As filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission on 7 April 2016
UNITED STATES
SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION
Washington, D.C. 20549
FORM 20-F
¨ | REGISTRATION STATEMENT PURSUANT TO SECTION 12(B) OR (G) OF THE SECURITIES EXCHANGE ACT OF 1934 |
OR
x | ANNUAL REPORT PURSUANT TO SECTION 13 OR 15(D) OF THE SECURITIES EXCHANGE ACT OF 1934 |
For the fiscal year ended 31 December 2015
OR
¨ | TRANSITION REPORT PURSUANT TO SECTION 13 OR 15(d) OF THE SECURITIES EXCHANGE ACT OF 1934 |
OR
¨ | SHELL COMPANY REPORT PURSUANT TO SECTION 13 OR 15(d) OF THE SECURITIES EXCHANGE ACT OF 1934 |
Commission File Number: 1-15040
PRUDENTIAL PUBLIC LIMITED COMPANY
(Exact Name of Registrant as Specified in its Charter)
England and Wales
(Jurisdiction of Incorporation)
12 Arthur Street,
London EC4R 9AQ, England
(Address of Principal Executive Offices)
Rebecca Wyatt
Head of Financial Accounting
Prudential plc
12 Arthur Street,
London EC4R 9AQ, England
+44 20 7220 7588
rebecca.wyatt@prudential.co.uk
(Name, telephone, e-mail and/or facsimile number and address of company contact person)
Securities registered or to be registered pursuant to Section 12(b) of the Act:
Title of Each Class |
Name of Each Exchange on Which Registered | |||
American Depositary Shares, each representing 2 Ordinary Shares, 5 pence par value each |
New York Stock Exchange | |||
Ordinary Shares, 5 pence par value each |
New York Stock Exchange* | |||
6.75% Perpetual Subordinated Capital Securities Exchangeable at the Issuers Option into Non-Cumulative Dollar Denominated Preference Shares |
New York Stock Exchange | |||
6.50% Perpetual Subordinated Capital Securities Exchangeable at the Issuers Option into Non-Cumulative Dollar Denominated Preference Shares |
New York Stock Exchange |
Securities registered or to be registered pursuant to Section 12(g) of the Act:
None
Securities for which there is a reporting obligation pursuant to Section 15(d) of the Act:
None
The number of outstanding shares of each of the issuers classes of capital or common stock as of 31 December 2015 was:
2,572,454,958 Ordinary Shares, 5 pence par value each
Indicate by check mark if the registrant is a well-known seasoned issuer, as defined in Rule 405 of the Securities Act.
Yes X No
If this report is an annual or transition report, indicate by check mark if the registrant is not required to file reports pursuant to Section 13 or 15(d) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934.
Yes No X
Indicate by check mark whether the registrant: (1) has filed all reports required to be filed by Section 13 or 15(d) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 during the preceding 12 months (or for such shorter period that the registrant was required to file such reports) and (2) has been subject to such filing requirements for the past 90 days.
Yes X No
Indicate by check mark whether the registrant has submitted electronically and posted on its corporate Web sites, if any, every Interactive Data File required to be submitted and posted pursuant to Rule 405 of Regulation S-T (§ 232.405 of this chapter) during the preceding 12 months (or for such shorter period that the registrant was required to submit and post such files).
Yes No
Indicate by check mark whether the registrant is a large accelerated filer, an accelerated filer, or a non-accelerated filer. See definition of accelerated filer and large accelerated filer in Rule 12b-2 of the Exchange Act. (Check one):
Large accelerated filer X Accelerated filer Non-accelerated filer
Indicate by check mark which basis of accounting the registrant has used to prepare the financial statements included in this filing:
U.S. GAAP International Financial Reporting Standards as issued by the International Accounting Standards Board X Other
If Other has been checked in response to the previous question, indicate by check mark which financial statement item the registrant has elected to follow:
Item 17 Item 18
If this is an annual report, indicate by check mark whether the registrant is a shell company (as defined in Rule 12b-2 of the Exchange Act).
Yes No X
* | Not for trading, but only in connection with the registration of American Depositary Shares. |
Page | ||||||
Item 1. | Not Applicable |
|||||
Item 2. | Not Applicable |
|||||
Item 3. | 1 | |||||
1 | ||||||
3 | ||||||
4 | ||||||
5 | ||||||
13 | ||||||
14 | ||||||
Item 4. | 15 | |||||
15 | ||||||
15 | ||||||
18 | ||||||
18 | ||||||
19 | ||||||
24 | ||||||
34 | ||||||
48 | ||||||
59 | ||||||
64 | ||||||
75 | ||||||
77 | ||||||
78 | ||||||
79 | ||||||
79 | ||||||
80 | ||||||
81 | ||||||
91 | ||||||
107 | ||||||
115 | ||||||
Item 4A. | 115 | |||||
Item 5. | 116 | |||||
116 | ||||||
129 | ||||||
Summary Consolidated Results and Basis of Preparation of Analysis |
131 | |||||
131 | ||||||
Explanation of Movements in Profits Before Shareholder Tax by Nature of Revenue and Charges |
166 | |||||
177 | ||||||
178 | ||||||
180 | ||||||
Item 6. | 188 | |||||
193 | ||||||
218 | ||||||
220 | ||||||
245 |
i
Item 7. | 245 | |||||
245 | ||||||
246 | ||||||
Item 8. | 246 | |||||
Item 9. | 246 | |||||
246 | ||||||
247 | ||||||
Item 10. | 247 | |||||
247 | ||||||
254 | ||||||
254 | ||||||
254 | ||||||
259 | ||||||
Item 11. | 259 | |||||
259 | ||||||
260 | ||||||
260 | ||||||
261 | ||||||
261 | ||||||
Item 12. | 264 | |||||
Item 13. | 264 | |||||
Item 14. | 264 | |||||
Item 15. | 264 | |||||
Item 16A. | 265 | |||||
Item 16B. | 265 | |||||
Item 16C. | 266 | |||||
Item 16D. | 266 | |||||
Item 16E. | Purchases of Equity Securities by Prudential plc and Affiliated Purchasers |
267 | ||||
Item 16F. | 267 | |||||
Item 16G. | 268 | |||||
Item 17. | ||||||
Item 18. | F-1 | |||||
F-1 | ||||||
S-1 | ||||||
Item 19. |
As used in this document, unless the context otherwise requires, the terms Prudential, the Group, we, us and our each refer to Prudential plc, together with its subsidiaries, while the terms Prudential plc, the Company or the parent company each refer to Prudential plc.
Portions of the Prudentials Annual Report 2015 incorporated by reference herein contain references to our website. Information on our website or any other website referenced in the Prudential Annual Report 2015 is not incorporated into this Form 20-F and should not be considered to be part of the Form 20-F. We have included any website as an inactive textual reference only.
Limitations on Enforcement of US Laws against Prudential, its Management and Others
Prudential is an English public limited company. Most of its directors and executive officers are resident outside the United States, and a substantial portion of its assets and the assets of such persons are located outside the United States. As a result, it may be difficult for you to effect service of process within the United States upon these persons or to enforce against them or Prudential in US courts judgments obtained in US courts predicated upon the civil liability provisions of the federal securities laws of the United States. We believe that there may be doubt as to the enforceability in England and Wales, in original actions or in actions for enforcement of judgments of US courts, of liabilities predicated solely upon the federal securities laws of the United States.
ii
Selected Historical Financial Information of Prudential
The following table sets forth selected consolidated financial data for Prudential for the periods indicated. Certain data is derived from Prudentials audited consolidated financial statements prepared in accordance with International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) as issued by the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) and as endorsed by the European Union (EU). EU-endorsed IFRS may differ from IFRS as issued by the IASB if, at any point in time, new or amended IFRSs have not been endorsed by the EU. As at 31 December 2015, there were no unendorsed standards effective for the years presented below affecting the consolidated financial information of Prudential and there were no differences between IFRSs endorsed by the EU and IFRSs issued by the IASB in terms of their application to Prudential. Accordingly, the selected consolidated financial data presented below that is derived from Prudentials audited consolidated financial statements is derived from audited consolidated financial statements prepared in accordance with IFRS as issued by the IASB. This table is only a summary and should be read in conjunction with Prudentials consolidated financial statements and the related notes included elsewhere in this document, together with Item 5, Operating and Financial Review and Prospects.
Income statement data
Year ended 31 December | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
2015 $m(1) | 2015 £m | 2014 £m | 2013 £m | 2012 £m | 2011 £m | |||||||||||||||||||
Gross premium earned | 54,063 | 36,663 | 32,832 | 30,502 | 29,113 | 24,837 | ||||||||||||||||||
Outward reinsurance premiums | (1,706) | (1,157) | (799) | (658) | (491) | (417) | ||||||||||||||||||
Earned premiums, net of reinsurance | 52,357 | 35,506 | 32,033 | 29,844 | 28,622 | 24,420 | ||||||||||||||||||
Investment return | 4,872 | 3,304 | 25,787 | 20,347 | 23,931 | 9,361 | ||||||||||||||||||
Other income | 3,679 | 2,495 | 2,306 | 2,184 | 1,885 | 1,711 | ||||||||||||||||||
Total revenue, net of reinsurance | 60,908 | 41,305 | 60,126 | 52,375 | 54,438 | 35,492 | ||||||||||||||||||
Benefits and claims and movement in unallocated surplus of with-profits funds, net of reinsurance | (43,732) | (29,656) | (50,169) | (43,154) | (45,144) | (28,706) | ||||||||||||||||||
Acquisition costs and other expenditure | (12,104) | (8,208) | (6,752) | (6,861) | (6,032) | (4,717) | ||||||||||||||||||
Finance costs: interest on core structural borrowings of shareholder-financed operations | (460) | (312) | (341) | (305) | (280) | (286) | ||||||||||||||||||
Disposal of Japan life business: | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
Cumulative exchange loss recycled from other comprehensive income |
(68) | (46) | - | - | - | - | ||||||||||||||||||
Remeasurement adjustments |
- | - | (13) | (120) | - | |||||||||||||||||||
Total charges, net of reinsurance | (56,364) | (38,222) | (57,275) | (50,440) | (51,456) | (33,709) | ||||||||||||||||||
Share of profits from joint ventures and associates, net of related tax | 351 | 238 | 303 | 147 | 135 | 76 | ||||||||||||||||||
Profit before tax (being tax attributable to shareholders and policyholders returns)(2) | 4,895 | 3,321 | 3,154 | 2,082 | 3,117 | 1,859 | ||||||||||||||||||
Tax (charges) credit attributable to policyholders returns | (255) | (173) | (540) | (447) | (370) | 7 | ||||||||||||||||||
Profit before tax attributable to shareholders | 4,640 | 3,148 | 2,614 | 1,635 | 2,747 | 1,866 | ||||||||||||||||||
Tax charge attributable to shareholders returns | (839) | (569) | (398) | (289) | (584) | (415) | ||||||||||||||||||
Profit for the year | 3,801 | 2,579 | 2,216 | 1,346 | 2,163 | 1,451 |
1
2015(1) | 2015 | 2014 | 2013 | 2012 | 2011 | |||||||||||||||||||
(In $m, except Share Information) |
£m, except Share Information | |||||||||||||||||||||||
Statement of financial position data | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
Total assets | 570,648 | 386,985 | 369,204 | 325,932 | 307,644 | 270,018 | ||||||||||||||||||
Total policyholder liabilities and unallocated surplus of with-profits funds | 494,896 | 335,614 | 321,989 | 286,014 | 268,263 | 233,538 | ||||||||||||||||||
Core structural borrowings of shareholder financed operations | 7,389 | 5,011 | 4,304 | 4,636 | 3,554 | 3,611 | ||||||||||||||||||
Total liabilities | 551,543 | 374,029 | 357,392 | 316,281 | 297,280 | 261,411 | ||||||||||||||||||
Total equity | 19,105 | 12,956 | 11,812 | 9,651 | 10,364 | 8,607 | ||||||||||||||||||
Other data | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
Based on profit for the year attributable to the equity holders of the Company: | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
Basic earnings per share (in pence) |
148.9¢ | 101.0p | 86.9p | 52.8p | 85.1p | 57.1p | ||||||||||||||||||
Diluted earnings per share (in pence) |
148.8¢ | 100.9p | 86.8p | 52.7p | 85.0p | 57.0p | ||||||||||||||||||
Dividend per share declared and paid in reporting period (in pence)(5) | 56.1¢ | 38.05p | 35.03p | 30.52p | 25.64p | 25.19p | ||||||||||||||||||
Equivalent cents per share(6) |
59.11¢ | 58.44¢ | 50.58¢ | 40.68¢ | 40.39¢ | |||||||||||||||||||
Market price per share at end of period(7) |
2,257.6¢ | 1,531.0p | 1,492.0p | 1,340.0p | 865.5p | 638.5p | ||||||||||||||||||
Weighted average number of shares (in millions) |
2,553 | 2,549 | 2,548 | 2,541 | 2,533 | |||||||||||||||||||
New business: |
||||||||||||||||||||||||
Single premium sales(3) |
41,096 | 27,869 | 24,508 | 22,976 | 22,358 | 18,889 | ||||||||||||||||||
New regular premium sales(3)(4) |
4,158 | 2,820 | 2,199 | 2,125 | 1,959 | 1,792 | ||||||||||||||||||
Funds under management |
749,982 | 508,600 | 496,000 | 443,000 | 406,000 | 352,000 |
(1) | Amounts stated in US dollars in the 2015 US dollar column have been translated from pounds sterling at the rate of $1.4746 per £1.00 (the noon buying rate in New York City on 31 December 2015). |
(2) | This measure is the formal profit (loss) before tax measure under IFRS but is not the result attributable to shareholders. See Presentation of results before tax in note A3.1(k) to Prudentials consolidated financial statements in Item 18 for further explanation. |
(3) | The new business premiums in the table shown above are provided as an indicative volume measure of transactions undertaken in the reporting period that have the potential to generate profits for shareholders (see EEV basis, new business results and free surplus generation below). The amounts shown are not, and are not intended to be, reflective of premium income recorded in the IFRS income statement. Internal vesting business is classified as new business where the contracts include an open market option. |
The details shown above for new business include contributions for contracts that are classified under IFRS 4 Insurance Contracts as not containing significant insurance risk. These products are described as investment contracts or other financial instruments under IFRS. Contracts included in this category are primarily certain unit-linked and similar contracts written in UK insurance operations and Guaranteed Investment Contracts and similar funding agreements written in US operations. |
(4) | New regular premium sales are reported on an annualised basis, which represents a full year of instalments in respect of regular premiums irrespective of the actual payments made during the year. The comparative figures as shown above included the premiums from the PruHealth and PruProtect businesses for which the Groups 25 per cent interest was sold in November 2014. The PruProtect and PruProtect new business premiums for the years ended 31 December 2014 and 2013 of £23 million and £26 million, respectively are shown in Item 4 UK business. |
(5) | Under IFRS, dividends declared or approved after the balance sheet date in respect of the prior reporting period are treated as a non-adjusting event. The appropriation reflected in the statement of changes in equity, therefore, includes dividend in respect of the prior year that was declared or approved after the balance sheet date of the prior reporting period. Parent company dividends relating to the reporting period were an interim dividend of 12.31p per share in 2015 (2014: 11.19p, 2013: 9.73p), a second interim dividend of 26.47p per share in 2015 (2014: final dividend 25.74p, 2013: final dividend 23.84p) and a special dividend of 10.00p per share in 2015 only. |
(6) | The dividends have been translated into US dollars at the noon buying rate in New York City on the date each payment was made. |
(7) | Market prices presented are the closing prices of the shares on the London Stock Exchange on the last day of trading for each indicated period. |
2
Under UK company law, Prudential may pay dividends only if distributable profits of the holding company are available for that purpose. Distributable profits are accumulated, realised profits not previously distributed or capitalised less accumulated, realised losses not previously written off, on the applicable GAAP basis. Even if distributable profits are available, under UK law Prudential may pay dividends only if the amount of its net assets is not less than the aggregate of its called-up share capital and undistributable reserves (such as, for example, the share premium account) and the payment of the dividend does not reduce the amount of its net assets to less than that aggregate. For further information about the holding company refer to Schedule II. The financial information in Schedule II has been prepared under UK GAAP reflecting the legal basis of preparation of the Companys separate financial statements as distinct from the IFRS basis that applies to the Companys consolidated financial statements.
As a holding company, Prudential is dependent upon dividends and interest from its subsidiaries to pay cash dividends. Many of its insurance subsidiaries are subject to regulations that restrict the amount of dividends that they can pay to the Company. These restrictions are discussed in more detail in Item 4, Information on the CompanySupervision and Regulation of PrudentialUK Supervision and RegulationRegulation of Insurance BusinessDistribution of Profits and With-profits Business and Item 4, Information on the CompanySupervision and Regulation of PrudentialUS Supervision and RegulationGeneral.
Historically, Prudential has declared an interim and a final dividend for each year (with the final dividend being paid in the year following the year to which it relates). From 2016, Prudential will make twice-yearly interim dividend payments to replace the final and interim dividend payments. Subject to the restrictions referred to above, Prudentials directors have the discretion to determine whether to pay an interim dividend and the amount of any such interim dividend but must take into account the Companys financial position. The directors still retain the discretion to recommend payment of a final dividend, such recommendation to be approved by ordinary resolution of the shareholders. The approved amount may not exceed the amount recommended by the directors. For the 2015 reporting period, Prudential has approved a second interim dividend and a special dividend.
The following table shows certain information regarding the dividends per share that Prudential declared for the periods indicated in pence sterling and converted into US dollars at the noon buying rate in effect on each payment date. First interim dividends for a specific year now generally have a record date in August and a payment date in September of that year, and second interim dividends (or final dividends) now generally have a record date in the following March/April and a payment date in the following May.
Year | Interim Dividend |
Interim Dividend |
Final Dividend/ Second interim |
Final Dividend/ Second interim |
Special dividend |
Special dividend | ||||||||||||||||
(pence) | (US Dollars) | (pence) | (US Dollars) | (pence) | (US Dollars) | |||||||||||||||||
2011 |
7.95 | 0.1221 | 17.24 | 0.2706 | ||||||||||||||||||
2012 |
8.40 | 0.1362 | 20.79 | 0.3143 | ||||||||||||||||||
2013 |
9.73 | 0.1558 | 23.84 | 0.4019 | ||||||||||||||||||
2014 |
11.19 | 0.1825 | 25.74 | 0.4034 | ||||||||||||||||||
2015 |
12.31 | 0.1877 | 26.47 | 10.00 |
The Board has decided to increase the full-year ordinary dividend by 5 per cent to 38.78 pence per share, reflecting the continued strong financial performance of the Group in 2015. In line with this, the directors have approved a second interim ordinary dividend of 26.47 pence per share (2014: final dividend of 25.74 pence) which brings the total ordinary dividend for the year to 38.78 pence (2014: 36.93 pence). In addition, the Board has decided to award a special dividend of 10 pence per share reflecting the additional contribution to earnings from the specific management actions taken to position the balance sheet more efficiently under the new Solvency II regime.
Although the Board has been able to approve a special dividend of 10 pence per share in 2015, the Groups dividend policy remains unchanged. The Board will maintain its focus on delivering a growing ordinary dividend, which will continue to be determined after taking into account the Groups financial flexibility and our assessment of opportunities to generate attractive returns by investing in specific areas of the business. The Board believes that in the medium term a dividend cover of around two times is appropriate.
3
Prudential publishes its consolidated financial statements in pounds sterling. References in this document to US dollars, US$, $ or ¢ are to US currency, references to pounds sterling, £, pounds, pence or p are to UK currency (there are 100 pence to each pound) and references to euro or are to the single currency adopted by the participating members of the European Union. The following table sets forth for each year the average of the noon buying rates on the last business day of each month of that year, as certified for customs purposes by the Federal Reserve Bank of New York, for pounds sterling expressed in US dollars per pound sterling for each of the five most recent fiscal years. Prudential has not used these rates to prepare its consolidated financial statements.
Year ended 31 December | Average rate | |||
2011 |
1.61 | |||
2012 |
1.59 | |||
2013 |
1.56 | |||
2014 |
1.65 | |||
2015 |
1.53 |
The following table sets forth the high and low noon buying rates for pounds sterling expressed in US dollars per pound sterling for each of the previous six months:
High | Low | |||||||
October 2015 |
1.55 | 1.52 | ||||||
November 2015 |
1.54 | 1.50 | ||||||
December 2015 |
1.52 | 1.47 | ||||||
January 2016 |
1.47 | 1.42 | ||||||
February 2016 |
1.46 | 1.39 | ||||||
March 2016 |
1.45 | 1.39 |
On 1 April 2016 the latest practicable date prior to this filing, the noon buying rate was £1.00 = $1.42.
4
A number of risk factors affect Prudentials operating results and financial condition and, accordingly, the trading price of its shares. The risk factors mentioned below should not be regarded as a complete and comprehensive statement of all potential risks and uncertainties. The information given is as of the date of this document, and any forward-looking statements are made subject to the reservations specified below under Forward-Looking Statements.
Risks relating to Prudentials business
Prudentials businesses are inherently subject to market fluctuations and general economic conditions
Prudentials businesses are inherently subject to market fluctuations and general economic conditions. Uncertainty or negative trends in international economic and investment climates could adversely affect Prudentials business and profitability. Since 2008 Prudential has operated against a challenging background of periods of significant volatility in global capital and equity markets, interest rates (which in some jurisdictions have become negative) and liquidity, and widespread economic uncertainty. For example, government interest rates remain at or near historic lows in the US, the UK and some Asian countries in which Prudential operates. These factors have, at times during this period, had a material adverse effect on Prudentials business and profitability.
In the future, the adverse effects of such factors would be felt principally through the following items:
| investment impairments and/or reduced investment returns, which could reduce Prudentials capital and impair its ability to write significant volumes of new business, increase the potential adverse impact of product guarantees, or have a negative impact on its assets under management and profit; |
| higher credit defaults and wider credit and liquidity spreads resulting in realised and unrealised credit losses; |
| failure of counterparties who have transactions with Prudential (e.g. banks and reinsurers) to meet commitments that could give rise to a negative impact on Prudentials financial position and on the accessibility or recoverability of amounts due or, for derivative transactions, adequate collateral not being in place; |
| estimates of the value of financial instruments being difficult because in certain illiquid or closed markets, determining the value at which financial instruments can be realised is highly subjective. Processes to ascertain such values require substantial elements of judgement, assumptions and estimates (which may change over time); and |
| increased illiquidity also adds to uncertainty over the accessibility of financial resources and may reduce capital resources as valuations decline. |
Global financial markets are subject to uncertainty and volatility created by a variety of factors, including concerns over the energy and commodity sectors, sovereign debt, general slowing in world growth, the monetary policies in the US, the UK and other jurisdictions and potentially negative socio-political events. In addition, a possible withdrawal of the UK from the EU would have political, legal and economic ramifications for both the UK and the EU, although these are expected to be more pronounced on the UK.
Upheavals in the financial markets may affect general levels of economic activity, employment and customer behaviour.As a result, insurers may experience an elevated incidence of claims, lapses, or surrenders of policies, and some policyholders may choose to defer or stop paying insurance premiums. The demand for insurance products may also be adversely affected. In addition, there may be a higher incidence of counterparty failures. If sustained, this environment is likely to have a negative impact on the insurance sector over time and may consequently have a negative impact on Prudentials business and its balance sheet and profitability. For example, this could occur if the recoverable value of intangible assets for bancassurance agreements and deferred acquisition costs are reduced. New challenges related to market fluctuations and general economic conditions may continue to emerge.
5
For some non-unit-linked investment products, in particular those written in some of the Groups Asian operations, it may not be possible to hold assets which will provide cash flows to match those relating to policyholder liabilities. This is particularly true in those countries where bond markets are not developed and in certain markets where regulated surrender values are set with reference to the interest rate environment prevailing at the time of policy issue. This results in a mismatch due to the duration and uncertainty of the liability cash flows and the lack of sufficient assets of a suitable duration. While this residual asset/liability mismatch risk can be managed, it cannot be eliminated. Where interest rates in these markets remain lower than those used to calculate surrender values over a sustained period, this could have a material adverse effect on Prudentials reported profit.
In the US, fluctuations in prevailing interest rates can affect results from Jackson which has a significant spread-based business, with the majority of its assets invested in fixed income securities. In particular, fixed annuities and stable value products written by Jackson expose Prudential to the risk that changes in interest rates, which are not fully reflected in the interest rates credited to customers, will reduce spread. The spread is the difference between the rate of return Jackson is able to earn on the assets backing the policyholders liabilities and the amounts that are credited to policyholders in the form of benefit increases, subject to minimum crediting rates. Declines in spread from these products or other spread businesses that Jackson conducts, and increases in surrender levels arising from interest rate rises, could have a material impact on its businesses or results of operations.
Jackson also writes a significant amount of variable annuities that offer capital or income protection guarantees. The value of these guarantees is affected by market factors (such as interest rates, equity values, bond spreads and realised volatility) and policyholder behaviour. There could be market circumstances where the derivatives that Jackson enters into to hedge its market risks may not fully cover its exposures under the guarantees. The cost of the guarantees that remain unhedged will also affect Prudentials results.
Jackson hedges the guarantees on its variable annuity book on an economic basis (with consideration of the local regulatory position) and, thus, accepts variability in its accounting results in the short term in order to achieve the appropriate result on these bases. In particular, for Prudentials Group IFRS reporting, the measurement of the Jackson variable annuity guarantees is typically less sensitive to market movements than for the corresponding hedging derivatives, which are held at market value. However, depending on the level of hedging conducted regarding a particular risk type, certain market movements can drive volatility in the economic or local regulatory results that may be less significant under IFRS reporting.
A significant part of the profit from Prudentials UK insurance operations is related to bonuses for policyholders declared on with-profits products, which are broadly based on historical and current rates of return on equity, real estate and fixed income securities, as well as Prudentials expectations of future investment returns. This profit could be lower in a sustained low interest rate environment.
Prudential is subject to the risk of potential sovereign debt credit deterioration owing to the amounts of sovereign debt obligations held in its investment portfolio
Prudential is subject to the risk of potential sovereign debt credit deterioration on the amounts of sovereign debt obligations held in its investment portfolio.
Investing in sovereign debt creates exposure to the direct or indirect consequences of political, social or economic changes (including changes in governments, heads of states or monarchs) in the countries in which the issuers are located and the creditworthiness of the sovereign. Investment in sovereign debt obligations involves risks not present in debt obligations of corporate issuers. In addition, the issuer of the debt or the governmental authorities that control the repayment of the debt may be unable or unwilling to repay principal or pay interest when due in accordance with the terms of such debt, and Prudential may have limited recourse to compel payment in the event of a default. A sovereign debtors willingness or ability to repay principal and to pay interest in a timely manner may be affected by, among other factors, its cash flow situation, its relations with its central bank, the extent of its foreign currency reserves, the availability of sufficient foreign exchange on the date a payment is due, the relative size of the debt service burden to the economy as a whole, the sovereign debtors policy toward local and international lenders, and the political constraints to which the sovereign debtor may be subject.
6
Moreover, governments may use a variety of techniques, such as intervention by their central banks or imposition of regulatory controls or taxes, to devalue their currencies exchange rates, or may adopt monetary and other policies (including to manage their debt burdens) that have a similar effect, all of which could adversely impact the value of an investment in sovereign debt even in the absence of a technical default. Periods of economic uncertainty may affect the volatility of market prices of sovereign debt to a greater extent than the volatility inherent in debt obligations of other types of issuers.
In addition, if a sovereign default or other such events described above were to occur, other financial institutions may also suffer losses or experience solvency or other concerns, and Prudential might face additional risks relating to any debt of such financial institutions held in its investment portfolio. There is also risk that public perceptions about the stability and creditworthiness of financial institutions and the financial sector generally might be affected, as might counter party relationships between financial institutions. If a sovereign were to default on its obligations, or adopt policies that devalue or otherwise alter the currencies in which its obligations are denominated this could have a material adverse effect on Prudentials financial condition and results of operations.
Prudential is subject to the risk of exchange rate fluctuations owing to the geographical diversity of its businesses
Due to the geographical diversity of Prudentials businesses, Prudential is subject to the risk of exchange rate fluctuations. Prudentials operations in the US and Asia, which represent a significant proportion of operating profit based on longer-term investment returns and shareholders funds, generally write policies and invest in assets denominated in local currencies. Although this practice limits the effect of exchange rate fluctuations on local operating results, it can lead to significant fluctuations in Prudentials consolidated financial statements upon the translation of results into pounds sterling. This exposure is not currently separately managed. The currency exposure relating to the translation of reported earnings could impact on financial reporting ratios such as dividend cover, which is calculated as operating profit after tax on an IFRS basis, divided by the dividends relating to the reporting year. The impact of gains or losses on currency translations is recorded as a component of shareholders funds within other comprehensive income. Consequently, this could impact on Prudentials gearing ratios (defined as debt over debt plus shareholders funds). The Groups surplus capital position for regulatory reporting purposes may also be affected by fluctuations in exchange rates with possible consequences for the degree of flexibility the Prudential has in managing its business.
Prudential conducts its businesses subject to regulation and associated regulatory risks, including the effects of changes in the laws, regulations, policies and interpretations and any accounting standards in the markets in which it operates
Changes in government policy and legislation (including in relation to tax and capital controls), regulation or regulatory interpretation applying to companies in the financial services and insurance industries in any of the markets in which Prudential operates, which in some circumstances may be applied retrospectively, may adversely affect Prudentials product range, distribution channels, competitiveness, profitability, capital requirements and, consequently, reported results and financing requirements. Also, regulators in jurisdictions in which Prudential operates may change the level of capital required to be held by individual businesses or could introduce possible changes in the regulatory framework for pension arrangements and policies, the regulation of selling practices and solvency requirements. In addition, there could be changes to the maximum level of non-domestic ownership by foreign companies in certain jurisdictions. Furthermore, as a result of interventions by governments in response to recent financial and global economic conditions, it is widely expected that there will continue to be a substantial increase in government regulation and supervision of the financial services industry, including the possibility of higher capital requirements, restrictions on certain types of transactions and enhanced supervisory powers.
The European Unions Solvency II Directive came into effect on 1 January 2016. This measure of regulatory capital is more volatile than under the previous Solvency I regime and regulatory policy may evolve under the new regime. The European Commission will review elements of the Solvency II legislation from 2016 onwards including a review of the Long Term Guarantee measures by 1 January 2021.
7
Currently there are also a number of other global regulatory developments which could impact the way in which Prudential is supervised in its many jurisdictions. These include the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act (Dodd-Frank Act) in the US, the work of the Financial Stability Board (FSB) on Global Systemically Important Insurers (G-SIIs) and the Common Framework for the Supervision of Internationally Active Insurance Groups (ComFrame) being developed by the International Association of Insurance Supervisors (IAIS).
The Dodd-Frank Act represents a comprehensive overhaul of the financial services industry within the US that, among other reforms to financial services entities, products and markets, may subject financial institutions designated as systemically important to heightened prudential and other requirements intended to prevent or mitigate the impact of future disruptions in the US financial system. The full impact of the Dodd-Frank Act on Prudentials businesses is not currently clear, as many of its provisions are primarily focused on the banking industry, have a delayed effectiveness and/or require rulemaking or other actions by various US regulators over the coming years.
The IAIS has various initiatives which are detailed in this section. On 18 July 2013, it published a methodology for identifying G-SIIs, and a set of policy measures that will apply to them, which the FSB endorsed. Groups designated as a G-SII are subject to additional regulatory requirements, including enhanced group-wide supervision, effective resolution planning, development of a Systemic Risk Management Plan, a Recovery Plan and a Liquidity Risk Management Plan. Prudentials designation as a G-SII was reaffirmed on 3 November 2015. Prudential is monitoring the development and potential impact of the policy measures and is continuing to engage with the PRA on the implications of the policy measures and Prudentials designation as a G-SII.
