CORRESP 1 filename1.htm

LIFE SCIENCES RESEARCH, INC.

 

 

 

 

CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT REQUESTED

BY LIFE SCIENCES RESEARCH, INC.

 

 

 

 

November 29, 2007

 

 

VIA FEDERAL EXPRESS

 

Frank Wyman

Staff Accountant

Division of Corporation Finance

Securities and Exchange Commission

100 F Street, N.E., Mail Stop 6010

Washington, DC 20549

 

Dear Mr. Wyman:

 

As requested, please find attached our proposed changes to Note 4 and Note 11, for your consideration and confirmation that the revisions address the items we previously discussed over the phone. In addition to the notes in Word, I have also attached a spreadsheet that details the payment schedule for all of the components of the Alconbury leases.

 

Please contact me regarding any query regarding the detail of Note 4 and 11. Thank you for your assistance and kind regards.

 

 

Sincerely,

 

 

 

/s/ Richard A. Michaelson

 

Chief Financial Officer

 

 

cc:

Andrew Baker – Chairman and Chief Executive Officer

 

Mark Bibi – General Counsel and Corporate Secretary

 

Hugh Scott, P.C. – Independent Auditors

 

 

 


.

 

4.

 

 

 

 


.

 

PROPERTY, PLANT AND EQUIPMENT

 

Property, plant and equipment as of December 31 consisted of the following:

 

 

 

2006

2005

 

 

$000

$000

Property, plant and equipment at cost:

 

 

 

Building and facilities

 

$-

$122,723

Leasehold buildings and improvements

 

34,336

-

Plant, equipment, vehicles, computers and software

 

121,269

108,108

Assets in the course of construction

 

319

316

 

 



 

 

155,924

231,147

Less: Accumulated depreciation

 

(92,294)

(125,542)

 

 



Property and equipment, net

 

$63,630

$105,605

 

 



 

Depreciation expense aggregated $9,514,000, $9,581,000 and $9,530,000 for 2006, 2005 and 2004 respectively.

 

The net book value of assets held under capital leases and included above is as follows:

 

 

2006

2005

 

 

Cost

Accumulated Depreciation

Net book

Value

 

 

Cost

Accumulated Depreciation

Net book

Value

 

$000

$000

$000

 

$000

$000

$000

Alconbury capital leases

 

$23,201

$1,204

$21,997

 

$-

$-

$-

Other capital leases

$2,684

$505

$2,179

 

$1,995

$246

$1,749

 








 

$25,885

$1,709

$24,176

 

$1,995

$246

$1,749

 








 

The assets and liabilities under capital leases are recorded at the lower of the present value of the minimum lease payments or the fair value of the asset.

 

The Alconbury capital leases are included in Leasehold buildings and improvements whilst Other capital leases are included in Plant, equipment, vehicles, computers and software.

 

Depreciation expense on these capital leases and included above, amounted to $1,017,000 (of which $683,000 related to Alconbury capital leases), $140,000, and $192,000 for the years ended at December 31, 2006, 2005 and 2004, respectively.

 

 


.

 

                                                                                                

 

11.

COMMITMENTS AND CONTINGENCIES

 

Commitments

 

The Company leases certain equipment under various non-cancelable operating and capital leases. The Company is also obligated under purchase agreements, including long term power contracts. These commitments are set out in the table below:

 

 

Year ended December 31

 

 

Total

2007

2008

2009

2010

2011

2012+

 

$000

$000

$000

$000

$000

$000

$000

Alconbury operating lease obligations (a)

$100,160

$2,433

$2,506

$2,581

$2,659

$2,738

$87,243

Operating leases

2,653

1,437

726

388

78

24

-

Alconbury capital lease obligations (a) (b)

137,558

3,032

3,123

3,217

3,313

3,413

121,460

Other capital lease obligations (b)

1,790

1,011

683

96

-

-

-

Purchase obligations

8,236

8,236

-

-

-

-

-

Pension plan contributions

52,848

5,872

5,872

5,872

5,872

5,872

23,488

 








 

$303,245

$22,021

$12,910

$12,154

$11,922

$12,047

$232,191

 








 

(a) The Alconbury capital and operating lease contractual obligations include the fixed 3% per year rental increases on the UK leases, and an estimate of 3% for the future United States Consumer Price Index (CPI) increases required under the US lease.

