ps. 499.1 million as compared to 2014 due to an increase in debit and credit card expenses as result of an aggressive marketing campaigns for credit card products as part of our strategy to strengthen our credit card market share.

2014 and 2013 - In 2014 service charge expenses increased 32% or Ps.298 million as compared to 2013 due to an increase in debit and credit card expenses as result of an aggressive marketing campaigns for credit card products as part of our strategy to strengthen our credit card market share.

Administrative expenses

The components of our administrative expenses for the years ended December 31, 2013, 2014 and 2015 are reflected in the following table:

 

     Year Ended December 31,  
     2013      2014      2015  
     (in thousands of Pesos)  

Personnel expenses

     2,351,921         3,190,774         4,324,067   

Directors and statutory auditors fees

     117,077         163,378         233,030   

Other professional fees

     138,212         181,427         217,948   

Advertising and publicity

     103,437         128,387         143,883   

Taxes

     218,491         323,463         411,789   

Depreciation of equipment

     98,666         130,678         170,613   

Amortization of organization costs

     89,019         122,704         150,619   

Maintenance, conservation and repair expenses

     187,684         256,937         322,436   

Security services

     192,873         249,176         313,310   

Electric power and communications

     102,023         146,145         172,669   

Lease payments

     77,713         110,875         137,288   

Insurance

     18,251         22,678         27,200   

Stationery and office supplies

     19,858         26,761         35,446   

Other

     300,131         445,496         565,610   

Total administrative expenses

     4,015,356         5,498,879         7,225,908   

2015 and 2014 - Administrative expenses increased 31% or Ps. 1,727.0 million in 2015, due to increase personnel expenses and other administrative expenses.

Personnel expenses increased by 35% as a result of a salary increase between 28 and 33% agreed with the labor unions between January and June 2015 and higher other personnel expenses. The remaining administrative expenses increased by 26% in 2015, in line with the recorded annual inflation.

 

91


Table of Contents

2014 and 2013 - Administrative expenses increased 37% or Ps.1,483.5 million in 2014, due to higher personnel expenses and other administrative expenses.

Personnel expenses increased by 36% as a result of a salary increase of 29% arranged with the labor unions in April 2014 and higher other personnel expenses. The remaining administrative expenses increased in total by 39% in 2014, mainly due to a 48% increase in taxes mainly in tax on debits and credits on Argentine bank accounts and the turnover tax, a 37% increase in repair and maintenance expenses (mainly due to an increase in rates paid to cleaning companies) and a 29% increase in security services expenses (mainly due to an increase in rates paid to additional police and private security companies).

Net other income (expense)

2015 and 2014. In 2015 net other income was a loss of Ps.34.5 million, decreasing 139% or Ps.123.3 million compared to 2014. The variation was mainly due to higher total other expenses by 69% or Ps.181.3 million, mainly because of an increase in charges for other receivables uncollectibility and other allowances of Ps.143 million. Total other income increased by 16% or Ps.58 million as compared to 2014, mainly as a result of higher other income (mainly tax return for Ps.49 million) and an increase in recovered loans and reversed allowances by Ps.25.3 million.

2014 and 2013. In 2014 net other income was Ps.88.8 million, decreasing 19% or Ps.20.7 million compared to 2013. The variation was mainly due to an increase of other expenses of 83% or Ps.118.7 million as result of the cancellation of contingent liabilities. Other income increased by 39% or Ps.98 million as compared to 2013, mainly as a result of increasing interest on other receivables and a significant increase in income from long-term investments.

Income tax

2015 and 2014. In 2015 income tax expenses increased 27% to Ps. 2,485.7 million compared to 2014 with a tax effective rate of 33.2% for fiscal year 2015. This increase was due to the increase in taxable revenues.

2014 and 2013. In 2014 income tax expenses increased 47% to Ps.1,962.2 million compared to 2013 with a tax effective rate of 36.1% for fiscal year 2014. This increase was due to the increase in taxable revenues.

U.S. GAAP and Central Bank Rules Reconciliation

General

We prepare our consolidated financial statements in accordance with Central Bank Rules, which differ from U.S. GAAP in certain respects. For more detail on differences in the accounting treatment between Central Bank Rules and U.S. GAAP as of December 31, 2015, see Note 35 to our consolidated financial statements as of and for the year ended December, 2015.

Summary of significant differences between Central Bank Rules and U.S. GAAP:

 

a. Exposure to the Argentine Public Sector and Private Securities:

 

a.1. Loans—Non-financial federal government sector: Guaranteed loans (maturing around 2017) were valued according to Central Bank Communication “A” 4898 and “A” 5180. Under U.S. GAAP, the difference between the cost of each acquired loan and its expected future cash flows is accounted for in accordance with FASB ASC 310-30 “Loans and debts acquired with deteriorated credit quality”. In accordance with this rule, we should continue to estimate the cash flows expected to be collected over the life of the loan. The effects of the adjustments required to state such amounts in accordance with U.S. GAAP would decrease assets by Ps.148.2 million, Ps.200.3 million and Ps.158.2 million as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively. On the other hand, income would increase by Ps.52 million for the year ended December 31, 2015 and would decrease Ps.42 million and Ps.11.4 million for the years ended December 31, 2014 and 2013, respectively.

 

a.2. Government and private securities:

 

  (i) Available for sale: Under U.S. GAAP, securities for which the Bank’s management has the intention and the ability to hold them for an indefinite period of time, but not necessarily to maturity, are classified as “available for sale securities”. They are carried at fair value with the unrealized gains and losses reported as net of income tax within the shareholders’ equity accounts in accordance with FASB ASC 320 “Investment – Debt and Equity Securities”.

 

  (ii) Trading securities: Under U.S. GAAP, securities maintained for intermediation are classified as “trading securities” because they are bought mainly with the intent to buy and sell in the short term as part of the Bank’s trading or intermediation activities. They are carried at fair value considering their active market, with changes in fair value recorded in the consolidated statement of income.

 

92


Table of Contents

Under Central Bank rules, Government and private securities were valued as explained in Note 4.5.b) to our consolidated financial statements. The effects of the adjustments required in accordance with U.S. GAAP would decrease assets by Ps.26.2 million, Ps.21.3 million and Ps.1.1 million as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively. On the other hand, net income, excluding OCI effects, would decrease by Ps.29.3 million for the year ended December 31, 2015 and would increase by Ps. 3 thousand and Ps.38.1 million for the years ended December 31, 2014 and 2013, respectively.

 

a.3. Instruments issued by Central Bank of Argentina: Under Central Bank Rules, instruments issued by the Central Bank of Argentina were valued at the quoted price of each security or at the cost value increased by their internal rate of return. Under U.S. GAAP, considering what is mentioned in Note 35.2.b.1) to our consolidated financial statements, these securities should be considered as “available for sale” and carried at fair value, with unrealized gains and losses reported as net of income tax within the shareholders’ equity accounts in accordance with FASB ASC 320. The effects of the adjustments required to state such amounts in accordance with U.S. GAAP would increase assets by Ps.4.1 million, Ps.2.4 million and Ps.41 thousand as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively. On the other hand, net income, excluding OCI effects, would increase by Ps.12.3 million, Ps.7.2 million and Ps.0.1 million for the years ended December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively.

 

a.4. Securities in financial trust and others: Under Central Bank Rules, securities in financial trust and others were valued at the cost value increased by their internal rate of return. Under U.S. GAAP, considering what is mentioned in Note 35.2.b.1) to our consolidated financial statements, these securities should be considered as “available for sale” and carried at fair value, with unrealized gains and losses reported as net of income tax within the shareholders’ equity accounts in accordance with FASB ASC 320. The effects of the adjustments required to state such amounts in accordance with U.S. GAAP would increase assets by Ps.35.8 million, Ps.30.9 million and Ps.14.3 million as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively. On the other hand, net income excluding OCI effects would increase by Ps.16.5 million for the year ended December 31, 2015 and would decrease Ps.10.4 million and Ps.5.1 million for the years ended December 31, 2014 and 2013, respectively.

 

b. Loans origination fees: Fees on consumer loans, such as credit cards, mortgage, pledged and personal loans, stand by letters of credit and guarantees issued, are recognized when collected and charges direct origination costs when incurred. In accordance with U.S. GAAP under FASB ASC 310-20 “Nonrefundable Fees and Other Costs”, loan origination fees and certain direct loan origination costs should be recognized over the life of the related loan as an adjustment of yield or by straight-line method, as appropriate. The effects of the adjustments required to state such amounts in accordance with U.S. GAAP, would decrease assets by Ps.38 million, Ps.91.3 million and Ps.111.8 million as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively. On the other hand, income would increase by Ps. 53.2 million and Ps.20.6 million for the years ended December 31, 2015 and 2014, respectively, and would decrease by Ps.6.5 million for the year ended December 2013.

 

c. Allowance for loan losses

 

c.1. Credit card loans: We establish a reserve for credit card loans based on the past due status of the loan. All loans without preferred guarantees greater than 180 days have been reserved at least at 50% in accordance with the Central Bank Rules. Under U.S. GAAP, we adopted a policy to fully provision loans which are 180 days past due. Had U.S. GAAP been applied, our assets would decrease by Ps.33.9 million, Ps.25.7 million and Ps.17 million as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively. In addition, income would decrease by Ps.8.2 million, Ps.8.7 million and Ps.3.5 million for the years ended December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively.

 

c.2. Impaired loans - Non Financial Private Sector and residents abroad: FASB ASC 310 “Receivables”, requires a creditor to measure impairment of a loan based on the present value of expected future cash flows discounted at the loan’s effective interest rate, or at the loan’s observable market price or the fair value of the collateral if the loan is collateral dependent. This statement is applicable to all loans (including those restructured in a troubled debt restructuring involving amendment of terms), except large groups of smaller-balance homogenous loans, not considered troubled debt restructuring, that are collectively evaluated for impairment. Loans are considered impaired when, based on Management’s evaluation, a borrower will not be able to fulfill its obligation under the original loan terms. The collective impairment allowance is calculated on a portfolio basis using statistical models which incorporate various estimates and judgments. We have performed a migration analysis based on uncollectability following the FASB ASC 450 “Contingencies”. Had U.S. GAAP been applied, the Bank’s assets would decrease by Ps.17.1 million for the year ended December 31, 2015 and would increase by Ps.3.8 million and Ps.2.8 million as of December 31, 2014 and 2013, respectively. In addition, income would decrease by Ps.20.9 million and Ps.1 million for the years ended December 31, 2015 and 2013, respectively, and would increase by Ps.0.9 million for the year ended December 31, 2014.

 

c.3. Interest recognition – non-accrual loans : The method applied to recognize income on loans is described in Note 4.5.d) to our consolidated financial statements. Additionally, the accrual of interest is discontinued generally when the related loan is non-performing and the collection of interest and principal is in doubt generally after 90 days of being past due. Accrued interest remains on the Bank’s books and is considered a part of the loan balance when determining the reserve for credit losses. Under U.S. GAAP the accrual of interest is discontinued when the management has serious doubts about further collectability of principal or interest, usually after 90 days, even though the loan is currently performing. When a loan is placed on non-accrual status, unpaid interest credited to income in the current year is reversed and unpaid interest accrued in prior years is charged against the allowance for credit losses. Had U.S. GAAP been applied, the Bank’s assets would decrease by Ps.24.2 million, Ps.22.1 million and Ps.13 million as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively. In addition, income would decrease by Ps.2.2 million, Ps.9.1 million and Ps.6.2 million for the years ended December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively.

 

d.

Income Tax: Central Bank Rules do not require the recognition of deferred tax assets and liabilities and, therefore, income tax is recognized on the basis of amounts due in accordance with Argentine tax regulations and no deferred tax and liabilities are

 

93


Table of Contents
  recognized. Under U.S. GAAP we apply FASB ASC 740 “Income Taxes”. Under this method, income tax is recognized based on the liability method whereby deferred tax assets and liabilities are recorded for temporary differences between the financial reporting and tax basis of assets and liabilities at each reporting date. FASB ASC 740 requires that an allowance for deferred tax assets be provided to the extent that it is more likely than not that they will not be realized, based on the weight of available evidence. In order to determine the amount of the valuation allowance required, in accordance with FAS ASC 740-10-30-16 through 30-25, we evaluate for each consolidated entity all available evidence, both positive and negative and the future realization of the tax benefit in a relatively short period of time, considering future reversals of existing taxable temporary differences, future taxable income exclusive of reversing temporary differences and carryforwards and tax-planning strategies. Had U.S. GAAP been applied, the Bank’s net assets would increase by Ps.190.2 million, Ps.366.1 million and Ps.242.6 million as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively. In addition, income would decrease by Ps.104.9 million for the year ended December 31, 2015 and would increase by Ps.154.9 million and Ps.64 million for the years ended December 31, 2014 and 2013, respectively.

 

e. Intangible assets:

 

  (i) Software cost: Under Central Bank Rules, it includes software costs relating to preliminary, application development and post – implementation stages of software development. Central Bank Rules permits the capitalization of certain costs that are not eligible for capitalization under FASB ASC 350-40 “Internal- Use Software”. The effects of the adjustments required to state such amounts in accordance with U.S. GAAP, would decrease assets by Ps.7.7 million, Ps.9.1 million and Ps.12.2 million as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively. In addition income would increase by Ps.1.5 million, Ps.3 million and Ps.5.4 million for the years ended December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively.

 

  (ii) Organizational costs: Under Central Bank Rules, it includes inherent cost of set up and organization of the Bank. Applying U.S. GAAP and in accordance with FASB ASC 720-15 “Start Up Costs”, these cost are not eligible for capitalization and would result in a decrease to the Bank’s assets by Ps.4.9 million and Ps.2.6 million as of December 31, 2014 and 2013, respectively. In addition income would increase by Ps.4.9 million for the year ended December 31. 2015, and would decrease by Ps.2.3 million and Ps.0.9 million for the years ended December 31, 2014 and 2013, respectively.

 

f. Vacation accrual: The cost of vacations earned by employees is generally recorded by us when paid. U.S. GAAP requires that this expense be recorded on an accrual basis as the vacations are earned. Had U.S. GAAP been applied, the Bank’s liabilities would increase by Ps.268.4 million, Ps.202.9 million and Ps.152.3 million as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively. In addition, income would decrease by Ps.65.5 million, Ps.50.6 million and Ps.0.9 million for the years ended December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively.

 

g. Business combination: Under Central Bank Rules, business combinations and step acquisitions are accounted for the carryover book value of the acquired company. Additionally, at the acquisition date, the Bank recognized the difference between the book value of the net equity acquired and the purchase price as a positive goodwill. Such goodwill is being amortized under the straight line method over 10 years. Under U.S. GAAP FASB ASC 805 requires the acquisition of controlling interest to be accounted for as a business combination applying the purchase method. The assets acquired and liabilities assumed are measured based on their estimated fair values as of the acquisition date. Had U.S. GAAP been applied, the Bank net assets would decrease by Ps.29.4 million, Ps.37.7 million and Ps.47.7 million as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively. In addition income would increase by Ps.8.5 million, Ps.9.8 million and Ps.17.5 for the years ended December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively.

 

h. Accounting for derivative instruments and hedging activities: Pursuant to Central Bank Rules, derivatives are recorded as described in Notes 4.5.g) and 4.5.k) to our consolidated financial statements. FASB ASC 815 “Derivatives and Hedging” establishes accounting and reporting standards for derivative instruments, including certain ones embedded in other contracts (collectively referred to as derivatives) and for hedging activities. It requires that an entity recognize all derivatives as either assets or liabilities in the statement of financial position and measure those instruments at fair value. Had U.S. GAAP been applied, the Bank’s liabilities would decrease by Ps.35.5 million for the year ended December 31, 2015, and the Bank’s assets would increase by Ps.1.7 million as of December 31, 2013. In addition income would increase by Ps.35.5 million and Ps.2.2 million for the years ended December 31, 2015 and 2013, respectively, and would decrease Ps.1.7 million for the year ended December 31, 2014.

 

i. Foreign currency translation: U.S. GAAP foreign currency translation requirements are covered by FASB ASC 830-20 “Foreign Currency Matters” and differ from Central Bank Rules in the translation of the income statement accounts, which under U.S. GAAP should have been translated at the average exchange rate other than at the year-end exchange rate. Had U.S. GAAP been applied, the Bank’s net income would decrease by Ps.200.5 million, Ps.87.6 million and Ps.69.5 for the years ended December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively, and these resulting differences recognized as other comprehensive income.

 

j. Corporate bonds: Under Central Bank Rules, cost of issuance was recognized as expenses when they were incurred and the interest has accrued according to the contract terms of the bonds in the period in which it was generated. Under U.S. GAAP, the Bank recognizes direct incremental costs and interest based on the effective interest method over the life of the loan. Had U.S. GAAP been applied, the Bank’s assets would increase by Ps.85.9 million, Ps.38.6 million and Ps.5.4 million as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively. In addition income would increase by Ps.47.3 million and Ps.33.3 million for the years ended December 31, 2015 and 2014, respectively, and would decrease by Ps.5.5 million for the year ended December 31, 2013.

 

k.

Foreclosed assets: Under Central Bank Rules, these assets are carried at cost adjusted by depreciation over the life of the assets. Under U.S. GAAP, in accordance with FASB ASC 360 “Property, Plant and Equipment”, such assets classified as held for sale shall be measured at the lower of its carrying amount or fair value less cost to sell. Had U.S. GAAP been applied, the Bank’s assets would

 

94


Table of Contents
  increase by Ps.15.5 million, Ps.12.8 million and Ps.14.2 million as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively. In addition income would increase by Ps.2.7 million and Ps.0.7 million for the years ended December 31, 2015 and 2013, respectively, and would decrease Ps.1.3 for the year ended December 31, 2014.

 

l. Capitalization of interest cost: Under Central Bank Rules, is not allowed to capitalized interest cost from borrowings. Under U.S. GAAP, in accordance with FASB ASC 835-20 “Capitalization of Interest Cost”, if an asset requires a period of time in which to carry out the activities necessary to bring it to the condition and location necessary for its intended use, the interest cost incurred during that period as a result of expenditures for the asset is a part of historical cost of acquiring the asset. Had U.S. GAAP been applied, the Bank’s assets would increase by Ps.112.8 million, Ps.37.8 million and Ps.9.4 million as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively. In addition, income would increase by Ps.75 million, Ps.28.3 million and Ps.9.4 million for the years ended December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively.

 

m. Contingencies: In accordance with Central Bank note dated August 4, 2008 we recognizes the effects of the Argentine Supreme Court rulings dated December 27, 2006, and August 28, 2007, upon payment of such precautionary measures, related to foreign-currency denominated deposits (amparos). Additionally, as provided by Central Bank Communiqué “A” 5689, includes provisions for summary judgements and sanctions applied by the Central Bank and other regulators, which are equivalent to the amounts not yet paid. Under US GAAP, in accordance with FASB ASC 450 “Contingencies”, the Bank should recognize a liability to cover contingent losses in view of their remote probability of occurrence. The effects of adjustments required to state such amounts in accordance with US GAAP would increase the Bank’s liabilities by Ps.17.8 million, Ps.43.4 million and Ps.69 million as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively. In addition, income would increase by Ps.25.6 million for the years ended December 31, 2015 and 2014, respectively, and would decrease by Ps.9 million for the year ended December 31, 2013.

 

n. Noncontrolling Interest in subsidiaries: Central Bank Rules requires to record noncontrolling interests as a component of liabilities. FASB ASC 810 requires to record such interest as shareholders’ equity. Had U.S. GAAP been applied, the Bank’s shareholder’s equity would increase by Ps.128.3 million, Ps.93 million and Ps.69.5 million for the years ended December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively. In addition income would increase by Ps.35.3 million, Ps.23.5 million and Ps.18.1 million for the years ended December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively.

Had U.S. GAAP been applied the Bank’s stockholders’ equity would decrease by Ps.2.8 million, Ps.73.3 million and Ps.225 million as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively.

In addition, net income calculated according U.S. GAAP would decrease by Ps.61.3 million for the year ended December 31, 2015, and would increase by Ps.93.4 million and Ps.36.1 million for the years ended December 31, 2014 and 2013, respectively.

B. Liquidity and Capital Resources

Our main source of liquidity consists of deposits, which totaled Ps. 76,521.6 million as of December 31, 2015, Ps.54,716.6 million as of December 31, 2014 and Ps.43,427 million as of December 31, 2013. These deposits include deposits generated by our branch network, from institutional, very large corporate clients and from provincial governments for whom we act as financial agent. We consider the deposits generated by our branch network and the provincial deposits to be stable.

Approximately 12% of our total deposits as of December 31, 2015 were derived from the non-financial government sector, in particular as a consequence of the Bank’s role as financial agent of four provinces. This is an important source of low-cost funding.

Total deposits, which grew 40% in 2015 compared to 2014, represented 86% of our total liabilities as of December 31, 2015. Deposits were used primarily to finance the growth in credit made available to the private sector and the balance was invested in liquid assets. This approach has enabled us to maintain a high liquidity to deposits ratio while we await a return to stronger demand for private sector loans.

During 2015 the liquidity ratio decreased from 40.6% as of December 31, 2014 to 38.4% as of December 31, 2015. The Bank’s liquidity ratio exceeds the liquidity ratio of the argentine financial system as a whole.

As of December 31, 2015 we have outstanding Ps.1,957.6 million of our 2036 Notes and Ps.1,432.7 million of our 2017 Notes.

Additionally, we currently have access to uncommitted lines of credit with foreign banks and to letters of credit.

We manage the excess liquidity by analyzing interest rates from a limited number of liquid and short-term assets including Central Bank bills, deposits with the Central Bank and overnight loans to highly rated companies. The amount allocated to overnight loans is determined by the amount of deposits received from institutional investors, and as such, there is a high degree of volatility in our overnight allocations.

We believe that we have adequate working capital to meet our current and reasonably foreseeable needs. As of December 31, 2015, we had excess capital of Ps. 6,915.6 million. Our excess capital is aimed at supporting growth, and consequently, a higher leverage of our balance sheet.

For further information regarding management and administration guidelines in relation to liquidity risk please note 18 “Risk management policies” to our audited consolidated financial statements as of and for the three years ended December 31, 2015. Additionally for further

 

95


Table of Contents

information regarding our restricted assets, assets in custody and trust agreements please see notes 8 “Restricted assets,” 12 “Items in custody” and 14 “Trust agreements” to our audited consolidated financial statements as of and for the three years ended December 31, 2015.

Minimum capital requirements

Our excess capital (representing the amount in excess of minimum reserve requirements of the Central Bank) is as set forth in the table:

 

     As of December 31,  
     2013 (1)     2014     2015  
    

(in thousands of Pesos, except

ratios and percentages)

 

Calculation of excess capital:

      

Allocated to assets at risk

     2,516,833        3,667,402        5,416,151   

Allocated to Bank premises and equipment, intangible assets and equity investment assets

     179,776        185,636        335,663   

Market risk

     52,026        388,136        568,798   

Operational risk

     709,873        1,278,035        1,734,888   

Interest rate risk (2)

     838,215        —          —     

Government sector and securities in investment account

     55,866        138,693        336,573   

Required minimum capital under Central Bank Rules

     4,352,590        5,657,902        8,392,073   

Common Equity Tier 1 (COn1)

     8,150,742        11,204,326        14,892,648   

Deductible concepts COn1

     (363,488     (431,969     (535,091

Additional Tier 1 (CAn1)

     412,668        366,816        320,964   

Tier 2 Capital (COn2)

     388,919        441,495        629,164   

Total capital under Central Bank Rules

     8,588,841        11,580,668        15,307,685   

Excess capital

     4,236,251        5,922,766        6,915,612   

Selected capital and liquidity ratios:

      

Regulatory capital/risk weighted assets

     25.29     24.02     20.79

Average shareholders’ equity as a percentage of average total assets

     13.79     15.37     15.58

Total liabilities as a multiple of total shareholders’ equity

     5.87     5.53     5.61

Cash as a percentage of total deposits

     29.61     28.21     25.36

Liquid assets as a percentage of total deposits (3)

     33.34     40.57     38.43

Loans as a percentage of total assets

     65.81     58.32     59.39

 

(1) Based on Communication “A” 5369, the calculation for the total capital requirement as of January 2013 remains as reference for the total capital requirement for 2013.
(2) According to Communication “A” 5369 of BCRA the interest rate risk requirement has been excluded from the total capital requirement since February 2013, being January 2013 the last month where interest risk requirement should be contemplated.
(3) Liquid assets include cash, cash collateral, reverse repos, Lebacs and Nobacs and interfinancing loans.

As of December 31, 2015, we had no material commitments for capital expenditures. We believe that our capital resources are sufficient for our present capital requirements on an individual and a consolidated basis.

Funding

Our principal source of funding is mainly deposits from individuals and corporate clients located in Argentina. Deposits include checking accounts, savings accounts and time deposits. The following table sets forth our sources of funding as of December 31, 2013, 2014 and 2015.

 

     As of December 31  
     2013      2014      2015  
     (in thousands of Pesos)  

Deposits

        

From the non-financial government sector

     6,580,041         8,570,055         9,588,378   

From the financial sector

     26,874         38,683         40,145   

From the non-financial private sector and foreign residents

        

Checking accounts

     8,602,700         11,896,322         14,062,853   

Savings accounts

     8,440,709         11,013,878         15,507,850   

Time deposits

     18,416,520         21,510,754         34,719,816   

Investment accounts (1)

     199,003         190,503         545,092   

Other (2)

     878,032         1,137,750         1,348,989   

Accrued interest, adjustments, foreign exchange and quoted price differences payable

     283,139         358,609         708,475   

 

96


Table of Contents
     As of December 31  
     2013      2014      2015  
     (in thousands of Pesos)  

Borrowing from Central Bank and financial institutions

        

Central Bank

     21,994         16,959         12,917   

Banks and international institutions

     326,495         88,313         98,598   

Financing received from Argentine financial institutions

     56,942         51,787         84,384   

Other

     2,440,877         3,899,498         5,024,061   

Minority interest in subsidiaries

     69,502         93,001         128,305   

Non-subordinated Corporate Bonds

     718,044         942,115         1,432,672   

Subordinated Corporate Bonds

     981,142         1,287,317         1,957,618   

Shareholders’ equity

     8,627,431         11,491,817         15,876,082   

Total funding

     56,669,445         72,587,361         101,136,235   

 

(1) Time deposit-payable at the option of the depositor.
(2) Includes, among others, expired time deposits and judicial deposits.

Critical accounting policies

Our accounting and reporting policies comply with Central Bank Rules, which differ in certain significant respects from U.S. GAAP. See Note 35 to our audited consolidated financial statements as of and for the three years ended December 31, 2015 included in this annual report for a reconciliation of our audited financial statements to U.S. GAAP. The preparation of our consolidated financial statements requires management to make, in certain cases, estimates and assumptions to determine the book value of assets and liabilities, income, expenses and contingencies. Our financial position and results of operations are based on the best estimate regarding the probability of occurrence of different future events and, thereof, the final amount may differ from such estimates, which may have a positive or negative impact on future years.

Critical accounting policies are those accounting policies that require management to make estimates based on assumptions about matters that are highly uncertain at the time the estimate is made and such estimates reasonably could have a material impact on the financial condition. Several factors are considered in determining whether or not a policy is critical in the preparation of our financial statements. These factors include, among others, whether the estimates are material to our financial statements, the nature of the estimates, the ability to readily validate the estimates with other information including information from third parties or available prices, and sensitivity of the estimates to changes in economic conditions and whether alternative accounting methods may be utilized under Central Bank Rules. Significant accounting policies are discussed in Note 4 to our audited consolidated financial statements as of the year ended December 31, 2015.

Allowance for loan losses

The loan loss reserve represents the estimate of probable losses in the loan portfolio. Pursuant to Central Bank Rules, a bank must classify its loan portfolio into two categories: consumer and commercial portfolio. Under each of these categories, customers are included within one of six sub-categories depending on the credit quality and the fulfillment of its obligations. A minimum allowance for loan losses is required to be established primarily based upon this classification and guarantees and collateral, supporting the transactions.

Determining the loan loss reserve requires significant management judgments and estimates. According to Central Bank Rules, for consumer portfolio, management must classify each customer based primarily on delinquency aging with the Bank and the financial system. For commercial portfolio, management must analyze the borrowers’ operating and payment history, ability to service its debt, its internal information and control systems and the risk of the sector in which it operates.

In addition, Central Bank Rules allows the Bank to establish additional allowances for loan losses and changes loan classification, as the case may be, based on management’s risk management policies. Our executive committee decided to increase the allowance for loan losses related to our loan portfolio as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013 after evaluating the risk of our loan portfolio. Our management determines increase or decrease in allowances based on repayment estimates. International and local macroeconomic conditions generate a certain degree of uncertainty regarding future progress as a result of the contractions in growth levels, the volatility of financial assets and the foreign exchange market, among other issues, which has been observed with various degrees of intensity over the last few years. This scenario leads us to the assumption that some of the loans that currently make up our portfolio might sustain an impairment value.

The accounting for loan loss reserve under Central Bank Rules differs in some respects with practices of U.S.-based banks, as mentioned below.

Under U.S. GAAP loans are considered impaired when, based on management’s evaluation, a borrower will not be able to fulfill its obligation under the original loan terms.

The methodology used for calculating impairment involves significant judgment. First, it involves the early identification of credits that are deteriorating. Second, it involves judgment in establishing the inputs used to estimate the allowance and third, it involves management judgment to evaluate certain macroeconomic factors and other relevant internal and external factor affecting the credit quality of a current portfolio, and to refine loss factors to better reflect these conditions.

FASB ASC 310, not applicable for large groups of smaller-balance homogeneous loans that are collectively evaluated, requires a creditor to measure impairment of a loan based on the present value of expected future cash flows discounted at the loan’s effective interest rate, or at the loan’s observable market price or the fair value of the collateral if the loan is collateral dependent. An allowance for impaired loans is provided when discounted future cash flows or the fair value of the collateral is lower than the book value.

 

97


Table of Contents

To calculate the allowance required for smaller-balance impaired loans and other groups of loans that have not yet been individually identified as impaired or measured in the group mention before, historical loss ratios are determined by analyzing historical losses. Loss estimates are analyzed by loan type for homogeneous groups of clients. Such historical ratios are updated to incorporate the most recent data reflecting current economic conditions, trends and any other pertinent information that may affect the estimation of the allowance for loan losses.

Management estimates require significant judgment including, among others, identifying impaired loans, determining customers’ ability to pay and estimating the fair value of underlying collateral or the expected future cash flows to be received. Actual events will likely differ from the estimates and assumptions used in determining the loan loss reserve. Additional loan loss reserves could be required in the future.

Income tax

In estimating accrued taxes, we assess the relative merits and risks of the appropriate tax treatment considering statutory, judicial and regulatory guidance in the context of the tax position.

Because of the complexity of tax laws and regulations, interpretation can be difficult and subject to legal judgment. It is possible that others, given the same information, may at any point reach different reasonable conclusions regarding the estimated amounts of accrued taxes.

Changes in the estimate of accrued taxes occur periodically due to changes in tax rates, interpretations of the status of examinations being conducted by various taxing authorities, and newly-enacted statutory and regulatory guidance that impact the relative merits and risks of tax positions. These changes, when they affect accrued taxes, can be material to our operating results.

As explained in note 5 to our audited consolidated financial statements as of and for the three years ended December 31, 2015, Central Bank Rules do not require the recognition of deferred tax assets and liabilities and, therefore, income tax is recognized on the basis of amounts due in accordance with Argentine tax regulations and no deferred tax and liabilities are recognized.

For purposes of U.S. GAAP reporting, we apply FASB ASC 740 “Income Tax”. Under this method, income tax is recognized based on the liability method whereby deferred tax assets and liabilities are recorded for temporary differences between the financial reporting and tax basis of assets and liabilities at each reporting date. FASB ASC 740 requires the Bank to record an allowance for deferred tax assets to the extent that it is more likely than not that deferred tax assets will be realized, based on the weight of available evidence. In order to determine the amount of the valuation allowance required, in accordance with FASB ASC 740-10-30-16 through 30-25, we evaluate for each consolidated entity all available evidence, both positive and negative and the future realization of the tax benefit in a relatively short period of time, considering future reversals of existing taxable temporary differences, future taxable income exclusive of reversing temporary differences and carryforwards and tax-planning strategies.

FASB ASC 740 also prescribes a recognition threshold and a measurement attribute for the financial statement recognition and measurement of tax positions taken or expected to be taken in a tax return. For those benefits to be recognized, a tax position must be more-likely-than-not to be sustained upon examination by taxing authorities.

There were no unrecognized tax benefits as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013.

Contingent liabilities

In the normal course of business, we are a party to lawsuits of various types. We disclose contingent liabilities with respect to existing or potential claims, lawsuits and other legal proceedings and record an accrual for litigation when it is probable that future costs will be incurred and these costs can be reasonably estimated. These accruals are based on the most recent developments, our evaluation of the merit of each claim, our assessment of the likely outcome of the litigation and our counsel’s advice in dealing with, litigating and settling this and other similar legal matters. Thus, these determinations are based on certain assumptions from our management. Changes to the accrual may be necessary if future events differ substantially from the assumptions used in the assessment for each period.

Fair Value of financial instruments

Under U.S. GAAP, a portion of our assets and liabilities are measured at fair value, including Government and private securities (debt instruments issued by Argentine government and the Central Bank and shares), other receivables from financial intermediation (mutual funds, securities in financial trusts and corporate bonds), forward transaction pending settlement and derivative instruments.

Under Central Bank Rules, those assets are valued as mentioned in Note 4.5 to our audited consolidated financial statements as of and for the three years ended December 31, 2015.

FASB ASC 820 defines fair value as the exchange price that would be received for an asset or paid to transfer a liability (an exit price) in the principal or most advantageous market for the asset or liability in an orderly transaction between market participants on the measurement date. To measure fair value, FASB ASC 820 has established a three-level hierarchy to prioritize the valuation input among (1) unadjusted quoted prices for identical assets or liabilities in an active market that we have the ability to access, (2) other than quoted

 

98


Table of Contents

prices that are observable for the asset or liability, either directly or indirectly and (3) prices or valuation techniques that require inputs that are both unobservable and significant to the overall fair value measurement. These inputs reflect management’s own assumptions about the assumptions a market participant would use in pricing the asset or liability.

When observable quoted prices are not available, fair value is based upon internally developed valuation techniques that use, quoted prices for similar assets or liabilities in active markets. Financial instruments valued at this manner are classified within Tier 2 of the fair value hierarchy. We used the followings methods:

a) For unlisted government and private securities: yield curve based on observable inputs taking similar instruments and the less active market approach for identical instruments traded in the market that will have a “less active market”.

b) For corporate bonds: discounted cash flow.

For instruments classified in Levels 1 and 2, where inputs are principally based on observable market data, there is less judgment applied in arriving at the fair value measurement.

For assets and liabilities that do not have similar or identical instruments traded in the market we used an internally developed model to measure significant instruments. Those instruments would be classified as Level 3 of the fair value hierarchy, which requires significant management judgment or estimation. In arriving at an estimate valuation policies and procedures for Level 3 instruments (in the case of the Bank mainly debt securities and derivative instruments) are under the direction of the accounting and financial management.

Management is in charge of developing, reviewing, approving and monitoring the key model inputs, critical valuation assumptions and proposed discount rates utilized for the valuation of Level 3 instruments. In addition, management is also in charge of monitoring the changes in fair values of Level 3 instruments from period to period.

An income approach is used in this level for estimates fair value. We use discounted cash flow methodologies, such as discount interest rate and projected exchange rate.

Our management believes its valuation methods are appropriate and consistent with other market participants, however, the use of different methodologies, or assumptions, to determine the fair value could result in a different estimate or fair value at different reporting dates.

C. Research and Development, Patents and Licenses, Etc.

We incur research and development expenses in connection with information technology projects. The amount spent during each of the last three years was not material. We plan infrastructure development (processing, telecommunications, Internet, information security) based upon present and projected future demand of such services. See Item 4. “Information on the Bank—Business Overview—Technology”.

D. Trend Information

We believe that the macroeconomic environment and the following trends in the Argentine financial system and in our business have affected and will, for the foreseeable future, continue to affect our results of operations and profitability. Our continued success and ability to increase our value to our shareholders will depend, among other factors, upon the economic growth in Argentine economy and the corresponding growth of the market for long-term private sector lending. For information about the macroeconomic environment see Item 5.A. “Operating Results”.

For 2016 we estimate a slowdown in the economy, affecting the growth of loans and deposits, recording figures lower than those of the preceding year. We expect an unsubstantial increase in default levels and stable margins, in an environment with high rates during the first semester and a minor reduction in the second semester. Likewise, the efficiency ratio, measured as expenses over net financial and service income is expected to remain stable.

The increase in credit in Argentina offers strong prospects for the future due to the low penetration in the current market. Penetration is low both in respect of consumer loans and commercial loans, with loans comprising 16% of GDP, a percentage less than various other countries in the region. Argentina possesses the second highest GDP in the region, and the informal sector is less significant than in other countries, which suggests that the conditions exists for further growth in the banking sector when adequate policies are implemented, and levels of inflation and rates are normalized.

 

99


Table of Contents

The Argentine Financial System

The Argentine financial system has maintained a solid trend in the last three years with the Bank’s performance improving accordingly, as evidenced by the following indicators:

 

     As of December 31,  
     2013      2014      2015  
     (In million of Pesos)  

Banco Macro

  

Total loans

     39,022         43,740         62,332   

Total deposits

     43,427         54,717         76,522   

Financial System

        

Total loans

     563,344         666,170         911,871   

Total deposits

     752,422         979,691         1,354,393   

Source: Central Bank

Financial activity gained strength during the last three years.

Total loans in the financial system increased 30% in 2013, 18% in 2014 and 37% in 2015 and amounted to Ps.911.9 billion as of December 31, 2015, driven by private sector loans.

Total deposits in the financial system increased by 26% in 2013, 30% in 2014 and 38% in 2015, driven by private sector deposits. Private sector deposits increased by 27% in 2013, 31% in 2014 and 47% in 2015, amounting to Ps.1,052.2 billion as of December 31, 2015. Public sector deposits increased 24% in 2013, 27% in 2014 and 13% in 2015, amounting to Ps.289.5 billion.

The level of loans and deposits over GDP was still low as of December 31, 2015, at 16% for total loans/GDP and 24% for total deposits/GDP. As a result of such GDP levels, we believe that there is considerable potential for growth in upcoming years.

Interest rates increased throughout the year due to a higher devaluation rate but were partially mitigated by the limits established by the Central Bank. Maximum interest rates for personal loans and pledged loans and minimum interest rates applicable to certain time deposits made by individuals reduced the rate’s variation. For more information see Item 4.B “Argentine banking regulation—Interest rates and fees regulations”.

Private sector lending

The extension of credits to the private sector in Argentina has recovered since 2010. During the last three years, loans to the private sector grew 31% in 2013, 20% in 2014 and 37% in 2015 for the financial system as a whole. This trend was also reflected in the evolution of our portfolio. Our private sector loan portfolio increased to Ps. 39,024 million (25%) in 2013, Ps.44,108 million (13%) in 2014 and Ps.62,853 million (42%) in 2015 as shown in the following table:

 

     As of December 31,  
     2013      2014      2015  
     (In million of Pesos)  

Banco Macro

  

Private sector loans

     39,024         44,108         62,853   

Financial System

        

Private sector loans

     501,857         603,969         827,943   

Source: Central Bank

We see the following trends in this important area of our business:

 

    As a result of our low cost of funds and our high level of liquidity, a key driver of our results is our ability to increase our lending within the scope of our credit policy, as such lending is always at a positive margin. Therefore, we have seen our gross intermediation margin widened as our private sector lending has increased.

 

    Growth prospects are subject to inflation and long-term fixed rate lending development. We believe that the main obstacle preventing a faster recovery of Argentina’s private sector long-term lending has been the uncertain outlook on long-term inflation, which has a significant impact on both the supply of and demand for long-term loans as borrowers try to hedge against inflation risk by borrowing at fixed rates while lenders hedge against inflation risk by offering loans at floating rates.

 

    Stable intermediation spread. Based on the low banking penetration in Argentina, we believe that the expected loan growth mix, with a larger participation of consumer loans compared to commercial loans, will improve spreads. However, price competition could offset this effect and intermediation spreads might remain stable.

Asset Quality

The financial system continued to show low levels of non-performing portfolio and extensive coverage ratios for non-performing portfolio.

As of December 31, 2015, the non-performing credit portfolio level reached 1.6% of the total credit portfolio, whereas the coverage ratio level reached 147% for the financial system as a whole.

Our figures reflect the similar level and evolution registered by the financial system as a whole, with a non-performing ratio of 1.5% and a coverage ratio of 151% as of December 31, 2015. During 2013, 2014 and 2015, we established additional allowances above those required by the Central Bank, with the aim of maintaining the coverage ratio set forth by the Bank’s policies.

 

100


Table of Contents

The table below reflects the asset quality of the Bank and the financial system for 2013, 2014 and 2015:

 

     As of December 31,  
     2013     2014     2015  

Banco Macro

      

Allowances/lending (1)

     2.5     2.6     2.3

Non-performing lending ratio (2)

     1.7     1.9     1.5

Coverage ratio (3)

     149     135     151

Financial System

      

Allowances/lending (1)

     2.0     2.3     2.1

Non-performing lending ratio (2)

     1.5     1.8     1.6

Coverage ratio (3)

     150     142     147

Source: Central Bank

 

(1) Allowances as a percentage of total credit portfolio. Credit portfolio includes loans, other receivables from financial transactions, financial leases, memorandum accounts—other guarantees provided and unused portion of loans granted (included in Debtors Rating Standards).
(2) Non-performing lending includes all lending to borrowers classified as “3—troubled/medium risk,” “4—with high risk of insolvency/high risk,” “5—irrecoverable” and “6—irrecoverable according to Central Bank Rules” under the Central Bank loan classification system.
(3) Allowances for uncollectibility risk as a percentage of non-performing credit portfolio.

Profitability

During the last three years the profitability of the financial system increased by 50% in 2013, 57% in 2014 and 31% in 2015, achieving a total of Ps.60,004 million as of December 31, 2015.

The table below reflects the profitability of the Bank and the financial system for 2013, 2014 and 2015:

 

     As of December 31,  
     2013     2014     2015  

Banco Macro

      

Net income (in millions of Pesos) (1)

     2,443.6        3,479.5        5,008.4   

Return on average equity

     33.3     33.4     37.2

Return on average assets

     4.6     5.1     5.8

Financial System

      

Net income (in millions of Pesos) (1)

     29,169        45,937        60,004   

Return on average equity

     29.5     32.7     32.4

Return on average assets

     3.4     4.1     4.1

Source: Central Bank

 

(1) This indicator excludes results and asset accounts related to permanent interests in domestic financial institutions.

Commercial and balance sheet strategies

We have the most extensive branch network among private-sector banks in Argentina, with 93% of our branches located outside of the City of Buenos Aires. Our extended presence in Argentine regional economies and sectors that have benefited from Argentina’s economic recovery grant us a key advantage with respect to other banks upon competing in the credit expansion service in Argentina. In addition, this strong network of branches and the functions of financial agents from different provinces provide us with a source of growth and low cost in our deposit base.

We will continue with the diversification strategy regarding the credit portfolio, thus enabling to obtain satisfactory efficiency, growth, security and profitability in commercial management. We also intend to stress our assistance to small- and medium-sized enterprises, emphasizing the election of dynamic economic sectors and growth potential in industrial, commercial and service areas for the purpose of contributing to companies’ expansion and ensuring an acceptable return of the funds assigned. At the same time, a complete range of corporate financial services will be offered, including exports and imports financing, letters of credit confirmation and opening, and granting guarantees to third parties on behalf of its customers.

We maintain a strong position with respect to excess capital, the liquidity ratio and the level of our provisions for loan losses. To counteract the effects that a run on deposits may have, one of our main priorities is to give depositors confidence that we would be able to absorb losses and fulfill our obligations to them.

Our practice of maintaining high liquidity levels throughout the business cycles helps us to withstand the economic crisis by serving two key purposes. First, we have funds available in the face of adverse systemic events. Second, we give our depositors confidence that they would be able to have access to their deposits at any time, even during the depth of a crisis. We also minimize excess cash deposited in the Central Bank, without harming our overall liquidity position. In this way, we maximize the return on our liquidity stock by keeping funds in more profitable assets, such as Central Bank-issued Lebacs/Nobacs.

 

101


Table of Contents

E. Off-Balance Sheet Arrangements

We enter into various transactions involving off-balance sheet financial instruments and we use these instruments to meet the risk management, trading and financing needs of customers or for our proprietary trading and asset and liability management purposes.

These instruments are subject to varying degrees of credit and market risk. We monitor credit risk and market risk associated with on- and off-balance sheet financial instruments on an aggregate basis. We use the same credit policies in determining whether to enter or extend option contracts, commitments, conditional obligations and guarantees as we do for granting loans. Our management believes that the outstanding off-balance sheet items do not represent an unusual credit risk.

For additional information of financial instruments with off-balance sheet risk see note 33 ”Financial instruments with off-balance sheet risk” to our audited consolidated financial statements as of and for the three years ended December 31, 2015.

F. Contractual Obligations

The following table represents our contractual obligations and commercial commitments as of December 31, 2015:

 

     Payments due by period  
     Total     

Less than

1 year

     1-3 years      3-5 years     

After

5 years

 
     (in thousands of Pesos)  

Contractual obligations

  

Central Bank

     12,917         12,706         106         105         —     

Banks and international institutions

     98,598         98,598         —           —           —     

Non-Subordinated Corporate Bonds

     1,432,672         49,005         1,383,667         —           —     

Financing received from Argentine financial institutions

     84,384         61,644         22,740         —           —     

Other

     5,024,061         4,926,449         3,736         —           93,876   

Operating leases

     212,268         103,833         82,728         23,327         2,380   

Subordinated corporate bonds

     1,957,618         6,868         —           —           1,950,750   

Total contractual obligations

     8,822,518         5,259,103         1,492,977         23,432         2,047,006   

Commercial commitments

              

Lines of credit

     528,706         528,706         —           —           —     

Guarantees

     301,132         178,163         22,026         105         100,838   

Standby letters of credit

     711,142         711,142         —           —           —     

Total commercial commitments

     1,540,980         1,418,011         22,026         105         100,838   

Item 6. Directors, Senior Management and Employees

A. Directors and Senior Management

We are managed by our board of directors, which as of the date of this annual report is comprised of 13 members and 3 alternate members. On April 16, 2012, our shareholders approved the proposal of the board of directors and amended our bylaws increasing the maximum size of our Board from 12 to 13 members. Currently, the shareholders present at any annual ordinary meeting may determine the size of the board of directors, provided that there shall be no less than three and no more than thirteen directors. Any director so appointed will serve for three fiscal years. If the shareholders elect more than nine board members, each director will be reelected as a staggered board, to be renewed by thirds, provided that in all cases no less than three directors shall be renewed each time. The annual ordinary shareholders’ meeting may also appoint an equal or lesser number of alternate directors, to hold office for the same term than regular directors, to fill any vacancy in the board occurring for any reason whatsoever, and shall further determine the order of substitution. Alternate directors shall hold office until the regular directors in whose place they have acted as substitutes shall resume office, and in case any such absence is permanent, until the next ordinary meeting of shareholders where at directors shall be appointed. Both regular and alternate directors may be re-elected indefinitely.

DUTIES AND LIABILITIES OF DIRECTORS

Under Argentine Corporate Law, directors have the obligation to perform their duties with the loyalty and the diligence of a prudent business person. Directors are jointly and severally liable to a corporation, the shareholders and third parties for the improper performance of their duties, for violating the law, the corporation’s bylaws or regulations, if any, and for any damage caused by fraud, abuse of authority or gross negligence. The following are considered integral to a director’s duty of loyalty: (i) the prohibition on using corporate assets and confidential information for private purposes; (ii) the prohibition on taking advantage, or to allow another to take advantage, by action or omission, of the business opportunities of the Bank; (iii) the obligation to exercise board powers only for the purposes for which the law, the corporation’s bylaws or the shareholders’ or the board of directors’ resolutions have intended; and (iv) the obligation to take strict care so that acts of the board do not go, directly or indirectly, against the Bank’s interests. A director must inform the board of directors and the supervisory committee of any conflicting interest he may have in a proposed transaction and must abstain from voting thereon.

Under Argentine law, the board of directors is in charge of the management and administration of the Bank and, therefore, makes any and all decisions in connection therewith, as well as those decisions expressly provided for in the Argentine Corporate Law, the Bank’s bylaws and other applicable regulations. Furthermore, the board is generally responsible for the execution of the resolutions passed by shareholders meetings and for the performance of any particular task expressly delegated by the shareholders. In general, our board of directors is more involved in operating decision-making than might be customary in other jurisdictions. The board of directors delegates affairs related to management and corporate activities to an executive committee with the assignment of specific duties pursuant to the Bank’s bylaws.

 

102


Table of Contents

BOARD OF DIRECTORS

The following table sets forth certain relevant information of the members of the board of directors as of December 31, 2015:

 

Name

  

Position

   Age    Year First
Appointed
   Year of Expiration
of Term

Jorge Horacio Brito

  

Chairman

   63    2002    2017

Guillermo Eduardo Stanley

  

Vice Chairman

   67    2002    2015

Jorge Pablo Brito

  

Director

   36    2002    2017

Marcos Brito

  

Director

   33    2007    2017

Delfín Federico Ezequiel Carballo

  

Director

   30    2015    2017

Juan Pablo Brito Devoto

  

Director

   55    2002    2016

Luis Carlos Cerolini

  

Director

   61    2002    2016

Carlos Enrique Videla

  

Director

   70    2002    2015

Alejandro Macfarlane

  

Director

   50    2005    2015

Constanza Brito

  

Director

   34    2007    2015

Santiago Brito

  

Alternate director

   28    2012    2017

Santiago Horacio Seeber

  

Alternate director

   38    2012    2017

Ernesto Eduardo Medina

  

Alternate director

   48    2002    2017

Matías Eduardo Carballo

  

Alternate director

   56    2015    2017

On April 26, 2016, the shareholders’ meeting resolved the integral reorganization of the Board of Directors, establishing the Board shall be composed of 13 regular directors and 3 alternate directors. As result, it is composed as follows:

 

Name

  

Position

   Age      Year First
Appointed
     Year of Expiration
of Term
 

Jorge Horacio Brito

   Chairman      63         2002         2017   

Delfin Jorge Ezequiel Carballo (1)

   Vice Chairman      63         2002         2017   

Jorge Pablo Brito

   Director      36         2002         2018   

Carlos Alberto Giovanelli (1)

   Director      59         2016         2018   

Nelson Damian Pozzoli (1)

   Director      49         2016         2018   

José Alfredo Sanchez (1)

   Director      60         2016         2018   

Martĺn Estanislao Gorosito (1)

   Director      32         2016         2018   

Roberto Julio Eilbaum (1)

   Director      71         2016         2017   

Mario Luis Vicens (1)

   Director      64         2016         2017   

Luis Marĺa Blaquier (1)

   Director      50         2016         2017   

Marcos Brito

   Director      33         2007         2016   

Ariel Marcelo Sigal (1)

   Director      51         2016         2016   

Alejandro Eduardo Fargosi (1)

   Director      61         2016         2016   

Delfĺn Federico Ezequiel Carballo

   Alternate director      31         2015         2018   

Constanza Brito

   Alternate director      34         2007         2018   

Eliseo Santi (1)

   Alternate director      27         2016         2018   

 

(1) Pending Central Bank approval.

Since the Central Bank has not yet issued its decision under paragraph 5.2.3 of Section 5, Chapter I of Circular CREFI-2 (Communication “A” 2241, as amended and supplemented) regarding the approval of the appointment of newly elected regular directors, in order to allow the normal operation of the management and the composition of the audit committee with directors acting as independent directors, pursuant to the rules of the CNV (Argentine Securities Exchange Commission) and the New York Stock Exchange, the above mentioned shareholders’ meeting resolved that: (i) the alternate directors already approved by the Central Bank, Ms. Constanza Brito and Mr. Delfĺn Federico Ezequiel Carballo, shall temporarily act as regular directors; and that (ii) the three independent directors whose term of office has already expired, Messrs. Carlos Enrique Videla, Guillermo Stanley and Alejandro Macfarlane, shall continue to hold office as independent directors under the provisions of the second paragraph of section 257 of the Argentine General Companies Act, in both cases for the time it is necessary.

The following family relationships currently exist within our board of directors: (i) Jorge Horacio Brito and Delfĺn Jorge Ezequiel Carballo are brothers-in-law; (ii) Jorge Pablo Brito and Marcos Brito are the sons of Jorge Horacio Brito and the nephews of Delfĺn Jorge Ezequiel Carballo; (iii) Constanza Brito is the daughter of Jorge Horacio Brito and the niece of Delfĺn Jorge Ezequiel Carballo; (iv) Jorge Pablo Brito, Marcos Brito and Constanza Brito are siblings; (v) Delfĺn Federico Ezequiel Carballo is the son of Delfĺn Jorge Ezequiel Carballo and the nephew of Jorge Horacio Brito; (vi) Delfĺn Federico Ezequiel Carballo and Jorge Pablo Brito, Marcos Brito and Constanza Brito are cousins.

The business addresses of Mr. Jorge H. Brito and Mr. Carballo are Sarmiento 735 and Esmeralda 130, 4th Floor, respectively, in each case in Buenos Aires. The business address of each of the other directors is Sarmiento 447, Buenos Aires, Argentina.

Set forth below are brief biographical descriptions of members of our board of directors as of April 26, 2016:

Jorge Horacio Brito, was born on July 23, 1952. He is the chairman of our board of directors our Chief Executive Officer. He has been with our bank since June 1988. He also serves as chairman of the board of directors of Banco del Tucumán S.A. and Inversora Juramento S.A.

Delfĺn Jorge Ezequiel Carballo, was born on November 21, 1952. He was the vice-chairman of our board of directors until April 23, 2015 and was again elected as vice-chairman on April 26, 2016. Mr. Carballo holds a law degree from the Law School of the Catholic University in Argentina. He was with our bank since June 1988. Mr. Carballo also serves as vice-chairman of the board of directors of Banco del Tucumán S.A.

Jorge Pablo Brito, was born on June 29, 1979. He is a member of our board of directors, and has been our Chief Financial Officer since April 16, 2012. He has been a member of the board since June 2002. Mr. Brito also serves as chairman of the board of directors of Macro Securities S.A., Coy Aike S.A. and Genneia S.A., as vice-chairman of the board of directors of Inversora Juramento S.A., as director of Banco del Tucumán S.A., Mercado Abierto Electrónico S.A. and Macro Bank Limited.

Carlos Alberto Giovanelli, was born on April 6, 1957. He is a member of our board of directors since April 26, 2016. He also serves as director of Banco del Tucumán S.A.

Nelson Damián Pozzoli was born on May 6, 1966. He is a member of our board of directors since April 26, 2016. Mr. Pozzoli holds a public accountant degree from the Catholic University in Argentina.

José Alfredo Sanchez was born on January 27, 1956. He is a member of our board of directors since April 26, 2016. Mr. Sanchez holds an actuary degree from the University of Buenos Aires and an M.B.A. on Finance from the University of Chicago. He also serves as director of Macro Securities S.A.

Martin Estanislao Gorosito was born on March 11, 1984. He is a member of our board of directors since April 26, 2016. Mr. Gorosito holds a degree in Political Science from the Catholic University in Argentina.

Roberto Julio Eilbaum was born on December 23, 1944. He is a member of our board of directors since April 26, 2016. Mr. Eilbaum holds a law degree from the Law School of the University of Buenos Aires in Argentina.

Mario Luis Vicens was born on July 14, 1951. He is a member of our board of directors since April 26, 2016. Mr. Vicens holds an economics degree from Catholic University of Argentina and a superior course in monetary and banking finance of the University of Buenos Aires in Argentina

Luis Marĺa Blaquier was born on October 26, 1965. He is a member of our board of directors since April 26, 2016. Mr. Blaquier holds an economics degree from the Catholic University of Argentina and a master’s degree from Amok Tuck Graduate School.

Marcos Brito, was born on October 5, 1982. He is a member of our board of directors. He holds a business administration degree from the University Torcuato Di Tella. He has been a member of our staff since October 2005. Mr. Brito also serves as chairman of the board of directors of Macro Fiducia S.A., Macro Warrants and Comercio Interior S.A., as director of Inversora Juramento S.A. and as alternate director of Banco del Tucumán S.A. and Genneia S.A.

Ariel Marcelo Sigal was born on September 10, 1964. He is a member of our board of directors since April 26, 2016. Mr. Sigal holds an accountant degree from the University of Buenos Aires and master’s degree in finance from the University of CEMA. He also serves as director of Macro Securities S.A.

Alejandro Eduardo Fargosi was born on November 28, 1954. He is a member of our board of directors since April 26, 2016. Mr. Fargosi holds a law degree from the Law School of the University of Buenos Aires in Argentina.

Delfĺn Federico Ezequiel Carballo was born on July 4, 1984. He is an alternate member of our Board of Directors since April 26, 2016. He holds an economics degree from the University Torcuato Di Tella. Mr. Carballo also serves as alternate director of Genneia S.A.

Constanza Brito, was born on October 2, 1981. She is an alternate member of our board of directors. She has been a member of our staff since May 2005. Ms. Brito has a degree in Human resources from the University of Salvador. Ms. Brito also serves as alternate director of Banco del Tucumán S.A.

Eliseo Santi was born on August 11, 1988. He is a member of our board of directors since April 26, 2016. He holds an economics degree from the University of Buenos Aires in Argentina and a master’s degree in applied economy from the University Torcuato Di Tella.

SENIOR MANAGEMENT

Our senior management oversees our day-to-day operations to ensure that our overall strategic objectives are being implemented. Three deputy general managers report to the executive committee; one is in charge of the commercial area, other is in charge of the financial area and the third is in charge of organization, IT and services. Senior managers report to them. In addition, we have the following committees comprised of different directors and senior management: executive committee, internal audit committee, systems committee, senior credit committee, assets and liabilities committee, anti-money laundering committee, senior legal recovery committee, risk management committee, ethics and compliance committee, corporate governance and appointments committee and personnel incentives committee.

 

103


Table of Contents

The following table sets forth certain relevant information of our executive officers and our senior management, as of March 31, 2016:

 

Names

  

Position

   Age    Year First
Appointed

Jorge Horacio Brito

  

Chief Executive Officer

   63    2002

Jorge Pablo Brito

  

Chief Financial Officer

   36    2006

Juan Pablo Brito Devoto

  

Chief Accounting Officer

   56    2002

Ernesto Eduardo Medina

  

Deputy general manager in charge of organization, IT and services

   49    2007

Guillermo Goldberg

  

Deputy general manager in charge of financial area

   59    2007

Gustavo Alejandro Manriquez

  

Deputy general manager in charge of commercial area

   46    2015

Jorge Francisco Scarinci

  

Finance and investor relations manager

   45    2006

Ana María Magdalena Marcet

  

Credit risk manager

   55    2002

Alejandro Becka

  

Corporate credit risk manager

   45    2013

Juan Carlos Benoit

  

Business banking manager

   61    2013

Juan Alberto Piccinini

  

Corporate banking manager

   52    2013

Francisco Muro

  

Distribution and sales manager

   43    2008

Brian Anthony

  

Human resources manager

   42    2005

Antonio Carnuccio

  

Systems manager

   56    2014

Leonardo Gabriel Leonardis

  

Organization and processes manager

   48    2012

Eduardo Roque Covello

  

Operations manager

   59    2004

Gerardo Adrián Alvarez

  

Administration manager

   46    2010

Daniel Hugo Violatti

  

Accountancy and tax manager

   53    2003

Cármen Esther Estévez

  

Internal audit manager

   58    2002

María Milagro Medrano

  

Institutional relations manager

   39    2002

Alberto Figueroa

  

Compliance manager

   55    2009

María José Perez Vanmorlegan

  

Legal manager

   41    2016

Sebastian Palla

  

Government portfolio manager

   41    2010

Agustín Devoto

  

Investment banking manager

   39    2015

Juan Ignacio Perdoménico

  

Integrated risk manager

   42    2015

Set forth below are brief biographical descriptions of members of our executive officers and our senior management as of March 31, 2016:

Jorge Horacio Brito, was born on July 23, 1952. He is the chairman of our board of directors, our Chief Executive Officer and a member of our executive committee and our senior credit committee. He has been with our bank since June 1988. Mr. Brito also serves as chairman of the board of directors of Banco del Tucumán S.A. and Inversora Juramento S.A.

Juan Pablo Brito Devoto was born on March 25, 1960. He was a member of our board of directors and our Chief Accounting Officer until April 26, 2016. Mr. Brito Devoto holds an accounting degree from the school of Economics of the University of Buenos Aires in Argentina. He has been with our bank since June 1988.

Jorge Pablo Brito, was born on June 29, 1979. He is a member of our board of directors, and has been our Chief Financial Officer since April 16, 2012. He is a member of our executive committee, our assets and liabilities committee, our risk management committee and our senior legal recovery committee. He has been a member of the board since June 2002. Mr. Brito also serves as chairman of the board of directors of Macro Securities S.A. and Coy Aike S.A., as vice-chairman of the board of directors of Inversora Juramento S.A., as director of Banco del Tucumán S.A., Mercado Abierto Electrónico S.A. and Macro Bank Limited.

Ernesto Eduardo Medina, was born on January 9, 1967. He is a deputy general manager in charge of our organization, the IT and services area and a member of our systems committee and our risk management committee. He has been a member of our staff since February 1989. Mr. Medina holds a public accountant and business administration degree from the School of Economics of the University of Buenos Aires in Argentina. In addition, Mr. Medina holds a degree in systems analysis from the University of Buenos Aires, as well as a psychology degree from the Business and Social Sciences University, in Argentina. Mr. Medina also serves as director of Provincanje S.A. and as alternate director of Banco del Tucumán S.A.

Guillermo Goldberg, was born on January 31, 1957. He is our deputy general manager in charge of our financial area. He is a member of our systems committee, our senior credit committee, our asset and liabilities committee and our risk management committee. Mr. Goldberg holds an economics degree from the School of Economics of the University of Buenos Aires in Argentina. Mr. Goldberg has been with us since July 2005.

Gustavo Alejandro Manriquez was born on August 23, 1969. He is our deputy general manager in charge of our commercial area and a member of our assets and liabilities committee, our senior credit committee, our systems committee and our risk management committee. He holds a degree in business administration from the University of Belgrano in Argentina. Mr. Manriquez holds a master’s degree in finance from the University of CEMA and has taken the Management Development Program in IAE, in Argentina. He has been with us since February 2015.

 

104


Table of Contents

Jorge Francisco Scarinci, was born on May 19, 1970. He is our finance and investor relations manager. He is a member of our assets and liabilities committee. Mr. Scarinci holds an economic degree from the School of Economics of the University of Belgrano and a master’s degree in finance from the University of CEMA, in Argentina and became CFA in 2001. Mr. Scarinci has been with us since May 2006.

Ana María Magdalena Marcet, was born on February 24, 1961. She is our credit risk manager and a member of our senior credit committee and our senior legal recovery committee. Ms. Marcet holds a public accountant, economics and business administration degree from the School of Economics of the University of Buenos Aires and a master’s degree in banking management from the University of CEMA, in Argentina. She has been a member of our staff since December 1996.

Alejandro Becka, was born on April 23, 1970. He is our corporate credit risk manager and a member of our senior credit committee. He holds a public accountant degree from the School of Economics of the University of Buenos Aires and a master’s degree in financial administration from the University Torcuato Di Tella, in Argentina. He has been with us since September 1994.

Juan Carlos Benoit, was born on January 13, 1955. He is our business banking manager and a member of our senior credit committee and our assets and liabilities committee. He holds an engineering degree in agricultural production from Catholic University of Argentina, a post-graduate degree in marketing from the Universidad Argentina de la Empresa (UADE) and has taken the Management Development Program in IAE in Argentina. He has been with us since April 2007.

Juan Alberto Piccinini, was born on September 28, 1963. He is our corporate banking manager and a member of our senior credit committee. He holds a master’s degree in business administration from the University of Palermo in Argentina. He has been with us since February 2012.

Francisco Muro, was born on March 2, 1973. He is our distribution and sales manager. Mr. Muro holds an accounting degree from the School of Economics of the University of Buenos Aires and an MBA from the IAE (Universidad Austral), in Argentina. Mr. Muro has been with us since August 2004.

Brian Anthony, was born on April 17, 1973. He is our human resources manager. He is a member of our ethics and compliance committee, our corporate governance and appointments committee and our personnel incentives committee. Mr. Anthony holds a business administration degree from the CAECE University in Argentina. Mr. Anthony has been with us since September 2005.