The G-SII regime also introduces two types of capital requirements. The first, a Basic Capital Requirement (BCR), is designed to act as a minimum group capital requirement and the second, a Higher Loss Absorption (HLA) requirement reflects the drivers of the assessment of G-SII designation. The IAIS intends for these requirements to take effect from January 2019, but G-SIIs will be expected to privately report to their group-wide supervisors in the interim.
The IAIS is also developing ComFrame which is focused on the supervision of large and complex Internationally Active Insurance Groups (IAIGs). ComFrame will establish a set of common principles and standards designed to assist regulators in addressing risks that arise from insurance groups with operations in multiple jurisdictions. As part of this, work is underway to develop a global Insurance Capital Standard (ICS) that would apply to IAIGs. Once the development of the ICS has been concluded, it is intended to replace the BCR as the minimum group capital requirement for G-SIIs. Further consultations on the ICS are expected over the coming years, and a version of the ICS is expected to be adopted as part of ComFrame in late 2019.
Various jurisdictions in which Prudential operates have created investor compensation schemes that require mandatory contributions from market participants in some instances in the event of a failure of a market participant. As a major participant in the majority of its chosen markets, circumstances could arise where Prudential, along with other companies, may be required to make such contributions.
The Groups accounts are prepared in accordance with current International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) applicable to the insurance industry. The International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) introduced a framework that it described as Phase I, which permitted insurers to continue to use the statutory basis of accounting for insurance assets and liabilities that existed in their jurisdictions prior to January 2005. In July 2010, the IASB published its first Exposure Draft for its Phase II on insurance accounting, which would introduce significant changes to the statutory reporting of insurance entities that prepare accounts according to IFRS. A revised Exposure Draft was issued in June 2013. The IASB is currently re-deliberating the Exposure Draft proposals in light of comments by the insurance industry and other respondents. The timing of the final proposals taking effect is uncertain but not expected to be before 2020.
Any changes or modification of IFRS accounting policies may require a change in the future results or a retrospective adjustment of reported results.
8
The resolution of several issues affecting the financial services industry could have a negative impact on Prudentials reported results or on its relations with current and potential customers
Prudential is, and in the future may be, subject to legal and regulatory actions in the ordinary course of its business, both in the UK and internationally. These actions could involve a review of types of business sold in the past under acceptable market practices at the time, such as the requirement in the UK to provide redress to certain past purchasers of pension and mortgage endowment policies, changes to the tax regime affecting products, and regulatory reviews on products sold and industry practices, including, in the latter case, lines of business it has closed.
Regulators interest may include the approach that product providers use to select third party distributors and to monitor the appropriateness of sales made by them. In some cases, product providers can be held responsible for the deficiencies of third-party distributors.
In the US, there has been significant attention on the different regulatory standards applied to investment advice delivered to retail customers by different sectors of the industry. As a result of reports relating to perceptions of industry abuses, there have been numerous regulatory inquiries and proposals for legislative and regulatory reforms. This includes focus on the suitability of sales of certain products, alternative investments and the widening of the circumstances under which a person or entity providing investment advice with respect to certain employee benefit and pension plans would be considered a fiduciary which would subject the person or entity to certain regulatory requirements. There is a risk that new regulations introduced may have a material adverse effect on the sales of the products by Prudential and increase Prudentials exposure to legal risks.
In Asia, regulatory regimes are developing at different speeds, driven by a combination of global factors and local considerations. New requirements could be introduced in these and other regulatory regimes that challenge current practices, or could retrospectively be applied to sales made prior to their introduction, which could have a negative impact on Prudentials business or reported results.
Litigation, disputes and regulatory investigations may adversely affect Prudentials profitability and financial condition
Prudential is, and may be in the future, subject to legal actions, disputes and regulatory investigations in various contexts, including in the ordinary course of its insurance, investment management and other business operations. These legal actions, disputes and investigations may relate to aspects of Prudentials businesses and operations that are specific to Prudential, or that are common to companies that operate in Prudentials markets. Legal actions and disputes may arise under contracts, regulations (including tax) or from a course of conduct taken by Prudential, and may be class actions. Although Prudential believes that it has adequately provided in all material aspects for the costs of litigation and regulatory matters, no assurance can be provided that such provisions are sufficient. Given the large or indeterminate amounts of damages sometimes sought, other sanctions that might be applicable and the inherent unpredictability of litigation and disputes, it is possible that an adverse outcome could, from time to time, have an adverse effect on Prudentials reputation, results of operations or cash flows.
Prudentials businesses are conducted in highly competitive environments with developing demographic trends and continued profitability depends upon managements ability to respond to these pressures and trends
The markets for financial services in the UK, US and Asia are highly competitive, with several factors affecting Prudentials ability to sell its products and continued profitability, including price and yields offered, financial strength and ratings, range of product lines and product quality, brand strength and name recognition, investment management performance, historical bonus levels, developing demographic trends and customer appetite for certain savings products. In some of its markets, Prudential faces competitors that are larger, have greater financial resources or a greater market share, offer a broader range of products or have higher bonus rates. Further, heightened competition for talented and skilled employees and agents with local experience, particularly in Asia, may limit Prudentials potential to grow its business as quickly as planned.
9
In Asia, the Groups principal competitors in the region are international financial companies, including global life insurers such as Allianz, AXA, AIA and Manulife, and multinational asset managers such as J.P. Morgan Asset Management, Schroders, HSBC Global Asset Management and Franklin Templeton. In a number of markets, local companies have a very significant market presence.
Within the UK, Prudentials principal competitors include many of the major retail financial services companies and fund management companies including, in particular, Aviva, Legal & General, Lloyds Banking Group, Standard Life, Schroders, Invesco Perpetual and Fidelity.
Jacksons competitors in the US include major stock and mutual insurance companies, mutual fund organisations, banks and other financial services companies such as AIG, AXA Financial Inc., Allianz, Prudential Financial, Lincoln National, MetLife and Aegon.
Prudential believes competition will intensify across all regions in response to consumer demand, technological advances, the impact of consolidation, regulatory actions and other factors. Prudentials ability to generate an appropriate return depends significantly upon its capacity to anticipate and respond appropriately to these competitive pressures.
Downgrades in Prudentials financial strength and credit ratings could significantly impact its competitive position and damage its relationships with creditors or trading counterparties
Prudentials financial strength and credit ratings, which are used by the market to measure its ability to meet policyholder obligations, are an important factor affecting public confidence in Prudentials products, and as a result its competitiveness. Downgrades in Prudentials ratings, as a result of, for example, decreased profitability, increased costs, increased indebtedness or other concerns, could have an adverse effect on its ability to market products; retain current policyholders; and on the Groups financial flexibility. In addition, the interest rates Prudential pays on its borrowings are affected by its credit ratings, which are in place to measure the Groups ability to meet its contractual obligations.
Prudential plcs long-term senior debt is rated as A2 by Moodys, A+ by Standard & Poors and A by Fitch. These ratings are all on a stable outlook.
Prudential plcs short-term debt is rated as P-1 by Moodys, A-1 by Standard & Poors and F1 by Fitch.
The Prudential Assurance Company Limiteds financial strength is rated Aa3 by Moodys, AA by Standard & Poors and AA by Fitch. These ratings are all on a stable outlook.
Jacksons financial strength is rated AA by Standard & Poors and Fitch, A1 by Moodys, and A+ by AM Best. These ratings have a stable outlook.
Prudential Assurance Co. Singapore (Pte) Ltds financial strength is rated AA by Standard & Poors. This rating is on a stable outlook.
In addition, changes in methodologies and criteria used by rating agencies could result in downgrades that do not reflect changes in the general economic conditions or Prudentials financial condition.
Adverse experience in the operational risks inherent in Prudentials business could disrupt its business functions and have a negative impact on its results of operations
Operational risks are present in all of Prudentials businesses, including the risk of direct or indirect loss resulting from inadequate or failed internal and external processes, systems and human error or from external events. Prudentials business is dependent on processing a large number of transactions across numerous and diverse products, and is subject to a number of different legal and regulatory regimes. Further, because of the long-term nature of much of the Groups business, accurate records have to be maintained for significant periods.
10
These factors, among others, result in significant reliance on and require significant investment in information technology (IT), compliance and other operational systems, personnel and processes. In addition, Prudential outsources several operations, including a significant part of its UK back office and customer-facing functions as well as a number of IT functions, resulting in reliance upon the operational processing performance of its outsourcing partners.
Although Prudentials IT, compliance and other operational systems and processes incorporate controls designed to manage and mitigate the operational risks associated with its activities, there can be no assurance that such controls will always be effective. Due to human error among other reasons, operational incidents do happen periodically and no system or process can entirely prevent them although there have not been any material such events to date. Prudentials legacy and other IT systems and processes, as with operational systems and processes generally, may be susceptible to failure or breaches.
Such events could, among other things, harm Prudentials ability to perform necessary business functions, result in the loss of confidential or proprietary data (exposing it to potential legal claims and regulatory sanctions) and damage its reputation and relationships with its business partners and customers. Similarly, any weakness in administration systems (such as those relating to policyholder records or meeting regulatory requirements) or actuarial reserving processes could have a material adverse effect on its results of operations during the effective period.
Attempts by third parties to disrupt Prudentials IT systems could result in loss of trust from Prudentials customers, reputational damage and financial loss
Being part of the financial services sector, Prudential and its business partners are increasingly exposed to the risk that third parties may attempt to disrupt the availability, confidentiality and integrity of its IT systems, which could result in disruption to the key operations, make it difficult to recover critical services, damage assets and compromise data (both corporate or customer). This could result in loss of trust from Prudentials customers, reputational damage and financial loss. The cyber-security threat continues to evolve globally in sophistication and potential significance. As a result of Prudentials increasing market profile, the growing interest by customers to interact with their insurance provider and asset manager through the internet and social media, improved brand awareness and the classification of Prudential as a G-SII, there is an increased likelihood of Prudential being considered a target by cyber criminals. Prudential has not identified a failure or breach which has had a material impact in relation to its legacy and other IT systems and processes to date. However, it has been, and likely will continue to be, subject to computer viruses, attempts at unauthorised access and cyber-security attacks such as denial of service attacks (which, for example, can cause temporary disruption to websites and IT networks), phishing and disruptive software campaigns.
Prudential is continually enhancing its IT environment to remain secure against emerging threats, together with increasing its ability to detect system compromise and recover should such an incident occur. However, there can be no assurance that such events will not take place with adverse consequential effects on Prudentials business and financial position.
Adverse experience relative to the assumptions used in pricing products and reporting business results could significantly affect Prudentials results of operations
In common with other life insurers, the profitability of the Groups businesses depends on a mix of factors including mortality and morbidity levels and trends, policy surrenders and take-up rates on guarantee features of products, investment performance and impairments, unit cost of administration and new business acquisition expenses.
Prudential needs to make assumptions about a number of factors in determining the pricing of its products, for setting reserves, and for reporting its capital levels and the results of its long-term business operations. For example, the assumption that Prudential makes about future expected levels of mortality is particularly relevant for its UK annuity business, where payments are guaranteed for at least as long as the policyholder is alive. Prudential conducts rigorous research into longevity risk, using industry data as well as its own substantial annuitant experience. As part of its pension annuity pricing and reserving policy, Prudentials UK business assumes that current rates of mortality continuously improve over time at levels based on adjusted data and
11
informed by models from the Continuous Mortality Investigation (CMI) as published by the Institute and Faculty of Actuaries. Assumptions about future expected levels of mortality are also of relevance to the Guaranteed Minimum Withdrawal Benefit (GMWB) of Jacksons variable annuity business. If mortality improvement rates significantly exceed the improvement assumed, Prudentials results of operations could be adversely affected.
A further factor is the assumption that Prudential makes about future expected levels of the rates of early termination of products by its customers (known as persistency). This is particularly relevant to its lines of business other than its UK annuity business, especially Jacksons portfolio of traditional and variable annuities. Prudentials persistency assumptions reflect recent past experience for each relevant line of business. Any expected change in future persistency is also reflected in the assumption. If actual levels of future persistency are significantly different than assumed, the Groups results of operations could be adversely affected. Furthermore, Jacksons variable annuity products are sensitive to other types of policyholder behaviour, such as the take-up of its GMWB product features.
Another example is the impact of epidemics and other effects that give rise to a large number of deaths or additional sickness claims. Significant influenza epidemics have occurred a number of times over the past century but the likelihood, timing, or the severity of future epidemics cannot be predicted. The effectiveness of external parties, including governmental and non-governmental organisations, in combating the spread and severity of any epidemics could have a material impact on the Groups loss experience.
As a holding company, Prudential is dependent upon its subsidiaries to cover operating expenses and dividend payments
The Groups insurance and investment management operations are generally conducted through direct and indirect subsidiaries.
As a holding company, Prudentials principal sources of funds are remittances from subsidiaries, shareholder-backed funds, the shareholder transfer from long-term funds and any amounts that may be raised through the issuance of equity, debt and commercial paper.
Certain of Prudentials subsidiaries are restricted by applicable insurance, foreign exchange and tax laws, rules and regulations that can limit remittances. In some circumstances, this could limit Prudentials ability to pay dividends to shareholders or to make available funds held in certain subsidiaries to cover operating expenses of other members of the Group.
Prudential operates in a number of markets through joint ventures and other arrangements with third parties (including in China and India), involving certain risks that Prudential does not face with respect to its consolidated subsidiaries
Prudential operates, and in certain markets is required by local regulation to operate, through joint ventures (including in China and India). For the Groups joint venture operations, management control is exercised jointly with the venture participants. The level of control exercisable by the Group depends on the terms of the joint venture agreements, in particular, the allocation of control among, and continued co-operation between, the joint venture participants. Prudential may face financial, reputational and other exposure (including regulatory censure) in the event that any of its joint venture partners fails to meet its obligations under the joint venture, encounters financial difficulty, or fails to comply with local or international regulation and standards such as those pertaining to the prevention of financial crime. In addition, a significant proportion of the Groups product distribution is carried out through arrangements with third parties not controlled by Prudential and is dependent upon continuation of these relationships. A temporary or permanent disruption to these distribution arrangements, such as through significant deterioration in the reputation, financial position or other circumstances of the third party or material failure in controls (such as those pertaining to the prevention of financial crime) could adversely affect the results of operations of Prudential.
Prudentials Articles of Association contain an exclusive jurisdiction provision
Under Prudentials Articles of Association, certain legal proceedings may only be brought in the courts of England and Wales. This applies to legal proceedings by a shareholder (in its capacity as such) against Prudential and/or
12
its directors and/or its professional service providers. It also applies to legal proceedings between Prudential and its directors and/or Prudential and Prudentials professional service providers that arise in connection with legal proceedings between the shareholder and such professional service provider. This provision could make it difficult for US and other non-UK shareholders to enforce their shareholder rights.
Changes in tax legislation may result in adverse tax consequences
Tax rules, including those relating to the insurance industry, and their interpretation may change, possibly with retrospective effect, in any of the jurisdictions in which Prudential operates. Significant tax disputes with tax authorities, and any change in the tax status of any member of the Group or in taxation legislation or its scope or interpretation could affect Prudentials financial condition and results of operations.
This document may contain forward-looking statements with respect to certain of Prudentials plans and its goals and expectations relating to its future financial condition, performance, results, strategy and objectives. Statements that are not historical facts, including statements about Prudentials beliefs and expectations and including, without limitation, statements containing the words may, will, should, continue, aims, estimates, projects, believes, intends, expects, plans, seeks and anticipates, and words of similar meaning, are forward-looking statements. These statements are based on plans, estimates and projections as at the time they are made, and therefore undue reliance should not be placed on them. By their nature, all forward-looking statements involve risk and uncertainty. A number of important factors could cause Prudentials actual future financial condition or performance or other indicated results to differ materially from those indicated in any forward-looking statement. Such factors include, but are not limited to, future market conditions, including fluctuations in interest rates and exchange rates, the potential for a sustained low-interest rate environment, and the performance of financial markets generally; the policies and actions of regulatory authorities, including, for example, new government initiatives; the impact of continuing designation as a Global Systemically Important Insurer or G-SII; the impact of competition, economic uncertainty, inflation, and deflation; the effect on Prudentials business and results from, in particular, mortality and morbidity trends, lapse rates and policy renewal rates; the timing, impact and other uncertainties of future acquisitions or combinations within relevant industries; the impact of changes in capital, solvency standards, accounting standards or relevant regulatory frameworks, and tax and other legislation and regulations in the jurisdictions in which Prudential and its affiliates operate; and the impact of legal actions and disputes. These and other important factors may, for example, result in changes to assumptions used for determining results of operations or re-estimations of reserves for future policy benefits. Further discussion of these and other important factors that could cause Prudentials actual future financial condition or performance or other indicated results to differ, possibly materially, from those anticipated in Prudentials forward-looking statements can be found under the Risk Factors heading of this annual report, as well as under the Risk Factors heading of any subsequent Prudential Half Year Financial Report furnished to the US Securities and Exchange Commission on Form 6-K.
Prudential may also make or disclose written and/or oral forward-looking statements in reports filed with or furnished to the US Securities and Exchange Commission, the UK Prudential Regulation Authority and Financial Conduct Authority or other regulatory authorities, as well as in its annual report and accounts to shareholders, proxy statements, offering circulars, registration statements, prospectuses and, prospectus supplements, press releases and other written materials and in oral statements made by directors, officers or employees of Prudential to third parties, including financial analysts. All such forward-looking statements are qualified in their entirety by reference to the factors discussed under the Risk Factors heading of this document, as well as under the Risk Factors heading of any subsequent Prudential Half Year Financial Report furnished to the US Securities and Exchange Commission on Form 6-K. These factors are not exhaustive as Prudential operates in a continually changing business environment with new risks emerging from time to time that it may be unable to predict or that it currently does not expect to have a material adverse effect on its business. Any forward-looking statements contained in this document speak only as of the date on which they are made. Prudential expressly disclaims any obligation to update any of the forward-looking statements contained in this document or any other forward-looking statements it may make, whether as a result of future events, new information or otherwise except as required pursuant to the UK Prospectus Rules, the UK Listing Rules, the UK Disclosure and Transparency Rules, the Hong Kong Listing Rules, the SGX-ST listing rules or other applicable laws and regulations.
13
EEV Basis, New Business Results and Free Surplus Generation
In addition to IFRS basis results, Prudentials filings with the UK Listing Authority, the Stock Exchange of Hong Kong, the Singapore Stock Exchange and Group Annual Reports include reporting by Key Performance Indicators (KPIs). These include results prepared in accordance with the European Embedded Value (EEV) Principles and Guidance issued by the Chief Financial Officers (CFO) Forum of European Insurance Companies, New Business and Free Surplus Generation measures.
The EEV basis is a value-based method of reporting in that it reflects the change in the value of in-force long-term business over the accounting period. This value is called the shareholders funds on the EEV basis which, at a given point in time, is the value of future cash flows expected to arise from the current book of long-term insurance business plus the net worth (based on statutory solvency capital or economic capital where higher and free surplus) of Prudentials life insurance operations. Prudential publishes its EEV results semi-annually in the UK, Hong Kong and Singapore markets.
New Business results are published quarterly and are provided as an indicative volume measure of transactions undertaken in the reporting period that have the potential to generate profits for shareholders. New business results are categorised as single premiums and annual regular premiums. New business results are also summarised by annual premium equivalents (APE) which are calculated as the aggregate of regular new business amounts and one-tenth of single new business amounts. The amounts are not, and are not intended to be, reflective of premium income recorded in the IFRS income statement. EEV basis new business profits and margins are also published quarterly.
Underlying free surplus generation is used to measure the internal cash generation by our business units. For the insurance operations it represents amounts maturing from the in-force business during the period less investment in new business and excludes other non-operating items. For asset management it equates to post-tax IFRS operating profit based on longer-term investment returns for the period.
14
Item 4. Information on the Company
Overview and Summary of Strategy
Overview
Background
Prudential is the parent company of the Prudential group (the Prudential Group or the Group). The Group is an international financial services group, with significant operations in Asia, the United States and the United Kingdom. It has been in existence for more than 167 years, serving circa 24 million insurance customers and with £509 billion in assets under management (as at 31 December 2015). Prudential is not affiliated with Prudential Financial, Inc. or its subsidiary, The Prudential Insurance Company of America.
Prudential is structured around four main business units: Prudential Corporation Asia (incorporating the asset management business, Eastspring Investments), Jackson, Prudential UK and Europe insurance operations and M&G (the UK and European fund manager of the Group). These are supported by central functions which are responsible for Prudential strategy, cash and capital management, leadership development and succession, reputation management and other core group functions.
Asia
Prudential Corporation Asia has operations in Hong Kong, Malaysia, Singapore, Indonesia and other Asian countries. Its core business is health, protection, either attached to a life policy or on a standalone basis, other life insurance (including participating business) and mutual funds. It also provides selected personal lines property and casualty insurance, group insurance, institutional fund management and consumer finance (Vietnam only). The product range offered is tailored to suit the individual country markets. Insurance products are distributed mainly through an agency sales force together with selected banks, while the majority of mutual funds are sold through banks and brokers. Joint venture partners are mandatory in some markets, as reflected in Prudentials life insurance operations in China (through its joint venture with CITIC) and in India (through its joint venture with ICICI Bank) and Prudentials Takaful business in Malaysia (through its joint venture with Bank Simpanan Nasional). In the fund management business, Prudential has joint venture operations in India (through its joint venture with ICICI Bank), China (through its joint venture with CITIC) and Hong Kong (through its joint venture with Bank of China International).
As at 31 December 2015, Prudential Corporation Asia had:
| over 14 million life insurance customers with life and fund management operations in 14 markets; |
| distribution through over 10,000 active bank branches across Asia with relationships including Standard Chartered Bank (SCB), United Overseas Bank Limited (UOB), joint venture partners ICICI Bank in India and CITIC in China and Thanachart (Thailand); |
| one of the largest networks of tied agents in Asia; |
| consistently high brand recognition, outperforming many other financial services companies and had received multiple awards for its customer service; and |
| a top 3 position in 9 out of the 12 life markets.(1) |
United States
In the United States, Prudential offers a range of products through Jackson, including fixed annuities (fixed interest rate annuities, fixed index annuities and immediate annuities), variable annuities and institutional products (including guaranteed investment contracts and funding agreements). Jackson distributes these products through
(1) | Prudentials rank in insurance market by new business APE. Based on formal (competitors results releases, local regulators, insurance associations) and informal (industry exchange) market share data. |
15
independent insurance agents, independent broker-dealers, regional broker-dealers, wirehouses, banks, credit unions and other financial institutions. Although Jackson historically also offered traditional life insurance products, it discontinued new sales of life insurance products in 2012.
As at 31 December 2015, in the United States, Jackson:
| was among the 15 largest life insurance companies in terms of general account assets(2); |
| was the number one writer of variable annuities in the US(3); |
| was once again awarded the Highest Customer Satisfaction by Industry awardfor the tenth successive yearfrom Service Quality Measurement Group; and |
| was once again rated as a World Class service providerfor the tenth successive yearby Service Quality Measurement Group. |
United Kingdom
In the United Kingdom, Prudential is structured into Prudential UK & Europe (providing insurance and investment products) and M&G (the UK and European fund manager of the Group) and offers a range of retail financial products and services, including long-term insurance and asset accumulation and retirement income products (life insurance, pensions and pension annuities), retail investment and unit trust products, and fund management services. Prudential in the United Kingdom primarily distributes these products through financial advisers, partnership agreements with other financial institutions, and direct marketing, by telephone, mail, internet and face-to-face advisers.
As at 31 December 2015, Prudential UK & Europe:
| was one of the market leaders in the retirement income and the with-profits market(4) and |
| had total company assets of £175 billion on the balance sheet, comprising £104 billion within the with-profits sub-fund, £65 billion within shareholder-backed business and £6 billion in the Scottish Amicable Insurance Fund. |
As at 31 December 2015, M&G:
| had responsibility for £246 billion of investment on behalf of both internal and external clients; and |
| has been recognised for its investment expertise with awards across nearly all its asset categories in 2015, including Investment Manager of the Year at the European Pension Awards. |
Group Strategy Overview
Our clear and consistent strategy utilises our capabilities, footprint and scale to serve the global savings of our customers and protection needs of an increasingly self-reliant Asian middle class to create long term value for our customer and our shareholders.
(2) | Source: Fourth Quarter 2015 SNL Financial |
(3) | Source: Morningstar Annuity Research Center (MARC) Fourth Quarter 2015 Sales Report©. © Morningstar, Inc. All Rights Reserved. The information contained herein: (1) is proprietary to Morningstar and/or its content providers; (2) may not be copied or distributed; and (3) is not warranted to be accurate, complete or timely. Neither Morningstar nor its content providers are responsible for any damages or losses arising from any use of this information. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. |
(4) | Source: Association of British Insurers (ABI) |
16
We focus on three markets: Asia, the US and the UK where we see continued growing demand for our products:
| In Asia there is a growing and increasingly affluent middle class which by 2020 is forecast to become 1.9 billion people and represent over half of the global middle class. This group is increasingly wealthy but largely uninsured and have significant and growing savings, accumulation, health and protection needs. |
| The US baby boomer generation is the wealthiest demographic in the global economy. Over the next 20 years they will be retiring at a rate of 10,000 per day, creating significant demand for solutions to best help retirees with their retirement challenges. |
| The UK has an ageing population which remains under-saved for the long-term. This will drive increasing demand for savings products and retirement income solutions which will provide opportunities for both life insurers and asset management. |
To capture these opportunities we:
Focus on customers & distribution | Leverage strength & scale and proactively manage risk | |
Our customers are at the heart of the decisions we make. We focus on understanding our customers needs and requirements in each of our chosen markets as we believe that in order to do well for our shareholders we must first serve our customers.
We consistently develop our product portfolio, designing it around our customers needs and providing them with peace of mind, whether that be in relation to saving for retirement or insuring against the risks of illness, death or critical life events. Satisfied customers become our advocates, recommending our products and services to their friends and families.
Distribution plays a key role in our ability to reach, attract and retain these valued customers across our regions. Building out and diversifying our distribution capabilities helps ensure that we fully capitalise on the opportunities available to us in each of our regions. |
Balance sheet strength and proactive risk management enable us to make good our promises to customers and are therefore key drivers of long-term value creation and relative performance. In spite of the challenging macroeconomic environment we continue to strengthen our capital position through generation of organic earnings and specific management actions, which since 2010 include:
Controlling sales of US variable annuities in a manner which appropriately balances value, volume, capital generation and balance sheet risk.
Longevity reinsurance and asset portfolio optimisation in our UK life businesses. | |
Allocate capital with discipline, focussing on long-term returns |
Provide balanced metrics & disclosures | |
We rigorously allocate capital to the highest-return products and geographical locations with the shortest payback periods, in line with our risk appetite. This has had a positive and significant impact on our capital generative growing in-force portfolio and, in turn, has transformed the capital dynamics of our Group. This transformation enabled our business operations to remit £1,625 million to the Group in 2015, compared to £1,105 million in 2011. | We aim to have clarity and consistency internally and externally in the performance indicators that drive our businesses. Alongside this we develop our financial disclosures to enable our stakeholders to fairly assess our long-term performance. We have three main objectives:
to demonstrate how we generate profits under the different accounting regimes;
to show how we think about capital allocation via measures that highlight the returns we generate on capital invested in new business; and
to highlight the cash generation of our business, which over time is the ultimate measure of performance. |
17
Prudential plc is a public limited company incorporated on 1 November 1978 and registered in England and Wales. Refer to Item 10, Additional informationMemorandum and Articles of Association for further information on the constitution of the Company.
Prudentials registered office is Laurence Pountney Hill, London EC4R 0HH, England (telephone: +44 20 7220 7588). Prudentials agent in the United States for purposes of Item 4 of this annual report on Form 20-F is Jackson National Life Insurance Company, located at 1 Corporate Way, Lansing, Michigan 48951, United States of America.
The table below sets forth Prudentials significant subsidiaries.
Main activity | Country of incorporation | |||||||
The Prudential Assurance Company Limited |
Insurance | England and Wales | ||||||
Prudential Retirement Income Limited (PRIL)* |
Insurance | Scotland | ||||||
M&G Investment Management Limited* |
Asset management | England and Wales | ||||||
Jackson National Life Insurance Company* |
Insurance | US | ||||||
Prudential Assurance Company Singapore (Pte) Limited* |
Insurance | Singapore | ||||||
PT Prudential Life Assurance* |
Insurance | Indonesia | ||||||
Prudential Hong Kong Limited* |
Insurance | Hong Kong |
* | Owned by a subsidiary undertaking of the Company. |
The Company has 100 per cent of the voting rights of the subsidiaries except the Indonesian subsidiary, where the Company has 94.6 per cent of the voting rights attaching to the aggregate of the shares across the types of capital in issue. The percentage of equity owned is the same as the percentage of the voting power held.
Each subsidiary operates mainly in its country of incorporation, except for PRIL, which operates mainly in England and Wales.
18
Life Insurance
Introduction
Prudential has built a well-diversified Asian platform that matches our distribution and product strengths to each markets long-term opportunities in the life sector and maximises our asset gathering capabilities in the regions investment management industry.
Asias economic transformation continues to generate material increases in personal wealth and drives significant demand for solutions to individuals financial planning needs. During 2015, macro-economic and geopolitical turbulence continued to create some challenges but the long-term potential remains compelling.
The degree of state-sponsored financial provision for healthcare and other social services varies by market, but is typically very basic and it is widely appreciated that the private sector has a very important complementary role. Protection gaps remain high and the regulators have tasked the industry with improving levels of financial literacy and addressing this issue. Consequently, the regulations governing the industry continue to evolve in largely positive ways with good outcomes for customers and shareholders.
There is a healthy competitive environment with a good mix of domestic, regional and international companies operating in the markets. However, barriers to entry remain high in terms of the availability of new licences, the need for a significant capital investment and the challenges in building distribution scale and quality.
Given the low penetration rates of insurance and investment products we see considerable growth opportunities over the long term.
Asia (excluding Japan) is leading the world in terms of GDP growth. In the period 2014 to 2020, it is expected to generate around US$7.0 trillion(5) of new GDP, more than the US and the other advanced economies combined.
Economic growth is contributing to the rapid increase of the Asian middle class. Between 2010 and 2020 it is estimated that there will be over 700 million people who will have risen from rural subsistence to middle-class lifestyles. Families are getting smaller, life expectancies are lengthening and the incidence of chronic diseases is increasing significantly.
As people move into the middle class, their increased wealth and higher income give them the opportunity to make financial plans for the first time. Typically the priority is to provide protection for their families and establish a regular savings plan through a life insurance policy.
Social welfare provisions vary by market in Asia but generally fall well below the levels people need to sustain their families lifestyle in the event of a personal tragedy such as the diagnosis of a critical illness. Also, while basic medical services may be provided by the state, there can be a high level of out-of-pocket expenses, creating demand for financial solutions to significantly improve an individuals experience through access to private medical services. Therefore, critical illness and medical riders are popular additions to life insurance policies.
Traditionally, Asians would have relied on their children to provide for them in their retirement but with family sizes decreasing people are increasingly making their own financial provisions and life insurance policies are a popular part of a retirement plan.
Once the savings and protection solutions are in place there is the opportunity to invest. Single premium insurance policies are also important in more developed markets and it is likely that customers will increasingly seek access to different asset classes through mutual funds as their wealth grows and financial needs become more sophisticated.
(5) | Prudential estimates based on IMF data October 2013 |
19
Although Prudential has been operating in Asia for over ninety years we began building our business in earnest in 1994 with the establishment of Prudential Corporation Asia (PCA). Since then PCA has entered new markets, added considerable agency scale and launched bank distribution, developed product capabilitiesparticularly unit-linked with protectionand built a customer-centric brand anchored on the tag line Always Listening, Always Understanding.
Today PCA is focused on leveraging this platform to grow in a disciplined way for the benefit of our customers, shareholders and communities. Success is defined by metrics that ensure we deliver both volume, value and good service.
Each market is unique and our overarching regional strategy is very specifically tailored to the opportunities that reflect the many differences in each country including its stage of economic development, cultural preferences, regulation, the competitive landscape and our own risk appetite.