 

(b) The Alconbury and Other capital lease contractual obligations reflected above include imputed interest.

 

Leases

 

In 2005, the Company entered into a sale-leaseback arrangement for its two UK and one US properties with a related party, as more fully described in Note 2 to the financial statements. The UK buildings and the US land and buildings were determined to be capital leases, while the land portion of the UK properties were determined to be operating leases under FASB No. 13. The gain of approximately $9.6 on the sale of the US property has been deferred and is being amortized over the 30-year term of the lease. The leases on these properties are for 30 year terms and expire in 2035. The leases also have two 5-year renewal options under the same terms and conditions in effect under the leases immediately prior to the renewal periods. The annual rental payments on the US leases currently approximate $2.0 million and call for annual CPI increases. The annual rental payments on the UK leases currently approximate $3.5 million and have fixed annual increases of 3% per year during the term of the lease. All of the Alconbury

 

 


.

 

leases are "triple net" leases and the Company is required to pay for all of the costs associated with the operation of the facilities, including insurance, taxes and maintenance. The implicit interest rate on the Alconbury capital leases approximate 12.25%, representing the rate required to discount the future stream of rental payments to equal the appraised value of the properties at the date of the sale-leaseback transaction.

 

The following is a schedule by year of future minimum lease payments under capital leases, together with the present value of net minimum lease payments as of December 31, 2006:

 

 

Alconbury capital leases

Other capital leases

Total capital leases

 

$000

$000

$000

Total payments due

$137,558

$1,790

$139,348

Less amounts representing interest

(114,357)

(194)

(114,551)

 




Present value of net minimum lease payments

23,201

1,596

24,797

Less current portion of capital lease obligations

-

(889)

(889)

 




Non-current portion of capital lease obligations

$23,201

$707

$23,908

 




 

Depreciation expense on these capital leases amounted to $1,017,000, (of which $683,000 related to the Alconbury capitalized leased assets) for the year ended December 31, 2006.

 

Operating lease expenses were as follows:

 

 

2006

2005

2004

 

$000

$000

$000

Alconbury operating leases

1,104

-

-

Plant and equipment

1,403

441

291

Other operating leases

209

418

405

 

 

Contingencies

 

The Company is party to certain legal actions arising out of the normal course of its business. In management's opinion, none of these actions will have a material effect on the Company's operations, financial condition or liquidity. No form of proceedings has been brought, instigated or is known to be contemplated against the Company by any government agency.

 

 

 


 

HUNTINGDON LIFE SCIENCES LIMITED

BJ 9/11/2006

Land & Buildings

Land & Buildings

Land & Buildings

 

SALE AND LEASEBACK

 

UK

UK

UK

UK

Land & Buildings

 

UK

UK

UK

UK

UK

UK

UK

UK

UK

HRC

HRC

ERC

ERC

UK

%age of

Proceeds

US

PRC

US

PRC

 


 

Total

HRC

ERC

Total

HRC

ERC

Total

HRC

ERC

Quarterly

Annual

Quarterly

Annual

LAND

69.49%

Quarterly

Annual

 

Year

Payment

Payment

Payment

Land

Land

Land

Buildings

Buildings

Buildings

Payment

Payment

Payment

Payment

BUILDINGS

30.51%

Payment

Payment

 

















 

 

2005

£914,692

£762,244

£152,449

£635,662

£529,719

£105,944

£279,030

£232,525

£46,505

£348,645

£762,244

£69,729

£152,449

$459,375

$918,750

 

2006

£1,723,702

£1,436,418

£287,284

£1,197,881

£998,234

£199,647

£525,821

£438,184

£87,637

£359,105

£1,436,418

£71,821

£287,284

$473,156

$1,892,625

 

2007

£1,775,413

£1,479,511

£295,902

£1,233,817

£1,028,181

£205,636

£541,596

£451,330

£90,266

£369,878

£1,479,511

£73,976

£295,902

$487,351

$1,949,404

 

2008

£1,828,676

£1,523,896

£304,779

£1,270,832

£1,059,027

£211,805

£557,844

£464,870

£92,974

£380,974

£1,523,896

£76,195

£304,779

$501,971

$2,007,886

 