Antonio Carnuccio, was born on February 13, 1960. He is our systems manager and a member of our systems committee. He holds a banking organization degree from the Catholic University of Argentina. He has been with us since January 2011.

Leonardo Gabriel Leonardis, was born on May 12, 1967. He is our organization and processes management. He has been with us since July 1987.

Eduardo Roque Covello, was born on February 20, 1957. He is our operations manager. Mr. Covello holds a business administration degree from the Argentine Business School. He has been a member of our staff since January 1996.

Gerardo Adrián Alvarez, was born on December 13, 1969. He is our administration manager and a member of our anti-money laundering committee. Mr. Alvarez holds a law degree from the University of Argentine Federal Police and a post-graduate degree in Anti -Money Laundering from University Torcuato Di Tella in Argentina. He has been with us since January 2006.

Daniel Hugo Violatti, was born on May 27, 1962. He is our accountancy and tax manager. Mr. Violatti holds an accounting degree from the School of Economics of the University of Buenos Aires in Argentina. He has been a member of our staff since December 1997.

Cármen Esther Estévez, was born on April 28, 1957. She is our internal audit manager and a member of our internal audit committee and our systems committee. Ms. Estévez holds an accounting degree and a master’s degree in system from the School of Economics of the University of Buenos Aires in Argentina. She has been a member of our staff since October 1997.

María Milagro Medrano, was born on October 27, 1976. She is our institutional relations manager. She is an alternate director of Banco del Tucumán S.A. Ms. Medrano holds a business administration degree from the Catholic University of Salta in Argentina. She has been a member of our staff since April 1997.

Alberto Figueroa, was born on September 1, 1960. He is our compliance manager. He is a member of our systems committee, our risk management committee, our ethics and compliance committee and our anti-money laundering committee. He holds a public accounting degree from the School of Economics of the University of Buenos Aires in Argentina. He has been with us since March 2007.

María José Perez Vanmorlegan was born on August 31, 1974. She is our legal manager and a member of our senior legal recovery committee. Mrs. Perez Vanmorlegan holds a law degree from the Law School of the Argentine Catholic University. She has been a member of our staff since July 2012.

Sebastian Palla, was born on June 12, 1974. He is our government portfolio manager and a member of our senior credit committee. He holds a economics degree from University Torcuato Di Tella in Argentina. He has been with us since February 2009.

Agustín Devoto was born on April 11, 1976. He is our investment banking manager and a member of our senior credit committee. He holds a business administration degree from the Catholic University of Argentina and a master’s degree in Finance from the University Torcuato Di Tella in Argentina. He has been with us since December 2000. Mr. Devoto also serves as chairman of the board of directors of Macro Fondos S.G.F.C.I. S.A., as vice-chairman of the board of directors of Macro Securities S.A. and as director of Macro Bank Limited.

 

105


Table of Contents

Juan Ignacio Perdoménico was born on April 9, 1973. He is our integrated risk manager and a member of our risk management committee. Mr. Perdoménico holds a public accountant and economic degree from the School of Economics of the University of Buenos Aires and a master’s in finance from the University of CEMA, in Argentina. He has been with us since September 2005.

B. Compensation

Argentine law provides that the compensation paid to all directors and syndics (including those directors who are also members of senior management) in a fiscal year may not exceed 5.0% of net income for such year, if the Bank is not paying dividends in respect of such net income. Argentine law increases the annual limitation on director compensation to up to 25.0% of net income based on the amount of such dividends, if any are paid. In the case of directors that perform duties at special commissions or perform administrative or technical tasks, the aforesaid limits may be exceeded if a shareholders’ meeting so approves and such issue is included in the agenda and is in accordance with the regulations of the CNV. In any case, the compensation of all directors and members of the supervisory committee requires shareholders’ approval at an ordinary meeting.

The aggregate amount of compensation paid by Banco Macro and its subsidiaries to all of their directors, alternate directors and members of supervisory committee for fiscal year 2015 was Ps.233.0 million. The aggregate amount of compensation paid by Banco Macro to its senior management during 2015 was Ps.51.2 million, including salaries and bonuses. This amount also includes compensation accrued during 2014 and paid in 2015.

Neither we nor any of our subsidiaries have entered into any agreement that provides for any benefit or compensation to any director after the expiration of his term or upon his retirement.

C. Board Practices

Corporate Governance

As a listed company on the NYSE, we are required under the rules governing listed companies to (i) comply with SEC’s requirements concerning an audit committee, (ii) submit an annual written affirmation to the NYSE and interim written affirmations, if applicable, (iii) disclose any significant ways in which our corporate governance practices differ from those followed by domestic companies under the NYSE listing standards, and (iv) our CEO must promptly notify the NYSE in writing after any executive officer becomes aware of any non-compliance with any of the applicable NYSE corporate governance rules. We incorporate the information regarding the significant ways in which our corporate governance practices differ from those followed by domestic companies under the NYSE listing standards by reference to our website www.macro.com.ar. For further information see item 16.G.

Independence of the Members of the Board of Directors and the Supervisory Committee

The members of the board of directors and the supervisory committee of a public company in Argentina must inform the CNV within ten days from the date of their appointment whether such members of the board of directors or the supervisory committee are “independent” pursuant to CNV standards.

CNV standards provide that a director will not be considered independent in certain specified situations, including where a director (i) owns a 15% equity interest in a company, or a lesser interest if such director has the right to appoint one or more directors of a company (hereinafter “significant participation”) or has a significant participation in a corporation having a significant participation in the company or a significant influence in the company; (ii) depends on shareholders, or is otherwise related to shareholders, having a significant participation in the company or of other corporations in which these shareholders have directly or indirectly a significant participation or significant influence; (iii) is or has been in the previous three years an employee of the company; (iv) has a professional relationship or is a member of a corporation that maintains professional relationships with, or receives remuneration (other than the one received in consideration of his performance as a director) from, a company or its shareholders having a direct or indirect significant participation or significant influence on the same, or with corporations in which the shareholders also have a direct or indirect significant participation or a significance influence; (v) directly or indirectly sells or provides goods or services to the company or to the shareholders of the same who have a direct or indirect significant participation or significant influence, for higher amounts than his remuneration as a member of the administrative body; or (vi) is the spouse, legally acknowledged partner or parent (up to second grade of affinity or consanguinity) of persons who, if they were members of the administrative body, would not be independent, according to the above listed rules.

As of December 31, 2015, Carlos Enrique Videla, Alejandro Macfarlane and Guillermo Eduardo Stanley qualified as independent members of the board of directors under these criteria specified by the CNV.

The newly directors elected by the annual shareholders meeting on April 26, 2016 are pending BCRA approval. As a result, the shareholders meeting resolved that until such approved is received: (i) the two alternate directors previously approved by the Central Bank, Ms. Constanza Brito and Mr. Delfĺn Federico Ezequiel Carballo, shall temporarily serve as directors; and (ii) the three independent directors whose term of office has expired, Mr. Carlos Enrique Videla, Mr. Guillermo Stanley and Mr. Alejandro Macfarlane, shall continue to serve as independent directors, in each case for so long as required.

Pursuant to the Capital Markets Law, all of the members of the supervisory committee of companies admitted to the public offering regime shall have independent status.

Additionally, the Buenos Aires Professional Council of Economic Sciences (Consejo Profesional de Ciencias Económicas de la Ciudad de Buenos Aires or “CPCECABA”) also established certain requirements regarding the independence of public accountants which act as members of the supervisory committee. Pursuant to regulations issued by the CPCECABA and the CNV, syndics must be independent from the company they are auditing. A syndic will not be independent if: (i) it is the owner, partner, director, administrator, manager or employee of the company or economically related entities; (ii) it is the spouse or relative (collateral until fourth grade), or relatives by affinity until second grade, of one of the owners, partners, directors, administrators or managers; (iii) it is a shareholder, debtor, creditor or

 

106


Table of Contents

guarantor of the company or economically related entities, representing a significant amount if compared with its own wealth or the company’s net equity; (iv) it posses a significant amount of interest in the company or economically related entities (or if it has had such interest during the period to be audited); (v) if the remuneration depends on or is contingent with the conclusions or results of its auditing work; (vi) if the remuneration agreed depends on the result of the operations of the company.

As of December 31, 2015, Alejandro Almarza, Carlos Javier Piazza, Vivian Haydee Stenghele, Alejandro Carlos Piazza, Leonardo Pablo Cortigiani and Javier Rodrigo Siñeriz qualified as independent members of our supervisory committee under these criteria. Mr. Enrique Alfredo Fila and Ms. Silvana Marĺa Gentile that were elected on April 26, 2016 as syndic and as alternate syndic respectively, also qualified as independent members of our supervisory committee under these criteria.

For information on the expiration of current terms of directors see Item 6.A “Directors and Senior Management”.

For information on service contracts with directors providing benefits upon termination of employment see Item 6.B “Compensation”.

Supervisory Committee

Our bylaws provide for a supervisory committee, which consists of three syndics and three alternate syndics that serve for a term of one fiscal year. Pursuant to the Argentine Corporate Law, only lawyers and accountants admitted to practice in Argentina or civil partnerships composed of such persons may serve as syndics of an Argentine sociedad anónima, or limited liability corporation.

The primary responsibilities of the supervisory committee are to monitor the management’s compliance with Argentine Corporate Law, the bylaws, its regulations, if any, and the shareholders’ resolutions, and to perform other functions, including, but not limited to: (i) attending meetings of the board of directors, management committee and shareholders, (ii) calling extraordinary shareholders’ meetings when deemed necessary and ordinary and special shareholders’ meetings when not called by the board of directors and (iii) investigating written complaints of shareholders. In performing these functions, the supervisory committee does not control our operations or assess the merits of the decisions made by the directors.

The supervisory committee has unlimited access to our books and registers and a right to request as much information as necessary for the performance of its duties.

The following table sets forth certain relevant information of the members of our supervisory committee as of December 31, 2015:

 

Name

  

Position

   Age    Year of
Appointment
   Current
Term Ends
 

Alejandro Almarza

   Syndic    57    2015      April 2016   

Carlos Javier Piazza

   Syndic    57    2015      April 2016   

Vivian Haydee Stenghele (1)

   Syndic    46    2015      April 2016   

Alejandro Carlos Piazza

   Alternate syndic    61    2015      April 2016   

Leonardo Pablo Cortigiani

   Alternate syndic    47    2015      April 2016   

Javier Rodrigo Siñeriz (1)

   Alternate syndic    45    2015      April 2016   

 

(1) Elected by ANSES (as manager of the Fondo de Garantía de Sustentabilidad), through the exercise of its cumulative voting rights. See Item 10.B “Additional Information - Memorandum and Articles of Association - Quorum and voting requirements” for a description of cumulative voting.

At the shareholder’s meeting held on April 26, 2016, Mr. Alejandro Almarza, Mr. Carlos Javier Piazza and Mr. Enrique Alfredo Fila were named syndics and Mr. Alejandro Carlos Piazza, Mr. Leonardo Pablo Cortigiani and Ms. Silvana Marĺa Gentile were named alternate syndics, in each case for one term.

The businness address of the members of the Supervisory Committee is Sarmiento 447, Buenos Aires, Argentina. Set forth below are brief biographical descriptions of the members of our supervisory committee as of December 31, 2015:

Alejandro Almarza is a syndic on our supervisory committee. Mr. Almarza holds an accounting degree from the University of Buenos Aires in Argentina. Mr. Almarza also serves as syndic of Macro Securities S.A., Macro Fiducia S.A., Banco del Tucumán S.A., Macro Warrants S.A., and Seguro de Depósitos S.A. Mr. Almarza was admitted to the Accountants Professional Association of the City of Buenos Aires in 1983.

Carlos Javier Piazza is a syndic on our supervisory committee. Mr. Piazza holds an accounting degree from the University of Buenos Aires in Argentina. Mr. Piazza also serves as syndic of Macro Warrants S.A. and served as alternate syndic of Macro Securities S.A., Macro Fiducia S.A. and Banco del Tucumán S.A. Mr. Piazza was admitted to the Accountants Professional Association of the City of Buenos Aires in 1983.

 

107


Table of Contents

Vivian Haydee Stenghele is a syndic on our supervisory committee. Ms. Stenghele holds an accounting degree from the University of Buenos Aires in Argentina.

Alejandro Carlos Piazza is an alternate syndic on our supervisory committee. Mr. Piazza holds accounting and business administration degree from the School of Economics of the University of Buenos Aires in Argentina. Mr. Piazza also serves as syndic of Macro Warrants S.A., Macro Fondos Sociedad Gerente de Fondos Comunes de Inversion S.A., CRIBA S.A. and Ingemática S.A. and as alternate syndic of Macro Securities S.A. and Macro Fiducia S.A. Mr. Piazza was admitted to the Accountants Professional Association of the City of Buenos Aires in 1978.

Leonardo Pablo Cortigiani is an alternate syndic on our supervisory committee. Mr. Cortigiani holds an accounting degree from the University of Buenos Aires in Argentina. Mr. Cortigiani also serves as syndic of Macro Fiducia S.A., Macro Fondos Sociedad Gerente de Fondos Comunes de Inversion S.A., Macro Securities S.A. and serves as alternate syndic of Macro Warrants S.A. Mr. Cortigiani was admitted to the Accountants Professional Association of the City of Buenos Aires in 1995.

Javier Rodrigo Siñeriz is an alternate syndic on our supervisory committee. Mr. Siñeriz holds a law degree from the Law School of the Catholic University of Argentina. Mr. Siñeriz also holds a master’s degree in law and juricature from the Austral University, a master’s degree in Govermental law from the School of Lawyers of the government and a specialization in fiscal law from the Litoral National University. He is also a certified financial advisor from the Spaniard Institute of Financial Advisors (Instituto Español de Asesores Financieros).

Audit Committee

As of December 31, 2015, our audit committee is comprised of three directors, Carlos Enrique Videla, Alejandro Macfarlane and Guillermo Eduardo Stanley, all of which have independent status pursuant to applicable SEC, NYSE and CNV rules. The audit committee is responsible for the fulfillment of the duties within its powers, as set forth under the Capital Markets Law, including, among others: (i) delivering an opinion regarding the board of director’s proposal of appointment of our external auditors and controlling their independent status, (ii) supervising the correct performance of our internal control and accounting systems, (iii) supervising the observance of the policies regarding information about our risk management and (iv) delivering an opinion regarding transactions with related parties or transactions that may threaten any conflicts of interest.

As of the date of this report, the Central Bank has not approved the newly appointed directors elected by the shareholders meeting on April 26, 2016, pursuant to Communication “A” 2231, which grants the Central Bank such approval powers. Pending the Central Bank’s approval, the shareholders meeting resolved that: (1) the two alternate directors previously approved by the Central Bank, Ms. Constanza Brito and Mr. Delfín Federico Ezequiel Carballo, shall temporarily serve as directors; and (ii) the three independent directors whose term of office has expired, Mr. Carlos Enrique Videla, Mr. Gullermo Stanley and Mr. Alejandro Macfarlane, shall continue to serve as independent directors, in each case for so long as required.

Committees Reporting to the Board of Directors and to the CEO and the CFO

The following committees are under the supervision of our board of directors:

Executive committee. The executive committee is established in the bylaws, and comprised by at least two directors.

The executive committee is responsible for the management of the business and common affairs of the Bank and its powers include to: (i) manage the business and common affairs of the Bank and all other matters delegated by the board of directors; (ii) develop the commercial, credit and financial policy of the Bank subject to the goals approved by the board of directors; (iii) establish, maintain, eliminate, restructure or move the offices and areas of the administrative and operating organization of the Bank; (iv) establish special committees and approve various operating structures and determine the scope of their functions and duties; (v) approve personnel, including to appoint the General Manager, Assistant Managers, Executive Vice Presidents and other Department Heads and Managers, and to set the amount of their remunerations, working terms and conditions and any other personnel policy measure, including promotions; (vi) propose the establishment, opening, moving or closing of branches, agencies or representatives in the country or abroad; and (vii) supervise the management of subsidiary companies and of the other companies in which the Bank holds a participating interest and to propose to the board of directors the incorporation, acquisition or total or partial sale of participating interests in companies in financial services.

Internal audit committee. The internal audit committee is comprised of at least two directors, and the internal audit manager of the Bank. The term of each member is for a minimum period of two years (provided their directorship does not expire beforehand) and a maximum of three years.

The internal audit committee is responsible for supervising the correct functioning of our internal control systems and procedures. Furthermore, this committee reviews our annual and quarterly financial statements, the external auditor’s reports, the syndic’s reports, the relevant financial information and the audit committee’s reports.

 

108


Table of Contents

Systems committee. The systems committee must be composed of, at least, one director or equivalent authority and the manager of the informatics technology and systems area.

The systems committee is responsible for the issuance of the systems and operations management policies. Furthermore, this committee verifies that the several management plans are in accordance with our business strategy and oversees the implementation of our strategic projects.

The main functions of the systems committee are to: i) oversee the proper functioning of Information Technology and Systems, ii) contribute to the improvement of the information technology and systems environment effectiveness; iii) note Systems Plan; iv) periodically evaluate the Systems Plan and review its compliance; v) review the reports issued by environmentally related audits of Information Technology and Systems and oversee the implementation of corrective actions designed to stabilize or minimize any weaknesses observed; and vi) maintain timely communication with officials of the External Audit Management Systems Division of the Superintendence in relation with any problems identified in inspections and monitor actions undertaken to solve such problems.

Senior credit committee. The senior credit committee is comprised of two directors of the Executive Committee, the deputy general manager in charge of the commercial area, the deputy general manager in charge of financial area, the credit risk manager, the corporate credit risk manager, corporate banking manager and the banking manager.

The senior credit committee is responsible for the issuance of our credit policy and credit analysis guidelines. Furthermore, this committee reviews and approves credit transactions in excess of Ps.35,000,000 and examines periodic reports related to our loan portfolio.

Assets and liabilities committee. The assets and liabilities committee is responsible for the financial strategy of the Bank. In addition, it carries on deep market analysis and establishes strategic policies related to the Bank’s liquidity, market, interest rate and currency risks.

Anti-money laundering committee. The committee is comprised by the designated head (board member), three directors and a top level officer with expertise in financial intermediation operations.

The anti-money laundering committee is responsible for planning, coordinating and monitoring compliance with anti-money laundering policies approved by the board of directors and its powers include to: (i) define policies for compliance with anti-money laundering corporate guidelines, (ii) be a permanent forum for the discussion of money laundering and terrorist financing risks that affect the Bank, (iii) promote the definition of strategies controls to prevent money laundering and terrorist financing and implement such controls, (iv) be responsible for the continued update of the manual of procedures for the prevention of money laundering and terrorist financing, in accordance with regulatory changes and new Bank needs, (v) monitor the implementation of a program designed to provide training and raise awareness regarding the prevention and control of money laundering and terrorist financing, (vi) establish appropriate mechanisms for internal reporting of unusual / suspicious activities, (vii) analyze any unusual or suspicious transactions to be reported to the relevant governmental agencies in compliance with applicable regulations, and subsequently inform to the board of directors, (viii) provide support to the head of the anti-money laundering committee in the examination of unusual or suspicious transactions, (ix) approve and follow-up on the work program submitted by the anti-money laundering committee for the relevant fiscal year, for which it will report to the board of directors and (x) perform any other duties that may be imposed under applicable laws and regulations.

Senior legal recovery committee. The senior legal recovery committee manages outstanding loans on behalf of the board of directors, which nevertheless retains its power in that regard. The committee’s functions and powers are to: i) define and approve the general debt reduction and refinancing policy; ii) decide on repayment or refinancing proposals in amounts exceeding Ps.5.0 million; iii) analyze and decide on proposals for the termination of account management and the filing of court proceedings for unpaid principal amounts and higher than Ps.2.0 million; iv) discuss and decide on recovery policies or portfolio sales proposed by the Junior Recovery Committee and v) decide on the value of assets to be auctioned where the outstanding debt exceeds Ps.5.0 million.

Risk management committee: The risk management committee is comprised of five directors, two of whom are independent, the deputy general managers, the integral risk manager, the compliance manager and the head of each of the control of credit risk, financial risk and operational risk. The composition of the committee is approved by the Board of Directors.

The committee is responsible for monitoring senior management activities involving the management of credit, market, liquidity, operational, compliance and reputational risks, among others. The committee’s mission is to supervise that the controls and procedures in place are adequate to mitigate any risk, and to recommend and implement updates to risk management policies and procedures. In addition, this committee gives advice to the board of directors regarding the Bank’s overall risk. Furthermore, this committee is responsible for notifying the board of directors and senior management about any failure to comply with applicable limits to risk exposure, suggesting remedies, such as assuming the risk or mitigating the risk.

Ethics and compliance committee: The ethics and compliance committee is comprised of two independent directors, a non-independent director, the compliance manager and the human resources manager.

This committee is responsible for implementing ethic guidelines set forth by the board of directors and supervising compliance. In addition, this committee promotes the implementation of the Bank’s social responsibility policies and fosters the adoption of such policies by setting forth tools and procedures that will enable management to incorporate social responsibility policies and consequently spread those policies within the Bank.

 

109


Table of Contents

Corporate governance and appointments committee: The committee is comprised of three directors, two of whom are independent, and the human resources manager.

This committee is responsible for processes related to the renewal, substitution and succession of members of our senior management. This committee is also responsible for the implementing our corporate governance Code at the Bank and its subsidiaries.

Personnel incentives committee: The personnel incentives committee is comprised of three directors, two of whom are independent, and the human resources manager.

The committee’s main functions are to control that incentives plans to all personnel -excluding directors- are consistent with the business culture, goals, long term business plan, business strategy, the control environment of the Bank and prudent risk taking.

D. Employees

As of December 31, 2015, we had 8,727 employees, 39% of whom worked at our headquarters and the remaining 61% at our branches. Our employees are represented by a national bank union, which negotiates a collective bargaining agreement setting minimum wages for all of its members. We maintain good relations with our employees and have never experienced a work stoppage.

 

     As of December 31,  
Employees    2013      2014      2015  

Headquarters

     3,341         3,453         3,429   

Branches

     5,272         5,240         5,298   

Total (1)

     8,613         8,693         8,727   

 

(1) Were workers performing their duties pursuant to the “Acciones de entrenamiento para el trabajo” program of the Ministry of Labor, Employment and Social Security and other casual workers included, the number of employees of the Bank would have been 8,708, 8,728 and 8,765 for 2013, 2014 and 2015, respectively. We do not account for such workers as employees, as the Bank does not remunerate them for their services, which are paid directly by the Argentine province where they work.

E. Share Ownership

As of March 31, 2016, the persons who were members of our board of directors and our supervisory committee held as a group a total of 124,272,043 shares of our capital stock. This represented approximately 21% of our outstanding capital stock and 23% of the voting rights as of such date. Other than Jorge Horacio Brito, Juan Pablo Brito Devoto, Delfín Federico E. Carballo, Matías E. Carballo and Jorge Pablo Brito, no member of our board of directors or our supervisory committee directly or beneficially owned shares of the Bank as of March 31, 2016. In addition, Alberto Figueroa and Alejandro Becka, members of our senior management, each beneficially owned less than one percent of Class B shares as of March 31, 2016.

The following table sets forth the beneficial ownership of our shares by the members of our board of directors and our supervisory committee, as of March 31, 2016:

 

Shareholder Name (1)   

Number of Class A

shares owned

    

Number of Class B

shares owned

   

Percentage of

Capital stock (%)

   

Percentage of

Voting rights(%)

 

Jorge Horacio Brito

     5,366,463         109,285,244        19.61     21.62

Juan Pablo Brito Devoto

     289,453         3,868,154 (2)      0.71     0.84

Other members

     0         5,462,729        0.93     0.87

Total

     5,655,916         118,616,127        21.25     23.33

 

(1) This table does not reflect the shareholding of Delfín Jorge Ezequiel Carballo¸ appointed to the board as of April 26, 2016, whom as of that date owned 4,895,416 Class A Shares and 106,805,523 Class B Shares for an aggregate shareholding of 19.11% representing 20.85% of voting rights.
(2) Includes capital stock held in the form of ADSs issued by the Bank of New York.

Item 7. Major Shareholders and Related Party Transactions

A. Major Shareholders

As of December 31, 2015, we had 584,563,028 outstanding shares of common stock, consisting of 11,235,670 Class A shares and 573,327,358 Class B shares. Each share of our common stock represents the same economic interests, except that holders of our Class A shares are entitled to five votes per share and holders of our Class B shares are entitled to one vote per share. Other than aforementioned differences among holders of Class A shares and holders of Class B shares, the holders of these shares listed in the table below do not have different voting rights.

The following table sets forth information regarding the ownership of our Class A and Class B shares as of December 31, 2015:

 

Shareholder Name   

Number of

Class A shares

owned

    

Number of

Class B shares
owned

    Total     

Percentage of

capital stock (%)

   

Percentage of

Voting rights (%)

 

ANSES (as manager of the Fondo de Garantía de Sustentabilidad)

     0         184,120,650        184,120,650         31.50     29.25

Jorge Horacio Brito

     5,366,463         109,285,244        114,651,707         19.61     21.62

Delfín Jorge Ezequiel Carballo

     4,895,416         106,805,523 (1)      111,700,939         19.11     20.85

Juan Pablo Brito Devoto

     289,453         3,869,068 (1)      4,158,521         0.71     0.84

Other Shareholders (2)

     684,338         169,246,873        169,931,211         29.07     27.44

Total

     11,235,670         573,327,358        584,563,028         100.00     100.00

 

(1) Includes capital stock held in the form of ADSs issued by the Bank of New York.
(2) Includes the Bank of New York as depositary of our ADSs.

 

110


Table of Contents

As of March 31, 2016, we had 584,563,028 outstanding shares of common stock, consisting of 11,235,670 Class A shares and 573,327,358 Class B shares. Each share of our common stock represents the same economic interests, except that holders of our Class A shares are entitled to five votes per share and holders of our Class B shares are entitled to one vote per share. Other than aforementioned differences among holders of Class A shares and holders of Class B shares, the holders of these shares listed in the table below do not have different voting rights.

The following table sets forth information regarding the ownership of our Class A and Class B shares as of March 31, 2016:

 

Shareholder Name   

Number of

Class A shares

owned

    

Number of

Class B shares

owned

    Total     

Percentage of

capital stock (%)

   

Percentage of

Voting rights (%)

 

ANSES (as manager of the Fondo de Garantía de Sustentabilidad)

     0         184,120,650        184,120,650         31.50     29.25

Jorge Horacio Brito

     5,366,463         109,285,244        114,651,707         19.61     21.62

Delfín Ezequiel Carballo

     4,895,416         106,805,523 (1)      111,700,939         19.11     20.85

Other Shareholders (2)

     973,791         173,115,941        174,089,732         29.78     28.27

Total

     11,235,670         573,327,358        584,563,028         100.00     100.00

 

(1) Includes capital stock held in the form of ADSs issued by the Bank of New York
(2) Includes the Bank of New York as depositary of our ADSs.

The table below represents the evolution of our capital stock and the material changes in equity participation of the major shareholders, in both cases, during the past three years:

 

Date    Capital Stock (Shares)      Event    Major Shareholders

December 31, 2013

     594,485,168         

Jorge H. Brito 19.87%

Delfín Jorge Ezequiel Carballo 18.79%

ANSES (as manager of the Fondo de Garantía de Sustentabilidad) 30.97%

Juan Pablo Brito Devoto 0.88%

December 31, 2014

     584,563,028      

Increase by 77,860(1)

Decrease by 10,000,000(2)

  

Jorge H. Brito 19.76%

Delfín Jorge Ezequiel Carballo 19.11%

ANSES (as manager of the Fondo de Garantía de Sustentabilidad) 31.50%

Juan Pablo Brito Devoto 0.88%.

December 31, 2015

     584,563,028         

Jorge H. Brito 19.61%

Delfín Jorge Ezequiel Carballo 19.11%

ANSES (as manager of the Fondo de Garantía de Sustentabilidad) 31.50%

Juan Pablo Brito Devoto 0.71%.

 

(1) Related to the capital increase in the amount of 77,860 Class B shares issued and delivered to the minority shareholders of former Banco Privado de Inversiones S.A., in connection with its merger into Banco Macro.
(2) Related to decrease in capital stock resulting from the cancellation of 10,000,000 Class B shares as a consequence of the three-year term from its original acquisition (September through December 2011). These shares have not been sold and the shareholders´ meeting has issued no resolution as to the application thereof.

B. Related Party Transactions

We are not party to any transactions with, and have not made any loans to, any of our directors, key management personnel or other related parties, nor are there any proposed transactions with such persons, except for those permitted by applicable law. Some of our directors have been involved in certain credit transactions with us. The Argentine Corporate Law and Central Bank Rules allow directors of a corporation to enter into a transaction with such corporation if the transaction is in line with prevailing market practice.

“Related parties” under local regulations, refers to our directors, our key officers, our syndics, our shareholders that hold a significant participation as well as individuals related to them and any entities directly or indirectly affiliated with any of these parties that are not required to be consolidated.

For the years ended December 31, 2013, 2014 and 2015 an aggregate of Ps.210.6 million, Ps.300.4 million and Ps. 602.8 million, respectively, in financial assistance granted by us (including loans, leases and guarantees granted) was outstanding to related parties. The largest outstanding amount granted by us (including loans, leases and guarantees granted) to related parties during 2015 was a total amount of Ps. 252.9 million to Solnik S.A. mainly composed of Ps.154.2 million in import letters of credit (unutilized credit), Ps.61.3 million of documents (with 26.4% average rate), Ps.32 million of other advances in dollars (with a 10.2% average rate) and Ps.5.3 million of other loans (with a 15.2% average rate).

 

111


Table of Contents

All financial assistance to related parties (a) were made in the ordinary course of business; (b) were made on substantially the same terms, including interest rates and collateral, as those prevailing at the time for comparable transactions with other persons, and (c) did not involve more than the normal risk of collectability or present other unfavorable features.

Likewise, as of December 31, 2013, 2014 and 2015, the total amount of deposits made by related parties to the Bank amounted to Ps.591.1 million, Ps.909.9 million and Ps.1,272.2 million, respectively. In addition, as of December 31, 2015 we held deposits for an aggregate amount of Ps. 2,106 million made by ANSES (as manager of the Fondo de Garantía de Sustentabilidad or Sustainability Guarantee Fund), which we consider “related party” as from April 2011 in accordance with FASB 850 and for purposes of this item (although it is not considered a “related party” under local rules). As of December 31, 2015 ANSES (as manager of the Fondo de Garantía de Sustentabilidad or Sustainability Guarantee Fund) held 31.50% of the Bank’s capital stock and 29.25% of the Bank’s votes, following the issuance of Emergency Decree No. 441 in April 2011.

For further information regarding related party transactions see note 9 “Transactions with related parties” to our audited consolidated financial statements as of and for the three years ended December 31, 2015.

C. Interest of experts and counsel

Not applicable.

Item 8. Financial Information

A. Consolidated Statements and Other Financial Information

See Item 18 and our audited consolidated financial statements as of and for the three years ended December 31, 2015 included in this annual report.

Legal Proceedings

We are involved in normal collection proceedings and other legal proceedings in the ordinary course of business. We are not involved in any litigation or other legal proceedings that, if adversely determined, would individually or in the aggregate have a material adverse effect on our operations.

For further information regarding legal proceedings, see note 17 “Tax and other claims” to our audited consolidated financial statements as of and for the three years ended December 31, 2015. In connection with such claims, the Bank´s management and its tax and legal advisors believe there are no additional significant effects to those already recognized in the books that may result from the final outcome of such claims.

As required by the BCRA Communication “A” 5689, we detail in note 20 “Summary Judgements and sanctions applied by certain regulators against Banco Macro S.A. and Banco del Tucumán S.A.” to our audited consolidated financial statements as of and for the three years ended December 31, 2015 the summaries initiated and sanctions imposed by the BCRA to the Bank or their authorities, also we mention the sanctions imposed by the UIF and pending summaries at CNV and UIF. In January 2015, pursuant to such regulations, the Bank accounted provisions for administrative and/or disciplinary sanctions, which were applied or initiated by the Central Bank, UIF and CNV. Such provisions totaled Ps.11.7 million as of December 31, 2015. In April 2016, the Central Bank issued Communication “A” 5940, which amended Communication “A” 5689 provisions. Pursuant to such Communication, the financial entities that, to the date thereof, have an amount for these items registered in the account “Provisions – For administrative, disciplinary and criminal penalties”, must analyze, according to the applicable legal reports, if each such penalty meets the conditions for its total or partial accountable registration, according to the provisions in the “Accounts Plan and Manual” (which set forth that penalties must be probable and that their amount can be reasonably estimated).

Dividend Policy

Although we do not have, and have no current plans to adopt, a formal dividend policy governing the amount and payment of dividends, we currently intend to pay dividends subject to approval by a majority vote of our shareholders. All shares of our capital stock are pari passu with respect to the payment of dividends.

In addition, we are subject to Central Bank Rules regarding dividends distribution. In particular, pursuant to Communication “A” 5273 (as amended and supplemented), the Central Bank imposed restrictions on the payment of dividends, limiting the ability of financial institutions to distribute dividends without its prior consent. In addition, under the Central Bank Rules, dividends cannot be distributed if, among other requirements, after effecting such distribution certain minimum capital requirements are not met. For more information, see Item 4.B “Argentine banking regulation—Liquidity and Solvency Requirements—Requirements Applicable to Dividend Distribution”.

 

112


Table of Contents

The following table sets forth the cash dividends paid to our shareholders from 2003 through 2015. All banks were prohibited by the Central Bank from paying dividends in respect of the results of 2001 and 2002.

 

Based on financial statements for year ended December 31,   Payment Dates  

Dividends per
Share

(in Pesos)

   

Aggregate Dividend
Payment

(in millions of Pesos)

 

2003

  July 2004     0.10        60.9   

2004

  April 2005     0.05        30.4   

2005

  May 2006     0.10        68.4   

2006

  May 2007     0.15        102.6   

2007

  May 2008     0.25        171.0   

2008

  September 2009     0.25        149.9 (1) 

2009

  June 2010     0.35        208.1   

2010

  May 2011     0.85        505.3   

2013

  July 2014     1.02        596.3   

2014

  March 2016     0.39        227.7 (2) 

2015

                     (3)     1.10        643.0   

 

(1) For fiscal year ended December 31, 2008, dividends paid in cash were Ps.148.3 million based on the outstanding number of shares on the payment dates.
(2) For fiscal year ended December 31, 2014, we sought authorization from the Central Bank to distribute Ps.596.3 million (Ps.1.02 per share) and on February 2016 we received authorization to distribute Ps. 227.7 million (Ps.0.3895 per share).
(3) For fiscal year ended December 31,2015 dividends are still pending approval from the Central Bank as of the date of this annual report.

For fiscal years ended December 31, 2011 and 2012 we were not able to distribute dividends because we did not reach the regulatory threshold for dividend distribution under Central Bank Rules. We cannot assure that in the future we will be able to reach this regulatory threshold for dividend distribution.

Our shareholders’ meeting held on April 26, 2016, resolved to distribute cash dividends in the amount of Ps.1.10 per outstanding share, which will produce a total distribution of Ps.643.0 million. Deductions in respect of income tax in accordance with Law 26,893 will be made from the amount payable to each shareholder, as applicable, at the time dividends are paid. In March 2016 we requested prior authorization from the Central Bank to distribute such dividends, but such authorization remained pending as of the date of this annual report.

For more information, see Item 4.B “Argentine banking regulation—Liquidity and Solvency Requirements—Requirements Applicable to Dividend Distribution”.

Central Bank and contractual limitations on distribution of dividends

The Central Bank has imposed restrictions on the payment of dividends, substantially limiting the ability of financial institutions to distribute such dividends without its prior consent.

The Central Bank has eased these restrictions through Communication “A” 4,589, as amended by Communication “A” 4,591, “A” 5,072, “A” 5827 and others, by providing for a mechanism for the calculation of distributable profits of the financial institutions.

The Superintendency will review the ability of the Bank to distribute dividends upon the Bank’s requests for its approval. Such request has to be filed within 30 business days prior to the shareholders meeting that will consider dividend distributions. The Superintendency will authorize the distribution of dividends when none of the following circumstances are verified during the month preceding the request for the payment of dividends:

(i) we are subject to a liquidation procedure or the mandatory transfer of assets by the Central Bank in accordance with section 34 or 35 bis of the Financial Institutions Law;

(ii) we are receiving financial assistance from the Central Bank;

(iii) we are not in compliance with or have failed to comply on a timely basis with our reporting obligations to the Central Bank;

(iv) we are not in compliance with minimum capital requirements (both on an individual and consolidated basis) or with minimum cash reserves (on average) whether in Pesos, foreign currency or securities issued by the public sector; or

(v) we are subject to a significant fine, debarment, suspension, revocation or prohibition imposed in the last five years by the Central Bank, the UIF, the CNV, and/or the National Superintendency of Insurance (Superintendencia de Seguros de la Nación), that are considered as significant, except when such financial institution has implemented corrective measures that are satisfactory to the Superintendency (such corrective measures would also be brought to the attention of the regulatory body that originally imposed the sanction). The Superintendency also takes into consideration information that it receives from, and/or sanctions imposed by, equivalent foreign agencies or authorities. When weighing the significance of the sanctions, the Superintendency takes into account the type of sanctions, the underlying reason for such sanctions and the amount of sanctions imposed on the financial institution. Additionally, the Superintendency factors in the degree of participation in the events leading up to the sanction, the economic effects of the violation, the degree of damage caused to third parties, the economic benefit that the sanctioned party received from the violation, the sanctioned party’s operating volume, its liability and the title or function that such party holds.

The amount to be distributed, as filed with the Superintendency, shall not compromise the liquidity and solvency of the entity.

Any distribution of dividends will be authorized only to the extent the Bank complies with the minimum capital and minimum cash requirements calculated considering the proposed distribution and the additional capital margins, as applicable pursuant to Communication “A” 5827. The dividend distribution shall be limited whenever the level and composition of the RPC – even when it complies with the

 

113


Table of Contents

minimum capital requirements – is within the range of the capital conservation margin. This limitation applies solely to the dividend distribution, but not the operation of the entity. For more information see Item 4.B “Argentine banking regulation—Liquidity and Solvency Requirements—Requirements Applicable to Dividend Distribution”.

We have consistently obtained authorization from the Central Bank to distribute dividends corresponding to fiscal years 2003 through 2010. For fiscal years ended December 31, 2011 and 2012 we were not able to distribute dividends because we did not reach the regulatory threshold for dividend distribution under Central Bank Rules. For fiscal year 2013, we obtained authorization from the Central Bank to distribute dividends, which we paid in July 2014. For fiscal year 2014, we sought authorization from the Central Bank to distribute Ps. 596 million and received authorization to distribution Ps. 227 million, which we paid in March 2016.

We cannot assure that in the future we will be able to reach the regulatory threshold for dividend distribution. For more information, see Item 4.B “Argentine banking regulation—Liquidity and Solvency Requirements—Requirements Applicable to Dividend Distribution”.

Additional regulatory and contractual restrictions exist which could affect the distribution of earnings and are included in note 16 of our audited consolidated financial statements as of and for the three years ended December 31, 2015.

Amounts available for distribution and distribution approval process

Under Argentine Corporate Law, declaration and payment of annual dividends, to the extent funds are legally available, is determined by our shareholders at the annual ordinary shareholders’ meeting. Generally, but not necessarily, the board of directors makes a recommendation with respect to the payment of dividends.

Dividends may be lawfully declared and paid only out of our retained earnings stated in our yearly financial statements according to Central Bank Rules and approved by a shareholders’ meeting as described below.

The board of directors submits our financial statements for the preceding fiscal year, together with reports thereon by the supervisory committee, at the annual ordinary shareholders’ meeting for approval. Within four months of the end of each fiscal year, an ordinary shareholders’ meeting must be held to approve the financial statements and determine the allocation of our net income for such year.

Under applicable CNV regulations, but subject to prior Central Bank approval, cash dividends must be paid to shareholders within 30 days of the shareholders’ meeting approving such dividends. In the case of stock dividends, shares are required to be delivered within three months of our receipt of notice of the CNV authorization for the public offering of the shares arising paid as dividends. We were not able to make payment of dividends within this term in connection with fiscal years 2003, 2008 and 2009 due to Central Bank’s delay in granting its approval. For fiscal years ended December 31, 2011 and 2012 we were not able to distribute dividends because we did not reach the regulatory threshold for dividend distribution under Central Bank Rules. For fiscal year 2013, we obtained authorization from the Central Bank to distribute dividends, which we paid in July 2014. For fiscal year 2014, we sought authorization from the Central Bank to distribute Ps. 596 million and received authorization to distribution Ps. 227m, which we paid in March 2016. We have met the regulatory threshold for dividend distribution for fiscal year 2015, but as of the date of this annual report, we are awaiting the Central Bank approval to pay dividends for that fiscal year.

Legal reserve requirement

Pursuant to the Financial Institutions Law, we are required to maintain a legal reserve which must be funded with no more than 20% and no less than 10% of yearly income. Pursuant to Central Bank Rules, we maintain a legal reserve which is funded with 20% of our yearly income. This reserve can only be used during periods in which a financial institution has incurred losses and has exhausted all other reserves. If a financial institution does not comply with the required legal reserve, it is not allowed to pay dividends to its shareholders.

Under Argentine Corporate Law and our bylaws, our yearly net income (as adjusted to reflect changes in prior results) is allocated in the following order: (i) to comply with the legal reserve requirement, (ii) to pay the accrued fees of the members of the board of directors and statutory supervisory committee; (iii) to pay fixed dividends, which are applied first to pending and unpaid dividends and holders of preferred stock (if applicable); (iv) for voluntary or contingent reserves, as may be resolved from time to time by our shareholders at the annual ordinary shareholders’ meeting; and (v) the remainder of the net income for the year may be distributed as dividends on common stock or as otherwise decided by our shareholders at the annual ordinary shareholders’ meeting.

Personal assets tax

Our shareholders approved the absorption of personal asset tax by us for fiscal year 2015. There can be no assurance that in the future this tax will be absorbed by the Bank. For more information, see Item 10.E “Taxation—Material Argentine tax considerations relating to our Class B shares and ADSs—Personal assets tax”.

B. Significant Changes

Except as otherwise disclosed in this annual report, there has been no undisclosed significant change since the date of the most recent annual financial statements included herein.

 

114


Table of Contents

Item 9. The Offer and Listing

A. Offer and listing details

The table below shows the high and low market prices in Pesos for our Class B shares on the MERVAL for the periods indicated:

 

     Ps.per Class B Share  

Banco Macro

   High      Low  

2016:

     

March

     111.50         106.00   

February

     117.50         103.00   

January

     90.00         87.00   

2015:

     

December

     90.00         72.50   

November

     103.00         79.60   

October

     90.00         50.00   

2015

     103.00         45.00   

2014

     61.00         19.00   

2013

     30.25         10.70   

2012

     12.50         7.35   

2011

     21.40         8.50   

2016

     

1st quarter

     117.50         87.00   

2015

     

4th quarter

     103.00         50.00   

3rd quarter

     69.30         47.55   

2nd quarter

     72.00         54.40   

1st quarter

     80.00         45.00   

2014

     

4th quarter

     59.20         39.90   

3rd quarter

     61.00         37.00   

2nd quarter

     40.50         27.25   

1st quarter

     28.20         19.00   

Source: Yahoo Finance.

The ordinary shares trade on the NYSE in the form of ADSs issued by The Bank of New York, as depositary. Each ADS represents ten ordinary shares. The table below shows the high and low market prices of the ADSs in dollars on the NYSE for the periods indicated.

 

     US$ per ADS  
Banco Macro    High      Low  

2016:

     

March

     71.78         67.66   

February

     74.64         70.00   

January

     64.00         60.67   

2015:

     

December

     59.08         51.60   

November

     69.75         56.16   

October

     64.88         35.93   

2015

     69.75         35.93   

2014

     51.96         16.42   

2013

     32.85         13.53   

2012

     27.06         10.79   

2011

     51.94         18.09   

2016

     

1st quarter

     74.64         60.67   

2015

     

4th quarter

     69.75         35.93   

3rd quarter

     51.97         36.25   

2nd quarter

     59.74         43.90   

1st quarter

     67.00         38.00   

2014

     

4th quarter

     47.20         28.03   

3rd quarter

     51.96         33.56   

2nd quarter

     38.26         27.50   

1st quarter

     29.01         16.42   

Source: Yahoo Finance

 

115


Table of Contents

B. Plan of Distribution

Not applicable.

C. Markets

Our Class B shares are currently traded on the MERVAL (since November 1994) and MAE (since October 2015) under the symbol ‘BMA’. Additionally, our ADSs have been trading on the NYSE since March 24, 2006 under the symbol ‘BMA’.

Our notes are currently listed on both the MERVAL and the Luxembourg Stock Exchange.

D. Selling Shareholders

Not applicable.

E. Dilution

Not applicable.

F. Expenses of the issue

Not applicable.

Item 10. Additional Information

A. Share Capital

Not applicable

B. Memorandum and Articles of Association

General

We are a financial institution incorporated on November 21, 1966 as a sociedad anónima, or a stock corporation, duly incorporated under the laws of Argentina for a 99-year period and registered on March 8, 1967 with the Public Registry of Commerce of Bahía Blanca, Province of Buenos Aires, Argentina, under No. 1154 of Book 2, Folio 75 of Estatutos. We subsequently changed our legal address to the City of Buenos Aires and registered it with the IGJ on October 8, 1996 under No. 9777 of Book 119, Volume A of Sociedades Anónimas. A translation of our bylaws has been filed as an exhibit to our 2011 annual report on form 20-F filed on April 26, 2012.

As of December 31, 2015, our capital stock consists of Ps.584,563,028, represented by 11,235,670 common, book-entry Class A shares, with a par value of one Peso each and the right to five votes per share, and 573,327,358 common, book-entry Class B shares, with a par value of one Peso each and the right to one vote per share.

Under our bylaws, we may issue different classes of shares of common stock entitled with one or five votes per share. However, as long as we remain in the public offering regime we cannot issue additional shares of any class of capital stock that could entitle the holder thereof to more than one vote per share. All outstanding shares are fully paid.

Our Class B shares have been listed on the MERVAL since November 1994 and have been authorized to list on the Mercado Abierto Electrónico (“MAE”) since October 2015. Our ADSs have been listed in the NYSE since March 24, 2006. Holders of Class A shares are permitted to convert their shares into Class B shares on a one-for-one basis.

Corporate Purpose

Our bylaws sets forth that our corporate purpose is to engage within or outside of Argentina in any banking transaction contemplated and authorized under the Financial Institutions Law and other laws, rules and regulations governing banking activities in the place of performance, under the guidelines and with prior authorization, if appropriate, of the Central Bank. In addition, we are capable of acting as any category of “agent” under the Capital Markets Law and supplementing regulations, in connection with securities in the transactions contemplated under the legal provisions in effect governing the activity, under the guidelines and with the prior authorization, if appropriate, of the CNV. To that effect, we have full legal capacity to develop rights, incur obligations, and execute any kind of act and transaction related thereto. Furthermore, we are capable of having interests in other domestic or foreign financial institutions and or companies with the prior authorization of the Central Bank and in compliance with the rules of such entity, as applicable.

In respect of the different categories of agents established by the Capital Markets Law, effective as of January 28, 2013, and the CNV Rules, we, and certain of our subsidiaries are registered with the CNV in one or more of the following categories: negotiation, clearing and settlement agent (ALyC), custody of collective investment products agent (AC PIC FCI), placement and distribution of mutual funds agent (ACYD FCI), financial trustees agent (FF) and nonfinancial trustees agent (FNOF), as applicable.

 

116


Table of Contents

Shareholders’ liability

Shareholders’ liability for losses of a company is limited to the value of their shareholdings in the company. Under Argentine Corporate Law, however, shareholders who voted in favor of a resolution that is subsequently declared void by a court as contrary to Argentine laws or a company’s bylaws (or regulations, if any) may be held jointly and severally liable for damages to such company, other shareholders or third parties resulting from such resolution. See also Item 3.D Risk Factors— Risks relating to our Class B shares and the ADSs—Our shareholders may be subject to liability for certain votes of their securities”.

Redemption and rights of withdrawal

Our shares are subject to redemption in connection with a reduction in capital by the vote of a majority of shareholders at an extraordinary shareholders’ meeting. Any shares so redeemed must be cancelled by us. Whenever our shareholders approve a spin-off or merger in which we are not the surviving corporation, the change of our corporate legal status, a fundamental change in our corporate purpose, change of our domicile outside of Argentina, voluntary withdrawal from public offering or delisting, our continuation in the case of mandatory delisting or cancellation of the public offering authorization, or a total or partial recapitalization following a mandatory reduction of our capital or liquidation, any shareholder that voted against such action that was approved or did not attend the meeting at which the decision was taken, may withdraw and receive the book value of its shares, determined on the basis of our latest balance sheet prepared or that should have been prepared in accordance with Argentine laws and regulations, provided that such shareholder exercises its appraisal rights within a determined period. However, because of the absence of legal precedent directly on point, there is doubt as to whether holders of ADSs will be able to exercise appraisal rights either directly or through the depositary with respect to Class B shares represented by ADSs. Appraisal rights must be exercised within the five days following the adjournment of the meeting at which the resolution was adopted, in the event that the dissenting shareholder voted against such resolution, or within 15 days following such adjournment if the dissenting shareholder did not attend such meeting and can prove that he was a shareholder on the date of such meeting. In the case of merger or spin-off, appraisal rights may not be exercised if the shares to be received as a result of such transaction are authorized for public offering or listed. Appraisal rights are extinguished if the resolution giving rise to such rights is revoked at another shareholders’ meeting held within 75 days of the meeting at which the resolution was adopted.

Payment on the appraisal rights must be made within one year of the date of the shareholders’ meeting at which the resolution was adopted, except when the resolution was to delist our stock or to continue following a mandatory delisting, in which case the payment period is reduced to 60 days from the resolution date.

Preemptive and accretion rights

In the event of a capital increase, a holder of existing common shares of a given class has a preemptive right to subscribe for a number of shares of the same class sufficient to maintain the holder’s existing proportionate holdings of shares of that class.

In addition, shareholders are entitled to the right to subscribe on pro-rata basis for the unsubscribed shares remaining at the end of a preemptive rights offering, known as accretion rights.

Holders of ADSs may be restricted in their ability to exercise preemptive rights if an annual report under the Securities Act relating thereto has not been filed or is not effective or an exemption is not available. Preemptive rights are exercisable during the 30 days following the last publication of notice to the shareholders in the Official Bulletin of the Republic of Argentina, or the Official Gazette and an Argentine newspaper of wide circulation. Pursuant to Argentine Corporate Law, in the case of public companies, such 30-day period may be reduced to a minimum of ten days if so approved by the company’s shareholders at an extraordinary shareholders’ meeting.

Shares not subscribed by the shareholders by virtue of their exercise of preemptive rights or accretion rights may be offered to third parties.

Voting rights

Under our bylaws, each Class A share entitles the holder thereof to five votes at any meeting of our shareholders and Class B shares entitle the holders thereof to one vote per share. However, according to Argentine Corporate Law, shares entitle the holder to only one vote per share to vote the approval of: an early dissolution, a merger or spin-off when we are not the surviving entity, a reduction of capital stock and redemption of shares, a transformation from one type of entity to another, a limitation of shareholders’ preemptive rights, a transfer of our domicile outside Argentina, and a fundamental change of our corporate purpose set forth in our bylaws. In such cases Class A shares are entitled to only one vote per share and Class B shares are entitled to only one vote per share. In addition, pursuant to Argentine applicable law, as long as we remain public we cannot issue additional shares of any class of capital stock that could entitle the holder thereof to more than one vote per share.

Rights attaching to shares

Shareholders may not claim the payment of dividends from us once three years have elapsed from the date on which the relevant dividend was made available to such shareholders. For a description of requirements applicable to dividend distribution see Item 4.B “Argentine banking regulation—Liquidity and solvency requirements—Requirements applicable to dividend distribution”.

 

117


Table of Contents

Registration requirements of foreign companies that hold Class B shares directly

There are no restrictions imposed by Argentine law or our by-laws or other organizational documents regarding the rights of non-residents or foreign persons to hold or vote our shares or our ADSs.

Under Argentine regulations, foreign companies that hold shares directly (and not as ADSs) in an Argentine company must register with the IGJ to exercise certain shareholder rights, including voting rights. The registration requires the filing of corporate and accounting documents in order to demonstrate that the foreign shareholder’s main activity is conducted outside of Argentina.

Liquidation rights

In the case of our liquidation or dissolution we are requested to communicate such event to the Central Bank, and our assets will be applied to satisfy our outstanding liabilities and proportionally distributed first among our holders of preferred stock as per the terms of the preferred stock, if any. If any surplus remains, it will be proportionally distributed among holders of our common stock.

Other shareholders’ rights

In addition to the rights mentioned above, the shareholders of Argentine corporations are entitled to the following additional rights that cannot be subject to any kind of limitation or suspension as they protect the minority shareholders in such capacity, (i) the right to participate in the company’s profits; (ii) right to be informed and receive information from the company through the syndics or supervisory committee, including the right to request information or reports (shareholders representing at least 2% of the capital stock of the company are entitled to request the syndic or the members of the supervisory committee information related to their functions and certain investigations); (iii) right to request a shareholders’ meeting (shareholders representing at least 5% of the capital stock of the company may request the call of a shareholders’ meeting); (iv) right to disapprove the performance of the members of the board of directors (the liability of the company’s directors and managers shall be extinguished if their performance is later approved by the shareholders at a shareholders’ meeting, or if they resign, provided that such liability is not incurred as a consequence of the violation of the applicable laws or the company’s bylaws and if it does not mediate opposition of at least 5% of the capital stock) and (v) right to judicially object those shareholders´ meetings resolutions violating the law or company’s regulations and a right to ask for a judicial or administrative intervention when the administrator or administrators of a company execute acts or neglect acts whose omission places the company in serious danger.

In addition, according to the Capital Markets Law, the CNV is entitled to (i) appoint supervisors with powers of veto of the resolutions adopted by the board of directors and (ii) separate the board of directors for a period of 180 days when, as determined by the CNV, the interests of the minority shareholders and/or securities holders are affected.

Ordinary and extraordinary meetings

Shareholders’ meetings may be ordinary meetings or extraordinary meetings. We are required to convene and hold an ordinary meeting of shareholders within four months of the close of each fiscal year to consider the matters specified in the first two paragraphs of Section 234 of the Argentine Corporation Law, such as the approval of our financial statements, allocation of net income for such fiscal year, approval of the reports of the board of directors and the supervisory committee and election and remuneration of directors and members of the supervisory committee. In addition, pursuant to the Capital Markets Law, at an ordinary shareholders’ meetings, our shareholders must consider (i) the disposition of, or creation of any lien over, our assets as long as such decision has not been performed under the ordinary course of business; (ii) the execution of administration or management agreements; and (iii) whether to approve the payment of any agreement providing assets or services to us as long as such payment is material when measured against the volume of the ordinary course of business and our shareholders’ equity. Other matters which may be considered at an ordinary meeting convened and held at any time include the responsibility of directors and members of the supervisory committee, capital increases and the issuance of certain corporate bonds. Extraordinary shareholders’ meetings may be called at any time to consider matters beyond the authority of an ordinary meeting, including amendment of the bylaws, issuance of debentures, early dissolution, merger, spin off, reduction of capital stock and redemption of shares, transformation from one type of entity to another and limitation of shareholders’ preemptive rights.

Notices of meetings

Notices of shareholders’ meetings are governed by the provisions of Argentine Corporations Law, and in case of publicly traded companies, Capital Markets Law. Furthermore, notice of shareholders’ meetings must be published for five days in the Official Gazette, in an Argentine newspaper of wide circulation and in the publications of Argentine exchanges or securities markets in which our shares are traded, at least twenty (20) but not more than forty five (45) days prior to the date on which the meeting is to be held. Such notice must include information regarding the type of meeting to be held, the date, time and place of such meeting and the agenda. If a quorum is not available at such meeting, a notice for a second meeting, which must be held within 30 days of the date on which the first meeting was called, must be published for three days, at least eight days before the date of the second meeting. The above described notices of shareholders’ meetings may be effected simultaneously for the second meeting to be held on the same day as the first meeting, only in the case of ordinary meetings. Shareholders’ meetings may be validly held without notice if all shares of our outstanding capital stock are present and resolutions are adopted by unanimous vote of such shares.

Quorum and voting requirements

The quorum for ordinary meetings of shareholders on first call is a majority of the shares entitled to vote, and action may be taken by the affirmative vote of an absolute majority of the shares present that are entitled to vote on such action. If a quorum is not available at the first

 

118


Table of Contents

meeting a second meeting may be held at which action may be taken by the holders of an absolute majority of the shares present, regardless of the number of such shares. The quorum for an extraordinary shareholders’ meeting on first call is 60% of the shares entitled to vote, and if such quorum is not available, a second meeting may be held, for which the quorum is 20% of the shares entitled to vote.

Action may be taken at extraordinary shareholders’ meetings by the affirmative vote of an absolute majority of shares present that are entitled to vote on such action, except that: the approval of a majority of shares with voting rights (for these purposes non-voting preferred shares shall have voting rights), without application of multiple votes, is required at both the first and second meeting for: (i) the transfer of our domicile outside Argentina, (ii) a fundamental change of the corporate purpose set forth in our bylaws, (iii) our anticipated dissolution, (iv) the total or partial redemption of shares, (v) our merger or spin-off, if we are not the surviving entity, or (vi) the transformation of our corporate legal status, in which cases resolutions shall be adopted by the affirmative vote of the majority of shares with the right to vote. Preferred shares will be entitled to one vote in these circumstances.

Argentine Corporate Law reserves the right to cumulative voting in order to elect up to one third of the directors and one third of the members of the supervisory committee to fill vacancies of the board of directors and of the supervisory committee, respectively, sharing such part with candidates voted for by means of the plural system. Cumulative voting is a system designed to protect minority interests, as it gives rise to the possibility, but does not ensure, that minority interests will be able to elect some of their candidates. Each shareholder who votes cumulatively shall have a number of votes equal to the result of multiplying his/her own votes by the number of vacancies. On the other hand, shareholders who vote by the ordinary procedure and those who vote by cumulative vote will compete for the election of one third of the vacancies. The larger the number of vacancies, the greater the possibility that minority groups or shareholders will win positions in the board of directors or the supervisory committee.

Shareholders’ meetings may be called by the board of directors or the members of the supervisory committee whenever required by law or whenever they deem it necessary. Also, the board or the members of the supervisory committee are required to call shareholders’ meetings upon the request of shareholders representing an aggregate of at least five percent of our outstanding capital stock. If the board or the supervisory committee fails to call a meeting following such a request, a meeting may be ordered by the CNV or by the courts. In order to attend a meeting, a shareholder must also deposit with us a certificate of book-entry shares registered in its name and issued by Caja de Valores S.A. at least three business days prior to the date on which the meeting is to be held. If so entitled to attend a meeting, a shareholder may be represented by proxy. Proxies may not be granted to our board, members of the supervisory committee, officers or employees.

Election of directors

The shareholders present at any annual ordinary meeting may determine the size of the board of directors, provided that there shall be no less than three and no more than 13 directors. Any director so appointed will serve for three fiscal years. If the shareholders elect nine or more board members, each director will be re-elected as a staggered board, to be renewed by thirds, provided that in all cases no less than three directors shall be renewed each time. The annual ordinary shareholders’ meeting may also appoint an equal or lesser number of alternate directors, to hold office for the same term than regular directors, to fill any vacancy in the board occurring for any reason, and shall further determine the order of substitution. Alternate directors shall hold office until the regular directors in whose place they have acted as substitutes shall resume office, and in case any such absence is permanent, until the next ordinary meeting of shareholders where at directors shall be appointed. Both regular and alternate directors may be re-elected indefinitely.

Change in capital

Our by-laws do not establish conditions for the changes in our capital more stringent than those conditions imposed by the Argentine Corporate Law. For a description of conditions for the changes in our capital imposed by the Argentine Corporate Law see “—Ordinary and extraordinary meetings”.

Purchases of Equity Securities by the Issuer

According to the Capital Markets Law, a stock corporation may acquire the shares issued by it, provided that the public offering and listing thereof has been authorized, subject to the following terms and conditions and those set forth by the CNV. The above-mentioned conditions are: (a) the shares to be acquired shall be fully paid up; (b) there shall be a resolution signed by the board of directors to such effect (duly reported to the supervisory committee and the audit committee); (c) the acquisition shall be made out of net profits or free or voluntary reserves; and (d) the total amount of shares acquired by the company, including previously acquired shares (and still hold by the company), shall not exceed 10% of the capital stock or such lower percentage determined by the CNV. The shares acquired by the company in excess of such limit shall be disposed of within the term of 90 days after the date of the acquisition originating such excess. The shares acquired by the company shall be disposed of by the company within the maximum term of three years counted as from the date of acquisition thereof or cancelled. Upon disposing of the shares, the issuer shall make a preemptive offer thereof. Such preemptive offer will not be mandatory in certain specific cases, pursuant to which shares may be sold in the open market. For more information, please see Item 16.E “Purchases of Equity Securities by the Issuer and Affiliated Purchasers”.

Anti-takeover provisions

Our bylaws do not contain any provision that would (i) oblige us to disclose information regarding our shareholders; and (ii) have the effect of delaying, deferring or preventing a change in control, the last of which may happen only in the event of a merger, acquisition or public offering for acquisition.

 

119


Table of Contents

Tender offer regime

Optional mandatory tender offer regime in the case of a change in control

Mandatory tender offer or exchange in Argentina

The mandatory tender offer rules set forth in Capital Markets Law, apply to all companies having publicly traded shares in Argentina. Under such rules, in the event of change of control or acquisition of a significant shareholding, as described below, a company having publicly traded shares will be subject to a mandatory tender offer (“oferta pública de adquisción” or “OPA”) with respect to some or all of the outstanding shares, as described below.

Pursuant to such regulation, the mandatory tender offer will take place when anyone intends to purchase, either directly or indirectly, for cash, either individually or collectively, either in one act or in a series of successive acts during a period of 90 consecutive days, a number of voting shares, subscription rights or stock options, negotiable securities or similar securities which directly or indirectly, and by computing the prior holding of such person, may entitle such person to subscribe, purchase or convert voting shares, shares entitled to or that once exercised grant the right to a “significant share” in the voting capital stock and/or in the votes of a company having publicly traded shares. In such cases, the OPA must be launched by the prospective purchaser within 10 days of having made the decision to participate in such offer, except in those cases expressly mentioned in the CNV Rules.

Such obligation is not applicable in cases where the acquisition of the significant share does not imply the acquisition of the company’s control. It also does not apply in cases where there is a change of control as a consequence of a corporate reorganization, merger or split-off. However, the regulation is applicable in certain cases of indirect acquisitions by means of a merger of the purchaser with the controlling shareholding company of the affected company or the taking of control of such controlling shareholding company.

Concept of a “Significant Share”

The regulations establish a duty to effect an offer with respect to a part or all of the outstanding shares depending on the percentage of the capital stock or relating to the votes to be acquired. The regulations provide for the following duties relating to the OPA:

 

    Whenever the goal is to acquire participation rights equal to or greater than 15% of the capital stock and/or the company’s votes, the offer must be made for a number of securities that would enable the purchaser to acquire at least 50% of the voting capital stock of the affected company.

 

    Whenever an entity already holds participation rights equal to or greater than 15% of the voting capital stock and/or the company’s votes but less than 51% of such rights, and the intention is to increase such share of the affected company’s capital stock at least 6% during a 12-month period, the offer shall be made on the number of securities representing at least 10% of the voting capital stock of the affected company.

 

    Whenever participation rights equal to or greater than 51% of the voting capital stock and/or the company’s votes are sought, the offer shall be made for the number of securities that would enable the purchaser to obtain 100% of the voting capital stock of the affected company. The application of this stipulation shall have priority over the stipulations discussed in the preceding paragraphs.

Determination of the price of the OPA in the case of a change in control

The price shall determined by the offeror with the following exceptions:

 

  Whenever the purchaser would have purchased other securities related to the offering in the prior 90 consecutive days beginning as of the date the price was announced, the price cannot be lower than the highest price the purchaser would have paid in such transactions.

 

  Whenever the purchaser would have obtained firm sales commitments from the controlling shareholder or other shareholders with the right to take part in the public offering, the price cannot be lower than the price provided for in such commitments.