Prudential in Asia has over 14 million life insurance customers and over 22 million in-force policies. We actively monitor customer satisfaction levels across multiple indicators but key statistics are the numbers of customers who keep their policies, (our retention rate is over 90 per cent) and the number of customers who buy more policies from us (in 2015 a significant portion of sales were from existing customers) reflecting the success of our advice-driven approach and that customers appreciate the value of the products we provide.
Innovations in service are also important to customer satisfaction. Some are technology based such as e-submissions (up 35 per cent in 2015) and automated underwriting, but a key component is also innovation with the human touch such as Singapores PRUhealthcare assist.
Prudential is a committed member of the communities where we operate and through the Prudence Foundation, we drive social responsibility activities, with a focus on providing disaster relief, promoting financial literacy and childrens education.
During 2015, Prudential extended its highly successful childrens financial literacy programme, Cha-Ching and recently launched the second stage of the SafeSteps programme focusing on road safety with ambassador Michelle Yeoh.
Distribution
Prudential in Asia is well positioned in terms of its scale and diversity of distribution. Over 500,000 agents produce the majority of the sales with the remainder mainly coming from bancassurance that includes exclusive agreements with Standard Chartered Bank, UOB and Thanachart. At the core of our distribution model is face-to-face interaction with customers that delivers high quality, needs-based advice.
Despite our strong progress over the last decade, insurance penetration in the markets in which we operate remains low and the demand for savings, health and protection products from a growing middle class continues to be high. Our scale and scope in the region, combined with proven operational expertise, enables us to execute precisely on strategic growth opportunities, invest in building the business through the economic cycle and remain flexible to resist market pressure for products we consider to be less attractive. This approach will, from time to time, lead to fluctuations in sales at a country level but allows us to conserve value without compromising the overall regional delivery.
In 2015 our sales performance continued to benefit from our broad-based multi-channel distribution platform, new product launches and continued actions to improve both distribution scale and productivity. Agency sales were strong across the region, reflecting continued investment in agency manpower and an improvement in average agent productivity. Our core bank partnerships continue to make good progress, led primarily by those with Standard Chartered Bank.
Products
The life insurance products offered by Prudential in Asia include with-profits (participating) and non-participating term, whole life and endowment and unit-linked policies often combined with protection riders and typically with regular premium payments. Prudential in Asia also offers stand-alone health, disablement, critical illness and accident cover to supplement its core life products.
20
It is part of our strategy to focus on regular premium products which allow our customers to invest over the long term and smooth the impact of timing on their investment returns. We aim to make most of our sales as regular premiums and the proportion of regular premium has been consistently high, which ensures the profitability and resilience of our growing in-force book. Although single premium products can provide appropriate opportunities for customers with lump sums, we believe that regular premium policies with protection riders best meet the majority of our customers needs.
Unit-linked products combine savings with protection, with the cash value of the policy depending on the value of the underlying unitised funds. Since the end of 2014, Prudential is offering unit-linked products in all markets except Cambodia. However, given the recent volatility in the financial markets, we have seen a shift towards non-linked products. With unit-linked products, shareholders receive the profits arising from managing the policy, its investments and the insurance risk. Policyholders within the underlying unitised fund receive investment gains.
Participating products provide savings with protection where the basic sum assured can be enhanced by a profit share (or bonus) from the underlying fund as determined at the discretion of the insurer. Policyholder and insurer share the profits from participating policies.
Non-participating products offer savings with protection where the benefits are guaranteed or determined by a set of defined market-related parameters. Accident and health products provide mortality or morbidity benefits and include health, disablement, critical illness and accident cover. These products are commonly offered as supplements to main life policies, but can also be sold separately. The profits from accident and health and non-participating products come from any surplus remaining after paying policy benefits.
In Malaysia and Indonesia, Prudential also offers life insurance policies that comply with Islamic principles known as Takaful. The main principles are that policyholders co-operate amongst themselves for the common good, uncertainty is eliminated in respect of subscription and compensation and there is no investment in prohibited areas such as gambling or alcohol.
Our product portfolio is tailored to suit the savings and protection needs of customers in each market.
For example in markets such as Indonesia and Malaysia there is a high demand for regular premium unit-linked
policies that provide coverage for hospital and surgical and critical illnesses combined with savings for items such as childrens education. In Hong Kong there is high demand for participating products where the smoothed investment returns are particularly appealing as part of a broader financial plan.
New Business Premiums
In 2015, total sales of insurance products were £4,761 million, up 11 per cent from 2014 (£4,282 million). Of this amount, regular premium insurance sales increased 31 per cent to £2,641 million and single premium insurance sales decreased 7 per cent to £2,120 million.
21
The following table shows Prudentials Asian life insurance new business premiums by territory for the periods indicated.
Actual Exchange Rate* | ||||||||||||||
Single premiums | 2015 £m | 2014 £m | 2013 £m | |||||||||||
Hong Kong | 546 | 419 | 326 | |||||||||||
Indonesia | 230 | 280 | 303 | |||||||||||
Malaysia | 100 | 117 | 114 | |||||||||||
Philippines | 146 | 121 | 193 | |||||||||||
Singapore | 454 | 677 | 571 | |||||||||||
Thailand | 69 | 92 | 66 | |||||||||||
Vietnam |
6 | 4 | 2 | |||||||||||
South East Asia operations including Hong Kong | 1,551 | 1,710 | 1,575 | |||||||||||
China (Prudentials 50% interest in joint venture with CITIC) | 308 | 239 | 114 | |||||||||||
Korea | 182 | 212 | 311 | |||||||||||
Taiwan | 45 | 83 | 102 | |||||||||||
India (Prudentials 26% interest in joint venture with ICICI Bank) |
34 | 28 | 34 | |||||||||||
Total |
2,120 | 2,272 | 2,136 | |||||||||||
Regular premiums | 2015 £m | 2014 £m | 2013 £m | |||||||||||
Cambodia | 8 | 3 | 1 | |||||||||||
Hong Kong | 1,158 | 603 | 455 | |||||||||||
Indonesia | 303 | 357 | 445 | |||||||||||
Malaysia | 201 | 189 | 197 | |||||||||||
Philippines | 44 | 39 | 34 | |||||||||||
Singapore | 264 | 289 | 304 | |||||||||||
Thailand | 88 | 74 | 61 | |||||||||||
Vietnam |
82 | 61 | 54 | |||||||||||
South East Asia operations including Hong Kong | 2,148 | 1,615 | 1,551 | |||||||||||
China (Prudentials 50% interest in joint venture with CITIC) | 111 | 81 | 71 | |||||||||||
Korea | 123 | 92 | 82 | |||||||||||
Taiwan | 127 | 116 | 107 | |||||||||||
India (Prudentials 26% interest in joint venture with ICICI Bank) |
132 | 106 | 100 | |||||||||||
Total |
2,641 | 2,010 | 1,911 | |||||||||||
2015 £m | 2014 £m | 2013 £m | ||||||||||||
Total |
4,761 | 4,282 | 4,047 |
* | Actual Exchange Rate (AER) for translating new business premiums are actual historical exchange rates for the specific accounting period, being the average rates over the accounting period shown. |
Reserving
The overarching principles for measuring IFRS liabilities under the Groups accounting policies stem from the broad requirements of the ABI statement of Recommended Practice which underpinned the predecessor accounting to IFRS, the Modified Statutory Basis, which codified the UK application of the Insurance Accounts Directive.
The policyholder liabilities for businesses in Asia are determined in accordance with methods prescribed by local GAAP adjusted to comply, where necessary, with the Modified Statutory Basis. A gross premium valuation method is used in those countries where a risk-based capital framework is adopted for local solvency. For operations in India, Taiwan and, up to 2015, Japan, the local GAAP is not appropriate as a starting point in the context of the Modified Statutory Basis and instead, the accounting for insurance contracts is based on US GAAP. Further information is given in Item 18 (Note C.4.2).
Eastspring Investments
Eastspring Investments, Prudentials asset management business in Asia, manages investments for Prudentials Asia, UK and US life companies and also has a broad base of third-party retail and institutional clients.
22
The asset mix is well balanced with 50 per cent equities, 43 per cent fixed income and 7 per cent money market. Around 54 per cent of funds have outperformed their benchmarks over a three year period. Eastspring has been building expertise in infrastructure, negotiated credit and quantitative investment capabilities.
Distribution
In order to capitalise on the sizeable opportunities in Asias retail financial services market, Eastspring Investments maintained its focus on building a strong third-party customer retail franchise. The customer proposition is driven by Eastspring Investments investment capabilities, which enable it to develop innovative product suites, and distribute them through diverse channels including regional banks, local banks, private banks, and securities houses and an internal sales force.
The mutual fund industry continues to diversify its investments, with expectations for increasing volumes of net flows over the coming years. Bank distribution continues to be important in most markets in Asia, with Prudential having established strong relationships with both regional and local banks and placing significant emphasis on providing good service. Prudentials Asian asset management business is also growing its third party institutional and pension fund management business.
Products
Eastspring Investments offers mutual fund investment products primarily in India, Taiwan, Japan, Singapore, Malaysia, Hong Kong, Korea, Vietnam, China and Indonesia, thus enabling customers to participate in debt, equity and money market investments across the region.
Net flows and funds under management
Eastspring Investments levies management fees on assets under management and in some countries transaction charges (initial and/or surrender depending on the type of fund and the length of the investment) and also a service charge based on assets under management. The charges vary by country and fund, with money market style funds generally having the lowest charges and equity funds the highest. Eastspring Investments also levies performance related fees on certain funds, particularly institutional mandates and life funds, if the investment performance exceeds the pre-agreed benchmark(s).
Despite significant volatility in capital markets, Eastspring Investments, our Asia asset management business, delivered strong results in 2015 with record third-party net inflows of £6.0 billion, up 11 per cent on 2014. The businesses benefited from robust inflows into equity funds, including Asian equity funds in Japan, strong investment performance in Korea and India driving excellent domestic flows and healthy net inflows into bond funds from our joint ventures in China and India. Total funds under management at 31 December 2015 were a record £89.1 billion, up 16 per cent on the prior year as a result of net inflows from both our third party and our life businesses.
The following table shows funds managed by Eastspring Investments at the dates indicated.
At 31 December £bn | ||||||||||||
2015 | 2014 | 2013 | ||||||||||
Internal fund management |
52.8 | 47.2 | 37.7 | |||||||||
External fund management |
36.3 | 30.1 | 22.2 | |||||||||
Total |
89.1 | 77.3 | 59.9 |
23
Prudential conducts its US insurance operations through Jackson National Life Insurance Company (Jackson) and its subsidiaries. The US operations also include PPM Holdings, Inc. (PPM), Prudentials US internal and institutional investment management operation, and National Planning Holdings, Inc. (NPH), Prudentials US affiliated independent broker dealer network. As at 31 December 2015, Prudentials US operations had more than 4.1 million policies and contracts in effect and PPM managed approximately £71.8 billion of assets. In 2015, new business premiums totalled £17,286 million.
Jacksons subsidiaries at 31 December 2015 included Curian Capital, LLC, a registered investment advisor. In 2015, Jackson announced that Curian would no longer accept new business effective from 31 July 2015. Curian continues to actively manage existing accounts into 2016 to allow for the transition of accounts, but will have substantially exited the business by the end of the first quarter of 2016.
Jackson
Jackson is a leading provider of retirement income and savings solutions in the mass and mass-affluent segments of the US market, primarily to retirees and those planning for retirement. It offers products that help people plan for their retirement, and offers products with specialised features and guarantees to meet customers needs. By seeking to add value to both the representatives who sell Jackson products, and to their customers, Jackson has built a strong position in the US retirement savings and income market with an over four-fold increase in variable annuity sales over the past decade. Over the same period, Jackson improved its total annuity market share from 3.4 per cent in 2005 to 10.4 per cent in 2015 and moved from 12th in total annuity sales to 1st(6).
Prudentials strategy in the US is well established and continues to focus on:
| Capitalising on baby boomer retirement opportunities |
| Maintaining a balanced product suite throughout the economic cycle |
| Streamlining operating platforms, driving further operational efficiencies |
| Conservative, economic based approach to pricing and risk management |
Jacksons long-term strategy is focused on profitable growth opportunities created by the demand for retirement income and accumulation products in the worlds largest retirement market. We take a disciplined approach by leveraging our distinctive distribution capabilities and asset liability management expertise to offer prudently-priced annuity products aligned with our risk appetite. There continues to be strong consumer demand for our products. We continue to respond to this demand with product innovation and distribution strategies that meet the needs of a growing retirement population while generating shareholder value. With a long-term focus on balancing the needs of multiple stakeholders, Jackson has forged a solid reputation and built strong relationships based upon its financial stability, innovative and creative products and market-leading advisor support.
Our relentless pursuit of excellence has earned us a leading position in the industry.
In 2015, we continued to see significant changes across the competitive landscape. Sales in the annuity industry were marginally down comparing the first nine months of 2015 (latest available data) to the same period in 2014, and total industry variable annuity sales were also slightly down. These results partially reflect the headwinds the industry faced in 2015 including market volatility and unknown regulatory outcomes.
Competitors continued to make product changes across many segments and we noted competitors evolving across product categories. In 2015, we saw more competitors join the fixed index annuities space. In many cases they offered living benefits on their products in an attempt to compete with variable annuities. In addition, some insurers have made changes to the fund platforms within their variable annuity products, requiring managed volatility funds with a living benefit guarantee which purportedly protect annuity customers from downside market risks. There are now seventeen Investment Only Variable Annuity (IOVA) products that compete directly with Elite Access, our variable annuity product with no guarantee benefits. The majority of those competitors have added guaranteed benefits to the IOVA products. Elite Access still commands a significant market share with strong sales in 2015.
(6) | Source: Fourth Quarter 2015 Life Insurance and Market Research Association. |
24
Despite positive demographic trends and the needs of retirees, these competitive activities, market volatility and regulatory headwinds have impacted the industry and further market share adjustments have resulted as customers and distributors seek insurers like Jackson that offer consistency, stability and financial strength.
In addition to the uneven economic conditions in 2015, the insurance industry continues to deal with an evolving regulatory landscape and a multitude of initiatives. Many of these initiatives began in response to the financial crisis over eight years ago and were focused on the broader financial services industry. Within the insurance industry, we continue to see changes in supervisory structures, new global group supervision and capital standards and a focus on the reduction of systemic risk.
More recently, the US Department of Labor (DOL) issued a series of new rules and amendments introducing new fiduciary obligations for distributors of investment products to holders of certain retirement/qualified retirement accounts. The industry is now dealing with a regulatory initiative that will significantly impact the delivery of advice to our customers. Prior to the rules being finalised, as a leader in the industry, we spent many hours with a wide variety of stakeholders to highlight the issues and to ensure that lawmakers and regulators understood the impact of what was proposed and the consequences it may have on various segments of the retirement market. With the rules only recently finalised, it will take some time to form a view on the impact of the new DOL rules to Jacksons business.
Jackson has a good track record of navigating and, at times, benefiting from changes in the regulatory environment. This remains our mindset as we work to meet the needs of all of our stakeholders.
We support our industry-leading product development and distribution teams with award-winning customer service. Jackson was awarded by Service Quality Measurement Group, Inc. World Class Certification in customer satisfaction and received the Highest Customer Satisfaction by Industry award, achieving the top rating for the financial industry, for the tenth consecutive year.
High-quality information technology systems are critical for providing award-winning customer service. We leverage technology to enhance processing quality and reduce the time required to process new business and commissions. The flexibility of our information technology systems contributes to our ability to manufacture, distribute and service an unbundled product design unique to the industry. The focus on our operational platforms, and the efficiencies achieved as a result, has provided us with among the lowest general and administration expense to asset ratio relative to competitors.
Jackson operates within a well-defined risk framework aligned with the overall Prudential Group risk appetite. The type and number of products we sell remains balanced. Our conservative and disciplined economic approach to pricing is designed to achieve both adequate returns on our products and sufficient resources to support our hedging programme.
Our hedge philosophy has not changed in 2015. Jackson is able to aggregate financial risks across the company, obtain a unified view of our risk positions, and actively manage net risks through an economically-based hedging program. A key element of our core strategy is to protect the company from severe economic scenarios while maintaining adequate regulatory capital. We benefit from the fact that the competitive environment continues to favour companies with robust financial strength and a demonstrated track record of financial discipline, both key elements of our long-term strategy.
Products
Jackson develops and distributes products that address the retirement needs of our customers through various market cycles. These products include variable annuities, fixed annuities and fixed index annuities.
Among the main attractions of a variable annuity product are the optional lifetime guarantee whereby customers can access a stream of payments with downside protection, while still being able to invest in a broad range of assets, and the benefit of tax deferral on the investment growth within the product. The breadth of our product offering, strength of our distribution relationships, as well as our ability to maintain financial stability through the 2008 financial crisis and remain as a consistent presence within the market, has resulted in Jackson being the number one(7) writer of variable annuities in the US.
(7) | LIMRA/Secure Retirement Institute, U.S. Individual Annuities Sales Survey (Q4 2015). Jackson is ranked first in total Variable Annuities sales out of 44 participating companies in LIMRAs quarterly survey as of 4Q YTD 2015. |
25
As of fourth quarter of 2015, Jackson offers three of the top ten best-selling variable annuity products across the industry(8). Additionally, Jacksons success with the development, launch and execution of Elite Access demonstrates the depth and strength of our creative and distribution capabilities in the industry. We now command a leading position in a market we were not operating in prior to 2012. Elite Access is the third best-selling variable annuity product in the US(8).
The strength of our product development capabilities continues to support the diversification of our product mix with the sale of variable annuities with living benefit guarantees remaining in line with our risk appetite in 2015. As expected, in the current historically low interest rate environment, variable annuities continue to outsell fixed rate products. While sales of fixed annuities have been lower in recent years, fixed index annuities increased 15 per cent from 2014. These products still make up a significant portion of our balance sheet and earnings.
Jackson stopped selling traditional life insurance products in 2012; however, we continue to look for opportunistic bolt on acquisitions to further diversify our earnings and balance sheet risks. In the past, these disciplined acquisitions have shaped Jacksons earnings while helping to diversify Jacksons overall risk profile.
We continue to proactively balance value, volume, capital and balance sheet strength across our suite of product offerings, which allows us to compete effectively throughout the economic cycle.
The following table shows total new business premiums in the United States by product line and distribution channel for the periods indicated. Total new business premiums include Jacksons deposits for investment contracts with limited or no life contingencies.
Actual Exchange Rate | ||||||||||||
Year Ended 31 December £m | ||||||||||||
2015 | 2014 | 2013 | ||||||||||
By Product |
||||||||||||
Annuities |
||||||||||||
Fixed annuities |
||||||||||||
Fixed interest rate |
462 | 512 | 533 | |||||||||
Fixed index |
458 | 370 | 907 | |||||||||
Immediate |
15 | 15 | 22 | |||||||||
Variable annuities |
11,977 | 10,899 | 10,795 | |||||||||
Elite Access (Variable annuities) |
3,144 | 3,108 | 2,585 | |||||||||
Total |
16,056 | 14,904 | 14,842 | |||||||||
Life insurance |
- | 2 | ||||||||||
Institutional products |
||||||||||||
GICs, funding agreements and Federal Home Loan Bank of Indianapolis (FHLBI) funding agreements |
1,230 | 651 | 868 | |||||||||
Total |
17,286 | 15,555 | 15,712 | |||||||||
By Distribution Channel |
||||||||||||
Independent broker dealer |
10,145 | 9,521 | 8,717 | |||||||||
Bank |
2,730 | 2,394 | 3,053 | |||||||||
Regional broker dealer |
2,634 | 2,477 | 2,527 | |||||||||
Independent insurance agents |
547 | 512 | 546 | |||||||||
Institutional products |
1,230 | 651 | 868 | |||||||||
Captive agents |
- | - | 1 | |||||||||
Total |
17,286 | 15,555 | 15,712 |
Of the total new business premiums of £17,286 million in 2015 (2014: £15,555 million; 2013: £15,712 million), £16,056 million (2014: £14,904 million; 2013: £14,842 million) were single premiums, nil (2014: nil; 2013: £2 million) were regular premiums and £1,230 million (2014: £651 million; 2013: £868 million) were institutional product premiums.
(8) | ©2016 Morningstar Inc. All Rights Reserved. The information contained herein: (1) is proprietary to Morningstar and/or its content providers: (2) may not be copied or distributed; and (3) is not warranted to be accurate, complete or timely. Neither Morningstar nor its content providers are responsible for any damages or losses arising from any use of this information. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. Morningstar Annuity Research Center 4QYTD15 variable annuity sales by contract. |
26
Annuities
Fixed Annuities
Fixed Interest Rate Annuities
In 2015, fixed interest rate annuities accounted for 3 per cent (2014: 3 per cent) of total new business premiums and 9 per cent (2014: 9 per cent) of policy and contract liabilities of the US operations. Fixed interest rate annuities are primarily deferred annuity products that are used for asset accumulation in retirement planning and for providing income in retirement. They permit tax-deferred accumulation of funds and flexible payout options.
The contract holder of a fixed interest rate annuity pays Jackson a premium, which is credited to the contract holders account. Periodically, interest is credited to the contract holders account and in some cases administrative charges are deducted from the contract holders account. Jackson makes benefit payments at a future date as specified in the contract based on the value of the contract holders account at that date. On more than 93 per cent (2014: 93 per cent) of in-force business, Jackson may reset the interest rate on each contract anniversary, subject to a guaranteed minimum, in line with state regulations. When the annuity matures, Jackson either pays the contract holder the amount in the contract holder account or begins making payments to the contract holder in the form of an immediate annuity product. This latter product is similar to a UK annuity in payment.
At 31 December 2015, Jackson had fixed interest rate annuities totalling £12.1 billion (US$17.8 billion) (2014: £11.7 billion (US$18.3 billion)) in account value with minimum guaranteed rates ranging from 1.0 per cent to 5.5 per cent and a 3.00 per cent average guaranteed rate (2014: 1.0 per cent to 5.5 per cent and a 3.03 per cent average guaranteed rate).
Fixed interest rate annuities are subject to early surrender charges for the first six to nine years of the contract. In addition, the contract may be subject to a market value adjustment at the time of surrender. During the surrender charge period, the contract holder may cancel the contract for the surrender value. Jacksons profits on fixed interest rate annuities arise primarily from the spread between the return it earns on investments and the interest credited to the contract holders account, less expenses. The fixed interest rate annuity portfolio could be impacted by the continued low interest rate environment as lower investment portfolio earned rates could result in reduced spread income. In addition, increased surrenders and lower sales could result if customers seek higher yielding alternative investment opportunities elsewhere.
Approximately 62 per cent (2014: 57 per cent) of the fixed interest rate annuities Jackson wrote in 2015 provide for a market value adjustment (MVA) that could be positive or negative on surrenders in the surrender period of the policy. This formula-based adjustment approximates the change in value that assets supporting the product would realise as interest rates move up or down. The minimum guaranteed rate is not affected by this adjustment. While the MVA feature minimizes the surrender risk associated with certain fixed interest rate annuities, Jackson still bears a portion of the surrender risk on policies without this feature, and the investment risk on all fixed interest rate annuities.
Fixed Index Annuities
Fixed index annuities accounted for 3 per cent (2014: 2 per cent) of total new business premiums in 2015 and 6 per cent (2014: 6 per cent) of Jacksons policy and contract liabilities. Fixed index annuities vary in structure, but generally are deferred annuities that enable the contract holder to obtain a portion of an equity-linked return (based on participation rates and caps) and provide a guaranteed minimum return. These guaranteed minimum rates are generally set at 1.0 per cent to 3.0 per cent on index funds. At 31 December 2015, Jackson had fixed index annuities allocated to index funds totalling £6.4 billion (US$9.5 billion) (2014: £6.3 billion (US$9.8 billion)) in account value with minimum guaranteed rates on index accounts ranging from 1.0 per cent to 3.0 per cent and a 1.79 per cent average guaranteed rate (2014: 1.0 per cent to 3.0 per cent and a 1.83 per cent average guaranteed rate). Jackson also offers fixed interest accounts on some fixed index annuity products. At 31 December 2015, fixed interest accounts on fixed index annuities totalled £1.9 billion (US$2.8 billion) (2014: £1.8 billion (US$2.8 billion)) in account value with minimum guaranteed rates ranging from 1.0 per cent to 3.0 per cent and a 2.52 per cent average guaranteed rate (2014: 1.0 per cent to 3.0 per cent and a 2.53 per cent average guaranteed rate).
27
Jacksons profit arises from the investment income earned and the fees charged on the contract, less the expenses incurred, which include the costs of hedging the equity component of the interest credited to the contract. Fixed index annuities are subject to early surrender charges for the first five to 12 years of the contract. During the surrender charge period, the contract holder may cancel the contract for the surrender value.
Jackson hedges the equity return risk on fixed index products using offsetting equity exposure in the variable annuity product. The cost of these hedges is taken into account in setting the index participation rates or caps. Jackson bears the investment risk and a portion of the surrender risk on these products.
Immediate Annuities
In 2015, immediate annuities accounted for less than one per cent (2014: less than one per cent) of total new business premiums and one per cent (2014: one per cent) of Jacksons policy and contract liabilities. Immediate annuities guarantee a series of payments beginning within a year of purchase and continuing over either a fixed period of years and/or the life of the contract holder. If the term is for the life of the contract holder, then Jacksons primary risks are mortality and reinvestment. This product is generally used to provide a guaranteed amount of income for contract holders and is used both in planning for retirement and in retirement itself. The implicit interest rate on these products is based on the market conditions that exist at the time the policy is issued and is guaranteed for the term of the annuity.
Variable Annuities
In 2015, variable annuities accounted for 87 per cent (2014: 90 per cent) of total new business premiums and 70 per cent (2014: 69 per cent) of Jacksons policy and contract liabilities. Variable annuities are deferred annuities that have the same tax advantages and payout options as fixed interest rate and fixed index annuities. They are also used for asset accumulation in retirement planning and to provide income in retirement.
The contract holder can allocate the premiums between a variety of variable sub-accounts with a choice of fund managers and/or a guaranteed fixed interest rate option. The contract holders premiums allocated to the variable accounts are held apart from Jacksons general account assets, in a separate account, which is analogous to a unit-linked fund. The value of the portion of the separate account allocated to variable sub-accounts fluctuates with the underlying investments. Variable annuities are subject to early surrender charges for the first four to nine years of the contract. During the surrender charge period, the contract holder may cancel the contract for the surrender value. Jackson offers one variable annuity that has no surrender charges.
At 31 December 2015, Jackson had variable annuity funds in fixed accounts totalling £5.5 billion (US$8.1 billion) (2014: £4.4 billion (US$6.8 billion)) with minimum guaranteed rates ranging from 1.0 per cent to 3.0 per cent and a 1.70 per cent average guaranteed rate (2014: 1.0 per cent to 3.0 per cent and a 1.81 per cent average guaranteed rate).
Jackson offers a choice of guaranteed benefit options within its variable annuity product portfolio, which customers can elect for additional fees. These guaranteed benefits might be expressed as the return of either a) total deposits made to the contract adjusted for any partial withdrawals, b) total deposits made to the contract adjusted for any partial withdrawals, plus a minimum return, or c) the highest contract value on a specified anniversary date adjusted for any withdrawals following that contract anniversary. These options include the guaranteed minimum death benefits (GMDB), which guarantee that, upon death of the owner, the beneficiary receives at least the minimum value regardless of past market performance. In addition, there are three other types of guarantees: guaranteed minimum withdrawal benefits (GMWB), guaranteed minimum accumulation benefits (GMAB) and guaranteed minimum income benefits (GMIB). GMWBs provide a guaranteed return of the minimum value by allowing for periodic withdrawals that are limited to a maximum percentage of the initial premium. One version of the GMWBs provides for a minimum annual withdrawal amount that is guaranteed for the contract holders life without annuitisation. GMABs generally provide a guarantee for a return of the defined minimum value after a specified period. Jackson no longer offers GMABs. GMIBs provide for a minimum level of benefits upon annuitisation regardless of the value of the investments underlying the contract at the time of annuitisation. Jackson no longer offers GMIBs, with existing coverage being substantially reinsured with an unaffiliated reinsurer.
As the investment return on the separate account assets is attributed directly to the contract holders, Jacksons profit arises from the fees charged on the contracts, less the expenses incurred, which include the costs of
28
hedging and eventual payment of any guaranteed benefits. In addition to being a profitable book of business, the variable annuity book also provides an opportunity to utilise the offsetting equity risk among various lines of business to effectively manage Jacksons equity exposure. Jackson believes that the internal management of equity risk coupled with the utilisation of external derivative instruments where necessary, continues to provide a cost-effective method of managing equity exposure.
Profits in the variable annuity book of business will continue to be subject to the impact of market movements on both sales and allocations to the variable accounts and the effects of the economic hedging programme. Hedging is conducted based on an economic approach so the nature and duration of the hedging instruments, which are recorded at fair value through the income statement, will fluctuate and produce some accounting volatility.
Elite Access, launched in 2012, is a variable annuity without guarantees, offering customers tax deferred growth and access to a wide range of alternative investments, which were previously unavailable to retail investors. In less than four years after its launch, Elite Access is the third(8) best-selling variable annuity product in the US. As of fourth quarter 2015, Jackson offers three of the top ten best-selling variable annuity products in the industry.
The success of Elite Access has helped increase the diversification of Jacksons product mix with a substantial portion of its 2015 variable annuities sales not featuring living benefit guarantees. As a percentage of total sales, variable annuities with living benefit guarantees were broadly in line with 2014.
Aggregate distribution of account values
The table below shows the distribution of account values for fixed annuities (fixed interest rate and fixed index) and variable annuities fixed options within the range of minimum guaranteed interest rates as described above as at 31 December 2015 and 2014:
Account value £m | ||||||||
Minimum guaranteed interest rates - annuities | 2015 | 2014 | ||||||
1.0% |
5,563 | 3,927 | ||||||
> 1.0% - 2.0% |
7,670 | 7,887 | ||||||
> 2.0% - 3.0% |
9,586 | 9,365 | ||||||
> 3.0% - 4.0% |
1,263 | 1,239 | ||||||
> 4.0% - 5.0% |
1,639 | 1,567 | ||||||
> 5.0% - 5.5% |
212 | 207 | ||||||
Total |
25,933 | 24,192 |
Life Insurance
Background
Jackson discontinued new sales of life insurance products in 2012. Jacksons life insurance products accounted for none of the total new business premiums in either 2015 or 2014 and 11 per cent (2014: 12 per cent) of Jacksons policy and contract liabilities in 2015. Life products include term life and interest sensitive life (universal life and variable universal life.) Term life provides protection for a defined period and a benefit that is payable to a designated beneficiary upon death of the insured. Universal life provides permanent individual life insurance for the life of the insured and includes a savings element. Variable universal life is a type of life insurance policy that combines death benefit protection with the ability for the contract holder account to be invested in separate account funds. Jacksons life insurance book has delivered consistent profitability, driven primarily by positive mortality and persistency experience. For certain fixed universal life plans, additional provisions are held to reflect the existence of guarantees offered in the past that are no longer supported by earnings on the existing asset portfolio, or for situations where future mortality charges are not expected to be sufficient to provide for future mortality costs.