2009

£1,883,536

£1,569,613

£313,923

£1,308,957

£1,090,797

£218,160

£574,579

£478,816

£95,763

£392,403

£1,569,613

£78,481

£313,923

$517,031

$2,068,122

 

2010

£1,940,042

£1,616,702

£323,340

£1,348,226

£1,123,521

£224,704

£591,816

£493,180

£98,636

£404,175

£1,616,702

£80,835

£323,340

$532,542

$2,130,166

 

2011

£1,998,243

£1,665,203

£333,041

£1,388,672

£1,157,227

£231,445

£609,571

£507,976

£101,595

£416,301

£1,665,203

£83,260

£333,041

$548,518

$2,194,071

 

2012

£2,058,191

£1,715,159

£343,032

£1,430,333

£1,191,944

£238,389

£627,858

£523,215

£104,643

£428,790

£1,715,159

£85,758

£343,032

$564,973

$2,259,893

 

2013

£2,119,936

£1,766,614

£353,323

£1,473,243

£1,227,702

£245,540

£646,694

£538,911

£107,782

£441,653

£1,766,614

£88,331

£353,323

$581,923

$2,327,690

 

2014

£2,183,534

£1,819,612

£363,922

£1,517,440

£1,264,533

£252,907

£666,095

£555,079

£111,016

£454,903

£1,819,612

£90,981

£363,922

$599,380

$2,397,521

 

2015

£2,249,040

£1,874,200

£374,840

£1,562,963

£1,302,469

£260,494

£686,077

£571,731

£114,346

£468,550

£1,874,200

£93,710

£374,840

$617,362

$2,469,446

 

2016

£2,316,512

£1,930,426

£386,085

£1,609,852

£1,341,543

£268,309

£706,660

£588,883

£117,777

£482,607

£1,930,426

£96,521

£386,085

$635,882

$2,543,530

 

2017

£2,386,007

£1,988,339

£397,668

£1,658,147

£1,381,790

£276,358

£727,859

£606,550

£121,310

£497,085

£1,988,339

£99,417

£397,668

$654,959

$2,619,836

 

2018

£2,457,587

£2,047,989

£409,598

£1,707,892

£1,423,243

£284,649

£749,695

£624,746

£124,949

£511,997

£2,047,989

£102,399

£409,598

$674,608

$2,698,431

 

2019

£2,531,315

£2,109,429

£421,886

£1,759,129

£1,465,941

£293,188

£772,186

£643,488

£128,698

£527,357

£2,109,429

£105,471

£421,886

$694,846

$2,779,384

 

2020

£2,607,254

£2,172,712

£434,542

£1,811,903

£1,509,919

£301,984

£795,352

£662,793

£132,559

£543,178

£2,172,712

£108,636

£434,542

$715,691

$2,862,765

 

2021

£2,685,472

£2,237,893

£447,579

£1,866,260

£1,555,216

£311,043

£819,212

£682,677

£136,535

£559,473

£2,237,893

£111,895

£447,579

$737,162

$2,948,648

 

2022

£2,766,036

£2,305,030

£461,006

£1,922,247

£1,601,873

£320,375

£843,789

£703,157

£140,631

£576,257

£2,305,030

£115,252

£461,006

$759,277

$3,037,108

 

2023

£2,849,017

£2,374,181

£474,836

£1,979,915

£1,649,929

£329,986

£869,102

£724,252

£144,850

£593,545

£2,374,181

£118,709

£474,836

$782,055

$3,128,221

 

2024

£2,934,488

£2,445,406

£489,081

£2,039,312

£1,699,427

£339,885

£895,175

£745,979

£149,196

£611,352

£2,445,406

£122,270

£489,081

$805,517

$3,222,067

 

2025

£3,022,522

£2,518,768

£503,754

£2,100,492

£1,750,410

£350,082

£922,031

£768,359

£153,672

£629,692

£2,518,768

£125,938

£503,754

$829,682

$3,318,729

 

2026

£3,113,198

£2,594,332

£518,866

£2,163,506

£1,802,922

£360,584

£949,691

£791,410

£158,282

£648,583

£2,594,332

£129,717

£518,866

$854,573

$3,418,291

 

