XML 60 R23.htm IDEA: XBRL DOCUMENT v3.20.1
Note 16 - Related Party Transactions
12 Months Ended
Dec. 31, 2019
Notes to Financial Statements  
Related Party Transactions Disclosure [Text Block]
NOTE
16.
RELATED PARTY TRANSACTIONS
 
Former CEO, Erhartic
 
As of the year ended
December 31, 2015,
the Company previously purported to lease its office building in Lynchburg, Virginia, from the Former CEO, Frank Erhartic, of the Company. Public records indicate that the owner of this property from at least
January 1, 2014,
through
December 31, 2015,
was the Former CEO’s ex-wife. The Company has filed a lawsuit against the Former CEO, Erhartic, in order to recover, among other amounts, the payments made to the Former CEO. Additional information on this lawsuit can be found in Note
12.
The Company vacated the building as of
January 15, 2016.
 
The Company also leased a storage facility in Salem, Virginia, from the Former CEO, Erhartic. The Company is attempting to recover the payments made to the Former CEO related to this facility. The lease was
not
approved by the process required by the Company’s Code of Ethics. The Former CEO has refused to provide access to the storage facility to management and has
not
returned Company-owned equipment located at the storage facility. The value of this equipment is also included in the lawsuit. Additional information can be found in Note
12.
 
The Former CEO, Erhartic, created several land trusts and designated the Company as the trustee. The Former CEO and, the Company believes, the Former CFO placed personally owned properties within these land trusts. This activity was
not
approved by the process required by the Company’s Code of Ethics. This activity is the subject of litigation involving the Former CEO, Erhartic. Additional information can be found in Note
12.
 
Bonhoeffer Fund, LP
 
The Company’s subsidiary, Willow Oak Asset Management, LLC, signed a fee share agreement on
June 13, 2017,
with Coolidge Capital Management, LLC (“Coolidge”), whose sole member is Keith D. Smith, also an ENDI director. Willow Oak is the sole member of Bonhoeffer Capital Management LLC, the general partner to Bonhoeffer Fund, LP, a private investment partnership. Under their agreement, Willow Oak pays all start-up and operating expenses that are
not
partnership expenses under the limited partnership agreement. Willow Oak receives
50%
of all performance and management fees earned by the general partner. During the years ended
December 31, 2019 
and
2018,
the Company earned
$38,599
 and
$26,196,
respectively, of revenue through this Bonhoeffer Fund arrangement.
 
Willow Oak Capital Management, LLC
 
On
August 1, 2018,
Willow Oak, through a wholly-owned Company subsidiary, Willow Oak Capital Management, LLC (“Willow Oak Capital Management”), launched a newly organized private investment partnership, Willow Oak Select Fund, LP (“Select Fund”). Willow Oak Capital Management served as the general partner of Select Fund. During the year ended
December 31, 2018,
Willow Oak Capital Management entered into fee share arrangements related to the Select Fund initiative with each of the following related party funds or managers: (i) Steven Kiel, a director of the Company, pursuant to a fee share agreement dated
June 25, 2018; (
ii) JDP Capital Management, LLC, pursuant to a fee share agreement dated
June 15, 2018 (
the counterparty was affiliated with Jeremy Deal, a director of the Company); and (iii) Coolidge Capital Management, LLC, pursuant to a fee share agreement dated
June 25, 2018 (
the counterparty was affiliated with Keith Smith, a director of the Company). These related party transactions were considered and approved by the Audit Committee of the Board of Directors of the Company, acting unanimously, on
May 19, 2018.
However, Select Fund ultimately dissolved in
June 2019
so that other joint ventures and partnerships could be pursued, and these related party arrangements terminated accordingly. During the years ended
December 31, 2019
and
2018,
the Company earned
$1,521
and
$610,
respectively, of revenue through this Select Fund arrangement.
 
Willow Oak Asset Management, LLC
 
On
October 1, 2017,
Willow Oak Asset Management, LLC entered into sub-lease agreements with Arquitos Capital Management, LLC, which is managed by our director and principal executive officer, Steven L. Kiel, JDP Capital Management, LLC, which is managed by our director and vice-chairman, Jeremy K. Deal, and B.E. Capital Management, LLC, which is managed by our director, Thomas Braziel. At the commencement of the sub-lease arrangement, neither Jeremy K. Deal nor Tomas Braziel met the criteria for a related party. Upon Jeremy K. Deal’s board appointment on
April 3, 2018
and Thomas Braziel’s appointment on
May 5, 2019,
the sub-lease arrangements qualify as related party transactions. During the years ended
December 31, 2019
and
2018,
the Company earned
$28,405
and
$41,632,
respectively, of sub-lease revenue through these arrangements. Willow Oak’s sub-lease agreement with Arquitos Capital Management, LLC expired on
October 31, 2018,
and as of
December 31, 2019,
the remaining
two
sub-lease arrangements have also expired.
 
On
November 1, 2018,
Willow Oak Asset Management, LLC entered into a fund management services agreement with Arquitos Investment Manager, LP, which is managed by our director and principal executive officer, Steven L. Kiel, to provide Arquitos with Willow Oak Fund Management Services (“FMS”) consisting of the following services: investor relations, marketing, administration, legal, accounting and bookkeeping, annual audit coordination, and liaison to
third
-party service providers. As considerations for the services, Arquitos pays Willow Oak a fixed monthly fee and a performance-based fee. During the years ended
December 31, 2019 
and
2018,
the Company earned
$100,461
and
$17,614,
respectively, of revenue through this fund management services arrangement.
 
Mt Melrose Transaction
 
The Company’s and its Mt Melrose subsidiary’s transactions with Old Mt. Melrose and Jeffrey I. Moore, a former director of the Company, were related party transactions and are set out in Notes
5
 and
9,
respectively.