(8) | ©2016 Morningstar Inc. All Rights Reserved. The information contained herein: (1) is proprietary to Morningstar and/or its content providers: (2) may not be copied or distributed; and (3) is not warranted to be accurate, complete or timely. Neither Morningstar nor its content providers are responsible for any damages or losses arising from any use of this information. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. Morningstar Annuity Research Center 4QYTD15 variable annuity sales by contract. |
29
Aggregate distribution of account values
Excluding the business formally of the REALIC operations acquired in 2012 that is subject to the retrocession treaties, at 31 December 2015, Jackson had interest-sensitive life business in force with total account value of £6.1 billion (US$9.0 billion) (2014: £5.9 billion (US$9.3 billion)), with minimum guaranteed interest rates ranging from 2.5 per cent to 6.0 per cent with a 4.66 per cent average guaranteed rate (2014: 2.5 per cent to 6.0 per cent with a 4.65 per cent average guaranteed rate). The table below shows the distribution of the interest-sensitive life business account values within this range of minimum guaranteed interest rates as at 31 December 2015 and 2014:
Account value £m | ||||||||
Minimum guaranteed interest rates | 2015 | 2014 | ||||||
> 2.0% - 3.0% |
204 | 195 | ||||||
> 3.0% - 4.0% |
2,322 | 2,265 | ||||||
> 4.0% - 5.0% |
2,023 | 1,971 | ||||||
> 5.0% - 6.0% |
1,574 | 1,514 | ||||||
Total |
6,123 | 5,945 |
Institutional Products
Institutional products consist of traditional guaranteed investment contracts (GICs), funding agreements (including agreements issued in conjunction with Jacksons participation in the US Federal Home Loan Bank of Indianapolis (FHLBI) programme) and Medium-Term Note funding agreements. In 2015, institutional products accounted for 7 per cent (2014: 4 per cent) of total new business premiums and 3 per cent (2014: 3 per cent) of Jacksons policy and contract liabilities. The GICs are marketed by Jacksons institutional products department to defined contribution pension and profit sharing retirement plans. Funding agreements are marketed to institutional investors, including corporate cash accounts and securities lending funds, as well as money market funds, and are issued to the FHLBI in connection with its programme. Jackson makes its profit on the spread between the yield on its investments and the interest rate credited to contract holders.
Traditional Guaranteed Investment Contracts
Under a traditional GIC, the contract holder makes a lump sum deposit. Interest is paid on the deposited funds, usually on a quarterly basis. The interest rate paid is fixed and is established when the contract is issued.
Traditional GICs have a specified term, usually two to three years, and typically provide for phased payouts. Jackson tailors the scheduled payouts to meet the liquidity needs of the particular retirement plan. If deposited funds are withdrawn earlier than scheduled, an adjustment is made that approximates a market value adjustment.
Jackson sells GICs to retirement plans, in particular 401(k) plans. The traditional GIC market is extremely competitive, due in part to competition from synthetic GICs, which Jackson does not sell.
Funding Agreements
Under a funding agreement, the contract holder either makes a lump sum deposit or makes specified periodic deposits. Jackson agrees to pay a rate of interest, which may be fixed or a floating short-term interest rate linked to an external index. Interest is paid quarterly to the contract holder. The duration of the funding agreements range between one and thirty years. At the end of the specified term, contract holders may re-deposit the principal in another funding agreement.
Typically, brokerage accounts and money market mutual funds are required to invest a portion of their funds in cash or cash equivalents to ensure sufficient liquidity to meet their customers requirements. The funding agreements permit termination by the contract holder on seven to 90 days notice, and thus qualify as cash equivalents for the clients purposes. In 2015 and 2014, there were no funding agreements terminable by the contract holder with less than 90 days notice.
Jackson is a member of the FHLBI. Membership allows Jackson access to advances from FHLBI that are collateralised by mortgage related assets in Jacksons investment portfolio. These advances are in the form of funding agreements issued to FHLBI.
30
Medium Term Note Funding Agreements
Jackson has also established European and global medium-term note programmes. The notes offered may be denominated in any currency with a fixed or floating interest rate. Notes are issued to institutional investors by a special purpose vehicle and are secured by funding agreements issued by Jackson. Jacksons medium-term note sales totalled £1,030 million in 2015 (2014: £485 million).
Distribution and Marketing
Jackson distributes products in all 50 states of the United States and in the District of Columbia, although not all products are available in all states. Operations in the state of New York are conducted through a New York insurance subsidiary. Jackson markets its retail products primarily through advice based distribution channels, including independent agents, independent broker-dealer firms, regional broker-dealers, wirehouses, and banks.
Our distribution teams set us apart from our competitors. Jacksons wholesaling force is the largest in the industry, supporting thousands of advisors across multiple channels and distribution outlets.
Our wholesalers provide extensive training to these advisors. In 2015, we led the industry with the highest level of sales efficiency with gross sales per wholesaler 32 per cent higher than the nearest competitor.
Independent Agents and Broker Dealers
National Planning Holdings, an affiliate of Jackson, is the sixth(9) largest independent broker-dealer network in the US. Leveraging the collective strength of the four broker-dealers within the network, National Planning Holdings is able to meet the specific needs of three key distribution channels: independent representatives, financial institutions, and tax and accounting professionals. We offer registered representatives and investment advisors access to industry-leading mutual fund/asset management companies, insurance carriers, and to thousands of brokerage products. National Planning Holdings provides significant benefits for Jackson by offering Jackson products and providing market intelligence.
Jacksons wholesalers meet directly with independent broker dealers and financial planners and are supported by an extensive internal sales staff. At 31 December 2015, Jackson had active selling agreements with independent broker dealer organisations throughout the United States providing access to more than 70,800 appointed representatives. Jackson provides training for its broker dealers and also provides them with product information and sales materials.
Regional Broker Dealers
Jacksons Regional Broker Dealer (RBD) team provides dedicated service and support to regional brokerage firms and wirehouses. Regional broker dealers are a hybrid between independent broker dealers and wirehouses. Like representatives who work for wirehouses, financial representatives at regional broker dealers are actual employees of the firm. However, unlike wirehouses, RBD firms have limited institutional investment banking services. The RBD team develops relationships with regional firms throughout the US and provides customised materials and support to meet their specialised advisory needs.
Jacksons RBD team also provides support for the wirehouse channel, which produced £2.1 billion of premium in 2015.
Jacksons RBD team supports more than 39,400 representatives in regional broker dealers and wirehouses.
Banks, Credit Unions and Other Financial Institutions
Jacksons Institutional Marketing Group distributes annuity products through banks, credit unions and other financial institutions and through third party marketing organisations that serve these institutions. Jackson is a leading provider of annuities offered through banks and credit unions and at 31 December 2015 had access to more than 32,000 financial institution representatives through existing relationships with banks and credit unions. Jackson has established distribution relationships with medium sized regional banks, which it believes are unlikely to develop their own insurance product capability.
(9) | Paikert, C. (2015). New Paths to Scale. Financial Planning. June 2015. |
31
Independent Broker Dealers
Jacksons retail distribution is managed by Prudentials independent broker dealer network, NPH, which is described in more detail above. NPH had more than 3,400 registered representatives at the end of 2015.
Institutional Products Department
Jackson markets its institutional products through its institutional products department. It has direct contacts with banks, municipalities, asset management firms and direct plan sponsors. Institutional products are distributed and marketed through intermediaries to these groups.
Factors Affecting Pricing of Products and Asset Liability Management
Jackson prices products based on a variety of assumptions including, but not limited to, mortality, investment yields, expenses and contract holder behaviour. Pricing is influenced by Jacksons objectives for return on capital and by competition. Although Jackson includes a profit margin in the price of its products, the variation between the assumptions and actual experience can result in the products being more or less profitable than originally assumed. This variation can be significant.
Jackson designs its interest sensitive products and conducts its investment operations to match closely the duration of the assets in its investment portfolio with the annuity, life, and guaranteed investment contract product obligations. Jackson seeks to achieve a target spread between what it earns on its assets and what it pays on its liabilities by investing principally in fixed-rate securities. Jackson also enters into options and futures contracts to hedge equity related movements in its products.
Jackson segregates its investment portfolio for certain investment management purposes, and as part of its overall investment strategy, into four portfolios: life and fixed annuities without market value adjustment, fixed annuities with market value adjustment, fixed index annuities and institutional liabilities. The portfolios backing life and fixed annuities with and without market value adjustments and the fixed index annuities have similar characteristics and differ primarily in duration. The portfolio backing the institutional liabilities has its own mix of investments that meet more limited duration tolerances. Consequently, the institutional portfolio is managed to permit less interest rate sensitivity and has limited exposure to mortgage backed securities. At 31 December 2015, two per cent of the institutional portfolio was invested in residential mortgage backed securities.
The fixed-rate products may incorporate surrender charges, market value adjustments, two-tiered interest rate structures or other limitations relating to when policies can be surrendered for cash, in order to encourage persistency. As of 31 December 2015, 60 per cent of Jacksons fixed annuity reserves had surrender penalties or other withdrawal restrictions. Substantially all of the institutional portfolio had withdrawal restrictions or market value adjustment provisions.
Fixed index annuities issued by Jackson also include an equity component that is hedged using the offsetting equity exposure in the variable annuity product. The equity component of these annuities constitutes an embedded derivative that is carried at fair value, as are other derivative instruments.
Guaranteed benefits issued by Jackson in connection with the sales of variable annuity contracts expose Jackson to equity risk as the benefits generally become payable when equity markets decline and contract values fall below the guaranteed amount. As discussed previously, the liability for certain of these benefits is carried at fair value with changes in fair value recorded in income. Jackson manages the exposure of the tail risk associated with the equity exposure using equity options and futures contracts, which are also carried at fair value. Jackson seeks to manage the economic risk associated with these contracts and, therefore, has not explicitly hedged its fair value risk as determined for IAS 39. In addition, certain benefits have mortality risk and are therefore precluded from being carried at fair value. As a result of these factors, the income statement may include a timing mismatch related to changes in fair value. However, as demonstrated during the economic crisis, subsequent rebound and recent volatility in the equity markets, Jacksons hedges have effectively operated as designed.
32
Reserves
Except for certain non-insurance deposit-type accounts and as allowed under IFRS, Jackson uses reserves established on a grandfathered US GAAP basis as the basis for consolidation into Prudentials IFRS accounts.
For the fixed interest rate and variable annuity contracts and institutional products, the reserve is the contract holders account value. For the fixed index annuities, the reserve is based on three components, 1) the imputed value of the underlying guaranteed host contract, 2) the fair value of the embedded option component of the contract, and 3) the liability for guaranteed benefits related to the optional lifetime income rider. For the immediate annuities, reserves are determined as the present value of future policy benefits. Mortality assumptions are based on company experience. Interest rate assumptions currently range from three per cent to eight per cent.
The IFRS accounting for guarantees on Jacksons variable annuity contracts has a mixed measurement approach due to requirements of the guidance of the grandfathered US GAAP basis. GMWB not for life contract features are fair valued under current US GAAP (similar to IAS 39) for embedded derivatives, with a capping feature to prevent early anticipation of expected fees for guarantees. However, the GMDB and GMWB for life blocks of business are accounted for under US GAAP guidance related to valuing life-contingent guarantees, which does not, and is not intended to, fair value the liabilities.
For the traditional term life contracts, reserves for future policy benefits are determined using the net level premium method and assumptions as to mortality, interest, policy persistency and expenses. Interest rate assumptions range from two and one half per cent to six per cent. Persistency, mortality, and expense assumptions are based on Jacksons experience.
For the interest sensitive and single premium life contracts, reserves approximate the contract holders account value.
Reinsurance
Jackson reinsures portions of the coverage provided by its life insurance products with other insurance companies under agreements of indemnity reinsurance. Indemnity reinsurance agreements are intended to limit a life insurers maximum loss on a large or unusually hazardous risk or to obtain a greater diversification of risk for the life insurer. Indemnity reinsurance does not discharge the original insurers primary liability to the insured. Jacksons reinsured business is ceded to numerous unaffiliated reinsurers and, except as noted below, the amount of reserves ceded to any one reinsurer is not material to Jacksons overall financial position. Typically, the reinsurers have an AM Best Co rating of A or higher.
As a condition to the REALIC acquisition and after receipt of all required regulatory approvals, REALIC entered into three retrocession reinsurance agreements with Swiss Re. Pursuant to these reinsurance agreements, REALIC ceded to Swiss Re on a 100 per cent coinsurance basis, subject to pre-existing reinsurance, certain blocks of business written or assumed by REALIC. The effective date of the three retrocession agreements was 1 July 2012. In addition and pursuant to these reinsurance agreements, Jackson holds certain assets, primarily in the form of policy loans and fixed maturities, as collateral. This collateral is reported as a funds held liability. The three retrocession agreements are further collateralized by Swiss Re assets held in trust accounts (total collateral exceeds the reinsurance recoverable).
At 31 December 2015, Jacksons largest amount ceded to one reinsurer totalled £4.3 billion, which is primarily related to the retrocession reinsurance arrangements.
In force level premium term products are generally 90 per cent reinsured.
Jackson cedes the guaranteed minimum income benefit previously offered on variable annuities to an unaffiliated reinsurer.
Policy administration
Jackson provides a high level of administrative support for both new and existing contract holders. Jacksons ability to implement new products quickly and provide quality customer service is supported by integrated computer systems that issue and administer complex life insurance and annuity contracts. Jackson continues to
33
develop its fixed and variable annuity administration systems to enhance the service capabilities for both new and existing customers. The REALIC business is currently administered by third party administrators.
PPM
PPM is Prudentials US institutional investment management operation, with its primary offices in Chicago and New York. PPM manages assets for Prudentials US, UK and Asian affiliates. PPM provides affiliated and unaffiliated institutional clients with investment services including managing assets for separate accounts, US mutual funds and similar foreign pooled investment vehicles, a collateralised loan obligation and private equity funds. PPMs strategy is focused on managing existing assets effectively, maximising the benefits derived from synergies with our international asset management affiliates, and leveraging investment management capabilities across the Group. PPM also pursues third-party mandates on an opportunistic basis.
Introduction
As at 31 December 2015, Prudentials UK business was structured into two business units, each focusing on its respective target customer markets. Prudentials UK business units are Prudential UK & Europe (Prudential UK&E, providing insurance and investment products) and M&G (being the asset management business).
Prudential UK & Europe business overview
When compared to 2012 the UK pensions industry today is almost unrecognisable. Three years of unprecedented regulatory change has resulted in a structural marketplace shift in how customers view retirement with consumers being given greater flexibility to access their pension savings in retirement. Customers are engaging more frequently with their providers and the demand for financial advice and guidance is increasing. Those companies who are well-known, financially strong and create products and services to match the pension freedom needs and expectations of customers will prosper.
Prudential UK is well placed in this evolving marketplace. This is evident in our new business profile relative to a few years ago. Where once bonds and annuities were the dominant components of new business, since the emergence of greater post pension freedoms we have been writing more bond, ISA, pension saving and income drawdown business, and a significantly lower volume of annuity business, giving a better balance to our business portfolio.
The UK is the worlds fifth largest retail investment market. Wealth is concentrated in the 50+ age group with the younger generation of savers being typically less well-funded. In our target over- 50 demographic, the population growth rate is almost double the growth rate of the UK population as a whole and while the introduction of pension freedom reforms in April 2015 has fundamentally changed the way in which individuals can access their savings to help fund their income in retirement, the need to accumulate savings remains unchanged. These radical changes, when combined with our trusted brand and product capabilities, provide new and significant opportunities for the profitable and capital efficient growth of our business in the UK.
For over 167 years Prudential has been providing financial security to generations of UK customers through an unwavering focus on long-term value as evidenced by our longevity experience, multi-asset investment capabilities and our financial strength. Such attributes are highly sought after today by customers adjusting to pension freedoms and by financial advisers who require a brand they can trust to help secure dependable incomes in retirement for their clients. Our inherent brand strength, in combination with our range of market leading with-profits and retirement income products, continues to resonate more strongly than ever with customers and distributors. This is driving significant demand for our differentiated and market leading retirement solutions.
We continue to focus on meeting customer needs through the following actions:
| providing products and retirement solutions perfectly tailored to help customers take advantage of the new pension freedoms; |
| broadening the ways in which customers can do business with us through financial adviser intermediaries, providing advice to customers in their homes through our 250 Prudential Financial Planning partners, or by telephone and increasingly online; |
34
| investing in technology that enables customers to engage more flexibly with us online; |
| enhancing access to our market leading PruFund investment range through an ISA wrapper; |
| introducing income drawdown specifically designed for the pension freedoms market; and |
| consistently committing to customer service improvement, which was recognised at the 2015 Financial Adviser Service Awards where we received the accolade of Company of the Year, for the first time, while also retaining our two 5-Star ratings in the Life & Pensions and Investment categories for the fifth consecutive year. |
Our business in Poland has established a strong customer franchise, growing steadily since launching in 2013. Headquartered in Warsaw, the business now has 18 branches across the country and 597 financial planning consultants. Its success demonstrates our ability to build a new business franchise by applying our existing product and distribution expertise to a new market.
Prudential UK & Europe has a well-established franchise in its chosen markets which continues to drive strong growth and ongoing product demand among customers. The business is focused on delivering retail growth and the optimisation of in-force business. It will continue to develop retirement solutions based on the market-leading and differentiated PruFund range. Developments will be underpinned by the latest technology including the introduction of a new policy administration system to support the launch of a Retirement Account specifically designed for the post pension freedom marketplace.
UK&E Products and profitability
Prudential UK&Es long-term products consist of life insurance, pension products and pension annuities. In common with other UK long-term insurance companies, Prudential UK&Es products are structured as either with-profits (or participating) products, or non-participating products including annuities in payment and unit-linked products. Depending on the structure, the level of shareholders interest in the value of policies and the related profit or loss varies.
With-profits policies are supported by a with-profits sub-fund and can be single premium (for example, Onshore Bonds) or regular premium (for example, certain pension products). Prudential UK&Es primary with-profits sub-fund is part of The Prudential Assurance Company Limited (PAC). The return to shareholders on virtually all Prudential UK&Es with-profits products is in the form of a statutory transfer to PAC shareholders funds. This is analogous to a dividend from PACs with-profits sub-fund, and is dependent upon the bonuses credited or declared on policies in that year. Prudentials with-profits policyholders currently receive 90 per cent of the distribution from the main with-profits sub-fund as bonus additions to their policies, while shareholders receive 10 per cent as a statutory transfer.
We have a competitive advantage in with-profits with the market-leading PruFund proposition. Importantly for customers, our PruFund range provides smoothing in a volatile and uncertain investment environment. The strength of the proposition is reflected in the consistent growth we have experienced, both in terms of the number of customers invested and the assets under management. In addition to our customers, our shareholders also continue to benefit from the steady performance of our with-profits based products and the cash they generate. The performance of our with-profits fund has allowed us to add £2.0 billion to with-profits policies in the year and policyholders will typically see year-on-year increases of between 2 per cent and 4 per cent in accumulating with-profits policy values over the past year.
The Defined Charge Participating Sub-Fund (DCPSF) comprises the accumulated investment content of premiums paid in respect of the defined charge participating with-profits business issued in France and the defined charge participating with-profits business reassured into PAC from Prudential International Assurance plc and Canada Life (Europe) Assurance Ltd. It also includes the portfolio of with-profits annuity policies acquired from Equitable Life in 2007. All profits in this fund accrue to policyholders in the DCPSF.
The profits from almost all of the new non-participating business accrue solely to shareholders. Such business is written in PAC, or in various shareholder-owned direct or indirect subsidiaries. The most significant of these is Prudential Retirement Income Limited (PRIL), which writes conventional annuities including all new conventional annuities arising from vesting deferred annuity and personal pension policies in the with-profits sub-fund of PAC. There is also a substantial volume of in-force non-participating business in PACs with-profits sub-fund, part of which was originally written in that funds wholly owned subsidiary Prudential Annuities Limited (PAL). On 1 October 2014, the business of PAL transferred into PAC following a Part VII Transfer under the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000.
35
The significant reforms of the pensions industry announced by the UK Government, including removal of the requirement to purchase a pension annuity from April 2015, have resulted in an increasing proportion of customers deferring the decision to convert their pension savings into retirement income. Sales of individual annuities in 2015 were 46 per cent lower than in 2014, reflecting the market contraction since the UK Budget announcement These changes have also opened up opportunities for us to meet customer needs for alternative retirement solutions, including income drawdown. From April 2015 our Flexible Drawdown product has allowed customers to access income drawdown without limits from April 2015, and is suited to customers who want more choice over how they use their retirement savings for income. Our sales of income drawdown have almost trebled from 2014 levels to £1,024m in 2015 and our market share has doubled to 21%(10).
Prudential UK&E provides a comprehensive range of risk managed investments, including with-profits bonds, pensions and drawdown, which continue to outperform competitors propositions. We have continued to develop our with-profits proposition, enhancing the range of investment choices available to policyholders by launching the PruFund range of investments within an ISA wrapper in February 2015.
Distribution
Retail financial services products are distributed face to face through independent financial advisers (IFAs) and restricted advisers, or directly by mail, telephone and over the internet. IFAs dominate the advice market and offer products from a range of insurance companies selected from the whole of the market. Restricted advisers do not need to select from the whole market and are typically tied to a single insurer or a small panel of insurers. Direct and e-commerce distribution methods are generally non-advised and therefore operate on a lower-cost basis than other distribution channels. Accordingly, products distributed directly are generally aimed at more simple financial planning needs.
Prudential UK&E has a diversified distribution model focusing on intermediaries, Prudential Financial Planning (our direct advice service) and individual customers via mail, email and telephone.
In 2013-2015, Prudential UK&Es new business premiums by channels are as follows:
Year Ended 31 December £m | ||||||||||||
2015 | 2014 | 2013 | ||||||||||
Individual Annuities: |
||||||||||||
Direct & Partnerships |
107 | 162 | 284 | |||||||||
Intermediated |
62 | 139 | 488 | |||||||||
Internal Vesting* |
396 | 764 | 1,305 | |||||||||
Total Individual Annuities |
565 | 1,065 | 2,077 | |||||||||
Other Products: |
||||||||||||
Direct & Partnerships |
980 | 702 | 661 | |||||||||
Intermediated |
5,589 | 3,370 | 2,301 | |||||||||
Wholesale |
1,508 | 1,710 | 275 | |||||||||
Total Other Products |
8,077 | 5,782 | 3,237 | |||||||||
Department of Work and Pensions Rebates*** |
- | - | 1 | |||||||||
Total New Business Premiums (excluding PruHealth and PruProtect businesses) | 8,642 | 6,847 | 5,315 | |||||||||
PruHealth and PruProtect businesses** |
- | 23 | 26 | |||||||||
Total New Business Premiums |
8,642 | 6,870 | 5,341 |
* | Internal vesting business is classified as new business where the contracts include an open market option. |
** | Following the disposal of Prudentials 25 per cent interest in PruProtect and PruHealth in November 2014, the 2014 and 2013 comparatives have been adjusted to show the premiums of those businesses separately. |
*** | Discontinued from April 2012. |
Direct and Partnerships
Direct distribution channels include the telephone, mail and internet, and focus on annuities, investments and protection products. Prudential UK&Es direct advice
(10) | Source: ABI |
36
service, Prudential Financial Planning (PFP), focuses primarily on the financial planning needs of our existing direct customer base. At the end of 2015, its fourth year of trading, adviser partner numbers had reached 250, assets under advice were c£2.9bn and clients under advice were c41,000.
Partnerships are primarily arrangements with other insurers whereby we offer our annuity products to their vesting pension customers.
Intermediaries
Strong growth in sales through our intermediary channel reflected the strength of our PruFund proposition and our relationships with key intermediary firms. Increased sales of with-profits bonds, individual pensions and income drawdown outweighed the impact of the slow down in the annuities market. With-profits bond sales through intermediaries grew by 13 per cent, largely due to our PruFund bond proposition, where our track record of investment performance differentiates us from our competitors. The value of UK invested assets on platforms continues to increase, and we are seeking to develop new solutions to target this opportunity.
Wholesale
Our approach to bulk transactions in the UK will continue to be one of selective participation, where we can bring both significant value to our customers and meet our shareholder return requirements. Our bulk annuity buy-in insurance agreements generated £1,508 million of new business premiums, which included four significant deals. Through our longstanding presence in this segment of the life and pensions market, we have developed considerable longevity experience, operational scale and a solid investment track record, which together represent expertise and capabilities that are increasingly in demand. Whilst our approach to bulk transactions remains selective, the financial resource requirement to write annuity business increases under Solvency II means that we can expect the market for this business to evolve over time and we will be monitoring the situation.
Long-term Products
Prudentials long-term products in the United Kingdom consist of life insurance, pension products and pensions annuities. The following table shows Prudential UK&Es new business insurance and investment premiums by product line for the periods indicated. New business premiums include deposits for policies with limited or no life contingencies. Prudential UK&E also distributes life insurance products, primarily investment bonds, in other European countries and has started up a business in Poland which primarily sells with-profits savings and protection products. The volume of such business is relatively small and is included in the table below.
Year Ended 31 December £m | ||||||||||||
2015 | 2014 | 2013 | ||||||||||
Individual annuities |
565 | 1,065 | 2,077 | |||||||||
Bonds |
3,327 | 2,934 | 2,188 | |||||||||
Corporate Pensions |
310 | 230 | 281 | |||||||||
Individual Pensions |
1,217 | 530 | 319 | |||||||||
Income drawdown |
1,024 | 352 | 146 | |||||||||
PruFund ISA* |
669 | - | - | |||||||||
Other products |
22 | 26 | 28 | |||||||||
Wholesale |
1,508 | 1,710 | 276 | |||||||||
Total New business premiums (excluding PruHealth and PruProtect businesses) |
8,642 | 6,847 | 5,315 | |||||||||
PruHealth and PruProtect businesses** |
- | 23 | 26 | |||||||||
Total new business premiums |
8,642 | 6,870 | 5,341 |
* | The PruFund range of investments was launched within an ISA wrapper in February 2015 |
** | Following the disposal of Prudentials 25 per cent interest share in PruProtect and PruHealth in November 2014, the 2014 and 2013 comparatives have been have been adjusted to show the premiums of those businesses separately. |
Of the total new business premiums of £8,642 million (2014: £6,847 million; 2013: £5,315 million), £8,463 million (2014: £6,681 million; 2013: £5,129 million) were for single premiums and £179 million (2014: £166 million; 2013: £186 million) were for regular premiums.
37
Pension Annuities (including Wholesale)
Prudential UK&E offers individual conventional immediate annuities that are either fixed or retail price indexed (referred to as RPI), where annuity payments are guaranteed from the outset, or with-profits annuities, where annuity payments are variable dependent on the investment performance of underlying assets but with an income floor.
A total of £565 million of individual annuities were sold in 2015. Of this total, £396 million was sold through internal vesting, that is existing Prudential UK&E customers with maturing pension policies. The other £169 million were sold to new customers, typically individuals with a pension maturing with another provider who chose Prudential UK&E to provide their annuity. Prudential UK&Es immediate annuity products provide guaranteed income for a specified time, usually the life of the policyholder, in exchange for a lump sum capital payment. No surrender value is available under any of these products. The primary risks to Prudential UK&E from immediate annuity products are mortality improvements and credit risk.
Conventional Annuities
Prudential UK&Es conventional annuities include level (non-increasing), fixed increase and RPI annuities. Prudential UK&Es fixed increase annuities incorporate automatic increases in annuity payments by fixed amounts over the policyholders life. The RPI annuities provide for a regular annuity payment to which an additional amount is added periodically based on the increase in the UK Retail Prices Index. In 2015, sales of RPI annuities were £893 million (including £887 million of bulk annuities). In 2015, sales of level and fixed increase conventional annuities amounted to £1,073 million (including £621 million of bulk annuities). The total sales of individual conventional annuities excluding the wholesale bulk annuities were £458 million.
With-profits Annuities
Prudential UK&Es with-profits annuities combine the income features of annuity products with the investment smoothing features of with-profits products and enable policyholders to obtain equity-type returns over time. In 2009, Prudential UK&E launched the Income Choice Annuity, which allows customers to choose an income between a defined maximum and minimum level, with the option of re-setting this every year. It also provides an opportunity for pension income to grow based on the returns of the with-profits fund. Through this product, Prudential UK&E brings its product development strengths to bear while also capitalising on peoples need for protection from inflation through increasingly long periods of retirement.
Prudential is one of only a few companies in the United Kingdom which are active in the with-profits annuities market and has been operating in this market since 1991. In 2015, Prudential UK&Es premiums for this business were £107 million.
Pension Products
Prudential UK&E provides both corporate and individual pension products. Pension products are tax advantaged long-term savings products that comply with rules established by the HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) and are designed to supplement state provided pensions.
These products provide policyholders with a number of options at retirement. From age 55 onwards, policyholders may elect to use part or all of their maturity benefits to purchase a pension annuity, they may choose to draw-down funds without purchasing an annuity, they may delay taking any benefits, take cash or take a combination of these options. They are also permitted to take a portion as a tax-free lump sum.
For products with drawdown features, the investment risk remains with the policyholder, payments are not guaranteed, and tend to cost more to administer. In the past, this has meant that the option to drawdown tended to apply mainly to more sophisticated policyholders and to larger retirement funds. The changes in the rules governing access to pension savings mean that consumers now have more choice and flexibility in how they access their retirement income.However, draw-downs from pension savings that are greater than the tax-free lump sum remain taxable at the individuals marginal tax rate.
Many of the pension products Prudential UK&E offers are with-profits products or offer the option to have all or part of the contributions allocated to a with-profits fund. Where funds invested in the with-profits fund are
38
withdrawn prior to the pension date specified by the policyholder, Prudential UK&E may apply a market value adjustment to the amount paid out. The remaining pension products are non-participating products, which include unit-linked products.
Corporate Pensions
There are two categories of corporate pension products: defined benefit and defined contribution. Prudential UK&E has an established defined benefit plan client base covering the small to medium sized employer market. Prudential UK&Es defined contribution client base ranges from small unlisted companies to some of the largest companies in the United Kingdom as well as a number of clients in the public sector (in particular where Prudential UK&E offers the Additional Voluntary Contribution (AVC) facility). Additional Voluntary Contribution plans enable employees to make additional pension contributions, either regularly or as a lump sum, to supplement their occupational pension plans. Prudential UK&E administers corporate pensions for over 600,000 scheme members sponsored by some of the UKs largest employers and has also built a very strong position in the provision of with-profits AVC arrangements. Prudential UK&E provides AVCs to 73 of the 101 Local Government Authorities in the UK.
Defined benefit plans and products have previously dominated the corporate pensions market in terms of funds under management. In recent years, however, most new plans established have been defined contribution products. In addition, there is an increasing trend among companies to close defined benefit plans to new members or to convert existing schemes from defined benefit to defined contribution in order to stabilise or reduce potential pension liabilities.
Prudential UK&E offers group unit-linked policies and with-profits policies to the corporate pensions market. Prudential UK&Es defined contribution products are AVC plans, Group Money Purchase plans, Group Personal Pension plans, Group Stakeholder Pension plans and Executive Pension plans.
In addition, Prudential UK&E has a Company Pension Transfer Plan (or Bulk S32), designed to accept benefits from both defined benefit and defined contribution pension schemes which are winding up (ceasing to exist or being replaced by a new type of scheme). Prudential UK&E also has the facility to accept enhanced transfers from deferred members of a corporates defined benefit pensions scheme into Prudential UK&E Personal Pension plan where the member has received advice from an independent financial adviser (often called an enhanced transfer value exercise).
From 2012, individuals who are not already in a pension scheme, who are over 21 and below retirement age and whose earnings are over a minimum amount have had to be automatically enrolled in a pension scheme by their employer, who will be required to make contributions. These requirements were applied first to larger employers and are being rolled out gradually to medium sized and smaller employers.
Individual Pensions
Prudential UK&Es individual pension range offers unit-linked and unitised with-profits products, including products that meet the criteria of the UK governments stakeholder pension program.
The stakeholder pension is intended for individuals earning enough to be able to afford to make contributions to a pension but who are not currently doing so. The introduction of stakeholder pensions has had implications for, among other things, how Prudential UK&E designs, administers and charges for and distributes pension products. The most significant requirements involve capped charges and a low minimum contribution which must be accepted by the provider. The UK government has capped charges at 1.5 per cent per annum of the policyholder account balance for stakeholder pensions for the first ten years, decreasing to 1 per cent thereafter, which is below the charges on personal pension products previously offered by the UK pensions industry.
Bonds
Onshore Bonds
Prudential UK&E offers customers a range of investment funds to meet different risk and reward objectives. Prudential UK&Es main onshore bond product wrapper is the Prudential Investment Plan (PIP). Through this plan, based on a single premium with no fixed term, customers have the option to invest in the with-profits fund through PruFund or in a range of unit-linked investment funds.
39
PIP also gives financial advisers the opportunity to choose from different external fund management groups and the flexibility to make changes to portfolio and asset allocation over time. In 2015, sales of the unit-linked option within on-shore bond wrappers, including PIP were £184 million.