In order to determine the price, the purchaser shall also consider (“ponderar”) the following criteria, according to the CNV Rules: (i) book value of the shares; (ii) valuation of the target company according to discounted cash flows (DCF) or other applicable valuation criteria applicable to comparable business; and (iii) average price of the shares for the last six months before the “offer”.

Penalties for breach

Without prejudice to the penalties established by the CNV, the Capital Markets Law provides that purchases of shares of a company in violation of the OPA regime shall be declared irregular and ineffective for administrative purposes by the CNV and cause the auction of the shares acquired on infringement, without prejudice to the penalties that may correspond.

Tender offer regime in the case of a voluntary withdrawal from the public offering and listing system in Argentina

The Capital Markets Law and its regulation also established that when a company, whose shares are publicly offered and listed in Argentina, agrees to voluntary withdraw from the public offering and listing system in Argentina, it must follow the procedures provided

 

120


Table of Contents

for in the CNV’s regulations and it must likewise launch an OPA for its aggregate shares and/or subscription rights or securities convertible into shares or stock options under the terms provided for in such regulation. It is not necessary to extend the public offering to those shareholders that voted for the withdrawal at the shareholders’ meeting. The public offering can only be made as a purchase and sale and the consideration must be cash.

The acquisition of one’s own shares must be made with liquid and realized profits or with free reserves, whenever paid up in full, and for the amortization or disposition thereof, within the term set forth in section 221 of the Argentine Companies Law and the company must present the CNV with evidence that it has the necessary solvency to effect such purchase and that the payment for the shares will not affect its solvency.

Determination of the price of the OPA in the case of a voluntary withdrawal from the public offering and listing system in Argentina

The price offered should be an equitable price, as such, one must consider the following relevant criteria:

 

    The equity value of the shares, taking into account a special financial statement for the withdrawal from the public offering system and/or listing.

 

    The value of the company, in accordance with discounted cash flow criteria and/or ratios applicable to comparable businesses or companies.

 

    The company’s liquidation value.

 

    Average quotation prices on the stock exchange where the shares are listed during the six month period immediately preceding the withdrawal application, no matter the number of sessions necessary for such negotiation.

 

    The consideration offered beforehand, or the placement of the new shares, in the event that a public offering has been made with regard to the same shares or if new shares have been issued, if applicable, during the last year, to be counted as of the date of the agreement for the withdrawal application.

Under no circumstances can the price offered be lower than the average quotation price discussed in this paragraph.

Form and transfer

Our current capital stock is represented by book-entry shares. Our shareholders are required to hold their shares through book-entries directly made by Caja de Valores S.A. in the stock registry of the company carried by Caja de Valores S.A. or through book-entries with brokers, banks and other entities approved by the CNV that have accounts with Caja de Valores S.A., or with the participants of the Caja de Valores S.A.

Caja de Valores S.A. is in charge of maintaining a stock registry on our behalf based on information received from shareholders that choose to hold their shares directly by registration on the stock registry of the company and from participants of the Caja de Valores S.A., and in accordance with Argentine law only those holders listed in the stock registry either directly or through participants of the Caja de Valores S.A. will be recognized as shareholders. Shares held by participants of the Caja de Valores S.A. have the same rights as shares recorded in our shareholders’ register.

C. Material Contracts

During the past two years we did not enter into or become a party to any contract that is required to be disclosed under this item.

D. Exchange Controls

Exchange rates

On January 7, 2002, the Argentine congress enacted the Public Emergency Law, abandoning over ten years of fixed Peso-U.S. dollar parity at Ps.1.00 per US$1.00. After devaluing the Peso and setting the official exchange rate at Ps.1.40 per US$1.00, on February 11, 2002, the government allowed the Peso to float. The shortage of U.S. dollars and their heightened demand caused the Peso to further devalue significantly in the first half of 2002 reaching a value of Ps.3.8675 per US$1.00 in June 2002. During the first quarter of 2014, the Peso-U.S. dollar exchange rate has significantly increased, resulting in a devaluation of the Peso by 23% since December 31, 2013. The value of Peso has gradually depreciated during 2014. In 2015, the Peso lost up to a 52% of its value against the U.S. Dollar. See Item 3.B “Risk Factors—Risks relating to Argentina—Significant devaluation of the capital Peso against the U.S. dollar may adversely affect the Argentine Economy.”

 

121


Table of Contents

The following table sets forth the annual high, low, average and period-end exchange rates for the periods indicated, expressed in Pesos per U.S. dollar and not adjusted for inflation. The Federal Reserve Bank of New York does not report a noon buying rate for Pesos.

 

     Exchange Rates (Peso per Dollar)  
     High      Low      Average (1)      Period-end  

2011

     4.3035         3.9715         4.1302         4.3032   

2012

     4.9173         4.3048         4.5515         4.9173   

2013

     6.5180         4.9228         5.4798         6.5180   

2014

     8.5555         6.5430         8.1188         8.5520   

2015

     13.7633         8.5537         9.2689         13.0050   

October 2015

     9.5460         9.4273         9.4896         9.5460   

November 2015

     9.6880         9.5540         9.6272         9.6880   

December 2015

     13.7633         9.6975         11.4278         13.0050   

January 2016

     13.9413         13.0692         13.6548         13.9040   

February 2016

     15.5842         14.0883         14.8146         15.5842   

March 2016

     15.9192         14.2458         14.9615         14.5817   

Source: Central Bank

 

(1) Based on daily closing price.

The exchange rate on April 27, 2016 was Ps.14.2408 to US$1.00.

Exchange controls

In January 2002, with the approval of the Public Emergency Law, Argentina declared a public emergency situation in its social, economic, administrative, financial and foreign exchange matters and authorized the Argentine Executive Branch to establish a system to determine the foreign exchange rate between the Peso and foreign currencies and to issue foreign exchange-related rules and regulations. Within this context, on February 8, 2002, through Decree No. 260/2002, the Argentine Executive Branch established (i) the MULC through which all foreign exchange transactions in foreign currency must be conducted, and (ii) that foreign exchange transactions in foreign currency must be conducted at the foreign exchange rate to be freely agreed upon among contracting parties, subject to the requirements and regulations imposed by the Central Bank (please see below for a summary of the main regulations).

On June 9, 2005, through Decree No. 616/2005, the Argentine Executive Branch mandated that (a) all inflows of funds into the local foreign exchange market arising from foreign debts incurred by residents, both individuals or legal entities in the Argentine private sector, except for those concerning foreign trade financing and primary issuances of debt securities admitted to public offering and listed in authorized markets; and (b) all inflows of funds by non-residents channeled through the MULC and aimed at being held in local currency, acquiring all types of financial assets or liabilities in the financial or nonfinancial private sector (except for foreign direct investments and primary issuances of debt securities and shares admitted to public offering and listed in authorized markets), and investments in securities issued by the public sector and acquired in secondary markets, must meet the following requirements: (a) such inflows of funds may only be transferred outside the local foreign exchange market at the expiration of a term of 365 calendar days as from the date of settlement of such funds into Pesos; (b) the proceeds of such inflows of funds must be credited to an account in the local banking system; (c) a non-transferable and non-interest-bearing deposit for 30% of the amount of the transaction must be kept in Argentina for a period of 365 calendar days, in accordance with the terms and conditions set forth in the applicable regulations (the “Deposit”); and (d) the Deposit is to be denominated in U.S. dollars and held in Argentine financial institutions and it may not be used to guarantee or as collateral of any type of credit transactions. The requirements of Decree 616/2005 were subsequently eased, as detailed below.

Within this context and pursuant to Communication “A” 4359, as amended, the Central Bank issued regulations relating to the Deposit, which was required to be made as soon as foreign currency was transferred into Argentina through the MULC in certain cases, such as: (i) financial indebtedness incurred by the financial sector and by the private, non-financial sector, except for primary issuances of publicly traded and listed debt securities, (ii) primary issuance of shares by resident companies whose shares are neither registered for public offering nor listed in any authorized market, to the extent they do not qualify as “foreign direct investment” and (iii) portfolio investments by non-residents to be applied to holdings of local currency and financial assets and liabilities in the financial sector and in the private, non-financial sector, to the extent they do not relate to the primary issuance of publicly traded and listed debt securities or publicly traded and listed shares issued by resident companies. Subsequently, Resolution No. 365/2005 and No. 637/2005 issued by the Ministry of Economy, Public Finance and Production included additional transactions for which the Deposit was mandatory starting from June 29, 2005. However, exceptions established under Argentine Central Bank Rules reduced the number of situations in which this Deposit was required.

On December 18, 2015, through Resolution No. 3/2015, the Ministry of Treasury and Public Finance amended Executive Decree No. 616/2005, reducing (i) the Deposit percentage to 0% and (ii) the required period that the proceeds from any new financial indebtedness incurred by residents, held by foreign creditors and transferred through the MULC must be kept in Argentina, from 365 calendar days to 120 calendar days from the date the relevant amount was transferred.

The following is a description of the main aspects of Central Bank Rules concerning inflows and outflows of funds in Argentina.

Inflow of Capital

Capital

New foreign financial indebtedness incurred by the private non-financial sector, the financial sector and Argentine local governments are not required to have proceeds from such indebtedness transferred and settled through the MULC. However, the settlement of funds through the MULC will be necessary for subsequent access to the MULC to repay principal and interest. Pursuant to Communication “A” 5850, it will be necessary to demonstrate the settlement of such funds, if the funds are credited to foreign-currency denominated local accounts in Argentina.

 

122


Table of Contents

Debt issuances by the private (financial and non-financial) sector denominated in foreign currency, with principal and interest services not solely payable in Pesos in Argentina are to be subscribed in foreign currency and the proceeds must be settled through the MULC (Communication “A” 5265 as amended).

Any new financial indebtedness channeled through the MULC and any debt renewal with foreign creditors incurred by Argentine residents from the financial sector and from the private, non-financial sector, must be agreed and maintained for terms of at least 120 calendar days as from the date of the inflow of the funds into Argentina or renewal of the debt, as applicable, and they may not be prepaid before the lapse of said term, irrespective of the manner of cancellation of the obligation to the foreign creditor and of whether said cancellation is effected with or without access to the MULC (Communication “A” 5265 and 5850, as amended).

Exempted from the provisions described in the preceding paragraph are the primary issuances of publicly traded and listed securities.

Outflow of Capital

Payment of Services

There are no restrictions on remittances abroad for payment of services rendered by non-residents, irrespective of the item (including, but not limited to, freights, insurance, royalties, technical assistance and fees) (Communication “A” 5264 and 5850, as amended). Access to the MULC for such payments requires the filing of documentation by residents evidencing the authenticity of the transaction related to the type of service rendered and the amount to be transferred abroad.

Payment of Profits (Interest, Earnings and Dividends)

Access to the MULC is granted for the payment of interest by the private, non-financial sector and in the financial sector (Communication “A” 5264, as amended) in the following circumstances: (i) if applicable regulations allow the repayment of the debt corresponding to such interest service and if all general regulatory requirements related to principal repayment are met; (ii) if the settlement of the currency is made within 10 calendar days of the maturity date of each interest payment; and (iii) if the interest payment is for the unpaid amounts accrued from the date of settlement of the foreign currency originating the foreign indebtedness or within 48 hours from the date of disbursement of the funds abroad and until settlement thereof through the MULC (within 48 hours from disbursement).

In addition, access to the MULC is permitted for remittances abroad to pay earnings and dividends insofar as they arise from closed and audited financial statements (Communication “A” 5377).

In order to proceed with remittances abroad for payment of interest on debt of all types, earnings and dividends, the entities involved must first verify that the debtor has complied with the reporting of (i) outstanding foreign indebtedness imposed under Communication “A” 3602 dated May 7, 2002 and (ii) direct investments pursuant to Communication “A” 4237 dated November 10, 2004, if applicable.

Financial Debts

Payment of principal under foreign financial indebtedness incurred by Argentine residents in the financial sector and in the private, non-financial sector (except in the case of payment of primary issuances of publicly traded and listed debt securities) may only proceed after the expiration of a 120 calendar-day term as from the date of inflow of the loan proceeds into Argentina.

In the case of foreign financial indebtedness settled and registered through the MULC from December 17, 2015, debtors in the financial sector and in the private, non-financial sector will have access to the MULC to prepay of their financial foreign debt, subject to compliance with the minimum stay period.

In the case of foreign financial indebtedness settled and registered through the MULC prior to December 16, 2015, debtors in the financial sector and in the private non-financial sector shall have access to the MULC to pay capital services of their financial debts on the following terms:

a. at any time within 10 business days prior to maturity, to the extent the applicable minimum stay-period has been complied with.

b. with the necessary operational anticipation for the payment of principal installments, whose payment depends on the enforcement of specific contractual conditions

 

123


Table of Contents

c. partial or total payment before 10-business-day term prior to maturity, to the extent the applicable minimum stay-period has been complied with, and that the payment is entirely financed with capital contributions settled through the MULC.

d. Partial or total payment before 10-business-day term prior to maturity, to the extent the applicable minimum stay-period has been complied with, and that the payment is entirely financed with new foreign debt settled through the MULC and/or through the issuance of bonds or other debt instruments that can be considered foreign debt issuance. Argentine companies that form part of the same economic group may use this benefit, provided that such condition is met at a consolidated level.

Moreover, access to the MULC before such 10-business-day term is allowed for the tender and/or exchange of bonds or other securities, even when the amount of new bonds being issued exceed the face value of the notes being exchanged so long as such extra value reflects reasonable market conditions. This permission is also subject to the new notes qualifying as foreign indebtedness pursuant to BCRA’s regulation ant the new notes are listed on a stock market.

In all cases of anticipated capital payments, the payment must be to the creditor or the payment agent of the obligation for its immediate payment to the lender. The obligation stops bearing interests for the prepaid portion from the date of the payment to the lender. (Communication “A” 5890).

In addition, pursuant to Communication “A” 5899, subject to certain conditions and provided that certain requirements are complied with, entities may grant residents access to the MULC to make principal and interest payments on certain foreign financial debts.

Other Regulations

Sales of Foreign Currency to Non-residents

Communication “A” 4662 as subsequently amended published a restatement of, as well as newly-issued, regulations applicable to access to the MULC by non-residents (as per the definitions contained in the IMF’s Balance of Payments Manual, fifth edition, chapter IV).

In this respect, no prior Central Bank approval is required for any of the following transactions conducted by non-residents in so far as all the requirements imposed in each case have been met:

1. purchases of foreign currencies for remittances abroad provided that the documentation prescribed by the previously mentioned regulations has been furnished, in the examples stated below, when transactions relate to, or pertain to collections in Argentina, of:

1.1. financial indebtedness originating in external loans of non-residents;

1.2. recovery of claims in local bankruptcy proceedings and collection of debts under reorganization proceedings to the extent that the non-resident client has been recognized as a creditor by a final non-appealable decision of the court of such proceedings;

1.3 repatriations of direct investments in companies in the private, non-financial sector, that do not control local financial institutions and/or real estate, provided that: the foreign beneficiary, either a natural or legal entity residing in or is incorporated and established or the payment is performed in domains, jurisdictions, territories or associated states that are considered “cooperators for the purposes of fiscal transparency” according to the provisions of Art. 1 of Decree 589/2013, as amended and supplemented (Communication “A” 5899) for the following purposes:

1.3.1. sale of the direct investment;

1.3.2. final liquidation of the direct investment;

1.3.3. capital reduction decided by the local company; and

1.3.4. reimbursement of irrevocable contributions by the local company;

1.4. collections of services or sales proceeds of other portfolio investments (and their profits) provided that the foreign beneficiary is either a real or legal person residing in or incorporated and established in domains, jurisdictions, territories or associated states that are considered “cooperators for the purposes of fiscal transparency” according to the provisions of Art. 1 of Decree 589/2013, as amended and supplemented (Communication “A” 5899). These portfolio investment repatriations include, but are not limited to, portfolio investments in shares and ownership interests in local companies, investments in mutual funds and local trusts, purchases of portfolios of loans granted to residents by local banks, purchases of invoices and promissory notes for local business transactions, investments in local bonds issued in Pesos and in foreign currency payable locally, as well as purchases of other internal receivables. Provided that investment proceeds settlement through the MULC and the applicable minimum period of 120 calendar days from the date of the inflow of the funds into Argentina have been complied with, non-residents will be allowed access to the MULC for the repatriation of their investment without any need to obtain the Central Bank’s prior authorization.

1.5. indemnifications awarded by local courts in favor of non-residents; and

1.6. payments of Argentine imports.

2. purchases of foreign currency by diplomatic and consular representatives and diplomatic staff accredited in the country for transfers, representations from courts, authorities or departments, special missions, bilateral commissions or bodies established by international treaties or agreements, in which Argentina is a party, to the extent that transfers to be made in the exercise of their functions; and

3. purchases of foreign currency by international organizations and institutions acting as official export credit agencies, as listed in Communication “A” 4662 (as amended and supplemented).

 

124


Table of Contents

The prior authorization of the Central Bank will not be required when the purchase of foreign currency or foreign banknotes by a non-resident does not exceed the equivalent of US$2,500 per calendar month across all entities authorized to deal in foreign currency transactions.

Formation of Off-shore Assets by Residents

On December 17, 2015, Communication “A” 5850 established that resident individuals, private legal entities organized in Argentina and not authorized to deal in foreign exchange, certain trusts and other estates domiciled in Argentina and Argentine local governments will be allowed access to the MULC without the prior authorization of the Central Bank with respect to the following types of transactions; (i) real estate investments in a foreign country; (ii) loans extended to non-residents; (iii) direct investments abroad by residents; (iv) portfolio investments abroad by natural persons and legal entities; (v) other investments by residents abroad; (vi) purchases of foreign currency banknotes in Argentina for holding purposes; and (vii) purchases of traveler checks and certain donations, in each case provided that the following conditions are satisfied:

(i) The total amount of the transactions does not exceed the equivalent of US$2.0 million per month across all entities authorized to perform foreign currency transactions;

(ii) The entity must have received a sworn statement from the client indicating that the foreign exchange transaction to be conducted is in compliance with the limits established by applicable rules for the client’s operations across all entities authorized to perform foreign currency transactions;

(iii) In the case of purchases of foreign currency banknotes and foreign currency that exceed the equivalent of US$500 per month across all entities authorized to perform foreign currency transactions, the transaction is only made by means of either a debit against a checking account created in an Argentine financial institution in the client’s name, a transfer via MEP (Electronic Payment System) to the relevant entity from a client’s checking account or payment by a check drawn against a client’s own account; and

(iv) In the case of foreign currency sales to residents for the creation of portfolio investments abroad, the transfer must be made to an account in the name of the client performing the exchange transaction and created at a foreign bank or investment banks or other entities providing financial services and controlled by foreign banks. Such banks or entities must not have been organized in countries or jurisdictions considered non-cooperative for fiscal transparency purposes under section 1 of Executive Decree No. 589/13, as amended, or in countries or jurisdictions where the Recommendations of the Financial Action Task Force are not followed or sufficiently followed. Non-cooperative countries or jurisdictions are designated as such by the Financial Action Task Force (www.fatf-gafi.org). The identification of the foreign entity where the client’s account was created and the account number must be properly recorded.

The above-mentioned limits are calculated as of the date when a new transaction is performed. For foreign currency purchases other than the U.S. dollar, the Peso amount settled for each transaction is computed at the Central Bank’s reference exchange rate on the business day immediately preceding the day on which the transaction was performed.

These rules do not preclude the enforcement of any other applicable rules regarding the prevention of money laundering, terrorism financing and other illicit activities.

Residents that perform their own offshore asset sales through the MULC as from December 17, 2015 will not be subject to the limit established in item (i) above to exchange foreign currency and/or foreign currency banknotes for up to the amount of such sales’ proceeds.

In addition, the requirement to register foreign exchange transactions in the AFIP’s (Argentine Federal Administration of Public Revenue) Exchange Transactions Consultation Program has been eliminated, which previously required all entities authorized to conduct operations related to foreign exchange to obtain prior approval by the Argentine tax authorities to execute any sale of foreign currency on behalf of their clients.

Capital Markets

Securities-related transactions carried out through stock exchanges and authorized securities markets must be paid using any of the following mechanisms: (i) in Pesos; (ii) in foreign currency through electronic fund transfers from and to sight accounts in local financial institutions; and (iii) through wire transfers against foreign accounts. Under no circumstances is the settlement of these securities purchase and sale transactions to be made in foreign currency bills or through deposits in escrow accounts or in third-party accounts (Communication “A” 4308).

Report of Issuances of Securities and Other Foreign Indebtedness of the Private Financial and Non-financial Sector

Pursuant to Communication “A” 3602 dated May 7, 2002, as amended, all individuals and legal entities in the private financial and non-financial sector must report their outstanding foreign indebtedness (whether Peso or foreign currency-denominated) at the end of each quarter. The debts incurred and repaid within the same calendar quarter need not be reported.

Direct Investments Report

Communication “A” 4237 dated November 10, 2004 established reporting requirements in connection with direct investments made by local residents abroad and by non-residents in Argentina. Direct investments are defined as those that reflect the long-standing interest of a

 

125


Table of Contents

resident in one economy (direct investor) in another economy’s resident entity, such as an ownership interest representing at least 10% of a company’s capital stock or voting rights. The reporting requirements prescribed by this Communication “A” 4237 are to be met on a bi-annual basis.

E. Taxation

Material U.S. federal income tax considerations relating to our Class B shares and ADSs

The following discussion is a summary of the material U.S. federal income tax considerations relating to the purchase, ownership and disposition of our Class B shares or ADSs. This discussion applies only to beneficial owners of Class B shares or ADSs that are “U.S. holders” (as defined below) that hold Class B shares or ADSs as “capital assets” (generally, property held for investment). This discussion is based on the U.S. Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended (the “Code”), final, temporary and proposed Treasury regulations, administrative pronouncements of the IRS and judicial decisions, all as currently in effect and all of which are subject to change (possibly on a retroactive basis) and to different interpretations. This discussion does not purport to address all U.S. federal income tax considerations that may be relevant to a particular U.S. holder and you are urged to consult your own tax advisor regarding your specific tax situation. The discussion does not address the tax considerations that may be relevant to U.S. holders in special tax situations, such as:

 

    dealers in securities or currencies;

 

    insurance companies;

 

    holders liable for the Medicare tax on net investment income;

 

    individual retirement accounts and other tax deferred accounts;

 

    tax-exempt organizations;

 

    traders in securities that elect to mark to market;

 

    certain financial institutions;

 

    partnerships or other pass-through entities;

 

    holders whose functional currency for U.S. federal income tax purposes is not the U.S. dollar;

 

    U.S. expatriates;

 

    holders that hold Class B shares or ADSs as part of a hedge, straddle, conversion transaction, constructive sale transaction or other integrated transaction;

 

    holders that own, directly, indirectly, or constructively, 10% or more of the total combined voting power of our shares;

 

    real estate investment trusts; or

 

    regulated investment companies.

This discussion does not address the estate, gift, or alternative minimum tax consequences of holding Class B shares or ADSs or the indirect consequences to holders of equity interests in partnerships or other entities that own our Class B shares or ADSs. Moreover, this discussion does not address the state, local, or non-U.S. income or other tax consequences of an investment in our Class B shares or ADSs, or any aspect of U.S. federal taxation other than income taxation.

While we do not believe that we are currently a passive foreign investment company (a “PFIC”), it is not entirely clear whether we were a PFIC in the past and we cannot preclude with certainty that we may be a PFIC in any future periods. As discussed below under “Passive Foreign Investment Companies”, the application of the PFIC rules to banks is unclear under present U.S. federal income tax law. If we were treated as a PFIC in the past or if we are treated as a PFIC in any future periods, a U.S. holder that held our Class B Shares or ADSs while we were or are a PFIC could be subject to unfavorable U.S. tax consequences. You should carefully consider the discussion under “Passive Foreign Investment Companies” and consult your own tax advisor regarding the consequences of investing in a PFIC. Unless otherwise noted, the following discussion assumes that we are not a PFIC.

You should also consult your own tax advisor regarding the U.S. federal, state, local, and foreign income and other tax consequences of purchasing, owning and disposing of our Class B shares or ADSs in your particular circumstances.

For the purposes of this discussion, you are a “U.S. holder” if you are a beneficial owner of Class B shares or ADSs and you are for U.S. federal income tax purposes:

 

    an individual who is a citizen or resident of the United States;

 

    a corporation, or any other entity taxable as a corporation, created or organized in or under the laws of the United States, any state thereof or the District of Columbia;

 

    an estate the income of which is subject to U.S. federal income taxation regardless of its source; or

 

    a trust if (i) a court within the United States is able to exercise primary supervision over the administration of the trust and one or more U.S. persons have the authority to control all substantial decisions of the trust or (ii) the trust has a valid election in effect under applicable Treasury regulations to be treated as a U.S. person.

If a partnership holds our Class B shares or ADSs, the tax treatment of a partner in such partnership will generally depend upon the status of the partner and upon the activities of the partnership. A prospective investor who is a partner of a partnership holding our Class B shares or ADSs should consult its own tax advisor.

In general, for U.S. federal income tax purposes, U.S. holders that are beneficial owners of ADSs will be treated as the beneficial owners of the Class B shares represented by those ADSs.

 

126


Table of Contents

Taxation of Dividends. Distributions of cash with respect to the Class B shares or ADSs (other than distributions in redemption of the Class B shares that are treated as sales or exchanges under Section 302(b) of the Code or upon our liquidation) will, to the extent made from our current or accumulated earnings and profits as determined under U.S. federal income tax principles, constitute dividends for U.S. federal income tax purposes. Whether such current or accumulated earnings and profits will be sufficient for all such distributions on the Class B shares or ADSs to qualify as dividends for U.S. federal income tax purposes depends on our future profitability and other factors, many of which are beyond our control.

We do not currently maintain calculations of our earnings and profits under U.S. federal income tax principles. Unless and until these calculations are made, distributions should be presumed to be taxable dividends for U.S. federal income tax purposes. As used below, the term “dividend” means a distribution that constitutes a dividend for U.S. federal income tax purposes. In general, cash dividends (including amounts withheld in respect of Argentine taxes) paid with respect to:

 

    the Class B shares generally will be includible in the gross income of a U.S. holder as ordinary income on the day on which the dividends are received by the U.S. holder; or

 

    the Class B shares represented by ADSs generally will be includible in the gross income of a U.S. holder as ordinary income on the day on which the dividends are received by the depositary;

and, in either case, these dividends will not be eligible for the dividends received deduction allowed to corporations. To the extent that a distribution by us exceeds the amount of our earnings and profits, it will be treated as a non-taxable return of capital to the extent of the U.S. holder’s adjusted tax basis in the Class B shares or ADSs, and thereafter as capital gain.

Subject to certain exceptions for short-term and hedged positions, the amount of dividends received by certain U.S. holders (including individuals) with respect to the ADSs will be subject to taxation at a maximum rate of 20% under current law if the dividends represent “qualified dividend income”. Dividends paid on the ADSs will be treated as qualified dividend income if (i) the ADSs are readily tradable on an established securities market in the United States and (ii) we were not in the year prior to the year in which the dividend was paid, and are not in the year in which the dividend is paid, a PFIC. Under current guidance issued by the IRS, the ADSs (but not the Class B shares) should qualify as readily tradable on an established securities market in the United States so long as they are listed on the NYSE, but no assurances can be given that the ADSs will be or remain readily tradable under future guidance. See “Passive Foreign Investment Companies” below for a discussion of the PFIC rules.

In addition, the U.S. Treasury Department has indicated that it continues to consider whether detailed information reporting guidance is necessary pursuant to which holders of ADSs and intermediaries through whom such securities are held will be permitted to rely on certifications from issuers to establish that dividends are treated as qualified dividend income. However, no such detailed procedures have yet been issued and therefore we are not certain that we will be able to comply with them. You should consult your own tax advisors regarding the availability of the preferential dividend tax rate in light of your own particular circumstances.

Dividends paid in Pesos will be includible in the gross income of a U.S. holder in a U.S. dollar amount calculated by reference to the exchange rate in effect on the day they are received by the U.S. holder, in the case of Class B shares, or the depositary, in the case of Class B shares represented by ADSs, regardless of whether the payment is in fact converted to U.S. dollars. If dividends paid in Pesos are converted into U.S. dollars on the day they are received by the U.S. holder or the depositary, as the case may be, U.S. holders should not be required to recognize foreign currency gain or loss in respect of the dividend income. Generally, any gain or loss resulting from currency exchange fluctuations during the period from the date the dividend payment is included in the gross income of a U.S. holder through the date such payment is converted into U.S. dollars (or otherwise disposed of) will be treated as U.S. source ordinary income or loss. However, U.S. holders should consult their own tax advisors regarding the treatment of any foreign currency gain or loss if any Pesos received by the U.S. holder or the depositary are not converted into U.S. dollars on the date of receipt.

A U.S. holder will be entitled, subject to a number of complex limitations and conditions, to claim a U.S. foreign tax credit in respect of any Argentine income taxes withheld on dividends received on shares. The limitation on foreign taxes eligible for credit is calculated separately with respect to specific classes of income. For this purpose, the dividends should generally constitute “passive category income,” or in the case of certain U.S. holders, “general category income”. U.S. holders who do not elect to claim a credit for any foreign taxes paid during the taxable year may instead claim a deduction of such Argentine income taxes, provided that the U.S. holder elects to deduct (rather than credit) all foreign income taxes paid or accrued for the taxable year. Dividends received with respect to the Class B shares or ADSs will be treated as foreign source income, which may be relevant in calculating a U.S. holder’s foreign tax credit limitation. The rules relating to computing foreign tax credits or deducting foreign taxes are extremely complex, and U.S. holders are urged to consult their independent tax advisors regarding the availability of foreign tax credits with respect to any Argentine income taxes withheld from a dividend on the Class B shares or ADSs. The IRS has expressed concern that intermediaries in connection with depositary arrangements may be taking actions that are inconsistent with the claiming of foreign tax credits by U.S. persons who are holders of depositary shares. Accordingly, investors should be aware that the discussion above regarding the availability of foreign tax credits for Argentine withholding tax on dividends paid with respect to Class B shares represented by ADSs could be affected by future action taken by the IRS.

Taxation of Capital Gains. Deposits and withdrawals of Class B shares by U.S. holders in exchange for ADSs will not result in the realization of gain or loss for U.S. federal income tax purposes.

In general, gain or loss realized by a U.S. holder on the sale, redemption or other taxable disposition of Class B shares or ADSs will be subject to U.S. federal income taxation as capital gain or loss in an amount equal to the difference between the amount realized (including

 

127


Table of Contents

the gross amount of the proceeds of the sale or other taxable disposition before the deduction of any Argentine tax) on the taxable disposition and such U.S. holder’s adjusted basis in the Class B shares or the ADSs. Capital gains of certain non-corporate U.S. holders, including individuals, derived with respect to capital assets held for more than one year may be eligible for various reduced rates of taxation. For example, for capital assets held for over one year, the maximum rate of tax under current law generally will be 20% (rather than the higher rates of tax generally applicable to items of ordinary income). The deductibility of capital losses is subject to limitations. Any gain or loss realized by a U.S. holder will generally be treated as a U.S. source gain or loss for U.S. foreign tax credit purposes.

If Argentine withholding tax is imposed on the sale or disposition of Class B shares or ADSs, the amount realized by a U.S. holder will include the gross amount of the proceeds of such sale or disposition before deduction of the Argentine withholding tax. The availability of U.S. foreign tax credits for these Argentine taxes and any Argentine taxes imposed on distributions that do not constitute dividends for U.S. tax purposes is subject to various limitations and involves the application of rules that depend on a U.S. holder’s particular circumstances. In particular, because any gain from the sale or other disposition of Class B shares or ADSs generally will be treated as U.S. source income, a U.S. holder may not be able to fully utilize its U.S. foreign tax credits in respect of such Argentine withholding taxes unless such U.S. holder has other income from foreign sources. U.S. holders are urged to consult their own tax advisors regarding the application of the U.S. foreign tax credit rules to their investment in, and disposition of, Class B shares or ADSs.

Passive Foreign Investment Companies. U.S. holders should carefully consider the discussion below regarding our potential treatment as a PFIC for U.S. federal income tax purposes.

In general, if during any taxable year of a non-U.S. corporation, 75% or more of the corporation’s gross income consists of certain types of “passive” income, or the average value of the “passive assets” of the corporation (generally assets that generate passive income) is 50% or more of the average value of all the corporation’s assets, the corporation will be treated as a PFIC under U.S. federal income tax law. Passive income for this purpose generally includes interest, dividends, royalties, rents and gains from commodities and securities transactions. Certain exceptions are provided, however, for passive income derived in the conduct of an active business.

We do not believe that we were a PFIC for our most recent taxable year and do not expect to be a PFIC for our current taxable year. However, we have been unable to determine with certainty whether we were a PFIC in the past because the application of the PFIC rules to banks is unclear under present U.S. federal income tax law. Banks generally derive a substantial part of their income from assets that are interest bearing or that otherwise could be considered passive under the PFIC rules. The IRS has issued a notice and has proposed regulations that exclude from passive income any income derived in the active conduct of a banking business by a qualifying foreign bank (the “active bank exception”). The IRS notice and proposed regulations have different requirements for qualifying as a foreign bank, and for determining the banking income that may be excluded from passive income under the active bank exception. Moreover, the proposed regulations have been outstanding since 1995 and will not be effective unless finalized.

Because final regulations have not been issued and because the definition of banking income for purposes of the active bank exception is unclear under both the notice and the proposed regulations, our status under the PFIC rules is subject to uncertainty. We conduct, and intend to continue to conduct, a significant banking business, and therefore we believe we should qualify as an active foreign bank. However, there can be no assurance that a sufficient amount of our assets will be treated as generating qualifying banking income to avoid our characterization as a PFIC. In particular, we have in the past held a significant amount of cash and securities that may have been considered passive assets, even if we are treated as an active foreign bank. Accordingly, U.S. holders that held our Class B shares or ADSs in certain periods in the past (with respect to which it is not entirely clear whether we were a PFIC) or persons that are U.S. holders of our Class B shares or ADSs in any future periods in which we are a PFIC (with respect to which we cannot preclude with certainty) could be subject to U.S. federal income tax under the rules described below. U.S. holders should consult their tax advisors regarding this issue.

If we are treated as a PFIC for any taxable year, a U.S. holder would be subject to special rules (and may be subject to increased tax liability and form filing requirements) with respect to (a) any gain realized on the sale or other disposition of Class B shares or ADSs, and (b) any “excess distribution” made by us to the U.S. holder (generally, any distribution during a taxable year in which distributions to the U.S. holder on the Class B shares or ADSs exceed 125% of the average annual distributions the U.S. holder received on the Class B shares or ADSs during the preceding three taxable years or, if shorter, the U.S. holder’s holding period for the Class B shares or ADSs). Under those rules, (a) the gain or excess distribution would be allocated ratably over the U.S. holder’s holding period for the Class B shares or ADSs, (b) the amount allocated to the taxable year in which the gain or excess distribution is realized and to taxable years before the first day on which we became a PFIC would be taxable as ordinary income, (c) the amount allocated to each prior year in which we were a PFIC would be subject to U.S. federal income tax at the highest tax rate in effect for that year and (d) the interest charge generally applicable to underpayments of U.S. federal income tax would be imposed in respect of the tax attributable to each prior year in which we were a PFIC. In addition, as discussed above, a U.S. holder would not be entitled to (if otherwise eligible for) the preferential reduced rate of tax payable on certain dividend income.

A U.S. holder may mitigate these effects by electing mark-to-market treatment for its ADSs or Class B shares, provided the relevant shares constitute “marketable stock” as defined in Treasury regulations. Our ADSs and our Class B shares will be “marketable stock” if they are “regularly traded” on a “qualified exchange or other market”. The term “qualified exchange or other market” includes the NYSE where our ADSs are listed. Our ADSs will be “regularly traded” if they are traded on at least 15 days during each calendar quarter, other than in de minimis quantities. No assurance can be provided that our ADSs will be characterized as regularly traded on a qualified exchange or other market for this purpose. Our Class B shares will be treated as listed on a “qualified exchange or other market” for purposes of the relevant Treasury regulations if the exchange on which they are listed has sufficient trading volume, listing, financial disclosure and surveillance, is regulated or supervised by a governmental authority of the country in which the market is located, and meets certain other characteristics. It is unclear whether the MERVAL and MAE would meet these requirements and whether there would be sufficient trading of the Class B shares for the Class B shares to be characterized as “regularly traded”. It is therefore unclear whether a U.S. holder would be able to elect mark-to-market treatment for the Class B shares.

 

128


Table of Contents

A U.S. holder electing the mark-to-market regime generally would compute gain or loss at the end of each taxable year as if the Class B shares or ADSs had been sold at fair market value. Any gain recognized by the U.S. holder under mark-to-market treatment, or on an actual sale, would be treated as ordinary income, and the U.S. holder would be allowed an ordinary deduction for any decrease in the value of Class B shares or ADSs as of the end of any taxable year, and for any loss recognized on an actual sale, but only to the extent, in each case, of previously included mark-to-market income not offset by previously deducted decreases in value. Any loss on an actual sale of Class B shares or ADSs would be a capital loss to the extent in excess of previously included mark-to-market income not offset by previously deducted decreases in value. A U.S. holder’s tax basis in Class B shares or ADSs would increase or decrease by gain or loss taken into account under the mark-to-market regime.

A mark-to-market election under the PFIC rules applies to all future years of an electing U.S. holder during which the Class B shares or ADSs are regularly traded on a qualifying exchange, unless revoked with the IRS’s consent.

If we are characterized as a PFIC and, at any time, we have non-U.S. subsidiaries that are classified as PFICs, U.S. holders generally will be deemed to own, and also would be subject to the PFIC rules with respect to, their indirect ownership interests in that lower-tier PFIC. If we are characterized as a PFIC, the U.S. holder could incur liability for the deferred tax and interest charge described above if either:

 

(1) we receive a distribution from, or dispose of all or part of our interest in, the lower-tier PFIC or

 

(2) the U.S. holder disposes of all or part of its Class B shares or ADSs.

A mark-to-market election under the PFIC rules with respect to shares would not apply to a lower-tier PFIC, and a U.S. holder would not be able to make such a mark-to-market election in respect of its indirect ownership interest in that lower-tier PFIC. Consequently, U.S. holders of shares could be subject to the PFIC rules with respect to income of the lower-tier PFIC the value of which already had been taken into account indirectly via mark-to-market adjustments.

Furthermore, if we are characterized as a PFIC, a U.S. holder will be required to annually file an IRS Form 8621. Under recent legislation, the statute of limitations on assessment and collections will remain open with respect to unreported PFIC interests.

Information Reporting and Backup Withholding. Information reporting requirements will apply to dividends in respect of the Class B shares or ADSs or the proceeds from the sale, exchange, or redemption of the Class B shares or ADSs paid within the United States (and, in some cases, outside of the United States) to U.S. holders, unless, in either case, the U.S. holder is an exempt recipient (such as a corporation). A 28% backup withholding tax may apply to such amounts if the U.S. holder fails to provide an accurate taxpayer identification number or to report interest and dividends required to be shown on its U.S. federal income tax returns. The amount of any backup withholding from a payment to a U.S. holder will be allowed as a credit against the U.S. holder’s U.S. federal income tax liability, provided that the required information is timely furnished to the IRS. U.S. holders should consult their tax advisers about these rules and any other reporting obligations that may apply to the ownership or disposition of Class B shares or ADSs, including requirements related to the holding of certain foreign financial assets.

FATCA. Beginning on January 1, 2019 (or, if later, the date on which final regulations are published defining the term “foreign passthru payment”), we may be required, pursuant to Sections 1471 through 1474 of the Code, and the regulations promulgated thereunder (often referred to as the “Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act” or “FATCA”) to withhold U.S. tax at a 30% rate on all or a portion of any distributions on Class B shares or ADSs which are treated as “foreign passthru payments.”

We have entered into an agreement with the IRS effective June 30, 2014, pursuant to which we have agreed to certain due diligence, information reporting and withholding obligations under FATCA. Therefore, an investor considered to have a “U.S. account” maintained by us may be required to provide certain information regarding such investor (or relevant beneficial owner of the Class B shares or ADSs) or be subject to U.S. withholding tax on any distribution on Class B shares or ADSs that is treated as a “foreign passthru payment.” Investors in Class B shares or ADSs that are non-U.S. financial institutions, or non-U.S. financial institutions that receive payments on behalf of other persons, and that have not entered into an agreement with the IRS (or otherwise established an exemption from FATCA) would also be subject to this U.S. withholding tax.

Generally, under FATCA, a U.S. account is a financial account maintained by a foreign financial institution that is held by one or more specified U.S. persons or U.S.-owned foreign entities. However, an equity instrument in a financial institution that is regularly traded on an established securities market is not a financial account. Further, a “financial account” does not include an equity instrument in a financial institution, such as us, that is not engaged (or holding itself out as engaged) primarily in certain investment activities, unless the value of the equity instrument is determined, directly or indirectly, primarily by reference to assets giving rise to withholdable payments and certain other requirements are met.

FATCA is particularly complex and its application to us is uncertain at this time. Each holder of Class B shares or ADRs should consult its own tax adviser to obtain a more detailed explanation of FATCA and to learn how FATCA might affect each holder in its particular circumstances.

 

129


Table of Contents

Material Argentine tax considerations relating to our Class B shares and ADSs

The following discussion is a summary of the material Argentine tax considerations relating to the purchase, ownership and disposition of our Class B shares or ADSs.

Amendments to the Argentine Income Tax Law. On September 23, 2013, Law No. 26,893 was published in the Official Gazette, incorporating amendments to the Argentine Income Tax Law in connection with, among others, the taxation of dividend distributions and gains derived from transfers of shares and other securities. Law No. 26,893 became effective on September 23, 2013, and applies to taxable events taking place on or after that date. On February 7, 2014, the Executive Branch issued Decree No. 2,334/13, which regulates Law 26,893.

Taxation on Dividends. Prior to September 23, 2013, dividends distributed on Class B shares or ADSs were, in general, exempt from Argentine income tax withholding except for the application of the “Equalization Tax” described below.

Dividends paid in excess of taxable accumulated income at the previous fiscal period will be subject to an additional withholding tax (the “Equalization Tax”) at the rate of 35% applicable on such excess and regarding both Argentine and non-Argentine resident shareholders. Equalization Tax is applicable when dividends distributed are higher than the “net accumulated taxable income” of the immediate previous fiscal year from when the distribution is made. In order to assess the “net accumulated taxable income” from the income calculated by the Income Tax Law, the income tax paid in the same fiscal period should be subtracted and the local dividends received in the previous fiscal year should be added to such income.

As of Law Nº 26,893’s entry into force, dividends distributed, whether in cash, property or any other kind -except in fully paid shares (“acciones liberadas”)- are subject to an income tax withholding (the “Dividend Tax”) at a 10% rate on the amount of such dividends, in respect of both Argentine and non-Argentine resident shareholders. However, if dividends are distributed to Argentine companies, no dividend tax should apply on such transactions.

The Dividend Tax and the Equalization Tax will be imposed as a withholding tax on the shareholder receiving the dividend. Dividend distributions made in property (other than cash) will be subject to the same tax rules as cash dividends. Stock dividends on fully paid shares (“acciones liberadas”) are neither subject to Dividend Tax nor to Equalization Tax.

In case both the Dividend Tax and the Equalization Tax apply, the latter should be applied first and then the 10% rate of the Dividend Tax should be applied on the remaining amount of dividends (i.e. the effective rate of both taxes on dividends would be 41.5%). Certain tax treaties contemplate the application of a ceiling tax rate on dividends (for example, 10% on gross dividends).

Holders are encouraged to consult a tax advisor as to the particular Argentine income tax consequences derived from profit distributions made on Class B shares and ADSs.

Capital gains tax. Prior to September 23, 2013, gains derived by non-resident individuals or foreign companies from the sale, exchange or other disposition of ADSs or Class B shares were exempt from income tax in Argentina. As of September 23, 2013, the results derived from the transfer of shares, quotas and other equity interests, titles, bonds and other securities, are subject to Argentine income tax, regardless of the type of beneficiary who realizes the gain.

Capital gains obtained by Argentine corporate entities (in general, entities organized or incorporated under Argentine law, certain traders and intermediaries, local branches of non-Argentine entities, sole proprietorships and individuals carrying on certain commercial activities in Argentina) derived from the sale, exchange or other disposition of shares are subject to income tax at the rate of 35% on net income. Losses arising from the sale of shares can only be offset against income derived from the same type of operations, for a five-year carryover period.

Due to the amendments made to the Argentine Income Tax Law by Law 26,893, income derived by Argentine resident individuals from the sale of shares and other securities are subject to income tax at a 15% rate on net income, unless such securities were traded in stock markets and/or have public offering authorization, in which case an exemption applies. The amendments introduced by the implementing decree 2334/2013 state that the exemption includes income derived from the sale of shares and other securities made through a stock exchange market duly authorized by the CNV. It is not clear whether the exemption also includes securities traded through a stock exchange market duly authorized by the CNV (i.e. in addition to publicly offered securities), or whether the exemption only includes securities made through a stock exchange market duly authorized by the CNV. Certain qualified tax authorities publicly held the latter opinion in tax conferences.

Capital gains obtained by non-Argentine resident individuals or non-Argentine entities from the sale, exchange or other disposition of shares would be subject to income tax, as the above-mentioned exemption for shares is not applicable to non-Argentine beneficiaries. Therefore, the gain derived from the disposition of shares would be subject to Argentine income tax at a 15% rate on the net capital gain or at a 13,5% rate on the gross price. The purchaser of the shares, whether Argentine resident or not, will be under the obligation to withhold the tax due by the seller and pay it to the Argentine tax authorities, although the Argentine tax authorities have not yet implemented any mechanism to make such withholding and payment when both seller and purchaser are non-Argentine residents.

Holders are encouraged to consult a tax advisor as to the particular Argentine income tax consequences derived from holding and disposing of Class B shares and ADSs.

Personal assets tax. Argentine entities, such as us, have to pay the personal assets tax corresponding to Argentine and foreign domiciled individuals and foreign domiciled entities for the holding of company shares at December 31 of each year. The applicable tax rate is 0.5% and is levied on the proportional net worth value (“valor patrimonial proporcional”), or the book value, of the shares arising from the last

 

130


Table of Contents

balance sheet. Pursuant to the Personal Assets Tax Law, the Argentine company is entitled to seek reimbursement of such paid tax from the applicable Argentine domiciled individuals and/or foreign domiciled shareholders. The Argentine company may seek this reimbursement of Personal Assets Tax by setting off the applicable tax against any amount due to its shareholders or in any other way or, under certain circumstances, waive its right under Argentine law to seek reimbursement from the shareholders.

Holders are encouraged to consult a tax advisor as to the particular Argentine personal assets tax consequences derived from the holding of Class B shares and ADSs.

Value added tax. The sale, exchange or other disposition of our Class B shares or ADSs and the distribution of dividends are exempted from the value added tax.

Tax on debits and credits on Argentine bank accounts. All credits to and debits from bank accounts held at Argentine financial institutions, as well as certain cash payments, are subject to this tax, which is assessed at a general rate of 0.6%. There are also increased rates of 1.2% and reduced rates of 0.075%. Owners of bank accounts subject to the general 0.6% rate may consider 34% of the tax paid upon credits to such bank accounts as a tax credit. The taxpayers that are subject to the 1.2% rate may consider 17% of all tax paid upon credits to such bank accounts as a credit. Such amounts can be utilized as a credit for income tax or tax on presumed minimum income. Whenever financial institutions governed by Law No. 21.526 make payments acting in their own name and behalf, the application of this tax is restricted to certain specific transactions. Such specific transactions include, among others, dividends or profits distributions.

Tax on minimum presumed income. Entities domiciled in Argentina are subject to this tax at the rate of 1% applicable over the total value of their assets, above an aggregate amount of AR$ 200,000. Specifically, the Law establishes that banks, other financial institutions and insurance companies will consider a taxable base equal to 20% of the value of taxable assets. This tax shall be payable only to the extent the income tax determined for any fiscal year does not equal or exceed the amount owed under the tax on minimum presumed income. In such case, only the difference between the tax on minimum presumed income determined for such fiscal year and the income tax determined for that fiscal year shall be paid. Any tax on minimum presumed income paid will be applied as a credit toward income tax owed in the immediately-following ten fiscal years. Please note that shares and other equity participations in entities subject to tax on minimum presumed income are exempt from this tax.

Holders are encouraged to consult a tax advisor as to the particular Argentine tax on minimum presumed income consequences derived from the holding of Class B shares and ADSs.

Gross turnover tax. In addition, gross turnover tax could be applicable to Argentine residents on the transfer of Class B shares or ADSs and on the perception of dividends to the extent such activity is conducted on a regular basis within an Argentine province or within the City of Buenos Aires. However, under the Tax Code of the City of Buenos Aires, any transaction with shares as well as the perception of dividends are exempt from gross turnover tax. Holders of Class B shares and ADSs are encouraged to consult a tax advisor as to the particular gross turnover tax consequences of holding and disposing of Class B shares and ADSs in the involved jurisdictions. Different tax authorities (i.e., City of Buenos Aires, Corrientes, Córdoba, Tucumán, Province of Buenos Aires and Salta, among others) have established collection regimes for gross turnover tax purposes applicable to those credits verified in accounts opened at financial entities, of any type and/or nature and including all branch offices, irrespective of territorial location. These regimes apply to those taxpayers included in the lists provided monthly by the tax authorities of each jurisdiction. The applicable rates may vary depending on the jurisdiction involved. Collections made under these regimes shall be considered as a payment on account of the turnover tax. Note that certain jurisdictions have excluded the application of these regimes on certain financial transactions. Holders shall corroborate the existence of any exclusions to these regimes in accordance with the jurisdiction involved.

Stamp taxes. Contracts entered into for consideration may be subject to stamp tax in certain Argentine provinces or in the City of Buenos Aires in case agreements related to the transfer of our Class B shares or ADSs is performed or executed within such jurisdictions. In the City of Buenos Aires, acts or instruments related to the negotiation of shares and other securities duly authorized for its public offering by the CNV are exempt from stamp tax. Holders of Class B shares and ADSs are encouraged to consult a tax advisor as to the particular stamp tax consequences arising in the involved jurisdictions.

Other taxes. There are no Argentine inheritance or succession taxes applicable to the ownership, transfer or disposition of our Class B shares or ADSs, except for the province of Buenos Aires and Entre Ríos. In such jurisdictions, there is a tax on free transmission of assets, including inheritance, legacies, donations, etc. Since January 2011, the tax rates have been set between 4% and 21.925% according to the taxable base and the degree of kinship involved. Free transmission of Class B shares or ADSs could be subject to this tax. Holders of Class B shares and ADSs are encouraged to consult a tax advisor as to the particular tax consequences arising in the involved jurisdictions.

Court tax. In the event that it becomes necessary to institute enforcement proceedings in relation to our Class B shares and ADSs in the federal courts of Argentina or the courts sitting in the City of Buenos Aires, a court tax (currently at a rate of 3.0%) will be imposed on the amount of any claim brought before such courts. Certain court and other taxes could be imposed on the amount of any claim brought before the Province courts.

Tax treaties. Argentina has signed tax treaties for the avoidance of double taxation with Australia, Belgium, Bolivia, Brazil, Canada, Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Italy, the Netherlands, Norway, Russia, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland and the United Kingdom. New treaties with Chile and Mexico have been recently signed but are still undergoing their respective ratification procedures. There is currently no tax treaty or convention in effect between Argentina and the United States.

 

131


Table of Contents

Deposit and Withdrawal of Class B shares in Exchange for ADSs. No Argentine tax is imposed on the deposit or withdrawal of Class B shares in exchange for ADSs.

F. Dividends and Paying Agents

Not applicable.

G. Statement by Experts

Not applicable.

H. Documents on Display

We are required to file annual reports, including exhibits, and other information with the SEC and to furnish interim information on Form 6-K. You may read and copy any documents filed by the Company at the SEC’s public reference room at 100 F Street, NE, Washington, D.C. 20549. Please call the SEC at 1-800-SEC-0330 for further information on the public reference room. The SEC also maintains a website at http://www.sec.gov which contains reports and other information regarding registrants that file electronically with the SEC.

We are subject to the reporting requirements of the Exchange Act of 1934, as applied to foreign private issuers. Because we are a foreign private issuer, the SEC’s rules do not require us to deliver proxy statements or to file quarterly reports. In addition, our “insiders” are not subject to the SEC’s rules that prohibit short-swing trading.

We prepare quarterly and annual reports containing consolidated financial statements in accordance with Central Bank Rules which are translated into English and filed with the SEC. Our annual consolidated financial statements are certified by an independent accounting firm.

We have appointed The Bank of New York Mellon to act as depositary for our ADSs. During the time the deposit agreement remains in force, we will furnish the depositary with:

 

    our annual reports; and

 

    summaries of all notices of general meetings of shareholders and other reports and communications that are made generally available to our shareholders.

The depositary will, as provided in the deposit agreement, if we so request, arrange for the mailing of summaries in English of the reports and communications to all record holders of our ADSs. Any record holder of ADSs may read the reports, notices, or summaries thereof, and communications at the depositary’s office located at 101 Barclay Street, 22W, New York, New York 10286.

I. Subsidiary Information

Not applicable.

Item 11. Quantitative and Qualitative Disclosure About Market Risk

Market Risk

Market risk is the risk of loss arising from fluctuations in financial markets variables such as interest rates, foreign exchange rates and other rates or prices. This risk is a consequence of our lending, trading and investments businesses and mainly consists of interest rate risk, foreign exchange risk and financial asset quotes.

In order to measure significant market risks (whether they arise in trading or non-trading portfolios) we use the VaR methodology. This methodology is based on statistical methods that take into account many variables that may cause a change in the value of our portfolios, including interest rates, foreign exchange rates, securities and equity prices, volatility and any correlation among them.

VaR is an estimation of potential losses that could arise from reasonably likely adverse changes in market conditions. It expresses the maximum amount of loss expected (given confidence interval) over a specified time period, or “time horizon,” if that portfolio were held unchanged over that time period.

All VaR models, while forward-looking, are based on past events and are dependent upon the quality of available market data. The quality of our VaR’s models is therefore continuously monitored. As calculated by the Bank, VaR is an estimate of the expected maximum loss in the market value of a given portfolio over a five-day horizon at a one-tailed 99% confidence interval. We assume a five day holding period and adverse market movements of 2.32 standard deviations as the standard for risk measurement and comparison.

The following table shows the 5-day 99% confidence VaR for the Bank combined trading portfolios (securities and foreign exchange position) for the last two years (in millions of Pesos):

 

     2014      2015      Change  

Minimum

     46.1         360.4         314.3   

Maximum

     474.6         663.4         188.8   

Average

     243.9         495.0         251.1   

December 31

     388.1         568.8         180.7   

 

132


Table of Contents

In order to take advantage of good trading opportunities we have sometimes increased risk, however during periods of uncertainty have also reduced it. During 2015, the main source of our VaR was the securities portfolio.

The following tables show the VaR for trading portfolio by categories for the last two years (in millions of Pesos):

 

Currency risk for foreign exchange position

   2014      2015      Change  

Minimum

     20.3         45.1         24.8   

Maximum

     131.6         85.4         (46.2

Average

     57.6         71.3         13.7   

December 31

     53.6         51.0         (2.4

Market risk for securities position

   2014      2015      Change  

Minimum

     25.6         295.6         270.0   

Maximum

     415.7         579.1         163.4   

Average

     186.4         423.7         237.3   

December 31

     334.7         517.8         183.1   

In respect of currency risk for foreign exchange position, our average VAR increased as compared to 2014 mainly due to an important increase in the average exchange rate and, to a lesser extend due to a variation in the average position in foreign currency.

The average Var for securities position increased significantly as compared to 2014, due to the an increase in the VAR for government securities (other than LEBACS/NOBACS) and for corporate securities portfolio mainly as results of an increase in market prices (DICP, PAMP, ALUA and ERAR market prices increased significantly year over year).

The following tables show the main reasons for changes in VaR between December 31, 2015 and December 31, 2014 (in millions of Pesos):

 

Change in currency risk (VaR) for foreign exchange position (YoY):

      

Change in VaR due to change in position

     (20.2

Change in VaR due to change in volatility

     0.7   

Change in VaR due to change in price

     17.1   

Total Change in VaR

     (2.4

Change in market risk (VaR) for securities position (YoY):

      

Change in VaR due to change in position

     59.1   

Change in VaR due to change in volatility

     14.4   

Change in VaR due to change in price

     109.6   

Total Change in VaR

     183.1   

Pursuant to Communication “A” 5867, in force as of March 1, 2016, market risk will be defined as the possibility of incurring losses in on- and off-balance sheet recorded positions as a result of adverse changes in market prices. The market risk minimum capital requirement will be the arithmetic sum of the minimum capital requirement for interest rate, stock, exchange rate and options risks. To meet this capital requirement, entities must apply a “Standard Measurement Method” based on an aggregate of components that separately capture the specific and general market risks for securities positions.

Commodity Price Risk

Commodity risks are the risks associated with adverse movements in the value of commodities or related indexes. We do not have any material exposure to either of them.

Interest Rate Risk

Interest-rate risk is the effect on our net interest income of the fluctuations of market interest rates. Sensitivity to interest rate arises in our normal course of business as the re-pricing characteristics of its interest-earning assets do not necessarily match those of its interest-bearing deposits and other borrowings. The re-pricing structure of assets and liabilities is matched when an equal amount of assets and liabilities re-price for any given period. Any excess of assets or liabilities over these matched items results in a gap or mismatch.

Our interest rate sensitivity analysis measures the risk arising from the different sensitivity of assets and liabilities when interest rate changes occur (“duration” approach). It covers all the assets and liabilities excluding tradable portfolios.

In this case our VaR model or maximum potential loss in the net economic value of the portfolio of assets and liabilities due to interest rate risk increases, considers a 3-month horizon and with a confidence level of 99%.

Our methodology also captures the real interest rate risk, which is the risk arising from the mismatch produced as a consequence of an imperfect correlation between inflation rate movements and financing interest rate variations.

 

133


Table of Contents

The following table shows the 3-month 99% confidence VaR for the Bank combined interest rate position for last two years (in millions of Pesos):

 

     2014      2015  

Minimum

     1,064.3         1,315.1   

Maximum

     1,282.1         1,861.2   

Average

     1,177.9         1,555.7   

December 31

     1,282.1         1,861.2   

The Central Bank removed all rules and regulations regarding minimum capital requirements for interest rate risk. Notwithstanding this, financial entities must continue to calculate the interest rate risk and remain subject to the Superintendency’s supervision.

For additional information regarding market and interest rate risk management see note 18 “Risk Management Policies” to our audited consolidated financial statements as of and for the three years ended December 31, 2015.

Item 12. Description of Securities Other Than Equity Securities

A- Not applicable

B- Not applicable

C- Not applicable

D – American Depositary Shares

Fees and Charges Applicable to ADS Holders

The depositary collects its fees for delivery and surrender of ADSs directly from investors depositing shares or surrendering ADSs for the purpose of withdrawal or from intermediaries acting for them. The depositary also collects fees for making distributions to investors, by deducting those fees from amounts being distributed or by selling a portion of the distributable property to pay the fees. The depositary may generally refuse to provide fee-attracting services until its fees for those services are paid.

 

Persons depositing or withdrawing shares may be request to pay:    For:
US$5.00 (or less) per 100 ADSs (or portion thereof)   

•       Issuance of ADSs, including issuances resulting from a distribution of shares or rights or other property

 

•       Cancellation of ADSs for the purpose of withdrawal, including if the deposit agreement terminates

A fee equivalent to the fee that would be payable if securities distributed had been shares and the shares had been deposited for issuance of ADSs   

•       Distribution of securities distributed to holders of deposited securities which are distributed by the depositary to ADS registered holders

US$0.02 (or less) per ADS (or portion thereof)   

•       Any cash distribution to ADS registered holders

Registration fees   

•       Registration of transfer of shares on our stock registry to or from the name of the depositary or its nominee or the custodian, or its nominee when making deposits or withdrawals

Expenses of the depositary   

•       Cable, telex and facsimile transmissions

 

•       Conversion of foreign currencies into U.S. dollars

Taxes and other governmental charges the depositary or the custodian, have to pay on any ADS or share underlying an ADS   

•       As necessary

Any charges incurred by the depositary or its agents, including the custodian, for servicing the deposited securities   

•       As necessary

Fees and Direct and Indirect Payments Made by the Depositary to us

Past Fees and Payments

During 2015, we received from the depositary, after withholding income tax deduction, a net reimbursement of US$149,192 for (i) investor relation expenses, (ii) annual NYSE listing fees, and (iii) standard out-of-pocket administrative, maintenance and shareholder service expenses for providing services to the registered American depositary receipts holders, consisting, without limitation, of expenses of postage and envelopes for mailing annual and interim financial reports, printing and distributing dividend checks, electronic filing of U.S. Federal tax information, mailing required tax forms, stationery, postage, facsimile, and telephone calls, incurred by us during the year ended December 31, 2014. In addition, the depositary waived the cost of various support services that it provided to us.

Future Fees and Payments

The depositary has agreed to reimburse us for expenses incurred by us in connection with the administration and maintenance of the ADSs program, including, but not limited to, investor relation expenses, annual NYSE listing fees or other program related expenses. The depositary has also agreed to pay its standard out-of-pocket administrative, maintenance and shareholder services expenses for providing services to the registered American depositary receipts holders, which consist, without limitation, of expenses of postage and envelopes for mailing annual and interim financial reports, printing and distributing dividend checks, electronic filing of U.S. Federal tax information, mailing required tax forms, stationery, postage, facsimile, and telephone calls. There are limits and conditions on the amount of expenses for which the depositary will reimburse us. In addition, the depositary has waived the cost of various support services that it provides to us.

 

134


Table of Contents

PART II

Item 13. Defaults, Dividend Arrearages and Delinquencies

None.

Item 14. Material Modifications to the Rights of Security Holders and Use of Proceeds

None.

Item 15. Controls and Procedures

Disclosure Controls and Procedures

We carried out an evaluation under the supervision and with the participation of our management, including our Chief Executive Officer and Chief Financial Officer, of the effectiveness of the design and operation of our disclosure controls and procedures, as defined in Rules 13a-15(e) and 15d-15(e) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as of December 31, 2015. There are, as described below, inherent limitations to the effectiveness of any system of disclosure controls and procedures. Accordingly, even effective disclosure controls and procedures can only provide reasonable assurance of achieving their control objectives.

Based upon and as of the date of our evaluation, our Chief Executive Officer and Chief Financial Officer concluded that the disclosure controls and procedures were effective to provide reasonable assurance that information required to be disclosed in the reports we file and submit under the Securities Exchange Act is recorded, processed, summarized and reported as and when required.

Management’s Annual Report on Internal Control over Financial Reporting

The management of the Bank is responsible for establishing and maintaining adequate internal control over financial reporting as defined in Rule 13a-15(f) and 15d-15(f) under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934. The Bank’s internal control over financial reporting is a process designed to provide reasonable assurance regarding the reliability of financial reporting and the preparation of financial statements for external purposes in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles.

The Bank’s internal control over financial reporting includes those policies and procedures that:

 

  a) pertain to the maintenance of records that, in reasonable detail, accurately and fairly reflect the transactions and dispositions of the assets of the Bank;

 

  b) provide reasonable assurance that transactions are recorded as necessary to permit preparation of financial statements in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles, and that our receipts and expenditures are being made only in accordance with authorizations of management and directors of the Bank; and

 

  c) provide reasonable assurance regarding prevention or timely detection of unauthorized acquisition, use or disposition of the Bank’s assets that could have a material effect on the financial statements.

Because of its inherent limitations, internal control over financial reporting may not prevent or detect misstatements. Also, projections of any evaluation of effectiveness to future periods are subject to the risk that controls may become inadequate because of changes in conditions, or that the degree of compliance with the policies or procedures may deteriorate.

The Bank’s management assessed the effectiveness of the Bank’s internal control over financial reporting as of December 31, 2015. In making this assessment, it used the criteria set forth by the Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission (COSO) in Internal Control – Integrated Framework (2013). Based on its assessment and those criteria, the Bank’s management concluded that, as of December 31, 2015 the Bank’s internal control over financial reporting was effective.

The effectiveness of the Bank’s internal control over financial reporting as of December 31, 2015, has been audited by Pistrelli, Henry Martin y Asociados S.R.L. (Member of Ernst & Young Global), an independent registered public accounting firm, as stated in their report which appears herein.

