X0202 4/A 2005-02-16 2005-02-18 0 0001070412 CONSOL ENERGY INC CNX 0001241243 HARVEY J BRETT CONSOL PLAZA 1800 WASHINGTON ROAD PITTSBURGH 15241 1 1 0 0 President & CEO Common Shares 2005-02-16 4 M 0 4600 18.81 A 74873 D Common Shares 2005-02-16 4 S 0 4600 43.66 D 70273 D Common Shares 2005-02-16 4 M 0 1200 18.81 A 71473 D Common Shares 2005-02-16 4 S 0 1200 43.65 D 70273 D Common Shares 2005-02-16 4 M 0 300 18.81 A 70573 D Common Shares 2005-02-16 4 S 0 300 43.62 D 70273 D Common Shares 2005-02-16 4 M 0 600 18.81 A 70873 D Common Shares 2005-02-16 4 S 0 600 43.60 D 70273 D Common Shares 2005-02-16 4 M 0 1100 18.81 A 71373 D Common Shares 2005-02-16 4 S 0 1100 43.59 D 70273 D Common Shares 2005-02-16 4 M 0 700 18.81 A 70973 D Common Shares 2005-02-16 4 S 0 700 43.58 D 70273 D Common Shares 2005-02-16 4 M 0 400 18.81 A 70673 D Common Shares 2005-02-16 4 S 0 400 43.56 D 70273 D Stock Options 18.81 2005-02-16 4 M 0 600 0 D 2001-10-25 2011-10-25 Common Shares 600 650170 D Stock Options 18.81 2005-02-16 4 M 0 1100 0 D 2001-10-25 2011-10-25 Common Shares 1100 649070 D Stock Options 18.81 2005-02-16 4 M 0 700 0 D 2001-10-25 2011-10-25 Common Shares 700 648370 D Stock Options 18.81 2005-02-16 4 M 0 400 0 D 2001-10-25 2011-10-25 Common Shares 400 647970 D Stock Options 18.81 2005-02-16 4 M 0 5200 0 D 2001-10-25 2011-10-25 Common Shares 5200 642770 D Stock Options 18.81 2005-02-16 4 M 0 700 0 D 2001-10-25 2011-10-25 Common Shares 700 642070 D Stock Options 18.81 2005-02-16 4 M 0 1700 0 D 2001-10-25 2011-10-25 Common Shares 1700 640370 D Stock Options 18.81 2005-02-16 4 M 0 600 0 D 2001-10-25 2011-10-25 Common Shares 600 639770 D Stock Options 18.81 2005-02-16 4 M 0 1000 0 D 2001-10-25 2011-10-25 Common Shares 1000 638770 D Stock Options 18.81 2005-02-16 4 M 0 11800 0 D 2001-10-25 2011-10-25 Common Shares 11800 626970 D AMENDED TO REFLECT CORRECT EXERCISE PRICES ALL TRANSACTION PURSUANT TO RULE 10(b)-5 TRADING PLAN. FORM 2 OF 8 J. B. Harvey by P. M. Greene, his attorney-in-fact 2005-02-22