Prudential Dynamic Portfolios, launched in 2010, offer advisers a choice of portfolio options to match a clients risk/reward profile as an alternative to building an individual portfolio.
Prudential UK&E offers a unitised and smoothed with-profits investment fund entitled PruFund, which is designed to provide increased transparency and smoothed investment returns to the customer with a choice of Cautious, Growth or risk-managed funds. PruFund also offers clients an optional guarantee on the initial investment in either the Cautious or Growth funds with a term from six to eight years depending on the clients requirements. PruFund is available across Prudential UK&Es range of tax wrappers including individual pensions, income drawdown, ISA and onshore and offshore bonds. In 2015, total new business premiums attributable to PruFund, including new business through PIP, was £2,164 million.
With-profits bonds aim to provide capital growth over the medium to long term, and access to a range of investment sectors without the costs and risks associated with direct investment into these sectors. Capital growth for the policyholder on with-profits bonds apart from PruFund is achieved by the addition of reversionary or annual bonuses, which are credited to the bond on a daily basis from investment returns achieved within PACs long-term with-profits fund, offset by charges and expenses incurred in the fund. A final bonus may also be added when the bond is surrendered. The PruFund return to policyholders is based on a published expected growth rate, updated quarterly, which aims to deliver more stable growth. In contrast the capital return on unit-linked bonds directly reflects the movement in the value of the assets underlying those funds. When funds invested in PACs long-term with-profits fund are either fully or partially withdrawn, PAC may apply a market value adjustment to the amount paid out.
The sales growth across Prudential UK&Es with-profits range has been achieved on the back of sustained strong investment performance in its Life Fund over a number of years, reflecting the benefits of its diversified investment policy. Prudential believes that this market will continue to see further growth as investors turn to trusted and financially strong brands and products offering an element of capital protection.
Offshore Bonds
Prudential UK&Es offshore bond products are the Prudential International Investment Bond and the Prudential International Investment Portfolio offering clients access to a wide range of quoted UK investments. Prudential UK&Es offshore bond sales grew by 22 per cent to £753 million in 2015.
Other Products
Other products include income drawdown, PruFund ISA, life insurance and equity release mortgages.
Income Drawdown
Income drawdown products have historically provided a bridge between pensions and annuities, allowing customers to access pension savings from age 55, subject to certain limits. These products help customers manage their pensions through the various stages of retirement, and also offer flexibility while providing potential for capital growth. Prior to the pension reforms announced in the 2014 UK Budget, the market had seen good growth, reflecting an increasingly sophisticated consumer population and the rising incidence of second careers and semi-retirement as a result of increasing longevity. This growth accelerated in the interim period created by the Budget 2014 announcement before the introduction of pension reforms in April 2015 and has continued into 2015 where Prudential UK&E sold £1,024 million of income drawdown products. Income drawdown has proved popular with customers seeking greater flexibility than that offered by a traditional annuity product, but preferring to draw funds gradually rather than withdrawing all of their savings as cash. Depending on the size of their pension pot and the individuals tax position, it may also be more tax efficient for a customer to invest in a drawdown product rather than to take cash.
In December 2014 we launched a new Flexible Drawdown product ahead of the introduction of the April 2015 pension reforms. This product allows customers to access income drawdown without limits from April 2015, and is suited to customers who want more choice over how they use their retirement savings for income.
40
In October 2015 Prudential UK&E launched a Pension Choices Plan product which increases the choice available to our existing customers allowing them to exercise their pensions freedoms by having direct access to their pension fund, where they are comfortable making that decision, without the help of a financial adviser. The new product is a pension and income drawdown product giving customers access to four risk managed funds in our popular PruFund range, a choice of four funds from the risk-rated Dynamic Portfolios range, as well as a cash fund.
PruFund ISA
On 26 February 2015 Prudential UK&E added the PruFund range of investment funds to the Prudential ISA to offer clients a level of smoothing in the current volatile market within a tax efficient wrapper. Sales in 2015 were £669 million.
Life Insurance Products
Prudentials UK life insurance products are predominantly pure protection (term) products, and include the PruProtect product previously sold through an associate company. On 14 November 2014 Prudential sold its remaining 25 per cent share in PruProtect to Discovery and no further sales are included after that date. PAC continues to write PruProtect business under a white labelling agreement but has no economic interest in the business written.
Equity Release Mortgage
In November 2009, Prudential UK&E closed its equity release operation to new business. Existing customers may, however, still draw down additional funds, subject to their overall borrowing limits.
Reserves
In the United Kingdom, a life insurance companys reserve and other requirements are determined by its Board, with advice from its Actuarial Function Holder (under the Solvency I regime), subject to minimum reserve requirements. These minimum reserve requirements are established by the rules and guidance of the PRA.
Under the Solvency I regime, the reserves are published in annual returns to the PRA. Under IFRS reporting, applying the modified statutory basis of reporting as grandfathered upon the adoption of IFRS in 2005, similar provisions are included with limited adjustments. The Actuarial Function Holder must pay due regard to the fair treatment of policyholders in making recommendations to the companys board. The Actuarial Function Holder is required to report directly to the PRA any serious concerns regarding the companys ability to treat its customers fairly.
Prudential UK&Es regulatory reserving for with-profits products, as required by UK regulation, takes into account annual bonuses/annual interest credited to policyholders because these are attached to the policies and are guaranteed. Realistic reserves are also calculated for with-profits products under UK regulation. These include an allowance for final bonuses based on the asset share or a prospective valuation of the policies and the cost of guarantees, smoothing and enhancements.
Prudential UK&E reserves for unit-linked products on the basis of the value of the unit fund and additional reserves are held for expenses and mortality where this is required by the contract design.
As well as the reserves, under Solvency I, the companys assets must also cover other capital requirements set out in the PRA Prudential Sourcebook. These comprise a with-profits insurance capital component, which is a measure of the difference in the surplus assets on regulatory and realistic bases; a resilience capital requirement for entities other than PAC, which makes prudent allowance for potential future adverse movements in investment values; and the long-term insurance capital requirement, which must be held by all EU insurance companies. See Financial Strength of PACs With-Profits Fund for further information on solvency.
Financial strength of PACs with-profits fund
The PACs with-profits fund is supported by a large inherited estate, with the free assets of the with-profits fund valued at approximately £7.7 billion (as at 31 December 2015 as estimated at 8 March 2016 and included in the consolidated financial statements), on a Solvency I regulatory realistic basis. This provides the working capital required to support the fund for the long-term benefit of current and future policyholders. The strength of the with-profits fund offers strong policyholder protection and assists in generating positive returns for both policyholders and shareholders.
41
The table below shows the change in the investment mix of PACs main with-profits fund:
2015 % | 2014 % | 2013 % | ||||||||||
UK equities |
20 | 19 | 19 | |||||||||
International equities |
29 | 24 | 17 | |||||||||
Property |
16 | 16 | 14 | |||||||||
Fixed Interest |
29 | 34 | 41 | |||||||||
Cash and other asset classes |
6 | 7 | 9 | |||||||||
Total |
100 | 100 | 100 |
The with-profits sub-fund earned a return of 3.6 per cent before tax in 2015 on investments covering policyholder liabilities. The with-profits sub-fund has delivered investment returns of 80.8 per cent over 10 years for policyholder asset shares in the fund, compared with the FTSE All-share index (total return) of 71.8 per cent over the same period (figures are to 31 December 2015, before tax and charges).
From 1 January 2016 available capital will be measured on a Solvency II basis following the European Unions Solvency II Directive coming into effect. The PAC with-profits fund remained well-capitalised with an estate value, representing Solvency II own funds, estimated at £7.6 billion covering its solvency capital requirement approximately 1.75 times. The reconciling items from the Solvency I basis to Solvency II mainly reflect the risk margin net of transitionals, with other items including differences in the definition of the risk-free rate and the matching adjustment impact for non-profit annuity liabilities within the with-profits funds.
Shareholders Interests in Prudential UK&Es Long-term Insurance Business
In common with other UK long-term insurance companies, Prudential UK&Es products are structured as either with-profits products or non-participating (including unit-linked) products. With-profits policies are supported by a with-profits fund. Prudential UK&Es primary with-profits fund is part of PACs long-term fund. For statutory and management purposes, PACs long-term fund consists of a number of sub-funds in which shareholders and policyholders have varying interests.
With-profits Products
With-profits products provide an equity-type return to policyholders through bonuses that are smoothed. There are two types of bonuses: annual and final. Annual bonuses, often referred to as reversionary bonuses, are declared once a year and, once credited, are guaranteed in accordance with the terms of the particular product. Unlike annual bonuses, final bonuses are only guaranteed until the next bonus declaration. Final bonuses are only credited on a products maturity or surrender or on the death of the policyholder. Final bonuses can represent a substantial portion of the ultimate return to policyholders.
With-profits products provide benefits that are generally either the value of the premiums paid, less charges and fees and with the addition of declared bonuses, or the guaranteed death benefit with the addition of declared bonuses. Smoothing of investment returns is an important feature of with-profits products. It is designed to reduce the impact of fluctuations in investment return from year to year and is accomplished predominantly through the level of final bonuses declared.
The return to Prudentials shareholders in respect of with-profits business Prudential UK&E writes is an amount equal to up to one-ninth of the value of the bonuses Prudential UK&E credits or declares to policyholders in that year. Prudential UK&E has a large block of in-force with-profits business with varying maturity dates that generates a relatively stable stream of shareholder profits from year to year.
PACs board of directors, with the advice of its Actuarial Function Holder (Chief Actuary from 1 January 2016) and its With-Profits Actuary, determines the amount of annual and final bonuses to be declared each year on each group of contracts.
When determining policy payouts, including final bonuses, PAC follows an actuarial practice of considering asset shares for specimen policies. Asset shares broadly reflect the value of premiums paid in respect of a policy accumulated at the investment return on the assets PAC notionally attributes to the policy. In calculating asset shares, PAC takes into account the following items:
| the cost of mortality risk and other guarantees (where applicable); |
42
| the effect of taxation; |
| management expenses, charges and commissions; |
| the proportion of the amount determined to be distributable to shareholders; and |
| the surplus arising from surrenders, non-participating business included in the with-profits fund and other miscellaneous sources. |
However, Prudential UK&E does not take into account the surplus assets of the long-term fund, or investment return earned on them, in calculating asset shares. The determination of final bonuses takes into account asset shares, as well as the need to smooth claim values and payments from year to year, competitive considerations and the desire to treat customers fairly.
Prudential UK&E is required by UK law and regulation to consider the fair treatment of its customers in setting bonus levels. The concept of treating customers fairly is established by statute but is not defined. In practice, it provides one of the guiding principles for decision making in respect of with-profits products.
The overall return to policyholders is an important competitive measure for attracting new business. The ability to declare competitive bonuses depends, in part, on the financial strength of PACs long-term fund, enabling it to maintain high levels of investment in equities and real estate, if it wishes to do so. Equities and real estate have historically over the long-term provided a return in excess of fixed interest securities.
In 2015, PAC declared a total surplus of £2,208 million (2014: £2,012 million) from PACs primary with-profits sub-fund, of which £1,994 million (2014: £1,812 million) was added to with-profits policies and £214 million (2014: £200 million) was distributed to shareholders. These amounts included annual bonus rates of 1.75 per cent for Prudence Bond and 1.75 per cent for personal pensions.
The closed Scottish Amicable Insurance Fund (SAIF) declared total bonuses in 2015 of £358 million compared to £362 million in 2014. Shareholders have no interest in profits from the SAIF fund, although they are entitled to the investment management fees paid by this business. For greater detail on the SAIF fund, see The SAIF sub-fund below.
Surplus Assets in PACs Long-term With-profits Fund
The assets of the main with-profits sub-fund within the long-term fund of PAC comprise the amounts that it expects to pay out to meet its obligations to existing policyholders and an additional amount used as working capital. The amount payable over time to policyholders from the with-profits sub-fund is equal to the policyholders accumulated asset shares plus any additional payments that may be required by way of smoothing or to meet guarantees. The balance of the assets of the with-profits sub-fund is called the inherited estate and has accumulated over many years from various sources.
The inherited estate, as working capital, enables Prudential UK&E to support with-profits business by providing the benefits associated with smoothing and guarantees, by providing investment flexibility for the funds assets, by meeting the regulatory capital requirements that demonstrate solvency and by absorbing the costs of significant events or fundamental changes in its long-term business without affecting the bonus and investment policies. The size of the inherited estate fluctuates from year to year depending on the investment return and the extent to which it has been required to meet smoothing costs, guarantees and other events.
Depletion of Surplus Assets and Shareholders Contingencies
As a proprietary insurance company, PAC is liable to meet its obligations to policyholders even if the assets of the long-term funds are insufficient to do so. The assets, represented by the unallocated surplus of with-profits funds, in excess of amounts expected to be paid for future terminal bonuses and related shareholder transfers (the excess assets) in the long-term funds could be materially depleted over time by, for example, a significant or sustained equity market downturn, costs of significant fundamental strategic change or a material increase in the pension mis-selling provision. In the unlikely circumstance that the depletion of the excess assets within the long-term fund was such that the Groups ability to satisfy policyholders reasonable expectations was adversely affected, it might become necessary to restrict the annual distribution to shareholders or to contribute shareholders funds to the long-term funds to provide financial support.
43
In 1998, Prudential stated that deducting personal pensions mis-selling costs from the inherited estate of the with-profits sub-fund would not impact its bonus or investment policy and it gave an assurance that if this unlikely event were to occur, it would make available support to the fund from shareholder resources for as long as the situation continued, so as to ensure that policyholders were not disadvantaged. The assurance was designed to protect both existing policyholders at the date it was announced, and policyholders who subsequently purchased policies while the pension mis-selling review was continuing.
This review was completed on 30 June 2002. The assurance will continue to apply to any policy in force at 31 December 2003, both for premiums paid before 1 January 2004, and for subsequent regular premiums (including future fixed, retail price index or salary related increases and Department of Work and Pensions rebate business). The assurance has not applied to new business issued since 1 January 2004. New business in this context consists of new policies, new members to existing pension schemes plus regular and single premium top-ups, transfers and switches to existing arrangements. The maximum amount of capital support available under the terms of the assurance will reduce over time.
The bonus and investment policy for each type of with-profits policy is the same irrespective of whether or not the assurance applies. Hence removal of the assurance for new business has had no impact on policyholder returns.
Prudential and PAC have put in place intra-group arrangements to formalise circumstances in which capital support would be made available by Prudential (including in the scenarios referred to in pension mis-selling review above). While Prudential considers it unlikely that such support will be required, the arrangements are intended to provide additional comfort to PAC and its policyholders.
In addition, Prudential has put in place intra-group arrangements to formalise undertakings by Prudential to the regulators of the Hong Kong subsidiaries, which from 1 January 2014, contain the domesticated branch business from PAC regarding their solvency levels. In addition, the scheme of transfer of the Hong Kong branch includes short-term support arrangements between Prudential and PAC to underpin similar arrangements between PAC and the newly domesticated business. It is considered unlikely that support will need to be provided under these arrangements.
The SAIF Sub-fund
The SAIF sub-fund is a ring-fenced sub-fund of PACs long-term fund and was formed following the acquisition of the mutual Scottish Amicable Life Assurance Society in 1997. No new business may be written in SAIF, although regular premiums are still being paid on policies in-force at the time of the acquisition and top-ups are permitted on these policies.
This fund is solely for the benefit of those Scottish Amicable Life Assurance Society policyholders whose policies were transferred to SAIF. Shareholders have no interest in the profits of this fund, although they are entitled to the investment management fees paid on this business. The brand name and rights to profit on new business were transferred to a new PAC subsidiary, Scottish Amicable Life plc, which operated for the benefit of shareholders.
SAIF with-profits policies contain minimum levels of guaranteed benefit to policyholders. In addition, as mentioned below, certain pensions products have guaranteed annuity rates at retirement. Should the assets of SAIF be inadequate to meet the guaranteed benefit obligations of the policyholders of SAIF, the PAC long-term fund would be liable to cover any such deficiency in the first instance.
Non-participating Business
The majority of Prudential branded non-participating business is written in the non-profit sub-fund of PACs long-term fund or in subsidiaries owned by PAC. Since mid-2004, Prudential UK&E has written the majority of its new non-profit annuity business through Prudential Retirement Income limited (PRIL), from which the profits are attributed solely to shareholders. Prior to that time, certain non-profit annuity business was written through Prudential Annuities Limited (PAL), which is wholly owned by PACs with-profits fund. The profits on this business are attributable to the fund and not to shareholders, although indirectly shareholders get one-ninth of additional amounts paid to policyholders of the with-profits fund through the declaration of bonuses.
The unit-linked business written by PAC and Prudential International Assurance is written with capital provided by shareholders.
44
Guaranteed Annuities
Prudential used to sell guaranteed annuity products in the United Kingdom and held a technical provision of £47 million as at 31 December 2015, within the main with-profits fund to honour guarantees on these products. PACs main exposure to guaranteed annuities in the United Kingdom is through SAIF and a provision of £412 million was held in SAIF as at 31 December 2015, to honour the guarantees. As SAIF is a separate sub-fund of PACs long-term business fund, wholly attributable to the policyholders of the fund, the movement in this provision has no impact on shareholders.
M&G
M&G is the UK and European fund manager of the Prudential Group with responsibility for investments on behalf of both internal and external clients. It manages the investments of individuals, institutions and the UK policyholders of Prudential funds.
M&G has been managing money on behalf of third-party investors for more than 80 years. We believe our active approach to investment selecting investments on a conviction basis rather than following a market indexproduces superior returns for our customers over the longer term. We offer our customers the ability to invest in a diverse range of assets: not only equities and fixed income but also unlisted investments such as property, direct lending, infrastructure and private equity. M&G is one of the UKs largest real estate investors, with a property portfolio of £23.4 billion at 31 December 2015, and is the third largest private debt lender in the world.
M&G operates a range of UK-domiciled retail funds which are now distributed in 15 markets across Europe and Asia. At the end of 2015 clients outside the UK account for 41 per cent of our retail assets under management.
In the institutional market, M&G provides a range of strategies that help pension funds, sovereign wealth funds and other large institutional investors match liabilities and achieve growth targets. Some of these strategies were developed originally for Prudentials insurance funds.
The European asset management market is the second-largest in the world with net assets of 12.6 trillion(11). Demand for asset management services is expected to continue to grow as governments and employers increasingly pass the responsibility for retirement planning and other long-term savings to individuals. Asset managers with records of strong investment returns and a high-level of client service are in a good position to attract flows of new money.
The UK asset management industry, M&Gs core market, is the second-largest national market in the world with £870.7 billion(12) of assets and is a global centre of excellence for investment management and a major source of long-term funding for the UK economy.
The global economy in 2015 was dominated by three factors: fears of an economic slowdown in China, which led to the Chinese stock market crash in August; the continued decline in global commodity prices; and a strong US dollar. While commodity-exporting emerging markets and currencies suffered during 2015, the US dollar strengthened in anticipation of a rise in the federal funds rate, further bolstered by investors seeking a safe haven during heightened geopolitical tensions. Despite signs of economic recovery in developed countries, 2015 saw heightened market volatility across most asset classes and regions.
In Europe, investors shifted away from fixed income and equities towards mixed asset funds and cash, accompanied by a significant increase in funds flowing to exchange traded funds. Net sales of UK domiciled mutual funds were £17.0 billion(12) during 2015, with annual net outflows of £4.7 billion from the fixed income asset class by itself, although property and money market funds held up well.
Retail fund markets are highly fragmented, with no single company dominating. This reflects the competitive nature of the business and the multiplicity of providers.
(11) | Based on data as at Q4 2015. European Fund & Asset Management Association (published on 22 February 2016). |
(12) | Source: Investment Association, 31 December 2015. |
45
Retail clients favour pooled funds such as open-ended investment companies which they buy directly from M&G or more typically through an intermediary such as an independent financial adviser or discretionary fund manager. By total UK assets under management, M&G is the second largest retail fund manager with £35.7 billion of assets under management, equivalent to a market share of 6.8 per cent(12). In Europe, where M&G has distributed funds since 2002, it has over £23.5 billion of assets under management and a market share of 0.4 per cent(13).
Institutional clients require investment strategies that help them meet future outgoings, from a pension scheme making payments to retired employees to a sovereign wealth fund that finances schools, transport and other infrastructure developments. M&Gs ability to design and commercialise investment strategies for such clients is founded on the quality of its people and their acknowledged expertise in the worlds credit and real estate markets.
Many of the innovative strategies developed for todays institutional clients consist of investing in long-term, illiquid investmentsfrom infrastructure and housing to solar parks and corporate lending. Such investments often require a client to sign up for multiple years, creating long-term stability and security in the yields received by the client and the fees received by M&G.
M&Gs institutional fixed income clients include some of the UKs largest pension funds, 51 UK local-authority pension schemes and a number of sovereign wealth funds. M&G Real Estate is one of the worlds largest international property investors enabling clients to access a wide range of investment opportunities in real estate across all the major sectors in the UK, Europe and Asia.
Our investment edge is our people. We employ more than 2,000 people operating from offices across Europe, Asia and in South Africa. We take pride in attracting, developing and retaining people of the highest calibre. In return, they are committed to working with us to meet the long-term needs of our customers.
Our investment teams are primarily based in our headquarters in London, where they benefit from the provision of high quality support staff and investment infrastructure: from analysts and dealers to operations, risk and compliance. Reflecting the need for local expertise in real estate, we also have specialist real estate teams in Paris, Frankfurt, Luxembourg, Singapore, Seoul and Tokyo in addition to those in London.
A committed focus on long-term investment returns means that the interests of M&G and its customers are aligned, whether clients are individual savers, institutional investors or the funds of Prudentials insurance operations.
M&G has a strong investment brand, built over decades and based on a reputation for honesty, innovation and a commitment to building long-term wealth for our investors. We aim to put our customers at the heart of everything we do and seek to be a trusted partner for all of our clients.
M&Gs investment expertise spans all the principal asset classesequities, fixed income, multi asset and real estateso that we can always offer investment solutions to our clients as market conditions and investor sentiment change.
Equities: Our fund managers have the freedom to develop their own investment approaches. Their main strength lies in stock selection, focusing on fundamental company analysis. M&Gs size and standing enables our fund managers to develop an effective dialogue with the management teams of the companies in which they invest.
Fixed Income: M&G is one of Europes largest fixed income investors. Our fund managers benefit from one of the regions largest and most experienced in-house credit research teams, whose knowledge covers the full range of fixed income investment, from the management of sovereign debt and public corporate bond portfolios through to private debt such as leveraged finance, real estate finance, direct lending and infrastructure. In a ranking of global private debt managers for 2015, M&G ranked third, with a book of over £20.7 billion(14).
(13) | Lipper FMI FundFile, 31 December 2015, based on Europe ex. UK and International region. M&G data sourced internally. |
(14) | Private Debt Investor figures based on amount of capital raised over the last 5 years for discrete private debt strategies. |
46
Multi-asset: M&Gs Multi-Asset team, the Macro Investment Business, is responsible for the management of a range of funds for retail investors and segregated accounts for institutional clients. The team applies a top-down macro approach, with a strong valuation framework, which can be applied across markets and regions in many market conditions.
Real Estate: M&G Real Estate is a leading global property investor and manager covering all major real estate sectors including business space, retail and leisure, residential and alternatives sectors. We actively manage our assets, drawing on our long heritage of expertise and knowledge and our extensive network of contacts. This approach enables the business to identify and capitalise on attractive investment opportunities. We also have a track record of identifying and exploiting real estate development opportunities and for the successful delivery of projects. M&G concluded 2015 with £4.2 billion of global property transactions. This included £2.6 billion of acquisitions with an average deal size of £56 million.
Since launching the UKs first open-ended fund in 1931, we have brought a succession of new investment strategies to the retail and institutional markets. In combination with this tradition of innovative investment thinking, M&G has a proven ability to convert ideas into products that meet our clients needs and attract significant fund flows. It is these two qualities in combination that make M&G distinctive.
M&G saw healthy inflows to its ranges of retail multi-asset funds in 2015, as investors sought flexibility and stability in times of low yields and economic and political uncertainty. During the year, M&G launched a third fund in its popular European multi-asset range: the M&G Prudent Allocation Fund.
In the institutional market, pension funds, sovereign wealth funds and other large clients require stable, long term cashflows that help meet their liabilities. Our reputation for innovation in the institutional market continues to grow, with M&G at the forefront of a number of specialist fixed income markets, including leveraged finance and infrastructure investment. The consistency of our institutional investment returns helped earn M&G the prestigious 2015 Financial News Institutional Asset Management Awards for Infrastructure Manager of the Year for our infrastructure investment arm, Infracapital.
Diversification
M&G has pursued business diversification across:
| asset class: expertise across equities, fixed income, real estate and multi asset strategies; |
| client type: retail customers and institutional clients including pension funds, sovereign wealth funds, and Prudentials own long-term insurance funds; |
| investment strategy: over 60 pooled retail funds covering domestic, global and emerging market strategies, 14 of which have funds under management of over £1 billion, up from 13 in 2014. Institutional clients benefit from a wide-range of pooled and/or segregated fixed income, equity and real estate strategies; and |
| countries. |
The following table shows funds managed by M&G at the dates indicated.
At 31 December £bn | ||||||||||||
2015 | 2014 | 2013 | ||||||||||
Retail fund management |
61 | 74 | 67 | |||||||||
Institutional fund management |
65 | 63 | 59 | |||||||||
Internal fund management |
120 | 127 | 118 | |||||||||
Total |
246 | 264 | 244 |
47
Risk Management
Introduction
The Group aims to help customers achieve their long term financial goals by providing and promoting a range of products and services that meet customer needs, are easy to understand and deliver real value. We recognise that we are implicitly committing to customers that we will maintain a healthy company, and are there to meet our long term commitments to them.
From the shareholders perspective, we generate value by selectively taking exposures to risks that are adequately rewarded and that can be appropriately quantified and managed. The Groups approach is to retain risks where doing so contributes to value creation, the Group is able to withstand the impact of an adverse outcome, and has the necessary capabilities, expertise, processes and controls to manage appropriately the risk.
This section explains the main risks inherent in our business and how we manage those risks, with the aim of ensuring we maintain an appropriate risk profile.
Principles and objective
(Unaudited)
Prudential defines risk as the uncertainty that Prudential faces in successfully implementing its strategies and objectives. This includes all internal or external events, acts or omissions that have the potential to threaten the success and survival of Prudential. As such, material risks will be retained only where this is consistent with the Groups risk appetite framework and its philosophy towards risk-taking.
Risk governance
(Unaudited)
The organisational structures, reporting relationships, delegation of authority, and roles and responsibilities that Group Head Office and the business units establish to make decisions and control their activities on risk related matters form the foundation of Prudentials risk governance. Effective risk governance encompasses individuals, Group-wide functions and committees involved in the management of risk.
Risk framework
(Unaudited)
The Groups risk framework has been developed to monitor and manage the risk of the business at all levels and is owned by the Board. The aggregate Group exposure to market, credit, insurance, liquidity and operational risks is monitored and managed by the Group Risk function whose responsibility it is to seek to ensure the maintenance of an adequate risk exposure and solvency position from the Group economic, regulatory and ratings perspectives.
Our Group Risk Framework requires that all our businesses and functions establish processes for identifying, evaluating and managing the key risks faced by the Group and is based on the concept of the three lines of defence. These comprise risk taking and management, risk control and oversight, and independent assurance.
48
The key risks inherent in the insurance and capital management operations of Prudentials business:
Risks from our investments | Risks from our products | Risks from our business operations | ||
Uncertainty around investment returns can arise through credit risk via the potential of defaults, and market risks resulting from the volatility of asset values as a result of fluctuations in equity prices, interest rates, foreign exchange and property prices. Liquidity risk is also a key area of focus. Regular stress testing is undertaken to ensure the Group is able to generate sufficient cash resources to meet financial obligations as they fall due in business as usual and in stress scenarios. | Insurance risk The processes of determining the price of our products and reporting the results of our long-term business operations require us to make a number of assumptions.
In common with other life insurers, the profitability of our businesses depends on a mix of factors including mortality and morbidity levels and trends, persistency, and claim inflation. |
Operational risk As a group we are dependent on the successful processing of a large number of transactions, utilising various IT systems and platforms across numerous and diverse products.
We also operate under the ever-evolving requirements set out by different regulatory and legal regimes (including tax), as well as utilising a significant number of third parties to distribute products and to support business operations; all of which add to the complexity of the operating model if not properly managed. |
Risk mitigation and hedging
(Unaudited)
We manage our risk profile according to our desired acceptance of risk. To do this, Group Head Office and the business units maintain risk registers that include details of the risks identified and of the controls and mitigating actions used in managing them. Our identified keys risks are set out in the table below.
Key Risks
Risk Type | Risk Definition | |
Market Risk | The risk of loss for our business, or of adverse change in the financial situation, resulting, directly or indirectly, from fluctuations in the level or volatility of market prices of assets and liabilities. | |
Equity | ||
Investment risk | ||
Interest rates | ||
Foreign exchange | ||
Credit Risk | The risk of loss for our business, or of adverse change in the financial situation, resulting from fluctuations in the credit standing of issuers of securities, counterparties and any debtors in the form of default or other significant credit event (eg downgrade or spread widening). | |
Counterparty | ||
Invested credit | ||
Insurance Risk | The risk of loss for our business, or of adverse change in the value of insurance liabilities, resulting from changes in the level, trend, or volatility of a number of insurance risk drivers. This includes adverse mortality, longevity, morbidity, persistency and claim inflation. | |
Mortality/Longevity | ||
Morbidity/Health | ||
Persistency | ||
Medical expense inflation risk | ||
Liquidity Risk | The risk of the Group being unable to generate sufficient cash resources to meet financial obligations as they fall due in business as usual and stress scenarios. | |
Operational Risk | The risk of loss (or unintended gain/profit) arising from inadequate or failed internal processes, or from personnel and systems, or from external events (other than those external events covered under Business Environment Risk). | |
Regulatory and legislative compliance | ||
Third party management | ||
IT and information (including cybersecurity) | ||
Business continuity | ||
Business Environment Risk | Exposure to forces in the external environment that could significantly change the fundamentals that drive the businesss overall strategy | |
Strategic Risk | Ineffective, inefficient or inadequate senior management processes for the development and implementation of business strategy in relation to the business environment and the Groups capabilities. |
49
The drivers of each of the key risks vary by business unit, and depend primarily on the value of locally held products.
Market Risk
Investment Risk
(Audited)
In Prudential UK, investment risk arising out of the assets in the with-profits fund impacts the shareholders interest in future transfers and is driven predominantly by equities in the fund as well as by other investments such as property and bonds. The value of the future transfers is partially protected against equity falls by hedging conducted outside of the fund. The funds large inherited estateestimated at £7.6 billion (representing Solvency II own funds of the UK with-profits funds) as at 31 December 2015 on a Solvency II basiscan absorb market fluctuations and protect the funds solvency. The inherited estate is partially protected against falls in equity markets through an active hedging programme within the fund.
In Asia, our shareholder exposure to equities arises from unit-linked products where revenue is linked to funds under management and on its with-profits businesses where bonuses declared are broadly based on historical and current rates of return on equity.
In Jackson, investment risk arises in relation to the assets backing the policies. In the case of spread business, including fixed annuities, these assets are generally bonds and our shareholder exposure comes from the minimum asset return required to be generated to meet the guaranteed rates of return offered to policyholders. For the variable annuity business, these assets include equities as well as other assets such as bonds. In this case the impact on the shareholder comes from the guarantees on return on investments embedded in variable annuity products. Shareholders exposure to these guarantees is mitigated through a hedging programme, as well as reinsurance. Further measures have been undertaken including re-pricing initiatives and the introduction of variable annuities without guarantees. Furthermore, it is our philosophy not to compete on price; rather, we seek to sell at a price sufficient to fund the cost incurred to hedge or reinsure the risks and to achieve an acceptable return.