Attestation Report of the Independent Registered Public Accounting Firm

The Bank’s independent registered public accounting firm, Pistrelli, Henry Martin y Asociados S.R.L. (Member of Ernst & Young Global), has issued an attestation report on the effectiveness of the Bank’s internal control over financial reporting. The report follows below:

REPORT OF INDEPENDENT REGISTERED PUBLIC ACCOUNTING FIRM

To the Board of Directors and Shareholders of

BANCO MACRO S.A. and subsidiaries

Sarmiento 447

City of Buenos Aires

 

135


Table of Contents

We have audited the internal control over financial reporting of BANCO MACRO S.A. (a bank organized under Argentine legislation) and its subsidiaries (the Bank) as of December 31, 2015, based on criteria established in Internal Control — Integrated Framework issued by the Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission (2013 framework) (the COSO criteria). The Bank’s management is responsible for maintaining effective internal control over financial reporting, and for its assessment of the effectiveness of internal control over financial reporting included in the accompanying Management’s Annual Report on Internal Control over Financial Reporting. Our responsibility is to express an opinion on the Bank’s internal control over financial reporting based on our audit.

We conducted our audit in accordance with the standards of the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (United States of America). Those standards require that we plan and perform the audit to obtain reasonable assurance about whether effective internal control over financial reporting was maintained in all material respects. Our audit included obtaining an understanding of internal control over financial reporting, assessing the risk that a material weakness exists, testing and evaluating the design and operating effectiveness of internal control based on the assessed risk, and performing such other procedures as we considered necessary in the circumstances. We believe that our audit provides a reasonable basis for our opinion.

A company’s internal control over financial reporting is a process designed to provide reasonable assurance regarding the reliability of financial reporting and the preparation of financial statements for external purposes in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles. A company’s internal control over financial reporting includes those policies and procedures that (1) pertain to the maintenance of records that, in reasonable detail, accurately and fairly reflect the transactions and dispositions of the assets of the company; (2) provide reasonable assurance that transactions are recorded as necessary to permit preparation of financial statements in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles, and that receipts and expenditures of the company are being made only in accordance with authorizations of management and directors of the company; and (3) provide reasonable assurance regarding prevention or timely detection of unauthorized acquisition, use, or disposition of the company’s assets that could have a material effect on the financial statements.

Because of its inherent limitations, internal control over financial reporting may not prevent or detect misstatements. Also, projections of any evaluation of effectiveness to future periods are subject to the risk that controls may become inadequate because of changes in conditions, or that the degree of compliance with the policies or procedures may deteriorate.

In our opinion, BANCO MACRO S.A. and its subsidiaries maintained, in all material respects, effective internal control over financial reporting as of December 31, 2015, based on the COSO criteria.

We also have audited, in accordance with the standards of the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (United States of America), the consolidated balance sheets of BANCO MACRO S.A. and its subsidiaries as of December 31, 2014 and 2015, and the related consolidated statements of income, shareholders’ equity and cash flows for each of the three years in the period ended December 31, 2015 of BANCO MACRO S.A. and its subsidiaries, and our report dated April 28, 2016 expressed an unqualified opinion thereon.

City of Buenos Aires,

April 28, 2016

PISTRELLI, HENRY MARTIN Y ASOCIADOS S.R.L.

Member of Ernst & Young Global

/S/ NORBERTO M. NACUZZI

Partner

Changes in Internal Control Over Financial Reporting

There has been no change in our internal control over financial reporting during 2015 that has materially affected, or is reasonably likely to materially affect, our internal control over financial reporting.

Item 16A. Audit Committee Financial Expert

As of March 31, 2016 Guillermo Eduardo Stanley, independent member of the audit committee, met the standards set forth in Item 16A of Form 20-F for “audit committee financial experts.”

Item 16B. Code of Ethics

The Bank adheres to the best practices and requires that all its employee’s act according to the highest standards of personal and professional integrity in all aspects of their activities.

In addition to the general code of conduct that applies to all of our employees, we have adopted a code of ethics that applies to directors and senior management, including specifically to our chief executive officer, chief financial officer, chief accounting officer, as well as persons performing similar functions. The text of our code of ethics for our directors and senior management is posted on our web site at: https://www.macro.com.ar/PortalMacro/content/conn/macro/path/Contribution%20Folders/contenido/legales/Pdf/Code_of_Ethics.pdf

 

136


Table of Contents

Item 16C. Principal Accountant Fees and Services

Fees Paid to the Bank’s Principal Accountant

Since 2006 Pistrelli, Henry Martin y Asociados S.R.L. (Member of Ernst & Young Global) has served as our principal external auditor. Fees payable to Pistrelli, Henry Martin y Asociados S.R.L. (Member of Ernst & Young Global) in 2014 and 2015 are detailed below.

 

Thousands of Pesos    2014      2015  

Audit Fees

     19,952         25,882   

Audit Related Fees

     —           —     

Tax Fees

     —           —     

All Other Fees

     590         462   

Total

     20,542         26,344   

Audit Fees

Audit fees were paid for professional services rendered by the auditors for the audit of our consolidated financial statements.

Audit-Related Fees

Audit-related fees are typically services that are reasonably related to the performance of the audit or review of the consolidated financial statements and are not reported under the audit fees item above. This item includes fees for attestation services on our financial information.

Tax Fees

The auditors do not provide any tax advice.

All Other Fees

Fees disclosed in the table above under “All Other Fees” consisted of other fees paid for professional services.

Audit Committee’s Pre-approval Policies and Procedures

Our audit committee is responsible for, among other things, the oversight of our independent auditors. During the year, the audit committee reviews together with management and the independent auditor, the audit plan, audit related services and other non-audit services and approves the related fees.

Item 16D. Exemptions from the Listing Standards for Audit Committees

Not applicable.

Item 16E. Purchases of Equity Securities by the Issuer and Affiliated Purchasers

None.

Item 16F. Change in Registrant’s Certifying Accountant

None.

Item 16G. Corporate Governance

Companies listed on the NYSE must comply with certain standards regarding corporate governance as codified in Section 303A of NYSE’s Listed Company Manual, as amended. Nevertheless, the Bank, while a listed company, qualifies also as a foreign private issuer and, as such, is permitted to follow its home country corporate governance practices, governed by the Argentine Corporate Law, the Capital Markets Law and the standards of the CNV and the Central Bank, in lieu of the provisions of Section 303A, except that it is required to comply with the requirements of Sections 303A.06, 303A.11 and 303A.12(b) and (c).

Accordingly:

(i) we must satisfy the audit committee requirements of Rule 10A-3 under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (the “Exchange Act”) (Section 303A.06);

(ii) we must provide a brief description of any significant differences between our corporate governance practices and those followed by U.S. companies under NYSE listing standards (Section 303A.11); and

(iii) (y) our Chief Executive Officer (as of the date hereof, Mr. Jorge Horacio Brito) must promptly notify the NYSE in writing after any executive officer of the Bank becomes aware of any non-compliance with the applicable NYSE corporate governance rules (Section 303A.12(b)); and (z) we must submit an executed written affirmation (in relation to the members of our audit committee) annually or interim written affirmations, if required by the NYSE (Section 303A.12(c)).

 

137


Table of Contents

As required by Section 303A.11 of NYSE’s Listed Company Manual, the table below discloses any significant differences between the NYSE rules and the Bank’s corporate governance practices pursuant to Argentine corporate governance rules.

 

NYSE Corporate Governance Standards - Section 303.A

  

Banco Macro Corporate Practices

303A.01-Independent Directors- Listed companies must have a majority of independent directors on their Boards of Directors.

 

   Neither Argentine law nor our by-laws require us to have a majority of independent directors.

303A.02-Independence Tests- This section establishes general standards to determine directors’ independence.

 

(a)    (i) No director qualifies as “independent” unless the board of directors affirmatively determines that the director has no material relationship with the listed company (either directly or as a partner, shareholder or officer of an organization that has a relationship with the company). The board of directors is required to identify its independent directors indicating the criteria on which such determination was made.

 

(ii) In addition, in affirmatively determining the independence of any director who will serve on the compensation committee of the listed company’s board of directors, the board of directors must consider all factors specifically relevant to determining whether a director has a relationship to the listed company which is material to that director’s ability to be independent from management in connection with the duties of a compensation committee member, including, but not limited to:

 

(A)   the source of compensation of such director, including any consulting, advisory or other compensatory fee paid by the listed company to such director; and

 

(B)   whether such director is affiliated with the listed company, a subsidiary of the listed company or an affiliate of a subsidiary of the listed company.

 

(b)    In addition, a director is not independent if:

 

A.     the director is or has been within the last three years, an employee, or an immediate family member is, or has been within the last three years, an executive officer, of the listed company, its parent or a consolidated subsidiary. Employment as interim chairman or CEO or other executive officer shall not disqualify a director from being considered independent.;

 

B.     the director has received, or has an immediate family member who has received, during any twelve-month period within the last three years, more than US$120,000 in direct compensation from the listed company, its parent or a consolidated subsidiary, other than director and committee fees and pension or other forms of deferred compensation for prior services (provided such compensation is not contingent in any way on continued service);

 

C.     (i) the director is a current partner or employee of a firm that is the listed company’s internal or external auditor; (ii) the director has an immediate family member who is a current partner of such firm; (iii) the director has an immediate family member who is a current employee of such firm and personally works on the company’s audit; or (iv) the director or an immediate family member was within the last three years a partner or employee of such firm and personally worked on the company’s audit within that time;

 

D.     the director, or an immediate family member is, or has been with the last three years, employed as an executive officer of another company where any of the listed company’s present executive officers at the same time serves or served on that company’s compensation committee;

 

E.     the director is a current employee, or an immediate family member is a current executive officer, of a company that has made payments to, or received payments from the listed company its parent or a consolidated subsidiary for property or services in an amount which, in any of the last three fiscal years, exceeds the greater of US$1 million, or 2% of such other company’s consolidated gross revenues.

 

A non-independent director will only be deemed independent upon the elapse of a three-year look-back period.

 

“Immediate family member” includes a person’s spouse, parents, children, siblings, mothers and fathers-in law, sons and daughters-in-law, brothers and sisters-in-law and anyone (other than domestic employees) who share such person’s home.

  

Pursuant to General Resolution No. 622/13 of the CNV, a director is not independent if such director is:

 

(a)    a member of management or an employee of shareholders who hold material holdings in the listed company or of other entities in which these shareholders have material holdings or over which these shareholders exercise a material influence;

 

(b)    is currently an employee or has, in the last three years, been an employee of the listed company;

 

(c)    a person who has a professional relationship or is part of a company or professional association that maintains professional relations with, or that receives remunerations or fees (other than directors’ fees) from, the listed company or from shareholders that have material holdings in the listed company, or with a company in which such shareholders have material holdings or exercise a material influence;

 

(d)    a person who has material holdings in the listed company or in an entity that has material holdings in, or exercises a material influence over, the listed company;

 

(e)    a person who provides goods or services to the listed company or to shareholders that have material holdings in or exercise a material influence over the listed company and receives compensation for such services that is substantially higher than that received as director of the listed company; or

 

(f)     the member is married to or is the legally acknowledged partner or a family member, up to the second degree of consanguinity or affinity, of an individual who would not qualify as independent according to the CNV Rules.

 

“Material holdings” are shareholdings, either directly or indirectly, that represent at least 15% of the capital stock of the relevant entity, or a smaller percentage when the person has the right to elect one or more directors per class of shares or by having entered into agreements with other shareholders relating to the governance and the management of the relevant entity or of its parent company. Likewise, the definition of “material influence” should consider the criteria established in the generally accepted accounting standards.

 

Pursuant to Central Bank Communication “A” 5201 “Corporate Governance Guidelines for Financial Institutions”, a director is not independent if such director:

 

(a)    has control over the Bank pursuant to the guidelines set forth under Section 2, subsection 2.2.1 of the “Credit Risk Fractioning” regulations;

 

(b)    is carrying out executive functions or has carried out executive functions for the Bank during the last three years as of the day following the last day in office. In the case of public financial institutions, this term shall be one year;

 

(c)    is married to or a family member up to the second degree of consanguinity or first degree of affinity of an individual meeting the above criteria.

 

The above-mentioned Credit Risk Fractioning regulations establish general standards to determine the existence of control and a relationship:

 

In this regard, the following individuals and entities shall be considered “related” to the Bank:

 

i) any entity or person other than from the non-financial public sector of the country, having direct or indirect control over the Bank.

 

ii) any entity or person, other than from the non-financial public sector of the country, directly or indirectly controlled by an entity or person having direct or indirect control over the Bank.

 

iii) any entity or person directly or indirectly controlled by the Bank, pursuant to the provisions of section 28, subsection a) of the Law on Banks and the regulations on “Services supplementary to the financial activity and permitted activities” and “Credit Grading”.

 

iv) any Bank or entity engaged in the provision of supplementary services to the financial activity other than those contemplated in the preceding items, subject to consolidated supervision with the Bank.

 

138


Table of Contents

NYSE Corporate Governance Standards - Section 303.A

  

Banco Macro Corporate Practices

  

v) any entity other than those contemplated in the preceding items, having directors in common with the institution or entity, other than from the non-financial public sector of the country, having direct or indirect control over of with the Bank, to the extent such directors represent a simple majority of the members of the boards of each such entities or the Bank.

 

Likewise, control by one person or entity over another is defined as:

 

i) holding or controlling, directly or indirectly, 25% or more of the total voting stock in the other entity.

 

ii) having held, directly or indirectly, 50% or more of the total voting stock in the other entity, at the last election of directors or managers.

 

iii) holding a direct or indirect interest in the other entity, even if its voting rights do not amount to 25%, sufficient to adopt resolutions in shareholders’ meetings or meetings of the board or a similar corporate body.

 

iv) having direct or indirect controlling influence over the management and/or policies of the other entity, as of the effective date of the relevant resolution of the board of directors of the Central Bank of the Republic of Argentina, based on the recommendation of the Head of the Supervisory Board of Financial and Exchange Institutions (Superintendencia de Entidades Financieras y Cambiarias).

 

303A.03-Executive Sessions- Non-management directors of each listed company must meet at regularly scheduled executive sessions without management.   

Neither Argentine law nor our by-laws require the holding of such meetings and we do not hold non-management directors meetings.

 

Our by-laws provide, however, that the board shall meet as often as required in the best interest of the Bank and at least once a month.

 

303A.04-Nominating/Corporate Governance Committee- Listed companies must have a nominating/corporate governance committee composed entirely of independent directors, with a written charter that covers certain minimum specified duties.   

Neither Argentine law nor our by-laws require a nominating/corporate governance committee, however, our by-laws provide for the possibility to create a nominating/corporate governance committee. As a result of a general recommendation issued by the Central Bank of the Republic of Argentina to all financial institutions, we have created a Corporate Governance and Appointments Committee composed of three members from the board of directors, two of whom are independent, and our human resources manager. This Committee has an approved charter establishing its functions and responsibilities.

 

Directors are nominated and appointed by the shareholders, with no involvement of the Corporate Governance and Appointments Committee.

 

303A.05-Compensation Committee- Listed companies must have a compensation committee composed entirely of independent directors, with a written charter that covers certain minimum specified duties.   

Neither Argentine law nor our by-laws require the establishment of a compensation committee. The compensation of our directors is determined at the annual ordinary shareholders’ meeting. Additionally, the audit committee must issue an opinion regarding the reasonableness of such compensation.

 

However, as a result of a general recommendation issued by the Central Bank to all financial institutions, we have created an Personnel Incentives Committee composed of three members from the board of directors, two of whom are independent, and our human resources manager. The Committee’s main function is to control that the fixed and variable staff incentives -excluding directors- are consistent with the business culture, long term business plan, goals and business strategy of the Bank as well as with the applicable regulations governing the Bank.

 

303A.06/07- Audit Committee/Requirements- Listed companies must have an audit committee that satisfies the requirements of Rule 10A-3 under the Exchange Act.

 

(a)    The audit committee must have a minimum of three members. All of its members shall be financially literate or must acquire such financial knowledge within a reasonable period of time after the appointment and at least one of its members shall have experience in accounting or financial administration. In addition to meeting any requirement of Rule 10A-3(b)(1), all audit committee members must satisfy the independence requirements set out in Section 303A.02.

 

(b)    The audit committee must have a written charter that establishes the duties and responsibilities of its members, including, at a minimum, some of the duties and responsibilities required by Rule 10A-3 of the Exchange Act and the following responsibilities set forth in NYSE Sections 303A.07(b)(iii)(A)-H) of the NYSE Manual.

 

A.     at least annually, obtain and review a report by the independent auditor describing: the firm’s internal quality-control procedures; any material issues raised in the most recent internal quality-control review, or peer review, of the firm, or by any inquiry or investigation by governmental or professional authorities, within the preceding five years, with respect to one or more independent audits carried out by the firm, and any steps

  

(a)    Argentine law requires that the audit committee be composed of three or more members from the board of directors (with a majority of independent directors), all of whom must be well-versed in business, financial or accounting matters. All the members of our audit committee, as appointed on April 26, 2016, satisfy the independence requirements of Rule 10A-3.

 

(b)    Neither Argentine law nor the CNV standards contain provisions relating to an audit committee member’s simultaneous service on the audit committee of other public companies.

 

(c)    The responsibilities of the audit committee, as provided for in the Capital Markets Law No. 26,831, as regulated by Decree No. 1023 and the CNV standards (NT 2013) regarding the functions of the Committee, are essentially the same as those provided for under Rule 10A-3 of the Exchange Act, including, without limitation, the following:

 

i. issuing an opinion about the board of directors’ proposal for the appointment of the external auditors to be retained by the Bank, and ensuring that auditors are independent;

 

ii. overseeing the performance of the internal control systems and the administrative-accounting system as well as the reliability of the latter and of all financial information or other facts which could be submitted to the CNV and self-regulated entities in compliance with the applicable reporting regime;

 

iii. supervising the enforcement of the Bank’s risk management information policies;

 

iv. providing the market with full disclosure with respect to transactions that give rise to conflict of interests with the members of the Bank’s corporate bodies or controlling shareholders;

 

139


Table of Contents

NYSE Corporate Governance Standards - Section 303.A

  

Banco Macro Corporate Practices

taken to deal with any such issues; and (to assess the auditor’s independence) all relationships between the independent auditor and the listed company;

 

B.     meet with management and the independent auditor to review and discuss the listed company’s annual audited financial statements and quarterly financial statements, including a review of the company’s specific disclosures under “Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations”;

 

C.     discuss the listed company’s earnings press releases, as well as financial information and earnings guidance provided to analysts and rating agencies;

 

D.     discuss risk assessment and risk management policies;

 

E.     hold separate regular meetings with management, the internal auditors (or other personnel responsible for the internal audit function) and the independent auditors;

 

F.      review any issue or difficulty arising from the audit or management’s response with the independent auditor;

 

G.     set clear policies for the recruitment of employees or former employees of the independent auditors; and

 

H.     report regularly to the board of directors.

 

(c)    Rule 303A.07(c) establishes that each listed company must have an internal audit function to provide management and the audit committee with ongoing advice on the company’s risk management processes and internal control systems.

 

If a member of the audit committee is simultaneously a member of the audit committee of more than three public companies the board of directors shall determine whether such simultaneous service would prevent such members from effectively serving on the listed company’s audit committee, and disclose such determination in the order of business of the annual shareholders’ meeting of the listed company or in the company’s annual report on Form 10-K filed with the SEC.

 

  

v. issuing an opinion on the reasonableness of any proposal regarding the Directors’ and management fees and stock option plans proposed by the board of directors;

 

vi. issuing an opinion on the compliance with applicable legal requirements and on the reasonableness of the terms of any issuance of stock or convertible securities in case of capital increase excluding or limiting preemptive rights;

 

vii. assessing compliance with relevant rules of conduct;

 

viii. issuing a well-founded opinion on transactions with related parties as established in this Decree. Issue a well-founded opinion and inform the same to the self-regulated entities as determined by the CNV in the event of a conflict or interest or a potential conflict of interest.

 

In addition, pursuant to the provisions of the CNV Rules, the audit committee is responsible for:

 

•       reviewing external and internal auditors’ plans, evaluating their performance, and issuing an opinion on such regard upon the publication of the annual financial statements;

 

•       analyzing the various services provided by the external auditors and their independence, as established in the Professional Technical Resolutions of the Federación Argentina De Consejos Profesionales De Ciencias Económicas and any other regulations of the applicable supervisory authorities;

 

•       reporting on invoiced fees, broken down as follows: 1) external audit and other related services aiming to ensure reliability (e.g. special analyses on the verification and assessment of internal controls, taxes, involvement in offering memorandums, certifications and special reports required by supervisory authorities, etc.); 2) special services other than those mentioned in item 1) above (e.g. design and implementation of information systems, legal, financial aspects, etc.). Said assessment shall be made by the audit committee including a verification of their respective independence policies to ensure compliance therewith.

 

303A.08-Shareholder Approval of Equity Compensation Plans- Shareholders must be given the opportunity to vote on all equity compensation plans and material amendments thereto, except for employment inducement awards, certain grants, plans and amendments in the context of mergers and acquisitions, and certain specific types of plans.

 

   We do not currently offer equity-based compensation to our directors, executive officers or employees; therefore, we have no policy on this matter.
303A.09-Corporate Governance Guidelines- Listed companies must adopt and disclose corporate governance guidelines.   

Neither Argentine law nor our by-laws require the adoption or disclosure of corporate governance guidelines. However, due to our size and the importance of our business we have implemented a Corporate Governance Code based on the recommended Code of Corporate Governance for listed companies issued by the CNV and the recommended corporate governance guidelines for financial institutions issued by the Central Bank.

 

303A.10-Code of Business Conduct and Ethics- Listed companies must adopt and disclose a code of business conduct and ethics for directors, officers and employees, and promptly disclose any waivers of the code for the benefit of directors or executive officers.

 

  

Neither Argentine law nor our by-laws require the adoption or disclosure of a code of business conduct and ethics. However, we have adopted a code of conduct applicable to all our employees. In addition, we have adopted a specific Code of Ethics applicable to our Directors and Senior Officers.

 

303A.12-Certification Requirements-

 

(a)    The CEO of each listed company must certify to the NYSE, on an annual basis, that he or she is not aware of any breach by the company of NYSE corporate governance listing standards, qualifying the certification to the extent necessary.

 

(b)    The CEO of each listed company must promptly notify the NYSE in writing upon any executive officer of the listed company becoming aware of any non-compliance with any applicable provisions of this Section 303A.

 

(c)    Each listed company must submit an annual executed Written Affirmation to the NYSE. In addition, each listed company must submit an interim written affirmation as and when required and using the interim written affirmation form specified by the NYSE.

  

No comparable provisions exist under Argentine law.

 

However, the Bank is in compliance with the certification requirements of Section 303A.12 (b) and (c) of the NYSE rules.

PART III

Item 17. Financial Statements

We have responded to Item 18 in lieu of responding to this Item.

Item 18. Financial Statements

See pages F-1 through F-113 of this annual report.

 

140


Table of Contents

Item 19. Exhibits

EXHIBIT INDEX

 

Exhibit
Number

  

Description

  1.1    Restated Bylaws of the Bank , as amended and restated on April 29, 2014, incorporated by reference to the Form 6-K filed by the Bank on August 21, 2014 (File No. 001-32827).
  2.1    Deposit Agreement among the registrant, The Bank of New York, as depositary, and the holders from time to time of American depositary shares issued thereunder, including the form of American depositary receipts, incorporated by reference to the Registration Statement on Form F-1, as amended, filed by the Bank on March 20, 2006 (File No. 333-130901).
  8.1*    List of subsidiaries of the Bank as of December 31, 2015.
12.1*    Certification of Chief Executive Officer pursuant to Section 302 of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002.
12.2*    Certification of Chief Financial Officer pursuant to Section 302 of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002.
13.1*    Certification of Chief Executive Officer pursuant to Section 906 of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002.
13.2*    Certification of Chief Financial Officer pursuant to Section 906 of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002.

 

* Filed herein

 

141


Table of Contents

SIGNATURE

The registrant hereby certifies that it meets all of the requirements for filing on Form 20-F and that it has duly caused and authorized the undersigned to sign this annual report on its behalf.

 

BANCO MACRO S.A.
By:   /s/ Jorge Horacio Brito
Name:   Jorge Horacio Brito
Title:   Chief Executive Officer

Date: April 28, 2016

 

142


Table of Contents

LOGO

CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AS OF AND FOR THE THREE YEARS ENDED DECEMBER 31, 2015 TOGETHER WITH THE REPORT OF INDEPENDENT REGISTERED PUBLIC ACCOUNTING FIRM

 

F - 1


Table of Contents

REPORT OF INDEPENDENT REGISTERED PUBLIC ACCOUNTING FIRM

To the Board of Directors and Shareholders of

BANCO MACRO S.A. and subsidiaries

Sarmiento 447

City of Buenos Aires

We have audited the accompanying consolidated balance sheets of BANCO MACRO S.A. (a bank organized under Argentine legislation) and its subsidiaries (the Bank) as of December 31, 2015 and 2014, and the related consolidated statements of income, shareholders’ equity and cash flows for each of the three years in the period ended December 31, 2015. These financial statements are the responsibility of the Bank’s Management. Our responsibility is to express an opinion on these financial statements based on our audits.

We conducted our audits in accordance with the standards of the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (United States of America). Those standards require that we plan and perform the audit to obtain reasonable assurance about whether the financial statements are free of material misstatement. An audit includes examining, on a test basis, evidence supporting the amounts and disclosures in the financial statements. An audit also includes assessing the accounting principles used and significant estimates made by management, as well as evaluating the overall financial statement presentation. We believe that our audits provide a reasonable basis for our opinion.

In our opinion, the financial statements referred to above present fairly, in all material respects, the consolidated financial position of BANCO MACRO S.A. and its subsidiaries as of December 31, 2015 and 2014, and the consolidated results of their operations and their cash flows for each of the three years in the period ended December 31, 2015, in accordance with Central Bank of Argentine Republic rules applicable to the consolidated financial statements, which differ in certain respects from the United States of America generally accepted accounting principles (see note 35 to the consolidated financial statements).

We also have audited, in accordance with the standards of the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (United States of America), the internal control over financial reporting of BANCO MACRO S.A. and its subsidiaries as of December 31, 2015, based on criteria established in Internal Control – Integrated Framework issued by the Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission (2013 framework) and our report dated April 28, 2016 expressed an unqualified opinion thereon.

City of Buenos Aires,

April 28, 2016

 

PISTRELLI, HENRY MARTIN Y ASOCIADOS S.R.L.
Member of Ernst & Young Global
/S/ NORBERTO M. NACUZZI
Partner

 

F - 2


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO S.A. AND SUBSIDIARIES

CONSOLIDATED BALANCE SHEETS

AS OF DECEMBER 31, 2015 AND 2014

(Figures stated in thousands of pesos)

 

     2015     2014  

ASSETS

    

CASH

    

Cash on hand

     5,575,677        4,703,574   

Due from banks and correspondents

    

Central Bank of Argentina

     11,956,958        9,459,016   

Local Other

     17,046        17,921   

Foreign

     1,852,327        1,253,156   

Other

     813        535   
  

 

 

   

 

 

 
     19,402,821        15,434,202   
  

 

 

   

 

 

 

GOVERNMENT AND PRIVATE SECURITIES

    

Holdings booked at market value

     4,955,290        3,469,616   

Holdings booked at amortized cost

     1,005,691        336,302   

Instruments issued by the Central Bank of Argentina

     8,302,992        5,729,925   

Investments in listed private securities

     1,127,399        776,655   
  

 

 

   

 

 

 
     15,391,372        10,312,498   
  

 

 

   

 

 

 

LOANS

    

To the non-financial government sector

     748,067        604,417   

To the financial sector

    

Interfinancing (granted call)

     160,000        105,000   

Other financing to Argentine financial institutions

     67,010        107,657   

Accrued interest, adjustments, foreign exchange and quoted price differences receivable

     380        1,210   

To the non-financial private sector and foreign residents

    

Overdrafts

     4,707,889        3,385,551   

Documents

     6,550,151        4,627,375   

Mortgage loans

     3,508,512        2,466,073   

Pledge loans

     2,152,645        1,857,121   

Personal loans

     23,231,551        16,120,921   

Credit cards

     14,793,346        9,189,482   

Other

     7,078,576        5,835,233   

Accrued interest, adjustments, foreign exchange and quoted price differences receivable

     1,186,116        831,683   

less: Unearned discount

     (355,864     (205,384

less: Allowances

     (1,495,964     (1,186,044
  

 

 

   

 

 

 
     62,332,415        43,740,295   
  

 

 

   

 

 

 

 

F - 3


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO S.A. AND SUBSIDIARIES

CONSOLIDATED BALANCE SHEETS

AS OF DECEMBER 31, 2015 AND 2014

(Figures stated in thousands of pesos)

 

     2015     2014  

OTHER RECEIVABLES FROM FINANCIAL INTERMEDIATION

    

Central Bank of Argentina

     1,606,203        810,922   

Amounts receivable from spot and forward sales pending settlement

     187,196        275,223   

Securities and foreign currency receivables from spot and forward purchases pending settlement

     119,752        50,246   

Unlisted corporate bonds

     603,567        463,816   

Receivables from forward transactions without delivery of underlying asset

     —          136,613   

Other receivables not covered by debtors classification standards

     604,344        501,417   

Other receivables covered by debtors classification standards

     416,946        345,953   

Accrued interest receivables covered by debtors classification standards

     273        673   

less: Allowances

     (243,028     (235,755
  

 

 

   

 

 

 
     3,295,253        2,349,108   
  

 

 

   

 

 

 

RECEIVABLES FROM FINANCIAL LEASES

    

Receivables from financial leases

     432,506        383,668   

Accrued interest and adjustments

     6,778        5,202   

less: Allowances

     (5,352     (4,459
  

 

 

   

 

 

 
     433,932        384,411   
  

 

 

   

 

 

 

INVESTMENTS IN OTHER COMPANIES

    

In financial institutions

     1,025        1,176   

Other

     11,479        11,561   

less: Allowances

     (1,595     (1,506
  

 

 

   

 

 

 
     10,909        11,231   
  

 

 

   

 

 

 

OTHER RECEIVABLES

    

Receivables from sale of assets

     36        2,804   

Other

     983,440        607,819   

Accrued interest and adjustments receivable on from sale of assets

     1        160   

Other accrued interest and adjustments receivable

     —          14   

less: Allowances

     (4,596     (5,383
  

 

 

   

 

 

 
     978,881        605,414   
  

 

 

   

 

 

 

BANK PREMISES AND EQUIPMENT, NET

     1,180,959        925,427   
  

 

 

   

 

 

 

OTHER ASSETS

     1,405,155        808,239   
  

 

 

   

 

 

 

INTANGIBLE ASSETS

    

Goodwill

     30,684        44,736   

Organization and development costs

     464,415        364,414   
  

 

 

   

 

 

 
     495,099        409,150   
  

 

 

   

 

 

 

ITEMS PENDING ALLOCATION

     25,163        15,659   
  

 

 

   

 

 

 

TOTAL ASSETS

     104,951,959        74,995,634   
  

 

 

   

 

 

 

 

F - 4


Table of Contents

(Contd.)

BANCO MACRO S.A. AND SUBSIDIARIES

CONSOLIDATED BALANCE SHEETS

AS OF DECEMBER 31, 2015 AND 2014

(Figures stated in thousands of pesos)

 

     2015      2014  

LIABILITIES

     

DEPOSITS

     

From the non-financial government sector

     9,588,378         8,570,055   

From the financial sector

     40,145         38,683   

From the non-financial private sector and foreign residents

     

Checking accounts

     14,062,853         11,896,322   

Savings accounts

     15,507,850         11,013,878   

Time deposits

     34,719,816         21,510,754   

Investment accounts

     545,092         190,503   

Other

     1,348,989         1,137,750   

Accrued interest, adjustments, foreign exchange and quoted price differences payable

     708,475         358,609   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 
     76,521,598         54,716,554   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

OTHER LIABILITIES FROM FINANCIAL INTERMEDIATION

     

Central Bank of Argentina – Other

     12,917         16,959   

International Banks and Institutions

     97,789         87,858   

Non-subordinated Corporate Bonds

     1,383,667         909,890   

Amounts payable for spot and forward purchases pending settlement

     279,858         122,466   

Securities and foreign currency to be delivered under spot and forward sales pending settlement

     42,752         235,574   

Financing received from Argentine financial institutions

     

Interfinancing (received call)

     44,000         —     

Other financing received from Argentine financial institutions

     15,106         —     

Accrued interest payable

     39         20,489   

Payables from forward transactions without delivery of underlying asset

     562,123         —     

Other

     5,022,561         3,898,070   

Accrued interest, adjustments, foreign exchange and quoted price differences payable

     76,553         65,406   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 
     7,537,365         5,356,712   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

OTHER LIABILITIES

     

Dividends Payable

     596,254         —     

Fees

     25,721         12,196   

Other

     2,028,484         1,859,148   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 
     2,650,459         1,871,344   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

PROVISIONS

     259,493         171,923   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

SUBORDINATED CORPORATE BONDS

     1,957,618         1,287,317   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

ITEMS PENDING ALLOCATION

     21,039         6,966   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

MINORITY INTERESTS IN SUBSIDIARIES

     128,305         93,001   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

TOTAL LIABILITIES

     89,075,877         63,503,817   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

SHAREHOLDERS’ EQUITY

     15,876,082         11,491,817   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

TOTAL LIABILITIES AND SHAREHOLDERS’ EQUITY

     104,951,959         74,995,634   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

The accompanying Notes 1 through 35 to the consolidated financial statements

are an integral part of these consolidated financial statements.

 

F - 5


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO S.A. AND SUBSIDIARIES

CONSOLIDATED BALANCE SHEETS

AS OF DECEMBER 31, 2015 AND 2014

MEMORANDUM ACCOUNTS

(Figures stated in thousands of pesos)

 

     2015      2014  

DEBIT-BALANCE ACCOUNTS

     241,010,767         99,719,828   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Contingent

     19,539,120         13,422,838   

Guarantees received

     17,998,080         12,934,170   

Other not covered by debtors classification standards

     60         126   

Contingent debit-balance contra accounts

     1,540,980         488,542   

Control

     214,365,689         80,804,064   

Receivables classified as irrecoverable

     1,641,179         1,386,465   

Other

     212,111,015         78,789,541   

Control debit-balance contra accounts

     613,495         628,058   

Derivatives

     6,703,049         5,125,002   

Notional value of put options taken

     11,821         8,759   

Notional value of forward transactions without delivery of underlying asset

     3,253,734         2,432,466   

Derivatives debit-balance contra accounts

     3,437,494         2,683,777   

Trust activity

     402,909         367,924   

Trust funds

     402,909         367,924   

 

F - 6


Table of Contents

(Contd.)

BANCO MACRO S.A. AND SUBSIDIARIES

CONSOLIDATED BALANCE SHEETS

AS OF DECEMBER 31, 2015 AND 2014

MEMORANDUM ACCOUNTS

(Figures stated in thousands of pesos)

 

     2015      2014  

CREDIT-BALANCE ACCOUNTS

     241,010,767         99,719,828   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Contingent

     19,539,120         13,422,838   

Other guarantees provided covered by debtors classification standards

     163,905         112,092   

Other guarantees provided not covered by debtors classification standards

     137,227         145,861   

Other covered by debtors classification standards

     1,227,180         219,559   

Other not covered by debtors classification standards

     12,668         11,030   

Contingent credit-balance contra accounts

     17,998,140         12,934,296   

Control

     214,365,689         80,804,064   

Checks to be credited

     613,495         628,058   

Control credit-balance contra accounts

     213,752,194         80,176,006   

Derivatives

     6,703,049         5,125,002   

Notional value of call options sold

     138,521         114,479   

Notional value of forward transactions without delivery of underlying asset

     3,298,973         2,569,298   

Derivatives credit-balance contra account

     3,265,555         2,441,225   

Trust activity

     402,909         367,924   

Trust activity credit-balance contra accounts

     402,909         367,924   

The accompanying Notes 1 through 35 to the consolidated financial statements

are an integral part of these consolidated financial statements.

 

F - 7


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO S.A. AND SUBSIDIARIES

CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF INCOME

FOR THE YEARS ENDED DECEMBER 31, 2015, 2014 AND 2013

(Figures stated in thousands of pesos)

 

     2015      2014      2013  

FINANCIAL INCOME

        

Interest on cash and due from banks

     155         127         241   

Interest on loans to the financial sector

     87,991         64,293         51,468   

Interest on overdrafts

     1,407,015         1,338,170         1,074,900   

Interest on documents

     1,146,153         960,429         654,111   

Interest on mortgage loans

     556,620         483,143         333,854   

Interest on pledge loans

     385,022         274,287         197,135   

Interest on credit card loans

     2,646,060         1,930,082         1,022,177   

Interest on financial leases

     81,711         76,320         68,435   

Interest on other loans

     8,811,767         6,272,353         4,782,671   

Net income from government and private securities

     3,985,892         1,974,166         409,054   

Interest on other receivables from financial intermediation

     4,105         3,455         3,101   

Income from guaranteed loans - Presidential Decree No. 1387/01

     25,077         40,201         26,026   

CER (Benchmark Stabilization Coefficient) adjustment

     58,463         78,299         35,155   

CVS (Salary Variation Coefficient) adjustment

     669         737         606   

Difference in quoted prices of gold and foreign currency

     653,120         827,599         808,143   

Other

     259,303         358,988         286,454   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 
     20,109,123         14,682,649         9,753,531   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

FINANCIAL EXPENSE

        

Interest on checking accounts

     —           533         497   

Interest on savings accounts

     68,169         49,237         41,060   

Interest on time deposits

     6,704,910         5,137,168         3,065,823   

Interest on interfinancing received loans (received call)

     7,036         1,202         2,883   

Interest on other financing from financial institutions

     1         17         7   

Interest on other liabilities from financial intermediation

     96,022         91,733         61,674   

Interest on subordinated bonds

     136,191         120,407         80,953   

Other interest

     2,634         3,109         3,369   

CER adjustment

     4,595         9,183         4,295   

Contribution to Deposit Guarantee Fund

     418,437         151,048         67,808   

Other

     1,404,660         1,018,924         693,171   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 
     8,842,655         6,582,561         4,021,540   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

GROSS INTERMEDIATION MARGIN – GAIN

     11,266,468         8,100,088         5,731,991   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

PROVISION FOR LOAN LOSSES

     877,134         664,882         540,032   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

SERVICE-CHARGE INCOME

        

Related to lending transactions

     124,559         92,101         164,097   

Related to deposits transactions

     3,561,203         2,798,967         2,022,656   

Other commissions

     120,120         76,690         50,236   

Other

     2,309,480         1,688,030         1,189,335   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 
     6,115,362         4,655,788         3,426,324   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

F - 8


Table of Contents

(Contd.)

BANCO MACRO S.A. AND SUBSIDIARIES

CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF INCOME

FOR THE YEARS ENDED DECEMBER 31, 2015, 2014 AND 2013

(Figures stated in thousands of pesos)

 

     2015     2014     2013  

SERVICE-CHARGE EXPENSE

      

Commissions

     410,588        288,053        205,176   

Other

     1,304,245        927,706        712,631   
  

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 
     1,714,833        1,215,759        917,807   
  

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

ADMINISTRATIVE EXPENSES

      

Personnel expenses

     4,324,067        3,190,774        2,351,921   

Directors’ and statutory auditors’ fees

     233,030        163,378        117,077   

Other professional fees

     217,948        181,427        138,212   

Advertising and publicity

     143,883        128,387        103,437   

Taxes

     411,789        323,463        218,491   

Depreciation of equipment

     170,613        130,678        98,666   

Amortization of organization costs

     150,619        122,704        89,019   

Other operating expenses

     1,008,349        812,572        598,402   

Other

     565,610        445,496        300,131   
  

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 
     7,225,908        5,498,879        4,015,356   
  

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

NET INCOME FROM FINANCIAL INTERMEDIATION - GAIN

     7,563,955        5,376,356        3,685,120   
  

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

OTHER INCOME

      

Income from long-term investments

     33,692        49,635        25,132   

Penalty interest

     72,770        60,801        40,972   

Recovered loans and allowances reversed

     151,829        126,502        109,449   

CER adjustment

     30        102        63   

Other

     150,851        114,163        77,598   
  

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 
     409,172        351,203        253,214   
  

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

OTHER EXPENSE

      

Penalty interest and charges payable to the Central Bank of Argentina

     48        1,531        30   

Charges for other receivables uncollectibility and other allowances

     185,714        42,731        50,624   

Depreciation and loss of other assets

     3,748        3,196        3,051   

Goodwill amortization

     14,052        14,052        14,052   

Other

     240,122        200,840        75,931   
  

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 
     443,684        262,350        143,688   
  

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

MINORITY INTEREST IN SUBSIDIARIES

     (35,359     (23,492     (18,173
  

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

INCOME BEFORE INCOME TAX

     7,494,084        5,441,717        3,776,473   
  

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

INCOME TAX

     2,485,663        1,962,186        1,332,909   
  

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

NET INCOME FOR THE FISCAL YEAR

     5,008,421        3,479,531        2,443,564   
  

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

NET INCOME PER SHARE (1) – stated in pesos

     8.57        5.95        4.18   
  

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

 

(1) See Note 31. to the accompanying consolidated financial statements.

The accompanying Notes 1 through 35 to the consolidated financial statements

are an integral part of these consolidated financial statements.

 

F - 9


Table of Contents

(Contd.)

BANCO MACRO S.A. AND SUBSIDIARIES

STATEMENTS OF CHANGES IN SHAREHOLDERS’ EQUITY

FOR THE YEARS ENDED DECEMBER 31, 2015, 2014 AND 2013

(Figures stated in thousands of pesos)

 

                      Earnings reserved              

Changes

  Capital
stock
    Stock
issuance
premium
    Adjustments to
Shareholders’
equity
    Legal     Subordinated
Corporate
Bonds
    Voluntary     Unappropriated
earnings
    Total  

Balances as of December 31, 2012

    594,485        398,750        4,511        1,201,445        —          2,443,352        1,556,552        6,199,095   

Legal merger of Banco Privado de Inversiones S.A. (1)

    78        5        —          —          —          —          (77     6   
 

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 
    594,563        398,755        4,511        1,201,445        —          2,443,352        1,556,475        6,199,101   

Distribution of unappropiated earnings, as approved by the Shareholders’ Meeting held on April 11, 2013,

               

- Legal reserve

          298,724            (298,724  

- Special reserve for Subordinated Corporate Bonds (2)

            71,916          (71,916  

- Voluntary reserve for future distribution of earnings

              1,170,681        (1,170,681  

- Tax on personal assets

                (15,234     (15,234

Reversal of special reserve for Subordinated Corporate Bonds (2)

            (71,916       71,916     

Net income for the fiscal year

                2,443,564        2,443,564   
 

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

Balances as of December 31, 2013

    594,563        398,755        4,511        1,500,169        —          3,614,033        2,515,400        8,627,431   
 

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

Distribution of unappropiated earnings, as approved by the Shareholders’ Meeting held on April 29, 2014,

               

- Legal reserve

          488,713            (488,713  

- Cash dividends

              (596,254       (596,254

- Special reserve for Subordinated Corporate Bonds (2)

            95,326          (95,326  

- Voluntary reserve for future distribution of earnings

              1,911,651        (1,911,651  

- Tax on personal assets

                (19,712     (19,712

Reversal of special reserve for Subordinated Corporate Bonds (2)

            (95,326       95,326     

Other changes derived from the legal merger with Banco Privado de Inversiones S.A.

      744                77        821   

Capital stock decrease (3)

    (10,000               10,000     

Net income for the fiscal year

                3,479,531        3,479,531   
 

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

Balances as of December 31, 2014

    584,563        399,499        4,511        1,988,882        —          4,929,430        3,584,932        11,491,817   
 

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

 

F - 10


Table of Contents

(Contd.)

BANCO MACRO S.A. AND SUBSIDIARIES

STATEMENTS OF CHANGES IN SHAREHOLDERS’ EQUITY

FOR THE YEARS ENDED DECEMBER 31, 2015, 2014 AND 2013

(Figures stated in thousands of pesos)

 

                      Earnings reserved              

Changes

  Capital
stock
    Stock
issuance
premium
    Adjustments to
Shareholders’
equity
    Legal     Subordinated
Corporate
Bonds
    Voluntary     Unappropriated
earnings
    Total  

Balances as of December 31, 2014

    584,563        399,499        4,511        1,988,882        —          4,929,430        3,584,932        11,491,817   

Distribution of unappropiated earnings, as approved by the Shareholders’ Meeting held on April 23, 2015,

               

- Legal reserve

          695,908            (695,908  

- Cash dividends (4)

              (596,254       (596,254

- Special reserve for Subordinated Corporate Bonds (2)

            125,073          (125,073  

- Voluntary reserve for future distribution of earnings

              2,736,054        (2,736,054  

- Tax on personal assets

                (27,902     (27,902

Reversal of special reserve for Subordinated Corporate Bonds (2)

            (125,073       125,073     

Net income for the fiscal year

                5,008,421        5,008,421   
 

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

Balances as of December 31, 2015

    584,563        399,499        4,511        2,684,790        —          7,069,230        5,133,489        15,876,082   
 

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

 

(1) Includes the retroactive accounting effects of legal merger of Banco Privado de Inversiones SA as of January 1, 2013. See Note 35. 7.b). to the accompanying consolidated financial statements.
(2) See Notes 4.5.o.2) and 11.a.1). to the accompanying consolidated financial statements.
(3) See Note 10.
(4) See Note 16.

The accompanying Notes 1 through 35 to the consolidated financial statements

are an integral part of these consolidated financial statements.

 

F - 11


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO S.A. AND SUBSIDIARIES

CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF CASH FLOWS

FOR THE YEARS ENDED DECEMBER 31, 2015, 2014 AND 2013

(Figures stated in thousands of pesos)

 

     2015     2014     2013  

CHANGES IN CASH AND CASH EQUIVALENTS (Note 4.5.q))

      

Cash and cash equivalents at the beginning of the fiscal year

     18,193,305        13,512,271        10,526,353   

Cash and cash equivalents at the end of the fiscal year

     22,672,977        18,193,305        13,512,271   
  

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

Net increase in cash and cash equivalents

     4,479,672        4,681,034        2,985,918   
  

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

Causes of changes in cash and cash equivalents

      

Operating activities

      

Net collections / (payments) for:

      

- Government and private securities

     (1,381,114     (4,804,248     451,488   

- Loans

      

- To the financial sector

     74,468        215,323        (152,924

- To the non-financial government sector

     (60,705     152,978        6,051   

- To the non-financial private sector and foreign residents

     (4,443,122     5,594,127        (256,172

- Other receivables from financial intermediation

     (241,524     851,139        20,890   

- Receivables from financial leases

     31,300        77,320        1,836   

- Deposits

      

- From the financial sector

     1,462        11,809        2,652   

- From the non-financial government sector

     328,522        1,210,587        (2,246,827

- From the non-financial private sector and foreign residents

     14,281,665        4,727,295        6,305,546   

- Other liabilities from financial intermediation

      

- Financing facilities from the financial sector (received calls)

     37,003        (1,298     95,906   

- Others (except liabilities included under financing activities)

     1,804,336        1,193,222        724,159   

Collections related to service-charge income

     6,114,393        4,652,186        3,400,939   

Payments related to service-charge expenses

     (1,689,901     (1,174,403     (889,886

Administrative expenses paid

     (6,780,651     (5,091,123     (3,748,636

Payment of organization and development costs

     (250,620     (201,927     (158,508

Net collections from penalty interest

     72,760        60,798        40,945   

Differences from payments related to court orders

     (5,677     (4,938     (7,687

Collections of dividends from other companies

     22,869        27,619        100   

Other collections related to other income and losses

     56,516        17,527        81,950   

Net payments from other operating activities

     (1,087,999     (1,410,131     (735,780

Payment of income tax / minimum presumed income tax

     (2,330,121     (1,623,725     (906,557
  

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

Net cash flows generated by operating activities

     4,553,860        4,480,137        2,029,485   
  

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

Investing activities

      

Net payments for bank premises and equipment

     (382,214     (261,181     (174,960

Net payments for other assets

     (601,266     (394,756     (100,661

Collections from sales of investment in others companies

     —          11,126        —     

Other collections for investing activities

     —          —          39   
  

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

Net cash flows used in investing activities

     (983,480     (644,811     (275,582
  

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

Financing activities

      

Net (payments) / collections for:

      

- Non-subordinated corporate bonds

     (80,680     (73,443     (47,455

- Central Bank of Argentina:

      

- Other

     (4,835     (6,343     (1,334

- International Banks and Institutions

     4,851        (247,742     46,396   

- Subordinated corporate bonds

     (167,819     (121,994     (85,368

- Financing received from Argentine financial institutions

     (5,384     (3,883     11,428   

- Payment of dividends

     —          (598,486     (19
  

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

Net cash flows used in financing activities

     (253,867     (1,051,891     (76,352
  

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

Financial income and holding gains on cash and cash equivalents

     1,163,159        1,897,599        1,308,367   
  

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

Net increase in cash and cash equivalents

     4,479,672        4,681,034        2,985,918   
  

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

The accompanying Notes 1 through 35 to the consolidated financial statements

are an integral part of these consolidated financial statements.

 

F - 12


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS

AS OF DECEMBER 31, 2015 AND 2014

(Figures stated in thousands of pesos, except otherwise indicated)

 

1. OVERVIEW OF THE BANK

Macro Compañía Financiera SA was created in 1977 as a non-banking financial institution. In May 1988, it received the authorization to operate as a commercial bank and it was incorporated as Banco Macro SA Subsequently, as a result of the merger process with other entities, it adopted other names (among them, Banco Macro Bansud SA) and since August 2006, Banco Macro SA (hereinafter, the Bank).

The Bank’s shares have been publicly listed on the Merval (Mercado de Valores de Buenos Aires – Buenos Aires Stock Market) since November 1994. Since March 24, 2006, they are listed on the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE). Additionally, on October 15, 2015 they were authorized to list on the Mercado Abierto Electrónico SA (MAE).

Since 1994, Banco Macro SA’s market strategy was mainly focused on the regional areas outside the City of Buenos Aires. Following this strategy, in 1996, Banco Macro SA started the process to acquire entities and assets and liabilities during the privatization of provincial and other banks.

In 2001, 2004, 2006 and 2010, the Bank acquired the control of Banco Bansud SA, Nuevo Banco Suquía SA, Nuevo Banco Bisel SA and Banco Privado de Inversiones SA, respectively. Such entities merged with and into Banco Macro SA in December 2003, October 2007, August 2009 and December 2013, respectively. In addition, during fiscal year 2006, Banco Macro SA acquired control over Banco del Tucumán SA.

The Bank currently offers traditional bank products and services to companies, including those operating in regional economies, as well as to individuals, thus reinforcing the Bank’s objective to be a multi-services bank.

In addition, the Bank performs certain transactions through its subsidiaries, Banco del Tucumán SA, Macro Bank Limited (an entity organized under the laws of Bahamas), Macro Securities SA, Macro Fiducia SA and Macro Fondos SGFCISA.

The chart showing the organizational structure as of December 31, 2015, is disclosed in Note 4.1 with the percentages indicating the ownership in each subsidiary.

 

2. CHANGES IN THE ARGENTINE MACROECONOMIC ENVIRONMENT, AND THE SITUATIONS OF THE FINANCIAL AND CAPITAL SYSTEM AND THE BANK

The international and local macroeconomic context generates a certain degree of uncertainty regarding its future progress as a result of the volatility of financial assets, the foreign exchange market and the economic level growth, among other issues, which has been observed globally with various degrees of intensity and different behavior, over the last few years. In addition, at a local level, there is high volatility of government and private securities and in interest rates, as well as somewhat increase significant changes in the prices for other relevant economic variables, such as salary costs, the prices of the main raw materials and the exchange rate. In addition, a claim against the Argentine Government by holders of government securities who did not join the debt restructuring carried out in 2005 and 2010, which has generated consequences in the interest payment service of certain government securities, is in the final resolution stages.

Specifically in connection with the Argentine foreign exchange market, from October 2011 through mid-December 2015, there were certain restrictions to access the MUyLC (single and freely-floating foreign exchange market), the only market approved by Argentine regulations for purchasing and selling foreign exchange. As from that date, the new authorities of the Federal Government made relevant amendments to current foreign exchange regulations, while there was a significant Argentine peso depreciation with respect to the US dollar.

The Federal Government has also implemented new monetary and tax policies, such as over the regulation of lending and borrowing rates, restrictions to foreign currency positions and operations involving foreign-currency futures at the different markets, among others.

 

F - 13


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

Therefore, the Bank’s Management monitors the change of the abovementioned situations in international and local markets, to determine the possible actions to adopt and to identify the possible impacts on its financial situation that may need to be reflected in the financial statements for future periods.

 

3. BANK OPERATIONS

 

  3.1. Agreement with the Misiones Provincial Government

The Bank and the Misiones Provincial Government entered into a special-relationship agreement whereby the Bank was appointed, for a five-year term since January 1, 1996, as the Provincial Government’s exclusive financial agent, as well as revenue collection and obligation payment agent.

On November 25, 1999, and December 28, 2006, extensions to such agreement were agreed upon, making it currently effective through December 31, 2019.

As of December 31, 2015 and 2014, the deposits held by the Misiones Provincial Government with the Bank amounted to 1,579,311 and 2,303,677 (including 86,650 and 63,924 related to court deposits), respectively.

 

  3.2. Agreement with the Salta Provincial Government

The Bank and the Salta Provincial Government entered into a special-relationship agreement whereby the Bank was appointed, for a ten-year term since March 1, 1996, as the Provincial Government’s exclusive financial agent, as well as revenue collection and obligation payment agent.

On February 22, 2005 and August 22, 2014, extensions to such agreements were agreed upon, making it currently effective through February 28, 2026.

As of December 31, 2015 and 2014, the deposits held by the Salta Provincial Government with the Bank amounted to 877,967 and 1,058,824 (including 301,855 and 273,786 related to court deposits), respectively.

 

  3.3. Agreement with the Jujuy Provincial Government

The Bank and the Jujuy Provincial Government entered into a special-relationship agreement whereby the Bank was appointed, for a ten-year term since January 12, 1998, as the Provincial Government’s exclusive financial agent, as well as revenue collection and obligation payment agent.

On April 29, 2005 and July 8, 2014, extensions to such agreement were agreed upon, making it currently effective through September 30, 2024.

As of December 31, 2015 and 2014, the deposits held by the Jujuy Provincial Government with the Bank amounted to 1,439,377 and 1,545,710 (including 186,700 and 127,743 related to court deposits), respectively.

 

  3.4. Agreements with Tucumán Provincial and Municipal Governments

Banco del Tucumán SA entered into special-relationship agreements with the Tucumán Provincial Government and with the Municipality of San Miguel de Tucumán, appointing it their exclusive financial agent, as well as revenue collection and obligation payment agent, through 2011 and 2013, respectively.

On June 30, 2010, the service agreement with the Tucumán Provincial Government was extended through July 8, 2021, while the agreement executed with the Municipality of San Miguel de Tucumán was automatically extended through July 8, 2018, as set forth in the original agreement.

As of December 31, 2015 and 2014, the deposits held by the Tucumán Provincial Government and the Municipality of San Miguel de Tucumán with Banco del Tucumán SA amounted to 2,688,401 and 2,525,505 (including 750,818 and 608,089 related to court deposits), respectively.

 

F - 14


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

  3.5. Uniones Transitorias de Empresas (joint ventures)

 

  a) Banco Macro SA - Siemens Itron Business Services SA

On April 7, 1998, the Bank entered into a joint venture agreement with Siemens Itron Business Services SA, in which each holds a 50% equity interest, whereby a provincial data processing center would be provided to manage tax-related issues, to modernize tax collection systems and procedures in the Province of Salta, and to manage and perform the recovery of taxes and municipal assessments payable.

 

  b) Banco Macro SA – Gestiva SA

On May 4, 2010, and August 15, 2012, the Bank and Gestiva SA entered into a joint venture under the name “Banco Macro SA – Gestiva SA – Unión Transitoria de Empresas” which is jointly controlled and is engaged in providing a comprehensive tax processing and management system for the Province of Misiones, its administration and collection of taxes thereof. The Bank has a 5% interest in its capital stock.

As of December 31, 2015 and 2014, the net assets of such joint ventures recorded and consolidated in the Bank’s consolidated financial statements through the proportionate consolidation method amounted to 35,102 and 19,663, respectively.

Also, as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, net income recorded through the method mentioned in the previous paragraph amounted to 44,910, 35,674 and 24,513, respectively.

 

4. SIGNIFICANT ACCOUNTING POLICIES

 

  4.1. Consolidation and basis of presentation

The consolidated financial statements have been prepared in accordance with accounting principles issued by the Central Bank of Argentine (Central Bank rules).

For the purpose of these consolidated financial statements, certain disclosures related to formal legal requirements for reporting in Argentina have been omitted since they are not required for SEC (Securities and Exchange Commission) reporting purposes.

Under Central Bank rules, Banco Macro SA has consolidated the following subsidiaries:

 

     Shares      Percentage held of     Equity Investment amounts
as of
 

Company

   Class      Number      Capital
Stock
    Votes     December 31,
2015
     December 31,
2014
 

Banco del Tucumán SA

     Common         395,341         89.932     89.932     1,142,776         827,903   

Macro Bank Limited (a)

     Common         39,816,899         99.999     100.00     595,553         376,229   

Macro Securities SA (b) and (c)

     Common         12,776,680         99.921     99.932     169,286         94,160   

Macro Fiducia SA

     Common         6,475,143         98.605     98.605     18,032         17,812   

Macro Fondos SGFCISA

     Common         327,183         99.936     100.00     15,545         7,488   

 

(a) Consolidated with Sud Asesores (ROU) SA (voting rights: 100%, equity interest: 2,949).
(b) Consolidated with Macro Fondos SGFCISA.
(c) The indirect equity interest of Banco Macro SA comes from Macro Fiducia SA.

Intercompany transactions were eliminated in the consolidation process.

Furthermore, the financial statements of Macro Bank Limited (consolidated with Sud Asesores (ROU) SA) were adapted to the Central Bank rules. Also, as they are originally stated in US dollars, they were translated into pesos following the procedures indicated below:

 

  (a) Assets and liabilities were translated at the reference exchange rate at the closing of transactions on the last business day of the years ended December 31, 2015 and 2014.

 

F - 15


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

  (b) Figures related to the owners’ contributions (capital stock, additional paid-in capital and irrevocable capital contributions) were translated by applying the effective exchange rates as of the date on which such contributions were paid in.

 

  (c) Retained earnings were estimated by the difference between assets, liabilities and owners’ contributions, translated into pesos, as indicated above.

 

  (d) The amounts of income were translated into pesos, as described in (a) above. The difference between retained earnings at beginning of year and retained earnings at year-end was recorded in “Other income – Income from long-term investments” and “Financial income – Difference in quoted prices of gold and foreign currency’’ or “Financial expense – Difference in quoted prices of gold and foreign currency” accounts, as the case may be.

 

  4.2. Comparative information

The consolidated financial statements as of December 31, 2015, are presented comparatively with those as of December 31, 2014 and 2013.

 

  4.3. Unit of measurement

The Bank’s consolidated financial statements recognize the changes in the peso purchasing power until February 28, 2003, when the adjustments to reflect those changes were discontinued, as provided by the professional accounting standards effective in the City of Buenos Aires and as required by Presidential Decree 664/2003, Article N° 312 of General Resolution No. 7/2015 of the Business Association Regulatory Agency, Central Bank Communiqué “A” 3921 and CNV (Argentine Securities Commission) General Resolution No. 441.

However, the interpretation of the consolidated financial statements should consider the fact that, in recent fiscal years, there have been significant changes in the prices for relevant economic variables, such as salary cost, interest and exchange rates, which do not require such adjustments according to the abovementioned regulations.

 

  4.4 Significant accounting judgments, estimates and assumptions

The preparation of consolidated financial statements requires the Bank to make, in certain cases, estimates to determine the book values of assets and liabilities, income, expenses and contingencies, as well as the disclosures thereof, as of each date of accounting information filing. The Bank’s records are based on the best estimate regarding the probability of occurrence of different future events and, therefore, the final amount may differ from such estimates, which may have a positive or negative impact on future fiscal years.

 

  4.5 Valuation methods

The main valuation methods used to prepare these consolidated financial statements as of December 31, 2015, and 2014, were as follows:

 

  a) Assets and liabilities denominated in foreign currency:

The assets and liabilities denominated in US dollars were valued at Central Bank benchmark US dollar exchange rate effective as of the closing date of transactions on the last respective business day. Additionally, assets and liabilities denominated in other foreign currencies were translated at the exchange rate communicated by the Central Bank’s dealing room. Foreign exchange differences were recorded in the related consolidated statements of income.

 

F - 16


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

  b) Government and private securities:

 

  b.1) Government securities - Holdings booked at market value:

They were valued at the quoted prices or present values reported by the Central Bank, as the case may be. Differences in quoted prices and present values were recorded in the related consolidated statements of income, translated into pesos, in accordance with the criterion stated in Note 4.5.a), wherever applicable.

 

  b.2) Government securities - Holdings booked at amortized cost:

As set forth in Central Bank Communiqué “A” 5180, as supplemented, except what is mentioned in the third paragraph, they were valued at acquisition cost increased by the accrued internal rate of return, net of the related offset account, also compared with the present values calculated by the Bank, in accordance with the criterion stated in Note 4.5.a), wherever applicable. The acquisition value previously mentioned is related to the present value of each security at acquisition date.

As of December 31, 2015 and 2014, the present value calculated by the Bank for these securities amounted to 800,944 and 200,331, respectively.

As required under Central Bank Communiqué “A” 5506, BAADE (Argentine saving bonds for the economy development) were valued at acquisition cost increased by the accrued internal rate of return, translated into pesos, in accordance with the criterion stated in Note 4.5.a).

 

  b.3) Listed Instruments issued by the Central Bank – Holdings booked at market value:

They were valued at the quoted price as of the last respective business day. Differences in quoted prices were recorded in the related consolidated statements of income.

 

  b.4) Instruments issued by the Central Bank – Holdings booked at amortized cost:

Holdings with no volatility (active market in accordance with Central Bank rules) published by the Central Bank were valued at acquisition cost plus accrued interest, exponentially applying the internal rate of return as per their issuance terms and conditions, translated into pesos, in accordance with the criterion stated in Note 4.5.a), wherever applicable. The accruals of the internal rate of return mentioned above were recorded in the related consolidated statements of income.

 

  b.5) Private Securities – Investment in listed private securities:

They were valued at the quoted price as of the last respective business day. Differences in quoted prices were recorded in the consolidated statement of income.

 

  c) Guaranteed loans – Presidential Decree No. 1387/2001:

As set forth in Central Bank Communiqués “A” 4898, “A” 5180, as supplemented, the guaranteed loans issued by the Argentine Government under Presidential Decree No. 1387/2001 were valued at the specific acquisition value of each security, increased by accrued income including the benchmark stabilization coefficient (CER), net of the related offset account, compared in turn with the present values reported by the Central Bank.

As of December 31, 2015 and 2014, the present value reported by the Central Bank for these securities amounted to 533,962 and 429,982, respectively.

 

  d) Interest accrual:

Interest has been accrued according to a compound interest formula in the period in which it was generated, except interest on transactions in foreign currency and those whose maturity does not exceed 92 days, on which interest has been accrued according to a simple interest formula.

 

F - 17


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

The Bank suspends the interest accrual whenever loan payments are not settled (generally, after 90 days) or when the recoverability of the collection of principal or interest accrued is doubtful. Accrued interest is considered part of the loan balance when determining the allowances for loan losses. Afterwards, interest is only recognized on a cash basis.

 

  e) CER accrual:

Receivables and payables have been indexed by the CER, wherever applicable, as follows:

 

  e.1) Guaranteed loans: as explained in Note 4.5.c).

 

  e.2) Deposits and other assets and liabilities: the CER as of the last respective business day was applied.

 

  f) Allowance for loan losses and provision for contingent commitments:

These provisions have been calculated based on the estimated uncollectibility risk of the Bank’s credit portfolio, which, among other factors, results from the evaluation of the degree of debtors compliance and the guarantee/security supporting the respective transactions, considering Central Bank Communiqué “A” 2950, as supplemented, and the Bank’s provisioning policies.

When loans covered by specific allowances are settled or generate a reversal of the allowances recorded in the current fiscal year, and in cases where the allowances set in prior years exceed what is considered necessary, the excess allowance is reversed with effects on income for the current fiscal year.

The recovery of receivables previously classified under “Debit-balance control memorandum accounts - Receivables classified as irrecoverable” are recorded directly in the related consolidated statement of income.

The Bank assesses the credit risk related to possible commitments and determines the appropriate amount of allowances to be recorded. The allowances related to amounts recorded in memorandum accounts contingent commitments, are included under “Provisions”.

