X0303 4 2010-03-05 0 0000783603 AMERICAN SAFETY INSURANCE HOLDINGS LTD ASI 0001199351 HUTTO RANDOLPH L M 44 CHURCH STREET P.O. BOX HM2064 HAMILTON D0 HM 11 BERMUDA 0 1 0 0 General Counsel Common Stock 2010-03-05 2010-03-05 4 A 0 3357 14.64 A 10965 D Common Stock 2010-03-05 2010-03-05 4 A 0 5000 14.64 A 15965 D Stock Option (Right to Buy) 14.64 2010-03-05 2010-03-05 4 A 0 8962 14.64 A 2011-03-05 2020-03-05 Common Stock 8962 51870 D Restricted Stock Awards pursuant to the Company's 2008 Long-Term Incentive Compensation Plan, which vest 25% on the first and second anniversary of the date of grant and 50% on the third anniversary of the date of grant. Restricted Stock Awards pursuant to the Company's 2008 Long-Term Incentive Compensation Plan. Shares cliff vest three years from grant date. Options awarded pursuant to the Company's 2007 Incentive Stock Option Plan. These options have a three-year vesting schedule, pursuant to which the shares underlying the options shall vest in one-third increments commencing one year after the date of grant. The date shown is the date the first vested number of shares becomes/became exercisable. Randolph L. Hutto 2010-03-09