2027

£3,206,594

£2,672,161

£534,432

£2,228,412

£1,857,010

£371,402

£978,182

£815,152

£163,030

£668,040

£2,672,161

£133,608

£534,432

$880,210

$3,520,840

 

2028

£3,302,792

£2,752,326

£550,465

£2,295,264

£1,912,720

£382,544

£1,007,528

£839,606

£167,921

£688,082

£2,752,326

£137,616

£550,465

$906,616

$3,626,465

 

2029

£3,401,875

£2,834,896

£566,979

£2,364,122

£1,970,102

£394,020

£1,037,754

£864,795

£172,959

£708,724

£2,834,896

£141,745

£566,979

$933,815

$3,735,259

 

2030

£3,503,932

£2,919,943

£583,989

£2,435,046

£2,029,205

£405,841

£1,068,886

£890,738

£178,148

£729,986

£2,919,943

£145,997

£583,989

$961,829

$3,847,317

 

2031

£3,609,050

£3,007,541

£601,508

£2,508,097

£2,090,081

£418,016

£1,100,953

£917,461

£183,492

£751,885

£3,007,541

£150,377

£601,508

$990,684

$3,962,736

 

2032

£3,717,321

£3,097,768

£619,554

£2,583,340

£2,152,783

£430,557

£1,133,981

£944,984

£188,997

£774,442

£3,097,768

£154,888

£619,554

$1,020,405

$4,081,619

 

2033

£3,828,841

£3,190,701

£638,140

£2,660,840

£2,217,367

£443,473

£1,168,001

£973,334

£194,667

£797,675

£3,190,701

£159,535

£638,140

$1,051,017

$4,204,067

 

2034

£3,943,706

£3,286,422

£657,284

£2,740,665

£2,283,888

£456,778

£1,203,041

£1,002,534

£200,507

£821,605

£3,286,422

£164,321

£657,284

$1,082,547

$4,330,189

 

2035

£2,031,009

£1,692,507

£338,501

£1,411,443

£1,176,202

£235,240

£619,566

£516,305

£103,261

£846,254

£1,692,507

£169,251

£338,501

$1,115,024

$2,230,047

 

 
















 

30 years

£80,889,532

£67,407,942

£13,481,590

£56,213,908

£46,844,923

£9,368,985

£24,675,624

£20,563,019

£4,112,604

£17,433,197

£67,407,942

£3,486,640

£13,481,590

$22,969,980

$88,731,124

 
















 

 

2035

£1,411,443

£1,176,202

£235,240

£619,566

£516,305

£103,261

£846,254

£1,692,507

£169,251

£338,501

$1,115,024

$2,230,047

 

2036

£4,183,878

£3,486,565

£697,313

£2,907,572

£2,422,976

£484,595

£1,276,306

£1,063,588

£212,718

£871,641

£3,486,565

£174,328

£697,313

$1,148,474

$4,593,898

 

2037

£4,309,394

£3,591,162

£718,232

£2,994,799

£2,495,666

£499,133

£1,314,595

£1,095,496

£219,099

£897,790

£3,591,162

£179,558

£718,232

$1,182,929

$4,731,715

 

2038

£4,438,676

£3,698,896

£739,779

£3,084,643

£2,570,536

£514,107

£1,354,033

£1,128,361

£225,672

£924,724

£3,698,896

£184,945

£739,779

$1,218,417

$4,873,666

 

2039

£4,571,836

£3,809,863

£761,973

£3,177,182

£2,647,652

£529,530

£1,394,654

£1,162,212

£232,442

£952,466

£3,809,863

£190,493

£761,973

$1,254,969

$5,019,876

 

2040

£4,708,991

£3,924,159

£784,832

£3,272,498

£2,727,081

£545,416

£1,436,494

£1,197,078

£239,416

£981,040

£3,924,159

£196,208

£784,832

$1,292,618

$5,170,472

 

2041

£4,850,261

£4,041,884

£808,377

£3,370,672

£2,808,894

£561,779

£1,479,588

£1,232,990

£246,598

£1,010,471

£4,041,884

£202,094

£808,377

$1,331,397

$5,325,586

 