 

  g) Other receivables from financial intermediation and Other liabilities from financial intermediation:

 

  g.1) Amounts receivable from spot and forward sales pending settlement and amounts payable for spot and forward purchases pending settlement:

They were valued based on the prices agreed upon for each transaction, plus related premiums accrued.

 

  g.2) Securities and foreign currency to be received for spot and forward purchases pending settlement and to be delivered for spot and forward sales pending settlement:

 

  i. With volatility (active market): they were valued at the effective quoted prices for each of them at the last respective business day. Differences in quoted prices were recorded in the related consolidated statements of income.

 

  ii. Without volatility (without active market): they were valued at their cost value increased exponentially by their internal rate of return. Such accruals were recorded in the related consolidated statements of income.

 

  g.3) Debt securities and certificates of participation in financial trusts:

 

  i. Debt securities: they were valued as provided by Central Bank Communiqué “A” 4414, at their cost value, increased exponentially by their internal rate of return, translated into pesos according to the method described in Note 4.5.a), as the case may be.

 

  ii. Certificates of participation: they were stated at cost or face value increased as the case may be, by interest accrued until the last respective day, translated into Argentine pesos according to the method described in Note 4.5.a), as appropriate.

 

F - 18


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

The values recorded, net of allowances, do not exceed the recoverable values from the respective trusts.

 

  g.4) Unlisted corporate bonds purchased:

They were valued by the accrual method based on their internal rate of return, as provided by Central Bank Communiqué “A” 4414 as supplemented. Such accruals were recorded in the related consolidated statements of income.

 

  g.5) Non subordinated corporate bonds issued:

They were valued at the amount due for principal and interest accrued, translated into pesos pursuant to the method described in Note 4.5.a). Such accruals were recorded in the related consolidated statements of income.

 

  g.6) Receivables from forward transactions without delivery of underlying assets:

They were valued at the amounts outstanding originated in forward transactions of foreign currency payables in pesos without delivery of the underlying asset. Such amounts arise from the difference between quoted price of transactions on the last respective business day and the related future price agreed.

 

  h) Receivables from financial leases:

They were valued at the net investment in the lease less unearned income and calculated in accordance with the conditions agreed upon in the respective agreements, by applying the interest rate imputed therein.

Additionally, their characteristics are among the usual ones for this kind of transactions, and there are no differentiating issues of any kind compared with the transactions agreed on the Argentine financial market. These transactions are distributed among the Bank’s customers, and there are no pre-established contingent installments or automatic renewal clauses.

 

  i) Investments in other companies:

 

  i.1) In non-controlled financial institutions (less than 50% ownership interest), supplementary and authorized activities:

 

  i. In pesos: they were valued at acquisition cost, plus the nominal value of share-dividends received, restated as explained in Note 4.3, as the case may be.

 

  ii. In foreign currency: they were valued at the acquisition cost in foreign currency, plus the nominal value of share-dividends received, translated into pesos in accordance with the criterion stated in Note 4.5.a).

Such net values do not exceed the values calculated by the equity method on the basis of the latest financial statements published by the companies.

 

  i.2) In other non-controlled companies: they were valued at acquisition cost, plus the nominal value of share-dividends received, restated as described in Note 4.3., as the case may be, net of allowances for impairment in value. Such net values do not exceed the values calculated by the equity method on the basis of the latest financial statements published by the companies.

 

  j) Bank premises and equipment, other assets and intangible assets:

They were valued at their acquisition cost, restated as explained in Note 4.3., less the related accumulated depreciation and amortization calculated based on their estimated useful life using the straight line method.

 

F - 19


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

  k) Valuation of derivatives:

 

  k.1) Forward transactions without delivery of underlying asset: they were valued at the quoted price of each transaction, as of the last respective business day. Differences in quoted prices were recorded in the related consolidated statements of income.

 

  k.2) Put options taken and call option sold: valued at the agreed-upon exercise price.

In all cases, see also Note 33.1.

 

  l) Severance payments:

The Bank charges these payments directly to expenses.

 

  m) Provisions included in liabilities:

The Bank carries certain contingent liabilities related to current or future claims, lawsuits and other proceedings, including those related to labor and other obligations. Liabilities are recorded when it is probable that future costs will be incurred and whenever such costs may be reasonably estimated.

Additionally, and as provided by Central Bank Communiqué “A” 5689, as supplemented, includes provisions for summary judgments and sanctions applied by the Central Bank and other regulators, which are equivalent to the amounts not yet paid, regardless of the amounts involved and the final conclusions of each cause (see Note 20.).

 

  n) Subordinated corporate bonds:

They were valued at the amount due for principal and interest accrued, translated into pesos pursuant to the method described in Note 4.5.a). Such accruals were recorded in the related consolidated statements of income.

 

  o) Shareholders’ equity accounts:

 

  o.1) They are restated as explained in Note 4.3., except for the “Capital stock” account which has been kept at its original value. The adjustment resulting from its restatement as explained in such note was included in the “Adjustments to shareholders’ equity” account.

 

  o.2) Special reserve for subordinated corporate bonds: related to the reserve created for paying the financial services of the subordinated corporate bonds issued by the Bank (see Note 11.a.1)). This reserve is reversed on a monthly basis as the related interests are recorded in the consolidated statements of income.

 

  p) Consolidated Statements of income accounts:

 

  p.1) The accounts comprising monetary transactions (financial income (expense), service-charge income (expense), provision for loan losses, administrative expenses, among others) were computed at their historical amounts on a monthly accrual basis.

 

  p.2) The accounts reflecting the effects on income from the sale, retirement or consumption of non monetary assets were computed on the basis of the amounts of such assets, which were restated as mentioned in Note 4.3.

 

  q) Statements of cash flows and cash equivalents:

The Bank considers “cash and cash equivalents” to include the following accounts: Cash and investments which mature less than three months from their date of acquisition. Below is a breakdown of the reconciliation of the “cash and cash equivalents” item on the consolidated statement of cash flows with the related consolidated balance sheet accounts as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013:

 

     2015      2014      2013  

Cash

     19,402,821         15,434,202         12,860,529   

Government and private securities

        

Holdings booked at market value

     997,435         769,679         638,762   

Instruments issued by the Central Bank of Argentina

     2,018,994         1,809,774         12,980   

Other receivables from financial intermediation

        

Other receivables covered by debtors classification standards

     253,727         179,650         —     
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Cash and cash equivalents

     22,672,977         18,193,305         13,512,271   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

F - 20


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

5. INCOME TAX AND MINIMUM PRESUMED INCOME TAX (TOMPI)

The Bank calculates income tax by applying the effective 35% rate to the estimated taxable income for each fiscal year, without considering the effect of temporary differences between book and taxable income.

In 1998, Law No. 25,063 established minimum presumed income tax for a ten-year term. At present, after subsequent extensions, such tax is effective through December 30, 2019. This tax is supplementary to income tax, while the latter is levied on the taxable income for the year, minimum presumed income tax is a minimum levy assessment by applying 1% over 20% of certain assets as provided by the law for financial institutions. Therefore, the Bank’s tax obligation for each year will be equal to the higher of these taxes. However, if minimum presumed income tax exceeds income tax in a given tax year, such excess may be computed as a payment on account of any income tax in excess of minimum presumed income tax that may occur in any of the following ten years, once accumulated net operating losses (NOLs) have been used.

As of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, the Bank estimated an income tax charge of 2,485,663, 1,962,186 and 1,332,909, respectively, included in Other Liabilities – Other, hence no minimum presumed income tax should be assessed for fiscal years ended on such dates.

Additionally, as of December 31, 2015, the Bank made income tax prepayments for 1,431,046 for the 2015 fiscal year, which will be applied to the tax amount assessed in the 2015 tax return.

 

6. DIFFERENCES BETWEEN CENTRAL BANK RULES AND PROFESSIONAL ACCOUNTING STANDARDS EFFECTIVE IN THE CITY OF BUENOS AIRES

Argentine professional accounting standards effective in the City of Buenos Aires differ, in certain valuation aspects, from Central Bank accounting standards. The differences between those standards, which the Bank identified and deemed material to these consolidated financial statements, are as follows:

 

     Adjustments under professional
accounting standards to equity
 

Item

   2015      2014      2013  

Government securities and assistance to the government sector (a)

        

Holdings of government securities booked at amortized cost

     (26,399      (21,420      35,162   

Instruments issued by the Central Bank booked at amortized cost

     4,058         2,381         41   

Guaranteed loans – Presidential Decree No. 1387/01

     95,083         15,155         (13,614

Business Combinations (b)

        

Acquisition of Nuevo Banco Bisel SA

     (73,544      (83,157      (92,636

 

F - 21


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

     Adjustments under professional
accounting standards to equity
 

Item (cont)

   2015      2014      2013  

Other

     (48,846      (53,359      (58,060

Deferred assets - Income tax (c)

     93,593         243,854         116,694   

Other assets (d)

     —           —           1,717   

Liabilities – Provisions (e)

     (9,009      (81,534      (67,994
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total

     34,936         21,920         (78,690
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

In addition, income would have increased by around 13,016, 100,610 and 71,494 for the fiscal years ended December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively.

 

a) Holdings of government securities, instruments issued by the Central Bank and credit assistance to the nonfinancial government sector: these holdings and financing are valued based on the specific regulations and standards issued by the Argentine government and the Central Bank, which set forth, among other issues, the use of present values, technical values and offset accounts, as explained in Notes 4.5.b.2), 4.5.b.4) and 4.5.c). Pursuant to the argentine professional accounting standards effective in the City of Buenos Aires, the securities, instruments and assistance mentioned in those notes should be stated at their market and/or present values, as the case may be. In addition, current Central Bank regulations establish that financing to the nonfinancial government sector is not subject to loan-loss provisioning, whereas the argentine professional accounting standards effective in the City of Buenos Aires require that assets in general to be compared with their recoverable value every time financial statements are prepared.

 

b) Business combinations: under the standards set forth by Central Bank, business acquisitions are recorded according to the book values of the acquired company and, if the purchase price exceeds the book value, the excess amount is recorded in the acquiring company’s books as a positive goodwill. On the other hand, if the purchase price is lower than book value, the difference is recorded in the acquiring company’s books as a negative goodwill. If the goodwill is positive, Central Bank standards establish that such goodwill should be amortized under the straight-line method based on an estimated useful life of ten years. If the goodwill is negative, Central Bank Communiqué “A” 3984 establishes specific amortization methods; the maximum amortization allowed per year is 20%.

According to the argentine professional accounting standards effective in the City of Buenos Aires, business combinations are recorded based on the market values of the acquired company’s identifiable net assets and the difference between the purchase price and the identifiable net asset measurement value is recorded as either a positive or a negative goodwill, as the case may be. If a positive goodwill is recognized, this goodwill will be amortized systematically over the estimated useful life, unless it has an indefinite useful life considering the estimates made by the Bank’s Management, in which case it shall not be amortized, but compared with its recoverable value as of each year-end. If a negative goodwill is recognized due to expected losses or future expenses of the acquired entity and which should not have been recorded as liabilities as of the acquisition date, it will either be charged to the consolidated statement of income according to the change in specific circumstances that gave rise to it or systematically, taking into account an average weighted useful life of the acquired entity’s assets subject to depreciation and amortization.

 

c) Income tax: the Bank and its subsidiaries determine income tax applying the effective rate to the estimated taxable income, without considering the effect of the temporary differences between book and taxable income. According to the argentine professional accounting standards effective in the City of Buenos Aires, income tax should be booked following the deferred tax method, according to which (i) in addition to the current tax payable, either an asset (if certain conditions are met) or a liability is recognized for deferred taxes related to the tax effect of the temporary differences between the book and tax valuation of assets and liabilities, and (ii) a tax expense (income) is recognized in relation to the portion involving the current tax expense (income) as well as the one involving the deferred tax expense (income), resulting from the creation and reversal of the abovementioned temporary differences in the year. Under argentine professional accounting standards effective in the City of Buenos Aires, a deferred tax asset is recognized when there are unused NOLs or tax credits that can be deducted from future taxable income, provided they are likely.

 

F - 22


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

d) Other assets: as of December 31, 2013, the Bank recorded interest rate swap agreements under memorandum accounts in conformity with Central Bank accounting standards. According to the argentine professional accounting standards effective in the City of Buenos Aires, the measurement of derivative financial instruments should be made at their net realizable value if they have quoted prices, or lacking this, using mathematical models that are appropriate in relation to the instrument’s characteristics and using variables that can be verified.

 

e) Liabilities: the Bank books the effects of the Argentine Supreme Court (CSJN) rulings dated December 27, 2006, and August 28, 2007, upon payment of such precautionary measures, in conformity with Central Bank indications in the notice dated August 4, 2008. According to the argentine professional accounting standards effective in the City of Buenos Aires, the Bank should have recorded a liability related to this item. Additionally, as explained in Note 4.5.m), the Bank booked certain provisions that should not have been booked under the Argentine professional accounting standards effective in the City of Buenos Aires, in view of their remote probability of occurrence (see Note 20.).

 

7. IMPLEMENTATION PLAN TOWARDS INTERNATIONAL FINANCIAL REPORTING STANDARDS (IFRS)

On February 12, 2014 the Central Bank, through Communiqué “A” 5541 established the general guidelines towards conversion to the IFRS issued by the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) for preparing financial statements of the entities under its supervision, for the annual fiscal years beginning on January 1, 2018 as well as those of interim-periods.

According to such conversion process, on March 27, 2015, the Bank presented to the Central Bank, their own implementation plan together with the appointment of a person in charge, according to Central Bank Communiqué “A” 5635, which was considered and approved by the Board of Directors on March 10, 2015. Additionally, on September 30, 2015, the Bank presented to the Central Bank the implementation plan update, which was considered and approved by the Board of Directors on September 16, 2015.

As of the date of issuance of these consolidated financial statements, the Bank is implementing the abovementioned IFRS conversion process.

 

8. RESTRICTED ASSETS

As of December 31, 2015, and 2014, the following Bank’s assets are restricted:

 

Item

   2015      2014  

Government and private securities

     

•   Discount bonds in pesos regulated by Argentinean legislation, maturing 2033 securing the role of custodian of Sustainability Guarantee Fund investments.

     308,570         —     

•   Federal Government bond in pesos at Badlar private + 250 basis points, maturing in 2019, securing the role of custodian of Sustainability Guarantee Fund investments.

     103,524         92,464   

•   Federal Government bond in pesos at Badlar private + 200 basis points, maturing in 2017 and used as security in favor of SEDESA (1).

     97,292         84,569   

•   Discount bonds regulated by Argentinean legislation, maturing 2033 and Federal Government bond in pesos at Badlar Private + 300 basis points, maturing in 2015 for the performance of forward foreign currency trading transactions, respectively.

     33,651         45,274   

•   Secured Bonds under Presidential Decree No. 1579/02 as security for a loan received from Banco de Inversión y Comercio Exterior SA (Bice).

     32,606         36,748   

•   Central Bank of Argentina Internal Bills in pesos, maturing in 2016 securing the operation through negotiation secured transaction Segment as the main counterparty of the MAE.

     20,662         —     

 

F - 23


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

Item (cont.)

   2015      2014  

•   Federal Government bond in pesos at Badlar private + 200 basis points, maturing in 2017, for the minimum amount required to perform as an Agent in the new categories provided by CNV General Resolution No. 622/2013.

     15,528         13,991   

•   Discount securities in pesos regulated by Argentinean legislation, maturing 2033 securing a BID loan of San Juan Provincial Government No. 2763/OC-AR.

     9,414         —     

•   Secured bonds in pesos under Presidential Decree N° 1579/2002, maturing in 2018, for the minimum amount required to perform as an Agent in the new categories provided by CNV General Resolution No. 622/2013.

     5,613         8,284   

•   Federal secured bonds maturing 2048 for the minimum amount required to perform as an Agent in the new categories provided by CNV General Resolution No. 622/2013

     3,352         4,421   

•   Federal Government bond in pesos at Badlar private + 300 basis points, maturing in 2015 securing the role of custodian of Sustainability Guarantee Fund investments.

     —           62,043   

•   Other government and private securities.

     1,129         2,881   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Subtotal government and private securities

     631,341         350,675   

Loans

     

•   Guaranteed Loans under Presidential Decree No. 1387/01 – Global 17 at a variable rate provided as guarantee in favor of the Central Bank in relation to the auctions of advances intended for the production sector under the Bicentennial Production Financing Program.

     64,619         56,577   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Subtotal Loans

     64,619         56,577   

Other receivables from financial intermediation

     

•   Special guarantee checking accounts opened in Central Bank for transactions related to the electronic clearing houses and similar entities.

     1,541,363         810,922   

•   Interests resulting in contributions made in the Bank´s capacity by contributory partner of the following venture funds: (2)

     

-   Risk Fund of Los Grobo SGR (mutual guarantee association), with an original contribution of 30,000 made on December 23, 2014

     30,000         30,000   

-   Risk Fund of Garantizar SGR, with an original contribution of 20,000 made on December 22, 2014

     20,000         20,000   

-   Risk Fund of Los Grobo SGR (mutual guarantee association), with an original contribution of 10,000 made on December 30, 2015.

     10,000         —     

-   Risk Fund of Intergarantías SGR, with an original contribution of 7,000 made on December 22, 2014

     7,000         7,000   

-   Risk Fund of Intergarantías SGR, with an original contribution of 7,000 made on December 28, 2015

     7,000         —     

-   Risk Fund of Intergarantías SGR, with an original contribution of 3,000 made on December 30, 2013

     —           3,000   

•   Share of interest of the mutual fund Pionero Renta for the minimum amount required to perform as an Agent in the new categories provided by CNV General Resolution No. 622/2013.

     8,492         8,446   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Subtotal Other receivables from financial intermediation

     1,623,855         879,368   

 

F - 24


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

Item (cont.)

   2015      2014  

Other receivables

     

•   Security deposits related to credit card transactions.

     255,957         185,146   

•   Security deposits related to transactions of forward transactions without delivery of underlying assets.

     111,743         2   

•   Deposits mainly provided in guarantee for the credit card transaction and related to court deposits and MAEClear transactions.

     21,327         11,202   

•   Sundry receivables includes an item related to the attachment ordered in the context of a claim initiated by the City of Buenos Aires tax authorities on turnover tax differences.

     827         827   

•   Other guarantee security.

     3,746         5,098   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Subtotal Other receivables

     393,600         202,275   

Investments in other companies

     

•   Other

     1,453         1,453   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Subtotal Investments in other companies

     1,453         1,453   

Other assets

     

•   Building related to call option sold (see Note 33.1.(b)).

     103,531         105,258   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Subtotal other assets

     103,531         105,258   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total

     2,818,399         1,595,606   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

(1) As replacement for the preferred shares of former Nuevo Banco Bisel SA to secure to SEDESA the price payment and the fulfillment of all the obligations assumed in the purchase and sale agreement dated May 28, 2007, maturing on August 11, 2021.

 

(2) In order to keep tax benefits related to these contributions, they must be maintained between two and three years from the date they were made.

 

9. TRANSACTIONS WITH RELATED PARTIES

Banco Macro SA’s receivables / payables and income (loss) from transactions performed with subsidiaries and related parties are as follows. As mentioned in Note 4.1., transactions with subsidiaries were eliminated in the consolidation process:

 

     Banco del
Tucumán
SA
     Macro
Bank
Limited
     Macro
Securities
SA
     Other
subsidiaries
and related
parties
(1)
     Total
2015
     Total
2014
 

ASSETS

                 

Cash

     —           9,246         —           —           9,246         6,083   

Loans

     —           —           —           471,807         471,807         297,432   

Other receivables from financial intermediation

     —           —           —           6,414         6,414         401,646   

Receivables from financial leases

     —           —           8,761         1,417         10,178         10,458   

Other receivables

     —           —           —           —           —           993   

Items pending allocation

     —           —           —           —           —           20   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total assets

     —           9,246         8,761         479,638         497,645         716,632   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

F - 25


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

     Banco del
Tucumán
SA
     Macro
Bank
Limited
     Macro
Securities
SA
     Other
subsidiaries
and related
parties
(1)
     Total
2015
     Total
2014
 

LIABILITIES

                 

Deposits

     —           5         37,441         1,272,164         1,309,610         942,799   

Other liabilities from financial intermediation

     —           —           —           82,558         82,558         342,496   

Other liabilities

     —           138         —           1,414         1,552         —     
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total liabilities

     —           143         37,441         1,356,136         1,393,720         1,285,295   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

MEMORANDUM ACCOUNTS

                 

Debit balance accounts - Control

     —           —           —           2,089,274         2,089,274         1,272,193   

Credit balance accounts - Contingent

     —           —           1,328         129,627         130,955         3,724   

Credit balance accounts - Derivatives (2)

     —           —           —           393,836         393,836         154,555   

 

     Banco del
Tucumán
SA
    Macro
Bank
Limited
     Macro
Securities
SA
    Other
subsidiaries
and related
parties
(1)
    Total
2015
    Total
2014
    Total
2013
 

INCOME (LOSS)

               

Financial income

     1,305           2,939        29,764        34,008        27,910        33,517   

Financial expense

     (6,344          (126,411     (132,755     (36,271     (16,692

Service-charge income

     25        5         442        6,212        6,684        5,824        5,533   

Service-charge expense

          (178       (178     (1,701     (6

Administrative expenses

     (12            (12     (12     (11

Other income

     13,189               13,189        11,384        9,765   
  

 

 

   

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

Total income / (loss)

     8,163        5         3,203        (90,435     (79,064     7,134        32,106   
  

 

 

   

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

 

(1) Related to receivables from and payables to other related parties to the Bank for transactions performed in the normal course of business, under normal market conditions, in terms of interest rates and prices, as well as guarantees required. Additionally, as of December 31, 2015 and 2014, balances for transactions between Macro Group companies amounted to 798 and 527, respectively. Net income from those transactions for the fiscal years ended December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013 amount to 4, 8 and 4, respectively. Both balances and income were eliminated in the consolidation process.

 

(2) The Bank has recorded foreign currency trading transactions without delivery of the underlying asset and involving related parties, in its memorandum accounts. According to the Bank’s policy, they are matched in terms of amounts and maturity with transactions carried out with third parties who are not related parties. As of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, the net intermediation income from such transactions generated (loss) / earnings for the year of around (30,142), 14,116 and (350), respectively.

Additionally, the ANSES -National Social Security Administration (as manager of the “Fondo de Garantía de Sustentabilidad” or Sustainability Guarantee Fund), held (i) 31.50% of the capital stock of the Bank, and (ii) since the issuance of Emergency Decree No. 441 (April, 2011), 29.25% of votes. In accordance with FASB ASC 850, from April 2011, the Sustainability Guarantee Fund is considered other related party.

 

F - 26


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

Thus, as of December 31, 2015 and 2014, the Bank recorded on demand deposits made by ANSES (as manager of the Sustainability Guarantee Fund), for an amount of 2,105,955 and 199,936, respectively. In addition, the Bank recorded interest for such time deposits in “Financial Expense” for an amount of 108, 442 for the year ended December 31, 2014. Additionally, as of December 31, 2015 and 2014, the Bank recorded an amount of 173,556,927 and 55,081,889, respectively, in “Checks and securities in custody” under Memorandum accounts.

 

10. CAPITAL STOCK

As of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, the legal capital structure is as follows:

 

SHARES

     CAPITAL STOCK  

Class

   Stock number     Votes
per
share
     Issued and
outstanding
     In
treasury
    Pending
issuance
    Paid-in  

Registered Class A shares of common stock

     11,235,670        5         11,236         —          —          11,236   

Registered Class B shares of common stock

     583,327,358        1         573,249         10,000        78        583,327   
  

 

 

      

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

Total 2013

     594,563,028           584,485         10,000        78        594,563   
  

 

 

      

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

Capital decrease – Registered Class B Shares (1)

     (10,000,000     1         —           (10,000     —          (10,000

Registered Class B shares of common stock (2)

     —          1         78         —          (78     —     
  

 

 

      

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

Total 2014

     584,563,028           584,563         —          —          584,563   
  

 

 

      

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 
              
  

 

 

      

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

Total 2015

     584,563,028           584,563         —          —          584,563   
  

 

 

      

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

As of December 31, 2015:

              

Registered Class A shares of common stock

     11,235,670        5         11,236         —          —          11,236   

Registered Class B shares of common stock

     573,327,358        1         573,327         —          —          573,327   
  

 

 

      

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

Total 2015

     584,563,028           584,563         —          —          584,563   
  

 

 

      

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

 

(1) Related to capital stock decrease resulting from the lapse of three years from acquisition from September through December 2011, involving 10,000,000 own registered Class B shares of common stock for a total amount of 92,919. These shares have not been sold and the shareholders´ meeting has issued no resolution as to the application thereof. On June 25, 2015, the capital stock decrease was registered in the Public Registry.

 

(2) Related to the capital increase in the amount of 77,860 Class B shares of common stock with a face value of Ps 1, each one entitled to one vote, and delivered to the minority shareholders of former Banco Privado de Inversiones SA, in the merger process with Banco Macro SA.

 

F - 27


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

11. CORPORATE BONDS ISSUANCE

The amounts recorded in the consolidated financial statements related to corporate bonds are as follows:

 

            As of December, 31  

Class

   Original face
value
    Residual face
value as of
12/31/2015
     2015      2014  

Subordinated - Class 1

     USD 150,000,000   a.1)      USD 150,000,000         1,957,618         1,287,317   

Non-subordinated - Class 2

     USD 150,000,000   a.2)      USD 106,395,000         1,432,672         942,115   
       

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total

          3,390,290         2,229,432   
       

 

 

    

 

 

 

Maturities of the corporate bonds as of December 31, 2015, are as follows:

 

Fiscal Year

   Amounts  

2016

     55,873   

2017

     1,383,667   

2036

     1,950,750   
  

 

 

 

Total

     3,390,290   
  

 

 

 

On September 1, 2006, June 4, 2007, April 26, 2011, April 23, 2015 and April 26, 2016, the general regular shareholders’ meeting approved the creation, and subsequent extension, of a Global Program for the Issuance of Simple Corporate Bonds in a short, medium or long term, either subordinated or non subordinated, with or without guarantee, in accordance with the provisions of Law No. 23,576, as amended by Law No. 23,962, and further applicable regulations, up to a maximum amount outstanding at any time during the term of the program of USD 1,000,000,000 (one billion US dollars), or an equal amount in other currencies, under which it will be possible to issue different classes and/or series of corporate bonds denominated in US dollars or other currencies and reissue the successive classes or series to be amortized.

 

  a.1) On December 18, 2006, under the abovementioned Global Program, Banco Macro SA issued the 1st series of Class 1 subordinated Notes for a face value of USD 150,000,000 (US dollars one hundred and fifty million). The main characteristics of this issuance are:

 

    Computable to the Bank’s required minimum capital (computable equity), as established by Communiqué “A” 4576.

 

    The Notes fall due within a 30-year term, with full amortization upon maturity (December 18, 2036), with full redemption option in 10 years since the issuance date.

 

    Interest payments will be made with a semiannual frequency (June 18 and December 18, every year).

 

    During the first 10 years, the interest rate will be a fixed one (9.75%), and a variable one for the remaining years (six-month LIBOR, plus 7.11%). As established by Communiqué “A” 4576, the interest rate payable can be increased only once over the life of the instrument and subsequent to the 10-year term since their issuance.

 

    They do not include covenants that change the subordination order.

 

    No interest on the Notes will neither fall due and payable if: (i) payments of such interest is the distributable amount, as defined in the pricing supplement dated November 23, 2006; (ii) there is a general prohibition by the Central Bank; (iii) the Bank is subject to the provisions of Articles 34 or 35 bis, Financial Institutions Law; (iv) the Bank is receiving financial assistance from Central Bank for illiquidity under Article 17 of Central Bank Charter; (v) the Bank is not in compliance with or has failed to comply in a timely basis with reporting obligations to the Central Bank; and/or (vi) the Bank is not in compliance with minimum capital requirements (both on an individual and consolidated basis levels) or with minimum cash reserves (on average).

 

F - 28


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

    Unpaid interest is not cumulative.

 

    They have authorizations both for their public offering and their listing on domestic or foreign stock exchanges or markets.

 

    In no case, the payment of financial services may exceed net unappropriated retained earnings as per the consolidated financial statements for the last fiscal year, with an external auditor’s report, which should be appropriated to a reserve created to such end, as established by Communiqué “A” 4576 (see Note 16.b)).

The Bank used the funds derived from such issuance to grant loans.

 

  a.2) On January 29, 2007, Banco Macro SA issued the 1st series of Class 2 non subordinated simple corporate bonds at a fixed rate of 8.5% p.a., not convertible into shares, fully amortizable upon maturity (February 1, 2017) for a face value of USD 150,000,000 (one hundred and fifty million US dollars), under the terms and conditions set forth in the price supplement dated January 10, 2007. Interest is paid semiannually on February 1 and August 1 of every year.

Additionally, the Bank has the option to redeem such issuance, either fully or partially, at any time and from time to time. The Bank used the funds derived from such issuance to grant loans.

On August 16, 2007, the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) authorized the abovementioned exchange offers mentioned in a.1) and a.2).

 

12. ITEMS IN CUSTODY

 

  12.1. Portfolio Management

 

Item

   Managed portfolio as of  
   2015      2014  

•  On March 1, 1996, former Banco de Salta SA (which was absorbed by the Bank) and the Salta Provincial Government entered into an Agreement to Manage the Loan Portfolio of Banco Provincial de Salta (in liquidation) related to the nonfinancial private sector,

     13,976         14,026   

•  On August 11, 1998, former Banco de Jujuy SA (which was absorbed by the Bank) and the Jujuy Provincial Government entered into an agreement to manage the loan portfolio of the former Banco de la Provincia de Jujuy and to provide a monthly report on the tasks performed,

     40,389         40,927   

•  On April 6, 2001, through Provincial Decree No. 806, the Ministry of the Treasury of the Province of Salta approved an extension to the “Contract for the service of collecting, processing and arranging information, managing the loan portfolio and performing collection procedures related to the receivables of the IPDUV (Provincial Institute of Urban and Housing Development)” entered into on March 27, 2001, between such Agency and Banco Macro SA,

     89,380         110,469   

•  On June 30, 2006, the Bank and Macro Fiducia SA entered into a management and custody agreement regarding the “RETUC 1” trust loan portfolio,

     55,712         55,738   

•  On December 31, 2008, Banco del Tucumán S.A. and Macro Fiducia S.A. entered into a management and custody agreement regarding the “BATUC 1” trust loan portfolio,

     15,329         15,910   

•  On November 22, 2012, 2013, November 26, 2014 and November 30, 2015, the Bank (trustor) and Macro Fiducia SA (trustee), created the financial trusts Fideicomiso Financiero Privado “SECANE I”, “SECANE II”, “SECANE III” and “SECANE IV”, respectively; in the trusts agreement the trustor assumes the role of collection agent, administration and custodian,

     612,457         368,358   

 

F - 29


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

Item (contd.)

   Managed portfolio as of  
   2015      2014  

•  On August 19, 2002, ABN AMRO Bank NV Sucursal Argentina, as trustee, the former Scotiabank Quilmes SA, as trustor, Banco Comafi SA, as an agent and collecting manager and the former Banco Bansud SA (currently Banco Macro SA), entered into an “Agreement for the LAVERC financial trust’s collection administration and management”. On May 4, 2015, the Bank incorporated the loan portfolio to its equity,

     —           70,015   

•  Other manager portfolios,

     313,828         355,555   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total

     1,141,071         1,030,998   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

  12.2. Mutual Funds

As of December 31, 2015, the Bank, in its capacity as Depository Company, held in custody the shares of interest subscribed by third parties and assets from the following mutual funds:

 

Fund

   Shares of interest      Equity      Assets (a)  

Pionero Pesos

     649,982,255         1,579,677         1,268,836   

Pionero Renta Ahorro

     1,150,675,261         4,544,136         4,557,223   

Pionero F F

     59,075,157         195,604         200,978   

Pionero Renta

     85,413,221         810,949         892,786   

Pionero Acciones

     3,497,547         32,245         33,069   

Pionero Renta Dólares

     6,027         25      

Pionero Empresas FCI Abierto PYMES

     89,089,874         143,588         145,379   

Pionero Consumo

     80,081         122         119   

Argenfunds Renta Pesos

     471,507,853         636,736         637,394   

Argenfunds Renta Argentina

     130,824,065         189,351         275,785   

Argenfunds Ahorro Pesos

     842,854,206         1,745,667         1,735,285   

Argenfunds Renta Privada FCI

     197,943,427         386,261         525,069   

Argenfunds Abierto Pymes

     57,751         35         1   
     

 

 

    

 

 

 
        10,264,396         10,271,924   
     

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

(a) “Memorandum accounts – Debit-balance accounts – Control – Other” includes mainly items in custody. Consequently, this account includes the above mentioned amounts related to the mutual funds’ investment portfolios.

 

13. BANK DEPOSITS GUARANTEE INSURANCE SYSTEM

Law No. 24,485, and Presidential Decree No. 540/1995, provided for the organization of a Bank Deposit Guarantee Insurance System, characterized as being limited, mandatory and for valuable consideration, designed to provide coverage for risks inherent in bank deposits subsidiarily and supplementary to the bank deposit privileges and protection offered by the system created by Financial Institutions Law. Such law also provided for the organization of Sedesa to manage the Deposit Guarantee Fund. Such company was organized in August 1995. The Bank holds an 8.3648% equity interest therein, according to the percentages set forth in Central Bank Communiqué “B” 11250 of April 4, 2016.

This system shall cover the deposits up to the amount of 350 in Argentine pesos and foreign currency with the participating institutions as checking accounts, savings accounts, certificates of deposit or any other modes determined by the Central Bank, as long as the requirements under Presidential Decree No. 540/1995 and any others established by the enforcement agency are fulfilled. On the other hand, Central Bank established that the deposits made by other financial institutions, those made by persons related to the Bank, and deposits of securities, among others, must be excluded from the deposit guarantee system.

 

F - 30


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

14. TRUST AGREEMENTS

The Bank is related to different types of trusts. The different trust agreements are disclosed below, according to the Bank’s business purpose:

 

  14.1. Interest in trusts for investment purposes.

As of December 31, 2015 and 2014, the Bank holds (i) investments in certificates of participation amounted to 10,302 and 21,134 (net of allowances), respectively, and (ii) debt securities amounted to 195,556 and 168,385, respectively (see Note 25).

Debt securities include mainly:

 

    prepayments towards the placement price of trust securities of the financial trusts under public offerings, made by the Bank through underwriting agreements (Mila, Garbarino, Credicuotas consumo and Credimas). The assets managed for these trusts are mainly related to securitizations of consumer loans. Trust securities are placed once the public offering is authorized by the CNV. Upon expiry of the placement period, once all trust securities have been placed on the market, the Bank recovers the disbursements made, plus an agreed-upon compensation (“underwriting Price”). If after making the best efforts, such trust securities cannot be placed, the Bank (“Underwriter”) will retain the securities subject to underwriting and,

 

    debt securities related to Loma Blanca Financial Trust.

According to the latest accounting information available as of the date of issuance of these consolidated financial statements, the corpus assets of the trusts, exceed the carrying amount in the related proportions.

 

  14.2. Trusts created using financial assets transferred by the Bank

The Bank transferred financial assets (loans) to trusts for the purpose of issuing and selling securities for which collection is guaranteed by the cash flow resulting from such assets or group of assets. This way, the funds that were originally used to finance the loans are obtained earlier.

As of December 31, 2015 and 2014, the managed assets through trustees amounted to 35,521 and 20,818, respectively.

 

  14.3. Trusts guaranteeing loans granted by the Bank

As it is common in the Argentine banking market, the Bank requires, in some cases, that the debtors present certain assets or entitlements to receive assets in a trust as a guarantee for the loans granted. This way, the risk of losses is minimized and access to the security is guaranteed in case of the debtor’s noncompliance.

Trusts usually act as conduits to collect cash from the debtor’s flow of operations and send it to the bank for the payment of the debtor’s loans and thus ensure compliance with the obligations assumed by the trustor and guaranteed through the trust.

Additionally, other guarantee trusts manage specific assets, mainly real property.

Provided there is no noncompliance or delays by debtor in the obligations assumed with the beneficiary, the Trustee shall not execute the guaranty and all excess amounts as to the value of the obligations are reimbursed by the Trustee to the debtor.

As of December 31, 2015, and 2014, the managed assets amounted to 176,113 and 493,078, respectively.

 

  14.4. Normal trust activities (The Bank acts as trustee)

The Bank performs management duties in relation to the corpus assets directly according to the agreements, performing only trustee duties and has no other interests in the trust.

 

F - 31


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

In no case shall the Trustee be liable with its own assets or for any obligation deriving from the performance as trustee. Such obligations do not imply any type of indebtedness or commitment for the trustee and they will be fulfilled only through trust assets. In addition, the trustee will not encumber the corpus assets or dispose of them beyond the limits established in the related trust agreements. The fees earned by the Bank from its role as trustee are calculated according to the terms and conditions of the agreements.

Trusts usually manage funds derived from the activities performed by trustors for the following main purposes:

 

  (a) Guaranteeing, in favor of the beneficiary, the existence of the resources required to finance and/or pay certain obligations, such as the payment of amortization installments regarding work or service certificates, and the payment of invoices and fees stipulated in the related agreements.

 

  (b) Promoting the production development of the private economic sector at a provincial level.

 

  (c) Being a party to public work concession agreements granting road exploitation, management, keeping and maintenance.

As of December 31, 2015, and 2014, the managed assets amounted to 1,180,773 and 933,245, respectively.

 

15. INFORMATION REQUIRED BY CENTRAL BANK AND CNV

 

  15.1 Compliance with requirements to act in the capacity of agents belonging to different categories of agents defined by the CNV.

Considering Banco Macro SA’s current operations, and according to the different categories of agents established by CNV General Resolution 622, the Bank is registered with this agency as an agent for the custody of collective investment products of mutual funds (AC PIC FCI), comprehensive clearing and settlement agent and trading agent (ALyC y AN - integral), and financial trustee agent (FF) categories.

Additionally, the Bank’s shareholders´ equity exceeds the minimum amount required by this regulation, amounting to 25,000, as well as the minimum offsetting required of 11,000, which the Bank paid-in at the end of the fiscal year with government securities as described in Note 8.

 

  15.2 Documentation in custody.

As a general policy, the Bank delivers for custody to third parties, the documentary support of its aged accounting and management operations, i.e those whose date is prior to the last fiscal year-end, except for the inventory book, in which aging is deemed to include those with a date prior to the two fiscal years ended. In compliance with CNV General Resolution No. 629 requirements, the Bank has kept (i) the inventory books for fiscal years ended through December 31, 2012 included, and (ii) certain documentation supporting the economic transactions for fiscal years ended through December 31, 2014, included, under the custody of the following companies: AdeA Administradora de Archivos SA (warehouse located at Ruta 36, km 31.5, Florencio Varela, Province of Buenos Aires) and ADDOC Administración de Documentos SA (warehouse located at avenida Circunvalación, between Camino San Carlos and 60 cuadras, Province of Cordoba and avenida Sargento Cayetano Beleira 410, formerly Ruta 8 Km 51.2, Pilar, Province of Buenos Aires).

 

  15.3 Minimum cash requirement under Central Bank rules: the items computed by the Bank to constitute the minimum cash requirement effective for December 2015 are listed below, indicating the balances as of month-end of the related accounts:

 

Item

   12/31/2015  

Cash

  

Amounts in Central Bank accounts

     11,956,958   

Other receivables from financial intermediation

  

Special guarantee accounts with the Central Bank

     1,541,363   
  

 

 

 

Total

     13,498,321   
  

 

 

 

 

F - 32


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

  15.4 Minimum capital requirement under Central Bank rules: as the table disclosed, the minimum capital requirements measured on an consolidated basis, effective for December 2015, along with its computable capital as of the end of that month:

 

Item

   12/31/2015  

Minimum capital requirement

     8,392,073   

Computable capital

     15,307,685   
  

 

 

 

Excess amount

     6,915,612   
  

 

 

 

 

  15.5 Financial statements publication: under Communiqué “A” 760, the Central Bank prior intervention is not required for the publication of these consolidated financial statements.

 

  15.6 Breakdown of the items included in “other”:

 

     12/31/2015      12/31/2014  

15.6.1       Loans – Other

     

Other loans

     6,342,367         4,841,556   

Export financing and prefinancing

     736,209         993,677   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 
     7,078,576         5,835,233   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

15.6.2       Other receivables from financial intermediation – Other
 not covered by debtor classification standards

     

Certificates of participation in financial trusts (a)

     234,345         244,965   

Debt securities issued by financial trusts (a)

     195,556         168,385   

Other

     174,443         88,067   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

(a)    See also Notes 14 and 25.

     604,344         501,417   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

15.6.3       Other receivables – Other

     

Sundry receivables

     422,246         301,482   

Security deposits

     392,773         201,448   

Advanced prepayments

     105,313         68,853   

Tax prepayments

     2,554         5,846   

Other

     60,554         30,190   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 
     983,440         607,819   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

F - 33


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

     12/31/2015      12/31/2014  

15.6.4       Other liabilities from financial intermediation – Other

     

Purchase financing payables

     2,042,345         1,572,472   

Other withholdings and additional withholdings

     836,574         510,108   

Miscellaneous not subject to minimum cash requirements

     740,988         465,373   

Collections and other transactions on account and behalf of others

     665,973         464,778   

Other payment orders pending settlement

     368,318         394,883   

Sociedad Seguro de Depósitos (SEDESA) – Purchase of preferred shares of former Nuevo Banco Bisel S.A. (See Note 8.)

     94,300         90,643   

Miscellaneous subject to minimum cash requirements

     83,429         193,427   

Retirement pension payment orders pending settlement

     56,001         90,091   

Other

     134,633         116,265   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 
     5,022,561         3,898,070   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

15.6.5       Other liabilities – Other

     

Taxes payable (net of prepayments)

     1,346,612         1,286,384   

Salaries and payroll taxes payable

     363,818         288,481   

Miscellaneous payables

     195,850         197,642   

Withholdings on salaries

     72,027         55,065   

Prepayment for the sale of assets

     2,873         3,529   

Other

     47,304         28,047   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 
     2,028,484         1,859,148   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

15.6.6       Memorandum accounts – Debit-balance account –
 Control – Other

     

Checks and securities in custody – ANSES

     173,556,927         55,081,889   

Securities in custody – Other

     25,823,867         14,507,997   

Checks and securities not yet collected

     5,016,972         3,406,076   

Managed portfolios (see Note 12.1.)

     1,141,071         1,030,998   

Checks and securities to be debited

     1,074,444         916,581   

Checks and securities to be collected

     354,654         147,135   

Other

     5,143,080         3,698,865   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 
     212,111,015         78,789,541   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

15.6.7       Financial Income – Interest in other loans

     

Personal loans

     7,318,466         5,128,521   

Other

     1,493,301         1,143,832   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 
     8,811,767         6,272,353   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

15.6.8       Financial expense – Other

     

Turnover tax and municipal assessments

     1,396,656         1,009,440   

Premiums on repurchase agreements with the financial sector

     8,004         9,249   

Other

     —           235   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 
     1,404,660         1,018,924   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

F - 34


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

     12/31/2015      12/31/2014  

15.6.9       Service-charge income – Other

     

Debit and credit card income

     1,616,026         1,147,739   

Rental of safe deposit boxes

     95,553         84,201   

Service commissions – Joint ventures (see Note 3.5.)

     87,795         70,304   

Other

     510,106         385,786   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 
     2,309,480         1,688,030   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

15.6.10     Service-charge expense – Other

     

Debit and credit card expenses

     732,969         526,809   

Turnover tax and municipal assessments

     307,636         215,320   

Commissions paid to lending agents

     207,646         109,555   

Other

     55,994         76,022   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 
     1,304,245         927,706   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

15.6.11     Other income – Other

     

Other adjustments and interest on other receivables

     43,239         39,633   

Gain on sale of bank premises and equipment, and other assets

     6,544         2,679   

Other

     101,068         71,851   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 
     150,851         114,163   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

15.6.12     Other expense – Other

     

Portfolio transactions

     84,591         51,824   

Donations

     48,672         21,959   

Municipal assessment

     9,098         13,656   

Turnover tax

     4,536         7,587   

Other

     93,225         105,814   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 
     240,122         200,840   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

16. RESTRICTION ON EARNINGS DISTRIBUTION

 

  a) According to Central Bank regulations, 20% of income for the year plus/minus prior-year adjustments and less accumulated losses as for the prior year-end, if any, should be allocated to the Legal Reserve. Consequently, the Shareholders’ Meeting held on April 26, 2016, decided to apply 1,001,684 out of “Unappropriated retained earnings” to increase such legal reserve.

 

  b) As established in the issuance conditions for the instruments representing long term debt mentioned in Note 11.a.1), the Shareholders’ Meeting held on April 26, 2016, decided to appropriate 190,198 out of “Unappropriated retained earnings” to set a special reserve for the interest to be paid upon the maturities taking place in June and December 2016.

 

  c) Under Law No. 25,063, dividends to be distributed in cash or in kind in excess of taxable income accumulated as of the end of the fiscal year immediately preceding the payment or distribution date shall be subject to a 35% income tax withholding as a single and definitive payment. For this purpose, income to be considered in each year will result from adding dividends or earnings from other corporations not computed in the calculation of those earnings in the same tax period(s) to the earnings determined under application of Income Tax Law, and deducting the tax paid for the tax period(s) in which the earnings, or the related proportional amount, being distributed were generated.

 

F - 35


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

Additionally, from the amendments introduced by Law No. 26,893, distributions of dividends (except for shares) to local individuals or foreign individuals or legal entities shall be subject to a 10% income tax.

 

  d) Through Communiqué “A” 5827 with effective date January 1, 2016, the Central Bank establishes the general procedure to distribute earnings, keeping the provisions under Communiqué “A” 5694 effective through December 31, 2015. According to that procedure, earnings may only be distributed previously express authorization of the Central Bank, and only if the following circumstances are met like not records of financial assistance from the Central Bank due to illiquidity or shortages in payments of minimum capital or minimum cash requirement deficiencies, there are no sanctions established by certain regulators entities, weighted to be significant, and/or no corrective measures have been applied, among other previous conditions listed in the abovementioned communiqué.

Therefore, earnings may only be distributed to the extent that income was booked, after deducting, on a nonaccounting basis, from unappropriated retained earnings and the voluntary reserve for future distribution of earnings, the amounts of the legal and statutory reserves which are mandatory, the positive net difference between the book value and market value or present value reported by the Central Bank, as the case may be, of government debt securities and/or monetary regulation instruments issued by the Central Bank not valued at market value and the amounts recognized in the bank assets due to court cases related to deposits, among other items.

On December 31, 2015, only for earning distribution calculation, a regulatory adjustment to Unappropriated retained earnings was performed as a result of the positive difference arise from the book value and the market value of unlisted government securities for an amount of 31,020.

In addition, the maximum amount to be distributed cannot exceed the excess the required minimum capital considering, solely for this purpose an 75% incremental adjustment to the total requirements of the minimum capital.

Finally, the Bank shall verify whether –after the proposed earning distribution– a capital maintenance margin equal to 0.875% of risk-weighted assets is kept, apart from the minimum capital required by regulations, to be integrated by level-1 ordinary capital (COn1), net of deductible items (CDCOn1).

 

  e) Under CNV General Resolution No. 593, the Shareholders’ Meeting in charge of analyzing the annual financial statements will be required to establish a specific use for the Bank’s retained earnings, whether through the actual distribution of dividends, the capitalization thereof through the delivery of bonus shares, the creation of voluntary reserves additional to the legal reserve or a combination of any of these applications.

On April 26, 2016, the Regular and Special General Shareholders’ Meeting of Banco Macro SA approved, among other issues, (i) the distribution of cash dividends for an amount up to 643,019, subject to prior express authorization of the Central Bank, (ii) the compensation paid to the Directors amounting to 207,714 and (iii) the write off of payments made on behalf of shareholders for their personal assets tax for an amount of 38,009.

In addition, related to the dividend distribution for 2014, through Resolution of February 24, 2016, the Central Bank authorized a cash dividend distribution for an amount of 227,708.

 

17. TAX AND OTHER CLAIMS

 

  17.1. The AFIP (Federal Public Revenue Agency) and provincial tax authorities have reviewed the tax returns filed by the Bank related to income tax, minimum presumed income tax and other taxes (mainly turnover tax).

The most significant ongoing claims arising from the previous paragraph are detailed below:

 

  a) Afip challenged the income tax returns filed by the former Banco Bansud SA (for the fiscal years since June 30, 1995, through June 30, 1999, and of the irregular six-month period ended December 31, 1999) and by the former Banco Macro SA (for the fiscal years ended since December 31, 1998, through December 31, 2000).

 

F - 36


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

The matter under discussion that has not been resolved as yet and on which the regulatory agency bases its position is the impossibility of deducting credits that have collateral security, an issue that has been addressed by the Federal Administrative Tax Court and CSJN in similar cases, which have issued resolutions that are favorable to the Bank’s position.

 

  b) AFIP challenged a compensation amount arising from the tax on bank account transactions for 2008, which was used to settle the amount reported in the income tax return filed by former Banco Bisel for tax period 2008, taking into account that the origin could only be computed as from the tax period following the one in which it was used. An appeal was filed with the Federal Administrative Tax Court in order to challenge the resolution issued by the AFIP.

 

  c) City of Buenos Aires tax authorities attributed a turnover tax difference to Banco Macro SA for fiscal period 2002, in relation to the treatment of the compensation bond, over which a precautionary measure was issued in 2009 in favor of the Bank by the Federal Court of First Instance in Countentios and Administrative No. 6, which was confirmed by the Courtroom IV of the CNACAF.

 

  d) City of Buenos Aires tax authorities attributed a turnover tax difference to former Banco Privado de Inversiones for fiscal periods 2002 and 2003. On October 19, 2015, Courtroom II of the Administrative and Tax Contentious Court of Appeals confirmed the trial court decision as it agreed with the Bank in that the “compensation bond” is not subject to turnover tax. On December 21, 2015, the Bank was notified that the Buenos Aires City Government filed an action for declaration of unconstitutionality with the Buenos Aires City Highest Court, which is pending resolution. In 2009, the Buenos Aires City Government filed a collection claim and obtained an attachment for 827 (see also Note 8.).

Additionally, there are other appeals filed with the Tax Court, which are not relevant.

 

  17.2. Moreover, as a result of a lawsuit filed in 2007 by consumers’ association “ADECUA” claiming about various aspects related to the collection of the “life insurance” charge for products marketed by former Banco Privado de Inversiones SA, on November 29, 2010, the parties reached a settlement agreement, approved by the Federal Commercial Court in and for the City of Buenos Aires No. 3, clerk’s office No. 5, and complied with by the Bank.

However, on March 22, 2013, the judge hearing the case ordered to adjust the performance of the agreement, as regards the reimbursement of the funds to the customers from whom the charge had been collected, a resolution which was appealed by the Bank.

On April 24, 2014, the Court of Appeals dismissed the appeals filed and changed what was resolved in First Instance, ordered the Agreement nullity, to continue with the proceeding and to allow the Bank to answer the complaint. Such resolution was appealed by the Bank.

Additionally, there are other claims filed by consumers’ associations against the Bank, which are not relevant.

The Bank’s Management and its tax and legal advisors believe there are no additional significant effects to those already recognized in the books that may result from the final outcome of such claims.

 

18. RISK MANAGEMENT POLICIES

Within the framework of the Corporate Governance policy, the Board of Directors of the Bank resolved the creation of a Risk Management Committee and appointed a Comprehensive Risk Manager.

Its duties includes ensuring that an independent risk management be established, establishing policies, procedures and measurement methodologies and report systems which allow the identification, measurement and monitoring of the risk under its charge and also, the duties of each organizational level in the process.

The Comprehensive Risk manager coordinates the heads of financial risk, credit risk and operational risk.

 

F - 37


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

The risk management process includes the establishment of the exposure limits for each risk by the Board of Directors, a follow-up on the exposure to each limit by the persons in charge, the preparation of regular reports for the Risk Management Committee, a follow-up on the alerts and the implementation of action plans regarding the alerts and the guidelines for developing stress tests.

The system is supplemented with policies and procedures specific to each risk (financial, credit, operational, counterparty credit, country risk, securitization, reputational, compliance, strategic risks, among others).

In addition, the Credit Risk Management area is in charge of interpreting, executing and guaranteeing the application of the General Credit Policy approved by the Board of Directors, ensuring proper identification, assessment, control, follow-up and mitigation of the credit risk, pursuant to the internal and external standards and regulations on the matter. Credit Risk Management reports functionally to the Deputy General Commercial Manager.

Comprehensive risk management

“The Comprehensive Risk Management area is formed by the Financial Risk, Credit Risk and Operational Risk sectors. The main procedures carried out are:

 

    Stress tests

The process of stress test includes documenting and formalizing the program as well as the persons in charge of carrying it out, the frequency of testing and the validation of the system. It also contemplates the Contingency Plan based on the test results. The Risk Management Committee leads and coordinates this application.

 

    Economic capital calculation

The Comprehensive risk Department estimates the economic capital for each one of the risks (market, liquidity, interest rate, credit, counterparty credit, concentration, operational, securitization, strategic and reputational) determined for the Bank on a consolidated basis.

Quantified economic capital was implemented as a formal procedure, both currently and prospectively, and is a tool used in the day-to-day management of risks, in preparing the Business Plan and the Stress Tests.

The methods used to measure the economic capital of each risk were documented and approved by Management, pursuant to the internal rules on Corporate Governance and Risk Management.

The most significant risks managed by the Bank are disclosed as follows:

 

    Financial risk

Financial risk is understood to be the group comprising Liquidity, Market and Interest Rate risks, which, independently or in an interrelated manner, can affect the Bank’s liquidity and solvency.

Definitions

Liquidity Risk is mainly understood to be the funding liquidity risk, defined as that in which Grupo Macro is unable to efficiently meet cash flows that are both expected and unexpected, current and noncurrent and with guarantees, without hindering daily operations or the financial situation. Market Liquidity Risk is understood to be the risk that the Bank may not be able to offset or unwind a position at market price.

Market Risk is defined as the possibility of incurring losses in on-and off-balance sheet positions as a result of adverse fluctuations in the market price for various assets.

Interest Rate Risk is defined as the possibility that there may be changes in the Bank’s financial situation as a result of fluctuations in the interest rates, which may have adverse effects on the Bank’s net financial income and financial value.

 

F - 38


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

Process

The Bank has strategies, policies and limits defined for each exposure which have been approved by the Board of Directors within the framework of Market, Liquidity and Interest Rate Risk management. These are also applicable to the subsidiaries in a consolidated framework. This process is reviewed periodically by the Risk Management Committee in accordance with Central Bank guidelines for Financial Institutions Risk Management and the adjustments or amendments approved by the Board of Directors.

The purpose of the Financial Risk Policy is to ensure that the Risk Management Committee and Senior Management have the proper procedures, tools and information enabling them to measure, manage and control the applicable risks.

The Risk heads will report regularly, to the Assets and Liabilities (Cap) and the Risk Management Committees on the financial risk exposure and the effects that may be caused in the Bank’s financial margin. A set of predetermined reports is prepared enabling a clear comparison between the existing exposure and the policy on limits.

The Cap is in charge of setting out the Bank’s financial strategy, analyzing the markets and establishing the policies on assets and liabilities, considering, market, liquidity, interest rate and currency risks.

The Financial Risk area uses the following instruments in preparing its reports: sensitivity analysis, stress tests, index curves and other simulations. The adoption of measures regarding the detected departures based on the information provided is left to Senior Management’s discretion, for which it must take into consideration several factors such as the market conditions or the complexity and variety of transactions, considering the defined action plans. The Risk Management Committee learns about these situations and the plans implemented, analyzing the impact on risk exposure. As a result, it may require an explanation about the case from Senior Management or, based on its survey, recommend adjustments to the policies, procedures and limits to the Board of Directors.

The goal set by the Board of Directors is to maintain an adequate degree of liquidity through the prudent management of assets and liabilities, in regard to both the cash flow as well as the concentration thereof.

The administration of liquidity is supported by an adequate planning process that considers the current and future cash needs, as well as possible changes in economic, political, regulatory and other conditions.

This makes it necessary to identify forecast and possible cash outflows, as well as alternative strategies to handle assets and liabilities in critical situations.

The reports prepared contemplate the following aspects: changes in yield curves; a mismatch of assets and liabilities in relation to currency, rates, terms and based on their volatility and speed of realization; changes, rates and volatility of term deposits, and the participation of institutional investors; liquidity and interest rate risk; established limits and issuance of warnings.

The Bank evaluates the Liquidity Risk situation through different tools, some of which include:

 

    Cash Flow at Risk (CFAR): it is calculated as the difference between the liquidity gap, obtained in the average or expected scenario and that resulting from the critical scenario. The liquidity average scenario is obtained from the arithmetic mean of simulated liquidity scenarios, while the critical scenario is obtained by applying the percentile related to that confidence level for that set of simulation;

 

    stress tests: they are used to quantify the impact as a result of illiquidity scenarios arising from different shocks in the risk factors involved;

 

    Liquidity Coverage Ratio (LCR): this indicator shows the liquidity coverage over the outflows of funds within the next 30 days. Through different weightings factors established by Basel, the indicator is able to capture those outflows in systemic stress situations.

Market Risk is measured by computing the Var (value at risk), which consists in the maximum expected loss for a trading portfolio over a certain period of time and with a 99% confidence level.

 

F - 39


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

As to the interest rate risk, Economic Value methodology (EVM), is used to measure the risk of sensitive assets and liabilities to interest rate. Through stochastic processes, different interest rate scenarios are estimated, for which different Bank´s economic values will be obtained. Var is the difference between the expected economic value (“mean value”) and the economic value for a specific confidence level and holding period as a result of simulations.

There are Contingency Plans which are assessed and reviewed on a regular basis by the Risk Management Committee.

Credit risk

The Credit Risk Area reporting to the Comprehensive Risk Management area participates in the development of the individual stress test program for credit risk and comprehensive stress tests, cooperates in defining scenarios and follows up results. It also participates in the design and implementation of contingency plans for credit risk purposes.

It is in charge of reviewing and adapting methodology and the economic capital calculation model for credit risk purposes through the capital adequacy assessment process, which, with different development and implementation stages, form part of the Bank Action Plan being undertaken to adjust to local regulations (Communiqués “A” 5394 and “A” 5398), the Basel principles and best practices for risk management.

This area is in charge of proposing and monitoring the internal limits of tolerance to credit risk, as well as defining indicators, specifying their calculation method and expressing the grounds used for alert and cap selection. Its include an automated tool for the calculation of key performance indicators, for which alert and limit values have been determined in order to monitor business changes according to the risk appetite defined by the Board of Directors. The results produced by this tool are included in a report on the credit risk tolerance limits, which is submitted to the Risk Management Committee for its consideration and to adopt corrective measures where necessary

Securitization risk

The Bank do not assume any significant risks involving securitization activities. This operation consists mainly in financing, such as prepayments of prices and underwriting in the placement of debt securities of Corporate Banking customers, loans to trusts which are given the same treatment as legal entities and potentially securitizing the proprietary portfolio.

Holding debt securities or certificates of participation in trust generally creates exposure related mainly to credit risk and interest rate risk, just as in a traditional credit transaction. Therefore, they are included in the assessment and administration of each one of the risks involved.

Operational risk

The Bank adopted the definition of Operational risk under the Basel II Accord and the definition established by the Central Bank through its Communiqué “A” 5398, which consists in the risk of suffering losses due to the lack of adjustment or defects in the internal processes, systems or persons, or due to external events.

This definition includes legal risk but excludes strategic and reputation risk.

The Bank has policies, procedures and structures, appointing a Head of Operational Risk. The Operational Risk Committee’s main mission is to secure an Operational Risk Management plan which includes policies, programs, measurements and competencies for identifying, assessing and managing risks, with the purpose of assisting Area Managers and the Bank’s Board of Directors, in an environment of rapidly changing and significant risks.

In this context, the Evolutionary Comprehensive Operational Risk Management Model was developed, which involves the identification, measurement, management and monitoring of operational risks. A training plan was designed to begin conveying the concepts inherent to Operational Risk and the cultural change that this generates, and an implementation plan of the model was put into practice to achieve full implementation of all of its stages.

 

F - 40


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

A quantitative approach is used to measure operational risk and technological risk, which includes the following:

 

    assessing all relevant processes;

 

    integrating the operational and technological risk assessment models;

 

    applying risk impact and frequency evaluation matrices for the assessment of processes and subprocesses;

 

    the quantitative assessment of the risks, identifying action plans and proposals for improving the critical processes, all in full compliance with the objectives set forth;

 

    the procedure to gather information on events and losses, the purpose of which is to reduce incidents and loss amounts, thus incorporating a quantitative assessment into the risk management model, by registering risk events and losses in a centralized database;

 

    the IT tool put into practice to manage operational risk, used to manage identified risks and calculate the different indicators so as to have an information system providing an overall view of the results of the different practices and tools involved in operational risk management; and

 

    the methodology through which the IT areas identify, assess and control the risks related to the Bank’s information assets and to specific events, creating information that is later taken into account in decision-making processes.

As regards Risk Management related to the IT and information systems, the Bank has contingency and business continuity plans in place to minimize the risks that could affect the Bank’s continuity of operations.

The Bank has an incentives system to manage operational risk in such a way that it would encourage involvement and risk assessment. The risk assessment policy has also been reinforced for new products and in modifications to existing products.

In addition, the implementation of improvements on the different functions of the risk management system also continued.

Credit risk management

Credit Risk Management is in charge of interpreting, executing and guaranteeing the application of the General Credit Policy approved by the Board of Directors, ensuring proper identification, assessment, control, follow-up and mitigation of the credit risk, pursuant to the internal and external standards and regulations on the matter.

Credit risk results from the possibility of loss derived from customers or counter-parties from fully or partially breaching financial obligations they have undertaken with the Bank.

The Bank has counter-party and credit risk policies and strategies the purpose of which is to ensure that risks fall within a risk tolerance level decided by the Board of Directors and Central Bank and other oversight agency regulations.

It has the proper structure, procedures and different tools (information systems, rating and monitoring systems, measurement models, recovery policies) which enable it to handle risk effectively.

For loan granting, there are specific policies and procedures for Corporate Banking clients and Consumer Banking clients, which in turn differ, according to the segment to which they belong (Public or Private Payroll, Retirees or Open Market).

Credit risk assessment for Consumer Banking clients includes the use of risk applications based on screening and scoring methods related to an arrears level. There is also a mass-scale and centralized qualification process for clients (which allows branches to provide assistance within defined margins) and credit prequalification models for assessment of potential customers from different sales campaigns.

 

F - 41


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

Loans to Corporate Banking clients are analyzed in Credit Committee, which are made up of business and risk area officers from different levels, with powers to operate within them. Specialized risk analysts prepare a risk report per client (or group of companies), which serves to support the credit decisions made by Committee members. There are also decentralized assessment methods for Agro, SMEs and Microprojects, including screening and scoring parameters, which allow speeding up the approval of predefined products and smaller amounts. In order to authorize transactions involving lower amounts or self-liquidating collaterals, or temporary transactions, special credit powers have been granted to higher-rank officers based on their knowledge, experience and training.

Once the credit limits have been approved, the Credit Administration and Transactions Department controls the formalities and settlement of the transactions and every month it reviews the classification of debtors and the debtors’ guarantees, assessing the sufficiency of the provisions according to the standards established by the Central Bank.

In order to manage credit risk, assessment or score models are used (for admission, behavior and collections) for Retail Banking and Company Rating Models at different stages of the credit cycle, allocating an internal risk rating to customers, according to which the assigned credit limits are managed and according to which the portfolio is monitored. These tools are supplemented with the Expected Loss and Provision Models prepared by Management.

In turn, the Credit recovery Management Department is in charge of managing the recovery of non performing loans, aiming at integrating these actions into the other risk instances, which increases the efficacy of collection processes and provides information on recovery management results, so as to adjust the origination and expected loss models.

 

19. CORPORATE GOVERNANCE TRANSPARENCY POLICY

As a financial institution, Banco Macro SA’s business activity is governed by Financial Institutions Law No. 21,526, as supplemented, and the regulations issued by the Central Bank. Moreover, the Bank adheres to the good banking practices laid out in Central Bank Communiqué “A” 5201 (Guidelines for Corporate Governance in Financial Institutions) as supplemented.

The Bank publicly trades its shares on the Merval and, thus, it is subject to the regulations issued by the CNV.