Jackson hedges the guarantees on its variable annuity book on an economic basis and, thus, accepts variability in its accounting results in the short term in order to achieve the appropriate economic result. In particular, under Prudentials Group IFRS reporting, the measurement of the Jackson variable annuity guarantees is typically less sensitive to market movements than the corresponding hedging derivatives, which are held at market value. However, depending on the level of hedging conducted regarding a particular risk type, certain market movements can drive volatility in the economic result which may be either more or less significant under IFRS reporting. The Jackson IFRS shareholders equity and US statutory capital are also sensitive to the effects of policyholder behaviour on the valuation of guarantees.
Interest Rate Risk
(Audited)
Long-term rates remain close to historic lows. Products that we offer are sensitive to movements in interest rates. We have already taken a number of actions to de-risk the in-force business as well as re-price and restructure new business offerings in response to historically low interest rates. However, this remains an area of sensitivity and persistently low rates may impact policyholders savings patterns and behaviour.
Interest rate risk arises in our UK business from the need to match cash flows for annuity payments with those from investments; movements in interest rates may have an impact on profits where durations are not perfectly matched. As a result, we aim to match the duration of assets and liabilities as closely as possible and the position is monitored regularly. Under the European Unions Solvency II Directive, additional interest rate exposure is created due to the nature of the construction of this balance sheet, such as the inclusion of the risk margin. The UK business continually assesses the need for any derivative overlays in managing this sensitivity. The with-profits business is exposed to interest rate risk as a result of underlying guarantees. Such risk is largely borne by the with-profits fund but shareholder support may be required in extremis.
In Asia, exposure to interest rate risk arises from the guarantees of some non-unit-linked investment products. This exposure arises because it may not be possible to hold assets which will provide cash flows to match exactly those relating to policyholder liabilities. While this residual asset/liability mismatch risk can be managed, it cannot be eliminated.
50
Jackson is exposed to interest rate risk in its fixed, fixed index and variable annuity books. Movements in interest rates can influence the cost of guarantees in such products, in particular the cost of guarantees may increase when interest rates fall.
Interest rate risk across the entire business is managed through the use of interest rate swaps, interest rate options and hybrid options (options protecting against simultaneous decreases in equity values and interest rates).
Foreign Exchange Risk
(Audited)
We principally operate in Asia, the US and the UK. The geographical diversity of our businesses means that we are inevitably subject to the risk of exchange rate fluctuations. Our operations in the US and Asia, which represent a significant proportion of our operating profit and shareholders funds, generally write policies and invest in assets denominated in local currencies. Although this practice limits the effect of exchange rate fluctuations on local operating results, it can lead to significant fluctuations in our consolidated financial statements when results are expressed in UK Sterling.
We retain revenues locally to support the growth of our business and capital is held in the local currency of the business to meet local regulatory and market requirements, accepting the accounting balance sheet translation risks this can produce. However, in cases where a surplus arising in an overseas operation supports Group capital or where a significant cash remittance is due from an overseas subsidiary to the Group, this exposure is hedged where we believe it is economically optimal to do so. We do not have appetite for significant shareholder exposure to foreign exchange risks in currencies outside the local territory. Where this arises, currency borrowings, swaps and other derivatives are used to manage exposures.
Credit Risk
(Audited)
We invest in fixed income assets in order to match policyholder liabilities and enter into reinsurance and derivative contracts to mitigate various types of risk. As a result, we are exposed to credit and counterparty credit risk across our business. We employ a number of risk management tools to manage credit risk, including limits defined on an issuer/counterparty basis as well as on average credit quality to seek to ensure the diversification of the portfolio and have in place collateral arrangements in derivative transactions. The Group Credit Risk Committee oversees credit and counterparty credit risk across the Group and conducts sector and/or name specific reviews as required. In particular, in 2015 it has conducted sector reviews in the banking, commodities and energy sectors.
Debt and loan portfolio
(Audited)
Our UK business is primarily exposed to credit risk in the shareholder-backed portfolio, with fixed income assets of £32.1 billion. Credit risk arising from a further £44.5 billion of fixed income assets is largely borne by the with-profits fund, although in extremis shareholder support may be required should the with-profits fund become unable to meet its liabilities.
The debt portfolio of our Asia business totalled £28.3 billion at 31 December 2015. Of this, approximately 68 per cent was in unit-linked and with-profits funds with minimal shareholder risk. The remaining 32 per cent is shareholder exposure.
Credit risk arises in the general account of our US business, where £34.1 billion of fixed income assets back shareholder liabilities including those arising from fixed annuities, fixed index annuities and life insurance.
The shareholder-owned debt and loan portfolio of the Groups asset management operations of £2.2 billion as at 31 December 2015 is principally related to Prudential Capital operations. Prudential Capital generates revenue by providing bridging finance, managing investments and operating a securities lending and cash management business for the Prudential Group and our clients.
Certain sectors have seen specific pressure during 2015 and into early 2016. The Groups credit exposure to the oil and gas sector represents approximately 4 per cent or £3.1 billion of the shareholder credit portfolio. Prolonged, depressed oil prices are expected to exert downward rating pressure within the sector, which is being monitored
51
closely through Group risk processes and the Group Credit Risk Committee. The Groups credit exposure to the metal and mining sector represents 1 per cent of the total shareholder debt portfolio (£78 billion). Similarly, this sector is subject to ongoing monitoring and regular management information reporting to the Groups risk committees.
Further details of the composition and quality of our debt portfolio, and exposure to loans, can be found in the IFRS financial statements.
Group sovereign debt
(Audited)
Sovereign debt represented 17 per cent or £12.8 billion of the debt portfolio backing shareholder business at 31 December 2015 (31 December 2014: 15 per cent or £11.0 billion). 44 per cent of this was rated AAA and 94 per cent investment grade (31 December 2014: 43 per cent AAA, 95 per cent investment grade). At 31 December 2015, the Groups shareholder-backed businesss holding in Eurozone sovereign debt(14a) was £546 million. 75 per cent of this was AAA rated (31 December 2014: 82 per cent AAA rated). We do not have any sovereign debt exposure to Greece.
Bank debt exposure and Counterparty Credit Risk
(Audited)
Our bank exposure is a function of our core investment business, as well as of the hedging and other activities undertaken to manage our various financial risks. Given the importance of our relationship with our banks, exposure to the banking sector is a key focus of management information provided to the Groups risk committees and the Board.
The exposures held by the shareholder-backed business and with-profits funds in sovereign debt and bank debt securities at 31 December 2015 are given in Note C3.3(f) of the Groups IFRS financial statements.
Our exposure to derivative counterparty and reinsurance counterparty credit risk is managed using an array of risk management tools, including a comprehensive system of limits.
Where appropriate, we reduce our exposure, purchase credit protection or make use of additional collateral arrangements to control our levels of counterparty credit risk. At 31 December 2015, shareholders exposure to corporate debt by rating and sector is shown below:
| 95 per cent of the Shareholder portfolio is investment grade rated. In particular, 67 per cent of the portfolio is rated A- and above(14b). |
| The Groups Shareholder portfolio is well diversified: no individual sector makes up more than 10 per cent of the total portfolio (excluding the financial and utilities sectors). |
Insurance Risk
(Audited)
Insurance risk constitutes a sizeable proportion of the Groups exposure; the profitability of our businesses depends on a mix of factors including mortality and morbidity levels and trends, persistency, investment performance and claim inflation.
Longevity risk (peoples propensity to live longer) is a significant contributor to our insurance risk exposure and is also capital intensive under the Solvency II regime. One tool used to manage this risk is reinsurance. During 2015, we completed deals on a number of tranches of bulk and retail annuity liabilities when terms were sufficiently attractive and aligned with our risk management framework. The recently enhanced pensions freedoms in the UK have greatly reduced the demand for retail annuities and further liberalisation is anticipated. However, given our significant UK annuity portfolio, the assumptions that we make about future rates of mortality improvement will remain key to the measurement of insurance liabilities and to the assessment of any subsequent reinsurance transactions.
We continue to conduct research into longevity risk using both experience from our annuity portfolio and industry data. Although the general consensus in recent years is that people are living longer, there remains considerable volatility in year-on-year longevity experience, which is why we need expert judgement in setting our longevity assumptions.
(14a) | Excludes Groups proportionate share in joint ventures and unit-linked assets and holdings of consolidated unit trust and similar funds. |
(14b) | In the Shareholder exposure by rating: 75 per cent of non-rated assets are internally rated, privately held loans. |
52
Morbidity risk is mitigated by appropriate underwriting when policies are issued and claims are received. Our morbidity assumptions reflect our recent experience and expectation of future trends for each relevant line of business.
In Asia, a key assumption is the rate of medical inflation, typically in excess of general price inflation. This is the risk that the expenses of medical treatment increase more than expected, so that the medical claim cost passed on to Prudential is much higher. Medical expense inflation risk is best mitigated through retaining the right to re-price our products each year and by having suitable overall claim limits within our policies, either limits per type of claim or in aggregate across policies.
Our persistency assumptions similarly reflect recent experience for each relevant line of business, and future expectations. Persistency risk is mitigated by appropriate training and sales processes and managed locally post-sale through regular experience monitoring and the identification of common characteristics of poor persistency business. Where appropriate, allowance is also made for the relationshipeither assumed or historically observedbetween persistency and investment returns, and for the resulting additional risk. Modelling this dynamic policyholder behaviour is particularly important when assessing the likely take-up rate of options embedded within product features.
Liquidity Risk
(Audited)
The Group has significant internal sources of liquidity which are sufficient to meet all of its expected requirements, for a period of at least 12 months from the date the financial statements are approved, without having to make use of external funding. In aggregate the Group currently has £2.6 billion of undrawn committed facilities, expiring in 2020. In addition, the Group has access to liquidity via the debt capital markets. We also have in place an unlimited commercial paper programme and have maintained a consistent presence as an issuer in this market for the last decade.
Liquidity uses and sources have been assessed at the Group and at a business unit level under base case and stressed assumptions. The liquidity resources available and the subsequent Liquidity Coverage Ratio are regularly monitored and are assessed to be sufficient.
Operational Risk
(Unaudited)
The Group does not actively seek to take operational risk to generate returns. Instead, it accepts a level of risk whereby the controls in place should prevent material losses, but should also not excessively restrict business activities. Direct and/or indirect financial losses are likely to arise if there is a failure to develop, implement and monitor appropriate controls.
For each business unit, accountabilities for operational risk management and oversight are based on the principles of the three lines of defence model of risk taking and management, risk control and oversight, and independent assurance. The approach adopted is proportional to the size, nature and complexity of the business unit and the risks it manages.
We have an operational risk management framework in place that facilitates both the qualitative and quantitative analysis of operational risk exposures. The output of this framework, in particular management information on key operational risk and control assessments, scenario analysis, internal incidents and external incidents, is reported by the business units and presented to the Group Operational Risk Committee.
This information also supports business decision-making and lessons-learned activities, the ongoing improvement of the control environment, and determination of the adequacy of our corporate insurance programme.
Top Operational Risks
Key areas of focus within the operational risk framework are:
| the risk of non-compliance due to the momentum of regulatory change in both our developed and developing markets, as well as recognising that Prudentials designation as a Global Systemically Important Insurer which requires the Group to comply with additional policy measures including enhanced Group-wide supervision; |
53
| the risk of improper, or mis-selling of Prudential products and the resulting risk of censure from local regulators; |
| the risk of regulatory censure due to poor conduct or weaknesses in systems and controls; |
| the risk of censure for money laundering, sanctions or anti-bribery and corruption failures; |
| the risk that reliance on IT infrastructures which support core activities/processes of the business, could fail or otherwise negatively impact business continuity and scalability needed to support the growth and changing needs of the business; |
| the risk of a significant failure of a third-party provider impacting critical services; |
| the risk of trading, transacting or modelling errors having a material cost across Group; |
| the risk of the Group failing to attract and retain quality senior managers and other key employees; |
| the risk that key people, processes and systems are unable to operate (thus impacting the on-going operation of the business) due to a significant unexpected external event occurring (e.g. a pandemic, terrorist attack, natural disaster, political unrest); and |
| the risk of losses resulting from damage to the firms reputation. This can be either real or perceived reputational damage but which could nevertheless diminish the standing of the organisation in the eyes of key stakeholders (e.g. customers, shareholders), destroy shareholder value, adversely impact revenues or result in significant costs to rectify. |
Cyber Security
Cyber security is an increasingly important risk facing the Group. The risk is that a member of the Group could be the target of a cyber-related attack which could result in disruption to the key operations, make it difficult to recover critical services, damage assets, and compromise data (both corporate and customer). This is a global issue which is rising in prominence across the financial services industry. As a result of Prudentials increasing market profile, the growing interest by customers to interact with their insurance provider and asset manager through the internet and social media, improved brand awareness and the classification of Prudential as a Global Systemically Important Insurer, there is an increased likelihood of Prudential being considered a target by cyber criminals. A number of industry, company-wide and local business unit-specific initiatives are underway in response to this risk.
Business environment and strategic risks
(Unaudited)
Global Regulatory and Political Risk
There are a number of on-going policy initiatives and regulatory developments that are having, and will continue to have, an impact on the way Prudential is supervised. These include addressing Financial Conduct Authority reviews, on-going engagement with the Prudential Regulation Authority and includes the work of the Financial Stability Board and standard-setting institutions such as the International Association of Insurance Supervisors.
The International Association of Insurance Supervisors has various initiatives. On 18 July 2013, it published a methodology for identifying Global Systemically Important Insurers, and a set of policy measures that will apply to them, which the Financial Stability Board endorsed. Groups designated as a Global Systemically Important Insurer are subject to additional regulatory requirements, including enhanced group-wide supervision, effective resolution planning, development of a Systemic Risk Management Plan, a Recovery Plan and a Liquidity Risk Management Plan. Prudentials designation as a Global Systemically Important Insurer was reaffirmed on 3 November 2015. Prudential is monitoring the development and potential impact of the policy measures and is continuing to engage with the Prudential Regulation Authority on the implications of the policy measures and Prudentials designation as a Global Systemically Important Insurer.
The Global Systemically Important Insurer regime also introduces two types of capital requirements. The first, a Basic Capital Requirement, is designed to act as a minimum group capital requirement and the second, a Higher Loss Absorption requirement reflects the drivers of the assessment of Global Systemically Important Insurer designation. The International Association of Insurance Supervisors intends for these requirements to take effect from January 2019, but Global Systemically Important Insurers will be expected to report privately to their group-wide supervisors in the interim.
The International Association of Insurance Supervisors is also developing a Common Framework (ComFrame) which is focused on the supervision of large and complex Internationally Active Insurance Groups. ComFrame will establish a set of common principles and standards designed to assist regulators in addressing risks that arise
54
from insurance groups with operations in multiple jurisdictions. As part of this, work is underway to develop a global Insurance Capital Standard that would apply to Internationally Active Insurance Groups. Once the development of the Insurance Capital Standard has been concluded, it is intended to replace the Basic Capital Requirement as the minimum group capital requirement for Global Systemically Important Insurers. Further consultations on the Insurance Capital Standard are expected over the coming years and a version of the Insurance Capital Standard is expected to be adopted as part of ComFrame in late 2019.
The International Association of Insurance Supervisors Insurance Core Principles, which provide a globally accepted framework for the supervision of the insurance sector and ComFrame evolution, are expected to create continued development in both prudential and conduct regulations over the next two to three years, particularly in the emerging markets of Asia.
The European Unions Solvency II Directive came into effect on 1 January 2016. The European Commission will review elements of the Solvency II legislation from 2016 onwards including a review of the Long Term Guarantee measures by 1 January 2021.
Similar national and regional efforts to curb systemic risk and promote financial stability are also underway in certain jurisdictions in which Prudential operates, including the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act in the US, and other European Union legislation related to the financial services industry.
The UK Government has committed to holding a remain/leave referendum on EU membership which will be held on 23 June 2016. The possible withdrawal of the UK from the EU would have political, legal and economic ramifications for both the UK and the EU, although these are expected to be more pronounced on the UK.
In the US, the implementation of the Department of Labor rules introducing new fiduciary obligations for distributors of investment products to holders of regulated accounts has the potential to dramatically reshape the distribution of retirement products. Jacksons strong relationships with distributors, history of product innovation and efficient operations should help mitigate any impacts.
Emerging Risks
(Unaudited)
Generally, emerging risks are qualitative in nature and are not amenable to modelling using statistical techniques. The emerging risk identification process at Prudential seeks to leverage the expertise of the organisation through a combination of top-down and bottom-up assessments of risks. Following two years of development, the emerging risk identification process is now well-embedded across the Group.
The use of brainstorming sessions at various levels of the organisation is used as a central pillar of the emerging risk identification process to identify, develop and challenge potential emerging risks. Input is also taken from external speakers, forums and databases.
The Group has also sought to maintain contacts with industry experts and peers to benchmark and refine the emerging risk management process. For example, Prudential has been a member of the Emerging Risk Initiative at the CRO Forum for two years, and chaired this initiative for 2015.
Risk factors
(Unaudited)
Our disclosures covering risk factors can be found in Item 3, Key informationRisk Factors.
Risk Management Cycle and Governance
Our Group Risk Framework requires that all our businesses and functions establish processes for identifying, evaluating and managing the key risks faced by the Group. The framework is based on the concept of three lines of defence comprising risk taking and management, risk control and oversight and independent assurance.
Risk identification
(Unaudited)
The Groups risk profile is a robust assessment of the principal risks facing the Group, including those that would threaten its business model, future performance, solvency or liquidity. The risk profile is a key output from the risk
55
identification and risk measurement processes, and is used as a basis for setting Group-wide limits, management information, assessment of solvency needs, and determining appropriate stress and scenario testing.
An annual top-down identification of our key risks assesses the risks that have the greatest potential to impact the Groups operating results and financial condition. The bottom up approach of risk identification is more granular and refers to the processes by which the business units identify, assess and document risks, with the appropriate coordination and challenge from the risk functions.
The Group Own Risk and Solvency Assessment Report pulls together the analysis performed by a number of risk and capital management processes, which are embedded across the Group, and provides quantitative and qualitative assessments of the Groups risk profile, risk management and solvency needs on a forward looking basis. The scope of the Group Own Risk and Solvency Assessment Report covers the full known risk universe of the Group.
Insurers are also required to undertake Reverse Stress Testing, which requires firms to work backwards from an assumed point of business model failure, to identify the stress scenarios that could result in such adverse outcomes. Each firm must then consider whether the likelihood of these scenarios, taking into account likely management actions, is consistent with its risk appetite and, if not, must initiate actions to address any inconsistencies. The actions considered form a part of our Recovery Plan.
Risk measurement and assessment
(Unaudited)
All identified risks are assessed based on an appropriate methodology for that risk. All quantifiable risks which are material and mitigated by holding capital are modelled in the Groups Internal Model, which is used to determine capital requirements under the Solvency II Pillar 1 and economic capital bases. Governance arrangements are in place to support the internal model. This includes independent validation and process and controls around model changes and limitations.
Manage and control
(Unaudited)
The control procedures and systems established within the Group are designed to manage the risk of failing to meet business objectives. This can of course only provide reasonable and not absolute assurance against material misstatement or loss. They focus on aligning the levels of risk-taking with the achievement of business objectives.
The management and control of risks are set out in the Group risk policies. These risk policies define:
| the Groups risk appetite in respect of material risks, and the framework under which the Groups exposure to those risks is limited; |
| the processes to enable Group senior management to effect the measurement and management of the Group material risk profile in a consistent and coherent way; and |
| the flows of management information required to support the measurement and management of the Group material risk profile and to meet the needs of external stakeholders. |
Monitoring and reporting
(Unaudited)
The management information received by the Group Risk Committees and the Board is tailored around the risks identified in the annual top-down process, and also covers on-going developments in other key and emerging risks.
Risk Appetite and Limits
(Audited)
The extent to which the Group is willing to take risk in the pursuit of its objective to create shareholder value is defined by a number of risk appetite statements, operationalised through measures such as limits, triggers and indicators.
56
Risk appetite has been set at a Group aggregate level and by risk type, and covers all risks to shareholders, including those from participating and third party business. The qualitative statements are operationalised down to the local business units through measures such as limits, triggers and indicators, and cover the most significant exposures to the Group, particularly those that could impact the Groups aggregate risk appetite metrics.
The Group Risk function is responsible for reviewing the scope and operation of these measures at least annually, to determine that they remain relevant. On the recommendation of the Group Risk Committee, the Board approves all changes made to the Groups risk appetite framework.
We define and monitor aggregate risk limits based on financial and non-financial stresses for our earnings volatility, liquidity and capital requirements as follows:
Earnings volatility:
The objectives of the aggregate risk limits seek to manage that:
| the volatility of earnings is consistent with the expectations of stakeholders; |
| the Group has adequate earnings (and cash flows) to service debt, expected dividends and to withstand unexpected shocks; and |
| earnings (and cash flows) are managed properly across geographies and are consistent with funding strategies. |
The two measures used to monitor the volatility of earnings are IFRS operating profit and EEV operating profit, although IFRS and EEV total profits are also considered.
Liquidity:
The objective is to monitor that the Group is able to generate sufficient cash resources to meet financial obligations as they fall due in business as usual and stressed scenarios.
Capital requirements:
The limits aim to manage that:
| the Group meets its internal economic capital requirements; |
| the Group achieves its desired target rating to meet its business objectives; and |
| supervisory intervention is avoided. |
The two measures used to define the limits are Solvency II capital requirements and internal economic capital requirements. In addition, outside the UK capital requirements are monitored on local statutory bases.
We use an internal economic capital assessment calibrated on a multi-term basis to monitor our capital requirements across the Group. This approach considers, by risk drivers, the timeframe over which each risk can threaten the ability of the Group to meet claims as they fall due, allowing for realistic diversification benefits. This assessment provides valuable insights into our risk profile and for continuing to maintain a strong capital position.
With the introduction of Solvency II, the existing European Union Insurance Group Directives risk appetite statement has been replaced with a Solvency II Pillar 1 risk appetite. As part of our annual business planning cycle the risk appetite framework plays an integral role. The Group Risk Committee is responsible for reviewing the risks inherent in the Groups business plan and for providing the Board with input on the risk/reward trade-offs implicit therein. This review is supported by the Group Risk function, which uses submissions from our local business units to calculate the Groups aggregated position (allowing for diversification effects between local business units) relative to the aggregate risk limits.
Risk policies
(Unaudited)
Risk policies set out specific requirements for the management of, and articulate the risk appetite for, key risk types. There are core risk policies for credit, market, insurance, liquidity and operational risks and a number of internal control policies covering, internal model risk, underwriting, dealing controls and tax risk management.
57
They form part of the Group Governance Manual, which was developed to make a key contribution to the sound system of internal control that we maintain in line with the UK Corporate Governance Code and the Hong Kong Code on Corporate Governance Practices.
Risk Culture
(Unaudited)
The increasing regulatory focus on market participants instilling corporate cultures that support prudent management and outcomes for consumers is indelibly linked to what we do and how we do it. The risk culture (as a subset of the broader business culture) is reflected in the values and behaviours the Group displays when managing risk. It therefore permeates throughout the Groups Risk Framework and governance processes.
The Group promotes a responsible risk culture in three main ways:
| By the leadership and behaviours demonstrated by management; |
| By building skills and capabilities to support risk management; and |
| By including risk management (through the balance of risk with profitability and growth) in the performance evaluation of individuals. |
Senior management leadership
Senior management promote a responsible culture of risk management by emphasising the importance of balancing risk with profitability and growth in decision making, while seeking to ensure compliance with regulatory requirements and internal policies. As part of this, they encourage all employees to be risk-aware and to take personal responsibility for identifying and helping to address risk issues.
Building skills and capabilities
The Group works to build skills and capabilities in risk management, which are needed by both senior management and risk management specialists, while attempting to allocate scarce resources appropriately.
Performance management
The Group includes risk management measures that balances risk taken with profitability and growth achieved in the performance evaluation of key individuals, including both senior management and those directly responsible for risk management (objectives may be quantitative or qualitative as appropriate).
The remuneration strategy at Prudential is designed to be consistent with its risk appetite, and the Group Chief Risk Officer advises the Group Remuneration Committee on adherence to our risk framework and appetite.
58
(Unaudited)
Solvency II capital position at 31 December 2015
The estimated Group Solvency II surplus at 31 December 2015 was £9.7 billion, before allowing for the 2015 second interim ordinary and special dividend.
Estimated Group Solvency II capital position | 31 December 2015 £bn |
|||
Own funds |
20.1 | |||
Solvency capital requirement |
10.4 | |||
Surplus |
9.7 | |||
Solvency ratio |
193% |
These results allow for:
| Capital in Jackson in excess of 250 per cent of the US local Risk Based Capital requirement. As agreed with the Prudential Regulation Authority, this is incorporated in the result above as follows: |
| Own funds: represent Jacksons local US Risk Based available capital less 100 per cent of the US Risk Based Capital requirement (Company Action Level); and |
| Solvency Capital Requirement: represent 150 per cent of Jacksons local US Risk Based Capital requirement (Company Action Level); |
| Non-recognition of a portion of Solvency II surplus capital relating to the Groups Asian life operations, reflecting regulatory prudence; |
| Matching adjustment for UK annuities, based on the 31 December 2015 calibration published by the European Insurance and Occupational Pensions Authority; and |
| Transitional measures which have the effect of preserving the Solvency II surplus for our UK business at the same level as under Solvency I, for business written before 1 January 2016. |
The Groups Solvency II capital surplus excludes:
| Diversification benefits between Jackson and the rest of the Group; |
| Surplus in ring-fenced with-profits funds including the shareholders share of the estate of with-profits funds; and |
| Surplus in pension funds. |
Analysis of movement in capital position
We previously reported our economic capital results at year end 2013 and year end 2014 before there was certainty in the final outcome of Solvency II and before we received internal model approval. The Solvency II results now reflect the output from our approved internal model under the final Solvency II rules. Allowing for this change in basis, the movement from the previously reported economic capital basis solvency surplus at 31 December 2014 to the Solvency II approved internal model surplus at 31 December 2015 is set out in the table below:
Analysis of movement in Group surplus | £bn | |||
Economic capital surplus as at 1 January 2015 |
9.7 | |||
Operating experience |
2.4 | |||
Non-operating experience (including market movements) |
(0.6) | |||
Other capital movements |
||||
Subordinated debt issuance |
0.6 | |||
Foreign currency translation impacts |
0.2 | |||
Dividends paid |
(1.0) | |||
Methodology and calibration changes |
||||
Changes to Own Funds (net of transitionals) and Solvency Capital Requirement calibration strengthening |
(0.2) | |||
Effect of partial derecognition of Asia Solvency II surplus |
(1.4) | |||
Estimated solvency II surplus as at 31 December 2015 |
9.7 |
59
The movement in Group surplus over 2015 is driven by:
| Operating experience of £2.4 billion: generated by in-force business and new business written in 2015, including £0.4 billion of benefit from the specific actions taken in the second half of the year to position the balance sheet more efficiently under the new Solvency II regime; |
| Non-operating experience of £0.6 billion: mainly arising from negative market experience during the year; and |
| Other capital movements: comprising an increase in capital from subordinated debt issuance, a gain from positive foreign currency translation effects and a reduction in surplus from payment of dividends. |
In addition, the methodology and calibration changes arose as part of the internal model approval process and related to:
| A £0.2 billion reduction in surplus due to an increase in the Solvency Capital Requirement from strengthening of internal model calibrations, mainly relating to longevity risk, operational risk, credit risk and correlations, and a corresponding increase in the risk margin, which is partially offset by UK transitionals; and |
| A £1.4 billion reduction in surplus due to the negative impact of Solvency II rules for contract boundaries and a reduction in the capital surplus of the Groups Asian life operations, as agreed with the Prudential Regulation Authority. |
The change in US treatment from including 150 per cent, rather than 250 per cent of US Risk Based Capital (Company Action Level) in the Group Solvency Capital Requirement, is offset by a corresponding reduction in the Group Own Funds and therefore has no impact on surplus despite the positive impact on the solvency ratio.
The impacts above, including the impact of the change in basis from economic capital to Solvency II, represent an overall reduction in the Group solvency ratio from 218 per cent to 193 per cent.
Analysis of movement in Group solvency position (£ billion) | Own Funds |
Solvency Capital Requirement |
Surplus | Solvency ratio |
||||||||||||
Economic capital position at 1 January 2015 |
17.9 | 8.2 | 9.7 | 218% | ||||||||||||
Capital generation and other movements |
2.0 | 0.4 | 1.6 | 13% | ||||||||||||
Methodology and calibration changes |
||||||||||||||||
Changes to Own Funds (net of transitionals) and Solvency Capital Requirement calibration strengthening | 2.3 | 2.5 | (0.2) | (32)% | ||||||||||||
Effect of partial derecognition of Asia Solvency II surplus |
(1.4) | - | (1.4) | (12)% | ||||||||||||
US Risk Based Capital treatment |
(0.7) | (0.7) | - | 6% | ||||||||||||
Estimated Solvency II position at 31 December 2015 |
20.1 | 10.4 | 9.7 | 193% |
Analysis of Group Solvency Capital Requirements
The split of the Groups estimated Solvency Capital Requirement by risk type including the capital requirements in respect of Jacksons risk exposures based on 150 per cent of US Risk Based Capital requirements (Company Action Level) but with no diversification between Jackson and the rest of the Group, is as follows:
31 December 2015 |
31 December 2015 |
|||||||
Split of the Groups estimated Solvency Capital Requirements | % of Solvency Requirements |
% of Solvency Requirements |
||||||
Market |
55% | 72% | ||||||
Equity |
11% | 16% | ||||||
Credit |
28% | 47% | ||||||
Yields (interest rates) |
13% | 6% | ||||||
Other |
3% | 3% | ||||||
Insurance |
27% | 20% | ||||||
Mortality/morbidity |
5% | 2% | ||||||
Lapse |
14% | 14% | ||||||
Longevity |
8% | 4% | ||||||
Operational/expense |
11% | 7% | ||||||
FX translation |
7% | 1% |
60
Reconciliation of IFRS equity to Group Solvency II Own Funds
Reconciliation of IFRS equity to Group Solvency II Own Funds | 31 December 2015 £bn |
|||
IFRS shareholders equity |
13.0 | |||
Restate US insurance entities from IFRS onto local US statutory basis |
(1.5) | |||
Remove DAC, goodwill & intangibles |
(3.7) | |||
Add subordinated-debt |
4.4 | |||
Impact of risk margin (net of transitionals) |
(2.5) | |||
Add value of shareholder-transfers |
3.1 | |||
Liability valuation differences |
8.6 | |||
Increase in value of net deferred tax liabilities (resulting from valuation differences above) |
(0.9) | |||
Other |
(0.4) | |||
Estimated Solvency II Own Funds |
20.1 |
The key items of the reconciliation are:
| £1.5 billion represents the adjustment required to the Groups shareholders funds in order to convert Jacksons contribution from an IFRS basis to the local statutory valuation basis. This item also reflects a derecognition of Own Funds of £0.7 billion, equivalent to the value of 100 per cent of Risk Based Capital requirements (Company Action Level), as agreed with the Prudential Regulation Authority; |
| £3.7 billion due to the removal of DAC, goodwill and intangibles from the IFRS balance sheet; |
| £4.4 billion due to the addition of subordinated debt which is treated as available capital under Solvency II but as a liability under IFRS; |
| £2.5 billion due to the inclusion of a risk margin for UK and Asia non-hedgeable risks, net of transitionals, all of which are not applicable under IFRS; |
| £3.1 billion due to the inclusion of the value of future shareholder transfers from with-profits business (excluding the shareholders share of the with-profits estate, for which no credit is given under Solvency II), which is excluded from the determination of the Groups IFRS shareholders funds; |
| £8.6 billion due to differences in insurance valuation requirements between Solvency II and IFRS, with Solvency II Own Funds partially capturing the value of in-force business which is excluded from IFRS; |
| £0.9 billion due to the impact on the valuation of deferred tax assets and liabilities resulting from the other valuation differences noted above; and |
| £0.4 billion due to other items, including the impact of revaluing loans, borrowings and debt from IFRS to Solvency II. |
Sensitivity analysis
Solvency II as a measure of regulatory capital is more volatile than under the previous Solvency I regime. At 31 December 2015, the estimated sensitivity of the Group Solvency II surplus to significant changes in market conditions is as follows:
| An instantaneous 20 per cent fall in equity markets would reduce surplus by £1.0 billion and reduce the solvency ratio to 186 per cent; |
| A 40 per cent fall in equity markets (comprising an instantaneous 20 per cent fall followed by a further 20 per cent fall over a four-week period) would reduce surplus by £1.8 billion and reduce the solvency ratio to 179 per cent; |
| A 50 basis points reduction in interest rates (subject to a floor of zero and allowing for transitional recalculation) would reduce surplus by £1.1 billion and reduce the solvency ratio to 179 per cent; |
| A 100 basis points increase in interest rates (allowing for transitional recalculation) would increase surplus by £1.1 billion and increase the solvency ratio to 210 per cent; and |
| A 100 basis points increase in credit spreads (with credit defaults of 10 times the expected level in Jackson) would reduce surplus by £1.2 billion and reduce the solvency ratio to 187 per cent. |
UK Solvency II capital position1, 2
On the same basis as above, the estimated UK Solvency II surplus at 31 December 2015 was £3.3 billion. This relates to shareholder-backed business including the shareholders share of future with-profits transfers, but excludes the shareholders share of the estate in line with Solvency II requirements.