2042

£4,995,769

£4,163,141

£832,628

£3,471,793

£2,893,161

£578,632

£1,523,976

£1,269,980

£253,996

£1,040,785

£4,163,141

£208,157

£832,628

$1,371,339

$5,485,354

 

2043

£5,145,642

£4,288,035

£857,607

£3,575,946

£2,979,955

£595,991

£1,569,695

£1,308,079

£261,616

£1,072,009

£4,288,035

£214,402

£857,607

$1,412,479

$5,649,915

 

2044

£5,300,011

£4,416,676

£883,335

£3,683,225

£3,069,354

£613,871

£1,616,786

£1,347,322

£269,464

£1,104,169

£4,416,676

£220,834

£883,335

$1,454,853

$5,819,412

 

2045

£2,729,506

£2,274,588

£454,918

£1,896,861

£1,580,717

£316,143

£832,645

£693,871

£138,774

£1,137,294

£2,274,588

£227,459

£454,918

$1,498,499

$2,996,997

 

 
















 

£126,123,494

£105,102,910

£21,020,584

£89,060,541

£74,217,116

£14,843,425

£39,093,962

£32,578,301

£6,515,661

£28,271,839

£106,795,417

£5,654,368

£21,359,086

$37,250,976

$140,628,062

 
















 

 

 



 

Note 11

GROUP

Disclosure

GROUP

 



 

Total lease payments on UK properties

£80,889,532

FX rate =

1.9572

31/12/06

 

Lease obligations

UK Land

UK Builidings

UK Property

Alconbury Operating

Alconbury Capital

US Property Lease

Obligations

 

2006

£1,206,865

£529,765

£1,736,630

UK Land

UK Builidings

UK Property

US Property

Total Property

Group

USD

USD

$1,906,820

2007

£1,243,071

£545,658

£0

£1,788,729

$2,432,939

$1,067,961

$3,500,900

$1,964,024

$5,464,924

$5,465

2,433

3,032

0

$1,964,024

2008

£1,280,363

£562,027

£0

£1,842,391

$2,505,927

$1,100,000

$3,605,927

$2,022,945

$5,628,872

$5,629

2,506

3,123

0

$2,022,945

2009

£1,318,774

£578,888

£0

£1,897,662

$2,581,105

$1,133,000

$3,714,105

$2,083,633

$5,797,738

$5,798

2,581

3,217

0

$2,083,633

2010

£1,358,337

£596,255

£0

£1,954,592

$2,658,538

$1,166,990

$3,825,528

$2,146,142

$5,971,670

$5,972

2,659

3,313

0

$2,146,142

2011

£1,399,087

£614,143

£0

£2,013,230

$2,738,294

$1,202,000

$3,940,294

$2,210,527

$6,150,821

$6,151

2,738

3,413

0

$2,210,527

2012+

£44,575,306

£23,735,374

£0

£68,310,680

$87,242,789

$46,454,873

$133,697,662

$75,005,126

$208,702,788

$208,703

87,243

121,460

0

$75,005,126











£51,174,939

£26,632,345

£0

£77,807,284

$100,159,591

$52,124,825

$152,284,416

$85,432,398

$237,716,814

$237,717

100,160

137,558

1

$85,432,398













Operating lease on Alconbury for 2006 (July to December 2006 only) =

£598,941

1.8432

$1,103,967

 

 

 

Independent Valuation

Residual Land Value

Land

Buildings

Total

HRC

£8,500,000

£2,890,000

£11,390,000

ERC

£1,000,000

£1,280,000

£2,280,000



Total

£9,500,000

£4,170,000

£13,670,000



69.50%

30.50%

100.00%

UK Sale & Leaseback

£9,546,050

£4,190,214

£13,736,264

Allocation of Proceeds

Capital lease value

Check to orignial receipt in USD @ 1.82

$25,000,000

UK Capital lease value in GBP

£4,190,214

UK Capital value at December 31, 2006 fx rate

$8,201,086

1.9572

US Capital lease value

$15,000,000

Total Cost at year end

$23,201,086

(i)


Future minimal lease payments

$137,557,223

(i)

see detailed worksheet

Amount representing interest

$114,356,137

(i)

(i) to Note 11