Through General Resolution No. 622/13, the CNV established the minimum contents of the Corporate Governance Code, adding notions of good corporate governance to corporate management as guidelines or recommendations that seek to provide transparency thereto. The CNV does not require that the recommendations be implemented, although it does require that the Bank explain the reasons why it decided not to adopt the good practices described in such resolution by publishing a document called Information Report on Corporate Governance together with the letter to the shareholders for the fiscal year; the report is available on the website and that of such enforcement agency.

This regulation reinforces the notions contained in Capital Markets Law establishing principles such as “full disclosure”, “transparency”, “efficiency”, “public investor protection”, “equal footing between investors” and “protection of the stability of financial institutions and financial intermediaries”.

Moreover, as the Bank lists its shares on the NYSE, qualifying as a foreign private issuer, it is required to comply with certain corporate governance standards as established in section 303A of the NYSE’s Listed Company Manual, as amended.

The main guidelines under Central Bank Communiqué “A” 5293 as supplemented are as follows:

 

    Board of Directors, Senior Management and Committees

The Bank’s Board of Directors is currently made up of thirteen members and three alternate members. Members are renewed by thirds and the appointed Directors remain in office for three fiscal years. Directors are appointed by the Shareholders’ Meeting.

Seven directors and one alternate director are independent, according to the guidelines set by CNV and the Central Bank regulations.

 

F - 42


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

Directors should be morally suitable, experienced and knowledgeable in the banking business and meet the requirements established in the effective regulations.

Compliance with these requirements is assessed when the Shareholders’ Meeting appoints the directors and on a regular basis during their term of office.

In this regard, through its CREFI (Creation, Operation and Expansion of Financial Institutions) circulars, the Central Bank establishes the assessment criteria used for granting the authorization to the directors appointed by the Shareholders’ Meeting.

The Board of Directors delegates the usual affairs related to management and corporate activities to an Executive Committee with the assignment of specific duties as defined in the Bank’s bylaws.

In relation to Senior Management and Committees, see next paragraph Organizational structure

 

    Ownership structure

As of December 31, 2015, the Bank’s shareholders are:

 

Full name / Corporate name

   Percentage
of capital
stock
     Percentage
of votes
 

Brito Jorge Horacio

     19.61         21.62   

Carballo Delfín Jorge Ezequiel

     19.11         20.85   

ANSES FGS under Law No. 26,425

     31.50         29.25   

Grouped shareholders (Argentine stock exchanges)

     6.79         6.93   

Grouped shareholders (foreign stock exchanges)

     22.99         21.35   

 

    Organizational structure

Senior management

Three deputy general managers report to the Executive Committee; one is in charge of the commercial areas, the other one is in charge of the operating areas and the last one is in charge of the financials areas. Sixteen-line managers report to them. Additionally, the Bank has seven staff areas reporting directly to the Executive Committee.

Committes

Its states by-laws that the Board of Directors may establish Committee as they deem appropriate for corporate activities, as well as appoint their members. The followings committees operate in the bank:

 

Committee

  

Roles

Audit Committee    They are established in Capital Markets Law as supplemented.
Internal Audit Committee    Overseeing the proper operation of the internal control systems defined at the Bank through a periodic assessment thereof and contributing to improving the effectiveness of internal controls.
Risk Management Committee    It is in charge of monitoring Senior Management’s activities involving the management of credit, market, liquidity, operational, compliance and reputation risks, among others. It advises the Board of Directors on the Bank’s risks.
Assets and Liabilities Committee    Setting out the Bank’s financial strategy, analyzing the markets and establishing the policies on assets and liabilities, management of market, liquidity, interest rate and currency risks.
IT Committee    Overseeing the proper operation of the information technology environment and contributing to improving the effectiveness thereof.

 

F - 43


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

Committee

  

Roles

Receivables Committee    Approving credit transactions based on credit capacity.
Legal Recovery department    Incumbent in defining payment arrangements exceeding the predetermined parameters, as well as reclassifying portfolio to be subject to legal proceedings or accounting retirements.
Personnel Incentives Committee    Ensuring the financial incentives for personnel system is consistent with the culture, the objectives, the business in the long term, the strategy and the control environment of the Bank.
Ethics and Compliance Committee    Ensuring the Bank has the proper means with which to promote correct decision-making and compliance with internal and external regulations.
Corporate Governance and Appointments Committee    The Committee’s duties include those related to the process of renewing and replacing Senior Management members and the succession plans. It is also in charge of applying the Corporate Governance Code at the Bank and at its subsidiaries.
Anti-money Laundering Committee    Planning and coordinating compliance with the policies established by the Board of Directors on the matter.

Branches

The Bank has a broad network of branches (439) throughout Argentina.

Subsidiaries

The Bank carries out certain transactions through its subsidiaries, which are identified in Note 4.1. (see also Note 9).

Business lines

The Bank’s business lines and transactions with trusts are mentioned in Notes 1. and 14., respectively.

 

    Incentive practices

The Bank has a personnel incentives system based on the identification of officers’ “outstanding performance”, which is understood to be their contribution in connection with the obtained results and their manner of conducting management.

The Incentives Committee is in charge of ensuring for the financial incentives for personnel system to be consistent with the culture, the objectives, the business in the long term, the strategy and the control environment of the Bank, and the prudent assumption of risks. The Incentives Committee is the body responsible for approving the Compensation Policy (salary and variable incentives), as well as any reviews it may require.

The Incentives System in place is based on assessing personal competence and performance associated with the compliance of non-related organizational objectives to be compensated based on extraordinary profit targets or direct financial achievement. The system is also adjusted according to the objective premise of generating sustained revenues (on a sustainable basis), thus, when establishing the total amount of compensation with regard to income (loss) for the year, extraordinary income is not taken into account. The system only provides cash compensation.

The Compensation Policy also includes a specific chapter regarding how remuneration is set and adjusted. In this case, the idea is to compensate personnel by ensuring performance recognition, internal equity, external competitiveness, productivity, efficiency and added value, finding an appropriate point of equilibrium with the business’s economic capacity and consistency in the long term.

 

F - 44


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

The following aspects are taken into consideration:

 

    the complexity of the positions, their contribution to the organization’s strategy and the professional development attained by the employee;

 

    employees with enhanced performance in achieving their objectives and assuming greater responsibilities; and

 

    levels of remuneration that are competitive in comparison to market levels.

 

    Codes of ethics and conduct

The Bank adheres to the best practices and requires that all its employees act according to the highest standards of personal and professional integrity in all aspects of their activities.

In addition, compliance with its Code of Conduct and other policies and procedures governing employee conduct is considered to be essential. Moreover, the Code of Ethics for directors and officers is supplemental to the Bank’s Code of Conduct.

 

    Role of financial agent

The Bank is a financial agent for the Provinces of Misiones, Salta and Jujuy. In addition, the subsidiary Banco del Tucumán SA is a financial agent for the Province of Tucumán and the Municipality of San Miguel de Tucumán. See also Notes 3.1. through 3.4.

 

    Transactions with related parties – Policy on conflict of interest

As an authorized financial institution, Banco Macro S.A. complies with the provisions and reporting requirements established in Financial and Foreign Exchange Institutions Law No. 21,526 and the regulations issued by the regulatory agency (Central Bank).

As established by the legislation (Argentine General Associations Law No. 19,550), specific applicable regulations (Capital Markets Law as supplemented), professional accounting standards (TR No. 21) and best practice recommendations, the Bank reports on the transactions with related parties in notes to the financial statements. Such transactions are carried out under usual market conditions. See also Note 9.

Under current Argentine legislation, directors are required to perform their duties with the loyalty and diligence of a prudent business man. Directors are jointly and severally liable before the Bank, the shareholders and third parties for a poor performance of duties and infringements to the law, bylaws and regulations, as the case may be, and are responsible for repairing the damages caused by fraud, abuse of authority or negligence.

The loyal duties of a director are considered to include: (i) the ban from using corporate assets and the confidential information to which he/she may have access for personal purposes; (ii) the ban from taking advantage or, due to errors or omissions, allowing a third party to take advantage of the Bank’s business opportunities, (iii) the obligation of acting as director only for the purposes established in the law, the Bank’s bylaws or the intention of the shareholders or the Board of Directors; and (iv) the obligation of taking extreme care so that the acts conducted by the Board of Directors have no direct or indirect effects against the Bank’s interest.

A director should notify the Board of Directors and the Audit Committee about any conflict of interest there may be in a transaction proposal and should refrain from voting on the matter.

 

    Public information

The information related to corporate governance at the Bank is included within the transparency policy contained in such precepts and, hence, is available to interested members of the public on the website www.macro.com.ar (“Conocenos” – Relaciones con Inversores) and, additionally, some guidelines are disclosed in other notes and exhibits to these financial statements. Moreover, the Bank’s public information is disclosed on the websites of the Central Bank (www.bcra.gob.ar) and the CNV (www.cnv.gob.ar).

 

F - 45


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

20. SUMMARY JUDGEMENTS AND SANCTIONS APPLIED BY CERTAIN REGULATORS AGAINST BANCO MACRO S.A AND BANCO DEL TUCUMÁN S.A.

The Central Bank Communiqué “A” 5689 requires banks to disclose in their financial statements certain information regarding summaries and sanctions received from certain regulators, regardless of the amounts involved and the final conclusions of each cause. The information required as of December 31, 2015 is disclosed below:

 

  20.1. Summary Judgements initiated by the Central Bank:

Criminal Foreign Exchange Regime Summary: No. 3078 dated 06/24/2008.

Reason: Supposed infraction of article No. 8 of the Criminal Foreign Exchange Law (“CFEL”), for irregularities in exchange operations of US dollars (sale) of financial intermediation as provided by Central Bank Communiqué “B” 7174.

Responsible: Banco del Tucumán SA, manager and those in charge of Operations, Treasurer, Cashiers (Francisco Carlos Bustamante, Juan Ramón Lemoine, Héctor Gaspar Taranto, Héctor Arnaldo Brito, Ana Carolina De Genova Palomar, Jorge Marcelo Albertinetti, Sergio Fabián Intile, Lorena Natalia Frías and Carla Andrea Rocha).

Status: On 12/29/2011, the Federal court No. 1 of Tucumán decided to declare criminal action by prescription, in order to facts. On 02/01/2012, this resolution was appealed by the Federal Prosecutor No. 1 of Tucumán. On 07/31/2013 the Court of Appeals confirmed such resolution and subsequently, the cause was remitted to the Criminal Appeals Court, Panel I, as a result of the Prosecutor appeal. As of the date of issuance of these consolidated financial statements, Banco del Tucumán SA has not been notified of the final filing.

Criminal Foreign Exchange Regime Summary: No. 4674 dated 04/14/2011.

Reason: Supposed infraction of article No. 1 incs. e) and f) and No. 2 inc f) of the Criminal Foreign Exchange Law (“CFEL”), in an exchange operation transaction with a suspended customer with no Central Bank authorization.

Responsible: Banco Macro SA, as the follow-on of Nuevo Banco Bisel SA and Branch Manager (Mariano Raúl Misino and Roberto David Luna).

Status: The Central Bank raised the summary to the Criminal Office of the Federal Court No. 3 of the Judicial Department in Córdoba which is in process under No. FCB 3612/2014.

Criminal Foreign Exchange Regime Summary: No. 5645 dated 01/07/2014.

Reason: Supposed infraction of article No. 1 incs. e) and f) y No. 2 inc f) of the CFEL, for foreign exchange transactions with no Central Bank authorization.

Responsible: Banco Macro S.A and Responsible for Foreign Trade and Foreign Exchange (Susana Lerman, José Luis Vejo, Jorge Francisco Scarinci and Horacio Ricardo Javier Sistac).

Status: In process at the Central Bank. On 05/22/2015 the summary evidence period was initiated. This probationary period has already concluded. The BCRA ordered that the proceedings be filed with a criminal court and, therefore, they are currently pending with the Economic Criminal Trial Court in and for the City of Buenos Aires No. 11, Clerk’s Office No. 22, under case file No. 1282/2015.

Criminal Foreign Exchange Regime Summary: No. 6545 dated 09/03/2015.

Reason: Supposed infraction of article No. 1 incs e) and f) of CFEL and Central Bank Communiqué “A” 5264, as supplemented, for foreign exchange transactions with a customer without the documentation to support the genuineness of the transaction.

Responsible: Banco Macro S.A and Responsible for Foreign Trade and Foreign Exchange (Susana Lerman, José Luis Vejo, Jorge Francisco Scarinci and Horacio Ricardo Javier Sistac, Carlos Daniel Gomez and Oscar Luis Romero).

Status: In process at the Central Bank.

Financial summary: No. 1496 dated 02/24/2016

Reason: Deficiencies on supervision on a consolidated basis, exercised by the bank over its subsidiaries, related to Anti-money laundering procedures.

Responsible: Banco Macro SA and Banco Macro SA Directors (Jorge Horacio Brito, Delfín Jorge Ezequiel Carballo, Jorge Pablo Brito, Marcos Brito, Juan Pablo Brito Devoto, Luis Carlos Cerolini, Carlos Enrique Videla, Alejandro Macfarlane, Guillermo Eduardo Stanley, Constanza Brito and Emanuel Antonio Alvarez Agis).

Status: In process at the Central Bank. Rebuttal evidence was presented on April 7, 2016.

 

F - 46


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

  20.2. Sanctions imposed by the Central Bank:

Financial summary: No. 1227 dated 04/10/2008.

Reason: Supposed infraction of Communiqué “A” 2241; CREFI-2; Chapter IV, Section 4, point 4.1. and 4.2., involving two capital contributions to its subsidiary Sudbank and Trust Company Ltd. (currently Macro Bank Limited) with no previous Limited) with no previous Central Bank authorization. Original sanction amount: 2,625, current sanction amount: 1,400

Responsible: Banco Macro SA and Banco Macro SA’s Directors (Jorge Horacio Brito; Delfín Jorge Ezequiel Carballo; Juan Pablo Brito Devoto; Luis Carlos Cerolini; Carlos Enrique Videla; Fernando Andrés Sansuste, Enrique Jaratz and Jorge Pablo Brito).

Status: On 11/05/2013 the fine was debited from Banco Macro’s account 00285 at the Central Bank. On 11/20/2013 a direct appeal was filed against Resolution No. 723 issued by SEFyC (Argentine regulatory agency of financial and foreign exchange institutions), on 10/10/2013, representing the Bank and the natural persons subject to the summary proceeding, before the Federal Court of Appeals in Contentious and Administrative Matters in the City of Buenos Aires (CNACAF). As a result of the appeal filed, on 04/14/2015, the Bank was notified about the resolution that reduced the amount of the fine. On 04/29/2015 the Central Bank filed a federal extraordinary appeal to CNACAF. El 06/10/2015 se acusó la caducidad de la instancia extraordinaria atento a la falta de impulso procesal del BCRA; in the alternative, notice of the extraordinary appeal filed was answered. On October 6, 2015, notice was served regarding the request made to the BCRA. On November 24, 2015, Courtroom IV declared the nullity of the extraordinary instance, with charges to be borne by the losing BCRA. Measures are being taken for reimbursement of the amounts paid for fines exceeding the reductions established by the court. The request was dismissed because the court understands that it is beyond its jurisdiction.

Financial summary: No. 1349 dated 09/07/2012.

Reason: Supposed infraction of Central Bank Communiqués “A” 3054, OPRAC 1-476, Exhibit, Section 2, point 2.1. and Section 3, point 3.1.2.; and “A” 4798, OPRAC 1-613, Exhibit; Section 4, point 4.1., regulations related to financing to the non-financial public sector, for the acquisition of guarantee loans with no Central Bank authorization. Sanction amount: 1,440.

Responsible: Banco del Tucumán SA, and Directors (Jorge Horacio Brito, Luis Carlos Cerolini, Delfín Jorge Ezequiel Carballo, Jorge Pablo Brito, Claudio Alejandro Cerezo and Waldo Camilo López).

Status: On 03/12/2014 the Central Bank passed Sentence No. 149/14 imposing the fine. On 03/19/2014 the fine was debited from Banco del Tucumán SA account 00060 at the Central Bank. On 04/08/2014, a direct appeal was filed against the Resolution issued by SEFyC, representing Banco del Tucumán SA and the natural persons subject to the summary proceeding to CNACAF, which confirmed the Sentence No. 149/14. On 11/14/2014 an extraordinary federal appeal was filed by the arbitrariness of the judgment of the CNACAF. On February 18, 2015 at the Courtroom II of the General Federal Court of Appeal (CNAF) dismissed the extraordinary appeal filed by Banco del Tucumán SA with charges. On February 26, 2015 a complaint was present due to the extraordinary appeal was refused. As of the date, the file is pending resolution.

Financial summary: No. 1380 dated 03/11/2013.

Reason: Supposed excess in the assets used for guarantee purpose which should have been used for related statutory operation ratios; failure to fulfill with the limitations of deposits increase, lack of veracity in book records, neglect to present the corresponding accounting disclosure of such excess and failures according to Central Bank requirements. Sanction amount: 2,000

Responsible: Former Banco Privado de Inversiones SA, Directors, Statutory Audit Committee and Corporate Service Manager (Alejandro Manuel Estrada, Raúl Fernández, Alejandro Carlos Estrada, Eduardo Guillermo Castro, Jorge Norberto Cerrotta, Armando Rogelio Pomar, Carlos Soulé and Baruki Luis Alberto Gonzalez).

Status: On 06/12/2015 the Central Bank passed Sentence No. 527, imposing fines to those responsible. On 06/25/2015 the fine was paid. On 07/10/2015 a direct appeal was filed against such resolution to CNACAF. On December 2015, the sanction amount was recovered by the Entity as a result of the guarantee provided by the sellers at the moment of acquisition of the shares of former BPI SA. On September 2015, the appeals were presented at the Courtroom II of CNACAF. On 10/07/2015, the Court informed BCRA about the appeal presented by the Bank and on 11/12/2015, the court took into account the answer to the service of notice of the direct appeal granted to the BCRA. Proceedings were referred to the Prosecutor’s Office, where they are pending to date. The bank appealed the resolution under the terms of Art. 42 Law 21,256, giving rise to the below-referenced proceeding.

 

F - 47


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

Financial summary: No. 1394 dated 08/01/2013.

Reason: Supposed failure of Communiqué “A” 3700. CREFI 2-36, Exhibit, Item I, Sub-item 5.2. For presenting out of term the corresponding documentation regarding the appointment of authorities.

Responsible: Banco Macro SA and Chairman (Jorge Horacio Brito).

Status: On 12/02/2014 the Central Bank passed Sentence No. 828, imposing the sanction to those responsible. On 02/02/2015 the Bank rejected the resolution and presented an appeal to revoke the sentence at the Central Bank. On 03/27/2015 the Central Bank passed Sentence No. 272, whereby the appeal was dismissed and the sanction was confirmed.

Financial summary: No. 1401 dated 08/14/2013.

Reason: Supposed failure of financing to the non-financial public sector, for temporary overdrafts through checking accounts of the Municipality of Córdoba and Reconquista. Sanction amount: 2,400.

Responsible: Banco Macro SA and Directors (Jorge Horacio Brito, Jorge Pablo Brito and Marcos Brito).

Status: On 03/02/2015 the Central Bank passed Resolution No. 183/15 imposing fines to the Bank, which were debited from the Bank´s account 00285 on 03/12/2015. On 03/30/2015 a direct appeal was filed against such resolution to CNACAF. On April 2015 the appeal was presented at the Courtroom IV of the Federal Contentious Administrative Court of Appeals under No. 19,971/2015. On 06/23/2015 the Court informed BCRA about the appeal presented by Banco Macro. On 09/24/2015 proceedings were returned and are ready for the issuance of a decision. The bank appealed the resolution under the terms of Art. 42 Law 21,256, giving rise to the below-referenced proceeding.

 

  20.3. Sanctions imposed by the Financial Information Unit (UIF).

File: No. 62/2009 dated 01/16/2009.

Reason: Purchase of foreign currency from April 2006 through August 2007. Sanction amount: 718

Responsible: Banco Macro SA and those in charge of Anti-money laundering regulation compliance (Juan Pablo Brito Devoto and Luis Carlos Cerolini).

Status: UIF passed Resolution No. 72/2011 on 06/09/2011, imposing fines to those responsible. An appeal was presented at CNACAF.

File: No. 62/2009 (extension) dated 09/06/2011.

Reason: Extension of the summary issued by Resolution 72/2011 for transaction performed from 04/03/2006 through 10/11/2006. Sanction amount: 538.

Responsible: Banco Macro SA and those in charge of Anti-money laundering regulation compliance (Fernando Andrés Sansuste).

Status: UIF passed Resolution No. 04/2014 imposing fines to those responsible. An appeal was presented at CNACAF.

File: No. 6338/2011 dated 11/23/2011.

Reason: Purchase of foreign currency. Sanction amount: 2,136

Responsible: Banco Macro SA, Directors and those in charge of Anti-money laundering regulation compliance. (1)

Status: UIF passed Resolution No. 110/2014 imposing fines to those responsible. An appeal was presented at CNACAF. The Bank has appealed the sanction imposed via direct appeal and such appeal (No. 16,411/14) is currently underway before the CNACAF.

File: No. 6420/2011 dated 11/23/2011.

Reason: Purchase of foreign currency. Sanction amount: 822.

Responsible: Banco Macro SA, Directors and those in charge of Anti-money laundering regulation compliance. (1)

Status: UIF passed Resolution No. 124/2014 imposing fines to those responsible. An appeal was presented at CNACAF. On 04/21/2015 the Court rejected the appeal presented and confirmed UIF resolution No. 124/2014. On 05/08/2015, an extraordinary appeal was presented to the Argentine Supreme Court (CSJN). On 06/09/2015 the Court denied the extraordinary appeal presented, with cost. On 06/17/2015 a complaint appeal was presented to CSJN, as denial of extraordinary appeal. As of the date, the file was sent to the Attorney General’s Office to issue its resolution prior to the Argentine Supreme Court’s decision.

File: No. 6406/2011 dated 11/23/2011.

Reason: Purchase of foreign currency. Sanction amount: 677.

Responsible: Banco Macro SA, Directors and those in charge of Anti-money laundering regulation compliance. (1)

 

F - 48


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

Status: UIF passed Resolution No. 171/2014 imposing fines to those responsible. An appeal was presented at CNACAF. On 10/08/2015 the Court admitted the direct appeal presented and annulled the Resolution No. 171/2014, admitting the prescription defense. UIF presented an extraordinary appeal against such CNACAF sentence. On November 17, 2015, the Court decided to dismiss the extraordinary appeal filed by the Financial Information Unit (“UIF”). The UIF appealed such resolution to the CNACAF. The appeal was dismissed on 04/05/2016. As a result, this ruling is final.

File: No. 6407/2011 dated 11/23/2011.

Reason: Purchase of foreign currency. Sanction amount: 802.

Responsible: Banco Macro SA, Directors and those in charge of Anti-money laundering regulation compliance. (1)

Status: UIF passed Resolution No. 132/2014 imposing fines to those responsible. An appeal was presented at CNACAF. On 09/18/2015, the court ordered that the file be rendered for final decision.

File: No. 6405/2011 dated 12/07/2011.

Reason: Purchase of foreign currency. Sanction amount: 1,504.

Responsible: Banco Macro SA, Directors and those in charge of Anti-money laundering regulation compliance. (1)

Status: UIF passed Resolution No. 26/2014 imposing fines to those responsible. An appeal was presented at CNACAF. On 10/08/2015 the Court admitted the direct appeal presented and annulled the Resolution No. 26/2014, admitting the prescription defense. UIF presented an extraordinary appeal against such CNACAF sentence. On November, 17, 2015, the Court decided to dismiss the extraordinary appeal filed by the Financial Information Unit (“UIF”). As of the date, the file is pending with the Argentine Supreme Court due to the petition for denied appeal filed by the UIF.

File: No. 6491/2011 dated 12/07/2011.

Reason: Banco Suquía SA –Deposits in checking account. Sanction amount: 791.

Responsible: Banco Macro SA, Directors and those in charge of Anti-money laundering regulation compliance (Juan Pablo Brito Devoto and Luis Carlos Cerolini – as Compliance Officers and Directors- and Jorge Horacio Brito, Delfín Jorge Ezequiel Carballo, Fernando Andrés Sansuste, Jorge Pablo Brito, Roberto Julio Eilbaum, Alejandro Macfarlane, Carlos Enrique Videla) Guillermo Eduardo Stanley and Constanza Brito – as Directors of Banco Macro SA).

Status: UIF passed Resolution No. 118/2014 imposing fines to those responsible. An appeal was presented at CNACAF. On 10/08/2015 the Court admitted the direct appeal presented and annulled the Resolution No. 118/2014, admitting the prescription defense. UIF presented an extraordinary appeal against such CNACAF sentence. The court ordered service of notice of such appeal to the Bank for a term of 10 business days. On November, 17, 2015, the Court decided to dismiss the extraordinary appeal filed by the Financial Information Unit (“UIF”). The UIF appealed such resolution to the CNACAF, which was dismissed on 04/05/2016. As a result, this ruling is final.

File: No. 6612/2011 dated 12/28/2011.

Reason: Purchase of foreign currency. Sanction amount: 688.

Responsible: Banco Macro SA, Directors and those in charge of Anti-money laundering regulation compliance. (1)

Status: UIF passed Resolution No. 53/2014 imposing fines to those responsible. An appeal was presented at CNACAF. The court ordered that the file be rendered for final decision.

File: No. 6614/2011 dated 12/28/2011.

Reason: Purchase of foreign currency. Sanction amount: 843.

Responsible: Banco Macro SA, Directors and those in charge of Anti-money laundering regulation compliance. (1)

Status: UIF passed Resolution No. 6/2014 imposing fines to those responsible. An appeal was presented at CNACAF. The court ordered that the file be rendered for final decision.

File: No. 160/2012 dated 05/10/2012.

Reason: Purchase of foreign currency. Sanction amount: 376.

Responsible: Banco Macro SA, Directors and those in charge of Anti-money laundering regulation compliance. (Jorge Horacio Brito, Delfín Jorge Ezequiel Carballo, Juan Pablo Brito Devoto, Jorge Pablo Brito, Luis Carlos Cerolini, Roberto Julio Eilbaum, Alejandro Macfarlane, Carlos Enrique Videla, Guillermo Eduardo Stanley and Constanza Brito).

 

F - 49


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

Status: UIF passed Resolution No. 160/2015 imposing fines to those responsible. An appeal was presented at CNACAF. On 11/23/2015 the Attorney General issued a resolution stating that the court should dismiss the request for unconstitutionality filed by the Bank. On November 30, 2015, the court ordered that the file be rendered for final decision. On 04/07/2016, the fines imposed by the UIF were revoked, based on prescription. The ruling was passed down on 04/11/2016 and the UIF has not yet filed an extraordinary appeal.

File: No. 517/2012 dated 06/27/2012.

Reason: Purchase of foreign currency. Sanction amount: 1,857.

Responsible: Banco Macro SA, Directors and those in charge of Anti-money laundering regulation compliance. (Luis Carlos Cerolini – as Compliance Officer and Director - and Jorge Horacio Brito, Delfín Jorge Ezequiel Carballo, Fernando Andrés Sansuste, Juan Pablo Brito Devoto, Jorge Pablo Brito, Roberto Julio Eilbaum, Alejandro Macfarlane, Carlos Enrique Videla, Guillermo Eduardo Stanley and Constanza Brito – as Directors of Banco Macro SA).

Status: UIF passed Resolution No. 500/2014 imposing fines to those responsible. An appeal was presented at CNACAF. On 09/01/2015 the UIF answered the service of notice of the direct appeal filed. On October 9, 2015, the Bank filed a brief whereby it dismissed informative evidence and requested documentary evidence. On October 9, 2015, the court took into account the Bank’s request and ordered that the file be rendered for final decision.

 

(1) Fernando Andrés Sansuste, Juan Pablo Brito Devoto y Luis Carlos Cerolini – as Compliance Officer and Director—and Jorge Horacio Brito, Delfín Jorge Ezequiel Carballo, Jorge Pablo Brito, Roberto Julio Eilbaum, Alejandro Macfarlane, Carlos Enrique Videla, Guillermo Eduardo Stanley and Constanza Brito – as Directors of Banco Macro SA.

Although, sanctions do not involve material amounts, as of the date of issuance of these financial statements, the total amount of monetary sanctions received, pending to be paid for been appealed or about to be appealed, amounted to 11,752, which was recorded according to Communiqué “A” 5689 of Central Bank.

Additionally, there are pending summaries at CNV and UIF, as described below:

File: No.1480/2011 (CNV Resolution No. 17,529 dated 09/26/2014).

Reason: Potential non-compliance with the obligation to inform a “Significant Event”.

Responsible: Banco Macro SA, Directors, Statutory Audit Committee members and person in charge of Market relations (Jorge Horacio Brito, Delfín Jorge Ezequiel Carballo, Juan Pablo Brito Devoto, Jorge Pablo Brito, Luis Carlos Cerolini, Roberto Julio Eilbaum, Alejandro Macfarlane, Carlos Enrique Videla, Guillermo Eduardo Stanley, Constanza Brito, Daniel Hugo Violatti, Ladislao Szekely, Santiago Marcelo Maidana and Herman Fernando Aner).

Status: On 10/28/2014, rebuttal evidence was presented by the Bank and all the responsibles, requesting a ruling in their favor.

File: No. 248/2014 (UIF presidential note 245/2013 11/26/2013) dated 07/30/2014.

Reason: Alleged deficiencies in preparing certain “Reports on suspicious transactions (ROS)” due to cases of infringement detected in certain customer files.

Responsible: Banco Macro SA, Directors and those in charge of Anti-money laundering regulation compliance (Luis Carlos Cerolini (as Compliance Officer and Director) and Jorge Horacio Brito, Delfin Jorge Ezequiel Carballo, Juan Pablo Brito Devoto, Jorge Pablo Brito, Alejandro Macfarlane, Carlos Enrique Videla, Guillermo Eduardo Stanley, Constanza Brito, Emanuel Antonio Alvarez Agis, Marcos Brito and Rafael Magnanini – as Directors of Banco Macro SA).

The Bank Management and its legal advisors consider no further significant accounting effects than could arise from the effect of the above mentioned situations.

 

F - 50


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

21. BALANCES IN FOREIGN CURRENCY

The balances of assets and liabilities denominated in foreign currency are as follows:

 

     As of December 31,  
     2015      2014  

ASSETS

     

Cash

     10,102,645         5,804,389   

Government and private securities

     4,051,366         1,603,680   

Loans

     1,797,220         1,939,340   

Other receivables from financial intermediation

     539,707         449,205   

Investments in other companies

     1,089         1,217   

Other receivables

     174,348         85,025   

Items pending allocation

     4,776         3,286   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total

     16,671,151         9,886,142   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

LIABILITIES

     

Deposits

     10,475,281         4,652,287   

Other liabilities from financial intermediation

     2,361,244         1,660,830   

Other liabilities

     14,516         5,529   

Subordinated Corporate Bonds

     1,957,618         1,287,317   

Items pending allocation

     273         12   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total

     14,808,932         7,605,975   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

22. INTEREST-BEARING DEPOSITS WITH OTHER BANKS

“Cash” includes interest-bearing deposits in foreign banks totaling 1,271,350 and 954,817 as of December 31, 2015 and 2014, respectively.

Those interest-bearing deposits in foreign banks yielded a nominal annual interest rate of approximately 0.0913% and 0.30% as of December 31, 2015 and 2014, respectively.

In 2015 and 2014 the deposits with the Central Bank and other Banks did not bear any interest.

 

23. GOVERNMENT AND PRIVATE SECURITIES

 

     As of December 31,  
     2015      2014  
GOVERNMENT SECURITIES      

Government securities at market value

     

In pesos:

     

Discount bonds at 5.83% – Maturity: 2033

     1,597,140         862,088   

Federal government bonds at Badlar + 2% – Maturity: 03-28-2017

     484,928         494,833   

Federal government bonds at Badlar + 2% – Maturity: 2016

     337,075         377,042   

Federal government treasury bonds – Maturity: May 2016

     313,686         —     

Federal government treasury bonds – Maturity: March 2016

     143,470         —     

Consolidation bonds – 8° Serie

     119,119         65,085   

Secured bonds under Presidential Decree 1579/02 at 2% – Maturity: 02-04-2018

     94,259         111,749   

Federal government treasury bonds – Maturity: July 2016

     76,822         —     

Federal government bonds at Badlar Private + 2.5% – Maturity: 2019

     47,577         38,560   

Federal government bonds at Badlar Private + 3% – Maturity: 2017

     22,647         —     

Other

     11,527         337,344   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Subtotal Government securities at market value – In pesos

     3,248,250         2,286,701   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

In foreign currency:

     

US Treasury Bill – Maturity: 01-28-2016

     572,175         —     

US Treasury Bill – Maturity: 01-07-2016

     325,124         —     

US Treasury Bill – Maturity: 03-03-2016

     234,055         —     

Federal Government bonds at 8.75% – Maturity: 2024

     215,298         —     

US Treasury Bill – Maturity: 02-25-2016

     130,035         —     

US Treasury Bill – Maturity: 02-18-2016

     117,031         —     

US Treasury Bill – Maturity: 01-14-2016

     100,136         —     

Debt Securities of Province of Neuquén Series I Class I in US dollars – Maturity: 06-12-2016

     9,427         30,766   

Debt Securities of the Province of Córdoba in US dollars at 12% – Maturity: 2017

     1,723         1,864   

GDP – Related Securities – Maturity: 2035 (NY)

     1,687         1,640   

Other

     349         1,148,645   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Subtotal Government securities at market value – In foreign currency

     1,707,040         1,182,915   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Subtotal Government securities at market value

     4,955,290         3,469,616   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

F - 51


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

     As of December 31,  
     2015      2014  
GOVERNMENT SECURITIES (cont)      

Government securities at amortized cost

     

In pesos:

     

Province of Chubut treasury bills Class XVI – Maturity: 11-26-2016

     400,682         —     

Province of Neuquén guarantee Treasury Bills Class I Serie III – Maturity: 11-23-2017

     130,764         —     

Federal government bonds at Badlar Private + 2.5% – Maturity: 2019

     115,302         161,937   

Province of Neuquén guarantee Treasury Bills Class I Series I – Maturity: 03-07-2017

     67,704         —     

Province of Entre Ríos Treasury Bills – Maturity: 12-11-2016

     26,031         25,487   

Province of Chaco Treasury Bills Class I

     24,556         —     

Province of Neuquén guarantee Treasury Bills Class I Series I – Maturity: 05-28-2016

     19,723         —     

Province of Mendoza Bills – Maturity: 10-22-2016

     4,439         —     

Province of Tucumán bonds – 1° Serie – Maturity: 2018

     2,398         3,407   

Other

     —           15,453   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Subtotal Government securities at amortized cost – In pesos

     791,599         206,284   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

In foreign currency:

     

Argentine saving bond for the economy development in US dollars at 4% – Maturity: 07-27-2016

     196,411         129,184   

Deposit certificates of investment

     17,681         —     

Province of Tucumán bonds – 2° Serie in US dollars at 9.45% – Maturity: 2015

     —           834   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Subtotal Government securities at amortized cost – In foreign currency

     214,092         130,018   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Subtotal Government securities at amortized cost

     1,005,691         336,302   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Instruments issued by the Central Bank of Argentina

     

In pesos:

     

Listed Central Bank of Argentina bills and notes (Lebacs/Nobacs)

     5,066,846         3,820,548   

Unlisted Central Bank of Argentina bills and notes (Lebacs/Nobacs)

     1,105,912         1,618,630   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Subtotal instruments issued by Central Bank of Argentina – In pesos

     6,172,758         5,439,178   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

In foreign currency:

     

Unlisted Central Bank of Argentina bills and notes (Lebacs/Nobacs)

     2,130,234         290,747   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Subtotal instruments issued by Central Bank of Argentina – In foreign currency

     2,130,234         290,747   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Subtotal instruments issued by Central Bank of Argentina

     8,302,992         5,729,925   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total government securities (1)

     14,263,973         9,535,843   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 
PRIVATE SECURITIES      

Investments in listed private securities – Shares

     

In pesos:

     

Petrolera Pampa SA

     276,211         99,231   

Siderar SAIC

     218,781         154,670   

YPF SA

     196,423         258,458   

Aluar Aluminio Argentino SAIC

     195,354         124,724   

Telecom Argentina Stet-France Telecom SA

     156,951         87,378   

Petrobras Energía SA

     45,674         30,286   

Molinos Río de la Plata SA

     20,419         8,858   

Cresud SAIC

     13,015         9,169   

IRSA Inversiones y Presentación SA

     2,833         2,886   

Alto Palermo SA (Apsa)

     1,738         995   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Subtotal investment in listed private securities – Shares - In pesos

     1,127,399         776,655   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total Investment in listed private securities - Shares

     1,127,399         776,655   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 
               
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total private securities

     1,127,399         776,655   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total government and private securities

     15,391,372         10,312,498   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

(1) As of December 31, 2015 and 2014, includes government securities under reverse repurchase agreements for an amount of 3,450 and 117,938, respectively, and as of December 31 2014, instruments issued by Central Bank under reverse repurchase agreements for an amount of 58,582.

 

F - 52


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

     Maturing  
     Within 1
year
     After 1 year
but within
5 years
     After 5 years
but within 10
years
     After 10
years
     Without
due date
     Total  
     Book value  
GOVERNMENT SECURITIES                  

Government securities at market value

                 

In pesos:

     920,696         653,825         395,248         1,278,481         —           3,248,250   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Discount bonds at 5.83% – Maturity: 2033

     —           —           319,428         1,277,712         —           1,597,140   

Federal government bonds at Badlar + 2% – Maturity: 03-28-2017

     —           484,928         —           —           —           484,928   

Federal government bonds at Badlar + 2% – Maturity: 2016

     337,075         —           —           —           —           337,075   

Federal government treasury bonds – Maturity: May 2016

     313,686         —           —           —           —           313,686   

Federal government treasury bonds – Maturity: March 2016

     143,470         —           —           —           —           143,470   

Consolidation bonds – 8° Serie

     —           45,265         73,854         —           —           119,119   

Secured bonds under Presidential Decree 1579/02 at 2% – Maturity: 02-04-2018

     43,233         51,026         —           —           —           94,259   

Federal government treasury bonds – Maturity: July 2016

     76,822         —           —           —           —           76,822   

Federal government bonds at Badlar Private + 2.5% – Maturity: 2019

     —           47,577         —           —           —           47,577   

Federal government bonds at Badlar Private + 3% – Maturity: 2017

     —           22,647         —           —           —           22,647   

Other

     6,410         2,382         1,966         769         —           11,527   

In foreign currency:

     1,488,844         72,648         143,564         1,984         —           1,707,040   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

US Treasury Bill – Maturity: 01-28-2016

     572,175         —           —           —           —           572,175   

US Treasury Bill – Maturity: 01-07-2016

     325,124         —           —           —           —           325,124   

US Treasury Bill – Maturity: 03-03-2016

     234,055         —           —           —           —           234,055   

Federal Government bonds at 8.75% – Maturity: 2024

     —           71,737         143,561         —           —           215,298   

US Treasury Bill – Maturity: 02-25-2016

     130,035         —           —           —           —           130,035   

US Treasury Bill – Maturity: 02-18-2016

     117,031         —           —           —           —           117,031   

US Treasury Bill – Maturity: 01-14-2016

     100,136         —           —           —           —           100,136   

Debt Securities of Province of Neuquén Series I Class I in US dollars – Maturity: 06-12-2016

     9,427         —           —           —           —           9,427   

Debt Securities of the Province of Córdoba in US dollars at 12% – Maturity: 2017

     861         862         —           —           —           1,723   

GDP – Related Securities – Maturity: 2035 (NY)

     —           —           —           1,687         —           1,687   

Other

     —           49         3         297         —           349   

Government securities at amortized cost

                 

In pesos:

     502,684         288,915         —           —           —           791,599   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Province of Chubut treasury bills Class XVI – Maturity: 11-26-2016

     400,682         —           —           —           —           400,682   

Province of Neuquén guarantee treasury bills Class I Serie III – Maturity: 11-23-2017

     26,153         104,611         —           —           —           130,764   

Federal government bonds at Badlar Private + 2.5% – Maturity: 2019

     —           115,302         —           —           —           115,302   

Province of Neuquén guarantee treasury bills Class I Series I – Maturity: 03-07-2017

     —           67,704         —           —           —           67,704   

Province of Entre Ríos treasury bills – Maturity: 12-11-2016

     26,031         —           —           —           —           26,031   

Province of Chaco treasury bills Class I

     24,556         —           —           —           —           24,556   

Province of Neuquén guarantee treasury bills Class I Series I – Maturity: 05-28-2016

     19,723         —           —           —           —           19,723   

Province of Mendoza bills – Maturity: 10-22-2016

     4,439         —           —           —           —           4,439   

Province of Tucumán bonds – 1° Serie – Maturity: 2018

     1,100         1,298         —           —           —           2,398   

In foreign currency:

     196,411         —           —           —           17,681         214,092   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Argentine saving bond for the economy development in US dollars at 4% – Maturity: 07-27-2016

     196,411         —           —           —           —           196,411   

Deposit certificates of investment

     —           —           —           —           17,681         17,681   

 

F - 53


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

     Maturing  
     Within 1
year
     After 1 year
but within
5 years
     After 5 years
but within 10
years
     After 10
years
     Without
due date
     Total  
     Book value  
GOVERNMENT SECURITIES (contd.)                  

Instruments issued by the Central Bank of Argentina

                 

In pesos:

     6,172,758                     6,172,758   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Listed Central Bank of Argentina bills and notes (Lebacs/Nobacs)

     5,066,846         —           —           —           —           5,066,846   

Unlisted Central Bank of Argentina bills and notes (Lebacs/Nobacs)

     1,105,912         —           —           —           —           1,105,912   

In foreign currency:

     2,130,234         —           —           —           —           2,130,234   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Unlisted Central Bank of Argentina bills and notes (Lebacs/Nobacs)

     2,130,234         —           —           —           —           2,130,234   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total government securities

     11,411,627         1,015,388         538,812         1,280,465         17,681         14,263,973   
PRIVATE SECURITIES                  

Investments in listed private securities – Shares

                 

In pesos:

     —           —           —           —           1,127,399         1,127,399   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Petrolera Pampa SA

     —           —           —           —           276,211         276,211   

Siderar SAIC

     —           —           —           —           218,781         218,781   

YPF SA

     —           —           —           —           196,423         196,423   

Aluar Aluminio Argentino SAIC

     —           —           —           —           195,354         195,354   

Telecom Argentina Stet-France Telecom SA

     —           —           —           —           156,951         156,951   

Petrobras Energía SA

     —           —           —           —           45,674         45,674   

Molinos Río de la Plata SA

     —           —           —           —           20,419         20,419   

Cresud SAIC

     —           —           —           —           13,015         13,015   

IRSA Inversiones y Presentación SA

     —           —           —           —           2,833         2,833   

Alto Palermo SA (Apsa)

     —           —           —           —           1,738         1,738   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total private securities

     —           —           —           —           1,127,399         1,127,399   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total government and private securities

     11,411,627         1,015,388         538,812         1,280,465         1,145,080         15,391,372   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

24. LOANS

Description of certain categories of loans in the accompanying Balance Sheets include:

 

  a. Non-financial government sector: loans to the government sector, excluding government owned financial institutions.

 

  b. Financial sector: mainly, refers to short-term loans to financial institutions.

 

  c. Non-financial private sector and foreign residents: loans given to the private sector (excluding financial institutions) and residents outside Argentina.

 

F - 54


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

The classification of the loan portfolio in this regard was as follows:

 

     As of December 31,  

Description

   2015      2014  

Non-financial government sector

     748,067         604,417   

Financial sector

     227,390         213,867   

Non-financial private sector and foreign residents

     

Commercial

     

- With Senior “A” guarantees

     2,437,891         1,357,544   

- With Senior “B” guarantees

     4,331,975         2,901,979   

- Without Senior guarantees

     12,736,246         9,879,919   

Consumer

     

- With Senior “A” guarantees

     559,995         504,340   

- With Senior “B” guarantees

     2,302,121         2,100,410   

- Without Senior guarantees

     40,484,694         27,363,863   

Less: Allowance

     (1,495,964      (1,186,044
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total loans, net of allowances

     62,332,415         43,740,295   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Senior “A” guarantees consist mainly of cash guarantees, gold guarantees, warrants over primary products and other forms of self-liquidating collateral.

Senior “B” guarantees generally consist of mortgages and other forms of collateral pledged to secure the loan amount.

“Without senior guarantees” consist, in general, of unsecured third-party guarantees.

A breakdown of total loans by geographical location of borrowers is as follows:

 

Geographical location

   2015      2014  

Argentina

     63,810,233         44,816,064   

Costa Rica

     13,311         8,753   

Uruguay

     4,156         3,515   

Spain

     523         158   

Brazil

     52         22   

United States of America

     49         81   

Netherlands

     21         —     

France

     13         —     

Panama

     9         —     

Chile

     7         —     

Italy

     4         21   

Australia

     1         —     

British Virgin Islands

     —           96,787   

India

     —           878   

Germany

     —           35   

Bolivia

     —           24   

Romania

     —           1   

Less: Allowance

     (1,495,964      (1,186,044
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total loans, net of allowances

     62,332,415         43,740,295   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

A breakdown of total loans by sector activity classified according to the principal business of the borrowers is as follows:

 

Economic Activity

   2015      2014  

Retail loans

     31,867,480         21,299,813   

Agricultural livestock- Forestry-Fishing- Mining - Hunting

     6,625,416         4,526,591   

Retail and consumer products

     5,485,954         4,036,678   

Foodstuff and beverages

     3,245,347         2,542,659   

Construction

     3,164,972         2,266,493   

Other services

     2,547,403         2,027,874   

Manufacturing and wholesale

     1,692,774         1,022,551   

Transportation, storage and communications

     1,668,776         1,240,657   

Governmental services

     1,666,133         1,211,314   

 

F - 55


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

Economic Activity (Contd.)

   2015      2014  

Chemicals

     1,113,050         1,391,433   

Real estate, business and leases

     1,098,488         770,437   

Financial Services

     688,377         632,579   

Electricity, oil, water

     452,372         178,516   

Hotels and restaurants

     173,591         166,216   

Other

     2,338,246         1,612,528   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total loans

     63,828,379         44,926,339   

Less: Allowance

     (1,495,964      (1,186,044
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total loans, net of Allowance

     62,332,415         43,740,295   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

25. OTHER RECEIVABLES AND PAYABLES FROM FINANCIAL INTERMEDIATION

The breakdown of Other receivables from financial intermediation by guarantee type is as follows:

 

Description

   As of December 31,  
   2015      2014  

Without preferred guarantees

     3,538,281         2,584,863   

Allowances

     (243,028      (235,755
  

 

 

    

 

 

 
     3,295,253         2,349,108   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

The breakdown of private securities recorded in Other receivables from financial intermediation is as follows:

 

Description

   As of December 31,  
   2015      2014  

Corporate bonds — Unlisted (1)

     603,567         463,816   

Certificates of participation in financial trusts — Unlisted (1)

     234,345         244,965   

Debt securities in financial trusts — Unlisted

     195,556         168,385   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total investments in unlisted private securities

     1,033,468         877,166   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

(1) As of December 31, 2015 and 2014, the Bank booked allowances for impairment in value amounting to 237,191 and 232,574, respectively (see also Note 28).

As of December 31, 2015, maturities for the private securities disclosed above are as follows:

 

     Within 1
year
     After 1
year but
within 5
years
     After 10
years
     Without
due date
    Total  

Corporate bonds —Unlisted

     39,002         558,065         —           6,500        603,567   

Certificates of participation in financial trusts —Unlisted

     2,257         —           8,256         223,832  (1)      234,345   

Debt securities in financial trusts —Unlisted

     150,179         45,377         —           —          195,556   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

 

Total investments in unlisted private securities

     191,438         603,442         8,256         230,332        1,033,468   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

 

 

(1) As of December 31, 2015 this amount was included in the Bank allowances for impairment.

 

F - 56


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

The Bank enters into spot and forward transactions related to government securities and foreign currencies. The Bank recognizes cash, security or currency amount to be exchanged in the future as a receivable and payable at the original transaction date. The assets and liabilities related to such transactions are as follows:

 

     As of December 31,  

Description

   2015      2014  

Amounts receivable from spot and forward sales pending settlement

     

Receivable from spot sales of government and private securities pending settlement

     183,329         103,546   

Receivables from repo transactions of government securities

     3,160         163,755   

Receivables from spot sales of foreign currency pending settlement

     707         7,922   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 
     187,196         275,223   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Securities and foreign currency receivable from spot and forward purchases pending settlement

     

Spot purchases of government and private securities pending settlement

     64,837         31,867   

Spot purchases of foreign currency pending settlement

     52,868         7,919   

Forward purchases of securities under repo transactions

     2,047         —     

Other spot purchases pending settlement

     —           10,460   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 
     119,752         50,246   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Amounts payable for spot and forward purchases pending settlement

     

Payables for spot purchases of government securities pending settlement

     64,978         26,122   

Payables for spot purchases of foreign currency pending settlement

     52,747         7,925   

Payables for forward purchases of securities under repo transactions

     1,974         —     

Other payables for spot purchase pending settlement

     160,159         88,419   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 
     279,858         122,466   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Securities and foreign currency to be delivered under spot and forward sales pending settlement

     

Spot sales of government and private securities pending settlement

     38,448         50,946   

Forward sales of government securities under repo transactions

     3,456         176,662   

Spot sales of foreign currency pending settlement

     848         7,966   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 
     42,752         235,574   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

These instruments consist of foreign currency and securities contracts (spot and forward purchases and sales), whose valuation method is disclosed in Note 4.5.g). The fair value of these instruments were:

 

     End-of-year fair value  

Description

   2015      2014  

Assets

     119,752         50,360   

Liabilities

     42,752         235,652   

Premiums on these instruments have been included in the “Financial income” and “Financial expense” captions of the consolidated statements of income of each year.

 

F - 57


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

26. BANK PREMISES AND EQUIPMENT AND OTHER ASSETS

 

  26.1 Premises and Equipment

The major categories of the Bank’s premises and equipment, and related accumulated depreciation are presented in the following table:

 

     As of December, 31  

Description

   Estimated
useful life
(years)
     2015      2014  

Buildings

     50         866,459         672,136   

Furniture and facilities

     10         237,056         181,672   

Machinery and equipment

     5         639,006         567,805   

Vehicles

     5         85,199         74,104   

Accumulated depreciation

        (646,761      (570,290
     

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total

        1,180,959         925,427   
     

 

 

    

 

 

 

Depreciation expense was 170,613, 130,678 and 98,666 as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively.

 

  26.2 Other assets

Other assets consisted of the following as of December 31, 2015 and 2014:

 

     As of December, 31  

Description

   Estimated
useful life
(years)
     2015      2014  

Works in progress (1)

     —           756,855         364,037   

Works of art

     —           3,204         1,187   

Prepayments for the purchase of assets

     —           153,921         74,925   

Foreclosed assets

     50         113,604         115,582   

Stationery and office supplies

     —           31,961         28,562   

Other assets (2)

     50         361,127         236,791   

Accumulated depreciation

        (15,517      (12,845
     

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total

        1,405,155         808,239   
     

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

(1) As of December 31, 2015 and 2014, it includes 704,601 and 328,365, respectively, related to a new corporate building tower that is being constructed by the Bank. See also Note 35.16.
(2) Mainly includes improvement to properties leased by the Bank to be used in the normal course of business.

Depreciation expense was 3,748, 3,196 and 3,051 as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively.

 

  26.3. Operating Leases

As of December 31, 2015, the Bank’s branch network includes certain branches that were located in properties leased to the Bank (some of which are renewable for periods between 2 and 10 years).

 

F - 58


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

The estimated future lease payments in connection with these properties are as follows:

 

Fiscal year end

   Amounts  

2016

     103,833   

2017

     54,880   

2018

     27,848   

2019

     17,472   

2020

     5,855   

2021 and after

     2,380   
  

 

 

 

Total

     212,268   
  

 

 

 

As of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, rental expenses amounted to 137,288, 110,875 and 77,713, respectively. As of such dates, there are no contractual obligations with separate amounts of minimum rentals, contingent rentals, and sublease rental income.

 

27. INTANGIBLE ASSETS

 

  27.1 Goodwill:

As of December 31, 2015 and 2014 goodwill breakdown is as follows:

 

     As of December 31,  

Description

   Estimated
useful life
(years)
     2015      2014  

Goodwill for the purchase of Banco del Tucumán S.A., net of accumulated amortization of 17,639 as of December 31, 2015 (a)

     10         603         2,431   

Goodwill for the purchase of Nuevo Banco Bisel S.A., net of accumulated amortization of 62,190 as of December 31, 2015 (b)

     10         3,852         10,457   

Goodwill for the purchase of Banco Privado de Inversiones S.A., net of accumulated amortization of 29,976 as of December 31, 2015 (c)

     10         26,229         31,848   
     

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total

        30,684         44,736   
     

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

(a) On May 5, 2006, Banco Macro acquired 75% of the capital stock of Banco del Tucumán SA in the amount of 45,961. The assets transferred amounted to 700,612 and the liabilities assumed amounted to 660,547.

Additionally, from September through December 2006, Banco Macro SA acquired 4.84% of the capital stock of Banco del Tucumán SA.

Finally, on November 28, 2006, the General Regular and Special Shareholder’s Meeting of Banco del Tucumán SA approved a capital increase of 21,980, establishing an additional paid-in capital of 26,171. During January 2007, Banco Macro SA subscribed the total increase, thus increasing its overall interest in Banco del Tucumán SA to 89.93%.

Under Central Bank rules, as a result of the acquisition, the Bank booked a positive goodwill amounting to 18,242, which is amortized over ten years and no impairment is required.

 

(b) On August 11, 2006, the Bank acquired 92.73% of the capital stock of Nuevo Banco Bisel SA in the amount of 19,509. The assets transferred amounted to 1,824,644 and the liabilities assumed amounted to 1,804,534.

Under Central Bank rules, as a result of the acquisition, the Bank booked a positive goodwill amounting to 66,042, which is amortized over ten years and no impairment is required.

 

F - 59


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

(c) On September 22, 2010, the Bank acquired 100% of the capital stock of Banco Privado de Inversiones SA in the amount of USD 23.3 million, out of which, USD 10.4 million was related to an escrowed amount, as provided in the purchase agreement. The assets transferred amounted to 403,686 and the liabilities assumed amounted to 368,034.

Under Central Bank rules, as a result of the acquisition, the Bank booked a positive goodwill amounting to 56,205, which is amortized over ten years and no impairment is required.

Amortization expense on goodwill was 14,052, as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013.

 

  27.2. Organization and development costs:

As of December 31, 2015 and 2014, the organization and development costs breakdown is as follows:

 

     As of December 31,  

Description

   Estimated
useful life
(years)
     2015      2014  

Cost from information technology projects (a)

     5         392,058         290,654   

Organizational cost (b)

     5         4,899         4,195   

Other capitalized cost (c)

     5         67,458         69,565   
     

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total

        464,415         364,414   
     

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

(a) Under Central Bank rules, the Bank records as expense software cost relating to preliminary application development and post-implementation stages of software development.
(b) Under Central Bank rules, the Bank records cost inherent to the set up and organization of the Bank.
(c) Under Central Bank rules, the Bank records cost inherent to the improvements in building leased.

 

     Amortization expense was 150,619, 122,704 and 89,019 as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively, which was recorded in Administrative expenses and Other expenses.

Intangible assets changed as follows during fiscal years ended December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013:

 

     Fiscal year ended December 31,  
     2015      2014      2013  

Balance at the beginning of the fiscal year

     409,150         343,979         288,531   

Additions

     250,752         202,029         158,519   

Decreases

     (132      (102      —     

Amortization expense (1)

     (164,671      (136,756      (103,071
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Balance at the end of the fiscal year

     495,099         409,150         343,979   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

(1) See Note 31.

 

F - 60


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

28. ALLOWANCES AND PROVISIONS

The Bank had recorded allowances and provisions for:

Loans: recorded in compliance with the provision of Communiqué “A” 2950, as supplemented, of the Central Bank, taking into account Note 4.5.f).

Other receivables from financial intermediation: recorded in compliance with the provision of Communication “A” 2950, as supplemented, of the Central Bank, taking into account Notes 4.5.f) and 4.5.g.3).

Receivables from financial leases: recorded in compliance with the provision of Communiqué “A” 2950, as supplemented, of the Central Bank, taking into account Note 4.5.f).

Investment in other companies: recorded to cover possible impairment risk arising from investments in other companies.

Other receivables: recorded to cover collectibility risks of other receivables.

Contingent commitments: recorded under Central Bank’s rules to cover contingent losses related to loan commitments. These amounts have been accrued in accordance with Central Bank’s rules, which are similar to FASB ASC 450 “Contingencies”.

Other loss contingencies: mainly includes labor litigation and customer and other third-party claims. The amounts have been accrued in accordance with Central Bank’s rules, which are similar to FASB ASC 450 “Contingencies”.

Difference from court deposit dollarization: recorded under Central Bank’s rules to cover the difference from court deposit dollarization.

The followings are the changes in the Bank’s allowances and provisions:

 

     As of December 31, 2015  
     Balance at
the beginning
of the fiscal
year
     Increase      Reversals     Charge off     Balance at
the end of the
fiscal year
 

Allowances

            

- Loans

     1,186,044         1,057,228         (11,967     (735,341     1,495,964   

- Other receivables from financial intermediation

     235,755         14,568         (2,424     (4,871     243,028   

- Receivables from financial leases

     4,459         952         (25     (34     5,352   

- Investment in other companies

     1,506         252         —          (163     1,595   

- Other receivables

     5,383         2,133         (160     (2,760     4,596   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

Total of allowances

     1,433,147         1,075,133         (14,576     (743,169     1,750,535   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

Provisions

            

- Contingent commitments

     2,264         4,339         (13     —          6,590   

- Other loss contingencies

     138,604         163,448         (4     (105,542     196,506   

- Difference from court deposit dollarization

     31,055         16,235         (2,645     —          44,645   

- Administrative, disciplinary and criminal sanctions

     —           14,152         —          (2,400     11,752   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

Total of provisions

     171,923         198,174         (2,662     (107,942     259,493   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

 

F - 61


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

     As of December 31, 2014  
     Balance at
the beginning
of the fiscal
year
     Increase      Reversals     Charge off     Balance at
the end of the
fiscal year
 

Allowances

            

- Loans

     1,006,495         757,445         (14,713     (563,183     1,186,044   

- Other receivables from financial intermediation

     232,290         8,495         (989     (4,041     235,755   

- Receivables from financial leases

     5,015         1,076         (694     (938     4,459   

- Investment in other companies

     1,330         306         (130     —          1,506   

- Other receivables

     6,929         1,145         (2,254     (437     5,383   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

Total of allowances

     1,252,059         768,467         (18,780     (568,599     1,433,147   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

Provisions

            

- Contingent commitments

     4,806         12         (2,554     —          2,264   

- Other loss contingencies

     131,274         34,292         (2,167     (24,795     138,604   

- Difference from court deposit dollarization

     23,301         8,018         (231     (33     31,055   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

Total of provisions

     159,381         42,322         (4,952     (24,828     171,923   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 
     As of December 31, 2013  
     Balance at
the beginning
of the fiscal
year
     Increase      Reversals     Charge off     Balance at
the end of

the fiscal
year
 

Allowances

            

- Loans

     887,156         707,370         (24,606     (563,425     1,006,495   

- Other receivables from financial intermediation

     233,123         5,236         (2,831     (3,238     232,290   

- Receivables from financial leases

     6,599         912         (10     (2,486     5,015   

- Investment in other companies

     1,379         76         (125     —          1,330   

- Other receivables

     9,282         1,722         (894     (3,181     6,929   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

Total of allowances

     1,137,539         715,316         (28,466     (572,330     1,252,059   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

Provisions

            

- Contingent commitments

     5         4,804         (3     —          4,806   

- Other loss contingencies

     114,566         38,364         (556     (21,100     131,274   

- Difference from court deposit dollarization

     17,112         6,632         —          (443     23,301   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

Total of provisions

     131,683         49,800         (559     (21,543     159,381   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

Under Central Bank rules allowances for loan losses includes allowances for “loans”, “other receivables for financial intermediation” and “receivables from financial leases”.

 

29. DEPOSITS AND OTHER LIABILITIES FROM FINANCIAL INTERMEDIATION

 

  29.1 Deposits

The aggregate amount of time deposits and investment accounts exceeding Ps.100 (thousands) or more as of December 31, 2015 and 2014 is 32,927,711 and 20,560,610, respectively.

 

  29.2. Central Bank of Argentina

The Bank borrowed funds under various credit facilities from the Central Bank for specific purposes, as follows:

 

     As of December 31, 2015     As of December 31, 2014  
     Principal      Interest and
CER
adjustments
     Rate     Principal      Interest and
CER
adjustments
     Rate  

Short–term liabilities

     12,660         46         4.28     10,651         95         5.09

Long–term liabilities

     208         3         2.00     6,210         3         8.76
  

 

 

    

 

 

      

 

 

    

 

 

    

Total

     12,868         49           16,861         98      
  

 

 

    

 

 

      

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

F - 62


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

Accrued interest is included in the “Central Bank of Argentina” under the “Other Liabilities from Financial Intermediation” in the accompanying Consolidated Balance Sheets. Amounts are unsecured.

 

  29.3. International banks and institutions

The Bank borrowed funds under various credit facilities from International banks and institutions for specific purposes, as follows:

 

     As of December 31, 2015     As of December 31, 2014  
     Principal      Interest      Rate     Principal      Interest      Rate  

Short–term liabilities

     97,789         809         4.91     87,858         455         6.28
  

 

 

    

 

 

      

 

 

    

 

 

    

Total

     97,789         809           87,858         455      
  

 

 

    

 

 

      

 

 

    

 

 

    

Accrued interest is included in the “Accrued interest, adjustments, foreign exchange and quoted price differences payable” under the “Other Liabilities from Financial Intermediation” in the accompanying Consolidated Balance Sheets. Amounts are unsecured.

 

  29.4. Financing received from Argentine financial institutions

The Bank borrowed funds under various credit facilities from the Argentine financial institutions for specific purposes, as follows:

 

     As of December 31, 2015     As of December 31, 2014  
     Principal      Interest      Rate     Principal      Interest      Rate  

Short–term liabilities

     49,926         11,718         13.41     15,311         223         5.43

Long–term liabilities

     9,180         13,560         7.78     5,178         31,075         6.74
  

 

 

    

 

 

      

 

 

    

 

 

    

Total

     59,106         25,278           20,489         31,298      
  

 

 

    

 

 

      

 

 

    

 

 

    

Interest includes accrued interest rate and CER adjustments. These amounts are recorded in “Accrued interest payables” under the Financing received from Argentine financial institutions and “Accrued interest, adjustments, foreign exchange and quoted price differences payables” under the “Other liabilities from financial intermediation” in the accompanying consolidated balance sheets. Except for the liability assumed with BICE (see Note 8), amounts are unsecured.

Maturities of the long-term liabilities in the table above for each of the following periods are as follows:

 

Periods

   As of
December 31,
2015
 

2017

     18,244   

2018

     4,496   
  

 

 

 
     22,740   
  

 

 

 

 

  29.5. Other

The rest of liabilities included in “Other liabilities from financial intermediation” are liabilities assumed for the Bank, mainly related to operating banking activities.

 

     As of December 31, 2015     As of December 31, 2014  
     Principal      Interest      Rate     Principal      Interest      Rate  

Short–term liabilities (1)

     4,926,449         —           0.00     3,807,397         7         0.00

Long–term liabilities (2)

     96,112         1,500         4.12     90,673         1,421         4.00
  

 

 

    

 

 

      

 

 

    

 

 

    

Total

     5,022,561         1,500           3,898,070         1,428      
  

 

 

    

 

 

      

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

(1) Includes mainly pending settlement transactions and payment accounts.

 

(2) Includes the liability assumed with SEDESA related to the acquisition of preferred shares of former Nuevo Banco Bisel S.A. in the amount of 94,300 and 90,673 as of December 31, 2015 and 2014, respectively (see Note 15.6.4).

 

F - 63


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

Additionally, the Bank has other liabilities related to corporate bonds and forward transactions (see Notes 11 and 25, respectively).

Accrued interest is included in the “Accrued interest, adjustments, foreign exchange and quoted price differences payable” under the “Other Liabilities from Financial Intermediation” in the accompanying Consolidated Balance Sheets. Amounts are unsecured.

 

30. EMPLOYEE BENEFIT PLANS

The Bank does not maintain pension plans for its personnel. The Bank is required to pay employer contributions, determined on the basis of total monthly payroll.

These expenses aggregated 598,425, 449,962 and 335,821 for the fiscal years ended December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively, and are included in the “Administrative expenses—Personnel expenses” account.