61
While the surplus position of the UK with-profits funds remains strong on a Solvency II basis, it is ring-fenced from the shareholder balance sheet and is therefore excluded from both the Group and the UK shareholder Solvency II surplus results. The estimated UK with-profits funds Solvency II surplus at 31 December 2015 was £3.2 billion.
Estimated solvency II capital position 31 December 2015 |
UK £bn |
UK with-profits £bn |
||||||
Own Funds |
10.5 | 7.6 | ||||||
Solvency Capital Requirement |
7.2 | 4.4 | ||||||
Surplus |
3.3 | 3.2 | ||||||
Solvency ratio |
146% | 175% |
The UK with-profits funds surplus has reduced from £3.7 billion at 30 June 2015 to £3.2 billion at 31 December 2015. This is principally due to an increase in the equity backing ratio of the Prudential Assurance Company with-profits sub-fund by 5 per cent, in order to utilise the strength of the fund in line with the Principles and Practices of Financial Management, and strong new business growth.
Reconciliation of UK with-profits funds IFRS unallocated surplus to Solvency II own funds2 | 31 December 2015 £bn |
|||
IFRS unallocated surplus of UK with-profits funds |
10.5 | |||
Existing adjustments from IFRS to Solvency I in Capital Position Statement: |
||||
Value of shareholder transfers |
(2.1) | |||
Other valuation differences |
(0.7) | |||
With-profits fund estate (Solvency I Pillar 1 Peak 2 basis) |
7.7 | |||
Adjustments to Solvency II: |
||||
Risk margin (net of transitional) |
(0.7) | |||
Other valuation differences |
0.6 | |||
Estimated Solvency II Own Funds |
7.6 |
A reconciliation from IFRS to Solvency I is disclosed annually in the Capital Position Statement in the Group IFRS financial statements. The additional reconciling items to Solvency II mainly reflect the risk margin net of transitionals, with other items including differences in the definition of the risk-free rate and the matching adjustment impact for non-profit annuity liabilities within the with-profits funds.
UK shareholder sensitivity analysis
At 31 December 2015, the estimated sensitivity of the UK shareholder Solvency II surplus to significant changes in market conditions is as follows:
| An instantaneous 20 per cent fall in equity markets would reduce surplus by £0.4 billion; |
| 40 per cent fall in equity markets would reduce surplus by £0.8 billion; |
| A 50 basis points reduction in interest rates (subject to a floor of zero and allowing for transitional recalculation) would reduce surplus by £0.7 billion; |
| A 100 basis points increase in interest rates (allowing for transitional recalculation) would increase surplus by £0.9 billion; |
| A 100 basis points increase in credit spreads would reduce surplus by £0.2 billion; and |
| 15 per cent of the UK annuity portfolio downgrading by one whole letter rating would reduce surplus by £0.5 billion. |
Notes:
1. | The UK shareholder capital position represents the consolidated capital position of the shareholder funds of Prudential Assurance Company Ltd and all its subsidiaries. |
2. | The UK with-profits capital position includes the Prudential Assurance Company with-profits sub-fund, the Scottish Amicable Insurance Fund and the Defined Charge Participating Sub-Fund. |
62
IGD capital position at 31 December 2015
Up to 31 December 2015, Prudential was subject to the capital adequacy requirements of the European Union Insurance Groups Directive as implemented by the Prudential Regulation Authority in the UK. The Insurance Groups Directive capital surplus represents the aggregated surplus capital (on a Prudential Regulation Authority consistent basis) of the Groups regulated subsidiaries less the Groups borrowings. No diversification benefit is recognised. We estimate that our Insurance Groups Directive capital surplus is £5.5 billion at 31 December 2015 (before taking into account 2015 second interim ordinary and special dividends), with available capital covering our capital requirements 2.5 times. This compares to a capital surplus of £4.7 billion at the end of 2014 (before taking into account the 2014 final dividend).
The movements in 2015 mainly comprise:
| net capital generation (inclusive of market and foreign exchange movements) mainly through operating earnings (in-force releases less investment in new business, net of tax) of £1.8 billion; and |
| £0.6 billion of subordinated debt issuance; |
Offset by:
| Final 2014 dividend of £0.7 billion and first interim 2015 dividend of £0.3 billion; and |
| External financing costs and other central costs, net of tax, of £0.6 billion; |
IGD surplus represents the accumulation of surpluses across all of our operations based on local regulatory minimum capital requirements with some adjustments, pursuant to the requirements of Solvency I. The calculation does not fully adjust capital requirements for risk nor does it capture the true economic value of assets.
Local statutory capital
All of our subsidiaries continue to hold appropriate capital positions on a local regulatory basis. Jacksons Risk-Based Capital ratio at the end of 2015 was 481 per cent, having remitted £470 million to Group earlier in the year. The Prudential Assurance Company Limited, our main UK operation, has an estimated Solvency II surplus of £3.3 billion in respect of its shareholder business, equivalent to a ratio of 146 per cent. Separately the UK with-profits funds remained well capitalised with an estate value of £7.6 billion(15), covering its solvency capital requirements approximately 1.75 times.
Debt Portfolio
The Group continues to maintain a high quality defensively positioned debt portfolio. Shareholders exposure to credit is concentrated in the UK annuity portfolio and the US general account, mainly attributable to Jacksons fixed annuity portfolio. The credit exposure is well diversified and 98 per cent of our UK portfolio and 96 per cent of our US portfolio are investment grade. We experienced no default losses and reported impairments of £26 million (2014: £7 million) across these two fixed income securities portfolios.
(15) | Representing Solvency II own funds of the UK with-profits funds. |
63
General
The overall financial strength of Prudential and the results, both current and future, of the insurance business are in part dependent upon the quality and performance of the various investment portfolios in the United Kingdom, the United States and Asia.
Prudentials Total Investments
The following table shows Prudentials insurance and non-insurance investments, net of derivative liabilities, at 31 December 2015. In addition, at 31 December 2015 Prudential had £151.6 billion of external funds under management. Assets held to cover linked liabilities relate to unit-linked and variable annuity products. In this table, investments are valued as set out in note A3.1 to the consolidated financial statements in Item 18.
At 31 December 2015 £m | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
UK Insurance |
US Insurance |
Asia Insurance |
Total Insurance |
Asset Management(a) |
Other | Total | Less: assets to cover linked liabilities and external unit holders(b) |
Group excluding assets to cover linked liabilities and external unit holders |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Investment properties | 13,412 | 5 | 5 | 13,422 | - | - | 13,422 | (3,026) | 10,396 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Investments accounted for using the equity method | 434 | - | 475 | 909 | 125 | - | 1,034 | - | 1,034 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Financial investments: | - | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Loans |
3,571 | 7,418 | 1,084 | 12,073 | 885 | - | 12,958 | - | 12,958 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Equity securities |
47,593 | 91,216 | 18,532 | 157,341 | 85 | 27 | 157,453 | (108,452) | 49,001 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Debt securities |
83,101 | 34,071 | 28,292 | 145,464 | 2,204 | 3 | 147,671 | (19,007) | 128,664 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Other investments |
5,486 | 1,715 | 57 | 7,258 | 94 | 1 | 7,353 | (189) | 7,164 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Deposits |
11,226 | - | 773 | 11,999 | 89 | - | 12,088 | (1,049) | 11,039 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Total financial investments | 150,977 | 134,420 | 48,738 | 334,135 | 3,357 | 31 | 337,523 | (128,697) | 208,826 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Total investments | 164,823 | 134,425 | 49,218 | 348,466 | 3,482 | 31 | 351,979 | (131,723) | 220,256 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Derivative liabilities |
(2,125) | (249) | (140) | (2,514) | (283) | (322) | (3,119) | 92 | (3,027) | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Total investments, net of derivative liabilities | 162,698 | 134,176 | 49,078 | 345,952 | 3,199 | (291) | 348,860 | (131,631) | 217,229 |
(a) | Investments held by asset management operations are further split in note C2.4 to the consolidated financial statements in Item 18. |
(b) | Prudentials Group statement of financial position includes the line by line investments of unit-linked and the consolidated unit-trusts and similar funds. In the table above, these amounts have been deducted in deriving the underlying investments in the right-hand column. |
The disclosure below has been provided on a consistent basis as that included in previous Form 20-F submissions, with analysis focusing on the investments attributable to shareholders and consequently excluding those held to cover linked liabilities or attributable to unit holders of consolidated unit trusts and similar funds.
In addition to the detail provided below further analysis is included in the consolidated financial statements, in accordance with IFRS 7 Financial Instruments: Disclosures. The further analysis is included in notes C2 and C3 to Prudentials consolidated financial statements in Item 18.
64
Prudentials Average Investment Return
The following table shows the income from the investments of Prudentials operations, net of derivative liabilities, by asset category for the periods indicated. This table does not include investment income from assets held to cover linked liabilities and those attributable to external unit holders of consolidated unit trusts and similar funds. Average investment return has been calculated using the average of opening and closing balances for the appropriate asset.
Actual Exchange Rate | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
Year Ended 31 December | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
2015 | 2014 | 2013 | ||||||||||||||||||||||
Average investment return |
Amount £m |
Average investment return |
Amount £m |
Average investment return |
Amount £m |
|||||||||||||||||||
Investment properties |
||||||||||||||||||||||||
Net investment income |
5.6% | 562 | 5.7% | 533 | 5.2% | 477 | ||||||||||||||||||
Net realised investment (losses) gains |
2.0% | 201 | 0.4% | 41 | (0.1)% | (6) | ||||||||||||||||||
Net unrealised investment (losses) gains |
6.5% | 659 | 8.9% | 831 | 4.1% | 376 | ||||||||||||||||||
Ending assets |
10,396 | 9,852 | 8,768 | |||||||||||||||||||||
Investments accounted for using the equity method | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
Ending assets |
1,034 | 1,017 | 809 | |||||||||||||||||||||
Loans |
||||||||||||||||||||||||
Net investment income |
5.9% | 764 | 5.9% | 745 | 6.5% | 787 | ||||||||||||||||||
Net realised investment (losses) gains |
(0.3)% | (34) | (0.9)% | (116) | (0.2)% | (21) | ||||||||||||||||||
Net unrealised investment gains |
(0.1)% | (14) | 0.1% | 10 | 0.2% | 19 | ||||||||||||||||||
Ending assets |
12,957 | 12,841 | 12,566 | |||||||||||||||||||||
Equity securities |
||||||||||||||||||||||||
Net investment income |
2.5% | 1,135 | 2.6% | 997 | 2.6% | 929 | ||||||||||||||||||
Net realised investment gains |
2.0% | 901 | 2.3% | 881 | 3.8% | 1,354 | ||||||||||||||||||
Net unrealised investment gains (losses) |
(2.5)% | (1,149) | 1.9% | 743 | 4.9% | 1,766 | ||||||||||||||||||
Ending assets |
49,001 | 42,444 | 35,442 | |||||||||||||||||||||
Debt securities |
||||||||||||||||||||||||
Net investment income |
3.9% | 4,933 | 4.0% | 4,937 | 4.4% | 5,188 | ||||||||||||||||||
Net realised investment gains (losses) |
1.2% | 1,534 | 1.0% | 1,173 | 1.1% | 1,299 | ||||||||||||||||||
Net unrealised investment gains (losses) |
(3.1)% | (3,936) | 5.5% | 6,688 | (3.7)% | (4,308) | ||||||||||||||||||
Ending assets |
128,662 | 127,570 | 117,675 | |||||||||||||||||||||
Other investments (including derivative liabilities) | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
Net investment income |
15.5% | 725 | 16.7% | 812 | 12.5% | 597 | ||||||||||||||||||
Net realised investment (losses) gains |
(8.7)% | (408) | (1.0)% | (50) | (25.5)% | (1,218) | ||||||||||||||||||
Net unrealised investment (losses) gains |
(19.8)% | (927) | 12.9% | 626 | (4.6)% | (218) | ||||||||||||||||||
Ending assets, net of derivative liabilities |
4,138 | 5,228 | 4,484 | |||||||||||||||||||||
Deposits |
||||||||||||||||||||||||
Net investment income |
0.7% | 85 | 0.7% | 85 | 0.8% | 85 | ||||||||||||||||||
Ending assets |
11,039 | 12,158 | 11,191 | |||||||||||||||||||||
Total |
||||||||||||||||||||||||
Net investment income |
3.8% | 8,204 | 4.0% | 8,109 | 4.2% | 8,063 | ||||||||||||||||||
Net realised investment gains (losses) |
1.0% | 2,194 | 1.0% | 1,929 | 0.7% | 1,408 | ||||||||||||||||||
Net unrealised investment gains (losses) |
(2.5)% | (5,367) | 4.4% | 8,898 | (1.2)% | (2,365) | ||||||||||||||||||
Ending assets, net of derivative liabilities |
217,227 | 211,110 | 190,935 |
65
Prudentials Insurance Investment Strategy and Objectives
Prudentials insurance investments support a range of businesses operating in many geographic areas. Each of the operations formulates a strategy based on the nature of its underlying liabilities, its level of capital and its local regulatory requirements.
Internal Funds Under Management
Prudential manages 68 per cent of its group funds principally through its fund management businesses, M&G in the UK, PPM America in the United States and Eastspring Investments in Asia. The remaining 32 per cent of the Groups funds mainly relate to assets held to back unit-linked, unit trust and variable annuity liabilities.
In each of the operations, local management analyses the liabilities and determines asset allocation, benchmarks and permitted deviations from these benchmarks appropriate for its operation. These benchmarks and permitted deviations are agreed with internal fund managers, who are responsible for implementing the specific investment strategy through their local fund management operations.
Investments Relating to UK Insurance Business
Strategy
In the UK, Prudential tailors its investment strategy for long-term business, other than unit-linked business, to match the type of product a portfolio supports. The primary distinction is between with-profits portfolios and non-participating portfolios, which include the majority of annuity portfolios. Generally, the objective is to maximise returns while maintaining investment quality and asset security and adhering to the appropriate government regulations.
Consistent with the product nature, in particular regarding guarantees, the with-profits funds investment strategy emphasises a well-diversified equity portfolio (containing some international equities), real estate (predominantly in the UK), UK and international fixed income securities and cash.
For Prudentials UK pension annuities business and other non-participating business the objective is to maximise profits while ensuring stability by closely matching the cash flows of assets and liabilities. To achieve this matching, the strategy is to invest in fixed income securities of appropriate maturity dates.
For Prudentials unit-linked business, the primary objective is to maximise investment returns subject to following an investment policy consistent with the representations Prudential has made to its unit-linked product policyholders.
Investments
The following table summarises the total investments, net of derivative liabilities, of the UK insurance business at 31 December 2015.
At 31 December 2015 £m | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
SAIF | PAC with- profits fund |
Other | Total | Less: assets to cover linked liabilities and external unit holders(a) |
Total excluding assets to cover linked liabilities and external unit holders |
|||||||||||||||||||
Investment properties | 358 | 10,757 | 2,297 | 13,412 | (3,026) | 10,386 | ||||||||||||||||||
Investment accounted for using the equity method | - | 434 | - | 434 | - | 434 | ||||||||||||||||||
Financial investments: | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
Loans |
61 | 1,998 | 1,512 | 3,571 | - | 3,571 | ||||||||||||||||||
Equity securities |
2,530 | 29,804 | 15,259 | 47,593 | (11,394) | 36,199 | ||||||||||||||||||
Debt securities |
2,331 | 42,204 | 38,566 | 83,101 | (8,930) | 74,171 | ||||||||||||||||||
Other investments |
210 | 4,807 | 469 | 5,486 | (174) | 5,312 | ||||||||||||||||||
Deposits |
399 | 8,383 | 2,444 | 11,226 | (835) | 10,391 | ||||||||||||||||||
Total financial investments |
5,531 | 87,196 | 58,250 | 150,977 | (21,333) | 129,644 | ||||||||||||||||||
Total investments |
5,889 | 98,387 | 60,547 | 164,823 | (24,359) | 140,464 | ||||||||||||||||||
Derivative liabilities |
(76) | (1,436) | (613) | (2,125) | 89 | (2,036) | ||||||||||||||||||
Total investment, net of derivative liabilities | 5,813 | 96,951 | 59,934 | 162,698 | (24,270) | 138,428 |
(a) | Please refer to the notes in the total Group investments table within the Prudentials Total Investments section |
66
The following table shows additional analysis of the investments relating to Prudentials UK insurance business, excluding assets to cover linked liabilities and those attributable to external unit holders of consolidated unit trusts and similar funds, at 31 December 2015. The Other column includes investments relating to solvency capital of unit-linked funds and investments relating to non-life long-term business.
At 31 December 2015 £m | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
With- Profits |
PRIL | SAIF | Other | Total | Total % | |||||||||||||||||||
Investment properties |
8,436 | 1,383 | 358 | 209 | 10,386 | 7.5 | ||||||||||||||||||
Investments accounted for using the equity method | 434 | - | - | - | 434 | 0.3 | ||||||||||||||||||
Financial investments: |
||||||||||||||||||||||||
Loans: |
||||||||||||||||||||||||
Mortgage loans |
727 | 290 | - | 1,218 | 2,235 | |||||||||||||||||||
Policy loans |
5 | - | 3 | - | 8 | |||||||||||||||||||
Other loans |
1,266 | 4 | 58 | - | 1,328 | |||||||||||||||||||
Total loans and receivables |
1,998 | 294 | 61 | 1,218 | 3,571 | 2.6 | ||||||||||||||||||
Equity securities: |
||||||||||||||||||||||||
United Kingdom: |
||||||||||||||||||||||||
Listed |
11,827 | - | 890 | 37 | 12,754 | |||||||||||||||||||
Unlisted |
820 | - | 9 | - | 829 | |||||||||||||||||||
Total United Kingdom |
12,647 | - | 899 | 37 | 13,583 | 9.8 | ||||||||||||||||||
International: |
||||||||||||||||||||||||
United States |
4,241 | - | 373 | 1 | 4,615 | |||||||||||||||||||
Europe (excluding the United Kingdom) |
10,930 | - | 814 | 1 | 11,745 | |||||||||||||||||||
Japan |
2,078 | - | 173 | - | 2,251 | |||||||||||||||||||
Pacific (excluding Japan) |
2,500 | - | 169 | 1 | 2,670 | |||||||||||||||||||
Other |
1,233 | - | 102 | - | 1,335 | |||||||||||||||||||
Total international |
20,982 | - | 1,631 | 3 | 22,616 | 16.3 | ||||||||||||||||||
Total equity securities |
33,629 | - | 2,530 | 40 | 36,199 | 26.1 | ||||||||||||||||||
Debt securities: |
||||||||||||||||||||||||
UK government |
1,761 | 3,342 | 38 | 909 | 6,050 | |||||||||||||||||||
US government |
1,499 | - | 196 | 1 | 1,696 | |||||||||||||||||||
Other |
36,501 | 24,683 | 2,097 | 3,144 | 66,425 | |||||||||||||||||||
Total debt securities |
39,761 | 28,025 | 2,331 | 4,054 | 74,171 | 53.6 | ||||||||||||||||||
Other investments: |
||||||||||||||||||||||||
Other financial investments |
3,274 | - | 185 | 1 | 3,460 | |||||||||||||||||||
Derivative assets |
1,380 | 440 | 25 | 7 | 1,852 | |||||||||||||||||||
Total other investments |
4,654 | 440 | 210 | 8 | 5,312 | 3.8 | ||||||||||||||||||
Deposits |
8,383 | 1,142 | 399 | 467 | 10,391 | 7.5 | ||||||||||||||||||
Total investments |
97,295 | 31,284 | 5,889 | 5,996 | 140,464 | 101.5 | ||||||||||||||||||
Derivative liabilities |
(1,364) | (533) | (76) | (63) | (2,036) | (1.5) | ||||||||||||||||||
Total investment, net of derivative liabilities |
95,931 | 30,751 | 5,813 | 5,933 | 138,428 | 100.0 |
67
Equity Securities
Prudentials UK insurance operations, excluding assets to cover linked liabilities and those attributable to external unit holders of consolidated unit trusts and similar funds, had £36,199 million invested in equities at 31 December 2015. Most of these equities support Prudential Assurances with-profits fund and the SAIF fund, both of which are managed using the same general investment strategy.
The following table shows the geographic spread of this equity portfolio by market value in accordance with the policies described in note A3.1 to the consolidated financial statements in Item 18.
At 31 December 2015 | ||||||||
Market Value £m |
% | |||||||
United Kingdom |
13,583 | 37.5 | ||||||
United States |
4,615 | 12.7 | ||||||
Europe (excluding United Kingdom) |
11,745 | 32.4 | ||||||
Japan |
2,251 | 6.2 | ||||||
Pacific (excluding Japan) |
2,670 | 7.4 | ||||||
Other |
1,335 | 3.8 | ||||||
Total |
36,199 | 100.0 |
The equity holdings of the UK insurance operations are well diversified. Prudential held direct equities in 363 companies at 31 December 2015. The ten largest holdings in direct equities at 31 December 2015 amounted to £3,136 million, accounting for 8.7 per cent of the total equity holdings of £36,199 million supporting the UK insurance operations. The following table shows the market value of the ten largest holdings in direct equities at 31 December 2015.
At 31 December 2015 | ||||||||
Market Value £m |
Percentage of Total UK equities |
|||||||
British American Tobacco |
419 | 1.2 | ||||||
HSBC Holdings |
384 | 1.1 | ||||||
BP |
380 | 1.0 | ||||||
GlaxoSmithKline |
337 | 0.9 | ||||||
Royal Dutch Shell |
331 | 0.9 | ||||||
Vodafone Group |
275 | 0.8 | ||||||
BT |
272 | 0.8 | ||||||
Astrazeneca |
252 | 0.7 | ||||||
Imperial Tobacco |
244 | 0.7 | ||||||
Roche Holdings |
242 | 0.6 | ||||||
Total |
3,136 | 8.7 |
A wide variety of industry sectors are represented in UK insurance operations equity portfolio. At 31 December 2015, within the £36,199 million in equities supporting the UK insurance operations, Prudential had £27,484 million, or 75.9 per cent of the holdings, invested in ten industries. The following table shows the primary industry concentrations based on market value of the portfolio of direct equities relating to the UK insurance business at 31 December 2015.
At 31 December 2015 | ||||||||
Market Value £m |
Percentage of total UK equities |
|||||||
Financial |
7,139 | 19.7 | ||||||
Consumer, non-cyclical |
6,244 | 17.2 | ||||||
Consumer, cyclical |
3,006 | 8.3 | ||||||
Communications |
2,895 | 8.0 | ||||||
Industrial |
2,392 | 6.6 | ||||||
Energy |
1,822 | 5.0 | ||||||
Technology |
1,489 | 4.1 | ||||||
Basic Materials |
1,151 | 3.2 | ||||||
Utilities |
1,070 | 3.0 | ||||||
Diversified |
276 | 0.8 | ||||||
Total |
27,484 | 75.9 |
68
Debt Securities
At 31 December 2015, of the debt securities held by the UK insurance operations, excluding assets to cover linked liabilities and those attributable to external unit holders of consolidated unit trusts and similar funds, 97.7 per cent were issued by corporations and overseas governments other than the US, 8.2 per cent were issued or guaranteed by the UK government and 2.3 per cent were issued or guaranteed by the US government. These guarantees relate only to payment and, accordingly, do not provide protection against fluctuations in market price that may occur during the term of the fixed income securities.
The following table shows the market value of the debt securities portfolio by maturity at 31 December 2015, in accordance with the policies described in note A3.1 to the consolidated financial statements in Item 18.
At 31 December 2015 | ||||||||
Market Value £m |
% | |||||||
Securities maturing: |
||||||||
Within one year |
2,069 | 2.8 | ||||||
Over one year and up to five years |
14,569 | 19.6 | ||||||
Over five years and up to ten years |
13,549 | 18.3 | ||||||
Over ten years and up to fifteen years |
10,650 | 14.4 | ||||||
Over fifteen years |
33,334 | 44.9 | ||||||
Total debt securities |
74,171 | 100.0 |
The following table shows debt securities by rating:
At 31 December 2015 | ||||||||
Market Value £m |
% | |||||||
S&PAAA |
8,495 | 11.5 | ||||||
S&PAA+ to AA |
10,346 | 13.9 | ||||||
S&PA+ to A |
15,217 | 20.5 | ||||||
S&PBBB+ to BBB |
15,578 | 21.0 | ||||||
S&POther |
2,232 | 3.0 | ||||||
51,868 | 69.9 | |||||||
MoodysAaa |
1,710 | 2.3 | ||||||
MoodysAa1 to Aa3 |
6,738 | 9.1 | ||||||
MoodysA1 to A3 |
2,626 | 3.5 | ||||||
MoodysBaa1 to Baa3 |
924 | 1.2 | ||||||
MoodysOther |
178 | 0.2 | ||||||
12,176 | 16.3 | |||||||
Fitch |
506 | 0.7 | ||||||
Other |
9,621 | 13.1 | ||||||
Total debt securities |
74,171 | 100.0 |
In the table above, Standard & Poors (S&P) ratings have been used where available. For securities where S&P ratings are not immediately available, those produced by Moodys and then Fitch have been used as an alternative. Where no external ratings are available, internal ratings produced by the Groups asset management operation, which are prepared on the Companys assessment of a comparable basis to external ratings, are used where possible. Further information is provided in note C3.3 to the consolidated financial statements in Item 18.
69
Real Estate
At 31 December 2015, Prudentials UK insurance operations, excluding assets to cover linked liabilities and those attributable to external unit holders of consolidated unit trusts and similar funds, had £10,386 million of investments in real estate. The following table shows the real estate portfolio by type of investment. The real estate investments are shown at market value in accordance with the policies described in note A3.1 to the consolidated financial statements in Item 18.
At 31 December 2015 | ||||||||
Market Value £m | % | |||||||
Office buildings |
4,363 | 41.9 | ||||||
Shopping centers/commercial |
3,644 | 35.1 | ||||||
Retail warehouses/industrial |
1,608 | 15.5 | ||||||
Development |
434 | 4.2 | ||||||
Other |
337 | 3.3 | ||||||
Total |
10,386 | 100.0 |
Approximately 54.7 per cent of the UK held real estate investment is located in London and Southeast England with 40.3 per cent located throughout the rest of the UK and the remaining 5.0 per cent located overseas.
Investments Relating to Prudentials US Insurance Business
Strategy
The investment strategy of the US insurance operations, for business other than the variable annuity business, is to maintain a diversified and largely investment grade debt securities portfolio that maintains a desired investment spread between the yield on the portfolio assets and the rate credited on policyholder liabilities. Interest rate scenario testing is continually used to monitor the effect of changes in interest yields on cash flows, the present value of future profits and interest rate spreads.
The investment portfolio of the US insurance operations consists primarily of debt securities, although the portfolio also contains investments in mortgage loans, policy loans, common and preferred stocks, derivative instruments, cash and short-term investments and miscellaneous other investments.
Investments
The following table shows total investments, net of derivative liabilities, relating to the US insurance operations at 31 December 2015.
31 December 2015 £m | ||||||||||||
Variable annuity separate account assets |
Fixed annuity, GIC and other business |
Total | ||||||||||
Investment properties |
- | 5 | 5 | |||||||||
Financial investments: |
||||||||||||
Loans |
- | 7,418 | 7,418 | |||||||||
Equity securities* |
91,022 | 194 | 91,216 | |||||||||
Debt securities |
- | 34,071 | 34,071 | |||||||||
Other investments |
- | 1,715 | 1,715 | |||||||||
Total financial investments |
91,022 | 43,398 | 134,420 | |||||||||
Total investments |
91,022 | 43,403 | 134,425 | |||||||||
Derivative liabilities |
- | (249) | (249) | |||||||||
Total investment, net of derivative liabilities |
91,022 | 43,154 | 134,176 |
* | Equity securities include investments in mutual funds, the majority of which are equity-based. |
70
The following table further analyses the investments, net of derivative liabilities, of the US insurance operations, excluding the separate account investments supporting the variable annuity business, at 31 December 2015.
31 December 2015 | ||||||||
£m | % | |||||||
Non-institutional |
||||||||
Investment properties |
5 | - | ||||||
Loans |
6,876 | 15.9 | ||||||
Equity securities |
135 | 0.3 | ||||||
Debt Securities |
||||||||
Corporate securities |
22,673 | 52.6 | ||||||
Government securities |
4,241 | 9.8 | ||||||
Residential mortgage-backed securities |
1,207 | 2.8 | ||||||
Commercial mortgage-backed securities |
2,157 | 5.0 | ||||||
Other debt securities |
436 | 1.0 | ||||||
Total debt securities |
30,714 | 71.2 | ||||||
Other investments |
1,632 | 3.8 | ||||||
Derivative liabilities |
(50) | (0.1) | ||||||
Total non-institutional |
39,312 | 91.1 | ||||||
Institutional |
||||||||
Loans |
542 | 1.3 | ||||||
Equity securities |
59 | 0.1 | ||||||
Debt Securities |
||||||||
Corporate securities |
2,837 | 6.6 | ||||||
Government securities |
- | - | ||||||
Residential mortgage-backed securities |
77 | 0.2 | ||||||
Commercial mortgage-backed securities |
246 | 0.6 | ||||||
Other debt securities |
197 | 0.5 | ||||||
Total debt securities |
3,357 | 7.9 | ||||||
Other investments |
83 | 0.2 | ||||||
Derivative liabilities |
(199) | (0.5) | ||||||
Total institutional |
3,842 | 9.0 | ||||||
Total |
||||||||
Investment properties |
5 | - | ||||||
Loans |
7,418 | 17.2 | ||||||
Equity securities |
194 | 0.4 | ||||||
Debt Securities |
||||||||
Corporate securities |
25,509 | 59.2 | ||||||
Government securities |
4,242 | 9.8 | ||||||
Residential mortgage-backed securities |
1,284 | 3 | ||||||
Commercial mortgage-backed securities |
2,403 | 5.6 | ||||||
Other debt securities |
633 | 1.5 | ||||||
Total debt securities |
34,071 | 79.1 | ||||||
Other investments |
1,715 | 3.9 | ||||||
Derivative liabilities |
(249) | (0.6) | ||||||
Total |
43,154 | 100.0 |
Under IFRS, for the insurance operations, debt securities are shown at fair value and loans are at amortised cost (with the exception of certain policy loans which are held to back liabilities for funds withheld under reinsurance arrangements, which are also accounted on a fair value basis). Equity securities and investment properties are shown at fair value. The fair value of unlisted securities is estimated by Jackson using independent pricing services or analytically determined values.
71
Debt Securities
Corporate Securities
At 31 December 2015, the US insurance operations had £25,509 million of corporate securities representing 59.2 per cent of the US insurance operations total investments excluding separate account investments. Of the £25,509 million, £21,776 million consisted of debt securities that are publicly traded or trade under Rule 144A under the Securities Act of 1933, as amended (Rule 144A) and £3,733 million consisted of investments in non-Rule 144A privately placed fixed income securities.
