The Company primarily earns revenue at a point in time for sandwich shop sales which can occur in person at the shop, over our web or app platform, or through a third-party platform. Revenue is recorded net of sales-related taxes collected from customers. The payment on these sales is due at the time of the customer’s purchase. The Company also receives royalties from franchisees on their respective sales, which are recognized at the point in time the sale is made and invoiced weekly. Potbelly also records revenue from sales over time related to upfront franchise fees, gift card redemptions and breakage. For the 13 weeks ended March 29, 2020, revenue recognized from all revenue sources on point in time sales was $87.5 million, and revenue recognized from sales over time was $0.1 million. For the 13 weeks ended March 31, 2019, revenue recognized from all revenue sources on point in time sales was $97.8 million, and revenue recognized from sales over time was $0.3 million.

Potbelly licenses intellectual property and trademarks to franchisees through franchise agreements. As part of these franchise agreements, Potbelly receives an upfront payment from the franchisee, which the Company recognizes over the term of the franchise agreement. The Company records a contract liability for the unearned portion of the upfront franchise payments.

Potbelly sells gift cards to customers, records the sale as a contract liability and recognizes the associated revenue as the gift card is redeemed. A portion of these gift cards are not redeemed by the customer, which is recognized by the Company as revenue as a percentage of customers gift card redemptions. The expected breakage amount recognized is determined by a historical data analysis on gift card redemption patterns.

As described above, the Company records current and noncurrent contract liabilities for upfront franchise fees and gift cards. There are no other contract liabilities or contract assets recorded by the Company. The opening and closing balances of the Company’s current and noncurrent contract liabilities from contracts with customers were as follows:

	Current Contract Liability			Noncurrent Contract Liability
	(Thousands)			(Thousands)
Beginning balance as of December 30, 2019	$	(1,594	)	$	(2,054	)
Ending balance as of March 29, 2020		(1,264	)		(1,984	)
Decrease in contract liability	$	(330	)	$	(70	)

The aggregate value of remaining performance obligations on outstanding contracts was $3.2 million as of March 29, 2020. The Company expects to recognize revenue related to contract liabilities as follows (in thousands), which may vary based upon franchise activity as well as gift card redemption patterns:

Years Ending	Amount
2020	$	942
2021		302
2022		240
2023		206
2024		174
Thereafter		1,384
Total revenue recognized	$	3,248

For the 13 weeks ended March 29, 2020, the amount of revenue recognized related to the December 30, 2019 liability ending balance was $0.5 million. For the 13 weeks ended March 31, 2019, the amount of revenue recognized related to the December 30, 2018 liability ending balance was $0.8 million. This revenue related to the recognition of gift card redemptions and upfront franchise fees. For the 13 weeks ended March 29, 2020 and March 31, 2019, the Company did not recognize any revenue from obligations satisfied (or partially satisfied) in prior periods.