 

31. CONSOLIDATED INCOME STATEMENTS AND BALANCE SHEET

The presentation of consolidated financial statements under Central Bank’s rules differs significantly from the format required by the US SEC under Rules 9-03 and 9-04 of Regulation S-X (“Article 9”). The following consolidated financial statements were restated into constant pesos, as explained in Note 4.3. These consolidated financial statements were prepared using the measurement methods provided by Central Bank, but under US SEC requirements:

 

Consolidated Statements of Income

   2015      2014      2013  

Interest and fees on loans

     15,412,945         11,696,696         8,464,733   

Interest on bearing deposits with other banks

     155         127         241   

Interest on other receivables from financial intermediation

     109,151         260,977         168,173   

Interest on securities and foreign exchange purchased under resale agreements

     128,562         126,755         131,467   

Securities gains, net

     3,930,377         1,862,495         344,995   

Other interest income

     116,040         100,536         61,121   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total interest income

     19,697,230         14,047,586         9,170,730   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Interest on deposits

     6,774,958         5,188,797         3,109,168   

Interest on securities and foreign exchange purchased under resale agreements

     8,136         9,249         4,612   

Interest on short-term borrowings

     25,368         30,473         13,391   

Interest on long-term debt

     219,232         193,554         138,002   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total interest expense

     7,027,694         5,422,073         3,265,173   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Net interest income

     12,669,536         8,625,513         5,905,557   

Provision for loan losses, net (1)

     (729,124      (546,651      (435,556
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Net interest income after provision for loan losses

     11,940,412         8,078,862         5,470,001   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Service charges on deposit accounts and other fees

     3,561,203         2,798,967         2,022,656   

Credit-card service charges and fees

     1,399,351         1,004,636         677,716   

Other commissions

     115,093         93,768         76,563   

Foreign currency exchange trading income

     100,581         67,123         44,464   

Income from equity in other companies

     78,602         85,310         49,634   

Foreign exchange, net

     653,120         827,599         808,144   

Other

     838,208         611,690         453,225   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total non-interest income

     6,746,158         5,489,093         4,132,402   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Commissions

     410,588         288,053         205,176   

Salaries and payroll taxes

     4,310,559         3,180,761         2,344,369   

Outside consultants and services

     211,178         176,010         134,526   

Depreciation of bank premises and equipment

     173,611         132,376         99,256   

 

F - 64


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

Consolidated Statements of Income (Contd.)

   2015      2014      2013  

Rent

     135,970         110,274         77,229   

Stationery and supplies

     34,427         25,936         19,301   

Electric power and communications

     171,791         145,378         101,458   

Advertising and publicity

     143,883         128,387         103,438   

Taxes

     2,133,866         1,707,731         1,143,337   

Directors’ and Statutory Audits’ fee

     233,030         163,378         117,077   

Insurance

     27,159         22,646         18,227   

Security services

     313,309         249,176         192,874   

Maintenance, conservation and repair expenses

     321,287         255,965         186,990   

Amortization of organization and development costs (2)

     150,437         122,704         89,019   

Amortization of goodwill (2)

     14,052         14,052         14,052   

Provision for losses on other receivables and other allowances (3)

     185,714         42,731         50,624   

Other

     2,186,274         1,337,188         910,804   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total non-interest expense

     11,157,135         8,102,746         5,807,757   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Income before income tax expense

     7,529,435         5,465,209         3,794,646   

Income tax expense

     2,485,663         1,962,186         1,332,909   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Income from continuing operations

     5,043,772         3,503,023         2,461,737   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 
        
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Net income

     5,043,772         3,503,023         2,461,737   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Net income attributable to the noncontrolling interest

     35,359         23,492         18,173   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Net income attributable to the controlling interest

     5,008,413         3,479,531         2,443,564   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Earnings per common share attributable to controlling interest – stated in pesos (4)

     8.57         5.95         4.18   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

(1) Mainly includes allowances for loan losses and allowances for Receivables from financial leases, net of those related to Recovered loans.
(2) See Notes 27 and 35.5.
(3) Mainly includes provisions for losses, an other receivables and expenses related to contingent liabilities for probable claims, lawsuit and other proceedings, including those related to labor.
(4) Earnings per common share was computed by dividing net income by the weighted average number of outstanding common shares.

Central Bank rules also require certain classifications of assets and liabilities, which are different from those required by Article 9. The following table discloses the Bank’s consolidated balance sheets as of December 31, 2015, and 2014, as if the Bank followed the balance sheet disclosure requirements under Article 9:

 

     2015      2014  

ASSETS

     

Cash and due from banks

     17,304,712         14,036,728   

Interest-bearing deposits in other banks

     1,271,350         954,817   

Federal Funds sold and securities purchased under resale agreements of similar arrangements

     5,207         163,755   

Trading account assets

     6,211,975         4,106,719   

Investment securities available for sale

     10,148,716         6,714,356   

Loans

     64,359,734         45,368,057   

Allowance for loan losses

     (1,501,316      (1,190,503

Premises and equipment

     2,584,715         1,733,364   

Due from customers on acceptances

     1,364,407         365,420   

Other assets (1)

     3,737,931         2,485,987   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total assets

     105,487,431         74,738,700   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

F - 65


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

     2015      2014  

LIABILITIES AND SHAREHOLDERS’ EQUITY

     

Interest-bearing deposits

     55,877,265         37,634,505   

Non interest-bearing deposits

     19,828,730         16,646,159   

Federal Funds purchased and securities sold under repurchase agreements

     4,027         140   

Other short-term borrowings

     5,148,402         3,954,219   

Long-term borrowings

     1,504,230         1,044,450   

Contingent liabilities

     259,493         171,923   

Other liabilities

     3,538,872         2,049,749   

Bank acceptances outstanding

     1,364,407         365,420   

Subordinated corporate bonds

     1,957,618         1,287,317   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total liabilities

     89,483,044         63,153,882   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Common stocks

     584,563         584,563   

Retained appropriated earnings

     9,754,020         6,918,312   

Retained unappropriated earnings

     5,133,489         3,584,932   

Other shareholders’ equity

     404,010         404,010   

Noncontrolling interests

     128,305         93,001   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total shareholders’ equity

     16,004,387         11,584,818   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total liabilities and shareholders’ equity

     105,487,431         74,738,700   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

(1) As of December 31, 2015 and 2014, includes long-term investment for an amount of 10,909 and 11,231, respectively.

 

32. OPERATIONS BY GEOGRAPHICAL LOCATION

The principal financial information, classified by country of office where transactions originate, is shown below:

 

     As of December 31,  
     2015      2014      2013  

Total revenues

     26,633,657         19,689,640         13,433,069   

Argentina

     26,378,784         19,573,045         13,353,720   

Bahamas

     254,873         116,595         79,349   

Net income

     5,008,421         3,479,531         2,443,564   

Argentina

     4,789,093         3,382,597         2,383,265   

Bahamas

     219,328         96,934         60,299   

Total assets

     104,951,959         74,995,634         59,295,034   

Argentina

     102,093,543         73,269,854         57,625,024   

Bahamas

     2,858,416         1,725,780         1,670,010   

 

33. FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS WITH OFF-BALANCE SHEET RISK

The Bank enters into various transactions involving off-balance-sheet financial instruments. These instruments could be used to meet the risk management, trading and financing needs of customers or for the Bank’s proprietary trading and asset and liability management purposes, and could be subject to varying degrees of credit and market risk. Credit risk and market risk associated with on- and off-balance-sheet financial instruments are monitored on an aggregate basis.

The Bank uses the same credit policies in determining whether to enter or extend call and put option contracts, commitments, conditional obligations and guarantees as it does for granting loans.

 

F - 66


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

  33.1. Derivatives

In the normal course of business, the Bank enters into a variety of transactions principally in the foreign exchange and stock markets. Most counterparts in the derivative transactions are banks and other financial institutions.

These instruments include:

 

    Options: they confer the right to the buyer, but no obligation, to receive or pay a specific quantity of an asset or financial instrument for a specified price at or before a specified date. Options may be traded on a stock exchange or under OTC (Over-the-Counter) agreements.

 

    Forwards and Futures: they are agreements to deliver or take delivery at a specified rate, price or index applied against the underlying asset or financial instrument, at a specific date. Futures are exchange traded at standardized amounts of the underlying asset or financial instrument. Forwards contracts are OTC agreements and are principally dealt in by the Bank in securities/foreign exchange as forward agreements.

 

    Swaps: they are agreements between two parties with the intention to exchange cash flows and risks at a specific date and for a period in the future. Swaps may be exchange traded or under OTC agreements.

Pursuant to Central Bank’s rules, forward transactions with delivery of underlying assets, must be recorded under “Other receivables from financial intermediations” and “Other liabilities from financial intermediations” in the accompanying consolidated balance sheets and they were valued as mentioned in Note 4.5.g) (accrual method).

The notional contractual amount of these instruments represents the volume of outstanding transactions and does not represent the potential gain or loss associated with the market or credit risk of such transactions. The market risk of derivatives arises from the potential for changes in value due to fluctuations in market prices.

The credit risk of derivatives arises from the potential of the counterparty to default on its contractual obligations. The effect of such a default varies as the market value of derivative contracts changes. Credit exposure exists at a particular point in time when a derivative has a positive market value. The Bank attempts to limit its credit risk by dealing with creditworthy counterparts and obtaining collateral, where appropriate.

The following table shows, the notional value of options, swaps and outstanding forward contracts recorded in memorandum accounts as of December 31, 2015 and 2014:

 

     As of December 31,  
     2015      2014  

Forward sales of foreign exchange without delivery of underlying asset (a)

     3,298,973         2,569,298   

Forward purchases of foreign exchange without delivery of underlying asset (a)

     3,253,734         2,432,466   

Call options sold (b)

     138,521         114,479   

Put options taken (c)

     11,821         8,759   

 

(a) It is related to negotiation transactions of forward foreign currency exchange rates, carried out through MAE and “over the counter”. For transactions carried out through MAE, the differences of such trading transactions are settled on a daily basis based on the prices agreed upon and their quoted price upon maturity while “over the counter” transactions are settled upon maturity. In both cases, the underlying asset is not delivered or received.

 

(b) It is related to a call option sold to a Bank’s customer on a building received by the Bank as payment of loans granted by it. The initial price was set at 104,135, and will accrue interest at a corrected Badlar rate, re-calculated on a monthly basis, plus 200 basic points and the option’s exercise period is from July 24, 2014, through July 31, 2016, both dates included. As of the date of issuance of these consolidated financial statements, the holder has not exercised the option.

 

F - 67


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

(c) It is related to a put option taken with a Bank’s customer of a property received by the Bank as payment of loans granted by it for an amount of USD 908,975 and USD 1,024,250, respectively, and the option’s exercise period is from September 24, 2015, through September 23, 2016, both dates included. As of the date of the issuance of these consolidated financial statements, the Bank has not exercised the option.

Net income (loss) resulting from these transactions and repo and reverse repo, for the fiscal years ended December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, amount to income (loss) and are included in the “Financial Income - Other”:

 

Transactions

   2015      2014      2013  

Premiums on reverse repurchase agreements

     128,562         126,469         143,459   

Premiums on repurchase agreements

     8,137         9,249         16,666   

Interest rate swaps

     —           2,491         450   

Forwards of foreign currency

     48,901         143,459         100,442   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total

     185,600         281,668         261,017   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

  33.2. Credit-related financial instruments

The Bank’s exposure to credit loss in the event of the counterparts’ failure to fulfill the commitments to extending credit, guarantees granted and foreign trade acceptances is represented by the contractual notional amount of those investments.

Commitments to extend credit are agreements to lend to a customer at a future date, subject to compliance with contractual terms. Commitments generally have fixed expiration dates or other termination clauses and may require the payment of a fee. Since many of the commitments are expected to expire without being drawn upon, the total commitment amounts do not necessarily represent actual future cash requirements for the Bank. The Bank evaluates each customer’s creditworthiness on a case-by-case basis.

Foreign trade acceptances represent Bank customers’ liabilities on outstanding drafts or bills of exchange that have been accepted by the Bank and the Bank’s liability to remit payment upon the presentation of the accepted drafts or bills of exchange.

The credit risk involved in foreign trade acceptances and guarantees granted is essentially the same as that involved in extending loan facilities to customers. In order to grant guarantees to its customers, the Bank may require counter guarantees.

A summary of credit exposure related to these items is shown below (*):

 

     As of December 31,  
     2015      2014  

Other covered by debtors classification standards

     1,227,180         219,559   

Other guarantees provided covered by debtors classification standards

     163,905         112,092   

Other guarantees provided not covered by debtors classification standards

     137,227         145,861   

Other not covered by debtors classification standards

     12,668         11,030   

 

(*) Most of this amount as of December 31, 2015 and 2014, have a remaining maturity of less than one year.

 

F - 68


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

The Bank accounts for checks drawn thereon and on other banks, as well as other items in process of collection, such as notes, bills and miscellaneous items, in memorandum accounts until the related item clears or is accepted. In Management’s opinion, no significant risk of loss exists on these clearing transactions. The amounts of clearing items in collection process are as follows:

 

     As of December 31,  
     2015      2014  

Checks drawn on the Bank pending clearing

     1,429,098         1,063,717   

Checks drawn on other Banks

     613,495         638,058   

 

  33.3 Trust activities

See Note 14.

 

34. BUSINESS SEGMENT CONSOLIDATED INFORMATION

FASB ASC 280 “Segment reporting” requires that a public business enterprise report financial and descriptive information about its reportable operating segments. Operating segments are components of an enterprise about which separate financial information is available that is regularly by the chief operating decision maker in deciding how to allocate resources and in assessing performance. Generally, financial information is required to be reported on the basis that it is used internally for evaluating segment performance and deciding how to allocate resources to segments. Management has determined that the Bank has one reportable segment related to banking activities.

 

F - 69


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

35. SUMMARY OF SIGNIFICANT DIFFERENCES BETWEEN CENTRAL BANK RULES AND UNITED STATES ACCOUNTING PRINCIPLES

The following is a description of the significant differences between Central Bank rules followed in the preparation of the Bank’s financial statements and those applicable in the United States under generally accepted accounting principles (US GAAP). “FASB ASC” shall refer to Financial Accounting Standards Board Accounting Standards Codification.

In 2015 the Bank adopted the following Accounting Standards Update (ASU):

 

    2014-04 – Receivables - Trouble Debt Restructurings by Creditors (Subtopic 310-40), Reclassification of Residential Real Estate Collateralized Consumer Mortgage Loans upon Foreclose. The amendments of this ASU clarify when an in substance repossession or foreclosure occurs, the loan should be derecognized and the real estate property recognized. There was no significant effect on the accompanying consolidated financial statements for the adoption of this statement.

 

    2014-11 – Transfers and Servicing (Topic 860), Repurchase-to-Maturity Transaction, Repurchase Financings, and Disclosures. The amendments in this Update require two accounting changes. First, the amendments in this Update change the accounting for repurchase-to-maturity transactions to secured borrowing accounting. Second, for repurchase financing arrangement, the amendments require separate accounting for transfer of a financial asset executed contemporaneously with a repurchase agreement with the same counterparty, which will result in secured borrowing accounting for the repurchase agreement. There was no significant effect on the accompanying consolidated financial statements for the adoption of this statement.

 

    2015-10 - Technical Correction and Improvements. Effective upon issuance (June 12, 2015) for amendments that do not have transition guidance. There was no significant effect on the accompanying consolidated financial statements for the adoption of this statement.

 

  35.1. Income taxes

As explained in Note 5, Central Bank rules do not require the recognition of deferred tax assets and liabilities and, therefore, income tax is recognized on the basis of amounts due in accordance with Argentine tax regulations and no deferred tax and liabilities are recognized.

For purposes of US GAAP reporting, the Bank applies FASB ASC 740 “Income Taxes”. Under this method, income tax is recognized based on the liability method whereby deferred tax assets and liabilities are recorded for temporary differences between the financial reporting and tax basis of assets and liabilities at each reporting date. FASB ASC 740 requires that an allowance for deferred tax assets be provided to the extent that it is more likely than not that they will not be realized, based on the weight of available evidence. In order to determine the amount of the valuation allowance required, in accordance with FAS ASC 740-10-30-16 through 30-25, the Bank evaluates for each consolidated entity all available evidence, both positive and negative and the future realization of the tax benefit in a relatively short period of time, considering future reversals of existing taxable temporary differences, future taxable income exclusive of reversing temporary differences and carryforwards and tax-planning strategies.

FASB ASC 740 also prescribes a recognition threshold and a measurement attribute for the financial statement recognition and measurement of tax positions taken or expected to be taken in a tax return. For those benefits to be recognized, a tax position must be more-likely-than-not to be sustained upon examination by taxing authorities.

There were no unrecognized tax benefits as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013.

The Bank and its subsidiaries located in Argentina, file income tax returns in such country. The Bank is subject to Argentina income tax examination for calendar fiscal years ending 2010 through 2015 (in addition see Note 17).

 

F - 70


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

Deferred tax assets and liabilities (including those related to business combinations mentioned in Note 35.7.a) and b)) are summarized as follows:

 

     As of December 31,  

Description

   2015      2014  

Deferred tax assets:

     

Loans (mainly allowances for loan losses)

     360,724         363,451   

Vacation accrual

     93,937         71,021   

Allowance for loss contingencies

     86,931         85,514   

Governments and private securities

     —           63,857   

Net operating loss carry forwards

     34         65   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total deferred tax assets

     541,626         583,908   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Deferred tax liabilities:

     

Intangible assets

     (173,053      (136,342

Property, equipment and other assets

     (36,992      (1,913

Foreign exchange difference

     (31,922      (29,351

Government and private securities

     (28,415      —     

Other

     (26,131      (1,576
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total deferred tax liabilities

     (296,513      (169,182
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Deferred tax asset

     245,113         414,726   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Allowance for deferred tax assets

     (62,352      (58,859
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Net deferred tax assets under US GAAP

     182,761         355,867   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

As of December 31, 2015, the consolidated net operating loss carry forwards of 98 are as follows:

 

Expiration year

   Amount  

2016

     68   

2017

     30   
  

 

 

 
     98   
  

 

 

 

The change in the net deferred tax assets for the fiscal years presented is summarized as follows:

 

     As of December 31,  
     2015      2014      2013  

Net deferred tax assets at the beginning of the year

     355,867         229,571         168,125   

Net amount recorded in comprehensive income

     (70,925      (31,375      (5,327

Net deferred tax income for the year

     (102,181      157,671         66,773   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Net deferred tax assets at the end of the year

     182,761         355,867         229,571   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

The following table accounts for the difference between the actual tax provision under Central Bank regulations and the total income tax expense in accordance with US GAAP:

 

     Year ended December 31,  

Description

   2015      2014      2013  

Income tax in accordance with Central Bank regulations

     2,485,663         1,962,186         1,332,909   

Net deferred tax income

     102,181         (157,671      (66,773
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total income tax expense in accordance with US GAAP

     2,587,844         1,804,515         1,266,136   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

F - 71


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

The following table accounts for the difference between the actual tax provision and the amounts obtained by applying the statutory income tax rate in Argentina to income before income tax in accordance with US GAAP:

 

     Year ended December 31,  

Description

   2015     2014     2013  

Pre-tax income in accordance with US GAAP

     7,534,988        5,377,448        3,745,816   

Statutory income tax rate

     35     35     35
  

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

Tax on net income at statutory rate

     2,637,246        1,882,107        1,311,036   

Permanent differences at the statutory rate:

      

- Variation of allowances

     3,493        (9,694     (8,945

- Income not subject to income tax

     (119,769     (109,962     (66,168

- Other

     66,874        42,064        30,213   
  

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

Income tax in accordance with US GAAP

     2,587,844        1,804,515        1,266,136   
  

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

In Note 35.7 the abovementioned adjustments were split considering business combinations or other adjustments.

Had US GAAP been applied, the Bank’s assets would increase by 190,243, 366,107 and 242,591 as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively. In addition, income would decrease by 104,939 for the year ended December 31, 2015 and would increase by 154,891 and 63,993 for the years ended December 31, 2014 and 2013, respectively.

Besides the adjustment abovementioned, the Bank’s assets related to income tax acquired in business combination transactions, would decrease by 7,482, 10,240 and 13,020 as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively. In addition, income would increase by 2,758, 2,780, and 2,780 for the years ended December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively. Such adjustments are included in Note 35.7 a) and b).

 

  35.2. Exposure to the Argentine Public Sector and Private Securities

 

  a) Loans—Non-financial federal government sector

As of December 2015, 2014 and 2013, the Bank has guaranteed loans acquired mainly through business combinations (maturing around 2017) which were valued according to Central Bank Communiqués “A” 4898 and 5180, amounting to 465,193, 407,677 and 311,757, respectively (see Note 4.5.c)).

Under US GAAP, the difference between the cost of each acquired purchased credit impaired loan and its expected future cash flows is accounted for in accordance with FASB ASC 310-30 “Loans and debts acquired with deteriorated credit quality”. In accordance with this rule, the Bank should continue to estimate the cash flows expected to be collected over the life of the loan.

The effects of the adjustments required to state such amounts in accordance with US GAAP would decrease assets by 148,237, 200,250 and 158,214 as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively.

On the other hand, income would increase by 52,013 for the year ended December 31, 2015 and would decrease by 42,036 and 11,369 for the years ended December 31, 2014 and 2013, respectively.

Taking into account the terms of loans to the non-financial federal government sector acquired with deteriorated credit quality and considering that, historically, the government has not prepaid them, the Bank does not expect prepayments to occur and, therefore, has concluded that such prepayments need not be considered in the determination of cash flows expected to be collected.

 

F - 72


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

The following table presents the outstanding balance of loans to the non-financial federal government sector acquired with deteriorated credit quality and related carrying amount under US GAAP at the beginning and end of each year:

 

     Outstanding balance (*)
Year ended December 31,
     Carrying amount
Year ended December 31,
 
     2015      2014      2015      2014  

Beginning of the year

     407,677         343,583         207,427         147,868   

End of year

     465,193         407,677         316,956         207,427   

 

(*) It includes the undiscounted sum of all amounts, including principal, interest, fees and CER adjustments under the loans owed at the reporting date.

The following table reconciles the amounts of accretable yield of loans to the non-financial federal government sector acquired with deteriorated credit quality at the beginning and end of each year:

 

     Year ended December 31,  
     2015      2014      2013  

Accretable yield at the beginning

     124,596         70,306         38,506   

Accretion

     (135,005      (80,875      (47,236

Disposals

     (313      —           (610

Reclassification from nonaccretable yield

     286,169         135,165         79,646   

Accretable yield at the end

     275,447         124,596         70,306   

During 2015, 2014 and 2013, the Bank has not acquired loans or debt securities with deteriorated credit quality. In addition, the Bank applies the income recognition model required by FASB ASC 310-30.

In addition, the following table presents the activity in the allowances required in connection with loans to the non-financial federal government sector acquired with deteriorated credit quality:

 

     Year ended
December 31,
 
     2015      2014      2013  

Beginning balance

     —           —           4,294   

Provision for loan losses

     —           —           —     

Recoveries

     —           —           (4,294
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Ending balance

     —           —           —     
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

  b) Government and private securities

 

  b.1) Available for sale securities

Under US GAAP, securities for which the Bank’s management has the intention and the ability to hold them for an indefinite period of time, but not necessarily to maturity, are classified as “available for sale securities”. They are carried at fair value with the unrealized gains and losses reported as net of income tax within the shareholders’ equity accounts in accordance with FASB ASC 320 “Investment – Debt and Equity Securities”.

 

  b.2) Trading securities

Under US GAAP, securities maintained for intermediation are classified as “trading securities” because they are bought mainly with the intent to buy and sell in the short term as part of the Bank’s trading or intermediation activities. They are carried at fair value considering their active market, with changes in fair value recorded in the consolidated statement of income.

Under Central Bank rules, Government and private securities were valued as explained in Note 4.5.b). The effects of the adjustments required to state these securities in accordance with US GAAP would decrease assets by 26,196, 21,263 and 1,139 as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively.

 

F - 73


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

On the other hand, net income, excluding OCI effects, would decrease by 29,277 for the year ended December 31, 2015 and would increase by 3 and 38,162 for the years ended December 31, 2014 and 2013, respectively.

 

  c) Instruments issued by Central Bank of Argentina

As of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, the Bank had instruments issued by Central Bank of Argentina. Under Central Bank rules, these securities were valued at the quoted price of each security or at the cost value increased by their internal rate of return, as mentioned in Note 4.5.b.3 and b.4).

Under US GAAP, considering what is mentioned in Note 35.2.b.1), these securities should be considered as “available for sale” and carried at fair value, with unrealized gains and losses reported as net of income tax within the shareholders’ equity accounts in accordance with FASB ASC 320.

The effects of the adjustments required to state such amounts in accordance with US GAAP would increase assets by 4,064, 2,374 and 41 as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively.

On the other hand, net income, excluding OCI effects, would increase by 12,252, 7,242 and 105 for the years ended December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively.

 

  d) Securities in financial trust and others

As of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, the Bank had securities in financial trust and others. Under Central Bank rules, these securities were valued at the cost value increased by their internal rate of return, as mentioned in Note 4.5.g.3) and 4.5.g.4).

Under US GAAP, considering what is mentioned in Note 35.2.b.1), these securities should be considered as “available for sale” and carried at fair value, with unrealized gains and losses reported as net of income tax within the shareholders’ equity accounts in accordance with FASB ASC 320.

The effects of the adjustments required to state such amounts in accordance with US GAAP would increase assets by 35,775, 30,884 and 14,268 as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively.

On the other hand, net income, excluding OCI effects, would increase by 16,527 for the year ended December 31, 2015 and would decrease by 10,418 and 5,148 for the years ended December 31, 2014 and 2013, respectively.

 

F - 74


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

The following table presents the carrying amount under Central Bank rules and fair value of public and private securities:

 

     As for December 31,  
     2015      2014  
     Carrying
Amount
     Fair Value      Carrying
Amount
     Fair Value  

Trading

           

Government securities

     4,927,816         4,921,775         3,241,222         3,241,222   

Private securities

     1,301,840         1,301,840         865,497         865,497   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total trading securities

     6,229,656         6,223,615         4,106,719         4,106,719   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Available for sale

           

Government securities

     1,031,766         1,011,611         446,757         425,494   

Instruments issued by Central Bank of Argentina

     8,302,992         8,307,056         5,671,342         5,673,716   

Securities in financial trust and other

     796,277         832,052         596,257         627,141   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total available for sale securities

     10,131,035         10,150,719         6,714,356         6,726,351   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total

     16,360,691         16,374,334         10,821,075         10,833,070   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

The carrying amount under Central Bank rules, amortized cost, net unrealized gains and the fair value of securities classified as available for sale (see Note 31) mentioned in items b.1), c) and d) as of December 31, 2015 and 2014, are as follows:

 

     As of December 31, 2015  
     Carrying
Amount
     Amortized
Cost
     Net
Unrealized
Gains/(Loss)
     Fair Value  

- Government securities

     1,031,766         1,013,008         (1,397      1,011,611   

- Instruments issued by Central Bank of Argentina

     8,302,992         8,322,630         (15,574      8,307,056   

-Securities in financial trust and other

     796,277         817,937         14,115         832,052   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total

     10,131,035         10,153,575         (2,856      10,150,719   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

     As of December 31, 2014  
     Carrying
Amount
     Amortized
Cost
     Net
Unrealized
Gains/(Loss)
     Fair Value  

- Government securities

     446,757         451,235         (25,741      425,494   

- Instruments issued by Central Bank of Argentina

     5,671,342         5,678,728         (5,012      5,673,716   

-Securities in financial trust and other

     596,257         601,390         25,751         627,141   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total

     6,714,356         6,731,353         (5,002      6,726,351   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

F - 75


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

The proceeds from sales of available for sale securities and the gross realized gains that have been included in earnings as a result of those sales, for the years ended December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013 are as follows:

 

     Proceeds from sales
As of December 31,
 

Available for sale securities

   2015 (*)      2014 (*)      2013 (*)  

- Government securities

     302,169         725,206         230,888   

- Instruments issued by Central Bank of Argentina

     15,549,001         9,076,881         2,569,222   

-Securities in financial trust and other

     1,117,304         154,123         231,889   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 
     16,968,474         9,956,210         3,031,999   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

(*) As of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, realized gains as a result of those sales amounted to 651,133, 678,827 and 67,546, respectively.

The amount of the unrealized gain or loss on available for sale securities, before tax, that have been included in accumulated other comprehensive income (see Note 35.20) is as follows:

 

Securities

   2014      Increase      Decrease      2015  

- Government securities

     (25,741      39,877         (15,533      (1,397

- Instruments issued by Central Bank of Argentina

     (5,012      16,987         (27,549      (15,574

-Securities in financial trust and other

     25,751         29,844         (41,480      14,115   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total

     (5,002      86,708         (84,562      (2,856
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Securities

   2013      Increase      Decrease      2014  

- Government securities

     (5,614      8,590         (28,717      (25,741

- Instruments issued by Central Bank of Argentina

     (103      5,874         (10,783      (5,012

-Securities in financial trust and other

     (1,283      44,681         (17,647      25,751   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total

     (7,000      59,145         (57,147      (5,002
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Securities

   2012      Increase      Decrease      2013  

- Government securities

     40,300         970         (46,884      (5,614

- Instruments issued by Central Bank of Argentina

     23         —           (126      (103

-Securities in financial trust and other

     6,992         15,064         (23,339      (1,283
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total

     47,315         16,034         (70,349      (7,000
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

The maturities of available for sale securities as of December 31, 2015 are as follows:

 

     For the year ended December 31, 2015  

Securities

   Within 1
year
     After 1 year
but within 5
years
     After 5
year but
within 10
years
     After 10
years
     Total  

- Government securities

     711,337         300,274         —           —           1,011,611   

- Instruments issued by Central Bank of Argentina

     8,307,056         —           —           —           8,307,056   

-Securities in financial trust and other

     194,918         615,867         —           21,267         832,052   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total

     9,213,311         916,141         —           21,267         10,150,719   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

F - 76


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

The portion of trading gains and losses for the period that relates to trading securities still held as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013 are as follows:

 

     Gains/(loss) as of December 31,  

Trading Securities

   2015      2014      2013  

Government securities

     753,163         6,087         21,729   

Private securities

     233,404         (209,100      4,056   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 
     986,567         (203,013      25,785   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

The following table, presents the gross unrealized losses and fair value of securities classified as available for sale by length of time for each category of securities that have been in a continuous loss position:

 

     Less than 12 months      12 months or more      Total  
     Gross
Unrealized
losses
    Fair
Value
     Gross
Unrealized
losses
    Fair
Value
     Gross
Unrealized
losses
    Fair
Value
 

December 31, 2015

              

Government securities

     (13,896     575,135         (1,060     35,144         (14,956     610,279   

Instruments issued by Central Bank of Argentina

     (21,778     4,398,035         —          —           (21,778     4,398,035   

Securities in financial trust and other

     (3,433     189,823         (461     18,488         (3,894     208,311   
  

 

 

   

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

 

Total

     (39,107     5,162,993         (1,521     53,632         (40,628     5,216,625   
  

 

 

   

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

 
     Less than 12 months      12 months or more      Total  
     Gross
Unrealized
losses
    Fair
Value
     Gross
Unrealized
losses
    Fair
Value
     Gross
Unrealized
losses
    Fair
Value
 

December 31, 2014

              

Government securities

     (18,653     244,618         (14,411     114,741         (33,064     359,359   

Instruments issued by Central Bank of Argentina

     (10,783     3,442,946         —          —           (10,783     3,442,946   

Securities in financial trust and other

     (6,922     56,409         (2,900     40,388         (9,822     96,797   
  

 

 

   

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

 

Total

     (36,358     3,743,973         (17,311     155,129         (53,669     3,899,102   
  

 

 

   

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

 

For purposes of determining whether the decline in fair value for these categories of securities qualifies as “other than temporary impairment,” the Bank has considered the following factors:

 

    The decline in fair value is not believed to be attributable to credit quality. It solely derives from adverse interest rate fluctuations of observable inputs of similar instruments according to their fair value hierarchy.

 

    Future principal payments are expected to be sufficient to recover the current amortized cost of these investments.

 

    The Bank has the intention to hold these securities at least until their fair value recover to a level that exceeds their amortized cost.

 

    The extent to which the fair value has been less than the amortized cost is not relevant for these categories of securities.

The Bank has concluded that the decline in fair value for these securities does not qualify as “other than temporary impairment.”

 

F - 77


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

The Bank notes that the specific identification method was used in order to determine the cost of securities sold.

 

  35.3. Loan origination fees

The Bank recognizes fees on consumer loans, such as credit cards, mortgage, pledged and personal loans, stand by letters of credit and guarantees issued, when collected and charges direct origination costs when incurred. Pursuant to Central Bank Communiqué “A” 5460, the Central Bank has established certain regulatory limits on fees applicable to consumer financing, mainly personal and pledge loans.

In accordance with US GAAP under FASB ASC 310-20 “Nonrefundable Fees and Other Costs”, loan origination fees and certain direct loan origination costs should be recognized over the life of the related loan as an adjustment of yield or by straight-line method, as appropriate.

The effects of the adjustments required to state such amounts in accordance with US GAAP, would decrease assets by 38,045, 91,290 and 111,845 as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively. Income would increase by 53,245 and 20,555 for the years ended December 31, 2015 and 2014, respectively, and would decrease by 6,461 for the year ended December 31, 2013.

 

  35.4. Allowance for loan losses

According to FASB ASC 310 “Receivables”, loans are measured at their amortized cost using effective interest rate, after deduction of any allowance for loan losses.

The loan loss reserve represents the estimate of probable losses in the loan portfolio. Determining the loan loss reserve requires significant management judgments and estimates including, among others, identifying impaired loans, determining customers’ ability to pay and estimating the fair value of underlying collateral or the expected future cash flows to be received. Actual events will likely differ from the estimates and assumptions used in determining the loan loss reserve. Additional loan loss reserve could be required in the future.

The loan loss reserve is maintained in accordance with Central Bank rules. This results from evaluating the degree of debtors’ compliance and the guarantees (see Note 24.) and collateral supporting the respective transactions.

Increases in the reserve are based on the deterioration of the quality of existing loans, while decreases in the reserve are based on regulations requiring the charge off of non-performing loans classified as “non-recoverable”. The Bank charges-off non-performing loans on the month following the date on which such loans are classified as “irrecoverable without preferred guarantees” and fully provisioned.

In the case of the consumer portfolio, the charge-off takes place when the loan is approximately 270 days past due. For the commercial portfolio, the situation depends on the individual evaluation of the credit risk. All charged-off loans are registered in off balance sheet accounts while the Bank continues its collection efforts.

In addition, under Central Bank rules, the Bank records recoveries on previously charged-off loans directly to income and records the amount of charged-off loans in excess of amounts specifically allocated as a direct charge to the consolidated statement of income. The Bank does not partially charge off troubled loans until final disposition of the loan, rather, the allowance is maintained on a loan-by-loan basis for its estimated settlement value.

The Bank’s consumer portfolio consists principally of personal loans and credit card loans. Personal loans include mainly financing granted to clients under the “Plan Sueldo” payroll services. Clients enrolled in this type of services receive their wages directly through their accounts at the Bank. Payments on such loans are debited directly from the clients’ wages on the due date. The most significant factors affecting the Bank’s consumer portfolio’s credit risk are employment rates and real wages.

 

F - 78


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

The Bank’s commercial portfolio is currently diversified among clients of different size (small, medium-sized businesses and corporations) and who are active in different economic sectors (mainly the agricultural, food, services and construction sectors - see Note 24 to the consolidated financial statements). The risks associated with this portfolio are principally related to the specific economic performance of each individual client and to economic factors, such as the price and demand of products and services and competitiveness, among others.

The Bank implements monitoring, control and risk-management systems to maintain the credit risk of its loan portfolios at adequate levels.

Under Central Bank rules, a minimum loan loss reserve is calculated primarily based upon the classification of commercial loan borrowers and upon delinquency aging (or the number of days the loan is past due) for consumer and housing loan borrowers. Although the Bank is required to follow the methodology and guidelines for determining the minimum loan loss reserve, as set forth by the Central Bank, the Bank is allowed to establish additional loan loss reserve.

For commercial loans, the Bank is required to classify all commercial loan borrowers. In order to classify them, the Bank must consider different parameters related to each of those customers.

Pursuant to Central Bank regulations, commercial loans are classified as follows:

 

Classification

  

Criteria

In normal situation    Borrowers for whom there is no doubt as to their ability to comply with their payment obligations.
Subject to special monitoring/Under observation    Borrowers that, among other criteria, are up to 90 days past due and, although considered to be able to meet all their financial obligations, are sensitive to changes that could compromise their ability to honor debts absent timely corrective measures.
Subject to special monitoring / Under negotiation or refinancing agreement    Borrowers who are unable to comply with their obligations as agreed with the Bank and, therefore, formally state, within 60 calendar days after the maturity date, their intention to refinance such debts. The borrower must enter into a refinancing agreement with the Bank within 90 calendar days (if up to two lenders are involved) or 180 calendar days (if more than two lenders are involved) after the payment default date. If no agreement has been reached within the established deadline, the borrower must be reclassified to the next category according to the indicators established for each level.
Troubled    Borrowers with difficulties honoring their financial obligations under the loan on a regular basis, which, if uncorrected, may result in losses to the Bank.
With high risk of insolvency    Borrowers who are highly unlikely to honor their financial obligations under the loan.
Irrecoverable    Loans classified as irrecoverable at the time they are reviewed (although the possibility might exist that such loans might be collected in the future). The borrower will not meet its financial obligations with the Bank.
Irrecoverable according to Central Bank Rules    (a) Borrower has defaulted on its payment obligations under a loan for more than 180 calendar days according to the corresponding report provided by the Central Bank, which report includes (1) financial institutions liquidated by the Central Bank, (2) residual entities created as a result of the privatization of public financial institutions, or in the privatization or dissolution process, (3) financial institutions whose licenses have been revoked by the Central Bank and find themselves subject to judicial liquidation or bankruptcy proceedings and (4) trusts in which Seguro de Depósitos S.A. (SEDESA) is a beneficiary, and/or (b) certain kinds of foreign borrowers (including banks or other financial institutions that are not subject to the supervision of the Central Bank or similar authority of the country in which they are incorporated) that are not classified as “investment grade” by any of the rating agencies approved by the Central Bank.

 

F - 79


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

For consumer loan portfolio, the Bank classifies loans based upon delinquency aging, consistent with the requirements of the Central Bank. Minimum loss percentages required by the Central Bank are also applied to the totals in each loan classification.

Under the Central Bank regulations, consumer and housing borrowers are classified as follows:

 

Classification

  

Criteria

Performing    If all payments on loans are current or less than 31 calendar days overdue and, in the case of checking account overdrafts, less than 61 calendar days overdue.
Low Risk    Loans upon which payment obligations are overdue for a period of more than 31 and up to 90 calendar days.
Medium Risk    Loans upon which payment obligations are overdue for a period of more than 90 and up to 180 calendar days.
High Risk    Loans in respect of which a legal action seeking collection has been filed or loans having payment obligations overdue for more than 180 calendar days, but less than 365 calendar days.
Irrecoverable    Loans in which payment obligations are more than one year overdue or the debtor is insolvent or in bankruptcy or liquidation.
Irrecoverable according to Central Bank Rules    Same criteria as for commercial loans in the Irrecoverable according to Central Bank Rules.

In addition, under Central Bank rules, based on the overall risk of the portfolio, the Bank records additional loan loss reserves in excess of the minimum required and changes the loan classification as the case may be.

Under US GAAP, a portion of the total allowance typically consists of amounts that are used, for example, to cover loans that are analyzed on a “pool” or homogeneous basis and to supplement specific allowances in recognition of the uncertainties inherent in point estimates.

The Bank’s accounting for its loan loss reserve under Central Bank rules differs in some respects with practices of US-based banks, as discussed below.

For the foreclosed assets maintained by the Bank, see Note 35.15.

 

  a) Recoveries and write-offs

Under Central Bank rules, recoveries are recorded in a separate income line item under Other Income. Write-offs are recorded directly in the income statement. Under US GAAP, recoveries and write-offs would be recorded in the allowance for loan losses in the balance sheet; however there would be no net impact on net income or shareholders’ equity.

 

  b) Credit Card Loans

The Bank establishes its reserve for credit card loans based on the past due status of the loan. All loans without preferred guarantees greater than 180 days have been reserved at least at 50% in accordance with the Central Bank rules.

Under US GAAP, the Bank adopted a policy to fully provision loans which are 180 days past due.

Had US GAAP been applied, the Bank’s assets would decrease by 33,876, 25,664 and 16,965 as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively. In addition, income would decrease by 8,212, 8,699 and 3,517 for the years ended December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively.

 

F - 80


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

  c) Impaired loans—Non Financial Private Sector and residents abroad

FASB ASC 310 “Receivables”, requires a creditor to measure impairment of a loan based on the present value of expected future cash flows discounted at the loan’s effective interest rate, or at the loan’s observable market price or the fair value of the collateral if the loan is collateral dependent. This Statement is applicable to all loans (including those restructured in a troubled debt restructuring involving amendment of terms), except large groups of smaller-balance homogenous loans, not considered troubled debt restructuring, that are collectively evaluated for impairment. Loans are considered impaired when, based on Management’s evaluation, a borrower will not be able to fulfill its obligation under the original loan terms.

The following table discloses the amounts under US GAAP of specific loans considered impaired in accordance with FASB ASC 310 as of December 31, 2015 and 2014:

 

     Recorded
investment
     Unpaid
principal
balance
     Related
allowance
     Average
Recorded
Investment
     Interest
Income
recognized
 

2015

              

With no related allowance recorded

              

Commercial

              

Mortgage and pledge loans

     8,381         8,190         —           9,245         1,242   

Other loans

     625         623         —           625         2   

Consumer

              

Documents

     2,155         2,090         —           1,999         672   

Mortgage and pledge loans

     1,353         1,308         —           1,364         143   

Personal loans

     85,526         83,308         —           83,250         29,216   

Other loans

     8,219         7,989         —           7,985         1,673   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total

     106,259         103,508         —           104,468         32,948   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

With an allowance recorded

              

Commercial

              

Overdrafts

     15,404         15,404         9,211         11,063         —     

Documents

     56,000         51,326         15,758         56,730         —     

Mortgage and pledge loans

     136,120         123,680         66,931         135,298         11,514   

Credit card

     6,469         6,469         3,254         6,468         —     

Other loans

     182,243         180,467         101,479         153,622         15,824   

Consumer

              

Documents

     3,666         3,581         1,282         3,691         797   

Mortgage and pledge loans

     10,679         9,998         3,733         10,936         1,379   

Personal loans

     96,016         94,304         23,444         96,059         23,414   

Other loans

     13,228         12,899         4,210         13,206         2,059   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total

     519,825         498,128         229,302         487,073         54,987   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total Commercial

     405,242         386,159         196,633         373,051         28,582   

Total Consumer

     220,842         215,477         32,669         218,490         59,353   

 

F - 81


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

     Recorded
investment
     Unpaid
principal
balance
     Related
allowance
     Average
Recorded
Investment
     Interest
Income
recognized
 

2014

              

With no related allowance recorded

              

Commercial

              

Other loans

     15         15         —           15         —     

Consumer

              

Documents

     1,963         1,898         —           1,976         700   

Mortgage and pledge loans

     2,820         2,652         —           2,750         305   

Personal loans

     89,626         87,333         —           86,970         27,310   

Other loans

     5,351         5,196         —           5,083         1,248   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total

     99,775         97,094         —           96,794         29,563   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

With an allowance recorded

              

Commercial

              

Overdrafts

     19,033         18,994         16,652         20,587         —     

Documents

     28,662         26,947         17,795         28,520         24   

Mortgage and pledge loans

     124,819         114,634         53,690         128,306         13,900   

Credit card

     1,273         1,273         1,113         1,273         —     

Other loans

     152,260         147,666         86,636         154,292         7,480   

Consumer

              

Documents

     3,954         3,897         1,182         3,724         414   

Mortgage and pledge loans

     7,795         7,358         1,950         7,410         1,091   

Personal loans

     72,348         71,259         21,787         70,484         11,835   

Other loans

     11,529         11,254         3,307         11,376         1,414   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total

     421,673         403,282         204,112         425,972         36,158   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total Commercial

     326,062         309,529         175,886         332,993         21,404   

Total Consumer

     195,386         190,847         28,226         189,773         44,317   

The Bank recognizes interest income on impaired loans on a cash basis method.

In addition, the Bank has performed a migration analysis based on uncollectability following the FASB ASC 450 “Contingencies”.

The collective impairment allowance is calculated on a portfolio basis using statistical models which incorporate various estimates and judgments.

The collective impairment allowance has two components.

The first component is an allowance amount representing the incurred losses on the portfolio of smaller balance homogeneous loans, which are loans to individuals and small business customers of the consumer business portfolio. The loans are grouped according to similar credit risk characteristics and the allowance for each group is determined using statistical models based on historical experience.

The second component represents an estimate of incurred losses inherent in the group of loans that have not yet been individually identified as impaired or measured as part of the smaller-balance homogeneous loans. We use historical loss experience for these estimates. This historical loss experience is adjusted on the basis of actual observable data to reflect the effects of current conditions that did not affect the period on which the historical loss experience is based and to remove the effects of conditions in the historical period that do not exist currently. Estimates of changes in future cash flows reflect, and are directionally consistent with, changes in related observable data from period to period (e.g., changes in unemployment rates, macroeconomic conditions and other factors that are indicative of incurred losses in the group and their magnitude).

 

F - 82


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

For consumer loans, upon a TDR modification (see item below c.1) Trouble Debt Restructuring), in accordance with ASC 310-10, the Bank measures impairment of the consumer portfolio based on a present value of expected future cash flows methodology considering all available evidence using the effective interest rate. The amount of the required allowance for loan losses is equal to the excess of the recorded investment over the loan’s impaired value.

In general, commercial loans that are subject to a TDR modification will have been identified as impaired prior to the modification and accounted for under a present value of expected future cash flows methodology. Accordingly, upon a TDR modification, the allowance methodology remains unchanged.

When a TDR loan defaults, the methodology that the Bank uses in order to determine the allowance for loan losses is similar to the one used for TDR modifications, for both portfolio segments.

Had US GAAP been applied, the Bank’s assets would decrease by 17,124 as of December 31, 2015 and would increase by 3,772 and 2,839 as of December 31, 2014 and 2013, respectively. In addition, income would decrease by 20,896 and 980 for the years ended December 31, 2015 and 2013, respectively, and would increase by 933 for the year ended December 31, 2014.

 

  c.1) Troubled debt restructuring

A restructured loan is considered a TDR if the debtor is experiencing financial difficulties and the Bank grants a concession to the debtor that would not otherwise be considered. Concessions granted could include but it not necessary limited to: reduction in interest rate to rates that are considered below market, extension of repayment schedules and maturity dates beyond original contractual terms.

Loans considered TDR during 2015, 2014 and 2013 were as follows:

 

     2015  
     Number of
contracts
     Pre-modification
outstanding
recorded
investment
     Post-modification
Outstanding
recorded
investment
     Accruing
TDR loans
     Non-accruing
TDR loans
 

Commercial

              

Mortgage and pledge

     3         6,937         7,680         7,680         —     

Others

     1         25,770         31,125         31,125         —     

Consumer

              

Documents

     158         4,202         4,779         4,379         400   

Mortgage and pledge

     20         6,192         5,694         4,269         1,425   

Personal loans

     4,406         92,856         103,589         85,007         18,582   

Others loans

     300         12,791         14,244         12,686         1,558   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total

     4,888         148,748         167,111         145,146         21,965   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

F - 83


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

     2014  
     Number of
contracts
     Pre-modification
outstanding
recorded
investment
     Post-modification
outstanding
recorded
investment
     Accruing
TDR loans
     Non-accruing
TDR loans
 

Commercial

              

Mortgage and pledge

     2         1,123         1,422         1,422         —     

Consumer

              

Documents

     185         4,882         5,289         4,411         878   

Mortgage and pledge

     19         5,219         5,093         3,703         1,390   

Personal loans

     5,177         91,709         100,517         70,040         30,477   

Others loans

     328         11,082         12,290         10,189         2,101   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total

     5,711         114,015         124,611         89,765         34,846   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

     2013  
     Number of
contracts
     Pre-modification
outstanding
recorded
investment
     Post-modification
Outstanding
recorded
investment
     Accruing
TDR loans
     Non-accruing
TDR loans
 

Commercial

              

Mortgage and pledge

     4         13,988         17,813         17,813         —     

Others

     1         3,035         3,087         3,087         —     

Consumer

              

Documents

     158         3,460         3,620         2,948         672   

Mortgage and pledge

     18         2,215         2,325         2,222         103   

Personal loans

     4,637         64,582         72,218         48,390         23,828   

Others loans

     310         10,472         11,074         8,442         2,632   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total

     5,128           97,752         110,137         82,902         27,235   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

We consider that a TDR has subsequently defaulted if the borrower has failed to make payments of either principal, interest or both for a period of 90 days or more. Loans considered TDR that have defaulted during the years ended December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013 were as follows:

 

     2015  
     Number of
contracts
     Recorded
investment
 

Commercial

     

Mortgage and pledge

     1         1,164   

Consumer

     

Documents

     13         252   

Mortgage and pledge

     2         1,663   

Personal loans

     177         2,703   

Others loans

     17         317   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total

     210         6,099   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

F - 84


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

 

     2014  
     Number of
contracts
     Recorded
investment
 

Consumer

     

Documents

     3         42   

Mortgage and pledge

     1         136   

Personal loans

     167         2,002   

Others loans

     18         840   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total

     189         3,020   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

     2013  
     Number of
contracts
     Recorded
investment
 

Commercial

     

Others

     1         397   

Consumer

     

Documents

     11         123   

Mortgage and pledge

     4         390   

Personal loans

     217         2,638   

Others loans

     24         328   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total

     257         3,876   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

  c.2) Allowances - Roll forward

Under US GAAP, the activity in the allowance for loan losses for the years ended December 31, 2015 and 2014 respectively, is as follows:

 

     Commercial      Consumer      Total  

2015

        

Beginning balance

     371,868         862,605         1,234,473   

Provision for possible loan losses

     198,344         891,115         1,089,459   

Charge-off

     (116,635      (618,740      (735,375

Recoveries

     (10,411      (1,581      (11,992
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Ending balance

     443,166         1,133,399         1,576,565   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Period end allocated to:

        

Allowances individually evaluated for impairment

     196,633         32,669         229,302   

Allowances collectively evaluated for impairment

     246,533         1,100,730         1,347,263   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Ending balance

     530,083         1,133,399         1,576,565   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

     Commercial      Consumer      Total  

2014

        

Beginning balance

     240,033         798,883         1,038,916   

Provision for possible loan losses

     222,743         552,342         775,085   

Charge-off

     (76,045      (488,076      (564,121

Recoveries

     (14,863      (544      (15,407
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Ending balance

     371,868         862,605         1,234,473   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Period end allocated to:

        

Allowances individually evaluated for impairment

     175,886         28,226         204,112   

Allowances collectively evaluated for impairment

     195,982         834,379         1,030,361   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Ending balance

     371,868         862,605         1,234,473   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

F - 85


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

Impaired loans individually evaluated for impairment for commercial portfolio amounts to 405,242 and 326,062 for the years ended December 31, 2015 and 2014. In addition, non impaired loans collectively evaluated for impairment for commercial portfolio amounts to 20,477,049 and 14,928,723, for the years ended December 31, 2015 and 2014.

Loans individually evaluated for impairment for consumer portfolio amounts to 220,842 and 195,386 for the years ended December 31, 2015 and 2014. In addition, loans collectively evaluated for impairment for consumer portfolio amounts to 43,218,996 and 29,828,062 for the years ended December 31, 2015 and 2014.

 

  d) Interest recognition – non-accrual loans

The method applied to recognize income on loans is described in Note 4.5.d). Additionally, the accrual of interest is discontinued generally when the related loan is non-performing and the collection of interest and principal is in doubt generally after 90 days of being past due. Accrued interest remains on the Bank’s books and is considered a part of the loan balance when determining the reserve for credit losses.

Under US GAAP the accrual of interest is typically discontinued when Management has serious doubts about further collectability of principal or interest, usually after 90 days, even though the loan is currently performing. When a loan is placed on non-accrual status, unpaid interest credited to income in the current year is reversed and unpaid interest accrued in prior years is charged against the allowance for credit losses.

Had US GAAP been applied, the Bank’s assets would decrease by 24,249, 22,078 and 12,991 as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively. In addition, income would decrease by 2,171, 9,087 and 6,181 for the years ended December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively.

The following table represents the amounts of non-accruals, segregated by class of loans, including the amount of TDR loans, as of December 31, 2015 and 2014, respectively:

 

     2015      2014  
     Non-
accruing
loans
     Non-
accruing
TDR loans
     Non-
accruing
loans
     Non-
accruing
TDR loans
 

Commercial

           

Overdrafts

     15,401         —           19,957         —     

Documents

     56,000         —           25,803         —     

Mortgage and pledge loans

     118,411         10,747         118,677         10,549   

Credit card

     6,430         —           1,273         —     

Other loans

     154,136         31,536         147,347         8,064   

Consumer

           

Overdrafts

     18,288         —           26,431         —     

Documents

     7,942         2,292         7,482         2,482   

Mortgage and pledge loans

     30,147         7,447         25,302         4,992   

Personal loans

     342,973         50,918         335,887         50,496   

Credit Card

     69,533         —           69,318         —     

Other loans

     25,421         9,622         25,422         8,796   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total

     844,682         112,562         802,899         85,379   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

F - 86


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

An aging analysis of past due loans, segregated by class of loans, as of December 31, 2015 and 2014 were as follows:

 

     30-59
Days
past due
     60-89
Days
past due
     Greater
Than 90
days
     Total Past
Due
     Current      Total
Loans
 

2015

                 

Commercial

                 

Overdrafts

     49,816         14,459         34,748         99,023         4,114,024         4,213,047   

Documents

     29,575         58,029         52,935         140,539         4,563,976         4,704,515   

Mortgage and pledge loans

     88,551         21,326         130,731         240,608         3,325,071         3,565,679   

Credit card

     201         6,633         6,430         13,264         643,800         657,064   

Other loans

     146,413         103,655         96,913         346,981         7,395,005         7,741,986   

Consumer

                 

Overdrafts

     14,959         4,757         17,916         37,632         587,320         624,952   

Documents

     1,532         1,393         5,935         8,860         1,702,048         1,710,908   

Mortgage and pledge loans

     10,559         4,242         19,236         34,037         2,171,002         2,205,039   

Personal loans

     56,370         30,494         74,479         161,343         13,974,811         14,136,154   

Credit card

     127,021         79,529         191,412         397,962         23,297,454         23,695,416   

Other loans

     11,070         4,508         13,950         29,528         1,037,841         1,067,369   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total

     536,067         329,025         644,685         1,509,777         62,812,352         64,322,129   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

     30-59
Days
past due
     60-89
Days
past due
     Greater
Than 90
days
     Total Past
Due
     Current      Total
Loans
 

2014

                 

Commercial

                 

Overdrafts

     32,858         1,714         21,561         56,133         2,898,090         2,954,223   

Documents

     1,235         17,260         92,824         111,319         3,082,169         3,193,488   

Mortgage and pledge loans

     86,925         13,467         104,502         204,894         2,214,535         2,419,429   

Credit card

     —           8         1,838         1,846         327,159         329,005   

Other loans

     144,669         9,128         88,865         242,662         6,115,978         6,358,640   

Consumer

                 

Overdrafts

     15,505         3,660         24,929         44,094         514,675         558,769   

Documents

     1,335         870         7,706         9,911         1,355,907         1,365,818   

Mortgage and pledge loans

     12,009         3,530         14,185         29,724         1,939,725         1,969,449   

Personal loans

     51,674         26,332         81,110         159,116         8,693,221         8,852,337   

Credit card

     110,986         63,697         182,651         357,334         16,029,239         16,386,573   

Other loans

     12,204         8,668         16,359         37,231         853,271         890,502   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total

     469,400         148,334         636,530         1,254,264         44,023,969         45,278,233   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

F - 87


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

The following table shows the loans balances categorized by credit quality indicators for the years ended December 31, 2015 and 2014:

 

     2015  
     In normal
situation/
performing
     Subject to special
monitoring / Under
negotiation or
refinancing
agreement/ Low
risk
     Troubled /
Medium risk
     With high
risk or
insolvency /
High Risk
     Irrecoverable      Irrecoverable
according to
Central Bank
rules
 

Commercial

                 

Overdraft

     4,194,065         3,578         5         12,378         3,021         —     

Documents

     4,648,515         —           —           56,000         —           —     

Mortgage and pledge

     3,431,338         —           5,946         86,332         42,063         —     

Credit Card

     650,448         147         —           6,430         39         —     

Others loans

     7,535,249         27,649         34,999         86,980         57,109         —     

Consumer

                 

Overdraft

     597,082         8,281         6,792         8,942         3,759         96   

Documents

     1,693,316         7,686         1,217         7,243         1,446         —     

Mortgage and pledge

     2,160,291         14,593         9,141         9,985         11,029         —     

Personal loans

     13,883,168         118,320         57,516         61,005         15,941         204   

Credit Card

     23,033,222         283,568         188,611         147,265         42,589         161   

Others

     1,024,834         14,300         8,521         12,316         7,398         —     
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total

     62,851,528         478,122         312,748         494,876         184,394         461   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

     2014  
     In normal
situation/
performing
     Subject to special
monitoring / Under
negotiation or
refinancing
agreement/ Low
risk
     Troubled /
Medium risk
     With high
risk or
insolvency /
High Risk
     Irrecoverable      Irrecoverable
according to
Central Bank
rules
 

Commercial

                 

Overdraft

     2,924,483         10,707         —           19,033         —           —     

Documents

     3,157,716         7,110         —           28,662         —           —     

Mortgage and pledge

     2,260,564         39,301         33,503         86,061         —           —     

Credit Card

     327,713         19         —           1,273         —           —     

Others loans

     6,197,000         9,415         52,581         99,644         —           —     

Consumer

                 

Overdraft

     524,132         8,208         7,295         12,783         6,266         85   

Documents

     1,347,405         5,343         3,510         6,823         2,737         —     

Mortgage and pledge

     1,932,822         13,986         5,413         9,597         7,631         —     

Personal loans

     15,827,534         215,043         160,474         124,908         58,561         53   

Credit Card

     8,638,593         88,367         53,614         50,003         21,693         67   

Others loans

     844,063         20,991         9,239         11,519         4,690         —     
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total

     43,982,025         418,490         325,629         450,306         101,578         205   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

  e) Off balance sheet credit exposures

In the normal course of business, the Bank enters into transactions involving off balance sheet financial instruments to handle risk management and meet trading and financing needs of its customers and for the Bank’s own trading and assets and liabilities management purposes.

In determining whether to enter into transactions involving off balance sheet financial instruments, the Bank follows the credit policies it uses to grant loans.

 

F - 88


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

The management of the Bank believes that the outstanding off balance sheet items do not represent an unusual credit risk.

The Bank’s exposure to credit loss in the event of the counterparties’ failure to fulfill their commitments to extend credit or their obligations under guarantees granted and foreign trade acceptances is represented by the contractual notional amount of these instruments. See Note 35.12.

The process to determine allowances for off balance sheet credit exposures is similar to the methodology used for loans. The provision charged to expense is determined by management based upon client classification, actual loss experience, current and expected economic conditions, delinquency aging and evaluation of probable losses in the current credit portfolio. Any probable loss amounts are recognized as allowances in the consolidated balance sheet.

 

  35.5. Intangible assets

 

  a) Software costs

Under Central Bank Rules, the Bank capitalized software costs relating to preliminary, application development and post–implementation stages of software development. Central Bank rules permit the capitalization of certain costs that are not eligible for capitalization under FASB ASC 350-40 “Internal - Use Software”.

The effects of adjustments required to state such amounts in accordance with US GAAP, would decrease assets by 7,698, 9,136 and 12,175 as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively. In addition income would increase by 1,438, 3,039 and 5,369 for the years ended December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively.

 

  b) Organizational costs

Under Central Bank Rules, the Bank capitalized inherent cost of set up and organization of the Bank.

Applying US GAAP and in accordance with FASB ASC 720-15 “Start Up Costs” also effected in other adjustments relative to capitalized organizational costs resulting in a decrease to the Bank’s assets of 4,898 and 2,586 as of December 31, 2014 and 2013, respectively. In addition income would increase by 4,898 for the year ended December 31, 2015, and would decrease by 2,312 and 905 for the years ended December 31, 2014 and 2013, respectively.

 

  35.6. Vacation accrual

The cost of vacations earned by employees is generally recorded by the Bank when paid. US GAAP requires that this expense be recorded on an accrual basis as the vacations are earned.

Had US GAAP been applied, the Bank’s liabilities would increase by 268,392, 202,917 and 152,275 as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively. In addition, income would decrease by 65,475, 50,642 and 899 for the years ended December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively.

 

  35.7. Business Combinations

The Bank has effected several business combinations in the past few years. The Bank is presenting separately the US GAAP adjustments related to deferred income taxes, loans and securities valuation and the other effects of purchase accounting by business combination related to Banco del Tucumán S.A., which have not been legally merged into the Bank. The qualitative description of the adjustments related to business combinations were disclosed above, as the case may be. The details of these effects are described in this footnote.

 

F - 89


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

  a) Acquisition of controlling interest in Banco del Tucumán SA.

On May 5, 2006, the Bank acquired 75% of the capital stock of Banco del Tucumán SA at a cash purchase price of 45,961. Subsequently, in 2006 and 2007 the Bank acquired the 4.84% and 10.09% additional interest of Banco del Tucumán SA for cash payments of 2,907 and 9,709, respectively.

Under Central Bank rules, business combinations and step acquisitions are accounted for the carryover book value of the acquired company. Additionally, at the acquisition date, the Bank recognized the difference between the book value of the net equity acquired and the purchase price as a positive goodwill. Such goodwill is being amortized under the straight line method over 10 years.

Under US GAAP, FASB ASC 805 “Business Combination” required the acquisition of the controlling interest of Banco del Tucumán SA to be accounted for as a business combination applying the purchase method. The additional interest acquired was accounted for as a step acquisition applying the purchase method.

For US GAAP purposes, Banco Macro SA has allocated the purchase price to the assets acquired and liabilities assumed based on their estimated fair values as of the acquisition date, and the excess of the fair value of the acquired net assets over the cost has resulted in a negative goodwill.

The effects of adjustments required to state such amounts in accordance with US GAAP would decrease assets by 4,469, 6,518 and 8,515 as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively. In addition, income would increase by 2,049, 1,997 and 1,995 for the years ended December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively.

 

  b) Acquisition and merger of Banco Privado de Inversiones SA.

On September 20, 2010, the Bank acquired 100% of the common shares of Banco Privado de Inversiones SA at a cash purchase price of USD 23.3 million.

Under Central Bank Rules, business combinations is accounted for by the carryover book value of the acquired company and goodwill is recognized based on the difference of the book value of the net assets acquired and the purchase price (including contingent consideration). Under US GAAP FASB ASC 805 requires the acquisition of controlling interest of Banco Privado de Inversiones SA to be accounted for as a business combination applying the purchase method. Consequently, the Bank has allocated the purchase price to the assets acquired and liabilities assumed based on their estimated fair values as of the acquisition date, and the excess of the fair value of the acquired net asset over the cost was resulted in a gain.

Had US GAAP been applied, the effects on the Bank’s net assets, to account under US GAAP have resulted in a decrease by 11,398, 11,767 and 12,604 as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively. In addition income would increase by 369 and 837 for the years ended December 31, 2015 and 2014, respectively, and would decrease by 4,298 for the year ended December 31, 2013.

Additionally on December 23, 2013, the Board of Directors of the Central Bank authorized Banco Privado de Inversiones SA to merge with and into Banco Macro SA and on January 23, 2014, the CNV gave its approval.

In consequence, on December 27, 2013, Banco Macro SA carried out the legal merger of Banco Privado de Inversiones SA. with and into the former.

As a result, Banco Macro SA issued 77,860 registered Class B shares to be delivered to the non controlling interest of former Banco Privado de Inversiones SA. That non controlling interest belonged to subsidiaries of Banco Macro SA. Therefore, it was a transaction between entities under common control.

Under Central Bank rules, the merger was accounted for based on the carryover value of assets and liabilities as of January 1, 2013 since the merger was retroactively recognized to that date.