Rule 144A is a 1990 United States Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) rule that facilitates the resale of privately placed securities that are without SEC registration to qualified institutional investors. The rule was designed to develop a more liquid and efficient institutional resale market for unregistered securities.
For statutory reporting in the US, debt securities are classified into six quality categories specified by the Securities Valuation Office of the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC). The categories range from Class 1 (the highest) to Class 6 (the lowest). Performing securities are designated as Classes 1 to 5. Securities in or near default are designated Class 6. Securities designated as Class 3, 4, 5 and 6 are non-investment grade securities. Generally, securities rated AAA to A by nationally recognised statistical ratings organisations are reflected in Class 1, BBB in Class 2, BB in Class 3 and B and below in Classes 4 to 6. If a designation is not currently available from the NAIC, Jacksons investment adviser, PPM America, provides the designation for the purposes of disclosure below.
The following table shows the quality of the publicly traded and SEC Rule 144A debt securities by NAIC classifications:
2015 | ||||||||
Carrying value | ||||||||
£m | % of total | |||||||
NAIC designation: |
||||||||
1 |
8,777 | 40 | ||||||
2 |
12,151 | 56 | ||||||
3 |
594 | 3 | ||||||
4 |
230 | 1 | ||||||
5 |
22 | - | ||||||
6 |
2 | - | ||||||
21,776 | 100 |
The following table shows the quality of the non-SEC Rule 144A private placement portfolio by NAIC classifications:
2015 | ||||||||
Carrying value | ||||||||
£m | % of total | |||||||
NAIC designation: |
||||||||
1 |
1,775 | 48 | ||||||
2 |
1,832 | 49 | ||||||
3 |
87 | 2 | ||||||
4 |
38 | 1 | ||||||
5 |
1 | - | ||||||
6 |
- | - | ||||||
3,733 | 100 |
Residential Mortgage-Backed Securities
At 31 December 2015, the US insurance operations had £1,284 million of residential mortgage-backed securities, representing 3.0 per cent of US insurance operations total investments, excluding separate account investments. At 31 December 2015, of the £1,284 million, of which £902 million were prime securities with 77 per cent of the balance rated AA.
72
The primary investment risk associated with residential mortgage-backed securities is that a change in the interest rate environment or other economic conditions could cause payment of the underlying obligations to be made slower or quicker than was anticipated at the time of their purchase. If interest rates decline, then this risk is called pre-payment risk and the underlying obligations will generally be repaid quicker when the yields on reinvestment alternatives are lower. Alternatively, if interest rates rise, the risk is called extension risk and the underlying obligations will generally be repaid slower when reinvestment alternatives offer higher returns. Residential mortgage-backed securities offer additional yield to compensate for these risks. The US operations can manage pre-payment risk, in part, by reducing crediting rates on its products.
Commercial Mortgage-Backed Securities
At 31 December 2015, the US insurance operations had £2,403 million of commercial mortgage-backed securities, representing 5.6 per cent of US insurance operations total investments, excluding separate account investments. Of this total, 56.9 per cent were rated AAA (Standard & Poors ratings have been used where available and for securities where S&P ratings are not immediately available, those produced by Moodys and then Fitch have been used as an alternative). Due to the structures of the underlying commercial mortgages, these securities do not present the same pre-payment or extension risk as residential mortgage-backed securities.
Other Debt Securities
At 31 December 2015, the US insurance operations had £633 million of other debt securities, representing 1.5 per cent of US insurance operations total investments, excluding separate account investments.
Loans
At 31 December 2015, loans totaled £7,418 million, representing 17.2 per cent of US insurance operations total investments, excluding separate account investments. Of the total, £4,367 million related to commercial mortgage loans and £3,051 million to policy loans. Of the £3,051 million policy loans, £2,183 million were held to back the liabilities for funds withheld under reinsurance arrangement attaching to the purchase of REALIC in 2012.
Commercial Mortgage Loans
At 31 December 2015, commercial mortgage loans represented 10.1 per cent of US insurance operations total investments, excluding separate account investments. The average loan size is £8.6 million, collateralised by properties located in the United States.
Jackson has addressed the risk of these investments by building a portfolio that is diverse both in geographic distribution and property type.
The property types are mainly industrial, multi-family residential, suburban office, retail and hotel. The breakdown of the market value by property type is as follows:
31 December 2015 % | ||||
Multi-family residential mortgage loans |
29.9 | |||
Industrial mortgage loans |
27.5 | |||
Retail mortgage loans |
17.3 | |||
Suburban office mortgage loans |
11.3 | |||
Hotel mortgage loans |
10.1 | |||
Other loans |
3.9 | |||
Total |
100.0 |
The following table shows the geographic split of the collateral for these loans:
31 December 2015 % | ||||
California |
11.8 | |||
Florida |
6.9 | |||
Texas |
7.0 | |||
Ohio |
6.5 | |||
Washington |
5.2 | |||
Other (sum of all states < 5% each) |
62.6 | |||
Total |
100.0 |
73
Commercial mortgages generally involve more credit risk than residential mortgages due to several factors, including larger loan size, general and local economic conditions, local real estate conditions and the credit quality of the underlying tenants for the properties. Jacksons investment policy and strict underwriting standards are designed to reduce these risks while maintaining attractive yields. In contrast to residential mortgage loans, commercial mortgage loans have minimal or no pre-payment and extension risk.
Policy Loans
Policy loans represented 7.0 per cent of US insurance operations total investments, excluding separate account investments at 31 December 2015. Policy loans are fully secured by individual life insurance policies or annuity policies and are contractual arrangements made under the policy. As described above, £2,183 million out of the £3,051 million policy loans were held to back the liabilities for funds withheld under reinsurance arrangement attaching to the purchase of REALIC in 2012.
Equity Securities
Equity securities supporting US insurance operations, excluding separate account investments, totaled £194 million at 31 December 2015.
Other
Other financial investments of £1,715 million, representing 3.8 per cent of US insurance operations total investments, excluding separate account investments at 31 December 2015 were made up of £810 million of limited partnership interests and derivative assets of £905 million.
The largest investment in the limited partnerships category is a £72 million interest in the PPM America Private Equity Fund. The remainder of this category consists of diversified investments in 162 other partnerships managed by independent money managers that generally invest in various equity and fixed income loans and securities.
Investments Relating to Asian Insurance Business
Prudentials Asian insurance operations investments, excluding assets to cover linked liabilities and those attributable to external unit holders of consolidated unit trusts and similar funds, largely support the business of Prudentials Singapore, Hong Kong and Malaysia operations.
The following table shows Asias investments, net of derivative liabilities, at 31 December 2015. In this table, investments are valued in accordance with the policies described in note A3.1 to the consolidated financial statements in Item 18.
31 December 2015 £m | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
With-profits business |
Unit-linked assets |
Other | Total | Less: assets to cover linked liabilities and external unit holders(a) |
Total excluding assets to cover linked liabilities and external unit holders |
% | ||||||||||||||||||||||
Investment properties |
- | - | 5 | 5 | - | 5 | - | |||||||||||||||||||||
Investments accounted for using the equity method | - | - | 475 | 475 | - | 475 | 1.5 | |||||||||||||||||||||
Financial investments: |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Loans |
540 | - | 544 | 1,084 | - | 1,084 | 3.3 | |||||||||||||||||||||
Equity securities |
6,861 | 10,831 | 840 | 18,532 | (6,036) | 12,496 | 38.2 | |||||||||||||||||||||
Debt securities |
16,335 | 2,809 | 9,148 | 28,292 | (10,076) | 18,216 | 55.6 | |||||||||||||||||||||
Other investments |
28 | 16 | 13 | 57 | (16) | 41 | 0.1 | |||||||||||||||||||||
Deposits |
188 | 214 | 371 | 773 | (214) | 559 | 1.7 | |||||||||||||||||||||
Total financial investments |
23,952 | 13,870 | 10,916 | 48,738 | (16,342) | 32,396 | 98.9 | |||||||||||||||||||||
Total investments |
23,952 | 13,870 | 11,396 | 49,218 | (16,342) | 32,876 | 100.4 | |||||||||||||||||||||
Derivative liabilities |
(124) | (2) | (14) | (140) | 3 | (137) | (0.4) | |||||||||||||||||||||
Total investment, net of derivative liabilities | 23,828 | 13,868 | 11,382 | 49,078 | (16,339) | 32,739 | 100.0 |
(a) | Please refer to notes in the total Group investments table. |
74
Prudential manages interest rate risk in Asia by matching liabilities with fixed interest assets of the same duration to the extent possible. Asian fixed interest markets however generally have a relatively short bond issue term, which makes complete matching challenging. A large proportion of the Hong Kong liabilities are denominated in US dollars and Prudential holds US fixed interest securities to back these liabilities.
Debt Securities
The following table shows rating categorisation of the debt security investments of Prudential Corporation Asias long-term insurance fund, excluding assets to cover linked liabilities and those attributable to external unit holders of consolidated unit trusts and similar funds, at 31 December 2015.
31 December 2015 | ||||||||
Market Value £m | % | |||||||
S&PAAA |
804 | 4.4 | ||||||
S&PAA+ to AA |
6,485 | 35.6 | ||||||
S&PA+ to A |
2,504 | 13.7 | ||||||
S&PBBB+ to BBB |
1,731 | 9.5 | ||||||
S&POther |
1,166 | 6.4 | ||||||
12,690 | 69.6 | |||||||
MoodysAaa |
816 | 4.5 | ||||||
MoodysAa1 to Aa3 |
1,355 | 7.4 | ||||||
MoodysA1 to A3 |
322 | 1.8 | ||||||
MoodysBaa1 to Baa3 |
247 | 1.4 | ||||||
MoodysOther |
14 | 0.1 | ||||||
2,754 | 15.2 | |||||||
Fitch |
834 | 4.6 | ||||||
Other* |
1,938 | 10.6 | ||||||
Total debt securities |
18,216 | 100.0 |
* | Further information is provided in note C3.3 to the consolidated financial statements in item 18. |
Equity Securities
The following table shows a geographic analysis of equity security investments of Asias long-term insurance fund, excluding assets to cover linked liabilities and those attributable to external unit holders of consolidated unit trusts and similar funds, at 31 December 2015.
31 December 2015 | ||||||||
Market Value £m | % | |||||||
Hong Kong |
6,686 | 53.5 | ||||||
Singapore |
4,941 | 39.5 | ||||||
Taiwan |
538 | 4.3 | ||||||
Malaysia |
243 | 1.9 | ||||||
Other |
88 | 0.8 | ||||||
Total |
12,496 | 100.0 |
Description of Property Corporate Property
As at 31 December 2015, Prudentials UK headquartered businesses occupied 71 properties in the United Kingdom, Europe, India and Africa. These properties are primarily offices with some ancillary storage facilities. Prudentials global headquarters is located in London and is held on a freehold basis. Of the remainder, the most significant holdings are offices in London and Reading in England, Stirling in Scotland and Mumbai in India. The property in Stirling is held on a freehold basis, and is leased by the business from PACs with-profits fund. The rest of the properties occupied by Prudentials UK based businesses, in the UK and India, are held leasehold. Elsewhere in Europe, 25 of the properties are occupied leasehold and the rest (eleven) are short-term serviced offices. Seventeen properties are leased in Ghana, Kenya and Uganda, Africa. The leasehold properties range in size from 500 to 225,000 sq. ft. Overall, the UK, Europe, Africa and Asia occupied property portfolio totals approximately 835,000 sq. ft.
75
Prudentials UK headquartered businesses also hold one surplus owned property and approximately 18 surplus leasehold properties in the United Kingdom, spread geographically throughout the country. This surplus accommodation (i.e. not occupied by the Group but including those sublet) totals approximately 263,000 sq. ft. There are also two surplus land holdings in the United Kingdom, totalling 57 acres. A high proportion of the surplus estate has been sublet to third party occupiers generating income for the Group to cover this overhead. As at 31 December 2015 vacancy within the surplus estate stood at 47,000 sq. ft.
In the United States, Prudential owns Jackson National Lifes executive and principal administrative office located in Michigan. Prudential owns a total of eight facilities in Lansing, Michigan, which total approximately 867,665 sq. ft. Prudential also leases premises in Michigan, Colorado, Tennessee, California, Illinois, New York, New Jersey, Georgia, Florida, Wisconsin, Massachusetts, Connecticut, New Hampshire, Pennsylvania, Texas, Maryland and North Dakota for certain of its operations. Prudential holds 31 operating leases with respect to office space, throughout the United States. The leasehold properties range in size from 500180,000 sq. ft. In the United States, Prudential owns and leases a total of approximately 1,489,000 sq. ft. of property. In addition to the owned and leased properties, Prudential also owns a total of 446 acres of surplus land, all located in Lansing, Michigan.
Prudentials United States headquartered business also sublets two surplus office properties in Lansing, Michigan, totalling approximately 14,200 sq. ft., located in one of its owned properties.
In Asia, Prudential owns or leases properties principally in Hong Kong, Singapore, Malaysia, Indonesia, Thailand, the Philippines, China (50 per cent joint venture), Taiwan, Japan, Vietnam, India (26 per cent joint venture), Korea, United Arab Emirates, Myanmar, Laos and Cambodia.
Within these countries, Prudential owns 59 property assets (including those owned by its with-profits funds), ranging from office space to land holdings. The breakdown of these owned assets by country is as follows:
Malaysia (including the Malaysia Takaful joint venture): thirty two individually saleable owned assetsOffice and residential space totalling 307,104 sq. ft.
Philippines: two owned assetsOffice space totalling 4,278 sq. ft.
Singapore: one owned assetOffice space totalling 11,883 sq. ft.
Taiwan: sixteen owned assetsAll surplus land holdings totalling 30,137 sq. ft.
Thailand: eight owned assetsOffice space and surplus land holdings totalling 36,481 sq. ft.
Prudential has (excluding India but including the China and Malaysia Takaful joint ventures), a total of 504 external operating leases, totalling approximately 4.43 million square feet of property.
In India, Prudential holds a minority stake (26 per cent) with ICICI in a joint venture which holds the property interests. The property is occupied by the ICICIPru Life and ICICIPru AMC businesses. The holding comprises approximately 660 leased properties, totalling approximately 930,000 sq. ft. There is one owned and occupied asset comprising approximately 40,000 sq. ft. in Mumbai.
Prudential Corporation Asias real estate strategy involves consolidation of its existing property portfolio to support its local business strategies throughout the region, to take advantage of opportunities in the regional markets in securing long term cost savings for the business while maintaining competitive advantage.
M&G has agreed a pre-let transaction with a developer to lease 323,000 sq ft of offices in Central London, commencing in 2018. The building is currently under construction. The Malaysian headquartered businesses (forming part of Prudential Corporation Asia) have agreed a pre-let transaction with a developer to lease 326,500 sq ft of offices in Kuala Lumpur, commencing in 2018. Building groundworks have commenced.
There have been no other property transactions subsequent to 31 December 2015 which would have a material impact on the financial position of Prudential.
76
Prudential believes that its facilities are suitable for the conduct of its businesses. We periodically review our space requirements and may acquire or lease new space as needed to accommodate any future needs of our businesses. Prudentials operating leases have no material commercial value.
In summary, Prudential owns 43 properties which it also occupies and which are accounted for as owner occupied. These properties are comprised of thirty four in Asia, one in the UK and eight in the US. ICICI Pru also owns and occupies one property in India. The total value of Prudentials owner occupied properties at 31 December 2015 was £411 million. This represents less than 1 per cent of Prudentials total assets.
Prudential is the lessee under 592 operating leases used as office accommodation, comprising 504 leases held by the Asia business, 31 leases held by the US business and 57 leases held by the UK businesses. For the UK based businesses, Prudential holds 13 short-term serviced offices.
Investment Interests
Prudential also holds interests in properties within its investment portfolios accounted for as investment property. At 31 December 2015 the total value of investment properties was £13,422 million and comprised 471 properties held by the UK,3 held in Asia and 6 held by the US. In total they comprised 3.5 per cent of Prudentials total assets. The UK business holdings account for over 99 per cent by value of the total investment properties.
General
There are other significant participants in each of the financial services markets in which Prudential operates. Its competitors include both mutual and stock financial companies. In addition, regulatory and other developments in many of Prudentials markets have blurred traditional financial service industry lines and opened the market to new competitors and increased competition. In some of the Prudentials markets, other companies may have greater financial resources, allowing them to benefit from economies of scale, and may have stronger brands than Prudential does in that market.
The principal competitive factors affecting the sale of Prudentials products in its chosen markets are:
| price and yields offered, |
| financial strength and ratings, |
| commission levels, charges and other expenses, |
| range of product lines and product quality, |
| brand strength, including reputation and quality of service, |
| distribution channels, |
| investment management performance and |
| historical bonus/contract enhancement and bonus interest levels. |
An important competitive factor is the ratings Prudential receives in some of its target markets, most notably in the United States, from recognised rating organisations. The intermediaries with whom the Prudential works, including financial advisers, tied agents, brokers, wholesalers and financial institutions consider ratings as one factor in determining which provider to purchase financial products from.
Prudential offers different products in its different markets in Asia, the United Kingdom and the United States and, accordingly, faces different competitors and different types of competition in these markets. In all of the markets in which Prudential operates, its products are not unique and, accordingly, it faces competition from market participants who manufacture a varying range of similar and identical products.
77
Asia
The competitive landscape across the Asia Pacific region differs widely by geographical market, reflecting differing levels of market maturity and regulation. Prudentials competitors include both the subsidiaries of global life insurers and local domestic (including state-owned) entities. Subsidiaries of global life insurance groups that operate in the Asia Pacific region tend to operate in multiple markets in the region, and some currently have top five market shares in a small number of markets. The majority of local domestic life insurers in the Asia Pacific region remain focused on their core home markets. The developed and liberalised markets of Hong Kong and Singapore are dominated by subsidiaries and branches of global life insurance groups. The developing markets in South East Asia such as Indonesia, Vietnam and the Philippines also see a high level of participation by global life insurance groups. The large and relatively mature markets of Korea and Taiwan are dominated by local domestic insurers. In certain countries with continued foreign ownership restrictions (such as China and India), the life insurance markets are dominated by local domestic insurers or by joint venture entities between global insurance groups and local companies.
The global life insurers that are Prudentials competitors in the Asia Pacific region include AIA, Allianz, Aviva, AXA, and Manulife. Other competitors relevant in some of Prudentials key markets include HSBC Life in Hong Kong, Hanwha Life (formerly Korea Life), Kyobo Life and Samsung Life in Korea, Thai Life in Thailand, Great Eastern in Singapore and Malaysia, and China Life, China Pacific and Ping An in China. Prudentials principal competitors in respect of its fund management operations across the region largely comprise multinational asset manager such as J.P. Morgan Asset Management, Schroders, HSBC Global Asset Management, Franklin Templeton, Fidelity Worldwide Investment and Aberdeen Asset Management.
United States
Prudentials insurance operations in the United States operate under the Jackson brand. Prudential is not affiliated with Prudential Financial, Inc. or its subsidiary, The Prudential Insurance Company of America.
Jacksons competitors in the United States include major stock and mutual insurance companies, mutual fund organisations, banks and other financial services companies. National banks, in particular, may become more significant competitors in the future for insurers who sell annuities, due to current legislation, court decisions and regulatory actions. Jacksons principal life insurance company competitors in the United States include AIG, Prudential Financial, MetLife, Lincoln National, AXA Financial, AEGON and Allianz.
Jackson does not have a career agency sales force to distribute its annuity products in the United States and, consequently, competes for distributors such as banks, broker-dealers and independent agents.
United Kingdom
Prudentials principal competitors include many of the major retail financial services and fund management companies operating in the United Kingdom. These companies include Aviva, Legal & General, Standard Life, Scottish Widows, Aegon, AXA, Just Retirement, Zurich Financial Services, Liverpool Victoria, Fidelity, Invesco Perpetual, Jupiter, Threadneedle, Schroders and BlackRock. Prudential competes with other providers of financial products to be included on financial advisors panels of preferred providers.
Prudential conducts business under the Prudential, Jackson, M&G and Eastspring Investments brand names and logos. It is also the registered owner of over 100 domain names, including www.prudential.co.uk, www.prudentialcorporation-asia.com, www.jackson.com, www.mandg.co.uk, www.eastspringinvestments.com and www.pru.co.uk.
Prudential does not operate in the United States under the Prudential name and there have been long-standing arrangements between it and Prudential Financial, Inc. and its subsidiary, the Prudential Insurance Company of America, relating to their respective uses of the Prudential name. Under these arrangements Prudential Financial Inc has the right to use the Prudential name in the Americas and certain parts of the Caribbean, Japan, Korea and Taiwan and Prudential has the right to use the name everywhere else in the world although third parties have rights to the name in certain countries.
78
The Group is involved in a number of litigation and regulatory issues. These include civil proceedings involving Jackson, which appear to be substantially similar to other class action litigation brought against many life insurers in the US, alleging misconduct in the sale of insurance products. Whilst the outcome of such litigation and regulatory issues cannot be predicted with certainty, the Company believes that their ultimate outcome will not have a material adverse effect on the Groups financial condition, results of operations, or cash flows.
Throughout this annual report, Prudential describes the position and ranking of its overall business and individual business units in various industry and geographic markets. The sources for such descriptions come from a variety of conventional sources generally accepted as relevant business indicators by members of the financial services industry. These sources include information available from the Annuity Specs, Asia Asset Management Magazine, Asosiasi Asuransi Jiwa Indonesia, Association of British Insurers, Association of Vietnamese Insurers, Association of Unit Trusts and Investment Funds, Fitch, Hong Kong Federation of Insurers, Hong Kong Office of the Commissioner of Insurance, HSBC Global Research, Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India, Insurance Services Malaysia Berhad, Investment Management Association, Life Insurance Marketing and Research Association (LIMRA), Life Insurance Association of Malaysia, Life Insurance Association of Singapore, Life Insurance Association of Taiwan, Lipper Inc., Morningstar, Moodys, Neilsen Net Ratings, Propriety Research, Service Quality Management Group, SNL Financial, Standard & Poors, Thai Life Assurance Association, The Asset Benchmark Research, The Advantage Group, The Asset, Townsend and Schupp and UBS.
79
SUPERVISION AND REGULATION OF PRUDENTIAL
Prudentials principal insurance and investment operations are in Asia, the United Kingdom (UK), and the United States (US). Accordingly, it is subject to applicable Asian, UK and US insurance and other financial services regulation which is discussed below.
Since April 2013, the Prudential Regulation Authority (the PRA) has been Prudentials lead supervisor and played a principal role in assessing and ensuring the adequacy of Prudentials solvency and financial stability on a Group-wide basis. Draft UK legislation in the Bank of England Financial Services Bill proposes to change the PRAs status as a separate legal entity and subsidiary of the Bank of England and instead make it an integral part of the Bank of England itself. A new committee of the Bank of England, the Prudential Regulation Committee (the PRC) will be established to exercise the functions of the PRA. It is anticipated that the draft Bill will be enacted and come into force in the spring of 2016. The PRA brand and objectives will remain unchanged.
The regulators supervising the Group do so on a cross-border basis through a regulatory college. The college meets at an annual event hosted by the PRA and includes a number of non-UK regulators who supervise Prudentials overseas operations, as well as representatives from the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) and European Insurance and Occupational Pensions Authority (EIOPA). In 2015, other participants included representatives from regulators in Singapore, Taiwan, Hong Kong, Malaysia, Ireland and Michigan (US). The annual PRA college process began in 2014 and EIOPA has full participation rights. The aim of the college is to enhance cooperation and coordination of activities between the Groups key regulators.
As well as coordinating EU-level local regulators and hosting the college described above, since both Prudentials parent company and a significant proportion of its global insurance operations are in the UK, the PRA plays an important coordinating role in regulatory initiatives at a global level. This role is less formal than within the EU and depends principally on the various memoranda of understanding signed with non-EU regulators, including in the US and Asia. In consequence, although the PRAs role as a lead supervisor does not restrict the role of individual local regulators or override the local insurance and other financial services regimes described in the following sections, the PRAs rules and its regulatory agenda impact Prudentials operations globally.
Moreover, because the UK regulatory framework is considerably shaped and influenced by regulations, directives and subsidiary legislation and rules emanating from the EU, the significant Group-wide impact of such rules may, at times, result in legal and regulatory developments in the EU having a significant impact on the business and operations of the Group as a whole.
Global Regulatory Developments and Trends
There are a number of ongoing policy initiatives and regulatory developments at a global level that are having, and will continue to have, an impact on the way Prudential is supervised. These include the work of the Financial Stability Board (FSB) (an international body established to coordinate, develop and promote effective regulatory, supervisory and other financial sector policies in the interests of financial stability) and the work of standard-setting institutions such as the International Association of Insurance Supervisors (IAIS).
The IAIS has various initiatives which are detailed in this section. On 18 July 2013, it published a methodology for identifying G-SIIs, and a set of policy measures that will apply to them, which the FSB endorsed. Groups designated as a G-SII are subject to additional regulatory requirements, including enhanced group-wide supervision, effective resolution planning, development of a Systemic Risk Management Plan, a Recovery Plan and a Liquidity Risk Management Plan. Prudentials designation as a G-SII was reaffirmed on 3 November 2015. Prudential is monitoring the development and potential impact of the policy measures and is continuing to engage with the PRA on the implications of the policy measures and Prudentials designation as a G-SII. The IAIS is also developing ComFrame which is focused on the supervision of large and complex Internationally Active Insurance Groups (IAIGs). ComFrame will establish a set of common principles and standards designed to assist regulators in addressing risks that arise from insurance groups with operations in multiple jurisdictions.
See the Group Risk Framework section in Item 4 of this document for more on these two regulatory developments.
80
Similar national and regional efforts to curb systemic risk and promote financial stability are also underway in certain of the jurisdictions in which Prudential operates, including the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act (the Dodd-Frank Act) in the US (further discussed in US Supervision and RegulationFinancial services regulatory and legislative issues), and legislation in the European Union related to the financial services industry. The aggregate impact and possible interaction of these regulatory developments is difficult to determine at this stage.
At the national level, regulation and supervisory practice is evolving rapidly as regulators seek to strengthen their regimes in light of the lessons of the financial crisis and the influence of international standards (eg IAIS). The following points are discussed in greater detail in the regional sections below, but are referenced here due to their significant impact.
The European Unions Solvency II Directive came into effect on 1 January 2016. The European Commission will review elements of the Solvency II legislation from 2016 onwards including a review of the Long Term Guarantee measures by 1 January 2021.
The IAIS Insurance Core Principles (ICP), which provide a globally accepted framework for the supervision of the insurance sector and ComFrame evolution, are expected to create continued development in both prudential and conduct regulations over the next two to three years, particularly in the emerging markets of Asia.
The regulatory environment continues to evolve in Asia, where economies in the region are in various phases of maturity. In general (though there are exceptions), regulators in developing economies continue to build the regulatory framework relevant to their level of economic development. This increased regulatory pressure will continue to affect Prudentials Asian businesses as Asian regulators begin to adopt the new IAIS standards, which is expected to cause sharper focus on risk management systems and in some jurisdictions may result in a requirement to hold more capital to manage asset and liability positions.
Consumer protection continues to be a key theme influencing regulatory change in Asia. For example, in 2015 Bank Negara Malaysia (BNM) finalised the Life Insurance and Family Takaful Framework with the aim of increasing the professionalism of intermediaries, enhancing the transparency around the provision of products and services to consumers and achieving higher levels of insurance and Takaful penetration in Malaysia. Specific initiatives based on this framework will follow during 2016 up to early 2019.
A major focus of regulators and policymakers in recent years has been combating money laundering, terrorist financing, bribery and corruption, as well as enforcing compliance with economic sanctions. Such matters are not limited to certain jurisdictions, although the risks of non-compliance in developing markets are considered higher than in more established markets. In addition, laws in one country can affect how a firm operates in another country. For example, the UK Bribery Act 2010 and the U.S. Foreign Corrupt Practices Act (as amended in 1998) have a very broad jurisdictional reach, allowing for the prosecution of an individual or company with links to the UK or U.S., regardless of where the crime or potential crime occurred.
The Financial Services and Markets Act 2000
Prudentials insurance and investment businesses in the UK are regulated under the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 (FSMA 2000), as amended by the 2012 Financial Services Act (FS Act). In addition, those businesses are subject to various UK laws (for example, the Data Protection Act 1998 in relation to the processing of customer data and various Pension Acts) some of which require the relevant Prudential entity to be licensed or registered.
UK regulatory regime
There are two principal financial services regulators in the UK:
| The PRA, which oversees micro-prudential regulation of deposit-takers, insurers and some systemically important investment firms; and |
81
| The FCA, which is responsible for conduct of business regulation of all authorised firms and the prudential regulation of firms not regulated by the PRA. The FCA has also inherited the majority of the market regulatory functions (excluding certain functions which are the responsibility of the Bank of England) previously held by the FSA. |
In discharging their respective functions, the PRA and FCA have separate objectives as defined in FSMA 2000 as amended by the FS Act. The general objective of the PRA is to promote the safety and soundness of PRA-authorised persons. The PRA also has an insurance objective, which is to contribute to the securing of an appropriate degree of protection for those who are or may become policyholders. The strategic objective of the FCA is to ensure that the relevant markets that it regulates function properly. The FCA has three operational objectives: to secure an appropriate degree of protection for consumers; to protect and enhance the integrity of the UK financial system; and to promote effective competition in the interests of consumers.
The approach of the PRA and FCA
Close and regular contact between the PRA and FCA and senior management and those individuals in firms performing controlled functions remains a feature of the UK regulatory regime. Both regulators have continued to focus on risk, but with their approaches informed by separate statutory objectives and pursued through distinct supervisory programmes.
Both the PRA and FCA have sought to adopt a more judgement-led approach to supervision while also being more forward-looking in relevant judgments by assessing firms against both current and future risks. The approach of both the PRA and the FCA is also principles-based; reliance on technical rules is insufficient to ensure the correct outcomes are met. This has resulted in a more intrusive and proactive approach to supervision.
The PRA is weighting its supervision towards those issues and those insurers that, in its judgment, pose the greatest risk to its statutory objectives, conducting its assessment work on a continuous cycle. For significant firms such as Prudential, the PRA conducts detailed analysis of their business models including, in the case of an insurer, forming its own projection of the insurers ability to generate returns and the associated risks. In line with a more interventionist approach, the PRA has indicated that it will require the insurer to change its business model if it believes that mitigating measures alone cannot adequately reduce material risks to safety and soundness and policyholder protection. Both the PRA and the FCA have placed a significant focus on assessing the governance frameworks and culture that exist within financial firms.
The FCAs supervision model is built upon three pillars of supervision activity:
| Pillar I is a programme of proactive, firm-specific supervision for the largest firms and groups; |
| Pillar II is event-driven, reactive supervision, which is focused on dealing with crystallised or crystallising risks in accordance with the FCAs risk appetite; and |
| Pillar III is the FCAs thematic approach, where it focuses on risks and issues for a sector as a whole. |
The FCA is responsible for supervising around 73,000 firms and thus has to allocate its resources by perceived risk. All authorised firms have been allocated to one of the two following conduct categories.
| Fixed portfolio firms: Fixed portfolio firms are the largest firms and groups across both retail and wholesale markets. These firms, which include subsidiaries of Prudential, have an ongoing proactive relationship with a dedicated team of supervisors at the FCA and are subject to an ongoing cycle of proactive supervision. |
| Flexible portfolio firms: Flexible portfolio firms are supervised through thematic and market-based work, along with programmes of communication, engagement and education activity aligned to the key risks identified in the relevant sector. |
82
While the PRA has prudential responsibility for all deposit takers, insurers and significant investment firms, the FCA is the prudential supervisor for most firms across the financial services industry, such as asset managers, financial advisers, and mortgage and insurance brokers. The FCA is the conduct supervisor for all UK regulated financial services firms.
The FCAs approach aims to minimise the harm to consumers, wholesale market participants and market stability when firms experience financial stress or fail in a disorderly manner. The star