XML 75 R57.htm IDEA: XBRL DOCUMENT v3.5.0.2
Contingencies (Details)
1 Months Ended 3 Months Ended 9 Months Ended
Jul. 15, 2016
USD ($)
Jul. 13, 2016
USD ($)
Mar. 18, 2016
USD ($)
Feb. 22, 2016
USD ($)
Jul. 20, 2015
USD ($)
Dec. 02, 2014
USD ($)
Apr. 25, 2013
USD ($)
Sep. 20, 2011
USD ($)
patent
Jul. 31, 2015
USD ($)
Oct. 31, 2010
USD ($)
Aug. 31, 2008
patent
Sep. 30, 2015
USD ($)
Jun. 30, 2015
USD ($)
Sep. 30, 2016
USD ($)
patent
Sep. 30, 2015
USD ($)
Dec. 31, 2015
USD ($)
Mar. 02, 2015
USD ($)
Apr. 30, 2014
USD ($)
Dec. 31, 2011
USD ($)
Loss Contingencies [Line Items]                                      
Litigation liability gain (loss)                       $ 500,000   $ 43,310,000 $ 42,507,000        
Company's patents in phases of litigation | patent                           0          
Loss contingency, estimate of possible loss                                 $ 87,600,000    
Unrecorded royalty damages                           $ 0          
Litigation accrual                               $ 88,261,000      
OIG [Member]                                      
Loss Contingencies [Line Items]                                      
Litigation liability gain (loss)                             (13,800,000)        
Litigation charge                             13,800,000        
Loss contingency, settlement agreement, consideration                 $ 13,500,000                    
General Litigation Matter [Member]                                      
Loss Contingencies [Line Items]                                      
Litigation liability gain (loss)                             2,800,000        
Litigation charge                             3,300,000        
Medtronic Litigation [Member]                                      
Loss Contingencies [Line Items]                                      
Loss contingency, settlement agreement, consideration paid   $ 45,000,000         $ 7,500,000             45,000,000          
Litigation liability gain (loss)                           43,300,000 56,400,000        
Reduction in litigation accrual                           $ (88,300,000)          
Litigation charge               $ 101,200,000                      
Number of patents assigned or licensed | patent                     12     9          
Number of patents withdrawn | patent                           3          
Number of patents selected for litigation | patent               3                      
Company's patents in phases of litigation | patent               1                      
Loss contingency, settlement agreement, court                           On May 15, 2013, the District Court granted the parties’ joint motion to dismiss claims relating to one of the three Medtronic patents pursuant to a settlement agreement, leaving two Medtronic patents remaining in the litigation. On June 11, 2013, the District Court granted the parties ongoing royalties with respect to the two Medtronic patents and the one Company patent remaining in the first phase of the case (the “June 2013 ruling”).          
Company's cash and investment in escrow                           $ 113,300,000          
Release of funds from escrow                       $ 114,100,000     114,100,000        
Litigation liability                                     $ 101,200,000
Royalty accrual charge                           7,900,000          
Unrecorded royalty damages                           700,000          
Medtronic Litigation [Member] | Maximum [Member]                                      
Loss Contingencies [Line Items]                                      
Litigation accrual                           88,300,000          
Medtronic Litigation [Member] | Minimum [Member]                                      
Loss Contingencies [Line Items]                                      
Litigation accrual                           45,000,000          
Trademark Infringement [Member]                                      
Loss Contingencies [Line Items]                                      
Litigation liability gain (loss)                         $ 2,800,000   $ 2,800,000        
Company's cash and investment in escrow           $ 32,500,000                          
Litigation liability                           60,000,000       $ 30,000,000  
Jury award                   $ 60,000,000                  
Loss contingency, settlement agreement, consideration         $ 27,200,000                            
Litigation accrual                           0          
Restricted cash                           $ 0          
Madsen Medical, Inc. Litigation [Member]                                      
Loss Contingencies [Line Items]                                      
Loss contingency, settlement agreement, court                           On March 18, 2016, the trial court entered judgment in favor of MMI in the amount of $27.8 million, which amount excluded the $14.0 million disgorgement awarded by the jury.          
Loss contingency, estimate of possible loss                           $ 0          
Jury award     $ 27,800,000                                
Madsen Medical, Inc. Litigation [Member] | Loss Profits for Tortious Interference [Member]                                      
Loss Contingencies [Line Items]                                      
Jury award       $ 7,500,000                              
Madsen Medical, Inc. Litigation [Member] | Unjust Enrichment [Member]                                      
Loss Contingencies [Line Items]                                      
Jury award       14,000,000                              
Madsen Medical, Inc. Litigation [Member] | Punitive Damages [Member]                                      
Loss Contingencies [Line Items]                                      
Jury award       20,000,000                              
Madsen Medical, Inc. Litigation [Member] | Damages for Breach of Contract [Member]                                      
Loss Contingencies [Line Items]                                      
Jury award       $ 300,000                              
Madsen Medical, Inc. Litigation [Member] | Attorney Fees And Costs [Member]                                      
Loss Contingencies [Line Items]                                      
Jury award $ 1,100,000