Under US GAAP, FASB ASC 805 requires this transaction to be accounted for as a transaction between entities under common control. Therefore, the transaction is recorded at carryover value of assets and liabilities and in consequence, no gain or loss shall be recognized in consolidated net income. In addition, the merger effects were recognized from December 27, 2013 (merger date).

 

F - 90


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

  c) Other

In past years, the Bank consummated other business combinations which also generated similar adjustments. Had US GAAP been applied, other adjustments relative to these other business combination would decrease the Bank’s assets by 13,470, 19,461 and 26,539 as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively. In addition, income would increase by 5,991, 7,078 and 19,898 for the years ended December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively.

 

  35.8. Reporting on Comprehensive Income (loss)

FASB ASC 220 “Comprehensive Income” requires entities to report a measure of all changes in equity of an enterprise that result from transactions and other economic events of the period other than transactions with owners. Comprehensive income (loss) is the total of net income (loss) and all other non-owner changes in equity.

This statement requires that comprehensive income (loss) be reported in a financial statement that is displayed with the same prominence as other financial statements with an aggregate amount of comprehensive income (loss) reported in that same financial statement. The adoption of this accounting disclosure is shown in Note 35.19. In the Bank’s case, comprehensive income is affected by cumulative translation adjustments related to the foreign subsidiaries and unrealized gains and losses of available for sale securities, net of income taxes.

 

  35.9. Restatement of financial statements in constant pesos

Pursuant to Central Bank rules, the Bank’s financial statements recognize the effects of inflation as described in Note 4.3.

As allowed by the SEC, since the Banking financial statements are restated applying a methodology that comprehensively addresses the accounting for inflation, the effects of general price-level changes recognized in the Bank’s financial statements do not need to be eliminated in reconciling to US GAAP.

 

  35.10. Accounting for derivative instruments and hedging activities

Pursuant to Central Bank rules, the Bank’s derivatives are recorded as described in Notes 4.5.g) and 4.5.k). See Note 33.1.

FASB ASC 815 “Derivatives and Hedging” establishes accounting and reporting standards for derivative instruments, including certain ones embedded in other contracts (collectively referred to as derivatives) and for hedging activities. It requires that an entity recognize all derivatives as either assets or liabilities in the statement of financial position and measure those instruments at fair value. The Bank had no embedded derivatives and does not apply hedge accounting in accordance with FASB ASC 815.

Under US GAAP, FASB ASC 815 also requires disclosures with the intent to provide users of the financial statements with more information about Derivative Instruments and Hedging Activities.

In the Foreign Exchange contracts the Bank mainly operates as an intermediary between parties. The Bank performs these transactions in MAE, as well as private contracts. These derivatives are settled daily (those perform in MAE) or at maturity (private contracts).

The credit risk of derivatives arises from the potential of a counterparty to default on its contractual obligations. The effect of such a default varies as the market value of derivative contracts changes. Credit exposure exists at a particular point in time when a derivative has a positive market value.

 

F - 91


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

The tables below disclose the requirement of FASB ASC 815:

 

    As of December 31,  
    2015     2014  

Derivatives not designated as hedging instruments under FASB ASC 815

  Balance sheet
location (1)
  Fair value     Balance sheet
location (1)
    Fair value  

Assets derivatives

       

Foreign exchange contracts

  Other receivables
from financial
intermediation
    —         
 
 
Other receivables
from financial
intermediation
  
  
  
    136,613   
   

 

 

     

 

 

 

Total assets derivatives

          136,613   
   

 

 

     

 

 

 

Liability derivatives

       

Foreign exchange contracts

  Other liabilities
from financial
intermediation
    526,629       
 
 
Other liabilities
from financial
intermediation
  
  
  
    —     
   

 

 

     

 

 

 

Total liability derivatives

      526,629          —     
   

 

 

     

 

 

 
        As of December 31,  
        2015     2014     2013  

Derivatives not designated as hedging instruments under FASB ASC 815

  Location of gain
or (loss)
recognized in
income on

derivatives (1)
  Amount of gain
or (loss)
recognized in
income on
derivatives
    Amount of gain or
(loss) recognized in
income on
derivatives
    Amount of gain
or (loss)
recognized in
income on
derivatives
 

Interest rate contracts

  Financial income-
Other / (Financial
expense-Other)
    —          2,491        450   

Foreign exchange contracts

  Financial income-
Other
    48,901        143,459        100,442   
   

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

Total

      48,901        145,950        100,892   
   

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

 

(1) According to Central Bank rules.

Had US GAAP been applied, the Bank’s liabilities would decrease by 35,494 as of December 31, 2015 and the Bank’s assets would increase by 1,717 as of December 31, 2013. In addition income would increase by 35,494 and 2,194 for the years ended December 31, 2015 and 2013 respectively, and would decrease by 1,717 for the year ended December 31, 2014.

 

  35.11. Foreign currency translation

The financial statements of the subsidiary Macro Bank Limited were translated under Central Bank rules as described in Note 4.1. US GAAP foreign currency translation requirements are covered by FASB ASC 830-20 “Foreign Currency Matters” and differ from Central Bank rules in the translation of the income statement accounts, which under US GAAP should have been translated at the average exchange rate other than at the year-end exchange rate, and resulting differences in translation adjustments between assets and liabilities and components of shareholders’ equity are recognized as other comprehensive income.

Had US GAAP been applied, the Bank’s net income would decrease by 200,498, 87,646 and 69,536 for the years ended December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively, and these resulting differences recognized as other comprehensive income.

 

F - 92


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

  35.12. Accounting for guarantees

The Bank issues financial guarantees, which are obligations to pay to a third party when a customer fails to repay its obligation.

Under Central Bank rules, guarantees issued are recognized as liabilities when it is probable that the obligation undertaken by the guarantor will be performed.

Under US GAAP, FASB ASC 460 “Guarantees” requires that at inception of a guarantee, a guarantor recognize a liability for the fair value of the obligation undertaken in issuing the guarantee. Such liability at inception is deemed to be the fee received by the Bank with an offsetting entry equal to the consideration received. Subsequent reduction of liability is based on an amortization method as the Bank is decreasing its risk.

Had US GAAP been applied, no differences would have existed in the Bank records, besides the adjustment mentioned in Note 35.3.

 

  35.13. Earning Per Share

The Bank holds, and has held, a capital structure with only common stock outstanding.

Central Bank rules do not require the disclosure of earnings per share or dividends per share.

Under US GAAP, FASB ASC 260 “Earning Per Share”, it is required to present basic per-share amounts (basic EPS) which is computed by dividing income available to common shareholders by the weighted-average number of common shares outstanding during the period.

Diluted earnings per share (diluted EPS) measure the performance if the potential common shares that were dilutive had been issued. Potential common shares are securities that do not have a current right to participate fully in earnings but could do so in the future. No potential common shares exist, and therefore basic and diluted EPS are the same.

The following table sets forth the computation of basic EPS:

 

     2015      2014      2013  

Numerator:

        

Net income attributable to the controlling interest under US GAAP

     4,909,845         3,547,509         2,461,159   

Denominator:

        

Common stock outstanding for the fiscal year (1)

     584,563,028         584,563,028         584,485,168   

Weighted-average common shares outstanding for the year

     584,563,028         584,537,430         584,485,168   

Basic EPS attributable to controlling interest under US GAAP – stated in pesos

     8.40         6.07         4.21   

 

(1) See Note 10.

On March 29, 2016, the Bank paid 227,708 in cash dividends, related to 2014 earnings. Dividend per share amounted Ps.0.39. On April 26, 2016, the Regular and Special General Shareholder’s Meeting of Banco Macro SA approved, among other issues, the distribution of cash dividends for an amount of up 643,019. In addition see Note 16.

 

F - 93


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

  35.14. Corporate Bonds

As mentioned in Note 11., on December 18, 2006, the Bank issued the 1st series of Class 1 subordinated Corporate Bonds for a face value of USD 150,000,000.

In addition, on January 29, 2007, the Bank issued the 1st series of Class 2 nonsubordinated Corporate Bonds for a face value of USD 150,000,000.

In the issuance of these bonds, the Bank incurred direct incremental costs (mainly underwriting and legal fees).

Under Central Bank rules, the Bank has recognized as expenses these costs when they were incurred and the interest has accrued according to the contract terms of the bonds in the period in which it was generated.

Under US GAAP, the Bank recognizes direct incremental costs and interest based on the effective interest method over the life of the bond.

Had US GAAP been applied, the Bank’s assets would increase by 85,893, 38,625 and 5,373 as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively. In addition income would increase by 47,268 and 33,252 for the years ended December 31, 2015 and 2014 respectively, and would decrease by 5,475 for the year ended December 31, 2013.

 

  35.15. Foreclosed assets

As mentioned in Note 26.2, the Bank has real foreclosed assets and buildings not affected by banking activities. Under Central Bank rules, these assets are carried at cost adjusted by depreciation over the life of the assets (see Note 4.5.j)).

Under US GAAP, in accordance with FASB ASC 360 “Property, Plant and Equipment”, such assets classified as held for sale shall be measured at the lower of its carrying amount or fair value less cost to sell. If the asset is newly acquired the carrying amount of the asset shall be established based on its fair value less cost to sell at the acquisition date. A long-lived asset shall not be depreciated while it is classified as held for sale.

As of December 31, 2015 and 2014 the Bank has foreclosed assets amounted to 113,604 and 115,582, respectively.

Had US GAAP been applied, the Bank’s assets would increase by 15,517, 12,845 and 14,157 as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively. In addition income would increase by 2,672 and 656 for the years ended December 31, 2015 and 2013, respectively, and would decrease by 1,312 for the year ended December 31, 2014.

 

  35.16. Capitalization of interest cost

The Bank is constructing a new corporate building tower located in the City of Buenos Aires. The Bank will centralize its office in this new corporate tower. The construction works are expected to be completed in the following years.

Under Central Bank rules, is not allowed to capitalized interest cost from borrowings. Under US GAAP, in accordance with FASB ASC 835-20 “Capitalization of Interest Cost”, if an asset requires a period of time in which to carry out the activities necessary to bring it to the condition and location necessary for its intended use, the interest cost incurred during that period as a result of expenditures for the asset is a part of historical cost of acquiring the asset.

Had US GAAP been applied, the Bank’s assets would increase by 112,804, 37,763 and 9,415 as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively. In addition, income would increase by 75,041, 28,348 and 9,415 for the years ended December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively.

 

F - 94


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

  35.17 Contingencies

In accordance with Central Bank note dated August 4, 2008 the Bank recognizes the effects of the Argentine Supreme Court rulings dated December 27, 2006, and August 28, 2007, upon payment of such precautionary measures, related to foreign-currency denominated deposits (amparos).

Additionally, as provided by Central Bank Communiqué “A” 5689, includes provisions for summary judgements and sanctions applied by the Central Bank and other regulators, which are equivalent to the amounts not yet paid.

Under US GAAP, in accordance with FASB ASC 450 “Contingencies”, the Bank should recognize a liability to cover contingent losses in view of their remote probability of occurrence.

The effects of adjustments required to state such amounts in accordance with US GAAP would increase the Bank’s liabilities by 17,790, 43,420 and 69,017 as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively. In addition, income would increase by 25,630 and 25,597 for the years ended December 31, 2015 and 2014, respectively, and would decrease by 9,049 for the year ended December 31, 2013.

 

  35.18. Noncontrolling Interest in Subsidiaries

Central Bank rules require to record noncontrolling interests as a component of the liabilities. FASB ASC 810 requires to record such interests as shareholders’ equity.

Had US GAAP been applied, the Bank’s shareholder’s equity would increase by 128,305, 93,001 and 69,502 as of December 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively. In addition income would increase by 35,304, 23,499 and 18,147 for the years ended December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively.

 

F - 95


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

  35.19. Set forth below are the significant adjustments to consolidated net income and shareholders’ equity which would be required if US GAAP instead of Central Bank rules had been applied:

 

     Increase / (decrease)  
     Consolidated Net Income
Years ended December 31,
 
     Ref.    2015     2014     2013  

Net income in accordance with Central Bank rules

        5,008,421        3,479,531        2,443,564   

Income taxes

         

Deferred taxes, net of allowances

   35.1.a)      (104,939     154,891        63,993   

Exposure to the Argentine public sector and private securities

         

Loans – Non-financial federal government sector

   35.2.a)      52,013        (42,036     (11,369

Government and private securities

   35.2.b)      (29,277     3        38,162   

Instruments issued by Central Bank of Argentina

   35.2.c)      12,252        7,242        105   

Securities in financial trust and other

   35.2.d)      16,527        (10,418     (5,148

Loan origination fees

   35.3      53,245        20,555        (6,461

Allowance for loan losses

         

Credit Card Loans

   35.4.b)      (8,212     (8,699     (3,517

Impaired Loans – Non Financial Private Sector and residents abroad

   35.4.c)      (20,896     933        (980

Interest recognition – non accrual loans

   35.4.d)      (2,171     (9,087     (6,181

Intangible assets

         

Software costs

   35.5.a)      1,438        3,039        5,369   

Organizational costs

   35.5.b)      4,898        (2,312     (905

Vacation accrual

   35.6      (65,475     (50,642     (899

Business combination

         

Acquisition of Banco de Tucumán S.A.

   35.7.a)      2,049        1,997        1,995   

Acquisition and merger of Banco Privado de Inversiones S.A.

   35.7.b)      369        837        (4,298

Other

   35.7.c)      5,991        7,078        19,898   

Derivative instruments

   35.10      35,494        (1,717     2,194   

Foreign currency translation

   35.11      (200,498     (87,646     (69,536

Corporate bonds

   35.14      47,268        33,252        (5,475

Foreclosed assets

   35.15      2,672        (1,312     656   

Capitalization of interest cost

   35.16      75,041        28,348        9,415   

Contingencies

   35.17      25,630        25,597        (9,049

Noncontrolling interest in subsidiaries

   35.18      35,304        23,499        18,147   
     

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

Net income in accordance with US GAAP

        4,947,144        3,572,933        2,479,680   
     

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

Less: Net income attributable to the noncontrolling interest

        37,299        25,424        18,521   
     

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

Net income attributable to the controlling interest in accordance with US GAAP

        4,909,845        3,547,509        2,461,159   
     

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

 

F - 96


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

     Increase / (decrease)  
     Consolidated Net Income
Years ended December 31,
 
     2015      2014      2013  

Net income in accordance with US GAAP

     4,947,144         3,572,933         2,479,680   

Other comprehensive income, net of tax:

     131,719         58,269         9,894   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total comprehensive income, net in accordance with US GAAP

     5,078,863         3,631,202         2,489,574   

Less: Comprehensive income attributable to noncontrolling interest

     37,210         25,431         18,547   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Comprehensive income attributable to controlling interest

     5,041,653         3,605,771         2,471,027   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total earning per share attributable to controlling interest in accordance with US GAAP – stated in pesos

     8.40         6.07         4.21   

Weighted average number of shares outstanding (in thousands)

     584,563         584,537         584,485   

 

     Increase / (decrease)  
     Consolidated Shareholders’ Equity
as of December 31,
 
     Ref.    2015     2014     2013  

Shareholders’ equity in accordance with Central Bank rules

        15,876,082        11,491,817        8,627,431   

Income taxes

         

Deferred taxes, net of allowances

   35.1.a)      190,243        366,107        242,591   

Exposure to the Argentine public sector and private securities

         

Loans – Non-financial federal government sector

   35.2.a)      (148,237     (200,250     (158,214

Government and private securities

   35.2.b)      (26,196     (21,263     (1,139

Instruments issued by Central Bank of Argentina

   35.2.c)      4,064        2,374        41   

Securities in financial trust and others

   35.2.d)      35,775        30,884        14,268   

Loan origination fees

   35.3      (38,045     (91,290     (111,845

Allowance for loan losses

     

Credit Card Loans

   35.4.b)      (33,876     (25,664     (16,965

Impaired Loans – Non Financial Private Sector and residents abroad

   35.4.c)      (17,124     3,772        2,839   

Interest recognition – non accrual loans

   35.4.d)      (24,249     (22,078     (12,991

Intangible assets

     

Software costs

   35.5.a)      (7,698     (9,136     (12,175

Organizational costs

   35.5.b)      —          (4,898     (2,586

Vacation accrual

   35.6      (268,392     (202,917     (152,275

Business combination

     

Acquisition of Banco de Tucumán S.A.

   35.7.a)      (4,469     (6,518     (8,515

Acquisition and merger of Banco Privado de Inversiones S.A.

   35.7.b)      (11,398     (11,767     (12,604

Other

   35.7.c)      (13,470     (19,461     (26,539

Derivative instruments

   35.10      35,494        —          1,717   

Corporate bonds

   35.14      85,893        38,625        5,373   

Foreclosed assets

   35.15      15,517        12,845        14,157   

 

F - 97


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

     Increase / (decrease)  
     Consolidated Shareholders’ Equity
as of December 31,
 
     Ref.      2015     2014     2013  

Capitalization of interest cost

     35.16         112,804        37,763        9,415   

Contingencies

     35.17         (17,790     (43,420     (69,017

Noncontrolling interests in subsidiaries

     35.18         128,305        93,001        69,502   
     

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

Banco Macro S.A. Shareholders’ equity in accordance with US GAAP (1)

        15,873,233        11,418,526        8,402,469   

Noncontrolling interests (2)

        (132,778     (95,479     (70,055
     

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

Shareholders’ equity attributable to the controlling interest in accordance with US GAAP

        15,740,455        11,323,047        8,332,414   
     

 

 

   

 

 

   

 

 

 

 

(1) Includes the effects of other comprehensive income.
(2) Includes the amount mentioned in Note 35.17 and the effect of adjustments mentioned above.

 

  35.20. Set forth below are the accumulated other comprehensive income (loss) balances, as of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013 – net of related income tax effects:

 

     Foreign
Currency
Items (1)
     Unrealized
Gains/
(losses) on
securities (2)
     Accumulated
Other
Comprehensive

Income /
(Loss) (3)
 

Balances as of December 31, 2012

     36,223         30,754         66,977   

Other comprehensive income before reclassification (4)

     69,536         16,034         85,570   

Amounts reclassified from accumulated other comprehensive income (5)

     —           (70,349      (70,349

Tax effects

     (24,337      19,010         (5,327
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Balances as of December 31, 2013

     81,422         (4,551      76,871   

Other comprehensive income before reclassification (4)

     87,646         59,145         146,791   

Amounts reclassified from accumulated other comprehensive income (5)

     —           (57,147      (57,147

Tax effects

     (30,675      (700      (31,375
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Balances as of December 31, 2014

     138,393         (3,253      135,140   

Other comprehensive income before reclassification (4)

     200,498         86,708         287,206   

Amounts reclassified from accumulated other comprehensive income (5)

     —           (84,562      (84,562

Tax effects

     (70,174      (751      (70,925
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Balances as of December 31, 2015

     268,717         (1,858      266,859   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

F - 98


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

(1) See Note 35.11.
(2) See Note 35.2.
(3) Includes amounts attributable to the non controlling interest for (89), 7 and 26 for the years ended December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, respectively.
(4) Includes the unrealized gains or losses that had been included in Other Comprehensive Income before they were realized.
(5) Includes gains or losses that were realized and included in net income of the current period. Under US GAAP, those amounts would be included under “security gain, net” on the consolidated statement of income.

 

  35.21. Statement of Cash Flows

According to FASB ASC 230 “Statement of Cash Flow”, a statement of cash flows for a period shall report net cash provided or used by operating, investing, and financing activities and the net effect of those flows on cash and cash equivalents during the period in a manner that reconciles beginning and ending cash and cash equivalents.

The statement of cash flows under Central Bank rules differs from the statement of cash flows under US GAAP (see additionally Note 4.5.q).

In accordance with Central Bank Communiqué “A” 4667, cash equivalents include all high liquidity investments with original maturities of three months or less.

Under US GAAP rules, in accordance with FASB ASC 230-10, certain securities did not meet the requirements to be classified as cash equivalents, and instead, are classified as available for sale.

The Bank’s transactions that did not provide an actual movement of funds in each year (non cash transactions) were eliminated from the respective cash changes. As of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, the main non cash transactions, based on their book values under Central Bank rules, were generated by transactions with government securities exchanging non cash assets or liabilities for other non cash assets or liabilities (among other, redemption in kind of financial trusts, forwards, unsettled spot and repurchase contracts to buy or sell foreign currencies, listed Government and other securities at future dates and exchanged non cash assets or liabilities for other non cash assets or liabilities, and exchange agreements (mentioned in Note 35.2.a)) with a book value of 101,987, 814,477 and 251,649, respectively.

The statement of cash flows under US GAAP based on Central Bank figures is shown below:

 

     Year ended December 31,  
     2015      2014      2013  

Causes of changes in cash and cash equivalents

        

Cash provided by (used in) operating activities

        

Interest received on loans, leases and investments

     15,865,329         14,112,308         9,957,778   

Fees and commissions received

     6,114,393         4,652,186         3,400,939   

Purchases and sales of trading securities

     (609,566      (3,077,897      (405,442

Other sources of cash

     395,222         105,944         122,995   

Less:

        

Interest paid

     (8,690,640      (6,507,313      (3,902,576

Fees and commissions paid

     (1,689,901      (1,174,403      (889,886

Cash paid to suppliers and employees

     (6,780,651      (5,091,123      (3,748,636

Increase in intangible assets

     (256,297      (206,865      (166,195

(Increase) / Decrease in other receivables from financial intermediation and other assets

     (1,106,655      173,783         (323,630

Payment of income tax / minimum presumed income tax

     (2,330,121      (1,623,725      (906,557

Other

     —           (405,499      (57,327
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Net cash provided by operating activities

     911,113         957,396         3,081,463   

 

F - 99


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

     Year ended December 31,  
     2015      2014      2013  

Plus:

        

Cash provided by (used in) investing activities

        

Available for sale

        

- Purchases of investment securities

     (49,964,053      (34,007,787      (5,227,892

- Proceeds from sales and maturities of investment securities

     49,656,926         29,750,123         5,551,102   

Increase in loans and leases, net

     (19,282,249      (5,454,747      (8,462,434

Proceeds from sales of Bank premises and equipment

     5,808         5,178         1,225   

Purchases of Bank premises and equipment

     (388,022      (266,359      (176,185
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Net cash used in investing activities

     (19,971,590      (9,973,592      (8,314,184

Cash provided by (used in) financing activities

        

Increase in deposits, net

     20,395,781         10,503,539         7,194,012   

Increase in long term borrowings

     210,395         184,624         403,153   

Decrease in long term borrowings

     (392,478      (657,368      (489,411

Increase in other short term liabilities, net

     2,270,200         1,460,447         960,681   

Cash dividends paid

     —           (598,486      (19
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Net cash provided by financing activities

     22,483,898         10,892,756         8,068,416   

Increase in cash and cash equivalents

     3,423,421         1,876,560         2,835,696   

Cash at the beginning of fiscal year (1)

     14,475,634         12,599,074         9,763,378   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Cash at the end of fiscal year (1)

     17,899,055         14,475,634         12,599,074   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

(1) Includes interest bearing deposits.

Set forth below is the reconciliation of net income as per Central Bank rules to net cash flows from operating activities, as required by FASB ASC 230:

 

     Year ended December 31,  
     2015      2014      2013  

Net income for the fiscal year

     5,008,421         3,479,531         2,443,564   

Adjustments to reconcile net income to net cash from operating activities:

        

Amortization and depreciation

     338,914         269,799         202,987   

Provision for loan losses, net of reversals

     1,047,037         683,934         561,067   

Net income from government and private securities

     (4,904,035      (4,662,378      (334,885

Foreign exchange differences

     510,039         1,070,000         500,224   

Equity gain of unconsolidated subsidiaries

     (33,692      (49,635      (25,162

Increase from intangible assets

     (256,297      (206,865      (166,195

Non-computable VAT credit

     87,947         85,965         38,078   

Increase in taxes payable

     155,542         338,461         426,352   

(Increase) / Decrease in other receivables from financial intermediation and other assets

     (1,106,655      173,783         (323,630

Net Increase in interest receivable and payable and other accrued income and expenses

     (509,612      (69,635      (193,007

Non controlling interest in subsidiaries

     35,359         23,492         13,790   

Net Decrease in other sources of cash

     538,145         (179,056      (61,720
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Net cash provided by operating activities

     911,113         957,396         3,081,463   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

F - 100


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

  35.22. Fair value Measurement Disclosures

FASB ASC 820 “Fair Value Measurement” defines fair value, establishes a consistent framework for measuring fair value, and enhances disclosures about fair value measurements. Effective January 1, 2012, the Bank adopted new accounting guidance under FASB ASC 820 that requires additional disclosures including, among other things, (1) the amounts and reasons for certain significant transfers among, (2) information about transfers between Level 1 and Level 2 of the fair value hierarchy, (3) information about the sensitivity of a fair value measurement categorized within Level 3 of the fair value hierarchy to changes in unobservable inputs and any interrelationships between those unobservable inputs and (4) the categorization by level of the fair value hierarchy for items that are not measured at fair value in the statement of financial position, but for which the fair value of such items is required to be disclosed. The following information incorporates these new disclosure requirements.

Fair Value Measurements

FASB ASC 820 defines fair value as the exchange price that would be received for an asset or paid to transfer a liability (an exit price) in the principal or most advantageous market for the asset or liability in an orderly transaction between market participants on the measurement date. To measure fair value, FASB ASC 820 has established a hierarchy which requires an entity to maximize the use of observable inputs and minimize the use of unobservable inputs. This hierarchy uses three levels of inputs to measure the fair value of assets and liabilities as follows:

Level 1: Unadjusted quoted prices for identical assets or liabilities in an active market that Banco Macro SA has the ability to access.

Level 2: Other than quoted prices included within Level 1 that are observable for the asset or liability, either directly or indirectly. Level 2 inputs include the following:

 

  a) Quoted prices for similar assets or liabilities in active markets;

 

  b) Quoted prices for identical or similar assets or liabilities in less-active markets;

 

  c) Pricing models whose inputs are observable for substantially the full term of the asset or liability; and

 

  d) Pricing models whose inputs are derived principally from or corroborated by observable market data through correlation or other means for substantially the full term of the asset or liability.

Level 3: Prices or valuation techniques that require inputs that are both unobservable and significant to the overall fair value measurement. These inputs reflect management’s own assumptions about the assumptions a market participant would use in pricing the asset or liability.

Description of the measurement processes

The Bank uses fair value to measure certain assets and liabilities on a recurring basis when fair value is the primary measure for accounting. This is done primarily for government and private securities (debt instruments issued by National Government and Central Bank, debt securities issued by Trusts, shares, corporate bonds and other) classified as available for sale or trading account and derivatives (forward transactions without delivery of underlying assets).

As of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, the Bank has no assets measured at fair value on a nonrecurring basis.

The Bank identified and categorized different assets and liabilities measured at fair value in accordance with the requirements of FASB ASC 820.

 

F - 101


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

The Bank has categorized within Level 1, operations that were valued at market price according to trading on its main market, at the fair value at the closing of the fiscal year. According to the Level 1 category, assets and liabilities traded on active markets were analyzed in order to identify and recognize Level 1 type of instruments that are traded on active market.

The Bank has categorized within Level 2, operations that do not meet the requirements of the standard to be considered within Level 1 and whose fair value can be calculated from observable market information, assets and liabilities associated with similar or comparable instruments. Most fair value estimations were made using the “income approach”, converting future amounts (cash flows or income or expenses) to a single current (that is, discounted) amount, considering an effective interest rate developed on the basis of the “yield curve” methodology taking observable inputs of similar instruments. There are also certain assets and liabilities included in this level for which we used the less active market approach to value them identified identical instruments traded that have a “less active market” and took as inputs observable value trade on its main market at the measurement date. In addition, certain assets have projected flows of principal and interest, using the interest rate agreed on the date of issue, and then discounting these cash flows at the market rate for each asset or liability under analysis, obtaining thus the fair value of each investments. When these methods are used, the fair value measurement reflects current market expectations about those future amounts.

The Bank has categorized within Level 3, those assets and liabilities that do not have similar or identical assets traded in the market. In order to measure these instruments at fair value, we used the “income approach”, estimating the fair values based on their own assumptions, which were developed based on similar assumptions to those used by who would use any market participant. For this approach, we used discounted cash flow methodology.

The Bank has not changed the methods and assumptions used to estimate the fair value of financial instruments at the closing date of these consolidated financial statements.

In addition, the Bank’s valuation policies and procedures for Level 3 instruments (in the case of the Bank mainly, debt securities like Securities in financial trust) are under the direction of the accounting and financial management. The Management of the Bank is in charge of developing, reviewing, approving and monitoring the key model inputs, critical valuation assumptions and proposed discount rates utilized for the valuation of Level 3 instruments. In addition, the Management is also in charge of monitoring the changes in fair values of Level 3 instruments from period to period.

 

F - 102


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

Assets and liabilities measured at fair value on a recurring basis as of December 31, 2015 and 2014 are as follows:

 

     December 31, 2015  

DESCRIPTION

   Total      Level 1      Level 2     Level 3  

ASSETS

          

Government and private securities

          

Trading

          

- Government securities

     4,921,771         4,908,235         13,536        —     

- Equity securities

     1,127,399         1,112,646         14,753        —     

Available for sale

          

- Government securities

     1,011,611         32,606         979,005        —     

- Instruments issued by Central Bank

     8,307,056         5,066,846         3,240,210   (*)      —     

Other receivables from financial intermediation

          

Trading

          

- Mutual funds

     174,441         174,441         —          —     

Available for sale

          

- Unlisted Corporate Bonds

     609,387         149,886         459,501        —     

- Securities in financial trusts

     130,594         —           —          130,594   

Receivables from spot transactions

     117,705         90,033         27,672        —     

Other receivables in securities

     4         —           4        —     
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

 

Total Asset

     16,399,968         11,534,693         4,734,681        130,594   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

 

LIABILITIES

          

Other liabilities from financial intermediation

          

Payables from spot transactions

     39,302         39,302         —          —     

Derivative instruments

     526,629         —           526,629        —     
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

 

Total liabilities

     565,931         39,302         526,629        —     
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

 

 

F - 103


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

     December 31, 2014  

DESCRIPTION

   Total      Level 1      Level 2     Level 3  

ASSETS

          

Government and private securities

          

Trading

          

- Government securities

     3,241,222         3,241,213         9        —     

- Equity securities

     776,655         763,610         13,045        —     

Available for sale

          

- Government securities

     425,494         36,748         388,746        —     

- Instruments issued by Central Bank

     5,673,716         3,788,518         1,885,198   (*)      —     

Other receivables from financial intermediation

          

Trading

          

- Mutual funds

     88,067         88,067         —          —     

Available for sale

          

- Unlisted Corporate Bonds

     484,898         6,460         478,438        —     

- Securities in financial trusts

     142,243         —           —          142,243   

Receivables from spot transactions

     50,360         24,952         25,408        —     

Other receivables in securities

     775         775         —          —     

Derivative instruments

     136,613         136,613         —          —     
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

 

Total Asset

     11,020,043         8,086,956         2,790,844        142,243   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

 

LIABILITIES

          

Other liabilities from financial intermediation

          

Payables from spot transactions

     59,132         58,986         146        —     
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

 

Total liabilities

     59,132         58,986         146        —     
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

 

 

(*) Mainly includes instruments issued by Central Bank of Argentina with less than one year maturity.

 

F - 104


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

The following is the reconciliation of the beginning and ending balances for assets and liabilities measured at fair value on a recurring basis using significant unobservable inputs (Level 3) during the periods:

 

    Fair value measurements using significant
unobservable inputs (Level 3)

December 31, 2015
 

Description

  Derivatives      Securities in
financial
trusts
     Total  

Beginning balance

    —           142,243         142,243   

Transfer into Level 3

    —           —           —     

Transfer out of Level 3

    —           —           —     

Total gains or losses

       

- Included in earnings (or changes in net assets)

    —           (59,204      (59,204

- Included in other comprehensive income

    —           4,519         4,519   

Purchases, issuances, sales, and settlements

       

- Purchases

    —           45,879         45,879   

- Issuances

    —           —           —     

- Sales

    —           —           —     

- Settlements

    —           (2,843      (2,843
 

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Ending balance

    —           130,594         130,594   
 

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

    Fair value measurements using significant
unobservable inputs (Level 3)
 
    December 31, 2014  

Description

  Derivatives      Securities in
financial
trusts
     Total  

Beginning balance

    1,717         209,169         210,886   

Transfer into Level 3

    —           —           —     

Transfer out of Level 3

    —           —           —     

Total gains or losses

       

- Included in earnings (or changes in net assets)

    —           (6,219      (6,219

- Included in other comprehensive income

    —           (9,442      (9,442

Purchases, issuances, sales, and settlements

       

- Purchases

    —           8,468         8,468   

- Issuances

    —           —           —     

- Sales

    —           —           —     

- Settlements

    (1,717      (59,733      (61,450
 

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Ending balance

    —           142,243         142,243   
 

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

F - 105


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

Quantitative information about Level 3 Fair Value Measurements

The following table provides quantitative information about the valuation techniques and significant unobservable inputs used in the valuation of substantially all of our Level 3 assets and liabilities measured at fair value on a recurring basis for which we use an internal model.

 

     December 31, 2015

Description

   Fair value      Valuation
Technique
   Unobservable
Input
   Range (weighted
average)

Securities in financial trusts

     130,594       Income Approach
(discounted cash
flow)
   Discount rate in
pesos

 

Discount rate in
foreign currency

  

 

25% - 34% (33%)

 

12% -12% (12%)

     December 31, 2014

Description

   Fair value      Valuation
Technique
   Unobservable
Input
   Range (weighted
average)

Securities in financial trusts

     142,243       Income Approach
(discounted cash
flow)
   Discount rate in
pesos

 

Discount rate in
foreign currency

  

 

29% - 29% (29%)

 

6% - 6% (6%)

The decision to classify an instrument within Level 3 is based on the significance of the unobservable inputs to the overall fair value measurement Level 3 financial instruments typically include observable components (that is, components that are actively quoted and can be validated with external sources) in addition to the unobservable components.

Changes in Fair Value Levels

The Bank monitors the availability of observable market data to assess the appropriate classification of financial instruments within the fair value hierarchy and transfer between Level 1, Level 2, and Level 3 accordingly. Observable market data includes but is not limited to quoted prices and market transactions. Changes in economic conditions or market liquidity generally will drive changes in availability of observable market data.

Changes in availability of observable market data, which also may result in changing the valuation technique used, are generally the cause of transfers between Level 1, 2 or 3.

As of December 31, 2015 and 2014, the Bank has not made significant transfers in and out of Level 1, Level 2, and Level 3.

Fair Value Option

FASB ASC 825 “Financial Instruments” allows for the option to report certain financial assets and liabilities at fair value initially and at subsequent measurement dates with changes in fair value included in earnings. The option may be applied instrument by instrument, but is on an irrevocable basis. As of December 31, 2015, 2014 and 2013, the Bank did not elect to apply the fair value option.

Fair Value Disclosures

FASB ASC 825 requires disclosure of fair value information about financial instruments, whether or not recognized on the balance sheet, for which it is practicable to estimate fair value.

A significant portion of the Bank’s assets and liabilities are in short-term financial instruments, with a remaining maturity of less than one year, and/or with variable rates. These short-term and variable-rate financial instruments are considered to have a fair value equivalent to their carrying value at the balance sheet date.

 

F - 106


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

The following methods and assumptions were used to estimate the fair value for financial instruments with remaining maturity over a short term period and with fixed-rates, and financial instruments not included in Fair Value Measurement section:

 

    Loans and assets subject to financial leases: fair value is estimated, mainly, by discounting future cash flows using the current rates at which loans would be made to borrowers with similar credit ratings and for the same remaining maturities, considering the contractual terms in effect as of December 31, 2015 and 2014. Loans and assets subject to financial leases are not normally purchased and sold by the Bank, and there are no active trading markets for most of this portfolio. Accordingly, the Banks estimates are categorized in Level 3 of the Fair Value Hierarchy.

 

    Deposits: the Bank’s deposits as of December 31, 2015 and 2014, that have a remaining maturity of under a short period were considered to have a fair value equivalent to their carrying value at the balance sheet date while for those that have a remaining maturity over a short period (investments accounts and time deposits), the fair value was taken to be equal to the present value of future cash flows discounted at the average year-end observable market interest rates for similar deposits. In consequence, Demand Deposits are categorized in Level 1 and Time Deposits are categorized in Level 2 of the Fair Value Hierarchy.

 

    Other liabilities from financial intermediation (except Nonsubordinated corporate bonds) and Other liabilities: fair value for long-term loans is estimated by discounting future cash flows using current rates at which liabilities were received while fair value for short-term loans was considered to be equivalent to their carrying value at the balance sheet. Other liabilities from financial intermediation and Other liabilities are categorized in Level 2 of the Fair Value Hierarchy.

 

    Subordinated and Nonsubordinated corporate bonds: as of December 31, 2015 and 2014, fair value was taken to be equal to the present value of future cash flows discounted at the average year end market interest rates for securities of similar interest rate, credit risk and duration. These instruments are categorized in Level 2 of the Fair Value Hierarchy.

 

    Off-Balance sheet: commitments to extending credit, standby letters of credit, guarantees granted and foreign trade acceptances: it is estimated that the differential, if any, between the fees the Bank charged for these transactions and the fair value would not give rise to a material variance.

The following is a summary of carrying amounts under Central Bank rules and estimated fair values of financial instruments as of December 31, 2015 and 2014:

 

     As of December 31,  
     2015      2014  
     Carrying
Amount
     Level 1      Level 2      Level 3      Estimated
Fair Value
     Carrying
Amount
     Estimated
Fair Value
 

FINANCIAL ASSETS

                    

Cash

     19,402,821         19,402,821         —           —           19,402,821         15,434,202         15,434,202   

Government and private securities

     15,391,372         11,121,736         4,247,504         —           15,369,240         10,312,498         10,293,609   

Loans

     62,332,415         —           —           58,928,302         58,928,302         43,740,295         41,576,530   

Other receivables from financial intermediation

     3,295,253         2,056,607         1,124,439         130,594         3,311,640         2,349,108         2,337,194   

Receivables to financial leases

     433,932         —           —           356,512         356,512         384,411         306,914   

Other receivables

     978,881         978,879         —           —           978,879         605,414         605,353   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 
     101,834,674         33,560,043         5,371,943         59,415,408         98,347,394         72,825,928         70,553,802   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

F - 107


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

     As of December 31,  
     2015      2014  
     Carrying
Amount
     Level 1      Level 2      Level 3      Estimated
Fair Value
     Carrying
Amount
     Estimated
Fair Value
 

FINANCIAL LIABILITIES

                    

Deposits

     76,521,598         37,386,402         39,155,171         —           76,541,573         54,716,554         54,721,030   

Other liabilities from financial intermediation

     7,537,365         5,489,678         2,106,638         —           7,596,316         5,356,712         5,471,773   

Other Liabilities

     2,650,459         —           2,650,459         —           2,650,459         1,871,344         1,871,344   

Subordinated Corporate Bonds

     1,957,618         —           2,115,720         —           2,115,720         1,287,317         1,396,883   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 
     88,667,040         42,876,080         46,027,988         —           88,904,068         63,231,927         63,461,030   
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

These fair value disclosures represent the Bank’s best estimates based on relevant market information and information about the financial instruments. Fair value estimates are based on judgments regarding future expected loss experience, current economic conditions, risk characteristics of the various instruments, and other factors. These estimates are subjective in nature and involve uncertainties and matters of significant judgment and therefore cannot be determined with precision. Changes in the above methodologies and assumptions could significantly affect the estimates.

Further, because of the characteristics of all nonfinancial instruments, there were no disclosures required regarding such assets. Therefore, the fair value amounts shown in the schedule do not, by themselves, represent the underlying value of the Bank as a whole.

 

  35.23. Joint venture

As mentioned in Note 3.5., the Bank participates in certain joint ventures. Under Central Bank rules these interests are consolidated through the proportional consolidation method.

Under US GAAP, that method of consolidation is not appropriate for such investments and they are accounted for using equity method.

Therefore, had US GAAP been applied as of December 31, 2015 and 2014, “Other assets” would have increased by 35,102 and 19,663, respectively, with an offsetting decrease in various assets and liabilities accounts. Additionally, as of December 31, 2015 and 2014, income from equity in other companies would have increased by 44,910 and 35,674, respectively, with an offsetting decrease in various income and expense accounts, with no net effect in net income or equity.

 

  35.24. Items in process of collection

The Bank does not give accounting recognition to checks drawn against the Bank or other Banks or other items to be collected, until such time as the related item clears or is accepted. Such items are recorded by the Bank in Memorandum accounts. US banks, however, account for such items through balance sheet clearing accounts at the time the items are presented for collection.

Had US GAAP been applied, both the Bank’s assets and liabilities would decrease by approximately 815,603 and 435,658 as of December 31, 2015 and 2014, respectively.

 

F - 108


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

  35.25. Acceptances

Foreign trade acceptances are not recorded on the balance sheet by the Bank. In accordance with Regulation S-X, acceptances and related customer liabilities should be recorded on the balance sheet. Adjustment required to state balance sheets in accordance with Regulation S-X would be to increase assets (due from customers on acceptances) and increase liabilities (bank acceptances outstanding) by 1,364,407 and 365,420 as of December 31, 2015 and 2014, respectively.

 

  35.26. Repurchase agreements

The Bank entered into Repo and Reverse Repo agreements of financial instruments as disclosed in Note 25.

In accordance with Central Bank Rules, the Bank derecognizes the securities transferred under the repurchase agreement and records an asset related to the future repurchase of these securities. Contemporaneously, the Bank records a liability related to the cash received in the transaction. As mentioned in Notes 4.5.g.1) and g.2), the asset related to securities to be repurchased is measured as the same criteria as the transferred securities.

Similar treatment applies to reverse repo agreements.

Under US GAAP, FASB ASC 860 “Transfers and Servicing”, these transactions have not qualified as sales and therefore these transactions are recorded as secured financings.

Had US GAAP been applied, both the Bank’s assets and liabilities would have decreased by approximately 1,403 and 176,520 as of December 31, 2015 and 2014, respectively.

In addition, the measurement adjustments of those securities are included in Note 35.2.

 

  35.27. Variable Interest Entities (VIE) and other trusts

As mentioned in Note 14., Banco Macro S.A. is involved in several trust agreements.

Under Central Bank Rules, the Bank is not required to consolidate these trusts (see Note 4.5.g.3).

Under US GAAP, FASB ASC 810 “Consolidation” addresses consolidation of variable interest entities, as defined in the rules, which have certain characteristics.

The methodology for evaluating trust and transactions under the VIE requirements includes the following two steps:

 

    Determine whether the entity meets the criteria to qualify as a VIE and;

 

    Determine whether the Bank is the primary beneficiary of a VIE.

In performing the first step the significant factors and judgments that were considered in making the determination as to whether an entity is a VIE includes:

 

    The design of the entity, including the nature of its risks and the purpose for which the entity was created, to determine the variability that the entity was designed to create and distribute to its interest holders;

 

    The nature of the involvement with the entity;

 

    Whether control of the entity may be achieved through arrangements that do not involve voting equity;

 

    Whether there is sufficient equity investment at risk to finance the activities of the entity and;

 

    Whether parties other than the equity holders have the obligation to absorb expected losses or the right to received residual returns.

 

F - 109


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

For each VIE identified, the Bank performs the second step and evaluates whether it is the primary beneficiary of the VIE by considering the following significant factors and criteria:

 

    Whether the Bank has the power to direct the activities that most significantly impact the VIE’s economic performance and;

 

    Whether the Bank absorb the majority of the VIE’s expected losses or the Bank receive a majority of the VIE’s expected residual returns.

As of December of 31, 2014 under FASB ASC 810, TATSA Trust was considered a variable interest entity. In accordance with FASB ASC 810, the Bank was deemed to be the primary beneficiary of this trust and, therefore, the Bank included them in its consolidated financial statements. However, there were no significant impacts in the US GAAP shareholders’ equity or net income reconciliation. On July 8, 2015, all remaining securities issued by the Trust were settled.

As of December 31, 2015 and 2014, the table below presents the carrying amount and classification of the VIE’s assets and liabilities which have been consolidated for US GAAP purposes. As mentioned in Note 14., under Central Bank rules, those amounts were recorded principally under “Other receivables from financial intermediation – Other receivables not covered by debtors classification regulations

 

     As of December 31,  
     2015      2014  

Cash (a)

     —           231   

Other assets

     —           4,069   

Total Assets

     —           4,300   

Other liabilities

     —           71   

Total Liabilities (b)

     —           71   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

Net Assets

     —           4,229   
  

 

 

    

 

 

 

 

  (a) Includes intercompany deposits eliminated in the consolidation process amounted to 231 as of December 31, 2014.
  (b) Creditors (or beneficial interest holders) of these liabilities do not have recourse against the general credit of the primary beneficiary.

The involvements in variable interest entities do not have a material impact on the primary beneficiary’s financial position, financial performance and cash flows.

See also Note 13 for additional information of the trusts which have been considered variable interest entities.

As a result of consolidating the trust mentioned in this Note, total assets and liabilities would decrease by 160 as of December 31, 2014.

In addition, the others trusts mentioned in Note 14.1 were not considered VIE and were classified as investment securities available for sale under FASB ASC 320. See Note 35.2.d).

 

  35.28. Accounting pronouncements (US GAAP)

 

  a) Technical Corrections and Improvements – ASU 2015-10.

In June 2015, FASB issued ASU 10 “Technical Corrections and Improvements”. The amendments in this Update cover a wide range of Topics in the Codification. The reason for each amendment is provided before each amendment for clarity and ease of understanding. The amendments generally fall into one of the followings types of amendments: (i) Amendments Related to Differences between Original Guidance and the Codification, (ii) Guidance Clarification and Reference Corrections, (iii) Simplification and (iv) Minor Improvements.

 

F - 110


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

Amendments in this Update are effective for fiscal years, and interim periods within those fiscal years, beginning after December 15, 2015. The Bank does not expect significant impact from the adoption of this statement.

 

  b) Revenue from Contracts with Customers– ASU 2015-14 (Topic 606): Deferral of the effective date.

In August 2015, FASB issued ASU 14 “Revenue from Contracts with Customers”. The amendments in this Update defer the effective date of Update ASU 2014-09 for all entities by one year. Entities should apply the abovementioned Update to annual reporting periods beginning after December 15, 2017, including interim reporting periods within that reporting period.

Additionally, in March 2016, FASB issued ASU 08, “Revenue from Contracts with Customer”. The amendments in this update clarify the implementation guidance on principal versus agent consideration.

The bank is continuing to evaluate the potential effects of this new standard on our consolidated financial statements.

 

  c) Business Combination – ASU 2015-16 (Topic 805). Simplifying the Accounting for Measurement-Period Adjustment.

In September 2015, FASB issued ASU 16 “Simplifying the Accounting for Measurement-Period Adjustment”. The amendments in this Update require that an acquirer recognize adjustments to provisional amounts that are identified during the measurement period in the reporting period in which the adjustment amounts are determined. The acquirer is required to record, in the same period’s financial statements, the effect on earnings of changes in depreciation, amortization, or other income effects, if any, as a result of the change to the provisional amounts, calculated as if the accounting had been completed at the acquisition date.

Amendments in this Update are effective for fiscal years, and interim periods within those fiscal years, beginning after December 15, 2015. The Bank does not expect significant impact from the adoption of this statement

 

  d) Financial Instruments – Overall – ASU 2016-01 (Subtopic 825-10). Recognition of Financial Assets and Financial Liabilities.

In January 2016, FASB issued ASU 16 “Recognition of Financial Assets and Financial Liabilities”. The main provisions of this ASU are as follows: (i) requires equity investments (except those accounted for under the equity method of accounting or those that result in consolidation of the investee) to be measured at fair value with changes in fair value recognized in net income. However, an entity may choose to measure equity investments that do not have readily determinable fair values at cost minus impairment (if any), plus or minus changes resulting from observable price changes in orderly transactions for the identical or a similar investment of the same issuer, (ii) simplifies the impairment assessment of equity investments without readily determinable fair values by requiring a qualitative assessment to identify impairment. When a qualitative assessment indicates that impairment exists, an entity is required to measure the investment at fair value, (iii) eliminates the requirement for public business entities to disclose the method(s) and significant assumptions used to estimate the fair value that is required to be disclosed for financial instruments measured at amortized cost on the balance sheet, (iv) requires public business entities to use the exit price notion when measuring the fair value of financial instruments for disclosure purposes and (v) requires an entity to present separately in other comprehensive income (OCI) the portion of the total change in the fair value of a liability resulting from a change in the instrument-specific credit risk when the organization has elected to measure the liability at fair value in accordance with the fair value option for financial instruments.

Amendments in this Update are effective for fiscal years, and interim periods within those fiscal years, beginning after December 15, 2017. The bank is continuing to evaluate the potential effects of this new standard on our consolidated financial statements.

 

F - 111


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

  e) Leases – ASU 2016-02 (Topic 842).

In February 2016, FASB issued ASU 02 “Leases”. The core principle of this amendment is that a lessee should recognize the assets and liabilities that arise from leases. A lessee should recognize in the statement of financial position a liability to make lease payments (the lease liability) and a right-of-use asset representing its right to use the underlying asset for the lease term. When measuring assets and liabilities arising from a lease, a lessee (and a lessor) should include payments to be made in optional periods only if the lessee is reasonably certain to exercise an option to extend the lease or not to exercise an option to terminate the lease. The accounting applied by a lessor is largely unchanged from that applied under previous GAAP. However, some changes to the lessor accounting guidance were made to align both of the following: (i) the lessor accounting guidance with specific changes made to the lessee accounting guidance (for example, certain glossary terms); (ii) Key aspects of the lessor accounting model with the revenue recognition guidance in Topic 606.

Amendments in this Update are effective for fiscal years, and interim periods within those fiscal years, beginning after December 15, 2018. The bank is continuing to evaluate the potential effects of this new standard on our consolidated financial statements.

 

  f) Derivatives and Hedging – ASU 2016-05 (Topic 815). Effect of Derivative Contract Novations on Existing Hedge Accounting Relationships.

In March 2016, FASB issued ASU 05 “Derivatives and Hedging”. The amendments in this Update clarify that a change in the counterparty to a derivative instrument that has been designated as the hedging instrument under Topic 815 does not, in and of itself, require dedesignation of that hedging relationship provided that all other hedge accounting criteria (including those in paragraphs 815-20-35-14 through 35-18) continue to be met.

Amendments in this Update are effective for fiscal years, and interim periods within those fiscal years, beginning after December 15, 2016. The Bank does not expect significant impact from the adoption of this statement.

 

  g) Derivatives and Hedging – ASU 2016-06 (Topic 815). Contingent Put and Call Options in Debt Instruments.

In March 2016, FASB issued ASU 06 “Derivatives and Hedging. Contingent Put and Call Options in Debt Instruments”. The amendments in this Update clarify the requirements for assessing whether contingent call (put) options that can accelerate the payment of principal on debt instruments are clearly and closely related to their debt hosts. An entity performing the assessment under the amendments in this Update is required to assess the embedded call (put) options solely in accordance with the four-step decision sequence.

Amendments in this Update are effective for fiscal years, and interim periods within those fiscal years, beginning after December 15, 2016. The Bank does not expect significant impact from the adoption of this statement.

 

F - 112


Table of Contents

BANCO MACRO SA AND SUBSIDIARIES

 

  h) Investments – Equity Method and Joint Ventures – ASU 2016-07 (Topic 323). Simplifying the Transition to the Equity Method of Accounting.

In March 2016, FASB issued ASU 07, “Investments – Equity Method and Joint Ventures”. The amendments in this Update eliminate the requirement that when an investment qualifies for use of the equity method as a result of an increase in the level of ownership interest or degree of influence, an investor must adjust the investment, results of operations, and retained earnings retroactively on a step-by-step basis as if the equity method had been in effect during all previous periods that the investment had been held. The amendments require that the equity method investor add the cost of acquiring the additional interest in the investee to the current basis of the investor’s previously held interest and adopt the equity method of accounting as of the date the investment becomes qualified for equity method accounting. Therefore, no retroactive adjustment of the investment is required. Also, when an entity that has an available-for-sale equity security that becomes qualified for the equity method of accounting recognize through earnings the unrealized holding gain or loss in accumulated other comprehensive income at the date the investment becomes qualified for use of the equity method.

Amendments in this Update are effective for fiscal years, and interim periods within fiscal those years, beginning after December 15, 2016. The Bank does not expect significant impact from the adoption of this statement.

 

F - 113

EX-8.1 2 d176736dex81.htm EX-8.1 EX-8.1

Exhibit 8.1

 

Subsidiaries of the Company

 

Subsidiary

  

Jurisdiction of

Incorporation

  

Principal Activity

Banco del Tucumán S.A.    Republic of Argentina    Financial Institution
Macro Bank Limited    The Bahamas    Banking Services
Macro Securities S.A.    Republic of Argentina    Securities Agent and Brokerage Services
Macro Fiducia S.A.    Republic of Argentina    Trust Services
Macro Fondos S.G.F.C.I. S.A.    Republic of Argentina    Mutual Fund Administration
EX-12.1 3 d176736dex121.htm EX-12.1 EX-12.1

Exhibit 12.1

CERTIFICATE

I, JORGE HORACIO BRITO, CERTIFY THAT:

1. I have reviewed this annual report on Form 20-F of Banco Macro S.A.;

2. Based on my knowledge, this report does not contain any untrue statement of a material fact or omit to state a material fact necessary to make the statements made, in light of the circumstances under which such statements were made, not misleading with respect to the period covered by this report;

3. Based on my knowledge, the financial statements, and other financial information included in this report, fairly present in all material respects the financial condition, results of operations and cash flows of the company as of, and for, the periods presented in this report;

4. The company’s other certifying officer(s) and I are responsible for establishing and maintaining disclosure controls and procedures (as defined in Exchange Act Rules 13a-15(e) and 15d-15(e)) and internal control over financial reporting (as defined in Exchange Act Rules 13a-15(f) and 15d-15(f)) for the company and have:

(a) Designed such disclosure controls and procedures, or caused such disclosure controls and procedures to be designed under our supervision, to ensure that material information relating to the company, including its consolidated subsidiaries, is made known to us by others within those entities, particularly during the period in which this report is being prepared;

(b) Designed such internal control over financial reporting, or caused such internal control over financial reporting to be designed under our supervision, to provide reasonable assurance regarding the reliability of financial reporting and the preparation of financial statements for external purposes in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles;

(c) Evaluated the effectiveness of the company’s disclosure controls and procedures and presented in this report our conclusions about the effectiveness of the disclosure controls and procedures, as of the end of the period covered by this report based on such evaluation; and

(d) Disclosed in this report any change in the company’s internal control over financial reporting that occurred during the period covered by the annual report that has materially affected, or is reasonably likely to materially affect, the company’s internal control over financial reporting; and

5. The company’s other certifying officer and I have disclosed, based on our most recent evaluation of internal control over financial reporting, to the company’s auditors and the audit committee of the company’s board of directors (or persons performing the equivalent functions):

(a) All significant deficiencies and material weaknesses in the design or operation of internal control over financial reporting which are reasonably likely to adversely affect the company’s ability to record, process, summarize and report financial information; and

(b) Any fraud, whether or not material, that involves management or other employees who have a significant role in the company’s internal control over financial reporting.

Date: April 28, 2016

 

/s/ Jorge Horacio Brito

Name:   Jorge Horacio Brito
Title:   Chief Executive Officer
EX-12.2 4 d176736dex122.htm EX-12.2 EX-12.2

Exhibit 12.2

CERTIFICATE

I JORGE PABLO BRITO, CERTIFY THAT:

1. I have reviewed this annual report on Form 20-F of Banco Macro S.A.;

2. Based on my knowledge, this report does not contain any untrue statement of a material fact or omit to state a material fact necessary to make the statements made, in light of the circumstances under which such statements were made, not misleading with respect to the period covered by this report;

3. Based on my knowledge, the financial statements, and other financial information included in this report, fairly present in all material respects the financial condition, results of operations and cash flows of the company as of, and for, the periods presented in this report;

4. The company’s other certifying officer and I are responsible for establishing and maintaining disclosure controls and procedures (as defined in Exchange Act Rules 13a-15(e) and 15d-15(e)) and internal control over financial reporting (as defined in Exchange Act Rules 13a-15(f) and 15d-15(f)) for the company and have:

(a) Designed such disclosure controls and procedures, or caused such disclosure controls and procedures to be designed under our supervision, to ensure that material information relating to the company, including its consolidated subsidiaries, is made known to us by others within those entities, particularly during the period in which this report is being prepared;

(b) Designed such internal control over financial reporting, or caused such internal control over financial reporting to be designed under our supervision, to provide reasonable assurance regarding the reliability of financial reporting and the preparation of financial statements for external purposes in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles;

(c) Evaluated the effectiveness of the company’s disclosure controls and procedures and presented in this report our conclusions about the effectiveness of the disclosure controls and procedures, as of the end of the period covered by this report based on such evaluation; and

(d) Disclosed in this report any change in the company’s internal control over financial reporting that occurred during the period covered by the annual report that has materially affected, or is reasonably likely to materially affect, the company’s internal control over financial reporting; and

5. The company’s other certifying officer and I have disclosed, based on our most recent evaluation of internal control over financial reporting, to the company’s auditors and the audit committee of the company’s board of directors (or persons performing the equivalent functions):

(a) All significant deficiencies and material weaknesses in the design or operation of internal control over financial reporting which are reasonably likely to adversely affect the company’s ability to record, process, summarize and report financial information; and

(b) Any fraud, whether or not material, that involves management or other employees who have a significant role in the company’s internal control over financial reporting.

Date: April 28, 2016

 

/s/ Jorge Pablo Brito

Name:   Jorge Pablo Brito
Title:   Chief Financial Officer
EX-13.1 5 d176736dex131.htm EX-13.1 EX-13.1

Exhibit 13.1

CERTIFICATION

PURSUANT TO SECTION 906 OF THE SARBANES-OXLEY ACT OF 2002

(SUBSECTIONS (A) AND (B) OF SECTION 1350, CHAPTER 63 OF TITLE 18, UNITED STATES CODE)

Pursuant to 18 U.S.C. Section 1350, as adopted pursuant to Section 906 of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002, the undersigned officer of Banco Macro S.A. (the “Company”), does hereby certify that, to the best of such officer’s knowledge:

 

  1. The accompanying Report of the Company on Form 20-F (the “Report”) fully complies with the requirements of Section 13(a) or 15(d) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934; and

 

  2. Information contained in the Report fairly presents, in all material respects, the financial condition and results of operations of the Company.

 

Date: April 28, 2016    

/s/ Jorge Horacio Brito

    Name:   Jorge Horacio Brito
    Title:   Chief Executive Officer
EX-13.2 6 d176736dex132.htm EX-13.2 EX-13.2

Exhibit 13.2

CERTIFICATION

PURSUANT TO SECTION 906 OF THE SARBANES-OXLEY ACT OF 2002

(SUBSECTIONS (A) AND (B) OF SECTION 1350, CHAPTER 63 OF TITLE 18, UNITED STATES CODE)

Pursuant to 18 U.S.C. Section 1350, as adopted pursuant to Section 906 of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002, the undersigned officer of Banco Macro S.A. (the “Company”), does hereby certify that, to the best of such officer’s knowledge:

 

  1. The accompanying Report of the Company on Form 20-F (the “Report”) fully complies with the requirements of Section 13(a) or 15(d) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934; and

 

  2. Information contained in the Report fairly presents, in all material respects, the financial condition and results of operations of the Company.

 

Date: April 28, 2016    

/s/ Jorge Pablo Brito

    Name:   Jorge Pablo Brito
    Title:   Chief Financial Officer
GRAPHIC 7 g176736finlogo.jpg GRAPHIC begin 644 g176736finlogo.jpg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g176736g0423145003072.jpg GRAPHIC begin 644 g176736g0423145003072.jpg M_]C_X 02D9)1@ ! 0$ 8 !@ #_VP!# @&!@<&!0@'!P<)"0@*#!0-# L+ M#!D2$P\4'1H?'AT:'!P@)"XG("(L(QP<*#7J#A(6&AXB)BI*3E)66EYB9FJ*CI*6FIZBIJK*SM+6VM[BYNL+#Q,7& MQ\C)RM+3U-76U]C9VN'BX^3EYN?HZ>KQ\O/T]?;W^/GZ_\0 'P$ P$! 0$! M 0$! 0 $" P0%!@<("0H+_\0 M1$ @$"! 0#! <%! 0 0)W $" M Q$$!2$Q!A)!40=A<1,B,H$(%$*1H;'!"2,S4O 58G+1"A8D-.$E\1<8&1HF M)R@I*C4V-S@Y.D-$149'2$E*4U155E=865IC9&5F9VAI:G-T=79W>'EZ@H.$ MA8:'B(F*DI.4E9:7F)F:HJ.DI::GJ*FJLK.TM;:WN+FZPL/$Q<;'R,G*TM/4 MU=;7V-G:XN/DY>;GZ.GJ\O/T]?;W^/GZ_]H # ,! (1 Q$ /P#W^BBB@ HH MHH **** "BBB@ HHHH ***P[#Q;I6I:P^EV[7/VA3, 9+9TCP*Y0R6TJR*& !QD'K@C\ZNU1M=,AM-3O;Z(NK7BQ^;& M#A"R C?C^\5*J3W"(.U<%F1G &23S0!V6X>M& M1G%>(:K%IE[9?"R'7+>[NK"31Y#+%;+,[NWD0$'$7SGFN@^'C6,'C36]/T1K MVVT:&V@9+#4&D$@E)8L\:2?.J8QG/5J /4**** "BBB@ HHHH **** "BBB@ M HHHH **** "BBB@"MJ%_;:9I\][>2B*WA7<[8)/T '))/ Y)( YK&T30A_ M:]SXCU"TBBU:[C$(50"8( > 2%!.?XP\/ZSK.JZ;-I_BJ'1E@ M8^3$]@EP9)2#S\[X)"@XPN1\QSZ4/^$2^(6./B:/I_8,'^- '?%P&VY&<9Q7 ME=YX#\6IX)N/!FG7>D+I+%UBNIO,^T"(L7",@!7.2%+@].V>:Z;P9XEK>IIEI'J31O>K @N M'CY5I-HW$<#@G/8?A5?Q-ILVL^%=7TNW9%GO;*:WC:0D*&="H)P"<9/I6I10 M!YX_A/Q%9KX(GTT:9+98=.:TM;+3G9S)E@Y+/(J\Y4 =N>:[2D(R"/6@#'\)ZM541\+W+9[8K1T'P;!X7U>\ETJ[DATJZB7&F8)CBE!.9$ M)/RY!Y&.2,YZ 0^)?#.K3ZY!XB\,ZA;6FK16QMI8KM&>"[CW;E5]IRNTEB&4 M9YQTI=!\/:Z=9_M[Q/J5O-J MC;16=@'6U@4OEF&\DLS +DX&,8YX- '6T5Q M&E7FLMI=DU_?Z@AF@B:ZGN(84,6^/=OBVIC&_P"5@X)7@X ()ZG2Y3+;9\^2 M=5)59I%PTF."W ZYP0 ",$<&CC9 M3^=6--U>WU99&MHKQ%0@'[5936Y/T$B*3]15:_\ #=CJ-VUS//JB2, "+?5+ MF!.!CA8Y H_*K&FZ/;Z4LBVTMXX<@DW5[-]N?#\L- MM=QQ[]:OOH6DRR-))IEF[N2S,T"DDGWQ3?\ A']&_P"@38?^ R?X M4 4_!^EMHV@M8M;BW5+V\:*($86)KF5H\8[%&4_C6]6=_P (_HW_ $";'_P& M3_"C_A']&_Z!-C_X#)_A0!HT5G?\(_HW_0)L?_ 9/\*/^$?T;_H$V/\ X#)_ MA0!HT5G?\(_HW_0)L?\ P&3_ H_X1_1O^@38_\ @,G^% &C15*#2-.M9UFM M]/M(9%Z/'"JL/7D"KM !1110 4444 %%%% !1110 4444 )M'H/RI:** "BB MB@ HHHH *P_&D\UKX%\07%O+)#/%IMR\MRJ6K:=%K&CW MNF7#.L%Y ]O*8R VUU*G!/0X- 'F-I:ZQH(\$:X/$^KWS:O-!:WMM>S^9"PD MA+Y1>-I!3KR3GDGG/K0Z#-8MQX7L;BPT.S9YQ'HTT4]L0PR6C0HN[CD88YQB MMH=!0 M%%% !1110 4444 %%%% !1110 4444 %%%% !1110 4444 %%%% ! :1110 4444 %%%% !1110 4444 %%%% '_]D! end